calls to redefine policing as protesters march on,...2020/06/09  · c m y k x,2020-06-09,a,001,bsx...

1
U(D54G1D)y+$!&!$!?!z HOUSTON — It was the last day of 11th grade at Jack Yates High School in Houston, nearly three decades ago. A group of close friends, on their way home, were contemplating what senior year and beyond would bring. They were black teenagers on the precipice of manhood. What, they asked one another, did they want to do with their lives? “George turned to me and said, ‘I want to touch the world,’” said Jonathan Veal, 45, recalling the aspiration of one of the young men — a tall, gregarious star athlete named George Floyd whom he had met in the school cafeteria on the first day of sixth grade. To their 17-year-old minds, touching the world maybe meant the N.B.A. or the N.F.L. “It was one of the first moments I remembered after learning what happened to him,” Mr. Veal said. “He could not have imagined that this is the tragic way people would know his name.” The world now knows George Perry Floyd Jr. through his final harrowing moments, as he begged for air, his face wedged for nearly nine minutes between a city street and a police officer’s knee. Mr. Floyd’s gasping death, im- mortalized on a bystander’s cell- phone video during the twilight hours of Memorial Day, has pow- ered two weeks of sprawling pro- tests across America against po- lice brutality. He has been memo- rialized in Minneapolis, where he died; in North Carolina, where he was born; and in Houston, where thousands stood in the unrelent- ing heat on Monday afternoon to file past his gold coffin and bid him farewell in the city where he spent most of his life. Many of those who attended the public viewing said they saw Mr. Floyd as one of them: a fellow Houstonian who could have been their father, their brother or their son. “This is something that touched really close,” said Kina Ardoin, 43, a nurse who stood in a line that stretched far from the church en- trance. “This could have been anybody in my family.” Man of Outsize Dreams Stirred a Movement With Final Breaths By MANNY FERNANDEZ and AUDRA D. S. BURCH A Minneapolis memorial for victims of police violence. A high school friend recalled George Floyd’s aspiration to “touch the world.” JOSHUA RASHAAD McFADDEN FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Houston Residents Say Goodbye to Floyd, One of Their Own Continued on Page A17 MINNEAPOLIS In an abrupt change of course, the may- or of New York vowed to cut the budget of the nation’s largest po- lice force. In Los Angeles, the mayor called for redirecting mil- lions of dollars from policing after protesters gathered outside his home. And in Minneapolis, City Council members pledged to dis- mantle their police force and com- pletely reinvent how public safety is handled. As tens of thousands of people have demonstrated against police violence over the past two weeks, calls have emerged in cities across the country for fundamental changes to American policing. The pleas for change have tak- en a variety of forms — including measures to restrict police use of military-style equipment and ef- forts to require officers to face strict discipline in cases of mis- conduct. Parks, universities and schools have distanced them- selves from local police depart- ments, severing contracts. In some places, the calls for change have gone still further, aiming to abolish police departments, shift police funds into social services or defund police departments partly or entirely. “It is a critical time that we can see concrete change,” said the Rev. Al Sharpton, who last week addressed the crowd gathered for a memorial service for George Floyd, the black man who died af- ter a white police officer pressed his knee into his neck for nearly nine minutes in Minneapolis last month. “The legislation and the policy changes will be the ones that determine the victory of this movement.” Democrats in Congress on Mon- day unveiled legislation aimed at ending excessive use of force by the police and making it easier to identify, track and prosecute po- lice misconduct. The measures were seen as the most expansive As Protesters March On, Calls to Redefine Policing Hard Look at Money for Public Safety This article is by Dionne Searcey, John Eligon and Farah Stockman. Continued on Page A16 The New York Police Depart- ment may lose some funding. CHANG W. LEE/THE NEW YORK TIMES Former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. staked out a careful position on Monday in support of a law enforcement overhaul but not defunding police departments, re- butting a new Republican attack line as he tries to harness growing activism against systemic racism while not alienating protesters or more moderate voters. In the face of continuing protest marches calling to “defund the po- lice” nationwide in the aftermath of George Floyd’s killing, Mr. Bi- den’s campaign said in a state- ment that he “hears and shares the deep grief and frustration of those calling out for change” and that he “supports the urgent need for reform.” But a campaign spokesman, Andrew Bates, said flatly that Mr. Biden was opposed to cutting police funding and be- lieved more spending was neces- sary to help improve law enforce- ment and community policing. Mr. Biden’s effort to address the calls of protesters while support- ing law enforcement comes after gruesome videos and energetic protests have quickly reshaped public opinion about racial dis- crimination, seemingly opening a substantial window for new poli- cies that could bring far-reaching change to law-enforcement agen- cies long accused of racially dis- criminatory practices. But there are already signs of division be- tween activists who are eager to dismantle police departments and congressional Democrats who fa- vor a less drastic overhaul. President Trump’s campaign and leading Republicans have sought to drive a wedge between the immediate-but-incremental calls for change among elected Democrats and the more sweep- ing demands that protesters are calling for in places like Minne- apolis, where the death of Mr. Floyd after police officers pinned him down has prompted world- wide calls for racial justice. Mr. Trump has not endorsed any new changes to policing pro- cedures or funding. On Monday, he met with law enforcement offi- cials at the White House and praised them, saying virtually all police officers were “great, great people” and boasting on Twitter that crime was low nationwide. The debate within the Demo- cratic Party was on plain display on Monday, as congressional lead- ers unveiled a broad legislative program on policing, including new limits on the use of lethal force and on the legal protections afforded to officers accused of misconduct. Only hours before, progressives at the municipal lev- Biden Stopping Short of Push to Defund This article is by Jonathan Mar- tin, Alexander Burns and Thomas Kaplan. Continued on Page A15 It was among the last of the big conferences before the coro- navirus pandemic shuttered the massive casinos lining the Las Ve- gas Strip in March. More than 1,000 people gathered at MGM Resorts International’s Mirage Hotel & Casino for the Women of Power Summit, after organizers assured them that the risk of at- tending the networking event for executive women of color was “ex- tremely low.” That seemed a reasonable bet, given that Las Vegas had yet to record a single coronavirus case. What no one realized was that one of the conference speakers, a New Yorker, had already contracted the virus by the time she landed at McCarran International Airport on March 6. Two days later, she was in a hospital. Nevada’s case count now stands at more than 9,600, and as of Sunday afternoon, 438 people had died. But the case involving the Women of Power speaker is nowhere to be found in those grim totals, despite the fact that she What Makes Sin City Cautious? Risk of Virus as Casinos Reopen By JO BECKER Continued on Page A8 As the Trump administration lashes out at China over a range of grievances, Beijing’s top diplo- mats and representatives are us- ing the president’s favorite online megaphone — Twitter — to slap back with a pugnaciousness that is best described as Trumpian. Behind China’s combative new messengers, a murky hallelujah chorus of sympathetic accounts has emerged to repost them and cheer them on. Many are new to the platform. Some do little else but amplify the Beijing line. No doubt some of these ac- counts are run by patriotic, tech- savvy Chinese people who get around their government’s ban on Twitter and other Western plat- forms. But an analysis by The New York Times found that many of the accounts behaved with a single-mindedness that could sug- gest a coordinated campaign of the type that nation states have carried out on Twitter in the past. Of the roughly 4,600 accounts that reposted China’s leading en- voys and state-run news outlets during a recent week, many acted suspiciously, The Times found. One in six tweeted with extremely high frequency despite having few followers, as if they were be- ing used as loudspeakers, not as sharing platforms. Nearly one in seven tweeted al- most nothing of their own, instead filling their feeds with reposts of Murky Chorus Is Amplifying China’s Tweets This article is by Raymond Zhong, Aaron Krolik, Paul Mozur, Ronen Bergman and Edward Wong. Continued on Page A5 Michael Gilsenan celebrated the first day of New York City’s re- opening by treating himself to cof- fee and cheesecake at his neigh- borhood bakery in Greenwich Vil- lage. He doesn’t even like cheese- cake, but it was a chance to get back to the little things he never realized he would miss until the coronavirus took them away. “These are markers of your life in the city,” Mr. Gilsenan, a univer- sity professor, said. “It’s a sense that against all the odds — and I think it is against all of the odds — that they’re still around today.” Further uptown, Ashok Kumar couldn’t wait to throw open the doors to his plant and flower shop and drag out two dozen potted be- gonias and hydrangea onto the sidewalk for their first sunlight and fresh air in months. “It’s going to take a long time, but over the next few weeks we are going to try to catch up to where we were,” said Mr. Kumar, who lost about $70,000 in plants that withered away while the shop, in Chelsea, was closed. It was a perfect day — sunny but not too hot — as glimpses of the old New York that had seemed to disappear almost overnight now beckoned tantalizingly to vi- rus-weary residents and commut- ers. After months of wondering whether the city would ever re- turn to normal, there were small but reassuring signs that it would. Commuters headed back to the subway, wearing face masks as they gripped morning coffees, checked phones and boarded freshly scrubbed trains that smelled of cleaning solutions. Construction workers reported for work, lining up for tempera- tures checks so they could get back to building the city. And Masked and Relieved, New Yorkers Reclaim City By WINNIE HU Michelle Higgins and her friend Spencer Winson shopped for house plants in Chelsea on Monday. CHANG W. LEE/THE NEW YORK TIMES Streets Still a Shadow of the Past in Phase 1 of a Comeback Continued on Page A6 Afghans once tuned in twice a day to hear the death notices, but the ritual has lost much of its sway. PAGE A11 INTERNATIONAL A10-11 Waning Days for Death Scroll Naeem, who burst out in 2006 as Spank Rock with “YoYoYoYoYo,” is back with a new album, “Startisha.” PAGE C1 ARTS C1-8 A Rapper Speaks His Truth Using tiny sensors and equipment on the space station, the ICARUS project aims to transform animal tracking. PAGE D1 SCIENCE TIMES D1-8 Far Beyond a Bird’s-Eye View Although economists announced that the United States entered a recession in February, investors remain optimistic about a recovery. PAGE B1 BUSINESS B1-6 S&P 500 Recoups 2020 Losses President Jair Bolsonaro’s government has stopped disclosing comprehensive data on cases and deaths as infection rates continue to soar. PAGE A8 TRACKING AN OUTBREAK A4-9 Brazil Hides Virus Data Officials say they are willing to let the Palestinian Authority collapse to stop Israel’s annexation plans. PAGE A10 Plan to Preserve West Bank Books on the subject have soared up best-seller lists as protests continue across the country. PAGE C1 Reading About Racism Paul Krugman PAGE A22 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A22-23 Britain’s National Collection of Type Cultures, a library of human bacterial pathogens, turned 100 this year. PAGE D1 A Bounty of Microbial Strains A group of 511 infectious disease spe- cialists told The Times when they plan to resume their daily lives. PAGE A9 Epidemiologists Are People, Too Some Democrats think this is the year the state will flip and are urging the party to invest in its races. PAGE A12 NATIONAL A12-20 Predicting a Blue Georgia Adam Rapoport resigned after a photo of him dressed as a derogatory Puerto Rican stereotype resurfaced. PAGE B6 Bon Appétit Editor Steps Down For football, coronavirus has been an off-season story. Now the league is hoping it can stay on schedule. PAGE B7 SPORTSTUESDAY B7-8 N.F.L. Sets Protocol for Camps BAIL A judge set the amount at up to $1.25 million for Derek Chauvin, the white police officer charged with killing George Floyd. PAGE A18 Late Edition VOL. CLXIX .... No. 58,719 © 2020 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, TUESDAY, JUNE 9, 2020 Today, sunshine, very warm, high 86. Tonight, clear to partly cloudy, warm, low 69. Tomorrow, clouds and sunshine, more humid, high 88. Weather map is on Page A20. $3.00

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Calls to Redefine Policing As Protesters March On,...2020/06/09  · C M Y K x,2020-06-09,A,001,Bsx Nx -4C,E1 U(D54G1D)y+$!&!$!?!z HOUSTON It was the last day of 11th grade at Jack

C M Y K Nxxx,2020-06-09,A,001,Bs-4C,E1

U(D54G1D)y+$!&!$!?!z

HOUSTON — It was the lastday of 11th grade at Jack YatesHigh School in Houston, nearlythree decades ago. A group ofclose friends, on their way home,were contemplating what senioryear and beyond would bring.They were black teenagers on theprecipice of manhood. What, theyasked one another, did they wantto do with their lives?

“George turned to me and said,‘I want to touch the world,’” saidJonathan Veal, 45, recalling theaspiration of one of the young men

— a tall, gregarious star athletenamed George Floyd whom hehad met in the school cafeteria onthe first day of sixth grade. Totheir 17-year-old minds, touchingthe world maybe meant the N.B.A.or the N.F.L.

“It was one of the first momentsI remembered after learning whathappened to him,” Mr. Veal said.“He could not have imagined thatthis is the tragic way people wouldknow his name.”

The world now knows GeorgePerry Floyd Jr. through his finalharrowing moments, as hebegged for air, his face wedged fornearly nine minutes between acity street and a police officer’s

knee.Mr. Floyd’s gasping death, im-

mortalized on a bystander’s cell-phone video during the twilighthours of Memorial Day, has pow-ered two weeks of sprawling pro-tests across America against po-lice brutality. He has been memo-rialized in Minneapolis, where hedied; in North Carolina, where he

was born; and in Houston, wherethousands stood in the unrelent-ing heat on Monday afternoon tofile past his gold coffin and bid himfarewell in the city where he spentmost of his life.

Many of those who attended thepublic viewing said they saw Mr.Floyd as one of them: a fellowHoustonian who could have beentheir father, their brother or theirson.

“This is something that touchedreally close,” said Kina Ardoin, 43,a nurse who stood in a line thatstretched far from the church en-trance. “This could have beenanybody in my family.”

Man of Outsize Dreams Stirred a Movement With Final BreathsBy MANNY FERNANDEZand AUDRA D. S. BURCH

A Minneapolis memorial for victims of police violence. A high school friend recalled George Floyd’s aspiration to “touch the world.”JOSHUA RASHAAD McFADDEN FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Houston Residents SayGoodbye to Floyd, One of Their Own

Continued on Page A17

MINNEAPOLIS — In anabrupt change of course, the may-or of New York vowed to cut thebudget of the nation’s largest po-lice force. In Los Angeles, themayor called for redirecting mil-lions of dollars from policing afterprotesters gathered outside hishome. And in Minneapolis, CityCouncil members pledged to dis-mantle their police force and com-pletely reinvent how public safetyis handled.

As tens of thousands of peoplehave demonstrated against policeviolence over the past two weeks,calls have emerged in cities acrossthe country for fundamentalchanges to American policing.

The pleas for change have tak-en a variety of forms — includingmeasures to restrict police use ofmilitary-style equipment and ef-forts to require officers to facestrict discipline in cases of mis-conduct. Parks, universities andschools have distanced them-selves from local police depart-

ments, severing contracts. Insome places, the calls for changehave gone still further, aiming toabolish police departments, shiftpolice funds into social services ordefund police departments partlyor entirely.

“It is a critical time that we cansee concrete change,” said theRev. Al Sharpton, who last weekaddressed the crowd gathered fora memorial service for GeorgeFloyd, the black man who died af-ter a white police officer pressedhis knee into his neck for nearlynine minutes in Minneapolis lastmonth. “The legislation and thepolicy changes will be the onesthat determine the victory of thismovement.”

Democrats in Congress on Mon-day unveiled legislation aimed atending excessive use of force bythe police and making it easier toidentify, track and prosecute po-lice misconduct. The measureswere seen as the most expansive

As Protesters March On,Calls to Redefine Policing

Hard Look at Moneyfor Public Safety

This article is by Dionne Searcey,John Eligon and Farah Stockman.

Continued on Page A16

The New York Police Depart-ment may lose some funding.

CHANG W. LEE/THE NEW YORK TIMES

Former Vice President JosephR. Biden Jr. staked out a carefulposition on Monday in support of alaw enforcement overhaul but notdefunding police departments, re-butting a new Republican attackline as he tries to harness growingactivism against systemic racismwhile not alienating protesters ormore moderate voters.

In the face of continuing protestmarches calling to “defund the po-lice” nationwide in the aftermathof George Floyd’s killing, Mr. Bi-den’s campaign said in a state-ment that he “hears and sharesthe deep grief and frustration ofthose calling out for change” andthat he “supports the urgent needfor reform.” But a campaignspokesman, Andrew Bates, saidflatly that Mr. Biden was opposedto cutting police funding and be-lieved more spending was neces-sary to help improve law enforce-ment and community policing.

Mr. Biden’s effort to address thecalls of protesters while support-ing law enforcement comes aftergruesome videos and energeticprotests have quickly reshapedpublic opinion about racial dis-crimination, seemingly opening asubstantial window for new poli-cies that could bring far-reachingchange to law-enforcement agen-cies long accused of racially dis-criminatory practices. But thereare already signs of division be-tween activists who are eager todismantle police departments andcongressional Democrats who fa-vor a less drastic overhaul.

President Trump’s campaignand leading Republicans havesought to drive a wedge betweenthe immediate-but-incrementalcalls for change among electedDemocrats and the more sweep-ing demands that protesters arecalling for in places like Minne-apolis, where the death of Mr.Floyd after police officers pinnedhim down has prompted world-wide calls for racial justice.

Mr. Trump has not endorsedany new changes to policing pro-cedures or funding. On Monday,he met with law enforcement offi-cials at the White House andpraised them, saying virtually allpolice officers were “great, greatpeople” and boasting on Twitterthat crime was low nationwide.

The debate within the Demo-cratic Party was on plain displayon Monday, as congressional lead-ers unveiled a broad legislativeprogram on policing, includingnew limits on the use of lethalforce and on the legal protectionsafforded to officers accused ofmisconduct. Only hours before,progressives at the municipal lev-

Biden Stopping Short of Push to Defund

This article is by Jonathan Mar-tin, Alexander Burns and ThomasKaplan.

Continued on Page A15

It was among the last of the bigconferences before the coro-navirus pandemic shuttered themassive casinos lining the Las Ve-gas Strip in March. More than1,000 people gathered at MGMResorts International’s MirageHotel & Casino for the Women ofPower Summit, after organizersassured them that the risk of at-tending the networking event forexecutive women of color was “ex-tremely low.”

That seemed a reasonable bet,given that Las Vegas had yet torecord a single coronavirus case.

What no one realized was that oneof the conference speakers, a NewYorker, had already contractedthe virus by the time she landed atMcCarran International Airporton March 6. Two days later, shewas in a hospital.

Nevada’s case count nowstands at more than 9,600, and asof Sunday afternoon, 438 peoplehad died. But the case involvingthe Women of Power speaker isnowhere to be found in those grimtotals, despite the fact that she

What Makes Sin City Cautious? Risk of Virus as Casinos Reopen

By JO BECKER

Continued on Page A8

As the Trump administrationlashes out at China over a range ofgrievances, Beijing’s top diplo-mats and representatives are us-ing the president’s favorite onlinemegaphone — Twitter — to slapback with a pugnaciousness thatis best described as Trumpian.

Behind China’s combative newmessengers, a murky hallelujahchorus of sympathetic accountshas emerged to repost them andcheer them on. Many are new tothe platform. Some do little elsebut amplify the Beijing line.

No doubt some of these ac-counts are run by patriotic, tech-savvy Chinese people who getaround their government’s ban onTwitter and other Western plat-forms. But an analysis by TheNew York Times found that manyof the accounts behaved with asingle-mindedness that could sug-gest a coordinated campaign ofthe type that nation states havecarried out on Twitter in the past.

Of the roughly 4,600 accountsthat reposted China’s leading en-voys and state-run news outletsduring a recent week, many actedsuspiciously, The Times found.One in six tweeted with extremelyhigh frequency despite havingfew followers, as if they were be-ing used as loudspeakers, not assharing platforms.

Nearly one in seven tweeted al-most nothing of their own, insteadfilling their feeds with reposts of

Murky ChorusIs AmplifyingChina’s Tweets

This article is by Raymond Zhong,Aaron Krolik, Paul Mozur, RonenBergman and Edward Wong.

Continued on Page A5

Michael Gilsenan celebratedthe first day of New York City’s re-opening by treating himself to cof-fee and cheesecake at his neigh-borhood bakery in Greenwich Vil-lage.

He doesn’t even like cheese-cake, but it was a chance to getback to the little things he neverrealized he would miss until thecoronavirus took them away.

“These are markers of your lifein the city,” Mr. Gilsenan, a univer-sity professor, said. “It’s a sensethat against all the odds — and Ithink it is against all of the odds —that they’re still around today.”

Further uptown, Ashok Kumarcouldn’t wait to throw open the

doors to his plant and flower shopand drag out two dozen potted be-gonias and hydrangea onto thesidewalk for their first sunlightand fresh air in months. “It’s goingto take a long time, but over thenext few weeks we are going to tryto catch up to where we were,”said Mr. Kumar, who lost about$70,000 in plants that witheredaway while the shop, in Chelsea,was closed.

It was a perfect day — sunnybut not too hot — as glimpses ofthe old New York that had seemedto disappear almost overnightnow beckoned tantalizingly to vi-rus-weary residents and commut-ers. After months of wonderingwhether the city would ever re-turn to normal, there were smallbut reassuring signs that it would.

Commuters headed back to thesubway, wearing face masks asthey gripped morning coffees,checked phones and boardedfreshly scrubbed trains thatsmelled of cleaning solutions.Construction workers reportedfor work, lining up for tempera-tures checks so they could getback to building the city. And

Masked and Relieved, New Yorkers Reclaim CityBy WINNIE HU

Michelle Higgins and her friend Spencer Winson shopped for house plants in Chelsea on Monday.CHANG W. LEE/THE NEW YORK TIMES

Streets Still a Shadowof the Past in Phase 1

of a Comeback

Continued on Page A6

Afghans once tuned in twice a day tohear the death notices, but the ritualhas lost much of its sway. PAGE A11

INTERNATIONAL A10-11

Waning Days for Death ScrollNaeem, who burst out in 2006 as SpankRock with “YoYoYoYoYo,” is back with anew album, “Startisha.” PAGE C1

ARTS C1-8

A Rapper Speaks His Truth

Using tiny sensors and equipment on thespace station, the ICARUS project aimsto transform animal tracking. PAGE D1

SCIENCE TIMES D1-8

Far Beyond a Bird’s-Eye ViewAlthough economists announced thatthe United States entered a recession inFebruary, investors remain optimisticabout a recovery. PAGE B1

BUSINESS B1-6

S&P 500 Recoups 2020 LossesPresident Jair Bolsonaro’s governmenthas stopped disclosing comprehensivedata on cases and deaths as infectionrates continue to soar. PAGE A8

TRACKING AN OUTBREAK A4-9

Brazil Hides Virus Data

Officials say they are willing to let thePalestinian Authority collapse to stopIsrael’s annexation plans. PAGE A10

Plan to Preserve West BankBooks on the subject have soared upbest-seller lists as protests continueacross the country. PAGE C1

Reading About RacismPaul Krugman PAGE A22

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A22-23

Britain’s National Collection of TypeCultures, a library of human bacterialpathogens, turned 100 this year. PAGE D1

A Bounty of Microbial Strains

A group of 511 infectious disease spe-cialists told The Times when they planto resume their daily lives. PAGE A9

Epidemiologists Are People, Too

Some Democrats think this is the yearthe state will flip and are urging theparty to invest in its races. PAGE A12

NATIONAL A12-20

Predicting a Blue Georgia

Adam Rapoport resigned after a photoof him dressed as a derogatory PuertoRican stereotype resurfaced. PAGE B6

Bon Appétit Editor Steps Down

For football, coronavirus has been anoff-season story. Now the league ishoping it can stay on schedule. PAGE B7

SPORTSTUESDAY B7-8

N.F.L. Sets Protocol for Camps

BAIL A judge set the amount at up to $1.25 million for Derek Chauvin,the white police officer charged with killing George Floyd. PAGE A18

Late Edition

VOL. CLXIX . . . . No. 58,719 © 2020 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, TUESDAY, JUNE 9, 2020

Today, sunshine, very warm, high86. Tonight, clear to partly cloudy,warm, low 69. Tomorrow, clouds andsunshine, more humid, high 88.Weather map is on Page A20.

$3.00