burson-marsteller dc advocacy groups social media study final
TRANSCRIPT
A STUDY OF SOCIAL MEDIA AND POLITICAL ADVOCACY:
How Social Media is Changing Grassroots Organizing Among U.S. Political Advocacy Groups
Social Media and Political Advocacy
During recent election cycles, social media has become a powerful channel for political outreach and coalition building. Many key political advocacy groups are now active players in social media and using various platforms to connect with stakeholders. Social media provides political advocacy groups with a platform that widens their reach and can immediately mobilize grassroots support.
This study examines how U.S. Political Advocacy Groups are leveraging social media channels.
Methodology
Burson-Marsteller selected 34 U.S.-based political advocacy groups to evaluate how these groups utilize social media to communicate, specifically Twitter, Facebook and YouTube.
The sample breaks down as follows:
• 14 right-leaning advocacy groups
• 15 left-leaning advocacy groups
• 5 neutral advocacy groups*
At the outset of our research process, we could not identify a definitive index or compilation of political advocacy groups. Therefore, for the purposes of this study, we selected 34 politically-influential groups that represent a range of political viewpoints.
Data was collected in May-June 2010 based on the 34 advocacy groups’ communications from March 15 to April 30, 2010 (6 weeks).
Data was gathered from the advocacy groups’ social media accounts.
Data was collected by Burson-Marsteller’s Global Research Team.
*Note: Because of the small sample size, results for the 5 neutral groups is included in the overall results, but this data is not broken out in the detailed analysis.
Selected Advocacy Groups
Right-leaning Groups: American Conservative Union American Family Association (AFA) Americans for Tax Reform Business Roundtable Christian Coalition of America Family Research Council Federation for American Immigration Reform
(FAIR) Focus on the Family Freedom Works National Federation of Independent Business
(NFIB) National Rifle Association (NRA) National Right to Life National Taxpayers Union US Chamber of Commerce
Neutral Groups: AARP American Israeli Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) Anti-Defamation League (ADL) Common Cause Concord Coalition
Left-leaning Groups: American Association of People with Disabilities (AADP) American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) Coalition to Stop Gun Violence Human Rights Campaign (HRC) League of Conservation Voters MoveOn NARAL Pro-Choice America (National Abortion and
Reproductive Rights Action League) National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
(NAACP) National Committee For An Effective Congress (NCEC) National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare
(NCPSSM) National Council of La Raza (NCLR) National Gay and Lesbian Task Force National Organization for Women (NOW) National Urban League People for the American Way
Overwhelming Majority Use At Least One Social Media Platform
Thirty-three out of the 34 political advocacy groups examined use at least one social media platform, including either a Facebook page, Twitter account or YouTube channel.
Almost all Groups Are Using Multiple Platforms Simultaneously
Ninety-one percent of the political advocacy groups that use social media use Twitter, Facebook and YouTube as a means of outreach.
Only one group had no social media presence.
* No group used only 1 out of 3 platforms.
Interest Groups Use Social Media to Voice Opinions on Legislation
45
75
2621
2621
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Average Number of Mentions About Legislation/Regulation per Group
All of the political advocacy groups with Facebook pages and Twitter accounts use these social media platforms to share their views and news about specific local, state or federal legislationor regulation.
Advocacy groups use Twitter more than Facebook to relay legislative and regulation messages.
Right-leaning advocacy groups were more active in discussing legislation and regulation on Twitter and Facebook than Left-leaning groups in the six weeks studied (from March 15-April 30).
Examples of Tweets/Posts Concerning Legislation
Groups Encourage Direct Outreach to Politicians
Sixty-one percent of political advocacy groups on Twitter and 56 percent on Facebook use social media to encourage stakeholders to reach out politicians.
Ninety-five percent of direct outreach posts on Twitter and 89 percent on Facebookprovided phone numbers, instructions or easy to fill out forms to contact politicians.
Left-leaning advocacy groups were more active than Right-leaning groups in encouraging followers to reach out to Congress or politicians.
61%57%
71%
56% 57%
69%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Percentage of Groups with Posts About Outreach to Politicians
Examples of Tweets/Posts Reaching Out to Government
*** Easy instruction forms like the one to the right make it easy for the public to reach out – in this example, the letter is already written, they just have to fill out their information and sign!
YouTube Channels Also Keep People Informed
107
121
104
95
100
105
110
115
120
125
Average Number of Videos
Per YouTube Channel*
Total
Right-leaning
Left-leaning
The average number of videos per YouTube channel was 107. In total, these political advocacy groups have uploaded 3,432 videos to YouTube.
Many of the YouTube channels had videos about specific legislation.
*Data for YouTube is cumulative over the lifetime of the channel and is not restricted to the March 15- April 30, 2010 timeframe.
Stakeholders Are Seeking Out and Connecting With Groups
The average number of followers, fans, and subscribers on Twitter (4,880 followers), Facebook (32,588 fans) and YouTube (777 subscribers) suggests there is significant public interest in connecting with advocacy groups.
The number of Facebook fans is overwhelmingly higher than the number of Twitter followers and YouTube subscribers for all groups. The groups with the most fans were the National Rifle Association, Freedom Works, The Human Rights Campaign and MoveOn.
4,880 5,348 5,681
32,588 32,418
42,699
777 949 841
0
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
40,000
45,000
Total Righ-leaning Left-leaning
Average Number of Followers/Fans/Subscribers
YouTube
The Two-Way Street: Relationship Building on Twitter
2,261
3,354
1,585
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Average Number of Accounts Following on Twitter
Political advocacy groups on Twitter are not just using social media as a platform for lobbying efforts.
The average account follows more than 2,000 other Twitter users. Right-leaning groups follow the highest number with an average number of accounts following of 3,354 versus 1,585 for Left-leaning groups.
The Two-Way Street: Interacting With Stakeholders on Twitter
Seventy-six percent of advocacy groups are retweeting content from other users.
76%
64%
86%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Percentage of Groups Retweeting Content
The Two-Way Street: Interacting With Stakeholders on Twitter
On Twitter, 73 percent of political advocacy groups mentioned or directly responded to others (by using the “@account” convention).
Left-leaning advocacy groups were more likely to mention or respond to others (93 percent) than Right-leaning groups (50 percent).
73%
50%
93%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Percentage of Groups Mentioning or Responding to Others on Twitter
The Two-Way Street: Interacting With Stakeholders on Twitter
“Stakeholders” were defined as individuals who have an interest in the actions of the organization and can be affected by them. “Influencers” were defined as individuals such as journalists, organizations or politicians who have the ability to influence public opinion.
The percentages of advocacy groups that responded to stakeholders versus influencers were consistent across the board, showing that advocacy groups care equally about deepening their relationships with their stakeholders as well as influencers.
61%
43%
71%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Percentage of Groups Mentioning/Responding to Influencers
61%
50%
64%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Percentage of Groups Mentioning/Responding to Stakeholders
Examples of Groups Mentioning/Responding to Others
The Two-Way Street: Receiving Feedback from Stakeholders
Seventy-eight percent of political advocacy groups with Facebook pages allow their fans to post on their page.
Left-leaning groups were more likely to allow posts (92 percent) than Right-leaning groups.
78% 79%
92%
60%
80%
100%
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Percentage of Groups Allowing Fans to Post
Advocacy Groups Are Not Using Social Media For Raising Money
21%
29%
14%
19%
29%
8%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
Total Right-leaning Left-leaning
Percentage of Groups Asking for Fundraising Support
Less than a third of the political advocacy groups examined (21 percent on Twitter and 18 percent on Facebook) use Twitter and Facebook to ask for fundraising support.
Observations About Social Media Content
Overall, the study saw a variety of content published from political advocacy groups. While this study focused on looking at legislative, outreach and fundraising content other messages included:
• Coalition building• Articles of interest• News or blog posts about the organization• Protests/ Gatherings•Hot button litigation•Candidate endorsements
Key Insights
Some Groups Still Use Social Media as Primarily One-Way Channel
• These groups tend to use Social Media Platforms as a glorified RSS feed or newsletter.
• These groups lose the enormous benefit of community engagement and stakeholder participation that comes with direct interaction.
Social Media Allows for Communication/Mobilization In (Near) Real Time
• Whether during a lengthy legislative debate on the congressional floor (such as Healthcare Reform) or a public protest, advocacy groups are often using social media to communicate and even mobilize their supporters in real-time.
Both Facebook and Twitter are Leveraged to Encourage Outreach
• Beyond building community and disseminating information well over one-half of Advocacy Groups – particularly Left-leaning groups - provide phone and email contact information to inspire calls-to-action by their followers.
Key Insights (continued)
Facebook is Heavily Used to Rally Base Supporters and Build Community
• Facebook pages tend to become a destination for an organizations’ most devoted followers. The material and conversation posted to these pages is usually highly supportive of the organization. The Facebook page often becomes a virtual meeting place where supporters can cheerlead an organization’s efforts and disparage its opponents.
Twitter is Used for Disseminating Messages and Positions on Issues to Influencers and Other Stakeholders
• Twitter appears to be used to broadcast an organization's positions and news. Some groups have engaged with influencers (such as media and politicians) directly on Twitter.
Contacts
Dallas LawrenceManaging Director for Public Affairs202.530.4615 [email protected]/dallaslawrence
Ashley Welde
Director of Strategy Development
212.614.4924