case hardening report
TRANSCRIPT
Case Hardening Report
Prepared by: Eng. Marwa Alsayed Ali
Presented to: Prof. Dr. Mamdouh
2012
Metallurgy Department – Cairo University
1
Contents Page no.
1. Introduction……………………………... 2
2. History…………………………………... 3
3. Chemistry……………………………….. 4
4. Modern use……………………………… 5
5. Processes…………………………………6
5.1 Carburizing………………………….6
5.2 Nitriding…………………………… 12
5.3 Cyaniding ―Liquid Carbonitriding‖…………19
5.4 Carbonitriding………………………22
5.5 Ferritic nitrocarburizing…………….24
5.6 Flame and induction hardening……..27
6. Applications…………………………….. 31
7. References……………………………… 32
2
Introduction
Case hardening (or) Surface hardening:-
Case hardening (or) Surface hardening is a
process of heating the metal over its surface so
as to harden it. This process is adopted, as
many of the applications like gears, cams, and
crankshafts desire high hardness on the outer
surface and softer core, which is tough enough
to withstand the shocks. So to attain such
properties it is very difficult to employ low
carbon steels or high carbon steels as low carbon steels cannot be hardened where
as high carbon steels have poor toughness.
So for obtaining the required properties in general medium carbon steels are
used. These steels have intermediate properties of both the above-mentioned
steels. So the hardness of these materials over the surface is increased by any of
the following ways
1) So as to increase the surface of hardness of the material it is subjected to
heating so as to reduce the carbon in free form and helps in forming of cementite.
2) Nitriding is done so as to form nitrides which are very strong in nature
3) Hardening with out change of composition can also be done by some surface
hardening processes like flame hardening, electric arc hardening etc.
4) Steels can also harden by sending both nitrogen and carbon at a time along
with heating.
Surface hardening is done in many methods if the composition of the surface is
changed then the hardening is called as case hardening and if there is no change
in surface composition then the hardening technique is called surface hardening.
3
History
Early iron melting made use of bloomeries,
which produced two layers of metal: one
with a very low carbon content that is
worked into wrought iron, and the rest a high
carbon cast iron. Since the high carbon iron
is hot short, meaning it fractures and
crumbles when forged, it was not useful
without more smelting. The wrought iron,
with nearly no carbon in it, was
very malleable and ductile, but not very
hard.
Case hardening involves packing the low-carbon iron within a substance high in
carbon, then heating this pack to encourage carbon migration into the surface of
the iron. This forms a thin surface layer of higher carbon steel, with the carbon
content gradually decreasing deeper from the surface. The resulting product
combines much of the toughness of a low-carbon steel core, with the hardness
and wear resistance of the outer high-carbon steel.
The traditional method of applying the carbon to the surface of the iron involved
packing the iron in a mixture of ground bone and charcoal, or a combination
of leather, hooves, saltand urine, all inside a well-sealed box. This carburizing
package is then heated to a high temperature, but still under the melting point of
the iron, and left at that temperature for a length of time. The longer the package
is held at the high temperature, the deeper the carbon will diffuse into the surface.
Different depths of hardening is desirable for different purposes: sharp tools need
deep hardening to allow grinding and resharpening without exposing the soft
core, while machine parts like gears might need only shallow hardening for
increased wear resistance.
The resulting case hardened part may show distinct surface discoloration. The
steel darkens significantly, and shows a mottled pattern of black, blue and purple,
caused by the various compounds formed from impurities in the bone and
charcoal. This oxide surface works similarly to bluing, providing a degree of
corrosion resistance, as well as an attractive finish. Case coloring refers to this
4
pattern and is commonly encountered as a decorative finish
on replica historic firearms.
With modern steelworking techniques, it is possible to make homogeneous steels
of low to high carbon content, removing much of the original motivation for case
hardening. However, the heterogeneous nature of case hardened steel may still be
desirable, as it can combine both extreme hardness and extreme toughness,
something which is not readily matched by homogeneous alloys.
Chemistry
Carbon itself is solid at case-hardening
temperatures and so is immobile. Transport to
the surface of the steel was as gaseous carbon
monoxide, generated by the breakdown of the
carburising compound and the oxygen packed
into the sealed box. This takes place with pure
carbon, but unworkably slowly. Although
oxygen is required for this process it's re-
circulated through the CO cycle and so can be
carried out inside a sealed box. The sealing is necessary to stop the CO either
leaking out, or being oxidised to CO2 by excess outside air.
Adding an easily decomposed carbonate "energiser" such as barium
carbonate breaks down to BaO + CO2 and this encourages the reaction
C (from the donor) + CO2 <—> 2 CO
increasing the overall abundance of CO and the activity of the carburising
compound. Its 'common knowledge' that case-hardening was done with bone, but
this is misleading. Although bone was used, the main carbon donor was hoof and
horn. Bone contains some carbonates, but is mainly calcium phosphate
(as hydroxylapatite). This doesn't have the beneficial effect on encouraging CO
production and it can also supply phosphorus as an impurity into the steel alloy.
5
Modern Use
Both carbon and alloy steels are suitable for case-hardening; typically mild steels
are used, with low carbon content, usually less than 0.3% (see plain-carbon
steel for more information). These mild steels are not normally hardenable due to
the low quantity of carbon, so the surface of the steel is chemically altered to
increase the hardenability. Case hardened steel is formed by diffusing carbon
(carburization), nitrogen (nitriding) and/or boron (boriding) into the outer layer of
the steel at high temperature, and then heat treating the surface layer to the
desired hardness.
The term case hardening is derived from the practicalities of the carburization
process itself, which is essentially the same as the ancient process. The steel work
piece is placed inside a case packed tight with a carbon-based case hardening
compound. This is collectively known as a carburizing pack. The pack is put
inside a hot furnace for a variable length of time. Time and temperature
determines how deep into the surface the hardening extends. However, the depth
of hardening is ultimately limited by the inability of carbon to diffuse deeply into
solid steel, and a typical depth of surface hardening with this method is up to
1.5 mm. Other techniques are also used in modern carburizing, such as heating in
a carbon-rich atmosphere. Small items may be case hardened by repeated heating
with a torch and quenching in a carbon rich medium, such as the commercial
products Kasenit /Casenite or "Cherry Red". Older formulations of these
compounds contain potentially toxic cyanide compounds, such
as ferrocyanide compounds, while the more recent types
6
Processes
The following are the processes in case hardening
1. Carburizing
2. Nitriding
3. Cyano Nitriding
4. Carbo Nitriding
The following are the processes in surface hardening
5. Flame hardening
6. Induction hardening
Carburizing
is a process of adding Carbon to the surface. This is done by exposing the part to
a Carbon rich atmosphere at an elevated temperature and allows diffusion to
transfer the Carbon atoms into steel. This diffusion will work only if the steel has
low carbon content, because diffusion works on the differential of concentration
principle. If, for example the steel had high carbon content to begin with, and is
heated in a carbon free furnace, such as air, the carbon will tend to diffuse out of
the steel resulting in Decarburization.
7
To summarize, carburizing
methods include :
1. Gas carburizing
2. Vacuum carburizing
3. Plasma carburizing
4. Salt bath carburizing
5. Pack carburizing
These methods introduce carbon by the use of gas (atmospheric-gas, plasma, and
vacuum carburizing), liquids (salt bath carburizing), or solid compounds (pack
carburizing). All of these methods have limitations and advantages, but gas
carburizing is used most often for large-scale production because it can be
accurately controlled and involves a minimum of special handling.
8
Vacuum carbunzing and plasma carburizing have found applications because of
the absence of oxygen in the furnace atmosphere. Salt bath and pack carburizing
arc still done occasionally, but have little commercial importance today.
Carburizing is the addition of carbon to the surface of low-carbon steels at
temperatures generally between 850 and 950°C (1560 and 1740°F), at which
austenite, with its high solubility for carbon, is the stable crystal structure.
Hardening is accomplished when the high-carbon surface layer is quenched to
form martensite so that a high-carbon martensitic case with good wear and
fatigue resistance is superimposed on a tough, low-carbon steel core.
The Carbon content in the steel determines whether it can be directly hardened. If
the Carbon content is low (less than 0.25% for example) then an alternate means
exists to increase the Carbon content of the surface. Depending on the amount of
time and temperature, the affected area can vary in carbon content. Longer
carburizing times and higher temperatures lead to greater carbon diffusion into
the part as well as increased depth of carbon diffusion.
When the iron or steel is cooled rapidly by quenching, the higher carbon content
on the outer surface becomes hard via the transformation from austenite to
martensite, while the core remains soft and tough as a ferritic and/or pearlite
microstructure.This manufacturing process can be characterized by the following
key points: It is applied to low-carbon workpieces; workpieces are in contact with
a high-carbon gas, liquid or solid, it produces a hard workpiece surface;
workpiece cores largely retain their toughness and ductility and it produces case
hardness depths of up to 0.25 inches (6.4 mm).
9
Carburization of steel involves a heat treatment of the metallic surface using a
source of carbon.
Early carburization used a direct application of charcoal packed onto the metal
(initially referred to as case hardening), but modern techniques apply carbon-
bearing gases or plasmas (such as carbon dioxide or methane)
. Carburizing is the addition of carbon to the surface of low-carbon steels at
temperatures generally between 850 and 950°C (1560 and 1740°F), at which
austenite, with its high solubility for carbon, is the stable crystal structure.
Hardening is accomplished when the high-carbon surface layer is quenched to
form martensite so that a high-carbon martensitic case with good wear and
fatigue resistance is superimposed on a tough, low-carbon steel core.
In its earliest application, parts were simply placed in a suitable container and
covered with a thick layer of carbon powder (pack carburizing). In gas
carburizing, the parts are surrounded by a carbon-bearing atmosphere that can be
continuously replenished so that a high carbon potential can be maintained. In
efforts required to simplify the atmosphere, carburizing in an oxygen-free
environment at very low pressure (vacuum carburizing) has been explored and
developed into a viable and important alternative.
Furthermore, because the parts are
heated in an oxygen-free environment,
the carburizing temperature may be
increased substantially without the
risk of surface or grain-boundary
oxidation. Because vacuum
carburizing is conducted at very low
pressures, and the rate of flow of the
carburizing gas into the furnace is
very low, the carbon potential of the
gas in deep recesses and blind holes is
quickly depleted. Unless this gas is
replenished, a great nonuniformity in
case depth over the surface of the part
is likely to occur. If, in an effort to
overcome this problem, the gas pressure is increased significantly, another
problem arises, that of free-carbon formation, or sooting.
Case hardness of carburized steels is primarily a function of carbon content.
When the carbon content of the steel exceeds about 0.50% additional carbon has
no effect on hardness but does enhance hardenability. Carbon in excess of 0.50%
11
may not be dissolved, which would thus require temperatures high enough to
ensure carbon-austenite solid solution.
Case depth of carburized steel is
a function of carburizing time
and the available carbon
potential at the surface. When
prolonged carburizing times are
used for deep case depths, a high
carbon potential produces a high
surface-carbon content, which
may thus result in excessive
retained austenite or free
carbides. Consequently, a high
carbon potential may be suitable
for short carburizing times but
not for prolonged carburizing.
Gas carburizing is normally carried out at a temperature within the range of 900
to 950 °C. In oxy-acetylene welding, a carburizing flame is one with little
oxygen, which produces a sooty, lower-temperature flame. Carburizing steels for
case hardening usually have base-carbon contents of about 0.2%, with the carbon
content of the carburized layer generally being controlled at between 0.8 and 1%
C. However, surface carbon is often limited to 0.9% because too high a carbon
content can result in retained austenite and brittle martensite.
Pack carburizing containers are usually made of carbon steel coated with
aluminum or heat-resisting nickle-chromium alloy and sealed at all openings with
fire clay. There are different types of elements or materials that can be used to
perform this process, but these mainly consist of high carbon content material.
11
A few typical hardening agents include carbon monoxide gas (CO), sodium
cyanide and barium chloride, or hardwood charcoal. In gas carburizing, the CO is
given off by propane or natural gas. In pack carburizing, carbon monoxide is
given off by coke or hardwood charcoal.
Plasma carburization is increasingly used in major industrial regimes to improve
the surface characteristics (such as wear and corrosion resistance, hardness and
load-bearing capacity, in addition to quality-based variables) of various metals,
notably stainless steels. The process is used as it is environmentally friendly (in
comparison to gaseous or solid carburizing). It also provides an even treatment of
components with complex geometry (the plasma can penetrate into holes and
tight gaps), making it very flexible in terms of component treatment.
Steels made to coarse grain practices can be carburized if a double quench
provides grain refinement. Many alloy steels for case hardening are now
specified on the basis of core hardenability. First, in a case-hardened steel, the
hardenability of both case and core must be considered.
The relationship between the thermal gradient and the carbon gradient during
quenching of a carburized part can make a measurable difference in the case
depth as measured by hardness. That is, an increase in base hardenability can
produce a higher proportion of martensite for a given carbon level, yielding an
increased measured case depth. Therefore, a shallower carbon profile and shorter
carburizing time could be used to attain the desired result in a properly chosen
steel.
12
Nitriding
THE NITRIDING PROCESS: is a heat treating process that diffuses nitrogen
into the surface of a metal to create a case hardened surface. It is predominantly
used on steel, but also titanium, aluminum and molybdenum. In this process the
steel material is heated to a temperature of around 5500C and then exposed to
atomic nitrogen. This atomic nitrogen reacts with iron and other alloying
elements and forms nitrides, which are very hard in nature. By this process both
wear resistance and hardness of the product can be increased. Atomic nitrogen
only has the property to penetrate in the steel but where as molecular nitrogen
lacks in that property. So molecular nitrogen is never used as a nitriding medium
while hardening of steels. The atomic nitrogen required for this process is
generated by the decomposition of salt bath like NaCN.
first developed in the early 1900s, continues to play an important role in many
industrial applications. Along with the derivative nitrocarburizing process,
nitriding often is used in the manufacture of aircraft, bearings, automotive
components, textile machinery, and turbine generation systems. Though wrapped
in a bit of ―alchemical mystery,‖ it remains the simplest of the case hardening
techniques.The secret of the nitriding process is that it does not require a phase
change from ferrite to austenite, nor does it require a further change from
austenite to martensite. In other words, the steel remains in the ferrite phase (or
cementite, depending on alloy composition) during the complete procedure.
13
This means that the molecular structure of the ferrite (body-centered cubic, or
bcc, lattice) does not change its configuration or grow into the face-centered
cubic (fcc) lattice characteristic of austenite, as occurs in
more conventional methods such as carburizing. Furthermore, because only free
cooling takes place, rather than rapid cooling or quenching, no subsequent
transformation from austenite to martensite occurs. Again, there is no molecular
size change and, more importantly, no dimensional change, only slight growth
due to the volumetric change of the steel surface
caused by the nitrogen diffusion. What can (and does) produce distortion are the
induced surface stresses being released by the heat of the process, causing
movement in the form of twisting and bending.
The processes are named after the medium used to donate. The three main
methods used are: gas nitriding, salt bath nitriding, and plasma nitriding.
14
Gas nitriding
In gas nitriding the donor is a nitrogen rich gas, usually ammonia (NH3), which is
why it is sometimes known as ammonia nitriding. When ammonia comes into
contact with the heated work piece it disassociates into nitrogen and hydrogen.
The nitrogen then diffuses onto the surface of the material creating a nitride layer.
This process has existed for nearly a century, though only in the last few decades
has there been a concentrated effort to investigate the thermodynamics and
kinetics involved. Recent developments have led to a process that can be
accurately controlled. The thickness and phase constitution of the resulting
nitriding layers can be selected and the process optimized for the particular
properties required.
The advantages of gas nitriding over the other variants are:
Precise control of chemical potential of nitrogen in the nitriding
atmosphere by controling gas flow rate of nitrogen and oxygen.
All round nitriding effect (can be a disadvantage in some cases,
compared with plasma nitriding)
Large batch sizes possible - the limiting factor being furnace size
and gas flow
With modern computer control of the atmosphere the nitriding
results can be closely controlled
Relatively low equipment cost - especially compared with plasma
The disadvantages of gas nitriding are:
Reaction kinetics heavily influenced by surface condition - an oily
surface or one contaminated with cutting fluids will deliver poor
results
Surface activation is sometimes required to treat steels with a high
chromium content - compare sputtering during plasma nitriding
15
Ammonia as nitriding medium - though not especially toxic it can be
harmful when inhaled in large quantities. Also, care must be taken
when heating in the presence of oxygen to reduce the risk of
explosion.
Salt bath nitriding
In salt bath nitriding the nitrogen
donating medium is a nitrogen-
containing salt such as cyanide salt. The
salts used also donate carbon to the
workpiece surface making salt bath a
nitrocarburizing process. The
temperature used is typical of all
nitrocarburizing processes: 550–590 °C
(1022–1094 °F).
The advantages of salt nitriding are:
Quick processing time - usually in the order of 4 hours or so to
achieve
Simple operation - heat the salt and workpieces to temperature and
submerge until the duration has transpired
The disadvantages are:
The salts used are highly toxic - Disposal of salts are controlled by
stringent environmental laws in western countries and has increased
the costs involved in using salt baths. This is one of the most
significant reasons the process has fallen out of favor in recent
decades.
Only one process possible with a particular salt type - since the
nitrogen potential is set by the salt, only one type of process is
possible
16
Plasma nitriding
Plasma nitriding, also known as ion nitriding, plasma ion nitriding or glow-
discharge nitriding, is an industrial surface hardening treatment for metallic
materials.
In plasma nitriding, the reactivity of the nitriding media is not due to the
temperature but to the gas ionized state. In this technique intense electric fields
are used to generate ionized molecules of the gas around the surface to be
nitrided. Such highly active gas with ionized molecules is called plasma, naming
the technique. The gas used for plasma nitriding is usually pure nitrogen, since no
spontaneous decomposition is needed (as is the case of gas nitriding with
ammonia). There are hot plasmas typified by plasma jets used for metal cutting,
welding, cladding or spraying. There are also cold plasmas, usually generated
inside vacuum chambers, at low pressure regimes.
Usually steels are very beneficially treated with plasma nitriding. Plasma
nitriding advantage is related to the close control of the nitrided microstructure,
allowing nitriding with or without compound layer formation.
17
Not
only
the
performance of metal parts gets enhanced but working lifespan gets boosted. So
does the strain limit, and the fatigue strength of the metals being treated. For
instance, mechanical properties of austenitic stainless steel like wear can be
significantly reduced and the hardness of tool steels can be double on the surface.
A plasma nitrided part is usually ready for use. It calls for no machining, or
polishing or any other post-nitriding operations. Thus the process is user-friendly,
saves energy since it works fastest, and causes little or no distortion.
This process was invented by Dr. Bernhardt Berghaus of Germany who later
settled in Zurich to escape Nazi persecution. After his death in late 1960s the
process was acquired by Klockner group and popularized world over.
Plasma nitriding is often coupled with physical vapor deposition (PVD) process
and labeled Duplex Treatment, with enhanced benefits. Many users prefer to
have a plasma oxidation step combined at the last phase of processing to produce
a smooth jetblack layer of oxides which is resistant to wear and corrosion.
Since nitrogen ions are made available by ionization, differently from gas or salt
bath, plasma nitriding efficiency does not depend on the temperature. Plasma
nitriding can thus be performed in a broad temperature range, from 260°C to
more than 600°C. For instance, at moderate temperatures (like 420°C), stainless
steels can be nitrided without the formation of chromium nitride precipitates and
hence maintaining their corrosion resistance properties.
In plasma nitriding processes nitrogen gas (N2) is usually the nitrogen carrying
gas. Other gasses like hydrogen or Argon are also used. Indeed, Argon and H2
can be used before the nitriding process during the heating of the parts to clean
the surfaces to be nitrided. This cleaning procedure effectively removes the oxide
18
layer from surfaces and may remove fine layers of solvents that could remain.
This also helps the thermal stability of the plasma plant, since the heat added by
the plasma is already present during the warm up and hence once the process
temperature is reached the actual nitriding begins with minor heating changes.
For the nitriding process H2 gas is also added to keep the surface clear of oxides.
This effect can be observed by analysing the surface of the part under nitriding .
Examples of easily nitridable steels include the SAE 4100, 4300, 5100, 6100,
8600, 8700, 9300 and 9800 series, UK aircraft quality steel grades BS 4S 106, BS
3S 132, 905M39 (EN41B), stainless steels, some tool steels (H13 and P20 for
example) and certain cast irons.
19
Cyaniding
Cyaniding, or salt-bath carbonitriding, is a
heat-treating process that produces a file-
hard, wear-resistant surface on ferrous parts.
When steel is heated above Ac1 in a suitable
bath containing alkali cyanides and
cyanates, the surface of the steel absorbs
both carbon and nitrogen from the molten
bath. When quenched in mineral oil,
paraffin-base oil, water, or brine, the steel
develops a hard surface layer, or case, that contains less carbon and more
nitrogen than the case developed in activated liquid carburizing baths.
Because of greater efficiency and lower cost, sodium cyanide is used instead of
the more expensive potassium cyanide. The active hardening agents of cyaniding
baths--carbon monoxide and nitrogen--are not produced directly from sodium
cyanide.
Molten cyanide decomposes in the presence of air at the surface of the bath to
produce sodium cyanate, which in turn decomposes in accordance with the
following chemical reactions:
2NaCN + O2 2NaNCO
4NaNCO Na2CO3 + 2NaCN + CO + 2N
2CO CO2 + C
NaCN + CO2 NaNCO + CO
The rate at which cyanate is formed and decomposes, liberating carbon and
nitrogen at the surface of the steel, determines the carbonitriding activity of the
bath. At operating temperatures, the higher the concentration of cyanate, the
faster the rate of its decomposition.
Because the rate of cyanate decomposition also increases with temperature, bath
activity is greater at higher operating temperatures. A fresh cyaniding bath must
be aged for about 12 h at a temperature above its melting point to provide a
21
sufficient concentration of cyanate for efficient carbonitriding activity. For the
aging cycle to be effective, any carbon scum formed on the surface must be
removed. To eliminate scum, the cyanide content of the bath must be reduced to
the 25 to 30% range by addition of inert salts (sodium chloride and sodium
carbonate).
At the bath aging temperature--usually about 700 °C (1290 °F)--the rate of its
decomposition is low.
Bath Composition. A sodium cyanide mixture such as grade 30 in Table 3,
containing 30% NaCN, 40% Na2CO3, and 30% NaCl, is generally used for
cyaniding on a production basis. This mixture is preferable to any of the other
compositions given in the next table.
(a) Appearance: white crystalline solid. This grade also contains 0.5% sodium cyanate (NaNCO) and 0.2% sodium hydroxide
(NaOH); sodium sulfide (Na2S) content, nil.
(b) Appearance: white granular mixture.
The inert salts sodium chloride and sodium carbonate are added to cyanide to
provide fluidity and to control the melting points of all mixtures. The 30% NaCN
mixture, as well as the mixtures containing 45, 75, and 97% NaCN, may be
added to the operating bath to maintain a desired cyanide concentration for a
specific application.
Mixture grade
designation
Composition, wt% Melting point Specific gravity
NaC
N
NaCO3 NaCl °C °F 25 °C
(75
°F)
861 °C
(1580
°F)
96-98(a) 97 2.3 Trac
e
560 1040 1.50 1.10
75(b) 75 3.5 21.5 590 1095 1.60 1.25
45(b) 45.3 37.0 17.7 570 1060 1.80 1.40
30(b) 30.0 40.0 30.0 625 1155 2.09 1.54
Mixture grade
designation
Composition, wt% Melting point Specific gravity
NaC
N
NaCO3 NaCl °C °F 25 °C
(75
°F)
861 °C
(1580
°F)
96-98(a) 97 2.3 Trac
e
560 1040 1.50 1.10
75(b) 75 3.5 21.5 590 1095 1.60 1.25
45(b) 45.3 37.0 17.7 570 1060 1.80 1.40
30(b) 30.0 40.0 30.0 625 1155 2.09 1.54
Mixture grade
designation
Composition, wt% Melting point Specific gravity
NaC
N
NaCO3 NaCl °C °F 25 °C
(75
°F)
861 °C
(1580
°F)
96-98(a) 97 2.3 Trac560 1040 1.50 1.10
21
The carbon content of the case developed in cyanide baths increases with an
increase in the cyanide concentration of the bath, thus providing considerable
versatility. A bath operating at 815 to 850 °C (1500 to 1560 °F) and containing 2
to 4% cyanide may be used to restore carbon to decarburized steels with a core
carbon content of 0.30 to 0.40% C, while a 30% cyanide bath at the same
temperature will yield a 0.13 mm (0.005 in.) case containing 0.65% C at the
surface in 45 min.
22
Carbonitriding
Carbonitriding is a metallurgical surface modification technique that is used to
increase the surface hardness of a metal, thereby reducing wear. During the
process, atoms of carbon and nitrogen diffuse interstitially into the metal,
creating barriers to slip, increasing the hardness and modulus near the surface.
Carbonitriding is often applied to inexpensive, easily machined low carbon steel
to impart the surface properties of more expensive and difficult to work grades of
steel. Surface hardness of carbonitrided parts ranges from 55 to 62 HRC.
Certain pre-industrial case hardening processes include not only carbon-rich
materials such as charcoal, but nitrogen-rich materials such as urea, which
implies that traditional surface hardening techniques were a form of
carbonitriding.
Process
Carbonitriding is similar to gas carburization with the addition of ammonia to the
carburizing atmosphere, which provides a source of nitrogen. Nitrogen is
adsorbed at the surface and diffuses into the work piece along with carbon.
Carbonitriding (around 850 °C / 1550 °F) is carried out at temperatures
substantially higher than plain Nitriding (around 530 °C / 990 °F) but slightly
lower than those used for carburizing (around 950 °C / 1700 °F) and for shorter
times. Carbonitriding tends to be more economical than carburizing, and also
reduces distortion during quenching. The lower temperature allows oil
quenching, or even gas quenching with a protective atmosphere.
Characteristics of carbonitrided parts
Carbonitriding forms a hard, wear-resistant case, is typically 0.07mm to 0.5mm
thick, and generally has higher hardness than a carburized case. Case depth is
tailored to the application; a thicker case increases the wear life of the part.
Carbonitriding alters only the top layers of the work piece; and does not deposit
an additional layer, so the process does not significantly alter the dimensions of
the part.
Maximum case depth is typically restricted to 0.75mm; case depths greater than
this take too long to diffuse to be economical. Shorter processing times are
preferred to restrict the concentration of nitrogen in the case, as nitrogen addition
is more difficult to control than carbon. An excess of nitrogen in the work piece
can cause high levels of retained austenite and porosity, which are undesirable in
producing a part of high hardness.
23
Advantages
Carbonitriding also has other advantages over carburizing. To begin, it has a
greater resistance to softening during tempering and increased fatigue and impact
strength. It is possible to use both carbonitriding and carburizing together to form
optimum conditions of deeper case depths and therefore performance of the part
in industry. This method is applied particularly to steels with low case
hardenability, such as the seat of the valve. The process applied is initially
carburizing to the required case depth (up to 2.5mm) at around 900-955°C, and
then carbonitriding to achieve required carbonitrided case depth. The parts are
then oil quenched, and the resulting part has a harder case than possibly achieved
for carburization, and the addition of the carbonitrided layer increases
the residual compressive stresses in the case such that the contact fatigue
resistance and strength gradient are both increased.
24
Ferritic nitrocarburizing
Ferritic nitrocarburizing is a range of case hardening processes
that diffuse nitrogen and carbon into ferrous metals at sub-critical temperatures.
The processing temperature ranges from 525 °C (977 °F) to 625 °C (1,157 °F),
but usually occurs at 565 °C (1,049 °F). At this temperature steels and other
ferrous alloys are still in a ferritic phase, which is advantageous compared to
other case hardening processes that occur in the austenitic phase. There are four
main classes of ferritic nitrocarburizing: gaseous, salt bath, ion or plasma,
and fluidized-bed.
The process is used to improve three main surface integrity aspects:
scuffing resistance
fatigue properties
corrosion resistance
It has the added advantage of inducing little shape distortion during the hardening
process. This is because of the low processing temperature, which reduces
thermal shocks and avoids phase transitions in steel.
History
The first ferritic nitrocarburizing methods were done at low temperatures, around
550 °C (1,022 °F), in a liquid salt bath. The first company to successfully
commercialize was the Imperial Chemical Industries in England. They called
their process a "Sulfinuz" treatment because it had sulfur in the salt bath. While
the process was very successful with high-speed spindles and cutting tools, there
were issues with cleaning the solution off because it was not very water soluble.
Because of the cleaning issues the Joseph Lucas Limited company began
experimenting with gaseous forms of ferritic nitrocarburizing in the late 1950s.
The company applied for a patent by 1961. It produced a similar surface finish as
the Sulfinuz process with the exception of the formation of sulfides. The
atmosphere consisted of ammonia, hydrocarbon gases, and a small amount of
other carbon-containing gases.
This spurred the development of a more environmentally friendly salt bath
process by the German company Degussa. Their process is the widely known
Tufftride process. Following this the ion nitriding process was invented in the
early 1980s. This process had faster cycle times, required less cleaning and
preparation, formed deeper cases, and allowed for better control of the process.
25
Processes
Despite the naming the process is a modified form of nitriding and not
carburizing. The shared attributes of this class of this process is the introduction
of nitrogen and carbon in the ferritic state of the material. The processes are
broken up into four main classes: gaseous, salt bath, ion or plasma, or fluidized-
bed. The trade name and patented processes may vary slightly from the general
description, but they are all a form of ferritic nitrocarburizing.
Salt bath ferritic nitrocarburizing
Salt bath ferritic nitrocarburizing is also known as liquid ferritic nitrocarburizing
or liquid nitrocarburizing and is also known by the trademarked names Tufftride
and Tenifer.
The simplest form of this process is encompassed by the trademarked Melonite
process, also known as Meli 1. It is most commonly used on steels, sintered irons,
and cast irons to lower friction and improve wear and corrosion resistance.
The process uses a salt bath of alkali cyanate. This is contained in a steel pot that
has an aeration system. The cyanate thermally reacts with the surface of the
workpiece to form alkali carbonate. The bath is then treated to convert the
carbonate back to a cyanate. The surface formed from the reaction has a
compound layer and a diffusion layer. The compound layer consists of iron,
nitrogen, and oxygen, is abrasion resistant, and stable at elevated temperatures.
The diffusion layer contains nitrides and carbides. The surface hardness ranges
from 800 to 1500 HV depending on the steel grade. This also inversely affects
the depth of the case; i.e. a high carbon steel will form a hard, but shallow case.
A similar process is the trademarked Nu-Tride process, also known incorrectly as
the Kolene process (which is actually the company's name), which includes a
preheat and an intermediate quench cycle. The intermediate quench is an
oxidizing salt bath at 400 °C (752 °F). This quench is held for 5 to 20 minutes
before final quenching to room temperature. This is done to minimize distortion
and to destroy any lingering cyanates or cyanides left on the workpiece.
Other trademarked processes are Sursulf and Tenoplus. Sursulf has a sulfur
compound in the salt bath to create surface sulfides which creates porosity in the
workpiece surface. This porosity is used to contain lubrication. Tenoplus is a
two-stage high-temperature process. The first stage occurs at 625 °C (1,157 °F),
while the second stage occurs at 580 °C (1,076 °F).
Gaseous ferritic nitrocarburizing
26
Gaseous ferritic nitrocarburizing is also known as controlled nitrocarburizing,
soft nitriding, and vacuum nitrocarburizing or by the tradenames Nitrotec,
Nitemper, Deganit, Triniding, Corr-I-Dur, Nitroc, and Nitrowear. The process
works to achieve the same result as the salt bath process, except gaseous mixtures
are used to diffuse the nitrogen and carbon into the workpiece.
The parts are first cleaned, usually with a vapor degreasing process, and then
nitrocarburized around 570 °C (1,058 °F), with a process time that ranges from
one to four hours. The actual gas mixtures are proprietary, but they usually
contain ammonia and an endothermic gas.
Plasma-assisted ferritic nitrocarburizing
Plasma-assisted ferritic nitrocarburizing is also known as ion nitriding, plasma
ion nitriding or glow-discharge nitriding. The process works to achieve the same
result as the salt bath and gaseous process, except the reactivity of the media is
not due to the temperature but to the gas ionized state. In this technique intense
electric fields are used to generate ionized molecules of the gas around the
surface to diffuse the nitrogen and carbon into the workpiece. Such highly active
gas with ionized molecules is called plasma, naming the technique. The gas used
for plasma nitriding is usually pure nitrogen, since no spontaneous decomposition
is needed (as is the case of gaseous ferritic nitrocarburizing with ammonia). Due
to the relatively low temperature range (420 °C (788 °F) to 580 °C (1,076 °F))
generally applied during plasma-assisted ferritic nitrocarburizing and gentle
cooling in the furnace, the distortion of workpieces can be minimized. Stainless
steel workpieces can be processed at moderate temperatures (like 420 °C (788
°F)) without the formation of chromium nitride precipitates and hence
maintaining their corrosion resistance properties.
27
Flame and induction Hardening
FLAME HARDENING is a heat-treating
process in which a thin surface shell of a
steel part is heated rapidly to a temperature
above the critical point of the steel. After the
grain structure of the shell has become
austenitic (austenitized), the part is quickly
quenched, transforming the austenite to
martensite while leaving the core of the part
in its original state. In contrast, slow cooling
causes transformation, as the temperature
passes through the corresponding ranges, to
pearlite, bainite, and martensite, with the
final structure being a combination of the three. The result is relatively soft and
ductile steel. To achieve hardness, therefore, the steel must be cooled rapidly so
that it bypasses the first two transformation phases and transforms directly from
austenite to martensite.
Flame hardening employs direct impingement of a high-temperature flame or
high-velocity combustion product gases.
The part is then cooled at a rate that will produce the desired levels of hardness
and other properties. The high temperature flame is obtained by combustion of a
mixture of fuel gas with oxygen or air; flame heads are used for burning the
mixture. Depths of hardening from about 0.8 to 6.4 mm ( 1/32 to ¼ in.) or more
can be obtained, depending on the fuels used, the design of the flame head, the
duration of heating, the hardenability of the work material, and the quenching
medium and method of quenching used. The process can be used for the through
hardening of work 75 mm (3 in.) or less in cross section, depending on the
hardenability of the steel.
Hardening by flame differs from true case hardening because the hardenability
necessary to attain high levels of hardness is already contained in the steel, and
hardening is obtained by localized heating. Although flame hardening is mainly
used to develop high levels of hardness for wear resistance, the process also
improves bending and torsional strength and fatigue life. One of the major
advantages of flame hardening is the ability to satisfy stringent engineering
requirements with carbon steels.
28
Methods of Flame Hardening
The versatility of flame-hardening equipment and the wide range of heating
conditions obtainable with gas burners often permit flame hardening to be done
by a variety of methods, of which the principal ones are:
· Spot, or stationary
· Progressive
· Spinning
· Combination progressive-spinning
The selection of the appropriate method depends on the shape, size, and
composition of the workpiece; the area to be hardened; the depth of case
required; and the number of pieces to be hardened. In many instances, more than
one method will provide the desired result; the choice will then depend on
comparative costs.
The spot (stationary) method, shown in Fig. 1(a), consists of locally heating
selected areas with a suitable flame head and subsequently quenching. The
heating head may be of either single-orifice or multiple-orifice design, depending
on the extent of the area to be hardened. The heat input must be balanced to
obtain a uniform temperature over the entire selected area. After being heated, the
parts are usually immersion quenched; however, in some mechanized operations,
a spray quench may be used.
29
Fuel Gases
Several different fuel gases are used in flame hardening. In selecting a fuel gas
for a given application, the required rate of heating and the cost of the gas must
be considered, along with the initial cost of equipment and maintenance costs.
Flame hardening does not alter the composition of the base metal if done
properly. Carburizing, neutral, and oxidizing flames can be used. Oxidizing
flames have high oxygen ratios and can be detrimental because they produce
extremely hot temperatures that can cause decarburization and overheating. A
carburizing flame can prevent some decarburization but can also introduce
unwanted carbon into the surface. For best results, neutral or slightly carburizing
flames should be used.
A comparison of the heating rates of fuel gases can be made when certain
fundamental properties of usable mixtures with oxygen are known. A parameter
that correlates well with actual heating speed is combustion intensity, or specific
flame output. This is the product of the normal velocity of burning multiplied by
the net heating value of the mixture of oxygen and fuel gas.
A knowledge of these two properties often permits the selection of the most
suitable fuel gas for a specific hardening speed and depth of case. The fuels of
greatest commercial interest are ranked by combustion intensity (at
metallurgically suitable ratios of mixture with oxygen) in the following order:
Depth of Heating. Shallow hardness patterns (less than 3.2 mm, or 0.125 in.,
deep) can be attained only with oxy-gas fuels. The high-temperature flames
obtained with oxy-gas fuels provide the fast heat transfer necessary for effective
localization of the heat pattern.
Deeper hardness patterns permit the use of either oxy-gas fuels or air-gas fuels.
Oxy-gas fuels will localize the heat, but care is required in their application to
avoid overheating the surface during the development of the deeper-seated heat.
Air-gas fuels, with their slower rates of heat transfer (lower flame temperatures),
minimize or eliminate surface overheating but generally extend the heat pattern
beyond the desired hardness pattern. For this reason, air-gas flame hardening is
generally limited to steels of shallow hardenability.
In this manner, the hardness pattern is controlled by the quench rather than by
the heating. The deeper-seated heat produced by air-gas flames may preclude the
use of air-gas mixtures because excessive distortion may occur.
31
In consideration of these factors, the use of air-gas heating will depend primarily
on the shape of the part insofar as the configuration favors heat localization and a
lower rate of heat transfer.acetylene, MAPP (methylacetylene propadiene),
propane, methane.
31
Application
Parts that are subject to high pressures and sharp
impacts are still commonly case hardened.
Examples include firing pins and rifle bolt faces, or
engine camshafts. In these cases, the surfaces
requiring the hardness may be hardened selectively,
leaving the bulk of the part in its original tough
state.
Firearms were a common item case hardened in the
past, as they required precision machining best done
on low carbon alloys, yet needed the hardness and
wear resistance of a higher carbon alloy. Many modern replicas of older firearms,
particularly single action revolvers, are still made with case hardened frames, or
with case coloring, which simulates the mottled pattern left by traditional
charcoal and bone case hardening.
Another common application of case hardening is on screws, particularly self-
drilling screws. In order for the screws to be able to drill, cut and tap into other
materials like steel, the drill point and the forming threads must be harder than
the material(s) that it is drilling into. However, if the whole screw is uniformly
hard, it will become very brittle and it will break easily. This is overcome by
ensuring that only the case is hardened and the core remains relatively soft. For
screws and fasteners, case hardening is less complicated as it is achieved by
heating and quenching in the form of heat treatment
For theft prevention, lock shackles and chains are often case hardened to resist
cutting, whilst remaining less brittle inside to resist impacts. As case hardened
components are difficult to machine, they are generally shaped before hardening.
32
References
Machlet, U.S. Patent 1,092,925, 24 June 1913
Fry, U.S. Patent 1,487,554, 18 March 1924
H.W. McQuaid and W.J. Ketcham, Some Practical Aspects of the
Nitriding Process, reprinted from Trans. ASST, Vol 14, 1928, Source
Book on Nitriding, P.M. Unterweiser and A.G. Gray, Ed., American
Society for Metals, 1977, p 1–25
R. Sergeson, Investigation in Nitriding, reprinted from American Society
for Steel Treaters (ASST) Nitriding Symposium, 1929, in Source Book on
Nitriding, P.M. Unterweiser and A.G. Gray, Ed., American Society for
Metals, 1977, p 26–55
V.O. Homerberg and J.P. Walsted, A Study of the Nitriding Process— Part
I, reprinted from American Society for Steel Treaters (ASST) Nitriding
Symposium, 1929, in Source Book on Nitriding, P.M. Unterweiser and
A.G. Gray, Ed., American Society for Metals, 1977, p 56–99
Practical Nitriding and Ferritic Nitrocarburizing (#06950G)
www.asminternational.org
C.F. Floe, A Study of the Nitriding Process Effect of Ammonia
Dissociation on Case Depth and Structure, reprinted from Trans. ASM, Vol
32, 1944, Source Book on Nitriding, P.M. Unterweiser and A.G. Gray, Ed.,
American Society for Metals, 1977, p 144–171
C.K. Jones and S.W. Martin, Nitriding, Sintering and Brazing in Glow
Discharge, Met. Prog., Feb 1964, p 94–98
C.K. Jones, D.J. Sturges, and S.W. Martin, Glow-Discharge Nitriding in
Production, reprinted from Met. Prog., Dec 1973, Source Book on
Nitriding, P.M. Unterweiser and A.G. Gray, Ed., American Society for
Metals, 1977, p 186–187
Ion Nitriding and Nitrocarburizing of Sintered PM Parts, October 7, 2004
Menthe, E; Bulak, A; Olfe, J; Zimmermann, A; Rie, KT (2000).
"Improvement of the mechanical properties of austenitic stainless steel
after plasma nitriding". Surface and Coatings Technology 133 (1): 259.
Zagonel, L; Figueroa, C; Droppajr, R; Alvarez, F (2006). "Influence of the
process temperature on the steel microstructure and hardening in pulsed
plasma nitriding". Surface and Coatings Technology 201 (1-2): 452.
Larisch, B; Brusky, U; Spies, HJ (1999). "Plasma nitriding of stainless
steels at low temperatures". Surface and Coatings Technology 116: 205.
33
Zagonel, L; Figueroa, C; Alvarez, F (2005). "In situ photoemission
electron spectroscopy study of nitrogen ion implanted AISI-H13 steel".
Surface and Coatings Technology 200 (7): 2566
N.J. Fulco, Flame Hardening, Heat Treat., Aug 1974, p 14-17
G.M. Corbett, Fuel Gases for Flame Hardening, Weld. Res. Suppl., Oct
1965, p 476-479
Larisch, B; Brusky, U; Spies, HJ (1999). "Plasma nitriding of stainless
steels at low temperatures". Surface and Coatings Technology
J.A. Dean, Ed., Lange's Handbook of Chemistry, 13th ed., McGraw-Hill,
1985
―Pure Case Noncyanide Carburizing Process," Heatbath Corporation
technical data sheet
F.W. Eysell, Regenerable Salt Baths for Carburizing, Carbonitriding, and
Nitrocarburizing: A Contribution to Protecting the Environment, FWP
Journal, Oct 1989
L.S. Burrows, Durofer--A Low-Toxicity Salt-Bath Carburizing Process,
Heat Treat. Met., Vol 4, 1987
P. Astley, Liquid Nitriding: Development and Present Applications, Heat
Treatment '73, Book No. 163, The Metals Society, 1975, p 93-97
P. Astley, Tufftride--A New Development Reduces Treatment Costs and
Process Toxicity, Heat Treat. Met,. Vol 2, 1975, p 51-54
H. Kunst and B. Beckett, Cyanide-Free Regenerator for Salt Bath
Carburizing, Heat Treatment '84, Book No. 312, The Metals Society, 1984,
p 16.1-16.5
R. Engelmann, Paper presented at the 39th Heat Treatment Colloquium,
Wiesbaden, West Germany, 5-7 Oct 3891
C. Skidmore, Salt Bath Quenching--A Review, Heat Treat. Met., Vol 13,
1986, p 34-38