beth avraham yoseph of toronto ...when minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the...

12
Mara D’Asra Rabbi Daniel Korobkin Associate Rabbi Rabbi Zev Spitz Rabbi Emeritus Rabbi Baruch Taub Executive Director Morris Maron President Zac Kaye PARSHAS MISHPATIM BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO CONGREGATION ק" ק בית אברהם יוסףTHE JOSEPH AND FAYE TANENBAUM A Family Synagogue Emphasizing SYNAGOGUE CENTRE the Warmth of Torah Tradition SHAVUOS EDITION MAY 28 - 30, 2020 5 SIVAN 5780 BAYT WEEKLY BULLETIN שבועותפ" תש סיון הMAZEL TOV TO: Rachelle Frankel and Peter Frankel, Larry Silver and Bettes Silver on the birth of a grandson, Nadav Lev Frankel, a son to Tamara Frankel & Rabbi Zachary Silver. Mazel tov to the great grandmother Sylvia Wolynetz. Dr. Michael & Meira Kirzner on the birth of a grandchild, a daughter to Zahava & Moshe Goldfeiz. Tolly & Kalman Weber, Brian and Shirley Belzberg on the birth of a grandson Yaakov Gadol, a son to Rachel and Yehuda Belzberg. Mazel tov to the great grandparents Cooky and Sholem Horowitz. Tolly & Kalman Weber on the upcoming wedding of their son Yisrael to Sara Ben Haim of Jerusalem. Mazel tov to Ronit and Yossi Lustgarten, the grandparents Cooky and Sholem Horowitz and Shoshana Katabi. Earliest time for Tallis & Tefillin : Sun - Fri: 4:37am - 4:39 am Sof Zman Krias Shema: Sun - Fri: 9:27 am WEEKDAY SCHEDULE | זמני השבועFor the full Shavuos and Shabbos schedules please see pages 2 & 3. THANK YOU: Marcee Rosenzweig and all the volunteers who helped deliver plants to our seniors for Shavuos. Florence Dimant for organizing the flowers and cheesecakes for Shavuos and for the volunteers who helped distribute them. PAGE NUMBERS FOR SHAVUOS - TORAH/HAFTARAH READING Artscroll Siddur Torah Reading Maftir Haftarah Shavuos Day 1 Page 966 Page 968 Page 968 Shavuos Day 2 Page 965 Page 968 Page 969

Upload: others

Post on 13-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

שמיני

Mara D’Asra Rabbi Daniel Korobkin Associate Rabbi Rabbi Zev Spitz Rabbi Emeritus Rabbi Baruch Taub

Executive Director Morris Maron President Zac Kaye

ohypan ,arp

ohfrcn ,ca u"ga, yca zf

PARSHAS MISHPATIM FEB 5-6, 2016

27 SHEVAT 5776 BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO CONGREGATION ק בית אברהם יוסף"ק

THE JOSEPH AND FAYE TANENBAUM A Family Synagogue Emphasizing

SYNAGOGUE CENTRE the Warmth of Torah Tradition

SHAVUOS EDITION MAY 28 - 30, 2020

5 SIVAN 5780

BAYT WEEKLY BULLETIN

שבועות ה סיון תש"פ

MAZEL TOV TO:

Rachelle Frankel and Peter Frankel, Larry Silver and Bettes Silver on the birth of a grandson, Nadav Lev

Frankel, a son to Tamara Frankel & Rabbi Zachary Silver. Mazel tov to the great grandmother Sylvia

Wolynetz.

Dr. Michael & Meira Kirzner on the birth of a grandchild, a daughter to Zahava & Moshe Goldfeiz.

Tolly & Kalman Weber, Brian and Shirley Belzberg on the birth of a grandson Yaakov Gadol, a son to

Rachel and Yehuda Belzberg. Mazel tov to the great grandparents Cooky and Sholem Horowitz.

Tolly & Kalman Weber on the upcoming wedding of their son Yisrael to Sara Ben Haim of Jerusalem.

Mazel tov to Ronit and Yossi Lustgarten, the grandparents Cooky and Sholem Horowitz and Shoshana Katabi.

Earliest time for Tallis & Tefillin : Sun - Fri: 4:37am - 4:39 am

Sof Zman Krias Shema: Sun - Fri: 9:27 am

WEEKDAY SCHEDULE | זמני השבוע

For the full Shavuos and Shabbos schedules please see pages 2 & 3.

THANK YOU: Marcee Rosenzweig and all the volunteers who helped deliver plants to our seniors for Shavuos.

Florence Dimant for organizing the flowers and cheesecakes for Shavuos and for the volunteers who helped distribute them.

PAGE NUMBERS FOR SHAVUOS - TORAH/HAFTARAH

READING

Artscroll Siddur Torah Reading Maftir Haftarah

Shavuos Day 1 Page 966 Page 968 Page 968

Shavuos Day 2 Page 965 Page 968 Page 969

Page 2: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

SCHEDULE

Page 3: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

SCHEDULE

Page 4: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

THIS WEEK’S SCHEDULE & ANNOUNCEMENTS

DONATIONS: We are taking donations for online shiurim and event dedications. If you'd like to dedicate a shiur or

event in memory or honor of a loved one, please contact Morris Maron at [email protected] or Avital

Sandler at [email protected]

Shiur Sponsorships: Thank you to the sponsors of our Tikkun Leil Program:

*Our lead program sponsors, Mordie and Zahava Shields, in memory of Mordie's father, Dr. Yehudi Pesach Shields z"l.

*Rabbi Martin and Marylin Berman, sponsoring the Sisterhood shiur in memory of Marylin's mother, Hindel bat Yisrael, z"l, and her father, Yehuda

Avraham ben Shmuel z"l.

*Howard & Roz English, sponsoring the Rav's shiur, in commemoration of the yarzheit of Roz's father, Yaakov Shalom ben Yeshaya Halevi z"l.

*Marvin and Roberta Newman, sponsoring the Sisterhood shiur, commemorating the yarzheit of Roberta's father, Yehuda Tzvi ben Moshe z"l.

*Mindy Newman, sponsoring the Sisterhood shiur in honour of her father, Avram Ben Menachem Mendel HaCohen z”l and mother, Yehudit bas

David z"l and in honour and appreciation of all my dear friends who are always there for me.

*Dr. Harold and Michal Reiter, sponsoring the Sisterhood shiur, in admiration of the ongoing efforts by the Rabbanim, the Office Staff and the Shul

Volunteers in the extraordinary work they continue to perform under trying circumstances.

*Abie & Yaffa Rosenberg and Irene Rosenberg, sponsoring the Brotherhood Siyum, in memory of Abie's father & Irene's husband - Harav

Yehoshua Arieh ben Rav Yoel Zusman z"l, Abie's grandfather-Rav Yoel Zusman ben Yehudah Menachem z"l, Abie's grandmother-Reizel bas Rav

Yehoshua Arieh z"l, Irene's father-Rav Shlomo ben Yeshay z"l, Yaffa's father-Rav Shmuel ben Amram z"l and Yaffa's grandmother- Jamila bas

Shmuel z"l.

*Jerry & Anne Tollinsky, in commemoration of the yahrzeit of Jerry's Mother, Golda Rachel bat Shraga Feivel z"l.

*Anonymous in appreciation of Ezer Diena and for all that he does for our community.

Thank you to the following sponsors of shiurim & programs:

Gedalia & Chava Rutman, in honour of the birth of our son, Akiva Meir, and in appreciation to his Papa, Rabbi Korobkin, for performing the Bris.

Howard & Nancy Wasserman, in honour of the marriage of our daughter Maya Wasserman to Yoav Vodianoi.

Andy & Elke Gelberger, in memory of Andy & Elke's family who perished in the Holocaust at Auschwitz - Elka Beck z"l, grandmother of Elke,

Alexander Zusha Beck z"l, uncle of Elke, Esther Malka Beck z"l, aunt of Elke, Raiza Beck z"l, aunt of Elke, Shaindel Beck z"l, aunt of Elke, and of

Yehuda Aryeh Gelberger z"l, grandfather of Andy, Sarah Gelberger z"l, grandmother of Andy, Mordechai Gelberger z"l, uncle of Andy, Menachem

Gelberger z"l, uncle of Andy, and Miriam Yenta Gelberger z"l, aunt of Andy.

Nonny & Susan Beckerman, in memory of Nonny's father, Moshe Ben Shmuel Eliezar z"l.

Howard & Francine Kurlandski, to commemorate the Yarzheit of Francine's mother, Eva Hartstein, Rella bat Menachem z"l.

David & Nina Bernstein, in honour of Rabbi & Karen Korobkin.

PLEASE CLICK HERE TO DONATE

TO OUR SPECIAL YIZKOR APPEAL

If you have children or grandchildren currently serving in the IDF please email [email protected] and we will add them to a list

to be kept in mind during davening. Please send in their Hebrew name and the mother's Hebrew name.

Thank You .

NAMES TO KEEP IN MIND:

Ariel Abraham ben Tova Rivka, Eli Yaakov ben Gavriela, Esther Shoshana Netanya bat Malka Batya,

Miya Rachel Devorah bat Yehudit Chaya Sarah, Yonatan Menachem Dodi Ben Aura Chaya, Zacharya Zalman Ben Chana

Page 5: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

THIS WEEK’S SHIURIM AVAILABLE ONLINE

Choshen Mishpat Halacha shiur- Beginning Monday, April 27 daily at 6:30 am https://bit.ly/ChoshenMishpat

Rabbi Eisenberger's shiur - Monday to Friday: Start at 11am weekdays https://zoom.us/j/442539932 or phone either 647.558.0588 or 647.374.2685 Use Meeting ID 442 399 932 followed by # twice

Rabbi Torczyner - Gemara Avodah Zarah, Sunday evenings 7:30 PM https://us04web.zoom.us/j/165452920 and the password is 18.

@929 shiur - Monday at 8 p.m. Anyone interested can get the Zoom link by emailing [email protected]

Moreh Nevukhim on FaceBook Live with Rabbi Korobkin - Monday morning at 7:30 am https://www.facebook.com/webyeshiva/

Daf Yomi daily at 7:30am https://zoom.us/j/346757508

Daf Yomi daily at 8:45pm https://us02web.zoom.us/j/85771992923

Tuesday Morning Ladies' Kuzari+Parsha Shiur with Rabbi Korobkin, Tuesday at 10:00am https://us04web.zoom.us/j/102632319

Monday night Talmud Class with Rabbi Yeres - 8:30 pm starting March 23 (Masechet Shabbat ch 13 ) https://us04web.zoom.us/j/436290389?pwd=WTZoWjZuWDhIdlI0bGlmQVNIREpLZz09

Seder Boker for men with Rabbi Yeres - starting Wednesday March 18- Mon,Tues, Wed and Thurs 10:00 am - noon https://us04web.zoom.us/j/1007858

A Business Ethics Lunchtime Series- Shiurim with Rabbi Torczyner and Beit Midrash Zichron Dov, Wednesday at 12:30pm www.torontotorah.com/letslearn or at the link:https://bit.ly//bmlunches Password 18

Thursday night Chassidus, 8 pm https://us02web.zoom.us/j/601631681

" ALONE TOGETHER AT SINAI" PACKET- PLEASE CLICK HERE

ANNOUNCEMENTS

Weekly Halachah - R’ Mordechai Torczyner – [email protected]

When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed?

There has been great disagreement about this question. Aside from the shortcomings of the human attention span and the

safety of being in close proximity to other people for an extended time, it is unclear that such a make-up is even

necessary.

Four reasons are offered for exemption from all or part of the missed readings:

1) The weekly Torah reading may be considered a communal obligation, and not a personal one. Therefore, if no

minyan met on Shabbat, then there was no obligation to read.

2) Each Shabbat is linked to a designated reading, so that when a minyan is restored, we do not have any obligation

to read the missed readings.

3) The weekly Torah reading was designed for only one or two Torah portions. Therefore, the maximum number of

portions to be read on a given Shabbat is two.

4) The Torah reading for a particular Shabbat is linked to just one chumash, and not the entire Torah. Therefore, one

may not read from more than one chumash of a particular Sefer Torah.

Classically, all four of these points have been debated. Today’s halachic authorities continue this debate, and so:

Sephardi Chief Rabbi Yitzchak Yosef, and Kollel Eretz Hemdah, believe that we reject all of the aforementioned

exemptions and limitations. Shuls are obligated to make up the missed readings, even across chumashim.

Rabbi Yosef Zvi Rimon, Rav of Alon Shvut South, contends that we are obligated to make up missed readings,

and that we may read more than two portions on a Shabbat. However, he supports the fourth point, that we may

not read from more than one chumash.

Rabbi Hershel Schachter states that shuls may rely on the lenient views and not make up the missed readings, but

those who wish to make them up may do so – even by spreading them out over multiple Shabbatot. The rule

which permits adding aliyot on Shabbat also permits adding unnecessary readings. However, we may not read

from more than one chumash of a particular Sefer Torah.

Rabbi Asher Weiss believes that shuls must rely on the lenient views and not make up the readings; he contends

that a minyan may not perform unnecessary readings.

The mara d’asra will announce the policy of BAYT closer to the time of re-opening.

Page 6: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

YAHRZEIT LIST:

FRIDAY, MAY 29 - THURSDAY, JUNE 4

ANNOUNCEMENTS

MEMBER NAME RELATIONSHIP TO

MEMBER

DECEASED NAME

Mr. Larry Wolynetz Father Leo Wolynetz

Ms. Rachelle Wolynetz-Frankel

Father Leo Wolynetz

Mrs. Sarah Schlar Mother Rachel Biner

Mrs. Roberta Newman Father Harry Lensky

Mr. David Blustein Grandfather Joseph Grossman

Mrs. Annie Samuel Grandmother Haviva bat Eliyahu v'Esther

Dr. Yitzchok Dukesz Mother Caroline Dukesz

Mr. Robert Dukes Mother Caroline Dukes

Mr. John Nebel Mother-In-Law Feiga Gitel Jakober

Mr. John Nebel Father-In-Law Nathan Jakober

Mr. Seymour Berger Grandmother Eva Hislop

Rabbi Baruch Taub Grandmother Gertrude Taub

Mrs. Irene Rosenberg Father Shlomo Seidenfeld

Mr. Alan Greenspan Uncle Yona Greenspan

Mrs. Jolan Preiss Father Vilmos (William) Hajnal Hirschfeld

Mrs. Violette Klein Father Vilmos (William) Hajnal Hirschfeld

Mrs. Hanna Gal Mother Henia Byk

Dr. Dorit Sova- Ansel Father David Sova

Mrs. Sherri Wise Father Morris Gurvey

Mrs. Rena Winegust father Sam Isenberg

Mr. Nonny Beckerman Father Moshe Beckerman

Mrs. Marylin Berman Mother Hilda Gottlieb

MEMBER NAME RELATIONSHIP TO

MEMBER

DECEASED NAME

Mr. Allan Schlar Father Sol Schlar

Mrs. Esther Wortzman Mother Sara Sultan

Mrs. Susan Friedmann Grandfather Menachem Dov Karfunkel

Mr. Gabor Friedmann Grandfather Jeno Friedman

Mr. Gabor Friedmann Grandmother Nettie Friedman

Mrs. Suri Rosen Mother Fay Pauline Epstein

Mr. Gabor Friedmann Grandfather Yechiel Grosz

Mr. Gabor Friedmann Grandmother Rochel Grosz

Mr. Howard Kurlandski Mother-in-law Eva Hartstein

Mrs. Susan Friedmann Grandmother Chana Karfunkel

Mr. Aaron Wapner Aunt Sara Arya

Mr. Rafael Riaboy Mother Perel Riaboy

Dr. Larry Mittelmann Grandmother Rose Greenspan

Mr. Youri Riaboy Mother Perel Riaboy

Mr. Melech Goldman Mother Jan Goldman

Mrs. Roslyn English Father Jack Tepperman

Mr. Ari Tenenbaum Mother Marcie Tenenbaum

Mr. Asher Breatross Mother Deborah Breatross

Mrs. Yvonne Berman Mother of Issy Leah Berman

Mrs. Marcee Rosenzweig Mother Rose Korolnek

Mrs. Zehava Abramovitch Father Zvi Tyberg

Mrs. Blanca Abramson Mother Helena Felber

Mr. Andy Gelberger Grandfather Eliyahu Klein

BAYT Whatsapp Groups

BAYT General Info: Updates of new events and important items that are worthy of your immediate attention:

https://chat.whatsapp.com/G7ybnaTmXYI33fqBJGHvLW

BAYT Torah: Get a regular d'var Torah on your WhatsApp from one of our rabbinic staff: https://

chat.whatsapp.com/L0jSnNXDMr79lwPgQJDWrc

BAYT Chesed Exchage: An open exchange for people looking to perform or receive a Chesed for/from other

BAYT members: https://chat.whatsapp.com/IW5ekf7Tzkh15VgLMkb4dz

BAYT Youth Group: Stay in touch and keep you updated on all the BAYT YOUTH programs and Youth

events: https://chat.whatsapp.com/C9CFoph2QFvDgmpGytaI2i

Page 7: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

ANNOUNCEMENTS

On behalf of the outgoing Executive and Board of Governors I want to wish you and your families a safe and

healthy Shavuot. It is hard to believe that we have been in lock down since just after Purim, and it is amazing

what our Rabbis and office team as well as many volunteers have done in terms of online classes, shiurim,

programs as well as volunteering to do shopping and calling members in particular our seniors.

The shul throughout these weeks has exemplified an important message of Shavuot, that of Chesed - of loving

kindness which is very much the theme of Megillat Ruth, and we have to thank Rabbi Korobkin for his

leadership , who together with Rabbi Spitz have spearheaded this amazing response. Sadly we remain closed

for Shavuot, even for services in the parking lot, and will do so until the Emergency Regulations are lifted.

Currently they are in place until June 9. We ask you to pay attention to the continuing requirements set down

by the Government, in particular that no large gatherings are permitted, and that groups are limited to a

maximum of FIVE people only, and of course continue to practice social distancing when out and about.

At our last Board Meeting in April, the Board approved the establishment of a task force to advise the

Executive and the Board on the measures that will be needed to deal with the financial challenges facing the

shul .The task force under the leadership of Chuck English comprised nine shul members with deep financial ,

legal management and communal experience. They have recommended a number of proposals that are being

reviewed by the Executive and the Board , and the steps that will need to be taken in the coming months that

will set the priorities for the incoming Board and Executive who will take office on June 7. I want to to thank

Chuck and the members of the Task Force for their diligence and devotion in producing such a comprehensive

and detailed document in 3 weeks that will be the blueprint for securing the long term sustainability of the

shul. Full details of the plan will be shared with the Kehilla in the coming weeks.

I want to thank the outgoing members of the Executive and Board who will be stepping down after giving of

their time and energy to the many facets of shul life they have been involved with. A new Board and

Executive will take office on June 7 at the AGM , and with the many challenges facing the world in general

and the Jewish Community in particular , I am sure you will join me in wishing them well in their delibera-

tions, and in taking the actions needed to secure the long term future of the shul.

The shul has risen to the many challenges posed by the pandemic, and going forward, as I have indicated ,we

have major decisions to make, but this is no different to any shul or Jewish Communal organisation in Canada

and elsewhere. Together as a Kehilla and the wider Jewish Community we can meet the challenges facing us ,

and hopefully soon we can look forward to being together in Shul to celebrate simchas, as well as being able

to comfort each other in times of sadness.

Zac Kaye

President

The Rav, Associate Rabbi, President, Executive Committee, Board Members and

Staff of BAYT take this opportunity to express our warmest wishes for a Chag

Samayach to all our members, their families and guests.

Page 8: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

ANNOUNCEMENTS

Page 9: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

Our shopping for seniors continues. BAYT has expanded its shopping services. Through an online form members and

non-members can place orders of up to 15 items for anything you may require, not just from Anthony's No Frills.

Click here to access: bit.ly/Chesed-vs-C19

PS we are still happy to shop for you from Anthony's NoFrills and charge your credit card on file.

If you're not sure how to proceed please contact Avital at avital@bayt

ANNOUNCEMENTS

To our valued community partners,

Thank you for your ongoing trust and commitment to public health during these very difficult times.

We recognize that faith is a very important source of comfort and support, especially today, and to be unable to

practice that faith with your communities is in and of itself an extra challenge. We thank you for remaining so

strong, apart.

We felt with the coming of many religious observances and holy days over the next few weeks it would be a

good time to connect with some gentle reminders and public health advice about COVID-19.

At this time, no large gatherings are permitted. Groups are to have a maximum of five (5) people only

Practice physical distancing and remain at least 2 metres/6 feet apart from people who do not live in your household

Wear masks if physical distancing cannot be maintained

Consider different ways to celebrate; for example, bring your community together around a shared cause and fundraise

for those in need or use technology to observe religious and holy days, together but apart

Again, we thank you for your leadership and support.

Jean-Paul Fallavollita | Liaison Officer, Health Emergency Operations Centre

Community and Health Services Department

Page 10: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

PROGRAMS

Page 11: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

BAYT YOUTH

DIVREI TORAH:

By Keira Diamond: Before Matan Torah Har Sinai was just brown and plain. But on Matan Torah all of a sudden the flowers

and leaves came and it was full of pretty flowers. And other mountains said the Torah should be given on

me, I’m better than Har Sinai - I’m taller, I’m prettier, I can reach from side to side - all of the mountains

said that. Hashem picked Har Sinai because all of the other mountains were saying “I’m better” and Har

Sinai wasn’t bragging - she was sitting there sadly and crying and davening. And on Matan Torah

Hashem made Har Sinai covered in flowers and so beautiful! I think Hashem made a great decision be-

cause Har Sinai teaches us we should just daven to Hashem and if someone else gets something else that

you wanted don’t be jealous - thats one of the 10 commandments. This year if we can’t celebrate to-

gether, then maybe we can try to zoom with friends before and share the chag together. I want to wish

everyone a Happy Shavuot!

By Kobi Diamond:

Since Pesach I have been learning Pirkei Avot with my Saba on the computer. I want to share the first

Mishna - Moshe received the Torah on Har Sinai and gave it to Yehoshua. Yehoshua to the elders, the

elders to the prophets and the prophets and to the great Rabbis. They said 3 things - be careful in judge-

ment, teach a lot of students and make a fence for Torah so you always have it in your heart. Pirkei Avot

is about getting the Torah and passing it down and down to the new generations. I think that the most im-

portant pasuk in the Torah is “Breishit bara elokim et hashamayim v’et ha’aertz” because most people

have other Gods and don’t believe in Hashem. I think he created the world to give the Torah and he

needed people to do so. Now that we have the Torah we have to continue to pass it on like it says in

Pirkei Avot. Happy Shavuot!

Look at this yummy ice cream cone

Do you want to know why it is

here?

Check out the next page to see

why”

Page 12: BETH AVRAHAM YOSEPH OF TORONTO ...When minyanim resume, will we be obligated to make up all of the Torah readings we have missed? There has been great disagreement about this question

BAYT YOUTH