cato institute amicus brief in amendment 3 appeal

8/12/2019 Cato Institute Amicus Brief in Amendment 3 appeal

1/47

!"#$ &'()&*+, &)(-..', &)(-../

0! 123

!"#$%& ($)$%* +,-.$ ,/ 011%)2* /,. $3% 4%"$3 +#.5-#$

43536 601723!,31 89$,

!"#$%&$''()*++,"",,(,

:$

;85IC"

7S!K101G10S!89 781S 0!K101G13

877SG!18=0901< 73!135 &...R@##@LFM#?EE# 8:?,!U

&O.. &+EF KE$, !U, KE? -.& U@#FIH\E"H, 47 O...&

U@#FIH\E"H, 4$7$ O..'/ NO.OQ +)O(.O..

NO.OQ O]/(/++]

?AIX@Y?EF^EF?M#L"H#EIEMEI"H$"C\

6278%(," 7' 4,97:/

278%(," '7: *;$9$ 28:$#,

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* +!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* +


2/47

I

"#$#%&%'# (%)$(*+') ,-'"%'# #- .+/%

1F? >@CEI?# F@:? BIA?J _IEF EF? 7"MCE YA@HV?E A?EE?C# "B L"H#?HE E"

EF? BIAIH\ "B #;$98( 98:$#, YCI?B#$ 8LL"CJIH\AZ, 7@E" 0H#EIEME? @HJ

7"H#EIEMEI"H@A 8LL"MHE@YIAIEZ 7?HE?C F@:? L"H#?HE E" BIA? EFI# YCI?B$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 9!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 9


3/47

II

,-(0-($#% *+",/-"1(% "#$#%&%'#

TMC#M@HE E" 5MA? O/$& "B EF? W?J?C@A 5MA?# "B 8>>?AA@E? TC"L?JMC?,

#;$9$#E@E? EF@E H?IEF?C "C\@HIX@EI"H I# @ >MYAILAZ(F?AJ L"C>"C@EI"H, H"C

J" EF?Z I##M? #E"LV "C F@:? >@C?HE L"C>"C@EI"H#$ *;$9$ @C? H"H(>C"BIE

-.&NLQN'Q "C\@HIX@EI"H#$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ,!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ,


4/47

III

#$2/% -. ,-'#%'#"

KE@E?D?HE 5?\@CJIH\ 7"H#?HE E" WIA? $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ I

7"C>"C@E? 4I#LA"#MC? KE@E?D?HE $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ II

1@YA? "B 7"HE?HE# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ III

1@YA? "B 8MEF"CIEI?# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ I:

0HE?C?#E "B EF?*;$9$ 28:$#,


5/47


6/47

:

#$2/% -. $1#3-(+#+%" 789:;?

0456

D7 *A J7E ?< K8%#%,

&O W$ 7@#$ O-O N7$7$4$ 7@A$ &+*]Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &/(&*

1""$%7$( B&, 5;+"7@,,( 278%9$" LM ?< N,E$(,

)*' W$OJ -/& N*EF 7IC$ &]*OQ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ '.

O,:&H

O.&' U9 //]*+*) N4$ GE@F 4?L$, O., O.&'Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ O*(O+

N#E:,%9, ?< P,C#(,

-'] G$K$ --+ NO..'Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ O+

N7?$%G ?< Q$:G$%$#,

'++ G$K$ & N&]/*Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$+#(($;0


7/47

:I

#$2/% -. $1#3-(+#+%" 789:;?

0456

!"@",: ?< .7,,

)-* G$K$ O.O N&]+OQ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &'

47;,: ?< 5?#%(,

-&* G$K$ /O. N&]]/Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$+#(($;

48% ?< 4,+8>"$9#% !#:&@ 7' 1""$%7$(,

)]* G$K$ /O N&]].Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ O+(O]

B,9(@(H NN2 ?< Q$G$",

/// W$'J /*+ N&.EF 7IC$ O.&OQ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ -(/

BF$%%,: ?< SF"#A7;# ,C :,"< T$""$#;(7%,

'&/ G$K$ -'- N&])OQ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ O, OO(O-

B;$&AF"$%, =,,9A#; 27:+< ?< *>>7&& N#>(


8/47

:II

#$2/% -. $1#3-(+#+%" 789:;?

0456

V#>"79F$ ?< 4,/A#$",

)') G$K$ '*) N&]*+Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ', O'(O/

7"H#EIEMEI"H@A TC":I#I"H#, KE@EME?#, @HJ 9?\I#A@EI:? R@E?CI@A#

G$K$7S!K1$@D?HJ$d0b $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$+#(($;

7"H\$ ;A"Y?P

']EF7"H\$, EK?##$ N&+//QP

'&+ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ O.

')' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &](O.

-.) $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &]

&.]. $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ +

&.]' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ](&.

&O/' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &.

O)-] $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &)

O)/O $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &)

O-.O $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &)

O-'] $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ *

O*// $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &O(&'

O]/& $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ *, &'

@>>$ O&] $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &'

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 0!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 0


9/47


10/47

I`

#$2/% -. $1#3-(+#+%" 789:;?

0456

W5334SRP84S7GR3!185< 20K1S5< SW 3R8!70T810S!, &+/&(&+/*

N0$ =?CAIH ?E @A$ ?J#$ &]+OQ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ O&

6MCE 1$ 9@#F, PA, 27%(&$&8&$7%#" 4,',:,%/8; 7' XYZZ[ *%/:,E O7A%(7%

#%/ &A, S:$G$%#" 0,#%$%G 7' &A, !:$?$",G,( 7: 1;;8%$&$,( 2"#8(,,

&.& ;3S$9$c$ &O*- NO.&'Q $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &)

93S! W$901U876,=33! 0! 123 K1S5R KS 9S!;P1238W135R812 SW

K98b35


11/47


12/47


13/47

'

-)& N&])OQQ, >C"FIYIEIH\ @CYIEC@CZ @HJ IH:IJI"M# JI#LCIDIH@EI"H @HJ

#?LMCIH\ ?aM@A CI\FE# B"C @AA LA@##?# @HJ \C"M># "B >?C#"H#$

1F? 7"H#EIEMEI"H @A#" >C"E?LE# BMHJ@D?HE@A CI\FE# MHJ?C EF?

#MY#E@HEI:? AIY?CEZ >C":I#I"H# "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE$ 1F?

KM>C?D?

C""E

MHJ?C EF? A@_ @HJ ?

>C"E?LEI"H B"C #MY#E@HEI:? AIY?CEZ$ B,,H ,A?# $

1F? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJ >C"E?LEI"H "B ?aM@AIEZ @HJ #MY#E@HEI:?

AIY?CEZ L"H:?C\? IH #?LMCIH\ E" @AA >?C#"H# @H ?aM@A CI\FE E" D@CCZ$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* +,!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* +,


14/47

)

0H EFI# YCI?B, #;$9$ #>?LIBIL@AAZ B"LM# "H #M>>"CEIH\ TA@IHEIBB#(

@C\MD?HE B"C D@CCI@\? ?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H

7A@M#? "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE$ 1FI# YCI?B _IAA J?D"H#EC@E? EF@E

EF? E?`E "B EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? _@# IHE?HJ?J E" Y? MHI:?C#@A IH

GHIE?J KE@E?#h EF@E EFI# YC"@J @HJ #_??>IH\ \M@C@HE?? "B ?aM@AIEZ "B

C@EIBIL@EI"H E" >C"E?LE @HZ >?C#"H, "B @HZ \C"M> "C LA@##h @HJ EF@E, IH

A""VIH\ E" _F@E CI\FE# _?C? MHJ?C#E""J E" Y? >C"E?LE?J ?aM@AAZ, EF?

BC@D?C# "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE MHJ?C#E""J #E@E?(#@HLEI"H?J

D@CCI@\? @# @ >?C#"H@A, IHJI:IJM@A CI\FE EF@E DM#E Y? D@J? @:@IA@YA? "H

@H ?aM@A Y@#I# E" @AA >?C#"H#$ 8# EF? KM>C?D? 7"MCE C?L?HEAZ ?`>A@IH?J

IH T$%/(7:, i#jE@E? A@_# J?BIHIH\ @HJ C?\MA@EIH\ D@CCI@\?, "B L"MC#?,

DM#E C?#>?LE EF &'' K$ 7E$ @E O/]&$

1F? E?`E @HJ FI#E"CZ "B EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? D@V? LA?@C

EF@E EF? LF@AA?H\?J D@CCI@\? A@_# "B GE@F @HJ SVA@F"D@

MHL"H#EIEMEI"H@AAZ J?HZ EF? ?aM@A >C"E?LEI"H "B EF? A@_# C?\@CJIH\

D@CCI@\? E" #@D?(#?` L"M>A?#, @HJ >?C>?EC@E? @H ID>?CDI##IYA? IHfMCZ

E" EF?#? L"M >?C#"H@A JI\HIEZ$ B,,O


15/47

-

-&& G$K$ &O*, &-' N&]])Q N6?HH?JZ, c$, L"HLMCCIH\Q$ 9IV? EF? >C":I#I"H

"B EF? 4?B?H#? "B R@CCI@\? 8LE IH:@AIJ@E?J IH T$%/(7:, EF?#? #E@E? A@_#

J?D?@H i#@D?(#?`j L"M>A?i#j, _F"#? D"C@A @HJ

ij $ $ $

EF"M#@HJ# "B LFIAJC?H H"_ Y?IH\ C@I#?J YZ #@D?(#?` L"M T$%/(7:,

&'' K$ 7E$ @E O/])$ 1F? D@CCI@\? A@_# "B Y"EF GE@F @HJ SVA@F"D@, IH

EC?@EIH\ #@D?(#?` @HJ ">>"#IE?(#?` L"M>A?# JIBB?C?HEAZ, J?HZ \@Z D?H

@HJ A?#YI@H# EF? AIY?CEZ E" D@CCZ EF? >?C#"H "B EF?IC "_H LF""#IH\$

1F?Z EFM# >A@L? @ Y@J\? "B IHB?CI"CIEZ_IEF EF? BMAA @MEF"CIEZ "B EF?

KE@E? Y?FIHJ IE"H #@D?(

1FI# #E@E? @LEI"H

N7?$%G, '++ G$K$ @E &O$ 0E

EF@E F@# \MIJ?J

"MC H@EI"H #IHL? IE# B"MHJIH\$

$()1&%'#

+B #3% #%C# -. #3% %D1$/ 0(-#%,#+-' ,/$1"%1'$&2+)1-1"/A 0(-#%,#" $// 0%("-'" .(-&

$(2+#($(A $'* +'E+*+-1" *+",(+&+'$#+-'

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* +@!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* +@


16/47

/

8D?HJD?HE _@# _CIEE?H @HJ C@EIBI?J IH EF? @BE?CD@EF "B EF? 7I:IA U@C

@HJ EF? ?HJ "B #A@:?CZ, IE >C"E?LE# #"">?C#"H# "B"MHJ C?L"\HIEI"H "B

B,9(@(H NN2 ?< Q$G$",

/// W$'J /*+, /+) N&.EF 7IC$ O.&OQ$ 0E #?LMC?# EF? #@D? CI\FE# @HJ #@D?

>C"E?LEI"H MHJ?C EF? A@_ B"C @AA D?H @HJ _"D?H, "B @HZ C@L?, _F?EF?C

Z"MH\ "C "AJ, LIEIX?H "C @AI?H, \@Z "C #EC@I\FE$ B,,U$9F T7< ?< D7+F$%(,

&&+ G$K$ '-/, '/] N&++

@>>AIL@EI"H, E" @AA >?C#"H# _IEFIH EF? E?CCIE"CI@A fMCI#JILEI"H, _IEF"ME

C? 2$?$"

4$GA&( 2#(,( E

?`E?HJ# IE# >C"E?LEI"H E" C@L?# @HJ LA@##?#, @HJ >C"FIYIE# @HZ #E@E?

A?\I#A@EI"H _FILF F@# EF? ?BB?LE "B J?HZIH\ E" @HZ C@L? "C LA@##, "C E" @HZ

H#I\H?J E" EF? #E@EM# "B @

47;,:, -&* G$K$ @E /'-$

\M@C@HE?? E" YCIH\ EF? 7"H#EIEMEI"H Y@LV IHE" AIH? _IEF BMHJ@D?HE@A

>CIHLI>A?# "B 8D?CIL@H ?aM@AIEZ @# #?E B"CEF IH EF? 4?LA@C@EI"H "B

0HJ?>?HJ?HL?, _FILF F@J Y??H Y?EC@Z?J @HJ #EMHE?J YZ EF? IH#EIEMEI"H

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* +A!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* +A


17/47

*

"B #A@:?CZ$ B,, 09.7%#"/ ?< 2$&@ 7' 2A$9#G7, &'. K$ 7E$ '.O., '.-]

E" >C"E?LE IE, _?C? ICC?L"HLIA@YA? _IEF EF? >CIHLI>A?# "B ?aM@AIEZ $ $ $ @HJ

IH@AI?H@YA? CI\FE# >C"LA@ID?J YZ EF? 4?LA@C@EI"H "B 0HJ?>?HJ?HL? @HJ

_FILF EF? 7"H#EIEMEI"H #@HLEI"H?J C@LI@A #A@:?CZ @HJ EF? KM>C?D?

7"MCE B"MHJ EF@E 8BCI

.:,/ B97&& ?C"DI#? "B AIY?CEZ B"C @AA >?C

>C" (?:IJ?HE @HJ fM#E EF@E H" D@H $ $ $

L@H B@IA E" #?? @HJ @> 1/


18/47

+

1F? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE, "B L"MC#?, _@# IHE?HJ?J H"E "HAZ E"

C?#E"C? EF? \M@C@HE?? "B ?aM@AIEZ E" IE# CI\FEBMA L"H#EIEMEI"H@A >A@L?, YME

@A#" E" #?LMC? @ YC"@J, MHI:?C#@A \M@C@HE?? "B ?aM@A CI\FE# EF@E _"MAJ

>C"E?LE #""

B"LM#?J "H ?H#MCIH\ ?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C EF? A@_ B"C H?_AZ BC??J #A@:?#, EF?Z

_C"E? EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? E" ?AIDIH@E? @ _F"A? F"#E "B

JI#LCIDIH@E"CZ #E@E? >C@LEIL?#, H"E fM#E JI#LCIDIH@EI"H "H EF? Y@#I# "B

C@L?, EFC"M\F"ME EF? H@EI"H$ 1FI# YC"@J :I?_ "B EF? #L">? "B EF? 3aM@A

J OC"E?LEI"H IH ?:?CZ KE@E? IH EFI# GHI"H

?, ']EF7"H\$,

EK?##$ &.]. N&+//Q$ 0HJ??J, IH &+*., E_" Z?@C# @BE?C EF? W"MCE??HEF

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* +0!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* +0


19/47

]

C@EIBIL@EI"H, 7"H\C?## M#?J IE# ?`>C?## L"H#EIEMEI"H@A

E" @AA >?C#"H# YZ >@##IH\ EF? 3HB"CL?D?HE 8LE "B &+*.$ 1FI# 8LE #?LMC?J

E" EF? #@D?

CI\FE $ $ $ E" D@V? @HJ ?HB"CL? L"HEC@LE#, E" #M?, Y? >@CEI?#, \I:?

?:IJ?HL?, @HJ E" EF? BMAA @HJ ?aM@A Y?H?BIE "B @AA A@_# @HJ >C"L??JIH\#

B"C EF? #?LMCIEZ "B >?C#"H @HJ >C">?CEZ @# I# ?H

YZ EF? A@#E >C?L?JIH\ #?LEI"H "B EFI# @LE, "C E" JIBB?C?HE >MHI#FD?HE,

>@IH#, "C >?H@AEI?# "H @LL"MHE "B #MLF >?C#"H Y?

KE@E$ &)., &))h 7"H\$ ;A"Y?, )E7"H\$, OHJ

>C"E?LE 7FIH?#? @AI?H# "C @HZ "EF?C @AI?H# _F"D _? @AA"_ E" L"D? F?C?,

$ $ $h A?E EF?D Y? >C"E?LE?J YZ @AA EF? A@_# @HJ EF? #@D? A@_# EF@E "EF?C

D?H $/C"E?LEI"H "B EF?

A@_# E" ?H#MC? EF@E K"MEF?CH #E@E? \":?CHD?HE# C?#>?LE?J EF?IC

BMHJ@D?HE@A CI\FE#$ 09.7%#"/, &'. K$ 7E$ @E '.)' NJI#LM##IH\ EF?

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* +8!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* +8


20/47

&.

;A"Y?, ']EF 7"H\$, E

@D?HJD?HE I# ?##?HEI@

F@:? H" #?LMCIEZ IH EF? BMEMC? ?`L?>E YZ B"CL? "B H@EI"H@A A@_# \I:IH\

$/?C#"H# _IEFIH EF? GHIE?J KE@E?#, EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJ D?C#

LF"#? YC"@J MHI:?C#@A A@H\M@\? #>?LIBIL@AAZ IHE?HJ?J E" >C"FIYIE

@CYIEC@CZ @HJ IH:IJI"M# JI#LCIDIH@EI"H @HJ #?LMC? ?aM@A CI\FE# B"C @AA$O

O

TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? @BE?C @H ?`F@M#EI:? IH:?#EI\@EI"H YZ EF? c"IHE 7"DDIEE?? "H

5?L"H#ECMLEI"H, _FILF E""V EF? A?@J IH JC@BEIH\ EF? 8D?HJD?HE IH 7"H\C?##$ 1F?

YZ R?DY?C# "B EF? ']EF 09.7%#"/, &'. K$ 7E$ @E

'.'], B"MHJ EF@E EF? K"MEF?CH #E@E?# C?BM#?J E" >A@L? EF? L"A"C?J C@L?M>"H E?CD#

JAZ E" EF? GHI"H, Y? 53TS51 SW 123 cS0!1 7SRR01133 S! 537S!K15G710S!

`:II N&+//Q$ 8# EF? ?`E?H#I:? E?#EID"HZ E@V?H YZ EF? c"IHE 7"DDIEE?? #F"_?J, EF?

BC??J #A@:?# @HJ EF?IC GHI"HI#E @AAI?# F@J @# DMLF LF@HL? "B F@:IH\ EF?IC ?aM@A

CI\FE# C? 1/E 00, &*$ 8LL"CJIH\AZ, EF?

L"DDIEE?? LF@C\?J _IEF JC@BEIH\ EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE _C"E? EF? 3aM@A

TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? E" ?AIDIH@E? #E@E? A@_# @HJ >C@LEIL?# EF@E :I"A@E?J EF?

BMHJ@D?HE@A CI\FE# "B >@CEILMA@C LA@##?# "B >?">A?, Y@#?J "H D"C? EF@H fM#E C@L?$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 97!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 97


21/47

&&

1F? c"IHE 7"DDIEE?? EF@E JC@BE?J EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE C?f?LE?J

HMD?C"M# >C">"#@A# EF@E _"MAJ F@:? AIDIE?J EF? W"MCE??HEF

JI#LCIDIH@E?J "H @LL"MHE "B C@L?, >C?B?CCIH\ EF? MHI:?C#@A \M@C@HE?? "B

?aM@A >C"E?LEI"H, _FILF #?LMC?J ?aM@A CI\FE# E" @AA >?C#"H#, E" @ C@L?(

#>?LIBIL \M@C@HE?? "B ?aM@AIEZ EF@E >C"#LCIY?J C@LI@A JI#LCIDIH@EI"H @HJ

H"EFIH\ ?A#?$ B,,=3!c8R0! =$ 63!45076, 123 cSG5!89 SW 123 cS0!1

7SRR01133 SW W0W133! S! 537S!K15G710S!)/, -., +' N&]&)Q$ UF?EF?C

EF? >C">"#@A# _?C? YC"@J IH #L">? "C _?C? H@CC"_AZ JC@BE?J E" >C"FIYIE

C@LI@A JI#LCIDIH@EI"H IH LI:IA CI\FE#, EF? BC@D?C# L"H#I#E?HEAZ C?f?LE?J

@LI@A

JI#LCIDIH@EI"H$ B,, OC"FIYIE JI#

L"H#IJ?C@EI"H @HJ A@E?C C@E

86209 53348R85,123 =099 SW 50;21KP753810S! 8!4 537S!K15G710S!

O/.(

\?H?C@A AIY?CEZ @HJ ?aM@AI

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 9+!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 9+


22/47

&O

>C"E?LEI"H D?@HE, BIC#E @HJ B"C?D"#E, ?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C EF? A@_ @HJ

?aM@AIEZ "B CI\FE# B"C @AA >?C#"H#$ GHJ?C EF? >A@IH E?`E, EFI# #_??>IH\

\M@C@HE?? MH@DYI\M"M#AZ @>>AI?# E" EF? >A@IHEIBB# IH EFI# L@#? @HJ E" @AA

\@Z D?H @HJ A?#YI@H# _F" _I#F E" ?`?CLI#? EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ EF?

>?C#"H "B EF?IC LF"IL?$

++B #3% -(+)+'$/ &%$'+') -. #3% %D1$/ 0(-#%,#+-',/$1"% ,-'.+(&" #3$# +#" )1$($'#%% -. %D1$/

(+)3#" $'* %D1$/+#A 1'*%( #3% /$F $00/+%"

2(-$*/A #- $// 0%("-'"

1F? "CI\IH@A D?@HIH\ "B EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? L"HBICD#

_F@E EF? E?`E D@V?# LA?@CP EF@E ?aM@AIEZ "B CI\FE# @HJ ?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C

EF? A@_ @>>AZ YC"@JAZ E" @HZ @HJ @AA >?C#"H# _IEFIH EF? GHIE?J KE@E?#$

L"H\C?##I"H@A J?Y@E?#, >C?## L":?C@\? "B EF? >C">"#@A @HJ C@EIBIL@EI"H

?LI#I"H# IHE?C>C?EIH\ EF?

7A@M#? @AA @BBICD EFI# Y@#IL MHJ?C#E@HJIH\$

0HEC"JMLIH\ EF? 8D?HJD?HE IH EF? K?H@E?, c@L"Y 2"_@CJ

#E@YAI#F?# ?aM@AIEZ Y?B"C?

EF? A@_, @HJ $ $ $ \I:?# E" EF? FMDYA?#E, EF? >""C?#E, @HJ D"#E J?#>I#?J

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 99!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 99


23/47

&'

$ $ $ EF? #@D? CI\FE# @HJ EF? #@D? >C"E?LEI"H Y?B"C? EF? A@_ @# IE \I:?# E"

;A"Y?, ']EF

7"H\$, E

K?##$ O*// N&+//Q$ 1F? \M@C@HE?? "B ?aM@A

>C"E?L A?\I#A@EI"H IH EF? KE@E?# @HJ

J"?# @_@Z _IEF EF? IHfM#EIL? "B #MYf?LEIH\ "H? L@#E? "B >?C#"H# E" @ L"J?

H"E @>>AIL@YA? E" @H"EF?C$ $ $ $ 0E >C"E?LE# EF? YA@LV D@H IH FI#

BMHJ@D?HE@A CI\FE# @# @ LIEIX?H _IEF EF? #@D? #FI?AJ _FILF IE EFC"_#

":?C EF? _FIE? D 1/< B,, #"(7 $/$ O&] N?`>A@IHIH\ EF@E EF? 7A@M#? _@# H?L?##@CZ

Y? $ $ $ E"

J?HZ E" @AA LA@##?# "B IE# LIE

W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HEH?:?C

H?_#>@ 09.7%#"/, &'. K$ 7E$ @E '.*) N1F"D@#,

c$, L"HLMCCIH\Q

IHE?HJ?J E" _"CV H"EFIH\ A?## EF@H EF? @Y"AIEI"H "B @AA L@#E?(Y@#?J @HJ

IH:IJI"M# LA@##( !"@",: ?< .7,, )-* G$K$ O.O, O&'

@AIEZ _F?C? EF? CI\FE# "B >?C#"H# @C? @E

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 9,!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 9,


24/47

&)

47;,:

L"DD"H

1$ 9@#F, PA, 27%(&$&8&$7%#" 4,',:,%/8; 7' XYZZ[ *%/:,E O7A%(7% #%/

&A, S:$G$%#" 0,#%$%G 7' &A, !:$?$",G,( 7: 1;;8%$&$,( 2"#8(,H &.& ;3S$

9$c$&O*-,&O]](&'..NO.&'Q$

0H EF? 2"M#?, EF? BC@D?C#, E"", ?D>F@#IX?J EF@E ?aM@AIEZ "B CI\FE#

@HJ ?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C EF? A@_ _?C? EF? E"MLF#E"H? "B EF? ?aM@A >C"E?LEI"H

UF@E?:

7"H\$ ;A"Y?, ']EF 7"H\$, E K?##$ O)-] N&+//Q, _FIA? BMEMC? TC?#IJ?HE

LIEIX?H, _IEF 1/A@IH D?@HIH\ "B ?aM@A >C"E?LEI"H, BC@D?C @BE?C BC@D?C

">?C@E? ,\8#""@ $/F@#I# IH "CI\IH@AQ, EF?C?YZ

AIEZ "B CI\FE# E" @AA LIEIX?H# "B EF? GHIE?J KE@E?#, @HJ "B

@AA >?C#"H# _IEFIH EF?IC fMCI#J 1/


25/47


26/47

&/

0H #F"CE, IE _@# L"DD"HAZ MHJ?C#E""J @E EF? EID? EF? W"MCE??HEF

IHE?HJ?J E" >C"D"E? ?aM@AIEZ IH EF? KE@E?#, @HJ E" E@V? BC"D EF? KE@E?#

EF? >"_?C E" D@V? LA@## A?\I#A@EI"H @HJ E" LC?@E? IH?aM@AIEZ @D"H\ EF?IC

>?">A HJ7"H\$, OHJK?##$ +)* N&+*OQ$

7"H#I#E?HE _IEF EFI# FI#E"CZ @HJ EF? LA?@C @HJ MH?aMI:"L@A

L"H#EIEMEI"H@A E?`E, EF? KM>C?D? 7"MCE aMILVAZ L"HBICD?J EF? YC"@J

A@_ @H

W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE D@V?# H" @EE?D>E E" ?HMD?C@E? EF? CI\FE# IE

iI#j J?#I\H?J E" >C"E?LE$ 0E #>?@V# IH \?H?C@A E?CD#, @HJ EF"#? @C? @#

L"D>C?F?H#I:? @# >"##IYA?$ 0E# A@H\M@\? I# >C"FIYIE"CZh YME ?:?CZ

>C"FIYIEI"H ID>AI?# EF? ?`I#E?HL? "B CI\FE# @HJ IDDMHIEI?#, >C"DIH?HE

@D"H\ _FILF I# @H IDDMHIEZ BC"D IH?aM@AIEZ "B A?\@A >C"E?LEI"H, ?IEF?C

B&:#8/,: ?< T,(& Q$:G$%$#, &.. G$K$ '.',

'&. N&++.Q$ B,, #"(7=#:>$,: ?< 27%%7""@

B"MCE??HEF @D?HJD?HE $ $ $ MHJ"MYE?JAZ IHE?HJ?J $ $ $ EF@E ?aM@A

>C"E?LEI"H @HJ #?LMCIEZ #F"MAJ Y? \I:?H E" @AA MHJ?C AIV? LICLMD#E@HL?#

IH EF? ?Hf"ZD?HE "B EF?IC >?C#"H@A @HJ LI:IA CI\FE#h EF@E @AA >?C#"H#

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 9A!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 9A


27/47

&*

#F"MA 2$?$" 4$GA&(

2#(,(

>C"FIYIEI"H# "B EF? W"MC D7 *A J7E ?C?D? 7"MCE EMCH?J IE# Y@LV "H

EF?#? >CIHLI>A?#, M>F"AJIH\ ?HB"CL?J C@LI@A #?\C?\@EI"H "H EF? EF?"CZ EF@E A@_#

C?aMICIH\ EF? #?>@C@EI"H "B 8BCIL@H 8D?CIL@H# @HJ _FIE? >?C#"H# IH >MYAIL >A@L?#

1/?CI"C, J"DIH@HE CMAIH\ LA@## "B LIEIX?H#$

1F?C? I# H" L@#E? F?C?$ SMC L"H#EIEMEI"H I# L"A"C(YAIHJ, @HJ H?IEF?C VH"_# H"C

E"A?C@E?# LA@##?# @D"H\ LIEIX?H#$ 0H C?#>?LE "B LI:IA CI\FE#, @AA LIEIX?H# @C? ?aM@A

1/


28/47

&+

FJC@_# BC"D ;":?CHD?HE EF? >"_?C E" J?\C@J? "C J?D?@H,

#

A?#YI@H# L"M>A?#, J?HZ EF?IC ?aM@A JI\HIEZ, @HJ EC?@E EF?IC A":IH\

C?A@EI"H#FI># @ ?#>?LE?J EF T$%/(7:, &&' K$ 7E$ @E

O/]-, O/]/h B;$&AF"$%, =,,9A#; 27:+< ?< *>>7&& N#>($ @E O- N]EF 7IC$ c@H$ O&, O.&)Q N?`>A@IHIH\ EF@E T$%/(7:

H?IEF?C #?HJ H"C C?IHB"CL? D?##@\?# "B #EI\D@ "C #?L"HJ LA@## #E@EM#$

GHJ?C EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#?, #E@E?# D@Z H"E J?HZ E" \@Z D?H "C

C 47;,:, -&*

G$K$ @E Z"H? ?A# 1/?C#"H@A

CI\FE# ?##?HEI@A E" EF? "C N7?$%G, '++

G$K$ @E &O$ 1F? ?aM@AIEZ "B CI\FE# #?LMC?J YZ EF? W"MCE??HEF

HLAMJ?#

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 90!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 90


29/47

&]

W"MC

0C"E?LEI"H "B EF? A@_ _?C? EID? @HJ @\@IH #?>@C@E?J _F?H "H? #A@:?

_@# #"AJ E" @ JI#E@HE >@CE "B EF? K"MEF$ B,,235=351 ;$;G1R8!,123

=9876 W8R09< 0! K98b35< 8!4 W5334SR,&*-.(&]O-, @E '&+ N&]*/Q$ 8#

FM#Y@HJ "C B@EF?C IH EF? ?Z? "B EF? A@_, F? F@J H" LFIAJ, F? _@# H"E @E

AIY?CEZ E" IHJMA\? EF? H@EMC@A @BB?LEI"H# "B EF? FMD@H F?@CE B"C LFIAJC?H,

EF 7"H\$, E K?##$ -.)

N&+//Q$

0H EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE, EF? BC@D?C# EFM# #"M\FE E"

\M@C@HE?? E" EF? H?_AZ BC??J #A@:?# EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ EF@E EF?Z F@J

MHI:?C#@A MHJ?C

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* 98!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* 98


30/47


31/47

O&

0HJ??J, B?_ CI\FE# _?C? D"C? >C?LI"M# E" EF? H?_AZ BC??J #A@:?#

(#A@:?#

EF?D#?A:?# >C?##?J B"C L?C?D"HI?# @HJ A?\@A C?\I#EC@EI"H# EF@E @E "HL?

L?A?YC@E?J EF? H?_ #?LMCIEZ "B YA@LV B@DIAZ AIB? @HJ YC"M\FE EF?IC D"#E

IH

W5334SRP8 4S7GR3!185< 20K1S5< SW 3R8!70T810S!, &+/&(&+/*, @E

@# D@HZ @# #?:?HEZ L"M>A?# @E @ EID? Y?L@D? @ L"DD"H #I\FE IH EF?

93S! W$ 901U876, =33! 0! 123 K1S5R KS 9S!;P123

8W135R812 SW K98b35?C#"H "B EF?IC LF"IL? >C"E?LE?J @HJ #?LMC?J YZ A@_$

F@:? A"H\ Y??H >C@ZIH\ B"C IE$ 1F? R@CCI@\? 7":?H@HE I# @E EF?

B"MHJ@EI"H "B @AA "MC CI\FE#$ 0H #A@:?CZ _? L"MAJ H"E F@:? A?\@AI#?J

W5334SRP8 4S7GR3!185< 20K1S5F@#I# "DIEE?JQ$ SH c@HM@CZ &, &+//, 8BCIL@H 8D?CIL@H# L@AA?J

F? _@# IH E

G$7$9$8$ 9$ 53b$ @E

&'-.$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ,+!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ,+


32/47

OO

EF? BIC#E @HHI:?C#@CZ "B EF? 3

\C@EIEMJ? B"C EF? BC??J"D "B D@ECID"HZ$ W"CD?CAZ, EF?C? _@# H"

#?LMCIEZ B"C "MC J"D?#EIL F@>>IH?##$ $ $ $ =ME H"_ _? L@H D@CCZ @HJ AI:?

G$7$9$8$9$53b$ @E &''+ H$&)/$ 0H

#F"CE,

c8R3K R7T235KS!, 123

!3;5S3K70b09 U85/.) N&]]&Q$

0H _CIEIH\ IHE" EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE @ C?aMIC?D?HE "B

?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C EF? A@_ @HJ ?aM@AIEZ "B Y@#IL CI\FE# B"C @AA >?C#"H#

_FILF IHLAMJ?J EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ

EF@E JI#LCIDIH@E"CZ #E@E? A@_# _"MAJ H"E #E@HJ IH EF? _@Z "B 8D?CIL@H#

?`?CLI#IH\ EF?IC CI\FE E" D@CCZ EF? >?C#"H "B EF?IC "_H LF""#IH\$ 9@_#

EF@E JI#LCIDIH@E? @HJ J?HZ E" D?DY?C# "B L?CE@IH \C"M># EF? CI\FE E"

D@CCZ EF? >?C#"H "B EF?IC LF"IL? EFM# L"HEC@:?H? EF? "CI\IH@A D?@HIH\

"B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE$

1F? KM>C?D? 7"MCE F@# D@HZ EID?# :IHJIL@E?J EFI# >CIHLI>A?$

R"#E B@D"M#AZ, IH N7?$%G ?< Q$:G$%$#, EF? 7"MCE IH:@AIJ@E?J EF? A@_# "B

bIC\IHI@ @HJ BIBE??H "EF?C #E@E?# EF@E "MEA@_?J IHE?CC@LI@A D@CCI@\?$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ,9!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ,9


33/47

O'

Y@#IL LI:IA CI\FE# "B D@H,

N7?$%G, '++ G$K$ @E &O NaM"EIH\ BF$%%,:, '&/ G$K$ @E -)&Q, EF? 7"MCE

"B C@LI@A LA@##IBIL@EI"H# :I"A@E?# EF? L?HEC@A D?@HIH\ "B EF? 3aM@A

1/?C#"H "B @H"EF?C C@L? C? 1/A?, IH V#>"79F$ ?< 4,/A#$", )') G$K$ '*)

N&]*+Q, EF? KM>C?D? 7"MCE F?AJ EF@E @ UI#L"H#IH #E@EME? EF@E J?HI?J

EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ E" >@C?HE# _F" F@J B@IA?J E" #@EI#BZ >C?(?`I#EIH\ LFIAJ

#M>>"CE "YAI\@EI"H# :I"A@E?J EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#?, ?D>F@#IXIH\

B BMHJ@D?HE@A ID>"CE@HL? B"C @AA

IHJI:IJM 1/


34/47

O)

EF? BC?? 1/>AZIH\ #ECILE #LCMEIHZ, EF?

7"MCE IH:@A

D@CCZ E" >@C?HE# _F" F@J B@IA?J E" >@Z LFIAJ #M>>"CE, BIHJIH\ IE ID>"#?J

I"M# IHECM#I"H IHE" $ $ $ BC??J"D "B LF"IL? IH @H @C?@ IH _FILF _?

1/< @E '+*$ =?L@M#? EF?

3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? #?LMC?J @H ?aM@A CI\FE E" D@CCZ E" @AA >?C#"H#,

EF? \":?CHD?HE L"MAJ H"E >MC#M? IE# A?\IEID@E? IHE?C?#E IH ?H#MCIH\

>@ZD?HE "B LFIAJ #M>>" >IH\iIH\j "H

1/


35/47

O-

@C? #MYf?LE E" #ECILE #LCMEIHZ @HJ DM#E Y? H@CC"_AZ E@IA"C?J E" #?C:? @

L"D>?AAIH\ #E@E? IHE?C?#E$ B,, V#>"79F$, )') G$K$ @E '++h (,, #"(7

BF$%%,:, '&/ G$K$ @E -)& N@>>AZIH\ #ECILE #LCMEIHZ MHJ?C EF? 3aM@A

TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? E" A?\I#A@EI"H IH

D@H $ $ $ A?#E MH_IEEIH\AZ "C "EF?C_I#? IH:IJI"M# JI#LCIDIH@EI"H# @C?

D@J? @\@IH#E \C"M># "C EZ>?# "B IHJI:IJM@A# IH :I"A@EI"H "B EF?

B,, G,%,:#""@ GE@F

TA@IHEIBB#(8>>?AA??# =C$ @E '] H$], )+(/' N@C\MIH\ EF@E F?I\FE?H?J

#LCMEIHZ @>>AI?# IH EFI# L@#?Q$/

+EB #3% &$((+$)% /$F" -. 1#$3 $'* -G/$3-&$+'.(+')% #3% %D1$/ (+)3# #- &$((A $'* #31"

E+-/$#% #3% )1$($'#%% -. #3% %D1$/

0(-#%,#+-' ,/$1"% #3$# $// 0%("-'" "3$//

3$E% %D1$/+#A 1'*%( #3% /$F

1F? D@CCI@\? A@_# "B GE@F @HJ SVA@F"D@ :I"A@E? Y@#IL, _?AA(

#?EEA?J ?aM@A >C"E?LEI"H >CIHLI>A?#$ =Z B"CYIJJIH\ A":IH\, L"DDIEE?J

/ 0H P8:%,: ?< B#'",@, )+O G$K$ *+ N&]+*Q, EF? KM>C?D? 7"MCE JIJ H"E @>>AZ #ECILE

#LCMEIHZ, @>>AZIH\ IH#E?@J C?@#"H@YA?H?## C?:I?_ Y?L@M#? EF? LF@AA?H\? @C"#? IH EF?

>CI#"H L"HE?`E$ 3:?H MHJ?C EFI# J?B?C?HEI@A #E@HJ@CJ "B C?:I?_, F"_?:?C, EF? 7"MCEH"H?EF?A?## B"MHJ EF@E EF? #E@E? F@J H" A?\IEID@E? Y@#I# B"C J?HZIH\ >CI#"H?C# EF?

CI\FE E" D@CCZ EF? >?C#"H "B EF?IC "_H LF""#IH\$ 7?CE@IHAZ, IB EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ I#

#" BMHJ@D?HE@A EF@E EF?C? I# H" C?@#"H@YA? Y@#I# B"C J?HZIH\ EF? CI\FE E"

IHL@CL?C@E?J >CI#"H?C#, EF?C? I# H" Y@#I# MHJ?C @HZ #E@HJ@CJ "B #LCMEIHZYME

?#>?LI@AAZ MHJ?C #ECILE #LCMEIHZB"C J?HZIH\ EF@E CI\FE E" L"DDIEE?J, A":IH\, #@D?(

#?` L"M>A?#$ B,, GE@F TA@IHEIBB#(8>>?AA??# =C$ @E /'(+/ NJ?D"H#EC@EIH\ EF@E

A@_ L@HH"E #MC:I:? C@EI"H@A Y@#I# C?:I?_, DMLF A?## F?I\FE?H?J #LCMEIHZQ$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ,@!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ,@


36/47

O/

#@D?( ?A@EI"H

0#@%#:/ ?"79F$, )') G$K$ @E '+/,

EF?#? #E@E? A@_# L"HEC@:?H?

\M@C@HE?? "B ?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C EF? A@_ @HJ ?aM@A CI\FE# C?BA?LE?J IH Y"EF

EF? E?`E @HJ FI#E"CZ "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE$ 1F?#? #E@E? A@_#

?#E@YAI#F @ LA@##(Y@#?J Y@J\? "B IHB?CI"CIEZ EF@E

EF? >?C#"H@A JI\HIEZ @HJ AIY?CEZ "B \@Z D?H @HJ A?#YI@H# @HJ EF?IC

B@DIAI?#

"EF T$%/(7:, &'' K$ 7E$ @E O/]/$

4?HZIH\ \@Z D?H @HJ A?#YI@H# EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ EF? >?C#"H "B

EF?IC LF""#IH\ I# IHL"H#I#E?HE _IEF EF? E?`E "B EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H

7A@M#?, _FILF #?LMC?# ?aM@AIEZ "B CI\FE# E" @AA >?C#"H#, C?\@CJA?## "B

#?`M@A "CI?HE@EI"H, (,, T$%/(7:, (8+:#h 47;,:, (8+:#, @HJ IE# FI#E"CZ,

_FILF J?D"H#EC@E?# EF@E EF

I# @ Y@#IL @HJ BMHJ@D?HE@A CI\FE, \M@C@HE??J E" @AA >?C#"H# MHJ?C EF?

W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE$ 1F? LF@AA?H\?J #E@E? A@_# @C? >C"FIYIE?J LA@##

(Y@#?J ?H@LED?HEi#j Z #@D?(#?` L"M>A?# EF?

CI\FE E" D@CCZ IH "CJ?C E"

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ,A!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ,A


37/47

O*

47;,:, -&* G$K$ @E /'-$ GHJ?C GE@F @HJ SVA@F"D@ A@_, D?H @HJ

_"D?H _F" A":? @HJ LF""#? E" D@CCZ #"D?"H? "B EF? #@D? #?` J" H"E

#E@HJ ?aM@A Y?B"C? EF? A@_ @HJ J" H"E C?L?I:? IE# ?aM@A >C"E?LEI"H$

!" L"H#EIEMEI"H@AAZ A?\IEID@E? C@EI"H@A?A?E @A"H? @HZ L"D>?AAIH\

#E@E? IHE?C?#E C?BM#@A# E" @LL"CJ \@Z D?H @HJ

A?#YI@H# EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ EF? >?C#"H "B EF?IC LF""#IH\$ 8# IH T$%/(7:,

&'' K$ 7E$ @E O/]/, ? >MC>"#? ":?CL"D?# EF? >MC>"#? @HJ

?BB?LE E" JI#>@C@\? @HJ E" IHfMC? (#?` L"M>A?# IH L"DDIEE?J, A":IH\

1/C">?CAZ F?AJ, EF?#? #E@E? >C"FIYIEI"H# LC?@E?

: =$(A7+ ?@CEH?C#FI> Y@#?J "H A":?, IH

J$&9A,% ?< D,:>,:&, O.&' U9 //]*+*), @E [O] N4$ GE@F 4?L$, O., O.&'Q$

7"HEC@CZ E" EF? @C\MD?HE# #M\\?#E?J YZ EF? #E@E?# IH #M>>"CE "B

EF?IC JI#LCIDIH@E"CZ D@CCI@\? A@_#, EF? E?`E @HJ BIC#E >CIHLI>A?# EF?

BC@D?C# _C"E? IHE" EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE L"HEC"A EFI# 7"M

L"H

D@C 48% ?"$9#% !#:&@ 7' 1""$%7$(, )]* G$K$ /O, ]- H$& N&]].Q NKL@AI@, c$,

JI##?HEIH\Q$ B,,N#E:,%9, ?< P,C#(, -'] G$K$ --+, -**(*+ NO..'Q

B@LE EF@E EF? \":?CHIH\ D@f"CIEZ IH @ KE@E? F@# EC@JIEI"H@AAZ :I?_?J @

>@CEILMA@C >C@LEIL? @# IDD"C@A I# H"E @ #MBBILI?HE C?@#"H B"C M>F"AJIH\ @

A@_ >C"FIYIEIH\ EF? >C@LEIL?h H?IEF?C FI#E"CZ "C EC@JIEI"H L"MAJ #@:? @

A@_ >C"FIYIEIH\ DI#L?\?H@EI"H BC"D L"H#EIEM

=7E,:( ?< D#:/E$9F, )*+ G$K$ &+/, O&/ N&]+/Q NKE?:?H#, c$, JI##?HEIH\QQh

, -&+ G$K$

//+, /+& N&]]/Q NC?f?LEIH\ ? WIC#E

A"H\ @HJ

MHYC"V?H EC@JIEI"H

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ,0!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ,0


39/47

O]

IE@EI"H "DIEE?JQh D,"",: ?< .7,, -.] G$K$ '&O, 'O/

?@\? "B @ A?\@A L"HL?>E J"?# H"E \I:? IE IDDMHIEZ

48%

EC@JIEI"H EF@E I# C?A?:@HE IH EF?#? L@#?# I# EF? 8D?CIL@H L"DDIED?HE E"

?`@DIH? @HJ C??`@DIH? >@#E @HJ >C?#?HE >C@LEIL?# @\@IH#E EF? Y@#IL

>CIHLI> * 0B @ #"(L@AA?J EC@JIEI"H "C

FI#E"CZ "B JI#LCIDIH@EI"H _?C? #MBBILI?HE E" fM#EIBZ >?C>?EM@EIH\ EF?

JI#LCIDIH@E"CZ >C@LEIL?, "MC >MYAIL #LF""A#, JCIHVIH\ B"MHE@IH#, @HJ

#_IDDIH\ >""A# _"MAJ #EIAA Y? #?\C?\@E?J YZ C@L?$

1F?#? >CIHLI>A?# @>>AZ _IEF #>?LI@A B"CL? E" EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H

7A@M#?, _FILF LF@H\?J EF? 7"H#EIEMEI"H BC"D "H? EF@E #@HLEI"H?J

IH?aM@AIEZ E" "H? EF@E >C"FIYIE?J IE$ 1F? :?CZ >"IHE "B EF? 7A@M#? _@# E"

B J?HZIH\ E" 8BCIL@H

8D?CIL@H#@HJ "EF?C JI#B@:"C?J \C"M>#?aM@A CI\FE# MHJ?C EF? A@_$

8# B@C @# EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? I# L"HL?CH?J, JI#LCIDIH@E"CZ

* 1FI# I# ECM? ?:?H "B EC@JIEI"H# ?`I#EIH\ @E EF? EID? "B EF? C@EIBIL@EI"H "B EF?W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE$ B,,!"#%%,/ !#:,%&A77/ ?< 2#(,@, -.- G$K$ +'', +)+

LEIL?# "B KE@E?# @E EF? EID? "B EF?

@J">EI"H "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE D@CV# EF? "ME?C AIDIE# "B EF? #MY#E@HEI:?

#>F?C? "B AIY 48%, )]* G$K$ @E

+O H$O NKE?

IDDMHIX? BC"D L"H#EIEMEI"H@A C?:I?_ #E@E? L"HJMLE EF@E _"MAJ "EF?C_I#? :I"A@E? EF?

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ,8!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ,8


40/47

'.

2',A:, -&+ G$K$ @E /+& N?`>A@IHIH\ EF@E @ EC@JIEI"H "B >"AIEIL@A YI@# IH

@EI"H D@CV# "DIEE?JQ$

0HE?HEI"H@AAZ JC@BEIH\ EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? IH YC"@J,

MHI:?C#@A E?CD#, EF? BC@D?C# "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE J?AIY?C@E?AZ

E@C\?E?J EF? ?HEIC? C@H\? "B MH?aM@A A@_#, IHLAMJIH\ @ F"#E "B

A"H\#E@HJIH\, JI#LCIDIH@E"CZ #E@E? >C@LEIL?#$ 8E EF? EID? "B IE#

C@EIBIL@EI"H, JI#LCIDIH@EI"H @\@IH#E EF? H?_AZ BC??J #A@:?#, @# _?AA @#

"EF

KE@E?# A@_# D@VIH\ #MLF JI#LCIDIH@EI"H# EF?H ?`I#E?J, @HJ "EF?C#

DI\FE _?AA Y? ?` B&:#8/,:, &.. G$K$ @E './$ 7@C:IH\ "ME "B EF?

E?`E "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE @H ?`L?>EI"H B"C EC@JIEI"H@A B"CD# "B

JI#LCIDIH@EI"H _"MAJ F@:? #EC@H\A?J EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? IH IE#

LCIY, #MY:?CEIH\ IE# L?HEC@A D?@HIH\$ B,, 1""$%7$( B&, 5;+"7@,,(

278%9$" LM ?< N,E$(, )*' W$OJ -/&, -/+ H$&) N*EF 7IC$ &]*OQ NKE?:?H#, c$Q

I"M# >C@LEIL? _?C? @ #MBBILI?HE C?@#"H B"C IE#

L"HEIHM?J @LL?>E@HL?, EF? L"H#EIEMEI"H@A @EE@LV "H C@LI@A JI#LCIDIH@EI"H

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* .7!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* .7


41/47

'&

@ #E@E? A@_ "C >"AILZ EF@E L"HEC@:?H?# EF? 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7

L"DD@HJ "B ?aM@AIEZ MHJ?C EF? A@_ @HJ ?aM@AIEZ "B CI\FE# B"C @AA

>?C#"H#$

1F? KM>C?D?

>?C#"H# E" D@CCZ F@:? A"H\ C?L"\HIX?J EFI# Y@#IL >"IHE$ W"C D@HZ Z?@C#

IH EFI# L"MHECZ, #E@E?# >C"FIYIE?J D@CCI@\?# Y?E_??H >?C#"H# "B

JIBB?C?HE C@L?#, YME N7?$%G

D@CCI@\? :I"

BC??J"D E" D@CCZ #"A?AZ Y?L@M#? "B C@LI@A LA@##IBIL@EI"H# :I"A@E?# EF?

L?HEC@A D?@HIH\ "B N7?$%G, '++ G$K$ @E

&O$ B,, #"(72#(,@, -.- G$K$ @E ]+. H$& NKL@AI@, c$, JI##?HEIH\Q NJ?HZIH\

C?HL? E" EC@JIEI"H _"MAJ C?aMIC? M# E" M>F"AJ A@_# @\@IH#E

ILE?J >@ #

&,C&@H 3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? EF@E ?`>AILIEAZ ?#E@YAI#F?# C@LI@A

?aM@AIEZ @# @ L"H

@A"H? L@HH"E fM#EIBZ J?HZIH\ #@D?(#?` L"M>A?# EF? CI\FE E" D@CCZ @HZ

D"C? EF@H IE L"MAJ fM#EIBZ bIC\I

=7(&$9 ?< 4#$%,@, 7I:IA !"$ &'(']-, #AI> ">$ @E O/ N3$4$ b@$ W?Y$, &),

O.&)Q$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* .+!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* .+


42/47

'O

0E I# EFM# "B H" L"H#EIEMEI"H@A C?A?:@HL? EF@E EF? D@CCI@\?# IHE"

_FILF TA@IHEIBB# _I#F E" ?HE?C F@:? A"H\ Y??H J?HI?J A?\@A C?L"\HIEI"H$

8# EF? KM>C?D? 7"MCE L"HBICD?J IH N7?$%G, FI#E"CZ I# @ :@AIJ #"MCL? "B

IHaMICZ B"C IJ?HEIBZIH\ Y@#IL @HJ BMHJ@D?HE@A L"H#EIEMEI"H@A CI\FE# @HJ

TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? @H@AZ#I# E" fM#EIBZ @ A@_ "C >C@LEIL? EF@E J?HI?# @HZ

\C"M> EF? ?aM@A >C"E?LEI"H "B EF? A@_#$ 4?HI@A "B EF? ?aM@A CI\FE E"

D@CCZAIV? "EF?C BMHJ@D?HE@A L"H#EIEMEI"H@A >C"E?LEI"H#

JI#LCIDIH@EI"HH" D@EE?C F"_ ?HEC?HLF?JJ"?# H"E D@V? EF?

JI#LCIDI ,

]-* 8$OJ ).*, )*+ N7"HH$ O..+Q NaM"EIH\ D,:%#%/,I ?< 47>",(H +--

!$3$OJ &, '' N!$


43/47

''

!8>"$9 D,#"&AH *]+ !$3$OJ ])&, ]*' NR@##$ O..'Q N;C?@H?Z, c$,

F? D@HEC@ "B EC@JIEI"H $ $ $ L@HiH"Ej fM#EIBZ EF?

>?C>?EM@EI"H "B @ FI?C@CLFZ IH _FILF L"M>A?# "B EF? #@D? #?` @HJ EF?IC

B@DIAI?# @C? J??D?J A?## _"CEFZ "B #"LI@A @HJ A?\@A C?L"\HIEI"H EF@H

L"M>A?# "B EF? ">>"#IE? #?` @HJ EF?IC B@D

8# EF? E?`E @HJ FI#E"CZ "B EF? W"MCE??HEF 8D?HJD?HE #F"_, EF?

3aM@A TC"E?LEI"H 7A@M#? \M@C@HE??# E" @AA >?C#"H#C?\@CJA?## "B C@L?,

#?`M@A "CI?HE@EI"H, "C "EF?C \C"M> LF@C@LE?CI#EIL#?aM@AIEZ "B CI\FE#,

IHLAMJIH\ EF? BMHJ@D?HE@A CI\FE E" D@CCZ EF? >?C#"H "B EF?IC LF""#IH\$

1F? LF@AA?H\?J GE@F @HJ SVA@F"D@ A@_# L"HBAILE _IEF EFI#

BMHJ@D?HE@A L"H#EIEMEI"H@A >CIHLI>A?, @HJ EF? A"_?C L"MCE# _?C? L"CC?LE

E" F@:? IH:@AIJ@E?J EF?D$

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* .,!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* .,


44/47

')

,-',/1"+-'

1F? fMJ\D?HE "B EF? JI#ECILE L"MCE# #F"MAJ Y? @BBICD?J$

5?#>?LEBMAAZ #MYDIEE?J,

k#k 3AIX@Y?EF =$ UZJC@

3AIX@Y?EF =$ UZJC@[ 0AZ@ KF@>IC"

7S!K101G10S!89 781S 0!K101G13

877SG!18=0901< 73!135 &...R@##@LFM#?EE# 8:?,!U

&O.. &+EF KE$, !U, KE? -.& U@#FIH\E"H, 47 O...&

U@#FIH\E"H, 4$7$ O..'/ NO.OQ +)O(.O..

NO.OQ O]/(/++]

?AIX@Y?EF^EF?M#L"H#EIEMEI"H$"C\

6278%(," 7' 4,97:/

278%(," '7: *;$9$ 28:$#,

4@E?JP R@CLF ), O.&)

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ..!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ..


45/47

'-

,%(#+.+,$#% -. ,-&0/+$',%

0 F?C?YZ L?CEIBZ EF@E EFI# YCI?B L"D>AI?# _IEF EF? EZ>?(:"AMD?

AIDIE@EI"H "B W?J$ 5$ 8>>$ T$ 'ON@QN*QN=Q @HJ W?J$ 5$ 8>>$ T$ O]NJQ

Y?L@M#? IE L"HE@IH# *,... _"CJ#, ?`LAMJIH\ EF? >@CE# "B EF? YCI?B

?`?D>E?J YZ W?J$ 5$ 8>>$ T$ 'ON@QN*QN=QNIIIQ$

0 BMCEF?C L?CEIBZ EF@E EF? @EE@LF?J YCI?B #;$9$ 98:$#,L"D>AI?# _IEF

EF? EZ>?B@L? C?aMIC?D?HE# "B W?J$ 5$ 8>>$ T$ 'ON@QN-Q@HJ EF? EZ>?(#EZA?

C?aMIC?D?HE# "B W?J$ 5$ 8>>$ T$ 'ON@QN/Q, Y?L@M#? IE F@# Y??H >C?>@C?J

IH @ >C">"CEI"H@AAZ #>@L?J EZ>?B@L? M#IH\ RILC"#"BE U"CJ &)(>"IHE

7?HEMCZ KLF""AY""V B"HE$

3`?LME?J EFI# )EFJ@Z "B R@CLF, O.&)$

k#k 3AIX@Y?EF =$ UZJC@lll

3AIX@Y?EF =$ UZJC@

278%(," '7: *;$9$ 28:$#,

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* .@!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* .@


46/47

'/

,%(#+.+,$#% -. "%(E+,%

0 F?C?YZ L?CEIBZ EF@E 0 ?A?LEC"HIL@AAZ BIA?J EF? B"C?\"IH\ _IEF EF?

7A?CV "B EF? 7"MCE B"C EF? GHIE?J KE@E?# 7"MCE "B 8>>?@A# B"C EF? 1?HEF

7ICLMIE YZ M#IH\ EF? @>>?AA@E? 7Rk37W #Z#E?D "H R@CLF ), O.&)$

0 L?CEIBZ EF@E @AA >@CEI?# IH EF? L@#? @C? C?\I#E?C?J 7Rk37W M#?C#

@HJ EF@E #?C:IL? _IAA Y? @LL"D>AI#F?J YZ EF? @>>?AA@E? 7Rk37W #Z#E?D$



3AIX@Y?EF =$ UZJC@

278%(," '7: *;$9$ 28:$#,

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* .A!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* .A


47/47

%,. ,%(#+.+,$#+-'

TMC#M@HE

EF? MHJ?C#I\H?J L?CEIBI?#P

&$ 8AA C?aMIC?J >CI:@LZ C?J@LEI"H# F@:? Y??H D@J?h

O$ 2@CJ L">I?# "B EF? B"C?\"IH\ YCI?B C?aMIC?J E" Y? #MYDIEE?J E"

'$ 1F? YCI?B BIA?J :I@ 37W _@# #L@HH?J B"C :ICM#?# M#IH\ UIHJ"_#

4?B?HJ?C @HJ W(K?LMC? TK= U"CV#E@EI"H K?LMCIEZ &.$.. @HJ @LL"CJIH\

E" EF@E #"BE_@C? I# BC?? "B :ICM#?#$



3AIX@Y?EF =$ UZJC@

278%(," '7: *;$9$ 28:$#,

!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++/,7 1% :;$#%?#* ./!""#$$% (%)#* +,-.+/0 12345#6&* 7+7+89++07+ 1% :;$#%?#* ./

cato institute amicus brief in amendment 3 appeal

Documents