case of the embattled employer8

7/27/2019 Case of the Embattled Employer8

1/39

"#$% &' ()% *+,#((-%.*+/-&0%1

!"##$ &&' ( )*+,*-./0 12,33/3.4 5+/$*/ 6-,#-+7 8+""9- :++/3.*"37 :$;2-+"7 ?@$*/3 A+--3


2/39

2#,-% &' "&3(%3($

45 !"#$%&'(# *%++,-. ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////0

26+%-63% #3. 78.9%(

:1&;%$$

")#--%39%$

445 1,$23-4%56/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 7

:&(%3(6#- :8,-6;$

2 ?3#-0$6$

4445

*'&%,&'45 85,9.:'://////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////;

4@5 9#+//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ?

@5 @4,9 ,56 A>B#$&'(#: ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ?

>,A%;(6B%$

@45 C#. =%>9'$: /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// D

C81-&89)%. *+/-&0%%$

"811%3( D&+%$(0-% *+/-&0%%$

E36&3 F%#.%1$G&3/1&'6( #3. H63&16(0 >19#36I#(6&3$

@445 1%63#&//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////0E

@4445


3/39

*K%;8(6B% )6& ,8( .8% (& ()%

%;&3&+6; .&P3(813 QNOOO %+/-&0%%$ )#B% ,%%3 '81-&89)%.N #//1&K6+#(%-0 LR /%1;%3( &'()% (&(#- P&1S'&1;%5 *B%10(&P3 )#$ # /&/8-#(6&3 &' TMONOOON +#S639 D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ #

+#A&1 %+/-&0%15 ?$ # 1%$8-(N +#30 %+/-&0%%$ #3. ;&++836(0 +%+,%1$ )#B% ,%;&+%

;&3;%13%. #,&8( ()% '8(81% &' D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ #3. 6($ 6+/#;( &3 ()% ;&++836(05

H63&16(0 #3. 3&3/1&'6( &19#36I#(6&3$ #-$& )%#B6-0 1%-0 &3 D&+%$(0-%U$ /)6-#3()1&/05 ?$

RO /%1;%3( &' &81 P&1S%1$ #1% ?'16;#3 ?+%16;#3N +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3$ #1% # -#19% /#1( &'

()% -&;#- ;&++836(05 D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ )#$ #3 &//&1(836(0 (& ;&11%;( ()%$%

+6$;&3;%/(6&3$ #3. $(1%39()%3 -&39 (%1+ 1%-#(6&3$)6/$ P6() ()% -&;#- ;&++836(0 #3.

&19#36I#(6&3$ P6()63 6(5

=6() ()6$ ;#+/#693N P% )&/% (& 3%8(1#-6I% 1%$%3(+%3( #3. ;&11%;( +6$83.%1$(#3.639$

#,&8( D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P)6-% $(1%39()%3639 ()&$% 6+/&1(#3( 1%-#(6&3$)6/$5

I'+#9'5# ,56 1%63#&

2)6$ ;#+/#693 P6-- $/#3 ()% ;&81$% &' $%B%3 +&3()$5 4( P6-- ,%963 6++%.6#(%-0 63 &1.%1 (&

/1%B%3( '81()%1 .#+#9% (& D&+%$(0-%U$ 1%/8(#(6&35

4( P6-- ;&$( #//1&K6+#(%-0 VLWNOOO5 ? ,1%#S.&P3 &' /1&A%;(%. ;&$($ +#0 ,% '&83. 63 #

.%(#6-%. ,8.9%( ,%9633639 &3 /#9% QW5

=-4$#::

2)6$ ;#+/#693 P6-- ,%963 6++%.6#(%-0 ,0 ;&++836;#(639 P6() &81 ;)&$%3 /8,-6;$ (&

$(%+ 18+&1$ #3. 63;1%#$% (18$(5 D&+%$(0-% P6-- 9#63 # 1%/8(#(6&3 '&1 ,%639 &/%3N )&3%$(

#3. 9%3863%-0 ;&3;%13%. P6() ()%61 ;&++836(05 ?'(%1 636(6#- ;&++836;#(6&3N P% P#3( (&

+#63(#63 ;&3(#;( P6() S%0 /8,-6;$ #3. 63'-8%3(6#-$ (& S%%/ ()%+ 8/ (& .#(% #3. (& ,%/1(6B% 63 #;;&+/-6$)639 ()% ;#+/#693 9-N P)6;) 6$ (& 3%8(1#-6I% 1%$%3(+%3( #3.

;&11%;( +6$83.%1$(#3.639$ #,&8( D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P)6-% $(1%39()%3639 6+/&1(#3(

1%-#(6&3$)6/$5


4/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR R

=% /1&/&$% .%#-639 P6() ()% ;16$6$ &3 )#3. '61$(N #3. 91#.8#--0 ,1639639 3%9#(6B% /8,-6;

#((%3(6&3 #P#0 '1&+ D&+%$(0-% P)6-% 1%/#61639 #3. 6.%#--0 6+/1&B639 &81 .#+#9%.

1%/8(#(6&35

,3

!"##@3/*< >"++< "D #"+- D@+2"@.;$

/3 *;- D@*@+-

I/$@3E-+$*,3E/3. "D *;- $"@+0- "DD@+2"@.;$

!,33"* 0"3*+"2 >;-3 D@+2"@.;-E

-#C2",3

G"$$ "D *+@$* D+"# 3"3C+"D/*$ ,3E

#/3"+/*< "+.,3/K,*/"3$

=% 63B6(% 0&8 (& (#S% # '81()%1 -&&S #( ()% &8(-63%. ;#+/#693 (& 9#63 # .%(#6-%.

S3&P-%.9% &' ()% /1&/&$%. ;#+/#6935


5/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR \

7#;S91&83.

=4&',9 =%>9'$:

:&(%3(6#- /8,-6;$ 63;-8.% ()% '&--&P639 91&8/$] +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3$N 3&3/1&'6(

&19#36I#(6&3$N 836&3 1%/1%$%3(#(6B%$N D&+%$(0-% %+/-&0%%$N D&+%$(0-% '#+6-6%$N

D&+%$(0-% +#3#9%1$N +63&16(0 D&+%$(0-% %+/-&0%%$N /)6-#3()1&/6$($N -&;#- ,8$63%$$

&P3%1$N B&-83(%%1$N %K%;8(6B%^-%B%-N 1%;%3( )61%$N '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$N '81-&89)%.

'#+6-6%$N D&+%$(0-% /1&.8;( ,80%1$N $8//-6%1$N 2#6P#3 P&1S%1$N $(&;S)&-.%1$N 63B%$(&1$N

;6(0 &''6;6#-$N *K%;8(6B% +#3#9%+%3(N ;8$(&+%1$N '&&. $(&1%$N 1%$(#81#3($N 91&;%10 $(&1%$N

'#1+$N %K/%16%3;%. P&1S'&1;%N 3%P^)61%N ;6(6I%3$N ;&++836(0N -&;#- $;)&&-$N /#1%3($N #3.

-&;#- +%.6#5

2)% /8,-6;$ P% )#B% .%;6.%. (& (#19%( P6-- ,% .%(#6-%. -#(%15


6/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR M

*KAI 85,9.:':

_2` $(#3.$ '&1 $(1%39()$N P%#S3%$$%$N &//&1(836(6%$ #3. ()1%#($5 =% )#B% &8(-63%.

()%$% '%#(81%$ #$ '#1 #$ D&+%$(0-% $)&8-. ,% ;&3;%13%. ;811%3(-05

)6&5

C81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ $(6-- )#B% ,%3%'6($5

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ )#$ )#. # $(1&39 /1%$%3;% 63 ()% ;&++836(0 '&1 0%#1$5

*B%10(&P3 P#3($ D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ (& $8;;%%. ,%;#8$% 6( ,%3%'6($ ()% ;&++836(05

=%#S3%$$%$

2)&89) ()% '81-&89)$ #1% .8% (& ()% %;&3&+0N %+/-&0%%$N 836&3 -%#.%1$N %(;5

P&110 ()#( ()%1% 6$ +&1% '81-&89)$ ;&+639 #3. .& 3&( 83.%1$(#3. ()% 6+/#;( 6$

$&-%-0 .8% (& ()% %;&3&+05

2)% ;&+/#30 ;#33&( ;&3(1&- ()% %;&3&+05

2)% ;&+/#30 .&%$ 3&( )#B% #,$&-8(% ;&3(1&- ()% (6+% '1#+% P)%3 '81-&89)%.

%+/-&0%%$ ;#3 ,% ,1&89)( ,#;S5

"#33&( #$$81% %+/-&0%%$ ()#( ()%0 P6-- ,% 1%)61%.5

>//&1(836(6%$]


7/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR W

2)1%#($]

E/16$639 &' 836&3 -%#.%1$ #3. +%+,%1$

F&$$ &' $#-%$

F&$$ &' %+/-&0%% (18$(

F&$$ &' '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%% (18$(

Z%$%3(+%3( '&1 *B%10(&P3 ;&++836(0


8/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR T

)6&5 *B%10(&P3 )#$ # /&/8-#(6&3

&' TMONOOON $)&P639 D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ 6$ # $6936'6;#3( %+/-&0%1 &' ()% ;&++836(05 X8% (&()% 1%;%3( %;&3&+6; .&P3(813N #,&8( QNOOO %+/-&0%%$ )#B% ,%%3 '81-&89)%. '1&+

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$N #//1&K6+#(%-0 LR /%1;%3( &' ()% (&(#- P&1S'&1;%5 Z%;%3(-0N D&+%$(0-%

)#$ &/%3%. # 3%P +#38'#;(81639 /-#3( 63 2#6P#35 2)%$% (P& '#;(&1$ ;&+,63%. )#B%

;#8$%. ;&3;%13 #3. 1%$%3(+%3( '1&+ '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ #3. 836&3 -%#.%1$ (&P#1.$

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$5 2)%1% #1% 18+&1$ ()#( ()% ;&+/#30 6$ &8($&81;639 #3. P6-- 3&( ,1639

,#;S ()% '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$5 2)6$ 6$ # ;&++&3 +6$;&3;%/(6&3 #+&39 836&3$ #3.

%+/-&0%%$N #$ +#3#9%+%3( /-#3$ (& ,1639 ,#;S %+/-&0%%$ #$ $&&3 #$

/&$$6,-%5 C81()%1+&1%N ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3( #;(8#--0 /1&B6.%$ %;&3&+6; ,%3%'6($ (& ()%;&+/#30N ()#( +#0 ,% #--&P639 ()% ;&+/#30 (& '81-&89) 1#()%1 ()#3 -#0 &'' %+/-&0%%$5

2)% 2#6P#3 /-#3( ,%3%'6($ ()% ;&+/#30 ,0 63;1%#$639 91&P()N #3. ;&+/%(6(6B%3%$$ 63 ()%

'&&. 63.8$(105

?3&()%1 +6$;&3;%/(6&3 63 ()% ;&++836(0 6$ ()#( D&+%$(0-% 6$ &8($&81;639 A&,$5 2)6$ 6$

83(18%N #$ ()% '81-&89)$ #1% .8% $&-%-0 (& ()% %;&3&+6; ;16$6$N #3. 3&( (& ()% 2#6P#3

/-#3(5 >()%1 &19#36I#(6&3$ #1% ;&3;%13%. P6() D&+%$(0-%U$ %;&3&+6; $(1899-%$N .8% (&

18+&1$ #3. 1%$%3(+%3( '1&+ #+&39 ()% ;&++836(05 H63&16(0 #3. 3&3/1&'6(

&19#36I#(6&3$ 1%-0 &3 D&+%$(0-%U$ /)6-#3()1&/05 ?$ RO /%1;%3( &' ()% P&1S%1$ #1% ?'16;#3

?+%16;#3N +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3$ #1% # -#19% /#1( &' ()% -&;#- ;&++836(05 =% 3%%. (&

;&++836;#(% ()% ;&+/#36%$ 9-$N #3. +&(6B#(6&3 ,%)63. '81-&89)639 %+/-&0%%$5

C#6-81% (& .& $& P6-- )#1$)-0 .#+#9% /8,-6; &/636&3 #3. (18$( &' D&+%$(0-% C&&.$5 =%

3%%. (& )%-/ ()% ;&++836(0 83.%1$(#3. ()% $6(8#(6&3 #3. +#63(#63 # $(1&39N &/%3

1%-#(6&3$)6/ P6() 836&3 &''6;6#-$ #3. '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$5 2)6$ 6$ ()% &3-0 P#0 (& 16.%

&8( ()% ;811%3( .6''6;8-( %;&3&+6; ;&3.6(6&3$ #3. ,1639 ,#;S ()% '81-&89)%.

%+/-&0%%$5 X#+#9639 ;&+/#30 (18$( P6-- ;#8$% D&+%$(0-% (& -&$% ,8$63%$$N +#S639 6(+&1% .6''6;8-( (& ,1639 ,#;S '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$5 D&+%$(0-% P6-- 3&( $81B6B% ()6$

%;&3&+6; )#1.$)6/ P6()&8( /1&/%1 %K%;8(6&3 &' ()6$ ;&++836;#(6&35


9/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR a

"&1% :1&,-%+

2)% ;&+,63#(6&3 &' '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ #3. +6$83.%1$(#3.639 #,&8( ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3(

)#$ -%. (& ;&++836(0 1%$%3(+%3( &' D&+%$(0-% C&&.$N ()1%#(%3639 /1&'6($ #3. %+/-&0%%(18$(5

b- #3. >,A%;(6B%$

2& 3%8(1#-6I% 1%$%3(+%3( #3. ;&11%;( +6$83.%1$(#3.639$ #,&8( D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P)6-%

$(1%39()%3639 6+/&1(#3( 1%-#(6&3$)6/$5

A>B#$&'(#:

L5 2& .%;1%#$% 63$(#3;%$ &' 3%9#(6B% 18+&1$ ,0 WO /%1;%3( 63 ()1%% +&3()$ #3. TO /%1;%3(

63 '6B% +&3()$ '1&+ ;811%3( -%B%-$5

Q5 2& 63;1%#$% 83.%1$(#3.639 &' 3%;%$$#10 '81-&89)$ ,0 MO /%1;%3( 63 (P& +&3()$ #3. TO

/%1;%3( 63 ()1%% +&3()$ '1&+ ;811%3( -%B%-$5

R5 2& 63;1%#$% #P#1%3%$$ &' 3%;%$$6(0 &' ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3( ,0 WO /%1;%3( 63 (P& +&3()$

#3. TO /%1;%3( 63 '&81 +&3()$

\5 2& 63;1%#$% ;&+/#30 (18$( ,0 QO /%1;%3( 63 '&81 +&3()$ #3. RO /%1;%3( 63 $%B%3

+&3()$5


10/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR c

d%0 :8,-6;$

2)%$% #1% ()% .%(#6-%. B%1$6&3$ &' ()% /8,-6;$ P% )#B% .%%+%. (& ,% B6(#- (& D&+%$(0-%U$

$81B6B#-5

L%-94%3J#6 !+M94.##:

?//1&K6+#(%-0 QNOOO %+/-&0%%$ )#B% ,%%3 '81-&89)%. '1&+ D&+%$(0-% C&&.$5 2)%$%

%+/-&0%%$ ;&+/16$% LR /%1;%3( &' ()% (&(#- P&1S'&1;%5 ?,&8( RO /%1;%3( &' '81-&89)%.

%+/-&0%%$ #1% ?'16;#3 ?+%16;#35 H&$( &' ()%$% %+/-&0%%$ #1% /#1( &' 836&3$ ()#( )#B%

B&6;%. 1%$%3(+%3( (&P#1.$ D&+%$(0-% C&&.$5 2)%$% %+/-&0%%$ #1% #'1#6. '81-&89)$ P6--

,% %K(%3$6B% #3. 1%$8-( 63 /%1+#3%3( -&$$ &' A&,$5 e&, -&$$ P&8-. .%;1%#$% %;&3&+6;

$(#,6-6(0N #3. ()% -6'%$(0-% &' ()%+$%-B%$ #3. ()%61 '#+6-6%$5 8($&81;639 +#0 -%#. (& '%%-639$ &' ,%(1#0#-5 "&3$%f8%3(-0N ()%$% %+/-&0%%$ +#0

,% -&&S639 %-$%P)%1% '&1 3%P A&,$5 43'-8%3(6#-$ &' ()6$ /8,-6; 63;-8.%] H#3#9%1$N ,&$$%$N

836&3 &''6;6#-$N ;&^P&1S%1$N /%%1$N &()%1 '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$N %K%;8(6B% +#3#9%+%3(N

836&3 +%+,%1$ #3. 3%P$ +%.6#5 ")#33%-$ ()1&89) P)6;) ()6$ /8,-6; ;#3 ,% 1%#;)%. #1%]

63(%13#- ;&+/#30 ;&++836;#(6&3N 3%P$ +%.6#N 836&3 +%%(639$N 836&3 ;&++836;#(6&3N

%+#6-N /)&3% ;#--$ #3. .61%;( +#6-5

!"#$%&'($)

2)6$ /8,-6; P6-- $#(6$'0 &,A%;(6B%$ (P&N ()1%% #3. '&815

+$)),-$)

L5


11/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR LO

Q5 >8($&81;639 6$ 3&( 1%/-#;639 0&85

C81-&89)$ #1% # 1%$8-( &' ()% 1%;%$$6&3N 3&( &' ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3(5

H&1% '#B&1#,-% (#K%$N -&P%1 -#,&1 ;&$($ #3. 1&&+ '&1 %K/#3$6&3 P6-- -%#. (& 91&P()

'&1 D&+%$(0-%5

*K/#3$6&3 P6-- %3#,-% D&+%$(0-% (& ;&+/%(% ,%((%1 #3. 91&P '#$(%15

R5 =% #1% P&1S639 (& ,1639 0&8 ,#;S #$ $&&3 #$ /&$$6,-%5

=% S3&P 0&8 #1% $;#1%.N ,8( P% P6-- ,1639 0&8 ,#;S5

2)% %;&3&+0 P6-- 9%( ,%((%15 =% P6-- )#B% # A&, '&1 0&85

2)% 2#6P#3 /-#3( )#$ 3&()639 (& .& P6() 0&81 '81-&89)%. /&$6(6&35 4( 6$ #;(8#--0

)%-/639 $#B% 0&81 A&, ,0 /1&B6.639 ()% ;&+/#30 /1&'6( #3. 91&P()5

=% #1% P&1S639 )#1. (& )#B% $8;;%$$ #3. ,1639 0&8 ,#;S5

71639639 0&8 ,#;S 6$ # )69) /16&16(05

4( (#S%$ (6+% #3. 1%$&81;%$ (& (1#63 3%P %+/-&0%%$] (P& ()639$ &81 ;&+/#30 .&%$

3&( )#B% 63 ()% ;811%3( 1%;%$$6&3

\5 Y&8 #1% 6+/&1(#3( (& 8$ #3. )69) &3 &81 /16&16(0 -6$(5

Y&8 #1% B6(#- (& &81 $8;;%$$ #3. )%-/%. ,86-. ()6$ ;&+/#305

=6()&8( 0&8 P% P&8-.3U( )#B% %K/%16%3;%. ()% $8;;%$$ P% )#B% 8/ (& ()6$ /&63(5

=% 1%#--0 #1% .&639 P)#( 6$ 63 ()% ,%$( 63(%1%$( &' 0&81 A&, #3. ()% ;&+/#30 $& 0&8

;#3 ,% P6() 8$ '&1 ()% -&39^(%1+5

=% ;#1% #,&8( 0&8 #3. 0&81 '#+6-6%$5


12/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR LL

.&/,&$-'$) ,01 2,%&'%)

L5 43'&1+ '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ #,&8( ()% 3#(81% &' '81-&89)$ (& 63;1%#$% (18$( 63 ()%

&19#36I#(6&3 ()1&89) ;&+/#30 ;&++836;#(6&35

F%((%1 +#6-%. (& $/%;6'6;#--0 (& '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ &8(-63639 63'&1+#(6&3 #3.$(#(8$ 1%9#1.639 ()% ;&+/#30 #3. ()% '81-&89)$5

*+#6- +&3()-0 3%P$-%((%1 P6() 8/.#(%$ #,&8( ()% ;&+/#30 #3. ()% $(#(8$ &' ()%

%;&3&+0N #-$& ;&++836;#(639 ()% 6+/&1(#3;% &' ()% %+/-&0%%$5

X61%;( /)&3% ;#--$ (& '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ ()1&89) ()%61 +#3#9%1 &1 1%+#63639

;)#63 &' ;&++#3.5 ? $;16/( P6-- ,% /1&B6.%. ;&++836;#(639 ()%61 6+/&1(#3;% (&

8$ #3. ()#( P% #1% P&1S639 (& ,1639 ()%+ ,#;S5

>3^$6(% +%%(639N 63B6(639 #-- '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$5 2)% +%%(639 P6-- 63;-8.% #$

+#30 %K%;8(6B% &''6;%1$ #$ P6-- #91%% (& #((%3.5 4( P6-- ,% #3 &8(-63% &' ()% $6(8#(6&3N

'81-&89)$N #3. &81 /-#3 (& ,1639 %+/-&0%%$ ,#;S5 4( P6-- #-$& 63;-8.% 1%'1%$)+%3($5

43B6(#(6&3$ ;#3 ,% %K(%3.%. ()1&89) ()% -%((%1N 3%P$-%((%1N #3. /)&3% ;#--$5

43;-8.% # (#S%^#P#0 '1&+ ()% +%%(639N $8;) #$ # ,1&;)81% &8(-63639 ()%

63'&1+#(6&35

Q5 43'&1+ '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ #,&8( ()% 3%;%$$6(0 &' ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3( ()1&89) E36&3

;&++836;#(6&35


13/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR LQ

R5 Z%#$$81% '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ ()#( ()%0 #1% 6+/&1(#3( (& 8$ #3. P% #1% .&639 #-- P%

;#3 (& ,1639 ()%+ ,#;S ()1&89) .61%;( ;&3(#;(5

C81-&89)%. %+/-&0%% -83;)%&3 A8$( '&1 #//1%;6#(6&35 43B6(% A8$( ()% '81-&89)%.

%+/-&0%%$ #3. '&;8$ &3 #//1%;6#(6&35

F%((%1 '1&+ ()% "*> %K/1%$$639 #//1%;6#(6&3 (& '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ #3. /-#3$

(& ,1639 ()%+ ,#;S5

*^+#6- '1&+ +#3#9%+%3(N 1%.61%;(639 %+/-&0%%$ (& ()% ;&+/#30 P%,$6(% '&1 +&1%

63'&1+#(6&3

H#6- # ,1&;)81%N _=)#( Y>E H%#3 (& D&+%$(0-% C&&.$N` 63;-8.639 $(#($ #3.

)6$(&10 &' ()% ;&+/#305

b6B% ()%$% %+/-&0%%$ 63'&1+#(6&3#- /#;S%($N %K/-#63639 )&P -&39 '81-&89)$ +#0

-#$(N ,%3%'6($ %+/-&0%%$ 1%(#63 .81639 # '81-&89) #3. 63'&1+#(6&3 '&1 ()% DZ

.%/#1(+%3( P)& ()%0 ;#3 ;&3(#;( P6() f8%$(6&35


14/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR LR

#..6(6&3 (& %+/-&0%1 63(%916(05 43'-8%3(6#-$ &' ()6$ /8,-6; #1%] +#3#9%1$N ,&$$%$N ;&^

P&1S%1$N /%%1$N ()% %K%;8(6B% (%#+N 3&3/1&'6( B&-83(%%1$N +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3

B&-83(%%1$N $/&8$%$ #3. '#+6-6%$5 ")#33%-$ ()1&89) P)6;) /8,-6; ;#3 ,% 1%#;)%. #1%]

63(%13#- ;&+/#30 ;&++836;#(6&3N ;&+/#30 %B%3($N %K(%13#- ;&+/#30 $/&3$&1$)6/$N

;&+/#30 /#1(3%1$)6/$N 3&3/1&'6(N +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3$N .61%;( +#6-N %+#6-N '-0%1$N

;&+/#30 +#9#I63%$N 63.8$(10 /8,-6;#(6&3$N /163( +%.6#N .%/#1(+%3( +%%(639$N (%#++%%(639$N ;&+/#30 ,6--,.$N B%)6;-% P1#/$N ,8$ $(#(6&3$N $8,P#0 $(#(6&3$N

!"#$%&'($)

2)6$ S%0 /8,-6; P6-- $#(6$'0 &,A%;(6B%$ &3%N (P&N ()1%% #3. '&815

+$)),-$)

L5 8($&81;639 6$ 3&( 1%/-#;639 0&8

C81-&89)$ #1% # 1%$8-( &' ()% 1%;%$$6&3N 3&( &' ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3(

2)% /-#3( P#$ ;1%#(%. (& %K/#3. ,8$63%$$5


15/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR L\

H#3#9%+%3( '8--0 63(%3.$ (& ,1639 ,#;S '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ #$ $&&3 #$ /&$$6,-%5

4( (#S%$ (6+% #3. 1%$&81;%$ (& (1#63 3%P %+/-&0%%$] (P& ()639$ &81 ;&+/#30 .&%$

3&( )#B% 63 ()% ;811%3( 1%;%$$6&35

R5 2)% 2#6P#3 /-#3( 6$ 3&( ()% /1&,-%+g 6( 6$ ()% $&-8(6&35

2#6P#3 )#$ # -&P%1 ;&1/&1#(% (#K 1#(%N -&P%1 -#,&1 ;&$($ #3. ;&+/#30 91&P()5

2#6P#3 -&;#(6&3 P&8-. /&$6(6&3 D&+%$(0-% (& ,%((%1 ;&+/%(% 63 ()% '&&. 63.8$(10N

,%3%'6(639 $(#S%)&-.%1$5

2)1&89) -&P%1 ;&1/&1#(% (#K 1#(% #3. -&P%1 -#,&1 ;&$($N ()% ;&+/#30 )#$ $#B%.

+&3%0 63 ()% %;&3&+6; 1%;%$$6&35

2)%$% #.B#3(#9%$ )#B% )%-/%. D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ $(#0 /1&'6(#,-% 63 ()% ;811%3(

%;&3&+6; .&P3(8135

:1&'6($ '1&+ ()6$ /-#3( )#B% #--&P%. ()% ;&+/#30 (& '81-&89) %+/-&0%%$N 1#()%1

()#3 -#0 ()%+ &''5

.&/,&$-'$) ,01 2,%&'%)

L5 43'&1+ ;811%3( %+/-&0%%$ ()1&89) 63(%13#- ;&++836;#(6&3 ()#( '81-&89)$ #1% # 1%$8-(

&' ()% 1%;%$$6&3g ()%1%'&1%N D&+%$(0-% P#3($ (& $%;81% A&,$5

H%%(639 '&1 #-- -&P^ (& +6.^-%B%- +#3#9%1$5 2)6$ +%%(639 P6-- ,16%' ()%$% &/636&3

-%#.%1$ #,&8( ()% '81-&89)$N #3. 1%#$&3639 ,%)63. ()%+5 4( P6-- )69)-69)( ()%

%;&3&+6; 1%;%$$6&3N #3. $)&P ()#( A&,$ #1% ,%639 -&$( ,%;#8$% &' ()% 1%;%$$6&3N

#3. 3&( .8% (& &8($&81;6395

*+#6- #-- %+/-&0%%$ # ,6P%%S-0 8/.#(% &' ()% ;&+/#30U$ $8;;%$$ &' 1%)61639

'81-&89)$5 ?-()&89) ()% /1&91%$$ +#0 ,% $-&PN 6( P6-- ,% 8$%'8- (& $)&P %+/-&0%%$%K#;(-0 P)#( D&+%$(0-% 6$ .&6395 2)% %+#6- P6-- 63;-8.% ()% (&(#- %+/-&0%%$

1%)61%. h$(#1(639 63 # '%P +&3()$i #3. /1&B6.% (%$(6+&36#-$ &' ()&$% %+/-&0%%$

P)& )#B% ,%%3 1%)61%.5

?$$693 %#;) DZ %+/-&0%% # (%#+ &' P&1S%1$ 63 ()% ;&+/#305 b6B% ()% DZU$

63'&1+#(6&3 (& ()% (%#+N 63 ()% '&1+ &' # ,8$63%$$ ;#1.5 2)% (%#+ P6-- ,%


16/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR LM

%3;&81#9%. 63 %#;) (%#+ +%%(639 (& ;&3(#;( DZ P6() f8%$(6&3$ #3. ;&3;%13$

#,&8( ()% '81-&89)$5

X61%;( +#6- P6-- ,% $%3( (& #-- %+/-&0%%$ P6() ()% ;&+/#30 P%,$6(% -63SN P)%1%

()%0 ;#3 '63. &8( +&1% #,&8( ()% ;&+/#30U$ %''&1($ (& $81B6B% ()% %;&3&+6;

$(&1+5 2)% +#3#9%1$ P6-- ,% %3;&81#9%. (& /#$$ ()6$ 63'&1+#(6&3 #-&39 (&%+/-&0%%$5

=16(% #3 #1(6;-% 63 ()% ;&+/#30 +#9#I63% #,&8( ()% 1%;%3( '81-&89)$5

Q5 H&(6B#(% ;811%3( %+/-&0%%$ ()1&89) ;&+/#30 %B%3($ ()#( $8//&1( &' D&+%$(0-% '&&.$

h#3. ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3(i P6-- $#B% A&,$5

43 ()% +%%(639 '&1 -&P^ (& +6.^ -%B%- +#3#9%1$N ()1%% ,8((&3$ P6-- ,% 96B%3 (& %#;)

/%1$&3 #( ()% %3. &' ()% +%%(6395 H#3#9%1$ P6-- ,% 96B%3 ()% &/(6&3 (& P%#1 #

,8((&3N #3. ()%3 /#$$ #-&39 %K(1#^,8((&3$ (& (&/ /%1'&1+%1$ 63 ()%61 (%#+5 2)%$%

,8((&3$ P6-- $#0N _4 9&( $(0-%N` P6() ()% ;&+/#30U$ -&9&5 2)% +%$$#9% ,%)63. ()%

,8((&3$ 6$ (& $8//&1( D&+%$(0-% ()1&89) ()% ;16$6$N ,0 ,#3.639 (&9%()%1 (& $#B%

%#;) &()%1U$ A&,$5 ?-$&N 6( P6-- $)&P $8//&1( '&1 ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3(5

*#;) 2)81$.#0 &' ()% P%%SN %+/-&0%%$ P6-- ,% %3;&81#9%. (& P%#1 ;#$8#- ;-&()639N

#3. $)61($ ()#( $/&3$&1 ()% ;&+/#30 ;&-&1$5 70 P%#1639 ;&+/#30 ;&-&1$N

%+/-&0%%$ ;#3 $)&P ()#( ()%0 #1% ;&++6((%. (& P&1S639 )#1. '&1 D&+%$(0-% '&&.$N(& /1&+&(% '81-&89) 1%^)61639$ #3. A&, 1%(%3(6&35 2)6$ %B%3( P6-- ,% /1&+&(%.

()1&89) '-0%1$5

?( ()% %K%;8(6B% -%B%-N %+/-&0%%$ P#3(639 (& P%#1 ;#$8#- ;-&()%$ &3 2)81$.#0$

$)&8-. /#0 VL 63 &1.%1 (& P%#1 ;#$8#- ;-&()6395 2)% +&3%0 P6-- ,% /8( (&P#1.$ #

$;)&-#1$)6/ ()#( '81-&89)%. '#+6-6%$ ;#3 #//-0 '&15

2)81$.#0 %B%3($ P6-- ,% /1&+&(%. ()1&89) %+#6- (& %#;) (%#+ -%#.%1N P)& P6--

()%3 /#$$ ()6$ 63'&1+#(6&3 &3 (& %+/-&0%%$5

2)% 2)81$.#0 %B%3( P6-- #-$& ,% /1&+&(%. 63 ()% +%%(639 (& +#3#9%1$N ()1&89)

:&P%1:&63( /1%$%3(#(6&35 2)6$ P6-- /1&B6.% &3% P&1S#,-% #-(%13#(6B% (& ,&&$(

+&1#-% #+&39 %+/-&0%%$N #$ P%-- #$ $)&P #3 #((%+/( (& 1%#;) &8( (& '81-&89)%.

%+/-&0%%$5


17/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR LW

R5 :%1$8#.% %+/-&0%%$ ()1&89) /163( +%.6# ()#( '81-&89)$ #1% ,%((%1 ()#3 -#0&''$5

:8,-6$) 63(%1B6%P$ &' %+/-&0%%$ ()#( )#B% ,%%3 1%)61%. 63 ()% ;&+/#30 +#9#I63%

%#;) +&3()5


18/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR LT

P)%3 ()%0 /%1;%6B% %+/-&0%1 +6$(1%#(+%3(5 E36&3 -%#.%1$ #1% #-$& 63(%1%$(%. 63 ()%61

&P3 $#-#16%$N ()%61 &P3 P%--^,%639 #3. %#$% &' ()%61 A&,$5 2)%0 #-$& )#B% # 1%/8(#(6&3 (&

8/)&-.N #$ ()%0 .&3U( P#3( (& ,% $%%3 #$ /#3.%1639 (& ,69 ,8$63%$$5 43'-8%3(6#-$ &' ()6$

/8,-6; 63;-8.%] 836&3 +%+,%1$N -&;#- 9&B%13+%3( &''6;6#-$N /&-6(6;6#3$N '#+6-0 +%+,%1$

#3. $8/%16&1$5 ")#33%-$ ()1&89) P)6;) ()6$ /8,-6; +#0 ,% 1%#;)%. #1%] /%1$&3#- ;&3(#;(N

836&3 +%+,%1$N +%%(639$N %+#6-N .61%;( +#6-N /)&3% ;#--$N -&;#- (B #3. -&;#- 3%P$/#/%1$5

!"#$%&'($)

2)6$ /8,-6; P6-- $#(6$'0 &,A%;(6B%$ &3%N (P&N ()1%% #3. '&815

+$)),-$)

L5 C81-&89)$ #1% $(16;(-0 # 1%$8-( &' ()% %;&3&+0 #3. )#B% 3&()639 (& .& P6() ()% 2#6P#3

/-#3(5

2)% 2#6P#3 /-#3( P#$ '8--0 %$(#,-6$)%. ,%'&1% ()% '81-&89)$ )#//%3%.5

h"&11%-#(6&3 6$ 3&( ;#8$#(6&35i

2)% %;&3&+0 6$ (%116,-% '&1 %B%10&3% 169)( 3&P5

2)% #-(%13#(6B% (& ()%$% '81-&89)$ 6$ /%1+#3%3( A&, -&$$5 2)% 1%#$&3 P% #1%

63$(#(639 '81-&89)$ 6$ ,%;#8$% P% .&3U( P#3( /%1+#3%3( A&, -&$$5

>8($&81;639 #..$ (& ()% &B%1#-- /1&.8;(6B6(0 &' ()% ;&+/#30N 6( .&%$ 3&( 1%/-#;%

$(#(%$6.% P&1S%1$5

2)% 2#6P#3 /-#3( 6$ #;(8#--0 /1&B6.639 8$ ()% +%#3$ (& P%#()%1 ()% $(&1+ #3. ,0

%K(%3$6&3 1%^)61% &81 P&1S%1$5

2)% 2#6P#3 /-#3( $)&8-. ,% 63;1%.6,-0 6+/&1(#3( (&


19/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR La

?$ -&39 #$ ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3( 1%+#63$ 63 &/%1#(6&3N P% $)&8-. ,% #,-% (& $6( &8( ()%

;811%3( %;&3&+6; ;16$6$ #3. )61% ,#;S &81 P&1S%1$N +#S639 0&81 A&, '#1 %#$6%1 #3.

0&81 +%+,%1$ )#//05

4' ()% '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ 9%( ()%61 A&,$ ,#;SN 6( P6-- ,% # (%$(#+%3( (& 0&81

1%/8(#(6&3 63 ()% P&1S/-#;% #3. ()% +%.6# %0% #$ # 836&3 -%#.%1 P)& -&&S$ #'(%1()% +%+,%1$5

Q5 =% )69)-0 B#-8% &81 '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ #3. P#3( ()%+ ,#;S #$ $&&3 #$ /&$$6,-%5

=% .&3U( P#3( &81 %+/-&0%%$ (& $8''%1 A8$( -6S% 0&8 .&3U( P#3( ()%+ (& $8''%1^^P%

-&B% &81 %+/-&0%%$j =)6;) 6$ P)0 P%U1% (10639 (& )61% ()%+ ,#;S5

=%U1% (10639 (& )61% &81 '81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ ,#;S5

C81-&89)%. %+/-&0%%$ $(6-- 1%;%6B% B#16&8$ ,%3%'6($5


20/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR Lc

2)% %K/%16%3;% &81 ;811%3( P&1S%1$ )#B% $6+/-0 ;#33&( ,% 1%/-#;%. P6()&8( +#A&1

$%(,#;S$ (& ()% ;&+/#30N /&$$6,-0 $)8(.&P35

>81 P&1S%1$ #1% +&1% B#-8#,-% (& 8$ ()#3 ()%0 #1% (& 0&8N &1 P% -&B% &81

%+/-&0%%$ +&1% ()#3 0&8 .&5

=%U1% 3&( '81-&89)639 P6() 9-%%5

Y&8 P#3( %+/-&0%%$ (& 9%( +&3%05 =% P#3( (& /#0 ()%+ '&1 ()%61 P&1S5

E3'&1(83#(%-0N ()% %;&3&+0 )#$ +#.% 6( $& P% ;#3U( 96B% ()%+ ()%61 /1&/%1 .8%$

169)( 3&P5 =% .&3U( P#3( (& +#S% ()%+ .& P&1S P% ;#3U( /#0 ()%+ '&15

=% -&B% ()%+ $& +8;) $& P%U1% $(6-- 96B639 ()%+ ,%3%'6($^ '81-&89)N 3&( '616395

=% h9%3%1#--0i P#3( P)#( 0&8 P#3(j

\5 ?$ # -%#.%1 &B%1 +#30 %+/-&0%%$ P)&$% -6B%-6)&&.$ .%/%3. &3 ()%61 A&, #( D&+%$(0-%N

0&8 3%%. (& +#S% $81% 0&8 .&3U( /1&B6.% ()%+ P6() '#-$% 63'&1+#(6&35

=% P6-- /1&B6.% 0&8 P6() #;;81#(% 63'&1+#(6&3 &'(%3 #3. 63 # (6+%-0 +#33%15

Y&8 3%%. (& )#B% -&($ &' ;&3(#;( P6() &81 ;&+/#30 (& 9%( #;;81#(% 63'&1+#(6&35

=% P#3( (& /1&B6.% 0&8 P6() ()% +&$( ;&11%;( #3. 8/^(&^.#(% 63'&1+#(6&35

>3-0 D&+%$(0-% ;#3 /1&B6.% 0&8 P6() #;;81#(% 63'&1+#(6&3 ;&3;%13639 D&+%$(0-%5

D&+%$(0-% 6$ #3 &/%3 #3. )&3%$( ;&1/&1#(6&35

D&+%$(0-% 1%$/%;($ 0&81 -%#.%1$)6/ /&$6(6&35

.&/,&$-'$) ,01 2,%&'%)

L5 2& $)&P 836&3 -%#.%1$ ()#( ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3( .&%$ 3&( 1%/-#;% $(#(%$6.% A&,$ #3.

/%1$8#.% ()%+ (& $8//&1( 6( ()1&89) /%1$&3#- ;&3(#;( #3. /1%/#1%. +#(%16#-$5

H#6- #3 63B6(#(6&3^-%((%1^&''%1 (& /1%$%3( #( ()%61 /-#;% &' P&1S &1 '&1 ()%+ (& ;&+%

(& # /1%$%3(#(6&3 #( D&+%$(0-%U$ +#63 &''6;% ()#( 1%f8%$($ Z


21/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR QO

'&1 63'&1+#(6&3 /#;S%($k'#;( $)%%( 6' ()%0 .&3U( )#B% (6+% '&1 # /1%$%3(#(6&3N '&--&P

8/ P6() # /)&3% ;#-- 63B6(%

D#B% # ;&+/#30 1%/1%$%3(#(6B% .%-6B%1 %0%^#//%#-639N 91#/)6;^)%#B0 /1%$%3(#(6&3$

;&3;%13639 D&+%$(0-%U$ /-#3 (& 8$% ()% 2#6P#3 /-#3( (& 1%;&B%1 #3. 1%63$(#(% 9&&.

A&,$ '&1 $(#(%$6.% P&1S%1$5

?'(%1 /1%$%3(#(6&3$N -%#B% 63'&1+#(6&3 /#;S%($ '&1 836&3 -%#.%1$ ()#( ;&3(#63

;&3;6$% &8(-63%$ &' ()% 1%;&B%10 /-#3 '&1 1%'%1%3;% #3. P%,$6(%N /)&3% 38+,%1 &1

&()%1 +%()&.$ (& &,(#63 #..6(6&3#- 63'&1+#(6&35

X%-6B%1 ()% /1%$%3(#(6&3 ()#( (#S%$ /-#;% #( D&+%$(0-% &B%1 # -83;) +%%(639

+#63-0 ,%;#8$% %B%10&3%U$ )#//6%1 P6() '&&. 63 ()%+N #-$& /1&B6.%$ # ;)#3;% (&

$)&P;#$% D&+%$(0-% ;&&S639 h3&( +6;1&P#B%k'1&I%3 '&&.N ,8( #;(8#--0 )#B% &81

;)%'$ ()#( ;1%#(% /1&.8;( +#S% # 1%#- +%#-i5

Q5 2& +&(6B#(% 836&3 -%#.%1$ (& $(&/ $/1%#.639 18+&1$ ()1&89) /%1$&3#- ;&3(#;( #3.

/1%/#1%. +#(%16#-$5

d%%/ 836&3 -%#.%1$ '8--0 #,1%#$( &' #30 ;)#39%$ h.%;6$6&3$N /1&91%$$N $%(,#;S$i

P6() %6()%1 P%%S-0 &1 #$^3%;%$$#10 %+#6- ;&3(#;(5

43(1&.8;% ()%+ (& D&+%$(0-%U$ _18+&1 )&(-63%N` # 3%P-0 %$(#,-6$)%. P%,$6(% P6()

;)#(N %+#6- #3. #3 #B#6-#,-% /)&3% 38+,%1 $%( 8/ (& 1%;%6B% f8%$(6&3$ #,&8(

18+&1$5

D#B% #3 %K%;8(6B%N &1 &()%1 #8()&16(#(6B% $&81;% P6()63 ()% ;&+/#30N ,&() 1%'8(%

#3. ;&11%;( 18+&1$ P)6-% 1%$/&3.639 (& f8%$(6&3$ .81639 # B6.%&;&3'%1%3;% &1

&()%1 %#$0 +%%(639 P6() -&;#- 836&3 -%#.%1$5

>''%1 # '8-- '#;6-6(0 (&81 $& ()#( ()%0 ;#3 $%% ()% .6+636$)%. &/%1#(6&3$ '&1()%+$%-B%$ #3. )&P ()% %;&3&+6; ;16$6$ 6$N 63 '#;(N )81(639 D&+%$(0-% 7E2

1%+%+,%1 3&( (& +#S% 6( &8( -6S% P%U1% .0639^^/1&B% ()#( P%U1% .&639 %B%10()639

P% ;#3 (& $(#0 #'-( #3. 1%63$(#(% P&1S%1$5

:1&B6.% # '#;( S6( '&1 ()% (&815


22/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR QL

:1&B6.% 63B6(#(6&3$ (& ()% (&815


23/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR QQ

Q45M-4H'& ,56 R'54-'&. A-3,5'S,&'45:

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ &'(%3 63(%1#;($ P6() 3&3/1&'6( #3. +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3$5 2)%0 1%-0 &3

()% ;&+/#30 '&1 ;#/6(#-N 63 #..6(6&3 (& B&-83(%%1$ #3. $8//&1(5 ?//1&K6+#(%-0 RO /%1;%3(

&' ()% /&/8-#(6&3 6$ ?'16;#3 ?+%16;#3N $& 6( ;#3 ,% #$$8+%. ()#( +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3$

)#B% )69) /#1(6;6/#(6&3 #3. 1%$/%;( 63 ()% *B%10(&P3 ;&++836(05 2)% /8,-6; P#3($ (&

)%-/ ()% ;&++836(0 #3. 3%%.$ ()% .&3#(6&3$ &' D&+%$(0-% C&&.$5 2)% /8,-6; 6$ P&116%.

()#( D&+%$(0-% '&&.$ P6-- 3& -&39%1 ,% #,-% (& .&3#(% (& ()%61 ;#8$%$ #3. +#0 %B%3 '%#1

()#( D&+%$(0-% '&&.$ 6$ 9&639 &8( &' ,8$63%$$ &1 ;&+/-%(%-0 &8($&81;6395 2)6$ /8,-6;

P&8-. ,% ;&3;%13%. ()#( D&+%$(0-% 6$ &8($&81;639N ,%;#8$% 6( P&8-. +%#3 D&+%$(0-% 6$

+&B639 )%#.f8#1(%1$ #P#0 '1&+ *B%10(&P3 #3. .6$;&3(638% $8//&1( &' ()% &19#36I#(6&3$5

70 #$$81639 ()6$ /8,-6; ()#( '83.$ '&1 ()% ;&++836(0 #1% $%;81%N P% P6-- 63;1%#$% ()% (18$(

D&+%$(0-% #3. ,% /%1;%6B%. #$ # $(#,-% 9%3%1&8$ ,%3%'#;(&15 43'-8%3(6#-$ &' ()6$ /8,-6;

#1%] +#3#9%1$N ;&++836(0 -%#.%1$N B&-83(%%1$N ;&--%#98%$N /%%1$N &()%1 3&3^/1&'6( 91&8/$N

+63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3 B&-83(%%1$N $/&8$%$ #3. '#+6-6%$5 ")#33%-$ ()1&89) P)6;) ()6$/8,-6; +#0 ,% 1%#;)%. #1%] %K(%13#- ;&+/#30 $/&3$&1$)6/$N ;&+/#30 /#1(3%1$)6/$N

3&3/1&'6(N +63&16(0 &19#36I#(6&3$N .61%;( +#6-N '-0%1$N ;6(0 63'-8%3(6#-$N ;&++836(0

-%96$-#(81%N 63.8$(10 /8,-6;#(6&3$N $&;6#- +%.6#N .%/#1(+%3( +%%(639$N (%#+ +%%(639$N ,8$

$(#(6&3$N $8,P#0 $(#(6&3$N .&P3(&P3 ,86-.639$N ;&++836(0 ,86-.639$N ,8--%(63 ,.$N

%+#6-N /)&3% ;#--$N .61%;( +#6- #3. 3%69),&1)&&.$ &' &19#36I#(6&3$5

!"#$%&'($)

2)6$ S%0 /8,-6; P6-- $#(6$'0 &,A%;(6B%$ &3%N (P& #3. '&815

+$)),-$)

L5 =% #1% )%1% (& $(#05

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ 6$ 3&( 9&639 &8( &' ,8$63%$$5

X& 3&( P&1105

C81-&89)$ #1% &3-0 .8% (& ()% %;&3&+6; .&P3(8135

C81-&89)$ #1% .8% &3-0 (& ()% %;&3&+6; .&P3(813 #3. #1% 3&( 1%-#(%. (& #30

2#6P#3 /-#3(5

2)% *B%10(&P3 /-#3( 6$ 3&( $)8((639 .&P35


24/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR QR

D&+%$(0-% '&&.$ P6-- P%#()%1 ()% %;&3&+6; .&P3(8135

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ 6$ $%( 8/ '&1 $8;;%$$5

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P6-- $(6-- ,% # .&3#(&15

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P6-- ,% 0&81 /#1(3%1 -&39 (%1+5

Q5 D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P6-- $(6-- ,% # +#A&1 ;&3(16,8(&1 (& ()% ;&++836(05

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P6-- ;&3(638% (& .&3#(% P)#( 6( ;#3 ()1&89) 1&89) (6+%$5

Y&8 P6-- 3&( ,% '&19&((%35

=% P6-- 3&( #,#3.&3 &81 ;#8$% (& )%-/ &81 ;&++836(05

Y&8 #1% &81 ;&++836(0 #3. P% #1% $(6-- # /#1( &' 6(N '63#3;6#--0 #3. &()%1P6$%5

=% P6-- $(6-- 63B%$( 63 &81 ;&++836(0m$ '8(81% ,%;#8$% 0&8 #1% &81 '8(81%5

>81 +6$$6&3 (& $%1B% ()% ;&++836(0 P6-- 3%B%1 ;)#39%N 3& +#((%1 ()% %;&3&+6;

P%#()%15

>81 ;&1/&1#(% $&;6#- 1%$/&3$6,6-6(0 )#$ 3&( ;)#39%.5 G%6()%1 )#B% P%5

Y&8U1% 63 9&&. )#3.$5

.&/,&$-'$) ,01 2,%&'%)

L5 2& 1%#;) &8( (& ;&++836(0 &19#36I#(6&3$ ()1&89) ()% &19#36I#(6&3$ -%#.%1$ ,0 .61%;(

/%1$&3#- ;&3(#;(5

H#S% # /%1$&3#- /)&3% ;#-- '1&+ # )69) 1#3S639 &''6;6#- h$8;) #$ @: &' 1%-#(6&3$i (&

%#;) &19#36I#(6&3 (& P)6;) D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ .&3#(%$ -#19% $8+$N %K/-#63639 )&P

D&+%$(0-% C&&.$ P6-- ;&3(638% (& $8//&1( ()%+5

b6B% # -83;)%&3 P6() -&;#- ;&++836(0 &19#36I#(6&3 -%#.%1$ '&1 # /1%$%3(#(6&3 (&

%K/-#63 ()% ;811%3( %;&3&+6; $(#3.639 #3. (& #3$P%1 #3. nl?5 >' ;&81$%N &81

/1&.8;( P6-- ,% 8$%. 63 ()% /1&.8;(6&3 &' ()6$ -83;)%&35


25/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR Q\

:-#;% /&$(%1$N 3#/S63$N %(;5 #1&83. ()% 1&&+ 63 ()% -83;)%&3 P6() &81 +%$$#9%$5

:%1$&3#- ()#3S 0&8 3&(%$ )#3. P16((%3 (& %#;) &19#36I#(6&3 -%#.%1 ()#3S639 ()%+

'&1 ()%61 ;&3(638%. $8//&1( #3. %K/1%$$639 D&+%$(0-% C&&.U$ &39&639

;&++6(+%3( (& $8//&1( ()%+5

:%1$&3#- B6$6($ (& ()% &19#36I#(6&3$5

Q5 2& 1%#;) &19#36I#(6&3$ ()1&89) /163( +%.6#5


26/39

"?C 2D* *H7?22F*X *H:F>Y*Z [ H?Z"D QOLR QM

>''%1 (& /#0 '&1 ()% /#63( '&1 %B%10 &19#36I#(6&3 ()#( P6-- #--&P

;)6-.1%3kB&-83(%%1$k/#1(6;6/#3($ (& /#63( 63.&&1 &1 &8(.&&1 +81#-$ (& ,%#8(6'0 ()%

;&++836(05 2)% (&/6; '&1 ()% +81#- P6-- ,% _"&++836(0 :16.%`5 *B%10 +81#- P6--

)#B% # $-&9#3 ()#( $#0$N _"1%#(6B% b%368$ ,0 ooooo h63$%1( 3#+% &' &19#36I#(6&3i5


27/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 26

+789:;

(??>@AB9 CD9:E F>B;DAB ;H ;


28/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 26


29/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 26


30/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 26


31/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 53

!6789:6;

(77>?@9A B6A8C D>9E6@9 EF8DE8: 789AE< >= E@G8 =>; E


32/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 54


33/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 52


34/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 55


35/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 56

!7889:;;7: !7:?;@8=>;7: (=ABC

(DC ?7BB7E;:F G=FCH =;: = H988=@I 7? >DC CF;CHJ


36/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 56


37/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 56


38/39

!"#$ &' ()$ $*+"((,$- $*.,&/$0 1 *"0!) 2345 56

$789:8; !?


39/39

!789:;8 7?@A? B7

case of the embattled employer8

Documents