blumenfeld 06

8/4/2019 Blumenfeld 06

1/235

!

"#$%&'()$&%!#$!*+#$#,#-)"(,!)$&.'("&)#$%!

!

!!

!

!

!

(!/)%%.'&(&)#$!

%012)&&./!!&+.!/.*('&2.$&!#3!,)$-0)%&)"%!

($/!&+.!"#22)&&..!#$!-'(/0(&.!%&0/).%!#3!%&($3#'/!0$)4.'%)&5!

)$!*('&)(,!30,3),,2.$&!#3!&+.!'.60)'.2.$&%!

3#'!&+.!/.-'..!#3!!

/#"'!#3!*+),#%#*+5!

!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!!

,78!(9!1:;7:?!

%7@A7


2/235

! GG!

!!!!!!!!!!!!

H!"I@JCGKLA!BJ!,78!(9!1:;7:?!DEEF!(::!CGKLAM!C7M7C87?!

!


3/235

! GGG!

)!N7CAG>J!ALOA!)!LO87!C7O?!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!O=?!ALOAP!G=!;::J!O?7Q;OA7!G=!MNI@7!O=?!Q;O:GAJ!OM!O!?GMM7CAOAGI=!>IC!AL7!?7KC77!I>!/INAIC!I>!*LG:IMI@LJ9!!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !! RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! S*O;:!TG@OCMUJV! ! *CG=NG@O:!(?8GM7C!!!!!)!N7CAG>J!ALOA!)!LO87!C7O?!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!O=?!ALOAP!G=!;::J!O?7Q;OA7!G=!MNI@7!O=?!Q;O:GAJ!OM!O!?GMM7CAOAGI=!>IC!AL7!?7KC77!I>!/INAIC!I>!*LG:IMI@LJ9!!!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !! RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! S(CAI!(=AAG:OV!!!!!)!N7CAG>J!ALOA!)!LO87!C7O?!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!O=?!ALOAP!G=!;::J!O?7Q;OA7!G=!MNI@7!O=?!Q;O:GAJ!OM!O!?GMM7CAOAGI=!>IC!AL7!?7KC77!I>!/INAIC!I>!*LG:IMI@LJ9!!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !! RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! SWG::GOJ!ALOA!)!LO87!C7O?!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!O=?!ALOAP!G=!;::J!O?7Q;OA7!G=!MNI@7!O=?!Q;O:GAJ!OM!O!?GMM7CAOAGI=!>IC!AL7!?7KC77!I>!/INAIC!I>!*LG:IMI@LJ9!!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! S(CIC!AL7!0=G87CMGAJ!"I


4/235

! G8!

(BMACONA!!!

#@AG!I;A@;A!MAC;NA;C7M9!2OCU7?=7MM!NI=MACOG=AM!MAOA7!AL7M7!M;C>ON7!@C7>7C7=N7MP!O=?!KCOCI!@OALM!

SC7@OGC!MACOA7KG7MV!ALOA!7=>ICN7!AL7!I;A@;A!MAC;NA;C7M9!#&!>ON7M!MJMA7>GN;:AG7M!

XGAL!NOM7M!XL7C7!O!KG87=!7X7C!C7@OGCM!ALO=!

@C7?GNA7?!BJ!AL7!AL7ICJ9!&LGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!7ZO!ALGM!AJ@7P!A7CON7?!BJ!#&!GM!?;7!AI!AL7!

MGK=G>GNO=A!@LI=I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!B7G=K!;::J!MAOA7?!=IA!OM!I;A@;A!

@C7>7C7=N7MP!B;A!@C7>7C7=N7M!>IC!G=@;A\I;A@;A!IC!O!=7X!AJ@7!I>!#&!IC!G=A7CONAGI=M!B7AX77=!@CIMI?GN!O=?!M7KONA!ALOA!AL7!G7C7=N7!

AI!ALGM!7!G=A7CONAGI=!B7AX77=!AL7!C7:78O=A!NOA7KICG7M9!&L7M7!NI=MACOG=AM!

@7=O:GY7!AL7!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!G=8I:87!AJ@I:IKGNO::J!;=IBM7C87?!C7@OGC!MACOA7KG7M!G=!M;NL!O!

XOJ!ALOA!ALIM7!NO=?G?OA7M!NO==IA!B7!I@AGG=O:!@OCA!I>!AL7!?GMM7CAOAGI=!)!O@@:J!

AL7!=7X!AL7ICJ!I>!NI=MACOG=AM!AI!O=IAL7C!@CIB:7


5/235

! 8!

(NU=IX:7?KO=?!OCA>;:!O=O:JM7MP!O=?!@7CMI=O:!K7=7CIMGAJ!LO87!:7>A!O!?77@!G! (CAI!(=AAG:O!LOM!M;@@:G7?!O!L7O:ALJ!?IM7!I>!?GMNG@:G=7P!MU7@AGNGM!AL7!ALC77!X7C7!:ONUG=K9!+GM!@7=7ACOAG=K!Q;7MAGI=M!LO87!KC7OA:J!G!BIAL!AL7!G?7OM!O=?!AL7!XCGAG=K!I>!ALGM!AL7MGM9!

! )!O;:!AI!WG::!,7B7=[M!NOC7>;:!O=?!?7AOG:7?!NCGAGNGM!!

! (CAM!I>!IC!AL7!>C;GA>;:!?GMN;MMGI=M!

I=!GCMA!B7NO! 2O=J!@7I@:7!I;AMG?7!I>!*LG:G@!+I>

(9T9*I:G8O=I8OP!>IC!L7C!C7N7=A!O=?!=IA!MI!C7N7=A!XGM7!O?8GN7!O=?!K7=7CIMGAJP!/I=NO!

%A7CGO?7P!^;?GAL!&I=LO;M7CP!$G=O!&I@G=AYGP!*O;:!%IC?!

LOM!@CI8G?7?!O=!I@AG!M;@7C8GMGI=!

OA!AL7!CGKLA!AG


6/235

! 8G!


7/235

! 8GG!

&OB:7!I>!"I=A7=AM!

)=ACI?;NAGI=! ! a!! !"LO@A7C!a9!*CIMI?J\M7KONAM! F!! ! a9a9a!1G?GC7NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=M! c!! ! ! a9a9a9a!6;O=AGAJ! d!! ! ! a9a9a9D!&I=7! aa!! ! ! a9a9a9e!%I=ICGAJ! aa!! ! a9a9D!0=G?GC7NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=M! ! aa!! a9D!&II!


8/235

! 8GGG!

! ! e9F9a!6;O=AGAJ!IC!MI=ICGAJh!! aDg!! ! e9F9D!%7@OCOAG=K!@CICI!2OCG! aDd!! ! ! e9F9D9D!%AC7MM!IC!@CI!OAA7MA7?!NOM7M!I>!7@7=AL7MGM! aFf!! g9D!%J=NI@7! aFF!! ! g9D9a!';:7\BOM7?!8G7XM!I>!MJ=NI@7! aFi!! ! g9D9D!%J=NI@7!G=!#&!! aia!! ! g9D9e!"OM7!MA;?G7M!! aig!! ! ! g9D9e9a!"OCGB! aig!! ! ! g9D9e9D!&I=UOXO! aid!! ! ! g9D9e9e!,7BO=7M7!(COBGN!! aca!! ! ! g9D9e9g!(CNLOGN!,OAG=! acc!! ! ! g9D9e9f!57CM!G=!#:?!';MMGO=! adE!! ! ! g9D9e9F!%I;AL7OMA7C=!&7@7L;O=! adF!! ! ! g9D9e9i!+I@G! DED!! ! ! g9D9e9c!"7=ACO:!(:OMUO=!5;@GU!! Daa!! ! ! g9D9e9d!17?I;G=!+G]OYG!(COBGN!! Dag!! ! g9D9g!%J=NI@7!B:INUG=K!NI=?GAGI=M! Dai!!"I=N:;MGI=! ! Dad!

! !References 220

!


9/235

! a!

)$&'#/0"&)#$!!

&L7!N7=ACO:!OCK;IC!#@AGGCMA!AI!IBM7C87!ALOA!C;:7\BOM7?!@LI=I:IKJ!LO?!=I!

!@LI=I:IKGNO:!C;:7M9!%*.\

MAJ:7!BCONU7AG=K!NI=87=AGI=MP!L7!OCK;7?P!?G?!=IA!O:XOJM!@GNU!I;A!AL7!M7AM!I>!C;:7M!ALOA!

LO?!O!=OA;CO:!C7:OAGI=MLG@!XGAL!7ONL!IAL7CP!O!C7:OAGI=MLG@!ALOA!XOM!BOM7?!I=!AL7!MG!I;A@;AM!AL7M7!C;:7M!@CI?;N7?9!TGMM7B7CAL!MLIX7?!ALOA!:O=K;OK7M!A7=?!AI!NI=AOG=!

N:;MA7CM!I>!O@@OC7=A:J!?G>>7C7=A!C;:7MP!O::!I>!XLGNL!NI=M@GC7!AI!NC7OA7!O!@OCAGN;:OC!@OAA7C=!

I>!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7P!M777C7=N7!AI!@CI?;N7!O!N7CAOG=!UG=?!I>!I;A@;A9!#87C!AL7!J7OCMP!TGMM7B7CAL[M!ICGKG=O:!G=MGKLA!XOM!?787:I@7?P!N;:IC!MAO=?OC?!C;:7\BOM7?!AL7ICJ!AI!LO=?:79!

! &L7M7!OCK;!AL7ICG7M!ALOA!C7NIK=GY7?!AL7!G!I;A@;A!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M9!!

! )A!LOM!B7NION7M!O!=;!

MJMA7


10/235

! D!

! &L7!M7NI=?!MJMA7ON7?!BJ!#&P!XLGNL!XG::!B7!AL7!M;B]7NA!I>!ALGM!

AL7MGMP!O:MI!LOM!AI!?I!XGAL!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!=IA!B7G=K!M;C>ON7\BOM7?9!)A!LOM!B7NI!M;C>ON7!NI=M@GCONG7M!NO=!B7!

A;C=7?!OCI;=?!OM!O=!OCK;ON7!ICG7=AOAGI=!I>!#&9!*7CLO@M!!C7@OGCM!>IC!AL7!

NI=MACOG=A!OKOG=MA!>G=O:!8IGN7?!MAI@M9!-G87=!O!G=O:!

IBMAC;7=AM!>CIIC!8GI:OAGI=M!I>!

M;NL!O!NI=MACOG=A!GM!>G=O:!8IGNG=K9!#AL7C!@IA7=AGO:!NLO=K7M!ALOA!O:MI!NI;:?!IB8GOA7!

8GI:OAGI=M!I>!ALGM!NI=MACOG=A!OC7!=IA!OAA7MA7?!OM!C7M@I=M7M!AI!>G=O:!8IGNG=K9!(OC7!=OMO:GYOAGI=P!?7:7AGI=P!OGAL>;:!I;A@;AV!! ! ! ! ! !! ! kAO@n! ! S?78IGNG=KV!! ! ! ! ! !p !! kAO!C;:G=K!I;A!

M;NL!C7@OGCMP!OM!:I=K!OM!AL7!M;C>ON7!NI=?GAGI=!7Z@C7MM7?!BJ!AL7!G7?!G=!AL7GC!I;A@;AM9!)A!O@@7OCM!ALOA!M;C>ON7\ICG7=A7?!NI=MACOG=AM!

NI=M@GC7!AI!@CI?;N7!MI!>G=O:!?78IGNG=K!OG!>G=O:!IBMAC;7=A!=OMO:GYOAGI=P!?7:7AGI=P!


11/235

! e!

%;NL!NI=MACOG=A!NI=M@GCONG7M!XG::!B7!AL7!>IN;M!I>!!AL7!?G>>GN;:AJ!>ON7?!BJ!#&!G=!ALGM!O=?!IAL7C!MG!AL7!@LI=I:IKGNO::J!MGK=G>GNO=A!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M9!(A!:7OMA!MIIC


12/235

! g!

@CI@7CAG7M!M;NL!OM!MAC7MM!O=?!OM@GCOAGI=!AI!NIINN;C!I=!AL7!MOIC!OM@GCOAGI=!OAACONAGI=!AI!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M!SMAC7MM\?CG87=!OM@GCOAGI=V!

XGALI;A!O:MI!@C7?GNAG=K!G=A7CONAGI=!G=!AL7!C787CM7!?GC7NAGI=P!G979!OM@GCOAGI=\?CG87=!MAC7MM9!

&LGM!AII\

AL7ICJP!AL7!*\GZ7?!CO=UG=KM!B7AX77=!N:OMM7M!I>!NI=MACOG=AM9!

! )=!"LO@A7C!e!)!>GN;:AJ!>ON7?!BJ!

MAO=?OC?!#&!G=!AII\GNO=A!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=9!WLG:7!MAO=?OC?!#&!LOM!N:OG

MAC7MM\OM@GCOAGI=!NI=MACOG=A!XG::!B7!MAOA7?!G=!AL7!>IC!O!MJ::OB:7!GM!MAC7MM7?P!AL7=!GAM!

I=M7A!GM!OM@GCOA7?9!&L7!>ICCI


13/235

! f!

%AO=?OC?!#&!XI;:?!@C7?GNAP!O=?!MLIX!LIX!!AL7!@LI=I:IKGNO:!@CI@7CAG7M9!)!XG::!OCK;7!ALOA!8IX7:!7@7=AL7MGM!GM!;M7?!

7ZN:;MG87:J!OM!O!C7M@I=M7!AI!@C7MM;C7M!I>!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7P!MI=ICGAJ!M7Q;7=NG=KP!MJ::OB:7!

NI=AONAP!O=?!XIC?!77AP!O=?!MI!>ICAL9!"C;NGO::JP!)!XG::!OCK;7!ALOA!ICN7!AL7!?7:7AGI=!I>!%&'.%%./!8IX7:MP!O!N:OG

! )=!K7=7CO:P!BIAL!MJ=NI@7!O=?!7@7=AL7MGM!MLIX!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!ALOA!OC7!B7MA!MAOA7?!=IA!

G=!A7C!I;A@;A!@C7>7C7=N7MP!B;A!G=!A7C!AL7!7=8GCI=!AL7!@CIN7MM7M9!&LGMP!

I=N7!OKOG=P!?GOK=IM7M!AL7!?G>>GN;:AJ!ALOA!MAO=?OC?!#&!LOM!XGAL!AL7!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!AL7!@CIN7MM7MP!O=?!?GMM7CAOAGI=9!

!


14/235

! F!

"+(*&.'!a!

*'#%#/5\%.-2.$&(,!)$&.'("&)#$%b!&+.!&5*#,#-5!

!!

aaaa9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=!

!

)=!AL7!@C78GI;M!G=ACI?;NAICJ!NLO@A7C!)!?GMN;MM7?!MI!AL7!@CIB:7ONG=K!#&!OM!O!

CO?GNO::J!I;A@;A\ICG7=A7?!AL7ICJ!I>!@LI=I:IKJ9!&LGM!NLO@A7C!A;C=M!AI!O!AJ@I:IKGNO:!

M;C87J!I>!O!@L7=IG=A7CONAGI=!I>!AL7!@CIMI?GN!O=?!M7K!GMM;7MP!=IA!@C78GI;M:J!KG87=!O!MJMA7!AL7!AL7ICJP!B7NO;M7!GA!?7>G7M!O=J!OAA7IC!IAL7C!AII\

I>!MAO=?OC?!#&P!B7NO;M7!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!B7LG=?!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!>ONAM!GM!B7MA!

>ICONAM9a!&L7!>ONAM9a!&L7!>ONAM9a!&L7!>ONAM!!

!

)=!ALGM!M7NAGI=!)!XG::!M;C87J!AL7!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!AL7!G=A7CONAGI=!B7AX77=!@CIMI?GN!MAC;NA;C7!

O=?!M7K!@CI@7CAG7M!G=!O!C7@C7M7=AOAGI=9!*LI=I:IKGNO:!>ONAICM!ALOA!

GK;C7!G=!MAC7MM!OMMGK=


15/235

! i!

S8IX7:!:7=KAL!O=?!MJ::OB:7!X7GKLAVP!AI=7P!O=?!8IX7:!MI=ICGAJ9a!&L7!N:OG7=?!G=!

ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!GM!ALOA!O::!@LI=I:IKGNO:!MAC7MM!MJMA77C7=N7!

MI:7:J!AI!AL7M7!ALC77!NOA7KICG7M9!

! &L7!C787CM7!?GC7NAGI=!I>!G=A7CONAGI=!B7AX77=!@CIMI?J!O=?!M7K!O!LIMA!I>!M7K>7NAM!AL7!?GMACGB;AGI=!I>!:OCJ=K7O:!>7OA;C7M9!*CIMI?GN!NI=MAGA;7=AM!

NO=!M7C87!OM!?I!M7K>7NAM!I>!MAC7MM!I=!M7KONAICM!G=!MAC7MM!OMMGK=

B7!M7=MGAG87!AIb!@CIMI?J\M7K!NI;CM7P!!AL7!!XIC?M9!


16/235

! c!

8IX7:!MI=ICGAJ!m!OCK;G=K!ALOA!O:A7C=OAG87!O=O:JM7M!ALOA!@C7M7C87!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!N:OG

O8OG:OB:79!

!

aaaa9a9a!1G?GC7NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=M9a9a!1G?GC7NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=M9a9a!1G?GC7NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=M9a9a!1G?GC7NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=M!

!

)=!ALGM!M7NAGI=!)!M;C87J!AL7!ALC77!>ONAICM!XGAL!XLGNL!MAC7MM!G=A7CONAM!BG?GC7NAGI=O::Jb!

Q;O=AGAJP!AI=7P!O=?!8IX7:!MI=ICGAJ9!)=!7ONL!I>!AL7M7!NOM7MP!AL7C7!OC7!:O=K;OK7M!XL7C7!

MAC7MM!OMMGK=IC!MAC7MM!SXLGNLP!G=!A;C=P!GM!OMMGK=7?!ONNIC?G=K!AI!IAL7C!@CG=NG@:7MV9!

!2*2*2*2&3)#$1.1'!

!

27ACGNO:!MAC;NA;C7!LOM!O=!G=AG!MAC7MM!O=?!X7GKLA!OC7!7ZAC7


17/235

! d!

@OAA7C=!NO=!B7!M77=P!XGAL!8OCGOAGI=MP!G=!!5;@GU!SMI!AL7M7!MJMA7


18/235

! aE!

@OAA7C=M!C7@C7M7=A!AL7!AXI!AJ@7M!I>!:O=K;OK7MP!ALIM7!XGAL!AI=7\?CG87=!MAC7MM!O=?!ALIM7!

XGAL!MAC7MM\?CG87=!AI=79!/7!,ONJ!@CI8G?7M!7ZO!BIAL9!

! (J;A:O!2GZA7N!LOM!O!AI=7\?CG87=!MAC7MM!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=b!MAC7MM!>O::M!I=!AL7!:7>AO;:AP!AL7!:7>A!

AL7!AI=7!77A!G=!M;NL!O!XOJ!ALOA!AL7!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7!LOM!O!+!IC!O!2!

AI=7P!O=?!AL7!;=MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7!O!,!AI=79!/7!,ONJ!@CI@IM7M!O!NI=MACOG=A!MJMA7

K7=7COA7M!AL7!>I::IXG=K!LOC!77A\AI\AI=7!O:GK=7C7=N7!AI!ALGM!MNO:7b!>IC!7ONL!KG87=!>IC


19/235

! aa!

2*2*2*5&6(7/,&0($(8.1'&

!

4IX7:!Q;O:GAJ!NO=!O:MI!G=A7CONA!XGAL!MAC7MM!G=!O!BG?GC7NAGI=O:!>OMLGI=P!O=!G=A7CONAGI=!ALOA!

GM!:G!NOM7M9!1CIO?:J!M@7OUG=KP!AL7!LGKL7C!O!8IX7:M!MAO=?M!I=!AL7!MI=ICGAJ!MNO:7!SeVP!AL7!A7?!:IX7C!I=!

AL7!MI=ICGAJ!MNO:7P!8GO!COGMG=K!IC!8IX7:!C7?;NAGI=9!

!

SeV!! qP!G!!""!!GP!;!!""!!7P!I!!""!!O!

!

)!@IMA@I=7!>;CAL7C!?GMN;MMGI=!I>!MI=ICGAJ\?CG87=!MAC7MM!;=AG:!%7NAGI=!e9FP!XLGNL!XG::!B7!

?78IA7?!AI!7ZO!NOM7M!I;A:G=7?!OBI87!NI!AL7!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!

@CIMI?J\M7KCI

?GMACGB;AGI=!I>!O!:OCK7!=;!IAL7C!@CI@7CAG7M!NO=!B7!M7=MGAG87!AI!CI

M7KIIA\G=GAGO:!MJ::OB:7M!S5;@GUV9!#=M7A!

7@7=AL7MGM!S;M;O::J!k!nV!O:MI!>O::M!G=AI!ALGM!NOA7KICJ9!W7OU7=G=K!@CIN7MM7M!G=!=I=\


20/235

! aD!

@CIO:O@@G=K!NOM7P!OM!X7::!OM!IAL7C!AJ@7M!I>!

:7=GAGI=!M;NL!OM!%@O=GML!>CGNOAG8GYOAGI=9!%I


21/235

! ae!

SfV!! !.=K:GML! 8IGN7:7MM!MAI@!OM@GCOAGI=! I=M7A!I>!!! !%G:ONOJI@O=!2GZA7N! A!!!AL! I=M7A!I>!!! !&IC78O!+I@G! "!@C7OM@GCOAGI=! O>A7C!!! !)N7:O=?GN! "!@C7OM@GCOAGI=! O>A7C! !! XGAL! O! MLICA!

4!

!

%7=I;>I! "!"b! I=M7A!I>!!! 2G::M!adcg!*I@I:INO! "!"b! O>A7C!!! !,OA8GO=! 8IGN7:7MM!MAI@!K7A7C!!!XGAL!MLICA!4! TOCGuv!addF!2OICG! 8IGN7:7MM!MAI@!O>>CGNOAGI=! I=M7A!I>!!! !$ICAI=!%I;=?!5;@GU! yXP!]P!:z!!!y8P!YP!"z! >IIA\G=GAGO:! !

-;JOB7CI! ?!!!# O>A7C!!! !

$KO=OMO=! "!8IGNG=K$ >IIA\G=GAGO:! !&XO=O! !!OAACONAGI=! AI!!! !

1OK=7C7\?7\,;NLI=!3C7=NL!

:GQ;G?!OAACONAGI=! AI!!! 1:78G=M!{!-OCC7AA!addc!

/;ANL! !!7@7=AL7MGM! !! !

*OG@OG! !!7@7=AL7MGM! XIC?\G=GAGO:!!! !!

&L7!AOB:7!B7:IX!:GMAM!O!C7@C7M7=AOAG87!MO!MAC7MM\M7=MGAG87!X7OU7=G=K!@CIN7MM7M9!

!SFV!W7MA!&OCO=KO=! yKP?%z!!!yXP]z! IP!LOM!O=!;=;M;O::J!CGNL!OCCOJ!I>!

M7K>7NAM!I>!MAC7MM!S$GK7C!"I=KIP!-;CP!)8ICJ!"IOMAs!2G::M!adcgP!-I=Yx:7Y!DEEeV9!

%AC7MM!GM!;M;O::J!G=GAGO:!G=!ALGM!:O=K;OK7s!=I!M7NI=?OCJ!MAC7MM!GM!C7@ICA7?9!%7=I;>I!LOM!OA!

:7OMA!>G87!M7@OCOA7!@CIN7MM7M!M7=MGAG87!AI!MAC7MM9!#=M7A!NI=MI=O=AM!OC7!:7=GA7?!G=!

;=MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7MP!XGAL!8IGN7:7MM!NI=MI=O=AM!B7NI


22/235

! ag!

M7NI=?OCJ!OCAGN;:OAGI=!O=?!K:IAAO:GYOAGI=!OC7!NI=ACOMAG87!I=:J!G=!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M9!&L7M7!

@CIN7MM7M!OC7!M;!;=MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M!S@9!dFV! %7NI=?OCJ!OCAGN;:OAGI=!NI=ACOMAG87!I=:J!G=!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7!S@9ageV! -:IAAO:GYOAGI=!NI=ACOMAG87!I=:J!G=!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7!S@9agcV!

!&L7!M7NI=?!!G=A7CONAGI=!B7AX77=!7C7=N7!AI!CI

B7:IXP!XGAL!NO@GAO:GYOAGI=!G=?GNOAG=K!:OZ=7MM9!!

!

SiV!! O9! S@}=A0V! ! [[! ! B9! S@|=AOV! ! [>7[!! ! ! S~}U0V! ! [BIJ[! ! ! ! ! S~|UOV!! ! [KGC:[!! ! ! M7SU:0V! ! [AI!?CJ!LG77A!M7C8G=K!OM!AL7!?I!

:OZ=7MM!LOCIC!:OZ=7MM!M@C7O?G=K!NO=!B7!;=?7CMAII?!AI!C7M;:A!>CI

@CILGBGAGI=!I=!?GMOKC77IIA9!

! )!XG::!?GMN;MM!AL7!&;?O=NO!%@O=GML!NOM7!G=!


23/235

! af!

a9a9a9a9D!&II!:;7=N7!I>!@CIMI?J!I=!M7K


24/235

! aF!

&L7!AL7IC7AGNO:!;=?7C@G==G=KM!I>!M;NL!NICIIC!AL7!AL7ICJ!I>!LOC


25/235

! ai!

&L7!;@MLIA!I>!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!?GMN;MMGI=!OBI87!GM!ALOAP!G=!AL7!K7=7CO:!NOM7P!AL7M7!AXI!

MI:;AGI=M!OC7!AII!

! ,7A!OM@GCOAGI=9!&L7!NI=MACOG=A!(%*)'(&.p!wP!=I!IC>7C7=A!C7@OGCMb!

I=7!ALOA!G7M!AL7!M7K!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M!SaEV! (%*)'(&.p!w !! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!SDV!*;A!MAC7MM!I=!MJ::OB:7M!XGAL!OM@GCOA7?!I=M7AM!!

1IAL!C7@OGCM!C7M;:A!G=!O!M;C>ON7!MAC;NA;C7!ALOA!MOAGM>G7M!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!(%*)'(&.p!wP!O=?!

AL;M!BIAL!OC7!@C7?GNA7?!BJ!#&!AI!7ZGMA!G=!:O=K;OK7M9!&L7!M7K


26/235

! ac!

SaaV! ! ! ! %&'.%%!)$)&)(,!

(%*)'(&.p!w ! /.*\L! 2(\L!

p@GALOp! ! @|ALO! ! j! ! !

! ! @GALx! j! ! ! !! "! @L|AO! ! ! j! j!p@GAOp! ! @|AO! ! j! ! !! ! @|ALO! ! j! j! !! ! @GALx! j! ! j! !! "! @L|AO! ! ! j! !!&OB:7O;!SaaV!G::;MACOA7M!AL7!M7K!O!(%*)'(&.p!w!8GI:OAGI=!m!AL7!>O!MAC7MM\?CG87=!OM@GCOAGI=9!

! &L7!NI=MACOG=A!NO=!O:MI!:7O?!AI!AL7!I@@IMGA7!G=A7CONAGI=!m!OM@GCOAGI=\?CG87=!MAC7MM9!)>!CO=U7?!LGKL!7=I;KLP!(%*)'(&.p!w!NO=!NO;M7!MAC7MM!AI!B7!OAACONA7?!AI!AL7!MJ::OB:7!ALOA!LOM!

I=M7A!OM@GCOAGI=!G=!AL7!;=?7C:JG=K!>IC


27/235

! ad!

&L7!I=:J!8GOB:7!NO=?G?OA7!:7>A!GM!9.1";P!AL7!>ICO;:A!MAC7MM!ALOA!LOM!B77=!

OAACONA7?!AI!AL7!MJ::OB:7!XGAL!O=!OM@GCOA7?!I=M7A9!

! &I!G::;MACOA7!ALOA!AL7!?7>O;:A!MAC7MM!G=!ALGM!LJ@IAL7AGNO:!:O=K;OK7!GM!G=?77?!I=!AL7!

G=GAGO:!MJ::OB:7!GA!GM!7=I;KL!AI!M77!XLOA!LO@@7=M!AI!O=!G=@;A!XGALI;A!O=J!OM@GCOAGI=9!!

SaeV!! ! !(%*)'(&.p!w ! /.*\L!

%&'.%%!)$)&)(,!

2(\L!

p@GAOp! ! @|ALO! j! ! ! !! ! @GALx! ! j! j! !! "! @L|AO! ! j! ! !! ! @|AO! j! ! ! !

!+7C7P!AL7C7!GM!=I!>OGAL>;:=7MM!?G>>7C7=N7!B7AX77=!AL7!>G=O::J!MAC7MM7?!9.1";!O=?!AL7!

G=GAGO::J!MAC7MM7?!9:1"#!m!BIAL!G=8I:87!AL7!G=M7CAGI=!I>!O=!OM@GCOAGI=!m!O=?!AL;M!AL7!MAC7MM!

NI=MACOG=AM!?7NG?7!G=!>O8IC!I>!AL7!?7>O;:A!G=GAGO:!MAC7MM9!

! &I!M;CIONA!ALOA!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!

(%*)'(&.p!w!I=:J!MAOA7M!O!@C7>7CC7?!I;A@;A!@OAA7C=P!8GY9!ALOA!MAC7MM!O=?!OM@GCOAGI=!MLI;:?!

NIG=NG?7!G=!AL7!MO!B7AX77=!AL7!AXI!AJ@7M!I>!C7@OGC!GM!O!K7=7CO:!@CI@7CAJ!I>!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!

G=!ScV!O=?!IAL7C!MG


28/235

! DE!

MAC7MM!>IIAP!(-'..k=OMn"P!NO=!B7!MOAGM>G7?!7GAL7C!BJ!8GI:OAG=K!AL7!M7KOGAL>;:=7MM!

NI=MACOG=A!m!G979!BJ!O@@:JG=K!LOCIIA!m!IC!BJ!8GI:OAG=K!O!@CIMI?GN!

NI=MACOG=A!S>OGAL>;:=7MM!IC!

MJMA7O;:A!MAC7MM!7ZN7@A!G=!XIC?M!ALOA!LO87!O!?G>>7C7=A!

k=OMn!8O:;7!G=!AL7!>G=O:!O=?!@7=;:AGIC


29/235

! Da!

NI=M@GN;I;M!7ZO!O=!ON;A7!AII\NI=MACOG=AM!NO=!B7!MOAGM>G7?!G=!AL7!MOGNOAGI=b! ! pOBCOp! !!O9BCO!

!

&L7!CO=K7!I>!M7KOC!KC7OA7C!ALO=!AL7!OAA7MA7?!

C7@OGCMb!I=:J!?78IGNG=K!GM!OAA7MA7?!OM!O!C7M@I=M7!AI!jkl8IGnp"#/(9!&LGM!@CIB:7

=IA!NI=N7C=!;M!>IC!=IXb!GA!LOM!B77=!O??C7MM7?!BJ!%A7CGO?7!DEEa!O=?!;M7?!AI!OCK;7!>IC!AL7!

*\


30/235

! DD!

M@7NG>GNOAGI=P!A;C=G=K!AL7!8IGN7?!

MOAGM>JG=K!AL7!@CILGBGAGI=!I>!NI?O!8IGNG=K!BJ!!AL7!>I::IXG=K!MJ::OB:7P!XLGNL!O::IXM!AL7!:O=K;OK7!AI!B7!>OGAL>;:!AI!

;=?7C:JG=K!8IGNG=K9!! )=!AL7!NOM7!I>!?78IGNG=KP!AL7!:O=K;OK7!G=8I:8G=K!@CIMI?GN!C7@OGC!XI;:?!LO87!AL7!

>I::IXG=K!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=b!8IGN7:7MM!M7KGCMA!J!OM!NI?OM!I>!AL7!@C7N7?G=K!MJ::OB:7MP!XLG:7!8IGN7?!M7KIC

XGAL!>I::IXG=K!MJ::OB:7M9!

!SaiV! O9! pO@COp! !!! O@9CO!! ! B9! pOBCOp! !!! O9BCO!

!&LGM!LO@@7=M!B7NO;M7!AL7!8IGN7?!B;A!=IA!AL7!8IGN7:7MM!M7KCI

NI?OM9!+IX787CP!G>!AL7C7!GM!O!?G>>7C7=N7!G=!AL7!MJ::OBG>GNOAGI=!I>!NI=MI=O=AM!BOM7?!I=!

AL7GC!8IGNG=KP!GA!KI7M!AL7!IAL7C!XOJb!G=!)N7:O=?GN!O=?!(=NG7=A!-C77UP!AL7!8IGN7?!B;A!=IA!

AL7!8IGN7:7MM!M7K


31/235

! De!

aaaa9e9a9e9a9e9a9e9a!! %AC7MM!O=?!:7=GAGI=!G=!TOCI%AC7MM!O=?!:7=GAGI=!G=!TOCI%AC7MM!O=?!:7=GAGI=!G=!TOCI%AC7MM!O=?!:7=GAGI=!G=!TOCI!

!

TOCIP!O!&;@|!:O=K;OK7!I>!1COYG:P!LOM!B77=!N:OGNI=ACO?GNAM!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!@CI@IM7?!G=!ALGM!M7NAGI=9!(NNIC?G=K!AI!AL7!?7MNCG@AGI=!I>!

-OBOM!SaddcVP!MAC7MM!OMMGK=!IBMAC;7=A!MAI@MP!G=!

M;NL!O!XOJ!ALOA!N7CAOG=!AJ@7M!I>!MAI@M!OC7!@C7>7COB:J!:INOA7?!G=!X7OU!@IMGAGI=M!I>!>77A9!

&LGM!NI=ACO?GNAM!AL7!@CI@IMO:!ALOA!I=:J!MAC7MM!NO=!NOA7C!AI!M7K!TOCI!MAC7MM!GM!=IA!AL7!I=:J!

@IMMGB:7!I=7P!O=?!ALOA!O!?G>>7C7=A!O=O:JMGM!ALOA!?I7M!=IA!G=8I:87!8IGNG=K\M7=MGAG87!MAC7MM!GM!

=IA!I=:J!@IMMGB:7!B;A!@C7>7COB:79!

! TOCI!LOM!NI=ACOMAG87!AI=7!SXGAL!OA!ICI::IXM9!

!

SacV! O9! (MMGK=!MAC7MM!AI!AL7!MJ::OB:7!XGAL!+!AI=7s!! ! B9! .:M7!AI!AL7!MJ::OB:7!XGAL!AL7!=OMO:GY7?!8IX7:s!! ! N9! .:M7!AI!AL7!@7=;:AG!AL7!>G=O:!MJ::OB:7!B7KG=M!XGAL!kBnP!kKnP!IC!k&ns!! ! ?9! .:M7!AI!AL7!>G=O:!MJ::OB:79!

!&L7!!AL7!C;:7!GM!SacVNb!MAC7MM!O@@7OCM!AI!B7!M7=MGAG87!AI!AL7!=OA;C7!I>!

AL7!NI=MI=O=A!G=!AL7!>I::IXG=K9!&L7C7!GM!O!K7=7CO:!NCIMM\:G=K;GMAGN!@C7>7C7=N7!>IC!:7=GAG=K!

IC!8IGNG=K!@IMAAI=GN!I=M7AM!S.=K:GMLP!%XOLG:GP!&ILI=I!#[I?LO!ALGM!@IMAAI=GN!:7=GAGI=b!MAC7MM!GM!OMMGK=7?!AI!

MJ::OB:7M!@C7N7?G=K!8IGN7?!NI=MI=O=AM9!

! &L7!=IC


32/235

! Dg!

SadV!.=K:GML! %&'.%%! ,.$)&.! 3()&+!pOAI

=IA!O>>7NA7?!BJ!AL7!M7K!O?]ON7=A!NI=MI=O=AM9!

! )=!TOCIP!LIX787CP!AL7!MAC7MM!NI=MACOG=A!M77!AL7!>G=O:!MJ::OB:7!GM!O!>:O@P!G=!XLGNL!NOM7!MAC7MM!GM!@7=;:AG;:=7MM!O=?!


33/235

! Df!

SDeV!! ! ! j/p+.(/! )/.$&\"! 3)$(,%&'.%%!@OCOA! "! @x&OA! ! ! j!! ! @O&xA! j! ! !

! ! @OAxA! ! j! !! ! @xAOA! ! j! j!@OUI! ! @xKI! ! j! j!! ! @xUI! ! ! j!! "! @OU! ! ! !! ! @OK! j! j! !!)M!ALGM!O!NI;=A7C7ZO!7=8GCI=


34/235

! DF!

SDfV! O9! 4IGN7:7MM!MAI@M!INN;C!787CJXL7C7!7ZN7@A!G=A7C8INO:GN!I=M7AM!I>!;=MAC7MM7?!!M!

! ! ! ! 4RR4w ! ! SG=!ALGM!@IMGAGI=!8IGN7:7MM!MAI@M!OC7!:7=KAL7=7?V!! ! ! ! !RR4!! ! ! ! oRR4!

! ! ! ! 4RRo!! ! B9! 4IGN7?!MAI@M!INN;C!G=A7C8INO:GNO::J!! ! ! ! 4RR4!!

)=!I=M7AM!I>!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7MP!8IGN7?!O=?!8IGN7:7MM!MAI@M!NI=ACOMA9!)=!O::!IAL7C!@IMGAGI=MP!

AL7GC!?GMACGB;AGI=!GM!@C7?GNAOB:7b!8IGN7?!MAI@M!INN;C!XL7=!G=A7C8INO:GNP!O=?!8IGN7:7MM!

MAI@M!INN;C!7:M7XL7C79!!&L7!NI=ACOMA!G=!8IGNG=K!G=!I=M7AM!I>!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M!NO=!:7O?!AI!

.".*&)#$%!AI!AL7!MAC7MM!C;:7!SacVN9!)=!AL7!>I::IXG=K!7ZO!

>G=O:!MJ::OB:7M!?I!=IA!NO;M7!AL7!MAC7MM!AI!B7!@7=;:AGG=O:P!G=!NI=ACO?GNAGI=!AI!SacVN9!

!

SDFV! ONGB!! ! ! [COGY[!! ! UI&B!AL7!INN;CC7=N7M!I>!8IGN7?!MAI@M!G=!I=M7AM!I>!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M!?I!=IA!K7=7COA7!

7ZN7@AGI=M!AI!SacVNP!B7NO;M7!AL7!SacVO!IC!SacVB!N:O;M7M!@C7N:;?7!GA9!

!SDiV! O9! UI&A! ! ! ! []ON;[! ! ! ! ! kMAC7MM!OMMGK=7?!AI!4!XGAL!+!AI=7n!! ! ! !!! !!! ! ! !! !+!! ! B9! XOUqwJO! ! ! [N;AGO[!! ! ! ! kMAC7MM!OMMGK=7?!AI!=OMO:!4n!! ! !


35/235

! Di!

SDcV! ! p@P!AP!Up!! !!! kBpXP!&P!Kn! ! ! p!4RR4k\ONN7=An!!SDdV! O9! p7\@7=OIJp! ! !! ! k7B7=OJn! ! [8IN!?O=I;[!! ! ! p7\AOAGp! ! ! !! ! k7&OA|n! ! ! [A7!ACI;Z7[!

! ! ! p7\U;C;?N;p!!!

! ! k7K;C;?Nn! ! [


36/235

! Dc!

!SeeV!! ! ! 3()&+!

%&'.%%!2(k8IGn! j&p$#$+.(/! /.*k8IGn! 3)$(,%&'.%%!

@xAOA! "! @x&OA! ! ! ! ! j!! ! @O&xA! j! ! ! ! !! ! @OAxA! j! j! ! ! !! ! @xAOA! ! j! j! ! j!@OUI! ! @xKI! ! ! ! j! j!! ! @xUI! ! ! j! ! j!! "! @OU! ! ! ! ! !! ! @OK! ! ! ! j! !ONGB!! "! ONGB!! ! ! ! ! !! ! ONG@!! ! j! ! ! !

! ! ON|B7!! j! ! ! ! j!! ! ON|@7!! j! j! j! ! j!

!&L7C7!GM!O!@CIB:7ICG=O:!MJ::OB:7!LOM!O!MAI@!I=M7A!S-OBOM!@9N9V9!)=!O::!NOM7M!XL7C7!

AL7C7!GM!=I!MAI@!G=8I:87?P!AL7!>G=O:!MJ::OB:7!GM!ONN7=A7?9!

!

SegV! O9! U!J!w" " " " [];CGAG["

" " B9! JO!!w! ! ! ! [NO:O=KI[!! ! N9!

AI!7=M;C7!ALOA!#=.!!M;C>ON7M!>OGAL>;::J9!

!

!!


37/235

! Dd!

!SefV! ! -OBOM[M!MJMA7

%&'.%%!2(k8IGn! j/p+.(/! /.*k8IGn! 3)$(,%&'.%%!

ONGB!! "! ONGB!! ! ! j! ! !! ! ONG@!! ! j! ! ! !! ! ON|B7!! j! ! ! ! j!! ! ON|@7!! j! j! ! ! j!

!7ZN7@AGI=M!:GU7!o?;$.P!AL7!

C7O=O:JMGM!I>!AL7!TOCI!MAC7MM!MJMA7

M7=MGAG879!&L7!C7O=O:JMGM!ALOA!AOU7M!MAC7MM!COAL7C!ALO=!8IGNG=K!AI!B7!;=@C7?GNAOB:7!>OC7M!

B7AA7C!G=!ALOA!GA!7Z@C7MM7M!AL7!NI==7NAGI=!B7AX77=!ALC77!>ONAM!ALOA!X7C7!;=C7:OA7?!G=!

-OBOM[M!O=O:JMGMb!AL7!?GMACGB;AGI=!I>!8IGN7?p8IGN7:7MM!MAI@MP!AL7![CI

! %7NI=?P!G=!OA!:7OMA!I=7!:O=K;OK7P!(:JOXOCCOP!AL7C7!GM!O!8OCGOAGI=!I=!ALGM!@OAA7C=b!MAC7MM!

GM!C7@7::7?!=IA!I=:J!>CICI

G>!AL7!K:G?7M!NO=!B7!OCK;7?!AI!B7!G=!AL7!MJ::OB:7!=;N:7;M!COAL7C!ALO=!G=!AL7!I=M7A9!

! &LGM!M!NOM7M!?I7M!=IA!@C7M7=A!O!M7CGI;M!NI;=A7C7ZO


38/235

! eE!

-I7?777A!AI!B7!:7>A\O:GK=7?!XGAL!O!MJ::OB:7!I=M7A9!)!XG::!=IA!

>;CAL7C!?GMN;MM!AL7M7!I=M7A\C7@7::G=K!MJMA7


39/235

! ea!

"+(*&.'!D!

*'.4)#0%!(**'#("+.%!!!#\2($5\%#,0&)#$%!*'#1,.2%!

!

DDDD9E!)=ACI?;NA9E!)=ACI?;NA9E!)=ACI?;NA9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=GI=GI=GI=!

!

)=!AL7!@C78GI;M!NLO@A7C!)!M;C87J7?!AL7!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!@CIMI?J\M7K

G=!?7!,ONJ!DEEe!SM77!M7NAGI=!D9D!B7:IXVP!@CIMI?J\M7K!@LI=I:IKGNO:!AL7ICJ9!

! +IX787CP!AL7!NLO::7=K7!ALOA!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!?OAO!@IM7M!>IC!AL7!AL7ICJ!GM!=IA!7=AGC7:J!

=7X9!%787CO:!M7AM!I>!NOM7M!XL7C7!O!MGK=G>GNO=A!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!OBI;A!G=@;A\I;A@;A!

7ONL!NOM7P!O!


40/235

! eD!

! )=!ALGM!NLO@A7C!)!XG::!?GMN;MM!ALC77!G

!

SaV!! ! 3)'%&!"#$%#$($&!/.,.&)#$!SWG:MI=!DEEab!agcV!! ! ! (NCIMM!:O=K;OK7MP!?7:7AGI=!@CIN7MM7M!ALOA!O@@:J!AI!G=A7C8INO:GN!BGNI=MI=O=AO:!

N:;MA7CM!NI=MGMA7=A:J!?7:7A7!AL7!3)'%&!NI=MI=O=A!SMNL7


41/235

! ee!

OA!:7OMA!I=7!NI=MACOG=A!ALOA!>O8ICM!"a!I87C!"DP!B7NO;M7!AL7=!AL7!>ONAICGO:!AJ@I:IKJ!XG::!

NI=AOG=!AL7!@OAA7C=!I>!?7:7AGI=!XL7C7!"a!COAL7C!ALO=!"D!M;C>ON7M9!":7OC:JP!M;NL!O!

NI=MACOG=A!7ZGMAMb!GA!NI;:?!B7!O=J!I=7!I>!!"D!SWG:MI=!DEEab!agcV!! 4"a"D4! ",0%&.'"#$/! 2(\"! 2222!! 4"a"D4! j! ! !"! 4"D4! ! j! j!#! 4"a4! ! j! !!WG:MI=[M!@IG=A!GM!ALOA!GN!C7@OGC9!)=!AL7!NI=>GK;COAGI=!4"a"D4P!AL7!>GCMA!NI=MI=O=A!GM!

?7>GNG7=A!OM!NIICIC!AL7!?7:7AGI=!I>!AL7!@7CN7@A;O::J!

X7OU7C!=I=\@C78INO:GN!NI=MI=O=A!"aP!XLG:7!?7:7AG=K!AL7!MACI=K7C!NI=MI=O=A!"D!?I7M!=IA!

NI;=A!OM!O!C7@OGC!I>!AL7!AOCK7A7?!NI=MACOG=A9!

! &L7!MAO=?OC?!>7=?G=K!N:;MA7CP!O=?!GA!GM!MOAGM>G7?!BJ!O=J!NO=?G?OA7!ALOA!?I7M!=IAP!=I!


42/235

! eg!

IC!AL7!N:;MA7C!GMP!B7!GA!?7:7AGI=!I>!7GAL7C!NI=MI=O=AP!?7:7AGI=!I>!

AL7!XLI:7!N:;MA7CP!IC!7@7=AL7MGM9!)=!AL7!LOC


43/235

! ef!

ALOA!NO=?G?OA7!OC7!C7NIC?7?P!O=?!N;

AOB:7O;9!,IX7C\CO=U7?!NI=MACOG=AM!G

SfV!! p4"a"D4p! $#WT"! 2(\"! 2222!! 4"a"D4! 4"D4!!!4"a"D4!! ! S4"a4!!!4"a"D4V!!"! 4"D4! ! S4"a"D4!!!4"D4V! S4"a4!!!4"D4V!! 4"a4! ! 4"a"D4!!!4"a4!! !

! =)?),! 4"D4!!!4"a"D4! 4"D4!!!4"a"D4!!!4"a4! !!

&L7!CGKLA\CO=U7?!NI=MACOG=A!$#WT"!I=:J!OMM7CAM!AL7!IC?7CG=K!4"D4!!!4"a"D4s!GA!GM!

MG:7=A!I=!O::!IAL7C!NO=?G?OA7M9!&L7!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!2(!IC?7CM!4"a"D4!OBI87!

BIAL!I>!AL7!?7:7AGI=!NO=?G?OA7MP!B;A!I=7!I>!AL7M7!IC?7CG=KMP!4"a"D4!!!4"D4P!

NI=ACO?GNAM!AL7!IC?7CG=K!@OMM7?!?IX=!BJ!AL7!LGKL7C\CO=U7?!NI=MACOG=AM9!&L;M!AL7!

NO=?G?OA7M!4"a4!G=N;CM!O!>OAO:!8GI:OAGI=9!&L7!GN!7ZOCI

SWG:MI=!DEEab!aFfV9!)=!/GI:OP!NIGCMA!


44/235

! eF!

SFV!! p:7AlU;l]OXp! $#WT"! 2(! j/#'! j"#'!! :7AU;]OX! :7U;!!!:7AU;! ! S:7A;!!!:7AU;V! S:7U;!!!:7AU;V!"! :7U;]OX! ! S:7AU;!!!:7U;V! S:7A;!!!:7U;V! !

! :7A;]OX! ! :7AU;!!!:7A;! ! :7U;!!!:7A;!! =)?),! :7U;!!!:7AU;! :7U;!!!:7AU;!!!:7A;! ! !!

WG:MI=!?7!AL7!AOCK7A7?!87CMGI=!I>!AL7!N:;MA7C!NI=MACOG=A!

ONNI;=AM!>IC!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!G=!SaVb!AL7!>ONAICGO:!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!$#WT"P!

)/.$&P!2(P!O=?!GCMA!

NI=MI=O=A!G=!O!N:;MA7C!B7G=K!?7:7A7?9!3;CAL7C>GNG7=AP!OM!GA!O::IXM!8IX7:!7@7=AL7MGM!OM!O!C7@OGC!>IC!NI=MI=O=A!N:;MA7CM9!

! )=!AL7!C7!AL7!M7NAGI=!)!XG::!OAA7NI=MACOG=AM!NO==IA!ONNI;=A!>IC!AL7!C7:78O=A!AJ@I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=MP!O=?P!>I::IXG=K!

2N"OCALJ[M!SDEEDV!NCGAGNGM!WG:MI=[M!AL7ICJP!XG::!?GOK=IM7!AL7!@CIB:7!MAC7MM\OM@GCOAGI=!G=A7CONAGI=M9!-G87=!O!GK;COAGI=!

XL7C7!AL7!MAC7MM!O=?!OM@GCOAGI=!OC7!=IA!:INOA7?!I=!AL7!MOAM!AI!

AL7!MJ::OB:7!XGAL!OM@GCOAGI=P!XLG:7!AJ@I:IKGNO::JP!I=:J!AL7!C787CM7!C7@OGCP!OM@GCOAGI=!

MLG>AG=K!AI!AL7!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7P!GM!OAA7MA7?9!)=!AL7!K7=7CO:!NOM7P!KG87=!O!!!MO


45/235

! ei!

SiV!! &OCK7A7?!%&'.%%\\(%*)'(&)#$!S&\(%*)'(&.V!! ! ,7A!@!B7!O=J!NO=?G?OA7!O=?!#!O!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7!G=!@9!)>!NO=?G?OA7!'!GM!7ZONA:J!AL7!

MO7C7=N7b!SNV!NO=!MAG::!XG=9!&LGM!GM!MLIX=!G=!AL7!>I::IXG=K!AOB:7O;9!

!

ScV!! ! p@OALOp! &\(%*)'(&.! $#3,#*! *.$0,&!

! O9! @xALO! B!!!O! ! !

! B9! @LxAO! !SO!!!BV!N!!!B!

!

$! N! @OALx! ! !SO!!!NV!SB!!!NV!

! ! =)?),& B!!!O! N!!!B!!!O! !!

&\(%*)'(&.!>OAO::J!@7=O:GY7M!AL7!NO=?G?OA7!SOVP!XL7C7!OM@GCOAGI=!O=?!MAC7MM!OC7!

?GMOMMINGOA7?9!&L7!C7I=M7A!I>!AL7!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:79!&LGM!NO;M7M!AL7!;=XO=A7?!NO=?G?OA7!SNV!AI!7


46/235

! ec!

I@AG!AL7!&OCK7A7?!"I=MACOG=A!AL7ICJ!O::IXM!;M!AI!M77!XLJ9!

#BM7C8G=K!ALOA!AL7!O??GAGI=!I>!MIICIC!O!AJ@I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=9!

! %;@@IM7!AL7C7!GM!O!!OA!:7OMA!I>!AL7!AXI!NI=?GAGI=M!OBI87!>OG:M!AI!LI:?P!AL7=!AL7C7!OC7!CO=UG=KM!XL7C7!!GM!

I@AG


47/235

! ed!

! )=!AL7!NOM7!I>!@CIMI?J\M7K!2!BJ!JG=K!%P!O=?!NO=?G?OA7!!XLGNL!C7@OGCM!AL7!8GI:OAGI=!I>!2!BJ!JG=K!$9!

"O=?G?OA7!(!GM!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO::J!OAA7MA7?!M7KCIJG=K!$[9i!#=N7!OKOG=P!

"!?I7M!=IA!8GI:OA7!GA!B7NO;M7!GA!GM!AL7!>;::J!>OGAL>;:!NO=?G?OA7!IC!O!NO=?G?OA7!XGAL!?7>O;:A!

@CIMI?JP!XLG:7!(P!BJ!OMM;! [JG=K! $[! O;:A! @CIMI?GN! MAC;NA;C7! OMMGK=OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A9!


48/235

! gE!

=IA!7Q;O:!G=!>OGAL>;:=7MMb!!MOAGM>G7M!3()&+!B;A!(!8GI:OA7M!GA9!&LGM!7NA!I>!AL7!AOCK7A7?!IC!AL7!K7=7CO:!NOM7!GM!KG87=!B7:IX9!)A!MLIXM!ALOA!G>!3()&+!

I;ACO=UM!*'#%P!AL7=!AL7!;=XO=A7?!@CIMI?GN!C7@OGC!NO=?G?OA7!!XG=M9!!

SaDV!! p)p! &\2! 3()&+! *'#%!

! "! (!!!"! ! !

! (! !S"!!!(V!!!!(!

!

$! ! ! !S"!!!V!S(!!!V!

! =)?),& (!!!"! !!!(!!!"! !!

)=!IAL7C!XIC?MP!C7@:ONG=K!AL7!C7:78O=A!>7NA!I=!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!@C7?GNAGI=M!I>!AL7!AL7ICJP!>IC!AL7!C7OMI=!ALOA!2N"OCALJ!

O8IC!AL7!;=XO=A7?!NO=?G?OA7P!O=?!AL7M7!

NI=MACOG=AM!NO=!AC;>7NA!I>!AL7!AOCK7A7?!NI=MACOG=A9!(!O=?!!OC7!=IA!7Q;O:!G=!

>OGAL>;:=7MMP!>OG:G=K!AI!MOAGM>J!SaEVOb!(!8GI:OA7M!3()&+!O=?!!?I7M!=IA9!

! )!NI=N:;?7!ALOA!&OCK7A7?!"I=MACOG=AM!?I!=IA!@C7M7=A!O!8GOB:7!MACOA7KJ!>IC!?7O:G=K!XGAL!@CIMI?J\M7K


49/235

! ga!

MACOA7KJ!GM!AI!M7@OCOA7!#&!NI=MACOG=AM!G=AI!N:OMM7M!BOM7?!I=!XLOA!AJ@7!I>!@LI=I:IKGNO:!

NOA7KICJ!AL7J!C7>7C!AIP!O=?!AI!GGZ7?!CO=UG=KM!B7AX77=!ALIM7!N:OMM7M!I>!NI=MACOG=AM!

G=!IC?7C!AI!?7CG87!OMJ

M7K7CM!>CIGCMAP!MI!@CIMI?J\M7KGZ7?!CO=UG=KMP!O=?!M7NI=?P!GA!C7:G7M!I=!O=!OCBGACOCJ!

M7@OCOAGI=!I>!NI=MACOG=AM!G=AI!NOA7KICG7M9!

! &L7!N:OMM7M!I>!@CI@7CAG7M!S[C7@C7M7=AOAGI=O:!NOA7KICG7M[V!G=AI!XLGNL!?7!,ONJ!?G8G?7M!

AL7!@LI=I:IKGNO:!XIC:?!OC7!:GMA7?!B7:IXP!AIK7AL7C!XGAL!AL7!N:OMM7M!I>!#&!NI=MACOG=AM!AI!XLGNL!AL7!NOA7KICG7M!NICC7M@I=?!S?7!,ONJ!DEEeb!DV9!

!

SaeV! O9! %ACG=K!MAC;NA;C7!SAL7!=;!M7K


50/235

! gD!

/7!,ONJ[M!@CI@IMO:!GM!AI!M7@OCOA7!NI=MACOG=AM!G=AI!N:OMM7M!ALOA!NICC7M@I=?!AI!AL7!

C7@C7M7=AOAGI=O:!NOA7KICG7M!O=?!AI!GGZ7?!CO=UG=KM!B7AX77=!ICNG=K!?7>O;:A!>IIA!MAC;NA;C7P!'./0".P!@7=O:GYG=K!>;::!8IX7:M!G=!;=MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7MP!

O=?!)/.$&kCI;=?nP!O!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!ALOA!


51/235

! ge!

SaiV!?7!,ONJ!SDEEeb!dV!! p@OAIp! )/.$&kCI;=?n! './0".! &'#"+..!! @xAI! ! j! !! @xAq! j! ! !$! @qA! ! ! j!!

'7NO::!AL7!O=O:IKI;M!7ZOCI!

G87\8IX7:!G=87=AICJ!G=!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M!O=?!O!ALC77\

8IX7:!G=87=AICJ!G=!;=MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M9!+GKL\CO=UG=K!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI;:?!NO;M7!MAC7MM!AI!

B7!OAACONA7?!AI!;=XO=A7?!G=A7CONAGI=!NO=!B7!C;:7?!I;A!BJ!GGZ7?!CO=UG=K!B7AX77=!@CIMI?GN!

O=?!>7OA;CO:!NI=MACOG=AM9!)>!O::!@CIMI?GN!NI=MACOG=AM!:GU7!&'#"+..!OC7!C7Q;GC7?!AI!CO=U!

OBI87!O::!>7OA;CO:!NI=MACOG=AM!:GU7!)/.$&kCI;=?nP!ALGM!AJ@7!I>!G=A7CONAGI=!GM!C;:7?!I;AP!OM!

MLIX=!G=!AL7!AOB:7O;!B7:IX9!!

!

SacV!?7!,ONJ!SDEEeb!dV!! p@OAIp! &'#"+..! ! )/.$&kCI;=?n! './0".!"! @xAI! ! ! ! j!"! @xAq! ! ! j! !! @qA! j! ! ! !!

/7!,ONJ[M!MACOA7KJ!GM!O!K7=7CO:!I=79!&L7!@CIB:77OA;C7M!O=?!MAC7MM!?GMN;MM7?!G=!AL7!@C78GI;M!NLO@A7C!OC7!C;:7?!I;A!OM!:I=K!OM!AL7!

>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=AM!>IC!ALIM7!>7OA;C7M!OC7!C7Q;GC7?!AI!CO=U!B7:IX!AL7!C7:78O=A!MAC7MM!

@:ON7:O@@G=K!G=A7CONAGI=P!AL7!

@CIMI?GN!NI=MACOG=AM!OC7!C7Q;GC7!AI!CO=U!OBI87!AL7!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!8GI:OA7?!BJ!AL7!

pAp!"!!k&n!


52/235

! gg!

MAC;NA;C7r!SDEEeb!aEV9!&L7!M;@@ICAG=K!7ZO>7NAb!GA!GM!AL7!8IGN7?P!=IA!AL7!8IGN7:7MM!NI=MI=O=AM!ALOA!

@C7>7C!AI!MJ::OBG>J!OM!NI?OMP!;=?7C!@C7MM;C7!I>!MJ::OB:7!NI=AONA9!WLOA!GM!@CIB:7GZ7?P!AL7!;=XO=A7?!@C7?GNAGI=!?I7M!=IA!OCGM79!

!

SDEV!! ! ! $#"#/(! j"#2*,.! ! (-'..! )/.$&!pO?COp! "! O9?CO! ! j! ! ! !! ! O?9CO! j! ! ! ! !pOACOp! "! O9?CO! ! j! ! ! j!

! "! O9ACO! ! j! ! j! !! ! OA9CO! j! ! ! ! !!

)>P!OM!G=!SDEVP!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!$#"#/(!CO=UM!OBI87!j"#2*,.P!AL7!I;A@;AM!>IC!BIAL!

pO?COp!O=?!pOACOp!LO87!O!NI!AL7!C787CM7!CO=UG=K!LI:?MP!BIAL!G=@;AM!


53/235

! gf!

@CI?;N7!>ICI::IXG=K!?GOKCOGZ7?!CO=UG=K!@CI@IMO:!C7:78O=A!AI!AL7!

?GMN;MMGI=!L7C79!!

SDaV! ! ! ! ! ! 2US*CIMI?JV!!!! ! 2US37OA;C7MV! ! ! ! 3OGALS37OA;C7MV!!

)=!AL7!C7!ALGM!M7NAGI=!)!XG::!?GMN;MM!AL7!NI=M7Q;7=N7M!I>!?7!,ONJ[M!@CI@IMO:!>IC!

MAC7MM\M7K>7NAM!OC7!BCI;KLA!G=AI!AL7!@GNA;C79!)!XG::!O:MI!?GMN;MM!

MI:;7=N7!O::!IAL7C!

@LI=I:IKGNO:!NOA7KICG7M9!(!M;


54/235

! gF!

NI=MG?7COAGI=M!NO=!AC;ONAICM9!+IX787CP!G>!j$0"yGP;z!GM!O::IX7?!AI!I;ACO=U!MAC7MM!NI=MACOG=AMP!AL7=!MAC7MM!!AL7!MI=ICGAJ!NI=MACOG=A!OBI87!MAC7MMP!B;A!B7NO;M7!2(!I;ACO=UM!AL7!MAC7MM!

NI=MACOG=A9!)=?77?P!GCMA!B:;ML!O@@7OCM!AI!7:G


55/235

! gi!

SDgV!! ! p@G:OAOp! j$0"yGP;z! *.$0,&! 2(!! O9! @G:xAO! j! ! !"! B9! @:xAO! ! ! j!"! N9! @|:AO! ! ! j!! ?9! @|:OAO! ! j! !!

+7C7P!*.$0,&!GM!CO=U7?!LGKL!7=I;KL!AI!7:G!OCK;GZ7?!

CO=UG=K!2US*CIMI?JV!!!!%ACG=K%AC;NA;C79c!(M!)!XG::!MLIXP!AL7!;=XO=A7?!NO=?G?OA7!SDeV?!NO=!MAG::!XG=!787=!XGAL!ALGM!OMM;CO=UG=K!j$0"yGP;z!!!!*.$0,&9!

! )=!IC?7C!>IC!SDeV?!AI!XG=!KG87=!ALOA!*.$0,&!!!!2(P!MIG=?!XOJM!G=!XLGNL!SBV!O=?!SNV!OC7!

XICM7!ALO=!SOV!O=?!S?Vb!>IC!I=7!ALG=KP!AL7J!LO87!


56/235

! gc!

^;MA!OM!G=!AL7!NOM7!SDeVP!AL7!G=@;A!p@O:OAOp!XI;:?!M;C>ON7!XGAL!?7>O;:A!@7=;:AG

@CIMI?GN!XI;:?!IC!O!MGIIA!MAC;NA;C7!NI=MACOG=AMP!G=!

IC?7C!AI!ONNI;=A!>IC!BIAL!MI=ICGAJ\?CG87=!O=?!=I=\MI=ICGAJ\?CG87=!MAC7MM9!)A!GM!=IA!

NC;NGO:!ALOA!AL7!?7NGMGI=!I=!XL7C7!AI!@:ON7!MI=ICGAJ\MAC7MM!NI=MACOG=AM!B7!

KCOG=7?!MAC;NA;C7!XGAL!>IIA!O=?!MJ::OB:7!@CIMI?J!M7@OCOA7?!G=AI!AXI!NOA7KICG7M9!

!

!!


57/235

! gd!

SDiV! MI=ICGAJpMAC7MM! ! ! MAC7MM!! ! !!!!!\MAC;N!! ! !! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!IAL7C!MI=ICGAJ!!

+IX787CP!GA!A;C=M!I;A!ALOA!787=!SDiV!GM!=IA!7=I;KL9!&L7!j$0"yGP;z!NI=MACOG=A!?GMN;MM7?!OBI87!GM!C7O::J!O!MI=ICGAJ\MAC7MM!NI=MACOG=A!>CI

j$#$+.(/yqPGP;z!SOMM;! %I!>OC!)!LO87!;M7?!O!NI87C!NI=MACOG=A!>IC!MAC7MM!AI!C7>7C!AI!M787CO:!NI=MACOG=AM!OA!I=N7P!

79K9!*.$0,&!MLI;:?!B7!@CI@7C:J!?7NI


58/235

! fE!

M7KICXOC?:J!OM!X7::b!AL7!)/.$&!NI=MACOG=AM!O::!C7>7C!AI!>7OA;C7MP!AL7!2(!O=?!/.*!

NI=MACOG=AMP!OA!:7OMA!G=!MI!#&P!C7>7C!AI!M7K!G=A7C7MA!>IC!@CIMI?J!M7K!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=P!AL7!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!8IX7:!7@7=AL7MGM!O=?!8IX7:!


59/235

! fa!

MJ=NI@79!(M!)!XG::!OCK;7!G=!"LO@A7C!gP!MJ=NI@7!O=?!7@7=AL7MGM!OC7!C7MACGNA7?!G=!A7C!

7=8GCI=GNO=A!@CIN7?;CO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!

OBI;A!AL7M7!AXI!@CIN7MM7Mb!7@7=AL7MGM!;=G87CMO::J!M7C87M!AI!C7MI:87!NI=MI=O=A!N:;MA7C!

@LI=IAONAGNMP!XLG:7!MJ=NI@7!AOCK7AM!X7OU!S;=MAC7MM7?P!;=@OCM7?P!7AN9V!8IX7:M9!"I=87CM7:JP!7@7=AL7MGM!GM!=IA!;M7?!OM!O!C7M@I=M7!>IC!8GI:OAGI=M!I>!IC!=IXP!)!OMM;!>GZ7?!CO=UG=KM!IC!N:;MA7C!@LI=IAONAGNM!

C77:J!CO=U7?!XGAL!C7M@7NA!AI!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!OKOG=MA!IC!IC!IC!2(\4P!AL7!>GZ7?!CO=UG=KM!OC7!Q;GA7!?G>>7C7=A9!#=!AL7!I=7!LO=?P!2(\4!


60/235

! fD!

SDcV! ! ! ! ! ! ! /.*\4! ! ! ! 2(\4!

!! ! %5,,%&'0"!! ! 2.&')"(,! ! ! !%W*!!!

(:ALI;KL!7GZ7?!CO=UG=KM!XGAL!ALGM!O!?7AOG:!B7NI>GN;:A!

AI!];MAG>J9!2IC7!M7CGI;M:JP!AL7!G


61/235

! fe!

XI;:?!M;C7:J!?I9!(=?!J7AP!=I=7!I>!AL7M7!GM!OAA7MA7?9!&I!B7!M;C7P!>G=O:!=OMO:GYOAGI=P!

7@7=AL7MGMP!O=?!?7:7AGI=!OC7!NI


62/235

! fg!

AXI!I;A@;AM!>OC7!7Q;O::J!I=!MI! (@@:JG=K!AL7!@CI@IMO:!AI!:OCJ=K7O:!G=A7CONAGI=MP!%A7CGO?7!>GCMA!?7ICCI;MGI=!@IA7=AGO::JP!IAL7C!MI;CN7M9!%A7CGO?7!OCCG87M!OA!O!MNO:7!I>!@7CN7G87?!MGIC!XLJ!?7:7AGI=!O=?!IAL7C!@CIN7MM7M!:GU7!ALIM7!G=!

SDdVN\B!OC7!=IA!8GOB:7!C7@OGCM!>IC!>G=O:!8IGNG=Kb!M@7OU7CM!?I!=IA!@GNU!ALIM7!C7@OGCM!B7NO;M7!

AL7C7!GM!O:XOJM!O!:7MM!@7CN7@AGB:7!O:A7C=OAG87!O8OG:OB:7P!=OON7?b!AL7C7!GM!O!!AL7M7!AXI!C7@OGCMP!I=:J!I=7!GM!

AJ@I:IKGNO::J!OAA7MA7?9!

! &L7!O


63/235

! ff!

&L7!>GZ7?!CO=UG=K!?7CG87?!>CIOGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=AM!

O=?!?7A7C!AL7!G=@;A!X7C7!B7AA7C!SG979!:7MM!@7CN7@A;O::J!

NIMA:JV!ALO=!IAL7CM9!

! &LGM!M7A;@!MI;::J!>OGAL>;:!NO=?G?OA7!9;1"#!M7C87M!OM!O!UG=?!I>!BOM7:G=7!XGAL!

XLGNL!NIIC!@7CN7@A;O:!MGONAM!

NO=!B7!7MAOB:GML7?P!AL7=!AL7!>GZ7?!CO=UG=K!B7AX77=!>OGAL>;:=7MM!AI!MAC7MM!O=?!>OGAL>;:=7MM!

AI!OM@GCOAGI=!XI;:?!LI:?P!$#3,#*%&'.%%!!!!$#3,#*\"P!A!OM@GCOAGI=P!G=MI>OC!OM!BIAL!ONLG787!AL7!MO

BJ!(%*)'(&.!G=N;C!AL7!:7OMA!@7CN7@A;O:!NIMA9!+IX787CP!;=:GU7!G=!AL7!>OGAL>;:=7MM!7ZO!NIIC!@7CN7@A;O:!

MGCIIC


64/235

! fF!

! 3IC!=IX!:7A!

L7OC7CP!G979!O8IG?O=N7!I>!@7CN7@AGB:7!?78GOAGI=M!>CI

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!d!&LGM!?7>G=GAGI=!GM!M;@7C>GNGO::J!MG


65/235

! fi!

r&L7!8G7X!@C7M7=A7?!L7C7!GM!ALOA!M@7OU7CM!OC7!ONAG87:J!NI=N7C=7?!XGAL!O8IG?G=K!9/8=/91.CIOC! OM! GA! C7!

)>!%A7CGO?7[M!K7=7CO:!@CI@IMO:!GM!AI!B7!7ZA7=?7?!AI!AL7!G=A7CONAGI=M!B7AX77=!M7K

:IKGNO::J!@IMMGB:7!XOJM!I>!C7MI:8G=K!G=@;AM!:GU7!pOBCOpb!7GAL7C!=IA!LO87!O!8IGN7?!MAI@!IC!

=IA!LO87!O!NI?OP!G979!7GAL7C!AI!>GZ!M7KGZ!@CIMI?J9!&LGM!XI;:?!KG87!AL7!

I;A@;AM!kO@9COn!O=?!kO9BCOnP!C7M@7NAG87:J9!

!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!SaV!kO@9COn!S3GZ!M7K


66/235

! fc!

&L7!NLIGN7!B7AX77=!SaV!O=?!SDV!?7@7=?M!I=!AL7!C7:OAG87!CO=UG=K!I>!)/.$&k8IGn!O=?!

j"#2*,.b!G>!AL7!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!GM!:IX\CO=U7?P!AL7=!AL7!I;A@;A!NI=AOG=M!O!

?78IGN7?!MAI@P!B;A!G>!AL7!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!GM!LGKL!CO=U7?P!AL7!I;A@;A!NI=AOG=M!O!

NI7NA!AL7!!pO@COpP!OM!G::;MACOA7?!G=!AL7!>I::IXG=K!AOB:7O;9!

!

SeaV!! ! ! jkl8IGnp"#/(! )/.$&k8IGn! j"#2*,.! $#"#/(!pOBCOp! "! kO@9COn! ! jSV! ! j!! "! kO9BCOn! ! ! jSV! !! ! kOB9COn! j! ! ! j!! ! kO9@COn! ! jSV! jSV! !

pO@COp! "! kO@9COn! ! ! ! j!! ! kO9@COn! ! ! j! !!

#=N7!OKOG=P!AL7!C7:78O=A!@CI@7CAJP!MJ::OBG>GNOAGI=P!GM!=IA!@C7M7=A!G=!AL7!G=@;A9!)=!IC?7C!AI!

;M7!AI!*\GNOAGI=!

?I7M!=IA!=7N7MMOCG:J!G=8I:87!O=J!@7CN7@AGB:7!?G>>7C7=N7Mb!kOB9COn!O=?!kO9BCOn!NO=!B7!

@CI=I;=N7?!G?7=AGNO::J9!#>!AL7!AXI!C7@OGCMP!AL7!@CIMI?GN!C7@OGC!#*CI

@C7>7CC7?9!&L7!*\OG:M!AI!C;:7!I;A!AL7!;=XO=A7?!I;A@;A!G=!ALGM!

7ZO


67/235

! fd!

)=!O!!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7P!AL7!87CJ!I@AGI=!I>!

@CIMI?GN!C7MAC;NA;CG=K!?I7M!=IA!7ZGMA9!

! +IX787CP!OM!)!XG::!MLIX!B7:IXP!AL7!*\!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7!G=!:OCJ=K7O:!=7;ACO:GYOAGI=9!&L7!K7=7CO:!@C7?GNAGI=!I>!AL7!*\!GA!7ZGMAM!OA!O::P!MLI;:?!$.4.'!NI=?GAGI=!M7KOGAL>;:=7MMP!B7NO;M7!

JG=K!NI87CA!MAC;NA;C7!GM!BJ!?7>G=GAGI=!@7CN7@A;O::J!NL7O@7C!ALO=!JG=K!

O=JALG=K!I87CA9!&LGM!GM!AL7!:G!O!MGA;OAGI=!XL7C7!AL7!NLIGN7!I>!AL7!@CIMI?GN!

C7@OGC!G=8I:87M!O!?7M7KI::IX7?!GICI;C!@IMMGBG:GAG7M!I>!>IIAG=KP!

XLGNL!OC7!G?7=AGNO:!I=!AL7!M;C>ON7!B;A!C7@C7M7=A!?G>>7C7=A!


68/235

! FE!

@CIN7MM!I>!K:IAAO:!MAI@!?7:7AGI=!G=!"O@O=OL;O!S,IIM!adFiP!%O>GC!adidP!,IIM!adcFP!

-I=Yx:7Y!DEEDV9!*CG!AL7!AXI!MLO@7M!MNL7OMLGI=!ALOA!XI;:?!I87CA:J!MGK=O:!AL7!

@C7M7=N7!I>!M7NI=?OCJ!MAC7MM!>77A!@IMGA7?!G=!SeeVP!=IC!GM!AL7C7!O=J!IAL7C!NICC7:OA7!I>!

M7NI=?OCJ!MAC7MM!S,IIM!adFiP!-I=Yx:7Y!@9N9V9!+IX787CP!AL7!NI87CA!>77A!!AL7!K:IAAO:!MAI@9!(M!MLIX=!G=!AL7!>I::IXG=K!

7ZOIIA\>G=O::JP!MI!ALOA!AL7!!AL7!*\GN7M!M7KOGAL>;:=7MM!AI!NI87CA!@CIMI?J9!

&L7!@CIMI?J\M7K


69/235

! Fa!

! #=7!@IMMGB:7!O=MX7C!AI!ALGM!OCK;7CC7?9!,O=K;OK7M!MACG87!>IC!

XOJM!I>!I87CA:J!C7O:GYG=K!AL7!NI87CA!!ALG=UG=KP!NO=!B7!MOG?!AI!

7;=NAGI=O::J!;=NAGI=!G=!MGK=O:G=K!NI87CA!


70/235

! FD!

! &L7!*\OGAL>;:!!I87CA!M7KIC!8IX7:!C7?;NAGI=!G=!;=>IIA7?!MJ::OB:7MP!AL7=!AL7C7!GM!O:XOJM!AL7!@IMMGBG:GAJ!I>!NI=MAC;NAG=K!O!NI87CA!M7NI=?OCJ!MAC7MM!

>IIA!I87C!ALIM7!C7?;NGB:7!MJ::OB:7M!G=!IC?7C!AI!MO87!AL7CI

AL7!:7AA7C!I>!AL7!*\C77P!XLG:7!AL7!?O=K7C!I>!C7?;NG=K!8IX7:M!LOM!@7CN7@A;O:!NI=M7Q;7=N7M9!,GU7XGM7P!G>!O!

:O=K;OK7!S79K9!2OCI77A!I87C!:I=K!8IX7:M!G=!IAL7C!@IMGAGI=M!I>!AL7!XIC?!G=!IC?7C!AI!O::IX!AL7OGAL>;::J!M;C>ON79!(KOG=P!

I=!AL7!*\!NLIGN7P!B7NO;M7!AL7C7!GM!=I!NIMA!G=!

AL7!NI87CA!G==I8OAGI=P!XLG:7!AL7!B7=7>GA!I>!B;G:?G=K!O!M7NI=?OCJ!MAC7MM!>IIA!XI;:?!B7!AL7!

>OGAL>;:!C7=?GAGI=!I>!O!8IX7:!ALOA!XI;:?!IAL7CXGM7!MLICA7=9!

! ,IIUG=K!OA!:7MM!7ZAC7GN;:A!AI!A7OM7!I;Ab!AL7C7!GM!=IALG=K!-.$.'(,!OBI;A!LIX!@CIMI?J!

O=?!M7KI::IXM!>CI!AL7!AL7ICJ9!'OAL7CP!AL7!@C7?GNAGI=M!OC7!AI!B7!78O:;OA7?!I=!O!NOM7\BJ\NOM7!BOMGMP!?7A7C!

G=A7CONAGI=!XL7AL7C!B7G=K!;=>OGAL>;:!AI!@CIMI?J!IC!;=>OGAL>;:!AI!M7KG=A7=MGAJ!?J=O!=7GKLBICG=K!MJ::OB:7M9!*LI=7AGNO::J!@:O;MGB:7!ONNI;=AM!I>!47C=7C[M!,OX!O@@7O:!AI!LGKL!@GANLP!COAL7C!ALO=!@;C7:J!OBMACONA!@CIONAIC9!,GU7XGM7P!O7CI?J=OONAICM!OC7!:GU7:J!7Z@:O=OAGI=M!>IC!.=K:GML\MAJ:7!O:A7C=OAGI=M!:GU7!OM@GCOAGI=!O=?!>:O@@G=K9!(A!AL7!MO


71/235

! Fe!

?GC7NAGI=O:GAJ!I>!@CIMI?J\M7KGM!I=7!I>!?J=O!87CJ!:GB7CO:!XGAL!M7K>7C7=N7M!

B7AX77=!


72/235

! Fg!

ONNIC?G=K!AI!AL7!*\!O!>7OA;C79!+IX787CP!!OBMACONA=7MM!XGAL!XLGNL!AL7!*\


73/235

! Ff!

"+(*&.'!e!

(%522.&')"(,!)$&.'("&)#$%!($/!(%522.&')"(,!"#$%&'()$&%!

!

eeee9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=9E!)=ACI?;NAGI=!

&

&L7!ALC77!O@@CIONL7M!AI!AII\

GN;:A!NOM7M!O=?!O=O:JM7M9!%;C>ON7\ICG7=A7?!

AL7ICG7M!M;NL!OM!AL7!*\!

7ONL!@OCAGN;:OC!NOM7P!>ON7!ALGM!?G>>GN;:AJ!G=!O=!7M@7NGO::J!ON;A7!>ICG7?!ONNI;=A!>IC!O!MJMA77C7=A!

@LI=7AGNM9!&L7!OG!ALGM!NLO@A7C!GM!AI!C7>7CG=K!O!K7=7CO:!

O=O:JMGM!I>!=I=\M;C>ON7\BOM7?!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!ALOA!AC7OAM!AL7

@LI=I:IKGNO:!@CIB:7I::IXM9!)!B7KG=!BJ!OCK;G=K!OKOG=MA!O!@IA7=AGO:!IB]7NAGI=!

ALOA!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!OBI;A!G=@;A\I;A@;A!


74/235

! FF!

e9e9e9e9a!)M!Aa!)M!Aa!)M!Aa!)M!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!MJ=NLCI=GNhL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!MJ=NLCI=GNhL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!MJ=NLCI=GNhL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!MJ=NLCI=GNh!

!

&L7!MLICANI!AL7!@C78GI;M!O@@CIONL7M!?GMN;MM7?!G=!AL7!:OMA!NLO@A7CP!)!M;KK7MAP!

OC7!?;7!AI!O!K7=7CO:!@CI@7CAJ!I>!#&b!GAM!CO?GNO:!N:OGGNO=A!@LI=I:IKGNO:!

K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!OC7!:INOA7?!G=!AL7!NLOCONA7C!I>!I;A@;A!>ICON7!#&!O=?!G=!>O8IC!I>!O!AL7ICJ!I>!@LI=I:IKJ!ALOA!O>>IC?M!BIAL!UG=?M!I>!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!AL7GC!

@:ON79!+IX787CP!M;NL!O!N:OGI::IX!>CI

I>!AJ@I:IKGNO::J!IBM7C8OB:7!@CIN7?;CO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=MP!B7NO;M7!O=J!@LI=I:IKGNO:!

K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!NO=!@IA7=AGO::J!B7!MJ=NLCI=GNO::J!G=7CA!B;A!OCGM7!ALCI;KL!7ZA7C=O:!>ONAICM!

M;NL!OM!?GONLCI=GN!A7=?7=NG7M9!)>!ALGM!GM!AL7!NOM7P!O!MJ=NLCI=GN!AL7ICJ!I>!:G=K;GMAGN!

NIIC!?7O:G=K!XGAL!M;NL!O!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=9!&L;MP!B7>IC7!)!

A;C=!AI!?787:I@G=K!AL7!

AL7ICJ!AI!ONNI;=A!>IC!=I=\M;C>ON7\BOM7?!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=MP!GA!GM!=7N7MMOCJ!AI!MLIX!ALOA!AL7!

C7:78O=A!N:OG!KCOIC!IAL7C!C7OMI=Mb!

B7NO;M7!AL7J!OC7!?G>>GN;:A!AI!:7OC=!IC!AI!@CIN7MMP!IC!B7NO;M7!AL7C7!GM!=I!NI=N7G8OB:7!

?GONLCI=GN!@OAL!ALOA!:7O?M!AI!AL7!KCO


75/235

! Fi!

;=G87CMO:!IC!O=!ONNG?7=AO:!>ONA!ALOA!NO=!B7!7Z@:OG=7?!XGALI;A!G=8IUG=K!G==OA7!@CI@7CAG7M!

I>!KCOONAM!>O::!G=!AL7!NOA7KICJ!I>![;=G87CMO:M[!IC!

[AJ@I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M[!G=!AL7!M7=M7!I>!TG@OCMUJ!DEEg9!

! (@@:JG=K!M787CO:!I>!TG@OCMUJ[M!NCGA7CGO!AI!@CIMI?J\M7K!AL7!U=IX:7?K7!I>!:O=K;OK79!

! TG@OCMUJ!OCK;7M!ALOA!AC;7!;=G87CMO:M!OC7!)''.4.'%)1,.!G=!AL7!M7=M7!ALOA!:O=K;OK7!

NLO=K7!NO==IA!M;B87CA!AL7CI

&L7C7!GM!O!NI!787=AM!NO==IA!INN;C9!'OAL7CP!TG@OCMUJ!

OCK;7MP!XL7=787C!GA!?I7M!INN;CP!AL7!C7M;:A!XG::!B7P!>CI!8G7XP!O=!OCBGACOCJ!MAC7MM!MJMA7

AL7!@CI?;NAG87!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!ALOA!AL7!8IX7:!D!GM!IB:GKOAICG:J!MAC7MM7?9!)=!IAL7C!XIC?MP!

AL7!MI=ICGAJ!LG7COCNLJ!GM!O!AC;7!;=G87CMO:!7=MLCG=7?!G=!0-!B7NO;M7!GA!NI=MACOG=M!

:O=K;OK7!NLO=K79!


76/235

! Fc!

! &LGM!NCGA7CGI=!I>!)''.4.'%)1),)&5!G=?GNOA7M!ALOA!AL7!OMJALOA!:7O?M!AI!O!MJ=NLCI=GN!MJMA7

7Z@:OG=7?!G=!?7AOG:!G=!"LO@A7C!aP!AL7C7!GM!O!NI7OA;C7M!AI!B7!M7=MGAG87!AI!MAC7MM9!&LGM!A7=?7=NJ!:7O?M!AI!O!MJ=NLCI=GN!MAOA7!XL7C7!AL7!

:INOAGI=!I>!AL7!NI=MI=O=AO:!>7OA;C7!NO=!B7!@C7?GNA7?!G=!A7C!AL7!:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM9!

3CIIC!O!:O=K;OK7!AI!?787:I@!O!MJMA7!AL7!MAC7MM!MJMA7CI

8IGN7?!IC!:7=GA7?!M7KG=O:!MJ::OB:7!B7KG=M!XGAL!kBnP!kKnP!IC!k&ns!! ! ?9! .:M7!AI!AL7!>G=O:!MJ::OB:79!!

(:ALI;KL!MAC7MM!GM!=ICG=O:P!GA!MLG>AM!AI!AL7!@7=;:A!];MA!XL7=!AL7!>G=O:!MJ::OB:7[M!

I=M7A!GM!O!8IGN7?!MAI@!IC!O!k&nP!OM!G::;MACOA7?!BJ!AL7!AXI!C7@C7M7=AOAG87!GA7


77/235

! Fd!

SDV!! O9! p@OUIp! !!! k@OUn! ! [@ON;[!! ! B9! p@OCOAp! !!! k@x&OAn! ! [N;CG

! &L7!OCK;


78/235

! iE!

:INOAGI=!I>!O!NI=MI=O=AO:!@CI@7CAJ!NO=!OCGM7!ALCI;KL!OA!:7OMA!AXI!XOJM!?GONLCI=GNO::J9!

3GCMAP!NI=MI=O=AO:!>7OA;C7M!M;NL!OM!OM@GCOAGI=!NO=!?787:I@!G=!@CIMI?GNO::J!MACI=K!

@IMGAGI=MP!OM!LO@@7=7?!G=!.=K:GML9!%7NI=?P!@CIMI?GNO::J!MACI=K!@IMGAGI=M!NO=!@CIA7NA!

OM@GCOAGI=!>CIO8IC!I>!AL7!MAC7MM\M7K

e9e9e9e9D!,IN;M!I>!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=D!,IN;M!I>!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=D!,IN;M!I>!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=D!,IN;M!I>!AL7!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=!

!

(MM;7X7C!XOJM!ALO=!AL7!>C77:J!G=A7CONAG=KP!I;A@;A\ICG7=A7?!NI=MACOG=AM!ALOA!#&!XI;:?!

!?GMN;MMG=K!O!AII\?I!XIC?\>G=O:!?78IGNG=KP!%A7CGO?7!@IG=AM!I;A!ALOA!AL7!@CIB:7

AL7!!O!

?7CG8OAGI=O:!AL7ICJP!C;:7M!rNI=M@GC7r!AI!NC7OA7!O!@OCAGN;:OC!I;A@;A!MAC;NA;C7P!>CI

@IG=A!I>!8G7X!I>!#&!NI=MACOG=AM!rNI=M@GC7r!AI!@CI?;N7!I=:J!MI


79/235

! ia!

rTGMM7B7CAL[M!SadiEV!G=MGKLA!ALOA!NI=M@GCONG7M!OCGM7!XL7=!AL7!MI;=?!MJMA7GN!AOCK7A!MAC;NA;C7!8GO!!>G=O:!?78IGNG=K!OG!>G=O:!IBMAC;7=A!=OMO:GYOAGI=P!?7:7AGI=P!!@OCAGN;:OC!I;A@;A!

>IC!AL7GC!?7CG8OAGI=O:!@CI87=O=N7P!O=?!I>!O=J!IAL7C!@CI@7CAJ!I>!AL7!

KCOON7!>ICGN!7ZO


80/235

! iD!

MOIC!O!IC!O!:GNGA!C7@OGC!MACOA7KJP!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!!ALOA!M;C>ON7!>IC!AL7!C7:78O=A!@CI@7CAG7M!G=!GA9!&LGM!ON7?!XGAL!O=!I;A@;A!XL7C7!MAC7MM!O=?!OM@GCOAGI=!NIINN;C!I=!AL7!MOIC

B7LO87?!LO?!OM@GCOAGI=!=IA!B77=!@C7M7=A9!)=!IAL7C!XIC?MP!G>!O=!#&!G:7!!AL7!KCO!ALGM!NI=MACOG=A9!%;@@IM7!AL7C7!OC7!AXI!:O=K;OK7MP!G!O=?!HP!XLGNL!LO87!?G>>7C7=A!MAC7MM!

MJMA7G=O:!MJ::OB:7!BJ!?7>O;:AP!XLG:7!:O=K;OK7!H!MAC7MM7M!AL7!

G=GAGO:!MJ::OB:79!(=!G=@;A!XGALI;A!OM@GCOAGI=!:GU7!p@GAOp!XI;:?!M;C>ON7!XGAL!>G=O:!O=?!

G=GAGO:!MAC7MM!G=!AL7!AXI!:O=K;OK7MP!C7M@7NAG87:J9!$IX!M;@@IM7!O=!G=@;A!XGAL!OM@GCOAGI=P!

p@GALOpP!M;C>ON7M!G=!BIAL!:O=K;OK7M!XGAL!>G=O:!MAC7MMP!9.1";9!)=!ALGM!NOM7!MAC7MM!NO=!B7!MOG?!

AI!B7!OAACONA7?!AI!OM@GCOAGI=!G=!:O=K;OK7!HP!B7NO;M7!AL7!@C7M7=N7!I>!OM@GCOAGI=!>7C7=N7!>IC!AL7!:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM9!#=!AL7!IAL7C!LO=?P!:O=K;OK7!G!LOM!=I!MAC7MM\?CG87=!OM@GCOAGI=P!B7NO;M7!AL7!:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM!GM!AL7!MOIC


81/235

! ie!

SeV!! ! ,O=K;OK7!G! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ,O=K;OK7!H!! ! p@GAOp! !! ! 9.1;& & & & & & p@GAOp! !! ! 9:1#!! ! p@GALOp! !! ! 9.1";& & & & & & p@GALOp! !! ! 9.1";!! ! ! S=I!OAACONAGI=V! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! SOM@GCOAGI=\?CG87=!MAC7MMV! ! !!

&LGM!7ZOIC


82/235

! ig!

BIAL!@C7M7C87!AL7!@OCO::7:!MAC;NA;C7!I>!78O:;OAGI=!O=?!?7O:!M7CGI;M:J!XGAL!=I=\M;C>ON7!

K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!BJ!7:OBICOAG=K!7X!XIC?M!I>!NO;AGI=!OC7!G=!IC?7C!B7>IC7!)!@CIN77?!XGAL!AL7!O=O:JMGM9!(!N7=ACO:!

N:OG!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!GM!ALOA!AL7C7!OC7!N7CAOG=!@LI=I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!XLGNL!OC7!=IA!G=!AL7!I;A@;A!MAC;NA;C7M!B;A!G=!AL7!G=@;A\I;A@;A!>IC?!M;NL!

K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!AL7GC!@:ON7!G=!AL7!AL7ICJP!)!XG::!AOU7!AL7!ICXOC?!O@@CIONL!

@IMMGB:7b!)!XG::!G=ACI?;N7!O!=7X!N:OMM!I>!7C!AI!

@LI=I:IKGNO:!@CIN7MM7M!O=?!OMMGK=!7ZACO!8GI:OAGI=!;:=7MM!MJMA7!

8G7XP!O!AL7ICJ!I>!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=AM9!! )!XG::!OCK;7!B7:IX!ALOA!N;CC7=A!8G7XM!I>!G=@;A\I;A@;A!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NO==IA!?7O:!XGAL!

AL7!UG=?!I>!OMJ!!7GAL7CP!IC!BIALP!I>!AL7!N;CC7=A!AL7ICG7M!I>!

>OGAL>;:=7MM!O=?!!@CIN7?;CO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!OC7!AI!B7!ONNI;=A7?!

>IC9!)!NI=MG?7C!AL7!XICU!G=!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!AI!B7!O=!7Z@:ICOAGI=!I>!XLOA!GA!XI;:?!AOU7!>IC!

O![@;C7!!O!A7=OB:7![@;C7!

>OGAL>;:=7MM[!O@@CIONL!C7!AL7!AJ@7!7Z@:IC7?!G=!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!O!O!N7CAOG=!XOJ!I>!K7AAG=K!>CI

XG==G=KP!G979!XG::!G=ACI?;N7!NI=MACOG=AM!ALOA!?GC7NA:J!@7=O:GY7!ALIM7!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!G=8I:87!;=?7MGC7?!

G=@;A\I;A@;A!ICNLO@A7C!XG::!@CI8G?7!O=!O:KICGALIC!>G=?G=K!M;NL!NO=?G?OA7MP!O=?!>IC!7=M;CG=K!ALOA!AL7!8GI:OAGI=!@OAA7C=!I>!AL7!=7X!NI=MACOG=AM!7=AOG:M!ALIM7!NO=?G?OA7M[!@7C@7A;O:!:IM7C?I?GC7NA:J!AL7!?GC7NAGI=O:GAJ!I>!G=A7CONAGI=!B7AX77=!AXI!@LI=I:IKGNO:!NOA7KICG7MP!O=?!OMMGK=!

O!8GI:OAGI=!IC


83/235

! if!

>CI

! &L;MP!AL7!?GMN;MMGI=!B7KG=M!BJ!!#&9!)!XG::!AL7=!>ICNO=!ONNI;=A!>IC!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!;=?7C!?GMN;MMGI=9!

!e9e9e9e9e9a!&L7!=IAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!G=!#&e9a!&L7!=IAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!G=!#&e9a!&L7!=IAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!G=!#&e9a!&L7!=IAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!G=!#&!

!

)=!C;:7\BOM7?!@LI=I:IKJP!AL7!=IAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!GM!M7:>\7Z@:O=OAICJ9!'7XCGA7!C;:7M!AOU7!

I=7!>ICIC

NI;CM7!I>!O!?7CG8OAGI=!NICC7M@I=?M!AI!O!@CIN7MM9!&L7!NLO=K7!ALOA!AL7!C;:7!G=>:GNAM!;@I=!O!

>IC!OM!O!

NIICICXOC?:J!?7NICI!O!C;:79!

! )=!#&P!AL7C7!GM!=I!@CG!AL7!7OC:G7C!AL7ICG7M9aD!&L7C7!GM!I=:J!I=7!X7::\?7>G=7?!@CIN7MM!G=!#&P!AL7!

G=@;A\I;A@;A!!

rJG=Kr!O=!;=?7C:JG=K!>ICON7!>IC!XL7AL7C!O!@OCAGN;:OC!@CIN7MM!LOM!IC!LOM!=IA!O@@:G7?!G=!AL7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!aD!2N"OCALJ[M!AL7ICJ!I>!NO=?G?OA7!NLOG=M!S2N"OCALJ!DEEFVP!O=!GIC!>;A;C7!C7M7OCNL!AL7!Q;7MAGI=!I>!LIX!MAC;NA;C7\B;G:?G=K!I@7COAGI=M!M;NL!OM!MAC7MM!OMMGK=


84/235

! iF!

NI;CM7!I>!O!KG87=!?7CG8OAGI=!NO=!B7!MACOGKLA>ICXOC?:J!O=MX7C7?P!GA!GM!=IA!?GC7NA:J!

O=MX7COB:7!G=!O=!#&!?7CG8OAGI=9!,7A!G=O:!MJ::OB:7!GM!=IA!>IIA7?[!

! ! >9! "0,2)$! ! ! ! [&L7C7!GM!OA!:7OMA!I=7!>IIA!G=!787CJ!*CW?[!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!MAC;NA;C7!G=!K7=7CO:P!>GA!G=AI!AL7!AL7ICJP!O=?!XL7AL7C!GA!NO=!B7!;M7?!AI!NI=MACOG=!AL7!NO=?G?OA7!M@ON7!M;>>GNG7=A:J!AI!C;:7!I;A!AL7!;=XO=A7?!G=A7CONAGI=M!B7AX77=!@CIMI?J!O=?!M7K


85/235

! ii!

! ! ! 3&\1)$P!"0,2)$P!&'#"+..!! ! ! ! ! ! !! ! ! ! ! !!!!j)))!! ! ! ! ! ! !! ! ! ! ! $#$\3)$!! ! ! ! ! ! !! ! ! ! ! (,\3&\'!!

(::!I>!AL7M7!NI=MACOG=AM!OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!2(\

+.(/P!B7NO;M7!MAC7MM!G=!,OAG=!GM!SO:

MLG>A!B7NO;M7!O??G=K!GA!AI!AL7!KCOON7?!G=!GAM![=ICIC!AL7!>IC!MAC7MM!MLG>A9!&I!?7A7C>7NAM!MAC7MM!@:ON7>7C7=A!@:ON7!G=!AL7!I;A@;AM!I>!AL7!AXI!KCOI::IXM9!)!XG::!B7KG=!BJ!?7>G=G=K!O!NICC7M@I=?7=N7!C7:OAGI=!B7AX77=!

NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!MLOC7!O=!G=@;AP!!B7G=K![G=!O!?G>>7C7=A!@:ON7[!

G=!AXI!I;A@;AM!I>!AXI!KCO!%&'.%%!%+)3&!


86/235

! ic!

Se9e9a9DV9!+O8G=K!G::;MACOA7?!ALGM!@OCAGN;:OC!NOM7!I>!AL7!G=7!AL7!NI=N7@A!I>!/.%)-$(&./!%&(&.!I>!O!@LI=I:IKGNO:!IB]7NA!Se9e9a9eVP!XLGNL!XG::!

O::IX!>IC!O!K7=7CO:!?7>G=GAGI=!I>!*'#".%%!Se9e9a9gV9!

!#0&,)$.!3#'!&+.!'.%&!#3!&+.!%."&)#$!

SOV!/7>G=7!NICC7M@I=?7=N7!B7AX77=!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!MLOC7!O=!G=@;A! SBV!/7>G=7!%&'.%%!%+)3&! SNV!/7>G=7!/.%)-$(&./!%&(&.! S?V!/7>G=7!*'#".%%!

!

5*5*2*2&I(88/09($-/$=/&ICA!>IC!O!

@OCAGN;:OC!G=@;A!G>!C7CI>7C7=A!MAC7MM!@OAA7C=9!

! W7!=77?!AI!>GCMA!@G=!?IX=!AL7!NI=N7@A!I>![B7G=K!G=!AL7!MO>7C7=A!KCONI=N7@A!I>!&\"#''.%*#$/.$".!>CIG=GAGI=!B7:IX9!

!

SfV!! &&&&\\\\""""#''.%*#$/.$".#''.%*#$/.$".#''.%*#$/.$".#''.%*#$/.$".!S/7>G=GAGI=V!S2N"OCALJ!DEEebcV!! ! ,7A!=#$-2!O=?!=#$-4!B7!AXI!NO=?G?OA7M!>CI

IAL7C!NICC7M@I=?G=K!7:7!02!NICC7M@I=?M!AI!MI7C7=A!

KCO


87/235

! id!

! &LGM!?7>G=GAGI=!GM!MACOGKLA>ICXOC?!7=I;KL!XL7=!O@@:G7?!AI!ALIM7!OM@7NAM!I>!MAC;NA;C7!

ALOA!LO87!O=!G=@;A!NICC7MI@=?7=A9!1;AP!I>!NI;CM7P!7@7=AL7AGN!M7KG=GAGI=!G=!SfVP!?I!=IA!A\NICC7M@I=?!AI!

O=JALG=K9!(:MI!I;AMG?7!I>!AL7!MNI@7!I>!ALGM!?7>G=GAGI=!OC7!7:7IC!AL7!M7NI=?!O=?!ALGC?!

MJ::OB:7M!I>!ALIM7!>ICCIG=GAGI=!

G=!SfVP!B7NO;M7P!OCK;OB:JP!ALIM7!MJ::OB:7M!LO87!=I!NICC7M@I=?7=AM!G=!AL7!G=@;A!O=?!AL;M!AL7J!?I!=IA!A\NICC7M@I=?!AI!O=JALG=K9!)!XG::!XICU!OCI;=?!ALGM!@CIB:7

ALOA!AXI!MJ::OB:7M!A\NICC7M@I=?!AI!7ONL!IAL7C!G>!AL7!M7KG::!AL7GC!=;N:7G!A\

NICC7M@I=?9!!

!

SFV!! &&&&\\\\""""#''.%*#$/.$".#''.%*#$/.$".#''.%*#$/.$".#''.%*#$/.$".!S.ZA7=MGI=V!!! ! ,7A!=#$-2!O=?!=#$-4!B7!AXI!NO=?G?OA7M!>CI

=#$-2!O=?!!D!B7!O!MJ::OB:7!G=!=#$-49!&L7=!!a!A\NICC7M@I=?M!AI!!D!G>>!AL7!M7KG::G=K!AL7!=;N:7G!I>!!a!O=?!!D!A\NICC7M@I=?!ONNIC?G=K!AI!AL7!?7>G=GAGI=!G=!SfV9!

!

1J!ALGM!?7>G=GAGI=P!N:7OC:JP!AL7!>GCMA!MJ::OB:7M!I>!9":,.99)0&O=?!9".,:99)0!>CI

7ZO! &LGM!?7>G=GAGI=!7=AOG:M!ALOA!8IX7:!7@7=AL7MGM!O=?!?7:7AGI=P!OM!X7::!OM!IAL7C!MJ::OB:7\

O??G=K!I@7COAGI=MP!?I!=IA![?GMC;@A[!A\NICC7M@I=?7=N7!B7AX77=!MJ::OB:7Mb!G=!AL7!NO=?G?OA7!

XGAL!G=GAGO:!7@7=AL7MGM!D9":,.99)0P!AL7!M7NI=?!MJ::OB:7!9":!A\NICC7M@I=?M!AI!AL7!G=GAGO:!

MJ::OB:7!I>!9":,.99)0&B7NO;M7!AL7GC!=;N:7G!MLOC7!O=!G=@;A!O=?!AL;M!A\NICC7M@I=?9!&I!M77!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ae!(!MACI=K!OCK;OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=AM!C7>7CCG=K!AI!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7!SM77!TG@OCMUJ!AI!O@@7OCV9!)>!ALGM!GM!MIP!AL7=!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7!?I7M!>O::!;=?7C!AL7!MNI@7!I>!SfVP!O=?!C7Q;GC7M!=I!M@7NGO:!AC7OA


88/235

! cE!

LIX!8IX7:!MJ=NI@7!O>>7NAM!A\NICC7M@I=?7=N7P!NI=MG?7C!AL7!>I::IXG=K!AXI!NO=?G?OA7M!

MLOCG=K!O=!G=@;A!SiV9!(MM;

! &LGM!:7O?M!!%&'.%%!%+)3&P!?7>G=7?!>IC!MI


89/235

! ca!

)=!ALGM!M7=M7P!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!(%*)'(&.p!w!>ICN7M!O!MAC7MM!MLG>A!>IC!AL7!G=@;A!p@LG:G@@;MpP!

B7NO;M7!AL7!I;A@;A!G=!AL7!KCOIC>7C7=AP!OM!7Z@:OG=7?!OBI879!&L7!NI=MACOG=A!jkl8IGnP!I=!AL7!IAL7C!LO=?P!?I7M!=IA!>ICN7!O!MAC7MM!MLG>AP!B7NO;M7!GAM!@C7M7=N7!IC!OBM7=N7!G=!AL7!MJMA7>7NA!I=!AL7!

:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM9!,GU7XGM7P!(%*)'(&.p!w!?I7M!=IA!>ICN7!O!MAC7MM!MLG>A!>IC!AL7!G=@;A!

p@LOC7ACOp![Q;G87C[P!B7NO;M7!AL7!OM@GCOAGI=!GM!I=!AL7!MO


90/235

! cD!

! )=!AL7!MAC7MM!MLG>A!7ZO7CC7?!G=>ICO;:A[!@:ON7!I>!MAC7MM!m!

GAM!:INOAGI=!G=!AL7!I;A@;A!>IC!O!KCOG=GAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!B7JI=?!MAC7MMP!GA!GM!>GCMA!=7N7MMOCJ!AI!B7!![?7>O;:A[P!O=?!AI!7ZA7=?!GA!AI!@LI=I:IKGNO:!NOA7KICG7M!IAL7C!ALO=!

MAC7MM9!

! (=J!KG87=!@LI=I:IKGNO:!IB]7NAP!B7!GA!O!>7OA;C7P!O!@CIMI?GN!NI=MAGA;7=AP!O!AI=7P!O=?!MI!

>ICALP!NO=!B7!O>>7NA7?!BJ!O!>7NA7?!BJ!O!

NI=MACOG=A!G>!ALOA!IB]7NA!XI;:?!G=!MI>7C7=A:J!G>!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!X7C7!=IA!

AL7C7!m!G979!G>!GAM!A\NICC7M@I=?7=A!G=!AL7!KCO7C!AI!AL7!8O:;7!I>!O!>7OA;C7P!IC!GAM!:INOAGI=P!IC!AL7!

OMMINGOAGI=!:G=7M!I>!O!AI=7P!O=?!MI!>ICAL9!

! )=!IC?7C!AI!?7A7C>7NAM!

O!@LI=I:IKGNO:!IB]7NA!9P!X7!=77?!AI!NI!9!>IC!pGp!O=?!I!G=!L!GM!9[M!A\NICC7M@I=?7=A!G=!AL7!I@AG>7C7=N7!B7AX777=!AL7!AXIs!BIAL!?7@7=?!I=!AL7!?7>G=GAGI=!SdV9!

! *;A!MG!MIIC!O!KG87=!NI=MACOG=A!GM!LIX!ALOA!

IB]7NA!XI;:?!B7LO87!G>!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!X7C7!=IA!@C7M7=A9!! )!@IMA@I=7!AL7!?GMN;MMGI=!I>!


91/235

! ce!

XL7AL7C!AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!GM!;=GQ;7:J!?7A7CG=GAGI=!KG87=!G=!SdV!;=AG:!

%7NAGI=!e9e9g9!

! ,7A!!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!XGAL!MI


92/235

! cg!

5*5*2*P&+8(=/00!

!

&L7!NI=N7@A!I>!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!?7>G=7M!O!BOM7:G=7!I>!NICI

KCO>7NAG=K!99!

!

0=?7C!ALGM!G=GAGI=P!AL7!MAC7MM!MLG>A!>ICN7?!BJ!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!

(%*)'(&.p!w!G=!AL7!@M7;?I\,OAG=!7ZOICN7?!BJ!ALOA!NI=MACOG=A9!(=!7ZO!O!M7K:O@@G=K!G=!.=K:GMLP!>ICN7?!BJ!

AL7!NI=MACOG=A!jkAp?npW.(T9!)>!ALGM!NI=MACOG=A!X7C7!=IA!@C7M7=A!G=!AL7!MJMA7OGAL>;::J!XGALI;A!>:O@M9!%IP!AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!I>!AL7!

>7OA;C7!kMI=n!I>!AL7!.=K:GML!XIC?!kO&I:O@@G=K!>ICN7?!BJ!AL7!NI=MACOG=A9!

! &I!M;!

XL7AL7C!O!KG87=!NI=MACOG=A!LOM!>ICN7?!MIIC!O!KG87=!>IC


93/235

! cf!

MAC7MM!MLG>AMP!>IC!7ZO!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!G=!AL7!:O=K;OK7!

AI!?7A7C!MAC7MM!GM!m!G979!GAM![?7>O;:A[!:INOAGI=9!-G87=!ALGM!

#&\BOM7?!=IAGI=!I>!@CIN7MMP!X7!NO=!B7KG=!AO:UG=K!OBI;A!AJ@I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!

LO8G=K!AI!?I!XGAL!G=@;A\I;A@;A!7CC7?!I;A@;A9!)!XG::!C7>7C!AI!AL7M7!=7X!NI=MACOG=AM!OM!*'#"./0'(,!!NI=MACOG=AM!XG::!B7!

@C7N7?7?!BJ!AL7!MGK=!!b!@CIN7?;CO:!


94/235

! cF!

AL7!OBG:GAJ!AI!>ICN7!O!@CIN7MM!O>>7NAG=K!3!B;A!=IA!+9!&LGM!XOJ!I>!ONNI;=AG=K!>IC!@CIN7?;CO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!;MG=K!#&!!O!NI=MACOG=A!I>!AL7!>IC!+!LOM!@CI@7CAJ!@P!AL7J!3!LOM!@CI@7CAJ!'[!GM!G=A7C@C7A7?!

OM!O!MAO=?OC?!#&!NI=MACOG=AP!AL7!AL7!?GC7NAGI=!I>!G

;=XO=A7?![OM@GCOAGI=\?CG87=!MAC7MM[!:O=K;OK79!(MM;O;:AP!AL7!I::IXG=K!AOB:7O;!SaDV!G::;MACOA7M!ALGM!

AII\>7C7=A!


95/235

! ci!

>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=AM!OC7!8GI:OA7?!BJ!;=>OGAL>;::J!

G>7NAM!AL7!@LI=I:IKGNO:!@CI@7CAJ!![@CIN7MM[!G=!AL7!>I::IXG=K!MAOA77CM!AI!AL7!?7>G=GAGI=!G=!SaEV!OBI879!

!

!


96/235

! cc!

SaeV! &L7!)!+!LOM!@CI@7CAJ!@P!AL7=!3!LOM!

@CI@7CAJ!'[!G>>b!! ! ! O9! )=!=P!+!LOM!@CI@7CAJ!@P!O=?!3!?I7M!=IA!LO87!@CI@7CAJ!'P!#'#'#'#'!! ! ! B9! &L7!NI=MACOG=A!>ICN7M!O!@CIN7MM!O>>7NAG=K!@!G=!=9!!

,7A!G=GAGI=9!)A!C7:G7M!I=!AL7!=IAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!G=ACI?;N7?!G=!%7NAGI=!

e9e9aP!G=!AL7!?7>G=GAGI=M!SdV!O=?!SaEV9!1J!AL7M7!?7>G=GAGI=MP!XL7=!O!NI=MACOG=A!O>>7NAM!@!G=!

O!NO=?G?OA7P!AL7!ONA;O:!MAOA7!I>!@!?G>>7CM!>CI!@9!&L7!?7MGK=OA7?!

MAOA7P!G=!A;C=P!GM!AL7!:INOAGI=!SO=?!8O:;7P!G>!GA!GM!O!>7OA;C7V!I>!@[M!A\NICC7M@I=?7=A!G=!AL7!

I@AG>7C7=A!:ING!G=!AL7!MO!AL7!NI=MACOG=A9!WLOA!!BIAL!I>!AL7!NI=?GAGI=M!I>!SaeV!?I7M!=IA!:7O?!AI!AXI!OMA7CGMUM9!


97/235

! cd!

SagV!! ! !

(%*)'(&.p!w ! /.*\L!%&'.%%!)$)&)(,!

2(\L!

p@GALOp! ! @|ALO! j! ! ! !

! "! @GALx! ! ! j! !! ! @L|AO! ! j! ! j!! ! @|AO! j! ! ! j!!

(M!?GMN;MM7?!OA!:7=KAL!OBI87P!AL7!@CIB:7!#&!OCGM7!?;7!AI!AL7!ONAGI=!

I>!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!(%*)'(&.p!wP!XLGNL!AC;ICN7M!O!=I=\

?7>O;:A!MAC7MM!AI!B7!OMMGK=7?!AI!AL7!>IC!MAC7MM!>IC!AL7!G=@;A!p@GALOp!O=?!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!

!(%*)'(&.p!w!GM!I=!AL7!>GCMA!MJ::OB:79!(NNIC?G=K!AI!AL7!)"*P!O=J!NO=?G?OA7!XL7C7!O!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!af!)!@IMA@I=7!;=AG:!%7NAGI=!e9f!I=!NI=MACOG=A!KCI;=?G=K!AL7!K7=7CO:!?GMN;MMGI=!I>!LIX!AI!?7A7C


98/235

! dE!

MAC7MM!MLG>A!LOM!INN;CC7?!8GI:OA7M!ALGM!@CIN7?;CO:!NI=MACOG=A9!W7!LO87!AL7!AII:M!AI!>G=?!

M;NL!NO=?G?OA7Mb!O!MAC7MM!MLG>A!LOM!INN;CC7?!G=!O=J!GA7

A\NICC7M@I=?!AI!AL7!G=GAGO:!MJ::OB:7!G=!SafV9!(::!M;NL!NO=?G?OA7M!=IX!C7N7G87!7ZACO!

8GI:OAGI=!>7C7=N7!B7AX77=!!!;M7?!OM!O!8GI:OAGI=!I::IXG=K!AOB:7O;!MLIXM!AL7!!(%*)'(&.p!w!NI=MACOG=A!XGAL!AL7!=7X!8GI:OAGI=!@OAA7C=9!

!

SaFV! ! /%!I>!MAC7MMb!G=GAGO:!MJ::OB:7!! ! !

!(%*)'(&.p!w ! /.*\L!%&'.%%!)$)&)(,!

2(\L!

p@GALOp! ! @|ALO! j! ! ! !! ! @GALx! !! ! j! !! "! @L|AO! ! j! ! j!! ! @|AO! j! ! ! j!!

&L7!NO=?G?OA7M!9:1"#&O=?!9:1#!G=N;C!IC?G=OCJ!8GI:OAGI=!!AL7!!(%*)'(&.!

NI=MACOG=AP!B7NO;M7!AL7J!NI=AOG=!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7M!XGAL!O=!OM@GCOA7?!I=M7A9!&L7!

NO=?G?OA7!9.1";!G=N;CM!O!!!8GI:OAGI=!I>!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!!(%*)'(&.p!w!B7NO;M7!AL7!

:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM!GM!?G>>7C7=A!>CI

AJ@GNO:!#&!NI=MACOG=Ab!GAM!8GI:OAGI=!@CI>G:7!>IC!O!KG87=!NO=?G?OA7!M7A!?7@7=?M!I=!AL7!

CO=UG=K!I>!IAL7C!NI=MACOG=AM!G=!AL7!KCO!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!G=!AL7!:O=K;OK79!!!

!


99/235

! da!

!

e9e9e9e9e9e!e9e!e9e!e9e!&;?O=NO&;?O=NO&;?O=NO&;?O=NO!%@O=GML%@O=GML%@O=GML%@O=GML!

!

)=!"LO@A7C!aP!)!X7=A!I87C!:OZ=7MM!LOC!O!@CIMI?GN!NI=MAGA;7=A9!+OCO?OAO!AI!G::;MACOA7!AL7!I@7COAGI=!I>!AL7!)"*!G=!7ZN:;?G=K!;=XO=A7?!G=A7CONAGI=M9!3GCMAP!AI!

C7NO@GA;:OA7!AL7!>ONAMb!>G=O:!LGKL!8IX7:M!OC7!:OZP!O=?!:OZ=7MM!M@C7O?M!:7>AXOC?!;=AG:!GA!

C7ONL7M!AL7!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:79!.ZOCI

XGAL!NO@GAO:GYOAGI=!G=?GNOAG=K!:OZ=7MM9!&L7!>ICG=O:!LGKL!8IX7:!k0nP!

XLGNL!GM!:OZ9!(::!8IX7:M!@C7N7?G=K!GAP!;@!AI!AL7!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7P!OC7!O:MI!:OZs!ALOA!:OZ=7MM!

?I7M!=IA!M@C7O?!B7JI=?!AL7!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7!GM!MLIX=!BJ!AL7!>IC

>ICG=O:!8IX7:!GM!=IA!LGKLP!O=?!

AL7C7>IC7!=IA!:OZP!O=?!SiVN!MLIXM!:OZ=7MM!M@C7O?G=K!G=!>ICO::M!I=!O!

MJ::OB:7!IAL7C!ALO=!AL7!@7=;:A9!

!

SaiV! O9! S@}=A0V! ! [[! ! ! ! B9! ! ! S@|=AOV! ! [>7[!

! ! ! S~}U0V! ! [BIJ[! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! S~|UOV!! ! [KGC:[!! ! ! M7SU:0V! ! [AI!?CJ!LGIC!@7=;:AG


100/235

! dD!

&L7!NI=MACOG=A!?CG8G=K!:OZ=7MM!LOCIIAP!(-'..kA7=M7n"!SacVOP!NO=!

B7!MOAGM>G7?!7GAL7C!BJ!8GI:OAG=K!AL7!M7KOGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!m!G979!BJ!O@@:JG=K!

LOC

! ! M7SU:#V! ! ! ! jj!!

^;MA!OM!G=!IAL7C!@CIMI?GNO::J!M7=MGAG87!LOC


101/235

! de!

SjkM7SUx:0VnVP!IC!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!OKOG=MA!>G=O:!LGKL!A7=M7!8IX7:M!G>!A7=MG=K!?I7M!=IA!O@@:J!

SjkM7SUx:;VnVP!IC!AL7!>OGAL>;:=7MM!NI=MACOG=A!7OA;C7!SjkM7SU:0VnV9!&LGM!:7O87M!AL7!NO=?G?OA7!XGAL!>G=O:!MAC7MM!OM!AL7!I=:J!8GOB:7!

I@AGI=P!OM!G::;MACOA7?!B7:IX9!!

SDEV! *M7;?I\&;?O=NO!%@O=GML!! ! ! (-'..kA7=M7n"! jklLGKLP!lA7=M7no! )/.$&kA7=M7n! %&'.%%!pM7UO:;p! ! M7SUx:;V! ! j! ! !! "! M7UOS:V! ! ! j! j!! ! M7SUx:0V! j! ! j! !! ! M7SU:0V! ! ! jj! !pM7UO:Ip! "! M7SUx:IV! ! ! ! !

! ! M7UOS:V! ! ! j! j!! ! M7SUx:#V! j! ! j! !! ! M7SU:#V! ! ! jj! !!

,7A!;M!=IX!M77!LIX!r]IBr!I>!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!(-'..kA7=M7n"'GM!AI!@CI?;N7!LOCICN7!AI!NLO=K79!1J!AL7!)"*P!

AL7!NI=MACOG=A!!(-'..!GM!8GI:OA7?!=IA!I=:J!G=!NO=?G?OA7M!XL7C7!AL7C7!GM!=I!OKC77IIAP!B;A!O:MI!BJ!O=J!NO=?G?OA7!XL7C7!>IIA!BI;=?OCG7M!OC7!=IA!G=!AL7GC!

?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA79!!


102/235

! dg!

! )=!IC?7C!AI!?7A7C!>77AP!X7!AOU7!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!!(-'..!

I;A!I>!AL7!CO=UG=K9!&LGM!GM!MLIX=!G=!AL7!AOB:7O;!B7:IX9!&L7!XG==7CM!>IC!BIAL!I>!AL7!

G=@;AM!LO87!@7=;:AG!AL7M7!AXI!8IX7:M!GM![B7G=K!G=!AL7!MOIIA[s!O=J!NO=?G?OA7!XL7C7!AL7M7!AXI!8IX7:M!OC7!M7@OCOA7?!BJ!O!>IIA!BI;=?OCJ!AL;M!

G=N;CM!O!!!8GI:OAGI=!BJ!AL7!)"*!SOM!XI;:?!O=J!IAL7C!NO=?G?OA7!XLIM7!>IIAG=K!@OAA7C=!

?G>>7CM!>CIIC>7NA!AL7!XG==7C!>IC!AL7!G=@;A!XGAL!O!>G=O:!=I=\LGKL!

8IX7:P!pM7UO:IpP!OM!AL7!>I::IXG=K!AOB:7O;!G::;MACOA7M9!#=N7!OKOG=P!AL7!@OALI:IKGNO:!


103/235

! df!

NO=?G?OA7!kM7UOS:Vn!K7AM!O=!7ZACO!!!8GI:OAGI=!IIA!GM!?G>>7C7=A!

>CI>7NA!I=!AL7!I;ANI!MAC7MMb!@7=;:AG7OA7?!BJ!AL7!LGKL7C\CO=U7?!%&'.%%P!AL7!=7X!8GI:OAGI=!>7NA!AL7!I;ANII::IXG=K!AOB:7O;!G::;MACOA7M9!

!

SDfV! &;?O=NO!%@O=GML9!/%!I>!MAC7MMb!@7=;:AG


104/235

! dF!

!

&I!M;

MLG>A!NO=?G?OA7M!>CIOCP!AL7!N:OG!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!?I7M!=IA!@CI?;N7!O!@OALI:IKGNO:!XG==7C9!)=!

AL7!=7ZA!M7NAGI=!)!!ONA!($5!NO=?G?OA7!ALOA!G=N;CM!O!!!8GI:OAGI=!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!G=!#&9!

!e9e9e9e9eeee9g!"O=?G?OA7M!ALOA!G=N;C!9g!"O=?G?OA7M!ALOA!G=N;C!9g!"O=?G?OA7M!ALOA!G=N;C!9g!"O=?G?OA7M!ALOA!G=N;C!!!!!!8GI:OAGI=M!OC7!@7C@7A;O:!:IM7CM8GI:OAGI=M!OC7!@7C@7A;O:!:IM7CM8GI:OAGI=M!OC7!@7C@7A;O:!:IM7CM8GI:OAGI=M!OC7!@7C@7A;O:!:IM7CM!

!

)=!ALGM!M7NAGI=!)!I>>7C!O!>IC


105/235

! di!

KCO!AL7!KCI;=?P!AL7!O=MX7C!AI!ALGM!Q;7MAGI=!>GC7C!G=!AL7!:INOAGI=!IC!8O:;7!I>!

+!LO87!?G>>7C7=A!8GI:OAGI=!@CI>G:7M!G=!L[9!+O8G=K!O!?G>>7C7=A!@CI>G:7!I>!8GI:OAGI=M!G7?!

;=GQ;7:J!BJ!M;NL!O!KCOGNG7=A!ALOA!O=J!AXI!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!?G>>7C!G=!

MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7!G=N;C!O!?G>>7C7=A!M7A!I>!8GI:OAGI=M!I>!AL7M7!ALC77!NI=MACOG=AM9!&LGM!

O@@7OCM!AI!B7!AC;7P!ALI;KL!)!LO87!=I!@CII>9ai

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ai!)A!GM!G=!>ONA!@IMMGB:7!AI!?7MGK=!@OGCM!I>!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!?G>>7C!G=!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7!B;A!G=N;C!AL7!MO!8GI:OAGI=M!I>!AL7!ALC77!NI=MACOG=AMP!79K9!k@O9ACOA9COn!8M9!k@OA9CO9ACOnP!7ONL!G=N;CCG=K!I=7!8GI:OAGI=!I>!$#"#/(!O=?!j"#2*,.9!+IX787CP!M;NL!NO=?G?OA7M!LO87!O!BI;=?G=K!M7A!S%O;CAL7C!7Z@:ICOAGI=9!


106/235

! dc!

! $IX!)!O!AL7!OCK;IC!KCO!AL7!

?7>G=GAGI=!I>![@CIN7MM[!OBI87!)!C7>7CC7?!AI!AL7![?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7[!I>!MIIC!O=!G=@;A!O=?!O!NI=MACOG=A!OM!AL7!MAOA7!I>!ALOA!@CI@7CAJ!G=!AL7!I@AG!XL7AL7C!AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!NO=?G?OA7!GM!;=GQ;7:J!?7A7C

NO=?G?OA7MP!AL7J!?I!=IA!?G>>7C!XGAL!C7M@7NA!AI!AL7!@CI@7CAJ!!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!I9!

! %;@@IM7!AL7C7!GM!O!@CIN7?;CO:!NI=MACOG=A![!)>!+!LOM!@CI@7CAJ!@P!AL7=!3!LOM!@CI@7CAJ!

'[!O=?!O=!G=@;A!pGp9!&L7C7!GM!O!N7CAOG=!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!>IC!+!O=?!MI


107/235

! dd!

! ,7A!;M!OMM;;=NAGI=M!ALOA!AOU7!O!M7A!I>!NO=?G?OA7M!O=?!C7A;C=!O!

=I=\7!ALOA!M7A!S&7MOC!{!%;=NAGI=!NICC7M@I=?G=K!AI!O::!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!CO=U7?!:IX7C!ALO=!I9!ST!O=?!U!OC7!NI!

AL7!>;=NAGI=M!NICC7M@I=?G=K!AI!G=?G8G?;O:!NI=MACOG=AMV9!)>!I!GM!LGKL7MA\CO=U7?!S:IX7MA\

CO=U7?VP!:7A!T!SUV!B7!AL7!G?7=AGAJ!>;=NAGI=9!

! 1J!?7>G=GAGI=P!AL7!/"M!OC7!AL7!XG==7CM!G=!AL7!MJMA7

AL7!@CIN7?;CO:!NI=MACOG=A!LOM!B77=!C7CI

BJ!AL7!C7


108/235

! aEE

!

,7A!;M!NI=MG?7C!AL7!NOM7!SDdVO!>GCMA9!1J!AL7!VI+P!O::!NO=?G?OA7M!B7:I=KG=K!AI!S!G=N;C!!!

8GI:OAGI=M9!1J!OMM;IC7P!O::!M;NL!=I=\8GI:OAG=K!NO=?G?OA7M!B7:I=K!AI!M9!&L7M7!OC7!AL7!I=:J!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!OC7!@OMM7?!?IX=!AI!AL7!:IX7C\CO=U7?!NI=MACOG=AM9!&L7C7>IC7P!O>A7C!

AL7!O@@:GNOAGI=!I>!IP!O::!C7I::IXG=K!?GOKCO;=NAGI=b!GA!?I7M!=IA!7:G!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!OC7!MAG::!G=!AL7!

C;==G=K9!17NO;M7!I!NO=!B7!GK=IC7?P!AL7!XG==7C!I>!AL7!I87CO::!78O:;OAGI=!GM!

USISTSIGSMVVV!!USTSIGSMVV9!&LGM!XG==7C!GM!U=IX=b!GA!GM!AL7!@IMMGB:J!=I=\;=GQ;7!

/"!SDiV9!)=!IAL7C!XIC?MP!G=!AL7!NOM7!SDdVB!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!I!LOM!=I!7>>7NAP!MI!AL7!XG==7C!

GM!AL7!MO!AL7!M7As!BJ!OMM;


109/235

! aEa

&

e9e9e9e9e9f!2IC7!ALO=!I=7!e9f!2IC7!ALO=!I=7!e9f!2IC7!ALO=!I=7!e9f!2IC7!ALO=!I=7!@CIN7?;CO:@CIN7?;CO:@CIN7?;CO:@CIN7?;CO:!NI=MACOG=ANI=MACOG=ANI=MACOG=ANI=MACOG=A!

!

)=!AL7!AIJ!7ZOOCP!I=:J!I=7!@CIN7?;CO:!NI=MACOG=A!XOM!G=8I:87?9!":7OC:JP!ALGM!GM!

O=!;=C7O:GMAGN!MGGNOAGI=9!)!LO87!AI!O??C7MM!AL7!Q;7MAGI=!I>!LIX!AXI!IC!

AL7C7!GM!ONAP!OA!>GCMA!B:;MLP!AL7!MGA;OAGI=!O@@7OCM!COAL7C!

?G>>GN;:A9!)A!GM!7OMJ!AI!M77!ALOAP!G>!AL7C7!OC7!AXI!NI=MACOG=AMP!O@@:JG=K!AL7!78O:;OAGI=!

@CIN7?;C7!AI!AL7!AXI!NI=MACOG=AM!I=7!O>A7C!O=IAL7C!NO=!NC7OA7!;=XO=A7?!C7M;:AM9!%;@@IM7!

O!:O=K;OK7!LOMP!:GU7!.=K:GMLP!BIAL!O=!OM@GCOAGI=!NI=MACOG=A!ALOA!OAACONAM!kLn!AI!I=M7AM!I>!

MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7MP!O=?!O!NI=MACOG=A!ALOA!>:O@M!@IMAAI=GN!NICI=O:!NI=MI=O=AM9!(MM;!O!MJ::OB:7!GM!MAC7MM7?P!AL7=!GAM!I=M7A!GM!OM@GCOA7?s!! ! B9!!3,(*b!)>!O!MJ::OB:7!GM!MAC7MM7?P!GA!GM!>I::IX7?!BJ!O!>:O@9!!

,7A!;M!M77!AL7!NI=M7Q;7=N7M!I>!NI!MAC7MM!M7@OCOA7:J!>IC!

7ONL!NI=MACOG=A9!3GCMA!X7!XG::!O@@:J!AL7!@CIN7?;C7!AI!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!!(%*)'(&.P!O=?!

AL7=!AI!!3,(*9!%;@@IM7!AL7!:O=K;OK7!LOM!AL7!CO=UG=K!)/.$&kMI=n!!!!!(%*)'(&.!!!!

/.*\"!!!!!3,(*!!!!%&'.%%9!"I=MG?7C!AL7!G=@;A!p@GAO&Op9!&I!NI!MAC7MM!>IC!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!!(%*)'(&.P!X7!AOU7!GA!I;A!I>!AL7!MJMA7G=?!AL7!

MAC7MM!G=!AL7!I@AG!MAC7MM!>IC!!3,(*!LOM!=IA!

B77=!>I;=?!J7AP!X7!LO87!AI!AC7OA!GA!:GU7!O!=IC


110/235

! aED

CO=UG=KP!AL7!I@AG:O@@G=K9!

&L7!NI!AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!I>!MAC7MM!>IC!!(%*)'(&.!GM!G::;MACOA7?!B7:IX9!!

!

SeaV!! ! ! )/.$&kMI=n! !(%*)'(&.! /.*\"! !3,(*! %&'.%%!p@GAO&Op! ! @|AO&O! ! ! ! j! !! "! @GAx&O! ! ! ! ! j!! ! @|&O&O! j! ! ! ! !! ! @L|AO&O! ! ! j! j! !! ! @GALx&O! ! ! j! ! j!! ! @L|&O&O! j! ! j! ! !!

&L7!I@AGO;:A!MAC7MM!ALOA!LOM!B77=!OAACONA7?!AI!O!>:O@9!&LGM!GM!7ZONA:J!AL7!AJ@7!I>!@OAA7C=!ALOA!AL7!AL7ICJ!GM!?7MGK=7?!AI!C;:7!I;A!&L7!

@CIB:7IC!!(%*)'(&.P!

!MAC7MM!>IC!!(%*)'(&.b!M7NI=?!MJ::OB:7!S1#V!

! ! ! )/.$&kMI=n!!

(%*)'(&.! /.*\"!!

3,(*! %&'.%%!p@GAO&Op! ! @|AO&O! ! !! ! j! !! ! @GAx&O! ! j! ! ! j!! ! @|&O&O! j! !! ! ! !! ! @L|AO&O! ! !! j! j! !! $! @GALx&O! ! ! j! ! j!! ! @L|&O&O! j! !! j! ! !!

&LGM!C7M;:A!GM!>OAO:!>IC!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!@C7?GNAGI=Mb!AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!I>!MAC7MMP!OM!X7::!

OM!AL7!MAC7MM!G=!AL7!XG==7CP!GM!=IX!G=!O!@:ON7!XL7C7!GA!MLI;:?!=IA!B79!&L7!NO=?G?OA7M!XGAL!G=GAGO:!MAC7MM!m!AL7!I=7M!ALOA!MLI;:?!B7!I@AGOAO:!!\8GI:OAGI=M!I>!AL7!

!(%*)'(&.!NI=MACOG=A9!


111/235

! aEe

! 2I8G=K!I=!AI!AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!NO=?G?OA7!>IC!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!!3,(*P!AOUG=K!ALGM!

NI=MACOG=A!I;A!I>!AL7!CO=UG=K!?I7M!=IA!NLO=K7!AL7!XG==7C!OM!G::;MACOA7?!BJ!AL7!AOB:7O;!

B7:IX!SeeV9!!

!SeeV!!! ! ! )/.$&kMI=n! !(%*)'(&.! /.*\"! !3,(*! %&'.%%!p@GAO&Op! ! @|AO&O! ! !! ! j! !! ! @GAx&O! ! j! ! ! j!! ! @|&O&O! j! !! ! ! !! ! @L|AO&O! ! !! j! j! !! $! @GALx&O! ! ! j! ! j!! ! @L|&O&O! j! !! j! ! !

!&L7!?7MGK=OA7?!:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM!>IC!!3,(*!GM!O:MI!I=!AL7!M7NI=?!MJ::OB:7!1#9&LGM!

>7C7=A!MJ::OB:7!XG::!B7!!\@7=O:GY7?!BJ!

!3,(*!OM!X7::9!)=!ALGM!@OCAGN;:OC!NOM7P!OM!MLIX=!BJ!AL7!AOB:7O;!B7:IXP!AL7!7ZACO!

8GI:OAGI=M!>7C7=N7b!AL7!I;A@;A!GM!MAG::!AL7!@OALI:IKGNO:!NO=?G?OA7!9.1";!

!

SegV!! /%!I>!MAC7MM!>IC!!(%*)'(&.b!M7NI=?!MJ::OB:7!S1#V!! ! /%!I>!MAC7MM!>IC!!3,(*b!M7NI=?!MJ::OB:7!S1#V!

! ! ! )/.$&kMI=n! !(%*)'(&.! /.*\"! !3,(*! %&'.%%!p@GAO&Op! ! @|AO&O! ! !! ! !! !! ! @GAx&O! ! j! ! ! j!! ! @|&O&O! j! !! ! !! !! ! @L|AO&O! ! !! j! !! !! $! @GALx&O! ! ! j! ! j!! ! @L|&O&O! j! !! j! !! !!

&LGM!7ZO


112/235

! aEg

MAOA7!I>!MAC7MM!I>!I=7!I>!AL7M7!NI=MACOG=AMP!AL7!IAL7C!I=7!NO=![G=A7C>7C7[!O=?!@CI?;N7!O=!

;=XO=A7?!7>>7NAs!ALGM!GM!XLOA!KO87!AL7!BO?!C7M;:A!G=!AL7!AOB:7O;Z!OBI879!!

! "C;NGO::JP!M;NL!G=A7C>7C7=N7!I=:J!INN;CM!G>!AL7!AXI!@CIN7?;CO:!NI=MACOG=AM!MLOC7!AL7GC!

O=A7N7?7=A!@CI@7CAJ9!)=!AL7!7ZO>GNG7=A!AI!NI!MAC7MM!#$".!>IC!BIAL!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!!(%*)'(&.!O=?!!3,(*P!BJ!

AOUG=K!AL7!AL7!CO=UG=K!MGG=?G=K!AL7!:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM!G=!

AL7!I@AG!AL7!C7M;:AG=K!KCO!AL7!NI=MACOG=Ab!AL7C7!GM!O!%&'.%%!N:OMM!I>!NI=MACOG=AM!ALOA!LO87!AL7!>IC!O!

MJ::OB:7!GM!MAC7MM7?P!AL7=!3[P!O!$.!N:OMMP!O!W.)-+&!N:OMMP!O!$(%(,)&5!N:OMMP!7AN9!(::!NI=MACOG=AM!!7ONL!@CI@7CAJ!+!NO=!AL7=!B7!NIIC!7ONL!

O=A7N7?7=A!N:OMMP!OM!KG87=!BJ!AL7!>I::IXG=K!?7>G=GAGI=P!G7?!>CI

! !

SefV! ! &&&&+.!+.!+.!+.!////.%)-$(&./!.%)-$(&./!.%)-$(&./!.%)-$(&./!%%%%&(&&(&&(&&(&....!S/7>G=GAGI=s!G7?V!! ! ! ,7A!AL7C7!B7!O!KCO!NI=MACOG=AM!O=A7N7?7=A!N:OMM!I>!NI=MACOG=AM!O=A7N7?7=A!N:OMM!I>!NI=MACOG=AM!IP!O=!G=@;A!

pGpO=?!GAM!I;A@;A!kIn!G=!LP!O=?!O!@LI=I:IKGNO:!IB]7NA!9!G=!kIn9!&L7=!AL7!

/.%)-$(&./!%&(&.!I>!9!>IC!pGp!O=?!I!G=!L!GM!9[M!NICC7M@I=?7=A!G=!AL7!I@AG!O::!I>!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!G=!I!LO87!B77=!C7G=GAGI=!I>!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!GM!ALOA!X7!>GCMA!

?7A7CO;:A!B7LO8GIC!I>!MI!MAC7MM!GM!I=!AL7!G=GAGO:!MJ::OB:79!

!


113/235

! aEf

SeFV!!! ! ! )/.$&kMI=n! !(%*)'(&.! /.*\"! !3,(*! %&'.%%!p@GAO&Op! "! @|AO&O! ! ! ! ! !! ! @GAx&O! ! ! ! ! j!

! ! @|&O&O! j! ! ! ! !! ! @L|AO&O! ! ! j! ! !! @GALx&O! ! ! j! ! j!! ! @L|&O&O! j! ! j! ! !!

$IXP!O=J!NO=?G?OA7!XGAL!MAC7MM!I=!O!MJ::OB:7!IAL7C!ALO=!AL7!G=GAGO:!I=7!XI;:?!C7N7G87!O!

>OAO:!!!!8GI:OAGI=P!O=?!AL;M!AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!@C7?GNAGI=M!OC7!@C7M7C87?9!&L7!>G=O:!

78O:;OAGI=!GM!G::;MACOA7?!B7:IX9!

!SeiV!! /%!I>!MAC7MMb!G=GAGO:!MJ::OB:7!! ! ! )/.$&kMI=n! !(%*)'(&.! /.*\"! !3,(*! %&'.%%!p@GAO&Op! ! @|AO&O! ! *! ! * !! ! @GAx&O! ! !! ! !! j! ! @|&O&O! j! * ! ! !! "! @L|AO&O! ! ! j! * !! @GALx&O! ! !! j !! j!! ! @L|&O&O! j! ! j! ! !!

&L7!C7

8GI:OAGI=!@OAA7C=!I>!O::!I>!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!G=!".!NLO=K7M9!&L7C7>IC7P!AL7!IC?7C!G=!XLGNL!

AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7M!>IC!AL7!?G>>7C7=A!O=A7N7?7=A!N:OMM7M!GM!?7A7C>7NA!AL7!I;ANI


114/235

! aEF

AL7!AJ@I:IKGNO:!@C7?GNAGI=M!I>!AL7!AL7ICJ!C7!7NA!AL7!

I;ANIMO;A;C7!C7M7OCNLb!GA!C7!AL7!OCK;!@CI@7CAG7M!AI!XLGNL!MAC7MM!NO=!B7!M7=MGAG87P!7GAL7C!

B7NO;M7!ALIM7!NI=MACOG=AM!OC7!=IA!@CIN7?;CO:P!IC!B7NO;M7!AL7J!B7:I=K!AI!O!?G>>7C7=A!

O=A7N7?7=A!N:OMM9!!! #=N7!OKOG=P!BJ!OMM;7NAM!OC7!


115/235

! aEi

AL;M!AL7!)"*!NO==IA!NO;M7!O=!;=XO=A7?!NO=?G?OA7!AI!XG=9!&LGM!NI!

8OCGI;M!@CI@7CAG7M!>IC!7ONL!G=@;AP!G=!XLOA!IC?7C!MLI;:?!AL7!?7MGK=OA7?!MAOA7!B7!

NI7NA!AL7!I;ANI!O!MJ::OB:7!GM!#P!AL7=!AL7!MJ::OB:7!GM!MAC7MM7?9!!

"I=MG?7C!AL7!G=@;A!p@GAOU;p!G=!O!KCO

IC?7C9!)=!AL7!C7!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=P!)!XG::!O@@:J!AL7!@CIN7?;C7!G=!AL7!IC?7C!G=!

XLGNL!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!OC7!CO=U7?P!MAOCAG=K!>CI

?IX=XOC?9!#=N7!OKOG=P!IC!ALGM!M7NI=?!NI=MACOG=A!?I7M!=IA!IC!=IXs!)!XG::!NI!MAC7MM!GM!G=!AL7!NI=M7Q;7=A9!


116/235

! aEc

e9e9e9e9g!1G?GC7g!1G?GC7g!1G?GC7g!1G?GC7NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=NAGI=O:!G=A7CONAGI=MMMM!

!

&L7!?GMN;MMGI=!MI!>OC!XOM!?78IA7?!AI!ALIM7!NOM7M!XL7C7!MAC7MM!G=A7CONAM!OMJ


117/235

! aEd

! &L7!7>7C7=N7!B7AX77=!AL7!AXI!O@@CIONL7M!:G7M!G=!AL7!AJ@7M!I>!@CIN7MM7M!

1.%)/.%!MAC7MM\M7KICN79!)>!AL7!

AL7ICJ!LOM!I=:J!AXI!NI=MACOG=AMP!!W%*!O=?!!%W*P!AL7=!AL7!I=:J!AXI!UG=?M!I>!C7@OGCM!

>IC!MAC7MM\X7GKLA!>7NA!I>!AL7!)"*!GM!AI!@C787=A!NI=MACOG=AM!>CIJG=K!AL7!@CI@7CAJ!

AP!

XLG:7!!W%*!NO==IA!NO;M7!O=J!C7@OGC!ALOA!G7M!AL7!ICGKG=O:!L7O8G=7MM!I>!O!MJ::OB:79!

! #=!AL7!IAL7C!LO=?P!G>!MAC7MM\X7GKLA!G=A7CONAGI=M!OC7!LO=?:7?!BJ!AL7!MAO=?OC?!#&!@OGC!

I>!NI=MACOG=A!:GU7!%W*!O=?!W%*P!=I!M;NL!@C7?GNAGI=M!OBI;A!@IMMGB:7!C7@OGCM!OC7!!

O!ICN7!

AL7!?7:7AGI=!I>!O!AL7!MAC7MM7?!8IX7:!4w D!];MA!G=!NOM7!O::!IAL7C!@IA7=AGO:!C7@OGCM!NC7OAG=K!O!

L7O8J!MAC7MM7?!MJ::OB:7!G=!AL7!I;A@;A!OC7!C;:7?!I;A!BJ!IAL7C!NI=MACOG=AM9!&L7!AOB:7O;!

B7:IX!G::;MACOA7M!M;NL!O!NOM7b!AL7!>;::J!>OGAL>;:!NO=?G?OA7!S"4a"4w DV"4e!GM!8GI:OA7M!%W*s!

:7=KAL7=G=K!I>!AL7!MAC7MM7?!8IX7:!S"4a"4w DbV"4e!8GI:OA7M!/.*\)s!O=?!AL7!?7:7AGI=!I>!AL7!

>G=O:!MJ::OB:7!AI!KG87!S"4a"4w D"V!GM!@C7N:;?7?!BJ!AL7!LGKL\CO=UG=K!$#$3)$!NI=MACOG=A9!

&LGM!:7O87M!AL7!?7:7AGI=!I>!AL7!MAC7MM7?!8IX7:!4w D!XGAL!C7MJ::OBG>GNOAGI=!I>!GAM!I=M7A!OM!AL7!

NI?O!I>!AL7!@C7N7?G=K!MJ::OB:7!OM!AL7!I=:J!8GOB:7!I@AGI=!ALOA!XI;:?!MOAGM>J!%W*9!(M!O!


118/235

! aaE

C7M;:AP!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!%W*!NO;M7M!AL7!?7:7AGI=!I>!O!MAC7MM7?!8IX7:!O=?!O!NI=NIA9!

!

SedV! p"4a"4w D"4ep!! ! %W*! /.*\)' $#$3)$! *('%.\!' 2(\4!! S"4a"4w DV"4e! j! ! ! j! !

! S"4a"4w DbV"4e! ! j! ! j! !

! S"4a"4w D"V! ! ! j! ! j!

"! S"4w a"V"4e! ! ! ! j! j!

!

#=!AL7!IAL7C!LO=?P!AL7!G!MJ=NI@7!@CIN7MM7M!ALOA!!AL7!@IX7C!I>!%W*!AI!

@CI?;N7!MAC7MM7?!8IX7:!?7:7AGI=!LO87!B77=!@CI@IM7?P!)!XG::!OCK;7!G=!"LO@A7C!g!ALOA!M;NL!

O=O:JM7M!OC7!G=NICC7NAP!O=?!B7AA7C!ONNI;=AM!OC7!O8OG:OB:7!>IC!AL7!C7:78O=A!NOM7M9!(M!)!XG::!

MLIXP!ALGM!G=OBG:GAJ!I>!%W*!AI!>ICN7!MAC7MM7?!8IX7:!?7:7AGI=!GM!@OCA!I>!O!

NI=MACOG=A!!%W*!GM!AI!B7!@C7>7CC7?!I87C!AL7!:7MM!C7MACGNAG87!87CMGI=!%W*P!B7NO;M7!AL7!

AJ@I:IKJ!I>!C7@OGCM!@C7?GNA7?!BJ!!%W*!GAM!AL7!IBM7C87?!AJ@I:IKJ9!

! !

!


119/235

! aaa

e9fe9fe9fe9f!-CI;=?G=K!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM-CI;=?G=K!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM-CI;=?G=K!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM-CI;=?G=K!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!

!

&L7!

NI=MACOG=AM!AI!C7>7C!?GC7NA:J!AI!@CIN7MM7MP!O=?!AI!@7=O:GY7!ALIM7!NO=?G?OA7M!ALOA!G=8I:87!

;=?7MGCOB:7!@CIN7MM7M9!&L7!@CI@IMO:!GM!G=A7=?7?!AI!C7@:ON7!%#2.!I>!AL7!N;CC7=A!#&!

!AL7!=7X!AJ@7P!B;AP!NC;NGO::JP!I;A@;A\ICG7=A7?!

NI=MACOG=AM!OC7!MAG::!@C7M7=A!G=!AL7!AL7ICJ9!

! &L7!COAGI=O:7!>IC!O::IXG=K!AL7M7!AXI!AJ@7M!I>!NI=MACOG=AM!G=!AL7!MJMA7

@LI=I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!OC7!I>!AXI!AJ@7M9!%ION7\BOM7?P!O=?!C7Q;GC7!AL7!

MAO=?OC?!#&!NI=MACOG=AM!AI!LO=?:7!AL7IC!@LI=I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!ALO=!LOM!B77=!MAO=?OC?:J!OMM;AI!A7::!XLGNL!NI=MACOG=AM!MLI;:?!B7!M;B]7NA!AI!AL7!MAO=?OC?!#&!

78O:;OAGI=P!O=?!XLGNL!NI=MACOG=AM!MLI;:?!B7!M;B]7NA!AI!AL7!)"*h!)=!IAL7C!XIC?MP!X7!LO87!

AL7!@CIB:7!-'#0$/)$-!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!G=!MI!AL7!IBM7C87?!

@CI@IM7?!?GC7NAGI=O:GAJ!I>!AL7!MAC7MM!NI=MACOG=AM9!+IX787CP!)!XG::!OCK;7!ALOA!AL7!B7MA!XOJ!

I>!?7A7C!O!KG87=!NI=MACOG=A!GM!AL7!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!AL7!G=A7CONAGI=M!

B7AX77=!AL7!@CI@7CAG7M!ALOA!GA!


120/235

! aaD

M7A!I>!@IMMGBG:GAG7M!@CI8G?7?!BJ!AL7!>IC!O!@OCAGN;:OC!>7OA;C79!&I!;M7!O!>O!MJ::OB:7!MAC;NA;C7!

@IG=AM!AI!AL7!NICC7NA!>IC!AL7!NI=MACOG=AM!S*CG=N7!O=?!%!@LI=I:IKGNO:!@CI@7CAG7M!?7@7=?!I=!

AL7!NICC7NA!O::INOAGI=!I>!@LI=I:IKGNO:!NOA7KICG7M!O!AL7!NI=MACOG=AP!

AL7!NO;M7C!SAL7!O=A7N7?7=AV!O=?!AL7!NO;M77!SAL7!NI=M7Q;7=AV9!&L7!>IC!7ONL!

NI=MACOG=AP!OM!MAOA7?!OBI87P!!G=A7CONAGI=!AL7!AJ@I:IKJ!G=?GNOA7M!:7NA7?!G=!AL7!MAOA7!AL7!NI=MACOG=A9!&LGM!:ONU!I>!7ZA7C=O:P!G=?7@7=?7=A!KCI;=?G=K!GM!@7CLO@M!AL7!X7OU7MA!OM@7NA!

I>!AL7!N;CC7=A!@CI@IMO:9!

! (M!C77?I

AL7!NLIGN7!I>!?GC7NAGI=O:GAJ!>IC!AL7!@CIN7?;CO:!NI=MACOG=AM9!WL7AL7C!IC!=IA!O!KG87=!

NI=MACOG=A!GM!@CIN7?;CO:!G=!AL7!>GCMA!@:ON7P!O=?!AL;M!NI=ACI::7?!BJ!AL7!8GI:OAGI=!

OMMGK=7C7=N7!AI!AL7!IBM7C87?!AJ@I:IKJ9!! &L7!!ALGM!?GMM7CAOAGI=!AI!NO=I=GNO:!#&!GM!ALOA!GAM!LJ@IAL7MGM!ALOA!O::!

@LI=I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M!OC7!G=!AL7!I;A@;A!GM!AII!CO?GNO:9!)!?I!=IA!G=A7=?!AI!C7@:ON7!

ALGM!CO?GNO:!LJ@IAL7MGM!XGAL!GAM!I@@IMGA7P!LIX787C9!$IALG=K!)!LO87!XCGAA7=!L7C7!MLI;:?!

B7!G=A7C@C7A7?!OM!I>>7CG=K!O!NI;=A7COCK;A7=!NI=M@GC7!AI!@CI?;N7!O!N7CAOG=!I;A@;A!@OAA7C=9!

&LGM!>;=?O

G=A7CONAGI=!I>!MION7\?CG87=9!&L7M7!AXI!MI;CN7M!I>!@LI=I:IKGNO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=MP!

M;C>ON7!@C7MM;C7M!O=?!G=@;A\I;A@;A!:7NA!AL7!:OAA7C!UG=?!I>!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=P!O=?!MAO=?OC?!


121/235

! aae

#&!NI=MACOG=AM!C7>:7NA!AL7!>IC7C!AI!@CIN7MM7M!O=?!@CILGBGA!N7CAOG=!G=@;A\I;A@;A!IC!NI=MACOG=AM!7=NI?7!M;C>ON7\BOM7?!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=MP!XLG:7!AL7!:OAA7C!AJ@7!C7>7C!AI!

@CIN7?;CO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=M9!3IC!O!KG87=!NI=MACOG=AP!AL7!IBM7C87?!AJ@I:IKJ!I>!G=A7CONAGI=M!

M7C87M!OM!O!N:;7!AI!OMMGK=G=K!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!AI!I=7!AJ@7!I>!AL7!IAL7C9!)>!AL7!C7:78O=A!

@LI=I:IKGNO:!NOA7KICG7M!G=A7CONA!G=!O!XOJ!ALOA!GM!;::J!?7MNCGB7?!G=!A7C!O!

@CIN7?;CO:!K7=7CO:GYOAGI=P!AL7=!AL7!NI=MACOG=A!

!CLJALIC!G=A7C=O:!>IC!AL7!:G=K;GMAGN!MJMA7


122/235

! aag

G=A7CONAGI=!I>!@OCAGN;:OC!M;BMAO=AG87!NI=MG?7COAGI=M!$#&!M@7NG>GN!AI!,O=K;OK7!XGAL!O=!

GCC7?;NGB:7!NI

AI!?GMN;MMG=K!AL7!C7:78O=A!7Z@7CG>7C7=N7!B7AX77=!ALIM7!

>7OA;C7M!XGAL!XLGNL!MAC7MM!GM!AJ@I:IKGNO::J!IBM7C87?!AI!G=A7CONA!BG?GC7NAGI=O::J!O=?!ALIM7!

XLGNL!MAC7MM!NO=!I=:J!G=>:;7=N7!G=!O!;=G:OA7CO:!>OMLGI=9!&XI!M7AM!I>!OCK;CI

@MJNLI:G=K;GMAGN!:GA7COA;C7!M;KK7MA!ALOA!AL7!@CIMI?GN!NI7C!G=!AL7!@CIMI?GN!O=?!M7K!MAC7MM!GM!NI=>GC!CLJAL!=I=\:G=K;GMAGN!@CIMI?J9!!

! )=!ALGM!M7NAGI=!)!XG::!C78G7X!AL7!O8OG:OB:7!78G?7=N7!ALOA!B7OCM!I=!AL7!CI:7!I>!@CIMI?J!G=!KCO!@CIMI?J\M7KIC!O!

?GC7NA!KCI;=?G=K!I>!AL7!OMJ


123/235

! aaf

?OAO9!&L7C7!OC7!AXI!C7OMI=M!AI!B7!NO;AGI;M!G=!ALGM!C7M@7NA9!3GCMAP!AL7!N:OG!ALGM!

M7NAGI=!!MO:A!B7NO;M7!!AL7!MA;?G7M!@C7M7=A:J!O8OG:OB:7!

LO87!B77=!?I=7!I=!.=K:GMLP!MI!X7!U=IX!:GAA:7!OBI;A!AL7!NCIMM:G=K;GMAGN!?G>>7C7=N7M!G=!

@CIN7MMG=K!O=?!ONQ;GMGAGI=!I>!@CIMI?GN!MAC;NA;C7P!M;NL!OM!AL7!?G>>7C7=N7!B7AX77=!@GANL!ONN7=A!O=?!?J=O!NI87CA!

@CIMI?GN!MAC;NA;C79!&L7!M7NI=?!C7OMI=!XLJ!M;NL!7ZA7C=O:!78G?7=N7!?I7M!7=AOG:!O!

@OCAGN;:OC!8G7X!I>!NI=MACOG=A!G=A7CONAGI=!G=!O!?GC7NA!XOJ!GM!ALOA!AL7!AL7ICJ!)!O

GM!O!AL7ICJ!I>!AL7!U=IX:7?K7!I>!:O=K;OK7P!=IA!I>!@CIN7MMG=K9!

! ,7A!IC\AL7\

AI=K;7!S&V!@L7=I

OC7!AJ@GNO::J!OXOC7!I>!AL7!@CIMI?GN!MAC;NA;C7!I>!AL7!>IC!MJ::OB:7M!O=?!AL7!MAC7MM!@OAA7C=!SFE\cEV9!&L7!G=GAGO:!M7K!AL7!AOCK7A!XIC?!GM!O:MI!O8OG:OB:7!AI!&!MAOA7!M@7OU7CM!G=!FE\iE!I>!AL7!AG7OA;C7M!G=!AL7!>ICICCI

! %@77NL!7CCIC!?OAO!O:MI!M;KK7MA!O!M7@OCOA7!B7LO8GIC!I>!@CIMI?J!OM!I@@IM7?!AI!M7K!


124/235

! aaF

@OAA7C=!AI!AL7!AOCK7A!XIC?9!&LGM!COA7!I>!OKC77G7?!OM!M7

7=AGC7:J!7CCICM!I>!O!MG=K:7!AJ@7b!O=!7CCI=7I;M!MAC7MM!@OAA7C=!GM![BICCIX7?[!>CI


125/235

! aai

! &L7M7!>ONAM!LO87!:7O?!C7M7OCNL7CM!:GU7!,787:A!AI!@IMGA!ALOA!@CIMI?GN!G=>ICGNG7=A:J!BJ!>IN;MG=K!I=!M7K


126/235

! aac

?7O>r!m!OC7!=IA!OB:7!AI!G?7=AG>J!7Z@:GNGA:J!XL7C7!MAC7MM!KI7M!G=!O!>ICNI=ACOMAG87!MAC7MM9!#=!AL7!IAL7C!LO=?P!M@7OU7CM!I>!%@O=GML!OC7!C7:OAG87:J!!

AL7!:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM!O=?!OC7!B7AA7C!OA!?GMAG=K;GMLG=K!CI

:7OC=G=K!O!:O=K;OK7!:GU7!3C7=NL!NO=!G=>7C!AL7!:INOAGI=!I>!MAC7MM!MI:7:J!XGAL!C7>7C7=N7!AI!

;AA7CO=N7!BI;=?OCG7M!m!=I!G=>IC>IC!7ONL!:7ZGNO:!7=ACJ9!"I=87CM7:JP!G=!O!:O=K;OK7!:GU7!%@O=GMLP!XL7C7!ICGK;C7M!G=!AL7!MAC7MM!C;:7P!ALOA!C;:7!NO==IA!B7!ONQ;GC7?!MI:7:J!>CI

@IMGAGI=!I>!MAC7MM!C7:OAG87!AI!XIC?!BI;=?OCG7MP!O=?!AL;M!NO==IA!B7!O8OG:OB:7!AI!AL7!NLG:?!

@C7:7ZGNO::J9!(M!O!NI=M7Q;7=N7!I>!ALGM!C7:OAG87:J!:OA7!ONQ;GMGAGI=!I>!AL7!MAC7MM!C;:7P!

/;@I;Z!O=?!*7@7CUOICIC!AL7!C7:OAG87:J!KC7OA7C!

OXOC7=7MM!I>!MAC7MM!BJ!%@O=GML!M@7OU7CM!ALO=!BJ!3C7=NL!M@7OU7CM9!*7@7CUO;CAL7C!:G=UM!ALGM!?G>>7C7=N7!AI!AL7!7ZGMA7=N7!I>!:7ZGNO:!MAC7MM!7ZN7@AGI=M!G=!%@O=GML\AJ@7!:O=K;OK7M!8M9!3C7=NL\AJ@7!:O=K;OK7M9!

! &LGM!XICU!M;KK7MAM!ALOA!AL7C7!>7C7=N7!G=!@CIN7MMG=K!I>!

MAC7MM9!17NO;M7!.=K:GMLP!XGAL!GAM!=;!@CIMI?GN!MAC;NA;C79!3OJ!O=?!";A:7C[M!Sadiib!faaV!

M;KK7MAGI=!ALOA!MAC7MM!@OAA7C=M!G=!.=K:GML!M7C87!OM!O=!G!AL7!:7ZGNI=!ALOA!OG?M!BIAL!@CI?;NAGI=!O=?!NI!O!@CIMI?GN!AJ@7!?G>>7CG=K!>CI

@MJNLI:G=K;GMAGN!?OAO!?GMN;MM7?!G=!ALGM!M7NAGI=!!MO:A9!


127/235

! aad

! %I!>OC!)!LO87!?GMN;MM7?!AL7!@MJNLI:G=K;GMAGN!?G>>7C7=N7M!B7AX77=!@CIMI?GN!O=?!

M7K!@LI=I:IKGNO:!@CI@7CAG7MP!XLJ!?I!G=A7=MGAJP!Q;O=AGAJP!O=?!AI=7!>O::!I=!AL7!@CIMI?GN!MG?7!I>!AL7!?G8G?7P!XLG:7!AL7!

M7K7OA;C7M!>O::!I=!AL7!IAL7C!MG?7h!&I!O??C7MM!ALGM!Q;7MAGI=!)!A;C=!AI!AL7!

:GA7COA;C7!I=!AL7!@MJNLI:IKJ!I>!CLJAL;=NAGI=!I>!CLJAL!MAC7MM!MJMA7

AL7!M@7NGO:!MAOA;M!I>!G=A7=MGAJP!?;COAGI=P!O=?!AI=7!G=!MAC7MM!MJMA77OA;C7M!G=!AL7!@MJNLI:IKJ!I>!CLJAL:O=K;OK7P!@CIMI?GN!>7OA;C7M!OC7!O:MI!AL7!I=:J!I=7M!ALOA!7Z@C7MM!XLOA!NO=!B7!NO::7?!

r@OCO:G=K;GMAGN!!77OA;C7M!I>!AL7!M@77NL!

MGK=O:P!IC!I87C:OJG=K!GA!XGAL!=7X!@CIMI?GN!NI=A7=A9!#=7!XI;:?!=IA!7Z@7NA!AI!>G=?!O!

:O=K;OK7!XL7C7P!MOJP!7ZAC7AM!G=!@GANL!C7KGMA7C9!(=?!>G=O::JP!AL7!@CIMI?GN!>7OA;C7M!OC7!AL7!I=:J!I=7M!ALOA!NO=!B7!;::J!O@@:G7?!AI!=I=\:G=K;GMAGN!8INO:GYOAGI=M!ALOA!OC7!@OCA!I>!AL7!

M@77NL

blumenfeld 06

Documents