Upload

Log InSign up

Browse

Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and

documents. See more ➡

 OF 427Download

REMLAW REVIEW CASE COMPILATION_Jurisdiction Til Rule 4Ratings: 0|Reads: 14,489|Likes: 139Published by cmv mendoza

original cases based on Prof. Herbosa's outline in remLaw review Remedial Law ReviewUniversity of the Philippines College of LawSecond Semester Yr 2010-2011Prof. TJ HerbosaJurisdictionSubject matter jurisdictionAllegations of complaint determine jurisdiction – Hasegawa et al v. Kitamura GR 149177 Nov 23, 2007Jurisdiction by estoppel – Figueroa v. People, GR 147407, Jul 14, 2008;Payment of filing fees -Ruby Shelter v. Hon. Formaran GR 174914 Feb 10, 2009Distinguished from venue – Chavez v. CA GR 125813 Feb 6, 2007Doctrine of non-interference – Springfield v. RTC Judge GR 142626 Feb 6, 2007Primary jurisdiction – Sta. Ana v. Carpo GR 164340 Nov 28, 2008Supreme CourtPhilippine Constitution,Article VIIIPower of judicial review – Garcillano v. House GR 170338 Dec 23, 2008Doctrine of stare decisis – Lazatin v. Desierto GR 147097 June 5, 2009Hierarchy of courts – Ferdinand Cruz v. Priscilla Mijares et al GR 154404 Sep 11, 2008;FirstUnited v. Poro Point GR 178799 Jan 19, 2009Appellate jurisdiction – First Lepanto Ceramics, Inc. v. CA, GR 110571, Mar 10, 1994SC Power of administrative supervision – Sarah Ampong v. CSC GR 167916 Aug 26, 2008Court of Appeals

1

BP 129, as amended by RA 7902,Sec. 9 and RA 8246Question of law , fact or both – CGP Transport v. PU Leasing GR 164547 Mar 28, 2007Court of Tax AppealsRA 9282SandiganbayanRA 8249Regional Trial CourtsBP 129, as amended by RA 7691, Sec. 5Incapable of pecuniary estimation -Bokingco v. CA, GR No. 161739, May 4, 2006;RCP v.CA GR 136109 Aug 1, 2002;Recovery  o f   possess ion – Honorio Bernardo v. Heirs of Eusebio Villegas GR 183357 Mar 15,2010;Encarnacion v. Amigo, GR No. 169793 Sep 15, 2006Issue of constitutionality – Planters Products v. Fertiphil GR 166006 Mar 14, 2008Quasi judicial agency – Badillo v. CA GR 131903 June 26, 2008CIAC – Fort Bonifacio v Domingo GR 180768 Feb 27, 2009RTC acting as Special Agrarian Court – Land Bank v. Ralla Balista GR 164631 Jun 26, 2009Default jurisdiction – Mun of Pateros v. CA GR 157714 Jun 16, 2009HLURB – Tricorp v. CA GR 165742 Jun 30, 2009;Ma. Luisa Dazon v. Kenneth Yap andPeople Jan 15, 2010Family CourtsSec 5, RA 8369 Family Courts Act of 1997A.M. No. 02-11-10-SC Rules on Declaration of Absolute Nullity of Void Marriages andAnnulment of Voidable MarriagesA.M. No. 02-11-11 Rule on Legal SeparationA.M. No. 02-11-12 Rule on Provisional OrdersA.M. No. 03-04-04-SC Rule on Custody of Minors and Writ of Habeas Corpus in Relation toCustody of MinorsA.M. No. 03-02-05-SC Rule on Guardianship of Minors Sunday, November 14, 201011:07 PM  REMLAW Page 1

 A.M. No. 02-6-02-SC Rule on AdoptionSummary Proceedings under the Family Code, Title XI, Chapters 1 to 3on separation in fact between husband and wife or abandonment by one of the other and incidents involving parental authority;Chapter 4on Art. 41 (declaration of a spouse as presumptively dead),Art. 51(action of a child for presumptive legitime),Art. 69 (judicial declaration of family domicile in case of disagreement of the spouses),Art. 73 (spouse’s objection to the profession of the other spouse),Arts. 96 and124 (annulment of husband’s decision in the administration and enjoyment of community or conjugal property; appointment of spouse as sole administrator except cases of “incompetent”other spouse which shall be under Rules 93 and 95)and Art. 217 (entrusting children to homes and orphanages).Madrinan v. Madrinan GR 159374 Jul 12, 2007Yu v Yu GR 164915 Mar 10, 2006Commercial CourtsSec. 5.2, RA 8799A.M. No. 01-2-04-SC Interim Rules of Procedure Governing Intra-corporate ControversiesA.M. 00-8-10-SC Interim Rules of Procedure on Corporate Rehabilitation (note FRIA)Oscar Reyes v. RTC Makati GR 165744 Aug 11, 2008Metropolitan Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts/Circuit Trial CourtsBP 129, as amended by RA 7691, Secs. 2 to 4Unlawful detainer v. agrarian dispute – Sps Fajardo v. Anita Flores GR 167891 Jan 15, 2010Recovery  o f   possess ion – Vda De Barrera et al v. Heirs of Vicente Legaspi GR 174346 Sept12, 2008;Ouano v. PGTT Gr No. 134230 July 7, 2002;Barangay LuponRA 7160 (Local Government Code of 1991) Secs 399-422Substantial compliance – Leo Wee v. George de Castro et al GR 1764095 Aug 20, 2008;Aquino v. Aure, GR 153567 Feb 18, 2008CIVIL PROCEDUREOrdinary Civil Actions Rules 1 to 39Rule 1 General Provisions of the Rules of CourtLiberal application – Makati Ins. V. Reyes et al GR 167403 Aug 6, 2008;Rural Bank of Seven Lakes v. Dan GR 174109 Dec 24, 2008;Rule 2 Cause of ActionElements of a cause of action -Ceroferr v. CA 376 SCRA 144;Camarines Sur Electric v.Aquino GR 167691 Sep 23, 2008Sufficiency of allegations – Vinzons-Chato v. Fortune GR 141309 Dec 23, 2008Splitting a cause of action – BPI Family v. De Coscuella, GR No. 167724, Jun 27, 2006Joinder of causes of action – UCPB v. Sps. Beluso GR 159912 Aug 17, 2007Rule 3 Parties to Civil ActionsReal party in interest – Carlos v. Sandoval GR 179922 Dec 16, 2008;Estreller v. Ysmael GR 170264 Mar 13, 2009Indispensable parties – Robert De Galicia v. Mercado, GR No. 146744, Mar 6, 2006;Lagunilla v. Velasco GR 169276 Jun 16, 2009;Josephine Marmo v Moises Anacay GR 182585 Nov 27 2009;Leonis Navigation v Catalina Villamater GR 179169 Mar 3, 2010 Necessary parties

 – Relucio v. Lopez 373 SCRA 578;AutoCorp v. Intra Strata GR 166662Jun 27, 2008Capac i ty to sue and be sued - Van ZuiDen v. GTVL Manufacturing 523 SCRA 233;Deutschev CA GR 152318 Apr 16, 2009Misjoinder/non-joinder of parties – Chua v. Torres GR 151900 Aug 30, 2005;Anicia ValdezTallorin v Heirs of Juanito Tarona GR 177429 Nov 24, 2009;Littie Sarah Agdeppa v Heirs of Ignacio Bonete GR 164436 Jan 15 2010Successors in interest – Sui Man Hui Chan v. CA, GR 147999, Feb 27, 2004Substitute parties – Carandang vs. Heirs of De Guzman GR 160347 Nov. 29, 2006;JudgeSumaljag v. Literato GR 149787 Jun 18, 2008;Domingo v Landicho GR 170015 Aug 29,2007; Napere v. Barbarona GR 160426 Jan 31, 2008Indigent parties – Sps Algura v. LGU GR 150135 Oct 30, 2006  REMLAW Page 2

  Rule 4 Venue of ActionsPersonal action – Uniwide v. Cruz GR 171456 Aug 9, 2007Real Action – Infante v. Aran Builders, GR 156594 Aug 24, 2007;HiYield v. CA GR 168863Jun 23, 2009Principal party ; when to object – Irene Marcos-Araneta v. CA GR 154096 Aug 22, 2008Stipulated venue not exclusive -Philbanking v. Tensuan, 230 SCRA 413;Spouses Lantin v.Judge Lantion, GR No. 160053, Aug 28, 2006Rule 5 Uniform Procedure in Trial CourtsRevised Rules on Summary ProcedureSummary procedure – Estate of Macadangdang v Gaviola GR 156809 Mar 4, 2009; AngelinaSoriente v Estate pf Arsenio Concepcion GR 160239 Nov 25 2009; Sps Edillo v Sps DulpinaGR 188360 Jan 21 2010Rule 6 Kinds of PleadingsAnswer   – Rosete v. Lim, GR No. 136051, Jun 8, 2006Compulsory counterclaim – Financial Builders. V. FPA 338 SCRA 346; Reillo v. San JoseGR 166393 Jun 18, 2009Permissive counterclaim – Banco de Oro v. CA GR 160354 Aug 25, 2005; Dec 19, 2007Third party complaint – Asian Construction v. CA 458 SCRA 750; Sy Tiong Shion v Sy ChinGR 174168/179438 Mar 30, 2009Cross-claim – Torres v. CA 49 SCRA 67Rule 7 Parts of a PleadingSufficient in form/substance – Sps Munsalado v. NHA GR 167181 Dec 23, 2008Signature of counsel – Republic v. Kenrich Dev. Do., GR No. 149576, August 8, 2006Verification/Certification – Madara v. Porillo GR 172449 Aug 20, 2008; Kaunlaran v. Uy GR 154974, Feb 4, 2008; Sps Valmonte v. Alcala GR 168667 Jul 23, 2008Who can sign w/o sec cert – Mid-Pasig Land v Mario Tablante GR 162924 Feb 4, 2010Rule 8 Manner of Making Allegations in PleadingsUltimate facts – Far East Marble v. CA GR 94093 Aug 10, 1993Specific denial under oath – Filipinas Textile v. CA 415 SCRA 635 No knowledge – Warner Barnes v. Reyes 103 Phil 602Modes of specific denial – Gaza et al v. Lim GR 126863 Jan 16, 2003;Actionable document – Casent Realty v. Philbanking GR 150731 Sep 14, 2007; Malayan v.Regis Brokerage GR 172156 Nov 23, 2007

Rule 9 Effect of Failure to Plead No default motu proprio – Santos v PNOC GR 170943 Sep 23, 2008Failure to appear  – Monzon v. Sps Relova GR 171827 Sep 17, 2008Remedies of party declared in default – Gomez v. Montalban GR 174414 Mar 14, 2008Default judgment – Gajudo v. Traders Royal GR 151098, Mar 21, 2006Rule 10 Amended and Supplemental PleadingsSubstantial amendment -PPA v. Gothong and Aboitiz GR 158401 Jan 28, 2008When amendments allowed -Quirao v. Quirao 414 SCRA 430; Bautista v. Maya-MayaCottages, GR 148361, Nov 29, 2005; Marcos-Araneta et al v. CA GR 154096 Aug 22, 2008Conform to evidence – Cagungun v. Planters Dev Bank GR 158674 Oct 17, 2005Rule 11 When to File Responsive PleadingSaturday, Sunday or legal holiday -Alarilla v. Ocampo 417 SCRA 601Rule 12 Bill of ParticularsWhen a complaint is vague – Bantillo v. IAC, GR No 75311, Oct. 18, 1988; Republic v. SBand Marcos, GR 148154, Dec 17, 2007Rule 13 Filing and Service of Pleadings, Judgments and Other PaperPersonal filing and service – Maceda, et al. v. Macatangay, GR 164947, Jan 31, 2006Service by registered mail -Andy Quelnan v. VHF Phil GR 138500, Sep16, 2005; MarcelinoDomingo v CA GR 169122 Feb 2 2010; Sps Belen v. Hon. Chavez, GR 175334, Mar 26, 2008Service upon counsel – GCP Many Transport v. Principe GR 141484, Nov 11, 2005 Notice of lis pendens – Sps Vicente v. Avera GR 169970 Jun 20, 2009  REMLAW Page 3

Activity (136)

Filters

Review Add note Like Embed

vocks_2000 liked this|about 1 month ago1 thousand reads|over 2 years ago1 hundred reads|over 2 years ago

Marites Cuyos liked this|2 months ago

azuka_devil6667485 liked this|2 months ago

maricel_aying liked this|2 months ago

Laila Esma Tan liked this|3 months ago

hambogalaga liked this|5 months ago

Liz Cruz-Kim liked this|5 months ago

monet_antonio liked this|6 months agoLoad moreRecommended

1. Duero vs. CA_digestEds Capanzana Brion

[BSL] CASE DOCTRINES IN CIVIL PROCEDURE (BRONDIAL)Butoy S. Lofranco

Case Digests on Civil Procedure (Part III)Danniel Ancheta

Asia's Emerging Dragon Corp vs DotcMedina Collegeoflaw

Civil Procedure Digest Pre Midtermskramsaga

RemLaw Class Notes for Quiz1_cha Mendozacmv mendoza

RemLaw Class Notes for Midterms_cha Mendozacmv mendoza

Civpro 1-28 Case DigestsPrincess Melody

Digest Special AssignmentTheHoneybhie

Crim Pro - Integration (1)ggfuentes

lagui reviewerraj-point

Red Notes: Remedial Lawjojitus

Criminal Procedure ReviewerChapapa

Remedial Law FaqKatrina Montes

The Benchbookraj-point

Crim Pro Digest 6cmv mendoza

Uncitral Model Lawcmv mendoza

Ateneo 2007 Civil ProcedureChapapa

2012 Bar Reviewer in Remedial LawGerry Micor

B2009 Labor Law Finals Reviewer (Part II Cont)lex libertadoreMore From This User

pnppopmanual2010cmv mendoza

Abra Valley College vs. Aquinocmv mendoza

8_Commissioner vs. CA (1996)cmv mendoza

5_Commissioner vs. CA (1998)cmv mendoza

Wells Fargo vs. Collectorcmv mendoza

Villanueva vs. City of Iloilocmv mendoza

Umali vs. Estanislaocmv mendoza

Tanada vs. Angaracmv mendoza

Tan vs. Del Rosariocmv mendoza

Taganito vs. Commissionercmv mendoza

Taganito vs. Commissioner (1995)cmv mendoza

Roxas vs. Raffertycmv mendoza

PLDT vs. City of Davaocmv mendoza

Philippine Acetylene vs. Commissionercmv mendoza

Pepsi Cola vs. Butuancmv mendoza

Pecson vs. CAcmv mendoza

Osmena vs. Orboscmv mendoza

Misamis Oriental Assn vs. Dept of Financecmv mendoza

7cmv mendoza

1_Conwi vs. CTA Digestcmv mendoza

Tax_notes

cmv mendoza

Tax 1 - terecmv mendoza

Requirements for RA 9480cmv mendoza

Republic Bank v Ebradacmv mendoza

RA 9480cmv mendoza

Download and print this document

Read offline in your PDF viewer Edit this document in Adobe Acrobat, Notepad Keep a copy in case this version is deleted from Scribd Read and print without ads Email the file

Choose a format:

.PDF .TXT

Download

Recommended

1. Duero vs. CA_digestEds Capanzana Brion

[BSL] CASE DOCTRINES IN CIVIL PROCEDU...Butoy S. Lofranco

COMPILATION OF CASES (DOCTRINES) UNDER ATTY. HENEDINO M. BRONDIAL | CIVIL PRO...

Case Digests on Civil Procedure (Part...Danniel Ancheta

Philippine Remedial Law

Asia's Emerging Dragon Corp vs DotcMedina CollegeoflawPrevious|NextPage 1 of 5

About

About Scribd Team Blog Join our team! Contact Us

Subscriptions

Subscribe today

Advertise with us

Get started AdChoices

Support

Help FAQ Press

Partners

Developers / API

Legal

Terms Privacy Copyright

Get Scribd Mobile

Mobile Site

© Copyright 2013 Scribd Inc.

Language:

English