booklet by farooq rather
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
1/93
CHARITY &
INVESTMENT
A RECONSTRUCTION OF
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
2/93
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
3/93
Contents
Preface 03;
Charity 10;
Taxes 24;
Investment 39;
Usury 55;
Principal Plus 77.
3
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
4/93
In the name Allah the Beneficent, the Merciful!
Preface
The importance and significance of economics cannot
be overstated. Perhaps the biggest impact and influence on
human life and on animal and plant life, too is of
economics. Both peace as well as war have a lot to do withthe economics; and economics has to do a lot with the peace
and the war. Economics determines the living standard of any
people. Yet economic well-being remains the shattered dream
of mankind which is sharply divided into the rich and the
poor. The two classes do not co-exist; they are polarised and
repulsive of each other. Even inside a rich country the
affluent are luxurious while the others are miserable. There
continue to be millions of the destitute and the starving whoare human in genetics only. Obviously our economics is not a
success story.
An important reason for looking to Islam for a way
out of this failure was its claim that God has sent
Mohammad(saw) as a blessing for all the worlds. The
destitute people do constitute a world of their own. A big
question arises then: is their misery outweighing this blessing
or are they yet to receive it? This informative, notformulative, booklet is a modest attempt to uncover the
Islamic theory of economics which seeks to ensure that no
one is deprived of his livelihood. THOSE WHO DONOT LIKE TO
BELIEVE IN GOD MAY ONLY CONSIDER THE SPEECH AND IGNORE THE
SPEAKER. An attempt has been made to construe afresh the
relative verses of the Quran in their own light and in the light
of sayings of the Prophet (saw). As the very name suggests, only
4
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
5/93
the fundamentals or the macros have been discussed; themicro-economic details have been left out.
The macros discussed are broadly three. One is the
Islamic taxation system with particular emphasis on
separation of a defence tax to be levied on wealth instead of
income. Second is the imperative of investment: asserting
that investment is the key to growth and therefore superior to
charity which only ensures existence and that poverty is due
to lack of investment rather than for want of charity. Theseparation of a wealth tax for defence purposes can prevent
us from the scourge of inflation and price hike; and the
investment in Islamic way can lead to a peaceful co-existence
of the individuals/ nations through poverty alleviation.
Nevertheless, for adopting the Islamic economic system
Islamisation is not at all a pre-requisite.
The third macro discussed is of course the prohibited
Riba. Obviously, any discourse on Islamic economics will beincomplete if it does not include Riba. Usury is essentially
an exorbitant rate of interest charged on a debt. And it is
because of this high rate of interest that usury has been
disapproved. The Greek philosophers also advocated its
abolition. Riba has somehow come to be translated as
Usury with the add-up that all interest is banned in Islam,
no matter what the rate. This view received general
acceptance because the need did not arise to delve into it. The
life was simple and the nature of international trade andfinance also was very primitive. The later development
demanded a review of the conventional view. The Non-
Muslims found a convenient way out of usury by
rationalising the interest rates. The Muslims found
themselves at the cross-roads of the conventional view and
the modern requirements. In this dilemma necessity became
5
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
6/93
the convenient tool to justify Riba where it was perceived asunavoidable or indispensable.
This approach is nave for more reasons than one. It
purports to bail out Islam from the modern pressures
unwittingly implying a flaw in Islam itself, i.e., its failure to
deliver in the modern times! This view in fact renders Islam an
imperfect code of life. Prohibition ofRiba is too absolute to
allow any legitimization even on individual level only. The
realisation of this flaw has lead to the creation of the so-calledNo-Riba Islamic banking as an alternative whose viability is
sought to be proved over and over again.
Necessity may account for a violation but it cannot justify
the violation. A violation should be known as a violation only.
The approach of necessity assumes that the conventional view is
impeccable. But disagreeing with a commentary does not
imply a disagreement with the text. A complete definition and
description ofRiba has been given in this booklet which plainly discredits the conventional approach. At the same
time it is also pointed out that the sooner the prohibition of
Riba is enforced, the better.
The intellectual freedom permitted in Islam has
encouraged me to be critical of the traditional interpretation
ofRiba and present a reconstruction of the concept. A few
words about this freedom should be helpful in appreciating
the views presented in this booklet. Intellectual freedom in
Islam has been exhibited through a significant incident in thelife of the Prophet(saw) and the revelation of the Quran. Verse
80 of Chapter 9 of the Quran was revealed about the
hypocrites: Whether you ask for their forgiveness or not,
(and even) if you ask forgiveness for them seventy times,
Allah will not forgive them. Some time after the revelation
of this verse the chief of the hypocrites Abdullah bin Ubai
breathed his last. His son came to the Prophet(saw) and
6
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
7/93
requested for his shirt to shroud his father and urged foroffering his funeral prayer also. The Prophet (saw) acceded to
both of his requests. But Umar(ra) argued with the Prophet(saw)
saying that the above verse did not permit them to offer
funeral prayer of an open hypocrite. The Prophet(saw) did not
accept the argument of Umar(ra) and maintained that he has
been given the choice to pray or not to pray, therefore he
chooses to pray. Then the Prophet(saw) offered the funeral
prayer of the deceased. Now this example of the Prophet(saw)
made the hypocrites funeral prayer quite permissible for the
Muslim because the Prophet(saw) has the constitutional
authority to interpret and construe the verses of Quran
revealed unto him(saw). However, Allah the Wise intervened
soon to clarify through verse 84 (And never shall thou ever
pray for any of them that dies, nor stand at his grave: for
they have rejected Allah and His apostle and have died as
hypocrites.) that the interpretation of Umar
(ra)
was correct.Thereafter the Prophet(saw) never offered funeral prayer of any
of the hypocrites. This incident is carried thrice in Sahih Al-
Bukhari as Hadith number 2:359, 6:194, 7:688.
The All-Knowing Allah did indeed know that this
difference of opinion will arise. In fact only He permitted it
to arise by revealing the two instant verses with a time gap in
between. The purpose was to exemplify for the Believers that
anyone can have a correct understanding of a thing and that a
correct or incorrect understanding of a point has nothing todo with the status of a person. Failure to understand one
particular thing is not the failure to understand everything;
nor is the clear concept of one particular thing the clear
concept of everything in life. Therefore, this incident did not
change the status of the beloved Prophet(saw) or that of
Umar(ra). Interestingly, the same Umar(ra) has admitted that
7
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
8/93
Riba is a subject on which he could not learn more from theProphet(saw).
There are umpteen examples from Quran and Hadith
to show that intellectual freedom in Islam is virtually
unlimited. Scope and space do not permit a full discussion
here. But it would be harsh to this brief reference if we do not
mention one famous Hadith related by Amr bin Al-As(ra) who
said that he has heard Allah's Apostle(saw) saying that if a
judge gives a verdict according to the best of his knowledgeand his verdict is correct (i.e., agrees with the verdict of
Allah and His Apostle(saw)), he will receive a double reward;
and if he gives a verdict according to the best of his
knowledge but his verdict is wrong (i.e., against that of Allah
and His Apostle(saw)), even then he will get a (single) reward
(Al-Bukhari 9:450). Thus the act of giving even an erroneous
judgement is a good deed and not a sin at all.
However, it has to be remembered that while theaforementioned incident of different interpretations of the
said verse (80) was allowed to occur for the purpose of
defining the intellectual freedom, the intellectual freedom is
no more available to the extent of taking a view different to
the view of the Prophet(saw). Only Umar(ra) could do it because
Quran was being revealed and the difference was resolved by
Allah. The religion is complete and it will be undoubtedly
blasphemous now to differ with the view of the Last
Messenger(saw) of Allah on any point. But this does not meanthat we cannot differ with the views of ancient or
contemporary scholars. Actually we should indeed review
many opinions of our ancestors for the simple reason that we
are more knowledgeable than our predecessors (excluding the
Prophet(saw)). That approach will not only conform to the
consequences of the educational evolution of mankind but
will also be upto fulfilment of the supplication of the
8
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
9/93
Prophet(saw) himself which he made during his Last Sermon:....... All those who listen to me shall pass on my words to
others and those to others again; and may the last ones
understand my words bet ter than those who l is ten to
me di rect ly . Be my witness oh God that I have conveyed
your message to your people. (Emphasis supplied)A very big question arises here: are we better than our
ancestors because of our more knowledge? The blunt answer
to this big question is an equally big NO. The Quran has predicted in no equivocal terms that majority of the
forerunners in faith will be from those of the earlier
generations and only a minority of them will be from the
succeeding generations. (See 56:10-14) There is no conflict
between this Quranic prediction and the above said
supplication of the Prophet (saw). Knowledge and performance
are two different, if not separate, things. There are
numberless people in the world who are qualified in one fieldbut they are working in another field. A little educated soldier
guarding his nation on the border is more loyal than a
knowledgeable officer who is an enemy agent. It is
abundantly clear from this prediction of the Quran and the
supplication of the Prophet(saw) that to differ with a scholar is
not tantamount to casting an aspersion on his faith.
Nevertheless, the views expressed in this discourse on
the three macros will be better taken as those of a coach than
a referee. All praise is due only to Allah without Whose help
nothing can be achieved. May He show us only the right as
right and give us to obey it; and may He show us only the
wrong as wrong and give us to avoid it! And may He bless all
those who have helped and guided me in this endeavour!
Kashmir; Nov., 2008. Mohammad Farooq
9
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
10/93
NarratedAbu Hurairah(RA )
Allahs Apostle(saw) said, I have been sent with
Jawami' al-Kalim, or the shortest expressions bearing the
widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with awe
(cast in the hearts of the enemy), and while I was sleeping,
the keys of the treasures of the world were brought to me
and put in my hand. Abu Huraira(ra) added: Allah's Apostle
has gone, and you people are utilizing those treasures, or
digging those treasures out, or said a similar sentence (Al-Bukhari: 4:220; 9:141; 9:378).
The right hand number is book number, the left the Hadith number.Likewise, in Quranic references the left hand number is the chapter
number and the right hand number the verse number.10
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
11/93
CHARITY
Consciously or sub-consciously we do like to think
that he who has must continue to have, and to continue to
have he must earn. And practically, to earn has come to
mean to earn anyway. This thinking has been the driving
force of all, individual and collective, human action. Wars
are fought and prevented for economic well being. Colonial
occupations have had economic reasons and goals. Strategic
alliances between countries are essentially economic
enterprises indeed. But even the unprecedented modern
world trade has miserably failed to provide even the bare
food to everyone on earth, let alone a dignified human life.
Even the huge social and charitable spending by thegovernment and other agencies worldwide stands out,
forgivably, as an exercise in futility. We may overlook the
sub-standard living conditions of the poor people around the
world, but we cannot justify the starvation of the millions of
the human beings worldwide.
The concern of economics should be to arrange
sufficient food for all. Certainly we do not live to eat, but to
live we must eat. Economics must circulate wealth fromricher persons to the rich ones. For those in adversity
economics should provide food security so that their
energies remain reserved for profitability. In short, dignity
of human life is the responsibility of economics. Indeed
economics may not be pervasive enough to contain every
opposite factor. For instance, if the population continues to
increase unabated, economics may find itself at the cross-
roads of frustration. But at the same time, it still remains
11
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
12/93
arguable that the prosperity due to right economics may go along way to check population over-growth. However, for
economics to be successful the world would have to be
economically united. Economic disunity can be only ill-
afforded. The unpleasant actions of the deprived ones are
directed only against the wealthy people. If a starving
person is not fed by a man of substance, he has nowhere to
commit the theft but in the house of the latter only. Once he
has entered the house for theft, there is nothing to restricthim to the theft of food only. And once he has laid his hands
on a valuable, he is encouraged to stretch his hands farther
and further.
Islam advises unity of mankind by reminding us of
our common ancestry, to name only one reason. Its
argument is that the descendants of common ancestors must
behave like a family. At the same time, however, it does not
negate the existence of nationalities. But it says that nationsand tribes are for facilitating identification and recognition
not for dividing the mankind1.
Within a nation also Islam does not envisage a class-
less society. It justifies the categorization of the individuals
into the rich and the poor: for our trial in what God has
given us2. In Islam riches are a means of trial for the rich as
well as the poor. When a rich person is deprived of his
1 O mankind! We created you from a single (pair of a) male and afemale, and made you into nations and tribes that you may (be able to)know (one another); verily, honourable among you before Allah is he
who is mindful(of Allah), and Allah is the All-Knowing, the All-Aware(49:13).2And He it is Who has made you viceroys on the earth and has raised
you in degrees some above others: so that He may try you in what He
has given you; verily, your Lord is quick in retribution, and He is
indeed the Forgiving, the Merciful (6:165).12
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
13/93
riches and rendered poor, or when riches are withheld froma poor person, they are tried in poverty 3; and so is a person
tried also when his wealth is with him. Another reason is also
given in Quran for making some people rich and some others
poor. It maintains that if every one were rich, there would
be only crime and dissent everywhere4. The existence of
both the rich and the poor produces the two important things
called fear and hope both manifestations of our inherent
characteristic to look beyond. The rich exercise a good dealof restraint for fear of poverty, and the poor hope to become
prosperous one day. (Simultaneously, the rich hope to stay
rich and the poor are scared of staying poor.) We are born,
and we live and die, on this not-our-own earth without our
choice or consultation. At the time of birth we are too small
to be consulted; and our consent is not sought for our death
either. Still we love this imposed life and we feel so bad
about its end that we never want it to end! We are scared ofdeath for ourselves or for our heirs-apparent. As for life,
we never want to give up hope even when it means self-
deception. But this is what keeps us going on in this
unbreakable jail of an invincible Master Who jails and frees
us whenever He chooses. It is in our own interest, therefore,
that as helpless jailbirds we better obey the Jailor. If we go
chaotic, we alone would see the chaos because this Jailor
does not stay in the jail.
Wealth can be lost for any reason. It can be wronginvestment, unmatched extravagance or any other faulty act
of commission and omission. There can also be a social,
3 See Quran: 2:155.4And if Allah were to enlarge the provision for (all) His Servants theywould indeed rebel on the earth; but He sends down in due measure as
He wills; verily, for He is with His servants Well-acquainted, Watchful
(42:27).13
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
14/93
political, or even a personal, reason for the adversity of a person who has no control over those circumstances.
Whatever the obvious reason of ones impoverishment, it is
a trial from the Lord. The only defender against the Lord is
the Lord Himself as the best and the surest way to come
out of a net is to surrender to the huntsman. We are caught
in a net when we are not careful. But in spite of all our
carelessness we would not be entrapped if the huntsman had
not laid the trap. These impoverished people, alongwithsome others, are enlisted in the Quran as the only persons
eligible to receive5 the Charity orZakah, the fourtieth part
of a Muslims surplus wealth (over 85 gms. of gold).
Amongst these beneficiaries the more deserving6 ones are
also highlighted. For the purposes of this discourse it is
important to point out that one of the beneficiaries ofZakah
is a distressed debtor7. However, the obligation of the
affluent Muslims to pay Charity is independent of theserecipients. The payers cannot avoid the payment for want of
a recipient, or by questioning the right of a recipient.
Payment of one fourtieth of the surplus wealth at the
end of an accounting year is one of the five fundamental
duties of a Muslim. There are plenty of verses to ordain this
duty unto the Believers8. The edifice of Islam is based on
five pillars of which one is the payment of Charity orZakah.
The collection and distribution ofZakah has to be better
5 See Quran: 9:60.6 See Quran: 2:273.7 Alms are not but for the poor and the needy and those who are incharge thereof; and for those whose hearts are to be won over; and for
(freeing) the captives and the debtors; and for cause of Allah; and forthe wayfarer: (thus is it) ordained by Allah and Allah is the All-
Knowing and the Wise"(9:60).8 See Quran: 2:43, 83, 110, 177, 277; 4:77, 162; 5:12, 55; 9:5, 11, 18, 71;
24:37, 56; 27:3; 31:4; 58:13; & 73:20.14
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
15/93
institutionalized9, for maximum efficacy. AllahsApostle(saw) instituted Charity in the second year ofHijra
(Migration) at Madina. Charity was prescribed by Allah
through earlier prophets also10. Charity cleanses and purifies
the Believers11(and not their properties).
There are quite a few interesting things about
Charity which though implied are equally significant. One,
its 2.5% rate is very low lovably low when compared to
the modern rates. Two, as a wealth tax it is favourablyrelated to the expenses of a Muslim. If a Muslim has had a
huge income in any given year but his expenses did not
leave him with the minimum surplus, he shall not be liable
to pay Charity for that year. This always tends to reduce the
number of potential payers. Three, the class of people
entitled to receive Zakah is very restricted: implying that the
role this particular tax is intended to play is also limited.
Four, to pay Zakah is mandatory. It can be safely inferredfrom these aspects of Zakah that Islam expects an
overwhelming majority of the Believers to be well off, so
that only the fourtieth part of their surplus wealth suffices to
provide social security to the remaining minority
impoverished from time to time, howsoever. In support of
this inference one can refer to the verse12 in which the
direction to pay Charity is separately given to the wives (ra)
of the Prophet(saw), even as they are ordained to stay in their
homes. In practice, however, Allahs Apostle never retainedhis wealth for so long as to be liable for Charity*1.
9See Quran: 22:41.10
See Quran: 5:12; 7:156; 19:31, 55; 21:73; 22:78; & 98:5.11 See Quran: 9:103.12 See Quran: 33:33.*1 Umar(ra) narrated that the Prophet(saw) used to sell the dates of the
garden ofBani An-Nadirand store for his family so much food as would15
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
16/93
The purpose of Charity is to ensure that the poor people do not starve. After all, remembrance of God and
starvation do not go in the same direction. Nevertheless,
Islam has not taken this measure of assured sustenance to
keep the poor alive today in order that their poverty is
prolonged to-morrow. This is a limited fulfilment, whileas
their duties are many: they too have been created by God
with the same purpose of his own worship13. By maintaining
that all the people shall not be rich Islam does not endorsepoverty as a divine discrimination. In respect of the property
abandoned by, or taken away from, an enemy without a
formal war the Quran advises the Islamic State that it should
equitably distributed among the poor kindred, orphans, the
needy and the wayfarer, and should not be allowed circulate
among your rich ones14. Here is an express injunction
against making the rich richer and leaving the poor to get
poorer. Thus an Islamic State should take off as a State offair distribution of the acquisitions which shall be
subsequently sustained by proper investment. It may be
added that the spoils that are gotten after an active war are
cover their needs for a whole year. (Al-Bukhari: 7:270) And narratedAisha(ra): The family of Mohammad(saw) had not eaten wheat bread to
their satisfaction for three consecutive days since his arrival at Medina
till he passed away ( Al-Bukhari 7:327); and The family ofMuhammad(saw) never ate wheat-bread with meat for three consecutivedays to their fill, till he met Allah (Al-Bukhari 8:678).[
13I have created jinns and men only for My worship; no sustenance doI require of them, nor do I ask them to feed Me; verily it is Allah Who is
the Provider, the All-Powerful (51:56-58).14 What Allah has bestowed on His Apostle (and taken away) from the
people of the townships is for Allah and for the Apostle and for thekindred, the orphans, the needy and the wayfarer, in order that it does
not circulate among your wealthy people ...... (59:7).16
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
17/93
substantially for the participants (soldiers) of the war withno scope for the bureaucratic usurpation15.
Besides this mandatory Charity or Zakah Islam
encourages other charitable spending also16. However, the
first thing to say about the discretionary spending is that for
its quantum we are guided by the sayings of the Prophet (saw),
rather than his actions*2. He (saw) has spent every thing as and
when directed by Allah. For us the guidelines have been set
and it is for us to decide what is judicious in a givensituation so that we are neither overgenerous nor niggardly.
The Islamic rule of wealth is that HE WHO HAS MUST SPEND.
There is no substitute for spending. It is only those who
spend that do become the God-fearing17, knowledgeable18
and receive the supplication of angels*3. Indeed the great
15 See Quran: 8:1, 41.16 See Quran: 2:177.*2 Narrated AbuHuraira(ra): Allah's Apostle(saw) said, Neither do I giveyou (anything) nor withhold (anything) from you; I am just a
DISTRIBUTOR, orQasim, and I give as I am ordered (Al-Bukhari: 4:346).Jabir Bin Abdullah Al Ansari(ra) narrated: A man amongst us begot a
boy whom he named Al-Qasim. On that the Ansar said (to the man),We will never call you Abu-al-Qasim and will never please you with
this blessed title. So, he went to the Prophet (saw) and said, O Allah's
Apostle! I have begotten a boy whom I named Al-Qasim and theAnsar
said, We will never call youAbu-al-Qasim, nor will we please you with
this title. The Prophet(saw) said, The Ansarhave done well. Name bymy name, but do not name by my Kunya, FOR I AMQasim (Al-Bukhari:4:345). Qasim was the name of the first son/ issue of the Prophet(saw), so thepeople gave the title (Kunya)Abu-Qasim, or Father of Qasim, to the Prophet(saw).
But Allahs Prophet(saw) said that HE HIMSELF IS Qasim. Muawiya(ra) narrated:
Allah's Apostle(saw) said, If Allah wants to do good for somebody, he
makes him comprehend the religion; and Allah is the Giver and I amAl-
Qasim, or the DISTRIBUTOR, and this (Muslim) nation will remainvictorious over their opponents till Allah's order comes and they will
still be victorious (Al-Bukhari: 4:346).17
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
18/93
human characteristic of judgement is reaffirmed by aspender since in spending we exercise our discretion to
spend rightly or wrongly. On the contrary, failure to spend
demotes an owner to the level of a sentinel, guarding his
wealth for unknown beneficiaries who shall get it after his
death. This has really semblance of a dog that is never
willing to share.
Approved spending presupposes the existence of
legitimate wealth only and not anything prohibited or ill-gotten19. Trading in stolen poultry will be unlawful,
although poultry trade is legal. Legitimate wealth spent for
any lawful purpose, including even that spent one ones own
family20, is appreciated by Allah the Appreciator. Ones
spending should be indicative of ones wealth also 21. This
is rather difficult for the rich who must apply some amount
17Who believe in the unseen, and establish (regular) Prayer, and
spend of what We have provided to them (2:3).Those who spend, whether in prosperity or in adversity; who restrain
anger and pardon men; and Allah loves those who do good (3:134).18 Those who rehearse the Book of Allah, establish regular prayer and
spend, secretly and openly, of what We have provided for them: hopingfor a commerce that will never fail (35:29).19*3 Abu Huraira(ra) narrated that the Prophet(saw) said that no day breaks
for the people without two angels descending of whom one prays O
God, compensate the spender as he spends, and the other prays O
God, destroy the miser (Al-Bukhari: 2:522).See Quran: 2:168.
20 They ask you what they should spend. Say: Whatever you spend that
is good is for parents and kindred and orphans and those in want andfor wayfarers. And whatever you do that is good Allah knows it well
(2:215).21Let the man of means spend according to his means, and let the man
whose resources are restricted spend according to what Allah has givenhim; Allah does not burden any one beyond what He has given him:
soon will Allah grant relief after difficulty (65:7).18
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
19/93
of caution also. They are supposed to spend more, but at thesame time they cannot afford to drain out their riches
thoughtlessly22. Extravagance is overspending, or unlawful
spending, on things which are not illegal in themselves. And
it is indeed sinful and Allah does not like the extravagant.
But extravagance has to be distinguished from squandering
which is simply illegal spending, or spending on the things
forbidden rather than desirable. The squanderers are
declared as brothers of Satans who are only rebellioustowards their Lord23.
While the Quranic principle of commercial spending,
or investment, is cloth according to the coat, that of
personal spending is coat according to cloth. In personal
matters the demand or consumption should be directly related
to the supply or affordability. In commercial activity one
must spend what ought to be spent and not what one likes, or
can afford, to spend. This is logical. A person desirous ofplying a bus must pay the price of the bus; he cannot have a
bus by paying the price of a taxi.
Ibn Kathirin his tafsirhas quoted an example from tafsir Ibn Jareerthus: Umar(ra) enquired about Abu Ubaidah(ra) and was told that he is
using coarse cloth and light food. Umar(ra) released one thousandDinar
in his favour and directed the delivery man to see what he (Abu
Ubaidah(ra)
) does of that amount. As Abu Ubaidah(ra)
received themoney, he started using fine clothes and nice foods. When this was
reported to Umar(ra), he said: May Allah bless him! He has acted up-to
the verse that a man of means should spend according .22 O children of Adam! Take your beautiful apparel in every mosque;
and eat and drink but do not overspend: verily He loves not theextravagant (7:31).23
And give his due to the kinsman and the needy and the wayfarer, and
squander not wantonly; verily squanderers are brothers of the Satans;
and Satan is rebellious towards his Lord (17:26, 27).19
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
20/93
Generally personal contribution and borrowingtogether fund an investment. But one may question the very
wisdom of taking the burden of debt along with the risk of
throwing ones own capital into a business whose result it is
always hard to predict? One has to evaluate two variables: the
inspiration of the lucrative profit, and the scare of the risk of
loss. Ostensibly the second factor weighs heavy and makes a
better reason for not venturing into any business. There is
always a large scope for financial errata in estimates,projections and expectations in spite of all good intentions.
And the resultant loss does not mean loss of ones capital
only; it includes the additional liability for the debts taken.
But then what on earth are millions of entrepreneurs doing?
Are they just gambling? No.
Quran contains an unwavering commandment on
investment and educates the Muslims that it is the Satan who
scares them by his pseudo-promise of destitution if theycommit the mistake of investing their wealth, and induces
them to indulge in lewdness instead of enterprise24. But Allah
promises forgiveness and bounty25 against investment. Satan
creates an inflated apprehension that the investment will fail
and the investor will be ruined. He advises indulgences in
lewdness to retain the pleasure and keep the financial ruin at
bay. Lewdness is open indulgence in morally disapproved
sensual pleasures. Lewdness per se is not antonymous to
investment. It is inversely proportional to investment since ittakes away in an extra large measure the time and energy of
the person which could be highly lucrative if utilized in an
economic enterprise. Likewise, Allahs promises of
24Satan promiseth you destitution and prompts you to conduct
unseemly. And Allah promiseth you His forgiveness from Himself andbounty and Allah is the All-Embracing the All-Knowing (2:268).
25 Ibid.20
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
21/93
forgiveness and bounty are apparently too diverse to convinceon investment. But actually these are pretty well relevant and
related. The forgiveness wipes out all the errors of judgement
we might make while making an investment; and the grant of
bounty ensures gain from the investment in spite of our
mistakes. Still more significantly, neither of these two
favours is to be besought by us, both of them are promised by
Allah Himself. All we have to do is to use our wealth to do
business.In simple words, success of entrepreneurship is
guaranteed by Allah. The only condition which is pretty
reasonable is that what we spend or invest should be our
legitimate earning and/or what is produced from the earth 26.
Notably the produce of earth is not linked with legitimacy or
equity. The inference therefore would be that land should
never be wasted and must be utilized by whomsoever it is
occupied. (With the Lords guarantee for success of their business, the Believers have the reason to be aggressive
entrepreneurs.) This explains the inability of charity to cause
economic growth. In charity we always have a predetermined
amount to give, so the recipient has to shrink his needs within
the limits of the donation. We cannot compel the donor to
give more than his liability. Likewise, the socialist type of
government business fails because the budget, rather than the
businesses, determines the amount of possible investments.
The government cannot invest more even if it wants to, because its revenues are limited. On the contrary, through
26O ye who believe, spend of the good things which ye have
(honourably) earned and of the fruits of the earth which We haveproduced for you and do not even aim at getting anything which is bad
in order that out of it ye may give away something when ye yourselveswould not receive it except with closed eyes. And know that Allah is free
of all wants and worthy of all praise (2:267).21
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
22/93
entrepreneurship the business demands and the investoryields. In other words, the business designs the coat and the
investor gets the requisite quantity of cloth.
Charitable spending should be from the surplus
wealth27. However, not all surpluses are for charity28.
Charitable spending is not synonymous with uncontrolled or
wasteful spending. In fact the maximum a Muslim can give
out charitably should not exceed one third of his wealth*4. It
27 They ask you how much they are to spend; say: What is28
beyond your needs. Thus does Allah make clear to you His Signs: in
order that you may consider (2:219).
O children of Adam! Take your beautiful apparel in every mosque;and eat and drink but do not squander: verily He loves not the
extravagant (7:31).*4 Narrates Sad(ra). The Prophet(saw) visited me duringHajjat-ul-Wida (theFarewell Pilgrimage) while I was suffering from a disease which
brought me to the verge of death. I said, O Allah's Apostle! My ailmenthas reached such a state as you see, and I have much wealth, but I have
no one to inherit from me except my only daughter. Shall I give two-
third of my property as alms? The Prophet(saw) said, No. I said, Shall
I give half of my property as alms? He said, No. I said, (Shall I
give) one-third of it? He replied, One-third, even one-third is too
much. It is better for you to leave your inheritors wealthy rather than to
leave them poor and begging people (for their sustenance); and
whatever you spend for Allah's sake, you will get reward for it, even for
the morsel of food which you put in your wife's mouth. I said, OAllah's Apostle! Should I remain (in Mecca) behind my companions
(who are going with you to Medina)? The Prophet (saw) said, If you
remain behind, any good deed which you will do for Allah's sake will
upgrade and elevate you. May be you will live longer so that some
people may benefit by you and some others (i.e., infidels) may get
harmed by you. The Prophet(saw) then added, O God! Complete the
migration of my companions and do not turn them on their heels. But
the poor Sad bin Khaula(ra) (not this narrator Sad(ra)) died in Mecca.
Allah's Apostle(saw) pitied Sad(ra) for he died in Mecca. (Al-Bukhari:22
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
23/93
is preferable to give even lesser in charity. Lastly, theBelievers are warned against negating all the virtue of
charity by injuring the sentiments of the recipients. Such
conduct has been equated with rejection of faith29. Charity is
however rewarding for the giver, regardless of who has
received it from him*5. Allah the Merciful wants excuses to
shower His blessings; and the Concerned Prophet (saw) missed
no chance to create one. The Prophet(saw) was authorised to
5.693).29
Kind word and forgiveness are better than charity followed by
injury; Allah is the Self-sufficient, the Forbearing.O you who believe!cancel not your charity by reminders or injury like those who spend
their wealth only to be seen by people and believe neither in Allah
nor in the Last Day; theirs are like a rock on which is a little soil, when
rain falls on it, it(just) a bare stone, they will be able to do nothing withthe aught they have earned; and Allah guides not those who reject faith
(2:263, 264).*5Abu Huraira(ra) narrated that the Allah's Apostle(saw) said, A mansaid that he would give something in charity. He went out with his
object of charity and unknowingly gave it to a thief. Next morning the
people said that he had given his object of charity to a thief. (On hearing
that) he said, O God! All the praises are for you. I will give alms
again. And so he again went out with his alms and (unknowingly) gave
it to an adulteress. Next morning the people said that he had given his
alms to an adulteress last night. The man said, O God! All the praises
are for you. (I gave my alms to an adulteress.) I will give alms again.So he went out with his alms again and (unknowingly) gave it to a rich
person. The people next morning said that he had given his alms to a
wealthy person. He said, O God! All the praises are for you. I have
given alms to a thief, to an adulteress and to a wealthy man. Then
someone came and said to him, The alms which you gave to the thief
might make him abstain from stealing, and that given to the adulteress
might make her abstain from adultery, and that given to the wealthy
man might make him take a lesson from it and spend his wealth which
Allah has given him, in Allah's cause (Al-Bukhari: 2:502).23
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
24/93
collect the Charity from the Believers and also pray forthem30. The rewards of Sadaqah being abundant for the
givers, they hardly needed any supplication. Yet the loving
Prophet(saw) made for them a supplication they needed the
most. He(saw) prayed for their dependants*6. So the Believers
who are desirous of prosperous children should give
Sadaqat and acquire for their dependants the prayers of the
beloved Prophet(saw) of Allah. It is stupid to loose these
rewards for the sake of some words or gestures.***********
TAXES
By making Charity one of the five fundamentals of
Islam Allah has signified that taxation is an integral part of
Islamic way of life: negating the idea that a tax is a fine
imposed for doing well. Well done is well done for others.
Therefore, imposition of production tax, besides Charity, hasalso been sanctioned by Allah in his Book31. Pursuant to this
authorisation the Prophet Mohammad(saw) has prescribed the
rates of this tax. Literally these rates are based on the modes
of irrigation available to the various farmers; prudentially
30 Do take (O Prophet!) alms from their wealth, wherewith they may be
cleansed and purified; and pray for them, verily your prayer will
comfort them; and Allah is the All-Hearing, All-Knowing (9:103).*6Ibn Abi Aufa(ra) narrated that whenever a man brought his alms to theProphet(saw), he would say, O God! Bestow your blessings upon the
family of so-and-so. When my father came to him (with his alms), he
said, O God! Bestow your blessings upon the family ofAbi Aufa.31 It is He who produces gardens with trellises and without and datesandtilth with produce of all kinds and olives and pomegranates similar
(in kind) and different(in variety): eat of their fruit in their season butrender the dues that are proper on the day that the harvest is gathered.
But waste not by excess: for Allah loves not the wasters (6:141).24
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
25/93
these are actually considerate of the input cost. Where theland is watered by the heavens or springs or its own roots, a
tithe (ushur or tenth) has been prescribed as tax on its
produce. Where the land is watered by a well or a stream,
only half a tithe has been prescribed. In case the land is
watered equally by artificial and natural means, then three-
fourths of a tithe. The difference between the Charity and
the tax on produce is clear. The former becomes due only
when a Muslim has a specified minimum amount of surpluswealth at the end of an accounting year. The latter is due at
the time of harvest. The former has period and status factors
and is a wealth tax; the latter has time factor only and is
income tax. The maximum tax prescribed by Allahs Last
Messenger(saw) is only a tithe or 10%. The lesser rates of
7.5% or 5% were prescribed where there was an additional
cost of input for want of natural irrigation. (Our exorbitant
rates of excise duty go a long way to convince ourmanufacturers for tax evasion.) Thus the statutory limits of
Sadaqat (all good spending) are 10% of any produce, annual
2.5% of the surplus wealth, and a maximum optional
charitable spending of 33% of the total wealth.
This general rule of limited rates has its own
exception in which no rate is fixed by Allah or His Last
Prophet(saw). They have only authorised the imposition of
this (amount-wise) exceptional tax and the rate has been left
open to be determined by the government of the time. Thisexceptional tax is the tax that should be levied for defence
purposes. While determination of the rate of defence tax has
been delegated to the government, the subject Believers
have been simultaneously advised to pay this with an open
heart. They are advised not to tighten their fists, apparently
25
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
26/93
for the sake of their dependants32. They are told that suchconduct will be indeed destructive33. This is quite
understandable: if the country is over-run by an enemy for
want of defence, the very dependants for whom the tax is
evaded shall be enslaved by the occupier; and slaves are
never wealthy. Moreover, paying this tax is declared as a
spending in the way of Allah. And there is no way in which
to spend ones wealth better than in the way of Allah. Nor is
there anything more inappropriate than removing thingsfrom the Allahs way. It is only Allah the Inheritor to Whom
belongs and returns all inheritance of the heavens and the
earth.
Two of the attributes of Allah are that He is the
Provider (Al-Razaak) and the Donor (Al-Wahaab). The
former is a necessary corollary of His act of creation34. He
has created, so He must provide. An owner of a car must
fuel his car if he wants to use it for self or others; it cannotfuel itself. The second mentioned attribute of gifting dispels
the misgivings of the former. A car does not have a right to
be fuelled because it cannot run for itself. The former
attribute alludes to an obligation cast as it were on Allah;
but the latter asserts a power/ choice/ discretion vesting in
Allah. At the same time the attribute of Gifting proves love
that God Who gifts away this beautiful life to every human
being. Whatever the Provider provides for someone is at the
32 And what cause do you have against spending in the way of Allah?and to Allah belongs the heritage of the heavens and the
earth(57:10).33 And spend in the Allahs way and let not your own hands contribute
to your destruction, and do excel (in good deeds): for Allah loves theexcellent (2:195).34 I have created jinns and men only for My worship; no sustenance do
I require of them, nor do I ask them to feed Me; verily it is Allah Who is
the Provider, the All-Powerful (51:56-58).26
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
27/93
same time gifted to him by the Donor. A donor has the rightto gift away something, or to refuse it altogether. As far as
we are concerned, when we die we leave our inheritance not
because we want to leave it but because we are unable to
take it along. So we are not gifting it to our children because
we do not have the power to retain it and refuse to gift it to
them. The law of inheritance is in fact a divine arrangement
providing for takeover, on behalf of the real Owner-
Inheritor, of the possession of the properties when anerstwhile possessor ceases to exist. Our ownerships are
ownerships inter-se ourselves and not vis--vis the Maker.
Our succession is essentially a trust and our inheritance laws
are a means to carry out this entrustment smoothly.
The Believers are better advised to spend everything
in the way of Allah if the defence requirements so demand.
Political freedom is not an abstract idea to be cherished in
notion. It can be relished only in a defined territory whichmust be guarded to guard the freedom. Like every esteemed
possession freedom can be desired only if deserved. Those
who loose sovereignty loose freedom. Therefore, nothing is
more important than defending ones country for ones free
existence. When ones very existence is under attack, what
for should one spare ones wealth?
The two verses cited about the imposition of the
defence tax (57:10; & 2:195) are remarkably distinguishable
from the other verses relating to other types of spending.Both these verses have used the expression spend in the
way of Allah which is clearly distinguishable from the
expression used elsewhere in the Quran: spendOF what We
have given you. The latter phrase indicates that only a
portion is intended to be spent. The wording of these two
verses fairly connotes that even the last penny may have to
be spent for defence requirements at any point in time. In
27
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
28/93
other words, the government can lawfully impose a defencetax at so high a rate that almost everything might have to be
paid towards this tax only. Interestingly, the Prophet(saw)
raised the wherewithal for wars by asking the Believers to
donate whatever they could. On one occasion Abu Bakr(ra)
donated for war all that he had. Better to put it in other
words: the Prophet(saw) did take from Abu Bakr(ra) all his
wealth for war. The Prophet(saw) could have fixed a high rate
also to do just the same thing. But in that case such ratewould become an inviolable precedent and consequently the
future governments would have to impose that high tax even
when a lower rate would also suffice or a higher rate would
be needed. This would not only disable the future
governments, but would also burden the subjects with a
burden not always unavoidable.
The power to determine the rate of the defence tax is
not a power exercisable during wartime only. In fact itswartime rigours are diluted by Islam by directing that it
should be appropriately utilized during peacetimes only35. A
sustained peacetime defence preparedness can safely and
easily keep away the panicky hike of wartime revenue. The
military prowess is, however, advised for deterrence ofenemies and not for any aggressive purposes. This military
tax is virtually a tax for peace because while peace is
destroyed by aggression, it is ensured by deterrence.
The reward for this spending is equally reassuring.
Allah promises the repayment of anything and everything
thus spent, as it were, for peace. The repayment promised
includes the repayment in this world also, without any
35 Muster against them all the military strength and cavalry that you
can afford, to deter the enemies of Allah and your enemies as alsoothers besides them whom you may not know but whom Allah does
know; ...... (8:60).28
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
29/93
injustice. Normally there is always a little room for injusticealso during economic correction. But in the matter of
defence spending God promises a repayment which shall not
be unjust in any case. In fact the receipt of every Sadaqah is
acknowledged, and its repayment promised, in Quran36. The
repetition of the same promise for the defence spending
signifies its special importance and significance. Its
repayment, it is added, shall not be unjust 37. Nonetheless,
this repayment shall not be a mere repayment; there will bealways something more to it. A just repayment is not up to
the beneficence of the Beneficent Allah. He is just in
punishment only: the minimum reward for any good is
always ten-fold38.
The generosity of Allah knows no bounds when it
comes to rewarding the defence spending of the Believers.
The Beneficent Allah deems this spending as a loan unto
Himself
39
, and uses for it the epithet of better. Loans are
36 And whatever you spend in charity or devotion be sure Allah knowsit all (2:270);Say: Verily my Lord enlarges and restricts the sustenance to such of
His servants as He pleases; and nothing do you spendbut He replaces
it: and He is the Best to Provide (34:39);
Do they not know that it is Allah Who accepts repentance from Hisvotaries and takes (their) charity, and that it is Allah Who is verily the
Relenting, the Merciful? (9:104).37 ...... and anything that you spend in the way of Allah shall be but
repaid to you and you shall not be treated unjustly (8:60).38 Whoever comes with a good deed shall have ten times the like
thereof, but whoever comes with an evil deed shall be requited with nomore than the like thereof and no injustice shall be done to them
(6:160).39 Who will loan to Allah a beautiful loan which Allah willincrease manifold? It is Allah Who decreases and increases (your
wealth) and unto Him shall you return.(2:245);29
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
30/93
graded according to their chances of repayment andrecovery which vary with various borrowers and different
times. A bad loan is the one which is lost. A good loan is
the one which is not bad but has some chances of turning
bad in future. A better loan has an assured recovery and no
chance of going bad. Certainly that is a beautiful loan also.
And indeed a loan to the Lord of the Worlds can only be a
beautiful loan. Now, along with this beauty of assured
repayment the multiplication of the loan is also promised40
.Again this multiplication of the loan is exceptional.
According to the general rule a good deed shall fetch ten
times the like thereof. On the contrary, the Sadaqah itself
shall be multiplied first, and the payer will come with the
multiplied Sadaqah which too shall then fetch a minimum
ten fold reward. In other words, the Sadaqah will be
Who will loan to Allah a beautiful loan? And (Allah) will increase it
manifold; and he will have (besides) a noble reward.(57:11);
Verily for those, men and women, who give in charity and loan to
Allah a beautiful loan, it shall be increased and they shall have(besides) a noble reward(57:18);
If you loan to Allah a beautiful loan, He will multiply it for youand will grant you forgiveness; and Allah is the Appreciative, the
Forbearing; Knower of the unseen and the visible, the Mighty, the
Wise(64:17-18). (See also Quran: 5:12 & 73:20.)40The parable of those who spend their substance in the way of
Allah is that of a grain of corn: it grows seven ears and each earhath a hundred grains. Allah gives manifold increase to whom He
pleases; and Allah cares for all and He knows all things (2:261); And the likeness of those who spend their substance seeking to
please Allah and to strengthen their souls is as a garden high and fertile: heavy rain falls on it but makes it yield a double increase
of harvest and if it receives not heavy rain light moisture suffices it.
Allah sees well whatever you do (2:265).30
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
31/93
rewarded twice. Or we may say, its reward shall becompounded.
This is fair enough. Sadaqah, unlike other things,
has time value. An example can illustrate the point. Suppose
the Day of Judgement is only a month away. Today a
Believer gives a Sadaqah of a thousand rupees. This amount
goes to some recipient who does with it whatever maximum
he could. This maximum utility will be determined, or rather
limited, by the current market prices. There was anotherBeliever who had given a Sadaqah of one thousand rupees,
say, ninety years back. Obviously that same amount of
thousand rupees those days had a lot more value. Therefore,
one month from now the two cannot be similarly rewarded
for this act of charity. One thousand rupees of the older
Believer may be today, say, one hundred thousand rupees:
so he will have that much to his credit and will be rewarded
for the same. Of course, there are other factors also thathave a role to play. For instance, a Believer gives Zakah of
two thousand five hundred rupees on his annual surplus of a
hundred thousand rupees, and another believer gives five
thousand rupees on his surplus of two hundred thousand
rupees; the two are equal because both give only the
fourtieth part of their respective surpluses.
Thus the Islamic financial management envisages
three distinct heads of revenue. Or, in other words, Islam
taxes the Believers thrice for three different purposes. Oneis the tax on produce whose upper limit is 10%. This is
essentially a tax on income to be levied the moment income
is generated. The modern diversification should warrant this
tax on every economic activity including both production
and the service sectors. Second is the 2.5% Zakah on annual
surplus wealth, after defraying all expenses. Third is the
defence tax on wealth which should be levied specifically
31
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
32/93
for defence purposes and its collections should beexclusively used for defence purposes. Defence purposes
would include both defence establishment as well as defence
research.Earlier the defence preparedness was in the hands
of individuals7. This is impossible today: individuals cannot
afford to maintain fighter planes, armoured vehicles and
other weaponry on personal levels. Even though some
affluent people can well afford it, but their own
governments will not permit it for security reasons. We areanyway living in an age of highly organised, complex
defence establishments. The civilians can relate themselves
to it only by bearing the cost of this establishment.
A Believer will be indeed taking part in Jihadwhen
he pays the defence tax; and the more he pays, the more will
7Abu Huraira(ra) related that Allah's Apostle(saw) said, Horses are
kept for one of three purposes: for some people they are a source ofreward, for some others they are a means of shelter and for some
others they are a source of sins. The one for whom they are a
source of reward is he who keeps a horse for Allah's cause ( i.e.,
Jihad), tying it with a long tether on a meadow or in a garden with
the result that whatever it eats from the area of the meadow or the
garden where it is tied will be counted as good deeds for his
benefit; and if it breaks its rope and jumps over one or two
hillocks, all its dung and its foot marks will be written as good
deeds for him; and if it passes by a river and drinks water from it,even though he had no intention of watering it, he will get the
reward for its drinking. As for the man for whom horses are a
source of sins, he is the one who keeps a horse for the sake of pride
and pretence and showing enmity for Muslims: such a horse will be
a source of sins for him. When Allah's Apostle was asked about
donkeys, he replied, Nothing has been revealed to me about them
except this unique, comprehensive verse: So anyone who does aparticle's weight of good shall see it; and anyone who does a particles
weight of evil, shall see it (101:7,8) (Al-Bukhari 4:112).32
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
33/93
be his participation41. Jihad literally means struggle.Struggle for defence is the Jihad actually envisaged by
Islam. It is remarkable that the Quran places wealth on the
first rung ofJihad, and the personal participation only
next42. When Believers bear the defence expenditure, they
are indeed involved in the Jihadof defending their country
in which they practise Islam. (Islam does not deify the
artifice of the political State; it establishes and protects
the State for the sake of its citizens.) This Jihad is anindependent proactive engagement in which Believers can
take part throughout their lives to affirm and maintain
their identity. This is the Jihad for peace, unlike the war-
time Jihad which is reactive and depends upon the
aggressors conduct. Once the aggressor gives in, the Jihad
is over. Here lies the difference. Islam does not desire aMujahid/ Believer for whose Jihad somebody should be an
aggressor. It wants the Believers who would persist in Jihadto keep any aggression at bay.
This is about the civilian Believers whose
participation in Jihad will be financial. With the
establishment of a regular army the personal participation in
Jihadwill be of the military personnel only. These will be,
therefore, the professional Mujahidin officially struggling
for defending the faith of their country-men. (In our modern
history here is where we have failed actually and our faith
appears defenceless!) These Mujahidin are not at par withthe civil servants of the State just because both are paid
from the exchequer. Army duty is different by all means.
41Only those are Believers who believe in Allah and His Apostle,and then never doubt but strive with their wealth and their persons
in the way of Allah: they are the sincere ones (49:15).
42 See 4:95; 8:72; 9:20, 41, 44, 81, 88; 49:15; 61:11.33
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
34/93
This special status is recognised by the Quran which accordsa share to the army from the spoils of any war43.
The rate of the defence tax may change every year,
and even within a year if an eventuality arises. Although the
Believers may choose to pay more for defence purposes, yet
it will not be competent for the government to divert this
collection for non-defence purposes. Briefly put, in modern
parlance, there should be a separa te defence budget
w i t h a s e pa ra t e de f e nc e t a x l e v i a b l e r a t he r on t heweal th than income of the Be l ievers .
The benefits of this system of separate defence tax
will be immense. This will save the hard-up people from the
every day price hike and inflation which owe their origin
mainly to defence expenditure. The prices of the consumer
goods will remain unaffected by hike in the defence tax due
to defence needs. The defence tax will be income related
only in the sense that only the wealth generated fromincome will become liable for tax. In other words, only the
persons having sufficient income will be bearing the cost of
defence. Modern defence tax being messed with other
general taxes has become related to the spending of the
people. As a result even if a person is spending the
borrowed money, he has to pay from it also. To tax a debt as
an income is indeed cruel. We are extracting this tax even
from beggars who are only spending on essentials what they
receive as alms! The rich are subsidised and the beggars aretaxed , this is hardly anything short of crime.
Separation of defence budgets would also have
another important benefit of very far reaching consequences.
As the defence expenditure would be exclusively borne only
by the rich and the affluent who do wield an effective
influence on the government policies and decisions, the
43 See Quran: 8:1, 41.34
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
35/93
governments would be actually dissuaded from embarkingon egoistic military adventures and expeditions in which
only human and material resources are squandered. These
influential tax payers will certainly refuse to pay for
satisfying false egos. This in turn would eliminate many
causes of disruption of peace in the world.
Between Zakah and the defence tax the priority for
collection is to be given to the latter8. If a Muslim has a
surplus wealth of two hundred thousand rupees, and thedefence tax is levied at the rate of 20%, the respective
amounts ofZakah and the defence tax payable by him will
not be five thousand and forty thousand rupees. The reason
is that when one tax is taken out, the wealth will get reduced
by that much amount. The amount of defence tax
recoverable first will be forty thousand rupees and its
recovery will bring down the remaining wealth to one
hundred sixty thousand rupees. Then the amount ofZakahrecoverable on this reduced wealth will be four thousand
rupees only.
This makes out a very significant point of the
economic philosophy of Islam. Zakah is payable only after
the other two taxes are paid. At a particular point of time in
a given Muslim country if the rate of defence tax is 100%,
the wealthy will end up paying the defence tax only. Then
8Abu Huraira(ra) related that Allah's Apostle(saw) ordered (a person)to collect Zakah, and that person returned and told him that Ibn
Jamil(ra), Khalid bin Walid(ra), and Abbas bin Abdul Muttalib(ra) hadrefused to give Zakah. The Prophet(saw) said, What made Ibn
Jamil(ra) refuse to give Zakah though he was a poor man and wasmade wealthy by Allah and His Apostle? But you are unfair in
asking Zakah from Khalid(ra) as he is keeping his armour forAllah's cause (forJihad). As for Abbas bin Abdul Muttalib (ra), he
is the uncle of Allah's Apostle and Zakah is compulsory on him and
he should pay it double (Al-Bukhari 2:547).35
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
36/93
they will have practically no Zakah to pay, and would beonly theoretically liable. Yet liability to payZakah, and not
the defence tax, is one of five fundamentals of Islam!
However, practically the amount ofZakah will be only
reduced on account of the defence tax. By raising the status
of the last recoverable tax (Zakah) to the level of a
fundamental Islam has only clarified to its followers that
even the last of the taxes must be paid if one wants to stay
a Believer. Impliedly there is absolutely no room for taxevasion in Islam.
The expenses of the defence and the social security
will come respectively from the defence tax, and the Zakah
and other charities. The two will be used and utilized for
their respective purposes only. The only tax that remains for
the civil expenses of the State must, therefore, come from
the duties to be levied on commerce and trade. On seeing
the miseries around us the only thing that we rush to do veryconveniently is to blame Providence. If a person is robbed
of his wages by a pick-pocket, the resultant starvation of his
family is the subject matter of criminal justice system. If the
thief is not brought to justice, the failure cannot be
attributed to Providence. According to one estimate, each
year photosynthesizing organisms produce about 170 billion
metric tons of extra carbohydrates, about 30 metric tons for
every person on earth. Such a huge provision is available to
mankind despite immense deforestation and the hugepopulation explosion! Even then if millions of us starve or
are deprived, it is only because of our own misdeeds and
mismanagement.
Quran does not accept a trustee as revenue in-charge
because a trust is only an obligation. A trustee can keep
trust of what is entrusted to him. If nothing is entrusted to
him, he has hardly anything to do. As per Quran the in-
36
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
37/93
charge revenue should be a GUARDING and KNOWING person,the two qualifications put forth by the prophet Joseph(as)
before the Egyptian king while seeking this post44. The
guarding will guard and the knowing will know what to
guard. Resultantly, nothing recoverable will escape recovery
and nothing payable will be withheld. The performance of
Joseph(as) on the post was exemplary. After seven years of
normal agricultural production he had seven consecutive
droughts45
, but no one starved. Even the other peoplepurchased food from this State. On the other hand, we have
the millions of people starving before our eyes in spite of
bumper crops because we have food for stores and not for
the starving. However, with these traits of Joseph (as) Quran
records only one austerity measure that was taken by the
king: he had imposed a complete ban on immigration46. Was
it, or was it not, a population control measure is anybodys
guess! In an Islamic State the defence tax and Zakah are not
collected from the Non-Muslim citizens. As we shall see
later, since Zakah cannot be given to Non-Muslims, it
cannot be collected from them either. In lieu of the defence
tax a separate tax is levied on the Non-Muslim subjects of
an Islamic State which is called Jizyah and is authorized by
Quran47. It may be reminded that taxes are not a punishment
in Islam. Jizyah is an annual head tax levied on free, adult
male citizen. Jizyah is not levied on children and women;and the poor persons who cannot afford to pay are exempt.
44 See Quran: 12:55.45 See Quran: 12:43, 47, 48.46 See Quran: 12:76.47 ..... until they pay the Jizyah by hand in a state of submission
(9:29).37
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
38/93
Different rates ofJizyah can be fixed for the Non-Muslimsof lower, middle and the upper classes. Non-Muslims who
pay, and those exempt from paying, Jizyah are all full
citizens of an Islamic country having equal rights of
education, employment and commerce. Their lives,
property, honour and all other rights are inviolable similarly
as those of the Muslims. They can hold high posts in
government, barring such of them as pertain to the religious
affairs of the Muslims. They will be governed by their own personal laws in such matters as marriage, divorce,
inheritance, and disputes among themselves. They are free
to consume pork and alcohol, provided they do not make
these accessible/ available to the Muslim population.
The words used in the Quran are eloquent: until
they pay Jizyah by hand in a state of submission. Contrary
to forcible collection, paying by hand implies a certain level
of volition on the part of the payer. Nevertheless, thisvolition wont be the same as free consent in a civil
transaction; it will be a political compromise to surrender
and live as peaceful citizen of an Islamic State. So the
Jizyah will be paid only by those Non-Muslims who accept
the sovereignty of the Islamic State and agree to live there.
And that is the beauty of this Quranic injunction which has
all along prevented the Muslims from becoming colonial
aggressors. According to this verse no Jizyah will be
collected from those Non-Muslims who refuse to live in theIslamic State, and fight back instead. On its part the Islamic
State will either let them go, or it will fight to subdue them.
If the Islamic State chooses to fight them, it will fight at its
own cost unlike imperial aggressors who tax the oppressed
to fight them only.
The Muslims have to fight in the way of Allah with
their wealth and lives. Normally they pay the defence tax
38
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
39/93
for the purpose, but in case of need they may be asked togive lives. But as the defence tax is not levied on the Non-
Muslims wealth and instead Jizyah is levied as the cost of
security, the Non-Muslims lives are also exempt from
military services. This is the regard extended by Islam to the
un-Islamic beliefs of the Non-Muslims. They do not believe
in Allah and His last Prophet(saw), so they are not asked to
fight in His way. Secondly, by this exemption from military
service, Islam prevents the Non-Muslims from fighting theirfellow Non-Muslims. It does not want a Christian to fight
another Christian just because he is living in an Islamic
State. Others may take pride in giving a Muslim to fight
another Muslim, Islam spurns this dirty game.*****
INVESTMENT
For Charity Quran has used the words give (or pay)
Zakah. For other charitable spending, payment of taxes,
and use of the remaining wealth it has used a common word
spend. However, this common word carries three different
connotations with three appellations which occur with it in
different verses. It alludes to the routine household and
charitable spending with the appellations prosperity and
adversity or openly and secretly. It refers to the defence
related spending with the appellation in the way of Allah.
The third phrase used is spend of what We/ God have/ hasgiven you which refers to the use of the wealth that
remains after defraying all the taxes, Charity and charitable
spending. Or we may say that this last mentioned Quranic
phrase refers to the investment of the capital, in modern
parlance. Investment, which signifies productive
commercial spending, is desirable because it results in
production of goods and services, besides generating wealth
39
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
40/93
for the investor, revenue for the State and employment forthe people.
In fact the Quranic verses relating to the commercial
spending are not restricted to investment of wealth only.
Quran calls upon a Believer to spend (invest) of what(ever)
Allah has given to him. Therefore, he must always keep on
investing all that he has his wealth, knowledge, expertise,
skill or mere time. The investment of all these possessions is
effective and useful. Mere capital of an investor does notfructify unless and until it is espoused with the human
resources. There is strong Quranic emphasis on investing
ones resources. One, Quran describes investment as an
important corollary of faith, second only to the daily Prayer
(Salaah), and asserts that only those Believers are true
Believers who do not fail or neglect to invest what Allah has
given them48. Two, it declares investment a condition
precedent for piety whose attainment is the cherished goalof every Believer49. Three, the double reward of the Judo-
Christian Believers is stated to be due to their investing,
besides being patient and repelling evil with good50. Four,
the great reward from Allah is promised only to those
Believers who do invest also51. Five, failure to invest is
48 (Believers are those) Who establish regular prayers and spend
of what We have given them; such in truth are the believers: for
them are the grades (of dignity) with their Lord and forgivenessand an honourable sustenance (in the Paradise) (8:3, 4).49 (the pious will be those) Who believe in the unseen, and
establish regular prayer and spend of what We have given them(2:3).50
(The Jews/Christians who followed Islam) their reward is twofold:
for they have been patient, and repel evil with good, and spend of what
We have given them (28:54).51
(O men!) Believe in Allah and His Apostle, and spend of what He
has made you heirs; for those of you who believe and spend, for them is40
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
41/93
described as nothing short of disbelief or rejection of faith52.Six, failure to invest during life is declared to be an
incurable omission53.
Earlier economies were mainly agricultural, and
agriculture too was primitive. Manufacturing activities were
quite limited. But amazingly the timeless Book of Allah has
all along been advising its followers to make big
investments, collectively! It called upon the Believers to
make what we call institutional investments, in modernlanguage. There is a general commandment unto the
Believers that in all matters they should take decisions by
consultation. An absolute injunction to this effect is
contained in the third chapter named Al-iImran54 (or The
Family of Imran, the grand-father of Jesus Christ(as)). The
merits of consultation are obvious. Consultations create pool
of intellects and dispel the futility of arrogance, to name
only two. Significantly, however, the best part of thisQuranic commandment is that it orders consultation with the
not so good people. The Believers referred to in this verse
a great reward (57:7).52 O you who believe! Spend of what We have given you before the
day comes when no bargaining or friendship or intercession will
avail; and the rejecters of faith, they are the wrong-doers (2:254);53 And (O Believers!) Spend of what we have given you before
death comes to any of you and he shall say, O my Lord! If onlyyou would have reprieved me for a little while, I would have given
charity and been among the righteous; But never does Allahreprieve any soul when its term ends (63:10, 11).54
It is but with the Allahs Mercy that you (O Prophet) are gentle with
them (thy followers); and if you would be severe or harsh-hearted, theywould have broken away from about you; so pardon them and seek
(Allah's) forgiveness for them; and consult them in (various) affairs:and when you have resolved(a course of action)put thy trust in Allah
verily, Allah loves those who put their trust(in Him) (3:159).41
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
42/93
are those who deserted the Prophet(saw) in the harmful battleof Uhud. And the Prophet is advised to overlook their
omissions, pray for them and take their counsel in different
matters. This is the best form of recognition imaginable that
Islam accords to the human intellect. Obviously, while the
Believers are instructed to take counsel of even the poor
performers, the performers have to be consulted any way.
{Can it be more than funny to say that Islam does not
approve of consulting the women?}The forty second chapter of Quran goes by the very
name of Consultation, or Shura. This chapter contains
only one verse on consultation and interestingly in that
verse the Believers are characterized as the people who
consult one another before going for commercial
spending, or investment55. In this way this verse actually
recognizes collective big investment only as true investment
and alludes to the institutionalization of investment sincefinancial institutions only can do justice to the
consultation for investment. Institutionalization would
also mean big investments which are not individually
desirable or advisable. It can be also taken as encouraging
cooperation between investors.
When Believers invest in an enterprise or an
investment institution both would be manned and managed
by others. These managers may not necessarily have a stake
in the enterprise or the institution; yet they will be stillinvestors of their time, labour, skill and expertise. Against
these personal investments they shall take what they
reasonably deserve and the institution can afford. Their
professional skills will not mutate into arrogance for
55And (the Believers are ) those who hearken to their Lord, andestablish regular prayer, and conduct their affairs by mutual
consultation, and spend of what We have given them (42:38).42
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
43/93
extraction of undue perquisites from the institution, norshall they be unduly generous with the others money. Their
humility will not be quotes and paintings on their office
walls, or an inscription on their products. To them life
would not be a competition to cut others throats for self-
aggrandisement; it would be a time-bound opportunity to
cooperate with fellow being for better service of humanity.
They will not come to believe in destiny after they have
failed in their sprees. They remember the Scribe of destinyon the rungs of success56.
Some Muslims maintain that they can throw away
their immeasurable wealth, as it were, here and there.
They seek this license ignorantly from the Quranic phrase
that Allah gives to whom He pleases without measure57.
They believe that by giving them without measure God has
actually honoured them with the freedom to do with their
wealth whatever they like. And they like to believe that asGod is not keeping a measure for their wealth, they should
not measure it either. This is grossly erroneous. The
expression without measure is used in relation to us and
not to God. We lose account of our wealth and riches as
soon as we start getting rich. We have a record of every
penny as long as we have no pound. But as for Allah the
All-Knowing, He has the record of every penny of even the
richest persons on earth; and every single penny has to be
accounted for58.
56Only they believe in Our verses who, when those are recited to
them, fall down in prostration and extol the praise of their Lord,and they are not arrogant; who forsake their beds to invoke their
Lord with fear and hope, and spend of what We have given them(32:15,16).57
See Quran: 2:212; 3:26, 37 & 24:38.43
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
44/93
The Believers and the non-Believers alike have beenalready spending their wealth, or investing their capital:
what is new then? Islam censures the spending of the
Unbelievers as akin to a nipping frost59. As a nipping frost
retards the growth of vegetation, so does the Unbelievers
spending inhibit the growth of economy. Although the
nipping effect would depend upon the cold of the frost and
the time at which it strikes a crop, yet in any case the effect
is always substantially damaging and the resultant loss isnever negligible. Interestingly, while a frost is nipping for
the others crops, it is no good to itself either. Since we are
not making investments the Islamic way, these are bound to
produce a frost. And we do witness the nipping effect of this
economic frost as it lands us into the (economic) depression/
recession caused by our own investment. The incidence of
economic recession demonstrates that something is wrong
with our investment for which it leads to the recession instead of development.
Since this verse highlights rather the fallacy of the
Unbelievers spending than the Unbelievers themselves, it
equally applies to the Believers spending if the latters is
also on the lines of the Unbelievers. As the modern
economic policies of the Non-Muslim world are what the
Muslims are also following willingly, their spending is
pretty like that of the Unbelievers. And if there are any
exceptions here and there, those are accidental rather than
58So anyone who does a particle's weight of good shall see it; andanyone who does a particles weight of evil, shall see it (99:7-8).59What they (the Unbelievers) spend in the life of this world maybe likened to a wind which brings a nipping frost: it reaches and
smites the harvest of a people who had wronged themselves; it is
not Allah Who hath wronged them but they wrong
themselves(3:117).44
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
45/93
conscious ones. However, this verse does not simply containa comment on the Unbelievers spending; it carries a bold
mention of the other aspects of the problem as well. While it
indicts improper spending as nipping frost, it deprecates the
affected people also for their contributory wrong.
Remarkably, they are not portrayed as victims. In all
fairness Almighty Allah not only blames these sufferers as
wrongdoers, but also raises His hands to declare that He has
not wronged them60
. And this carries the true message ofIslam: economic iniquities need to be remedied, and not to
be acquiesced.
The frosting effect of the un-Islamic spending
explains why the gap between the rich and the poor
continues to widen in the face of all those so-called
economic reforms put in place day in and day out. Even the
U-turns that were taken by some countries from capitalistic
to communistic economies and later again from socialism/communism back to capitalism failed to change the lot.
Every time the rhetoric ended with the change of hands. The
simple reason is the un-Islamic spending whose harmful
effect is ignored by the spenders (investors) under a peculiar
perception. They believe they are not born to change the
destiny which has denied prosperity to the poor. This
thinking is dismissed in Quran as a manifest error61. The
error of this thinking is obvious. Instead of doing his duty, a
servant is questioning the right of his master. If a masterspills a cup of milk on the floor and then asks his servant to
cleanse the floor, the servant cannot refuse and say that if
60Ibid.61 And when they are told spend you of what Allah has given
you, the Unbelievers say to those who believe: Shall we feed
those whom if Allah had so willed He would have fed (Himself)?
Verily, you are in nothing but manifest error (36:47).45
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
46/93
the master had not so willed the milk would not have beenspilt at all. We are neither to take Gods account, nor to
account for the acts of God. We need to do our stuff. {The
fund raising charity shows are no exception. Actually such
events are also a result of this erroneous thinking only.
Those who participate in these events pay for no other
reason than the entertainment provided in the events. That is
literally sadistic: giving not for the suffering but for the
pleasure!}The philosophy of Islamic spending/ investment has
been arranged in the form of a small story of the prophet
David(as) in just four verses of the Quran62. With reference to
their peculiar context, these verses are correctly understood
to restore the image of the prophet David(as) which is
tarnished in the Bible by accusing him of grave offences of
rape and murder. Briefly, according to the Quran David had
just thought of marrying the wife of a general in his army,most probably for her intelligence. But he soon turned in
repentance to Allah as this mere thought implied that Allah
62 Has the story of the disputants reached you? Behold they
climbed over the wall of the chamber. When they (so ) entered the
presence of David he was frightened of them, (but) they said: Fear
not, we are two disputants one of whom has wronged the other; sodecide between us with truth and treat us not with injustice, and
guide us to the path of rectitude. Verily, this is my brother, he hasnine and ninety ewes and I have (only) one; so he said: Commit
her to my care, and subjugated me in speech. (David ) said:Surely he has wronged you in asking for thy (single ) ewe to be
added to his (flock of) ewes, and indeed most of the fellow beingswrong one another except those who believe and do righteous
deeds, but only few are they. And (meanwhile) David realised thatWe have tried him; so he asked forgiveness of his Lord, bowed and
fell down prostate and turned to Him (in repentance) (38:21-24).
See Bible: II Samuel chapter 12.46
-
8/3/2019 Booklet by Farooq Rather
47/93