boosting refugee outcomes: evidence from policy, academia

54
IPL Working Paper Series Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia, and Social Innovation Salma Mousa Working Paper No. 18-01 October 2018 IPL working papers are circulated for discussion and comment purposes. They have not been formally peer reviewed. © 2018 by Salma Mousa. All rights reserved.

Upload: others

Post on 21-Oct-2021

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

IPL Working Paper Series

Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia, and Social Innovation

Salma Mousa

Working Paper No. 18-01

October 2018

IPL working papers are circulated for discussion and comment purposes. They have not been formally peer reviewed.

© 2018 by Salma Mousa. All rights reserved.

Page 2: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

#PPTUJOH 3FGVHFF 0VUDPNFT�&WJEFODF GSPN 1PMJDZ "DBEFNJB BOE 4PDJBM *OOPWBUJPO

4BMNB .PVTB�

0DUPCFS � ����

"CTUSBDU

)PXFWFS NFBTVSFE SFGVHFFT BSF MJLFMZ UP GBDF DPNNPO CBSSJFST UPXBSET BDIJFWJOH JOUFHSBUJPO JO UIF 8FTU JO�DMVEJOH MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ EJçDVMUZ mOEJOH B KPC DPNNFOTVSBUF XJUI UIFJS FEVDBUJPO BOE TLJMMT BOE NFOUBMIFBMUI TUSFTTPST� 5IJT SFWJFX ESBXT PO QPMJDZ SFQPSUT BOE BDBEFNJD TUVEJFT EFTDSJQUJWF BOE FYQFSJNFOUBM UPmSTU BOTXFS UXP RVFTUJPOT� � XIBU EP XF LOPX BCPVU SFGVHFF PVUDPNFT BOE� � XIBU GBDUPST BSF BTTPDJBUFEXJUI UIFTF PVUDPNFT * TZOUIFTJ[F JOGPSNBUJPO PO UIF JOEJWJEVBM BOE FOWJSPONFOUBM USBJUT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI UIFTPDJP�FDPOPNJD XFMM�CFJOH PG SFGVHFFT o SBOHJOH GSPN DPVOUSZ PG PSJHJO BOE HFOEFS UP FUIOJD FODMBWFT BOESJHJE MBCPS NBSLFUT� * UIFO TVSWFZ QJMPUT BOE QSPHSBNT BJNFE BU JOUFHSBUJOH SFGVHFFT HMPCBMMZ XJUI B GPDVTPO UIF 6�4� $BOBEB BOE &VSPQF� 5IF FWJEFODF CBTF TVHHFTUT UIBU QSPHSBNT MFWFSBHJOH DPNNVOJUZ TVQQPSUXIJMF TVQQMFNFOUJOH JODPNF o TVDI BT BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ BOE DBTI USBOTGFST EPWFUBJMFEXJUI mOBODJBM NFOUPSTIJQ o SFQSFTFOU QSPNJTJOH QBUIT GPSXBSE�

�%FQBSUNFOU PG 1PMJUJDBM 4DJFODF 4UBOGPSE 6OJWFSTJUZ� TNPVTB!TUBOGPSE�FEV� * UIBOL (SBOU (PSEPO +FOT )BJONVFMMFS %VODBO-BXSFODF +FSFNZ 8FJOTUFJO GPS UIFJS JOWBMVBCMF GFFECBDL BOE HVJEBODF�

Page 3: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

$POUFOUT� *OUSPEVDUJPO �

� 8IBU %P 8F ,OPX "CPVU 3FGVHFF 0VUDPNFT ���� &DPOPNJD PVUDPNFT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� &EVDBUJPO PVUDPNFT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� 8IBU &YQMBJOT 5IFTF 0VUDPNFT ���� (FPHSBQIJD "TTJHONFOU � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� %FMBZFE QSPDFTTJOH UJNFT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� )FBMUI � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� 'JOBODJBM -JUFSBDZ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� &UIOJD &ODMBWFT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� 4PDJBM 5JFT XJUI -PDBM $PNNVOJUZ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� %JTDSJNJOBUJPO BOE -BCPS .BSLFUT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

� 8IJDI "QQSPBDIFT 4FFN 1SPNJTJOH ����� 0VUTPVSDJOH 4FSWJDFT UP 7PMVOUFFST � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� .FOUPSTIJQ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� 1SJWBUF 4QPOTPSTIJQ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� %JSFDU $BTI 5SBOTGFST � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� &4- &EVDBUJPO � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

� 4VSWFZ PG 1JMPUT 1SPHSBNT BOE 3$5T ����� 1SF�EFQBSUVSF 1SFQBSBUJPO � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� 1SPDFTTJOH "SSJWBM BOE $PNNVOJUZ &OHBHFNFOU � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� 5SBJOJOH 3F�DSFEFOUJBMJOH BOE &NQMPZNFOU � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� 'JOBODJBM -JUFSBDZ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� .JDSP�mOBODF BOE &OUSFQSFOFVSTIJQ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� &�6� #FTU 1SBDUJDFT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� $BOBEJBO #FTU 1SBDUJDFT � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

� 1BUIT 'PSXBSE BOE $PODMVTJPOT ��

� "QQFOEJY ����� 8IBU NPUJWBUFT WPMVOUFFST � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� 3F�DSFEFOUJBMJOH 1SPHSBNT JO UIF 6�4� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQ "MUFSOBUJWF� 4VQQPSUFE &NQMPZNFOU � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� "QQT GPS "EVMU &OHMJTI -FBSOFST � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

Page 4: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

� *OUSPEVDUJPO

0GUFO nFFJOH WJPMFODF BOE TQFOEJOH ZFBST JO VOEFS�SFTPVSDFE BOE PWFS�DSPXEFE SFGVHFF DBNQT UIF �� NJMMJPOBTZMVN TFFLFST UPEBZ BSF BNPOH UIF XPSME�T NPTU WVMOFSBCMF DPNNVOJUJFT� 6OMJLF PUIFS NJHSBOUT SFGVHFFT EP OPUMFBWF UIFJS IPNFT WPMVOUBSJMZ� 5IF NJHSBUJPO FYQFSJFODF PG SFGVHFFT GSFRVFOUMZ UBLFT B UPMM PO NFOUBM BOE QIZTJDBMIFBMUI FWFO CFGPSF BSSJWJOH JO UIF SFDFJWJOH DPVOUSZ $POOPS ����� 8JUI GFX TPDJBM UJFT BOE SFTPVSDFT UIFZ NVTUUIFO BEBQU UP B GPSFJHO MBOHVBHF MBCPS NBSLFU BOE DVMUVSF o PGUFO SFNBJOJOH VOFNQMPZFE VOEFS�FNQMPZFE PSPUIFSXJTF MPX�JODPNF GPS ZFBST BGUFS BSSJWBM #BOTBL FU BM� ����� %FTQJUF UIF NBHOJUVEF PG UIFTF CBSSJFST UIFTDBMF PG UIF DIBMMFOHF UIF XPSME JT DVSSFOUMZ FYQFSJFODJOH UIF IJHIFTU MFWFMT PG EJTQMBDFNFOU PO SFDPSE BOE UIFQPMJUJDJ[BUJPO PG SFGVHFF BENJUUBODF QPMJDZ JO UIF 6�4� BOE &VSPQF XF LOPX MJUUMF BCPVU IPX SFGVHFFT GBSF PODFSFTFUUMFE� " DBTI�TUSBQQFE 6�4� 3FGVHFF 3FTFUUMFNFOU 1SPHSBN GVSUIFS DPNQFMT B TZTUFNBUJD BOBMZTJT PG SFGVHFFPVUDPNFT BOE CFTU QSBDUJDFT XPSMEXJEF JO PSEFS UP NBYJNJ[F SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODZ EPMMBST�� 5IJT EPDVNFOU BJNTUP DPNQJMF BOE BOBMZ[F UIF FWJEFODF CBTF PO SFGVHFF PVUDPNFT o BOE UIF GBDUPST UIBU TIBQF UIFN o HMPCBMMZ�

)PXFWFS NFBTVSFE SFGVHFFT BSF MJLFMZ UP GBDF DPNNPO CBSSJFST UPXBSET BDIJFWJOH JOUFHSBUJPO JO UIF 8FTU JO�DMVEJOH� B MBDL PG MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ EJçDVMUZ mOEJOH B KPC DPNNFOTVSBUF XJUI UIFJS FEVDBUJPO BOE TLJMMT IBWJOH GPSFJHO DSFEFOUJBMT SFDPHOJ[FE BOE XFBL TPDJBM UJFT� 5IJT SFWJFX ESBXT PO QPMJDZ SFQPSUT TUBUF�DPMMFDUFETVSWFZ EBUB BOE BDBEFNJD TUVEJFT UP mSTU BOTXFS UXP RVFTUJPOT� � XIBU EP XF LOPX BCPVU SFGVHFF SFTFUUMFNFOUPVUDPNFT BOE� � XIBU GBDUPST BSF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI UIFTF PVUDPNFT * UIFO IJHIMJHIU FNFSHJOH CFTU QSBDUJDFT QSPHSBNT BOE QSPNJTJOH QJMPUT BJNFE BU SFTFUUMJOH BOE JOUFHSBUJOH SFGVHFFT XPSMEXJEF XJUI B GPDVT PO MFWFSBHJOHDPNNVOJUZ FOHBHFNFOU� 5IJT JT B DIBMMFOHJOH FOEFBWPS HJWFO UIF MBDL PG iHSPVOE USVUIw EBUB PO SFGVHFFT� 'PSJOTUBODF XIJMF B VTFGVM BOE DSFBUJWF mSTU TUFQ BNPOH NJHSBUJPO TDIPMBST NPTU TUVEJFT PO SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6�4� SFMZPO JNQVUJOH SFGVHFF TUBUVT GSPN TVSWFZT UIBU IBWF ZFU UP CF FYUFSOBMMZ WBMJEBUFE XJUI B LOPXO SFGVHFF QPQVMBUJPO��5IF USFOET * IJHIMJHIU IFSF FTQFDJBMMZ UIPTF GSPN UIF 6�4� TIPVME CF UIFSFGPSF UBLFO BT TVHHFTUJWF� * QSJNBSJMZDPOTJEFS UIF SFGVHFF�TQFDJmD MJUFSBUVSF CVU OPUF XIFSF QSPHSBNT PS TUVEJFT JOTUFBE GPDVT PO PUIFS HSPVQT TVDI BTJNNJHSBOUT UIBU NBZ OFWFSUIFMFTT CF JOGPSNBUJWF�

� 8IBU %P 8F ,OPX "CPVU 3FGVHFF 0VUDPNFT

��� &DPOPNJD PVUDPNFT

(PWFSONFOUT UZQJDBMMZ WJFX GVMM�UJNF FNQMPZNFOU BT OFDFTTBSZ GPS TFMG�TVçDJFODZ CVU BQQSPBDIFT UP FODPVSBHJOHFNQMPZNFOU WBSZ BDSPTT BOE TPNFUJNFT XJUIJO DPVOUSJFT� *O UIF 6�4� UIF #VSFBV GPS 1PQVMBUJPO 3FGVHFFT BOE.JHSBUJPO 13. DPOUSBDUT OJOF 7PMVOUBSZ "HFODJFT 7PM"HT UP SFTFUUMF SFGVHFFT WFUUFE CZ UIF 6OJUFE /BUJPOT

�"U UIF DVSSFOU QBDF UIF 6�4� XJMM GBMM GBS TIPSU PG NFFUJOH JU�T QSFTJEFOUJBMMZ�TFU UBSHFU PG BENJUUJOH �� ��� SFGVHFFT o JUTFMG B UBSHFUXFMM CFMPX UIF 1SFTJEFOUJBM %FUFSNJOBUJPO PG ��� ��� JO ����� "U �� ��� FTUJNBUFE SFGVHFFT UIJT OVNCFS XJMM CF UIF MPXFTU TJODF UIF'FEFSBM 3FGVHFF 3FTFUUMFNFOU 1SPHSBN XBT DSFBUFE JO ����� 5IF 4UBUF %FQBSUNFOU TJNJMBSMZ TMBTIFE GVOEJOH UP SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODJFT BOEFODPVSBHFE UIFN UP EPXOTJ[F JO %FDFNCFS ���� 5PSCBUJ BOE 3PTFOCFSH �����

�4UVEJFT MJLF &WBOT BOE 'JU[HFSBME ���� BOE 'JY )PPQFS BOE ;POH ���� JNQVUF SFGVHFF TUBUVT VTJOH DPVOUSZ�ZFBS DPNCJOBUJPOT JOUIF "NFSJDBO $PNNVOJUZ 4VSWFZ� 3FGVHFF TUBUVT JT BTTJHOFE UP FBDI DPVOUSZ�ZFBS DPNCJOBUJPO GPS XIJDI iSFGVHFF BENJTTJPOT JO UIF %)4BOE 83"14 EBUB FYDFFE �� � PG UIF FTUJNBUFE GPSFJHO�CPSO QPQVMBUJPO JEFOUJmFE JO UIF "$4 EBUBw $BQQT FU BM� ����B� 8JUIPVU CFJOHFYUFSOBMMZ WBMJEBUFE BHBJOTU B SFQSFTFOUBUJWF EBUBTFU XIFSF SFGVHFF TUBUVT JT LOPXO IPXFWFS FWJEFODF UIBU SFMJFT PO JNQVUBUJPO NFUIPETTIPVME CF UBLFO BT TVHHFTUJWF CVU OPU EFmOJUJWF� 'PS JOTUBODF 'JY )PPQFS BOE ;POH ���� BQQMZ UIJT NFUIPE VTJOH EBUB GSPN GPVS 6�4�TUBUFT BOE DPODMVEF UIBU JOJUJBM MPDBUJPO POMZ XFBLMZ TIBQFT PVUDPNFT� :FU JOJUJBM TUBUF BOE NVOJDJQBM BTTJHONFOUT BU UIF UJNF PG BSSJWBM BTXFMM BT JOGPSNBUJPO PO TFDPOEBSZ NJHSBUJPO BSF VOLOPXO� 5IF EFTDSJQUJWF mOEJOHT JO UIFTF TUVEJFT BSF JNQPSUBOU mSTU TUFQT JO VODPWFSJOHSFGVHFF PVUDPNFT CVU NPSF XPSL JT OFFEFE BHBJOTU WFSJmFE iHSPVOE USVUIw EBUB UP VOEFSTUBOE UIF EJSFDUJPO PG JNQVUBUJPOBM CJBT VTJOH UIJTUFDIOJRVF�

Page 5: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

BOE 6�4� $JUJ[FOTIJQ BOE *NNJHSBUJPO 4FSWJDFT 64$*4�� 5ISPVHI TPNF ��� 7PM"H PçDFT BDSPTT UIF DPVOUSZ UIFTF BHFODJFT HSFFU BSSJWBMT BU UIF BJSQPSU mOE BOE GVSOJTI TVJUBCMF BDDPNNPEBUJPO BOE QSPWJEF DBTFXPSL TVQ�QPSU GPS B NFEJBO PG �� EBZT�� 0OF PG UIF GFX QJFDFT PG JOGPSNBUJPO UIBU 13. USBDLT QPTU�BSSJWBM JT FNQMPZNFOUSBUFT BU UIF �� BOE ��� EBZ NBSLT� 7PM"H GVOEJOH JT BMTP UJFE UP UIJT NFUSJD o MFBEJOH UP BO JODFOUJWF TUSVDUVSF UIBUQSJPSJUJ[FT GBTU FNQMPZNFOU� 5IF iXPSLomSTUw QBSBEJHN BTTVNFT UIBU PODF NBSHJOBMJ[FE HSPVQT KPJO UIF MBCPSGPSDF DVMUVSBM QTZDIPMPHJDBM BOE MJOHVJTUJD JOUFHSBUJPO XJMM GPMMPX� 5IJT BQQSPBDI JNQMJDJUMZ WBMVFT UIF TQFFESBUIFS UIBO UIF RVBMJUZ PG FNQMPZNFOU� 5IF DPVOUFSGBDUVBM PG XIFUIFS SFGVHFFT XPVME TFDVSF IJHIFS�RVBMJUZ KPCTXFSF UIFZ UP EFMBZ FNQMPZNFOU BOE QFSIBQT JOWFTU JO VQ�TLJMMJOH SFNBJOT VODMFBS� 8IJMF UIF 6�4� QSPHSBN JTEFTJHOFE BSPVOE GBTU FNQMPZNFOU UIF iTLJMMTomSTUw $BOBEJBO BOE &VSPQFBO NPEFMT JOTUFBE TUSFTT VQGSPOU JOWFTU�NFOU JO MBOHVBHF TLJMMT BOE KPC USBJOJOH� 8F IBWF MJUUMF DBVTBM FWJEFODF PO XIJDI BQQSPBDI JT NPSF TVDDFTTGVM GPSTPDJBMMZ FDPOPNJDBMMZ BOE MJOHVJTUJDBMMZ JOUFHSBUJOH SFGVHFFT� 8F DBO IPXFWFS DPNQBSF FNQMPZNFOU SBUFT BOEBWFSBHF FBSOJOHT GPS TPNF 8FTUFSO SFDFJWJOH DPVOUSJFT�

3FGVHFFT UFOE UP mOE XPSL GBTUFTU JO UIF 6�4� GPMMPXFE CZ $BOBEB DPOUJOFOUBM &VSPQF BOE 4DBOEJOBWJB 1SFTTÏBOE 5IPNTPO ����� )BMG PG 6�4� SFGVHFFT mOE XPSL XJUIJO FJHIU NPOUIT XJUI SFGVHFF NFO TVSQBTTJOH FN�QMPZNFOU SBUFT GPS 6�4��CPSO NFO ��� WT� ��� QFSDFOU BOE SFGVHFF XPNFO FRVBMMZ BT MJLFMZ UP XPSL BT 6�4��CPSO XPNFO ���� "HBJO UIFTF mHVSFT NBZ CF VQXBSEMZ CJBTFE EVF UP OPO�SFQSFTFOUBUJWF EBUB� /FWFSUIFMFTT #VSNFTF *SBRJ BOE 4PNBMJ NFO TFFN UP IBWF MPXFS�UIBO�OBUJWF FNQMPZNFOU QSPCBCJMJUJFT CVU UIFZ BSF BMTP UIFNPTU SFDFOUMZ TFUUMFE $BQQT FU BM� ����C� 8F PCTFSWF UIF TBNF HFOEFS HBQ PWFSBMM IJHI SFGVHFF FNQMPZNFOU SBUF��� FNQMPZFE BGUFS mWF ZFBST BOE XFBLFS QFSGPSNBODF PG .JEEMF &BTUFSO SFGVHFFT JO $BOBEB 4BMBOU BOE #FO�UPO ����� $PVOUSZ PG PSJHJO JT UIVT TUSPOH EFUFSNJOBOU PG PDDVQBUJPO TUBUVT GPS SFGVHFFT BT JU JT GPS JNNJHSBOUT7JHEPS ����� 4IJGUJOH UP &VSPQF POMZ B RVBSUFS PG SFGVHFFT JO 4XFEFO mOE XPSL BGUFS UXP ZFBST BOE NPTU JOTVCTJEJ[FE KPCT %FTJEFSJP ����� 8F UIVT EP OPU IBWF TVçDJFOU JOGPSNBUJPO UP EFUFSNJOF FWFO EFTDSJQUJWFMZ XIFUIFS SFGVHFFT BSF CFUUFS Pæ VOEFS UIF XPSLomSTU NPEFM JO UIF 6�4� XJUI JUT nFYJCMF MBCPS NBSLFU SFMBUJWF UPTLJMMTomSTU BQQSPBDI JO B SJHJE &VSPQFBO MBCPS NBSLFU�

)PX MPOH EPFT JU UBLF SFGVHFFT UP DPOWFSHF PO FNQMPZNFOU SBUFT XJUI PUIFS JNNJHSBOU HSPVQT 3FGVHFFT UBLFmWF ZFBST UP SFBDI QBSJUZ XJUI GBNJMZ SFVOJmDBUJPO NJHSBOUT JO $BOBEB TJY ZFBST JO UIF &�6� ��� FNQMPZNFOU IJHIFS UIBO GBNJMZ SFVOJmDBUJPO NJHSBOUT JO 'SBODF *UBMZ 4XJU[FSMBOE BOE #FMHJVN �� ZFBST ��� FNQMPZNFOUJO 4XFEFO BOE �� o�� ZFBST JO /PSXBZ �� � FNQMPZNFOU $BQQT FU BM� ����C� %FTJEFSJP ����� $POWFSHFODFJT TMPXFS XIFO DPNQBSJOH SFGVHFFT XJUI FDPOPNJD NJHSBOUT BOE OBUJWFT� SFGVHFFT UBLF �� ZFBST UP SFBDI ���FNQMPZNFOU BOE DPOWFSHF XJUI FDPOPNJD NJHSBOUT JO &VSPQF %FTJEFSJP ����� 4FDPOE�HFOFSBUJPO "VTUSBMJBOSFGVHFFT TFFN FYDFQUJPOBM PWFSTIPPUJOH UIF "VTUSBMJBO BWFSBHF BOE UIFJS QBSFOUT PO BMNPTU BMM MBCPS GPSDF NFB�TVSFT UIPVHI XJUIPVU SFBDIJOH OBUJWF�MFWFM FBSOJOHT )VHP FU BM� ����� 6OGPSUVOBUFMZ XF LOPX MJUUMF BCPVUTFDPOE�HFOFSBUJPO SFGVHFF PVUDPNFT FMTFXIFSF�

&NQMPZNFOU SBUFT CFMZ UXP SFMBUFE QIFOPNFOB� MPX BWFSBHF FBSOJOHT BOE UIF VOEFS�FNQMPZNFOU PG SFGVHFFT�/FBSMZ IBMG ��� PG 6�4� SFGVHFFT SFTFUUMFE CFUXFFO ���� o ���� XFSF MPX�JODPNF BOE UIFJS IPVTFIPME JODPNFSFNBJOFE CFMPX UIF 6�4� BWFSBHF FWFO BGUFS �� ZFBST� 5IJT JT B SFDFOU QIFOPNFOPO� OP TVDI JODPNF HBQ FYJTUFEJO ���� $BQQT FU BM� ����C� 5IPTF UIBU EP mOE FNQMPZNFOU BSF PWFSSFQSFTFOUFE JO VOTLJMMFE MPX XBHF TFDUPSTMJLF BHSJDVMUVSF DPOTUSVDUJPO DMFBOJOH TFSWJDFT IPUFMT BOE SFTUBVSBOUT BOE SFUBJM USBEF o BSPVOE ��� PG FNQMPZFESFGVHFFT XPSL JO TLJMMFE KPCT JO UIF 6�4� SFMBUJWF UP SPVHIMZ ��� PG PUIFS JNNJHSBOUT EF .BUPT BOE -JFCJH �����$POOPS ����� 6OEFSFNQMPZNFOU JT TUJDLZ� UIF TIBSF PG PWFS�RVBMJmFE SFGVHFFT TUBZT SPVHIMZ DPOTUBOU BU � XFFLTJO UIF 6�4� BOE �� NPOUIT ��� WT� ��� $IFVOH BOE 1IJMMJNPSF ����� 8F PCTFSWF UIF TBNF QIFOPNFOPO PG

�*O &VSPQF UIJT SPMF JT VTVBMMZ mMMFE CZ NVOJDJQBMJUJFT BOE TUBUF BHFODJFT XIJMF $BOBEB IBT CPUI HPWFSONFOU�SFTFUUMFE BOE QSJWBUFMZTQPOTPSFE USBDLT�

�4PNF TUBUFT QSPWJEF POMZ �� EBZT PG UIFTF i3FDFQUJPO BOE 1MBDFNFOUw 4FSWJDFT XIJMF 6UBI QSPWJEFT UIF NPTU BU UXP ZFBST�

Page 6: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

VOEFSFNQMPZNFOU MPX FBSOJOHT BOE PWFSSFQSFTFOUBUJPO JO UFNQPSBSZ BOE QBSU�UJNF XPSL BNPOH SFGVHFF NFO BOEXPNFO JO $BOBEB "VTUSBMJB BOE &VSPQF FWFO SFMBUJWF UP PUIFS JNNJHSBOU HSPVQT %FTJEFSJP ����� *NNJHSBUJPOBOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB ����� 4BMBOU BOE #FOUPO ����� )VHP FU BM� ����� "OBMZ[JOH EBUB PO O � ��� SFGVHFFT JOUIF ���� /FX *NNJHSBOU 4VSWFZ B TBNQMF PG JNNJHSBOUT XJUI QFSNBOFOU SFTJEFODZ JO UIF 6�4� $POOPS ����mOET B QFSTJTUFOU EJTQBSJUZ JO PDDVQBUJPOBM MFWFM BOE FBSOJOHT XIFO DPNQBSFE UP PUIFS NJHSBOUT o OFBSMZ IBMG PGXIJDI DBOOPU CF FYQMBJOFE CZ FEVDBUJPO &OHMJTI TLJMMT BOE OFJHICPSIPPE�

1FSIBQT CFDBVTF CBTFMJOF FBSOJOHT BSF TP MPX GPS SFGVHFFT UIF XBHF QSFNJVN GPS EVSBUJPO JO UIF IPTU DPVOUSZBOE MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ JT IJHI� 5IF NFEJBO SFGVHFF IPVTFIPME FBSOT ��� ��� NPSF BGUFS �� ZFBST JO UIF 6�4�DPNQBSFE UP mWF ZFBST BOE FBDI BEEJUJPOBM ZFBS TQFOU JO UIF6�4� JT BTTPDJBUFEXJUI B ���� TQJLF JO UIF FNQMPZNFOUSBUF $BQQT FU BM� ����C� #FBNBO ����� &NQMPZNFOU SBUFT BNPOH $BOBEJBO SFGVHFFT EPVCMF PWFS UJNF� GSPN ���FNQMPZNFOU BU � NPOUIT UP ��� BU � ZFBST *NNJHSBUJPO BOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB ����� -BOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZJT B TUSPOH QSFEJDUPS PG FBSOJOHT BOE FNQMPZNFOU PQQPSUVOJUJFT BMCFJU XJUI TNBMM NBSHJOBM FæFDUT PO QFSNBOFOUFNQMPZNFOU )PPQFS %FTJEFSJP BOE 4BMBOU ����� $POOPS ����� $IFVOH BOE 1IJMMJNPSF ����� )PXFWFS POMZ�� PG SFGVHFFT SFTFUUMFE JO UIF 6�4� CFUXFFO ���� o ���� SFQPSU TQFBLJOH iHPPEw &OHMJTI ��� TQPLF iTPNFwBOE PWFS IBMG BSF iMJNJUFE &OHMJTI QSPmDJFOUw FWFO BGUFS �� ZFBST JO UIF 6�4 $BQQT FU BM� ����C� %FTJEFSJP �����1SPNJTJOHMZ SFGVHFFT UFOE UP CF NVDI ZPVOHFS UIBO PUIFS NJHSBOU HSPVQT BOE NPSF MJLFMZ UP TUBZ JO UIF IPTUDPVOUSZ o QPJOUJOH UP B MBSHF QPUFOUJBM UP CF QSPEVDUJWF XJUI UIF SJHIU USBJOJOH BOE FEVDBUJPO )VHP FU BM� �����

-BTUMZ B OPUF PO XFBMUI� 5IF XFBMUI HBQ CFUXFFO OBUJWFT BOE GPSFJHOFST OP MPOHFS DPOWFSHFT BGUFS SPVHIMZ UXPEFDBEFT UIF XBZ JU EJE GPS DPIPSUT XIP BSSJWFE JO UIF �����T "LSFTI ����� 3FGVHFFT TFFN UP BDDVNVMBUF MFTTXFBMUI PWFS UJNF UIBO JNNJHSBOUT VQ UP ��� MFTT CZ FTUJNBUFT CBTFE PO UIF ���� /FX *NNJHSBOU 4VSWFZ CVUEFNPOTUSBUF IJHIFS QBUUFSOT PG IPNF FRVJUZ UIBO PUIFS UZQFT PG JNNJHSBOUT "LSFTI ����� %VSBUJPO JO UIF 6�4� DPVOUSZ PG PSJHJO BOE NBSJUBM TUBUVT NBUUFS� NBSSJFE JNNJHSBOUT JODSFBTF UIFJS OFU XPSUI CZ BSPVOE �����ZFBSXJUI OP DPNQBSBCMF DIBOHFT GPS TJOHMF JNNJHSBOUT JODMVEJOH SFGVHFFT� "HF BU BSSJWBM BMTP NBUUFST o QPTJUJWF OFUXPSUI EFDMJOFT CZ BCPVU ��� GPS FBDI BEEJUJPOBM ZFBS PG BHF VQPO BSSJWBM GPS BMM JNNJHSBOUT JODMVEJOH SFGVHFFT�"T FYQFDUFE JOJUJBM XFBMUI JT B TUSPOH QSFEJDUPS PG GVUVSF XFBMUI BT JT JOUFS�NBSSJBHF XJUI OBUJWFT� 6OGPSUVOBUFMZ FEVDBUJPO BOEXPSL FYQFSJFODF JO UIF DPVOUSZ PG PSJHJO BSF EJTDPVOUFE JO UIF 6�4� VOEFSTDPSJOH UIF EVBM DIBMMFOHFTPG VOEFSFNQMPZNFOU BOE SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH BNPOH SFGVHFFT )BP FU BM� ����� )BP ����� "LSFTI �����

5BLFBXBZT� "iSFGVHFF HBQw JO PDDVQBUJPO TUBUVT BOE BWFSBHF FBSOJOHT QFSTJTUT FWFO JO DPVOUSJFTXIFSF FNQMPZNFOU SBUFT FWFOUVBMMZ DPOWFSHF XJUI OBUJWFT� 3FGVHFFT XIP BSF FNQMPZFE UFOE UP CFPWFSRVBMJmFE� -BOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ EVSBUJPO JO UIF IPTU DPVOUSZ BOE SFDPHOJ[FE FEVDBUJPO BOE XPSLFYQFSJFODF BSF TUSPOHMZ DPSSFMBUFE XJUI FNQMPZNFOU PVUDPNFT�

��� &EVDBUJPO PVUDPNFT

5IF MJUFSBUVSF PO SFGVHFF FEVDBUJPOBM BUUBJONFOU GPDVTFT PO MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ BOE FBSMZ DIJMEIPPE FEVDBUJPOo MJUUMF JT LOPXO BCPVU IJHI TDIPPM BOE UFSUJBSZ QFSGPSNBODF� )PTU MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ JT B TUSPOH QSFEJDUPS PGFBSOJOHT BOE FNQMPZNFOU PQQPSUVOJUJFT GPS SFGVHFFT BDSPTT &VSPQF BOE /PSUI "NFSJDB )PPQFS %FTJEFSJP BOE4BMBOU ����� $POOPS ����� $IFVOH BOE 1IJMMJNPSF ����� :FU BO FTUJNBUFE �� PG SFGVHFFT SFTFUUMFE JO UIF 6�4�CFUXFFO ���� o ���� SFQPSU TQFBLJOH iHPPEw &OHMJTI ��� TQPLF iTPNFw BOE PWFS IBMG BSF iMJNJUFE &OHMJTIQSPmDJFOUw FWFO BGUFS �� ZFBST JO UIF 6�4 $BQQT FU BM� ����C� %FTJEFSJP ������ 3FGVHFF SFTQPOTFT GSPN UIF

�5IFTF mOEJOHT BSF CBTFE PO JNQVUJOH SFGVHFF TUBUVT GSPN UIF "NFSJDBO $PNNVOJUZ 4VSWFZ TP SFTVMUT TIPVME CF UBLFO BT SPVHIFTUJNBUJPOT�

Page 7: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

���� /FX *NNJHSBOU 4VSWFZ JOEJDBUF UIBU FOVNFSBUPS�SFQPSUFE &OHMJTI MFWFMT BSF BMTP MPXFS UIBO UIPTF PG PUIFSJNNJHSBOUT ��� WT� ��� PO BWFSBHF PO B ��QPJOU TDBMF $POOPS ����� #BSSJFST BSPVOE BDDFTT UP CJMJOHVBM JO�TUSVDUJPO MJUFSBDZ BOE MJOHVJTUJD EJTUBODF GSPN UIF NPUIFS UPOHVF MBOHVBHF BSF EFTDSJCFE JO 4FDUJPO ���� 3FGVHFFTBSF BMTP MJLFMZ UP GBDF BEEJUJPOBM DIBMMFOHFT BT BEVMU MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST 2VSFTIJ ����� 1FSIBQT EVF UP MJOHVJTUJDCBSSJFST SFGVHFF BEVMUT IBWF BO BWFSBHF IBMG B ZFBS MFTT PG TDIPPMJOH BOE IBMG BT NVDI FEVDBUJPO VOEFSUBLFO JOUIF 6�4� SFMBUJWF UP PUIFS JNNJHSBOUT $POOPS �����

1BSFOUBM MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ JT JNQPSUBOU GPS QBSFOUBM FOHBHFNFOU JO TDIPPMJOH BOE DIJMESFO�T MBOHVBHF BDRVJ�TJUJPO� &OHMJTI DPNQFUFODF BNPOH ZPVOH SFGVHFFT JO UVSO JT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI B SFEVDFE MJLFMJIPPE PG EFQSFTTJWFTZNQUPNT JO ZPVOH SFGVHFFT 'B[FM FU BM� ����� 6OGPSUVOBUFMZ POF�UIJSE PG SFGVHFF DIJMESFO MJWF JO MJOHVJTUJDBMMZJTPMBUFE IPVTFIPMET XIFSF OP NFNCFS PWFS �� JT QSPmDJFOU JO &OHMJTI )PPQFS FU BM� ����� "O PCTFSWBUJPOBMTUVEZ JO UIF 6�,� QPJOUT UP EJSFDU BDDFTT UP &OHMJTI MBOHVBHF TVQQPSU GPS IJHI�TDIPPMFST B XFMDPNJOH TDIPPM BU�UJUVEF BOE UIF QSFTFODF PG TQFDJBMJTU UFBDIFST BT LFZ GPS SFGVHFF FEVDBUJPOBM BUUBJONFOU )FL ����� " QPTJUJWFmOEJOH IFSF JT UIBU PODF SFTFUUMFE SFGVHFF DIJMESFO UFOE UP BDRVJSF DPOWFSTBUJPOBM BCJMJUZ JO UIF MBOHVBHF PG UIFJSOFX DPVOUSZ GBTUFS UIBO UIFJS QBSFOUT ;IPV �����

5IF MJOHVJTUJD DPHOJUJWF BOE FNPUJPOBM CFOFmUT PG IJHI�RVBMJUZ &$&$T &BSMZ $IJMEIPPE &EVDBUJPO $FOUFSTBQQFBS BNQMJmFE GPS SFGVHFF DIJMESFO BT EVBM�MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST BOE DIJMESFO XIPTF GBNJMJFT CFOFmU GSPN BDDFTTUP DPNQSFIFOTJWF TFSWJDFT BOE FBSMZ FYQPTVSF UP UIF 6�4� FEVDBUJPO TZTUFN )PPQFS FU BM� ����� .PSMBOE FU BM������ 1SFTDIPPM FEVDBUJPO BNPOH JNNJHSBOU DIJMESFO JT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI IJHIFS &OHMJTI QSPmDJFODZ SFBEJOH BOENBUI TDPSFT BOE B ��� SFEVDUJPO JO UIF JNNJHSBOU�OBUJWF BDIJFWFNFOU HBQ BDDPSEJOH UP POF TUVEZ PG .FYJDBOJNNJHSBOU GBNJMJFT O � �� ��� $SPTOPF ����� .BHOVTPO -BIBJF BOE 8BMEGPHFM ����� 8IJMF DPNQBSBCMF UPPUIFS JNNJHSBOUT UIF QSF�TDIPPM FOSPMMNFOU SBUF PG SFGVHFF DIJMESFO JT XFMM CFMPX SBUFT GPS 6�4� CPSO DIJMESFO oFYDFQU GPS SFGVHFFT GSPN *SBO $PMPNCJB 3VTTJB )BJUJ BOE 7JFUOBN )PPQFS FU BM� ����� 5BLBOJTIJ ����� $SPTOPF����� #BTT 4IJFMET BOE #FISNBO ����� 5IF WBSJBUJPO JO QSF�TDIPPM QBSUJDJQBUJPO SBUFT CZ FUIOJD HSPVQT NBZ CFQBSUJBMMZ CF FYQMBJOFE CZ QBSFOUBM CFMJFGT BOE BDDFTTJCJMJUZ UP BæPSEBCMF QSFTDIPPM QSPHSBNT .BHOVTPO -BIBJFBOE 8BMEGPHFM �����

4DIPPM BOE OFJHICPSIPPE RVBMJUZ NBUUFS GPS BDBEFNJD BDIJFWFNFOU� *NNJHSBOUT BTTJHOFE UP IJHI�RVBMJUZ IJHITDIPPMT XJUI NPSF OBUJWF TQFBLFST EP CFUUFS XIJMF UIPTF FOSPMMFE JO MPXFS�RVBMJUZ QSF�TDIPPMT EP OPU HBJO UIFNBYJNVN MBOHVBHF BOE DPHOJUJWF CFOFmUT QPTTJCMF $BUUBOFP BOE8PMUFS ����� (PVME -BWZ BOE 1BTFSNBO �����-FTFNBO ����� $PNNVOJUZ RVBMJUZ DBO FYBDFSCBUF OFHBUJWF FæFDUT PG DP�FUIOJDJUZ� -FWFSBHJOH SBOEPNJ[FEIPVTJOH BTTJHONFOUT JO 4XFEFO ¯TMVOE FU BM� ���� mOE UIBU B TUBOEBSE EFWJBUJPO JODSFBTF JO UIF GSBDUJPO PG IJHIMZFEVDBUFE DP�FUIOJDT JO UIF MPDBM DPNNVOJUZ SBJTFT UIF QSPCBCJMJUZ PG HSBEVBUJOH GSPN VQQFS�TFDPOEBSZ TDIPPM POUJNF CZ ��� QFSDFOUBHF QPJOUT BOE JNQSPWFT TUVEFOU QFSGPSNBODF CZ ��� QFSDFOUJMF SBOLT o DMPTJOH UIF BDIJFWFNFOUHBQ CFUXFFO JNNJHSBOU BOE OBUJWF CPZT CZ � o ��� 5IF TJ[F PG UIF FEVDBUFE FUIOJD DPNNVOJUZ JT NPSF JNQPSUBOUGPS CPZT BOE GPS DIJMESFO XIPTF QBSFOUT BSF MFTT FEVDBUFE UXP HSPVQT UIBU IBWF UIF QPPSFTU TDIPPM PVUDPNFT�)PXFWFS JNNJHSBOU GBNJMJFT XJUI BDBEFNJDBMMZ MPX�QFSGPSNJOH DIJMESFO UFOE UP NPWF UP FUIOJD FODMBWFT XJUIMPXFS GSBDUJPOT PG FEVDBUFE NFNCFST� 5IJT TPSUJOH CJBT PG JNNJHSBOUT XJUI iVOGBWPSBCMFw DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT TFMG�TFMFDUJOH JOUP FODMBWFT JT TP TFWFSF UIBU DP�FUIOJD DPODFOUSBUJPO JT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI MPXFS IJHI TDIPPM HSBEVBUJPOSBUFT JO 4XFEFO BOE ��� MPXFS BOOVBM FBSOJOHT PO BWFSBHF JO %FONBSL ¯TMVOE FU BM� ����� %BNN �����

3FGVHFF DIJMESFO GBDF TFWFSBM SJTL GBDUPST JO FEVDBUJPOBM BUUBJONFOU CVU BMTP IBWF TPNF BEWBOUBHFT� 3FGVHFFDIJMESFO BSF NPSF MJLFMZ UIBO PUIFS DIJMESFO UP MJWF JO B UXP�QBSFOU GBNJMZ XIPTF EVBM JODPNF DBO DPNQFOTBUF GPSCFMPX�BWFSBHF FBSOJOHT BNPOH SFGVHFFT )PPQFS FU BM� ����� 5IF QSFTFODF PG UXP QBSFOUT BOE FYUFOEFE GBNJMZNFNCFST BMTP JNQMJFT NPSF BEVMUT BWBJMBCMF GPS DIJME TVQFSWJTJPO BOE HVJEBODF� 3FGVHFF QBSFOUT BSF BMTP CFUUFSFEVDBUFE UIBO JNNJHSBOU QBSFOUT CVU OPU "NFSJDBO QBSFOUT POF�UIJSE PG SFGVHFF QBSFOUT IBWF B DPMMFHF FEVDBUJPO

Page 8: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

BOE PWFS GPVS�mGUIT IBWF B IJHI TDIPPM EFHSFF BDDPSEJOH UP )PPQFS FU BM� ����� 3FGVHFF QBSFOUT GSPN *SBO 3VTTJB BOE "SNFOJB BSF UIF NPTU MJLFMZ UP IBWF DPNQMFUFE B GPVS�ZFBS DPMMFHF EFHSFF PS IJHIFS o XFMM BCPWF UIF6�4� BWFSBHF��

8F IBWF TDBOU FWJEFODF PG UIF FæFDU PG FBSMZ FEVDBUJPO JOUFSWFOUJPOT PO GVUVSF FNQMPZNFOU� " ���� TUVEZ TVHHFTUTUIBU BHF PG BSSJWBM NBUUFST� SFGVHFFT XIP FOUFS UIF 6�4� CFGPSF BHF �� BQQFBS UP HSBEVBUF IJHI TDIPPM BOE FOUFSDPMMFHF BU UIF TBNF SBUFT BT OBUJWFT� $POWFSTFMZ UIPTF XIP FOUFS BT PMEFS UFFOBHFST TFFN UP IBWF MPXFS BUUBJONFOUQPUFOUJBMMZ CFDBVTF PG MBOHVBHF CBSSJFST BOE TUBUVT BT VOBDDPNQBOJFE NJOPST &WBOT BOE 'JU[HFSBME ����� 8IJMFUIFTF mOEJOHT BMJHO XJUI FWJEFODF PO UIF JNQPSUBODF PG BHF BU BSSJWBM POF TIPVME BHBJO JOUFSQSFU UIFTF SFTVMUTDBVUJPVTMZ HJWFO UIF EJçDVMUZ PG BDDVSBUFMZ JOGFSSJOH SFGVHFF TUBUVT GSPN OPO�SFQSFTFOUBUJWF BENJOJTUSBUJWF EBUB�

5BLFBXBZT� "DDFTT UP FBSMZ FEVDBUJPO DFOUFST F�H� QSF�TDIPPMT TJHOJmDBOUMZ CPPTUT MBOHVBHF QSPm�DJFODZ TPDJBMJ[BUJPO BOE DPHOJUJWF EFWFMPQNFOU JO JNNJHSBOU DIJMESFO CVU UIFZ BSF MFTT MJLFMZ UP BUUFOEIJHI�RVBMJUZ QSF�TDIPPMT� 4DIPPM RVBMJUZ BOE GSBDUJPO PG MBOHVBHF�QSPmDJFOU DMBTTNBUFT JNQSPWFT FE�VDBUJPOBM BDIJFWFNFOU� 4PSUJOH FæFDUT MFBE UP FUIOJD FODMBWFT CFJOH BTTPDJBUFE XJUI XPSTF MFBSOJOHPVUDPNFT� -JUUMF JT LOPXO BCPVU IJHI TDIPPM PS VOJWFSTJUZ BDIJFWFNFOU BNPOH SFGVHFFT BMUIPVHI ZFBSTPG TDIPPMJOH TFFN MPXFS UIBO PUIFS NJHSBOUT�

� 8IBU &YQMBJOT 5IFTF 0VUDPNFT

'BDUPST UIBU JOIJCJU FDPOPNJD BOE TPDJBM JOUFHSBUJPO JODMVEF� HFPHSBQIJD BTTJHONFOU USBOTJU BOE QSPDFTTJOH UJNF UFNQPSBSZ BOE JOTFDVSF IPVTJOH FTQFDJBMMZ XIFO MPDBUFE BXBZ GSPN DFOUFST PG FDPOPNJD BDUJWJUZ NFOUBM IFBMUITUSFTTPST mOBODJBM QSPEVDUT VOTVJUBCMF GPS SFGVHFF�TQFDJmD OFFET B MBDL PG SFGFSSBMT BOE BDDSFEJUBUJPO EPDVNFOUT BOE UIF BCTFODF PG USVTUFE TPDJBM OFUXPSLT�

��� (FPHSBQIJD "TTJHONFOU

5ISFF TFUT PG GBDUPST BæFDU UIF FNQMPZNFOU QSPCBCJMJUZ PG SFGVHFFT� HFPHSBQIJD TFUUJOH QFSTPOBM USBJUT BOE UIFTZOFSHJFT CFUXFFO UIF UXP� -PDBUJPO mYFE FæFDUT BSF LOPXO UP CF IJHIMZ JNQPSUBOU GPS FDPOPNJD JOUFHSBUJPO$POOPS ����� #BOTBL FU BM� ����� "MM FMTF FRVBM TPNF DJUJFT QSPWJEF CFUUFS FDPOPNJD BOE OFUXPSL PQQPSUVOJUJFTUIBU DBO CPPTU FNQMPZNFOU� -JLFXJTF TPNF JOEJWJEVBM DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT MJLF MBOHVBHF BOE FEVDBUJPOBM BUUBJONFOU BSF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI IJHI FNQMPZNFOU SBUFT SFHBSEMFTT PG SFTFUUMFNFOU MPDBUJPO� -BTUMZ UIFSF BSF JOUFSBDUJPO FæFDUTCFUXFFO QMBDFT BOE QFPQMF� $FSUBJO USBJUT SFOEFS B SFGVHFF B CFUUFS NBUDI GPS B QBSUJDVMBS DJUZ� 'PS JOTUBODF 'SBODPQIPOF SFGVHFFT BSF NPSF MJLFMZ UP CF FNQMPZFE XIFO BTTJHOFE UP 'SFODI�TQFBLJOH DBOUPOT BT PQQPTFEUP (FSNBO�TQFBLJOH DBOUPOT� 5IF BMHPSJUIN EFWFMPQFE CZ #BOTBL FU BM� ���� MFBSOT KVTU TVDI TZOFSHJFT BOEQSPWJEFT FTUJNBUFT GPS SFUVSOT UP FNQMPZNFOU HJWFO B QBSUJDVMBS SFGVHFF DBTF UIF TFU PG BWBJMBCMF SFTFUUMFNFOUMPDBUJPOT BOE BHFODZ�TQFDJmD DBQBDJUZ DPOTUSBJOUT� 3VOOJOH UIF NPEFM PO IJTUPSJD EBUB TVHHFTUFE JODSFBTFT JOFNQMPZNFOU SBUFT CZ BSPVOE ��� JO UIF 6�4� BOE ��� JO 4XJU[FSMBOE XJUI OP MPTTFT GPS BOZ SFGVHFF DBTFT� 5IFBMHPSJUIN JT TFU UP CF UFTUFE BHBJOTU UIF TUBUVT RVP BTTJHONFOU TZTUFN VTJOH GVUVSF BSSJWBMT JO 4XJU[FSMBOE JO �����*G SFBMJ[FE HBJOT BMJHO XJUI UIF CBDL�UFTUFE QSFEJDUJPOT UIF VTF PG EBUB�ESJWFO UFDIOJRVFT UP BT B LFZ JOQVU JO UIFQMBDFNFOU QSPDFTT DPVME DIBOHF UIF SFTFUUMFNFOU QJQFMJOF�

�(FOEFS QBUUFSOT PG QBSFOUBM FEVDBUJPO WBSZ TJHOJmDBOUMZ� GBUIFST GSPN TPNF PSJHJOT F�H� &UIJPQJB 4VEBO "GHIBOJTUBO $BNCPEJB -JCFSJB BOE 4PNBMJB BSF NVDI CFUUFS FEVDBUFE UIBO NPUIFST XIJMF UIPTF GSPN 6LSBJOF :VHPTMBWJB "SNFOJB #PTOJB $VCB 3VTTJB 6LSBJOF BSF MFTT FEVDBUFE UIBO UIFJS XJWFT�

Page 9: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

0ODF BTTJHOFE UP B DJUZ SFGVHFFT PGUFO TUSVHHMF UP mOE BæPSEBCMF BOE XFMM�MPDBUFE IPVTJOH FTQFDJBMMZ JO UIFBCTFODF PG QSF�FYJTUJOH TPDJBM BOE GBNJMZ OFUXPSLT� 4FWFSBM &VSPQFBO DPVOUSJFT MJLF 4XJU[FSMBOE %FONBSL BOE4XFEFO SBOEPNMZ BTTJHO SFGVHFFT UP B QSPWJODF PS NVOJDJQBMJUZ UP BWPJE PWFSCVSEFOJOH BOZ POF MPDBMJUZ XIFOSFTFUUMJOH SFGVHFFT ¯TMVOE FU BM� ����� 'PHFE BOE 1FSJ ����� )BJONVFMMFS )BOHBSUOFS BOE -BXSFODF ����B� 5IF6�4� BOE $BOBEB UBLF TPDJBM OFUXPSLT JOUP BDDPVOU #FJSFOT BOE 'SBU[LF ����� *O CPUI DBTFT IPXFWFS XF TFFTFDPOEBSZ NPWFNFOU UIBU JT CPUI IBSE UP QSFWFOU BOE UP QSFEJDU XJUI BDDVSBDZ� 8F EP LOPX UIBU UIFSF BSF PGUFOTQBUJBM NJTNBUDIFT CFUXFFO TFSWJDF QSPWJEFST DPODFOUSBUFE JO NVMUJ�FUIOJD EPXOUPXO BSFBT PO UIF POF IBOE BOESFGVHFFT FTQFDJBMMZ (PWFSONFOU "TTJTUFE 3FGVHFFT PS i("3Tw XIP TFUUMF PVUTJEF UIFTF BSFBT JO TVCVSCBO SVSBM PS FUIOJD DPNNVOJUJFT PO UIF PUIFS 1SFTTÏ BOE 5IPNTPO ����� *U JT UIVT VOTVSQSJTJOH UIBU ��� PG ("3T JO B$BOBEJBO HPWFSONFOU TVSWFZ O � ��� NPWFE JO UIF mSTU ZFBS BOE TPVHIU TFSWJDFT GSPN BOPUIFS SFTFUUMFNFOUBTTJTUBODF PçDF LOPXO BT 4FSWJDF 1SPWJEFS 0SHBOJ[BUJPOT� 0G UIF ("3T XIP JOEJDBUFE UIBU UIFZ NPWFE ���JOEJDBUFE JU XBT UP mOE FNQMPZNFOU ��� JOEJDBUFE JU XBT UP CF DMPTFS UP GSJFOET BOE ��� JOEJDBUFE JU XBT UP CFDMPTFS UP GBNJMZ *NNJHSBUJPO BOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB �����

8IJMF TPNF SFGVHFFT DBO SFMZ PO TQPOTPST GPS JOGPSNBUJPO PO BQQSPQSJBUF IPVTJOH o BOE NPSF PGUFO UIBO OPU BQMBDF UP TUBZ GPS GSFF o HPWFSONFOU�BTTJTUFE SFGVHFFT TUSVHHMF UP mOE BEFRVBUF BOE BæPSEBCMF IPVTJOH XJUIPVU UIJTTVQQPSU )ZOENBO ����� )PVTJOH DPOTJEFSFE BæPSEBCMF GPS SFGVHFFT JT PGUFO MPDBUFE JO MPX�RVBMJUZ OFJHICPS�IPPET GBS GSPN QVCMJD USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE DP�FUIOJD OFUXPSLT $POOPS ���� BOE NBZ CF QFSDFJWFE BT EJTSFQVUBCMFCZ OFX BSSJWBMT JO TUSFTT�JOEVDJOH XBZT� ("3T JO QBSUJDVMBS TUSVHHMF UP QBZ Pæ USBOTQPSUBUJPO MPBOT XIJDI NBZDPSSFMBUF XJUI HFPHSBQIJD JTPMBUJPO .PVTB ����B� 0O UIF PUIFS FOE PG UIF SFOU TQFDUSVN MBSHF GBNJMJFT BSFTVTDFQUJCMF UP CFJOH IPVTFE JO VOBæPSEBCMF MPEHJOH o UIVT TUBSUJOH UIFJS MJGF JO UIF 6�4� JO EFCU� 0GUFO XJUI POMZEBZT PS XFFLT OPUJDF CFGPSF B USBWFM EBUF JT TFU 7PM"HT BSF GPSDFE UP TQFOE QBSU PG SFGVHFFT� iXFMDPNF NPOFZw BGFEFSBM TUJQFOE QSPQPSUJPOBM UP GBNJMZ TJ[F PO IPUFMT .PVTB ����B� 3FHBSEMFTT PG XIBU ESJWFT TFDPOEBSZ NJHSB�UJPO GSFRVFOU SFTJEFODF DIBOHFT FTQFDJBMMZ GPS CPZT DBO XPSTFO NFOUBM IFBMUI PVUDPNFT GPS DIJMESFO BMUIPVHIUIFSF JT OP EJTDFSOJCMF EJæFSFODF JO MJWJOH JO BO VSCBO WT� SVSBM BSFB PO BEVMU NFOUBM IFBMUI 'B[FM FU BM� �����

5BLFBXBZT� (FPHSBQIJD BTTJHONFOU JT POF PG UIF TUSPOHFTU EFUFSNJOBOUT PG FDPOPNJD JOUFHSBUJPO�1MBDFNFOU BMHPSJUINT UIBU DPNCJOF SFGVHFF USBJUT XJUI MPDBUJPO mYFE FæFDUT UP PQUJNJ[F GPS FNQMPZ�NFOU BSF FODPVSBHJOH� 'JOEJOH XFMM�MPDBUFE BOE BæPSEBCMF IPVTJOH JT BSEVPVT GPS NBOZ HPWFSONFOU�BTTJTUFE SFGVHFFT� *OJUJBM IPVTJOH BXBZ GSPN FDPOPNJD IVCT TFSWJDF QSPWJEFST BOE DP�OBUJPOBM TPDJBMOFUXPSLT NBZ FODPVSBHF TFDPOEBSZ NJHSBUJPO XJUIJO UIF IPTU DPVOUSZ�

��� %FMBZFE QSPDFTTJOH UJNFT

5IF MJWFT PG SFGVHFFT BSF PGUFO QVU PO IPME GPS NPOUIT PS ZFBST CFGPSF PCUBJOJOH B EFDJTJPO PO UIFJS SFGVHFFTUBUVT� 5IJT XBJUJOH QFSJPE JT PGUFO EF�NPUJWBUJOH EFQSFTTJOH BOE VOQSPEVDUJWF .FTUIFOFPT BOE *PBOOJEJ �����"OBMZ[JOH SFGVHFFT JO 4XJU[FSMBOE CFUXFFO ���� BOE ���� B DBVTBMMZ JEFOUJmFE TUVEZ mOET UIBU POF BEEJUJPOBMZFBS PG XBJUJOH SFEVDFT UIF TVCTFRVFOU FNQMPZNFOU SBUF CZ � UP � QFSDFOUBHF QPJOUT B �� o ��� ESPQ DPNQBSFE UPUIF BWFSBHF SBUF )BJONVFMMFS )BOHBSUOFS BOE -BXSFODF ����C� 5IF SFTVMUT BSF DPOTJTUFOU XJUI UIF JEFB UIBU UIFFæFDU PG XBJU UJNF JT NPTUMZ ESJWFO CZ QTZDIPMPHJDBM NFDIBOJTNT SBUIFS UIBO TLJMM BUSPQIZ BMUIPVHI NPSF XPSL JTOFFEFE UP JOWFTUJHBUF UIF FæFDUT PG SFGVHFFT� TLJMM EFQSFDJBUJPO PWFS UJNF� 6OMJLF &VSPQF XBJU UJNFT GPS 6�4��CPVOESFGVHFFT UBLF QMBDF CFGPSF BSSJWBM PWFS B NJOJNVN UXP ZFBS QSPDFTTJOH QFSJPE� -POH XBJU UJNFT BMTP BæFDU IPTUQPQVMBUJPOT� UIF NPUJWBUJPO BOE JOUFSFTU PG QSJWBUF TQPOTPST JO $BOBEB HSFBUMZ EFDSFBTFT XJUI QSPDFTTJOH UJNFT)ZOENBO ����� 8IJMF VSHJOH RVJDL SFHJTUSBUJPO UJNFT CPUI UIF &�6� BOE UIF $BOBEJBO HPWFSONFOU SFDPNNFOEQSPWJEJOH SFGVHFFT XJUI DVMUVSBM PSJFOUBUJPO DPVSTFT MBOHVBHF BOE TPGU TLJMMT USBJOJOH GPS FEVDBUFE SFGVHFFT BOE

Page 10: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

KPC�NBUDIJOH BOE SFGFSSBM TFSWJDFT UP VTFXBJU UJNFT QSPEVDUJWFMZ :V 0VFMMFU BOE8BSNJOHUPO ����� 4PNNBSSJCBTFU BM� �����

��� )FBMUI

5IF NBKPSJUZ PG SFGVHFF�SFMBUFE IFBMUI TUVEJFT DPODFSO NFOUBM IFBMUI B TUSPOH DPSSFMBUF PG TPDJBM BOE FDPOPNJDJOUFHSBUJPO� *O B ���� TUVEZ O � � ��� KPC FYQFSJFODF JO $BOBEB XBT UIF TUSPOHFTU QSFEJDUPS PG FNQMPZNFOUGPS NFO XIFSFBT EFQSFTTJPO QSPWFE BO JNQPSUBOU QSFEJDUPS PG FNQMPZBCJMJUZ GPS XPNFO )PV BOE #FJTFS �����3FGVHFFT SFTFUUMFE JO UIF 8FTU BSF FTUJNBUFE UP CF UFO UJNFT NPSF MJLFMZ UP IBWF QPTU�USBVNBUJD TUSFTT EJTPSEFSUIBO BHF�NBUDIFE HFOFSBM QPQVMBUJPOT JO UIPTF DPVOUSJFT B QSFWBMFODF PG � o ��� BOE EPVCMF BT MJLFMZ UP TVæFSEFQSFTTJPO BOE BOYJFUZ BT MBCPS NJHSBOUT ��� WT� ��� BOE ��� WT� ��� BDDPSEJOH UP B O � �� ���NFUB�BOBMZTJT'B[FM 8IFFMFS BOE %BOFTI ����� )JHIFS (/1 JO UIF IPTU DPVOUSZ JT SFMBUFE UP MPXFS SBUFT PG EFQSFTTJPO BOEBOYJFUZ JO MBCPS NJHSBOUT CVU OPU JO SFGVHFFT 'B[FM 8IFFMFS BOE %BOFTI ����� "EVMU SFGVHFFT BMTP BQQFBSSFMVDUBOU UP SFQPSU NFOUBM BOE TPNBUJD DPOEJUJPOT UP SFTFUUMFNFOU BVUIPSJUJFT JO UIF QSF�EFQBSUVSF QFSJPE BOE UPNFEJDBM PçDJBMT JO UIF QPTU�EFQBSUVSF QFSJPE EFTQJUF IJHI SBUFT PG JOTVSBODF DPWFSBHF BNPOH TPNF DPNNVOJUJFT4PNNBSSJCBT FU BM� ����� 5BZMPS FU BM� ����� 0O UIF PUIFS IBOE FODPVSBHFE CZ GBWPSBCMF FMJHJCJMJUZ SVMFT DIJMESFOPG SFGVHFFT QBSUJDJQBUF JO QVCMJD IFBMUI QSPHSBNT BU IJHIFS SBUFT UIBO JNNJHSBOU DIJMESFO BMUIPVHI UIFZ BSF BMTPNPSF MJLFMZ UP CF QPPS )PPQFS FU BM� ����� 5IF QPPSFTU SFGVHFFT IBWF UIF IJHIFTU SBUFT PG CFOFmU VTF UIPVHI UIFSBOHF PG CFOFmUT WBSJFT CZ TUBUF )PPQFS FU BM� �����

5BLFBXBZT� 3FGVHFFT BSF IJHI�SJTL GPS EFQSFTTJPO BOYJFUZ BOE 154% XIJDI OFHBUJWFMZ JNQBDUT FN�QMPZBCJMJUZ� 3FGVHFF DIJMESFO BDDFTT IFBMUI TFSWJDFT BU IJHI SBUFT CVU UIFJS QBSFOUT BSF NPSF SFMVDUBOU�

��� 'JOBODJBM -JUFSBDZ

3FGVHFFT GBDF TQFDJmD mOBODJBM EJçDVMUJFT SFMBUJWF UP PUIFS NJHSBOUT UIBU DBO CF DPNQPVOEFE CZ UIF VSHFODZ PGUIFJS TJUVBUJPO B MBDL PG TPDJBM TVQQPSU BOE LOPXMFEHF BCPVU UIF IPTU DPVOUSZ BOE MJNJUFE PQQPSUVOJUJFT UP MJBJTFXJUI GBNJMZ NFNCFST� 5IFTF EJçDVMUJFT JODMVEF B MBDL PG EPDVNFOUBUJPO JODMVEJOH QSPPG PG BEESFTT MBOHVBHFCBSSJFST B MBDL PG USVTU JO UIF mOBODJBM TFDUPS BOE B IJHI PQQPSUVOJUZ DPTU GPS TIJGU XPSLFST UP WJTJU XJUI CBOLTPS TFSWJDF QSPWJEFST "ULJOTPO BOE .FTTZ ����� 0SP[DP ����� "NPOH JNNJHSBOUT UIJT EJTBEWBOUBHF BQQFBSTUP CF QBTTFE PO UP DIJMESFO� 0&$% 1*4" SFTFBSDI JOEJDBUFT UIBU TUVEFOUT XJUI BO JNNJHSBOU CBDLHSPVOE IBWFMPXFS MFWFMT PG mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ UIBO PUIFS TUVEFOUT FWFO XIFO DPNQBSJOH BDSPTT TUVEFOUT XIP TQFBL UIF TBNFMBOHVBHF BU IPNF BOE IBWF B TJNJMBS TPDJP�FDPOPNJD CBDLHSPVOE NBUI BOE SFBEJOH QFSGPSNBODF 1*4" �����&WFO JG NPTU USBOTBDUJPOT BSF VOEFSUBLFO JO DBTI SFGVHFFT NBZ OFFE TVQQPSU UP LOPX IPX UP� DBMDVMBUF FYDIBOHFSBUFT CVEHFU BOE NBLF FæFDUJWF VTF PG mOBODJBM SFTPVSDFT LFFQ SFDPSET PG NPOFZ TFOU BOE SFDFJWFE BOE TNPPUIJSSFHVMBS DBTI nPXT� 3FGVHFFT NBZ OPU CF BXBSF PG UIF GFFT UIFZ BSF QBZJOH UP NBLF NPOFZ USBOTGFST FWFO XIFOTFOEJOH DBTI UISPVHI JOGPSNBM DIBOOFMT 0&$% �����

.PTU XPSL PO UIF mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ PG SFGVHFFT GPDVTFT PO SFDFJWJOH DPVOUSJFT JO UIF (MPCBM 4PVUI� *O UIJT DPO�UFYU SFGVHFFT PGUFO SFRVJSF B NJY PG TFSWJDFT JODMVEJOH FNFSHFODZ MPBOT HSBOUT JOTVSBODF BOE FEVDBUJPOBM JOQVU"[PSCP ����� &WFO UIFO SFGVHFFT IBWF MPX SBUFT PG SVOOJOH TVTUBJOBCMF CVTJOFTTFT BOE SFQBZJOH MPBOT &BTUPO�$BMBCSJB BOE 0NBUB ����� 3FGVHFFT JOUFSBDUJOH DMPTFMZ XJUI /(0T IBWF BMTP CFFO GPVOE UP DPOGVTF MPBOT XJUIHSBOUT /PVSTF ����� 5IF 6/)$3 SPMMFE PVU B NPSF JODSFNFOUBM BQQSPBDI CFHJOOJOH XJUI mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ BOEFOEJOH XJUI NJDSP�MPBOT iUIF (SBEVBUJPO "QQSPBDIw XJUI POMZ TIPSU�UFSN QPTJUJWF SFTVMUT BT PG ���� &HZQU����� /POFUIFMFTT USBEJUJPOBM BDDFTT UP DSFEJU DPVME CF CFOFmDJBM GPS TPNF SFGVHFF HSPVQT o TVDI BT PMEFS BEVMUT

Page 11: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

XIP SBO TNBMM CVTJOFTTFT JO UIFJS DPVOUSJFT PG PSJHJO SFTFUUMFE JO FDPOPNJDBMMZ EFWFMPQFE DPVOUSJFT )PPQFS %FTJEFSJP BOE 4BMBOU ����� *O UIF 6�4� B DBS MPBO QSPHSBN CFOFmUJOH BSPVOE ��� SFGVHFFT TFUUMFE XJUI UIF *O�UFSOBUJPOBM 3FTDVF $PNNJUUFF JO 4BO %JFHP $" MFE UP B EFGBVMU SBUF PG ����� o CFMPX UIF OBUJPOBM BWFSBHF GPSTVCQSJNF BVUP MPBOT BU ������ o JO ���� .PSSJTTFZ ����� 5IF QSPHSBN�T TVDDFTT SFMJFT PO MPX JOUFSFTU SBUFTSFMBUJWF UP TVCQSJNF MFOEFST NBOEBUPSZ mOBODJBM FEVDBUJPO DPVSTFT SFHVMBS CVEHFUJOH TFTTJPOT XJUI B mOBODJBMDPVOTFMPS BOE FBSOFE JODPNF WFSJmDBUJPO TVHHFTUJOH UIBU MPBO QSPHSBNT NJHIU CF NPTU TVDDFTTGVM XIFO QBJSFEXJUI mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ TVQQPSU BOE XIFO UBSHFUFE BU GVMM�UJNF FNQMPZFFT�

4DIPMBST BOE JOUFSOBUJPOBM PSHBOJ[BUJPOT JODMVEJOH UIF 6/)$3 BSF TIJGUJOH UP NJDSP�TBWJOHT o UIF POMZ TVSFXBZ UP TFDVSF GVUVSF BTTFUT o SBUIFS UIBO NJDSP�mOBODF UP UBDLMF mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ BNPOH NJHSBOUT BOE SFGVHFFT�'JOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ JOUFSWFOUJPOT JNQSPWF TBWJOHT PVUDPNFT GPS UIF NPTU WVMOFSBCMF NJHSBOUT XIJMF UIF MFTT WVM�OFSBCMF EFWFMPQ NJDSP�TBWJOHT BOE MFOEJOH HSPVQT XJUIJO UIFJS PXO DPNNVOJUJFT 4FTIBO BOE :BOH ����� %PJ .D,FO[JF BOE ;JB ����� "TISBG FU BM� ����� &BTUPO�$BMBCSJB BOE 0NBUB ����� 'JOBODJBMMZ MJUFSBUF SFGVHFFT IPXFWFS XPVME MJLFMZ TUJMM CFOFmU GSPN TBWJOHT QSPEVDUT FMFDUSPOJD QBZNFOU GBDJMJUJFT BOE BDDFTT UP DSFEJU BOEJOTVSBODF BNPOH PUIFS QSPEVDUT 0&$% ����� "DDFTTJCMF JOGPSNBUJPO PO CVJMEJOH B DSFEJU IJTUPSZ BOE TUBSUJOHB CVTJOFTT TFFN JNQPSUBOU FTQFDJBMMZ HJWFO RVBMJUBUJWF SFTFBSDI JO UIF 6�4� SFQPSUJOH UIBU SFGVHFF FOUSFQSFOFVSTDJUF DPNQMFY MFHBM PCTUBDMFT BT B SFBTPO GPS OPU IBWJOH TUBSUFE B CVTJOFTT TPPOFS /JCCT �����

5BLFBXBZT� 3FGVHFF�TQFDJmD IVSEMFT UP mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ BOE HPPE TBWJOHT QSBDUJDFT BSF JOUFOTJmFEBNPOH MPX�TLJMMFE WVMOFSBCMF TVC�HSPVQT o BOE UIFTF HSPVQT BSF UIF NPTU MJLFMZ UP CFOFmU GSPN mOBO�DJBM MJUFSBDZ JOUFSWFOUJPOT� 'JOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ TVQQPSU DPVQMFE XJUI MPX�JOUFSFTU MPBOT UJFE UP QBSUJDVMBSBTTFUT DPVME CFOFmU IJHI TLJMMFE 6�4� SFGVHFFT PS UIPTF XJUI B CVTJOFTT PXOFSTIJQ CBDLHSPVOE� 5IFNJDSP�TBWJOHT SFBMN JT QSPNJTJOH GPS CPUI MPX� BOE IJHI�TLJMMFE SFGVHFFT�

��� &UIOJD &ODMBWFT

"SPVOE ��� PG SFGVHFFT IBWF QSF�FYJTUJOH UJFT JO UIF 6�4� 5IF OFUXPSL�DSFBUJOH FæFDUT PG DPNNPO OBUJPOBMJUZBNPOH JNNJHSBOUT DBO CF JOGPSNBUJWF JO VOEFSTUBOEJOH UIF QPUFOUJBM VTF PG UIFTF UJFT #BOEJFSB #BSBOLBZ BOE3BTVM ������ &UIOJD FODMBWFT DBO JNQSPWF FDPOPNJD JOUFHSBUJPO UISPVHI UISFF DIBOOFMT�

�� %JTTFNJOBUJOH KPC JOGPSNBUJPO XIJDI JODSFBTFT KPC�XPSLFS NBUDI RVBMJUZ BOE UIVT UIF IPVSMZ XBHF SBUF%BNN ����� 5PQB ����� #FBNBO �����

�� &UIOJD USBEF PS PWFSSFQSFTFOUBUJPO JO B QBSUJDVMBS TFDUPS PG UIF FDPOPNZ #FWFMBOEFS BOE -VOEI �����"MFTJOB )BSOPTT BOE 3BQPQPSU ����� 0UUBWJBOP BOE 1FSJ �����

�� -PXFS FYQPTVSF UP EJTDSJNJOBUJPO UIBO JO UIF NBJOTUSFBN FDPOPNZ 1PSUFT BOE #BDI ����� 8BMEJOHFS BOE-JDIUFS �����

5IFSF JT OP TDIPMBSMZ DPOTFOTVT PO UIF FæFDU PG FODMBWFT QFSIBQT CFDBVTF FæFDUT BSF IJHIMZ DPOUFYUVBM� 1PTJUJWFMBCPS NBSLFU FæFDUT TFFN UP CF DPODFOUSBUFE BNPOH UXP HSPVQT JO QBSUJDVMBS� � MPX�TLJMMFE MPX�JODPNF BOEMPX�FEVDBUJPO SFGVHFFT BOE JNNJHSBOUT XIP BSF NPSF MJLFMZ UP NPWF JOUP FODMBWFT UIBO UIFJS IJHI�DBQJUBM DPNQB�USJPUT BDDPSEJOH UP #PSKBT ����� BOE � SFGVHFFT TFUUMFE JO FODMBWFT XIP BSSJWF TFQBSBUFMZ GSPN MBSHF DP�OBUJPOBMDPIPSUT� &YQFSJNFOUBM FWJEFODF GSPN 4DBOEJOBWJB TVHHFTUT UIBU B TUBOEBSE EFWJBUJPO JODSFBTF JO FUIOJD DPODFOUSB�UJPO JODSFBTFT FBSOJOHT GPS MPX�TLJMMFE JNNJHSBOUT CZ ���XIJMF MJWJOH JO B MPX�RVBMJUZ FODMBWF EFQSFTTFT FBSOJOHT

�5IF TUSFOHUI PG UIFTF UJFT WBSJFT XJEFMZ SBOHJOH GSPN mSTU�PSEFS SFMBUJWFT UIBU DBO QSPWJEF IPVTJOH BOE FNQMPZNFOU TVQQPSU UPTVQFSmDJBM BDRVBJOUBODFT MJUUMF NPSF UIBO B OPNJOBM DPOUBDU PO BTZMVN EPDVNFOUT�

��

Page 12: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

GPS DP�FUIOJD NJHSBOUT JO CPUI 4XFEFO BOE %FONBSL &EJO 'SFESJLTTPO BOE ¯TMVOE ����� %BNN ����� -PX�TLJMMFE JNNJHSBOUT TFFN UP IBWF BO FBTJFS UJNF JOUFHSBUJOH FDPOPNJDBMMZ JO iFTDBMBUPS SFHJPOTw MJLF CJH DJUJFTCVU XJUI MPXFS SFUVSOT UIBO OBUJWF�CPSOT "OEFSTTPO ����� $POOPS ����� 1IJMMJNPSF BOE (PPETPO ����� 0OUIF TPDJP�QTZDIPMPHJDBM GSPOU QPTJUJWF FODMBWF FæFDUT NBZ CF ESJWFO JO QBSU CZ UIF QPTJUJWF FæFDU PG MJWJOH BOETPDJBMJ[JOH XJUI DP�FUIOJDT PO QTZDIPMPHJDBM GVODUJPOJOH 'B[FM FU BM� �����

5IF DPNQFUJUJPO QSPEVDFE CZ BSSJWJOH BU UIF TBNF UJNF BT B MBSHF DP�OBUJPOBM DPIPSU NBZ SFEVDF FNQMPZNFOUSBUFT BOE FBSOJOHT� " TUVEZ PG � ��� NBMF BEVMU NBMF SFGVHFFT SFTFUUMFE CZ UIF *3$ CFUXFFO ���� BOE ���� mOETUIBU B POF TUBOEBSE EFWJBUJPO JODSFBTF JO UIF OVNCFS PG DP�OBUJPOBMT XIP BSSJWF JO UIF 6�4� POF ZFBS QSJPS UPB OFXMZ BSSJWFE SFGVHFF MPXFST IFS QSPCBCJMJUZ PG CFJOH FNQMPZFE CZ ��� QFSDFOUBHF�QPJOUT BOE BWFSBHF IPVSMZFBSOJOHT CZ ������ 5IF OFHBUJWF DPNQFUJUJPO FæFDU NPSF UIBO PæTFUT UIF QPTJUJWF FæFDUT PG BO BEEJUJPOBM ZFBS PGSFTJEFODF #FBNBO ����� $POWFSTFMZ BO JODSFBTF JO UIF OVNCFS PG FTUBCMJTIFE OFUXPSL NFNCFST BSSJWFE � o �ZFBST QSJPS JODSFBTFT UIF FNQMPZNFOU QSPCBCJMJUJFT BOE BWFSBHF FBSOJOHT PG SFDFOUMZ BSSJWFE SFGVHFFT CZ UIF TBNFBNPVOU #FBNBO ����� 5IF SFTVMUT TVHHFTU UIBU CZ QSPWJEJOH KPC JOGPSNBUJPO OFUXPSLT BæFDU XBHFT CPUI UISPVHIUIF FNQMPZNFOU SBUF BOE KPC RVBMJUZ� *O PUIFS DBTFT IPXFWFS OFHBUJWF FODMBWF FæFDUT IBWF CFFO PCTFSWFE 1PSUFTBOE ;IPV ����� ,OPXMFEHF USBOTGFS NBZ BMTP EJTTFNJOBUF JOGPSNBUJPO EFUSJNFOUBM UP MBCPS NBSLFU TVDDFTT MJLFXFMGBSF FMJHJCJMJUZ #FSUSBOE -VUUNFS BOE .VMMBJOBUIBO �����

5BLFBXBZT� 5IF DBVTBM FæFDUT PG FUIOJD FODMBWFT PO FNQMPZNFOU BOE PUIFS JOUFHSBUJPO NFUSJDT JT VO�DMFBS CVU TVHHFTUJWF FWJEFODF QPJOUT UP B QPTJUJWF FæFDU GPS MPX�TLJMMFE SFGVHFFT XIJMF IJHI�TLJMMFESFGVHFFT UFOE UP NPWF BXBZ GSPN FODMBWFT� 5IF QPSUJPO PG FNQMPZFE BOE FEVDBUFE FODMBWF SFTJEFOUTBQQFBST UP TIBQF FEVDBUJPOBM BUUBJONFOU BOE FNQMPZNFOU PVUDPNFT GPS OFX BSSJWBMT�

��� 4PDJBM 5JFT XJUI -PDBM $PNNVOJUZ

4PDJBM DPOUBDUT o OPU OFDFTTBSJMZ XJUI DP�FUIOJDT o BOE B XFMDPNJOH SFDFQUJPO IBWF CFFO GPVOE UP JNQSPWF JOUFHSB�UJPO BOE XFMM�CFJOH BDSPTT B WBSJFUZ PG TFUUJOHT "HFS BOE 4USBOH ����� " TUVEZ PG � ��� .FYJDBO JNNJHSBOUT JOUIF 6�4� GPVOE UIBU UIF TBNF JOEJWJEVBM JT NPSF MJLFMZ UP CF FNQMPZFE BOE IPME B IJHIFS QBZJOH OPOBHSJDVMUVSBM KPCXIFO IFS OFUXPSL JT FYPHFOPVTMZ MBSHFS .VOTIJ ����� -JWJOH JO DMPTF QSPYJNJUZ UP GBNJMZ BOE GSJFOET EFDSFBTFEUIF RVBMJUZ PG FNQMPZNFOU GPS SFGVHFFT JO "MCFSUB $BOBEB CVU UIPTF XIP TPVHIU GBNJMJBM BOE FYUSB�GBNJMJBM BJEJO mOEJOH B KPC GPVOE CFUUFS RVBMJUZ FNQMPZNFOU UIBO UIFJS QFFST XIP EJE OPU IBWF TVDI OFUXPSLT 4BMBOU BOE#FOUPO ����� 4PDJBM OFUXPSLT DBO IFMQ SFGVHFFT BDDFTT GVODUJPOBM SFTPVSDFT MJLF IFMQ XJUI FNQMPZNFOU BOEIPVTJOH BOE TUSFOHUIFO &OHMJTI QSPmDJFODZ 1IJMMJNPSF BOE (PPETPO ����� $IFVOH BOE 1IJMMJNPSF ����� 5IFFDPOPNJD EJTBEWBOUBHF PG IBWJOH OP TPDJBM DPOUBDUT GBEFT BGUFS �� NPOUIT JO UIF 6�4� XIJDI NBZ FYQMBJO XIZSFGVHFF QBSUJDJQBUJPO JO SFMJHJPVT PS DVMUVSBM HSPVQT JT JOJUJBMMZ IJHI CVU ESPQT Pæ RVJDLMZ )VHP FU BM� ����� $IF�VOH BOE 1IJMMJNPSF ����� " TUSPOH DPOOFDUJPO XJUI POF�T OFJHICPSIPPE BOE TPDJBM TVQQPSU JO UIF IPTU DPVOUSZBSF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI MPXFS SBUFT PG EFQSFTTJPO JO SFGVHFFT 'B[FM FU BM� ����� /B[[BM FU BM� �����

*U JT VODMFBS IPX UJFT XJUI OBUJWFT TIBQF PVUDPNFT SFMBUJWF UP OPO�OBUJWF DP�FUIOJD UJFT� *U BQQFBST BU MFBTU JO$BOBEB UIBU SFGVHFFT TPDJBMJ[F NPTU XJUI DP�FUIOJDT BOE FYUFOEFE GBNJMJFT ��� BOE ��� SBUIFS UIBO OBUJWF�CPSOGSJFOET ��� PS FWFO TQPOTPST ��� 4BMBOU BOE #FOUPO ����� 0OF DPODFSO JT UIBU UIF FNQIBTJT PO SBQJE TFMG�TVçDJFODZ JO /PSUI "NFSJDB VOEFSNJOFT JOWFTUNFOUT JO CVJMEJOH QFSTPOBM DPOOFDUJPOT XJUI DPNNVOJUZ NFNCFSTPS MFBSOJOH &OHMJTI #FJSFOT BOE 'SBU[LF ����� 3FMBUFEMZ UIF SBUFT PG SFGVHFF QBSUJDJQBUJPO JO DJWJD PS DPNNVOJUZPSHBOJ[BUJPOT JO UIF 6�4� XBT MPX FOPVHI JO ���� UP QSPNQU POF 7PM"H UP DFBTF NFBTVSJOH UIJT PVUDPNF BU UIFUXP�ZFBS NBSL .PVTB ����B�

��

Page 13: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5BLFBXBZT� 4PDJBM DPOOFDUJPOT XJUI OFJHICPST DPNNVOJUZ NFNCFST BOE MPDBM PSHBOJ[BUJPOT IBWFQPTJUJWF FæFDUT PO MBOHVBHF BDRVJTJUJPO QTZDIPMPHJDBM XFMM�CFJOH BOE TFDVSJOH KPCT BOE IPVTJOH�)PX UJFT XJUI OBUJWFT WT� DP�FUIOJDT EJæFSFOUJBMMZ TIBQF PVUDPNFT JT VOLOPXO�

��� %JTDSJNJOBUJPO BOE -BCPS .BSLFUT

"U MFBTU UISFF TUSVDUVSBM GBDUPST JNQFEF SFGVHFF FNQMPZNFOU PVUDPNFT� 'JSTU IJHI NJOJNVN XBHFT FYUFOTJWFKPC QSPUFDUJPOT BOE TNBMM JOGPSNBM TFDUPST JO &VSPQFBO XFMGBSF SFHJNFT BSF QSPIJCJUJWF CBSSJFST UP SFGVHFF FN�QMPZNFOU� " 4XFEJTI TUVEZ O � ��� ��� SFGVHFFT GPVOE UIBU B �� JODSFBTF JO UIF NJOJNVN XBHF JODSFBTFT UIFMFOHUI PG VOFNQMPZNFOU GPS SFGVHFFT CZ ��� EBZT PO BWFSBHF BT XFMM BT SBJTJOH UIF VOFNQMPZNFOU SBUF CZ ������5IF FæFDU GPS BHF�NBUDIFE ZPVOH OBUJWFT JT IBMG BT MBSHF -VOECPSH BOE 4LFEJOHFS ����� 4FDPOE FWFO JG mSNTBSF XJMMJOH UP IJSF SFGVHFFT UIFZ GBDF TJHOJmDBOU IVSEMFT JODMVEJOH OBWJHBUJOH DPNQMFY JNNJHSBUJPO BOE MBCPSMFHJTMBUJPO BOE VOEFSTUBOEJOH UIF WBMVF PG GPSFJHO�BDRVJSFE RVBMJmDBUJPOT BOE TLJMMT� 5IFTF CBSSJFST BSF PGUFO JO�TVSNPVOUBCMF GPS TNBMM mSNT XJUIPVU EFEJDBUFE IVNBO SFTPVSDFT EFQBSUNFOUT PS FYQFSJFODF JO IJSJOH GPSFJHOFST)PPQFS %FTJEFSJP BOE 4BMBOU ����� 5IFSF JT B QSFTTJOH OFFE UP TUSFBNMJOF UIF QSPDFTT PG SFDPHOJ[JOH GPSFJHODSFEFOUJBMT GPS SFGVHFFT FTQFDJBMMZ JO MJHIU PG FODPVSBHJOH FWJEFODF UIBU JNNJHSBOUT XIP IBWF UIFJS GPSFJHO EF�HSFFT SFDPHOJ[FE JO UIF 6�4� BOE &VSPQF BSF NPSF MJLFMZ UP mOE XFMM�NBUDIFE KPCT FWFO BGUFS BDDPVOUJOH GPS UIFPSJHJO PG UIF RVBMJmDBUJPOT BOE UIF mFME PG TUVEZ EF.BUPT BOE -JFCJH ����� )BMQFSO ����� 5IJSE EJTDSJNJOBUJPOJO 8FTUFSO MBCPS NBSLFUT JT QFSWBTJWF BT FWJEFODFE CZ NZSJBE FYQFSJNFOUT DPNQBSJOH SFTVNF DBMM�CBDL SBUFT GPSBQQMJDBOUT XJUI FUIOJD WT� OBUJWF�TPVOEJOH OBNFT 3JBDI BOE 3JDI ����� ,BBT BOE .BOHFS ����� #MPNNBFSU $PFOEFST BOE 7BO 5VCFSHFO ����� #FSUSBOE BOE .VMMBJOBUIBO ����� "EJEB -BJUJO BOE 7BMGPSU �����

%JTDSJNJOBUJPO BOE QSFKVEJDF BSF DMPTFMZ UJFE UP UIF OBUVSF PG JOUFS�HSPVQ DPOUBDU &OPT ����� 1BMVDL (SFFO BOE(SFFO ����� 1FUUJHSFX BOE 5SPQQ ����� "MMQPSU ����� $BVTBM FWJEFODF GSPN (SFFDF BOE "VTUSJB TVHHFTUT UIBUDPOUBDU XJUI SFGVHFFT VOEFS PQUJNBM DPOEJUJPOT VODPNQFUJUJWF GSFRVFOU QPTJUJWF SFEVDFT WPUFT GPS GBS�SJHIU BOUJ�SFGVHFF QBSUJFT XIJMF CSJFG FYQPTVSF BU UIF CPSEFS DBO JODSFBTF JU )BOHBSUOFS FU BM� ����� 4UFJONBZS �����.PSFPWFS )PmOHFS BOE )PTFS ���� mOE UIBU ��� PG "VTUSJBOT JO NVOJDJQBMJUJFT UIBU SFDFJWFE MBSHF OVNCFST PGSFGVHFFT CFMJFWF UIBU IPTUJOH SFGVHFFT iXPSLFE XFMMw PS iWFSZ XFMMw JO UIFJS NVOJDJQBMJUZ XIJMF SPVHIMZ IBMG PGUIF QPQVMBUJPO SFQPSU JOUFSBDUJOH XJUI JNNJHSBOUT BU MFBTU TFWFSBM UJNFT QFS NPOUI O � ���� $POUBDU JT UIPVHIUUP JOEVDF FNQBUIZ CZ mMMJOH JOGPSNBUJPO HBQT BOE IVNBOJ[JOH UIF iPUIFSw "MMQPSU �����

" HSPXJOH FWJEFODF CBTF BçSNT UIF FNQBUIZ NFDIBOJTN� BO POMJOF QFSTQFDUJWF�UBLJOH HBNF SFEVDFE QSFKVEJDFBHBJOTU 3PNB JO )VOHBSZ BOE SFGVHFFT GPS BU MFBTU B NPOUI XIJMF SFEVDJOH GBS�SJHIU WPUF TIBSF CZ ��� 4J�NPOJWJU[ ,F[EJ BOE ,BSEPT ����� " TVSWFZ FYQFSJNFOU JO UIF MFBE�VQ UP UIF ���� 6�4� FMFDUJPO TJNJMBSMZ GPVOEUIBU BO FNQBUIZ USFBUNFOU JODSFBTFE UIF MJLFMJIPPE PG XSJUJOH B MFUUFS JO TVQQPSU PG SFGVHFFT BOE FOHFOEFSFE JODMV�TJPOBSZ BUUJUVEFT "EJEB -P BOE 1MBUBT ����� 8IFSFBT %FNPDSBUT ESPWF UIF MFUUFS XSJUJOH USFBUNFOU FæFDU UIFBVUIPST PCTFSWF B CBDLMBTI FæFDU BNPOH 3FQVCMJDBOT� (VCMFS ���� JOEJDBUFT UIBU UIPTF XJUI UIF NPTU IPTUJMFBUUJUVEFT UP CFHJO XJUI BSF UIF NPTU MJLFMZ UP FYQFSJFODF DPHOJUJWF EJTTPOBODF XIFO QSFTFOUFE XJUI JOGPSNBUJPOUIBU IVNBOJ[FT UIF PUIFS FWFOUVBMMZ iEPVCMJOH EPXOw PO QSFKVEJDF� " QSFEJDUJPO GPMMPXT GSPN UIFTF SFTVMUT� EJT�DSJNJOBUJPO JT NPTU MJLFMZ UP BæFDU SFGVHFF JOUFHSBUJPO XIFSF FNQBUIZ�JOEVDJOH FYQPTVSF XJUI SFGVHFFT o PGUFONFBOJOHGVM QPTJUJWF BOE GSFRVFOU o DPOUBDU JT MPXFTU� 5IPTF XJUI NJEEMJOH UP IJHI MFWFMT PG QSF�FYJTUJOH FNQBUIZBSF NPTU MJLFMZ UP CFOFmU GSPN UIJT FYQPTVSF�

��

Page 14: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5BLFBXBZT� 3JHJE MBCPS NBSLFUT EJçDVMUJFT JO SFDPHOJ[JOH GPSFJHO DSFEFOUJBMT FTQFDJBMMZ XJUIPVUEPDVNFOUBUJPO BOE EJTDSJNJOBUJPO BHBJOTU GPSFJHOFST BOE FUIOJD NJOPSJUJFT BMM TFSWF BT PCTUBDMFT UPFNQMPZNFOU GPS SFGVHFFT� 'SFRVFOU QPTJUJWF DPOUBDU XJUI SFGVHFFT MJLFMZ MPXFST BOUJ�SFGVHFF IPTUJMJUZ�

� 8IJDI "QQSPBDIFT 4FFN 1SPNJTJOH

��� 0VUTPVSDJOH 4FSWJDFT UP 7PMVOUFFST

'VOEJOH DVUT BOE BO PO�HPJOH NJHSBUJPO DSJTJT IBWF JODSFBTFE UIF OFFE GPS BOE FOUIVTJBTN PG WPMVOUFFST XPSLJOHJO UIF SFGVHFF TQBDF� 7PMVOUFFST IBWF TUFQQFE VQ HMPCBMMZ� (FSNBO SFGVHFF PSHBOJ[BUJPOT TBX WPMVOUFFS FOSPMMNFOUJODSFBTF CZ ��� BOE #SJUJTI WPMVOUBSZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOT IJTUPSJDBMMZ CFBS UIF CSVOU PG TUBUF XJUIESBXBM PG TVQQPSU GPSBTZMVN TFFLFST ,BSBLBZBMJ BOE ,MFJTU ����� 1BUFM BOE ,FSSJHBO ����� 7PM"HT JO UIF 6�4� TJNJMBSMZ TBX JODSFBTFTJO WPMVOUFFS SFHJTUSBUJPOT BMUIPVHI OPU BMM BSF BQQSPWFE CZ BT NVDI BT ���� .PVTB ����B� 5IF TVSHF JOWPMVOUFFSJTN JO SFTQPOTF UP UIF 4ZSJBO GBMM�PVU TVHHFTUT UIBU FOHBHFNFOU JT HFBSFE UPXBSE IFMQJOH SFGVHFFT SBUIFSUIBO WPMVOUFFSJOH JO JUTFMG ,BSBLBZBMJ BOE ,MFJTU ����� &WJEFODF GSPN UIF 6�4� $BOBEB BOE (FSNBOZ TVHHFTUTUIBU WPMVOUFFST UFOE UP CF QSFEPNJOBOUMZ GFNBMF BOE JO UIFJS UXFOUJFT PS PWFS �� (PWFSONFOU ����� *O (FSNBOZ UIFZ BSF UZQJDBMMZ PG NJHSBOU CBDLHSPVOE BOE OPO�SFMJHJPVT SFMBUJWF UP UIF TPDJFUBM BWFSBHF ,BSBLBZBMJ BOE ,MFJTU�����

8IBU LJOET PG UBTLT EP WPMVOUFFST UBLF PO BOE BSF UIFZ FæFDUJWF 7PMVOUFFST JO UIF SFGVHFF TQBDF HMPCBMMZ UFOEUP CFHJO XJUI B MJNJUFE MPHJTUJDBM NBOEBUF UIBU HSBEVBMMZ FYQBOET UP JODMVEF QFSTPOBM FTTFOUJBM DBSF� (FSNBOWPMVOUFFST TUBSUFE PVU CZ GBDJMJUBUJOH WJTJUT BOE DPNNVOJDBUJPO XJUI PçDJBMT BOE PæFSJOH USBOTMBUJPO BOE MBO�HVBHF MFTTPOT BOE UIFO CFHBO UP EPOBUF BOE EJTUSJCVUF FTTFOUJBMT JODMVEJOH GPPE BOE DMPUIJOH JO MJFV PG UIF TUBUFBDDPSEJOH UP B TVSWFZ PG ��� WPMVOUFFST BOE �� PSHBOJ[BUJPOT ,BSBLBZBMJ BOE ,MFJTU ����� 4ZSJBO WPMVOUFFSTXPSLJOH XJUI *SBRJ SFGVHFFT JO %BNBTDVT JEFOUJmFE WVMOFSBCMF SFGVHFFT QSPWJEFE JOGPSNBUJPO PO TFSWJDFT BWBJM�BCMF UP UIFN BOE BTTJTUFE XJUI BDDFTTJOH UIFTF TFSWJDFT CZ GBDJMJUBUJOH BQQPJOUNFOUT� "GUFS CFDPNJOH FOHBHFE WPMVOUFFST CFHBO PæFSJOH TQBDF JO UIFJS PXO IPVTFT DPOEVDUJOH SFHVMBS IPNF WJTJUT TIBSJOH UIFJS PXO GPPE BOEDMPUIFT BOE IBOEMJOH FNFSHFODJFT� -FWFSBHJOH UIF PQQPSUVOJUZ UP CVJME USVTU XJUI SFGVHFFT .DDBSUIZ BOE )BJUI�$PPQFS ���� UIF 6/)$3 UIFO USBJOFE WPMVOUFFST PO JTTVFT MJLF HFOEFS�CBTFE WJPMFODF TFMG�SFMJBODF mSTU BJE BOE QTZDIPTPDJBM JTTVFT .JSHIBOJ �����

7PMVOUFFST BSF FæFDUJWF BU BMMFWJBUJOH UIF CVSEFO GSPN BHFODJFT� TPNF 6�4� SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODZ PçDFT PVUTPVSDF��� PG GVSOJTIJOH SFRVJSFNFOUT UP WPMVOUFFST UIF (FSNBO TUBUF OPX JOUFOUJPOBMMZ SFMJFT PO WPMVOUFFST JO TPNFBSFBT BOE 4ZSJBO WPMVOUFFST BTTJTUFE BO BWFSBHF PG � ��� DBTFT QFS NPOUI CFUXFFO ���� o ������ .BOZ HPWFSO�NFOUT GVOE QSPHSBNT UP NBUDI WPMVOUFFST XJUI OFX BSSJWBMT 5BCMF � UP DPWFS CBTJD TIPSU�UFSN OFFET F�H� ESJWJOHUP BQQPJOUNFOUT JO BEEJUJPO UP MPOH�UFSN TPDJBM BEKVTUNFOU F�H� KPC TFBSDI IFMQ MBOHVBHF QSBDUJDF� 5IF MJUFSB�UVSF PO IPX CFTU UP NPUJWBUF WPMVOUFFST JT SFWJFXFE JO UIF "QQFOEJY TFDUJPO ���� $MFBS NJTTJPO TUBUFNFOUT JOQVUJO EFDJTJPO�NBLJOH HSPVQ�CBTFE XPSL UP TIBSF FYQFSJFODFT BOE DBSFFS QSPHSFTTJPO PQUJPOT BMM TFSWF UP JNQSPWFWPMVOUFFS TBUJTGBDUJPO BOE QFSGPSNBODF�

�#FTU QSBDUJDFT JO UIJT BSFOB JODMVEF� XFFLMZ NFFUJOHT CFUXFFO WPMVOUFFST BOE PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM TUBæ GPS TIBSJOH JEFBT BOE DBTF NBO�BHFNFOU TDFOBSJPT BO JOGPSNBUJPOBM iIPUMJOFw GPS SFGVHFFT DPWFSJOH USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE DPNNVOJDBUJPO DPTUT WJB B NPOUIMZ BMMPXBODF GPSWPMVOUFFST BOE FTUBCMJTIJOH B 'BDFCPPL HSPVQ UP TIBSF FYQFSJFODFT BOE SFDSVJU PUIFST .JSHIBOJ �����

��

Page 15: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5BLFBXBZT� 8F BSF JO UIF NJETU PG B HMPCBM WPMVOUFFSJOH NPWFNFOU BJNFE BU IFMQJOH 4ZSJBO SFGVHFFT BMUIPVHI TVQQPSU JT XBOJOH� 7PMVOUFFST PGUFO TUBSU PVU IBOEMJOH BENJOJTUSBUJWF UBTLT CVU RVJDLMZ NPWFPO UP QFSTPOBMJ[FE BOE DSVDJBM BSFBT PG DBSF� (PWFSONFOUT IBWF DPNF UP SFMZ PO DPNNJUUFE WPMVOUFFSTUP DPWFS TPNF CBTJD OFFET JO BEEJUJPO UP MPOH�UFSN BEKVTUNFOU TVQQPSU�

5BCMF �� 7PMVOUFFS�%SJWFO 3FTFUUMFNFOU 1SPHSBNT 8PSMEXJEF

1SPHSBN 5ZQF $PVOUSZ 5BSHFU(SPVQ

0VUDPNFT 3FTVMU

)BOEMJOH �TU SFDFQUJPO DFOUSBMMZ GPS�� EBZT X� JOUFSQSFUJOH TFSWJDFT QSPWJTJPO PG DMPUIJOH NFEJDBM DBSF DPVOTFMMJOH � DVMUVSBM PSJFOUBUJPOTVQQPSUFE CZ WPMVOUFFST

(PWU�1SPHSBN

(FSNBOZ 3FGVHFFT *OUFHSBUJPO�FOIBODJOHBSSJWBM SFDFQUJPO

(FSNBO CFTU QSBDUJDF SFGVHFF�SFQPSUFE QPTJ�UJWF PQQPSUVOJUZ UP HFUCFBSJOHT MFBSO BCPVU UIFDPVOUSZ � EBJMZ SPVUJOFT � JEFOUJGZ UIF SJHIUDPOUBDU QFPQMF

i)045w QSPHSBN NBUDIJOH WPM�VOUFFST X�OFXDPNFST GPS OBWJHB�UJPOBM TPDJBM � BENJO TVQQPSU KPCTFBSDI IFMQ MBOHVBHF QSBDUJDF

(PWU�1SPHSBN

$BOBEB 3FGVHFFT �*NNJHSBOUT

-BOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ DPNNVOJUZ LOPXMFEHF OBWJHBUJPOBM JOEF�QFOEFODF TPDJBM �QSPGFTTJPOBM OFUXPSL

.BUDIFE PWFS �� ���OFXDPNFST CZ ���� JOD�� ��� SFGVHFFT

1FFS TVQQPSU GSPN TFUUMFE SFGVHFFT� WPMVOUFFST F�H� IFMQ TJHOJOH VQGPS TQPSUT DMVCT UVUPSJOH CJLJOHMFTTPOT mFME USJQT

(PWU�1SPHSBN

&�6� NPTU FYQBO�TJWF JO #FMHJVN

3FGVHFFT *OUFHSBUJPO�FOIBODJOHTPDJBM TVQQPSU

&�6� CFTU QSBDUJDF

i#BOL PG 0æFSTw X� WBSJFUZ PG JO�LJOE TFSWJDFT PæFSFE PO B WPMVOUBSZCBTJT UP TVQQPSU JOUFHSBUJPO� 1SP�NPUFE CZ SFMJHJPVT PSHT DPNQBOJFT� WPMVOUFFST

(PWU��1SJWBUF1SPHSBN

1PMBOE 3FGVHFFT *OUFHSBUJPO�FOIBODJOHBSSJWBM SFDFQUJPO

1PMJTI CFTU QSBDUJDF

-VUIFSBO *NNJHSBUJPO 4FSWJDFT�#3:$4 QSPHSBN� EP[FOT PGQSPHSBNT OBUJPOBMMZ DPPSEJOBUJOHCFUXFFO SFGVHFF TFSWJDF QSPWJEFST SFMJHJPVT PSHBOJ[BUJPOT BOE MPDBMWPMVOUFFST UP MJOL SFGVHFFT X� JOGP USBJOJOH � FEVDBUJPO QSPHSBNT USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE "NFSJDBOiCVEEJFTw

1SJWBUF1SPHSBN

6�4� 3FGVHFFT -BOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ DIJMESFO FOSPMNFOUJO )FBE 4UBSU TPDJBMTVQQPSU QTZDIPMPHJDBMXFMM�CFJOH

4VCTUBOUJBM VQ�UBLF����T PG SFGVHFFT BOEJNQSPWFE PVUDPNFT JOTPNF TVC�QSPHSBNT

��

Page 16: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

��� .FOUPSTIJQ

.FOUPSJOH JT CSPBEMZ EFmOFE BT B iEFWFMPQNFOUBM SFMBUJPOTIJQw XIFSFCZ BO JOEJWJEVBM BEWJTFT TPNFPOF MFTT FY�QFSJFODFE GPS UIF TBLF PG UIF MBUUFS�T HSPXUI BOE BEWBODFNFOU ,SBN BOE *TBCFMMB ����� .FOUPSJOH JT BTTPDJBUFEXJUI FOIBODFE XPSL FæFDUJWFOFTT ,SBN BOE *TBCFMMB ���� KPC TVDDFTT 3PDI ����� 'BHFOTPO ���� TBMBSJFTBOE CPOVTFT 3PDIF ���� QSPNPUJPOT 4UVNQG BOE -POEPO ���� BOE TFMG�SFQPSUFE DBSFFS NPCJMJUZ SFDPHOJ�UJPO BOE TBUJTGBDUJPO 4DBOEVSB ����� 6OGPSUVOBUFMZ OPOF PG UIFTF TUVEJFT BSF DBVTBMMZ JEFOUJmFE� 1SPUFHFT BOEOPO�QSPUFHFT MJLFMZ EJæFS PO VOPCTFSWFE NPUJWBUJPO�

8JUI UIJT DPOTUSBJOU JO NJOE NFOUPSTIJQ JT UIPVHIU UP XPSL UISPVHI UXP NBJO QBUIXBZT� 'JSTU QTZDIPTPDJBMTVQQPSU BMMPXT B QSPUFHF UP DPQF XJUI UIF TUSFTT PG DBSFFS NBOBHFNFOU IPME QPTJUJWF BUUJUVEFT UPXBSE UIF XPSLFOWJSPONFOU BOE WJFX UIF NFOUPS BT B SPMF NPEFM BOE DPBDI ,SBN BOE *TBCFMMB ����� 0TUSPæ BOE ,P[MPXTLJ����� 8BMMBDF ����B� #BVHI -BOLBV BOE 4DBOEVSB ����� *O UIJT WFJO iTPDJBM MFBSOJOHw UIFPSJFT TVHHFTU UIBU UIFFYBNQMF�TFUUJOH GSJFOETIJQ BOE DPVOTFMJOH QSPWJEFE CZNFOUPST JNQSPWFT UIFNFOUFF�T TFOTF PG DPNQFUFODF &CZ -PDLXPPE BOE #VUUT ����� /PF (SFFOCFSHFS BOE 8BOH ����� 4FDPOE NFOUPSTIJQ DBO FOIBODF FBSOJOHT BOEDBSFFS GVODUJPO JO NPSF EJSFDU XBZT� .FOUPST JNQBSU BEWJDF BCPVU UIF DVMUVSF BOE QSPUPDPMT XJUIJO BO PSHBOJ[BUJPOUIBU FOBCMF QSPUFHFT UP SBQJEMZ BDDMJNBUF� .FOUPST BMTP BEWPDBUF PO CFIBMG PG QSPUFHFT SFDPNNFOEJOH UIFN GPSMFBEFSTIJQ QPTJUJPOT QBZ SBJTFT BOE DPNNVOJDBUJOH UIFJS BDDPNQMJTINFOUT UP TFOJPS NBOBHFNFOU $IBP 8BM[BOE (BSEOFS ����� 5IJT CMFOE PG BDDFMFSBUFE TLJMM BDRVJTJUJPO BOE SFQVUBUJPO�CVJMEJOH DBO SBJTF QSPUFHF FBSOJOHT8BMMBDF ����C� %SFIFS BOE $PY +S ���� BOE PQFO VQ EPPST UP QSPNPUJPOT 'BHFOTPO ����� 4DBOEVSB �����.VSSFMM BOE 5BOHSJ ����� 5IJT TVQQPSU JT QPTTJCMF CFDBVTF PG UIF TFOJPS JOEJWJEVBM�T TUBUVT FYQFSJFODF BOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOBM JOnVFODF "MMFO FU BM� ����� 3BHJOT ����� 3FJDINBO BOE 4UFSMJOH ����� 5IJT FYQMBOBUJPO BMJHOTXJUI UIF JNQPSUBODF PG TPDJBM DBQJUBM UP FNQMPZNFOU IJHIMJHIUFE JO B TVSWFZ O � ��� PG $BOBEJBO SFGVHFFT XIJDImOET UIBU TPDJBM OFUXPSLT o OPU IVNBO DBQJUBM o BSF NPTU QSFEJDUJWF PG FNQMPZNFOU -BNCB �����

"MUIPVHI JO OFFE PG VQEBUJOH BOE UFTUJOH CFTU QSBDUJDFT GPS NFOUPSTIJQ QSPHSBNT JODMVEF 4DBOEVSB �����

t 1FSDFJWFE JOQVU JOUP UIF NBUDIJOH QSPDFTT DPSSFMBUFE XJUI CPUI NFOUPS BOE NFOUFF TBUJTGBDUJPO BOE NPUJ�WBUJPO "MMFO &CZ BOE -FOU[ ����� 7JBUPS ����

t 4LJMM PS TFDUPS�CBTFE NBUDIFT #BSSPO #MBDL BOE -PFXFOTUFJO ����t 4IBSFE DVMUVSBM CBDLHSPVOE FOIBODFT JEFOUJmDBUJPO XJUI SPMF NPEFM 3BHJOT ����t )PVST TQFOU JO IJHI�RVBMJUZ USBJOJOH QPTJUJWFMZ BTTPDJBUFE XJUI NFOUPSTIJQ TBUJTGBDUJPO GPS QSPUFHFT "MMFO &CZ BOE -FOU[ ����

$BOBEB IBT QJPOFFSFE TFDUPS�NBUDIFE DBSFFS NFOUPSTIJQ QSPHSBNT UBSHFUFE BU JNNJHSBOUT BOE SFGVHFFT� 1BSUOFSTJODMVEF QSPGFTTJPOBM BTTPDJBUJPOT FEVDBUJPOBM JOTUJUVUJPOT FNQMPZFST GBDJOH MBCPS TIPSUBHFT BOE DJUJFT� 4FDUPSDPVODJMT XPSL XJUI DPNNVOJUZ DPMMFHFT UP QSPWJEF CSJEHJOH QSPHSBNT GPS UFDIOJDBM VQHSBEJOH JO UIFJS TFDUPS F�H�*OGPSNBUJPO 5FDIOPMPHZ "TTPDJBUJPO PG $BOBEB BOE QSPWJODJBM IPTQJUBM BTTPDJBUJPOT� #Z FODPVSBHJOH UIFJS FN�QMPZFFT UP CF NFOUPST FNQMPZFST HBJO BDDFTT UP QPUFOUJBM SFDSVJUT ��� PG BQQSFOUJDFT BSF SFDSVJUFE WJB FNQMPZFFSFGFSFODFT -FSNBO &ZTUFS BOE $IBNCFST ���� CFDPNF FMJHJCMF GPS UBY DSFEJUT GVMmMM DPSQPSBUF TPDJBM SFTQPOTJ�CJMJUZ QSFSPHBUJWFT BOE PGUFO SFDFJWF EJWFSTJUZ MFBEFSTIJQ USBJOJOH PO CFIBMG PG UIF NFOUPSTIJQ QSPHSBN "MCPJN����� *G $BOBEJBO FNQMPZFST IJSF BO JOEJWJEVBM XIP IBT CFFO PO XFMGBSF BTTJTUBODF GPS UIF QSFWJPVT TJY NPOUIT UIFZ DBO BQQMZ GPS XBHF TVCTJEJFT� *OUFSFTUJOHMZ JOUFSWJFXT XJUI TUBæ BU UIF *NNJHSBOU &NQMPZNFOU $PVODJM PG#SJUJTI $PMVNCJB *&$#$ SFWFBM UIBU NPTU DPSQPSBUJPOT BSF OPU BXBSF PG UIFTF GVOET XIFO UIFZ TJHO VQ UP VTFUIF QMBUGPSNT EFTDSJCFE CFMPX .PVTB ����C�

��

Page 17: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5XP $BOBEJBO QSPHSBNT TUBOE PVU CPUI PG XIJDI BSF FNQMPZFS�GBDJOH BOE CBTFE JO 0OUBSJP BOE #SJUJTI $PMVNCJB�+PC $POOFDU XPSLT XJUI SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODJFT UP JOQVU UIF QSPmMFT PG HPWFSONFOU�BTTJTUFE SFGVHFFT ("3T BOEJNNJHSBOUT JOUP UIFJS EBUBCBTF� &NQMPZFST UIFO CSPXTF BOE mMUFS QPUFOUJBM SFDSVJUT� &NQMPZFST JEFOUJGZ DBOEJEBUFTBOE SFRVFTU B DPOOFDUJPO GBDJMJUBUFE CZ +PC $POOFDU BOE TFU VQ BO JOUFSWJFX� /PUF UIBU +PC $POOFDU JT OPU BKPC�NBUDIJOH UPPM PS KPC CPBSE CVU SBUIFS B GSFF QPSUBM GPS FNQMPZFST TFFLJOH EJWFSTF BOE NPUJWBUFE FNQMPZFFT�.PTU SFDSVJUNFOUT BSF NBEF GPS TLJMMFE KPCT EFTQJUF UIF GBDU UIBU FNQMPZFST BSF NPTU JO OFFE PG MPX�TLJMM MBCPS�5IJT JT CFDBVTF DMJFOUT BSF UZQJDBMMZ VOBCMF UP NFFU MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ SFRVJSFNFOUT JNQPTFE CZ +PC $POOFDUo DBOEJEBUFT TIPVME SFBDI B MFWFM TJY $BOBEJBO -BOHVBHF #FODINBSL $-# PVU PG UFO CVU NPTU MJF CFUXFFOMFWFMT [FSP BOE UXP BDDPSEJOH UP *&$#$ TUBæ� (PWFSONFOU TUBUJTUJDT JOEJDBUF UIBU ��� PG ���� BSSJWBMT JODMVEJOHJNNJHSBOUT TQPLF OP &OHMJTI PS 'SFODI (PWFSONFOU ����� .PSFPWFS DMJFOUT GBDF PCTUBDMFT JO BDDFQUJOH MPX�TLJMMFE QPTJUJPOT EVF UP USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE DIJMEDBSF JTTVFT JO BEEJUJPO UP MPX XBHFT UIBU NBLF QVCMJD CFOFmUTNPSF BUUSBDUJWF� -PX�TLJMM KPCT UIBU IBWF CFFO mMMFE IBWF CFFO BU GBSNT DPOTUSVDUJPO TJUFT BOE "SBCJD�TQFBLJOHCBLFSJFT� 4JODF MBVODIJOH JO 'FCSVBSZ ���� +PC $POOFDU IBT QPTUFE ��� SFGVHFF QSPmMFT JO #�$� .PVTB ����C�

5IF TFDPOE QSPHSBN .FOUPS $POOFDU NBUDIFT SFGVHFFT BOE JNNJHSBOUT UP NFOUPST CBTFE PO XPSL FYQFSJFODFBOE FEVDBUJPO� .BUDIFE QBJST FNCBSL PO B ���XFFL SFMBUJPOTIJQ NFFUJOH GPS BO IPVS FWFSZ XFFL� 5IF NFOUPSNVTU JOUSPEVDF UIF NFOUFF UP BU MFBTU UISFF QFPQMF XJUIJO UIF JOEVTUSZ CZ UIF FOE PG UIF QSPHSBN� 5IF SFGFSSBMTZTUFN BU UIF IFBSU PG UIJT NPEFM TVHHFTUT UIBU .FOUPS $POOFDU SFMJFT PO TPDJBM OFUXPSLT BOE JOEVTUSZ FYQPTVSF UPJNQSPWF FNQMPZNFOU PVUDPNFT� #Z ���� UIF OBUJPOBM .FOUPSJOH 1BSUOFSTIJQ 1SPHSBN HSBEVBUFE � ��� TLJMMFEJNNJHSBOU NFOUFFT XJUI ��� PG UIFTF mOEJOH FNQMPZNFOU XJUIJO B ZFBS� )PXFWFS UIF JOEFQFOEFOU FæFDU PGFOSPMMNFOU JT VOLOPXO BOE TFWFSBM NFOUPSTIJQ QSPHSBNT BSF SFTUSJDUFE UP QSPGFTTJPOBMT��

5BLFBXBZT� .FOUPSTIJQ JT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI CPUI QTZDIP�TPDJBM BOE DBSFFS GVODUJPO CFOFmUT UIBU NBZFOIBODF DBSFFS NPCJMJUZ BOE FBSOJOHT� *U JT VODMFBS XIJDI NFDIBOJTN JG BOZ JT MFBEJOH UP UIFTF PVU�DPNFT� .FOUPSTIJQ QSPHSBNT UFOE UP CF UBSHFUFE UPXBSE IJHI�TLJMM QSPGFTTJPOT� .BUDIFT CBTFE POTFDUPS TIBSFE DVMUVSBM CBDLHSPVOE BOE QFSTPOBM DIPJDF JO UIF TFMFDUJPO QSPDFTT BSF CFTU QSBDUJDFT�

��� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQT

"QQSFOUJDFT BSF BQQMJFE TUVEFOUT UIBU FOUFS JOUP B TUSVDUVSFE USBJOJOH QSPHSBN PG DMBTTSPPN BOE QBJE PO�UIF�KPCUSBJOJOH VOEFS UIF HVJEBODF PG B NFOUPS� $MBTTSPPN JOTUSVDUJPO JT PGUFO PæFSFE BU DPNNVOJUZ PS WPDBUJPOBMDPMMFHFT� "T UIFJS TLJMMT JODSFBTF TP EP UIFJS XBHFT� 6QPO DPNQMFUJPO PG UIF QSPHSBN BQQSFOUJDFT FBSO BO JOEVTUSZ�SFDPHOJ[FE DSFEFOUJBM BOE BSF VTVBMMZ IJSFE JOUP B KPC UIBU NBSLT UIF TUBSU PG B DBSFFS� -FOHUIT PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQTWBSZ GSPN BSPVOE POF UP GPVS ZFBST UZQJDBMMZ � o � ZFBST GPS NBOVGBDUVSJOH BOE DPOTUSVDUJPO BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT XJUI DPTUT SBOHJOH BOZXIFSF GSPN ��� ��� UP ���� ��� QFS BQQSFOUJDF� .PTU PG UIJT NPOFZ HPFT UP DPNQFOTBUJOHUIF BQQSFOUJDF 4NJUI BOE ,FNNJT ����� 0UIFS JNQPSUBOU DPTUT DPWFS QSPHSBN TUBSU�VQ UVJUJPO BOE FEVDBUJPOBMNBUFSJBMT NFOUPST� UJNF BOE PWFSIFBE� *ODMVEJOH OPO�SFHJTUFSFE BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT NPTU BQQSFOUJDFT ��� JO UIF6�4� XPSL GVMM�UJNF )FMQFS FU BM� �����

5IF QBZPæ GPS XPSLFST JT DMFBS� ��� PG "NFSJDBO BQQSFOUJDFT mOE FNQMPZNFOU BGUFS DPNQMFUJOH UIFJS QSPHSBN BOE UIFJS BWFSBHF TUBSUJOH XBHF JT BCPWF ��� ��� 4UFJOCFSH BOE 4DIXBSU[ ����� " TUVEZ PG UFO 6�4� TUBUFTmOET UIBU BQQSFOUJDFT FBSO ��� UJNFT NPSF UIBO OPO�QBSUJDJQBOUT NBUDIFE GPS QSF�BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ IJTUPSZ TJY ZFBSTPO SFUVSOJOH ��� JO CFOFmUT GPS FWFSZ �� JO DPTUT BOE ZJFMEJOH OFU HBJOT PG ���� ��� PWFS B XPSLFS�T DBSFFS

�'PS JOTUBODF UIF 5PSPOUP�CBTFE 53*&$ QSPHSBN TFUT UIF MBOHVBHF SFRVJSFNFOU BU B MPGUZ MFWFM FJHIU PVU PG UFO SFRVJSFT QPTU�TFDPOEBSZ FEVDBUJPO BDDSFEJUFE MPDBMMZ JG QPTTJCMF BOE GPDVTFT FYDMVTJWFMZ PO IJHI�TLJMM QSPGFTTJPOT MJLF BDDPVOUBODZ BOE *5�

��

Page 18: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

'JHVSF �� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQ 6Q�5BLF JO UIF 6�4�

3FFE FU BM� ����� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQT FOKPZ IJHIFS SFUVSOT SFMBUJWF UP PUIFS USBJOJOH QSPHSBNT JODMVEJOH UXP�ZFBSDPNNVOJUZ DPMMFHF QSPHSBNT JO B WBSJFUZ PG DPOUFYUT )PMMFOCFDL BOE )VBOH ����� #SPEBUZ $SÏQPO BOE 'PVHÒSF����� 4JNJMBS JODSFBTFT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BSF PCTFSWFE HMPCBMMZ .D*OUPTI ����� &VXBMT BOE8JOLFMNBOO ����� 0G DPVSTF UIFSF BSF TFSJPVT TFMFDUJPO QSPCMFNT XJUI UIFTF TUVEJFT UIBU DPVME WBSZ BDSPTTTFDUPST� $POTUSVDUJPO BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT CPPTU XBHFT CZ ��� JO UIF 6�,� XJUI OP PCTFSWFE FæFDU GPS UIPTF JO SFUBJMo JU JT IBSE UP LOPX IPX NVDI PG UIJT EJæFSFODF JT FYQMBJOFE CZ TFMFDUJPO WT� UIF QSPHSBN JUTFMG .D*OUPTI �����

&NQMPZFST TFF SFUVSOT UPP� "QQSFOUJDF TQPOTPST HBJO B QJQFMJOF PG MPZBM SFMJBCMF TLJMMFE XPSLFST JODSFBTF QSP�EVDUJWJUZ BOE JNQSPWF UIF CPUUPN MJOF -FSNBO &ZTUFS BOE $IBNCFST ����� #FDBVTF BQQSFOUJDFT TUBSU PVUFBSOJOH BCPVU �� o ��� MFTT UIBO B GVMMZ USBJOFE FNQMPZFF CVTJOFTTFT TBWF NPOFZ PO XBHFT BOE UIVT PæTFU TPNFPG UIF DPTUT PG PæFSJOH BO BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ QSPHSBN JODMVEJOH NFOUPS UJNF USBJOJOH FRVJQNFOU BOE UVJUJPO GPSDMBTTSPPN�CBTFE JOTUSVDUJPO� 0WFS ��� PG 6�4� FNQMPZFST TVSWFZFE TBJE TBWJOH NPOFZ PO XBHFT XBT FJUIFS BiWFSZ JNQPSUBOUw PS iTPNFXIBU JNQPSUBOUw CFOFmU PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ XJUI ��� TBZJOH UIFZ XPVME iTUSPOHMZ SFD�PNNFOEw IJSJOH BO BQQSFOUJDF O � ��� )FMQFS FU BM� ����� 5IF QSPEVDUJWF WBMVF PG BQQSFOUJDFT JT BQQBSFOUDSPTT�OBUJPOBMMZ� #SJUJTI BQQSFOUJDFT JODSFBTF UIFJS mSN�T FDPOPNJD PVUQVU CZ BO BWFSBHF PG ���� QFS XFFL $BOB�EJBO FNQMPZFST NBLF ����� GPS FWFSZ �� JOWFTUFE JO BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BOE 4XJTT BQQSFOUJDFT HFOFSBUF ���� NJMMJPOJO QSPmUT GPS UIF ��� PG DPNQBOJFT UIBU QBSUJDJQBUF JO UIFJS OBUJPOBM BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ TDIFNFT QFSIBQT UIF XPSME�TCFTU GPS &DPOPNJDT BOE 3FTFBSDI ����� 'PSVN ����� PG 'PSFJHO "æBJST ����� 4JNJMBS SFUVSOT UP JOWFTUNFOU GPSDPNQBOJFT IBWF CFFO PCTFSWFE BDSPTT UIF 0&$% )PFDLFM BOE 4DIXBSU[ �����

'VOEJOH GPS 6�4� BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ QSPHSBNT SFMJFT IFBWJMZ PO FNQMPZFST PGUFO JO DPMMBCPSBUJPO XJUI USBEF VOJPOT� *OUIF DPOTUSVDUJPO JOEVTUSZ JU JT DPNNPO GPS CPUI FNQMPZFST BOE XPSLFST UP DPOUSJCVUF B NPEFTU BNPVOU UP mOBODFUIF DMBTTSPPN DPNQPOFOU PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT� 8JUI TPNF FYDFQUJPOT TQPOTPST SFDFJWF OP QVCMJD GVOEJOH GPS UIFXPSL�CBTFE MFBSOJOH PS DMBTTSPPN�CBTFE DPNQPOFOUT PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ 3JDIBSE ����� )PXFWFS FNQMPZFST BSFUZQJDBMMZ BCMF UP UBLF BEWBOUBHF PG MPX�DPTU UVJUJPO QSPHSBNT BU DPNNVOJUZ DPMMFHFT TVCTJEJ[FE CZ TUBUF BOE MPDBM

��

Page 19: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

HPWFSONFOUT� " GFX TUBUFT MJLF /PSUI $BSPMJOB BOE $POOFDUJDVU VTF mOBODJBM JODFOUJWFT UP FODPVSBHF UIF DSFBUJPOPG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT���

#FDBVTF PG UIFTF QPTJUJWF SFTVMUT UIF 6�4� %FQBSUNFOU PG -BCPS JOWFTUFE ���� NJMMJPO UP NFFU 1SFTJEFOU 0CBNB�THPBM PG EJWFSTJGZJOH BOE EPVCMJOH UIF OVNCFS PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ TMPUT UP ��� ��� CZ UIF FOE PG ���� 4UFJOCFSHBOE 4DIXBSU[ ����� 5IF IBMG NJMMJPO NBSL XBT QBTTFE JO ���� 4UFJOCFSH BOE 4DIXBSU[ ����� 1SFTJEFOU 5SVNQTJHOFE B FYFDVUJWF PSEFS JO +VOF ���� UP EPVCMF UIF ���� NJMMJPO JO UBYQBZFS NPOFZ TQFOU PO BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT CZSF�BMMPDBUJOH NPOFZ GSPN FYJTUJOH KPC USBJOJOH QSPHSBNT ,FMMNBO ����� .BOZ TUBUFT BSF JODSFBTJOH GVOEJOH GPSUFDIOJDBM BTTJTUBODF UBY DSFEJUT UP FNQMPZFST BOE DBSFFS BOE UFDIOJDBM USBJOJOH UP QSFQBSF TUVEFOUT GPS BQQSFOUJDF�TIJQT 4UFJOCFSH BOE 4DIXBSU[ ����� 0WFS � ��� PDDVQBUJPOT BSF JODMVEFE JO UIF 6�4� SFHJTUFSFE BQQSFOUJDFTIJQTZTUFN USBEJUJPOBMMZ JO DSBGU USBEFT� 'JWF PG UIF UPQ TJY PDDVQBUJPOT BSF JO DPOTUSVDUJPO FMFDUSJDJBO DBSQFOUFS QMVNCFS DPOTUSVDUJPO DSBGU MBCPSFST BOE QJQF mUUFST XJUI ��� PG TQPOTPST BOE ��� PG BQQSFOUJDFT JO DPOTUSVD�UJPO 4NJUI BOE ,FNNJT ����� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQT BSF TMPXMZ FYQBOEJOH GSPN DPSF TLJMMFE USBEFT UP JOEVTUSJFT MJLFIFBMUI DBSF BOE *5 XJUI B OFFE GPS TLJMMFE XPSLFST BOE PQFOOFTT UP XPNFO BOE NJOPSJUJFT )FMQFS FU BM� �����

%FTQJUF UIFJS QSPWFO CFOFmUT "NFSJDBO DPNQBOJFT BSF OPU GBNJMJBS XJUI BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BDDPSEJOH UP BO 0CBNBBENJOJTUSBUJPO SFQPSU ,FMMNBO ����� 5IF 6�4� BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ TZTUFN JT TNBMM DPNQBSFE UP UIPTF PG PUIFS BE�WBODFE FDPOPNJFT BT B SFTVMU XJUI WFSZ MJNJUFE HPWFSONFOU TVQQPSU� $POTJEFS UIBU &OHMBOE TUBSUFE ��� ��� OFXBQQSFOUJDFT JO ���� XIJMF UIF 6�4� TUBSUFE ��� ��� EFTQJUF B TJYGPME EJæFSFODF JO QPQVMBUJPO TJ[F 4UFJOCFSH BOE4DIXBSU[ ����� ��� PG ZPVOH QFPQMF JO 4XJU[FSMBOE BOE (FSNBOZ FOUFS UIF XPSLGPSDF UISPVHI BO BQQSFOUJDF�TIJQ CVU POMZ ��� PG "NFSJDBO XPSLFST SFQPSU VOEFSHPJOH USBJOJOH QSPHSBNT BU BMM� 5IF IBMG�NJMMJPO BQQSFOUJDFTJO UIF 6�4� NBLF VQ B NFSF ���� PG UIF XPSLGPSDF 4NJUI BOE ,FNNJT �����

"QQSFOUJDFTIJQT DPNFXJUI TPNF DIBMMFOHFT� 'JSTU BOENPTU TJHOJmDBOUMZ OPO�DPNQMFUJPO JT B DPOUJOVJOH DPODFSOGPS BCPVU IBMG PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ TQPOTPST 4NJUI BOE ,FNNJT ����� 4FDPOE VOMJLF BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT QSPHSBNTJO NPTU PUIFS DPVOUSJFT UIF 6�4� TZTUFN SBSFMZ SFBDIFT TUVEFOUT JO UIF ��o�� BHF HSPVQ UIF NFEJBO BHF JT ��o�� XJUI B UIJSE BCPWF UIF BHF PG �� XIFO UIFZ TUBSU� 5IJSE iQPBDIJOHw CZ DPNQFUJUPST QPTU�DPNQMFUJPO JT B DPODFSO CVU B XBOJOH POF BDDPSEJOH UP B ���� TUVEZ PG O � ��� BQQSFOUJDF TQPOTPST 4NJUI BOE ,FNNJT ����� 'PVSUI BCPVU B UIJSE PG "NFSJDBO FNQMPZFST DJUF JOTUSVDUJPO DPTUT BOE UIF DPTUT UP FYQFSJFODFE XPSLFST� UJNF UP JOTUSVDUBQQSFOUJDFT BT B NJOPS QSPCMFN -FSNBO &ZTUFS BOE $IBNCFST ����� .BOZ BMTP TBZ UIFZ XBOU IFMQ JO mOEJOHBOE TDSFFOJOH BQQMJDBOUT BT XFMM BT JO mOEJOH SFMBUFE JOTUSVDUJPO�

8IP CFDPNFT BO BQQSFOUJDF BOE BSF SFGVHFFT MJLFMZ UP CFOFmU "NFSJDBO TQPOTPST DJUF SFGFSSBMT CZ DVSSFOUFNQMPZFFT ��� FEVDBUJPOBM JOTUJUVUJPOT ��� BOE DPNNVOJUZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOT JODMVEJOH QSF�BQQSFOUJDFTIJQQSPHSBNT ��� BT SFDSVJUNFOU TPVSDFT -FSNBO &ZTUFS BOE $IBNCFST ����� :FU UIF NBSLFU NBZ CF IBSEFSGPS EJTBEWBOUBHFE HSPVQT MJLF SFGVHFFT� *O /PSXBZ FUIOJD NJOPSJUZ BQQMJDBOUT PG OPO�XFTUFSO PSJHJO IBWF UPPVUQFSGPSN UIFJS NBKPSJUZ QFFST JO PSEFS UP IBWF UIF TBNF DIBODF PG PCUBJOJOH BO BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ )FMMBOE BOE4U�SFO ����� /POFUIFMFTT EJTBEWBOUBHFE HSPVQT UISJWF XIFO UIFZ DBO BDDFTT iFBSO BOE MFBSOw QSPHSBNT FTQF�DJBMMZ XIFO QSPWJEFE CZ mSNT XJUI HSFBUFS USBJOJOH DBQBDJUZ $BSE BOE 4VMMJWBO ����� 'VISFS BOE 4DIXFSJ �����.PISFOXFJTFS ����� #SJEHF QSPHSBNT IBWF BMTP CFFO IFMQGVM JO QSFQBSJOH SFGVHFFT GPS BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BT UISFTI�PMET JO &OHMJTI BOE NBUI TLJMMT OFFE UP CF NFU 3JDIBSE ����� 5BLJOH VQ B KPC XJUI OP QSJPS MFBSOJOH DBO JNQSPWFDPOmEFODF BOE TPGU TLJMMT BNPOH UIPTF XJUI QPPS TLJMMT CVU UIF RVBMJUZ PG UIF NBUDI XJUI FNQMPZFST CFDPNFT TPDSJUJDBM UIBU PO�UIF�KPC MFBSOJOH QSPHSBNT BSF TUJMM QSFGFSSFE )BTMVDL BOE (SFFO ����� &OHMBOE �����

��5IF 4PVUI $BSPMJOB HPWFSONFOU GVOEFE BOOVBM FNQMPZFS UBY DSFEJUT PG �� ��� QFS BQQSFOUJDF QFS ZFBS CFHJOOJOH JO ����� $POOFDUJDVUPæFST FNQMPZFST ��� PG UIF XBHFT PG BQQSFOUJDFT VQ UP �� ��� CVU POMZ GPS BQQSFOUJDFT JO UIF NBOVGBDUVSJOH DPOTUSVDUJPO PS QMBTUJDT�SFMBUFE USBEFT�

��

Page 20: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

*O &VSPQF JOUFSOTIJQT BOE BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BSF TFFO BT B XBZ UP JNQSPWF MBOHVBHF TPGU TLJMMT BOE TPDJBM JOUFHSBUJPOGPS OFXMZ BSSJWFE SFGVHFFT XIJMF HFUUJOH B GPPUIPME JO UIFJS IPTU DPVOUSZ�T MBCPS NBSLFU FTQFDJBMMZ GPS UIPTF XJUIPVUGPSNBM QSPPG PG XPSL FYQFSJFODF PS RVBMJmDBUJPOT� 5IFTF PQQPSUVOJUJFT BMTP PæFS B WBMVBCMF mSTU TBMBSZ UP OFXBSSJWBMT� 3FTFUUMFNFOU BHFODJFT MJLF UIF *3$ IBWF TJNJMBSMZ HSBEVBUFE IVOESFET PG DMJFOUT UISPVHI BQQSFOUJDFTIJQQSPHSBNT�

t 53*&$�T i$BOBEJBO #SJEHFw QSPHSBN� &NQMPZFST QBZ B �� ��� QFS NPOUI TUJQFOE UP JOUFSOT XIP XPSL GPS� � � PS �� NPOUIT XIJMF HBJOJOH $BOBEJBO XPSL FYQFSJFODF JO UIFJS mFME�

t 5IF 6�,�T /BUJPOBM )FBMUI 4FSWJDF /)4 QSPGFTTJPOBM SF�DFSUJmDBUJPO QSPHSBN HSBEVBUFE ��� SFGVHFFEPDUPST TVQQPSUFE PWFS UIF ������� QFSJPE PVU PG XIJDI ��� FOUFSFE B NFEJDBM QPTJUJPO BU B MFWFM DPSSF�TQPOEJOH UP IJT�IFS RVBMJmDBUJPOT JNNFEJBUFMZ BGUFS�

t 4XFEJTI 'BTU 5SBDL *OJUJBUJWF JODMVEFE iCSJEHJOH DPVSTFTw UIBU HSBEVBUFE ��� QBSUJDJQBOUT JO UFBDIFS DPVSTFTBOE ��� QBSUJDJQBOUT JO IJHIFS BENJOJTUSBUJWF DPVSTFT ≤ �� PG UIF FMJHJCMF QPQVMBUJPO� 6TJOH B NBUDIJOHUFDIOJRVF UP DPNQBSF UIPTF JO UIF QSPHSBN XJUI UIPTF TJNJMBS PO SFMFWBOU EJNFOTJPOT CVU OPU FOSPMMFE UIFQSPHSBN JT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI� IJHIFS FBSOJOHT ��� ��� 4&,�ZFBS WT� ��� ��� 4&,�ZFBS FNQMPZNFOU SBUFTJO SFMFWBOU mFMET ��� WT� ��� BOE QSPGFTTJPO BDDPSEJOH UP FEVDBUJPO ��� WT� ����

t 1PSTDIF BOE 4JFNFOT PæFS QBJE JOUFSOTIJQT GPS SFGVHFFT XJUI HSBEVBUF EFHSFFT BOE (FSNBO PS &OHMJTI QSPm�DJFODZ� *OUFSOTIJQT JODMVEFEXPSLQMBDF PSJFOUBUJPO TLJMMT BTTFTTNFOU BOE USBJOJOH BOE BO BOUJ�EJTDSJNJOBUJPOTUBæ DBNQBJHO� 1PSTDIF UFDIOJDBM ZPVUI BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ QSPHSBN FNQMPZFE �� PVU PG �� SFGVHFF BQQSFOUJDFTJO GVMM�UJNF QPTJUJPOT� 4JFNFOT FNQMPZFE �� SFGVHFFT JO B ��NPOUI QSF�RVBMJmDBUJPO DPVSTF UP QSFQBSF GPSBO BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ�

5BLFBXBZT� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQT BSF QSPWFO UP CF QSPEVDUJWF BOE SFWFOVF�HFOFSBUJOH GPS CPUI FNQMPZFSTBOE BQQSFOUJDFT� 6Q�UBLF SFNBJOT MPX CVU HSPXJOH JO UIF 6�4� MBSHFMZ EVF UP B MBDL PG DPSQPSBUFBXBSFOFTT PG UIFTF CFOFmUT ��� PG BQQSFOUJDF TQPOTPST XPVME SFDPNNFOE UIF QSPHSBN JO B ����TVSWFZ PG ��� mSNT� 5IF DBVTBM FæFDUT BSF VOLOPXO EVF UP TFMG�TFMFDUJPO PG NPUJWBUFE JOEJWJEVBMT CVUSFGVHFFT DBO BOE EP mOE TUBCMF TLJMMFE XPSL XJUI CSJEHJOH QSPHSBNT MFBEJOH UP BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT�

��� 1SJWBUF 4QPOTPSTIJQ

5IF QSJNBSZ BMUFSOBUJWF UP UIF HPWFSONFOU�TFUUMFE SFGVHFF USBDL JT QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ� 4QPOTPSTIJQ JT B DPNNJU�NFOU CZ B HSPVQ PG QSJWBUF DJUJ[FOT UP BTTJTU XJUI SFTFUUMJOH B SFGVHFF DBTF UISPVHI BO PSHBOJ[FE DPOUSJCVUJPO PGJO�LJOE HPPET TFSWJDFT BOE mOBODJBM BTTJTUBODF� 8IFO SFTFUUMFNFOU EVUJFT BSF TIBSFE XJUI HPWFSONFOU BHFODJFT UIJT BSSBOHFNFOU JT LOPXO BT DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ� 1SJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ JT HBJOJOH USBDUJPO BNPOH IPTU DPVOUSJFT BSPVOEUIF HMPCF o XJUI UIF 6, *SFMBOE "SHFOUJOB BOE /FX ;FBMBOE BOOPVODJOH QSPHSBNT JO ���� *NNJHSBUJPO BOE$BOBEB ����� 4JNQMZ QVU QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ DPNCJOFT NFOUPSTIJQ XJUI DBTI USBOTGFST BOE TPNF DPSF TFSWJDFT MJLF TFDVSJOH IPVTJOH�

5IF NPTU FYQBOTJWF BOE FTUBCMJTIFE QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ QSPHSBN JO UIF XPSME JT UIBU PG $BOBEB� 5IFSF QSJWBUFMZTQPOTPSFE SFGVHFFT 143T FOUFS UIF MBCPS NBSLFU NPSF RVJDLMZ UIBO HPWFSONFOU�BTTJTUFE SFGVHFFT ("3T ���WT� ��� BOE FBSO EPVCMF PO BWFSBHF ��� ��� POF ZFBS PO o DPOWFSHJOH PO BO BWFSBHF JODPNF PG ��� ��� POMZBGUFS B EFDBEF )ZOENBO ����� *NNJHSBUJPO BOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB ����� %F7PSFU[ 1JWOFOLP BOE #FJTFS �����5IFSF JT B MBSHF TFMFDUJPO FæFDU IPXFWFS� /PU POMZ NVTU SFGVHFFT SFRVFTU 143 TUBUVT CVU UIFZ BSF TJHOJmDBOUMZNPSF MJLFMZ UP CF CFUUFS FEVDBUFE BOE TQFBL &OHMJTI PS 'SFODI TQPOTPST PGUFO BSSBOHF FNQMPZNFOU GPS 143T QSJPSUP BSSJWBM 143T UFOE UP MJWF XJUI UIFJS TQPOTPST BU MFBTU JOJUJBMMZ BOE ��� PG UIFN BSF TQPOTPSFE CZ GBNJMZ

��

Page 21: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

NFNCFST� (JWFO UIFTF EJTQBSJUJFT JO TVQQPSU TZTUFNT JU JT VOTVSQSJTJOH UIBU ("3T BSF EPVCMF BT MJLFMZ UP CFSFDFJWJOH TPDJBM BTTJTUBODF BU UIF UXP�ZFBS QPJOU UIBO UIFJS 143 DPVOUFSQBSUT ��� WT� �� � *NNJHSBUJPO BOE$JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB ����� ("3T BSF BMTP EJTQSPQPSUJPOBUFMZ JNQBDUFE CZ EFMBZT JO BDDFTTJOH MBOHVBHF USBJOJOHBOE IVSU CZ SFEVDUJPOT JO HPWFSONFOU mOBODJBM TVQQPSU VQPO mOEJOH B KPC :V 0VFMMFU BOE 8BSNJOHUPO �����*NNJHSBUJPO BOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB ����� 5IF FYDFQUJPO UP UIJT USFOE BSF ("3T BHFE �� o �� XIP mOE XPSLGBTUFS UIBO 143T PG UIF TBNF BHF QFSIBQT EVF UP IJHI QSFTTVSF UP FOUFS UIF MBCPS NBSLFU JNNFEJBUFMZ HJWFO GFXmOBODJBM BTTFUT� 143T BOE ("3T BSF OFBSMZ JEFOUJDBM IPXFWFS JO BQQMJDBUJPO SBUFT GPS $BOBEJBO DJUJ[FOTIJQ1SFTTÏ BOE 5IPNTPO �����

'VMM�nFEHFE QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ o QSJWBUF DJUJ[FOT QSPWJEJOH DPSF TFSWJDFT BOE TVQQPSU JO MJFV PG UIF HPWFSONFOUo IBT OPU UBLFO Pæ JO UIF 6�4� $P�TQPOTPSTIJQ IPXFWFS JT VOEFSXBZ PO B TNBMM MPDBMJ[FE BOE PGUFO BE�IPDMFWFM BNPOH "NFSJDBO SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODJFT� $P�TQPOTPSTIJQ JT TJNJMBS UP $BOBEB�T 143 NPEFM JO UIBU JU PGUFOJODMVEFT mOBODJBM SFTQPOTJCJMJUJFT TVDI BT QBZJOH SFOU PS VUJMJUJFT BOE QSPWJEJOH NBUFSJBM HPPET MJLF GVSOJTIJOHTGPS BO BQBSUNFOU PS DIJMESFO�T TDIPPM TVQQMJFT� $P�TQPOTPSTIJQ EJæFST GSPN QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ JO UIBU UIF QSJ�NBSZ SFTQPOTJCJMJUZ GPS DPSF TFSWJDFT BOE XFMM�CFJOH SFNBJOT UIF SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODZ� 4PNFXIBU TVSQSJTJOHMZ DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ JO $BOBEB LOPXO BT UIF #703 IZCSJE QSPHSBN IBT CFFO GBS MFTT QPQVMBS UIBO QSJWBUF TQPOTPS�TIJQ SFTFUUMJOH POMZ ��� #703T CFUXFFO ���� BOE ���� DPNQBSFE UP BMNPTU �� ��� 143T��� 4JNJMBS UP UIFJS$BOBEJBO DPVOUFSQBSUT QSJWBUFMZ TQPOTPSFE SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6�4� FBSO IJHIFS NFEJBO JODPNFT UIBO HPWFSONFOU�TFUUMFE SFGVHFFT o ��� ��� WT� ��� ��� BNPOH UIF ����o���� BSSJWBMT %FTJEFSJP ����� &CZ FU BM� ����� 4QPO�TPSTIJQ BTTJTUBODF GSPN DPNNVOJUZ HSPVQT IBT CFDPNF JODSFBTJOHMZ BE�IPD IPXFWFS BT 7PM"HT XPSL NBJOMZUISPVHI OBUJPOBM JOTUJUVUJPOT /BXZO ����� .PSFPWFS UIF TDSFFOJOH QSPDFTT JT TMPX GPS 6�4��CPVOE SFGVHFFT ��UP �� NPOUIT XIJDI DBO EFDSFBTF CPUI TQPOTPS FOUIVTJBTN BOE DMJFOU NPUJWBUJPO )BJONVFMMFS )BOHBSUOFS BOE-BXSFODF ����C� )ZOENBO �����

5IF BQQFUJUF UP BTTJTU SFGVHFFT CPPNFE BNPOH TPNF"NFSJDBO DJWJD PSHBOJ[BUJPOT JO SFTQPOTF UP UIF 4ZSJBO SFGVHFFDSJTJT� �� NBZPST QMFEHFE UP SFTFUUMF NPSF SFGVHFFT 4DPUU ���� BOE TFWFSBM DVMUVSBM HSPVQT TVDI BT UIF 4ZSJBO"NFSJDBO $PVODJM UIF "SBC "NFSJDBO *OTUJUVUF UIF 6�4� $POGFSFODF PG $BUIPMJD #JTIPQT BOE UIF *TMBNJD 4PDJFUZPG /PSUI "NFSJDB TJHOFE PQFO MFUUFST FYQSFTTJOH JOUFSFTU JO TVQQPSUJOH SFTFUUMFE SFGVHFFT 'PMFZ ����B� 1SJWBUFTQPOTPSTIJQ CZ DVMUVSBM HSPVQT IBT B NJYFE QBTU JO UIF 6�4�� JO ���� UIF 6�4� $PPSEJOBUPS GPS 3FGVHFF "æBJSTDSFBUFE B POF�ZFBS VOGVOEFE SFGVHFF QJMPU QSPHSBN GPS 4PWJFU +FXJTI SFGVHFFT UISPVHI .06T TJHOFE JO 'FCSVBSZ����XJUI UIF )FCSFX *NNJHSBOU "JE 4PDJFUZ BOE UIF $POGFSFODF GPS +FXJTI 'FEFSBUJPOT UP QSJWBUFMZ SFTFUUMF � ���SFGVHFFT� 5IFTF SFGVHFFT XFSF JOFMJHJCMF GPS QVCMJD BTTJTUBODF QSPHSBNT IPXFWFS BOE XFSF SFTFUUMFE UP TNBMMUPXOT XJUI QPPS FNQMPZNFOU QSPTQFDUT MFBEJOH UP B GBJMVSF PG QSPHSBN SFOFXBM $FOUFS ����� /POFUIFMFTT B QSPWJTJPO JO UIF 13.�7PM"H DPOUSBDU BMMPXT GPS SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODJFT UP PVUTPVSDF OPO�FTTFOUJBM TFSWJDFT UPTQPOTPST SFHJTUFSFE XJUI B DPNNVOJUZ BTTPDJBUJPO o NPTU PGUFO DIVSDI DPOHSFHBUJPOT�

8IBU DPVME BO "NFSJDBO DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ QSPHSBN MPPL MJLF 5IFSF JT MFHBM QSFDFEFOU BOE GFEFSBM BVUIPSJUZ GPS BO"NFSJDBO QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQ QSPHSBN XIFSFCZ UIF 1SFTJEFOU DBO BMMPDBUF TMPUT GPS QSJWBUFMZ�TQPOTPSFE SFGVHFFTJOWPLFE CZ 1SFTJEFOU 3FBHBO UP BENJU �� ��� SFGVHFFT� 4VDI B QSPHSBN NVTU DPNQMZ XJUI UIF QSJODJQMF PGiBEEJUJPOBMJUZ w J�F� BOZ QSJWBUFMZ TQPOTPSFE SFGVHFFT TIPVME CF JO BEEJUJPO UP o OPU JOTUFBE PG o HPWFSONFOU TFU�UMFE SFGVHFFT� 1SJWBUFMZ TQPOTPSFE SFGVHFFT XPVME BMTP IBWF UP VOEFSHP FYJTUJOH TZTUFNT GPS TDSFFOJOH QSF�BSSJWBM�3FGVHFFT XJUI OP 6�4� UJFT DPVME UIFO CF NBUDIFE XJUI B USBJOFE BOE WFUUFE "NFSJDBO TQPOTPS BO JOEJWJEVBM PS PS�HBOJ[BUJPO PS TQPOTPSFE CZ B QSF�FYJTUJOH 6�4� UJF� 3FTFUUMFNFOU BHFODJFT DPVME USBJO BOE NPOJUPS TQPOTPSTIJQT FOTVSJOH UIBU CBTJD OFFET BSF CFJOHNFU BWPJEJOH FYQMPJUBUJPO PS BCVTF BOE TFSWJOH BT B TBGFUZ OFU TIPVME UIF TQPO�

��5IF IJHI EFNBOE GPS UIF 143 QSPHSBN BOE UIF NJTBMJHONFOU PG 6/)$3 BOE $BOBEJBO TFMFDUJPO QSPDFTTFT SFEVDFE UIF FMJHJCMF QPPMPG DBOEJEBUFT BOE QPQVMBSJUZ PG UIF #703 QSPHSBN� 5IF EBUB XF IBWF IPXFWFS TVHHFTU UIBU #703T UFOE UP CF ZPVOHFS BOE NPSF FEVDBUFEUIBO ("3T CVU MFTT MJLFMZ UP TQFBL BO PçDJBM MBOHVBHF *NNJHSBUJPO BOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB �����

��

Page 22: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

TPSTIJQ SFMBUJPOTIJQ EJTTPMWF *3"1 ����� "HFODJFT DPVME BMTP NBUDI TQPOTPST UP SFGVHFFT CBTFE PO MBOHVBHF DVMUVSF PS PDDVQBUJPO TFDUPS UP PQUJNJ[F UIF QTZDIPMPHJDBM BOE FDPOPNJD SFUVSOT UP OFUXPSL FæFDUT� 8IFSFBTFUIOJD DVMUVSBM PSHBOJ[BUJPOT BSF FYQFSJFODFE TQPOTPST JO $BOBEB UIF TNBMM�TDBMF DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ QSPHSBNT JO UIF6�4� DVSSFOUMZ UFOE UP BUUSBDU 8IJUF QSJNBSJMZ &OHMJTI�TQFBLJOH DIVSDI DPOHSFHBUJPOT .PVTB ����B� 4USVDUVS�JOH B DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ NPEFM BSPVOE UIF JOUFSFTU FYQSFTTFE CZ DJWJD HSPVQT UIBU TIBSF B DVMUVSBM CBDLHSPVOE XJUIOFX BSSJWBMT DPVME QSPWF GSVJUGVM� -PDBMJUJFT VOJWFSTJUJFT PS DJWJD PSHBOJ[BUJPOT DBO ESJWF DBNQBJHOT UP SFDSVJU DP�TQPOTPST� 5PSPOUP�T 3ZFSTPO 6OJWFSTJUZ 0$"% 6OJWFSTJUZ 6OJWFSTJUZ PG 5PSPOUP BOE :PSL 6OJWFSTJUZ MBVODIFEKVTU TVDI B DBNQBJHO� " ZFBS BGUFS JUT MBVODI UIF VOJWFSTJUJFT� SFGVHFF SFTFUUMFNFOU FæPSU SBJTFE $"% ��� NJMMJPO GPSNFE ��� TQPOTPSTIJQ HSPVQT BOE TVQQPSUFE ��� SFGVHFF GBNJMJFT BU BO FTUJNBUFE DPTU PG $"% �� ��� QFS GBNJMZ,FVOH �����

4PNF TQPOTPST DPVME CF FYDMVTJWFMZ mOBODJBM QPPMJOH UPHFUIFS SFTPVSDFT UP TVQQPSU PUIFS QSJWBUF TQPOTPST JO DPW�FSJOH NFEJDBM TDSFFOJOH BOE PUIFS DPTUT PS EPOBUJOH EJSFDUMZ UP UIF SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODZ *3"1 ����� %POBUJOHUP TDSFFOJOH DPTUT DPVME BDDFMFSBUF UIF QSPDFTT XJUIPVU TLJQQJOH TFDVSJUZ PS IFBMUI DIFDLT 'PMFZ ����C� " IZ�CSJE NPEFM DPVME DPNCJOF mOBODJBM DPNNJUNFOUT GSPN EJTUBOU TQPOTPST XJUI UIF WPMVOUFFSJTN BOE NFOUPSTIJQPG QSPYJNBUF DJWJD HSPVQT MJLF DP�FUIOJD SFMJHJPVT HSPVQT XJUI MPX mOBODJBM SFTPVSDFT� "O BEEJUJPOBM NPEFMPG DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ DPVME TUSFTT DBSFFS NFOUPSTIJQ BOE UBLF QMBDF BU UIF NVOJDJQBM MFWFM PS WJB DPSQPSBUJPOT� 6O�EFS UIJT BSSBOHFNFOU SFGVHFFT DPVME CF QSPWJEFE TQFDJBM KPC PQQPSUVOJUJFT MJLF TFDUPS�NBUDIFE BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT�$P�TQPOTPSTIJQ QSPHSBNT MJLF UIJT DPVME UBDLMF POF PG UIF CJHHFTU EJTBEWBOUBHFT PG UIF $BOBEJBO NPEFM o PWFS�EFQFOEFODF BOE iGSJFOETIJQ GBUJHVFw ,BOUPS BOE &JOIPSO ����� "OPUIFS JOOPWBUJPO DBO CF UBQFSJOH Pæ mOBODJBMBTTJTUBODF OFBS UIF FOE PG UIF TQPOTPSTIJQ SFMBUJPOTIJQ UP BWPJE UIF mOBODJBM BOE QTZDIPMPHJDBM TUSFTT BTTPDJBUFEXJUI CFOFmUT DMJæT .PVTB ����B�

5BLFBXBZT� 1SJWBUFMZ TQPOTPSFE SFGVHFFT GBSF CFUUFS CVU UIF JOEFQFOEFOU FæFDU PG QSJWBUF TQPOTPSTIJQJT VOLOPXO BT UIFTF SFGVHFFT BSSJWF XJUI NPSF iGBWPSBCMFw USBJUT� 5IF GVOET DPNNJUUFE CZ TQPOTPSTDPVME GSFF VQ SFGVHFF BSSJWBMT UP GPDVT PO MBOHVBHF BDDMJNBUJOH BOE UIF KPC TFBSDI SBUIFS UIBO NBLJOHSFOU CVU NBZ MFBE UP PWFS�SFMJBODF� 3$5 FWJEFODF JT OFFEFE UP EJTFOUBOHMF UIF DPOUSJCVUJPOT PG UIFNFOUPSTIJQ WT� DBTI BTQFDUT PG TQPOTPSTIJQ�

��

Page 23: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5BCMF �� 7PMVOUFFS�%SJWFO 3FTFUUMFNFOU 1SPHSBNT 8PSMEXJEF

1SPHSBN 4BNQMF $PNNJUNFOUT %VSBUJPO 1SPT $POT

1SJWBUFMZ�4QPOTPSFE3FGVHFFT$BOBEB PGUFO UISPVHIGBJUI HSPVQT

�� ��� BQQSPWFEBOE �� ��� SFTFUUMFE���� HSPVQT PG���� JOEJWJEVBMT PSGBNJMJFT

��� ��� UIBU DBO CF UJFEPS VOUJFE BU TQPOTPST�EJTDSFUJPO SFHJTUFSJOHGPS TFSWJDFT SFQMBDFBHFODZ TPDJBM BEKVTU�NFOU � NFOUPSTIJQ KPCIFMQ BT B TPGU HPBM

��NPOUIT

4FMG�TVçDJFODZ BOE MFBSOJOH CZ EP�JOH BU CFTU XIFO TQPOTPST BSFIBOET�Pæ FODPVSBHF &4- BOE IFMQDMJFOUT SFBDI UIFJS PXO HPBMT� 1SPTBOE DPOT UP VOUJFE DBTI� $BTI BT�TJTUBODF DSVDJBM UP GSFFJOH VQ DMJFOUTUP GPDVT PO &OHMJTI mOEJOH XPSL BOE BDDMJNBUJOH� &BTZ UP GVOESBJTF�"SBCJD MBOHVBHF DPNNVOJUZ IVHFIFMQ F�H� CBOL TUBæ EPDUPST� BOEDP�FUIOJD DP�TQPOTPST NPSF FæFD�UJWF GPS UIJT SFBTPO

0WFS�SFMJBODF FYUSB JOGVTJPOT PGDBTI BGUFS �� NPOUIT BOE EJTTBUJT�mFE TQPOTPST o UIFTF UFOE UP NJTVO�EFSTUBOE UIFJS SPMFT BT TQPOTPST JO�TUFBE JOUFSOBMJ[JOH DMJFOU QSPCMFNTSBUIFS UIBO UFBDIJOH CZ EPJOH BOETUFQQJOH BXBZ� $POT PG VOUJFE DBTI�mOBODJBM NJTNBOBHFNFOU QPTTJCMF

*3*4 TQPO�TPSTIJQ QJMPU/FX )BWFO $5 DIVSDIHSPVQT

�� SFGVHFF GBNJ�MJFT NBUDIFE XJUIHSPVQT PG � o��DP�TQPOTPST

4FDVSF TIPSU�UFSN IPVT�JOH 13. GVSOJUVSFSFRVJSFNFOUT � SFOUBMBTTJTUBODF GPS VQ UP �NPOUIT �� ����� ��� DPSF TFSWJDF FOSPMMNFOU DIFDL JO SFHVMBSMZ X�DBTF XPSLFS

��NPOUIT

.POFZ JT iIVHF w NPTU JNQPS�UBOU DPNQPOFOU� $P�TQPOTPSTIJQXPSLFE XFMM GPS IJHI�SJTL *$.DBTFT

0WFS�SFMJBODF TPDJBM JTPMBUJPO BOEXPSTF FDPOPNJD PVUDPNFT UIBO OPODP�TQPOTPSFE HSPVQT� 0GUFO SF�TFUUMFE JO SFNPUF MPDBUJPOT DMPTFUP DP�TQPOTPST DP�TQPOTPST EPJOHUIJOHT GPS DMJFOUT SBUIFS UIBO UFBDI�JOH UIFN IPX SFTFOUNFOU CVJMU VQCFDBVTF DP�TQPOTPST IBE TQFDJmDFYQFDUBUJPOT PG HSBUJUVEF

��� %JSFDU $BTI 5SBOTGFST

"O JNQPSUBOU DPNQPOFOU PG DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ JT B mOBODJBM DPNNJUNFOU UIBU DBO CF UJFE F�H� SFOU QBZNFOUT PSVOUJFE F�H� NPOUIMZ TUJQFOE� 5IFSF JT SFBTPO UP CF PQUJNJTUJD BCPVU UIF JNQBDU PG EJSFDU DBTI USBOTGFST CBTFE POQSPHSBN FWBMVBUJPOT BOE SBOEPNJ[FE DPOUSPM USJBMT BNPOH UIF QPPS JO CPUI EFWFMPQJOH BOE JOEVTUSJBMJ[FE DPOUFYUT�.PTU SFMFWBOU UP UIF 6�4� SFGVHFF TQBDF B TFSJFT PG OFHBUJWF JODPNF UBY i/*5w FYQFSJNFOUT JO UIF 6�4� BOE$BOBEB JO UIF ����T O � � ��� UBSHFUFE QPPS GBNJMJFT BOE QSPWJEFE CFOFmUT QFHHFE UP UIF OBUJPOBM QPWFSUZ MJOF��� ��� JO ���� EPMMBST GPS B GBNJMZ PG GPVS JO UIF 6�4� "T GBNJMJFT HPU DMPTFS UP UIF QPWFSUZ MJOF WJB FBSOFEJODPNF UIF DBTI EFDSFBTFE VOUJM JU XBT MPTU FOUJSFMZ� /PUF UIBU UIJT JODFOUJWF TUSVDUVSF JT TJNJMBS UP UIF DVSSFOU 6�4�QVCMJD CFOFmUT TZTUFN� 4UVEJFT PG UIFTF /*5 QSPHSBNT GPVOE MJUUMF FWJEFODF PG SFEVDFE XPSLJOH IPVST #VSUMFTTFU BM� ���� XIJMF UIPTF XIP EJE SFEVDF IPVST JOTUFBE JOWFTUFE JO FEVDBUJPO PS DIJMEDBSF 8JEFSRVJTU ����� "WBSJFUZ PG QPTJUJWF JNQBDUT VOSFMBUFE UP XPSL XFSF BMTP SFDPSEFE TVDI BT JNQSPWFE OVUSJUJPO FTQFDJBMMZ GPS DIJMESFO JODSFBTFE IPNF PXOFSTIJQ BOE JNQSPWFE UFTU TDPSFT GPS DIJMESFO #VSUMFTT FU BM� ����� " SFWJFX PG ��� DBTIUSBOTGFS QSPHSBNT JO UIF EFWFMPQJOH XPSME SFBDIFE UIF TBNF DPODMVTJPOT� DBTI USBOTGFST PO BWFSBHF JNQSPWF UIFIFBMUI BOE TDIPPMJOH PG DIJMESFO BOE TBWJOHT JOWFTUNFOU BOE IFBMUI JO BEVMUT #BTUBHMJ FU BM� ����� %VnP �����#BJSE FU BM� ����� .BDPVST 4DIBEZ BOE 7BLJT ����� "NBSBOUF FU BM� ����� %F .FM .D,FO[JF BOE 8PPESV���� #MBUUNBO 'JBMB BOE .BSUJOF[ ����� 'PS UIFTF SFBTPOT 6/*$&' 6, "JE UIF 8PSME 'PPE 1SPHSBNNF 64"*% BOE PUIFST IBWF MBVODIFE nBHTIJQ DBTI USBOTGFS QSPHSBNT XJUI NJMMJPOT PG CFOFmDJBSJFT DPMMFDUJWFMZ�

��

Page 24: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5XP DPNNPO DPODFSOT BSF PGUFO DJUFE JO SFTQPOTF UP EJSFDU DBTI QBZNFOUT� 'JSTU POF NJHIU XPSSZ UIBU DBTIUSBOTGFST DPVME EJTJODFOUJWJ[F XPSL� :FU UIFSF JT MJUUMF FWJEFODF UIBU DBTI USBOTGFST BæFDU PO UIF OVNCFS PG IPVSTXPSLFE XJUI TPNF TUVEJFT mOEJOH JODSFBTFT JO XPSLJOH IPVST BT IPVTFIPME NFNCFST NJHSBUF UP PCUBJO CFUUFS KPCT4BMFIJ�*TGBIBOJ BOE .PTUBGBWJ ����� 'JT[CFJO BOE 4DIBEZ ����� .PTU TUVEJFT UIBU SFQPSU B TJHOJmDBOU FæFDU POBEVMUT PG XPSLJOH BHF GPVOE BO JODSFBTF JO XPSL QBSUJDJQBUJPO ��� TUVEJFT BOE JOUFOTJUZ ��� )BHFO�;BOLFS FU BM������ 5SBOTGFST CFMPX B MJWJOH XBHF BMTP TFFN TVDDFTTGVM� B DPOUSPMMFE 6/*$&' TUVEZ EJTUSJCVUJOH ��� SVQFFT����� QFS NPOUI UP *OEJBO SFDJQJFOUT JOUFOUJPOBMMZ TJ[FE UIF USBOTGFS CFMPX UIF MFWFM SFRVJSFE GPS CBTJD OFFETTP BT OPU UP NBLF UIFN B iTVCTUJUVUF GPS FNQMPZNFOU�w 5IF TUVEZ GPVOE JNQSPWFE OVUSJUJPO JNQSPWFE TDIPPMBUUFOEBODF JODSFBTFT JO BTTFUT BOE JODSFBTFT JO IPVST XPSLFE #IBSBU 6/*$&' FU BM� ����� " TFDPOE DPODFSOJT UIBU EJSFDU DBTI NBZ FODPVSBHF TPNF SFDJQJFOUT UP TRVBOEFS DBTI PO OPO�FTTFOUJBM PS IBSNGVM HPPET� " 8PSME#BOL NFUB�BOBMZTJT DPODMVEFE UIBU UIF QPPS EP OPU TZTUFNBUJDBMMZ BCVTF DBTI USBOTGFST XJUI TUVEJFT DPOTJTUFOUMZTIPXJOH OP TJHOJmDBOU JNQBDU PS B TJHOJmDBOU OFHBUJWF JNQBDU PG USBOTGFST PO iUFNQUBUJPO HPPETw TQFOEJOH &WBOTBOE 1PQPWB ����� 8F NBZ mOE IPXFWFS UIBU UIF JOGPSNBUJPO BTZNNFUSJFT FYQFSJFODFE CZ SFGVHFFT BT PQQPTFEUP UIF XPSLJOH QPPS JO OBUJWF QPQVMBUJPOT NBZ MFBE UP VOJOGPSNFE PS PUIFSXJTF TVCPQUJNBM TQFOEJOH EFDJTJPOT� "OFYU TUFQ JO UIJT SFTFBSDI BHFOEB JT UP TUVEZ IPX USBOTGFST BæFDU mOBODJBM CFIBWJPS JO DPVOUSJFT XJUI MPX XFBMUIBOE MBSHF BNPVOUT PG IJHI DPTU EFCU TVDI BT UIF 6�4� BDDPSEJOH UIF UIF *OOPWBUJPOT GPS 1PWFSUZ "DUJPO *1"�T6�4� 'JOBODF *OJUJBUJWF�

$BTI USBOTGFST BSF OPU SFWPMVUJPOBSZ o IBMG PG XPSME�T DPVOUSJFT JODPSQPSBUF EJSFDU DBTI JOUP UIFJS TPDJBM TBGFUZ OFUT(FOUJMJOJ FU BM� ���� o CVU VODPOEJUJPOBM BOE VOUBSHFUFE CBTJD JODPNF JT� $VSSFOU CBTJD JODPNF QJMPUT BSF POHPJOHJO 'JOMBOE �����NPOUI GPS BMM SFTJEFOUT 0BLMBOE $" �� ��� o � ���� NPOUI GPS �� SFTJEFOUT BOE 4UPDLUPO $"BOOPVODFE JO 0DUPCFS ����� 6OUJFE TUJQFOET BMTP FYJTU JO "MBTLB BSPVOE ������ZFBS UP XJEFTQSFBE TVQQPSUBOE BNPOH &BTUFSO $IFSPLFF JO /PSUI $BSPMJOB ������ZFBS GPS ��� NFNCFST MJOLFE UP MPXFS SBUFT PG TVCTUBODFBCVTF TDIPPM BCTFODF BOE NJOPS DSJNFT $PTUFMMP FU BM� ����� 5IF EFTJHO PG DPSF USBOTGFS GFBUVSFT QBSUJDVMBSMZUIF TJ[F PG UIF USBOTGFS EVSBUJPO PG JUT SFDFJQU BOE NFUIPE PG USBOTGFS F�H� NPCJMF NPOFZ JT DSVDJBM UP BDIJFWJOHHSFBUFS JNQBDUT )BVTIPGFS BOE 4IBQJSP ����� 1SPHSBNT TIPVME CF EFTJHOFE DSFBUJWFMZ BOE DBSFGVMMZ UP NFFU UIFEJTUJODU OFFET PG FBDI UBSHFU HSPVQ�

5BLFBXBZT� $BTI USBOTGFST FTQFDJBMMZ UIPTF MBSHF BOE SFHVMBS FOPVHI UP CSJOH CFOFmDJBSJFT VQ UP BOEBCPWF UIF QPWFSUZ MJOF BSF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI JNQSPWFE IFBMUI OVUSJUJPO BOE FEVDBUJPOBM BUUBJONFOUJO DIJMESFO BOE HSFBUFS TBWJOHT BTTFUT JOWFTUNFOUT BOE NFOUBM IFBMUI JO BEVMUT JO EFWFMPQJOH BOEEFWFMPQFE DPOUFYUT� 4FWFSBM 3$5T TIPX UIBU DBTI USBOTGFST BSF VOMJLFMZ UP SFEVDF UIF OVNCFS PG IPVSTXPSLFE� .PSF XPSL JT OFFEFE UP UFTU UIF EJSFDU FæFDUT PG DBTI USBOTGFS BNPOH SFGVHFFT XIP NBZ CFMFTT JOGPSNFE BCPVU DPOTVNQUJPO PQUJPOT JO UIFJS OFX FOWJSPONFOU�

��� &4- &EVDBUJPO

5IF QFSDFOUBHF PG QVCMJD TDIPPM TUVEFOUT JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT XIP BSF i&--Tw &OHMJTI -BOHVBHF -FBSOFST IBTCFFO SJTJOH ZFBS BGUFS ZFBS SFBDIJOH ���� PS SPVHIMZ ��� NJMMJPO TUVEFOUT JO ���� 4UBUJTUJDT ����� 0OF PG UIFHSFBUFTU DIBMMFOHFT GBDJOH UIF UFBDIFST PG &--T MJFT JO UIF EJWFSTJUZ PG UIFJS MJOHVJTUJD FUIOJD BOE FEVDBUJPOBMCBDLHSPVOET XJUI &--T BMTP FOUFSJOH UIF 6�4� BU FWFSZ BHF BOE HSBEF MFWFM� "O FTUJNBUFE ��� PG &-- TUV�EFOUT BSF 4QBOJTI�TQFBLJOH CVU B NVDI NPSF EJWFSTF QJDUVSF JT QBJOUFE XIFO DPOTJEFSJOH SFGVHFFT FTQFDJBMMZBEVMUT UIBU GBDF BEEJUJPOBM CBSSJFST UP MBOHVBHF BUUBJONFOU $BMEFSØO 4MBWJO BOE 4ÈODIF[ ����� 5IF QPMJDZ MBOE�TDBQF GVSUIFS DPOTUSBJOT PQQPSUVOJUJFT UP MFBSO &OHMJTI� 1VCMJD JOWFTUNFOUT JO TFDPOE MBOHVBHF BDRVJTJUJPO JT MPX�POMZ B UFOUI PG BEVMUT XJUI MJNJUFE &OHMJTI QSPmDJFODZ -&1T BSF FOSPMMFE JO &4- DPVSTFT 'PVOEBUJPO �����

��

Page 25: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

.PSFPWFS QSPQPTJUJPOT QBTTFE JO "SJ[POB $BMJGPSOJB BOE .BTTBDIVTFUUT JNQPTJOH &OHMJTI�POMZ MBOHVBHF DMBTTFTBDUVBMMZ XPSTFOFE &OHMJTI QSPmDJFODZ BOE BDBEFNJD BDIJFWFNFOU JO UIF MPOH SVO (PMEFOCFSH ����� 8JUI UIFTFDPOTUSBJOUT JO NJOE XIBU GBDUPST BSF BTTPDJBUFE XJUI TFDPOE MBOHVBHF BDRVJTJUJPO 1SFEJDUPST PG TVDDFTT DBO CFDBUFHPSJ[FE JOUP UISFF QPPMT� � JOEJWJEVBM USBJUT� � MFBSOJOH FOWJSPONFOU� BOE � NFUIPET PG JOTUSVDUJPO�

7BSJBUJPO JO TUVEFOUT� MJUFSBDZ XJUIJO UIFJS OBUJWF MBOHVBHF JT B TUSPOH QSFEJDUPS PG UIFJS BCJMJUZ UP MFBSO BOE CFDPNFnVFOU JO &OHMJTI� 5IF TIPSUFS UIF iMJOHVJTUJD EJTUBODFw CFUXFFO UIF TUVEFOUT� OBUJWF UPOHVF BOE &OHMJTI UIFFBTJFS JU JT UP MFBSO &OHMJTI ,PEB ����� *MMJUFSBDZ JO POF�T mSTU MBOHVBHF UIVT QSFTFOUT B TJHOJmDBOU PCTUBDMF UPTFDPOE MBOHVBHF BUUBJONFOU� 3FMBUFEMZ UIPTF XJUI JOUFSSVQUFE GPSNBM FEVDBUJPO BOE FTQFDJBMMZ SFGVHFF DIJMESFOXIP IBWF OFWFS BUUFOEFE TDIPPM UFOE UP IBWF MJUFSBDZ BOE TVCKFDU NBUUFS HBQT UIBU HP CFZPOE MBOHVBHF MFBSOJOH QBSUJDVMBSMZ JG UIFZ FOUFS 6�4� TDIPPMT JO UIF VQQFS HSBEFT 'MFHF BOE -JV ����� "OPUIFS JNQPSUBOU JOEJWJEVBM�MFWFM GBDUPS JT NPUJWBUJPO� 5IJT XBT UIF TUSPOHFTU QSFEJDUPS PG TVDDFTT GPS VTFST PG %VPMJOHP BOE NPUJWBUJPO PGQBSFOUT XBT DJUFE BT BO VOUBQQFE SFTPVSDF GPS TDIPPMT JO B TFNJOBM SFWJFX PG &4- DPNNJTTJPOFE CZ UIF 6�4�%FQBSUNFOU PG &EVDBUJPO 'MFHF BOE -JV ����� 7FTTFMJOPW BOE (SFHP ����� .PUJWBUJPO JUTFMG NBZ CF OFHBUJWFMZTIBQFE CZ QFSDFJWJOH POFTFMG BT B NFNCFS PG B MPX�TUBUVT MBOHVBHF HSPVQ "VHVTU 4IBOBIBO BOE &TDBNJMMB �����.PUJWBUJPO NBZ CF MPX BNPOH TPNF SFGVHFFT HJWFO UIBU NPTU EJE OPU DIPPTF UP FNJHSBUF 3JDINPOE �����

1FSIBQT UIF NPTU DSVDJBM EFUFSNJOBOU PG MBOHVBHF BDRVJTJUJPO JT BHF� -JOHVJTUT IBWF mFSDFMZ EFCBUFE UIF iDSJUJDBMQFSJPE IZQPUIFTJT�w UIF JEFB UIBU BO JEFBM UJNF XJOEPX FYJTUT UP BDRVJSF MBOHVBHF BGUFS XIJDI GVSUIFS MBOHVBHFBDRVJTJUJPO CFDPNFT NVDI NPSF EJçDVMU BOE FæPSUGVM� .FUB�BOBMZTFT JOEJDBUF UIBU iZPVOHFS � CFUUFS JO UIF MPOHSVO w CVU XJUI TFWFSBM DBWFBUT� "SPVOE �� PG BEVMU CJMJOHVBMT NBTUFS B TFDPOE MBOHVBHF FWFO UIPVHI UIFZ CFHJOMFBSOJOH XFMM JOUP BEVMUIPPE NPUJWBUJPO DBO DPNQFOTBUF TPNFXIBU GPS OFVSPCJPMPHJDBM DBQBDJUJFT XFBLFOFE CZBHF ,MFJO ����� .PZFS ����� 1JMMFS ���� BOE BEVMUT� QFSGPSNBODF DBO JNQSPWF NFBTVSBCMZ PWFS UJNF XJUIB TVCTUBOUJBM BNPVOU PG OBUJWF TQFBLFS JOQVU 'MFHF BOE -JV ����� 4PNF MJOHVJTUJD BTQFDUT BQQFBS UP CF NPSFBæFDUFE CZ BHF UIBO PUIFST� GPS JOTUBODF BEVMU &--T XJMM OFBSMZ BMXBZT SFUBJO BO JEFOUJmBCMF GPSFJHO BDDFOU JODMVEJOH UIPTF XIP EJTQMBZ QFSGFDU HSBNNBS� *O TIPSU &OHMJTI UFTU QFSGPSNBODF JT HFOFSBMMZ MJOFBSMZ SFMBUFE UPBHF PG BSSJWBM VQ UP QVCFSUZ� BGUFS QVCFSUZ QFSGPSNBODF JT MPX CVU IJHIMZ WBSJBCMF +PIOTPO BOE /FXQPSU �����2VSFTIJ �����

5IFSF JT DMFBS FWJEFODF UIBU UBQQJOH JOUP mSTU�MBOHVBHF MJUFSBDZ DBO DPOGFS BEWBOUBHFT UP &--T� 4FWFSBM NFUBOBMZTFTDVNVMBUJWF O � ��� TUVEJFT SFBDIFE UXP DPODMVTJPOT� 'JSTU JOTUSVDUJPOBM QSPHSBNT XPSL CFTU XIFO UIFZ QSPWJEFPQQPSUVOJUJFT GPS TUVEFOUT UP EFWFMPQ QSPmDJFODZ JO UIFJS mSTU MBOHVBHF (FOFTFF FU BM� ����� (SFFOF ����� 3PMTUBE .BIPOFZ BOE (MBTT ����� 4MBWJO BOE $IFVOH ����� 4FDPOE JOTUSVDUJPO JO POF�T OBUJWF MBOHVBHF BT XFMM BT JO&OHMJTI JNQSPWFT &OHMJTI SFBEJOH QSPmDJFODZ DPNQBSFE XJUI TUVEFOUT JOTUSVDUFE POMZ JO &OHMJTI O � �� TUVEJFT�*OTUSVDUJPOBM QSPHSBNT UIBU JOWFTU UJNF BOE SFTPVSDFT JOUP UIF EFWFMPQNFOU PG UIF mSTU MBOHVBHF MJUFSBDZ BSF NPSFFæFDUJWF UIBO UIPTF UIBU BSF &OHMJTI NFEJVN PS &OHMJTI POMZ QSPHSBNT� 5IFTF mOEJOHT DPODVS XJUI UIPTF PGWJSUVBMMZ BMM PG UIF PUIFS SFTFBSDI TZOUIFTFT JO UIJT BSFB (FOFTFF FU BM� ����� (SFFOF ����� 3PMTUBE .BIPOFZ BOE(MBTT ����� 4MBWJO BOE $IFVOH �����

1PMJDZ FWJEFODF GVSUIFS CPMTUFST UIF DBTF GPS CJMJOHVBM JOTUSVDUJPO� 1SPQPTJUJPOT TFWFSFMZ MJNJUJOH CJMJOHVBM JO�TUSVDUJPO JO UISFF TUBUFT MPXFSFE &OHMJTI QSPmDJFODZ BOE BDBEFNJD BDIJFWFNFOU BNPOH TUVEFOUT JNNFSTFE JO&OHMJTI�POMZ JOTUSVDUJPO BT XFMM BT TUVOUJOH UIF TVQQMZ PG CJMJOHVBM JOTUSVDUPST GPS EFDBEFT UP DPNF��� 6OGPSUV�OBUFMZ "NFSJDBO MFHJTMBUJPO GSPN UIF #JMJOHVBM &EVDBUJPO "DU PG ���� UP /P $IJME -FGU #FIJOE JO ���� IBT TIJGUFEDPOUJOVPVTMZ BXBZ GSPN CJMJOHVBM JOTUSVDUJPO BOE UPXBSE &OHMJTI�POMZ FEVDBUJPO XIJDI GVSUIFS DPOUSJCVUFT UP FE�

��" 4UBOGPSE 6OJWFSTJUZ TUVEZ GPVOE UIBU JO "SJ[POB UIF SFBEJOH BDIJFWFNFOU HBQ CFUXFFO &OHMJTI�MFBSOFST BOE OPO�&OHMJTI�MFBSOFSTJODSFBTFE CZ BCPVU ��� HSBEF MFWFMT GPS �UI BOE �UI HSBEFST� *O $BMJGPSOJB UIF HBQ JODSFBTFE BMNPTU BT ESBNBUJDBMMZ JO �UI HSBEF BOE TMJHIUMZJO �UI� *O .BTTBDIVTFUUT UIF BDIJFWFNFOU HBQ JODSFBTFE TPNFXIBU BU CPUI HSBEF MFWFMT CFUXFFO &--T BOE OBUJWF TQFBLFST (PMEFOCFSH�����

��

Page 26: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

VDBUJPOBM JOFRVJUZ TVæFSFE CZ FNFSHFOU CJMJOHVBMT (BSDÓB BOE ,MFJGHFO ����� #JMJOHVBM JOTUSVDUJPO JT BTTPDJBUFEXJUI B iNPEFSBUFw FæFDU TJ[F 1MPOTLZ BOE 0TXBME ���� BOE IBT OPU CFFO GPVOE UP EFMBZ PS IJOEFS &OHMJTI BU�UBJONFOU $VNNJOT ����� 5IJT mOEJOH DPODPSET XJUI RVBMJUBUJWF FWJEFODF MJOLJOH IJHIFS FEVDBUJPO BDIJFWFNFOUBNPOH TFDPOE HFOFSBUJPO JNNJHSBOU TUVEFOUT XJUI NBJOUBJOJOH UIFJS OBUJWF MBOHVBHFT BOE DVMUVSFT 1PSUFT BOE3VNCBVU �����

&OWJSPONFOUT CPUI JOTJEF BOE PVUTJEF PG UIF DMBTTSPPN TIBQF MBOHVBHF BUUBJONFOU BT XFMM� $POTJEFS UIBU QPWFSUZJT B TUSPOH QSFEJDUPS PG MBOHVBHF nVFODZ� DIJMESFO PO XFMGBSF IFBS BO BWFSBHF PG ��� XPSET BO IPVS XIJMF BæMVFOUDIJMESFO IFBS ��� BOE B EJæFSFODF PG �� NJMMJPO XPSET JO FYDIBOHFT XJUI BEVMUT TFQBSBUFT UIF UXP HSPVQT CZUIF BHF PG UISFF 1VUOBN ����� )BSU BOE 3JTMFZ ����� -BOHVBHF EFDBZT JO TJNJMBS XBZT UP PUIFS FEVDBUJPOBMBUUBJONFOUT BNPOH EJTBEWBOUBHFE HSPVQT� *O B ��ZFBS QBOFM TUVEZ PG JNNJHSBOU DIJMESFO O � ��� JO #PTUPO BOE4BO 'SBODJTDP (1"T ESPQQFE DPOTJTUFOUMZ PWFS UJNF BOE GBUIFS�T FNQMPZNFOU TUBUVT XBT B TUSPOH QSFEJDUPS PGBDBEFNJD BDIJFWFNFOU 4VÈSF[�0SP[DP 4VÈSF[�0SP[DP BOE 5PEPSPWB ����� 4DIPPM RVBMJUZ BMTP NBUUFST XJUIJNNJHSBOU TUVEFOUT NPSF MJLFMZ UP BUUFOE MPX�QFSGPSNJOH TDIPPMT BOE POMZ ��� PG QVCMJD TDIPPM UFBDIFST BSFUSBJOFE UP UFBDI &--T ,PEB ����� -FTT JT LOPXO BCPVU UIF FæFDU PG FOWJSPONFOUBM GBDUPST PO BEVMUT CVU UIFUJNF NPUJWBUJPO BOE FNPUJPOBM IFBMUI DPOTUSBJOUT JNQPTFE CZ QPWFSUZ MJLFMZ QMBZ B SPMF�

5BLFBXBZT� #JMJOHVBM JOTUSVDUJPO IBT CFFO GPVOE UP CF DPOTJTUFOUMZ NPSF FæFDUJWF UIBO &OHMJTI�POMZJNNFSTJPO� 1SPmDJFODZ JO POF�T OBUJWF MBOHVBHF JNQSPWFT TFDPOE MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ GVSUIFS BDDFM�FSBUFE CZ MJOHVJTUJD EJTUBODF UP &OHMJTI� .PUJWBUJPO BOE BHF BSF LFZ EFUFSNJOBOUT PG &OHMJTI MBOHVBHFBDRVJTJUJPO BT XFMM BT FOWJSPONFOUBM GBDUPST MJLF TDIPPM RVBMJUZ BOE QPWFSUZ�

.FUB�BOBMZTFT JEFOUJmFE UIF GPMMPXJOH QFEBHPHJDBM CFTU QSBDUJDFT XJUI B GPDVT PO DIJMESFO� 'PS B SFWJFX PG BQQTBJNFE BU BEVMU &--T TFF 4FDUJPO ��� JO UIF "QQFOEJY�

t 5FBDIJOH &OHMJTI VTJOH UIF MFBSOFS�T OBUJWF MBOHVBHF� #JMJOHVBM DMBTTSPPN DPOUFYUT BSF IVHFMZ WBSJFE CVUiIFSJUBHF MBOHVBHF TDIPPMTw BSF DPNNPO JO NVMUJDVMUVSBM TPDJFUJFT $SFFTF BOE #MBDLMFEHF ����

t 5ZQFT PG JOTUSVDUJPO UIBU IFMQ OBUJWF &OHMJTI TQFBLJOH DIJMESFO MFBSO UP SFBE JO &OHMJTI BSF BEWBOUBHFPVTGPS &--T BT XFMM� IPXFWFS UIF FæFDU TJ[FT BSF MPXFS BOE BEKVTUNFOUT BSF OFFEFE O � �� TUVEJFT� 5IJT NBZCF MJOLFE UP UIF mOEJOH UIBU TJNJMBS QSPQPSUJPOT PG &--T BOE NPOPMJOHVBM TQFBLFST BSF DMBTTJmFE BT QPPSSFBEFST BOE XPSE�MFWFM TLJMMT F�H� EFDPEJOH TQFMMJOH PG CPUI HSPVQT BSF WFSZ TJNJMBS� /PUF UIBU UIJT JT OPUUIF DBTF GPS UFYU�MFWFM TLJMMT F�H� SFBEJOH DPNQSFIFOTJPO XSJUJOH� 5IFTF TLJMMT SBSFMZ SFBDI MFWFMT FRVBM UPNPOPMJOHVBM &OHMJTI TQFBLFST O � ��� TUVEJFT "VHVTU 4IBOBIBO BOE &TDBNJMMB �����

t 7PDBCVMBSZ JOTUSVDUJPO EJWJEFE CZ QSBDUJDBM DPOUFOU BSFBT 4IPSU BOE 'JU[TJNNPOT ����� 'SFRVFOU FYQP�TVSF UP B XPSE JO NVMUJQMF GPSNT� FOTVSJOH VOEFSTUBOEJOH PG NFBOJOHT� QSPWJEJOH FYBNQMFT PG JUT VTF JOQISBTFT JEJPNT BOE VTVBM DPOUFYUT QSPOVODJBUJPO TQFMMJOH BOE XPSE QBSUT� BOE XIFO QPTTJCMF UFBDIJOHJUT DPHOBUFT PS B GBMTF DPHOBUF JO UIF MFBSOFS�T QSJNBSZ MBOHVBHF� 5IJT IFMQT SFNPWF WPDBCVMBSZ�SFMBUFEDPOTUSBJOUT UP QBTTJOH TUBOEBSEJ[FE UFTUT $BMEFSØO 4MBWJO BOE 4ÈODIF[ ����

t *OTUSVDUJPO UIBU DPWFST UIF LFZ DPNQPOFOUT PG SFBEJOH JEFOUJmFE CZ UIF /BUJPOBM 3FBEJOH 1BOFM QIPOFNJDBXBSFOFTT QIPOJDT nVFODZ WPDBCVMBSZ BOE UFYU DPNQSFIFOTJPO "VHVTU 4IBOBIBO BOE &TDBNJMMB ����

t 0QFO�FOEFE RVFTUJPOT BOE NVMUJQMF FYQPTVSF UP XPSET EVSJOH TIBSFE SFBEJOH IFMQ DIJMESFO LOPX IPX UPVTF UIPTF XPSET 3PCCJOT BOE &ISJ ����

t 5P CFDPNF HPPE SFBEFST o UP CF BCMF UP SFDPHOJ[F XPSET BOE DPNQSFIFOE B UFYU TJNVMUBOFPVTMZ o &OHMJTIMFBSOFST SFRVJSF QSBDUJDF BU CPUI EFDPEJOH BOE nVFODZ )BZOFT BOE (SBCF ����

��

Page 27: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

t 5IFSF JT OP TJOHMF BQQSPBDI UP XSJUJOH JOTUSVDUJPO UIBU XJMM NFFU UIF OFFET PG BMM TUVEFOUT� *O HFOFSBM UIFSFTFBSDI CBTF PO DSPTT�MJOHVJTUJD JOnVFODFT JO UIF BDRVJTJUJPO PG XSJUJOH JT TQBSTF $BMEFSPO BOE .JOBZB�3PXF ����

t "EFRVBUF BTTFTTNFOU TZTUFNT� "T UIF /BUJPOBM -JUFSBDZ 1BOFM IBT GPVOE BTTFTTNFOUT VTFE UP HBVHFMBOHVBHF�NJOPSJUZ TUVEFOUT� MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ BOE UP NBLF QMBDFNFOU BOE SFDMBTTJmDBUJPO EFDJTJPOTBSF JOBEFRVBUF JO NPTU SFTQFDUT "VHVTU 4IBOBIBO BOE &TDBNJMMB ����

� 4VSWFZ PG 1JMPUT 1SPHSBNT BOE 3$5T

#FMPX JT B SFWJFX PG TFMFDU FYQFSJNFOUT BOE QJMPUT XPSMEXJEF� * OPUF XIFSF TBNQMF TJ[FT BSF LOPXO XIFSF OPUSFBUNFOU FæFDUT XFSF GPVOE JO SFMBUFE JOUFSWFOUJPOT BOE XIFSF QSPHSBNT XFSF UBSHFUFE BU CPUI JNNJHSBOUT BOESFGVHFFT� #FTU QSBDUJDFT SFGFS UP HPWFSONFOU USJFE UFTUFE BOE SFDPNNFOEFE QSPHSBNT� 5BCMF ��� PVUMJOFT JO�UFSWFOUJPOT GPS UIF QSF�EFQBSUVSF QFSJPE TVHHFTUJOH QSPEVDUJWF VTFT PG XBJU UJNFT TVDI BT MBOHVBHF JOTUSVDUJPOPS DVMUVSBM PSJFOUBUJPO� 8IJMF UIF &VSPQFBO $PNNJTTJPO QSJPSJUJ[FT UIF QSF�EFQBSUVSF QFSJPE 6�4� 7PM"HT IBWFWJSUVBMMZ OP DPOUBDU XJUI SFGVHFFT GPS UIF UXP ZFBST PS NPSF CFGPSF UIFZ BSSJWF 5BCMF ������ 5BCMF ��� QSFTFOUTBDDFTT QPJOUT XJUI MPDBM IPTU DPNNVOJUJFT GPS UIF mSTU NPOUI BGUFS BSSJWBM� 4IJGUJOH UP FNQMPZNFOU�GPDVTFE JOUFS�WFOUJPOT 5BCMF ��� PVUMJOFT CSJEHJOH DPVSTFT KPC USBJOJOH SFDSFEFOUJBMJOH QSPHSBNT UBSHFUFENBJOMZ BU UIFNFEJVNUP IJHI TLJMMFE� 5IF mOBM UXP UBCMFT DPWFS mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ NJDSP�mOBODF BOE FOUSFQSFOFVSTIJQ QSPHSBNT 5BCMFT��� BOE ����

"WFSBHF JOUFSWFOUJPO EVSBUJPOT UFOE UP WBSZ CZ JTTVF BSFB JO UIF GPMMPXJOH XBZ CBTFE PO &6 QSBDUJDFT�

t 1SF�EFQBSUVSF QIBTF� � EBZT o � XFFLTt 8FMDPNF SFDFQUJPO QPTU�BSSJWBM PSJFOUBUJPO� � o � XFFLTt (SBEVBM USBOTJUJPO GSPN QBZJOH QBSUJBM UP GVMM SFOU� �� NPOUITt $BSFFS EFWFMPQNFOU�7&4-� � o �� NPOUITt *OUFSOTIJQT BOE CVTJOFTT JODVCBUPST� � o � NPOUITt 3F�DSFEFOUJBMJOH WJB UFTUJOH� � o � EBZT PG UFTUJOHt 'JOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ TFNJOBST� � o � IPVST

��4FF� UIF ���� "DUJPO 1MBO PO UIF *OUFHSBUJPO PG 5IJSE�$PVOUSZ /BUJPOBMT�

��

Page 28: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

��� 1SF�EFQBSUVSF 1SFQBSBUJPO

*OUFSWFOUJPO 5ZQF $PVOUSZ 4BNQMF %FQFOEFOU 7BSJBCMFT 3FTVMU

$VMUVSBM PSJFOUBUJPO WJB XFCJOBS PS4LZQF XJUI CJ�DVMUVSBM USBJOFS

(PWU�1SPHSBN

/FUIFSMBOET 'JOMBOE /PSXBZ

� ���SFGVHFFT/PSXBZ

"XBSFOFTT PG IPTU DPVOUSZ TPDJ�FUZ FYQFDUBUJPOT BCPVU BSSJWBM � SF�TFUUMFNFOU NJOJNJ[BUJPO PG DVMUVSFTIPDL

&�6� CFTU QSBDUJDF

3FGVHFF DPVOUSZ TFNJOBST GPS NV�OJDJQBMJUJFT BOE SFTFUUMFNFOU TFS�WJDF QSPWJEFST

(PWU�1SPHSBN

/PSXBZ ��� NVOJDJ�QBM XPSLFST

"XBSFOFTT PG DPVOUSJFT BOE DVM�UVSFT PG SFTFUUMFE SFGVHFFT ��SFGVHFF DPVOUSZ TFNJOBST IFME BTPG .BZ ����

&�6� CFTU QSBDUJDF

0OMJOF IFMQX� JEFOUJGZJOH QPUFOUJBMFNQMPZFST KPC TFBSDI TLJMMT � mMJOHGPS QSPGFTTJPOBM SFDFSUJmDBUJPO

1SPWJODF1SPHSBN

2VFCFD 3FGVHFFT 'BTUFS BDDSFEJUBUJPO KPC TFBSDI BT�TJTUBODF

&WBMVBUJPO VO�LOPXO QSPHSBNPO�HPJOH

���IPVS &OHMJTI�MBOHVBHF DPVSTFQJMPUFE CZ 13. JO DBNQT JO ,FOZB 5IBJMBOE BOE /FQBM

(PWU�1SPHSBN

6�4� 6�4��CPVOESFGVHFFT

#BTJD &OHMJTI QSPmDJFODZ *NQSPWFE QSFQB�SBUJPO BOE TFMG�DPOmEFODF

&BSMZ *OUFSWFOUJPO 1SPHSBN� MBO�HVBHF MFBSOJOH RVBMJmDBUJPOTSFDPHOJUJPO KPC TFBSDI IFMQ JOFBSMZ TUBHFT PG BQQMJDBUJPO

(PWU� 1J�MPU

(FSNBOZ ��� SFGVHFFT -BOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ DSFEFOUJBMTSFDPHOJUJPO JEFOUJGZJOH KPCT

4VDDFFEFE BOESPMMFE PVU OBUJPOBMMZ

��

Page 29: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

��� 1SPDFTTJOH "SSJWBM BOE $PNNVOJUZ &OHBHFNFOU

*OUFSWFOUJPO 5ZQF $PVOUSZ 4BNQMF %FQFOEFOU 7BSJBCMFT 3FTVMU

)BOEMJOH �TU SFDFQUJPO DFOUSBMMZ GPS�� EBZT X� JOUFSQSFUJOH TFSWJDFT QSPWJTJPO PG DMPUIJOH NFEJDBM DBSF DPVOTFMMJOH � DVMUVSBM PSJFOUBUJPO

(PWU�1SPHSBN

(FSNBOZ 3FGVHFFT *OUFHSBUJPO�FOIBODJOHBSSJWBM SFDFQUJPO

(FSNBO CFTU QSBDUJDF SFGVHFF�SFQPSUFE QPTJ�UJWF PQQPSUVOJUZ UP HFUCFBSJOHT MFBSO BCPVU UIFDPVOUSZ � EBJMZ SPVUJOFT � JEFOUJGZ UIF SJHIUDPOUBDU QFPQMF

%JSFDU BDDFTT UP BæPSEBCMF IPVTJOHXIJMF iTIJGUJOH UP SFOUw CBJM HMJT�TBOU JO 'SBODF� *ODSFNFOUBMMZ QBZSFOU QSPQPSUJPOBM UP JODPNF PWFS ��NPOUIT CFGPSF QBZJOH GVMM SFOU

(PWU�1SPHSBN

'SBODF EJSFDU IPVT�JOH� /FUIFSMBOETBOE 'JOMBOE

3FGVHFFT )PVTJOH JOEFQFOEFODF BU�� NPOUIT

'SFODI %VUDI BOE'JOOJTI CFTU QSBDUJDF

1FFS TVQQPSU GSPN TFUUMFE SFGVHFFT� WPMVOUFFST F�H� IFMQ TJHOJOH VQGPS TQPSUT DMVCT UVUPSJOH CJLJOHMFTTPOT mFME USJQT

(PWU�1SPHSBN

&�6� NPTU FYQBO�TJWF JO #FMHJVN

3FGVHFFT *OUFHSBUJPO�FOIBODJOHTPDJBM TVQQPSU

&�6� CFTU QSBDUJDF

i#BOL PG 0æFSTw X� WBSJFUZ PG JO�LJOE TFSWJDFT PæFSFE PO B WPMVOUBSZCBTJT UP TVQQPSU JOUFHSBUJPO� 1SP�NPUFE CZ SFMJHJPVT PSHT DPNQBOJFT� WPMVOUFFST

(PWU��1SJWBUF1SPHSBN

1PMBOE 3FGVHFFT *OUFHSBUJPO�FOIBODJOHBSSJWBM SFDFQUJPO

1PMJTI CFTU QSBDUJDF

-VUIFSBO *NNJHSBUJPO 4FSWJDFT�#3:$4 QSPHSBN� EP[FOT PGQSPHSBNT OBUJPOBMMZ DPPSEJOBUJOHCFUXFFO SFGVHFF TFSWJDF QSPWJEFST SFMJHJPVT PSHBOJ[BUJPOT BOE MPDBMWPMVOUFFST UP MJOL SFGVHFFT X� JOGP USBJOJOH � FEVDBUJPO QSPHSBNT USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE "NFSJDBOiCVEEJFTw

1SJWBUF1SPHSBN

6�4� �����T PGSFGVHFFT

-BOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ DIJMESFO FOSPMNFOUJO )FBE 4UBSU TPDJBMTVQQPSU QTZDIPMPHJDBMXFMM�CFJOH

4VCTUBOUJBM VQ�UBLF BOEJNQSPWFE PVUDPNFT JOTPNF TVC�QSPHSBNT

��

Page 30: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

��

Page 31: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

��� 5SBJOJOH 3F�DSFEFOUJBMJOH BOE &NQMPZNFOU

*OUFSWFOUJPO 5ZQF $PVOUSZ 4BNQMF %FQFOEFOU 7BSJBCMFT 3FTVMU

5IF *.13*/5 DPOTPSUJVN XPSLTEJSFDUMZ XJUI FNQMPZFST UP NFOUPS USBJO WJB 7&4- SF�DSFEFOUJBM BOEQMBDF JNNJHSBOUT

/(01SPHSBN

6�4� �$BOBEB

7PDBUJPOBMMZ�USBJOFE JNNJ�HSBOUT

3F�DSFEFOUJBMJOH &OHMJTIQSPmDJFODZ NFOUPSTIJQ KPCQMBDFNFOU

���ZFBS OBUJPOBM QSP�HSBNT OBUJPO�XJEF TFSWFE �� ���� JN�NJHSBOUT XJUI TPNFQSPHSBNT FYQBOEFE UPSFGVHFFT SFDFOUMZ

6OJ� PG .FUSPQPMJB�T 5FDIOPMPHZBOE &OHJOFFSJOH 1JMPU 1SPHSBN�UFTUT NBUI EJHJUBM DPNQFUFODF �FOHJOFFSJOH UFTUT JO "SBCJD &OHMJTI� 'JOOJTI

(PWU� 1J�MPU

'JOMBOE �� SFGVHFFT X�UFDIOPMPHZ PSFOHJOFFSJOHCBDLHSPVOE

4LJMMT BDDSFEJUBUJPO "MNPTU BMM QBSUJDJQBOUTDFSUJmFE SPMMFE PVU OB�UJPOBMMZ� "MTP QSPNJTJOH�&�6� XJMM IBWF ��� ���VOGVMmMMFE UFDI WBDBO�DJFT JO ����

'BTU USBDLJOH TLJMMFE SFGVHFFT JOUPTIPSUBHF PDDVQBUJPOT WJB WPDBUJPOBMUSBJOJOH QBUIT TFU VQ CZ DPNQBOJFTBOE UIF QVCMJD TFDUPS �� PDDVQB�UJPOT

(PWU�1SPHSBN

4XFEFO (FSNBOZ

)JHI�TLJMMSFGVHFFT

5SBJOJOH DFSUJmDBUJPO NFO�UPSJOH WPDBUJPOBM MBOHVBHFQSPmDJFODZ BOE XPSL QMBDF�NFOU

&�6� CFTU QSBDUJDF BT FN�QMPZFST USVTU UIF SFTVMUTPG WPDBUJPOBM USBJOJOHUIFZ EFTJHOFE

1BJE JOUFSOTIJQT BU 4JFNFOT �1PSTDIF GPS SFGVHFFT X� HSBEVBUFEFHSFFT BOE (FSNBO�&OHMJTI QSPm�DJFODZ JOD� XPSLQMBDF PSJFOUBUJPO TLJMMT BTTFTTNFOU � USBJOJOH BOEBOUJ�EJTDSJNJOBUJPO TUBæ DBNQBJHO

(PWU��1SJWBUF1JMPU

(FSNBOZ ��� IJHI�TLJMMSFGVHFFT

5SBJOJOH BDDSFEJUBUJPO BQ�QSFOUJDFTIJQ FNQMPZNFOU

4FDPOE FEJUJPO SPMMFE PVUJO /PW� ���� ����� CFO�FmDJBSJFT BU 1PSTDIF OPXFNQMPZFE UIFSF

,JSPO 0QFO )JHIFS &EVDBUJPO� ��VOJWFSTJUJFT PæFS POMJOF � JO�QFSTPO DMBTTFT OP (FSNBO SFRVJSFEJOJUJBMMZ

(PWU��1SJWBUFQSPHSBN

(FSNBOZ � ����SFGVHFFT

3FNPUF F�MFBSOJOH BOE BD�DSFEJUBUJPO PG VOJWFSTJUZ DSFE�JUT PCUBJOFE UIJT XBZ

&WBMVBUJPO VOLOPXO PO�HPJOH QSPHSBN

8PSME &EVDBUJPO 4FSWJDFT BMUFSOB�UJWF RVBMJmDBUJPOT BTTFTTNFOU� SF�DPOTUSVDUT BDBEFNJD IJTUPSJFT BOEBEWJTFT PO FRVJWBMFODZ PG DSFEFO�UJBMT XIFO EPDVNFOUBUJPO VOBWBJM�BCMF

1SJWBUF1SPHSBN

$BOBEB 4ZSJBOSFGVHFFT

"DBEFNJD BUUFTUBUJPO �SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH GPS 4ZSJBOSFGVHFFT

1JMPU QIBTF

/PSXFHJBO "HFODZ GPS 2VBMJUZ "T�TVSBODF JO &EVDBUJPO /0,65 BD�DSFEJUBUJPO QSPHSBN CBTFE PO BDB�EFNJDT� BTTFTTNFOU BOE XSJUUFOUFTUT

(PWU�1SPHSBN

/PSXBZ ���� SFGVHFFBQQMJDBOUT

"DDSFEJUBUJPO ������� BQQMJDBOUT PC�UBJOFE SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH PWFS IBMG PG UIPTF UIFOGPVOE SFMFWBOU KPCT JO/PSXBZ BOE ��� XFSFTBUJTmFE XJUI UIF TFSWJDF

4XFEJTI CSJEHJOH DPVSTFT GPS SFD�PHOJ[JOH RVBMJmDBUJPOT PG IJHIMZRVBMJmFE JNNJHSBOUT NFEJDBM QSP�GFTTJPOBMT UFBDIFST BOE MBXZFST

(PWU�1SPHSBN

4XFEFOTJTUFS QSP�HSBNT JO/PSXBZ BOE6,

)JHI�TLJMMJNNJHSBOUT �SFGVHFFT

1SPGFTTJPOBM BDDSFEJUBUJPO 'PSFJHO�RVBMJmFE UFBDI�FST XIP QBSUJDJQBUFE JOUIF DPVSTFT XFSF ���NPSF MJLFMZ UP mOE SFMF�WBOU FNQMPZNFOU

��

Page 32: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

��� 'JOBODJBM -JUFSBDZ

*OUFSWFOUJPO 5ZQF $PVOUSZ 4BNQMF %FQFOEFOU 7BSJBCMFT 3FTVMU

'JOBODJBM FEVDBUJPO TFNJOBSIFME GPS *OEJBO NJHSBOUT 4F�TIBO BOE :BOH ����

'JFME &Y�QFSJNFOU

2BUBS ��� *OEJBO NJ�HSBOU DPVQMFT��� USFBUFEIVTCBOET

'JOBODJBM� TBWJOHT LOPXMFEHF� QSBDUJDFT

5SFBUFE QBSUJDJQBOUT XFSF �����NPSF MJLFMZ UP MJTUFO UP mOBO�DJBM NBUUFST SBEJP TIPX ����QFSDFOUBHF�QPJOUT NPSF MJLFMZ UPNBLF mOBODJBM EFDJTJPOT XJUIUIFJS XJWFT BEWPDBUFE CZ UIFTFNJOBS BOE NPSF MJLFMZ UPEFNPOTUSBUF TPVOE mOBODJBM BOETBWJOHT QSBDUJDFT ����� NPOUITBGUFS UIF JOUFSWFOUJPO

8PSME #BOL 3$5 UP JOEVDFTBWJOHT BNPOH NJHSBOUTUISPVHI mOBODJBM FEVDBUJPOBJNFE FJUIFS BU NJHSBOUT UIF GBNJMJFT PG NJHSBOUT PSCPUI UIF NJHSBOU BOE UIFJSGBNJMZ %PJ .D,FO[JF BOE;JB ����

'JFME &Y�QFSJNFOU

*OEPOFTJB ��� NJHSBOUIPVTFIPMET��� USFBUFE

'JOBODJBM�TBWJOHT LOPXMFEHF� QSBDUJDFT

5SFBUNFOU JODSFBTFE LOPXMFEHFPG NJHSBOU JOTVSBODF � DPTUPG B SFNJUUBODF USBOTBDUJPOCZ ���� BOE ��� QFSDFOUBHF�QPJOUT� 5SFBUFE IPVTFIPMET ��QFSDFOUBHF�QPJOUT NPSF MJLFMZUP IBWF QSFQBSFE DBTI SFDPSET TBWFE BOE PQFOFE B CBOLBDDPVOU JO UIF QBTU � NPOUIT

7BSZJOH NJHSBOU DPOUSPM PWFS&M 4BMWBEPS�CBTFE TBWJOHTCZ PæFSJOH EJæFSFOU UZQFTPG BDDPVOUT BDSPTT USFBUNFOUHSPVQT "TISBG FU BM� ����

'JFME &Y�QFSJNFOU

6�4� ��� NJ�HSBOUT GSPN&M�4BMWBEPS

4BWJOHT .JHSBOUT PæFSFE UIF HSFBUFTU EF�HSFF PG DPOUSPM BDDVNVMBUFE UIFNPTU TBWJOHT BU UIF QBSUOFS CBOL DPNQBSFE UP PUIFST PæFSFE MFTTPS OP DPOUSPM PWFS TBWJOHT

'JOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ QSPHSBNT,BSVOBSBUIOF BOE (JCTPO����

'JFME &Y�QFSJNFOU

"VTUSBMJB� /FX;FBMBOE

1BDJmD JT�MBOEFS FBTU"TJBO �4SJ -BOLBONJHSBOUT

'JOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ LOPXMFEHF VTF PG DIFBQFS SFNJUUBODFQSPEVDUT BNPVOU � GSF�RVFODZ PG SFNJUUBODFT

4NBMM JODSFBTF JO LOPXMFEHF CVUOP FæFDU UIF VTF PG DIFBQFSSFNJUUBODF QSPEVDUT PS PO UIFBNPVOU BOE GSFRVFODZ PG TFOEJOHNPOFZ IPNF

��

Page 33: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

��� .JDSP�mOBODF BOE &OUSFQSFOFVSTIJQ

*OUFSWFOUJPO 5ZQF $PVOUSZ 4BNQMF %FQFOEFOU 7BSJBCMFT 3FTVMU

.POUIMZ TUBSU�VQ DMBTTFT BMMPXJOHSFGVHFFT UP DPOOFDU X� MPDBM CVTJ�OFTT DPNNVOJUZ UBLF DMBTTFT JO"SBCJD SFDFJWF NFOUPSJOH � MFHBMBTTJTUBODF

(FSNBOZ (PWU� 1J�MPU

3FGVHFFT JO#FSMJO

4UBSU�VQ TVQQPSU 4UJMM JO QJMPU QIBTF CZ (FSNBO$IBNCFS PG 5SBEF BOE *OEVTUSZ*),

*ODVCBUPS GPS *NNJHSBOUT QSPHSBNTJNJMBS UP (FSNBO QSPHSBN BCPWF

/FUIFSMBOET (PWU� 1J�MPU

3FGVHFF FO�USFQFOFVST

4UBSU�VQ TVQQPSU �� CVTJOFTT QMBOT GSPN BTZMVNTFFLFST BOE SFGVHFFT MFTT UIBO BZFBS BGUFS MBVODIJOH NJE�����

6/)$3 iHSBEVBUJPO BQQSPBDI�NJDSP�mOBODF QSPHSBN XIFSFSFGVHFFT QBTT JODSFNFOUBM TUFQTGSPN mOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ USBJOJOH UP NJDSP�HSBOUT UP NJDSP�MPBOT�5SFBUNFOUT� TFMG�FNQMPZNFOU USBDL4&5 � XBHF�FNQMPZNFOU USBDL8&5

6/)$3QSPHSBN

&HZQU � ��� MPX�JODPNF4ZSJBOSFGVHFFT

*ODPNF KPC QMBDFNFOU TUBSU�VQ DSFBUJPO � TVS�WJWBM

*ODPNF JODSFBTFE CZ �� o ���TUJMM DBOOPU NFFU CBTJD OFFET POMZ ������ PG 8&54 SFUBJOFEKPCT BGUFS � NPOUIT ������ PG4&5T PQFOFE CVTJOFTTFT CVU NB�KPSJUZ GPMEFE JO � NPOUIT

��� &�6� #FTU 1SBDUJDFT

8IJMF OPU ZFU EFWFMPQFE JOUP &6�XJEF QSPHSBNT CFMPX JT B DPNQJMBUJPO PG SFDPNNFOEBUJPOT QSPQPTFE CZ UIF&�6� UP NFNCFS�TUBUFT JO PSEFS UP JNQSPWF SFTFUUMFNFOU PVUDPNFT %FTJEFSJP �����

t *ODSFBTFE DPNNVOJDBUJPO BOE DPPQFSBUJPO CFUXFFO TUBLFIPMEFST F�H� TUFFSJOH DPNNJUUFFT RVBSUFSMZ NFFU�JOHT

t "EFRVBUF JOGPSNBUJPO BOE DVMUVSBM PSJFOUBUJPO BU QSF�EFQBSUVSF TUBHF UP QSFQBSF DBOEJEBUFT GPS USBOTGFS BOENBOBHF FYQFDUBUJPOT

t &BSMZ NFEJDBM BTTFTTNFOUT BOE DPPSEJOBUJPO XJUI MPDBM IFBMUI TUBæt %JSFDU BOE JNNFEJBUF BDDFTT UP IPVTJOH JEFBMMZ XJUIPVU QBTTJOH UISPVHI SFDFQUJPO DFOUFSTt 4PDJBM JOWPMWFNFOU GSPN WPMVOUFFST F�H� FOHBHJOH MPDBM DIVSDIFT BOE DPNNVOJUZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOT BOE QSFQBS�JOH UIFN GPS SFGVHFF BSSJWBMT

t (FPHSBQIJD BTTJHONFOU OFBS VSCBO DFOUFST

��� $BOBEJBO #FTU 1SBDUJDFT

5IF $BOBEJBO HPWFSONFOU QSPEVDFE B TJNJMBS TFU PG TVHHFTUJPOT BJNFE BU JNQSPWJOH SFTFUUMFNFOU PVUDPNFT *N�NJHSBUJPO BOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB �����

t %JSFDUMZ DPNNVOJDBUJOH XJUI BMM SFGVHFFT BCPVU UIF TFSWJDFT BWBJMBCMF UP UIFN UP SFCVæ PVUEBUFE PS JOBD�DVSBUF JOGPSNBUJPO GSPN GBNJMZ BOE GSJFOET

��

Page 34: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

t .BLJOH USBOTMBUJPO TFSWJDFT BWBJMBCMF BU BMM TFUUMFNFOU TFSWJDFT BHFODJFT SFGVHFFT DJUF UIJT BT UIF MBSHFTUCBSSJFS UP BDDFTTJOH TFUUMFNFOU TFSWJDFT� 5PP PGUFO MBOHVBHF TVQQPSU JT BE�IPD BOE QSP�CPOP� 4FSWJDFQSPWJEFST TIPVME QBSUOFS TP UIBU POF USBOTMBUPS FTQFDJBMMZ JO B MFTTFS TQPLFO MBOHVBHF DBO PæFS BTTJTUBODFUP EJæFSFOU QSPHSBNT�PçDFT CBTFE PO EFNBOE

t $PWFSJOH USBOTQPSUBUJPO DPTUT FTQFDJBMMZ GPS SFGVHFFT JO SVSBM BSFBT F�H� CVML CVT BOE UBYJ QBTTFT UP IFMQBDDFTT TFSWJDFT BOE FNQMPZNFOU PQQPSUVOJUJFT

t 0O�UIF�KPC USBJOJOH XJUI B $BOBEJBO DPNQBOZ PS PSHBOJ[BUJPO XIJDI DBO QSPWJEF WBMVF UP QPUFOUJBM FNQMPZ�FST BOE BMMPX SFGVHFFT UP MFBSO XPSLQMBDF OPSNT� 5IJT DBO JODMVEF FYQBOEJOH JOUFSOTIJQ BOE NFOUPSTIJQQSPHSBNT CVU EFQFOET PO FNQMPZFST� XJMMJOHOFTT UP UBLF QBSU BOE DBO CF PWFS�TVCTDSJCFE� 1SFEJDUFE MBCPSTIPSUBHFT TIPVME CF MFWFSBHFE

t 4USFBNMJOJOH UIF QSPDFTT PG SFDPHOJ[JOH GPSFJHO DSFEFOUJBMTt +PC�NBUDIJOH TVQQPSU PS TVCTJEJ[FE IJSFTt 1SFMJNJOBSZ TLJMMT BTTFTTNFOU BT QBSU PG PSJFOUBUJPO QSPHSBN CVU TQFDJmD FOPVHI UP CF VTFGVM GPS KPC NBUDI�JOH QVSQPTFT

� 1BUIT 'PSXBSE BOE $PODMVTJPOT

%FTQJUF B MBSHF QPUFOUJBM UP DPOUSJCVUF BOE UISJWF SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6�4� $BOBEB BOE &VSPQF PGUFO TUSVHHMF UPmOE BEFRVBUF FNQMPZNFOU BOE DBO UBLF EFDBEFT UP FTDBQF MPX�JODPNF USBQT� .BOZ PG UIF SJTL GBDUPST BSF XFMM�LOPXO� MBDL PG MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ SFDPHOJUJPO PG GPSFJHO DSFEFOUJBMT BOE BæPSEBCMF IPVTJOH MPDBUFE OFBS VSCBODFOUFST BNPOH PUIFST� 5IF JNQBDU PG PUIFS GBDUPST MJLF FUIOJD FODMBWFT PS XPSLomSTU SFTFUUMFNFOU NPEFMT BSFMFTT BQQBSFOU� .PSF MPOHJUVEJOBM EBUB BSF OFFEFE GPS B XJEFS BSSBZ PG PVUDPNFT F�H� VOJWFSTJUZ BENJTTJPO SBUFT TFDPOEBSZ NJHSBUJPO UP FTUBCMJTI HSPVOE USVUIT BCPVU SFGVHFF USBKFDUPSJFT o BOE IPX UIFTF EJæFS CZ TVC�HSPVQ JOUIJT JODSFEJCMZ EJWFSTF QPQVMBUJPO� 5IF IJHI EFHSFF PG IFUFSPHFOFJUZ XJUIJO UIF SFGVHFF DPNNVOJUZ QPTFT DMFBSDIBMMFOHFT JO QSPHSBNT EFTJHO BOE UBSHFUJOH� -FWFSBHJOH HFPHSBQIJD QMBDFNFOU BMHPSJUINT UIBU JOUFSBDU QFSTPOBMDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT XJUI QMBDF UP PQUJNJ[F FNQMPZNFOU QSPCBCJMJUJFT BT XFMM BT PæFSJOH CJMJOHVBM &-- JOTUSVDUJPOXIFSF QPTTJCMF BSF UXP JOUFSWFOUJPOT UIBU DBO BDDPNNPEBUF UIJT EJWFSTJUZ�

4JY JOUFSWFOUJPO TQBDFT JO QBSUJDVMBS TFFN FODPVSBHJOH HJWFO UIF FWJEFODF SFWJFXFE IFSF� 5IFTF JOUFSWFOUJPOTXPSLXJUIJO DVSSFOU 6�4� QPMJDZ DPOTUSBJOUT HFBSFE UPXBSE UIF ����EBZ FNQMPZNFOU PVUDPNF CZ BJNJOH UP FOIBODFMBCPS NBSLFU QSPTQFDUT XJUIPVU EFMBZJOH FNQMPZNFOU� 5BCMF � CFMPX QSPWJEFT FTUJNBUFT SFHBSEJOH UIF GFBTJCJMJUZ DPTU�FæFDUJWFOFTT BOE MJLFMZ FæFDU TJ[FT PG JOUFSWFOUJPOT JO UIFTF TQBDFT� 5IFTF SFDPNNFOEBUJPOT BEKVEJDBUFCFUXFFO JOUFSWFOUJPOT CBDLFE CZ FWJEFODF JO UIF 6�4� BOE FMTFXIFSF BOE UIPTF UIBU UBDLMF TQBDFT LOPXO UP CFJNQPSUBOU GPS JOUFHSBUJPO F�H� IPVTJOH QMBDFNFOU XIFSF TDBOU TZTUFNBUJD FWBMVBUJPOT FYJTU�

�� 3F�DSFEFOUJBMJOH QPTTJCMZ WJB FYUFSOBM UFTUJOH CZ QPUFOUJBM FNQMPZFST JO UIF QSJWBUF TFDUPS SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH/(0T PS VOJWFSTJUJFT UIBU UFTU QBSUJDVMBS TLJMM TFUT F�H� BDDPVOUJOH DPEJOH� (JWFO UIBU SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOHJUTFMG EPFT OPU SFRVJSF USBJOJOH UIFTF QSPHSBNT MFWFSBHF FYJTUJOH IVNBO DBQJUBM BU MPX DPTUT� $BTFXPSLFSTDPVME BMTP CF USBJOFE UP JEFOUJGZ IJHI�DBQBDJUZ JOEJWJEVBMT UP GBTU�USBDL GPS SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH���

�� 1MBDFNFOU BTTJHONFOUT� $JUZ BOE OFJHICPSIPPE FæFDUT TFFN TJHOJmDBOU BOE SBOEPNJ[BUJPO DPVME PDDVSJO UIF QMBDFNFOU QSPDFTT TVCKFDU UP FUIJDBM DPOTUSBJOUT BDSPTT BOE XJUIJO DJUJFT�

��5IF TVDDFTT PG EJæFSFOU TFSWJDF QSPWJTJPO NPEFMT UIFNTFMWFT IBT SFDFJWFE TDBOU BUUFOUJPO JO UIJT SFWJFX� 5IFSF BQQFBST UP CF MBSHFBNPVOUT PG WBSJBUJPO JO TFSWJDF QSPWJTJPO NPEFMT BU UIF MPDBM MFWFM BOE WBSJPVT NPEFMT F�H� JOUFHSBUJWF WT� QJFDF�NFBM MJLFMZ IBWF BTJHOJmDBOU FæFDU PO SFTFUUMFNFOU PVUDPNFT 4JNJDI FU BM� ����� 'PS UIJT SFBTPO BEKVTUJOH BOE TUBOEBSEJ[JOH TFSWJDF QSPWJTJPO NPEFMTDPVME CF B GSVJUGVM BWFOVF�

��

Page 35: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

�� %JSFDU DBTI BOE JOWFTUNFOU DBQJUBM GPS SFGVHFFT� 5IJT JODMVEFT NBUDIFE NJDSP�TBWJOHT DPOEJUJPOBM MPBOTF�H� UJFE UP FEVDBUJPOBM BUUBJONFOU PS CVTJOFTT TUBSU�VQ TVQQPSU GPS UIPTF XJUI B CVTJOFTT PXOFSTIJQ CBDL�HSPVOE�

�� 7PDBUJPOBM &4- BT BO JOEFQFOEFOU QSPHSBN PS BT QBSU PG B SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH PS USBJOJOH QBDLBHF� &OHMJTIQSPmDJFODZ JT TUSPOHMZ DPSSFMBUFEXJUI FNQMPZNFOU SBUFT BOE FBSOJOHT BOE7&4- JT BO FTUBCMJTIFE BMUIPVHIVOEFS�FWBMVBUFE NFUIPE PG FOIBODJOH UIF FNQMPZBCJMJUZ PG SFGVHFFT JO UIFJS QSPGFTTJPOBM mFMET�

�� 1SJWBUF DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ UIBU DPOOFDUT SFGVHFFT UP B OFUXPSL PG JOEJWJEVBMT JO B IPTU DPNNVOJUZ� 5IJTDBO SBOHF GSPN GPSNBM DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ XJUI IJHI mOBODJBM BOE UJNF DPNNJUNFOUT QFSIBQT NBUDIFE PO PD�DVQBUJPOBM TFDUPS UP NPSF MJHIU�UPVDI FOHBHFNFOU PG MPDBM DIVSDIFT TDIPPMT BOE WPMVOUFFS HSPVQT F�H�iCVEEZw TZTUFNT UIBU DPWFS BDUJWJUJFT MJLF TVQFSNBSLFU USJQT UVUPSJOH BOE BQBSUNFOU�IVOUJOH UIBU DBO QSP�WJEF QSBDUJDBM BEWJDF FNPUJPOBM TVQQPSU KPC TFBSDI TVQQPSU BOE FWFO TVQQMFNFOUBSZ mOBODJBM TVQQPSU�

�� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQT� 8PSL FYQFSJFODF JO UIF IPTU DPVOUSZ JT PGUFO IJHIMZ WBMVFE BOE BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BSFFYQBOEJOH JO UIF 6�4� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQ USBDLT GPS SFGVHFFT GPDVTFE PO MPDBM CPPN JOEVTUSJFT IBWF QSPWFOTVDDFTTGVM JO UIF 6�4� BOE &VSPQF CVU B NPEFM GPS TDBMJOH VQ UP SFHJPOBM PS OBUJPOBM TDIFNFT JT OFFEFE�

3FTPVSDF DPOTUSBJOUT JO UIF "NFSJDBO SFTFUUMFNFOU QSPHSBN UIF BWBJMBCJMJUZ PG MBSHF QPPMT PG WPMVOUFFST BOE UIFFçDBDZ PG WPMVOUFFS�MFE QSPHSBNT BCSPBE FODPVSBHF PVUTPVSDJOH TPNF TFSWJDFT UP MPDBM DPNNVOJUJFT� 1SPHSBNTUIBU DPNCJOF DPNNVOJUZ TVQQPSU XJUI mOBODJBM BTTJTUBODF TFFN QBSUJDVMBSMZ QSPNJTJOH� 5IF FWJEFODF SFWJFXFEIFSF TVHHFTUT UIBU QSJWBUF DP�TQPOTPSTIJQ BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BOE EJSFDU DBTI USBOTGFST BSF XFMM�QPTJUJPOFE UP PWFS�DPNF UIF OFUXPSL FDPOPNJD BOE MJOHVJTUJD DPOTUSBJOUT GBDFE CZ SFGVHFFT� 5IF SFMBUJWF JNQPSUBODF PG NFOUPSTIJQWT� mOBODJBM TVQQPSU o UIF LFZ DPNQPOFOUT PG TQPOTPSTIJQ o SFNBJOT VOLOPXO IPXFWFS� *O BEEJUJPO QSPHSBNTUIBU JODMVEF mOBODJBM BTTJTUBODF XPVME CFOFmU GSPN TIBSFE MFBSOJOH BOE UJF�JOT XJUI QSPHSBNT UIBU UBSHFU MPX�JODPNF "NFSJDBOT� 'PS JOTUBODF CPUI QPQVMBUJPOT SJTL MPTJOH FMJHJCJMJUZ GPS CBEMZ�OFFEFE XFMGBSF BTTJTUBODF CZBDDFQUJOH EJSFDU DBTI USBOTGFST� $SFBUJWF XPSL�BSPVOET DPVME JODMVEF NBUDIFE NJDSP�TBWJOHT PS UBSHFUJOH TNBMMGBNJMJFT JO TUBUFT XJUI MPX XFMGBSF DPWFSBHF JO PSEFS UP SFEVDF UIF PQQPSUVOJUZ DPTU PG GPSFHPJOH XFMGBSF BTTJTUBODF�8IJDIFWFS SPVUFT BSF UBLFO VQ CZ UIPTF PG VT XPSLJOH PO SFGVHFF JOUFHSBUJPO BO JODPOTJTUFOU EBUB MBOETDBQF BOEPO�HPJOH NJHSBOU DSJTJT SFOEFS UIF OFFE GPS TDIPMBST UP QBSUOFS XJUI TFSWJDF QSPWJEFST NPSF JNQPSUBOU UIBO FWFS�

��

Page 36: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5BCMF�

�'FBTJC

JMJUZ

$IFDLT

GPS1

PTTJC

MF*OUFSWFO

UJPO4Q

BDFT

*OUFSWFO

UJPO4Q

BDF

5BSHFU

(SPVQ

T

$PTU

4DBMBC

MF 4I

PSU�UFSN

FWBMVB

UJPO

QPTTJCMF

&æFDUT

J[F

&WJEFO

DF

3F�DSFEF

OUJBMJO

H1SPGFTTJP

OBMJ[

FE�

IJHI

�TLJMM

SFGVHF

FT

UFFO

BHFST

BOE

BEVMUT

PGBMMB

HFT

-PXo.

FEJVN

JGSF�

DSFE

FOUJB

MJOH

XJUI

PVU

BEEJUJP

OBM

USBJOJOH

EFQ

FOET

PODP

TUTPG

QBSUO

FSTI

JQT

*GEP

OFUISPVH

IDPSQP

SBUF

QBSUO

FST

PS/(

0�T

UIBU

EFTJH

ODFSUJ

mDBUJPOT

ZFT

CVUJG

EPOF

CZDSFBUJO

HFY

QFSU

QBOF

MT�

VOJWFS�

TJUZUFTUJ

OHTZTUF

NTG

SPN

TDSBUDI

MFTTT

P

:FT

F�H�

UFTU

QBTT

SBUF

PSBQ

QMJDBO

UDFSUJm

DBUJP

OSBUF

-JLF

MZUP

IBWF

BMBSHF

BWFSBH

FFæ

FDU

TJ[F

POCJOB

SZPV

UDPN

FTMJL

FUFTU�

QBTTJOH

TJODF

CBTF�

MJOF

VOEF

SFNQMPZ

NFO

UJT

TPIJHI

�#F

UUFSKPC

PQQP

SUVOJUJF

TXJMM

MJLFMZ

IBWF

GBNJMZ

TQJMMPW

FSFæ

FDUT

4USPOH

FWJEFO

DFUIBU

SF�DSFEF

OUJBMJO

HJT

VSHF

OUUP

BWPJE

FSPE

JOH

IVNBO

DBQJUBMB

OEBDDFTTJOH

UIFMBCP

SNBS�

LFU�

*.13

*/5

SF�DSFEF

OUJBM

QSP�

HSBN

TUBSHF

UJOHT

QFDJmD

QSPGFTTJP

OTJO

UIF6

�4�I

BWFS

F�DFSUJ

mFE��

���

�JN

�NJHSBOUT

&�6�

JOJUJBUJWFT

XJUI

DPN�

QBOJFT

4JFNFO

T 1P

STDI

F V

OJWF

STJ�

UJFT�

QVCMJD

TFDUP

SEP

DUPST MBX

ZFST

UFBDIF

STC

PPTU

KPCQMBDFN

FOU

1MBDFN

FOUMPD

BUJPO

"MMSFGVHF

FT-P

XBE

EJUJP

OBM

DPTUT

HJWF

OUIBU

IPVT

JOH

BTTJH

ONFO

UJT

QBSU

PGQSPD

FTTJO

HBO

ZXBZ

�"JS

#AO�#

QBSUO

FSTI

JQDP

VME

ESJWF

EPXODP

TUT

:FT

IPVT

JOH

BTTJT

UBOD

FBMSFBE

ZQB

SUPG

QSPD

FTT�

JOHGPSB

MMSFGVHF

FT

1PTTJCMZ

F�H�

SBUFT

PGUSB

OTQP

SUBUJP

OOF

UXPSL

�SFTFUUMFN

FOU

BHFO

DZPç

DFVT

F FN

QMPZ

NFO

URV

BMJUZ

�NPO

UITM

BUFS

)PV

TJOHM

PDBUJPO�

RVBM�

JUZBSFL

FZUP

NZSJBEPV

U�DP

NFT T

PMJL

FMZMBSHFFG�

GFDU

TJ[FT

POBU

MFBTUTPN

FPV

UDPN

FT

)PV

TJOH

MPDBUJP

OJT

LFZ

GPSTFSWJDF

VTF

USBOTQP

SUBUJP

O�

KPCBDDFTT C

VUUIFSFJ

TMJUUMF

TZTUF

NBUJD

FWJEFO

DFFTUJ�

NBUJOHU

IFFæ

FDUP

GIPV

TJOHD

IBSBDUF

S�JTU

JDTPO

UIFTFPV

UDPN

FTTFDPO

EBSZ

NJHSBUJP

OBMTP

BOJTT

VF

*OWF

TUNFO

UDBQJUBM

FOUSFQSFO

FVSJB

MTV

QQPSU

�FE

VDB�

UJPOB

MMPB

OT

)JHI

NPUJWBUJPO

BEVMUSFGVH

FFT

.FE

JVN

EFQF

OET

POMPBO

TJ[FT

�SFQB

ZNFO

USBUFT

4DBMBC

MFDP

OEJUJPO

BMPO

FçDJFO

UMZJEFO

UJGZJOH

TVJUB

CMFD

BOEJEB

UFT

:FT F�H

�DSFBUJPOP

GCVT

J�OF

TTQMBO

PSPC

UBJOJOHMJ�

DFOT

FGPSFO

USFQSFO

FVST

FEVD

BUJPOB

MFOSPMNFO

U�BUUBJONFO

UBN

POH

TUV�

EFOUT

%FQ

FOET

PORV

BMJUZ

PGDBOE

JEBUF

TCV

UMJL

FMZMBSHF

4NBMM�T

DBMF

JODV

CBUPST

BOE

FO�

USFQSFO

FVS

NFO

UPSTIJQ

QSPH

SBNT

TVDDFTTGV

MJO

&VSPQF

/:&%

$DV

S�SFOUMZ

QJMPUJO

HFE

VDBUJPOB

MMPBO

T�� ��

�PO

BWFSBH

FUP

���SFGVHF

FT

7PDBUJP

OBM&

4-3F

GVHF

FTX�

WPDBUJP

OBM

PSQSPGFTTJP

OBM

CBDL

HSPV

OET

-PXo.

FEJVN

EFQF

OET

POCSFBEUI

PGWP

DBUJP

OTDP

WFSFE

�XIF

UIFS

7&4

-QSPW

JEFE

BTQB

SUPG

SF�DSFEF

OUJBMJO

HQB

DLBH

F

:FT

DPOE

JUJPO

BMPO

DSJUJ�

DBMN

BTTP

GDMJF

OUTJ

OUIF

UBSHFUFE

WPDBUJP

OBMm

FMET

:FT

F�H�

UFDI

OJDBMM

BO�

HVBH

FQSPmD

JFOD

ZDFSUJ

m�DBUJP

O

-JLF

MZMBSHF

FæFDUT

POMBOH

VBHF

QSPm

DJFO

DZ�

XFMM�

NBUD

IFE

FN�

QMPZ

NFO

UJG

FNQMPZ

FST

SFDP

HOJ[FQ

SPHSBN

WBMVF

7&4

-TV

DDFTTGV

MMZCB

LFE

JOUP

*.�

13*/

5SF�DSFEF

OUJBMJO

HDP

VSTFT

JOUIF6�

4��� ��

��JN

NJHSBOUTT

FSWF

ETJO

DF��

���

USBJOJOHQSPH

SBNTEF

�TJH

OFEX

JUIFN

QMPZ

FSTB

DSPTTUIF

&�6�

UIBU

JODSFBTF

FNQMPZ

NFO

USBUFTBO

EDMJ

FOUT

BUJTG

BDUJP

O

1SJWBUF

DP�

TQPO

TPSTIJQ

MJHI

UUPVD

IWP

MVOUFFSJO

HUP

GPSN

BMTQPO

TPS�

TIJQ

"MM

SFGVHF

FTN

JHIU

CFTP

NF

QSFGFSFO

DFT

GPS

DP�SF

MJHJPVT

PSDP

�FUIOJDH

SPVQ

T

-PX

GPS

DPNNVO

JUZPV

USFBDI

JOGP

TFTTJPOT

BUTDIP

PMT

�DI

VSDI

FT

iCVE

EZw

TZTUF

NT�

)JHI

GPS

GPSN

BMDP

�TQPO

TPSTIJQ

CVU

CPUI

DPVMESFEV

DFSFMJB

ODFPO

GPSN

BMTFSWJDFQ

SPWJTJP

O

1SJWBUF

DP�TQ

POTP

STIJQ

EFQF

OET

POBWBJMBCJMJUZ

PGXJMMJOHQB

SUOFST MJH

IU�

UPVD

IMPDBMPV

USFBDI

JTTDBMBC

MFDP

OEJUJPO

POMPDBM�M

FWFM

DPPQ

FSBUJPO

:FT

F�H�

TFMG�

SFQP

SUFE

IBQQ

JOFTT

DPOO

FDUJP

OTUP

KPCT I

PVTJO

H �

DJWJD

PQQP

SUVOJUJF

T SFMJB

ODF

POSFTFUUMFN

FOUB

HFOD

JFT

JO���NPO

UISBOH

F

:FT

EFQF

OEJOH

POEF

QUIPG

QSPH

SBN D

PVME

QSPW

JEF

GVOD

UJPOB

MTP

�DJBM

TVQQ

PSU

UIBU

IFMQT

FNQMPZ

NFO

U MBOH

VBHF

BUUBJONFO

U�

NFO

UBM

IFBMUI

$PPSEJOB

UFE

�XF

MM�JOGPSN

FEMPDBM

SFDFQUJPO

JTBO

&�6�

ACFTUQSBDUJD

F�o

TVQQ

PSUT

SFGVHF

FTXIJMF

LFFQ

JOH

MPDBMDP

NNVO

JUZFO

HBHF

EBO

EQSF�

QBSFEGPSO

FXDP

NFSTN

JTTJOHJO

UIF

6�4�

MFWFSBH

FTHSBTTSPP

UTEF

TJSF

UPIF

MQ�

4PDJBM

TVQQ

PSUH

SFBUM

ZOF

FEFE

GPSH

PWFSON

FOU�S

FTFUUMF

ESFGVHF

FT

"QQ

SFOUJDFTIJQT

.JE

UPIJHI

TLJMMFE

SFGVHF

FT.

FEJVN E

FQFO

ETPO

BT�

TPDJBUF

EUVJUJPO

DPTUT

PSXB

HFTV

CTJEJFT

0OMZ

JGQB

SUOFSJOH

XJUI

OBUJP

OBM

DPSQPSBUJPOT

FYD

�GSB

ODIJTFT P

UIFS�

XJTF

WFSZ

MPDBMJ[

FE

:FT

F�H�

FNQMPZ

FSBO

ETFMG�

SFQP

SUFE

TLJMMT

BTTFTTNFO

UT BO

EDSFE

FO�

UJBMT

MBUFS

PO

-BSHF

HJWF

OUIBU

BQ�

QSFO

UJDFTIJQT

PGUFO

MFBE

GPGVMM�

UJNF

TLJMMFE

FNQMPZ

NFO

U

%FTDSJQUJW

FFW

JEFO

DFUIBU

BQQSFO

UJDF�

TIJQTJ

ODSFBTFD

SFEF

OUJBMJO

H GVMM�

UJNF

FNQMPZ

NFO

U BO

EFBSOJOHT

��

Page 37: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

� "QQFOEJY

��� 8IBU NPUJWBUFT WPMVOUFFST

*EFOUJGZJOH XIBU NPUJWBUFT WPMVOUFFST JT DSVDJBM UP SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODJFT UIBU IPQF UP MFWFSBHF UIFTF SFTPVSDFT�$PNNPO USFOET FNFSHF XIFO BTTFTTJOH WPMVOUFFS�MFWFM USBJUT BOE PSHBOJ[BUJPO�MFWFM QSBDUJDFT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI WPM�VOUFFS NPUJWBUJPO TBUJTGBDUJPO BOE KPC QFSGPSNBODF BNPOH UIF HFOFSBM QPQVMBUJPO PG WPMVOUFFST� "U UIF CSPBEFTUMFWFM B NJYUVSF PG TPDJBM SFXBSET BMUSVJTN BOE B TUSPOH BçOJUZ GPS HSPVQ BDUJWJUJFT BSF DPNNPO ESJWFST UP WPM�VOUFFS 4DIMFHFMNJMDI BOE 5ZOBO ����� *OEJDFT UIBU DBQUVSF PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM TVQQPSU QBSUJDJQBUJPO FçDBDZ BOEQFFS SFMBUJPOTIJQT IBWF TVCTFRVFOUMZ CFFO WBMJEBUFE JO DPOUFYUT BT EJæFSFOU BT UIF 6�4� BOE $IJOB 8POH $IVJBOE ,XPL ����� (BMJOEP�,VIO BOE (V[MFZ ����� 1FSIBQT UIF NPTU VCJRVJUPVT NFBTVSF PG WPMVOUFFS TBUJTGBDUJPOJT UIF 7PMVOUFFS 'VODUJPOT *OWFOUPSZ� .PUJWBUJPOT GPS WPMVOUFFSJOH BSF BTTFTTFE VTJOH UIF ���JUFN 7'* $MBSZ FUBM� ���� UIBU GPDVTFT PO TJY GVODUJPOT BTTFTTFE XJUI mWF JUFNT FBDI UIBU WPMVOUFFSJOH DBO TFSWF�

'JHVSF �� 7PMVOUFFS 'VODUJPO *OEFY

" NFUB�BOBMZTJT PG PWFS �� ��� WPMVOUFFST BDSPTT B SBOHF PG JTTVF BSFBT TIPXT UIBU UIF 7BMVFT GBDUPS PCUBJOFE UIFIJHIFTU NFBO TDPSF XIFSFBT UIF MPXFTU TDPSFT XFSF PCTFSWFE GPS UIF $BSFFS BOE &OIBODFNFOU GBDUPST� 4UVEJFTDPOEVDUFE XJUI TBNQMFT XJUI B NFBO BHF VOEFS �� ZFBST PCUBJO IJHIFS TDPSFT PO $BSFFS BOE 6OEFSTUBOEJOH TDBMFTXIFO DPNQBSFE UP TUVEJFT JO PMEFS TBNQMFT� 5IF HSPVQ PG TUVEJFT XJUI GFXFS UIBO ��� XPNFO ZJFME IJHIFS NFBOTDPSFT PO UIF 4PDJBM TDBMF UIBO TUVEJFT XJUI NPSF UIBO ��� XPNFO JO UIF TBNQMF� 5IF OJOF TUVEJFT SFQPSUJOHSFMJBCJMJUZ DPFçDJFOUT SBOHF GSPN ��� BOE ��� TVHHFTUJOH MJUUMF NFBTVSFNFOU FSSPS IJHI UFTU�SFUFTU SFMJBCJMJUZ JOUIF TDPSFT� 0G UIF �� TUVEJFT UIBU QFSGPSNFE GBDUPS BOBMZTJT �� DPOmSNFE UIF PSJHJOBM TUSVDUVSF PG TJY GBDUPST$IBDØO FU BM� �����

)PX QSFEJDUJWF BSF UIFTF GBDUPST PG WPMVOUFFS CFIBWJPST 3FDFOU TUVEJFT JOEJDBUF UIBU NPUJWBUJPOBM TBUJTGBDUJPO UBTLTBUJTGBDUJPO BOE NBOBHFNFOU TBUJTGBDUJPO DBO NBLF UIF EJæFSFODF CFUXFFO UIPTF XIP SFNBJO JO UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPOBOE UIPTF XIP MFBWF BGUFS B ���NPOUI USBDLJOH QFSJPE 7FDJOB $IBDPO � 4VFJSP ����� 4USPOHMZ JEFOUJGZJOHXJUI UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPO PGUFO NBUUFST NBOJGFTUFE JO CFMJFWJOH JUT HPBMT BOE WBMVFT XJMMJOH UP NBLF BO FæPSU UPCFOFmU UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPO BOE UIF EFTJSF UP SFNBJO B NFNCFS .FZFS � "MMFO ���� ����� .PXEBZ 4UFFST �1PSUFS ����� 5IJT WBSJBCMF NBQT XFMM POUP UIF JOUFOUJPO UP SFNBJO JO UIF MPOHFS UFSN BOE DBO DPNQFOTBUF GPSNPEFSBUF UFNQPSBSZ EFDSFBTFT JO TBUJTGBDUJPO BOE JNQSPWF SFTQPOTFT UP GSVTUSBUJOH FWFOUT 7FDJOB FU BM� �����(BSOFS BOE (BSOFS ����� .BOZ TUVEJFT TIPX UIBU DPNNJUNFOU SBUIFS UIBO TBUJTGBDUJPO JT UIF WBSJBCMF XIJDIDMFBSMZ EJæFSFOUJBUFT UXP FYUSFNF HSPVQT PG WPMVOUFFST� UIPTF XIP BCBOEPO UIFJS WPMVOUFFSJOH EVSJOH UIF mSTU ZFBS

��

Page 38: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

BOE UIPTF XIP SFNBJO BGUFS TFWFO ZFBST 7FDJOB $IBDPO � 4VFJSP ����� i0SHBOJ[BUJPO�CBTFE TFMG�FTUFFNw0#4& DBQUVSFT UIJT DPNNJUNFOU UP UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPO XFMM� UIF QFSDFQUJPO JOEJWJEVBMT IBWF PG UIFNTFMWFT BTJNQPSUBOU NFBOJOHGVM FæFDUVBM BOE XPSUIXIJMF XJUIJO UIFJS PSHBOJ[BUJPO 7FDJOB FU BM� �����

*NQPSUBOU WPMVOUFFS�MFWFM NPUJWBUJPOT UIVT JODMVEF DPNNJUNFOU UP UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPO�T WBMVFT B TFOTF PG CFJOH WBM�VFE BOE QBSUJDJQBUJOH JO EFDJTJPO�NBLJOH BOE XPSLJOH XJUIJO HSPVQT SBUIFS UIBO JOEJWJEVBMMZ� 'SPN BO PSHBOJ�[BUJPOBM QFSTQFDUJWF USBJUT BTTPDJBUFE XJUI TBUJTGBDUJPO JODMVEFE DMFBSMZ BSUJDVMBUFE NJTTJPO TUBUFNFOUT TUSVDUVSFETVQQPSU GPS WPMVOUFFST BOE BSSBOHJOH GPS WPMVOUFFST UP TIBSF FYQFSJFODFT BOE XPSL JO HSPVQT %SVDLFS ����� *UGPMMPXT UIBU UIF NBUDI CFUXFFO WPMVOUFFST BOE PSHBOJ[BUJPOT NBUUFST BT XFMM� 5IF GVODUJPOBM BQQSPBDI UP WPM�VOUFFSJTN IPMET UIBU PVUDPNFT GSPN WPMVOUFFSJOH F�H� TBUJTGBDUJPO BOE JOUFOUJPOT UP SFNBJO B WPMVOUFFS BSF BGVODUJPO PG UIF NBUDI CFUXFFO B WPMVOUFFS�T NPUJWBUJPOT BOE PQQPSUVOJUJFT UP NFFU UIPTF NPUJWBUJPOT GPVOE JO UIFFOWJSPONFOU J�F� UIF WPMVOUFFS BDUJWJUJFT QPTJUJPO PS PSHBOJ[BUJPO� *OEJDFT DBQUVSJOH NBUDI TVDDFTT TFFN DBQB�CMF PG QSFEJDUJOH PVUDPNFT CFUUFS UIBO WPMVOUFFS�MFWFM USBJUT PS PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM�MFWFM PQQPSUVOJUJFT� 5IF JNQPSUBODFPG HPPE NBUDIFT TFFN NPSF JNQPSUBOU JO MFTT TUSVDUVSFE BOE TNBMMFS PSHBOJ[BUJPOT 4UVLBT FU BM� �����

#BTFE PO UIFTF mOEJOHT UIF GPMMPXJOH BSF SFDPNNFOEBUJPOT UP BQQSPBDI WPMVOUFFS SFDSVJUNFOU BOE NPUJWBUJPO JOB NPSF JOUFOUJPOBM XBZ�

t 5SBJOJOH BOE PSJFOUBUJPO UIBU EFNPOTUSBUFT UIF WBMVF PG WPMVOUFFS XPSL UP UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPOt $MFBSMZ BSUJDVMBUF UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPO�T NJTTJPO BOE BçSN UIF JNQPSUBODF PG WPMVOUFFS XPSL UP BDIJFWJOH UIFTFIVNBOJUBSJBO HPBMT

t 3FDPHOJ[F HPPE QFSGPSNBODF IPME QFSGPSNBODF SFWJFXT BU MFBTU PODF B ZFBS BOE QSPWJEF DBSFFS MBEEFSTPS FYQBOEFE SFTQPOTJCJMJUJFT GPS ZPVOH WPMVOUFFST DPOWFSTFMZ SF�BMMPDBUJOH QPPS QFSGPSNFST FTQFDJBMMZ JOFOWJSPONFOUT XJUI MPOH XBJU MJTUT

t $POTVMUJOH WPMVOUFFST BOE JOWPMWJOH UIFN JO EFDJTJPO�NBLJOH UIBU BæFDUT UIFJS XPSL BOE UIF XPSL PG UIFPSHBOJ[BUJPO BMMPXJOH UIFN UP FYQSFTT UIFJS JEFBT BOE SBUF UIFJS TBUJTGBDUJPO XJUI UBTLT BOE QSPKFDUT F�H�DIFDL�JOT XJUI WPMVOUFFS DPPSEJOBUPST

t 0SHBOJ[JOH WPMVOUFFST JOUP XPSLJOH HSPVQT UIBU NFFU SFHVMBSMZ UP TIBSF FYQFSJFODFT BOE XPSL PO DPNNPOQSPCMFNT XJUI PQQPSUVOJUJFT UP TIBSF BDIJFWFNFOUT BOE CFTU QSBDUJDFT XJUI UIF PSHBOJ[BUJPO

��� 3F�DSFEFOUJBMJOH 1SPHSBNT JO UIF 6�4�

#FMPX BSF B GFX FTUBCMJTIFE SF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH QSPHSBNT SVO CZ JNNJHSBOU�GPDVTFE /(0T JO UIF 6�4� TPNF PG XIJDIIBWF FYQBOEFE UP XPSLJOH XJUI SFGVHFFT 4JOHFS �����

�� 6QXBSEMZ (MPCBM DVSSFOUMZ XJUI PçDFT JO $IJDBHP 4BO 'SBODJTDP BOE /FX :PSL VTFT WPMVOUFFST GSPN6�4� DPNQBOJFT UP TFSWF BT QFFS NFOUPST UP IFMQ JNNJHSBOUT XJUI JOUFSWJFXJOH UFDIOJRVFT BOE FYQFSJFOUJBMLOPXMFEHF� 5IFZ BMTP IBWF TDSFFO QSFTFOU BOE QMBDF DBOEJEBUFT JO KPCT BU QBSUOFS CVTJOFTTFT� 6( FEV�DBUFT FNQMPZFST BCPVU UIF QPUFOUJBM QPPM PG FNQMPZFFT UIF 6�4� WJTB TZTUFN BOE IPX UP FWBMVBUF GPSFJHODSFEFOUJBMT� 5IFJS FNQMPZFF FOHBHFNFOU QSPHSBN IBT USBJOFE NPSF UIBO � ��� JNNJHSBOU QSPGFTTJPOBMTGSPN ��� DPVOUSJFT TJODF �����

�� 5IF8FMDPNF#BDL *OJUJBUJWF 8#* JO �� MPDBUJPOT BDSPTT UIF DPVOUSZ XPSLT FYDMVTJWFMZXJUI QSPGFTTJPOBMMZ�USBJOFE JNNJHSBOUT JO UIF IFBMUIDBSF TFDUPS� 8#* DPOOFDUT UIFTF QSPGFTTJPOBMT XJUI UZQJDBMMZ VOEFSTFSWFEDPNNVOJUJFT DPNQBUJCMF XJUI UIFJS MBOHVBHF BOE DVMUVSBM TLJMMT� 8#* SFUSBJOT SFDSFEFOUJBMJ[FT BOE MJDFOTFTIFBMUIDBSF XPSLFST UP QSBDUJDF JO UIF 6�4� BOE NBSLFU UIFJS TLJMMT UP 6�4� FNQMPZFST� )PVTFE NBJOMZ JO DPN�NVOJUZ DPMMFHFT BOE PæFSJOH 7&4- DPVSTFT UIF 8#* IBT TFSWFE �� ��� JNNJHSBOU IFBMUI QSPGFTTJPOBMTTJODF �����

��

Page 39: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

�� 8PSME&EVDBUJPO 4FSWJDFT 8&4 WBMJEBUFT GPSFJHO DSFEFOUJBMT GPS KPC�TFFLFST BOE TUVEFOUT BT XFMM BT GPSFNQMPZFST BOE MJDFOTJOH CPBSET� 5IFJS (MPCBM 5BMFOU #SJEHF QSPHSBN SFDPOTUSVDUT DMJFOUT� BDBEFNJD IJTUPSZBOE BEWJTFT PO MJDFOTJOH GPS JOGPSNBUJPO UFDIOPMPHZ FOHJOFFSJOH BDDPVOUJOH BOE PUIFS QSPGFTTJPOBMT� #PUI6QXBSEMZ (MPCBM BOE UIF 8FMDPNF #BDL *OJUJBUJWF XPSL XJUI 8&4 UP HFU UIFJS DSFEFOUJBMT BTTFTTFE BOESFDPHOJ[FE CZ FNQMPZFST� 8&4 JT DVSSFOUMZ QJMPUJOH B QSPHSBN GPS 4ZSJBO SFGVHFFT JO $BOBEB�

�� 5PHFUIFS UIFTF PSHBOJ[BUJPOT BOE PUIFST JODMVEJOH UIF .BTTBDIVTFUUT *NNJHSBOU BOE 3FGVHFF "EWPDBDZ$PBMJUJPO DPNQSJTF UIF DPBMJUJPO LOPXO BT *.13*/5� *.13*/5�T NJTTJPO JT UP XPSL XJUI CVTJOFTT HPWFSONFOU IJHIFS FEVDBUJPO BOE PUIFS QBSUOFST UP SBJTF BXBSFOFTT BCPVU UIF UBMFOUT BOE DPOUSJCVUJPOTPG JNNJHSBOU QSPGFTTJPOBMT JO UIF 6�4� BOE UP TUSFBNMJOF UIF DPNQMFYJUJFT PG QSPGFTTJPOBM MJDFOTJOH BOESF�DSFEFOUJBMJOH PG TLJMMFE XPSLFST� JOUP UIF 6�4� XPSLGPSDF�

�� 5IF /FX :PSL $JUZ &DPOPNJD %FWFMPQNFOU $PSQPSBUJPO /:$&%$ JT TFU UP MBVODI JUT *NNJHSBOU#SJEHF 1SPHSBN XIJDI XJMM QSPWJEF DSFEFOUJBM BTTFTTNFOU USBJOJOH JOUFSOTIJQ SFGFSSBMT BOE KPC TFBSDITVQQPSU� *U XJMM BMTP PæFS MPX�JOUFSFTU NJDSP�MPBOT UP JNNJHSBOUT UP GVOE UVJUJPO USBJOJOH FYBN GFFT BOEBOZ PUIFS FEVDBUJPOBM DPTUT UP VQTLJMM JO UIFJS mFMET� 5IF /:$&%$ FYQFDUT UP MFOE UP BSPVOE ��� QFPQMFEVSJOH UIF mSTU �� NPOUIT XJUI BO BWFSBHF MPBO PG �� ����

��� "QQSFOUJDFTIJQ "MUFSOBUJWF� 4VQQPSUFE &NQMPZNFOU

4VQQPSUFE FNQMPZNFOU BJNT UP QMBDF iVOFNQMPZBCMFw DMJFOUT JOUP DPNQFUJUJWF KPCT XIJMF QSPWJEJOH PO�HPJOH JO�UFOTJWF TVQQPSU TFSWJDFT TVDI BT KPC DPBDIJOH SPMF iTIBEPXJOH w BOE NFOUPSJOH� 0WFSBMM TVQQPSUFE FNQMPZNFOUTFFNT UP TVCTUBOUJBMMZ JNQSPWF FNQMPZNFOU PVUDPNFT BOE QFSGPSNBODF BNPOH BU�SJTL QPQVMBUJPOT BOE NPEFTUMZJNQSPWF UIFN BNPOH UIF VOFNQMPZFE BU MBSHF #POE ����� 4VNOBMM BOE #SPUIFSIPPE ����� &EVDBUJPO BMTP UFOETUP JNQSPWF CVU VTVBMMZ BT B EJSFDU SFTVMU PG DSFEFOUJBMJOH CVJMU JOUP UIF QSPHSBN .BXO FU BM� ����� 5IF TPPOFSDMJFOUT FOSPMM UIF CFUUFS� 4UVEJFT PG 4XFEJTI KPC TVQQPSU TFSWJDFT BOE "VTUSJBO KPC�DPBDIJOH O � �� ��� JOEJDBUFUIBU QSPHSBN FæFDUT SFEVDJOH SFTJEVBM VOFNQMPZNFOU EVSBUJPO CZ ��� BSF NPTU DPODFOUSBUFE XJUIJO UIF DMJFOU�TmSTU ZFBS PG VOFNQMPZNFOU 8FCFS BOE )PGFS ����� 4JBOFTJ �����

4PNF DPODFSOT XPSUI OPUJOH JODMVEF� TVC�NJOJNVN XBHFT EJTJODFOUJWFT UP QBSUJDJQBUF EVF UP UIF JOUFSQMBZ PGCFOFmUT BOE B GPDVT PO FOUSZ�MFWFM SBUIFS UIBO TLJMMFE KPCT� 3FWFOVF TUSFBNT PGUFO JODMVEF XBHF TVCTJEJFT CZ/(0T XIJDI BSF HFOFSBMMZ FYQFOTJWF (SJNN BOE 1BæIBVTFO ����� 5IJT NBZ TUJMM CF BDDFQUBCMF JG UIF KPCTDSFBUFE BSF TVTUBJOBCMF CVU FWJEFODF SFHBSEJOH XIFUIFS UIJT JT SFBMMZ UIF DBTF JT TDBSDF� " NBKPS DPTU DPNQPOFOUJT UIF EFBE XFJHIU MPTT QSPEVDFE CZ UIF GBDU UIBU NBOZ PG UIF XPSLFST IJSFE VOEFS B TVCTJEJ[FE SBUF XPVME IBWFCFFO IJSFE BOZXBZ� "O FYQFSJNFOUBM TUVEZ JO 4SJ -BOLB GPVOE B TUSPOH DPSSFMBUJPO CFUXFFO QSF�QSPHSBN IJSJOHJOUFOUJPOT BOE QSPHSBN VQUBLF %F.FM .D,FO[JF BOE8PPESVæ ����� )PXFWFS FBSMJFS TUVEJFT SFQPSUFE CFOFmUTPG ����� UP FWFSZ �� JO DPTU XJUI ��� ��� JO HSPTT XBHFT BOE GSJOHF CFOFmUT UP UIF FNQMPZFF XIPN PUIFST WJFXFEBT iQFSNBOFOUMZ VOFNQMPZBCMFw )JMM FU BM� ����� " #SJUJTI KPC BTTJTUBODF BOE XBHF TVCTJEZ FYQFSJNFOU MJLFXJTFSBJTFE FNQMPZNFOU CZ BCPVU � QFSDFOUBHF QPJOUT CVU MPOH�SVO FWJEFODF XBT NJYFE #MVOEFMM FU BM� �����

*OEJWJEVBM�MFWFM USBJUT BMTP TIBQF TVDDFTT� /PO�DPHOJUJWF TLJMMT BOE NPUJWBUJPO BSF JNQPSUBOU EFUFSNJOBOUT PG TVD�DFTT BOE UIFTF DBO CF JNQSPWFE NPSF TVDDFTTGVMMZ BOE BU MBUFS BHFT UIBO CBTJD DPHOJUJWF TLJMMT )FDLNBO �����0O UIF PUIFS IBOE UIPTF XJUI EFFQMZ FOUSFODIFE CBSSJFST BOE XJUIPVU QPTJUJWF BUUJUVEFT BSF BNPOH UIF IBSEFTUUP IFMQ )BTMVDL BOE (SFFO ����� )FMQJOH UIF NPTU EJTBEWBOUBHFE JT SFTPVSDF JOUFOTJWF VTVBMMZ SFRVJSJOH JOEJ�WJEVBMMZ UBJMPSFE TVQQPSU PWFS B QSPMPOHFE QFSJPE� *OEJWJEVBMT NBZ NBLF DPOTJEFSBCMF QSPHSFTT XJUIPVU SFBDIJOHFNQMPZNFOU� 5IFSF JT B RVFTUJPO BT UP XIFUIFS FNQMPZNFOU JT B SFBMJTUJD HPBM GPS TPNF HSPVQT BOE CZ FYUFOTJPO IPX CFTU UP UBSHFU JOUFSWFOUJPOT� *U TIPVME CF TUSFTTFE UIBU TUVEJFT PO TVQQPSUFE FNQMPZNFOU IBWF NBJOMZ CFFOSVO PO BU�SJTL HSPVQT TVDI BT UIF TFWFSFMZ NFOUBMMZ JMM BOE UIF EJTBCMFE NFBOJOH UIBU MPX CBTFMJOFT NBZ MFBE UPMBSHF FæFDU TJ[FT UIBU BSF OPU EJSFDUMZ USBOTGFSSBCMF UP PUIFS HSPVQT�

��

Page 40: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

4VDDFTTGVM TVQQPSUFE FNQMPZNFOU QSPHSBNT CBTFE PO SPVHIMZ �� 3$5T JODMVEF�

t 4VQQPSU UP FNQMPZFST UP IFMQ UIFN VOEFSTUBOE UIF TUSFOHUIT BOE XFBLOFTTFT PG EJæFSFOU EJTBEWBOUBHFEHSPVQT

t 0O�UIF�KPC NFOUPSJOH PS CVEEZJOHt $PNQFUJUJWF FNQMPZNFOU OPU TIFMUFSFE XPSL BT BO BUUBJOBCMF HPBM GPS DMJFOUTt 3BQJE KPC TFBSDI BT PQQPTFE UP MFOHUIZ QSF�FNQMPZNFOU BTTFTTNFOU USBJOJOH BOE DPVOTFMMJOHt *OEJWJEVBMJ[FE KPC QMBDFNFOUT BDDPSEJOH UP DMJFOU QSFGFSFODFTt "U MFBTU � NPOUIT PG QSPHSBNNJOH XJUI GPMMPX�VQ VQ VOUJM � ZFBST

5BLFBXBZT� 4VQQPSUFE FNQMPZNFOU NFOUPSFE XPSL QMBDFNFOUT JNQSPWFT XBHFT IPVST XPSLFE BOEQSPGFTTJPOBMJTN GPS FYUSFNFMZ EJTBEWBOUBHFE TFHNFOUT PG "NFSJDBO TPDJFUZ CVU VOMJWBCMF XBHFT BOEMPX�TLJMMFE XPSL SFNBJO B QSPCMFN�

��� "QQT GPS "EVMU &OHMJTI -FBSOFST

0OMJOF MBOHVBHF QSPHSBNT BSF HSPXJOH TVCTUBOUJBMMZ JO VTFST BOE SFWFOVF� 5IF XPSMEXJEF NBSLFU GPS EJHJUBM&OHMJTI MFBSOJOH QSPEVDUT UIF NPTU QPQVMBS MBOHVBHF XBT ���� CJMMJPO JO ���� BOE QSPKFDUFE UP HSPX UP ����CJMMJPO CZ ���� 4FBWF ����� .BOZ DPNQBOJFT BSF DPNQFUJOH GPS NBSLFU TIBSF JODMVEJOH CVTVV %VPMJOHP #BCCFM BOE 3PTFUUB 4UPOF� )PXFWFS FOUSZ IBT TMPXFE DPOTJEFSBCMZ o UIF MBTU NBKPS DPNQFUJUPS UP FOUFS XBT%VPMJOHP JO ���� 4FBWF ����� 5IFTF DPNQBOJFT NBZ IBWF EJæFSFOU GFBUVSFT UP IFMQ TQFFE VQ MFBSOJOH BOEWBSZJOH QSJDF TDIFNFT CVU TUSVHHMF UP EJTUJOHVJTI UIFNTFMWFT BNPOH QPUFOUJBM OFX VTFST� /POFUIFMFTT EJæFSFOUBQQT IBWF DPNQBSBUJWF BEWBOUBHFT JO UFBDIJOH TUZMFT BOE TLJMM TFUT UBSHFUFE� +VTU BT XFMM� MBOHVBHF MFBSOJOH JTB DPNQMFY QSPDFTT XIFSF BOZ HJWFO TLJMM F�H� SFBEJOH DBO CF GVSUIFS CSPLFO EPXO JOUP EJTUJODU DPNQPOFOUTF�H� XPSE SFDPHOJUJPO EFDPEJOH BOE DPNQSFIFOTJPO� -FBSOFST BMTP IBWF EJæFSFOU HPBMT XJUI TPNF QSJPSJUJ[JOHDPOWFSTBUJPOBM nVFODZ XIFSF PUIFST BTQJSF UP XSJUUFO QSPmDJFODZ� 5IF NPTU TVDDFTTGVM QBUI UP &OHMJTI MFBSOJOHNBZ UIVT CF B DPNCJOBUJPO PG BQQT UBJMPSFE UP UIF VTFS�T OFFET NBLJOH TVSF UP DPWFS TQFBLJOH QSBDUJDF PæMJOF PSVTJOH JO�BQQ DIBU GFBUVSFT�

5IF BQQT SFQPSUFE CFMPX BSF BMM TVQQPSUFE PO NPCJMF BOE XFC CSPXTFST UBSHFUFE BU BEVMUT BOE PæFS JOTUSVDUJPOGSPN B SBOHF PG MBOHVBHFT JODMVEJOH "SBCJD 5VSLJTI BOE 'SFODI UP &OHMJTI�

��

Page 41: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

5BCMF �� "EVMU -BOHVBHF -FBSOJOH "QQT

1MBUGPSN 4LJMMT $PTU 6TFS #BTF "QQSPBDI $POT

%VPMJOHP 1SPOVODJBUJPO WPDBC TFOUFODFDPOTUSVDUJPO SFBE�JOH MJTUFOJOH

'SFF ��� NJMMJPO i�� ��� TFOUFODFTw BQQSPBDI SFQ�FUJUJPO HBNJmDBUJPO iTNBSUw BQQUIBU GPDVTFT PO ZPVS XFBLFTU BSFBT

-FTT FæFDUJWF PO NPCJMF UIBO DPN�QVUFS DBO CF DIFBUFE OFFET UP CFTVQQMFNFOUFE XJUI DPOWFSTBUJPOBMQSBDUJDF UP HFU CFZPOE "� MFWFM

-BOH�� 8SJUJOH 'SFF PS 1SF�NJVN

��� ��� 6TFST VQMPBE UFYU UIFZ�WF XSJUUFOBOE IBWF JU DPSSFDUFE CZ B OBUJWFTQFBLFS� 6TFST UIFO DPSSFDU PUIFST�UFYU JO UIFJS OBUJWF MBOHVBHF

1PTUT CZ OPO�QSFNJVN BDDPVOUTDBO HP VODIFDLFE RVBMJUZ PG DPS�SFDUJPOT JODPOTJTUFOU

#VTVV 4FOUFODF DPOTUSVD�UJPO SFBEJOH MJTUFO�JOH

'SFF PS1SFNJVN����NPOUI

�� NJMMJPO %JæFSFOU WPJDFT GPDVT PO XSJUJOHTLJMMT �� ��� TFOUFODFT BQQSPBDI HBNJmDBUJPO DIBU XJUI OBUJWFT GFB�UVSF XFC POMZ

/FFET UP CF TVQQMFNFOUFE XJUIDPOWFSTBUJPOBM QSBDUJDF MFTT GPDVTPO SFQFBUFE ESJMMT

.FNSJTF 7PDBCVMBSZ 'SFF PS 1SP���NPOUI

�� NJMMJPO 6TFS DIPPTFT GSPN B TFU PG DVFT UPSFNFNCFS B OFX XPSE NOFNPOJDTUFDIOJRVFT BOE SFUBJO JU MPOH�UFSN HBNJmDBUJPO iTNBSUw BQQ UIBU GP�DVTFT PO XFBL XPSET

/P TQFBLJOH PS HSBNNBS USBJOJOH XFC WFSTJPO JT JOGFSJPS UP BQQ

-JOHWJTU 3FBEJOH XSJUJOH MJTUFOJOH

'SFF PS 1SP���NPOUI

� NJMMJPO 4IPXT XPSET JO VTFGVM DPOUFYUT TQBDFE SFQFUJUJPO UP FODPVSBHFNFNPSJ[BUJPO UZQJOH OFX MBO�HVBHF UP BDUJWBUF NVTDMF NFNPSZBOE TQFMMJOH DBO HFU UP #��#� MFWFM

/P TQFBLJOH MJNJUFE UP UZQJOH FY�FSDJTFT

#BCCFM 7PDBCVMBSZ QSP�OVODJBUJPO

'SFF PS1SP �� o����NPOUI

�� NJMMJPO 'PDVTFT PO CVJMEJOH DPOWFSTBUJPOBMTLJMMT PDDBTJPOBMMZ TFUT Pæ JNNFS�TJWF MFTTPOT CZ FYQMBJOJOH HSBN�NBUJDBM DPODFQUT BU MFOHUI QSPOVO�DJBUJPO QSBDUJDF

$BO CF CVHHZ FTQFDJBMMZ QIPOF BQQWFSTJPO F�H� NVTU QSPOPVODFXPSETFYBDUMZ SJHIU UP NPWF PO

3FGFSFODFT

"EJEB $MBJSF - "EFMJOF -P BOE .FMJOB 1MBUBT� ����� i&OHFOEFSJOH &NQBUIZ #FHFUUJOH #BDLMBTI� "NFSJDBO"UUJUVEFT UPXBSE 4ZSJBO 3FGVHFFT�w�

"EJEB $MBJSF - %BWJE % -BJUJO BOE .BSJF�"OOF 7BMGPSU� ����� 8IZ .VTMJN JOUFHSBUJPO GBJMT JO $ISJTUJBO�IFSJUBHF TPDJFUJFT� )BSWBSE 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT�

"HFS "MBTUBJS BOE"MJTPO 4USBOH� ����� i6OEFSTUBOEJOH JOUFHSBUJPO� " DPODFQUVBM GSBNFXPSL�w +PVSOBM PG SFGVHFFTUVEJFT �������o����

��

Page 42: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

"LSFTI *MBOB 3FETUPOF� ����� i8FBMUI BDDVNVMBUJPO BNPOH 64 JNNJHSBOUT� " TUVEZ PG BTTJNJMBUJPO BOE EJæFS�FOUJBMT�w 4PDJBM 4DJFODF 3FTFBSDI ��������o�����

"MCPJN /BPNJ� ����� 'VMmMMJOH UIF QSPNJTF� *OUFHSBUJOH JNNJHSBOU TLJMMT JOUP UIF $BOBEJBO FDPOPNZ� $BMFEPO*OTUJUVUF PG 4PDJBM 1PMJDZ 0UUBXB�

"MFTJOB "MCFSUP +PIBOO )BSOPTT BOE )JMMFM 3BQPQPSU� ����� i#JSUIQMBDF EJWFSTJUZ BOE FDPOPNJD QSPTQFSJUZ�w+PVSOBM PG &DPOPNJD (SPXUI �������o����

"MMFO 5BNNZ % -JMMJBO 5 &CZ BOE &MJ[BCFUI -FOU[� ����� i.FOUPSTIJQ CFIBWJPST BOE NFOUPSTIJQ RVBMJUZ BTTP�DJBUFE XJUI GPSNBM NFOUPSJOH QSPHSBNT� DMPTJOH UIF HBQ CFUXFFO SFTFBSDI BOE QSBDUJDF�w +PVSOBM PG "QQMJFE1TZDIPMPHZ ��������

"MMFO 5BNNZ % -JMMJBO 5 &CZ .BSL - 1PUFFU &MJ[BCFUI -FOU[ BOE -J[[FUUF -JNB� ����� i$BSFFS CFOFmUTBTTPDJBUFE XJUI NFOUPSJOH GPS QSPUÏHÏT� " NFUB�BOBMZTJT�w�

"MMQPSU (PSEPO 8� ����� 5IF OBUVSF PG QSFKVEJDF� #BTJD CPPLT�

"NBSBOUF 7FSØOJDB .BSDP .BOBDPSEB &EXBSE .JHVFM BOE "OESFB 7JHPSJUP� ����� %P DBTI USBOTGFST JNQSPWFCJSUI PVUDPNFT &WJEFODF GSPN NBUDIFE WJUBM TUBUJTUJDT TPDJBM TFDVSJUZ BOE QSPHSBN EBUB� 5FDIOJDBM SFQPSU/BUJPOBM #VSFBV PG &DPOPNJD 3FTFBSDI�

"OEFSTTPO 3PHFS� ����� i5IF HFPHSBQIJDBM BOE TPDJBM NPCJMJUZ PG JNNJHSBOUT� FTDBMBUPS SFHJPOT JO 4XFEFO GSPNBO FUIOJD QFSTQFDUJWF�w (FPHSBmTLB "OOBMFS� 4FSJFT #� )VNBO (FPHSBQIZ QQ� �o���

"TISBG /BWB %JFHP "ZDJOFOB $MBVEJB .BSUÓOF[ " BOE %FBO :BOH� ����� i4BWJOHT JO USBOTOBUJPOBM IPVTFIPMET�B mFME FYQFSJNFOU BNPOH NJHSBOUT GSPN &M 4BMWBEPS�w 3FWJFX PG &DPOPNJDT BOE 4UBUJTUJDT �������o����

¯TMVOE 0MPG 1FS�"OEFST &EJO 1FUFS 'SFESJLTTPO FU BM� ����� i1FFST OFJHICPSIPPET BOE JNNJHSBOU TUVEFOUBDIJFWFNFOU� &WJEFODF GSPN B QMBDFNFOU QPMJDZ�w "NFSJDBO &DPOPNJD +PVSOBM� "QQMJFE &DPOPNJDT �����o���

"ULJOTPO "EFMF BOE 'MPSF�"OOF .FTTZ� ����� i1SPNPUJOH mOBODJBM JODMVTJPO UISPVHI mOBODJBM FEVDBUJPO�w0&$% 8PSLJOH 1BQFST PO 'JOBODF *OTVSBODF BOE 1SJWBUF 1FOTJPOT �����

"VHVTU %JBOF 5JNPUIZ 4IBOBIBO BOE ,BUIZ &TDBNJMMB� ����� i&OHMJTI MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST� %FWFMPQJOH MJUFSBDZ JOTFDPOE�MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST 3FQPSU PG UIF /BUJPOBM -JUFSBDZ 1BOFM PO -BOHVBHF�.JOPSJUZ $IJMESFO BOE :PVUI�w+PVSOBM PG -JUFSBDZ 3FTFBSDI �������o����

"[PSCP .JDIFMMF� ����� .JDSPmOBODF BOE 3FGVHFFT� MFTTPOT MFBSOFE GSPN 6/)$3�T FYQFSJFODF� 6/)$3 1PMJDZ %FWFMPQNFOU BOE &WBMVBUJPO 4FSWJDF�

#BJSE 4BSBI + 3JDIBSE 4 (BSGFJO $SBJH 5 .D*OUPTI BOE #FSL ½[MFS� ����� i&æFDU PG B DBTI USBOTGFS QSPHSBNNFGPS TDIPPMJOH PO QSFWBMFODF PG )*7 BOE IFSQFT TJNQMFY UZQF � JO .BMBXJ� B DMVTUFS SBOEPNJTFE USJBM�w 5IF-BODFU ������������o�����

#BOEJFSB 0SJBOB *XBO #BSBOLBZ BOE *NSBO 3BTVM� ����� i4PDJBM DBQJUBM JO UIF XPSLQMBDF� &WJEFODF PO JUTGPSNBUJPO BOE DPOTFRVFODFT�w -BCPVS &DPOPNJDT �������o����

#BOTBL ,JSL +FSFNZ 'FSXFSEB +FOT )BJONVFMMFS "OESFB %JMMPO %PNJOJL )BOHBSUOFS %VODBO -BXSFODF BOE+FSFNZ8FJOTUFJO� ����� i*NQSPWJOH SFGVHFF JOUFHSBUJPO UISPVHI EBUB�ESJWFO BMHPSJUINJD BTTJHONFOU�w 4DJFODF�����������o����

��

Page 43: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

#BSSPO +PIO . %BO " #MBDL BOE .BSL " -PFXFOTUFJO� ����� i&NQMPZFS TJ[F� 5IF JNQMJDBUJPOT GPS TFBSDI USBJOJOH DBQJUBM JOWFTUNFOU TUBSUJOH XBHFT BOE XBHF HSPXUI�w +PVSOBM PG -BCPS &DPOPNJDT �����o���

#BTT 4BOESB .BSHJF , 4IJFMET BOE 3JDIBSE & #FISNBO� ����� i$IJMESFO GBNJMJFT BOE GPTUFS DBSF� "OBMZTJT BOESFDPNNFOEBUJPOT�w 5IF GVUVSF PG DIJMESFO QQ� �o���

#BTUBHMJ 'SBODFTDB +FTTJDB )BHFO�;BOLFS -VLF )BSNBO (FPSHJOB 4UVSHF 7BMFOUJOB #BSDB 5BOKB 4DINJEU BOE-VDB 1FMMFSBOP� ����� i$BTI USBOTGFST� XIBU EPFT UIF FWJEFODF TBZ " SJHPSPVT SFWJFX PG JNQBDUT BOE UIF SPMFPG EFTJHO BOE JNQMFNFOUBUJPO GFBUVSFT�w 0WFSTFBT %FWFMPQNFOU *OTUJUVUF -POEPO �

#BVHI 4 (BZMF .FMFOJF + -BOLBV BOE 5FSSJ " 4DBOEVSB� ����� i"O JOWFTUJHBUJPO PG UIF FæFDUT PG QSPUÏHÏ HFOEFSPO SFTQPOTFT UP NFOUPSJOH�w +PVSOBM PG 7PDBUJPOBM #FIBWJPS �������o����

#FBNBO -PSJ "� ����� i4PDJBM OFUXPSLT BOE UIF EZOBNJDT PG MBCPVS NBSLFU PVUDPNFT� &WJEFODF GSPN SFGVHFFTSFTFUUMFE JO UIF 64�w 5IF 3FWJFX PG &DPOPNJD 4UVEJFT �������o����

#FJSFOT )BOOF BOE 4VTBO 'SBU[LF� ����� i5BLJOH 4UPDL PG 3FGVHFF 3FTFUUMFNFOU� 1PMJDZ PCKFDUJWFT QSBDUJDBMUSBEFPæT BOE UIF FWJEFODF CBTF�w�

#FSUSBOE .BSJBOOF &S[P '1 -VUUNFS BOE 4FOEIJM .VMMBJOBUIBO� ����� i/FUXPSL FæFDUT BOE XFMGBSF DVMUVSFT�w5IF 2VBSUFSMZ +PVSOBM PG &DPOPNJDT ���������o�����

#FSUSBOE .BSJBOOF BOE 4FOEIJM .VMMBJOBUIBO� ����� i"SF &NJMZ BOE (SFH NPSF FNQMPZBCMF UIBO -BLJTIB BOE+BNBM " mFME FYQFSJNFOU PO MBCPS NBSLFU EJTDSJNJOBUJPO�w 5IF "NFSJDBO &DPOPNJD 3FWJFX �������o�����

#FWFMBOEFS 1JFUFS BOE $ISJTUFS -VOEI� ����� i&NQMPZNFOU JOUFHSBUJPO PG SFGVHFFT� 5IF JOnVFODF PG MPDBM GBDUPSTPO SFGVHFF KPC PQQPSUVOJUJFT JO 4XFEFO�w�

#IBSBU 4&8" 6/*$&' FU BM� ����� i" MJUUMF NPSF IPX NVDI JU JT QJMPUJOH CBTJD JODPNF USBOTGFST JO .BEIZB1SBEFTI *OEJB�w +BOVBSZ 4FXB #IBSBU BOE 6/*$&' /FX %FMIJ �

#MBUUNBO $ISJTUPQIFS /BUIBO 'JBMB BOE 4FCBTUJBO .BSUJOF[� ����� i5IF FDPOPNJD BOE TPDJBM SFUVSOT UP DBTIUSBOTGFST� FWJEFODF GSPN B 6HBOEBO BJE QSPHSBN�w $PMVNCJB 6OJWFSTJUZ %FQBSUNFOUT PG 1PMJUJDBM 4DJFODFBOE *OUFSOBUJPOBM � 1VCMJD "æBJST �

#MPNNBFSU -JFTFMPUUF .BSDFM $PFOEFST BOE 'SBOL 7BO 5VCFSHFO� ����� i%JTDSJNJOBUJPO PG "SBCJD�OBNFE BQQMJ�DBOUT JO UIF /FUIFSMBOET� BO JOUFSOFU�CBTFE mFME FYQFSJNFOU FYBNJOJOH EJæFSFOU QIBTFT JO POMJOF SFDSVJUNFOUQSPDFEVSFT�w 4PDJBM GPSDFT �������o����

#MVOEFMM 3JDIBSE .POJDB $PTUB %JBT $PTUBT .FHIJS BOE +PIO 3FFOFO� ����� i&WBMVBUJOH UIF FNQMPZNFOUJNQBDU PG B NBOEBUPSZ KPC TFBSDI QSPHSBN�w +PVSOBM PG UIF &VSPQFBO FDPOPNJD BTTPDJBUJPO ������o����

#POE (BSZ 3� ����� i4VQQPSUFE FNQMPZNFOU� FWJEFODF GPS BO FWJEFODF�CBTFE QSBDUJDF�w 1TZDIJBUSJD SFIBCJMJ�UBUJPO KPVSOBM ��������

#PSKBT (FPSHF +� ����� i5P HIFUUP PS OPU UP HIFUUP� &UIOJDJUZ BOE SFTJEFOUJBM TFHSFHBUJPO�w +PVSOBM PG 6SCBO&DPOPNJDT �������o����

#SPEBUZ 5IPNBT #SVOP $SÏQPO BOE %FOJT 'PVHÒSF� ����� 6TJOH NBUDIJOH FTUJNBUPST UP FWBMVBUF BMUFSOBUJWFZPVUI FNQMPZNFOU QSPHSBNT� FWJEFODF GSPN 'SBODF ����o����� *O &DPOPNFUSJD FWBMVBUJPO PG MBCPVS NBSLFUQPMJDJFT� 4QSJOHFS QQ� ��o����

#VSUMFTT (BSZ FU BM� ����� 5IF XPSL SFTQPOTF UP B HVBSBOUFFE JODPNF� " TVSWFZ PG FYQFSJNFOUBM FWJEFODF� *O$POGFSFODF 4FSJFT�<1SPDFFEJOHT>� 7PM� �� 'FEFSBM 3FTFSWF #BOL PG #PTUPO QQ� ��o���

��

Page 44: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

$BMEFSPO .BSHBSJUB &TQJOP BOE -JMJBOB .JOBZB�3PXF� ����� 1SFWFOUJOH MPOH�UFSN &-T� 5SBOTGPSNJOH TDIPPMTUP NFFU DPSF TUBOEBSET� $PSXJO 1SFTT�

$BMEFSØO .BSHBSJUB 3PCFSU 4MBWJO BOE .BSUB 4ÈODIF[� ����� i&æFDUJWF JOTUSVDUJPO GPS &OHMJTI MFBSOFST�w 5IF'VUVSF PG $IJMESFO �������o����

$BQQT 3BOEZ ,BUIMFFO /FXMBOE 4VTBO 'SBU[LF 4VTBOOBI (SPWFT (SFH "VDMBJS .JDIBFM 'JY BOE .BSHJF.D)VHI� ����B� i*OUFHSBUJOH SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT� 5IF TVDDFTTFT BOE DIBMMFOHFT PG SFTFUUMFNFOUJO B (MPCBM $POUFYU�w 4UBUJTUJDBM +PVSOBM PG UIF *"04 �������o����

$BQQT 3BOEZ ,BUIMFFO /FXMBOE 4VTBO 'SBU[LF 4VTBOOBI (SPWFT (SFH "VDMBJS .JDIBFM 'JY BOE .BSHJF.D)VHI� ����C� i*OUFHSBUJOH SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT� 5IF TVDDFTTFT BOE DIBMMFOHFT PG SFTFUUMFNFOUJO B (MPCBM $POUFYU�w 4UBUJTUJDBM +PVSOBM PG UIF *"04 �������o����

$BSE %BWJE BOE %BOJFM . 4VMMJWBO� ����� i.FBTVSJOH UIF &æFDU PG 4VCTJEJ[FE 5SBJOJOH 1SPHSBNT PO.PWFNFOUT*O BOE0VU PG &NQMPZNFOU�w�

$BUUBOFP "MFKBOESB BOE 4UFGBO $8PMUFS� ����� i.JHSBUJPO QPMJDZ DBO CPPTU 1*4" SFTVMUT� 'JOEJOHT GSPN B OBUVSBMFYQFSJNFOU�w�

$FOUFS /JTLBOFO� ����� i4UBUFNFOU GPS UIF 3FDPSE PG UIF /JTLBOFO $FOUFS 4VCNJUUFE UP 5IF )PVTF $PNNJUUFFPO UIF +VEJDJBSZ )FBSJOH POi5IF 4ZSJBO 3FGVHFF $SJTJT BOE *UT *NQBDU PO UIF 4FDVSJUZ PG UIF 6�4� 3FGVHFF"ENJTTJPOT 1SPHSBNw�w�

$IBDØO 'FSOBOEP (FNB (VUJÏSSF[ 7FSØOJDB 4BVUP .BSÓB -VJTB 7FDJOB BOE "MGPOTP 1ÏSF[� ����� i7PMVOUFFS'VODUJPOT *OWFOUPSZ� " TZTUFNBUJD SFWJFX�w 1TJDPUIFNB �������o����

$IBP (FPSHJB 5 1BUN 8BM[ BOE 1IJMJQ % (BSEOFS� ����� i'PSNBM BOE JOGPSNBM NFOUPSTIJQT� " DPNQBSJTPO PONFOUPSJOH GVODUJPOT BOE DPOUSBTU XJUI OPONFOUPSFE DPVOUFSQBSUT�w 1FSTPOOFM QTZDIPMPHZ �������o����

$IFVOH 4JO :J BOE +FOOZ 1IJMMJNPSF� ����� i3FGVHFFT TPDJBM DBQJUBM BOE MBCPVS NBSLFU JOUFHSBUJPO JO UIF 6,�w4PDJPMPHZ �������o����

$POOPS 1IJMMJQ� ����� i&YQMBJOJOH UIF SFGVHFF HBQ� &DPOPNJD PVUDPNFT PG SFGVHFFT WFSTVT PUIFS JNNJHSBOUT�w+PVSOBM PG 3FGVHFF 4UVEJFT �������o����

$PTUFMMP & +BOF "MBBUUJO &SLBOMJ 8JMMJBN $PQFMBOE BOE "ESJBO "OHPME� ����� i"TTPDJBUJPO PG GBNJMZ JODPNFTVQQMFNFOUT JO BEPMFTDFODF XJUI EFWFMPQNFOU PG QTZDIJBUSJD BOE TVCTUBODF VTF EJTPSEFST JO BEVMUIPPE BNPOHBO "NFSJDBO *OEJBO QPQVMBUJPO�w +"." ����������o�����

$SFFTF "OHFMB BOE "ESJBO #MBDLMFEHF� ����� i5SBOTMBOHVBHJOH JO UIF CJMJOHVBM DMBTTSPPN� " QFEBHPHZ GPSMFBSOJOH BOE UFBDIJOH w 5IF NPEFSO MBOHVBHF KPVSOBM �������o����

$SPTOPF 3PCFSU� ����� i&BSMZ DIJME DBSF BOE UIF TDIPPM SFBEJOFTT PG DIJMESFO GSPN.FYJDBO JNNJHSBOU GBNJMJFT�w*OUFSOBUJPOBM .JHSBUJPO 3FWJFX �������o����

$VNNJOT +JN� ����� i1VUUJOH MBOHVBHF QSPmDJFODZ JO JUT QMBDF� 3FTQPOEJOH UP DSJUJRVFT PG UIF DPOWFSTBUJPOBM�B�DBEFNJD MBOHVBHF EJTUJODUJPO�w &OHMJTI JO &VSPQF� 5IF BDRVJTJUJPO PG B UIJSE MBOHVBHF QQ� ��o���

%BNN "OOB 1JJM� ����� i&UIOJD FODMBWFT BOE JNNJHSBOU MBCPS NBSLFU PVUDPNFT� 2VBTJ�FYQFSJNFOUBM FWJEFODF�w+PVSOBM PG -BCPS &DPOPNJDT �������o����

EF .BUPT "OB %BNBT BOE 5IPNBT -JFCJH� ����� i5IF RVBMJmDBUJPOT PG JNNJHSBOUT BOE UIFJS WBMVF JO UIF MBCPVSNBSLFU�w .BUDIJOH &DPOPNJD .JHSBUJPO XJUI -BCPVS .BSLFU /FFET QQ� ���o����

��

Page 45: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

%F .FM 4VSFTI %BWJE .D,FO[JF BOE $ISJTUPQIFS 8PPESVæ� ����� i0OF�UJNF USBOTGFST PG DBTI PS DBQJUBM IBWFMPOH�MBTUJOH FæFDUT PO NJDSPFOUFSQSJTFT JO 4SJ -BOLB�w 4DJFODF �����������o����

%F .FM 4VSFTI %BWJE .D,FO[JF BOE $ISJTUPQIFS 8PPESVæ� ����� i5IF EFNBOE GPS BOE DPOTFRVFODFT PG GPS�NBMJ[BUJPO BNPOH JOGPSNBM mSNT JO 4SJ -BOLB�w "NFSJDBO &DPOPNJD +PVSOBM� "QQMJFE &DPOPNJDT ������o���

%FTJEFSJP .BSJB 7JODFO[B� ����� i*OUFHSBUJOH 3FGVHFFT JOUP )PTU $PVOUSZ -BCPS.BSLFUT� $IBMMFOHFT BOE 1PMJDZ0QUJPOT�w�

%F7PSFU[ %PO + 4FSHJZ 1JWOFOLP BOE.PSUPO #FJTFS� ����� i5IF FDPOPNJD FYQFSJFODFT PG SFGVHFFT JO $BOBEB�w�

%PJ :PLP %BWJE .D,FO[JF BOE #JMBM ;JB� ����� i8IP ZPV USBJO NBUUFST� *EFOUJGZJOH DPNCJOFE FæFDUT PGmOBODJBM FEVDBUJPO PO NJHSBOU IPVTFIPMET�w +PVSOBM PG %FWFMPQNFOU &DPOPNJDT ������o���

%SFIFS (FPSHF ' BOE 5BZMPS ) $PY +S� ����� i3BDF HFOEFS BOE PQQPSUVOJUZ� B TUVEZ PG DPNQFOTBUJPO BUUBJONFOUBOE UIF FTUBCMJTINFOU PG NFOUPSJOH SFMBUJPOTIJQT�w +PVSOBM PG BQQMJFE QTZDIPMPHZ ��������

%SVDLFS 1FUFS '� ����� i8IBU CVTJOFTT DBO MFBSO GSPN OPOQSPmUT�w )BSWBSE CVTJOFTT SFWJFX ������o���

%VnP &TUIFS� ����� i(SBOENPUIFST BOE HSBOEEBVHIUFST� PME�BHF QFOTJPOT BOE JOUSBIPVTFIPME BMMPDBUJPO JO 4PVUI"GSJDB�w 5IF 8PSME #BOL &DPOPNJD 3FWJFX �����o���

&BTUPO�$BMBCSJB &WBO BOE /BPIJLP 0NBUB� ����� i.JDSP�mOBODF JO SFGVHFF DPOUFYUT� DVSSFOU TDIPMBSTIJQ BOESFTFBSDI HBQT�w�

&CZ +FTTJDB &SJLB *WFSTPO +FOJGFS 4NZFST BOE &SPM ,FLJD� ����� i5IF GBJUI DPNNVOJUZ T SPMF JO SFGVHFF SFTFU�UMFNFOU JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT�w +PVSOBM PG 3FGVHFF 4UVEJFT Q� GFS����

&CZ -JMMJBO 5 "OHJF - -PDLXPPE BOE .BSDVT #VUUT� ����� i1FSDFJWFE TVQQPSU GPS NFOUPSJOH� " NVMUJQMF QFS�TQFDUJWFT BQQSPBDI�w +PVSOBM PG 7PDBUJPOBM #FIBWJPS �������o����

&EJO 1FS�"OEFST 1FUFS 'SFESJLTTPO BOE 0MPG ¯TMVOE� ����� i&UIOJD FODMBWFT BOE UIF FDPOPNJD TVDDFTT PGJNNJHSBOUT� &WJEFODF GSPN B OBUVSBM FYQFSJNFOU�w 5IF RVBSUFSMZ KPVSOBM PG FDPOPNJDT ��������o����

&HZQU #FJU "M ,BSNB $POTVMUJOH� ����� i.JE�5FSN &WBMVBUJPO PG 6/)$3 (SBEVBUJPO 1SPHSBNNF JO &HZQU�w�

&OHMBOE 1VCMJD )FBMUI� ����� -PDBM BDUJPO PO IFBMUI JOFRVBMJUJFT� SFEVDJOH UIF OVNCFS PG ZPVOH QFPQMF OPUJO FNQMPZNFOU FEVDBUJPO PS USBJOJOH /&&5� 6�,� (PWFSONFOU 1)& (BUFXBZ OVNCFS� ��������

&OPT 3ZBO %� ����� 5IF TQBDF CFUXFFO VT� 4PDJBM HFPHSBQIZ BOE QPMJUJDT� $BNCSJEHF 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT�

&VXBMT 3PC BOE 3BJOFS8JOLFMNBOO� ����� i5SBJOJOH JOUFOTJUZ BOE mSTU MBCPS NBSLFU PVUDPNFT PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQHSBEVBUFT�w JOUFSOBUJPOBM +PVSOBM PG NBOQPXFS �������o����

&WBOT %BWJE , BOE "OOB 1PQPWB� ����� i$BTI USBOTGFST BOE UFNQUBUJPO HPPET� B SFWJFX PG HMPCBM FWJEFODF�w�

&WBOT 8JMMJBN / BOE %BOJFM 'JU[HFSBME� ����� 5IF FDPOPNJD BOE TPDJBM PVUDPNFT PG SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6OJUFE4UBUFT� &WJEFODF GSPN UIF "$4� 5FDIOJDBM SFQPSU /BUJPOBM #VSFBV PG &DPOPNJD 3FTFBSDI�

'BHFOTPO &MMFO "� ����� i5IF NFOUPS BEWBOUBHF� QFSDFJWFE DBSFFS�KPC FYQFSJFODFT PG QSPUÏHÏT WFSTVT OPO�QSPUÏHÏT�w +PVSOBM PG PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM CFIBWJPS �������o����

'B[FM .JOB +FSFNZ 8IFFMFS BOE +PIO %BOFTI� ����� i1SFWBMFODF PG TFSJPVT NFOUBM EJTPSEFS JO ���� SFGVHFFTSFTFUUMFE JO XFTUFSO DPVOUSJFT� B TZTUFNBUJD SFWJFX�w 5IF -BODFU ������������o�����

��

Page 46: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

'B[FM .JOB 3VUI 7 3FFE $BUIFSJOF 1BOUFS�#SJDL BOE "MBO 4UFJO� ����� i.FOUBM IFBMUI PG EJTQMBDFE BOE SFGVHFFDIJMESFO SFTFUUMFE JO IJHI�JODPNF DPVOUSJFT� SJTL BOE QSPUFDUJWF GBDUPST�w 5IF -BODFU �����������o����

'JT[CFJO "SJFM BOE /PSCFSU 3 4DIBEZ� ����� $POEJUJPOBM DBTI USBOTGFST� SFEVDJOH QSFTFOU BOE GVUVSF QPWFSUZ�8PSME #BOL 1VCMJDBUJPOT�

'JY .JDIBFM ,BUF )PPQFS BOE +JF ;POH� ����� i)PX "SF 3FGVHFFT 'BSJOH *OUFHSBUJPO BU 64 BOE 4UBUF -FWFMT�w�

'MFHF +BNFT &NJM BOE 4FSFOB -JV� ����� i5IF FæFDU PG FYQFSJFODF PO BEVMUT� BDRVJTJUJPO PG B TFDPOE MBOHVBHF�w4UVEJFT JO TFDPOE MBOHVBHF BDRVJTJUJPO �������o����

'PHFE .FUUF BOE (JPWBOOJ 1FSJ� ����� i*NNJHSBOUT� FæFDU PO OBUJWF XPSLFST� /FX BOBMZTJT PO MPOHJUVEJOBM EBUB�w"NFSJDBO &DPOPNJD +PVSOBM� "QQMJFE &DPOPNJDT ����o���

'PMFZ &MJTF� ����B� i3FGVHFF (SPVQT 4BZ $PNNVOJUJFT "SF 3FBEZ "OE 8JMMJOH 5P %P .PSF�w�

'PMFZ &MJTF� ����C� i5IFTF (SPVQT )BWF "O *EFB 5P )FMQ 4ZSJBO 3FGVHFFT� -FU 1FPQMF 4QPOTPS 5IFN�w�

GPS &DPOPNJDT $FOUSF BOE #VTJOFTT 3FTFBSDI� ����� i5)& *.1"$5 0' "113&/5*$&4)*14�w $FOUSF GPS&DPOPNJDT BOE #VTJOFTT 3FTFBSDI �

'PSVN $BOBEJBO "QQSFOUJDFTIJQ� ����� *5 1":4 50 )*3& "/ "113&/5*$&� $BMDVMBUJOH UIF 3FUVSO PO5SBJOJOH *OWFTUNFOU GPS 4LJMMFE 5SBEFT &NQMPZFST JO $BOBEB� $BOBEJBO "QQSFOUJDFTIJQ 'PSVN�

'PVOEBUJPO (BUFT� ����� i*OOPWBUJPO JO &4- 5FDIOPMPHZ� .PCJMF -FBSOJOH 5FDIOPMPHZ�w�

'VISFS .BSD BOE +àSH 4DIXFSJ� ����� i5XP�ZFBS BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT GPS ZPVOH QFPQMF XJUI MFBSOJOH EJçDVMUJFT� BDPTU�CFOFmU BOBMZTJT GPS USBJOJOH mSNT�w &NQJSJDBM SFTFBSDI JO WPDBUJPOBM FEVDBUJPO BOE USBJOJOH ������o����

(BMJOEP�,VIO 3PTFBOOB BOE 3VUI . (V[MFZ� ����� i5IF WPMVOUFFS TBUJTGBDUJPO JOEFY� $POTUSVDU EFmOJUJPO NFBTVSFNFOU EFWFMPQNFOU BOE WBMJEBUJPO�w +PVSOBM PG 4PDJBM 4FSWJDF 3FTFBSDI ������o���

(BSDÓB 0GFMJB BOE +P "OOF ,MFJGHFO� ����� &EVDBUJOH FNFSHFOU CJMJOHVBMT� 1PMJDJFT QSPHSBNT BOE QSBDUJDFTGPS &OHMJTI MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST� 5FBDIFST $PMMFHF 1SFTT�

(BSOFS +PIOZ 5 BOE -JOETFZ 5 (BSOFS� ����� i7PMVOUFFSJOH BO PQJOJPO� 0SHBOJ[BUJPOBM WPJDF BOE WPMVOUFFSSFUFOUJPO JO OPOQSPmU PSHBOJ[BUJPOT�w /POQSPmU BOE 7PMVOUBSZ 4FDUPS 2VBSUFSMZ �������o����

(FOFTFF 'SFE ,BUISZO -JOEIPMN�-FBSZ 8JMMJBN 4BVOEFST BOE %POOB $ISJTUJBO� ����� i&OHMJTI MBOHVBHF MFBSO�FST JO 64 TDIPPMT� "O PWFSWJFX PG SFTFBSDI mOEJOHT�w +PVSOBM PG &EVDBUJPO GPS 4UVEFOUT 1MBDFE BU 3JTL�������o����

(FOUJMJOJ 6HP .BEEBMFOB )POPSBUJ 3VTMBO :FNUTPW FU BM� ����� i5IF TUBUF PG TPDJBM TBGFUZ OFUT �����w 5IF8PSME #BOL 8BTIJOHUPO %$ �

(PMEFOCFSH $MBVEF� ����� i$POHSFTT� #JMJOHVBMJTN *T /PU B )BOEJDBQ�w�

(PVME &SJD % 7JDUPS -BWZ BOE . %BOJFMF 1BTFSNBO� ����� i*NNJHSBUJOH UP PQQPSUVOJUZ� &TUJNBUJOH UIF FæFDUPG TDIPPM RVBMJUZ VTJOH B OBUVSBM FYQFSJNFOU PO &UIJPQJBOT JO *TSBFM�w 5IF 2VBSUFSMZ +PVSOBM PG &DPOPNJDT��������o����

(PWFSONFOU $BOBEJBO� ����� i&WBMVBUJPO PG UIF )PTU 1SPHSBN�w�

��

Page 47: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

(SFFOF +BZ 1� ����� i" NFUB�BOBMZTJT PG UIF 3PTTFMM BOE #BLFS SFWJFX PG CJMJOHVBM FEVDBUJPO SFTFBSDI�w #JMJOHVBM3FTFBSDI +PVSOBM ���������o����

(SJNN .JDIBFM BOE "OOB -VJTB 1BæIBVTFO� ����� i%P JOUFSWFOUJPOT UBSHFUFE BU NJDSP�FOUSFQSFOFVST BOE TNBMMBOENFEJVN�TJ[FE mSNT DSFBUF KPCT " TZTUFNBUJD SFWJFX PG UIF FWJEFODF GPS MPX BOENJEEMF JODPNF DPVOUSJFT�w-BCPVS &DPOPNJDT �����o���

(VCMFS +PTIVB 3� ����� 8IFO)VNBOJ[JOH UIF &OFNZ 'BJMT� 5IF SPMF PG EJTTPOBODF BOE KVTUJmDBUJPO JO JOUFSHSPVQDPOnJDU� *O "OOVBM .FFUJOH PG UIF "NFSJDBO 1PMJUJDBM 4DJFODF "TTPDJBUJPO�

)BHFO�;BOLFS +FTTJDB 'SBODFTDB #BTUBHMJ -VLF )BSNBO 7BMFOUJOB #BSDB (FPSHJOB 4UVSHF BOE 5BOKB 4DINJEU������ i6OEFSTUBOEJOH UIF JNQBDU PG DBTI USBOTGFST� UIF FWJEFODF�w 0%* #SJFmOH� -POEPO� 0WFSTFBT %FWFM�PQNFOU *OTUJUVUF �

)BJONVFMMFS +FOT %PNJOJL )BOHBSUOFS BOE %VODBO -BXSFODF� ����B� i8IFO MJWFT BSF QVU PO IPME� -FOHUIZBTZMVN QSPDFTTFT EFDSFBTF FNQMPZNFOU BNPOH SFGVHFFT�w 4DJFODF BEWBODFT ���F��������

)BJONVFMMFS +FOT %PNJOJL )BOHBSUOFS BOE %VODBO -BXSFODF� ����C� i8IFO MJWFT BSF QVU PO IPME� -FOHUIZBTZMVN QSPDFTTFT EFDSFBTF FNQMPZNFOU BNPOH SFGVHFFT�w 4DJFODF "EWBODFT ���F��������

)BMQFSO 1FHHZ� ����� i3FGVHFF FDPOPNJD TFMG�TVçDJFODZ� "O FYQMPSBUPSZ TUVEZ PG BQQSPBDIFT VTFE JO PçDF PGSFGVHFF SFTFUUMFNFOU QSPHSBNT�w 64 %FQBSUNFOU PG )FBMUI BOE )VNBO 4FSWJDFT �

)BOHBSUOFS %PNJOJL &MJBT %JOBT .PSJU[ .BSCBDI ,POTUBOUJOPT .BUBLPT BOE %JNJUSJPT 9FGUFSJT� ����� i%PFT&YQPTVSF UP UIF 3FGVHFF $SJTJT .BLF /BUJWFT .PSF )PTUJMF w�

)BP -JOHYJO� ����� i8FBMUI PG *NNJHSBOU BOE /BUJWF�#PSO "NFSJDBOT�w *OUFSOBUJPOBM .JHSBUJPO 3FWJFX�������o����

)BP -JOHYJO FU BM� ����� i*NNJHSBOUT BOE 8FBMUI 4USBUJmDBUJPO JO UIF 64�w +PJOU $FOUFS GPS 1PWFSUZ 3FTFBSDI8PSLJOH 1BQFS �����o���

)BSU #FUUZ BOE 5PEE 3 3JTMFZ� ����� .FBOJOHGVM EJæFSFODFT JO UIF FWFSZEBZ FYQFSJFODF PG ZPVOH "NFSJDBODIJMESFO� 1BVM ) #SPPLFT 1VCMJTIJOH�

)BTMVDL $ISJT BOE "OOF & (SFFO� ����� 8IBU XPSLT GPS XIPN � B SFWJFX PG FWJEFODF BOE NFUB�BOBMZTJT GPSUIF %FQBSUNFOU GPS 8PSL BOE 1FOTJPOT� /VNCFS ��� $PSQPSBUF %PDVNFOU 4FSWJDFT�

)BVTIPGFS +PIBOOFT BOE +FSFNZ 4IBQJSP� ����� i)PVTFIPME SFTQPOTF UP JODPNF DIBOHFT� &WJEFODF GSPN BOVODPOEJUJPOBM DBTI USBOTGFS QSPHSBN JO ,FOZB�w .BTTBDIVTFUUT *OTUJUVUF PG 5FDIOPMPHZ �

)BZOFT .BSHPU BOE 8JMMJBN (SBCF� ����� i3FBEJOH JO B TFDPOE MBOHVBHF� .PWJOH GSPN UIFPSZ UP QSBDUJDF�w4UVEJFT JO 4FDPOE -BOHVBHF "DRVJTJUJPO ��������

)FDLNBO +BNFT +� ����� i1PMJDJFT UP GPTUFS IVNBO DBQJUBM�w 3FTFBSDI JO FDPOPNJDT �����o���

)FL 3BDIFM� ����� i5IF SPMF PG FEVDBUJPO JO UIF TFUUMFNFOU PG ZPVOH SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6,� 5IF FYQFSJFODFT PGZPVOH SFGVHFFT�w 1SBDUJDF �������o����

)FMMBOE )ÌWBSE BOE -JW "OOF 4U�SFO� ����� i7PDBUJPOBM FEVDBUJPO BOE UIF BMMPDBUJPO PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT� &RVBMDIBODFT GPS BQQMJDBOUT SFHBSEMFTT PG JNNJHSBOU CBDLHSPVOE w &VSPQFBO TPDJPMPHJDBM SFWJFX �������o����

)FMQFS 4VTBO 3ZBO /PPOBO +FTTJDB 3 /JDIPMTPO BOE %BWJE -BOHEPO� ����� i5IF #FOFmUT BOE $PTUT PG "Q�QSFOUJDFTIJQT� " #VTJOFTT 1FSTQFDUJWF�w 64 %FQBSUNFOU PG $PNNFSDF �

��

Page 48: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

)JMM .BSL - 1 %BWJE #BOLT 3JUB 3 )BOESJDI 1BVM ) 8FINBO +BOFU 8 )JMM BOE .JDIBFM 4 4IBGFS� �����i#FOFmU�DPTU BOBMZTJT PG TVQQPSUFE DPNQFUJUJWF FNQMPZNFOU GPS QFSTPOT XJUI NFOUBM SFUBSEBUJPO�w 3FTFBSDI JO%FWFMPQNFOUBM %JTBCJMJUJFT �����o���

)PFDLFM ,BUISJO BOE 3PCFSU 4DIXBSU[� ����� i-FBSOJOH GPS +PCT 0&$% 3FWJFXT PG 7PDBUJPOBM &EVDBUJPO BOE5SBJOJOH�w "VTUSJB� 0SHBOJTBUJPO GPS &DPOPNJD $P�PQFSBUJPO BOE %FWFMPQNFOU 0&$% �

)PmOHFS $� ;BOEPOFMMB .� BOE # )PTFS� ����� i*OUFHSBUJPOTNPOJUPS 0CFSPFTUFSSFJDI �����w�

)PMMFOCFDL ,FWJO BOE 8FJ�+BOH )VBOH� ����� i/FU JNQBDU BOE CFOFmU�DPTU FTUJNBUFT PG UIF XPSLGPSDF EFWFMPQ�NFOU TZTUFN JO 8BTIJOHUPO TUBUF�w�

)PPQFS ,BUF +JF ;POH 3BOEZ $BQQT BOE .JDIBFM 'JY� ����� i:PVOH DIJMESFO PG SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT�*OUFHSBUJPO TVDDFTTFT BOE DIBMMFOHFT�w�

)PPQFS ,BUF .BSJB 7JODFO[B %FTJEFSJP BOE #SJBO 4BMBOU� ����� i*NQSPWJOH UIF -BCPS .BSLFU JOUFHSBUJPO PG.JHSBOUT BOE 3FGVHFFT�w�

)PV 'FOH BOE .PSUPO #FJTFS� ����� i-FBSOJOH UIF -BOHVBHF PG B /FX $PVOUSZ� " 5FO�ZFBS 4UVEZ PG &OHMJTI"DRVJTJUJPO CZ 4PVUI�&BTU "TJBO 3FGVHFFT JO $BOBEB�w *OUFSOBUJPOBM .JHSBUJPO �������o����

)VHP (+ 4BOKVHUB 7BT %FW +BOFU 8BMM .& :PVOH 7JHZB 4IBSNB BOE ,FMMZ 1BSLFS� ����� i&DPOPNJD TPDJBMBOE DJWJD DPOUSJCVUJPOT PG mSTU BOE TFDPOE HFOFSBUJPO IVNBOJUBSJBO FOUSBOUT�w�

)ZOENBO +FOOJGFS� ����� i5IF 4UBUF PG 1SJWBUF 3FGVHFF 4QPOTPSTIJQ JO $BOBEB� 5SFOET *TTVFT BOE *NQBDUT�w�

*NNJHSBUJPO 3FGVHFFT BOE $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB� ����� 'JWF DPVOUSJFT XPSLJOH PO OFX SFGVHFF TQPOTPSTIJQQSPHSBNT� $JTJPO�

*NNJHSBUJPO 3FGVHFFT BOE &WBMVBUJPO %JWJTJPO $JUJ[FOTIJQ $BOBEB� ����� i&WBMVBUJPO PG UIF 3FTFUUMFNFOU 1SP�HSBNT ("3 143 #703 BOE 3"1�w�

*3"1 *OUFSOBUJPOBM 3FGVHFF"TTJTUBODF 1SPKFDU� ����� i1SJWBUF 4QPOTPSTIJQ PG 3FGVHFF 3FTFUUMFNFOU JO UIF6OJUFE4UBUFT� (VJEJOH 1SJODJQMFT BOE 3FDPNNFOEBUJPOT�w�

+PIOTPO +BDRVFMJOF 4 BOE &MJTTB - /FXQPSU� ����� i$SJUJDBM QFSJPE FæFDUT JO TFDPOE MBOHVBHF MFBSOJOH� 5IFJOnVFODF PG NBUVSBUJPOBM TUBUF PO UIF BDRVJTJUJPO PG &OHMJTI BT B TFDPOE MBOHVBHF�w $PHOJUJWF QTZDIPMPHZ������o���

,BBT -FP BOE $ISJTUJBO .BOHFS� ����� i&UIOJD EJTDSJNJOBUJPO JO (FSNBOZ�T MBCPVS NBSLFU� B mFME FYQFSJNFOU�w(FSNBO &DPOPNJD 3FWJFX �����o���

,BOUPS +PEJ BOE $BUSJO &JOIPSO� ����� i$BOBEJBOT "EPQUFE 3FGVHFF 'BNJMJFT GPS B :FBS� 5IFO $BNF A.POUI�����w�

,BSBLBZBMJ 4FSIBU BOE + 0MBG ,MFJTU� ����� i&'"�4UVEJF�w 4UVSLUVSFO VOE .PUJWF EFS FISFOBNUMJDIFO 'MàDIMU�JOHTBSCFJU &'" JO%FVUTDIMBOE� �� 'PSTDIVOHTCFSJDIU� &SHFCOJTTF FJOFS FYQMPSBUJWFO6NGSBHF WPN/PWFN�CFS�%F[FNCFS ���� �

,BSBLBZBMJ 4FSIBU BOE + 0MBG ,MFJTU� ����� i7PMVOUFFST BOE BTZMVN TFFLFST�w 'PSDFE .JHSBUJPO 3FWJFX ������

,BSVOBSBUIOF 8BTBOB BOE +PIO(JCTPO� ����� i'JOBODJBM MJUFSBDZ BOE SFNJUUBODF CFIBWJPS PG TLJMMFE BOE VOTLJMMFEJNNJHSBOU HSPVQT JO "VTUSBMJB�w +PVSOBM PG "TJBO &DPOPNJDT �����o���

��

Page 49: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

,FMMNBO -BVSJF� ����� 5SVNQ PSEFST NPSF DBTI JOEVTUSZ JOQVU GPS BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT� "TTPDJBUFE 1SFTT�

,FVOH /JDIPMBT� ����� i3ZFSTPO DFMFCSBUFT TVDDFTT PG 4ZSJBO TQPOTPSTIJQ DIBMMFOHF�w�

,MFJO &MBJOF $� ����� i4FDPOE WFSTVT UIJSE MBOHVBHF BDRVJTJUJPO� *T UIFSF B EJæFSFODF w -BOHVBHF MFBSOJOH�������o����

,PEB ,FJLP� ����� i3FBEJOH BOE MBOHVBHF MFBSOJOH� $SPTTMJOHVJTUJD DPOTUSBJOUT PO TFDPOE MBOHVBHF SFBEJOHEFWFMPQNFOU�w -BOHVBHF MFBSOJOH ��T���o���

,SBN ,BUIZ & BOE -ZOO " *TBCFMMB� ����� i.FOUPSJOH BMUFSOBUJWFT� 5IF SPMF PG QFFS SFMBUJPOTIJQT JO DBSFFSEFWFMPQNFOU�w "DBEFNZ PG NBOBHFNFOU +PVSOBM �������o����

-BNCB /BWKPU ,� ����� i5IF FNQMPZNFOU FYQFSJFODFT PG $BOBEJBO SFGVHFFT� .FBTVSJOH UIF JNQBDU PG IVNBOBOE TPDJBM DBQJUBM PO RVBMJUZ PG FNQMPZNFOU�w$BOBEJBO 3FWJFX PG 4PDJPMPHZ�3FWVF DBOBEJFOOF EF TPDJPMPHJF������o���

-FSNBO 3PCFSU -BVSFO &ZTUFS BOE ,BUF $IBNCFST� ����� i5IF #FOFmUT BOE $IBMMFOHFT PG 3FHJTUFSFE "QQSFO�UJDFTIJQ� 5IF 4QPOTPST� 1FSTQFDUJWF�w 6SCBO *OTUJUVUF /+� �

-FTFNBO 1BVM� ����� i&BSMZ FEVDBUJPO GPS JNNJHSBOU DIJMESFO�w 5IF 5SBOTBUMBOUJD 5BTL 'PSDF PO *NNJHSBUJPOBOE *OUFHSBUJPO .JHSBUJPO 1PMJDZ *OTUJUVUF�#FSUFMTNBOO 4UJGUVOH �

-VOECPSH 1FS BOE 1FS 4LFEJOHFS� ����� i.JOJNVN XBHFT BOE UIF JOUFHSBUJPO PG SFGVHFF JNNJHSBOUT�w�

.BDPVST ,BSFO /PSCFSU 4DIBEZ BOE 3FOPT 7BLJT� ����� i$BTI USBOTGFST CFIBWJPSBM DIBOHFT BOE DPHOJUJWFEFWFMPQNFOU JO FBSMZ DIJMEIPPE� FWJEFODF GSPN B SBOEPNJ[FE FYQFSJNFOU�w�

.BHOVTPO ,BUIFSJOF $MBVEJB -BIBJF BOE +BOF 8BMEGPHFM� ����� i1SFTDIPPM BOE TDIPPM SFBEJOFTT PG DIJMESFO PGJNNJHSBOUT�w 4PDJBM 4DJFODF 2VBSUFSMZ ��������o�����

.BXO -BVSFO &NJMZ + 0MJWFS /BTJNB "LIUFS $MBSF - #BNCSB $BSPMF 5PSHFSTPO $ISJT #SJEMF BOE )FMFO +4UBJO� ����� i"SF XF GBJMJOH ZPVOH QFPQMF OPU JO FNQMPZNFOU FEVDBUJPO PS USBJOJOH /&&5T " TZTUFNBUJDSFWJFX BOE NFUB�BOBMZTJT PG SF�FOHBHFNFOU JOUFSWFOUJPOT�w 4ZTUFNBUJD SFWJFXT ������

.DDBSUIZ 3PTF BOE .FMBOJF )BJUI�$PPQFS� ����� i&WBMVBUJOH UIF JNQBDU PG CFGSJFOEJOH GPS QSFHOBOU BTZMVNTFFLJOH BOE SFGVHFF XPNFO�w�

.D*OUPTI 4UFWFO� ����� " DPTU�CFOFmU BOBMZTJT PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT BOE PUIFS WPDBUJPOBM RVBMJmDBUJPOT� %F�QBSUNFOU GPS &EVDBUJPO BOE 4LJMMT /PUUJOHIBN�

.FTUIFOFPT &MJ[BCFUI BOE &MJ[BCFUI *PBOOJEJ� ����� i0CTUBDMFT UP SFGVHFF JOUFHSBUJPO JO UIF &VSPQFBO 6OJPONFNCFS TUBUFT�w +PVSOBM PG 3FGVHFF 4UVEJFT �������o����

.JSHIBOJ ;BISB� ����� i)FBMJOH UISPVHI TIBSJOH� BO PVUSFBDI QSPKFDU XJUI *SBRJ SFGVHFF WPMVOUFFST JO 4ZSJB�w*OUFSWFOUJPO �������o����

.PISFOXFJTFS +FOT� ����� i8IJDI mSNT USBJO EJTBEWBOUBHFE ZPVUI w &NQJSJDBM SFTFBSDI JO WPDBUJPOBM FEVDB�UJPO BOE USBJOJOH ������o����

.PSMBOE -ZO /JDPMF *WFT $MFB .D/FFMZ BOE $IFOPB "MMFO� ����� i1SPWJEJOH B )FBE 4UBSU� *NQSPWJOH "DDFTTUP &BSMZ $IJMEIPPE &EVDBUJPO GPS 3FGVHFFT�w .JHSBUJPO 1PMJDZ *OTUJUVUF �

.PSSJTTFZ ,BUF� ����� i3FGVHFF BVUP MPBO QSPHSBN NBZ CF NPEFM UP IFMQ MPX�JODPNF GBNJMJFT XJUI mOBODJOH�w�

��

Page 50: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

.PVTB 4BMNB� ����B� i*OUFSWJFXT XJUI �� SFGVHFF DBTFT BOE �� TUBæ NFNCFST BU UISFF SFTFUUMFNFOU BHFODZPçDFT BOE BU SFGVHFF DMJFOUT� IPNFT JO .PEFTUP 5VSMPDL BOE 0BLMBOE $" BOE 4BMU -BLF $JUZ 65�w�

.PVTB 4BMNB� ����C� i1IPOF JOUFSWJFX XJUI QSPHSBN NBOBHFS BU *NNJHSBOU &NQMPZNFOU $PVODJM PG #SJUJTI$PMVNCJB *&$#$�w�

.PZFS "MFOF� ����� "HF BDDFOU BOE FYQFSJFODF JO TFDPOE MBOHVBHF BDRVJTJUJPO� BO JOUFHSBUFE BQQSPBDI UPDSJUJDBM QFSJPE JORVJSZ� 7PM� � .VMUJMJOHVBM .BUUFST�

.VOTIJ ,BJWBO� ����� i/FUXPSLT JO UIF NPEFSO FDPOPNZ� .FYJDBO NJHSBOUT JO UIF 64 MBCPS NBSLFU�w 5IF2VBSUFSMZ +PVSOBM PG &DPOPNJDT ��������o����

.VSSFMM "VESFZ + BOE 4BOESB 4DIXBSU[ 5BOHSJ� ����� i.FOUPSJOH BU UIF NBSHJO�w .FOUPSJOH EJMFNNBT� %FWFM�PQNFOUBM SFMBUJPOTIJQT XJUIJO NVMUJDVMUVSBM PSHBOJ[BUJPOT QQ� ���o����

/BXZO 4UFQIBOJF +� ����� i'BJUIGVMMZ 1SPWJEJOH 3FGVHF� 5IF 3PMF PG 3FMJHJPVT 0SHBOJ[BUJPOT JO 3FGVHFF "TTJT�UBODF BOE "EWPDBDZ�w 5IF $FOUFS GPS $PNQBSBUJWF *NNJHSBUJPO 4UVEJFT QQ� ���o����

/B[[BM ,SJTUFM )FJEJ .BS[JFI 'PSHIBOZ . $IBSJT (FFWBSVHIFTF 7FOVT .BINPPEJ BOE +PSHF 8POH� �����i"O JOOPWBUJWF DPNNVOJUZ�PSJFOUFE BQQSPBDI UP QSFWFOUJPO BOE FBSMZ JOUFSWFOUJPO XJUI SFGVHFFT JO UIF 6OJUFE4UBUFT�w 1TZDIPMPHJDBM TFSWJDFT �������o����

/JCCT 'BJUI� ����� i.PWJOH *OUP UIF 'BTUMBOF� 6OEFSTUBOEJOH SFGVHFF VQXBSE NPCJMJUZ JO UIF DPOUFYU PG SFTFUUMF�NFOU�w�

/PF 3BZNPOE " %BWJE # (SFFOCFSHFS BOE 4IFOH 8BOH� ����� .FOUPSJOH� 8IBU XF LOPX BOE XIFSF XFNJHIU HP� *O 3FTFBSDI JO QFSTPOOFM BOE IVNBO SFTPVSDFT NBOBHFNFOU� &NFSBME (SPVQ 1VCMJTIJOH -JNJUFEQQ� ���o����

/PVSTF 5JNPUIZ )� ����� i.JDSPmOBODF GPS 3FGVHFFT &NFSHJOH 1SJODJQMFT GPS &æFDUJWF *NQMFNFOUBUJPO�w .J�DSPmOBODF BOE SFGVHFFT �

0&$%� ����� i3FTQPOTFT UP UIF SFGVHFF DSJTJT� 'JOBODJBM FEVDBUJPO BOE UIF MPOH�UFSN JOUFHSBUJPO PG SFGVHFFT BOENJHSBOUT�w�

PG 'PSFJHO "æBJST 'FEFSBM %FQU� ����� i&BSO8IJMF :PV -FBSO� 4XJU[FSMBOE T 7PDBUJPOBM &EVDBUJPO BOE 5SBJOJOH4ZTUFN " .PEFM GPS "QQSFOUJDFTIJQT JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT�w &NCBTTZ PG 4XJU[FSMBOE JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT PG"NFSJDB �

0SP[DP .BOVFM� ����� &DPOPNJD 4UBUVT BOE 3FNJUUBODF #FIBWJPS "NPOH -BUJO "NFSJDBO BOE $BSJCCFBO .J�HSBOUT JO UIF 1PTU�SFDFTTJPO 1FSJPE� *O *NNJHSBOU 7VMOFSBCJMJUZ BOE 3FTJMJFODF� 4QSJOHFS QQ� ���o����

0TUSPæ $IFSJ BOE 4UFWF 8+ ,P[MPXTLJ� ����� i5IF SPMF PG NFOUPSJOH JO UIF JOGPSNBUJPO HBUIFSJOH QSPDFTTFT PGOFXDPNFST EVSJOH FBSMZ PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM TPDJBMJ[BUJPO�w +PVSOBM PG 7PDBUJPOBM #FIBWJPS �������o����

0UUBWJBOP (JBONBSDP *1 BOE (JPWBOOJ 1FSJ� ����� i5IF FDPOPNJD WBMVF PG DVMUVSBM EJWFSTJUZ� FWJEFODF GSPN 64DJUJFT�w +PVSOBM PG &DPOPNJD HFPHSBQIZ ����o���

1BMVDL &MJ[BCFUI -FWZ 4FUI (SFFO BOE %POBME 1 (SFFO� ����� i5IF $POUBDU )ZQPUIFTJT 3FWJTJUFE�w 443/ �

1BUFM #IBSUJ BOE 4BPJSTF ,FSSJHBO� ����� i)VOHSZ BOE )PNFMFTT� 5IF JNQBDU PG UIF XJUIESBXBM PG TUBUF TVQQPSUPO BTZMVN TFFLFST SFGVHFF DPNNVOJUJFT BOE UIF WPMVOUFFS TFDUPS�w�

��

Page 51: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

1FUUJHSFX 5IPNBT ' BOE -JOEB 3 5SPQQ� ����� i" NFUB�BOBMZUJD UFTU PG JOUFSHSPVQ DPOUBDU UIFPSZ�w +PVSOBM PGQFSTPOBMJUZ BOE TPDJBM QTZDIPMPHZ ��������

1IJMMJNPSF +FOOZ BOE -JTB (PPETPO� ����� i1SPCMFN PS PQQPSUVOJUZ "TZMVN TFFLFST SFGVHFFT FNQMPZNFOUBOE TPDJBM FYDMVTJPO JO EFQSJWFE VSCBO BSFBT�w 6SCBO 4UVEJFT ���������o�����

1JMMFS *OHSJE� ����� i1BTTJOH GPS B OBUJWF TQFBLFS� *EFOUJUZ BOE TVDDFTT JO TFDPOE MBOHVBHF MFBSOJOH�w +PVSOBM PGTPDJPMJOHVJTUJDT ������o����

1*4" 0&$%� ����� i3FTVMUT� 4UVEFOUT BOE.POFZ� 'JOBODJBM -JUFSBDZ 4LJMMT GPS UIF ��TU $FOUVSZ 7PMVNF 7*�w�

1MPOTLZ -VLF BOE 'SFEFSJDL - 0TXBME� ����� i)PX CJH JT CJH *OUFSQSFUJOH FæFDU TJ[FT JO -� SFTFBSDI�w-BOHVBHF -FBSOJOH �������o����

1PSUFT "MFKBOESP BOE .JO ;IPV� ����� i5IF OFX TFDPOE HFOFSBUJPO� 4FHNFOUFE BTTJNJMBUJPO BOE JUT WBSJBOUT�w5IF BOOBMT PG UIF "NFSJDBO BDBEFNZ PG QPMJUJDBM BOE TPDJBM TDJFODF �������o���

1PSUFT "MFKBOESP BOE 3PCFSU - #BDI� ����� -BUJO KPVSOFZ� $VCBO BOE .FYJDBO JNNJHSBOUT JO UIF 6OJUFE4UBUFT� 6OJW PG $BMJGPSOJB 1SFTT�

1PSUFT "MFKBOESP BOE 3VCÏO ( 3VNCBVU� ����� -FHBDJFT� 5IF TUPSZ PG UIF JNNJHSBOU TFDPOE HFOFSBUJPO� 6OJWPG $BMJGPSOJB 1SFTT�

1SFTTÏ %FCSB BOE +FTTJF 5IPNTPO� ����� i5IF SFTFUUMFNFOU DIBMMFOHF� *OUFHSBUJPO PG SFGVHFFT GSPN QSPUSBDUFESFGVHFF TJUVBUJPOT�w 3FGVHF� $BOBEB�T +PVSOBM PO 3FGVHFFT ����

1VUOBN 3PCFSU %� ����� 0VS LJET� 5IF "NFSJDBO ESFBN JO DSJTJT� 4JNPO BOE 4DIVTUFS�

2VSFTIJ .VIBNNBE "TJG� ����� i" NFUB�BOBMZTJT� "HF BOE TFDPOE MBOHVBHF HSBNNBS BDRVJTJUJPO�w 4ZTUFN������o����

3BHJOT #FMMF 3PTF� ����� i#BSSJFST UP NFOUPSJOH� 5IF GFNBMF NBOBHFS�T EJMFNNB�w)VNBO SFMBUJPOT �����o���

3BHJOT #FMMF 3PTF� ����� i%JWFSTJmFE NFOUPSJOH SFMBUJPOTIJQT JO PSHBOJ[BUJPOT� " QPXFS QFSTQFDUJWF�w "DBEFNZPG .BOBHFNFOU 3FWJFX �������o����

3FFE %FCCJF "MCFSU :VOH�)TV -JV 3FCFDDB ,MFJONBO "OOBMJTB .BTUSJ %BWJO 3FFE 4BNJOB 4BUUBS +FTTJDB;JFHMFS FU BM� ����� "O FæFDUJWFOFTT BTTFTTNFOU BOE DPTU�CFOFmU BOBMZTJT PG SFHJTUFSFE BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ JO ��TUBUFT� 5FDIOJDBM SFQPSU .BUIFNBUJDB 1PMJDZ 3FTFBSDI�

3FJDINBO /BODZ + BOE +PZDF 4 4UFSMJOH� ����� i3FDBTUJOH UIF CSBTT SJOH� %FDPOTUSVDUJOH BOE SFDPOTUSVDUJOHXPSLQMBDF PQQPSUVOJUJFT GPS XPNFO MBXZFST�w $BQ� 6- 3FW� �������

3JBDI 1FUFS " BOE +VEJUI 3JDI� ����� i"O FYQFSJNFOUBM JOWFTUJHBUJPO PG BHF EJTDSJNJOBUJPO JO UIF 'SFODI MBCPVSNBSLFU�w�

3JDIBSE %PVH� ����� i5IF 3JDIBSE SFWJFX PG BQQSFOUJDFTIJQT�w�

3JDINPOE "� ����� i����� 4PDJPMPHJDBM UIFPSJFT PG JOUFSOBUJPOBM NJHSBUJPO� UIF DBTF PG SFGVHFFT� $VSSFOU 4PDJ�PMPHZ �� � �����w�

3PCCJOT $MBVEJB BOE -JOOFB $ &ISJ� ����� i3FBEJOH TUPSZCPPLT UP LJOEFSHBSUOFST IFMQT UIFN MFBSO OFX WPDBC�VMBSZ XPSET�w +PVSOBM PG FEVDBUJPOBM QTZDIPMPHZ �������

3PDI (3� ����� i.VDI BEP BCPVU NFOUPST�w )BSWBSE CVTJOFTT SFWJFX ������o���

��

Page 52: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

3PDIF (FSBSE 3� ����� i1SPCJOH PQJOJPOT�w )BSWBSE #VTJOFTT 3FWJFX �������

3PMTUBE ,FMMJF ,BUF .BIPOFZ BOE (FOF 7 (MBTT� ����� i5IF CJH QJDUVSF� " NFUB�BOBMZTJT PG QSPHSBN FæFDUJWF�OFTT SFTFBSDI PO &OHMJTI MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST�w &EVDBUJPOBM QPMJDZ �������o����

4BMBOU #SJBO BOE .FHIBO #FOUPO� ����� i5IF FDPOPNJD JOUFHSBUJPO PG SFGVHFFT JO $BOBEB� B NJYFE SFDPSE w�

4BMFIJ�*TGBIBOJ %KBWBE BOE .PIBNNBE�)BEJ .PTUBGBWJ� ����� i$BTI USBOTGFST BOE MBCPS TVQQMZ� FWJEFODF GSPNB MBSHF�TDBMF QSPHSBN JO *SBO�w�

4DBOEVSB 5FSSJ "� ����� i.FOUPSTIJQ BOE DBSFFSNPCJMJUZ� "O FNQJSJDBM JOWFTUJHBUJPO�w +PVSOBM PG PSHBOJ[BUJPOBMCFIBWJPS �������o����

4DIMFHFMNJMDI #PEP # BOE $BSPMZO 5ZOBO� ����� i8IP WPMVOUFFST � "O JOWFTUJHBUJPO JOUP UIF DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT PGDIBSJUZ WPMVOUFFST�w +PVSOBM PG .BSLFUJOH .BOBHFNFOU ������o����

4DPUU &VHFOF� ����� i.BZPST TUSJLF CBDL BHBJOTU HPWFSOPST JO SFGVHFF mHIU�w�

4FBWF "WB� ����� i*O 5IF #BUUMF 0G 0OMJOF -BOHVBHF -FBSOJOH 1SPHSBNT 8IP *T 8JOOJOH w�

4FTIBO (BOFTI BOE %FBO :BOH� ����� i.PUJWBUJOH NJHSBOUT� B mFME FYQFSJNFOU PO mOBODJBM EFDJTJPO�NBLJOH JOUSBOTOBUJPOBM IPVTFIPMET�w +PVSOBM PG %FWFMPQNFOU &DPOPNJDT �������o����

4IPSU %FCPSBI BOE 4IBOOPO 'JU[TJNNPOT� ����� %PVCMF UIF XPSL� $IBMMFOHFT BOE TPMVUJPOT UP BDRVJSJOH MBO�HVBHF BOE BDBEFNJD MJUFSBDZ GPS BEPMFTDFOU &OHMJTI MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST� " SFQPSU UP $BSOFHJF $PSQPSBUJPOPG /FX :PSL� "MMJBODF GPS &YDFMMFOU &EVDBUJPO�

4JBOFTJ #BSCBSB� ����� i"O FWBMVBUJPO PG UIF 4XFEJTI TZTUFN PG BDUJWF MBCPS NBSLFU QSPHSBNT JO UIF ����T�w3FWJFX PG &DPOPNJDT BOE TUBUJTUJDT �������o����

4JNJDI -BVSB .PSUPO #FJTFS .JSJBN 4UFXBSU BOE &EXBSE .XBLBSJNCB� ����� i1SPWJEJOH TPDJBM TVQQPSU GPSJNNJHSBOUT BOE SFGVHFFT JO $BOBEB� $IBMMFOHFT BOE EJSFDUJPOT�w +PVSOBM PG JNNJHSBOU IFBMUI ������o����

4JNPOJWJU[ (BCPS (BCPS ,F[EJ BOE 1FUFS ,BSEPT� ����� i4FFJOH UIF 8PSME 5ISPVHI UIF 0UIFS�T &ZF� "O 0OMJOF*OUFSWFOUJPO 3FEVDJOH &UIOJD 1SFKVEJDF�w "NFSJDBO 1PMJUJDBM 4DJFODF 3FWJFX QQ� �o��

4JOHFS "VESFZ� ����� i*OWFTUJOH JO UIF )VNBO $BQJUBM PG *NNJHSBOUT 4USFOHUIFOJOH 3FHJPOBM &DPOPNJFT�w8BTIJOHUPO %$� #SPPLJOHT *OTUJUVUJPO� 3FUSJFWFE 0DUPCFS ��������

4MBWJO 3PCFSU & BOE "MBO $IFVOH� ����� i" TZOUIFTJT PG SFTFBSDI PO MBOHVBHF PG SFBEJOH JOTUSVDUJPO GPS &OHMJTIMBOHVBHF MFBSOFST�w 3FWJFX PG &EVDBUJPOBM 3FTFBSDI �������o����

4NJUI &SJDB BOE 3PT #SFOOBO ,FNNJT� ����� 5PXBSET B NPEFM BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ GSBNFXPSL� B DPNQBSBUJWFBOBMZTJT PG OBUJPOBM BQQSFOUJDFTIJQ TZTUFNT� *-0�

4PNNBSSJCBT "EPMGP %BWJE 1FUSZ /PFNJF .BSDVT BOE #JSUF /JFOBCFS� ����� 3FTFUUMFNFOU BOE )VNBOJUBSJBO"ENJTTJPO 1SPHSBNNFT JO &VSPQFoXIBU XPSLT 5FDIOJDBM SFQPSU 6OJWFSTJUZ PG -VYFNCPVSH BOE UIF &VSPQFBO.JHSBUJPO /FUXPSL�

4UBUJTUJDT /BUJPOBM $FOUFS &EVDBUJPO� ����� i&OHMJTI MBOHVBHF MFBSOFST� 'BTU 'BDUT�w�

4UFJOCFSH 4BSBI "ZSFT BOE #FO 4DIXBSU[� ����� i&UIOJD FODMBWFT BOE UIF FDPOPNJD TVDDFTT PG JNNJHSBOUT�&WJEFODF GSPN B OBUVSBM FYQFSJNFOU�w $FOUFS GPS "NFSJDBO 1SPHSFTT 3FQPSU �

4UFJONBZS "OESFBT� ����� i&YQPTVSF UP SFGVHFFT BOE WPUJOH GPS UIF GBS�SJHIU�VOFYQFDUFE SFTVMUT GSPN "VTUSJB�w�

��

Page 53: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

4UVLBT "SUIVS " ,FJMBI " 8PSUI & (JM $MBSZ BOE .BSL 4OZEFS� ����� i5IF NBUDIJOH PG NPUJWBUJPOT UP BG�GPSEBODFT JO UIF WPMVOUFFS FOWJSPONFOU� "O JOEFY GPS BTTFTTJOH UIF JNQBDU PG NVMUJQMF NBUDIFT PO WPMVOUFFSPVUDPNFT�w /POQSPmU BOE 7PMVOUBSZ 4FDUPS 2VBSUFSMZ �����o���

4UVNQG 4UFQIFO " BOE .BOVFM -POEPO� ����� i.BOBHFNFOU QSPNPUJPOT� *OEJWJEVBM BOE PSHBOJ[BUJPOBM GBDUPSTJOnVFODJOH UIF EFDJTJPO QSPDFTT�w "DBEFNZ PG .BOBHFNFOU 3FWJFX ������o����

4VÈSF[�0SP[DP $BSPMB .BSDFMP . 4VÈSF[�0SP[DP BOE *SJOB 5PEPSPWB� ����� -FBSOJOH B OFX MBOE� )BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT�

4VNOBMM )BSSZ BOE "OHFMJOB #SPUIFSIPPE� ����� 4PDJBM SFJOUFHSBUJPO BOE FNQMPZNFOU� FWJEFODF BOE JOUFS�WFOUJPOT GPS ESVH VTFST JO USFBUNFOU� /VNCFS �� 1VCMJDBUJPOT 0çDF PG UIF &VSPQFBO 6OJPO -VYFNCPVSH$JUZ�

5BLBOJTIJ 3VCZ� ����� i-FWFMJOH UIF QMBZJOH mFME� 4VQQPSUJOH JNNJHSBOU DIJMESFO GSPN CJSUI UP FJHIU�w 5IFGVUVSF PG $IJMESFO QQ� ��o���

5BZMPS &CPOJ . &NBE " :BOOJ $MFMJB 1F[[J .JDIBFM (VUFSCPDL &SJO 3PUIOFZ &MJ[BCFUI )BSUPO +FTTJDB .PO�UPVS $PMMJO &MJBT BOE )FBUIFS #VSLF� ����� i1IZTJDBM BOE NFOUBM IFBMUI TUBUVT PG *SBRJ SFGVHFFT SFTFUUMFE JO UIF6OJUFE 4UBUFT�w +PVSOBM PG JNNJHSBOU BOE NJOPSJUZ IFBMUI ��������o�����

5PQB (JPSHJP� ����� i4PDJBM JOUFSBDUJPOT MPDBM TQJMMPWFST BOE VOFNQMPZNFOU�w 5IF 3FWJFX PG &DPOPNJD 4UVEJFT�������o����

5PSCBUJ :FHBOFI BOE .JDB 3PTFOCFSH� ����� i&YDMVTJWF� 4UBUF %FQBSUNFOU UFMMT SFGVHFF BHFODJFT UP EPXOTJ[F6�4� PQFSBUJPOT�w�

7FDJOB .BSÓB - 'FSOBOEP $IBDØO .BOVFM 4VFJSP BOE "OB #BSSØO� ����� i7PMVOUFFS FOHBHFNFOU� %PFT FO�HBHFNFOU QSFEJDU UIF EFHSFF PG TBUJTGBDUJPO BNPOH OFX WPMVOUFFST BOE UIF DPNNJUNFOU PG UIPTF XIP IBWF CFFOBDUJWF MPOHFS w "QQMJFE 1TZDIPMPHZ �������o����

7FTTFMJOPW 3PVNFO BOE +PIO (SFHP� ����� i%VPMJOHP FæFDUJWFOFTT TUVEZ�w $JUZ 6OJWFSTJUZ PG /FX :PSL 64" �

7JBUPS 3BMQI &� ����� i5IF BTTPDJBUJPO PG GPSNBM BOE JOGPSNBM QVCMJD BDDPVOUJOH NFOUPSJOH XJUI SPMF TUSFTT BOESFMBUFE KPC PVUDPNFT�w "DDPVOUJOH 0SHBOJ[BUJPOT BOE 4PDJFUZ ������o���

7JHEPS +BDPC -� ����� GSPN *NNJHSBOUT UP "NFSJDBOT� 5IF 3JTF BOE GBMM PG mUUJOH *O� 3PXNBO � -JUUMFmFME�

8BMEJOHFS 3PHFS BOE .JDIBFM * -JDIUFS� ����� )PX UIF PUIFS IBMG XPSLT� *NNJHSBUJPO BOE UIF TPDJBM PSHBOJ�[BUJPO PG MBCPS� 6OJW PG $BMJGPSOJB 1SFTT�

8BMMBDF +FBO &� ����B� i5IF CFOFmUT PG NFOUPSJOH GPS GFNBMF MBXZFST�w +PVSOBM PG 7PDBUJPOBM #FIBWJPS�������o����

8BMMBDF +FBO &� ����C� i5IF CFOFmUT PG NFOUPSJOH GPS GFNBMF MBXZFST�w +PVSOBM PG 7PDBUJPOBM #FIBWJPS�������o����

8FCFS "OESFB BOE )FMNVU )PGFS� ����� i&NQMPZNFOU FæFDUT PG FBSMZ JOUFSWFOUJPOT PO KPC TFBSDI QSPHSBNT�w�

8JEFSRVJTU ,BSM� ����� i" GBJMVSF UP DPNNVOJDBUF� 8IBU JG BOZUIJOH DBO XF MFBSO GSPN UIF OFHBUJWF JODPNFUBY FYQFSJNFOUT w 5IF +PVSOBM PG 4PDJP�&DPOPNJDT ������o���

8POH -PL 1JOH 8JOH )POH $IVJ BOE :BO :VFO ,XPL� ����� i5IF WPMVOUFFS TBUJTGBDUJPO JOEFY� " WBMJEBUJPOTUVEZ JO UIF $IJOFTF DVMUVSBM DPOUFYU�w 4PDJBM JOEJDBUPST SFTFBSDI �������o���

��

Page 54: Boosting Refugee Outcomes: Evidence from Policy, Academia

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3259255

:V 4PPKJO &TUFMMF 0VFMMFU BOE"OHFMZO8BSNJOHUPO� ����� i3FGVHFF JOUFHSBUJPO JO $BOBEB� " TVSWFZ PG FNQJSJDBMFWJEFODF BOE FYJTUJOH TFSWJDFT�w 3FGVHF� $BOBEB�T +PVSOBM PO 3FGVHFFT ����

;IPV .JO� ����� i4USBEEMJOH EJæFSFOU XPSMET�w &UIOJDJUJFT� $IJMESFO PG JNNJHSBOUT JO "NFSJDB QQ� ���o����

��