battling the bulge some immodest proposals
TRANSCRIPT
Battling the bulge:some immodest proposals
for tackling obesity
Stephen S Holden
www.halfamind2.com
24 Nov 2016
2
Food, glorious food !
3
Food, glorious food
"Any pleasure that does no harm to other people is to be
valued."
Bertrand Russell, The Conquest of Happiness, p.107
4
Food, glorious food !
5
Is it right to act ?
6
“Good” for who ?Self
– right way to live• “flourishing”
“ethics”
Others– right way to treat
others• cooperation /
compassion
“morals”“It is an ethical matter what colour you paint your house, but it is not a moral matter” -- A.C. Grayling (2005)
7
Self-harm ?
Moderate obesity -3yrs |Morbid obesity -10yrs | Smoking -10 yrs
Peto et al. 2010 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc1000079#t=article
8
Harm (costs) to others…
– obesity costs Australian taxpayers >$5.3b/yr• approximately $230/Australian
– obese more likely to • go to doctors• admitted to hospital• be unemployed and therefore, pay less tax
Grattan Institute, http://grattan.edu.au/why-we-should-tax-sugary-soft-drinks/, 23 Nov 16
9
Van Baal et al. (2008) “Lifetime m
edical costs of obesity: Prevention no cure for increasing health expenditure”
Annual vs lifetime costs ?
- annual health-care costs are highest for
- obese people earlier in life (<56 yrs)- smokers at older ages
- lifetime costs highest for -same for obese and non-obese- non-smokers !
10
Red herrings ?• growth• marketers seek
profits, wieldundue influence,behave unethically
• consensus• authority
Food for thought…or not ?
11
12
What is the right action ?
13
P1: do nothing !
14
Proportional
obesity kills…–2.8 million people /
yrhttp://
easo.org/education-portal/obesity-facts-figures
malnutrition kills…–3.1 million people /
yrhttps://www.wfp.org/hunger/stats
most under 5 yrs of age !
15
Effective actions
STRONG
Weak
16
Secrets of the food industry
The Science of Addictive Food, CBC, March 6, 2013
18
Which one do you want ?
19
The “secret” of marketing
Morebigger
tastier, shinier, brighter, etc.
Less$
efforttime
Consumers want …
for
20
“Convenience”
less effort & / or less time
fast-foodmedicines (Olestra), diets,
trainers/classes
motorised transportremote controls
Google, streaming, online videos
21
Conflicting desires …
22
Hyperbolic discounting
« on est plus longtemps mort
que vivant »« YOLO ! »
24
P2: sleep with the enemy
25
Make it “look” bigger
26
Make it “look” better
Rolls, Roe, Meengs 2006
27
Make it “look” better
Rolls, Roe, Meengs 2006
29
“Looks” bigger
Holden 2014 “Use your illusion”
30
31
P3: fat tax
32
Consumers want an “out”
• “[Our culture] simultaneously incentivizes people to gain weight and stigmatizes them when they do”
• “…and then offers the bullshit promise of instant weight loss through some miracle diet or incredible exercise secret.”
http://www.vox.com/2015/7/7/8877041/losing-100-pounds
33
Fat tax
Fast food Fasting
34
Some immodest proposals
Do nothing !………….
Sleep with the enemy
Fat tax
Battling the bulge:some immodest proposals
for tackling obesity
Stephen S Holden
www.halfamind2.com
http://www.slideshare.net/StephenSHolden/