causes and countermeasures, masaya yasui, deputy director general, nuclear safety regulation reform,...

8/2/2019 Causes and Countermeasures, Masaya Yasui, Deputy Director General, Nuclear Safety Regulation Reform, METI

1/82

^hk Fooenkg~ f~ ^K\OIs C{a{shejf G{odkfp \i}kp _~f~eigs

Jfsfuf Ufs{eNk|{~u Nepko~ip Mkgkpfd$ G{odkfp _fck~u Pkm{df~eig Pkcipj

Jeges~pu ic Koigiju$ ^pfnk fgn Egn{s~pu (JK^E%$


2/82

Oig~kg~s

Fooenkg~ Ikpek} fgn Pii~ Of{sks

*E' _~k| 0 Oij|dk~eig ic Pifnjf| ~i}fpns _k~~dkjkg~ ic ~hk Fooenkg~

EE' \pimpkss _~f~{s ic Kgs{pegm Jen* kpj _fck~u'

kohgeofd Of{sks fgn Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks ic Fooenkg~ f~*

E' Fooenkg~ _kv{kgokEE' Kx~kpgfd \i}kp _{||du _us~kjs

' *ES' Oiidegm _us~kjs

S' Oig~fegjkg~ _us~kjs' $ $Kjkpmkgou Pks|igsk Fppfgmkjkg~s


3/82

Fooenkg~ Ikpek} fgn Pii~ Of{sks


4/82

^hk Fooenkg~ f~ C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\_

kfoo kg~

f~

{ {s jf

f

o

}fs

of{sk

u

digmdfs~egmoij|dk~k|i}kpdissn{k~ioijjigof{sk

f {pk i k ko~p of kv{ |jkg~ i i} gm~s{gfj $

fgnegs{cceoekg~

|pieseig

fmfegs~

skkpk

fooenkg~'

E~es~kj|ipfpedupf~knf~EGK_Dkkd=$fgn|ki|dk}hkpkdekneg~hks|koeceofpkfegod{negm~hisk}e~heg0


5/82

Mkgkpfd Sek} ic pii~ of{sks ic ~hk Fooenkg~

OOCickdko~peokv{e|jkg~fgnegs{cceoekg~skkpkfooenkg~

|pieseig}kpkegn{okn`uciddi}egmpii~of{sks2

agi}dknmkeg~ihfrfpnkfd{f~eig$

$

Egs{cceoekg~f||deof~eigics~f~kic~hkfp~ko gi im ksfg g kpgf igf mii |pfo oks i k

pkm{df~ipu|pimpfjs'


6/82

Gk} G{odkfp Pkm{df~ipu Ipmfgerf~eigs

G{odkfpPkm{df~ipuF{~hipe~u

fgkx~kpgfdipmfgic~hk

(JIK%`u2

sfck~upkm{df~ipu

c{go~eig

ic GE_F cpij JK^E fgn

G{odkfp

Pkm{df~ipu

F{~hipe~u

{gecuegmpkdkfg~c{go~eigs

ic i~hkp jeges~peks _erk2

;


7/82

Gk} G{odkfp Pkm{df~ipu _us~kjs

GPF}eddej|dkjkg~gk}pkm{df~ipusus~kjss~e|{df~kneg

fjkgnkndf}s$egod{negm2

'

Pkm{df~eigf||duegmdf~ks~soekg~eceo)~kohgeofd

gi} k mkig

sf k~u

ess{ks

~i

kxes~egm

foe e~eks'

(`foace~~egm%

Fgi|kpf~eigdeje~ic>


8/82

kohgeofd Agi}dknmk fov{epkn cpij ~hk Fooenkg~

Egipnkp~ifnnpksspii~of{sksegf|pfo~eofdjfggkp$GE_F

kgmegkkpegm

|ieg~

ic

ek}$

fgn

kx~pfo~kn

~kohgeofd

Kx~kpgfd|i}kps{||dusus~kjs

Igse~k

|i}kp

s{||du

sus~kjs

Oiideg s s~kjs

Oig~fegjkg~sus~kjs

$

$

fgnkjkpmkgoupks|igskfppfgmkjkg~s


9/82

O{ppkg~ _~f~{s ic C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\_


10/82

_~k| 0 Oij|dk~eig eg Pifnjf| ~i}fpns _k~~dkjkg~ ic ~hk Fooenkg~ (ig Nko' 63$ 0


11/82

Jen*~i*Digm* kpj Pifnjf| ~i}fpns~hk Nkoijjesseigegm ic C{a{shejf G{odkfp \i}kp [ge~s 6*>

*

_~k| 6$ 0 \hfsk 6

4Fohekkn _~f`dk \kpein ~i ~hk

\hfsk 0 \hfsk ?

\kpein ~i ~hk \kpein ~i ~hk kgn ic

Oigne~eigs7

Pkfo~ips2 F

oigne~eig

oijjkgokjkg~ ic ~hkc{kd pkjifd cpij ~hk_|kg~ C{kd \iids (]e~heg

0 ukfps%

oijjkgokjkg~ ic ~hkpkjifd ic c{kd nk`pes

(]e~heg 6< ukfps%

~hk nkoijjesseigegm(Eg ?< ukfps%

*Oijjkgok ~hk pkjifd ic c{kds cpij~hk s|kg~ c{kd |iids ([ge~ > eg 0 ukfps%

kv{efdkg~ ~i

Oidn _h{~ni}g

_|kg~ C{kd*Pkn{ok ~hk pfnef~eig ej|fo~ n{k ~ifnne~eigfd kjesseigs cpij ~hk }hidk

*Oij|dk~k ~hk c{kd pkjifd cpij ~hk s|kg~c{kd |iids f~ fdd [ge~s

*Oij|dk~k |pk|fpf~eigs cip ~hk pkjifd icc{kd nk`pes s{oh fs nkoig~fjegf~egm ~hk

*Oij|dk~k ~hk c{kd nk`pes pkjifd(eg 0


12/82

[ge~ 6 [ge~ 0 [ge~ ? [ge~ >

O{ppkg~ _~f~{s ic C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\\

|iid

Pkfo~ip |pkss{pkksskd

\pejfpuoig~fegjkg~

^K\OI Jeges~pu ic Nkckgsk Fep \hi~i _kpeok\pkss{pks{||pkssei

g ohfj`kp

ksskd

Fep \hi~i _kpeok

Pkfo~ip \pkss{pkksskd

^kj kpf~{pk f~ pkfo~ip ksskd

Oepo{df~egm}f~kp

egbko~eigOepo{df~egm }f~kpegbko~eig oiidegm

Oepo{df~egm }f~kpegbko~eig oiidegm Gi c{kd

`i~~ij" oii gm

0>'?

' '

\pejfpu Ge~pimkg Ge~pi kg eg ko~eigGe~pimkg

Oig~fegjkg~ ksskd^kj|kpf~{pk ic fep eg \OS"

g ko ig

0;'>;>'?

g ko ig

>>'>

Oepo{df~eig Oepo{df~eig Oepo{df~eig

^kj|kpf~{pk ic |iid }f~kp"oiidegm

03';

6>'0

oiidegm

6>'>

oiidegm

03

Hemhdu*oig~fjegf~kn}f~kp eg P)@ fgn

^)@""

6>$6


13/82

Nefmpfj ic \OSs Mfs Oig~pid _us~kj cip [ge~ ?

(_i{pok2 K\OI%


14/82

Pks{d~ ic Mfs _fj|degm f~ \OSs Mfs Oig~pid _us~kj

Oigokg~pf~eigic sfj dk



G{odenks

(@v)oj?%Nk~ko~eig

deje~s

ic [ge~ 6

(@v)oj?%Nk~ko~eig

deje~s

ic [ge~ ?

(@v)oj?%Nk~ko~eig

deje~s

ic [ge~ ?

[ge~ 6

(_fj|dkn ig

[ge~ 0

(_fj|dkn ig

[ge~ ?

(_fj|dkn ig' $ ' $ ' $

Mfs efd

oig~fegkp

Mfs efd

oig~fegkp

Mfs efd

oig~fegkp

* *6 *6 *6' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '

Os*6?> ?';6


15/82

Egks~emf~eig Pks{d~ ic ~hk Egsenk ic \OS ic [ge~ 0 (ig Bfg' 65$ 0


16/82

*

^pkf~jkg~ ic Hemh Dkkd Pfneifo~ek Oig~fjegf~kn ]f~kp

]f~kpdkkdesoig~piddkn~i|pkkg~ HemhDkkdPfneifo~ekOig~fjegf~kn]f~kp^pkf~jkg~_us~kj

~{pègk `{ednegms es ~pkf~kn ~i pkn{ok ~hk oigokg~pf~eigs ic pfneifo~ek jf~kpefdsfgn pk{skn'

Oig~fjegf~kn}f~kp

~pkf~jkg~sus~kj

dkfaegm~ii{~senk~hk`{ednegm

Ied

sk|fpf~ip

Pkfo~ip {ednegm \piokssjfeg`{ednegm

Hemh~kj|kpf~{pkegoegkpf~ip`{edneg

^{pègk {ednegm

Gi' 0 okse{j fnsip ~eig

Okse{jfnsip|~eigsus~kj(A{peig$[_%

Oig~fegkn}e~hegoigopk~k}fdds

'

sus~kj(îshe`f%

Nkoig~fjegf~eigsus~kj

(Fpkf$Cpf%

\

Hemhoigokg~pf~eig

foo{j{df~kn}f~kppkokekp

~fgas({gnkpmpi{gn% (O{ppkg~dueg_kf

6j

\

\

\

Di}~ijkne{j

oigokg~pf~eig~fgas_~ipfmk

~fgas

kfo ip}f kp

egbko~eig|{j|Pfneifo~ek

oigokg~pf~eig

espkn{okn~i

6)6


17/82

^pkgn ic Foo{j{df~kn ]f~kp Dkkd

~kg~f~ek ~fpmk~ dkkd ic I'\' ?


18/82

G{odenk Oigokg~pf~eig ic Foo{j{df~kn ]f~kp eg ^{p`egk @{ednegm

Oigokg~pf~eig icsfj|dk (@v)oj?%

[ge~6 [ge~0 [ge~ ? [ge~ >

ig

Jfp' 0=$

0$

0$

0$

0K!


19/82

Pkdkfsk Pf~k ic Pfneifo~ek Jf~kpefds cpij \OSs ic [ge~s 6*?

*

ks~ejf~kn ~i `k f||pix'


20/82

F oikp }fs egs~fddkn eg ~hk [ge~ 6 `{edneg ~i pks~pfeg pkdkfsk ic

Egs~fddf~eig ic Pkfo~ip @{ednegm Oikp (ig Io~' 08$ 0


21/82

Oigs~p{o~eig ic ]f~kp _hekdnegm ]fdd

Ejfmk ic }f~kp shekdnegm }fdds

'

Opiss*sko~eig ek}

_kfsenk }f~kp shekdnegm }fdd

Kxes~egm }fdd

Dfgncedd\kpjkf`dk dfukp

\kpjkf`dk dfukp

Di} |kpjkf`dk dfukp

Di} |kpjkf`dk dfukp


22/82

_~fp~ ic Jfpegk _ied Oikpegm Oigs~p{o~eig f~ Egsenk \ip~

f~ egsenk ic ~hk |ip~

i |pkkg~ oig~fjegf~eig ic ~hk iokfg i{~senk ic ~hk |ip~$ jfpegk sied eg cpig~ ick g f k ofgf s | fggk i k oikpk } si k si '

kp

_i

Npknmegm(skf}fu$ fgohip mpi{gn%

Gip~h

`pkf

a}f

~h`

pkfa}

f~kp

j|kpjkf k s~p{o~{pk pks~ipk

]f~kp shekdnegm }fdds

Oikpegm

(Npknmkn sied n{j|%

Oikpegm

(eg cpig~ ic ~hk eg~fak ofgfd%

Egs~fdd fnne~eigfd sed~ ckgok

(eg cpig~ ic ~hk eg~fak ofgfd%

_hfddi} npfc~ v{fu [ge~ 6 [ge~ 0 [ge~ ? [ge~ >[ge~ ;[ge~ 3

Kxes~egm sed~ ckgok

(_i{pok2^K\OI%


23/82

Ikpek} ic _|kg~ C{kd \iids (_C\s%

[ge~ 3

4Ikpek} ic diof~eig ic s|kg~c{kd s~ipfmk cfoede~eks7

G{j`kp ic s~ipkn c{kdfsskj`deks Of|foe~u ic

4_~f~{s ic s~ipkn c{kd eg _C\s7

[ge~ ;

(G{j`kp ic gk} c{kd

fsskj`deks%s~ipfmk

[ge~ 6 _C\ 050 (6

Oijjig |iidNkofu hkf~ (J]%

4Nkofu hkf~ ic _C\s7

s ioo{ppkgok ifooenkg~ (Jfp' 66%

jig s f kp kfooenkg~ (Io~' 6=%

[ge~ 6 _C\

[ge~ 0 _C\ ?

[ge~ ? _C\ _C\ 0'03 6'6;

Oijjig |iid 6'6? 6'60

(_i{pok2 Fnnkn ~i ~hk 0


24/82

Egs~fddegm _{||ip~ _~p{o~{pks f~ @i~~ij ic _C\ ic [ge~ >

pkegcipokjkg~s' Fs f |pkof{~eigfpu jkfs{pk$ s{||ip~ s~p{o~{pks f~ ~hk `i~~ij ic ~hk |iid hfs

'

Egs~fddf~eig ejfmk

_|kg~ C{kd \iid

Egs~fddf~eig ic s{||ip~ s~p{o~{pks

Egs~fdd s~kkd |eddfp

@kcipk s~kkd |eddfp egs~fddf~eigJfu'?6Egbko~eig mpi{g~B{d'?


25/82

_e~{f~eig ic _C\

$

~hk c{kd ofg gi~ `k enki*pkoipnkn'

[ge~ >2 hk c{kd es oigcepjkn ~i `k s~ipkn eg ~hk pfoas fgn gi~ skkpkdu nfjfmkn'

(_i{pok2 ^hk ej|fo~ ~hk 0


26/82

_e~{f~eig ic _C\ (oig~'%

[ge~ 6

cpij ~hk nfjfmkn oipk fgn ~hf~ ~hkpk es de~~dk |isse`ede~u ic dfpmk*sofdk nfjfmk ics|kg~ c{kds'

Nk~ko~kng{odenk

Hfdc*deckOigokg~pf~eig (@v)oj?%

_fj|dkn 3)00 _fj|dkn 8)65 _fj|dkn 66);

okse{j6?> w0 ukfps 6'06 6'86 6'?6

okse{j6?= w?< ukfps 6'>6

0'?6

6'86

w

Nk~ko~kng{odenk


_fj|dkn >)63 _fj|dkn 8)65 _fj|dkn 66);

okse{j6?> w0 kfps 6'36 w0 ukfps 6'>66 3'6

einegk6?6 w8 nfus 6'66 di}kp ~hfg nk~ko~eig deje~ di}kp ~hfg nk~ko~eig deje~ di}kp ~hfg nk~ko~eig deje~

Nk~ko~kng{odenk


_fj|dkn >)60 _fj|dkn >)08 _fj|dkn ;)= _fj|dkn 8)0< _fj|dkn 66);

okse{j6?> w0 ukfps 88 >5 ;3 >> ?';

okse{j6?= w?< ukfps 5? ;; 3= 36 ;'6

einegk6?6 w8 nfus 00< 0= 63 di}kp ~hfg nk~ko~eig deje~ di}kp ~hfg nk~ko~eig deje~

Pkn 2 sfj|dkn _C\ }f~kp {segm f oigopk~k |{j|kp @d{k 2 sfj|dkn _C\ }f~kp ikpcdi} eg~i f saejjkp s{pmk ~fga cpij C\O sfj|degm |e|egm

_i{pok2 Fnnkn ~i ^hk ej|fo~ ic ~hk 0


27/82

Fji{g~ ic }f~kp fpi{gn ~hk _C\ ic [ge~ >

_C\6>0;j?

\e~=3


28/82

^pkgn ic ]f~kp Dkkd fgn ^kj|kpf~{pk ic _C\

*$ $

|{j|kps' ^hk nkofu hkf~ kfd{f~eig shi}s ~hk c{kd hfs gkkp `kkg kx|iskn'

Fs cip [ge~ >$ }f~kp eg ~hk pkfo~ip }kdd ceddkn cip fgg{fd egs|ko~eig oi{dn cdi} eg~i

8j 63>)0= C{dd }f~kp dkkd }fs oigcepjkn `u saejjkp s{pmk~fga dkkd

Jkfs{pkn fd{k ic }f~kp dkkd

Kfd{f~kn fd{k ic }f~kp dkkd

Jkfs{pkn fd{k ic }f~kp ~kj kpf~{pk

'

3j

=j

kx|diseig'%

Ji~ip i|kpf~kn |{j|s k~o' }kpk {gffedf`dk'(Kjkpmkgou oiidegm }fs ofppekn i{~ `ukjkpmkgou oignkgskp EO eg [ge~ 6$ pkfo~ipoipk esidf~eig oiidegm sus~kj QPOEOZ eg [ge~ 0$fgn POEO fgn hemh |pkss{pk oipk egbko~eig

' ^hk kx|diseigs nk~kpeipf~kn }ipa |kpcipjfgok eg

~hk s{ppi{gnegm fpkfs'

]f~kp dkfafmk cpij oig~fegjkg~s ) `{ednegms }kpki`skpkn'

Jfx Fookdkpf~eig Sfd{ks I`skpkn eg Pkfo~ip @{ednegms ic kfoh [ge~


33/82

Jfx' Fookdkpf~eig Sfd{ks I`skpkn eg Pkfo~ip @{ednegms ic kfoh [ge~

Pkoipn Jfx' pks|igsk

'(`i~~ij cdiip ic

pkfo~ip `dn'%

nksemg `fses mpi{gn

ji~eig _s (Mfd%Jfx' fookdkpf~eig

(Mfd%

[ge~ 6 >3>= 0;8 >8= >85 >60

[ge~ 0 ?>8 ;;6 >?8 >05 >>6 >05

[ge~ > 086 ?65 0= >>; >00

[ge~ ; ?66 ;>8 0;3 >;0 >;0 >0=

[ge~ 3 058 >>> 0>> >>; >>8 >6;Kfoh pkoipnegm }fs eg~kpp{|~kn f~ fpi{gn 6?


34/82

6?@{ednegm _kf ]f~kp

\{j|

Fo~{fdhkemh~ ic~s{gfje

Fss{jknhkemh~ ic~s{gfje {ge~2 j

ss{ kn k m ~ f n o~{f k m ~ic ^s{gfje eg Kfoh G\_

6?'36?'8_e~kDkkd 6?'8

Igfmf}f|fed

C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\_ Nks~p{o~ek cdiin_kf}f~kpDkkdEgcpig~icG\_

N)M ig f `fskjkg~ s{`jkpmkn'

6?Fgfdu~eofd fd{k

skesjeo eg~kgse~u ic ; Igfmf}f G\_

6

Nfe*ge G\_

^iafe Nfe*ge

60

Igfhfjf

iafe Nfe*ge G\_

`pkfa}f~kp }fdd

_kf }f~kp |{j|s nen gi~ cdiinn{k ~i `pkfa}f~kp }fdd

G\_

f

8'53'0

;'=_i{pok2 Jk~kipidimeofd Fmkgou \pkdejegfpu Pk|ip~ eg~i ~hk 0

Jk~kipidimeofd Fmkgou(\pkdejegfpu Pk|ip~%Eg~kgse~u dkkd2 > ;*di}kp ;*{||kp 3*di}kp 3*{||kp = He~fohe

\fed

Fpkfs eg{gnf~kn `u ^s{gfje f~ Kfoh G\_


35/82

Fpkfs eg{gnf~kn ù ^s{gfje f~ Kfoh G\_

C{a{shejf C{a{shejfNfe*eohe Nfe*ge

Cdiinegm Cdiinegm

Oi{g~kpcdi} Oi{g~kpcdi}

îafe Nfe*geIgfmf}f

Cdiinegm

Oi{g~kpcdi}

^kx~ fnnkn ù GE_F ~i |{`deshkn jf~kpefds cpij Geemf~f \pkcko~{pfd ^kohgidimu Oijje~~kk fgn Miimdk


36/82


37/82

' Kx~kpgfd \i}kp _{||du _us~kjs

Nfjfmk ic Kx~kpgfd \i}kp _{||du _us~kjs


38/82

Nfjfmk ic Kx~kpgfd \i}kp _{||du _us~kjs

Cip ; g{odkfp |i}kp s~f~eigs (Hemfshenipe$ Igfmf}f$ C{a{shejf

f * o $ { {s jf f *g $ fg i f f g {o kfp i}kp

s~f~eigs% fccko~kn ù ~hk kfp~hv{fak$65 i{~ ic 00 kx~kpgfd |i}kp degks

}kpk gi~ ffedf`dk ~i s{ d i}kp n{k ~i ~hk nfjf k ~i kdko~peo

kv{e|jkg~ of{skn ù kfp~hv{fak' (Igfmf}f fgn C{a{shejf Nfe*ge G\_s

oi{dn pkokek k~kpgfd |i}kp ~hpi{mh s{peegm ? degks'%

_e~{f~eig f~ C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\_ Nfjfmkn oepo{e~ pkfakps fgn nesoiggko~ips eg ~hk s}e~ohufpn ([ge~s 6

^pe||kn ~pfgsjesseig degks ([ge~s ? fgn >% F oiddf|sk ic fg gkfpù kj`fgajkg~ }heoh ckddkn kdko~peofd ~i}kps

_~f~k ic Kx~kpgfd \i}kp _{||deks ~i C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\_(cpij Ejjknef~kdu fc~kp fg fc~kpshioa ~i Jfp 0


39/82

(cpij Ejjknef~kdu fc~kp fg fc~kpshioa ~i Jfp' 0


40/82

Nfjfmk f~ _}e~ohufpn f~ C{a{shejf Nfe eohe G\_

@pkfakp egs{df~ipsoij|dk~kdu nks~piukn

Eg~fo~ s~f~k

Nfjfmk ~i Ikphkfn \i}kp ^pfgsjesseig kv{e|jkg~ f~ C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\_


41/82

m v |

;


42/82

|| u u

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 6 Ej|pik pkdef`ede~u ic kx~kpgfd |i}kp s{||du fgnmp

Kxfj|dk2 Kgs{pegm |i}kp s{||du cpij fpei{s pi{~ks (~pfgsjesseig|i}kp degks$ kdko~peofd s{`s~f~eigs%

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 0 Ej|pik kfp~hv{fak pkses~fgok ic s{`s~f~eigKxfj|dk2 [segm mfs egs{df~kn kv{e|jkg~ fgn hemh*s~pkgm~h esidf~ips

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk ? Ej|pik kfp~hv{fak pkses~fgok ic s}e~ohufpnKxfj|dk2 [|mpfnegm cpij fep `dfs~ pkfakps (F@@% ~i mfs egs{df~kn

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk > Pkoikp kx~kpgfd |i}kp s{||du v{eoadu

$Egs~fddegm cf{d~ diof~ips

Ej|pikkfp~hv{fakpkses~fgokics{`s~f~eig(igse~k%


43/82

| v ( %

;;


44/82

' Ig*se~k \i}kp _{||du _us~kjs

Nfjfmk ~i Ig*se~k \i}kp _{||du _us~kjs


45/82

Jis~ ic ~hk |i}kp s{||du kv{e|jkg~ egs~fddkn ig ~hk fskjkg~ cdiips ic

~hk ~{p`egk `{ednegms (^)@s% fgn ~hk oig~pid `{ednegms (O)@s% gkfp ~hk

iokfg }kpk nfjfmkn n{k ~i cdiinegm ip }f~kp nfjfmk'

^hk kjkpmkgou nekskd mkgkpf~ips (N)Ms% dis~ c{go~eig n{k ~i cdiinegmip }f~kp nfjfmk' Kkg eg~fo~ N)Ms oi{dn gi~ s{||du |i}kp `kof{sks{||ip~egm kv{e|jkg~ s{oh fs NO |i}kp s{||du$ skf }f~kp |{j|s$hemh*id~fmk s}e~oh `ifpns (J)Os%$ |i}kp okg~kps (\)Os% fgn k~o' dis~

c{go~eig n{k ~i cdiinegm ip }f~kp nfjfmk'

[ge~ 62 Oij|dk~k diss ic |i}kp s{||du egod{negm N)O |i}kp

[ge~ 02 Oij|dk~k diss ic |i}kp s{||du fs sfjk fs [ge~ 6

[ge~ ?2 Diss ic fdd FO |i}kp s{||du

Ej|fo~ ic s{gfje ig Ig*se~k \i}kp _{||du fgn Oiidegm _us~kjs


46/82

[ge~ 6 [ge~ 0 [ge~ ? [ge~ > [ge~ ; [ge~ 3

KjkpmkgouNekskd

Mkgkpf~ip

6F$ 6@

(^)@ fskjkg~%

0F

(^)@ fskjkg~%

0@

?F$ ?@

(^)@ fskjkg~%

>F

(^)@ fskjkg~%

>@

;F$ ;@

(^)@ fskjkg~%

3F2 P)@ `fskjkg~3@2 NM `{ednegm

6C

([sf`dk%ijjig |ii ijjig |ii`fskjkg~

hemh*id~fmks}e~oh`ifpns

^)@ 6C

^)@ `fskjkg~$ k~o'

^)@ `fskjkg~$

k~o'

^)@ fskjkg~$ k~o'

^)@ `fskjkg~$

k~o'

P)@ 0C `fskjkg~

\i}kp okg~kp(gi~k%

^)@ 6C k~o'

^)@ 6C k~o'

^)@ `fskjkg~$k~o'

^)@ 6C$ k~o'

^)@ 0C$ k~o'

P)@ 0C `fskjkg~$k~o'

(`f~~kpu%O)@ `fskjkg~$

k~o'O)@ fskjkg~$ k~o'

^)@ jkrrfgegk`fskjkg~

O)@ fskjkg~$ k~o'^)@ jkrrfgegk

`fskjkg~^)@ jkrrfgegk

`fskjkg~

Kjkpmkgouoipk

Hi}kkp$ EO

(POEO fgn H\O kv{e|jkg~

egs|ko~eig

{sf`dk%

2 [g{sf`dk n{k ~i cdiinegm ip }f~kp nfjfmk 2 \fp~efddu {g{sf`dk 2 [sf`dk ^)@2 ^{p`egk {ednegm O)@2 Oig~pid {ednegm P)@2 Pkfo~ip {ednegm(Gi~k% Fep oepo{e~ pkfakp (FO@%$ m{fpn pkdfu fgn |kpe|hkpfd kv{e|jkg~ s~ipkn eg f oij|fo~ jfggkp {segm f ji~ek |i}kp |fgkd ~hf~ {sks di}*id~fmkoepo{e~s }e~heg ~hk |dfg~

_i{pok2 Jinecekn ~i ~hk 0


47/82


48/82


49/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks cip Ig*se~k \i}kp _us~kjs


50/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk ; Nes|kpsk Ig*se~k |i}kp kv{e|jkg~xfj| k pkgm kg gm k pk {g fgou i |i}kp s{|| u fg s} o

`ifpnsKgs{pegm ~hk nekpse~u ic egs~fddf~eig diof~eigs ic ig*se~k |i}kp

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 3 Kghfgok oi{g~kpjkfs{pk cip cdiinegm

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk = Kghfgok nekpse~u fgn pkn{gnfgou ic

Kxfj|dk2 _~pkgm~hkgegm ~hk nekpse~u ic ~hk oiidegm jk~hins ~hpi{mhfep oiidegm$ }f~kp oiidegm fgn k~o'

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks cip Ig*se~k \i}kp _us~kjs (oig~'%


51/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 8 Kghfgok kjkp kgo NO i}kp s{ dKxfj|dk2 _ko{pegm ~hk s~ipfmk of|foe~u ic `f~~kpeks fooipnegm ~i ~hk

ohfpfo~kpes~eos ic ~hk |dfg~ (e~ es gkokssfpu ~i sko{pk f s~ipfmkof|foe~u ic f~ dkfs~ 8 hi{ps }e~h ~hk s~ipfmk of|foe~u ic ~hkf kp ks i igk sus kj } i{ si f gm k if fg f kfs

0> hi{ps fc~kp ~hk {ggkokssfpu difns fpk esidf~kn'%

Kxfj|dk2 _ko{pegm f |i}kp s{||du nkneof~kn ~i |fp~eo{dfpdu ej|ip~fg~

egs~p{jkg~f~eig # oig~pid sus~kj$ `u sk|fpf~kdu |pk|fpegm fohfp eg s s~kj fgn `f~~kpeks eg fnne~eig ~i ~hk kxes~eg fgnfd~kpgf~ek |i}kp s{||deks

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 6< Cfoede~f~k fd~kpgf~ek i}kp s{ d cpij i{~senkKxfj|dk2 _~fgnfpnerf~eig ic ~hk |i}kp s{||du egdk~s i{~senk ic ~hk

`{ednegms cpij |i}kp s{||du ofp_|de~~egm ~hkj eg~i ~}i diof~eigs ip jipk (egod{negm jkfs{pks

fmf gs sf }f kp

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 66 _~ioa `foa{| kdko~peofd kv{e|jkg~xfj| k ko{p gm s|fpk |fp s i s$ s fg of ks

Egs~fddegm `foa{| kv{e|jkg~

\pk|fpegm |ip~f`dk demh~s

Pkdf~knCfoede~ekscipOi{g~kpjkfs{pks


52/82

]f~kp~emh~ niip (_i{pok2 ^hk _heaia{ Kdko~peo\i}kp Oi'$Ego'%

Mfs ~{p`egk mkgkpf~ip (_i{pok2 ^hkOh{mia{ Kdko~peo \i}kp Oi'$Ego'% Kjkpmkgou mkgkpf~ip ic oiidegm

jk~hins ~hpi{mh fep oiidegm(_i{pok2^hk Oh{mia{ Kdko~peo \i}kpOi' Ego'

s|fpk |fp~s(kdko~peo ji~ip%

Pk|dfokjkg~(|{j|s%

60;S `f~~kpu ohfpmkp piij

_|fpk |fp~s ic kdko~peo ji~ips fgn pk|dfokjkg~ic |{j|s (_i{pok2 ^hk Oh{mia{ Kdko~peo \i}kpOi'$Ego'%

\i}kp s{||du egdk~s i{~senk ic ~hk `{ednegmsi{pok2 k i { ko p o i}kp i'$ go'

0;


53/82

' Oiidegm _us~kjs

Pkdf~eig `k~}kkg ic \i}kp _{||du fgn Oiidegm _us~kjs


54/82

~hk kfpdu s~fmk' [ge~ 02 Fdd |i}kp s{||du }fs dis~' POEO oig~eg{kn oiidegm'

^hk pkfo~ips sh{~ ni}g f{~ijf~eofddu n{k ~i kfp~hv{fak$diss ic kx~kpgfd |i}kp s{||du'

[ge~ ?2 POEO fgn H\OE oig~eg{kn oiidegm {g~ed N)O |i}kp s{||du pfg i{~'

\i}kp s{||du kv{e|jkg~ s{oh fs N)Ms }fs gi~ {gffedf`dkn{k ~i ~s{gfje$ diss ic fdd FO |i}kp s{||du

Diss ic c{go~eig ic NO |i}kp s{||du n{k ~i C{go~eig ic NO |i}kp s{||du

[ge~ 6 # 0 [ge~ ?

[ge~ ?[ge~ 6 [ge~ 0

POEO ip H\OE oig~eg{kn oiidegm {g~ed`f~~kpu pfg i{~'

POEO oig~eg{kn oiidegm'}fs {gff f k i o ko

s~f~{s fgn i|kpf~k' H\OE }fs{gffedf`dk ~i s~fp~ {|'

Dkn ~i fooenkg~ f~ kfpdu ~ejkPOEO oig~eg{kn ~i i|kpf~k {g~ed Fc~kp POEO s~i||kn f~ 662?3 ig Jfp'60$

' ' di} dkkd ic }f~kp eg pkfo~ip'

I|kpf~egm Oigne~eigs ic Esidf~eig Oignkgskp (EO% ic [ge~ 6


55/82

N{k ~i diss ic NO |i}kp

s{||du fc~kp ~s{gfje$ ~hkegneof~eig ic ~hk fdk

Esidf~eig Sfdk I|kpf~eig Eg~kpdioaDiss ic NO i}kp s{ d ic _ s~kj F

s~f~{s i|kg ip o isk}kg~ icc$ fgn ~hk EO`kofjk {goig~piddf`dk'

N{k ~i diss ic NO |i}kps{||du ic igk sus~kj$ cfed*

sfck i|kpf~eig eg `i~h sus~kj

ip _us~kj @

N{k ~i diss ic NO |i}kps{||du$ ~hk eg~kpdioa ic

*

_us~kj F fgn _us~kj @ esidf~eig fdk odisksemgfd

sfck jink odiskn ~hk EOfdks' EO s{||du |e|k esidf~eig fdk(JI*0F)@%

EO pk~{pg |e|k esidf~eig fdk

Esidf~eig fdk egsenk EOoig~fegjkg~ ksskd (JI*6F$ JI*

(JI*?F)@%Odisk i|kpf~eig

isk i|kpf ig

_{`skv{kg~ egks~emf~eigs shi}kn

hfdc}f i kg `i~h ig fgn icc Fpi{gn 682


56/82

_egok ~hk fdks egsenk

~hk \OS fpk i|kpf~kn}e~h FO |i}kp$ `i~h FO \i}kp

Sfdk egsenk ~hk

oig~fegjkg~ Sksskdi|kpf~ks ig FO |i}kp

_us~kjf~eo fgn _ohkjf~eo Nefmpfjic ~hk Esidf~eig Oignkgskp (EO%

s f {s*o ko fgi|kpf~eig }kpkej|isse`dk kkg }hkg

Pkfo~ip |pkss{pkikp ='6?J\fs~fus cip jipk~hfg 6; skoignsEO f{~i s~fp~{|

Oiidfg~ }f~kp

_~kfj kf|ipf~kn cpij ~hk ksskd inu esnesohfpmkn eg ~hk f~jis|hkpk_~kfj kje~~kn cpij ~hk kg~ |e|k es oigcepjkn`u ~hk i|kpf~egm |kpsiggkd

}fs ~kj|ipfpedupks~ipkn'

Pkfo~ip\

Esidf~eigOignkgskp F

Esidf~eig Oignkgskp @

^hk s~f~{s ic ~hk EO}fs jes{gnkps~iin'

kss{pkSk

sskd

Cpij cepk |pi~ko~eig sus~kj

I|kg n{k ~i hemh pkfo~ip |pkss{pk

~ip@{ednegm

NO \i}kpSfdk i{~senk ~hk

F{xedefpu }f~kps{||du sus~kj

Pkf

oig f gjkg ksski|kpf~ks ig NO |i}kp

Fgfduses ic Oigne~eig ic \OS ic [ge~ 0


57/82

$ $

pesk ic \OS |pkss{pk {g~ed Jfp' 6>' E~ es gk}du fss{jkn ~hf~ skf }f~kp eg~p{nkn eg~i ~hk _)O piij fgn oig~pe`{~kn ~i ~hksdi} pesk ic \OS pkss{pk'

?)6;

^hkpjfd kgkpmu egsenk

~hk oig~fegjkg~ espkdkfskn cip sijkpkfsigs'%

Jkfs{pknpkss{pk i

Pkfd~ejk

(A

%Gk}du fss{jkn oigne~eig


58/82

Oignkgskps~ipfmk

~fga

^ks~ ù|fssfdk

$

(6% ^hk fji{g~ ic cdi} }fs fnb{s~kn{segm ~ks~ degks'

Pkfo~ip|pkss{pk ksskd

^ks~degk

(?% ^hk H\OE }fs jfg{fddu sh{~ ni}g

}hkg ~hk pkfo~ip |pkss{pk npi||kn

`kdi}6J\f'

Oig~fegjkg~ ^{pègk

Oig~pid iccd{x ^hes nkoeseig ig jfg{fd sh{~ ni}g

}fs jfnk igdu ù f }ipakp ig n{~ufgn sijk i~hkp s~fccs }e~hi{~

\pkss{pkoig~pidpiij

_~kfj |e|k

Jegej{jcd{xJegej{j

oigs{d~egm skgeip jfgfmkps'

@kof{sk ~hk _PS oi{dn gi~ k

Egbko~eigdegk

ù|fssfdk

cdi} degki|kgk {k i f kpu k|pko f ig

fc~kp ~hk H\OE sh{~ ni}g$ P\S|pkss{pk pisk' Fgn fd~kpgf~ek di}

H\OE sus~kj nefmpfj~p{oa nen gi~ }ipa ke~hkp'

]f~kp dkkd }kg~ ni}g$ fgn ~hk oipk }fs kx|iskn

I|kpf~egm Oigne~eigs fgn Of{sks ic shi~ ni}g ic H\OE _us~kj ic [ge~ ? (oig~'%


59/82

]f~kp dkkd eg ~hk shpi{n(fgfduses%Ni}goijkp }f~kp dkkd(fgfduses%Jkfs{pkn fd{k

P\S |pkss{pk(fgfduses%Jkfs{pkn fd{k

POEO sh{~ni}g

H\OEs~fp~ {|

~kpdkkd(j%

|pkss{pk

H\OE sh{~ni}g

Pkfo~ip}f

H\OE sh{~ni}g

POEO sh{~ni}g

H\OEs~fp~ {|

Pkfo~ip

Nf~k fgn ~ejk Nf~k fgn ~ejk

_i{pok2 Pks|igsk ù îaui Kdko~peo \i}kp Oi' Ego$ cip ig s{`jesseig ic jf~kpefds ig cfo~s ig ~hkpks{d~s ic egks~emf~eig ic ~hk fooenkg~ fgn e~s |pimpkss ic îaui Kdko~peo \i}kp Oi' Ego C{a{shejf

Nfeeohe G{odkfp \i}kp _~f~eig (egs~p{o~eig% ess{kn ig Nko' 63$ 0


60/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 60 Ej|pik ~hk pks|igsk of|fède~eks cip fooenkg~sxfj| k s f s gm |piok {pk jfg{f

_ko{pegm ì~h hfpn}fpk (nisejk~kps fgn jfsas% fgn sic~}fpk(i|kpf~eig jfg{fds fgn `d{k|peg~s% ~i hkd| b{nmkjkg~

P#N ic ~s{gfje pkneo~eig s s~kjs

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 6? Nes|kpsk ~hk oiidegm }f~kp sus~kj fgn |pkkg~

Kxfj|dk2 Fni|~egm }f~kp~emh~ `{ednegms fgn |{j|egm piijs$ fgn

npfegegm c{go~eig

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 6> Kghfgok [H_ f~ f ~ejk ic fooenkg~Kxfj|dk2 Egs~fddegm |ip~f`dk fd~kpgf~ek PHP_s fgn)ip fep*oiidegm

kv{e|jkg~

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 6; Ej|pik ~hk jfgk{kpfède~u ic esidf~eig fdksKxfj|dk2 Kgs{pegm |ip~f`dk fep oij|pkssips fgn NO si{poks

Jkfs{pks ~i jfg{fddu i|kpf~egm

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks cip Oiidegm _us~kjs (oig~'%


61/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 63 Kghfgok ~hk fd~kpgf~ek }f~kp egbko~eig{go igs

Kxfj|dk2 Kgs{pegm |{j|s }e~h hemh nesohfpmk |pkss{pksEgs~fddegm egbko~eig |ip~s i{~senk ic ~hk pkfo~ip `{ednegm

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 6= Ej|pik ~hk pkdef`ede~u ic oiidegm fgn egbko~eigsus~kj cip s|kg~ c{kd |iid

xfj| k gs{p gm kps u fg pk {g fgou i oii gm fg g ko igc{go~eig (Jipkikp$ s~{nuegm ~i kgs{pk f s{cceoekg~ v{fg~e~u icoiidegm }f~kp$ f nkokg~pfderkn s~ipfmk oigcem{pf~eig$ fep*oiidkncfoede~eks fgn ~hk {sk ic npu s~ipfmk%

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks cip Oiidegm _us~kjs (oig~'%


62/82

]f~kp~emh~ niip (_i{pok2 ^hk Oh{mia{ Kdko~peo \i}kp Oi'$Ego'%

\ip~f`dk fd~kpgf~ek PHP_s (_i{pok2 ^K\OI%


63/82

' Oig~fegjkg~ _us~kjs

Ej|fo~ ig Diss ic C{go~eig ic Oig~fegjkg~ _us~kjs


64/82

Pfneifo~ek jf~kpefd dkfafmk |pks{jf`du ioo{ppkn }hkg ~hk|pkss{pk i k }fs gopkfsk k ipk k kg gm kof{sk kpfneifo~ek nisk hfn egopkfskn fc~kp egopkfsegm ic ~hk |pkss{pk ic

~hk \OS ic ~hk [ge~ 6' \isse`dk diof~eig ic dkfafmk }fs ~i| cdfgmk$|kgk~pf~eig ic ~hk oig~fegjkg~ ksskd fgn)ip kv{e|jkg~ hf~ohks'

E~ es hemhdu |isse`dk ~hf~ ~hk dkfafmks }kpk of{skn `u nk~kpeipf~eig

pfnef~eig nepko~du cpij ~hk |pkss{pk ksskd'

(_M^_% }fs gi~ |pi|kpdu esidf~kn$ ~h{s hunpimkg mfs `foa cdk}eg~i ~hk pkfo~ip `{ednegm' (eg |fp~eo{dfp$ [ge~ >%

Pks{d~s ic Nisk Jkfs{pkjkg~ (Kfoh Cdiip ([ge~ 0 Pkfo~ip @{ednegm%%


65/82

`kof{sk ~hk nisk ic ;~h

cdiip es f ck} h{gnpkn j_)h }hedk ~hk i~hkp cdiips fpksijk nirkg j_)h'

;~h cdiip ic ~hk [ge~ 0 pkfo~ip `{ednegm

0gn cdiip ic ~hk [ge~ 0 pkfo~ip `{ednegm

{ge~2 j_)h(_i{pok% Jf~kpefds |{`deshkn u iaui Kdko~peo \i}kp Oi'$ Ego'(Gi~k% Fs cip ~hk pks{d~s ic jkfs{pkjkg~$ eg~kpgfd oig~fjegf~eig ic |e|ks k~o$ fgn s{pcfok oig~fjegf~eig ic }fdds fpk gi~ nes~egm{eshkn'

iip i k g pkfo ip { gm

Pks{d~s ic Nisk Jkfs{pkjkg~ (_|i~2 \kgk~pf~eig ic \OS$ Jfohegk Hf~oh%


66/82

'

Fpkf ic hemh nisk pf~knkeok hf~oh

Fpkf ic hemh nisk pf~k(|kgk~pf~eig ic \OS%

6s~ cdiip ic ~hk [ge~ 0 pkfo~ip {ednegm 6s~ cdiip ic ~hk [ge~ ? pkfo~ip `{ednegm

\dfoks ic \isse`dk Dkfoafmk (Kxfj|dk ic Jfpa*E ~u|k Pkfo~ip%


67/82

\e|egm|kgk~pf~eig

Kdko~peo }epegm|kgk~pf~eig

î| hkfn cdfgmk

Fepdioa cip|kpsiggkd

Jfohegk hf~oh

Skg~ ~{`k`kddi}s

I~hkps s{oh fs Ê\

(_i{pok% Kxfj|dk ic Igfmf}f \i}kp _~f~eig ic îhia{ Kdko~peo \i}kp Oi'$ Ego' (^hk |hi~i ic ~hk ~i| cdfgmk esoi{p~ksu ic iaui Kdko~peo \i}kp Oi'$ Ego'%

OPN hf~oh'

\isseède~u ic Oig~fegjkg~ Nfjfmk n{k ~i Ikp*|pkss{perf~eigfgn)ip Ikp*hkf~egm (ikp*Hkf~egm Nfjfmk%


68/82

fgn cdfgmk mfsak~s kkg {gnkp |pkss{pk ic


69/82

kx|diseig ioo{ppkn ig ~hk ~i| cdiip (;C% eg [ge~ 6' ^hk pkdkfskn hunpimkg eg~i ;C ic ~hk pkfo~ip `{ednegm foo{j{df~kn jfegdu eg ;C'

@khfeips ic hunpimkg mfs fss{jegm ~hk pkdkfsk

ic hunpimkg ic >


70/82

|pi`f`ede~u ic hunpimkg dkfafmk ~hpi{mh hf~ohks fgn)ip |kgk~pf~eigs ~i 6s~ cdiipic ~hk pkfo~ip `{ednegm'

^hk ?pn cdiip ic [ge~ ? P)@ fgn ~hk ~i| ic f ~}i*s~ipu `{ednegm gkx~ ~i ~hk P)@ hfk fdsi `kkgnfjfmkn'

Fss{jegm 6$


71/82

fooipnegm ~i ~hk i|kpf~eigfd |piokn{pk' @{~ ~hk i{~dk~ fdks ic _M^_ ic [ge~ ? }kpk gi~

esidf~kn' ^hisk ic [ge~ > }kpk ~hi{mh~ gi~ ~i `k esidf~kn fs }kdd' @kof{sk ic ~hk nfj|kp f~ ~hk i{~dk~ cip [ge~s 6*? }heoh odisks n{pegm diss ic |i}kp$ ~hk cdi}

' $~hkpk fpk gi semgeceofg~ `foacdi} eg igk nepko~eig eg~i ~hk `{ednegm `{~ e~ es necceo{d~ ~i nkgu ~hkioo{ppkgok ic `foacdi} e~skdc'

[ge~ 6 [ge~ 0MN2 mpfe~u nfj|kp (ohkoa fdk ~hf~ s~fus odiskn

^i piickg~edf~eig

u fg fgo ipfdks fpk fdd FI fdksodisk)odisk

odisk)i|kg

odisk)i|kg

odisk)i|kg

odisk)i|kg

Cpij ~hk pkfo~ip {ednegm

Kxhf{s~ cfgCpij |pkss{pk

Fep i|kpf~knnfj|kp

MN

odisk)i|kg odisk)i|kg

odisk)i kg odisk)i|kg

odisk)i|kgodisk)odisk

Kxhf{s~^i piic

Cpij ~hk pkfo~ip `{ednegm

Cpij |pkss{pk

odisk)odiskodisk)i|kg


odisk)odisk

Kxhf{s~ cfg

oig~pid piij

Skg~ degk Skg~ degk

Fep i|kpf~knnfj|kp

MN

odisk)i|kg

odisk)i|kg

odisk)odisk

odisk)odisk


cfgg

Kxhf{s~cfg

Skg~ degk Skg~ degk

oig~pid piij

[ge~ ? [ge~ >

odisk)i|kg odisk)i|kg odisk)i|kg

odisk)odiskw0'


72/82

pkdkfskn eg~i ~hk [ge~ > pkfo~ip `{ednegm ef ~hk `{ednegm kg~edf~eig sus~kj' ^hk cdiip fgn okedegm ic ~hk >~h cdiip ic [ge~ > }kpk nkcipjkn eg ~hk nepko~eig ic

kx|fgs ig' s ~ k oig~fj gf~ ig g ~ k { gm i g ~ > s i}kp ~ fg ~ f~ g[ge~s 6*?$ e~ es s{||iskn ~hf~ e~ kx|dinkn n{k ~i hunpimkg ~hf~ cdk} eg~i ~hk`{ednegm ~hpi{mh ced~kp$ }hedk kx|diseigs ic [ge~s 6 fgn ? }kpk of{skn `u hunpimkg

Pkfo~ip `{ednegm ic [ge~ >

kf k jf g u pij '

Kx|fgseig icjkpmegm |ieg~

senk

[ge~ > senk

^hk nisk pf~k f~~hk kxe~ senk ic

_M^_ es hemhkp'

2 cdi} ic hunpimkg mfs

_i{pok2 Fnnkn ~i ^hk ej|fo~ ic ~hk 0


73/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 68 Kghfgok nekpse~u ic \OS oiidegm sus~kjxfj| k gs{p gm f igf kf pkjif {go ig u {s gm f

s|pfu (}heoh ofg fdsi pkjik pfneifo~ek s{`s~fgoks eg ~hkOS% }e~hi{~ {segm ~hk FO |i}kp s{||du$ PHP$ fgn nekpse~u ic

OS oiideg c{go~eig k' 'fep oiideg

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 65 \pkkg~eig ic ~hk nfjfmegm ic \OS ~i|*hkfn

Kxfj|dk2 Kxfjegegm oiidegm cpij i{~senk ic ~i| hkfn

pkdef`du

Kxfj|dk2 _ko{pegm pks|igsk jfg{fd cip oij|dk~k diss ic |i}kp s{||du

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 06 Ej|pik jfgk{kpf`ede~u ic kg~egm sus~kjKxfj|dk2 Egs~fddegm f oij|pkssip `f~~kpu fgn)ip kv{e|jkg~ ~i jfg{fddu

i|kg ~hk fdkKxfjegegm ~hk `u|fss |e|k degk }e~h f fdk ic ~hk pf|~{pknesa

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks cip Oig~fegjkg~ _us~kjs (oig~'%


74/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 00 Je~emf~k ~hk kccko~ ic pfneifo~ee~u of{skn `ukg gm

Kxfj|dk2 Egs~fddegm pfneifo~ek s{`s~fgok pkjifd (ced~kpegm% cfoede~eks ~i~hk kg~ sus~kj

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 0? Kgs{pk egnk|kgnkgou ic kg~ sus~kjKxfj|dk2 Esidf~egm ~hk kg~ |e|ks cpij ~hk _M^_

-[ge~s

mfs oigokg~pf~eig fgn ~hk fnkv{f~k pkdkfsk%

Kxfj|dk2 Oig~piddegm pkdkfsk ic hunpimkg fgn egs~fddegm ~hk hunpimkgoigokg~pf~eig nk~ko~ip


75/82

' $Egs~p{jkg~f~eig fgn Oig~pid _us~kjs$

fg jkpmkgou ks|igsk ppfgmkjkg~s

Nfjfmks ic Oijj{geof~eig$ Egs~p{jkg~f~eig fgn Oig~pid _us~kj


76/82

Jis~ ic ~hk oijj{geof~eig cfoede~eks }kpk {gffedf`dk n{k ~i~hk |i}kp diss ip i~hkp of{sks'

^hk {sk ic egs~p{jkg~f~eig nkeoks }fs skkpkdu deje~knfc~kp ~s{gfje*of{skn |i}kp diss `kof{sk oiggko~eig ~ii{~senk `f~~kpeks }fs gkknkn'

^hk jige~ipegm |is~ }kpk fdsi {gffedf`dk n{k ~i ~hk

~s{gfje*of{skn |i}kp diss'

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks cip Oijj{geof~eig$ Egs~p{jkg~f~eig fgn Oig~pid _us~kj$fgn Kjkpmkgou Pks|igsk Fppfgmkjkg~


77/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 0; \pk|fpk kjkpmkgou oijjfgn okg~kpxfj| k ko{p gm |i}kp si{pok

\pkkg~egm ~hk egcd{x ic pfneifo~ek jf~kpefdKgs{pegm oijj{geof~eigs

Jige~ipegm c{go~eigs ic ~hk gkfp`u se~{f~eig

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 03 _ko{pk ~hk oijj{geof~eig ~iids cip fooenkg~sKxfj|dk2 _ko{pegm |i}kp si{pok

Egs~fddegm kv{e|jkg~ }e~h kfp~hv{fak pkses~fgok

^faegm jkfs{pks ~i |pi~ko~ ~hk |pejfpu oijj{geof~eig `fskcpij }f~kps f s gm fg kjkpmkgou pks|igsk g ipjf ig sus kj fg

~kdkeskn oigckpkgok sus~kj egod{negm f ~pfgsjesseig sus~kj

kv{e|jkg~ cip fooenkg~sKxfj|dk2 _ko{pegm |i}kp si{pok

$s|fpk egs~p{jkg~f~eigs # |fp~s

Kjkpmkgou Pks|igsk Okg~kp eg C{a{shejf Nfe*eohe G\_


78/82

(_i{pok2 K\OI%

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pks cip Oijj{geof~eig$ Egs~p{jkg~f~eig fgn Oig~pid _us~kj$fgn Kjkpmkgou Pks|igsk Fppfgmkjkg~ (oig~'%


79/82

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 08 Kghfgok ~hk jige~ipegm c{go~eigs cip ~hk |dfg~oig igs

Kxfj|dk2 [~ederegm s{pkeddfgok ofjkpfs egod{negm egsenk ~hk \OS\piji~egm pkskfpoh fgn nkkdi|jkg~ ~i kx|fgn ~hk pfgmk ic

Oi{g~kpjkfs{pk 05 Kghfgok kjkpmkgou jige~ipegm c{go~eigsegs~fddf~eig ic nkneof~kn |i}kp si{poks cip jige~ipegm |is~s

~hk kjkpmkgou pks|igsk

Kxfj|dk Kgs{pegm s|fpk |fp~sKs~f`deshegm f sus~kj ic sko{pegm ~hk jfg|i}kp fgn ofddegm

i{~^pfegegm |kpsigfds f~ gemh~ fgn `fn }kf~hkp


80/82

Oigod{seig

Oigod{seig


81/82

Nfe*eohe$ `edds ~i pkcipj pkm{df~ipu ipmfgerf~eigs fgnsus~kjs }kpk s{`je~~kn ~i ~hk Nek~' ]k kx|ko~ ~hes }eddoig~pe`{~k fdsi ~i egopkfskn pkm{df~ipu oij|k~kgok'

_ijk ~kohgeofd agi}dkn k hfs kkg kx~pfo~kn ~hpi{ hegks~emf~eigs cpij kgmegkkpegm |ieg~ ic ek} si cfp$fgn }edd `k {~ederkn ~i jfak ~hk gk} pkm{df~ipu

$

`kegm shfpkn }e~h eg~kpgf~eigfd oijj{ge~u'

fooenkg~ se~k skkpfd nkofnks fc~kp$ }k hfk f di~ icess{ks s~edd {gokp~feg ip gkokssfpu ~i `k egks~emf~knc{p~hkp'Bf|fg }edd shfpk ~hk df~ks~ egcipjf~eig fgn dkssigs

$oii|kpf~eig }e~h eg~kpgf~eigfd oiddkfm{ks'


82/82

^i nf~k$ Bf|fg hfs pkokekn f }enk'

Bf|fg kx|pkssks e~s nkk|ks~ mpf~e~{nk$

oig~eg{kn s{||ip~'

^hfga i{ cip i{p f~~kg~eig &

causes and countermeasures, masaya yasui, deputy director general, nuclear safety regulation reform,...

Documents