cal parli invitational · room: dwinelle 263 start: 2:30 pm novice parli 3 105 -mutu., corina cal...

Room: Dwinelle 263 Start: 2:30 PM Novice Parli

3 105 - Mutu., Corina

CAL PARLI INVITATIONAL Oct 14 - 15, 2017

JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot.* Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.* Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision.* Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

~ov ~fN\- -L1./-v1.V OPP

Foste~ity Du & Chen POINTS RANK

Irvington Tang & Sactfar Spkr (20-30)

Spkr

~- Olina Du ~1 3 Kelly Tang

1~ Grant Chen c;. ry 1 ~. Kritika Sachar

Washington

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

Winner: -~5_o~s~+-~_S'r"c_h_oo-l/T-CAe_am·_tu--+_,~,,----- debating on the U?fG s~ oJ/J" I.flow point win? __ _ ~ , ( • Side (Gov or Opp)

' Sol.,61-v rw.9-Y\t~ ba. •. : '--signature: Co~'1>

Comments & Reason for Decision:

1.

<Al h'<fi J

Tabroom.com, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org. Iii

Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker In the top ten for the tournament. 28 A very strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times: Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new arguments may be presented in rebuttals, but new examples, explanation, and weighing are permitted.

Page 9 of25


3 110 - Nathan, Josh-

CAL PARLI INVITATIONAL Oct 14 -15, 2017

JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. * Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. ~o not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.* Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your, decision.* Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP

Bentley Zhang & Donn POINTS RANK

Spkr {20-30)

Evergreen Valley Sharma& ... Spkr

Jiawei Zhang "v z~.r { yL ?:or

Rahul Sharma ,

James Donn ~ i. ";}- "3 Kalyan Suvarna .{/

serkeley

. 4 ...

RANK PgJNTS

~0-30) ""'

Z'f lf ~?- z_

~ ell\_t-(..ty Winner: ------Sc_h_o_ol-/T-e-am-+---\-~----r __ debat:.ng :n the Low point win? ___ _

Side (Gov or Opp)

Signature: ----+~ ... Ll~-L'__~------,-------------Comments & Reason for Decision:

_·r;w:r rt~:~r;- .. -~---wf( /~th; 70 ~ c_cv,)v7r~ y >' ot <,{k ~

r

- ~~ tt<'J;:;/. vYll) vf(~5.ev1k)

..

Tabroom.com, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org.

Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker In the top ten for the tournament. 28 A very strong speech, both In terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:

Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new arguments may be presented in rebuttals, but new examples, explanation, and weighing are permitted .

Page 10 of 25

Room: Wheeler 120 Start: 2:30 PM Novice Parli

3 111 - Donn, Ted


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. *Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over. *Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision.* Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room matth the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. ~urn'i11,?al~o Wheeler, Room 126

OPP POINTS RANK

(20-30) Foster City Chen & Gao Spkr

z!3 I { Alina Chen

~ .3 Z- AmaryGao

Bentley

POINTS RANK

,("20-30)

z_g' 2--

27-- y

.re e"--\.._ Low point win? ___ _

Side (Goy or Opp)

Comments & Reason for Decision: / I '" , _k A- ~7 ro.-~~ C-'2 C/~(,C>-~. ft:A" µ-<.et7 ~r:= ~7~ ~,,.J tz<...::> :> ~ .- ~.e--( _, c/ ~ e>t--",,7 ~'·-~ ~~-<--<- e /.:;:...."' ~ -I' t!? c..c ~ /"'- .__,L._ Point Scale:

/A </'S-.V cP .h"' /? O" .S:-/" /'' ~ -L d' c:::! °'y:<C>- / C? J/ 9 p.e_.. r-=Do=no;..ot=g""iv~.e-fe_w_e_r-th_a_n_2_5_p_o_in_ts_u_n--

P c_,,.-e J /.-,,,,· - )'> ,r ~ ,, - -L- / / ,/ / ;v A / ,,a.:. less a speaker was rude or offensive. ,, ~ /y ..u-<- t7 .eA e-~~ ....,,. J,./ ~-r / :;:;-- q C' v C:0.~cC;::;r'( ~ You may give half points. ~ t-< ~ "'::?-- / / 30Aperfectspeech.Youwillprobably

r e _ "-~ / ~ /'' Id _,.e./ _ Y' 0 .f / ~C/ ::::; .r / e - ~o t./< ...::::~ e>e "--- not give any 30s. ,,, -~ k ~ c-' , /~ ~ ,,,.- ' ,/ X 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking

/ / ~ ~ ~ . .,...._.....e--? ~""'""" '/ '- this well every round should place ( T' ~~ .__.,e_/ 7CI thisspeakerinthetoptenforthetour-

~ .,..,y ~ ~ • / / /-? • nament. / ~ ,p,,.,.,...e_ ~-e / / C77 a / 28Averystrongspeech,bothinterms 4 // ;::r /? -4f' ~ ff ..P V-....S of content and delivery.

/ /. / 27 An average speech c- ~ CJ h-.e µ...-' ...e. ( , 26 A speech with multiple glaring

- / • weaknesses.

Ill


25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:

Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. Jhe first Opposition speaker will dell er a 5-minute rebuttal, then the fir Government speaker will deliver a 5- inute rebuttal. No new arguments ay be presented in rebuttals, but new xamples, explanation, and weighing a permitted.

Page2 of25

'.

't. ~ • . ~

... . ' ..

. '. '. . .

·, . •.

: .. " . . . .. - .. ~ # .. ~ ..

. : .

''

CAL PARLI INVITATIO,NAL:·. ''.

Oct 14 7 15, 2017 r ~ :t ~ '" ... •

.. "l ....

' .. If.'',•

JUDGING RULES ~ ' . - • ' Go to the room listed on top of this bal •. ; Before the ~Jund sta'rts, "tell tlrie'Ciebaters what prfor.jud~ing •experience you have'. '

. .....

. . "'"''" ;

. ..

• . ..

'•

., ..... ' •. i.; "I l •

".Campo1indo

"

.. , . Do not interrupt any speech or give com nts before t~e r,ound is over.~ Do no~ leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while maki your decision.• Please write dowA)1rguments made by the debaters.

, • ,:.- :BJ~a.se b.e..sure the COD"Jpetitors in the room m ch the ones on ;iour ballot ana they are spea~ing on the correct side. Turn in batlois to Wtteete~. Room 116 " ·, .• • • • •• • • '' '""

•. , .....

·' '1 '

0 .... ~ ·.·

' •• .. • ~ "'") • .- .. ~, -o1., .. .. : ·~ ' ,. 0 •'GOV "' .~ '

,., Spkr Berk~)ey Nathan &_itatchin·'

r.:..~~-r-~~~~~~~~......,..'--~~-+-,.-f-O_l_N_T_S~.-'-RA-"--N~K~--.. ,\

' . . ' , l~abella Nathan . . . . ' .....

'Ava Zlatchin ( .

•::. ....... · Winner: _W..___a=""-'>"""h~c'-'-n-'--· ~---bin ..... ·-"'._: '"""'. '-----

schoolfT(J/n · •

'• l

. '

',

.. ,

' )< '·

'"',...._ ~

'• .

'\abroom.com, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org.

(:20:~30) · .. .... \

I , ..

•.

~ • • • .. • ~ q

'Low pointWin? ' '· • • • • t

\\

....

Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30Aperfectspeech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this SP,eakerin th~ top ten fo~the tour-nament: ',_; .. "" '\ ,~ ~ ~.~' 28 A v'erY strong speech, both in terms oi content a11d delivery. i1 An·average speech 26 :A. speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. . • 25 A ll\oro~ghly.unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:

Each speaker will deliv11r a 7-rTlinute '"ton~tructjve speech, with·thd Govern-ment te~ntgoing fir~t. -The first Oppositlo speaker will de· liver a s:minut rebuttal, ·then the first Governm nt speaker will deliver a 5-minute reb11.ttal. No new. argu· ments may be presented in rebuttals, but new examples, explanation, and

, weighing are permitted.

' . ' ,.

' ...... \

. '

Page 7 of25


JUDGING RULES

3 124 - Toi, Swati Evergreen Valley


Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. •Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. •Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP POINTS RANK

Irvington Suresh & Vairavan POINTS RANK

Spkr (20-30)

spkr Hillview Das & Goel

'.2- Jatin Das Sumukh Suresh ).:<0~.5 .

z;._ .....

Colin Goel "'.2-- Natraj Vairavan 2-f{- 2f!

Winner: Trvif) <fon ~ll. reJ yan. (J(f debating on the

Side((;~ or Opp) Low point win? __ _

School/Team


fit;../;- ~ ;-:_ ,Redo(m,/it>YJ o;/. toJ1C-s¥dd ¥e, '/J~ rYllY'f, cie.a¥ w_r~ ~~~~ YeMM&llj ttt> /{; .J~J.7 ~ ~ "tl,,,'rt'I~~ t+,wn Pointscale:

p~~~-.l~ t~ ~~ \)Jf!Jft wdf d/Jow , f,j,m,L//::oa~~)l8WY' r-==-'oono~tgive-fewer-than2s-point-~un-• 0 (}J' ~ /

A J · _ J \ I J (/ less a speaker was rude or offensive. ' ~IL.fl> ·'- J.. fi.L sJ;>eec.n., ~ Sm '()f71,.. Youmaygivehalfpoints.

~ ,, tlK-C.- / \t _JJA 30 A ~erfect speech. You will probably

P ~ . ' ~ A 1 r :;ll}'Y f\ 1in ~ not give any 30s. l.~o • S - ~ l(J'l..lO ~ \ J-. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking

/ 01 t I- '::,-:. _ A - .I~ -·· .• · l.Jt. this well every round should place

\_~ f;p • ~ f - ~{ ~/; ~m.1/Z.{} /-/Ju- ~ ~ . ~~~S:n~~kerinthetoptenforthetour-'() r- f _ / J .J...Jp .~" ~ lfjj,Y'f'li- 28Averystrongspeech,bothinterms {J)rf,, t OY\; M ~ ~ ~ ~ () of content and delivery.

, ,., , 27 An average speech ~ e# • ~l) /Ji»]' t{, \ · 26 A speech with multiple glaring

()'t' • /V weaknesses.

_-? ~ !.-~ /~ •,' (,{JJJ,l; 25Athoroughlyunpersuasivespeech.

'' l. / +;t '81 J....n •• , , - • _A~f I " J ,;f " ;;ztr;w' s~::~hs:~:::; will deliver a 7-minute s~tf . ~ v::wrll\..S£ti(x.,_ W& ,JI ~~ - 1..,,-·~ constructlvespeech,withtheGovern-

f ~ · ILJ . !ti . . a 1 ')I\, • vu ment team going first.

L J. ,borq - w~ ~ ~ The first Opposition speaker will de-rof..Lf I /J . .J ~f I ../ . ~ liver a S·minute rebuttal, then the

v:i(J· f ~ drlJ ~ d'YJ ( fa..,.tl.Jv first Government speaker will deliver A.l I I AllllA c~rf a 5-minute rebuttal. No new argu-- ~eh~ ~ ~ ~ • P ~~ ...;:. ments may be presented in rebuttals,

but new examples, explanation, and

~ ~ l- ~ - &pell eJ wt.Cl t1l weighing are permitted.

-t- : ~.(v1Xul w ~ -t "• fh 1re..E f ()11' If,() Vi a.o

~~c~ - Of;o-vd_ ~ •

- ~·J.wk . ~ ~~ T•b<oomrnm,rnN;,,,fthoN.:;of:;,,'li~A="ti~,::,~,.:1 (/, ,/ L . L D~~~.~ ~

¥ /bf)H, ~/ll :-~ ~ ~ ~~~ y8tlY~:q~MWf~, 6"_r~\,~0ifof"\


3 125 - Sharma, Gau-


JUDGING RULES Go to t~e room listed on top of this ballot. • Before the round starts . . . Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round. 'tell :he debaters what pnor judging experience you have. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decisi • P~s over .. Do not leave the room during the round. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the on. ease wnte down arguments made by the debaters. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126 ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side.

GOV OPP

Spkr Irvington Gupta & Kumar POINTS RANK

(20-30) Hillview Willis & Rangarajan Spkr

2. Drishti Gupta - '2~ 3 ,-2_ Austin Willis

' Deiisha Kumar 2G:t I l Samek Rangarajan ' ..

Evergreen Valley

., ~OINTS RANK

(20-30)

2~ 4 Z8·~ 2.

Winner: ~..f!\(ri\ w~ /4~/tCA. 1~ I ;;J School/T~'aFrJ..~ r debating On the __ 9__,_ ___ _ Low point win? ___ _

C.omments & Reason for Decision:

"'- . (L Side (Gov or Opp)

Signature: 4'/~ ~

' \ '

.ft,.. 'f u,J,: r; ' '; bh..k. fyi>,o )i:gt., 1 ~RM. -~ ~ ' ~ r-f.1kt.

s.·ol,,. J"""'-"- ;J----. CovefbA.- ·~s ~ att~./ y~.R- ~'Y r err~~ r1~

, 9 'f:P/ ~?!- ~ F~ ~ ooi....w~ ~

r ~~ c/Jµ_;_rv arr~~ ~

~ ~~.1~ ttu. .ev.-J._ I

w-· .e,cF . ·?~·.

f3dk ~ 4~-4 ~ J4/\-.~'... 1-. t.,a:_l wk'~ 'O

It·~ i j~:l1'~.


J.JoT

Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive You may give half points. · 30 A ~erfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker in the top ten for the tour-nament. • 28 A very strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. • 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:

Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new arguments may be presented in rebuttals, but new examples, explanation and weighing are permitted. '

\ \ I

Page 15 of 25


3 126 Chowdhuri,-Evergreen Valley

CAL PARLI INVITATIONAL @ .:r e:. <2:-?' Oct 14 -15, 2017

JUDGING RULES @ -9S-'t() ~Ar

Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. • Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have.@) Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over. • Do not leave the room during the round. O Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. • Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the c ct side. fD Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126 't1}

GOV OPP

Washington Makkala &-T-ha ... POINTS RANK Berkeley Thompson & Vega Spkr Spkr

(20-30)

~~r-f<'.3fT

[k::3VA~~ 1.-} .1.

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

;Z- :J-- Bennett Thompson 267 3 :'.)_ Joey Vega :Z+- ~

Low ;oint win? __ _


'=?£...c::>? o S A;;.L

-C t+c (2.<2- GU b-c;. i-\a

Off ~~Q~t;O \~A-\ !1

Cu'\-\ \SH \\a1.../ 6 f dVE Cj2_C)~'O 1'N:~ ~K~lN ~+\

<;:o S~~1 ( YCSE-'S

Ao\~~\7" .--7 C(~v \'loT U-\o Cc

pev~tts.\i-0 , ~O\ caT-t ~\9:=:-NT· l-6'1'-C. ~ ~Ao ~ ~ ~ b-f'EA \1 'j---{ ~ t;;A++(J.DA-tA: V~L'f S1afT~ ~~co

(--+G~ Tabroom.com, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org.

Point Scale:

Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker in the top ten for the tournament. 28 A very strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 5 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:

Each speaker will deliver a 7-mlnut constructive speech, with the Gove~ ment team going first. The first Opposition speaker wi liver a 5-minute rebuttal, th first Government speaker will a 5-minute rebuttal. No n ments may be presented in but new examples, expla weighing are permitted.


3 133 - Vega, Joseph


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. * Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while makirl'gyour decision.• Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room ma'b the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP

Washington Sridhar & Mor ... Spkr Spkr Irvington Dave & Parghi RANK

~ Hridini Dave 2. Gopika Sridhar

l Mehek Parghi '-{ Isabella Morales

Berkeley

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

2.-1 2

t.-1 ~

Low point win? ___ _


1 ) \f>/ ., (0.. <c; c; ...!,.-. '"'-L 'SQ,l\.ie fl (,,o ......... "" ~ \,{ ~ f1;. \

Lcl\.c;;,~+- ~~. \

'f tlL~~ v-:JA. ,, b""...\- ~II\ Y.~,la ci .-{V cl ~Y. (~ 0. '-"...C..'I\..~ Co4c;;~~~L'1 \/1 '{°/O ~s <;.

2- UUJ".-1 __ o~f-~ f>o•'1.l<... b""~\~gl/ 6? ~-- (e.c -~ ' C>-J.J \ p /, . .Q. ')L-.t'\'"tL 0 \

~,J!(\ b._..\- J.;6 Ao_\-\ Cc9/){:ot'"\-\- )/\~ ~ \~_:·N-p \,,\.,...\-- £/\ D U ei "'

#.. \ l t>-\"' ""'J, . \


Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker in the top ten for the tournament. 28 A very strong speech, both In terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:

Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new arguments may be presented in rebuttals, but new examples, explanation, and weighing are permitted.

Page 22 of25


3 134 - Zhou, Fang


J,UDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot.• Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. •Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Tucn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP

Washington Shrestha & Thi ... POINTS RANK

. Spkr (20-30)

San Marin Klymenko &.Ng Spkr

' Niva Shrestha ~- t • t Mariya Klymenko

d- Aishwarya Thiyagarajan Lb 3 2 Sarah Ng

Berkeley

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

-v\ '2.

~ 4-

Winner: __ w __ <A_s_\A_'_, A~9~"'°-·~n_: _____ debating on the __ {-,_o_v_. __ Low point win? __ _

2- /v

S<h:,:::.~:. ~' ~ 8 o.vl:l_ ""'

Side (Gov or Opp)

w.ro~ olo1~

~v11

~ ¥"\'c:)A

()'a.&l (~ a. ~ p~ ~~S"'o~ ~ ).A. iAe. "5\'-~ -P"'-o~ ~r~ &»esfi ~ ~VJ -\.-o tu \....Q ~ V\,e'{ ~ G.fe. ..

- (J'~l is 1-Lo+ ~ ~ r'-luJL <Tb~ o-... l e~"-~ .

- d- fJ o-Ucf '1 -t.


Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every'round should place this speaker In the.top ten for the tour-nament. • 28 Avery strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:


b~ IA_, ?f1..

Page 25 of25


3 136 - Velugoti, Laks


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. •Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over. • Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. •Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP

Campolin_do Ly & Strohmeyer POINTS RANK

Spkr

- (20-30) Evergreen Valley Kazmi & B ... Spkr

I Alexander Ly -2.j l 2 Maham Kazmi

.. I Katie Strohmeyer 27 3 2. Samiyah Beary

Irvington

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

2& 2-

.26 4

Winner: Compolrndo !;}, ~ st7[l)hm'jt-r debating on the Gov Low point win?----

/

School/ m Side (Gov or Opp)

\ \.

\

\

'.~broom.com, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org.

Point Scale:


Speech Times:


Page23 of 25


3 137 - Prashar, Nari-


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. * Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over. * Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. * Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP

Nueva Ball & Singh POINTS RANK

Spkr (20-30)

Spkr Evergreen Valley Arun &Noru ..

i, Spencer Ball ··,,, 26 3 2. Nikhita Arun

I Amit Singh ', 7-1 ~ '\. I Sahana NonJ

'

Winner: _f:;_Vi_u-_-+1-~Yef!M---~---'-'-~,--~~,c..r· ____ debating on the V school/Team\ l7

C ments & Reason for Decision:

~w1>'1A~'~ kf,,v&n

/ ;· i/'

' \ ' \

' \ \\

\ \

\ '

\

\ \

\ \ \

\ \


\ \\

\ ' '

\,

POINTS

(20-30)

RANK

Point Scale:

Irvington


Speech Times:

Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new arguments may be presented in rebuttals. but new examples, explanation, and weighing are permitted.

Page 12 of 25


3 ~~ J~Wtstta== }3~


JUDGING RULES · Go to the room listed on top ~this ballot. • Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Clo not interrupt any speech or g1 e comments before the round is over. • Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else w 'le making your decision. •Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the oom match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP

Evergreen Valley Shenoy & POINTS RANK

Hillview Patnaik & Bjornsen POINTS ,RANK

Spkr (20·30)

Divya Shenoy

Zoe Corcoran


fl'bf 1) Ouf(rfLl VDW aller11aftw al--fl.tt. /,p of F ~nl-sp.tdi,

r,Jl,w #wt fl«#/-M+L( .f.ft~,h. 7/141- MY /U I~ ~i11 ff fJ "'""~ ~ Cfl1d(lftcit. 4· ~hal- JOW- Sid£ sknd& fur.

i}~H'f ~ ,.(rald -k as/c fo.J's { 1) & ca!Cfi./ abtrA-tf PIM' sla11ce. A-f .f~ l',ws rl--~

lift ("" S"ffor/J l~"J /""/~ ut 1,,( ~ ~ 1rte1.

4 Crrc"'41-$~ A/ 6/1.trt, tf· II/~ llraf. f?'1 Ila/41 #f11f of"'f,u rltdrl it~ kith/ .ffer Inds.

t.... ~ !kuzs ptf,11<, ~

Spkr (20-30)

( jay Patnaik ts-·f t I z.i:;. S' z,. Bjorn Bjornsen tf -

(}oV Low point win? __ _

Side (Gov or Opp)

jo<.I ullrf1Mkfi;, .J((is fll1'1 I- k> .,,,-~ Z f~{IA.

1) TH...~ lff 111,HCCJMJ- hf f1/0UA tuuffu i,..r14 ~Ii. i-'Po=in=ts=c=ale~: _____ _

L \ I · / Do not give fewer than 25 points un-7ti (aur/er -&. ~/.'/'Is IJt1I "h lfl.D/o; f k'lf()l41 less a speaker was rude or offensive.

/ f f 1 You may give half points.

(f1114 \ 30Aperfectspeech. You will probably

~~ Lf,~ ~~~~ 0Pf f'" ""' h 'Ule.rWJkk /Ulh "-hi of,~a,( 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking 1. __ / •.. / I .. ·u this well every round should place 7~ 11" /U l'tcft 411£/ p~vv Pw«I J J {rd~ flt.a.. thlsspeakerinthetoptenforthetour-

'- h f nament. lfltJ ''"'~,JI /;>41(, 28Averystrongspeech,bothinterms

tJ of content and delivery. 27 An average speech

1'. .,.,, 'f"l.UJ (af ft«. (.., J/.k, eJ(~ct/u /Al 26 A speech with multiple glaring - 1-tf.1(}11.r , v(A;I · r ~ . "J weaknesses.

~"J~ ~ ,,...(( 4< p,,,1

"f (,,,_, f'"lt). 25Athoroughlyunpersuasivespeech.

1'1'"1!./. 'tf-J~ fU. /~? " ~ kftfhc

4- yor.u .rr bl c11-s.-t •

CM-rdf, /U1r 1vM> "J~ ~~ Bldl-i

A.ut Al- lft1t !v1ttr#t~ "~ tJI fi./tw<co~ho111.s !

Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker wlll deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new arguments may be presented in rebuttals, but new examples, explanation, and weighing are pen;nitted.

Ta broom.com, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org. Page 19 of 25


3 139 - Shukla, Nag-


Go to the ro listed on top of this ballot. *Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt speech or give comments before the round is over. * Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with an ne else while making your decision. * Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the compet1 sin the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Roo 6

GOV OPP

Spkr RANK

Berkeley Harkins & Shumw ... Spkr

'J~-S Sonya Ahuja 3 R~· Vincent Harkins

·~ 1- Keya Kadakia '-t ~g Cole Shumway

Irvington

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

~;;.r ~ ':{'ff-

Winner: Low point win? ___ _



Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker in the top ten for the tournament. 28 A very strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:


Page 17 of 25

('{ O<IA k'uho ye_ Room: Wheeler 102 Start: 2:30 PM Novice Parli

3 140 - SacharfAbh-


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. •Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. *Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP POINTS RANK

Washington Cabrales & Mutu (20-30)

Spkr Spkr

Jr 2-- 2- Kristen Cabrales

2-1 !> ' Anna Mutu

Irvington

2- l ' Winner: \Jo-...s. " 1k '1"' f o'cfi


signature: ___ °"_""'"',__---L~---V ____ ' __ _,c_ ______ _


I


Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s.

• 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker in the top ten forthetournament. 28 A very strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 .A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:


Page14of25


3 142 - Goel, Sushil


J,UDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. •Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision.• Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV OPP

Berkeley Ortega & Barish POINTS RANK

• Spkr (20-30)

Foster City Liu & Huang Spkr

2. Sergei Ortega '2-'1 1 2 Brandon Liu

1- Solomon Barish , JZ 3 i Martin Huang

Irvington

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

:ii 2-

J.$ t

Winner: -<$~W_._......~.__.f/)(-"'<-'--\-c,Aj <..:..Ju..:+--_____ debating on the -~(j---r-1)0-+--_ School/Tea~ \', J Side (Gofokl;p)

Low point win?

Signature:---~~~..,,_..__j/_-__ _


Point Scale:

Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this welt every round should place this speaker in the top ten for the tournament. 28 A very strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:


3 150 - Dutta, Lara

CAL PARLI INVITATIONAL Oct 14 - 15, 2017

JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. * Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while ma1<ing your decision. * Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side.

Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV

Spkr

Amirah Mohame Rafi

Sachi Goel

POINTS

( 20-30)

RANK

OPP

Spkr Hillview Deutch & Goldberg

I Jackson Deutch

2 _Melanie Goldberg

El Cerrito

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

·21-- 3 2:r Lf


Q,~~~'":'~~ cRPW , \::OC-L \<\ e0£>.f'j ~o-N.. ~cl <[){\ ~~' C-. \ ~.re..5~1\e.A~~~~ \~\bf\.~\.\--Y- ~ ~ ~ ~r ~~'{\:'.\ '&0-\~ 8c.e--\~ <bFQJL\.I\~ s~;\~) c_\eour) ec0.~

\

Df.P -- '\)\d.V\:-\ <e.~ ~~'t)IJ~ --~ CD) -t\\ee 'P \CLV\.. - D'\~"-\ De:P-,ne_ c_-c-\ k\~u~ \f\ ~ef'µS

cX- ~M''' l'.)e__We- -:e- \!\~. ~ heoA'A- ~ ~\.\['\~ 0- ~'\~o\\~e_"

- l.-c:>-s+ ~ \ (\ ~e.__ 3 'cl. ~ l{J.U.. 'il!Jc.J 11td-5

-s po~ OE'{)J{ r y , caJ ,1_,1 t j OM L (,0 ; 41-----CfJ rt v 1 ci-t: on . _)

0


Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker in the top ten for the tournament. 28Avery strong speech, both in terms " of content and delivery. I,. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:


Page3 of 25


3 158 - Kajaria, Ved-


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. • Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. •Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

' ' GOV

Spkr

2 Rushda Umrani -· \ ..

\ Aahana Chowdhuri

Winner: I "r'Ji


Go"'

CD N'~ ~fi--~ - i~efJkUj 0 e-u·vw.·~ ~ ~--~ l1l ff (!/ o4..vt ~~-~'Dt...

""

POINTS

( 20-30)

~q..

J_.,G

Rt_ f : N ~ (]}J..e.J.. \vt j alt ta..vvV ~ c.~ tMJ·C ~~~£.,,.

_ p~ t-t ( M..<d W.tAt) l,IU.N.>l:. l~

[ N 6lF t>f ftrr.,......._........_J

..,µ ~ vYi u.L.

~ ')"'ti vr Jt-v rr-~ c..o..1-i't.Jt.(,A,.

[_ No 6&VUt:: Y>tctl v-e_ a. 'r-f S ·

~~fJ ..___.

OPP RANK

Irvington Mughal & Shukla RANK

Spkr

J ?-- Anam Mughal ~ 4 Anoushka Shukla :Z'6 I

Low point win?----

(a.ff~)

e~ COJA. ~ -'11-'/.

AK\LJVC./t -.rka.ff-ed-. c...~alQJ.

Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker In the top ten for the tournament. 28 A very strong speech, both In terms of content and delivery.

-~{~~~

~ 3 /. lfV'--Cl ..-e..

27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

.. "f ).~ kJBli,. VVUI ~e&

' Speech Times:

f?c~ui

$ <9-U.. y «l -of \ \I\. C..&-W'\..L .

6?~.J-y of U'k -Each speaker will deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new argu-

/. _ ~ ments may be presented in rebuttals, F ..e.e_ ~ ~ but new examples, explanation, and A

11 ,.. ,, _ _ ~I .• ~ weighing are permitted.

~~-...., u:;,.yvb'+i'dl-V\. • f't '"'4UA clpj

\I ~c •\ - V-> vu:rt {err~ """".

0 Tabroom.com, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org. Page 6 of25


3 160 - Zhang, Rebe-


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot.• Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. •Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

' ' GOV OPP

POINTS RANK Spkr

(20-30)

POINT~ RANK

-30) spkr Hillview Doran & Yu

-~ Jash Parekh J Katie Doran 1 c) Karan Chahal 1-l. AlexYu ,;i. .

Low point win? __ _

people (!_CV1nf}{ kwe . I PPl' ~ /(oer

sir t>~ , )'Wt Vio /~. v ho decvth fJr ~Ju,vtt. o/ve_ #ti 'DYOpf{!,11/1 . i--'Po=in~tS~ca~le~: _____ _

( . Do not give fewer than 25 points un-y i c,t,.._ bpAJ'D/f (le;(;",,.,~ -ffe.t, less a speaker was rude or offensive.

r~ f. /-;} . '!:::>" You may give half points. )lr)l»i1[ 30 A perfect speech. You will probably

.t.. -'··~ : not give any 30s. '{,l<()CN· f2 .j,.,,,,, -,, 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking

-p#U.. 1- ri~ iT 'f,~ C-fJJ4'1}1'fl'- this well every round should place -:J., ~f,t)lrV'.. T"'" thisspeakerlnthetoptenforthetour·

Ot cr,'r'A-{ ..:!;> nament. Z • - 28 A very strong speech, both in term~ ., '.:\. 5,, .. -1-,,,,,ce /I //A4L,.. vru"ls~~ of content and delivery.

D<- ~· L <r <-A ' , { · l' 27 An average speech ~PM ruzPDf.t! Vi' -l/tl- ;ln.d_ 26 A speech with multiple glaring (It. r - ( - r weaknesses.

edt.tt::at:ion) ~e.., 25Athoroughlyunpersuasivespeech.

~~~~::;-:-;:,-:;::-::z:-::::--t::;:;i;;,;-rlr;:;-:;;;.==j~~:-:-:-Q2'.If~uil!.~~t'e..~:?~'1!:_~~~ 1~~-rebUJttle::: ~ /14-lf -t/-t£, f'71>7,. eoµi!>ff/eV) C<f/;lh,&.'. /Pl'f = a.~e/rp/An . JW .fwn;':J ~det.tr~. ~ wiu:J m.11 Ut tJ ? itt ucdrd. dtJM kip r(!V1,-: I. Mi Jurmbj ~JM¢t crt~'rimes:

/.,,.p(T{JY s~ JieAfh bor. d ~ . .&-- ~. bi! bP,..d . €£uit f PtJJ v) ~- cJJV~> (). fa.p "b~au/

-. ef'il( is. lw-.e frn se.ni, sJwpttftt~~ ',

Each speaker will deliver a 7 -minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the

wk:J -~' (! ~CtAS~~ C/fllltJi pfCXICf. I. f'i// : }Wt fCLi~ -tk_rlcli.

/. Tw >tjtt(!.nf Juif-ik. ri'dv-- J -)MT{, f(}LAr. (flUArdu ~ ).

first Government speaker will deliver ·, a 5-minute rebuttal. No new argu

.ments may be presented in rebuttals, t new examples, explanation, and

OJA»t : I. f2.teA /,.av.R ·fW Sern!. i(l-t~ w · hing are permitted.

7k f tr171 kw~ -to NtUI ~ -fi.-L fl{Q}f .f!-'I

JtV}u/£.. "

lMfk l).r.f' FO<. M~ )uilt-cJ:e - t/P S ;ve,tlwu/d ftJLid

(). A»U P"U;t ·lftJl1 r~ cJ..or1e-~t!tf ...>. v,fi'T)/e >Jun,.(d be tt/ie -co "fUj tl;:l?-f/t.e bi/(. l _J.L ~ ~ v

Ol . f!>i / { 7.s (Pl ltfp1S' ti~ tJ on o1. . / "·' v~ - - r AX!,o7!'J4t ~red rrz till. 7'tcp/R. fa/ scxfer ~ -~ · t»nse'j-u01u,s

~ JVJuj_ ~{>'\ /.rlive. tl ttJIYA o-u:/,, a1w615 ·:lk=jJnP/!e p,«5-f~ Tabroom.com, a service of tlie Nation~! Speech & Debate Assocation: hftp://www.speecnand'debate.org. Page 24 of 25

,.t jvfi;tok._ ~Cf I~ i>-t . tJ/.m,a o{ae,'11/ll , ~-------- ---- ~~- --- -


3 161 - Huang, Ray


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. * Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.* Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else while making your decision. *Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side.

Turn in ballots to Wheeler, oom 126

OPP GOV

'a&Xin POINTS RANK

Spkr (20-30)

San Marin Colenbrander & ... POINTS RANK

Spkr

' '!... Darsh Singhania '"" "'~ z.. Evan Colenbrander

i.. Caroline Xin '2..4( 1- Ryan Miller

'", "' Low point win? ___ _

c.....~ \e M-t.-1'\-t'::.-;

- 'fl ~ c.e. ~ v-. ~ "\

- :!iood ~t~dc'O(\!i - c.-oo.J. tt-1-ef""'~. (~-('\~c.1if\~)

.1 I • ".S e>oJ. ".OM M.CAl\.l'-l1.. ff D.-"\

c,, o ,....~ 1 e.<'-1 e<"\. ~ ~ - c,.\~r ~


Point Scale:


Speech Times:


Page 5 of 25


3 169 - Ramakri·shn-


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. * Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any spee~ or give comments before the round is over. * Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone'e~e while making your decision. * Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors'h:!_ the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 't~6

GOV OPP POINTS RANK

Hillview Briggs & Yang Spkr (20·30}

Spkr

2- Geetika Yelugoti L- \ Alex Briggs

.. \ Tanya Jain ' 2 Ethan Yang

,, ,

/"

POINTS RANK

(20-30)

"2-~-s 4-2-0•c; 3


1i...~-Q_ Signature:----------'.,__ ______________ _


~(/-..~~

~,~l~Ja{

~~~~

rJ ~rcAJ ~~CA--eA ~~ L~~ckJ-,•

/

0


',

Point Scale:

Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place thisspeakerin the top ten for the tournament. 28 Avery strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:


Page 13 of25

I •

Room: Wheeler 124 Start: 2:30 PM ~ovice Parli

3 170 - Tahir, Afrah


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. •Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over.• Do not leave the room during the round. Qo not consult with anyone else while making your decision.• Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in the room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 126

GOV

Spkr Berkeley Meggyesy POINTS

( 20~30)

OPP RANK

Hillview Montoya & Behz~dl Spkr

()l.. Damon Meggyesy_ 3 Julian Montoya r--~-+-~~~~~_...~~~---+--"--~~f-->"'--------1

j_ ~ ~ Sahand Behzadi

POINTS

(20-30)

RANK

~~~-,..-~----.---,~~~~~~(J\YJ

Side (Gov or Opp) Lowpointwin?K ~

- Page 18 of 25

Ill


3 181 - Shi, Wendy


JUDGING RULES Go to the room listed on top of this ballot. •Before the round starts, tell the debaters what prior judging experience you have. Do not interrupt any speech or give comments before the round is over. • Do not leave the room during the round. Do not consult with anyone else ~hile making your decision. • Please write down arguments made by the debaters. Please be sure the competitors in e room match the ones on your ballot and they are speaking on the correct side. Turn in ballots to Wheeler, Room 1~

GOV OPP RANK

Irvington Xiong & Bagepalli POINTS

Berkeley Chaplin & Under . . Spkr Spkr

Saul Chaplin "\ Frederic Xiong

Nicholas Underwood 2... Neha Bagepalli

POINTS

(20-30)

RANK

\

Low point win? t--J.,.


\A: c~u q. "So\..'1&> s~ ·u;'\\\ ~Cir\ 'ru..A..& ~'CC. '-""-'..ul.."~\i\JI

\e:6 ~~on ~ 'd.~ -ec.~

.1'Pt: ~ s~~ ~ ~ -\o 'oL. ~~ ~ OV\.

~ "'i>~ vs~ o... \.\~ ~~

'!:>

Point Scale: Do not give fewer than 25 points unless a speaker was rude or offensive. You may give half points. 30 A perfect speech. You will probably not give any 30s. 29 A near perfect speech. Speaking this well every round should place this speaker in the top ten for the tournament. 28 Avery strong speech, both in terms of content and delivery. 27 An average speech 26 A speech with multiple glaring weaknesses. 25 A thoroughly unpersuasive speech.

Speech Times:

Each speaker wflt deliver a 7-minute constructive speech, with the Government team going first. The first Opposition speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal, then the first Government speaker will deliver a 5-minute rebuttal. No new argu-ments may be presented in rebuttals,

~ \~ but new examples, explanation, and \~ghing are permitted.

~~~ ~ ~ ~o~ ~~ ~\.::::.~~a~\:. ScM.d

~ s~ ~ ~ ~s~ ~:::. ~°""""--""

-:!.~ WO..~ ~ c:A.c~ VU~ 1 ~ -T~ CW1!'> ~~ ~ \\\t.. ~Gt,.,." &8l vv:k ~ q..lc* ~ t,...lb...\'\i\. ~ \..\.:0.\ 0-

Ta broom.corn, a service of the National Speech & Debate Assocation: http://www.speechanddebate.org.

~~ ~ ~ ~C\\].V°\.l.At'(S" -- ~ \\.~~.

Page 16 of 25

cal parli invitational · room: dwinelle 263 start: 2:30 pm novice parli 3 105 -mutu., corina cal...

Documents