berardi community owned solutions
TRANSCRIPT
Community Owned Solutions
Andrea Berardi The Open University, UK
Indigenous communities are frequently portraid as ‘undeveloped’
and in need of external assistance in health, education,
employment, agriculture. Or, at the other extreme, to be left
isolated.
Perception of indigenous communities
The Deficit Model proposes that communities lack appropriate
knowledge for managing their problems, and need to be
informed and educated by professional experts.
Models of Development: Deficit
Indigenous communities have the expertise and local knowledge to resolve problems.
Models of Development: Lay Expertise
What is a ‘community owned solution’?
• Local demand.• Locally executed.• Local beneficiaries. • Limited external assistance.• Positive long-term impact on the socio-ecological environment.
Dengue control
“Explore, record and share
‘community-owned
solutions’ for
environmental and social
challenges using
Information and
Communication
Technologies’
Project COBRA
Guiana Shield
Project COBRA communities
Project COBRA approach
Systematic Systemic
Onto-epistemology
Reductionist, positivist, mechanistic
Holistic, constructivist, ecological
Environment perceived to be...
Stable, predictable, controllable,
Complex, dynamic, unpredictable
Decision-making control
Top-down, international conventions
Participative, local
Organizational principles
Hierarchical,competitive
Consensual,cooperative
Communication
Written, numerical Oral, visual
Solutions Technocentric, ‘quick-fix’
Behavioural,experimental and adaptive
System Viability
Process
1. History
2. Challenges
3. Solutions
4. Indicators
5. Thresholds
6. Best practices
7. Share
History
Challenges
Solutions
indicators
Thresholds
Best practices
Share
A visual approach to communication
• Visual immagery promotes more relaxed and active participation.
• Visual imagery is more accessible than the written and spoken word.
‘Rich Pictures’
Storyboarding
Photostories
Participatory Video
Sharing Community Owned
Solutions
Some results
Community owned solutions of the North Rupununi, Guyana
Transmission of culture to youth
Farming techniques
Local CSO and partnerships
Community self-help
Sustainable fishing
New communication technologies
Policy
Social Enterprise
‘A social enterprise is a business with primarily social objectives whose surpluses are principally reinvested for that purpose in the business or in the community, rather than being driven by the need to maximise profit for shareholders and owners' (Department for Business Innovation and Skills, 2011)
Social Enterprise
Social Enterprise and Universities
"As this area of enterprise continues to grow it offers an opportunity for universities to strengthen community ties, support businesses, develop graduate skills and open up alternative career paths."
(Universities UK, 2012, Universities enabling social enterprise : Delivering benefits for all. p.3)
Community Interest Company
• Set up in July 2005 to give SEs a ‘branded’ business structure, and encourage external investment.
• Cost £35 – apply to CIC Regulator.• Needs a community interest statement and
pass the community interest test.• Asset lock - assets will only be used for
social/ecological objectives• Accounts, and community interest report, each
year.
Cobra Collective CIC
“Community: we enable communities to identify their own solutions;
Technology: we use technologies to record, evaluate and share best practices;
Environment: we bridge traditional knowledge and environmental science.”
Business model
• Training: 1, 2 and 5-day courses;
• Implementation: support clients in identifying and
sharing community owned solutions;
• Research: impact; effectiveness; policies; ICTs.
Impact research
(Source: Hansen et al. 2013. “Hansen/UMD/Google/USGS/NASA Tree Cover Loss and Gain Area.” University of Maryland, Google, USGS, and NASA. Accessed through Global Forest Watch on [16/01/15]. www.globalforestwatch.org)
10 km
Rupertee, Guyana Apoteri, Guyana Fairview, Guyana Kwamalasamutu, Suriname
Kavanayén, Venezuela
Laguna Colorada, Colombia
Antecuma Pata, French Guiana
Katoonarib, Guyana
Maturuca, Brazil Missão Tiriyo, Brazil
COBRA Project: www.projectcobra.orgCobra Collective: www.cobracollective.org
It’s more than just ‘fishing’….
Need to incorporate sustainable resource management practicesfor promoting ecosystem integrity and food security
Need to promotemodels where local CSOs are supported
to take a leadership role in the developmentof their own communities
Need to guarantee crop and farm
diversity to ensure forest conservation
and food sovereignty
Need greater focus
on maintaining youth inclusion insocial-ecological
community activities to
ensure stewardship in
the future
Need to incorporate ‘social capital’
to reinforce sustainable natural
resource management
Need to provide representation and
voice to communities, using new
communication tools, for social-ecological sustainability, and
input into public decision-making
Some results