brooks/petrochem redevelopment landscape architecture capstone project
DESCRIPTION
Kalie Brown's Capstone Project from winter 2010 -advisor: Omar Faruque -site: Petrochem Refinery in Ventura County, California -Brownfield Redevelopment PlanTRANSCRIPT
CHROMA • 1
A New Face for Industry: Crooked Palm Village, Ventura
Josephine ‘Kalie’ BrownLandscape Architecture Senior
Cal Poly San Luis ObispoProfessor: Omar Faruque
2 • CHROMA
CHROMA • 3
Central Plaza at Crooked Palm Village
A New Face for IndustryJosephine ‘Kalie’ Brown
Client: Petrochem Corporation/ Daly Group City of Ventura Rossi Enterprises
Thesis and ConceptAs a developed society we have moved away from living in our natural environment and into a more synthetic, contrived landscape. We have become somewhat invasive species to the environment that surrounds us by disregarding the natural systems that we affect. As we become more aware of the consequences of this lifestyle, we have the opportunity to reconnect with the systems we have damaged.
Designing based on community health, ecosystem integrity and economic viability is an engaging way to live within our local resources rather than having to look elsewere.
Project BackgroundLocated on 4777 Crooked Palm Road, the closed Ventura Petrochem Refinery lies adjacent to Hwy 33 and the Ventura River and bike trail. In the 1950’s the refinery was in prime production and surrounded by active oil wells. By the 1980’s it needed to expand to continue production. The expansion plan was denied due to air pollution so the plant was shut down. The 96-acre industrial parcel has been officially out of use since 1984 and is polluted by refining chemicals, brine, oil, gas and various metal wastes. These wastes are carried out to the Pacific Ocean via the adjacent Ventura River. The holding tanks and refinery structures have not been dismantled and still contain chemical contaminants. Groundwater remediation has begun, but other remediation efforts are
stopped. Proposals for rezoning, city annexation and redevelopment have been proposed since the owner was not able to sell the land.
Crooked Palm Village requires careful environmental design to be suitable for humans and natural systems alike. The natural Ventura River corridor runs along the western border of the site and is affected by the sites runoff, the erosion control measures implemented and the projected uses for the area. Much of the community is designed within the 100-year flood zone due to previous development encroaching onto the river’s natural watercourse, so many environmental and hydrologic solutions were inherent to the design. The site also is planning
to be re-zoned and annexed by the City of Ventura to serve as an economic catalyst.
InnovationAfter studying various methods of
contaminant removal I created a unique remediation design that allows for the aesthetic and environmental advantages of phyto-remediation to be integrated into the developed landscape to provide health to the community while mitigating environmental contaminants and hazards. Remediating and redesigning the polluted space will not only improve the health of the site, but it will provide sustainable living for the community.
4 • CHROMA
V I L L A G E A T C R O O K E D P A L M
A N
ew F
ace
for
Ind
ustr
y A
com
ple
te
syst
em a
pp
roac
h to
inte
grat
ing
com
mun
ity d
esig
n,
envi
ronm
enta
l rem
edia
tion
and
eco
nom
ic p
rogr
ess
Vent
ura
Pet
roch
em R
efine
ry a
nd B
roo
ks In
stit
ute
Exp
ansi
on
Pro
ject
Des
igne
r Kal
ie B
row
n C
onsu
lting
Pro
fess
or O
mar
Far
uque
S
enio
r P
roje
ct S
umm
er/F
all 2
010
LA
461
Sen
ior
Stu
dio
Lan
dsca
pe A
rchi
tect
ure
Dep
artm
ent
Cal
Pol
y, S
an L
uis
Obi
spo,
CA
Sep
tem
ber
22, 2
010
Mis
sio
nTo
eco
logi
cally
rem
edia
te a
nd r
edev
elop
the
ab
and
oned
Pet
roch
em R
efine
ry in
Ven
tura
C
ount
y as
an
envi
ronm
enta
lly v
iab
le h
ousi
ng c
omm
unity
and
rec
reat
ion
area
whi
le
cons
ervi
ng t
he s
ite’s
ind
ustr
ial a
nd n
atur
al h
erita
ge.
Co
ncep
tTo
des
ign
the
com
mun
ity a
s a
com
ple
te a
nd v
iab
le s
yste
m w
ith e
cono
mic
, en
viro
nmen
tal a
nd s
ocie
tal e
lem
ents
wor
king
tog
ethe
r as
a w
hole
for
mut
ual b
enefi
t.
Sca
le: 1
00’=
1”
Sound Berm
DescriptionTo acheive these goals the design leaves
programmed space for natural hydrologic cycles to run their cycle without being at expense the the inhabitants quality of life. There is somewhere for every demographic to find peace in nature and community, while allowing room for the sites native inhabitants to recolonize.
After studying native plants and animals to the area and the oil industries history in the area, the design reflects the two as viable components from the past as a part of the future development.
Exsisting Brooks Institute
Canada Larga River Resotred
Canada Larga Park
Anchor Commercial
Commercial/Office
Farmer’s Market Walk
Petro Blvd. Entry
Student Dorms w/ Studios below
Canada Larga Park
Student Dorms
Parterre Style (set)
Succulent Gravel Garden (set)
Bus stop/Pedestrian Entry
Maintained Oak Grassland (set)
Rolling Grass Hilss (set)
Orchard Amphitheater (set)
Insitute Plaza
Student Shopping
Student Dorms
Sound Berm Brooks Drive EntryBrooks Drive Entry
Crooked Palm Village Master Plan
MissionTo ecologically remediate and redevelop the abandoned Petrochem Refinery and expand the adjacent Brooks Institute in Ventura County as an environmentally viable housing and university community and recreation area while conserving the site’s industrial and natural heritage.
Goals• Remediate the land and surrounding
watershed for human and ecological health• Design a sustainable and connected mixed-
use community that ransitions into the broader environment and community
• Design a mixed transit circulation system to provide auto-alternative access to and through the community
• Design the community to function as a functioning hydrologic and ecologic system
• Work with the land and its resources to develop a community recreation plan
• Preserve the natural history and oil industry history on the site
• Use alternative safety measures and techniques to bring a safe community atmosphere to the area
Crooked Palm Village Early Concept
CHROMA • 5
V I L L A G E A T C R O O K E D P A L M
A N
ew F
ace
for
Ind
ustr
y A
com
ple
te
syst
em a
pp
roac
h to
inte
grat
ing
com
mun
ity d
esig
n,
envi
ronm
enta
l rem
edia
tion
and
eco
nom
ic p
rogr
ess
Vent
ura
Pet
roch
em R
efine
ry a
nd B
roo
ks In
stit
ute
Exp
ansi
on
Pro
ject
Des
igne
r Kal
ie B
row
n C
onsu
lting
Pro
fess
or O
mar
Far
uque
S
enio
r P
roje
ct S
umm
er/F
all 2
010
LA
461
Sen
ior
Stu
dio
Lan
dsca
pe A
rchi
tect
ure
Dep
artm
ent
Cal
Pol
y, S
an L
uis
Obi
spo,
CA
Sep
tem
ber
22, 2
010
Mis
sio
nTo
eco
logi
cally
rem
edia
te a
nd r
edev
elop
the
ab
and
oned
Pet
roch
em R
efine
ry in
Ven
tura
C
ount
y as
an
envi
ronm
enta
lly v
iab
le h
ousi
ng c
omm
unity
and
rec
reat
ion
area
whi
le
cons
ervi
ng t
he s
ite’s
ind
ustr
ial a
nd n
atur
al h
erita
ge.
Co
ncep
tTo
des
ign
the
com
mun
ity a
s a
com
ple
te a
nd v
iab
le s
yste
m w
ith e
cono
mic
, en
viro
nmen
tal a
nd s
ocie
tal e
lem
ents
wor
king
tog
ethe
r as
a w
hole
for
mut
ual b
enefi
t.
Sca
le: 1
00’=
1”
Environmental AnalysisThe site is being combined with the adjacent Brooks Institue, which has plans to quadruple its student population. The site is set at the base of the coastal mountains to the west and Hwy 33 to the east. The site is proposed for residential housing, commercial, office space, recreational space and mixed uses. The site will be annexxed by the city by the Summer or Fall of 2011. It is currently in the city’s Sphere of Influence.
• 136 acres to be developed• oriented north to south: approximately 1
mile long by 1/4 mile wide• the western portion of• oriented north to south: approximately 1
TopographyThe down gradient flows SW to the Ventura
river so most phytoremediation will happen in that corner of the site. Crooked Palm Road is the high point and the Ventura River holds the lowest point near the site and will collect all runoff that is not infiltrated within the site.
Residential Open Space
High Density HousingCentral Plaza
Commercial/Office
Orchard Sculpture WalkOrganic
Agriculture
Holding Tank Agriculture Plots
Medium Density Housing
Medium Density Housing
Mixed Use
Bus stop/Pedestrian Entry
Anchor Commercial
Light Industry/Offices
Manuel Park
Restored Manuel Creetk
Botanic Garden
Poplar Amphitheater
Hyperaccululator Clusters
Maintained Oak Grassland
River Paths
Sound Berm
Petro Blvd. Entry
mile long by 1/4 mile wide• the western portion of the site is protected
by SOAR • views to the east and west are naturally
vegetated or orchard covered mountains
Elements• Ojai/Ventura Bike Trail• Hwy 33• Ventura River• Manuel Creek• Canada Larga River• Brooks Institute• Petrochem Structures• Polluted Soils
Anchor Commercial
Commercial/Office
Farmer’s Market Walk
6 • CHROMA
Open SpaceThe core of this project is the connected
open space. Each resident, visitor and student has ample and equal access to a variety of open space experiences, unique to the Ventura River area. The open space is connected by a pedestrian spine runnig through the site’s mile length. The open spaces conect for accessibility, but also for hydrologic flood mitigation and remediation efforts. The open space doubles as recreation and gathering space as well as runoff filtration and detention areas. Each space is connected by circulation, water and activities.
RemediationThe bio-remediation process will begin with mass plantings of hyper-aclumulators and regrading to allow groundwater to flow down the site’s historic down slope and be cleansed by the hyper-acumulators. Mass plantings of remediatory plants such as Achellia millefolium will be planted and later extracted as toxic waste.
Historical PreservationThe oil industry has been an important part
of our history and evolution in the U.S., but as we advance our technologies and awareness of our affect on the land, we must balance heavy industry with environmental and social needs. Crooked Palm Village does not erase the site’s history, but reduces its scars and pays respect to the productivity of the site’s past.Hydrology
Water filtration and flow is crucial to the site’s environmental viability. All run off is filtered through either swales, bio-detention ponds, or rain gardens before fully percolating into the ground water or being piped into the river. The hydrology plan below shows the interconnected swales and biodetention ponds. The darkest green is the more environmentally sensitive the area and the lighter is more developed. The detention ponds along the rivers serve to filter runoff, provide open space for recreation and mitigate floods as overflow ponds.
Development and Circulation Diagram
Hydrology Diagram (below)
CHROMA • 7
Residential and CommunityThe village is a place for all types of people to take pride in living within a sustainable environment. The balance of living, working, shopping and recreating in the same space creates aims to create a strong community aesthetic.
University LifeThe Brooks Film Institute is planning the
quadruple its student population and will need to expand it campus and living quarters. The student village is connected to the larger community through auto and pedestrian access through the Institute. A main plaza serves as a student gathering and event space with outdoor eating and sweeping swales.
The student housing is high density dormitories to preserve open space opportunityies and to cluster development away from flood danger. Students will live in an outdoor focused, artistic community where film and photo opportunities surround them. After speaking with the developer, they expressed an interest in themed facades, so a series of streetscapes form a variety of film ready
opportunities. The developed portion of the site is surrounded by the primary auto circulation and detention ponds to prevent flood waters from entering the site. The Canada Larga River is known to flood the Brooks site so the road and detention pond is depressed to mitigate any flood dangers. The surrounding open space has been sectioned into a themed arboretum where each consecutive garden inspires a new set for film and photography. Each space in the arboretum is moldable for different artistic expressions, but retains ethic of ecological viability.
Community Public SpacesLiving and working in your community takes
on a new meaning through a walkable pedestrian core that leads to commercial and employment opportunities. The ‘quaint’ scale of the buildings and paths brings the community together and emphasizes cultural, arts and farmer’s markets. The local agriculture is just a step away from the market space and modern ‘Spanish” style plaza where local residents of all ages, along with the occasional tourist, can gather, shop and dine.
Light Industry and CommercialA new type of light industrial park will allow
outdoor experiences for employees to enjoy on their breaks and reduce envrionmental impact by incorporating greenroofs, parking structures, solar panels and pervious paving
The zoning of this industrial park is within a half mile of housing so the residents can live and work in their own neighborhood. A pedestrian and vehicular access bridge connects the two zones safely. The bridge is constructed out of exsisting steel structures from the refinery.
Brooks Union Plaza Section
LA Boulevard Detail
8 • CHROMA
experience a wholistic way of living. Views of the surrounding natural landscape, access the the rivers, plentiful common space and carefully designed hydrologic elements inspire appreciation for the environment.
AgricultureGrowing and selling food locally cuts down
on transportation pollution and maony organic techniques reduce the need for pestiides and herbicides. Bringing back hedgerows and
Environmental InteractionLiving ‘within’ an ecosystem means that resident must know the limits, benefits and resources of their environment. This means that opportunity for environmental interaction and community education are crucial components to the community design. Each space is designed to guide the resident or visitor to
alternating crops reduces pest issues and prevents a monocultural landscape. A local foods market, flower shop, restaurants and farmer’s market venue are in close vicinity to the agricultureal area to ensure a direct connection to the locally grown food.
Community and Education CentersThe first step to ensuring the communities
stong environmental ethic is educating them on sustainable practices, ecology and healthy living. The main education building is centered between the village and university housing for
CHROMA • 9
Orchard Sculpture WalkTo retain the site’s historical character, some
of the Petrochem structures are retained and repurposed for recreational use. These structures are placed within a citrus orchard reflecting the site’s surrounding landuses, a combination of agriculture and industry. The
orchard walk is a maleable space where the structures uses and appearances can evolve as the site ages. Access from the bike trail into the site is focused through the agriculture and orchard areas. Bikers can stop for a peaceful rest among the citrus scents and the cool sea breeze.
easy access for everyone. The village also has a community center for smaller scale educational events and community gatherings. These elements give a unique identity to the village beyond the physical space towards a healthier way of life.
10 • CHROMA
Concluding RemarksI aspire to create a balance between humans, the urban landscape and the natural landscape through my designs and restoration projects. I hope to ensure that people fully appreciate, understand and enjoy the story of spaces that surround them. Through studying landscape architecture we are in the unique position of being able to improve both human and environmental issues. My focus for the future is to design “complete” projects that encompass progress towards a healthier world.
Josephine ‘Kalie’ BrownLandscape Architecture SeniorCal Poly San Luis ObispoSenior Studio: Summer/Fall 2010Consulting Professor: Omar Faruque