battery electric biodiesel natural gas/ hydrogen plug-in ... · liquefied petroleum gas plug-in...
TRANSCRIPT
The Low EmissionVan Guide
Helping van operatorsto reduce costs and emissions
UPDATED
NOVEMBER2016
ConnectCollaborate Influence
Battery Electric Biodiesel HydrogenNatural Gas/Biomethane
LiquefiedPetroleum Gas
Plug-In Hybrid
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 1 25/11/2016 08:51
2 3
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 2 25/11/2016 08:51
2 3
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
This guide and accompanying low emission van web tool has been prepared by the Low Carbon Vehicle
Partnership in partnership with Cenex, Transport for London, SMMT, FTA, Royal Borough of Greenwich, Arval
and Commercial Group Ltd. This project was co-funded by Transport for London and a Defra Air Quality Grant
awarded to the Royal Borough of Greenwich.
First published June 2015. Updated July 2016, Nov 2016.
Contents
The Low Emission Van Guide 4
Why Choose A Low Emission Van? 5
Some Useful Background Information On Emissions 6
What To Consider When Choosing A Low Emission Van 7
Topic Sheet 1 Battery Electric Vans 10
Topic Sheet 2 Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vans 12
Topic Sheet 3 Liquefied Petroleum Gas Vans 14
Topic Sheet 4 CNG / Biomethane Vans 16
Topic Sheet 5 Biodiesel Vans 18
Topic Sheet 6 Hydrogen Vans 20
Best Practice - Making Existing Van Operations More Efficient 22
Low Emission Van Summary Matrix 23
What To Do Next? Getting involved 24
Assess The Savings For Yourself 25
Links To Further Information 26
Notes 27
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 3 25/11/2016 08:51
4 5
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
The Low Emission Van Guide
A low emission van operates using efficient technology or
alternative fuels rather than diesel. Low emission vans can
help lower the running cost and environmental impact of
your fleet.
This guide will assist you in choosing the most suitable low emission van for the type of work you do. The guide is
aimed at operators of small to medium-sized fleets of commercial vehicles, covering vans up to 3.5t GVW (gross
vehicle weight) - i.e., a Ford Transit sized van. The guide:
• Sets out the business, environmental and operational case for using low emission vans.
• Gives van operators the knowledge and resources required to assess which vans are right for them.
• Provides case studies showing the cost savings achievable from di�erent types of low emission fuels
and technologies.
Once you have read this guide, you can find more information about low emission vans at the LowCVP’s Low
Emission Van Information Hub at www.lowcvp.org.uk/lev. The LowCVP and Cenex have created the VC3 Van Cost
& Carbon Calculator tool where you can enter your own data and compare different low emission fuels and
technologies suitable for your fleet. See the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide for an introduction
to the tool.
Source: VW
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 4 25/11/2016 08:51
4 5
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Why Choose A Low Emission Van?
The right low emission van for you is the one that saves you
money, reduces your environmental impact and does not
restrict your operations.
Better for businessReducing CO
2 (carbon dioxide) emissions
from vehicles makes good business sense
as lower emissions normally means you are
also spending less money on fuel. Clean
and green vans help to demonstrate an
environmental commitment and enhance
your organisation’s image. The environmental
credentials of suppliers (you!) are becoming
more important to your customers. In fact,
there is an EU Directive called the Clean
Vehicles Directive that mandates public sector
organisations to take the environmental
impacts of vehicles into account during
procurement decisions. Transport for London
and many local authorities have introduced
performance standards for low emission
vans as part of their tendering process for
contractors. By operating a low emission
van you could be a step ahead of other
companies bidding for work.
Better for air quality and healthExhaust emissions from vehicles contribute to air quality problems in cities. Poor air quality is extremely harmful
to health; it is estimated to contribute to 29,000 premature deaths a year in the UK . Many UK cities are putting in
place measures to reduce air pollution from vehicles including vans. London has introduced the Low Emission
Zone and will be introducing an Ultra-Low Emission Zone by 2020. This aims to increase the use of cleaner
vehicles in central London. In September 2020 diesel vans operating in the London Ultra-Low Emission Zone
must comply with the Euro 6 emissions standard. Compliance is achieved through imposing restrictions and
different charges on the types of vehicles that are allowed into Low Emission Zone areas. Other cities across
the UK are also introducing local measures to encourage the use of cleaner vehicles to help improve air quality.
Birmingham, Leeds, Nottingham, Derby and Southampton are planning to introduce Clean Air Zones by 2020.
Better for the environmentThe UK Government is committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and has introduced regulations and
incentives to encourage low emission vehicle use by businesses and individuals. These measures are expected to
continue in the future.
Source: Nissan
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 5 25/11/2016 08:51
6 7
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Some Useful Background Information On Emissions
Understanding how air quality and CO2 emissions are defined will help you to choose a low emission van.
Air quality emissions are pollutants released from a vehicle’s exhaust pipe in to the atmosphere. You may have
heard of Particulate Matter (PM) and Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx). These are the principal pollutants released from
vehicles that contribute to poor air quality in cities.
Euro standards are a set of air quality standards that new vans must meet. Every few years tighter emission
standards are set out for new vans. The current standard is Euro 6 for the smallest vans (like a Citroen Nemo), with
larger vans (like a Transit Connect and bigger) moving to Euro 6 in September 2016. Many larger vans that comply
with the Euro 6 emission standard are already available.
Real-world emissions from vans may differ from the manufacturers’ published information for many reasons.
You have probably heard a lot about this in the press recently. Over the next couple of years van emission testing
procedures are set to change. The standard test cycle will change to one which represents real-world driving
better and legislation is coming into force to ensure that emission limits are not exceeded while a van is operating
in the real-world.
CO2 is a greenhouse gas which does not affect air quality but is considered the principal contributor to climate
change. In this guide we talk about the CO2 emissions from vans in two different ways as explained below.
- Tailpipe CO2 is emitted directly from the vehicle and every van model has its tailpipe emissions
declared by the manufacturer. They are expressed as the grams of CO2 emitted per km driven (g/km).
It’s important to know this before you buy a van as some tax rates, plug-in van grants and congestion
charge rates are based on tailpipe emissions. An Ultra-Low Emission Vehicle (ULEV), is a van which
emits less than 75g CO2 per km driven. A Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) is a van which has no tailpipe
CO2 emissions e.g. battery electric or pure hydrogen powered vans.
- Fuel life cycle CO2 is a much better method for understanding the true environmental performance
of a fuel. This takes into account the CO2 emissions associated with the energy used while extracting
and processing the fuel as well as the emissions from the vehicle when the fuel is burnt. Renewable
biofuels, which are generally derived from plants or waste, also cause CO2 emissions when used in a
vehicle. However, since this CO2 was taken from the atmosphere by the plant when it was growing, its
combustion does not contribute to climate change and is therefore not included when looking at the
fuel life cycle CO2 emissions from a van.
With the back seats
removed and a
bulk head installed,
Speedy use the BMW
i3 in a car derived
van configuration
to deliver products
in London and
Manchester city
centres. Source:
Speedy Services
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 6 25/11/2016 08:51
6 7
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
What To Consider When Choosing A Low Emission Van
For a fleet of vans it may be possible to specify vehicles
differently in order to arrive at a mix of van types to deliver the
variety of duties required. This allows low emission vans to play
a role in your fleet which is best suited to their capabilities.
Fit for purposeTo minimise costs it is important to avoid choosing a larger or more powerful model than is required. Purchasers
should be realistic about how often the largest payload, top speed or maximum range is needed.
Factors to consider
PayloadWhat type of goods will be carried, what is the maximum payload required? Payload is often reduced slightly in alternatively fuelled vehicles due to the weight of additional components such as batteries, motors or gas tanks.
Vehicle size What load space is required? The best way to reduce emissions and cost is to use smaller and lighter vehicles. Downsizing from a larger vehicle will also open doors to more low emission van options, for example most plug-in vans are only available in the smaller van range.
Daily / annual
mileage (range)
Local runs or long distance driving? Return to base for refuelling? Refuelling station availability and the time taken to refuel/recharge can vary for the different low emission van options.
Fuel/technology
options
What are the benefits of low carbon fuels? Apart from lower emissions and running costs, a quieter vehicle may be beneficial, or you may be looking to improve your company’s image.
Local
considerations
Is any preferential treatment given for a particular type of vehicle, such as concessionary parking charges or access to low emission zones? Low emission vans are often encouraged into cities by local authorities offering discounted access and parking fees.
Dealer support
Where is my closest trained dealer? Will my warranty be affected? Make sure your local service centre is able to support your alternatively fuelled vehicle. Different service frequencies have to be followed when running on biodiesel. An additional third party warranty may be needed to maintain full warranty cover of an LPG converted vehicle.
Buy or lease
What discount can you get through your dealership? Do you want a guaranteed fixed cost for vehicle ownership? The examples in this guide give whole life costs for vehicle ownership. You should look at both lease rates and ownership costs. Leasing companies can get much bigger discounts on buying vehicles compared to low volume van buyers. They offer convenient fixed monthly charges that can include maintenance. Plus many have specialists offering free advice for customers wanting to switch to lower carbon vehicles. Purchasing the vehicle yourself, especially if you can get a good dealer discount, can be cheaper, although you’ll have to absorb some risk when it comes to estimating the value of an alternatively fuelled van in future years when you want to sell it.
FlexibilityFinally, flexible thinking will help. This guide will show you that the cost and emission savings are there, you may just have to rethink how you operate your vans to take full advantage of them.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 7 25/11/2016 08:51
8 9
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
What To Consider When Choosing A Low Emission Van (continued)
It’s easy to fall into the trap of purchasing the lowest cost van
available to you.
Evaluating the cost
Since your choice of van will determine your business costs for years to come it pays to undertake a whole life
cost analysis. This includes not only the purchase cost, but also running costs (fuel, tax, maintenance, congestion
charge etc.) and how much you will get for the van when you come to sell it again. Most low emission vans will
cost you more up front, but deliver monetary savings due to their lower running costs. The key factor is whether
your annual mileage is high enough to allow the lower fuel costs to result in cost savings over the whole life of
the vehicle. The van technology Topic Sheets give example scenarios where low emission vans are also lower
cost vans.
Dual Fuel
Hydrogen-Diesel
Vans Source:
Commercial
Group
Dual Fuel
Hydrogen-Diesel
Vans Source:
Commercial
Group
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 8 25/11/2016 08:51
8 9
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Incentives for low emission vans
To encourage the purchase of low emission vans and assist in reducing whole life costs a number of financial
incentives are in place. National incentives have been put in place by the UK government and some councils also
offer local incentives.
INCENTIVE INFORMATION WHAT’S IT WORTH?
Plug-in van grant
(≤ 3.5 tonnes)
For vans with a total permissible weight of less than or equal to 3.5 tonnes, the plug-in van grant provides 20% off the cost of a new Ultra-Low Emission Vehicle (ULEV) up to a maximum of £8,000. A van which emits less that 75g CO
2 per km driven
is classed as an ULEV. To be eligible for the grant a van must have an electric only range of at least 10 miles and be an ULEV.
Up to £8,000
Plug-in van grant
(> 3.5 tonnes)
For vans with a total permissible weight of more than 3.5 tonnes, the plug-in van grant provides 20% off the cost of a ULEV up to a maximum of £20,000. This scheme was introduced in October 2016 and is valid for 200 grant claims, after which the grant level will fall in line with the lighter van scheme (above) which gives 20% off the price, up to a maximum of £8,000.
Up to £20,000
Workplace
Charging Scheme
A voucher-based scheme supports the upfront purchase and installation costs of EV charge points. The contribution is limited to £300 for each socket up to a maximum of 20 across all sites for each application. The voucher will be valid for four months (120 days) from the date of issue.
Up to £300
each
Electric vehicle
homecharge
scheme
The government offers a grant of 75% towards the cost of charging infrastructure installed at residential addresses.
Up to £500
On-street
charging scheme
The government offers a grant of 75% towards the costs of installing an on-street electric vehicle charging bay for residents with regular use of an electric vehicle.
Up to £7500
Road tax The road tax rate for a zero emission vans is £0.Up to £140
per year
Van benefit
charge
Using a company van for significant personal use is a taxable benefit. The government value this benefit at £3,170 per annum and a driver must pay their normal rate of tax on this. Using a zero emission van will reduce this taxable amount by 80%. From FY 2018/19 the benefit will reduce on a tapered basis reaching parity with the full taxable rate in April 2022.
£507 per year
for a basic
rate (20%) tax
payer
Van fuel benefit
charge
If an employer gives an employee a van to use which is subject to the van benefit charge and pays for their fuel, the employee will need to pay a fuel benefit charge. Van fuel benefit charge is set at a flat rate £598 in 2016-17. In 2017-18 this will increase by RPI. Electricity is not treated as a fuel, so it is not subject to the van fuel benefit charge.
£598 per year
Enhanced capital
allowance
Zero emission goods vehicles are eligible for 100% first year allowance until 2018. So if your business pays corporation tax at 20%, £20,000 spent on a battery electric van would reduce your tax bill in the year of purchase by £4,000. You cannot claim an enhanced capital allowance if you have received the plug-in van grant.
£4,000 on
a £20,000
purchase
Fuel dutySome clean fuels such as natural gas, LPG and biomethane are cheaper than diesel and petrol because the government applies less fuel duty to them. In the case of electricity or hydrogen, there is no fuel duty applied at all.
Up to 70%
reduction in
fuel costs
Free or dis-
counted parkingSome cities offer free or discounted parking at public charge points for electric vans.
Up to £10 per
day
Congestion
charge
Vans that emit 75g/km or less of CO2 receive a 100% discount on the London
Congestion Charge.
£11.50 per
day, or £10.50
if using auto-
pay
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 9 25/11/2016 08:51
10 11
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 1Battery Electric Vans
Technology Introduction Battery electric vans (BEVs) operate entirely on electricity using an electric motor instead of a diesel or petrol engine. A high capacity battery (usually lithium ion technology, the same as we have in our phones and laptops) powers the vans. BEVs are classed as ultra-low emission vehicles.
Fit for Purpose
• Electric vans are suitable for regular and low mileages due to their limited driving range between recharging.
• Typically they can offer up to an 80 mile (small van) or 100 mile (large van) range in the real-world. High payloads, aggressive driving or high heater use in winter can all reduce the available range. Range can be increased by using specialist routing software to optimise daily journeys for BEV use.
• The daily range can be extended by topping up the battery during the day.
• Fleets would normally drive back to base to recharge. The growing number of fast and rapid public charging stations also allow top-up charging during the day – links to charging station maps are provided in the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide.
• Due to the weight of the batteries, payload for a small panel van typically reduces by around 5 to 15% with up to 25% for a large panel van. Load space is not affected.
• Some manufacturers offer EVs on either an outright purchase or battery leasing arrangement. The battery leasing option alleviates any concerns around battery life time and potential performance degradation.
Environmental Performance
• Electric vans produce zero tailpipe emissions which makes them ideal for improving air quality in our cities and reducing CO
2 emissions. BEVs offer CO
2 savings of up to 35% even
when the carbon intensity of electricity production is taken into account.
Market Status
• Small battery electric van models are available from a growing number of mainstream manufacturers, such as the Nissan e-NV200 or the Renault Kangoo ZE and more. Due to running and purchasing incentives from the UK Government, coupled with the wide spread electricity network, electric vans are rapidly becoming a popular fleet choice.
• Large electric vans are available from BD Auto, with vans from Iveco and LDV becoming available throughout 2016. Due to the greater purchase cost of large electric vans, an additional environmental cost saving (such as the London Congestion Charge) is often required to show a whole life cost saving against a diesel van.
Environmental performance
(compared to diesel)
Tailpipe CO2
100% saving
Fuel life cycle CO2
35% saving
Excellent for air
quality
Low noise
Operational performance
Range
Up to 80 miles
(small van) or 100
miles (large van)
Recharging times
Standard: 10 hrs
Fast: 4 hrs
Rapid: 30 mins
Ideal operation
City and suburbs.
Back to base
Example fleet
City courier, light
delivery and service
engineer
spread electricity network, electric vans are rapidly becoming a popular fleet choice.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 10 25/11/2016 08:51
10 11
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 1 (continued)
Battery Electric Vans
Whole Life Cost Example
Nissan NV200 1.5dCi Acenta
(Diesel)
Nissan e-NV200 Acenta
(Electric)Vehicle:
2.2t Small panel van
Annual mileage:
12,000 miles (48 miles per day)
Ownership period:
5 years
Cost saving:
£4,514 rising to £17,639 if used
daily in the London Congestion
Charging Zone
The example shows the economic case for electric vehicles is strong. The plug-in van grant, lower fuel cost, zero
road tax, lower maintenance costs and stronger residual value all work
together to offer substantial whole life cost savings. When regional incentives,
such as free entry into the London Congestion Charging Zone are included the whole life savings available become comparable to the purchase cost of the
vehicle!
Vehicle £15,030 £22,088
Plug-in van grant discount £5,301
Fuel costs £5,449 £2,103
Road tax £700 £0
Maintenance costs £2,114 £1,416
Resale value £3,096 £4,622
Life time cost £20,198 £15,684
Cost per mile 33.7p 26.1p
Whole life cost savings £4,514
If used in the London Congestion Zone (5 days/week)
Life time cost £33,323 £15,684
Whole life cost savings £17,639
How we calculated the whole life cost and emissions
All costs exclude VAT. Purchase Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool. Fuel Consumption manufacturer’s literature with a 20% real-world small van uplift factor applied. Fuel Cost diesel 2015 average @ £0.96 per litre, electricity @ £0.11 per kWh. Maintenance Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool Resale Value Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool Emissions UK Government fuel emission factors applied to estimated van fuel consumption.
Case Study
Fruit 4 London is a small company, with a big environmental ethos, dedicated to delivering fresh fruit to over 200 London offices every day. Following a successful vehicle trial in 2012, Fruit 4 London operates five electric Renault Kangoo ZE delivery vans. The vans typically travel 40 to 70 miles and make up to 60 delivery stops per day.
Initially attracted by the environmental benefits of zero emission vehicles, they found it was easy to make the business case work too, as Fruit 4 London director Laszlo Mulato explains, “Operating in the congestion charging zone saves us nearly £15,000 per year over the five vehicles, we are also seeing around 75% fuel savings compared to our two diesel delivery vans”. Having operated BEVs for 3 years now Laszlo has also noticed the extra business the vehicles are directly responsible for as their customers seek a more sustainable supply chain.
Fruit 4 London purchase all their electric vans on a battery leasing model, preferring the financial security and comfort of knowing that the batteries performance and lifetime are guaranteed for as long as they own the vehicles.
Which other fleets are using electric?
British Gas, Birmingham City Council, Gnewt Cargo, Loughborough University and more.
Next steps Go to the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide to find links to electric van advice sites and tools, including public charging station locations.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 11 25/11/2016 08:51
12 13
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 2Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vans
Technology Introduction A Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicle (PHEV) operates using a petrol engine or battery powered electric motor to drive the wheels. It can operate in pure electric mode like a battery electric van, however due to a smaller battery the mileage available in electric mode is less. Once the battery has depleted, the petrol engine starts and the vehicle operates in a similar way to a normal hybrid vehicle. Plug-in hybrid vans are classed as ultra-low emission vehicles.
Fit for Purpose
• A plug-in hybrid van offers the same functionality as a conventional van as it can operate on petrol when the battery depletes.
• Maximising the electric only mileage is key to reducing costs and maximising the environmental benefits.
• Payload is normally reduced due to the additional weight of the batteries and electric motors, but load space is unaffected.
• Fleets would normally go back to base to base to recharge. The growing number of fast and rapid public charging stations also allow top-up charging during the day – links to charging station maps are provided in the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide.
Environmental Performance
• The PHEV is a zero emission vehicle when operating in electric mode.
• The reduction in fuel and engine use means that PHEVs are very good for air quality.
Market Status
• PHEVs are very limited in supply. Mitsubishi currently offer a 4Work model of their PHEV Outlander in a 2 seat, extended load space configuration.
• Only PHEVs which have tailpipe emissions of under 75g/km CO2 and a zero emission
range of at least 10 miles are eligible for the plug-in van grant.
Environmental performance
(compared to diesel)
Tailpipe CO2
100% saving when
operating in electric
mode
Fuel life cycle CO2
35% saving when
operating in electric
mode
Very good for air
quality
Low noise
Operational performance
Range in electric
mode
Up to 27 miles, plus
petrol reserve
Recharging times
Standard: 5 hrs
Rapid: 30 mins
Ideal operation
City, suburbs,
occasional
motorway.
Back to base.
High electric mode
utilisation
Example fleet
City courier, light
delivery and service
engineer
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 12 25/11/2016 08:51
12 13
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 2 (continued)
Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vans
Whole Life Cost Example
Mitsubishi Outlander 2.2DI-
D GX1 4Work (Diesel)
Mitsubishi Outlander Hybrid
GX3h 4Work (PHEV)
Vehicle:
2.2t PHEV Van
Annual mileage:
15,000 miles (60 miles per day)
Ownership period:
5 years
Cost saving:
£446 rising to £13,571 if used
daily in the London Congestion
Charging Zone
The example shows there are savings available for the PHEV. The plug- in van
grant and lower fuel costs work together to offer whole life cost savings. When regional incentives, such as free entry into the London Congestion Charging Zone are included the savings available
become enormous.
In this example the PHEV covers 60 miles per day and assumes the electric mode is used to cover 27 miles per day.
Savings will diminish if the vehicle is not fully charged each day and/or more miles are undertaken in petrol
mode.
Unlike the PHEV SUV, the 4Work model is a commercial vehicle and as such
does not qualify for £0 rate car road tax.
Vehicle £21,728 £29,603
Plug-in van grant discount
£7,105
Fuel costs £7,221 £5,435
Road tax £700 £700
Maintenance costs £4,230 £5,085
Resale value £4,306 £4,591
Life time cost £29,573 £29,128
Cost per mile 39.4p 38.8p
Whole life cost savings
£446
If used in the London Congestion Zone (5 days/week)
Life time cost £42,698 £29,128
Whole life cost savings
£13,571
How we calculated the whole life cost and emissions
All costs exclude VAT. Purchase Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool. Fuel Consumption manufacturer’s literature with a 20% real-world small van uplift factor applied. Fuel Cost diesel 2015 average @ £0.96 per litre, electricity @ £0.11 per kWh. Maintenance Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool Resale Value Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool Emissions UK Government fuel emission factors applied to estimated van fuel consumption.
Case Study
The Environment Agency operates over 1,400 commercial vehicles. The Agency’s current CO
2 reduction initiatives include the use of biodiesel in
nearly 300 vehicles and the use of retro-fit hybrid assist systems in rear-wheel transits.
The release of the Mitsubishi PHEV Outlander provides a great opportunity for them to expand their use of low carbon vehicles, as Dale Eynon, Head of Fleet Services explains “We already use Mitsubishi Diesel Outlanders within the fleet, the PHEV is available at the same cost, and even with a low level of charging we expect to break even, the main focus for us is to maximise EV use to ensure we are maximising our CO
2 savings.” The 68 PHEV Outlanders (deployed
in March 2015) leave the depots fully charged, and on average will travel around 60 miles a day. The Environment Agency are currently looking to install additional charge points at key work locations and educate staff as to the locations of public infrastructure which could be used during breaks.
Next steps Go to the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide to find links to the further plug-in hybrid electric van advice sites and tools, including public charging station locations.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 13 25/11/2016 08:52
14 15
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 3Liquefied Petroleum Gas Vans
Technology Introduction Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG) is a fossil fuel extracted alongside natural gas and is also a by-product of the oil refining process. LPG is stored on vehicles under pressure as a liquid.
Fit for Purpose
• LPG vehicles can undertake similar duties to regular vans due to the long range available between refuelling events.
• Refuelling is easy, there are nearly 1,500 refuelling stations offering LPG across the UK.
• The vehicles are bi-fuel, so they can operate on either petrol or LPG.
• Payload is similar to a regular van and the LPG tanks are normally mounted in the spare wheel cavity. If additional mileage is required tanks can also be fitted in the load space.
Environmental Performance
• LPG vehicles are quieter and emit less harmful air quality pollutants than diesel vehicles. They offer tailpipe and fuel life cycle CO
2 emissions when compared to petrol, but can
emit similar CO2 per km when compared to a diesel van.
Market Status
• LPG conversions and refuelling infrastructure are well established and proven. Although LPG vehicles are available from main stream manufacturers in Europe, here in the UK you would have a petrol van retro-fitted with an LPG system by an installer approved by UKLPG – the LPG trade association.
• A vehicle manufacturer’s warranty will not cover any faults caused by the LPG system, therefore a third party warranty (usually from the AA) can be taken out.
• LPG vans are available on contract hire from leasing companies, such as Fraikin, eliminating potential concerns around vehicle conversion, warranty and resale.
Environmental performance
(compared to petrol)
Tailpipe CO2
14% saving
Fuel life cycle CO2
20% saving
Good for AQ
Low noise
Operational performance
Miles on full tank
Up to 300 miles
(plus petrol reserve)
Ideal operation
No restrictions
Example fleet
City and long
distance courier,
delivery, service
engineer
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 14 25/11/2016 08:52
14 15
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 3 (continued)
Liquefied Petroleum Gas Vans
Whole Life Cost Example
Vauxhall Combo 1.4i 95PS (Petrol)
Vauxhall Combo 1.4i 95PS (LPG) Vehicle:
2.0t Small panel van
Annual mileage:
15,000 miles
Ownership period:
5 years
Cost saving:
£1,387
In this example the fuel savings from using LPG recoup the cost of the system and the additional maintenance costs – which come to £45 per 12,000 miles.
LPG conversions provide whole life cost savings when compared to petrol
vehicles and similar whole life costs when compared to diesel vehicles, with the advantage of better air quality and
lower noise performance.
Vehicle £14,293 £14,293
LPG Conversion £1,200
Fuel costs £9,427 £6,559
Road tax £700 £700
Maintenance costs £2,693 £2,974
Resale value £1,491 £1,491
Life time cost £25,622 £24,235
Cost per mile 34.2p per mile 32.3p per mile
Whole life cost savings
£1,387
How we calculated the whole life cost and emissions
All costs exclude VAT. Purchase Cost manufacturer’s list price, LPG system installation cost from supplier quotes. Fuel Consumption manufacturer’s literature with a 20% real-world small van uplift factor applied. Fuel Cost 2015 average price, petrol @ £0.93 per litre, LPG @ £0.50 per litre. Maintenance Cost Petrol from Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool with additional £45 per 12,000 miles LPG system service Resale Value Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool Emissions UK Government fuel emissions factors applied to estimated van fuel consumption.
Case Study
Outdoor advertising firm Clear Channel UK has many reasons to choose autogas LPG to fuel its fleet of service vehicles. However, it was firstly the environmental angle followed by the financial advantages that are a major benefit to Clear Channel UK. Glenn Ewen, Fleet Manager, Clear Channel UK, said: “As part of our wider strategy to minimise our impact on the environment, Clear Channel UK has set a target of 84 per cent LPG usage against petrol. As part of our commitment to this target, we have installed seven bunkers at Clear Channel depots nationwide where our drivers refuel.” Typically, their autogas LPG system provides annual (running) cost savings of around 40 per cent compared to petrol fuelled vans.
Which other fleets are using LPG?
Humberside Police Force, Grass Hopper Couriers, Camden Council and more.
Next steps Go to the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide to find links to thefurther van advice sites and tools, including a link to a list of approved installers and LPGrefuelling stations.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 15 25/11/2016 08:52
16 17
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 4CNG / Biomethane Vans
Technology Introduction CNG vehicles run on Compressed Natural Gas, the same gas we use to power our central heating boilers and cookers. CNG is stored on the vehicle in pressurised cylinders and used in a spark ignition engine, which is the type of engine used in petrol vehicles. CNG is a fossil fuel; however a renewable and sustainable version of natural gas is also available called biomethane. Biomethane is produced from organic waste and can be directly used in CNG vehicles.
Fit for Purpose
• CNG vans can undertake similar duties to regular diesel vans due to the long range available between refuelling.
• Payload is often reduced by about 10% due to the weight of the gas tanks. Load space is not affected.
• A limited, but growing, number of public CNG refuelling stations are available across the UK which are capable of filling the fuel tank in a few minutes. Smaller home or depot based refuelling units can compress natural gas from the gas network directly into a vehicle’s tank overnight.
• CNG vans can have a reserve petrol tank in case you run low on gas away from a refuelling station.
Environmental Performance
• CNG vehicles are good for air quality, they are quiet and emit similar levels of CO2 to
diesel vans. If operated on biomethane, then fuel life cycle CO2 savings of over 60% are
available.
Market Status
• CNG vehicles are popular all over the world. Model availability is limited in the UK due to our lack of refuelling stations. CNG versions of the Iveco Daily and Mercedes Sprinter are available. Until July 2014, VW supplied the UK with a CNG Caddy, these are now available on the second hand market or a new left hand drive model could be imported from Ireland.
• Direct biomethane supply in the UK is very limited. Fleets wishing to use biomethane can purchase Green Gas Certificates, these allow fleets to purchase the green credentials of biomethane (injected into the national gas grid elsewhere) when drawing gas from their local grid connection point. However, Green Gas Certificates are not currently accepted as a legitimate method of claiming fuel life cycle carbon reduction under the UK Government’s carbon reporting protocol, but this is under review.
Environmental performance
(compared to diesel)
Tailpipe CO2
Similar
Fuel life cycle CO2
Similar for CNG,
over 60% saving
for biomethane
Good for air
quality
Low Noise
Operational performance
Miles on full tank
Up to 300 miles
(plus petrol reserve)
Ideal operation
City, suburbs,
motorway. Back to
base. High mileage
Example fleet
City and long
distance courier,
delivery, service
engineer
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 16 25/11/2016 08:52
16 17
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 4 (continued)
CNG / Biomethane Vans
Whole Life Cost Example
Mercedes Sprinter 316 CDI (Diesel)
Mercedes Sprinter 316 NGT
(CNG)
Vehicle:
3.5t CNG Large Panel Van
Annual mileage:
25,000 miles
Ownership period:
6 years
Cost saving:
£1,823
The cost example opposite shows that the additional purchase cost of a CNG
Mercedes Sprinter covering 25,000 miles per annum saves the operator over £1,800 on a whole life cost basis over 6 years. With the increased purchase and maintenance costs and lower residual
value offset by the savings in fuel costs.
The price of CNG varies significantly between suppliers. Availability of low cost CNG coupled with high annual
mileage will be the key factors in achieving an overall whole life cost
saving.
Vehicle purchase cost £28,740 £31,710
Fuel cost £23,865 £16,219
Road tax £1,350 £1,350
Maintenance costs £8,760 £9,885
Resale value £3,135 £1,407
Life time cost £59,070 £57,247
Cost per mile 39.4p 38.2p
Whole life cost savings
£1,823
How we calculated the whole life cost and emissions
All costs exclude VAT. Purchase Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool. Fuel Consumption manufacturer’s literature with a 35% real-world large van uplift factor applied. Fuel Cost diesel 2015 average @ £0.96 per litre, gas @ 0.64p/kg from CNG Fuels public filling station. Maintenance Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool adjusted with data from Mercedes for CNG Van Resale Value Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool Emissions UK Government fuel emission factors applied to estimated van fuel consumption.
Case Study
Following a successful implementation of gas refuse collection vehicles, Leeds City Council took advantage of their on-site gas refuelling facilities and incorporated seven Volkswagen Caddy vans into their fleet. The bi-fuel vehicles run on CNG with a small petrol reserve and cover domestic repairs and maintenance at households in the city. The vehicles travel less than 70 miles per day so very much within their 300 mile range, supplying the council with a 3p per mile fuel cost saving.
Which other fleets are using CNG?
Tesco, Waitrose, Arla Foods, Balfour Beatty, Camden Council and more.
Next steps Go to the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide to find links to the further van advice sites and tools, including a map of UK gas refuelling stations.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 17 25/11/2016 08:52
18 19
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 5Biodiesel Vans
Technology Introduction Biodiesel is a renewable fuel produced from vegetable crops and/or used cooking oil, and is a low carbon alternative to fossil diesel. Today fuel suppliers are allowed to blend biodiesel, manufactured to the EN 14214 standard with regular road diesel up to 7%. This 7% blend, known as B7, is compatible with any vehicle. Some manufacturers design their vehicles to operate on higher biodiesel blends, normally up to a 30% blend (B30).
Fit for Purpose
• There are no operational restrictions. A vehicle running on biodiesel also maintains the ability to run on regular diesel, which can be used in the same tank.
• Vehicle payload and load space are unaffected.
• Biodiesel blends are mainly available from supplier facilities. If these are not convenient, a storage tank and dispenser can be installed at your depot.
• A vehicle’s fuel delivery system has to be designed to work with biodiesel and manufacturers will recommend more frequent maintenance.
• A good quality biodiesel, manufactured to the EN 14214 standard should be used.
Environmental Performance
• Tailpipe emissions are unaffected, but as biodiesel is a renewable fuel, fuel life cycle CO2
reductions of around 28% are available when using B30 manufactured from used cooking oil.
• Biodiesel vehicles normally emit less particulate matter with similar, or marginally increased, NOx emissions.
• You should ensure that biodiesel used is from sustainable sources. Biodiesel manufactured from used cooking oil has a very low environmental impact as it is a waste material and does not require additional food crops to be grown to produce it.
Market Status
• High blends of biodiesel are not widely supported by vehicle manufacturers, this coupled with greater maintenance frequencies and variable biodiesel costs means that higher blends of biodiesel are not widespread. Some manufacturers such as Peugeot and Citroen support blends of up to B30 in their HDi engine range.
Environmental performance
(compared to diesel)
Tailpipe CO2
Similar
Fuel life cycle CO2
28% saving (B30)
from used
cooking oil
Similar air quality
Similar noise
Operational performance
Miles on full tank
Same as diesel
Ideal operation
City, suburbs,
motorway.
Back to base
Example fleet
City and long
distance courier,
delivery, service
engineer
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 18 25/11/2016 08:52
18 19
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 5 (continued)
Biodiesel Vans
Whole Life Cost Example
PeugeotPartner L1
1.6HDi 92 HP (Diesel)
Peugeot Partner L1
1.6HDi 92 HP (Biodiesel B30)
Vehicle:
2.0t Small panel van
Annual mileage:
20,000 miles
Ownership period:
5 years
Cost saving:
Similar cost
Whilst biodiesel can cost less than fossil diesel the additional maintenance requirements coupled with higher fuel
use (due to the lower energy content of biodiesel) means that whole life costs
can be similar.
Vehicle £14,628 £14,628
Fuel costs £9,268 £8,872
Road tax £700 £700
Maintenance costs £3,460 £3,820
Resale value £1,848 £1,848
Life time cost £26,208 £26,172
Cost per mile 26.2p 26.2p
Whole life cost savings £36
How we calculated the whole life cost and emissions
All costs exclude VAT. Purchase Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool. Fuel Consumption manufacturer’s literature with a 20% real-world small van uplift factor applied. Fuel Cost diesel 2015 average @ £0.96 per litre, biodiesel B100 @ £0.75 per litre (avg. from supplier research). Maintenance Cost Diesel from Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool with additional biodiesel maintenance items as advised by Peugeot Resale Value Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool Emissions UK Government fuel emission factors applied to estimated van fuel consumption.
Case Study
The London Borough of Hackney operates 38 trucks on B100 and a further 100 on a B30 blend of biodiesel and seeking to roll out the biodiesel programme to additional vehicles where possible. The uptake of biodiesel is being promoted through the Mayor’s Biodiesel Programme which aims to turn London’s used cooking oils, fats and greases into biodiesel to power London’s buses and public sector road fleets.
Norman Harding, Corporate Fleet Manager at Hackney notes “…providing that operators source good quality biodiesel that meets the EN14214 standard for B100 or EN16709 for B20/B30 blends from a reputable supplier then vehicles should operate trouble free.” Harding ensures that his biodiesel is all derived from waste but is free from animal fats as the animal fats can cause the fuel to ‘wax’ at very cold temperatures.
Harding also commented “There is a Well-to-Wheel carbon saving with the implementation of the B30 fleet, at no rise in maintenance costs.” He continued “The future of biodiesel as a fuel depends on messages from Government and groups such as the LoCity programme promoting its benefits in terms of CO
2 reduction and cost of infrastructure relative to other alternatives”. Harding believes that Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil
(HVO) is the future of sustainable liquid fuels. HVO is a renewable bio-fuel from waste with similar properties to standard diesel, its use requires no vehicle modifications or extra maintenance yet is > than 80% CO
2 efficient and is currently
recognised as a ‘drop in fuel’ by a growing number of vehicle manufacturers.
Which other fleets are using biodiesel?
Environment Agency, McDonald’s UK, Commercial Group and more.
Next steps Go to the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide to find links to the further van advice sites and tools, including a link to biodiesel station locations and pricing.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 19 25/11/2016 08:52
20 21
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 6Hydrogen Vans
Technology Introduction Hydrogen as a road transport fuel is taking its first steps to becoming commercially available in the UK. Hydrogen can be used to power a vehicle by burning it in an engine or to generate electricity through a Fuel Cell. Hydrogen is stored on a vehicle in compressed gas cylinders. Hydrogen vans are currently available in the following two retro-fit formats:
Dual fuel diesel-hydrogen can be fitted to large vans. In this system hydrogen and diesel are mixed in the engine and burnt together.
Fuel cell range extender can be fitted to a battery electric van. Here hydrogen is used to generate electricity on-board the vehicle to extend the van’s daily range.
Fit for Purpose
• Currently the number of hydrogen refuelling stations in the UK is very limited, thereby limiting the area in which a vehicle can be used (see ‘Links To Further Information’ at the end of this guide for a list of hydrogen stations).
• Using hydrogen in a dual fuel engine offers up to 200 miles hydrogen range, with the ability to then operate in normal diesel mode if a hydrogen station is not available.
• When used as a range extender hydrogen can double the range of a battery electric van.
• Payload is reduced by around 10% due to the additional weight of the hydrogen tanks but load space is normally not affected.
Environmental Performance
• Hydrogen releases no tailpipe CO2 when used to power a vehicle, and when used in a fuel
cell only water vapour is emitted.
• When hydrogen is combusted along-side other fuels, such as diesel, the hydrogen proportion reduces the vehicle’s tailpipe emissions.
• The fuel life cycle CO2 emissions of hydrogen vans depend on how the hydrogen is
manufactured and the technology used on the van. It can be worse than diesel when manufactured from fossil fuels (brown hydrogen), or have a very low carbon intensity when made from renewable energy (green hydrogen).
• In the whole life cost example opposite, the fuel cell range extended vehicle results in a 40% reduction in life cycle emissions when using brown hydrogen and a 50% saving against the diesel van when using green hydrogen.
Market Status
• The hydrogen van market is currently in its infancy with few fleets operating vehicles, however a number of new models have been released as the supporting infrastructure is commissioned across the UK. Retro-fit hydrogen systems are available from companies like ULEMCo and SymbioFCell.
• Hydrogen fuel and vans are currently more expensive than their diesel equivalent. Costs can be reduced when purchase grants are available and when operated in areas where environmental charges and restrictions are in place (such as the London Congestion Zone – see whole life cost example opposite).
• Hydrogen is seen as a key part of improving the environmental impact of transport and as such the UK Government and the EU offer funded demonstration activity that fleets can get involved in. See the ‘Getting Involved’ section at the end of this guide.
Environmental performance
(compared to diesel)
Tailpipe CO2
100% saving from
hydrogen use
Fuel life cycle CO2
Variable, depending
on hydrogen
manufacture and
vehicle technology
Good for air quality
Low noise
Operational performance
Miles on full tank
Technology
dependent
Ideal operation
City, suburbs,
limited motorway,
good access to
infrastructure
required
Example fleet
City courier, delivery,
service engineer
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 20 25/11/2016 08:52
20 21
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Topic Sheet 6 (continued) Hydrogen Vans
Whole Life Cost Example
Kangoo Maxi
1.5dCi 90PS
(Diesel)
HyKangoo ZE Maxi (Battery Electric
with SymbioFCell Hydrogen Fuel Cell
Range Extender)
Vehicle:
2.2t Hydrogen Fuel Cell Range
Extended EV Van
Annual mileage:
20,000 miles (75 miles per day)
Ownership period:
5 years
Cost saving:
£1,413 if used daily in the London
Congestion Charging Zone
The example shows a saving is available from the fuel cell range extended battery electric
van. The plug-in van grant, EU grant and daily free entry into the London Congestion Charging Zone combine to offer a positive
total cost of ownership.
In this example the vehicle covers 65 miles per day using electricity stored in the battery
through normal charging and 10 miles per day using electricity generated on-board from the
hydrogen range extender.
The range extender allows the whole capacity of the EV battery to be used every day, taking
full advantage of low cost grid electricity.
Because the cost of hydrogen from refuelling stations is currently high, cost savings will diminish if more miles are driven using the
on-board hydrogen fuel cell.
Vehicle £15,296 £45,899
Plug-in van grant discount £5,436
H2ME Grant discount £7,500
Fuel costs £9,268 £3,328
Road tax £700 £0
Maintenance costs £4,260 £5,385
Resale value £1,975 £4,225
Life time cost £27,549 £39,999
Cost per mile 27.5p 39.3p
Whole life cost savings Not Available
If used in the London Congestion Zone (5 days /week )
Life time cost £40,674 £39,261
Whole life cost savings £1,413
How we calculated the whole life cost and emissions
All costs exclude VAT. Purchase Cost manufacturer’s data. H2ME Grant European vehicle subsidy (administered by vehicle supplier). Fuel Consumption diesel manufacturer’s literature with a 20% real-world small panel van uplift factor applied, battery electric daily range from real-world fleet data, fuel cell consumption from manufacturer’s data. Fuel Cost diesel 2015 average @ £0.96 per litre, electricity @ £0.11 per kWh, Hydrogen @ £10 per kg (Auto Express) Maintenance Cost Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool + £225 per annum for range extender Resale Value Commercial Fleet Van Running Cost tool + £2,250 buy back guarantee from SymbioFCell.
Case Study
The Commercial Group are a business service supply company with a strong environmental focus. Taking advantage of grant funding mechanisms to subsidise vehicle deployment the company now operate nine retro-fit dual fuel diesel-hydrogen Transit vans supplied by ULEMCo, which accounts for around half of their van fleet. The vans emit just 59g/km of CO
2 (over the regulated test cycle) meaning they are eligible for a 100% London Congestion Charge discount.
Commercial Group’s Andrew McKenzie explains the other benefits they are seeing operating the vehicles ‘Much of our new sales interest and existing customer base look to our environmental commitments when awarding contracts, which is very much part of our USP.’ Andrew continues ‘operating with dual fuel technology, and retaining the ability to have pure diesel operation as a fall back, was important to us in what remains an emerging hydrogen market’. Commercial Group operate the vans over repeatable delivery routes where access to public hydrogen refuelling stations is possible.
Next steps Go to the ‘What to do next?’ section at the end of this guide to find links to the further van advice sites and tools, including a link to biodiesel station locations and pricing.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 21 25/11/2016 08:52
Go to www.lowcvp.org.uk/lev
22 23
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Best Practice - Making Existing Van Operations More Efficient
Whatever type of vans and fuels are used in your organisation,
focusing on understanding the day-to-day van performance and
making it more efficient will help to reduce fuel costs and emissions.
Fuel ManagementUnderstanding fuel usage in your fleet is the first step in reducing it. You could appoint a ‘Fuel Champion’ who will monitor and track fuel use and costs and drive fuel efficiency improvements.
Environmental
Benchmarking
Get involved with and learn best practice from other fleet operators. You can join a benchmarking scheme, such as EcoStars, or join one of the fleet operator associations.
Driver BehaviourThe first easy win when reducing fuel costs is through encouraging employees to drive more economically. This not only reduces your fuel bills, but has the additional effects of reduced accidents and maintenance costs.
Vehicle Maintenance
Maintaining your vehicles properly helps to keep them running efficiently. For example, a 20% drop in tyre pressure can result in a 2% increase in fuel consumption. Tyre labels provide an easy to understand indicator of tyre performance when it comes to fuel economy and wet grip.
Telematics
Installing telematics onto vehicles gives you an insight into your working patterns, allowing more efficient routing of vehicles, elimination of non-business mileage, highlighting areas for improvements, and vehicle or driver based performance reporting.
Eco Technology
A growing number of fuel reduction retro-fit technologies are available for fleet vehicles. The systems should save money and emissions and a reputable system provider should be able to prove this to you before you part with your money.
Driver aids such as the Ashwoods Lightfoot system, provide real time visual and audible feedback to the driver, improving driving behaviour which commonly results in CO
2 and fuel savings of between 10% and 20%. The system sends regular performance
reports to drivers and managers.
Speed limiters reduce fuel consumption by reducing the maximum driving speed. Driving at 70mph uses 9% more fuel than at 60mph and driving at 80mph uses 25% more fuel than driving at 70mph.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 22 25/11/2016 08:52
22 23
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Low Emission Van Summary Matrix
The differences between the low emission van technologies discussed in this guide are summarised in the table
below. Key: Better than Diesel Similar to Diesel
Battery Electric PHEVCNG /
BiomethaneLPG
B30 Biodiesel
(30% Biodiesel
blend in
diesel)
Hydrogen
Whole life cost
Dependent on grant funding available to support early
market deploymentCost improvements dependent on annual mileage and ownership period
Financial
incentives
Vehicle and infrastructure funding. 100% London congestion charge discount. Regional council
schemes for discounted/free parking.
Reduced fuel duty rate
Reduced fuel duty rate
NoneNo fuel duty applied to hydrogen
Enhanced capital allowance OR Van grant on purchase. Reduced van benefit charge until
2020. No fuel duty applied. £0 road tax
No fuel duty applied to electricity
Market statusAvailable, around 15
models
One vehicle model only (Outlander
4Work)
Two models available
Conversions available for petrol vans
Some models warranted
for biodiesel use
Two retro-fit technologies
available
Example vehiclesNissan e-NV200, Renualt Kangoo, BD Auto eTrafic
Mitsubishi Outlander
4Work
Merc Sprinter, Iveco Daily
RetrofitPeugeot
Partner, Boxer
SymbioFCell (Fuel cell range
extended electric vans), ULEMCo
(dual fuel hydrogen-diesel)
Ideal operating
locationCity, suburbs
City, suburbs and occasional
motorwayCity, suburbs, motorway
Ideal refuelling
locationBack-to-base No restrictions Back-to-base
City, suburbs and occasional
motorway
Example useCity courier, light delivery and service
engineerCity and long distance courier, delivery, service engineer
City courier, delivery and
service engineer
Range between
refuelling
60 - 80 miles (small van),
80 - 100 miles (large van)
Around 30
electric miles, then petrol
reserve
Up to 300 miles, then petrol
reserve
Up to 300miles, miles, then
petrol reserve
Similar
Up to 150 - 200 miles between
hydrogen refuels
(technology dependent)
Payload impact5-25% reduction (model
dependent)
20% reduction
10% reduction
Similar
Similar
10% reduction
Refuelling
considerations
Public charging available but limited. Variable
charging times. Petrol reserve for plug-in hybrid
Limited public infrastructure
wWidespread infrastructure
Limited public infrastructure
Very limited public
infrastructure
Tailpipe CO2
emissions from
the vehicle
Zero emission
Zero emission when in battery electric mode
Similar when using natural gas
100% when using
biomethane
14% saving from petrol
28% saving
100% from pure hydrogen
operation
Fuel lifecycle CO2
emissions
35% saving
35% saving when in battery electric mode
Similar when using natural gas
over 60% from biomethane
20% saving from petrol
26% saving
Dependent on technology
and hydrogen source
Air quality
emissions
Zero emission
Zero emission when in battery electric mode
Good for air quality emissions
Good for air quality emissions
Similar
Good for air quality emissions
Ultra-Low Emission
Vehicle statusYes Yes No No No Yes
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 23 25/11/2016 08:52
24 25
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
What To Do Next?Getting involved
Becoming an active part of the low emission van community
will help you to make the right decisions for your fleet.
The thought of moving your van or fleet to a new technology can be daunting. Sharing your concerns with
like-minded operators and talking to fleets who are already operating low emission vans will help to inform your
decisions and build confidence in the technologies. Below are just a few examples of the things you can do to
enable you to become more familiar with your low emission van choices.
Fleet operator associations Get involved with and join one of the fleet operator associations.
Attend workshops
and events
Organisations such as Fleet News, Freight in the City and the Energy Saving Trust hold events and webinars that inform the industry of lower carbon options.
Trial alternative
technologies
Talk to your local dealer and ask if you can have a trial vehicle on loan. Assess the benefits for yourself.
You can contact your council or transport authority to understand if there are any local schemes which could
benefit you. Funding from central government is being given to local projects, for example.
Go-Ultra Low Cities Four UK cities (Nottingham, Bristol, Milton Keynes and London) have all
received funding to become exemplar cities in green technology and promote the use of plug-in
vehicles.
LoCity is a 5-year programme by TfL to accelerate the adoption of low emission commercial
vehicles in London. This includes the demonstration of vehicle and fuelling solutions, followed by
mass rollout as the vehicles’ real-world applicability is proven.
Operators are encouraged to get involved in LoCity industry working groups to assist TfL in making effective policy
and programme decisions, guiding and taking part in technology demonstrations, infrastructure placement and
the development of procurement requirements.
Case Study - Making the most of funding
The Commercial Group are a business service supply company with a strong environmental focus. The company wanted to act as a pioneer by integrating innovative future focused low carbon technology into their fleet. Following a successful trial of an early demonstration retro-fit hydrogen Transit van in 2012, the company investigated ways of introducing this technology into fleet operations. With a focus on reducing the ownership costs of operating the vans, Commercial Group partnered with the vehicle supplier to bid for UK research, development and demonstration funding. After successfully winning funding through two separate programmes, they now operate retro-fit dual fuel diesel-hydrogen Transit vans out of their depots in London and Swindon. Commercial Group’s Andrew McKenzie comments ‘Introducing these vans into commercial operations was not an overnight decision. We started with a short duration trial and over the years as we have become more confident in the technology and supply chain we have gradually increased the number of vans we operate’.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 24 25/11/2016 08:52
24 25
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Assess The Savings For Yourself
The VC3 Van Cost & Carbon CalculatorReview the cost and carbon performance of low emission vans over your operating conditions by entering some
simple information into the VC3 Van Cost & Carbon Calculator. The tool will present you with a tailored report
showing the cost and emission impact of operating different types of vans in your fleet.
Pick your
• van size
• typical driving routes
• driving style
• payload
• congestion charge payment
• number of years you want
to own your vehicle
• annual mileage
Discover your
• whole life cost savings
• emission savings
Van Cost & CarbonCalculator
Go to www.lowcvp.org.uk/lev
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 25 25/11/2016 08:52
26 27
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Links To Further Information
Some useful links to further information on each topic covered in this guide are provided below, once you
have done some of your own research, it’s time to contact your local dealer and start saving money, saving the
environment and improving your fleet image!
General Advice And Calculator Tools
www.lowcvp.org.uk/levThe Low Emission Van Hub on the LowCVP website provides advice for operators looking to make the switch to low emission vans.
www.cenex.co.uk/vc3Cenex provides a tool for allowing operators to calculate emission and cost savings available from alternatively fuelled vans
www.vanchooser.netVan Chooser allows users to search for a van type that meets their requirements and can display list price, emission performance, fuel costs and much more
http://www.commercialfleet.
org/tools/van/running-costs/
The Commercial Fleet website has whole life cost and emission calculator tools, best practice case studies and much more
www.ukconversionfactors
carbonsmart.co.uk
The UK Conversion Factors site provides official UK Government recommended factors for converting your fuel use into carbon emissions
Battery Electric And Plug-In Hybrid Electric Vehicles
www.zap-map.comZap Map contains a list of publically available charge points, vehicle model availability and charge point provider contact details
www.goultralow.comThe Go Ultra Low web site provides information about switching to ultra-low emission vehicles and vehicle availability
www.ukevse.org.ukUKEVSE, the electric vehicle supply equipment association, provide a guide for procuring charge points including equipment considerations and location choice
www.gov.uk/government/
publications/plug-in-van-grant
The Office for Low Emission Vehicles (OLEV) provides a list of vans that are eligible for the Plug-in Van Grant
LPG Vehicles
www.drivelpg.co.ukDrive LPG provides advice and information about converting to LPG including a list of approved installers and UK refuelling stations
CNG Vehicles
www.gasvehiclehub.orgThe Gas Vehicle Hub provides a map of UK CNG refuelling stations, a list of vehicle model availability and gas vehicle case studies plus much more
Biodiesel Vehicles
www.biodieselfillingstations
.co.uk
Biodiesel Filling Stations provides a list of filling stations and biodiesel blends available by UK area, with links to suppliers websites where many show pricing and other information
Hydrogen Vehicles
www.netinform.net/H2/
H2Stations
A map showing the location of UK (and global) hydrogen filling stations, with supporting information
The information and advice given is based on a range of public domain sources, data supplied by companies, in-house knowledge and analysis
and engagement with stakeholders. While the information is provided in good faith, the ideas and analysis presented in this guide report must
be subject to further investigation, and take into account other factors not presented here, before being taken forward. Therefore the authors
disclaim liability for any investment decisions made on the basis of this guide.
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 26 25/11/2016 08:52
26 27
The Low Emission Van Guide The Low Emission Van Guide
Notes
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 27 25/11/2016 08:52
The Low EmissionVan Guide
Helping van operatorsto reduce costs and emissions
Low CarbonVehicle Partnership
3 Birdcage WalkLondonSW1H 9JJ
[email protected] I www.lowcvp.org.uk+44 (0)20 7304 6880
CENEX
Advanced TechnologyInnovation CentreOakwood Drive, LoughboroughLeicestershire LE11 3QF
[email protected] I www.cenex.co.uk+44 (0)1509 635750
The LowCVP, which was established in 2003, is a public-private partnership working to accelerate a sustainable
shift to lower carbon vehicles and fuels and create opportunities for UK business. Around 200 organisations
are engaged from diverse backgrounds including automotive and fuel supply chains, vehicle users, academics,
environment groups and others.
LowCVP members have the opportunity to:
• Connect: With privileged access to information, you’ll gain insight into low carbon vehicle policy
development and into the policy process.
• Collaborate: You’ll benefit from many opportunities to work – and network - with key UK and EU
government, industry, NGO and other stakeholders.
• Influence: You’ll be able to initiate proposals and help to shape future low carbon vehicle policy,
programmes and regulations.
Cenex was established in 2005 as the UK’s first Centre of Excellence for Low Carbon and Fuel Cell technologies. Cenex was established in 2005 as the UK’s first Centre of Excellence for Low Carbon and Fuel Cell technologies. Cenex
Today Cenex operates as an independent not-for-profit consultancy specialising in the delivery of projects,
supporting innovation and market development, focused on low carbon vehicles and associated energy
infrastructure.
ConnectCollaborate Influence
LCVP_Guide_24pp_cx6154.indd 28 25/11/2016 08:51