bonding performance of tropical fast-growing wood...
TRANSCRIPT
1
BONDING PERFORMANCE OF TROPICAL FAST-GROWING WOOD SPECIES –BONDABILITY OF SIX INDONESIAN WOOD SPECIES IN
RELATION WITH DENSITY AND WETTABILITY-
EKA MULYA ALAMSYAH THE UNITED GRADUATE SCHOOL OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES, GIFU UNIVERSITY
MASAAKI YAMADA AND KINJI TAKI FACULTY OF AGRICULTURE, SHIZUOKA UNIVERSITY
2
INTRODUCTION
GLOBAL PLANTATION FOREST
187,086World Total79%Top 10%
148,403Top 10 total2,284Islamic Republic of Iran4,425Ukraine4,920Thailand4,982Brazil9,871Indonesia10,682Japan16,238United States17,340Russian Federation32,578India45,083China
Total area (1000ha)Country
Table. Plantation area for the 10 largest plantation development countries (Carle J, et.al, 2002)
3
GLOBAL PLANTATION FOREST
17%
9%9%
6%
5%
3%
3%
2%
1%
21% 24%
China
India
Russian Federation
United State
Japan
Indonesia
Brazil
Thailand
Ukraine
Islamic Republic of Iran
Others
Fig. Leaders in forest plantation development, percentage of area (Carle J, et.al, 2002)
4
Table. Wood resources of selected species in Indonesian plantation forest
1110 – 35Gmelina arboreaGmelina143020Shorea spMeranti kuning133020Shorea spMeranti putih123020Shorea spMeranti merah113026Shorea stenopteraTengkawang10525Leucaena leuchochepalaLamtoro9
5 – 1025 – 44Acacia mangiumMangium81023Acacia auriculiformisAkor71012Anthocepalus sinensisJabon61520Dalbergia latifoliaSonokeling51225Eucalyptus albaAmpupu4
10 – 2517 – 20Eucalyptus degluptaLeda315 – 3016 – 18Pinus merkusiiTusam210 – 1538 – 45Paraserianthes falcatariaSengon1
Rotation (year)Annual increment (m3/ha)
Botanical nameVernacular nameNo
Source: Prosea foundation (1995)
5
Acacia mangium Willd
a major fast-growing wood species
Description: Tree to 30m tall, bole often straigth, to over half the total tree height. Possible to utilized for particleboard, furniture, cabinet marking, and pulp and paper.
Distributon: Largely Australian (native) with small stands New Guinea and the Moluccas. Introduced to Bangladesh, Cameroon, Costa Rica, Hawaii, Indonesia, Malaysia, Nepal, Papua and the Philippines.
Yields: Very fast growing species attaining 15m height and 40cm DBH in 3 years. They have attained 23 m tall in 9 years (Duke JA, 1983)
Area in 2003: 800,000 ha
Proposed in 2010: 1,000,000 ha
6
Development ofPlantation Forest
Pulp and paper,Latex,MDF
Natural ForestLumber,Wood working,etc.S
UPPLY
Bonding performancePrevious study
Glulam???
Recent study
DEMAND
Facing the increasingly wood of fast-growing tree species from plantation forest in the future, more attention must be given to these fast-growing tree species. This is because these species are expected to be used not only for pulp and paper or fiber production but also for other wood bonded products such as for glulam production which is deserving of the most promotion in the future.
BACKGROUND
OBJECTIVEIn order to get more efficient and appropriate utilization of these fast-growing wood species for glulam production, the study of wood characteristics such as density and wettability related to its bonding performance is still great important.
7
Table 1. Wood speciesSpecies Symbol Age (year-old) Diameter (cm) Height (m) Density (g/cm3) MC (%)
Enterolobium xylocarpum Ex 7 28 11 0.30 9.5Paraserianthes falcataria Pf 8 30 10 0.34 9.3Toona sinensis Ts 11 11 10 0.49 9.0Gmelina arborea Ga 11 28 10 0.51 9.3Pinus merkusii Pm 11 23 12 0.59 9.3Acacia mangium Am 7 31 10 0.64 9.0MC, moisture content
MATERIALS I. Shear strength and wood failure
Paraserianthes falcataria Enterolobium xylocarpum Toona sinensis
Gmelina arborea Pinus merkusii Acacia mangium
8
Table 2. Adhesives
59±1
58±3
55
42
Solid content (%)
0.35
6.0±2
0.25
n.a
Viscocity(Pa.s)
250resin (100) : catalyst (15)Resorcinol formaldehyde (RF)
250resin (100) : cross link agent (15)
Aqueous polymer isocyanate (API)
300resin (100) : NH4Cl 20% (15) : flour (10)
Urea formaldehyde (UF)
200-Polyvinyl acetate emulsion (PVAc)
Spread rate (g/m2)
Glue mixture composition (p.b.w)
Adhesive type
9
METHODS
Two-ply laminations preparation
Laminae (230×120 × 10mm) Smoothened Conditioned in 20oC, 65%RH for 24h
Glued spread two-ply laminaeAssembledCold pressurized in 20oC, 65%RH for 24h
Cured conditioned in 20oC, 65%RHfor 1 week
Block-shear tested (6.25cm2)10 specimen per each treatment
Bond strength (BS) and wood failure (WF) Wood strength (WS)
Solid wood
Glue line
Load
Load pressure: 0.98MPa in EX, PF, S, TS, GA, PM 1.18MPa in AM, AH
10
Test condition: Normal (N) and after accelerated aging treatment
Specimen submerged in cold tap water for 1h→vacuumed at 635mmHg for 5m→ pressurized at 5.2±0.3kgf/cm2 for 1h → these step repeated→dried at 70±3oC for 24h
OOVacuum pressure soaking-dry (PSD)
Specimen submerged in cold tap water for 1h→vacuumed at 635mmHg for 5m→ pressurized at 5.2±0.3kgf/cm2 for 1h → these step repeated
OOVacuum pressure soaking (VPS)
Specimen submerged in boiled water for 4h→submerged in cold tap water for 1h→ dried at 70±3oC for 18h → submerged in boiled water for 4h
OOCyclic boiling (CB)
RFAPI
Specimen submerged in hot water at 60oC for 6hOOHot water dipping (HW)
Specimen submerged in cold tap water for 6h→dried at 40oC for 18h
OOWater dipping-dry (WD)Specimen submerged in cold tap water for 6hOOWater dipping (W)
MethodUFPVAcTreatment
Table Description of accelerated aging treatment
11
Maximum load at failure Shear strength (MPa): -----------------------------------
Glued area
Wood failure: the rupturing of wood fibers in strength test of bonded wood joints usually expressed as the percentage of the total area involved that shows such failure (Vick CB, 1999)
Bonding performance classifications
1. Excellent, if the strength retention and wood failure percentages are in the ranges from 80 to 100%
2. Good (60-79%)
3. Bad (40-59%)
4. Worst (0-39)
Where:Bond shear strength (BS)
Strength retention (%): ---------------------------------------- X 100 Wood shear strength (WS)
12
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Fig. Relationship between density and strength in solid wood
y = 30.837x - 0.6834R2 = 0.9037
y = 20.499x - 1.2316R2 = 0.7288
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Shea
r st
reng
th (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am Japanese wood (42 species)
Note: Japanese wood (Wood materials handbook, forestry and forest products research institute, in Japanese, 192-195, Maruzen, 2004)
13
Shear strength and wood failure
0
5
10
15
20
25
N (Dry) W (Wet) WD (Dry) HW (Wet)
Treatment
Shea
r str
engt
h (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
020406080
100
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
0
5
10
15
20
25
N (Dry) W (Wet) WD (Dry) HW (Wet)
Treatment
Shea
r str
engt
h (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
020406080
100
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
JAS
JAS
JAS
JAS
PVAc UF
14
PF
PM
TS
AM
EX
GA
Max Min
Fig. Type of failure for laminates bonded with PVAc in normal conditions
15
PF
PM
TS
AM
EX
GA
Max Min
Fig. Type of failure for laminates bonded with UF in normal conditions
16
Shear strength and wood failure
API
05
10152025
N (Dry) CB (Wet) VPS (Wet) VPSD(Dry)
Treatment
Shea
r str
engt
h (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
020406080
100
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
0
5
10
15
20
25
N (Dry) CB (Wet) VPS (Wet) VPSD(Dry)
Treatment
Shea
r str
engt
h (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
020406080
100
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
JAS
JAS
JAS
JAS
RF
17
PF
PM
TS
AM
EX
GA
Max Min
Fig. Type of failure for laminates bonded with API in normal conditions
18
y = 32.96x - 3.8703R2 = 0.6225
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Shea
r st
reng
th (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
y = 20.705x + 1.1439R2 = 0.6011
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Shea
r str
engt
h (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
y = 29.046x - 1.0988R2 = 0.7152
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Shea
r st
reng
th (M
Pa)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
y = 27.355x - 0.5092R2 = 0.7355
y = 18.185x - 0.0584R2 = 0.7305
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Shea
r stre
ngth
(MPa
)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am Japanese wood (39 species)
UF PVAc
Relationship between density and shear strength
API RF
Note: Japanese wood (Horioka K, report of forest research laboratory, 1956)
19
PF
PM
TS
AM
EX
GA
Fig. Type of failure for laminates bonded with RF in normal conditions
20
0102030405060708090
100
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
0102030405060708090
100
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
0102030405060708090
100
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
0102030405060708090
100
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90
Density (g/cm3)
Woo
d fa
ilure
(%)
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am Japanese wood (39 species)
PVAc UF
Wood failure transition based on the density
API RF
21
Solid wood Table 3. Wood shear strength (MPa) in average
N W WD HW CB VPS VPSDE. xylocarpum 7.5 5.6 9.0 5.4 4.7 5.7 8.3P. falcataria 10.4 4.8 9.7 5.5 4.7 5.9 7.0T. sinensis 16.3 11.8 17.7 10.0 8.9 10.8 18.0G. arborea 16.5 15.6 14.8 14.7 10.4 12.8 15.6P. merkusii 17.2 7.3 16.3 6.7 6.0 6.6 17.0A. mangium 18.1 13.4 16.5 12.3 9.3 12.0 17.1
Wood species Treatment
Bonding performance……….
Bond shear strength (BS) 1. Strength retention (%): ---------------------------------------- X 100
Wood shear strength (WS)
2. Wood failure percentage
22
T a b le 4 . E s tim a tio n o f b o n d in g p e r fo rm a n c e
N W W D HW C B V P S V P S DP V Ac
UFAP IRF
P V AcUFAP IRF
P V AcUFAP IRF
P V AcUFAP IRF
P V AcUFAP IRF
P V AcUFAP IRF
S p e c ie s Ad h e s iv e T re a tm e n t
E . x y lo c a rp u m
A . m a n g iu m
P . fa lc a ta r ia
T . s in e n s is
G . a rb o re a
P . m e rk u s i i
Excellent Good Bad Worst
23
II. NATURE WETTABILITYMATERIALS
Specimen: laminae of each wood species Repetition: 3 specimen of laminaeLiquid dropped: distilled water (pH 5.76)
METHODSSpecimen manufactured
(60 x 20 x 5mm)Conditioned in 20oC,
65%RH for 24hLaminae Smoothened
Contact-angle changes measured three times (every 10second within
120second observation time)
Distilled water dropped (0.20ml)
Fig. Face Contact-angle meter CA-DT, type-A
24
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
0102030405060708090
100
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120
Elapsed time (second)
Con
tact
-ang
le (o )
Ex-H Pf-H Ts-H Ga-H Pm-H Am-HEx-S Pf-S Ts-S Ga-S Pm-S Am-S
Fig. Contact-angle changes within 120s observation time
WETTABILITY
25
22
12
36
83
15
73
146
30
61
14
82
0
20
40
60
80
100
Ex Pf Ts Ga Pm Am
Wood species
Con
tact
-ang
le (
o )Heartwood Sapwood
Fig. Average contact-angle at 20s observation time
WETTABILITY
26
WETTABILITY
T. sinensis A. mangium
P. falcataria P. merkusii
Fig. Type of contact-angle at 20s observation time in examples
27
CONCLUSIONS
1. Bond strength increased with the increasing of laminated wood density as the same as in solid wood, even though their coefficient of determination (R2) values was lower than those of solid wood.
2. High wood failure for EX, PF, and TS with the density ranges from 0.30 to 0.50g/cm3 showing an indication of good adhesive penetration as compared to GA, PM and AM with the density ranges from 0.51 to 0.70g/cm3.
3. Low wood failure percentages, especially in AM laminates bonded with RF indicated that beside the effect of the density, extractives content of the wood might be interfere with the chemical cure the adhesive.
28
CONCLUSIONS
4. Small contact-angle and good wettability were obtained by EX, PF, PM and TS. It is suggested that good wettability resulting good adhesive penetration as shown by high wood failure percentages and resistance to delamination in those wood species. High contact-angle and poor wettability in GM and AM might be causes by deposits of extractives on the wood surfaces.
5. Our continuing study indicated that methanol sweep on the wood surface of AM could reduce the contact-angle and make better wettability as shown by the increasing of wood failure percentage.