case outline transportation - 4th year

8/13/2019 Case Outline Transportation - 4th Year

1/12

COMMERCIAL LAW REVIEW

Transportation Laws

Case Outline

Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

COMMON CARRIERS

I. COMMON CARRIERS IN ENERALArt. ! Case Title Citation"R !"#ate

A Laws

Appli$a%le

&'()

&'**

PAL v. CA 6 Mar 1992

American Home v. CA 5 May 1992

+ Contra$t o,Carria-e British Airways v. CA 9 Feb 1993

C #e,inition o,

Common

Carrier

&') e !"#man v. CA 22 ec 19$$

Bascos v. CA % A&r 1993

'ationa( )tee( v. CA 12 ec 199%

Fabre v. CA 26 *"( 1996

First Phi(i&&ine Pi&e(ine v. CA 29 ec 199$

Ca(vo v. +CPB 19 Mar 2,,2

F!+ -ns"rance v. )armiento 6 A" 2,,2

Phi(amen v. P/) )hi&&in 9 A&r 2,,3

Asia Lihterae v. CA 19 A" 2,,3

Crisostomo v. CA 25 A" 2,,3

)chmit# 0rans&ort v. 0- 22 A&r 2,,5

Loamaster v. !(oe( 1, *an 2,11

# Nature an/

+asis o,

Lia%ility"

+rea$0 o,

Contra$t

&')) Canco v. Mani(a ai(roa 14 ct 191$

Meina v. Cresencia 11 *"( 1956

PAL v. CA 31 *"( 19$1

H v. Loren#o )hi&&in % Feb 2,,5

'orthwest Air(ines v. Chion 31 *an 2,,$Aboiti# v. -C'A ,6 A" 2,,$

Phi(i&&ines First v. a((em 26 Mar 2,,9

E Lia%ility o,

re-istere/

owner

Beneicto v. -AC 19 *"( 199,

BA Finance v. CA 13 'ov 1992

1 State

Re-ulation

&'*( Fisher v. 7anco )teamshi& 31 Mar 1915

Pantranco v. CA 26 *"ne 194,

PAL v. CAB 26 Mar 199%

Can a Home -ns"rance v. American 4 A&r 196$


2/12

$ommon

$arrier

%e$ome a

pri2ate

$arrier3

Araa v. CA 1 *"( 1992

P(anters Pro"cts v. CA 15 )e& 1993

Loastar )hi&&in v. CA 2$ )e& 1999

II. COMMON CARRIER O1 OO#SArt. Case Title #ate"R!

A Vi-ilan$e O2er oo/s

1 Liabi(ity 8or

Loss

Pres"m&tion

o8

'e(ience

&')4

&')(

7ncha"sti v. e:ter ec. 14;192,

Miraso( v. o((ar Mar 2%; 1929

)tanar ac""m v. L"#on )teveorin A&r 1$;1956

e !"#man v. CA 22 ec 19$$

Firemanar Co=a(ion v. +CPB !enera( *"n 25;2,,3?146,1$

Asia Lihterae an )hi&&in v. CA A" 19;2,,3?14%246

)@)enator Lines v. Feera( Phoeni: ct %;2,,3?1353%%

Centra( )hi&&in v. -C'A )e& 2,;2,,4?15,%51

&')8 Araa v. CA *"( 1;1992

Phi(amen v. MC! Marine Mar $;2,,2

F!+ -ns"rance Cor&. v. CA Mar 31;2,,5?13%%%5

)chmit# 0rans&ort v. 0rans&ort ent"re A&r 22;2,,5?15,255

&'49 Phi(amen v. CA May 1%;1993

2 Act o8

)hi&&er

&')46)7

&')&

Com&ania Maritima v. CA A" 29;19$$

0abaca(era v. 'orth Front May 16;199%

3 Character o8

!oos

&')4647

&'4

!overnment v. 7ncha"sti; )e& 29;1919

)o"thern Lines v. CA *an 31;1962

Ban=ers an Man"8act"rers v. CA ct 2;1992Ca(vo v. +CPB Mar 19;2,,2

Be(ian verseas v. PF-C *"n 5;2,,2


3/12

-ron B"(= )hi&&in v. eminton ec $;2,,3?13696,

AF )anche# Bro=erae v. CA ec 21;2,,4?14%,%9

PC-C v. +n=nown *"( $; 2,,5

CL o8 )ina&ore v. 'ether(ans )e& 4; 2,,9

4 rer o8

Com&etentA"thority

&')46(7

&'4)

!an#on v. CA May 3,;19$$

II. COMMON CARRIER O1 OO#S: $ont::::C #uration o,

Lia%ility

&')*

&')'

&');

Com&ania Maritima v. -ns"rance ct 3,;1964

L" o v. Binamira A&r 22;195%

)ervano v. Phi( )team ct 23;19$2

)amar Minin v. 'ore"scher ct 23;19$4

!an#on v. CA May 3,;19$$

0abaca(era -ns"rance v. 'orth Front May 16;199%

Phi(. Home Ass"rance Cor&. v. CA *"n 2,;1996PAL v. CA Mar 14;1996

PAL v. CA May 1%;1996

Ba(iwa 0ransit v. CA May 15;1996

Macam v. CA A" 25;1999

)chmit# 0rans&ort v. 0rans&ort ent"re A&r 22;2,,5

# A-reement Limitin-

Lia%ility

1 As to

i(ience

e"ire

&'44

&'4(

Home -ns"rance v. American A&r 4;196$

e !"#man v. CA ec 22;19$$

a(en#"e(a Harwoo v. CA *"n 3,;199%

2 As to

Amo"nt o8

Liabi(ity

&'48

&'(9

H.>. Heacoc= v. Maconray ct 3;1921

*. 7smae( v. Barreto 'ov 25;192%

'orthern v. Prince Line Feb 29;196,

)ea Lan v. -AC A" 31;19$%

Citae( Lines v. CA A&r. 25;199,

>verett )teamshi& v. CA ct. $; 199$

>ar Co=a(ion v. +CPB !enera( *"n 25;2,,3

)hewaram v. Phi(i&&ine Air(ines 1% )CA 6,n 7i" v. CA an Phi(i&&ine Air(ines 91 )CA 223

Pan American or( Airways v. -AC 164 )CA 26$

Pan American Airways v. a&aas 2,9 )CA 6%

3 Passener

Baae

&'(4 ob(es v. )antos )e& 6;194%

Pan American v. -AC A" 11;19$$

A(ita(ia v. -AC ec 4;199,

PAL v. CA Mar 6;1992

Cathay Paci8ic v. CA Mar 5;1993

)ar=ies 0o"rs v. CA ct. 2; 199%


4/12

E #elay in t0e #eli2ery o,

Car-o

Maers= Line v. CA May 1%;1993

III. COMMON CARRIER O1 PASSENERSArt.!

Case Title #ate"R!

A Nature o,

Responsi%ility

#e,inition

&')

&'))

&'((

1 Am&an v. !"ino@o 0ransit A&r 3,; 1953

2 Lanicho v B0C )e& 2,; 1956

3 -saac v. A.L. Ammen A" 23; 195%

4 La"na v. 0ionson A&r 3,; 1966

5 La Ma((orca v. e *es"s May 14; 1966

6 An"ran v. B"o May 2,; 1966

% Maranan v. Pere# *"n 26; 196%

$ B0C v. Ca"imba( *an 24; 196$

9 e( Casti((o v. *ayma(in Mar 1%; 19$2

1, as"e# v. CA )e& 13; 19$5

11 Mecenas v. CA ec 14; 19$9

12 !atcha(in v. e(im ct 21; 1991

13 0rans@Asia v. CA Mar 4; 1996

14 'eros 'aviation v. CA 'ov 1%; 199%

15 Cervantes v. CA Mar 25; 1999

16 Ca(a(as v. CA May 31; 2,,,

1% *ose v. CA *an 1$; 2,,,

1$ Barit"a v. Mercaer *an 23; 2,,1

+ Presumption o,

Ne-li-en$e

&'(* 1 Picart v. )mith Mar 15; 191$

2 Macawi(i v. Panay Mar 1;19563 )y v. Ma(ate 0a:icab 'ov 29;195%

4 Abeto v. PAL *"(y 3,;19$2

5 PAL v. 'LC )e& 2;19$3

6 Bache(or >:&ress v. CA *"(y 231;199,

% Ma((ari v. CA *an 31; 2,,,

C +rea$0 o,

Contra$t o,

Carria-e

&'(( 1 )inson v. CA 'ov 1$; 199%

2 Cathay Paci8ic v. a#"e# Mar 14; 2,,3

3 )ina&ore Air(ines v. Anion ec 1,; 2,,3

4 *a&an Air(ines v. As"ncion *an 2$; 2,,5

5 'orthwest v. Chion *an 31; 2,,$6 ector )hi&&in v. Macasa *"( 21; 2,,$

% *a&an Air(ines v. )imanan A&r 22; 2,,$

$ Phi(i&&ine Air(ines v. CA )e& 22; 2,,$

9 'orthwest v. Hashan Feb 3; 2,1,

# 1ortuitous E2ent

as a #e,ense

1 Lasam v. )mith Feb 2; 1924

2 'ecesito v. Paras *"n 3,; 195$

3 *"nti((a v. Fontanar May 31; 19$5

4 7obio v. CA ct 1%; 199%

5 !aca( v. PAL 1$3 )CA 1$9

6 Pi(a&i( v. CA ec 22; 19$9

% Fort"ne >:&ress v. CA Mar 1$; 1999

$ *AL v. CA A" %; 199$

9 )ina&ore Air(ines v. Anion ec 1,; 2,,3


5/12

III. COMMON CARRIER O1 PASSENERS: $ont:&ress v. Ca Mar 1$;1999

% -saac v. A( Ammen 1,1 PH-L 1,46

I Responsi%ility ,or

A$ts o,

Employees:

Stran-ers an/

Co?pa5

&'(8

&'*)

1 M v. Ba((esteros A&r 29;1966

2 Bacarro v. Castao 'ov 5;19$2

3 !aca( v. PAL Mar 15;199,

4 Fort"ne >:&ress v. CA Mar 1$;1999

5 L0 A"thority v. Marorie 'avia Feb 6; 2,,3

@ Lia%ility ,or

uasi?#eli$t

1 China Air(ines v. CA May 1$;199,

2 Ca(a(as v. CA May 31;2,,,

3 Phoeni: Constr"ction v. -AC Mar 1,; 19$%

4 P' v. CA ct 15; 2,,%5 y 0eban v. *ose Chin Feb 4; 2,,$

B Lia%ility to

Ste2e/ores

1 )"(&icio Lines v. CA *"(y 14; 1995

MARITIME COMMERCE

I. Intro/u$tionTopi$ Se$. ! Case Title #ate"R

P# 4'4 #e,inition o, Vessel )ec. 3


6/12

RA &8)'

Vessels eli-i%le ,or ri2er li$ense )ec. 911

Vessels e5empte/ ,rom ri2er

li$ense

)ec. 912

II. Co/e o, Commer$e

A. (')?(;( ? Intro/u$tionTopi$ Se$. ! Case Title #ate"R

(') wnershi& o8 vesse(s "biso v. ivera A" 1$;192,

+. Persons W0o TaDe Part in Maritime Commer$e

&. Art. (;* S0ip A-entTopi$ Se$. ! Case Title #ate"R

(;* Liabi(ity o8 shi& owner an

shi& aent

)tanar i( v. Caste(o ct 1$;1921

Maconray v. Provient ec 9; 2,,4

. Art. *98?*(& ? Captains an/ Masters o, VesselsTopi$ Se$. ! Case Title #ate"R

*98 D"a(i8ications o8 a Ca&tain Coastwise Lihterae v. CA 245 )CA %96

*&9 F"nctions o8 a Ca&tain -nter@orient Maritime v. 'LC 235 )CA 26$

*&:

*'

b(iations o8 the Ca&tain Haverton )hi&&in v. 'LC 135 )CA 6$5

Far >astern )hi&&in v. CA 29% )CA 3,i(va((ey )hi&&in v. CA ct 6; 2,,,

Centennia( v. e(a Cr"# A" 22; 2,,$

*&4

*&(

Prohibite Acts )weet Lines v. CA 121 )CA %69

*9)

*9;

ischare o8 ca&tain an

crew

Maria( )hi&&in v. i(vie ct 3,; 195$

a((em v. Minister o8 Labor 1,2 )CA $35

C. #o$trine o, Limite/ Lia%ilityArt. ! Topi$ Case Title #ate"Citation

(;'

(89

;)'

octrine o8 Limite Liabi(ity 7" v. ssorio *"n 14;1922

7anco v. Lasema ct 29;1941

Mani(a )teamshi& v. Ab"(haman )e& 19;1956

Ch"a 7e= Hon v. -AC )e& 3,; 19$$

Phi(Am!en v. CA *"n 11;199%

'eros 'aviation v. CA 2$1 )CA 532

Heirs o8 e(os )antos v. CA 1$6 )CA 649

Aboiti# )hi&&in v. !enera( Accient *an 21;1993

as"e# v. CA 13$ )CA 553Monarch -ns"rance v. CA *"n $;2,,,

Aboiti# )hi&&in v. 'ew -nia May 2;2,,6


7/12

Centra( )hi&&in v. -ns"rance )e& 2,; 2,,4

Aboiti# )hi&&in v. >"itab(e ct 1%; 2,,$

#. Art. *(?*;8 C0arter Parties

Art. ! Topi$ Case Title #ate"Citation/ins P(anters Pro"cts v. CA 226 )CA 4%6

"ano v. CA 211 )CA %4,

Ca(te: v. )"(&icio Lines 315 )CA %,9

Loastar )hi&&in v. Pioneer Asia *an 24;2,,6

*( Forma( e"irements Marim&erio Com&ania v. CA 156 )CA 36$

-nter&retation o8 )antiao Lihterae v. CA *"n 21; 2,,4

E. Art. '9*?'&;: )()?)'( +ills o, La/in-Art. ! Topi$ Case Title #ate"Citation

e8inition Maconray v. Commissioner 62 )CA 42%

/en H"a Pa&er Pro"cts v. CA Feb 12;199$

-ron B"(= )hi&&in v. eminton ec $; 2,,3

Ma(ayan v. *arine )e& 1$; 2,,9

MF Com&any v. )hin 0an ec 1$; 2,,9

)() )"rrener o8 BL Macam v. CA A" 25;1999

P EH v. Loren#o )hi&&in Feb %;2,,5

)** Prescri&tive Perio o(an v. Lim Pon#o 3% PH-L 2$5'ew Gea(an v. Ch"a *oy 9% PH-L 646

Feera( >:&ress v. American Home A" 1$; 2,,4

Phi(. Charter v. Chemoi( *"n 29; 2,,5

Loren#o )hi&&in v. Ch"bb *"n $; 2,,4

Aboiti# v. -C'A A" 6; 2,,$

)'9 e(ay in e(ivery o8 !oos +y Ch"aco v. Amira( Line 46 PH-L 41$

1. Art. '&8?')& Loans on +ottomry Respon/entia

. Art. ;9*?;4) #ama-es an/ A$$i/ents in Maritime Commer$eArt. ! Topi$ Case Title #ate"Citation

;9*?

;&*

Averaes Masaysay v. Aan 96 PH-L 5,4

)tanar i( v. Caste(o ct. 1$; 1921

**9?

**&

!oos 'ot Liab(e 8or Payment o8

Freiht

**( Liabi(ity o8 !oos 8or !enera(

Averae*'' >88ect o8 ec(aration o8 ar -nternationa( v. Hamb"r *"( 29;191$

Com&anie v. Hanb"r 36 PH-L 59,


8/12

') Liabi(ity o8 Leners 8or Averae

;&8?

;&

Arriva( +ner )tress

. Art. ;9*?;4) #ama-es an/ A$$i/ents in Maritime Commer$e: $ont v. Maritime 14$ )CA 11$

-nterr"&tion o8 &rescri&tive&erio

)tevens v. 'ore"tcher 6 )CA 1$,Aetna -ns"rance v. L"#on )teveorin 62 )CA 11

-ns"rance v. Phi(i&&ine Ports *"( 1$; 1965

An v. American )teamshi& *an 2%;196%

+CPB v. Aboiti# Feb 1,;2,,9

a((em v. ) Farms *"( 9; 2,1,

'ew or( v. '7/@Fi(*a&an A" 24; 2,11

>88ect o8 &rescri&tive &erio on

(iabi(ity o8 ins"rer

Mayer )tee( v. CA 2%4 )CA 432

Fi(i&ino Merchants v. CA 1%9 )CA 2,9

46(7 Limitation o8 Liabi(ity >astern )hi&&in v. -AC May 29; 19$%

>astern v. !reat American 1,$ )CA 24$

Be(ian verseas v. First -ns"rance *"n 5; 2,,2

PC-C v. 'e&t"ne *"n 12; 2,,$

+nsworth v. CA *"( 6; 2,1,


9/12

AIR TRANSPORTATIONSe$. Case Title #ate"Citation

A RA ''*

&

)

4

(

*'

;

e8inition o8 an Air Carrier ) 6,7

/ins o8 Air 0rans&ortation )

Com&osition o8 CAB (

Power o8 CAB &96A7

"ties o8 CAB &96C7

!overnment e"irement && PAL . CAB 2%, ) 53$

Pec"(iarity PAL v. CA 226 ) 423

A"thority EA 6235 ;

+ Warsaw Con2ention Art Case Title #ate"Cit

& A&&(icabi(ity &.&

Meanin &. Ma&a v. CA *"( $; 199%

)"ccessive Air Carriers &.) American Air(ines v. )a(as Mar 9;2,,,

Liabi(ity o8 Carrier &':&;

&8

'orthwest v. C"enca 14 ) 1,63

A(ita(ia v. -AC ec 4;199,

Limitation o8 Liabi(ity

A&&(icabi(ity

(

Pan Am v. -AC A" 11; 19$$

PAL v. CA Mar 6;1992

PAL v. CA Meia Mar 14;1996

British Airways v. CA 2$5 ) 45,

)antos v. 'orthwest rient *"n 23; 1992

)abena v. CA 255 ) 3$

L"na v. CA 'ov 2%;1992

'orthwest v. 0orres *an 29;199$

Com&(aint to the carrier * )ave((ano v. 'orthwest *"( $;2,,3

PAL v. CA Meia Mar 14;1996

Feera( >:&ress v. AHA A" 1$;2,,4

) en"e?*"risiction 8or Fi((in

Actions

; American Air(ines v. )a(as Mar 9;2,,,

Ma&a v. CA *"( $; 199%

)antos v. 'orthwest rient *"n 23; 1992

Lh"i((ier v. British Airways Mar 5; 2,1,

4 Prescri&tive Perio 8 +nite Air(ines v. i((ie +y 'ov 19;1999PAL v. )avi((o *"( 4; 2,,$


10/12

( )"ccessive Carriers )9 /LM oya( "tch v. CA *"n 22; 19%5

L"8thansa v. CA 'ov 24; 1994

China Air(ines v. Chio= *"( 2,; 2,,3

#AMAES RECOVERA+LE 1ROM COMMON CARRIERSTopi$ Art. ! Case Title #ate"Citation

A eneral

Pro2isions

&'*4

&8'

A(ita(ia v. CA *an 24;199,

MM0C v. CA 'ov 16;199$

Fort"ne >:&ress v. CA Mar 1$;1999

Ca(te: v. )"(&icio )e& 3,;1999

7" >n Cho v. Pan Am Mar 2%;2,,,

+ A$tual or

Compensatory

&88

9&9)

Cariaa v. L0B ec 29;196,

i((a ey v. CA Feb 1$;19%,Pan American v. -AC A" 31;19$%

!atcha(in v. e(im ct 21;1991

/orean Air(ines v. CA )e& 24;19$%

Pantranco v. CA ct $;199$

*ose v. CA *an 1$;2,,,

1 hen

amaes

May be

ecovere

9( )oberano v. M 'ov 23;1966

Marchan v. Meno#a A" 3,;196$

2 amaes in

Case

>A0H

cc"rs

9* 6&7 e Ca(iston v. CA *"ne 24;19$3

PAL v. CA May ; 199,

Heirs o8 Am&aro v. CA *"ne 2; 199,

'eros 'aviation v. CA 'ov %;199%

C Moral

#ama-es

9* 6)7 Cachero v. Mani(a 7e((ow May 23;195%

&*

&'

&8

9

Lo&e# v. Pan@Am Mar 3,;1966

Air France v. Carrascoso )e& 2$;1966

'orthwest Air(ines v. C"enca A" 31;1965

G"("eta v. Pan@Am *an $;19%3

rtias *r. v. L"8thansa *"ne 3,;19%5

Phi(. abbit v. >s"erra ct 23;19$2

)weet Lines v. CA A&r 2$;19$3

Pan Am v. -AC A" 31;19$%

/orean Air(ines v. CA )e& 24;19$%

0A v. CA A" 3,;19$$

Armovit v. CA A&r 2,;199,

PAL v. CA A" 13;199,

China Air(ines v. CA *"(y 29;1992

/orean Air(ines v. CA A" 3; 1994/ier"(8 v. CA Mar 13;199%

PAL v. CA *"(y 1%;199%


11/12

)inson v. CA 2$2 )CA 149

n v. CA *an 21;1999

Cervantes v. CA Mar 2; 1999

0an v. 'orthwest Mar 3;2,,,

Ca(a(as v. CA May 31;2,,,

+A v. Fontani((a A&r 2,; 2,,1

#AMAES RECOVERA+LE: $ont

case outline transportation - 4th year

Documents