capital review: british council for school environments response

8/7/2019 Capital Review: British Council for School Environments response

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-review-british-council-for-school-environments-response 1/17

!!

"#$%&'(#)'!*+&!,-./%'0+)1!'2#!3%(#4!5#60#7!+*!8%$0'%9!:)6#4'(#)'!0)!;/2++94!

!!!

5#4$+)4#!<=!'2#!>&0'042!8+.)/09!*+&!

;/2++9!,)60&+)(#)'4!!!!!!

!"#$%&#$'!()!*$++)!,-./&01!2&+!3.#'-&/!&+'!,)!4.''&#'!

!5$%6$/($#!7898!

!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

3.#!:;#6-$#!<+:.#/&6<.+!=.+6&=6!;0!.+! >$++)?(=0$@;A@+$6!.#!878B!BCD!E7F9!

!!

!!

!!!



?@A!! :)'&+-./'0+)!!!,-$!G#<6<0-!H.;+=<I!:.#!5=-..I!J+K<#.+/$+60!LGH5JM!<0!6-$!NOP0!I$&'<+Q!=-&#<6)!<+!

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

!! #;++<+Q!&+!&++;&I!>8;,!:)-.4'&=!B7%&-4!W!=$I$(#&6<+Q!6-$!NOP0!/.06!<+0%<#<+Q!

0=-..I01!I.=&I!&;6-.#<6<$0!&+'!=./%&+<$0X!!

!! C%'0+)%9!;/2++9!,)60&+)(#)'4!D##E !Y!&!R$$A!I.+Q!%#.Q#&//$!.:!&=6<K<6<$01!

$K$+60!#&<0<+Q!&R&#$+$00!.:!0=-..I!'$0<Q+X!!!! F%G+&!/+)*#&#)/#4!0)/9.-0)H! 6-$!Z.#I'![$&#+<+Q!J+K<#.+/$+60!H.+:$#$+=$!

&+'!%.I<=)!$K$+60!<+=I;'<+Q!\$0<Q+<+Q!:.#!5%$=<&I!J';=&6<.+&I!]$$'0X!!

!! C#'7+&E0)H!#6#)'4I!4#(0)%&4!%)-!<&0#*0)H4 Y!=.++$=6<+Q!6-$!%;(I<=!&+'!%#<K&6$!0$=6.#!.+!<00;$0!0;=-!&0!:#$$!0=-..I01!0;06&<+&(<I<6)!&+'!6-$!:;6;#$!.:!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6X!!

!! 6-$!8#)'&#!*+&!;/2++9!"#40H) !Y!&!K<#6;&I!6-<+A6&+A!I..A<+Q!6.!0%#$&'!A+.RI$'Q$!&+'!I$&#+<+Q!;0<+Q!+$R!6$=-+.I.Q)!&+'!6-$!%.R$#!.:!0.=<&I!/$'<&@!!

!! Z$!&I0.!#$0$&#=-!&+'!R#<6$!>#4'!$&%/'0/#!&#4+.&/#4 !Y!<+=I;'<+Q!6-<0!)$&#!%#.';=<+Q!6-$!5=-..I!J+K<#.+/$+60!H-&#6$#!&+'!6-$!%;(I<=&6<.+!^,-$!]$R!_`0T!#$:;#(1!#$/.'$I!&+'!#$;0$!W!&!+$R!&%%#.&=-!6.!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6P!!

!

,-$!GH5J!-&0!&!06#.+Q!&'K.=&=)!#.I$!&+'!:.#!6-$!%&06!S!)$&#0!R$!-&K$!($$+!=.+0<06$+6!<+!.;#!/$00&Q$0!&(.;6!#$/.K<+Q!R&06$1!(;#$&;=#&=)!&+'!</%#.K<+Q!.;6=./$0!<+!/&>.#!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q!%#.Q#&//$0!0;=-!&0!G53!&+'!-&K$!R.#A$'!&I.+Q0<'$!6-$!`2Ga!&'K.=&6<+Q!($66$#!%#.=;#$/$+6@!Z$!&#$!&I0.!$V%$#60!<+!".06!U==;%&+=)!JK&I;&6<.+!L"UJM!&+'!#$=$+6I)!R.#A$'!.+!&!%#.>$=6!:.#!"&#6+$#0-<%0!:.#!5=-..I0!'$K$I.%<+Q!&!+&6<.+&I!:#&/$R.#A!:.#!"UJ!Y!R-<=-!#$0;I6$'!<+!D!0=-..I0!($<+Q!0)06$/&6<=&II)!$K&I;&6$'!&Q&<+06!&!#&+Q$!.:!<+'<=&6.#0!.:!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0@!a!=.%)!.:!6-<0!'#&:6!#$%.#6!<0!R<6-!"&#6+$#0-<%0!:.#!5=-..I0@!!5./$!$V&/%I$0!.:!6-$!R.#A!6-&6!6-$!GH5J!-&K$!($$+!<+K.IK$'!<+X!<+=I;'<+Q!=.+6#<(;6<.+0!6.!0$I$=6!=.//<66$$01!0%$$=-$0!&6!%&#6)!=.+:$#$+=$!:#<+Q$!$K$+601!&+'!0./$!0<Q+<:<=&+6!GH5J!%;(I<=&6<.+01!&#$!<+=I;'$'!<+!6-$!&%%$+'<=$0@!

!!J@A! >%/EH&+.)-!"#$%!&'(!)*+&!,!-(*%+.!&'(!/012!'*3(!4((5!*!6$5+7+&(5&!8!*59!+$:(&7:(+!;$5(!3$76(!8!75!6*:)*7<575<!=$%!4(&&(%!+6'$$;!(537%$5:(5&+.!;(++!>*+&(=?;!*59!4?%(*?6%*&76!)%$6(++(+!75!/1#!*59!+6'$$;!6*)7&*;!)%$<%*::(+!*59!75!6%(*&75<!<%(*&!+6'$$;+!=$%!(3(%-!6$::?57&-@!

2&+!3.#'-&/1!GH5J!!JK$+!6-.;Q-!=-<I'#$+!&+'!).;+Q!%$.%I$!0%$+'!&!0<Q+<:<=&+6!&/.;+6!.:!6-$<#!6</$!.;6!.:!0=-..I1!0=-..I0!#$/&<+!K<6&I!%I&=$0!R-$#$!6-$!+$V6!Q$+$#&6<.+!I$&#+1!%I&)!&+'!Q#.R!&+'!



=#<6<=&II)!R-$#$!6$&=-$#0!&+'!0;%%.#6!06&::!R.#A!&+'!:.=;0!6-$<#!$::.#60!.+!</%#.K<+Q!&=-<$K$/$+6@!!!

26!<0!.;#!=.+6$+6<.+!6-&6!6.!Q<K$!-$&'6$&=-$#0!&+'!0=-..I!06&::!6-$!($06!=-&+=$0!.:!</%#.K<+Q!06&+'&#'01!&+'!:.#!6-$!NO!$';=&6<.+!0)06$/!6.!=./%$6$!QI.(&II)1!R$!+$$'!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!6-&6!%.0<6<K$I)!$+&(I$!0=-..I!</%#.K$/$+6!6.!6&A$!%I&=$@!JK$#)!=.;+6#)!<+!6-$!R.#I'!<0!<+K$06<+Q!-$&K<I)!<+!<60!$';=&6<.+!<+:#&06#;=6;#$!Y!<+=I;'<+Q!+$R!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$0!>;06!I&;+=-$'!<+!Z&I$0!&+'!5=.6I&+'!W!R-)!0-.;I'!J+QI&+'!($!&+)!'<::$#$+6b!!!G;6!<+!6-$!=.+6$V6!.:!+$R!:<+&+=<&I!=<#=;/06&+=$0!&+'!&!%;(I<=!'$:<=<61!R$!A+.R!6-&6!R$!=&++.6!#$6;#+!6.!&!6.%!'.R+1!%#$0=#<%6<K$!&+'!=.//&+'!&+'!=.+6#.I!0)06$/!.:!%#.=;#<+Q!.#!'$I<K$#<+Q!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q0@!!!"A'(!6'*;;(5<(!7+!B&'*&!>(!6$:(C!=%$:!*!+&%?6&?%(!>'(%(!>(!)*&6'(9!*59!:(59(9!*;;!$=!

$?%!75=%*+&%?6&?%(D!/?&!5$>!&'(%(E+!&'(!$))$%&?57&-!>7&'!<$3(%5:(5&!753(+&:(5&!&$!&*F(!*!'*%9!;$$F!*&!&'(!:*++73(!%(=?%47+':(5&!$=!&'(!+6'$$;!(+&*&(!*59!&'(!4?7;975<!$=!5(>!+6'$$;+D!G(!'*3(5E&!4?7;&!*+!:*5-!+6'$$;+!*+!>(E%(!*4$?&!&$!9$!+756(!&'(!H76&$%7*5!*<(D@!

,)!4.''&#'1!GH5J!!,-$!,</$01!99!*;I)!788E!!

!!Z$!=&++.6!($!R&06$:;I1!(;#$&;=#&6<=!.#!Q$6!06&::!&+'!6$&=-$#0!6.!>;/%!6-#.;Q-!-..%0@!Z$!=&++.6!%#.=;#$!(;<I'<+Q0!6-#.;Q-!&!%#.=$00!6-&6!R&06$0!6-$!$c;<K&I$+6!.:!&!%#</&#)!0=-..I!<+!6-$!(<''<+Q!=.060!&+'!#$>$=60!6#<$'!&+'!6$06$'!I.=&I!%#.=;#$/$+6!:#&/$R.#A0!&+'!0)06$/0@!Z$!=&++.6!A$$%!.+!/&A<+Q!6-$!0&/$!/<06&A$0!&+'!+.6!I$&#+<+Q!:#./!6-$!-&#'!R.+!I$00.+0!&+'!:#./!6-$!($06!%#&=6<=$!.;6!<+!6-$!0)06$/@!Z$!=&++.6!0<I$+=$!6-$!

K.<=$0!.:!:#.+6I<+$!06&::!&+'!0=-..I01!I.=&I!&;6-.#<6<$0!&+'!.#Q&+<0&6<.+01!R-.!R<0-!6.!</%#.K$!6-$!0)06$/@!2+!.6-$#!R.#'0!Y!R$!+$$'!&!^+$R!0=#<%6P!:.#!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6!&+'!R$!R$I=./$!6-$!.%%.#6;+<6)!6-&6!6-$!H&%<6&I!`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`$=$+6!UJH\!:<Q;#$0!0-.R!6-&6!6-$!NO!

<+K$060!B@Ed!.:!6.6&I!$V%$+'<6;#$!.+!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$0!=./%&#$'!6.!F@Dd!<+!3<+I&+'1!F@Fd!<+!O.#$&!&+'!99@_d!<+!6-$!N5@!,.!=./%$6$!<+!6-$!QI.(&I!$=.+./)!<6!<0!K<6&I!6.!<+K$06!:.#!6-$!:;6;#$@!!!"A'(!+?66(++=?;!=?&?%(!$=!$?%!6$?5&%-!7+!4*+(9!$5!*!>(;;!(9?6*&(9!)$)?;*&7$5!>'76'!:?+&!4(!9$5(!75!9(6(5&!(537%$5:(5&+@!!!

GH5J![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)!/$/($#1!*;I)!7898!

!JK$+!<+!6-$!=.+6$V6!.:!&+!$=.+./<=!=#;+=-1!<6!<0!K<6&I!6-&6!R$!=.+6<+;$!<+K$06<+Q!<+!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!&+'!<+!6-$!:&(#<=!.:!.;#!0=-..I!$06&6$@!2+!6-$!N51!&!I$&'<+Q!$=.+./<=!6-<+A6&+A!0$6!.;6!6-$!($+$:<60!&+'!</%&=6!.:!0;=-!&+!<+K$06/$+6T!



!"L?4;76!(9?6*&7$5M756;?975<!&'(!4?7;&!75=%*+&%?6&?%(!&$!+?))$%&!7&!M7+!F(-!&$!&'(!(6$5$:76! )%$+)(%7&-!$=!$?%!6$::?57&7(+!*59!5*&7$5D!N(+)$5+74;(!:*5*<(:(5&!*59!753(+&:(5&!75!

)?4;76!B+&*&(C!+6'$$;!4?7;975<+!)*-+!&'%((!&7:(+O!$56(!=$%!+F7;;(9!P$4+!75!;$6*;!6$::?57&7(+Q!*!+(6$59!75!&'(!R?*;7&-!&'*&!'(*;&'-.!+*=(.!*59!(9?6*&7$5*;;-!*))%$)%7*&(!4?7;975<+!6%(*&(!=$%!+&?9(5&+!*59!&'(7%!&(*6'(%+Q!*59!=75*;;-.!*!&'7%9!&7:(!75!&'(!4(5(=7&+!&'*&!R?*;7&-!(9?6*&7$5!>7;;!%(*)!=$%!<(5(%*&7$5+!&$!6$:(@!

4..'!G;<I'<+Q01!G$66$#!5=-..I0T!&+!$=.+./<=!06</;I;0!.%%.#6;+<6)!R<6-!I.+QW6$#/!($+$:<601!J=.+./<=!".I<=)!2+06<6;6$!788C!!

!2+!$=.+./<=!6$#/0!&+'!:.#!>.(0!&+'!NO!%I=!<6!<0!</%.#6&+6!6.!=.+6<+;$!<+K$06<+Q!<+!6-$!!=.+06#;=6<.+!&+'!'$0<Q+!<+';06#)1!R-<=-!$/%I.)0!.K$#!9@S/!%$.%I$!&+'!&==.;+60!:.#!.K$#!Ed!.:!6.6&I!4\"@!Z$!/;06!&I0.!<+K$06!<+!&+'!#$=.Q+<0$!6-$!K&I;$!&+'!</%.#6&+=$!.:!0=-..I0!&+'!I.=&I!&;6-.#<6<$0!W!R-.!-&K$!'.+$!0.!/;=-!6.!/&A$!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6!R.#A!<+!6-$<#!I.=&I<6)@![.=&I!&;6-.#<6<$0!-&K$!0.!.:6$+!($$+!6-$!QI;$!6-&6!-&0!

(.;+'!6.Q$6-$#!&+'!%;0-$'!:.#R&#'!<++.K&6<.+!&+'!6-$!'$I<K$#)!.:!-<Q-!c;&I<6)!+$R!&+'!#$:;#(<0-$'!0=-..I0!6-&6!'$I<K$#!($66$#!#$0;I60!&+'!.;6=./$0!Y!&+'!/;06!($!&::.#'$'!&!0<Q+<:<=&+6!I$K$I!.:!<+%;6!<+6.!6-$!H&%<6&I!`$K<$RP0!R.#A!&+'!#$=.//$+'&6<.+0@!!U;#!0;(/<00<.+!(;<I'0!.+!.;#!.R+!$V6$+0<K$!R.#A!&+'!$V%$#6<0$!<+!6-$!&#$&!.:!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6!<+!6-$!NO!&+'!<+6$#+&6<.+&II)!&+'!6.!6-$!0;%%.#6!&+'!=.+6#<(;6<.+0!.:!.;#!GH5J!/$/($#0!R-.!&66$+'$'!6R.!-<Q-!%#.:<I$!0$/<+&#0!<+!6-$!5;//$#!7898!&+'!R-.!=.+6#<(;6$'!.::I<+$!&+'!.+I<+$!6-#.;Q-!6-$!H$+6#$!:.#!5=-..I!\$0<Q+!LRRR@6-$=$+6#$:.#0=-..I'$0<Q+@.#QM!!U;#!A$)!#$=.//$+'&6<.+!6.!6-$!H&%<6&I!`$K<$R!6$&/!<0!&!=&II!:.#!6-$!'$K$I.%/$+6!.:!&!'$=$+6!0=-..I!06&+'&#'!0.!&II!6-.0$!<+K.IK$'!<+!'$0<Q+<+Q1!/&+&Q<+Q!&+'!/&<+6&<+<+Q!

0=-..I!:&=<I<6<$0!=&+!($!=I$&#!&(.;6!R-&6!/&A$0!&!Q..'!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+61!R-&6$K$#!6-$!06#;=6;#$!.:!0=-..I<+Q!.#!R-.!%#.K<'$0!<6@!Z$!A+.R!0.!/;=-!/.#$!&(.;6!6-$!:&=6.#0!6-&6!=#$&6$!&+!^.%6</;/!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+6P!:.#!6$&=-<+Q!&+'!I$&#+<+Q!Y!I<Q-61!6$/%$#&6;#$1!&<#!c;&I<6)1!&=.;06<=01!=./:.#6!&+'!(;<I'!c;&I<6)@!e$6!6-$#$!<0!+.!:.#;/!6.!Q&6-$#!6-<0!<+:.#/&6<.+1!#$0$&#=-!&+'!A+.RI$'Q$!6.Q$6-$#!+.#!&!/$=-&+<0/!6.!0-&#$!<6!.#!Q#.R!6-$!A+.RI$'Q$!(&0$!R<6-!6-.0$!R-.!'$0<Q+1!%#.=;#$!.#!(;<I'!.;#!0=-..I0@!Z$!!#$=.//$+'!6-$!'$K$I.%/$+6!.:!&!%#.Q#&//$!.:!#$0$&#=-!&+'!&!($06!%#&=6<=$!+$6R.#A!6-&6!$+&(I$0!6-<0!</%.#6&+6!06$%!6.!6&A$!%I&=$@!!,-$!H&%<6&I!`$K<$R!-&0!6-$!.%%.#6;+<6)!6.!%;6!<+!%I&=$!&!:#&/$R.#A!6.!(;<I'!0=-..I0!6-&6!=.;I'!($!0$$+!6.!#$%#$0$+6!6-$!G$06!.:!G#<6&<+1!#&6-$#!6-&+!Q$6!6<$'!;%!<+!6-$!$V=$00$0!.:!(;#$&;=#&=)!&+'!#$'!6&%$@!Z$!&%%I&;'!6-$!0$6!;%!.:!&!#$K<$R!6.!I..A!#..6!&+'!(#&+=-!&6!

6-$!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$!&+'!;#Q$!6-$!&%%I<=&6<.+!.:!=.//.+!0$+0$!%#<+=<%I$01!$K<'$+=$!(&0$'!%#&=6<=$!&+'!I$&#+<+Q!:#./!6-$!%;(I<=!&+'!%#<K&6$!0$=6.#!6.!=#$&6$!&!(I;$%#<+6!6-&6!I$&'0!6.!($66$#!0=-..I0!:.#!$K$#)!=.//;+<6)@!!!!K@A! :($90/%'0+)4!*+&!'2#!/%$0'%9!&#60#7!Z$!+$$'!&!0)06$/!R<'$!#$:.#/!.:!6-$!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6!%#.Q#&//$!6-&6T!!!

!! G;<I'0!.+!6-$!I$&#+<+Q!.;6!<+!6-$!:<$I'!

!! 5-&#$0!&+!;+'$#06&+'<+Q!&(.;6!R-&6!/&A$0!&!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+61!6-#.;Q-!&!\$=$+6!5=-..I!56&+'&#'!



!! f&I;$0!6-$!#.I$!&+'!<+%;6!.:!6-$!K.I;+6&#)!0$=6.#!<+!<+:.#/<+Q!&+'!0-&%<+Q!($06!%#&=6<=$!

!! 2/%#.K$0!6-$!</%&=6!.:!6-$!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$1!6-#.;Q-!&!+&6<.+&II)!

0-&#$'!0$6!.:!/$&0;#$0!&+'!R<'$I)!0-&#$'!#$0$&#=-!&+'!$K<'$+=$!6.!<+:.#/!%#&=6<=$!!

!,-<0!%&%$#!R<II!+.R!0-&#$!&!0;//&#)!.:!6-$!A$)!<+:.#/&6<.+!Q&6-$#$'!:#./!.;#!GH5J!/$/($#0!<+!#$0%.+0$!6.!6-$!=&%<6&I!#$K<$R!<+=I;'<+Q!

!! 6-$!</%.#6&+=$!.:!($66$#!&II.=&6<.+!.:!=&%<6&I!:;+'0!

!! 6-$!'<06#<(;6<.+!.:!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6!!

!! =&%<6&I!#$6;#+!&+'!6-$!Q#.R<+Q!$K<'$+=$!(&0$!.:!6-$!</%&=6!.:!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!

!!L@A! B99+/%'0+)!+*!8%$0'%9!M.)-4!

U+$!.:!6-$!A$)!<00;$0!#$I&6<+Q!6.!6-$!=;##$+6!:;+'<+Q!/.'$I0!0;=-!&0!6-$!#$=$+6I)!%.06%.+$'!G;<I'<+Q!5=-..I0!:.#!6-$!3;6;#$!LG53M!%I;0!6-$!a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

!a0!6-$!=&%<6&I!#$K<$R!6$&/!R<II!($!&R&#$1!6-$!/$6-.'!()!R-<=-!:;+'<+Q!R&0!&II.=&6$'!<+<6<&II)!<+!6-$!G53!%#.Q#&//$!R&0!6-#.;Q-!'$%#<K&6<.+!<+'<=$0!.:![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!R<6-!6-.0$!R<6-!-<Q-$06!I$K$I0!.:!'$%#<K&6<.+!#$=$<K<+Q!:;+'<+Q!:<#06@!,-<0!R&0!+.6!I<+A$'!6.!6-$!=.+'<6<.+!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$!&+'!&0!&!#$0;I6!6-$#$!&#$!06<II!/&+)!0=-..I0!<+![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!6-&6!&#$!<+!+$$'!.:!/&<+6$+&+=$!.#!#$%I&=$/$+6@!a!/.#$!-.I<06<=!&00$00/$+6!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$!6-#.;Q-!&!=./%#$-$+0<K$!&00$6!/&+&Q$/$+6!&;'<6!0-.;I'!6&A$!%I&=$!6.!/&A$!/&V</;/!K&I;$!.;6!.:!&II!.:!6-$!%;(I<=!0$=6.#!&00$60!&K&<I&(I$!R<6-<+!&!I.=&I<6)@!,-$#$!<0!&+!.%%.#6;+<6)!6.!6&A$!&!g,.6&I!"I&=$h!&%%#.&=-1!=.+0<'$#<+Q!&II!6-$!&00$60!.:!&!I.=&I!&;6-.#<6)!.#!&#$&!6.Q$6-$#@!,-<0!R.;I'!&II.R!:.#!6-$!($06!&+'!/.06!$::$=6<K$!;0$!.:!:&=<I<6<$0!&K&<I&(I$!&+'!R.;I'!'<#$=6!<+K$06/$+6!6.!R-$#$!<6!<0!#$&II)!+$$'$'!6-#.;Q-!&!0$+0<(I$!a00$6!i&+&Q$/$+6!"I&+@!

!,-$!&II.=&6<.+!.:!=&%<6&I!:;+'<+Q!-&0!I$'!6.!K&#<&+=$!<+!6-$!c;&I<6)!.:!6-$!%#.K<0<.+!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$@!a0!6-$!:;+'<+Q!R&0!&II.=&6$'!6.!0=-..I0!&6!&!I.=&I!I$K$I!()!6-$![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)1!'<::$#$+6!=#<6$#<&!:.#!&II.=&6<.+!-&K$!($$+!&'.%6$'!<+!'<::$#$+6!&#$&0!.:!6-$!=.;+6#)@!,-$!+$$'1!<+!6$#/0!.:!:;+'<+Q!:.#!$&=-!0=-..I1!-&0!($$+!'$6$#/<+$'!()!$&=-![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)!:.#!6-$<#!.R+!&#$&@!i&+)![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!-&K$!'$K$I.%$'!&!:.#/;I&!()!R-<=-!6-$)!&II.=&6$!=&%<6&I1!6&A<+Q!<+6.!&==.;+6!&!+;/($#!.:!<00;$0@!,-$)!:$$I!6-&6!6-<0!-&0!&II.R$'!6-$/!6.!&II.=&6$!6-$!:;+'<+Q!<+!6-$!/.06!$::$=6<K$!R&)@!



!!U6-$#!/.#$!#$=$+6I)!'$K$I.%$'!=&%<6&I!:;+'<+Q!%#.Q#&//$0!0;=-!&0!6-$!"H"!<+=I;'$'!&!

#$c;<#$/$+6!:.#![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!6.!6&A$!&==.;+6!.:!6-$!06&6$!.:!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q0!&+'!Q#.;+'0!R-$+!&%%I)<+Q!:.#!:;+'<+Q!:#./!=$+6#&I!#$0.;#=$0@!,-;01!<6!<0!:$&0<(I$!6.!/$&0;#$!&Q&<+06!6-$0$!#$c;<#$/$+60!6.!'$6$#/<+$!6-$!0;==$00!.:!6-$!%#.Q#&//$!<+!&!/.#$!&==;#&6$!R&)@!!!"S?&'$%7&7(+!*;%(*9-!?59(%!)%(++?%(!&$!7:)%$3(!>(%(!$3(%!>'(;:(9!>7&'!:$5(-!T75!/1#U.!4?&!$=&(5!>7&'$?&!&'(!6*)*67&-!$%!(V)(%7(56(!&$!+)(59!7&!)%$9?6&73(;-@!

GH5J!H.+6#&=6.#!/$/($#!a;Q;06!7898!

!,-$!0<j$!.:!6-$!&II.=&6<.+!.:!=&%<6&I!:;+'<+Q!<0!&!=-&II$+Q$!&0!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$!<0!06&QQ$#<+Q@!2+!J+QI&+'1!5=.6I&+'!&+'!Z&I$0!6-$#$!&#$!7F1DFF!0=-..I0!R<6-!&!=./(<+$'!

&#$&!.:!.K$#!DC8!/<II<.+!0c;&#$!/$6#$0!.#!9B8!6</$0!6-$!0<j$!.:!:..6%#<+6!.:!,J5HU!06.#$0@!a+!$06</&6$'!D8d!.:!6-<0!&#$&!<0!/&'$!;%!.:!I&+'!R-<=-!=.+06<6;6$0!&!/&>.#!&00$6!&+'!#$0.;#=$1!(;6!Q<K$+!<60!0<j$!&+'!0=&I$!<0!'<::<=;I6!&+'!=./%I$V!6.!/&+&Q$@!!!2+!J+QI&+'1!C8d!.:!%#</&#)!0=-..I0!&+'!BSd!.:!0$=.+'&#)!0=-..I0!R$#$!(;<I6!($:.#$!9FBE@!,-$!/&<+6$+&+=$!.:!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q0!<0!&I0.!=#<6<=&I!.K$#!6-$<#!I<:$!=)=I$@!2+!5=.6I&+'1!6-$!/.06!#$=$+6!#$%.#6!.+!6-$!06&6$!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$!:.;+'!6-&6!.+I)!9B!%$#!=$+6!#$=$<K$'!&!#&6<+Q!.:!a!LQ..'M!R-<I06!DC!%$#!=$+6!R$#$!#&6$'!G!L0&6<0:&=6.#)M1!79!%$#!=$+6!R$#$!#&6$'!H!L%..#M!&+'!6R.!%$#!=$+6!R$#$!#&6$'!\!L(&'M@!5</<I&#!06&6<06<=0!:.#!0=-..I0!<+!J+QI&+'!&#$!+.6!:#$$I)!&K&<I&(I$@!,-$!GH5J!06#.+QI)!0;%%.#60!6-$!+$$'!6.!<+K$06!<+!&+'!</%#.K$!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$!<+!R<'$#!6$#/0!6-&+!0</%I)!6-$!06&6$!.:!#$%&<#!.:!6-$!(;<I'<+Q!:&(#<=@!3.#!$V&/%I$!%#.K<'<+Q!Q..'!0%.#60!:&=<I<6<$01!-<Q-!c;&I<6)!&+'!

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a;6-.#<6<$0!;0<+Q!:;+'<+Q!:#./!6-$!=;##$+6!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$!$::$=6<K$I)!6.!=#$&6$!0=-..I0!R-<=-!&#$!=;##$+6I)!%$#:.#/<+Q!R$II!<+!6$#/0!.:!#$';=<+Q!=&#(.+!

8%4#!;'.-0#4!k&I6.+!&+'!Z&##<+Q6.+![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!-&K$!'$K$I.%$'!&!:.#/;I&!:.#!6-$!&II.=&6<.+!

.:!G53!:;+'0!6.!6-$<#!0=-..I0!.+!6-$!(&0<0!.:!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$01!=.+'<6<.+1!0;<6&(<I<6)!&+'!0;::<=<$+=)@!!!5</<I&#I)!k;II!H<6)!H.;+=<I!-&K$!'$K$I.%$'!&!:.#/;I&!6.!&II.=&6$!=&%<6&I!6.!6-$<#!0=-..I0!(&0$'!;%.+!6-$!+$$'!:#./!&!=&%<6&I!&00$6!%.<+6!.:!K<$R!L=.+'<6<.+1!0;<6&(<I<6)1!-$&I6-!&+'!0&:$6)1!&==$00!&+'!0;::<=<$+=)M!&0!R$II!&0!&+!&+&I)0<0!.:!6-$!=.+6$V6;&I!K&I;$!&''$'!0=.#$0!R-<=-!#$I&6$!6.!$';=&6<.+&I!+$$'@!,-$0$!0=.#$0!R$#$!=./(<+$'!6.!<'$+6<:)!6-$!0=-..I0!R<6-!Q#$&6$06!+$$'!.:!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6!;+'$#!6-$!G53!%#.Q#&//$@!!



$/<00<.+0!R-<I06!06<II!%#.K<'<+Q!&+!$+K<#.+/$+6!6-&6!<0!%$#=$<K$'!6.!($!=./:.#6&(I$!:.#!06&::!&+'!06;'$+60!6.!R.#A!<+@!!!

!

!

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

(5(%<-!%(9?6&7$5!+'$?;9!756;?9(!*5!(;(:(5&!*4$?&!&'(!4?7;975<!75!?+(!*59!&'(!7:)*6&!$=!4('*37$?%D@!

GH5J!i$=-&+<=&I!&+'!J+Q<+$$#<+Q!"#.K<'$#!/$/($#!*;I)!7898!

!a+.6-$#!</%.#6&+6!=.+0<'$#&6<.+!<+!6-<0!&#$&!&#$!6-$!#$&I!=&#(.+!#$';=6<.+!($+$:<60!.:!#$:;#(<0-/$+6!K$#0;0!+$R!(;<I'!0=-..I0@!aI6-.;Q-!6-$#$!&#$!.:6$+!=&#(.+!#$';=6<.+0!<+!=.+06#;=6<.+!.+!#$:;#(<0-/$+6!%#.>$=601!6-$!.%$#&6<.+!.:!6-$0$!(;<I'<+Q0!/&)!($!I$00!$::<=<$+6!<+!6$#/0!.:!.%$#&6<.+!6-&+!&!+$R!(;<I'<+Q@!26!<0!</%.#6&+6!6.!=.+0<'$#!6-$!R-.I$!I<:$!=)=I$@!!!

N@A! "04'&0<.'0+)!+*!8%$0'%9!:)6#4'(#)'!Z-<I06!6-$#$!-&K$!($$+!&!+;/($#!.:!%#.(I$/0!<'$+6<:<$'!R<6-!6-$!=;##$+6!%#.=$00$01!6-$#$!&#$!&0%$=60!.:!6-$!'<::$#$+6!=&%<6&I!0%$+'<+Q!/.'$I0!R-<=-!R.#A!R$II!&+'!-&K$!($$+!&'&%6$'!()![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!&+'!%#<K&6$!0$=6.#!%#.K<'$#0!6.!/&A$!6-$/!K$#)!$::$=6<K$@!!a!=./%&#<0.+!.:!6-$!6-#$$!/&<+!=&%<6&I!0%$+'<+Q!%#.=;#$/$+6!/.'$I0!<+!J+QI&+'!&6!6-$!6</$!.:!R#<6<+Q!-&0!#$K$&I$'!6-&6!6-$#$!<0!&!%#$:$#$+=$!:.#!6-$!+$R!]&6<.+&I!3#&/$R.#A!:.#!a=&'$/<$0!%#.=;#$/$+6@!k.R$K$#1!<6!-&0!($$+!&#Q;$'!6-&6!6-<0!<0!I$00!$::$=6<K$!:.#!%#</&#)!0=-..I0!R-$+!6-$!"#</&#)!H&%<6&I!"#.Q#&//$!/.'$I!<0!%#$:$##$'@!!!

8%4#!;'.-0#4!Z-<6$=#.00!5=-..I1!k$#$:.#'!R-$#$!G;<I'<+Q!i&+&Q$/$+6!5)06$/0!'$/.+06#&6$!$+$#Q)!$::<=<$+=)!&+'!6-$!-$&'!6$&=-$#!-&0!#$%.#6$'!($66$#!$V&/!#$0;I601!($66$#!($-&K<.;#!&+'!($66$#!%$#:.#/&+=$!.:!6-$!06&::!<+!6-$!+$R!G53!0=-..I@!!!2+!k&I6.+!&+!&;6-.#<6)WR<'$!&%%#.&=-!6.!&II!%;(I<=!(;<I'<+Q0!-&0!($$+!&'.%6$'!&+'!6-<0!-&0!<+:I;$+=$'!6-$<#!G53!%#.Q#&//$!'$K$I.%/$+6@!a</<+Q!6.!($!=&#(.+!+$;6#&I!()!789_!%I&++<+Q!%$#/<00<.+!-&0!($$+!.(6&<+$'!6.!$#$=6!R<+'!6;#(<+$0!R-<=-!R<II!0&6<0:)!0./$!.:!6-$!$+$#Q)!#$c;<#$/$+60!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$@!



"A'(%(!7+!5$!+75<;(!79(*;!:$9(;!$=!6*)7&*;!97+&%74?&7$5!*+!(==(6&73(!7:);(:(5&*&7$5!7+!+$! )*&6'-!*59!&'(%(!7+!3*%7*47;7&-!75!6*)*47;7&-D!W5&(;;7<(5&!:$9(;+!$=!97+&%74?&7$5!5((9+!&$!%(6$<57+(!&'$+(!$%<*57+*&7$5+!>'$!9$!5$&!'*3(!(5$?<'!(V)(%7(56(!*59!'(;)!&'(:!>'7;+&!

;(*375<!*;$5(!&'$+(!>'$!F5$>!>'*&!&'(-E%(!9$75<@!GH5J!a#=-<6$=6!/$/($#1!

*;I)!7898!!!,-$!/&<+!%.0<6<K$0!&+'!+$Q&6<K$0!:.#!$&=-!%#.=;#$/$+6!/$6-.'1!=.II&6$'!:#./!.;#!GH5J!/$/($#!:.#;/01!&=#.00!6-$!=I<$+6!&+'!0;%%I)!0<'$!&#$!'$6&<I$'!<+!6-$!6&(I$!($I.RT!!

!O+40'06#4! C#H%'06#4!

!>;M!

!56#&6$Q<=!&%%#.&=-!6&A$+!&=#.00!&!+;/($#!.:!0=-..I0!!\$%#<K&6<.+!6&#Q$6$'!!\#<K$+!()!$';=&6<.+!K<0<.+!!"#.=$00!-&0!</%#.K$'!Y!/.+$)!&II.=&6<.+!+.R!/.#$!.:!&!/$#<6.=#&=)!&+'!$';=&6<.+&I!K<0<.+0!($66$#!'$K$I.%$'!!U%%.#6;+<6)!6.!=.+0<'$#!R-.I$!:&=<I<6)!-.I<06<=&II)!:#./!<+=$%6<.+!.:!%#.>$=6!!56&A$-.I'$#!%&#6<=<%&6<.+!$+=.;#&Q$'!!5./$!#$Q;I&6<.+!.:!%#.=$00!R<6-!&00<06&+=$!:.#!+$R!=I<$+601!Q;<'&+=$!.+!Q..'!%#&=6<=$!&+'!#$K<$R0!.:!%#.Q#$00!&+'!c;&I<6)!!"$.%I$!R$#$!I$&#+<+Q!-.R!6.!R.#A!$::$=6<K$I)!R<6-!G53!%#.Q#&//$!&+'!/&V</<0$!.%%.#6;+<6<$0!!

!].6!&0!>.<+$'W;%!<+!%#&=6<=$!$@Q@!2H,!&+'!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q!+.6!<+6$Q#&6$'!!"#.=$00!6..!I$+Q6-)!&+'!(;#$&;=#&6<=!/&A<+Q!<6!+$$'I$00I)!$V%$+0<K$!:.#!=I<$+6!&+'!%#.K<'$#0! !!a'-$#$+=$!6..!06#.+QI)!6.!Q;<'&+=$!0;=-!&0!GGFC!&+'!.6-$#!Q;<'&+=$!R-<=-!R&0!.:6$+!=.+:I<=6<+Q@!!!,-$!Q;<'&+=$!&=6;&II)!I$'!&0%$=60!.:!6-$!G53!%#.Q#&//$!0;=-!&0!:;+'<+Q!R-<=-!R&0!'$6#</$+6&I!6.!<++.K&6<.+!!![&#Q$!+;/($#0!.:!%$.%I$!#$c;<#$'!6.!'$&I!R<6-!=./%I$V<6)!.:!%#.=$00!0;=-!&0!=.+6#&=60!#$c;<#<+Q!I$Q&I!6$&/0!&+'!#<0A!-&K<+Q!6.!($!/&+&Q$'!=&#$:;II)!!G;#'$+!.+!$+'!;0$#0!&+'!=I<$+60!R&0!-<Q-!';$!6.!I$+Q6-)!=./%$6<6<K$!%#.=$00!';#<+Q!(<'!06&Q$!

!B/%-#(0#4!

!"#$W&%%#.K$'!06&6;0!.+!6-$!:#&/$R.#A!06<II!&II.R$'!:.#!=./%$6<6<.+!(;6!R<6-!%#$Wc;&I<:<=&6<.+!&I#$&')!'$6$#/<+$'!!i;=-!0-.#6$#!&+'!0</%I$#!%#.=$00!#$';=$'!(;#$&;=#&=)!&+'!R&06$!.:!

![$00!$/%-&0<0!.+!I<:$!&+'!.%$#&6<.+!.:!6-$!0=-..I!&0!/.06!=.+6#&=60!R$#$!'$0<Q+!&+'!(;<I'!![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!&+'!0%.+0.#0!06<II!-&'!&!0<Q+<:<=&+6!&/.;+6!.:!R.#A!6.!'.!6.!%#$%&#$!($:.#$!0=-..I!%#.>$=6!



#$0.;#=$0!!!i.'$I!:.#!R-<=-!/.06!

0;%%I<$#0l%#.K<'$#0!$V%#$00$'!&!%#$:$#$+=$!

R&0!'$$/$'!I<K$!R-<=-!R&0!+.6!=.;+6$'!&0!($<+Q!%&#6!.:!6-$!%#.=$00@!!

!\<::<=;I6!:.#!0./$!%#.K<'$#0!6.!$06&(I<0-!6-$/0$IK$0!<:!+.6!%&#6!.:!6-$!&%%#.K$'!:#&/$R.#A!.:!0;%%I<$#0!!5/&II$#!+;/($#!.:!0=-..I0!%$#!%#.>$=6!#$';=$'!%.00<(<I<6<$0!:.#!/&A<+Q!0&K<+Q0!6-.;Q-!$=.+./<$0!.:!0=&I$!!

!

O8O!

!

H.+0<'$#&6<.+!.:!&!Q#$&6$#!+;/($#!.:!:&=6.#0!R-$+!($<+Q!Q#&+6$'!:;+'<+Q!$@Q@!06&6$!.:!0=-..I!$06&6$1!06#.+Q!$';=&6<.+&I!K<0<.+1!$6=!!J=.+./<$0!.:!0=&I$!%.00<(I$!&=#.00!&!+;/($#!.:!0=-..I0!<+![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)!!3;+'<+Q!Q#&+6$'!%#</&#<I)!.+!#$&'<+$00!6.!'$I<K$#!&+'!R&0!&K&<I&(I$!6.!&II![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!

:#./!06&#6!.:!6-$!%#.Q#&//$!!3;+'<+Q!%#</&#<I)!6-#.;Q-!Q#&+60!#&6-$#!6-&+!"32!=#$'<60!![$00!R&06$'!#$0.;#=$!&+'!'.;(I<+Q!;%!.+!'$0<Q+!!

!

].6!&II!:;+'<+Q!:.#!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!%#.K<'$'!&+'!0./$!-&'!6.!($!.(6&<+$'!()!6-$![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)!6.!/&6=-!=$+6#&I!Q.K$#+/$+6!=.+6#<(;6<.+!

!!2+!&''<6<.+!6.!6-$!0%$=<:<=!%#.=;#$/$+6!/.'$I0!6-&6!&#$!'$6&<I$'!&(.K$1!6-$#$!<0!&!/.#$!06#&6$Q<=!<00;$!.:!6-$!'<06#<(;6<.+!.:!=&%<6&I!:;+'0!&+'!R-$6-$#!=$+6#&I!.#!I.=&I<0$'!

'<06#<(;6<.+!<0!/.06!$::$=6<K$@!,-$!=;##$+6!/.'$I!.:!'<06#<(;6<+Q!:;+'0!6-#.;Q-![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!-&0!(.6-!%.0<6<K$0!&+'!+$Q&6<K$0@!56#&6$Q<=!'<06#<(;6<.+!&6!&!I.=&I!I$K$I!=&+!I$&'!6.!Q#$&6$#!;+'$#06&+'<+Q!.:!6-$!I.=&I!+$$'01!:.#!$V&/%I$!0./$![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!-&K$!'$K$I.%$'!&!:;+'<+Q!&II.=&6<.+!:.#/;I&!6.!'<06#<(;6$!=&%<6&I!:;+'0!:.#!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!/.06!$::$=6<K$I)!6-#.;Q-.;6!6-$<#!&#$&!.:!#$0%.+0<(<I<6)!;0<+Q!6-$!<+W'$%6-!A+.RI$'Q$!6-$)!-&K$!.:!I.=&I!+$$'0@!,-$!/&+&Q$/$+6!.:!:;+'0!K<&!6-$![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)!&I0.!&II.R0!6-$/!6.!6&A$!&!06#&6$Q<=!K<$R!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$06&6$1!'$K$I.%!:#&/$R.#A0!R-<=-!R.#A!$::$=6<K$I)!<+!6-$<#!#$Q<.+!$@Q@!i&+=-$06$#!3#&/$R.#A1!2J5J!:#&/$R.#A!&+'!/&A$!0<Q+<:<=&+6!$=.+./<$0!.:!0=&I$!6-#.;Q-!6-$!#$';=6<.+!.:!#$%$6<6<.+!.:!R.#A!&+'!<+=#$&0$'!(;)<+Q!%.R$#@!!!



!

!!,-$!+$Q&6<K$!&0%$=60!.:!&II.=&6<+Q!:;+'0!K<&![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!&#$!6-&6!<6!<0!'$/&+'<+Q!<+!

6$#/0!.:!#$0.;#=$!&+'!+$R!6$&/0!R$#$!:#$c;$+6I)!$06&(I<0-$'!R<6-<+![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!<+=;##<+Q!=.060!.:!#$=#;<6/$+61!R&Q$01!$6=@!,-$#$!R&0!&I0.!K&#<&6<.+!<+!6-$!6#;$!#$&'<+$00!.:![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!6.!'$I<K$#!<+!6$#/0!.:!A+.RI$'Q$1!;+'$#06&+'<+Q1!$V%$#<$+=$!&+'!#$0.;#=$1!R-<=-!<+!6;#+!/&)!-&K$!&::$=6$'!6-$!c;&I<6)!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!'$I<K$#$'!&+'!:&<#+$00!<+!6$#/0!.:!:;+'<+Q!&II.=&6<.+@!!H$+6#&I!&II.=&6<.+!.:!:;+'<+Q!'<#$=6I)!6.!<+'<K<';&I!0=-..I0!.#!0/&II!Q#.;%0!.:!0=-..I0!R<II!&II.R!6-$/!6.!&%%I)!:.#!:;+'<+Q!.:!6-$!(;<I6!$+K<#.+/$+6!&+'!:;I:<I!+$$'0!<+!6$#/0!.:!=#$&6<+Q!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!R<6-.;6!6-$![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)!-&K<+Q!=.+6#.I@!,-<0!-&0!($$+!'$/.+06#&6$'!6.!R.#A!$::$=6<K$I)!.+!/&+)!a=&'$/)!%#.>$=60@!k.R$K$#1!6-<0!/$6-.'!.:!=&%<6&I!'<06#<(;6<.+!<0!+.6!R<6-.;6!:&;I6@!,-$#$!<0!&!+$$'!:.#!=&%&=<6)!6.!/&+&Q$!&+'!'$I<K$#!6-$!%#.>$=6!&6!&+!<+'<K<';&I!0=-..I!I$K$I!R-<=-!6-$)!/&)!+.6!$&0<I)!($!&(I$!6.!

#$0.;#=$!&+'!I$&'0!6.!<+=#$&0$'!.K$#&II!=.060!:.#!%#.K<'<+Q!+$R!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!&0!0./$!R.#A!<0!#$%$&6$'!+;/$#.;0!6</$0!<+!.+$!&;6-.#<6)@!,-$#$!<0!&I0.!I$00!.%%.#6;+<6)!6.!I$&#+!&+'!'$/.+06#&6$!=.+6<+;.;0!</%#.K$/$+6!<+!0=-..I!'$0<Q+1!%&#6<=;I&#I)!R<6-!+.!06&+'&#'<0$'!$K&I;&6<.+!/$6-.'!&+'!:#&/$R.#A!<+!%I&=$@!,-<0!<0!R-$#$!&!I.=&I!.#Q&+<0&6<.+!R<6-!$V%$#6<0$!&+'!6-$!&(<I<6)!6.!R.#A!R<6-!&!+;/($#!.:!0=-..I0!&0!.%%.0$'!6.!<+'<K<';&I!0=-..I0!<0!($+$:<=<&I@!,-$![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!&#$!<'$&II)!%I&=$'!6.!'$I<K$#!6-<0!0$#K<=$@!"X$6*;!S?&'$%7&7(+!>(%(!*4;(!&$!&'75F!:?6'!:$%(!+&%*&(<76*;;-!>7&'!/1#!*59!&'(!L0L!+6'(:(+!*59!7&!:*9(!&'(:!%(*;7+(!&'(!75(==767(567(+!$=!9(*;75<!>7&'!$5(!4?7;975<!$%!=*67;7&-!*&!*!&7:(D@!

GH5J![.=&I!a;6-.#<6)!/$/($#!*;I)!7898!

8%4#!;'.-0#4!

2/%#.K$/$+6!&+'!J::<=<$+=)!5.;6-!J&06!L2J5JM!<0!&!/&+&Q$'!:#&/$R.#A!'$K$I.%$'!()![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!<+!6-$!5.;6-!J&06!.:!J+QI&+'!6.!(#<+Q!&(.;6!</%#.K$'!$::<=<$+=)!&+'!%$#:.#/&+=$!<+!%#.=;#$/$+6@!]<+$![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!<+!6-$!5.;6-!J&06!-&K$!0;(0$c;$+6I)!$I$=6$'!6.!;0$!6-$!2J5J!:#&/$R.#A!&0!6-$!'$I<K$#)!#.;6$!:.#!6-$<#!.+$!0=-..I!%&6-:<+'$#!G53!%#.>$=60@!,&#Q$6!0&K<+Q0!:.#!$&=-!%#.>$=6!;0<+Q!6-<0!:#&/$R.#A!&0!.%%.0$'!6.!6-$!6#&'<6<.+&I!G53!#.;6$!R$#$!$06</&6$'!&6!($6R$$+!9@_d!&+'!Sd!L.#!m_@7/Wm98/M!:.#!6-$!.+$!0=-..I!%&6-:<+'$#!%#.Q#&//$0@!mBD81888!-&0!&I#$&')!($$+!0&K$'!<+!6-$!<+<6<&I!%#.=;#$/$+6!=.060!()!;0<+Q!6-$!2J5J!:#&/$R.#A@!2+!6$#/0!.:!%$#:.#/&+=$!6-$!:#&/$R.#A!-&0!<+:.#/$'!&!'$0<Q+!06&+'&#'<0&6<.+!06#&6$Q)!&+'!0;%%I)!=-&<+!06#&6$Q)!R-<=-!-&K$!I$'!6.!Q#$&6$#!$::<=<$+=<$0@!k&K<+Q!$V%$#6<0$!&6!&!I.=&I!I$K$I!&I0.!%#.K<'$0!6-$!0=-..I0!R<6-!0./$.+$!R-.!=&+!%#.K<'$!6-$/!R<6-!-$I%!&+'!&'K<=$!R-$#$!+$$'$'!6.!'$K$I.%!6-$<#!:&=<I<6<$0!()!I$&#+<+Q!:#./!R-&6!.6-$#0!-&K$!'.+$!0;==$00:;II)@!!a!0=-..I!<+!k&#I.R1!J00$V!R&0!#$=$+6I)!=./%I$6$'!6-#.;Q-!6-$!5/&#6$!J&06!:#&/$R.#A!'<#$=6I)!()!6-$!=.;+6)!=.;+=<I!.;60<'$!.:!G53@!,-<0!<+K.IK$'!=./%$6<6<K$!<+6$#K<$R01!0./$!'$0<Q+!'$K$I.%/$+6!&+'!K<0<60!()!6-$!=I<$+6!6.!.6-$#!(;<I'<+Q0!%#.';=$'!()!6-$!(<''<+Q!6$&/0@!,-$!(#<$:!R&0!'$K$I.%$'!<+!=.+>;+=6<.+!R<6-!6-$!&#=-<6$=6!.+=$!6-$!=.+6#&=6!R&0!&R&#'$'@!2+!6.6&I!6-<0!6..A!9_8!-.;#0@!H./%&#$!6-<0!R<6-!.K$#!S888!-.;#0!&=#.00!&!R-.I$!)$&#!6.!'$K$I.%!&!G53!0=-..I!<+!6-$!5.;6-R&#A!G53!0=-$/$@!



!P@A! 8%$0'%9!5#'.&)!"A'(!:$+&!+?66(++=?;!*59!755$3*&73(!6$:)*57(+!?59(%+&*59!&'(!7:)$%&*56(!$=!&'(7%!

(537%$5:(5&D!#$%!(V*:);(!Y$$<;(!F5$>!&'*&!&'(7%!$==76(+!%()%(+(5&!&'(:!*59!&'(-!*&&*6'!3*;?(!&$!&'(!);*6(!75!>'76'!&'(7%!(:);$-((+!>$%FD@!

GH5J!a#=-<6$=6!/$/($#!*;I)!7898!

!a!A$)!<00;$!#&<0$'!()!GH5J!/$/($#0!R&0!6-$!<00;$!.:!-.R!'.!).;!/$&0;#$!^K&I;$P!:#./!&!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$!Y!(.6-!<+!6$#/0!.:!($+$:<60!.:!6-$!%$#:.#/&+=$!.:!6-$!(;<I'<+Q!&+'!<60!&(<I<6)!6.!:;+=6<.+!$::$=6<K$I)!:.#!6-.0$!;0<+Q!6-$!:&=<I<6<$0!&+'!<+!</%#.K<+Q!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0@!,-$!</%&=6!.:!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q0!-&0!($$+!R$II!'.=;/$+6$'!<+!6-$!`2Ga!0;(/<00<.+!6.!6-$!H&%<6&I!`$K<$R!&+'!=&%6;#$'!<+!%&#6!6-#.;Q-!/&>.#!Q.K$#+/$+6!#$%.#60!0;=-!&0!6-$!JK&I;&6<.+!.:!6-$!G;<I'<+Q!5=-..I0!:.#!6-$!3;6;#$!"#.Q#&//$1!6-$!]&6<.+&I!a;'<6!U::<=$!#$%.#60!.+!6-$!</%&=6!.:!6-$!a=&'$/<$0!%#.Q#&//$!&+'!<+!

#$0$&#=-!#$%.#60!0;=-!&0!6-$!\$0<Q+!H.;+=<I!^,-$!2/%&=6!.:!5=-..I!J+K<#.+/$+60P!#$%.#6!,-$!2/%&=6!.:!5=-..I!G;<I'<+Q0!:#./!H3G,!&+'!()!/.#$!#$=$+6!#$0$&#=-!:#./!"$6$#!G&##$66!:#./!6-$!N+<K$#0<6)!.:!5&I:.#'!.+!U%6</&I![$&#+<+Q!5%&=$0@!U;#!.R+!:#&/$R.#A!:.#!/$&0;#<+Q!6-$!</%&=6!.:!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!<0!&0!:.II.R0T!!!

! ;2+&'Q'#&(! R+)HQS#&(!

,-./%'0+)!T.'/+(#4!

!a66$+'&+=$!G$-&K<.;#!H.//;+<6)!;0$!,$&=-$#!`$6$+6<.+!JV=I;0<.+!`&6$0!

!

!a66&<+/$+6!J/%I.)&(<I<6)!56&::!*.(!5&6<0:&=6<.+!`$';=$'!\$%#<K&6<.+!!

8+)4'&./'0+)!! !H&%<6&I!H.06!\$0<Q+!n;&I<6)!,</$!,&A$+!Z&06$!`$';=6<.+!!

![<:$!H)=I$!H.060!U%$#&6<.+&I!J::$=6<K$+$00!H.+6<+;.;0!2/%#.K$/$+6!J+K<#.+/$+6&I!0;06&<+&(<I<6)!

!Z$!-&K$!&I0.!:.;+'!&!R$&I6-!.:!$K<'$+=$!6.!'$/.+06#&6$!6-$!</%&=6!.:!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!.+!6-$0$!0-.#6!&+'!I.+Q!6$#/!:&=6.#0@!a0!%&#6!.:!6-$!GH5JP0!4#$&6!5=-..I0!2+c;<#)!R$!&0A$'!I$&'<+Q!#$0$&#=-!=.+0;I6&+=)!^i&6#<V!O+.RI$'Q$P!6.!=.+';=6!&!QI.(&I!6#&RI!.:!#$0$&#=-!<+6.!6-$!</%&=6!.:!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!.+!$';=&6<.+&I!&=-<$K$/$+6@!

,-$<#!R.#A!=.+:<#/$'!6-$!:<+'<+Q0!.:!&!#$=$+6!#$0$&#=-!%#.>$=6!:#./!5&I:.#'!N+<K$#0<6)!R-<=-!06&6$0!6-&6!6-$#$!<0!g=.+0<'$#&(I$!$K<'$+=$!6.!0-.R0!6-&6!6-$#$!<0!&+!$V%I<=<6!#$I&6<.+0-<%!($6R$$+!6-$!%-)0<=&I!=-&#&=6$#<06<=0!.:!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q01!&+'!6-$!0%&=$0!R<6-<+!6-$/1!&+'!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0h@!U%6</&I!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!Y!<+=I;'<+Q!6-$!($-&K<.;#&I1!&;#&I!&+'!K<0;&I!$+K<#.+/$+6!W!0;%%.#6!6$&=-<+Q!&+'!I$&#+<+Q!<+!6-$!=I&00#../1!#$6&<+!-<Q-!c;&I<6)!6$&=-$#0!<+!6-$!%#.:$00<.+1!%#.K<'$!&!0;%%.#61!=#$&6$!&!0&:$!-&K$+!:.#!K;I+$#&(I$!=-<I'#$+1!$+-&+=$!($-&K<.;#!&+'!&66<6;'$0!6.!I$&#+<+Q1!=;I6<K&6$!6-$!0%.#60!&+'!&#60!&+'!=#;=<&II)!&#$!&!6..I!:.#!0=-..I!</%#.K$/$+6@!!!,-$!;+'$#06&+'<+Q!Q&<+$'!:#./!6-$!#$0$&#=-!=&##<$'!.;6!-&0!I$'!6-$!GH5J!6.!<'$+6<:)!6-&6!6-$!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+6!=&+!</%&=6!;%.+!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0!.+!'<::$#$+6!I$K$I0@!,-$0$!&#$!#$%#$0$+6$'!<+!6-$!'<&Q#&/!($I.RT!



!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!,-<0!:#&/$R.#A!(;<I'0!.+!6-$!I&+'/&#A!#$0$&#=-!<+6.!6-$!:&=6.#0!6-&6!</%&=6!.+!&=-<$K$/$+6!()!"#.:$00.#!*.-+!k&66<$!R-.!=.+';=6$'!&!/$6&W&+&I)0<0!.:!.K$#!C88!%<$=$0!.:!#$0$&#=-!<+6.!6-$!/&<+!<+:I;$+=$0!.+!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0@!,-$0$!&#$!

<'$+6<:<$'!&0!6$&=-$#01!6-$!=;##<=;I;/1!06;'$+60l%$$#01!6-$!0=-..I!&+'!-./$@!!!2+!6$#/0!.:!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!6-$#$!<0!$K<'$+=$!6.!0;QQ$06!6-&6!&#$!6R.!0$60!.:!:&=6.#0!R-<=-!=&+!<+:I;$+=$!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0!$<6-$#!'<#$=6I)!.#!<+'<#$=6I)!6-#.;Q-!6-$<#!</%&=6!;%.+!6-$!=.#$!:&=6.#0@!,-$!$+&(I<+Q!:&=6.#0!&#$!6-.0$!6-&6!&#$!#$c;<#$'!:.#!&!/<+</;/!I$K$I!.:!+$$'!6.!($!/$6@!3.#!$V&/%I$!6-$!I<Q-6!I$K$I0!-&K$!6.!($!&'$c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

!,.!0;%%.#6!6-$!=&%<6&I!#$K<$R!6$&/P0!'$I<($#&6<.+01!R$!-&K$!&I0.!%#.';=$'!&!0;//&#)!.:!0./$!.:!6-$!A$)!&=&'$/<=!#$0$&#=-!%#.>$=60!'$/.+06#&6<+Q!6-$!</%&=6!.:!&!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+6!;%.+!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0!<+!6-$!:.II.R<+Q!6&(I$@!!!



,&A$+!6.Q$6-$#!6-$0$!:&=6.#0!0-.R!&!=I$&#!I<+A!($6R$$+!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!6-&6!Q.!($).+'!Q$66<+Q!6-$!(&0<=0!#<Q-6!&+'!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$01!)$6!6-$#$!-&0!6.!'&6$!($$+!+.!0)06$/&6<=!$K&I;&6<.+!.:!6-$!</%&=6!.:!6-$!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+6@!f&#<.;0!Q#.;%01!

.#Q&+<0&6<.+0!&+'!0=-..I0!-&K$!($$+!=&##)<+Q!.;6!0./$!%.06W.==;%&+=)!$K&I;&6<.+0!(;6!6-$0$!-&K$!+.6!($$+!;+<K$#0&II)!&'.%6$'!&=#.00!6-$!(.&#'!R<6-!=./%&#&(I$!'&6&!($<+Q!%#.K<'$'!:.#!&+&I)0<0@!Z<6-.;6!6-<0!<6!<0!+.6!%.00<(I$!6.!=I$&#I)!'$6$#/<+$!6-$!</%&=6!.:!6-$!0=-..I!(;<I'<+Q0!<+!6-$!NO@!!!"&#6+$#0-<%0!:.#!5=-..I0!($Q&+!6.!'$K$I.%!&!/.'$I!.:!%.06W.==;%&+=)!$K&I;&6<.+!<+!%&#6+$#0-<%!R<6-!6-$!GH5J!&+'!<+6$#$06<+Q!:<+'<+Q0!:#./!6-$!<+<6<&I!%<I.6!06;'<$0!R$#$!$06&(I<0-$'@!k.R$K$#1!6-$!/.'$I!-&0!+.6!)$6!($$+!'$K$I.%$'!$+.;Q-!6.!($!</%I$/$+6$'!&=#.00!&II!0=-..I0@!e$6!0./$!.:!6-$!A$)!/$00&Q$0!$/$#Q<+Q!R$#$T!

!! ,$/%$#&6;#$!R&0!&+!<00;$!<+!0=-..I0!R-$#$!6-$#$!R&0!&!I&=A!.:!%$#0.+&I!=.+6#.I!.K$#!6-$!$+K<#.+/$+6!&+'!+.!&(<I<6)!6.!&'>;06!6-$!=.+'<6<.+0!6.!</%#.K$!6-$#/&I!=./:.#6!

!! a=.;06<=0!:.#!6-$!/&>.#<6)!.:!06;'$+60!&+'!06&::!R$#$!&==$%6&(I$!<+!06&+'&#'!6$&=-<+Q!0%&=$0!(;6!6-$#$!R$#$!0./$!<00;$0!R<6-!/.#$!.%$+!.#!'.;(I$!-$<Q-6!0%&=$0!

!! 5%&=$!R&0!+.6!%$#=$<K$'!6.!($!I&=A<+Q!(;6!6-$!'<06#<(;6<.+!.:!0%&=$1!$K$+!R-$+!&'-$#<+Q!%#$'./<+&6$I)!6.!GGFC!R&0!+.6!&IR&)0!&%%#.%#<&6$!

!! 2H,!R&0!R$II!I<A$'!R-$+!<6!R&0!&K&<I&(I$1!$&0)!6.!&==$00!&+'!;0$!&+'!R-$+!6-$!-&#'R&#$!%#.K<'$'!R&0!#.(;06!$+.;Q-!6.!R<6-06&+'!0<Q+<:<=&+6!;0$!

!! i.06!06;'$+60!&+'!06&::!:$I6!6-&6!6-$#$!R&0!+.6!$+.;Q-!0.=<&I!.#!<+:.#/&I!I$&#+<+Q!0%&=$!%#.K<'$'!R<6-<+!6-$<#!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!

!! JV6$#+&I!0%&=$0!R$#$!Q#$&6I)!&%%#$=<&6$'!()!0=-..I!;0$#0!(;6!R$#$!+.6!;0$'!$::$=6<K$I)!<+!/.06!0=-..I0!:.#!#$=#$&6<.+!.#!I$&#+<+Q!.;60<'$!.:!%-)0<=&I!$';=&6<.+!&0!%$.%I$!R$#$!+.6!&R&#$!.:!6-$<#!%.6$+6<&I!

!! "$.%I$!:$I6!0&:$!<+!6-$!0=-..I!R-$+!<6!R&0!.%$+!&+'!6-$#$!R$#$!=I$&#!0<Q-6!I<+$0!6.!&<'!%&00<K$!0;%$#K<0<.+!

!! ,-$!K&06!/&>.#<6)!.:!06;'$+60!0&<'!6-&6!6-$<#!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+6!/&'$!6-$/!:$$I!Q..'!&(.;6!6-$/0$IK$0!&+'!06&::!($I<$K$!<6!$+-&+=$'!6-$<#!$+>.)/$+6!.:!R.#A!&+'!.::$#$'!$+.;Q-!:I$V<(<I<6)!6.!:&=<I<6&6$!6-$/!<+!'$I<K$#<+Q!6-$!=;##$+6!=;##<=;I;/!

!!"W53(+&$%+!*%(!&'(!$5(+!>'$!+'$?;9!'*3(!4((5!(3*;?*&75<!&'(!7:)*6&!$=!&'(!+6'$$;!(537%$5:(5&!?)$5!F(-!$?&6$:(+D!/?&!*+!*5!759?+&%-!>(!+'$?;9!'*3(!:?6'!4(&&(%!:(&'$9+!=$%!:(*+?%75<D@!

GH5J!H.+6#&=6.#!/$/($#!*;I)!7898!

!2+!6$#/0!.:!6-$!'$0<Q+!&+'!=.+06#;=6<.+!6-$#$!&#$!06&+'&#'<0$'!<+';06#)!/$&0;#$0!R-<=-!=&+!($!;0$'!6.!'$6$#/<+$!K&I;$!:.#!/.+$)!L$@Q@!H.+06#;=6<+Q!JV=$II$+=$!O"20M@!k.R$K$#1!&0!R<6-!6-$!$';=&6<.+&I!.;6=./$0!(.6-!0-.#6!6$#/!&+'!I.+Q!6$#/!.;6=./$0!+$$'!6.!($!#$=.Q+<0$'!&+'!/$&0;#$'@!3.#!$V&/%I$!&=6;&I!=.+06#;=6<.+!=.060!%$#!0c;&#$!/$6#$!&#$!$&0<I)!=.II$=6$'!&+'!6-<0!<+:.#/&6<.+!<0!-$I'!=$+6#&II)!6.!&II.R!($+=-/&#A0!6.!($!'$K$I.%$'!&6!(.6-!&!+&6<.+&I!&+'!I.=&I!I$K$I@!,-#.;Q-!6-<0!'&6&!=.II$=6<.+!R$!=&+!;+'$#06&+'!6-&6!6-$!6.6&I!=&%<6&I!=.06!%$#!0c;&#$!-&0!#$';=$'!:#./!&+!&K$#&Q$!.:!m717S8!%$#!0c/!<+!788B!%#<=$0!:.#!=./%I$6$'!a=&'$/<$0!6.!m91CD8!%$#!0c/!.:!6-$!&K$#&Q$!G53!0=-..I!()!788F@!e$6!R$!&I0.!;+'$#06&+'!6-&6!6-$#$!<0!&!'#<K$!6.!I.R$#!6-<0!=&%<6&I!=.06!



&+'!/$$6!I$K$I0!:.;+'!<+!=.;+6#<$0!0;=-!&0!2#$I&+'!R-$#$!(;<I'<+Q!=.060!&#$!&0!I.R!&0!m9888Wm9788!%$#!0c/@!!

2+!&''<6<.+!6.!6-$!0-.#6!6$#/!/$&0;#$0!0;=-!&0!=&%<6&I!=.0601![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!&+'![J"0!R$#$!%#$'<=6<+Q!</%#.K$/$+60!<+!I.+QW6$#/!.;6=./$0@!aI6-.;Q-!<+<6<&II)!R&#)!.:!%&#6+$#0-<%0!R<6-!6-$!%#<K&6$!0$=6.#1!I.=&I!&;6-.#<6<$0!R$#$!I$&#+<+Q!-.R!6.!$06&(I<0-!/;6;&II)!($+$:<=<&I!%&#6+$#0-<%0!R-<=-!R$#$!)<$I'<+Q!I.+Q!6$#/!=.06!0&K<+Q01!%&#6<=;I&#I)!&0!6-$![J"0!<+K$06$'!%#.:<6!(&=A!<+6.!6-$!%#.=$00!6.!</%#.K$!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60@![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!R$#$!&I0.!#$&I<0<+Q!6-$!($+$:<60!.:!R.#A<+Q!'<::$#$+6I)!6.!(#<+Q!&(.;6!/&V</;/!K&I;$!:.#!/.+$)!<+!6-$!I.+QW6$#/@!3.#!$V&/%I$!0/&II$#![.=&I!a;6-.#<6<$0!R$#$!>.<+<+Q!6.Q$6-$#!6.!'$I<K$#!G53!%#.Q#&//$0!6.!%#.K<'$!6-$/!Q#$&6$#!$=.+./<$0!.:!0=&I$!&6!&!06#&6$Q<=!I$K$I@!!!26!<0!=I$&#!6-&6!'$0%<6$!)$&#0!.:!06&6$!0=-..I<+Q!6-&6!6-$#$!<0!06<II!+.!+&6<.+&I!=.+0$+0;0!&(.;6!/&A$0!&!Q..'!0=-..I@!e$6!%&#&'.V<=&II)1!R$!&#$!06<II!%I&++<+Q!6.!(;<I'<+Q!0=-..I0!

6-&6!R<II!I&06!:.#!6-<0!6</$!:#&/$!&+'!($).+'@!2+!788B1!6-$!J';=&6<.+!&+'!5A<II0!5$I$=6!H.//<66$$!#$%.#6!.+!G;<I'<+Q!5=-..I0!:.#!6-$!3;6;#$!06&6$'!g6-$!=#;=<&I!c;$06<.+!-$#$1!&+'!.+$!6-&6!6-$!Q.K$#+/$+6!-&0!+.6!:;II)!&+0R$#$'1!<0!R-&6!'.!R$!R&+6!$';=&6<.+!6.!($!<+!6-$!7906!=$+6;#)b!a!=I$&#!06&6$/$+6!.:!6-$!+&6<.+&I!&/(<6<.+0!:.#!7906!=$+6;#)!$';=&6<.+!=.;I'!-$I%!6.!%#.K<'$!Q;<'&+=$!&+'!=-&II$+Q$!6.!6-$!I.=&I!'$=<0<.+W/&A<+Q!%#.=$00h@!!a!'$=$+6!0=-..I!06&+'&#'!R.;I'!#$c;<#$!;0!6.!#$&=-!&!=.+0$+0;0!&(.;6!R-&6!/&A$0!&!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+6!&+'!6.!<'$+6<:)!6-$!/.06!$::<=<$+6!R&)!.:!</%I$/$+6<+Q!6-<0!<+!%#&=6<=$@!,-$!<+K$06<Q&6<.+!<+6.!6-$!'$K$I.%/$+6!.:!&!'$=$+6!0=-..I0!06&+'&#'!0-.;I'!-&K$!&!=I$&#!'$0=#<%6<.+!&(.;6!R-&6!/&A$0!&!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+6!&+'!0-.;I'!%#.%$#I)!=.++$=6!6$&=-<+Q!&+'!I$&#+<+Q!&+'!'$0<Q+@!Z$!/;06!/.K$!&R&)!:#./!/<+</;/!

06&+'&#'0!&+'!>;06!A$$%<+Q!%$.%I$!R&#/!&+'!=./:.#6&(I$!6.!&+!$+6<6I$/$+6!:.#!$K$#)!).;+Q!%$#0.+@!!Z$!A+.R!6-&6!R$!&#$!<+!&!=I</&6$!.:!^/.#$!:.#!I$00P@!5=-..I!<+K$06/$+6!/;06!+.R!=./%$6$!R<6-!+&6<.+&I!<+K$06/$+6!<+!-.0%<6&I0!&+'!<+6$#+&6<.+&I!&<'@![.=&I!&;6-.#<6<$0!&+'!0=-..I0!(;'Q$60!&=#.00!6-$!=.;+6#)!&#$!($<+Q!0c;$$j$'!&+'!6-$!%#$00;#$!6.!'$I<K$#!($66$#!:&=<I<6<$0!R<6-.;6!&!Q#.R<+Q!(;'Q$6!0$$/0!</%.00<(I$!6.!#$=.+=<I$@!U;#!%.0<6<.+!<0!=I$&#!Y!=;6!6-$!=.0601!R&06$!&+'!(;#$&;=#&=)!Y!+.6!6-$!<+K$06/$+6@!a!#$=$+6!#$%.#6!:#./![JO!=.+0;I6<+Q!06&6$0!6-&6!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6!&''0!mD@8S!6.!4\"!:.#!$K$#)!%.;+'!<+K$06$'@!a0!R$!-&K$!%#$K<.;0I)!/$+6<.+$'1!0=-..I!<+K$06/$+6!&I0.!Q$+$#&6$0!/$&0;#&(I$!$=.+./<=!($+$:<60!I.=&II)!&+'!+&6<.+&II)@!e$6!R$!06<II!-&K$!&!0)06$/!R-$#$!0=&#=$!#$0.;#=$0!&#$!($<+Q!;0$'!<+!<+$::<=<$+6!R&)0@!

!3.#!6-$!%&06!S!)$&#0!6-$!GH5J!-&K$!=&/%&<Q+$'!6<#$I$00I)!6.!(#<+Q!&66$+6<.+!6.!6-$0$!/&66$#0!&+'!R$!-.%$!6-&6!6-$!H&%<6&I!`$K<$R!6$&/!R<II!6&A$!6-$!06$%0!#$c;<#$'!6.!/.K$!6-$!0=-..I!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$0!:.#R&#'!<+!R&)0!6-&6!I$&#+!:#./!6-$!I$00.+0!.:!6-$!%&06!98!)$&#0!&+'!6-$!%#&=6<=$!6-&6!<0!($<+Q!'$K$I.%$'!:#./!6-$!:<$I'@!GH5J!/$/($#0!R&+6!&!#$';=6<.+!.:!#$'!6&%$!&+'!Q#$&6$#!6#&+0%&#$+=)!<+!&!:;6;#$!=&%<6&I!%#.Q#&//$!&0!R$II!&0!&!j$#.!6.I$#&+=$!&%%#.&=-!6.!(;#$&;=#&=)!&+'!&+!$+=.;#&Q$/$+6!.:!=.II&(.#&6<K$!%#.=;#$/$+6!&+'!%&#6+$#0-<%@!!!!



Y@A!:)!;.((%&=!!;/2++9!,)60&+)(#)'4!F%''#& @!

5=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!'.!/&A$!&!'<::$#$+=$@!,-$!$::$=6<K$!%#.=;#$/$+61!'$I<K$#)!&+'!'$0<Q+!.:!Q..'!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!<0!$00$+6<&I!6.!$+0;#$!/&V</;/!($+$:<6!<0!Q&<+$'!:#./!&+)!=&%<6&I!<+K$06/$+6@!"#.=$00$0!6.!'$I<K$#!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!+$$'!6.!($!06#$&/I<+$'1!%.0<6<K$1!&+'!<+=.#%.#&6$!>.<+$'!;%!6-<+A<+Q!6.!$+0;#$!6-&6!0%$+'<+Q!<0!&6!6-$!:#.+6I<+$!R-$#$!<6!<0!+$$'$'!/.06@!!"#/#)'!;/2++9!;'%)-%&-4!4$66<+Q!6-$!(&0<=0!#<Q-6!<+!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!0;=-!&0!I<Q-61!&<#!c;&I<6)1!6$/%$#&6;#$1!=./:.#6!&+'!(;<I'!c;&I<6)!/&A$0!&!=I$&#!'<::$#$+=$@!,-$#$!&#$!.6-$#!:&=6.#0!R-<=-!&I0.!/&A$!&!'<::$#$+=$!<+'<#$=6I)!&+'!#$c;<#$!:;#6-$#!<+K$06<Q&6<.+!6.!$06&(I<0-!Q..'!%#&=6<=$@!Z-&6!<0!+$$'$'!6.!&=-<$K$!6-<0!<0!<+K$06<Q&6<.+!<+6.!6-$!'$K$I.%/$+6!.:!&!'$=$+6!0=-..I!06&+'&#'!I<+A$'!6.!.;6=./$0@!

!,60-#)/#Q>%4#-!"#40H)![&6$06!#$0$&#=-!<+6.!6-$!</%&=6!.:!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!0-.R!6-&6!'$=$+6!0=-..I!$+K<#.+/$+60!-&K$!&!=I$&#!</%&=6!.+!&=-<$K$/$+61!&66$+'&+=$!&+'!</%#.K$'!.;6=./$0!:.#!).;+Q!%$.%I$!&+'!06&::@!G;6!6-<0!A+.RI$'Q$!<0!+.6!0-&#$'!R<'$I)!+.#!$K<'$+=$!Q&6-$#$'!<+!&!=.+0<06$+6!R&)!6.!($!Q#.R+!<+6.!&!0.I<'!$K<'$+=$!(&0$@!,-$!R-.I$!0$=6.#!R.;I'!($+$:<6!:#./!6-<0!</%#.K$'!;+'$#06&+'<+Q@!!

capital review: british council for school environments response

Documents