calculating bk using hyp staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · fat7 + lepage + naik = asqtad ☛ hyp...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions
Weonjong Lee
Department of Physics and AstronomySeoul National University
College of William and Mary, 2008 July 14–19
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 1 / 21
![Page 2: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Outline
1 Staggered ε′/ε Project (1997 − Present)
2 IntroductionIndirect CP violation and BK
Staggered fermionsImprovements for Staggered fermions
3 BK
BK on the latticeBK and Staggered χPTPQ χPT and Staggered χPTBayesian method for BK data analysis
4 Conclusion and Future Plan
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 2 / 21
![Page 3: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Staggered ε′/ε Project (1997 − Present)
Collaboration
Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL): Chulwoo Jung
Seoul National University (SNU): Weonjong Lee, et al.
University of Washington, Seattle (UW): Stephen R. Sharpe
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 3 / 21
![Page 4: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Staggered ε′/ε Project (1997 − Present)
Computing Resources: cj20 and QCDOC
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 4 / 21
![Page 5: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Introduction Indirect CP violation and BK
ε and B̂K
ε = (2.280 ± 0.013) × 10−3 × e iφε , φε = 43.5 ± 0.05◦ in experiment.
Relation between ε and B̂K in standard model.
ε = exp(iφε)√
2 sin(φε) Cε Imλt X B̂K + ξ
X = Reλc [η1S0(xc) − η3S3(xc , xt)] − Reλtη2S0(xt)
λi = V ∗
isVid , xi = m2i /M
2W , Cε =
G 2FF 2
KmKM2W
6√
2π2∆MK
ξ = exp(iφε) sin(φε)ImA0
ReA0
Definition of BK in standard model.
BK =〈K̄0|[s̄γµ(1 − γ5)d ][s̄γµ(1 − γ5)d ]|K0〉
83〈K̄0|s̄γµγ5d |0〉〈0|s̄γµγ5d |K0〉
B̂K = C (µ)BK (µ), C (µ) = αs(µ)−
γ02b0 [1 + αs(µ)J3]
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 5 / 21
![Page 6: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Introduction Indirect CP violation and BK
CKM matrix, Unitarity triangle and B̂K
Unitarity Triangle: B̂K = 0.75 ± 0.09B̂K from experiments and CKM unitarity ansatz:
KB0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Pro
bab
ility
den
sity
0
0.0005
0.001
0.0015
0.002
0.0025
0.003
0.0035
0.004
0.0045
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 20
0.0005
0.001
0.0015
0.002
0.0025
0.003
0.0035
0.004
0.0045
KB0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Pro
bab
ility
den
sity
0
0.0005
0.001
0.0015
0.002
0.0025
0.003
0.0035
0.004
0.0045
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 6 / 21
![Page 7: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Introduction Staggered fermions
Staggered Chiral Perturbation Theory
At a = 0, we expect full SU(4) taste symmetry for pion multiplets:{ξT} are degenerate for all T .
At finite a, group theory (1985) predicts 8 irreps of SW4 for pionmultiplets: {ξ5}, {ξi}, {ξ4}, {ξij}, {ξi4}, {ξi5}, {ξ45}, {1}.Staggered Chiral Perturbation Theory (1999) predicts that
SU(4) is broken down to SO(4) at leading order of O(a2) ≈ O(p2).SO(4) is broken down to SW4 at NLO of O(a2p2) (1999, 2005).
SU(4)O(a2)−−−→ SO(4)
O(a2p2)−−−−−→ SW4
Hence, we expect 5 irreps of SO(4) for pion multiplets in the chirallimit: {ξ5}, {ξµ}, {ξµν}, {ξµ5}, {1}.We also expect that the slopes for pion multiplets are splitted into 8irreps of SW4.
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 7 / 21
![Page 8: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Introduction Improvements for Staggered fermions
Improved Staggered Actions
Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad
-
6-
?6���
-��
?6���
���
-�
����
?6
6-
?
? - - -
HYP = hypercubic blockinga) b)
Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection
HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 8 / 21
![Page 9: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Introduction Improvements for Staggered fermions
Improvement Scheme [AsqTad vs. HYP]
Nf = 2 + 1, MILC, a = 0.125 fm, Gol, CU1, 2007:
O(a2) ≈ O(p2) for AsqTad ; O(a2) . O(p2) for HYP.
O(a2p2): negligibly small for both AsqTad and HYP.
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 9 / 21
![Page 10: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Introduction Improvements for Staggered fermions
Improvement Scheme (III) [coarse vs. fine; HYP]
Nf = 2 + 1, MILC coarse (CU1) vs. MILC fine (CW).
Coarse lattices: O(a2) . O(p2) (Mixed).
Fine lattices: O(a2) ≈ O(p4) ≪ O(p2) (Mixed).
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 10 / 21
![Page 11: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
BK BK on the lattice
BK definition in standard model.
BK =〈K̄0|[s̄γµ(1 − γ5)d ][s̄γµ(1 − γ5)d ]|K0〉
83〈K̄0|s̄γµγ5d |0〉〈0|s̄γµγ5d |K0〉
B̂K = C (µ)BK (µ),
C (µ) = αs(µ)−
γ02b0 [1 + αs(µ)J3]
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 11 / 21
![Page 12: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
BK BK and Staggered χPT
BK and Staggered Chiral Perturbation Theory
BK = c1[1 +3
8
Mconn + Mdisc
f 2π G
] + c2G
Λ2+ c3(
G
Λ2)2 + c4
(XP − YP)2
GΛ2
+c5F(4)
C (4) + c6F(4)
C (6) + c7F(1) + c8F
(4)
C (5)
G = m2π,xy , Λ = SχPT scale
Mconn =1
6π2
∑
B=I ,P,V ,A,T
F(3)B
F(3)B =
f B
128[(G + XB)l(XB) + (G + YB)l(YB) + 2(G − KB)l(KB)
−2GKB l̃(KB)]
f B = {−1,−1,−4,−4,−6} for B = I ,P ,V ,A,T
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 12 / 21
![Page 13: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
BK BK and Staggered χPT
Mdisc =1
18π2FI
FI = l(ηI )(G + ηI )(XI − YI )
2(LI − ηI )(SI − ηI )
(XI − ηI )2(YI − ηI )2+ · · ·
F(4)
C(4)B
= N{2G l̃(KB ) + [l(XB) + l(YB) − 2l(KB)]}
F(4)
C (5) = N{∑
B=V ,A
[l(XB) + l(YB) − 2l(KB)]}
F(4)
C (6) = N{[l(XT ) + l(YT ) − 2l(KT )]}
F(1)B = N{l(ηB )
(YB − XB)2(LB − ηB)(SB − ηB)
(XB − ηB)2(YB − ηB)2(η′B − ηB)+ · · · }
N =3
8
1
f 2π G
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 13 / 21
![Page 14: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
BK PQ χPT and Staggered χPT
Comparison of PQ χPT and Staggered χPT
HYP, MILC 2064f21b676m010m050 [671], a = 0.125 fm:
(a) χ2 = 0.26(34) (b) χ
2 = 0.06(16)
3 term fitting; tree-level matching (preliminary).
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 14 / 21
![Page 15: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
BK Bayesian method for BK data analysis
Bayesian method (I) for BK data analysis
HYP, MILC 2064f21b676m010m050 [671], a = 0.125 fm:
(c) χ2 = 0.05(11) (d) χ
2 = 0.07(16)
Left: 3 term fitting, Right: F(4)
C(4)T
/3 fitting (Bayesian method).
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 15 / 21
![Page 16: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
BK Bayesian method for BK data analysis
Bayesian method (II) for BK data analysis
(e) χ2 = 0.07(16) (f) χ
2 = 0.06(7)
Left: the same, Right: F(4)
C (6) , F(1)A , 1/ F
(4)
C(4)T
/3 fitting (2 step Bayesian
method).
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 16 / 21
![Page 17: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
BK Bayesian method for BK data analysis
Fitting quality: ∆BK (MILC 2064f21b676m010m050)
∆BK = BK (data) − fitting function
Left: Partially Quenched χPT
Right: Staggered χPT
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 17 / 21
![Page 18: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
BK Bayesian method for BK data analysis
BK in Nf = 1 + 2 unquenched QCD
a (fm) aml/ams geometry ens BK (tree,Bayes)
0.12 0.03/0.05 203 × 64 564 0.8306(624)0.12 0.02/0.05 203 × 64 486 0.7162(606)0.12 0.01/0.05 203 × 64 671 0.7647(559)0.12 0.01/0.05 283 × 64 275 −0.12 0.007/0.05 203 × 64 651 0.8657(531)0.12 0.005/0.05 243 × 64 509 0.7988(442)0.12 0.01/0.03 203 × 64 312 −0.09 0.0062/0.031 283 × 96 995 0.7177(391)0.09 0.0031/0.031 403 × 96 500 −0.06 0.004/0.02 483 × 144 500 −
Here, we quote BK values obtained using the two step Bayesianmethod for fitting.
Tree level matching (preliminary).
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 18 / 21
![Page 19: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Conclusion and Future Plan
Theoretical Challenges
Matching Factor: Tree → One-loop (SNU/UW)
Matching Factor: non-perturbative renormalization for staggeredfermions (UW)
Matching Factor: One-loop → Two-loop (SNU)
Staggered χPT for the mixed action: done (SNU/UW)
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 19 / 21
![Page 20: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Conclusion and Future Plan
Numerical Challenges
VERY PRELIMINARY.
We need to increase statistics significantly for coarse and fine latticesin order to nail down the non-degenerate quark mass effect on BK
(SNU/BNL).
We need to extend the measurements to MILC superfine lattices(a = 0.06 fm, 483 × 144) (BNL).
Non-perturbative Renormalization: underway (UW).
Large scale fitting of multi-tera byte data (SNU).
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 20 / 21
![Page 21: Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions · 2008-08-01 · Fat7 + Lepage + Naik = AsqTad ☛ HYP = hypercubic blocking a) b) Fat7 = Fat7 + SU(3)/U(3) Projection HISQ = Fat7 + AsqTad](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050309/5f71174bc0ae1942ee250db8/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Conclusion and Future Plan
Tentative Goal
We would like to determine BK directly from the standard model withits systematic and statistical error around 2%.
We expect to achieve this goal in a few years using QCDOC and SNUclusters.
Weonjong Lee (SNU) Calculating BK using HYP staggered fermions Lattice 2008 21 / 21