caregiver stability and day care: continuity vs. daily association

1
89 CAREGIVER STABILITY AND DAY CARE: CONTINUITY VS. DAILY ASSOCIATION. E. }lark Cummings. Day care is a very complex child rearing environment. The critical factor in day care outcomes is likely to be day care quality. The present report examines caregiver stability and group size as programmatic elements of day care affecting children's socioemotional func- tioning in day care. Two aspects of caregiver stability are distinguished: Continuity and daily exposure. Children from two centers (one large and one moderate in attendance) were observed during day care separations with two caregivers, one stable and one relatively non-stable according to one of the two stability criteria. Continuity influenced re- sponding: Children were less resistant of physical contact with more continuous caregivers, were less likely to leave the caregiver and seek proximity with the mother, and showed less negative and more positive affect following separation. In contrast, comparisons in terms of daily association yielded no significant effects. Children in the smaller center showed more positive affect prior to separa- tion, less avoidance during entry, and searched less for the mother. In addition, continuity seemed to be less important in the smaller center. These results add to a growing literature that suggests that continuity is of considerable significance to infant-adult relations, and also to evidence that infants function better in smaller groups.

Upload: e-mark-cummings

Post on 15-Sep-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Caregiver stability and day care: Continuity vs. daily association

89

CAREGIVER STABILITY AND DAY CARE: CONTINUITY VS.DAILY ASSOCIATION. E. }lark Cummings. Day care is avery complex child rearing environment. The criticalfactor in day care outcomes is likely to be day carequality. The present report examines caregiverstability and group size as programmatic elements ofday care affecting children's socioemotional func­tioning in day care. Two aspects of caregiverstability are distinguished: Continuity and dailyexposure. Children from two centers (one large andone moderate in attendance) were observed during daycare separations with two caregivers, one stable andone relatively non-stable according to one of thetwo stability criteria. Continuity influenced re­sponding: Children were less resistant of physicalcontact with more continuous caregivers, were lesslikely to leave the caregiver and seek proximitywith the mother, and showed less negative and morepositive affect following separation. In contrast,comparisons in terms of daily association yieldedno significant effects. Children in the smallercenter showed more positive affect prior to separa­tion, less avoidance during entry, and searched lessfor the mother. In addition, continuity seemed tobe less important in the smaller center. Theseresults add to a growing literature that suggeststhat continuity is of considerable significance toinfant-adult relations, and also to evidence thatinfants function better in smaller groups.