celebrations4 metrologist | july 2015 vol. 8 no. 3 newmembers mchale & associates 4700 coster...
TRANSCRIPT
NCSLI WORLDWIDE NEWS
Publisher NCSL InternationalEditor Linda Stone, NCSL InternationalContributing Editors Prof. Horst Czichos, BHT Berlin, University of Applied SciencesMark Kuster, Pantex MetrologyEditorial Committee Craig Gulka, NCSLI Executive DirectorTim Osborne, Trescal How to Reach Us:NCSL International2995 Wilderness Place, Suite 107Boulder, CO 80301-5404 USAPhone 303-440-3339 • Fax 303-440-3384
© Copyright 2015, NCSL International. Permission to quote excerpts or to reprint any articles should be obtained from NCSL International. NCSLI, for its part, hereby grants permission to quote excerpts and reprint articles from this magazine with acknowledgment of the source. Individual teachers, students, researchers, and libraries in nonprofit institutions and acting for them are permitted to make hard copies of articles for teaching or research purposes. Copying of articles for sale by document delivery services or suppliers, or beyond the free copying allowed above is not permitted. Reproduction in a reprint collection, or for advertising or promotional purposes, or republication in any form requires permission from NCSL International.
®
Publication ISSN #1940-2988Vol. 8, No. 3, July 2015
Metrologist is published byNCSL International and distributedto its member organizations.
EXPANDWhen you advertise with us!
For complete advertising information, visit: ncsli.org or
contact Linda Stone at [email protected].
Vol. 8 No. 2 • June 2013
IN THIS ISSUE:The Circle Game: The use of theLunar Distance and Related Measurementsfor Celestial and Satellite-Based Navigationand Timekeeping
Two-Color One-Way FrequencyTransfer in a Metropolitan OpticalFiber Data Network
Experimental and Simulation Study fora Time Transfer Service via aCommercial Geostationary Satellite
A Survey of Time Transfer viaa Bidirectional Fiber Link for PreciseCalibration Services
measure®
YOUR REACH
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 1
34
inthisissue
World Metrology DayCelebrations
12
NCSLI WORLDWIDE NEWS JUL
2015
specialfeaturescontents
Steeped in STEMWilliam Hinton16Joe D. Simmons ScholarshipAward Winner22Eurolab 25th AnniversaryRoger Burton26
World Metrology DayCelebrations12
Technical PaperVirtual Instrumentation - New ChallengesJorge Martins and Paul Packebush
38
Toward a MeasurementInformation InfrastructureSmart CertificatesMark Kuster
34
From the President 2From the Boardroom 3
NCSLI New Members 42015 Workshop & Symposium 6
2016 Technical Exchange 372016 Call For Papers 46
New Products and Services 48Regional News 51
Trescal Conference Lab Tour 60
International NewsNRC Canada 24
Letter From Europe 30 CIM 2015 Conference 25
CPEM 2016 Conference 29 Test & Measurement Conference 71
Advertisers Index 72
16
22
38
26
2 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
regionalnews
Greetings! I hope you are enjoying the start of summer and
are making your plans to attend the 2015 NCSLI Workshop &
Symposium that will be held at the Gaylord Texan Resort and
Convention Center in Grapevine, Texas from July 19-23. The
conference theme is “Measurement Science and the Quality of
Life.” You will be seeing some exciting changes this year, so I
hope to see you there.
In April, I had the privilege to represent NCSLI and attend
Eurolab’s 25th Anniversary celebration in Odense, Denmark. It
was a great opportunity to interact with our European friends
and learn more about Eurolab. You can read more details about
the event in my review article included in this issue.
At our lab, we recently celebrated World Metrology Day with a
BBQ lunch for our employees. World Metrology Day is an annual
celebration of the signature by representatives of 17 nations
of the Meter Convention on 20 May 1875. The Convention
set the framework for global collaboration in the science of
measurement and in its industrial, commercial and societal
applications. The original aim of the Meter Convention - the
world-wide uniformity of measurement - remains as important
today as it was in 1875. More information can be found at
http://www.worldmetrologyday.org/. Our celebration included
Roger Burton | NCSLI President
fromthepresident
a contest with two questions for the attendees: 1) What year
was the Meter Convention signed? and 2), What are the seven
base units of the SI system? How well would you have done
answering those two questions? Check out some of the other
World Metrology Day celebrations in this issue.
I would like to congratulate Lindsey Bass, the 2015 Joe D.
Simmons Scholarship award winner. Lindsey is a junior at
Virginia Tech majoring in Mechanical Engineering and Music
Performance. Read more about this highly motivated young lady
on page 22.
We are making plans now for the 2016 NCSLI Technical
Exchange, which will be held at the Omni Jacksonville Hotel, in
Jacksonville, Florida on February 1-2. You can pencil this in on
your calendar now, and more details will be forthcoming as we
get closer to the date.
I would like to take this opportunity to thank the conference
committee and all the volunteers involved in making our
annual conference a great success. I look forward to seeing
everyone in Grapevine!
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 3
The April 2015 meeting of the NCSLI
Board of Directors was held April 26-
29 in Overland Park, Kansas. Nineteen
board members and three guests
were in attendance to kick off the
discussions. Key topics of discussion
included the 2014 financial numbers,
the 2015 proposed budget, the 2015
Slate of Candidates, and the ISO/IEC
17025 revision.
The NCSLI Treasurer, Ingrid Ulrich, gave a presentation to the
board on the financial health of the organization based on the
completion of the 2014 financial audit. Ingrid also reported that
work continues with the NCSLI team to make improvements in
the financial monitoring tools. Following these discussions, the
2015 proposed budget was presented for voting and approved.
In other discussions, the board approved the 2015 Slate of
Candidates. The 2015 Slate includes the following: Dr. James
Olthoff, as the 2016 Executive Vice President; Paul Packebush,
Bob Sawyer, and Tim Osborne, as Vice Presidents in various
roles. In accordance with the NCSLI Bylaws, notification of
the membership regarding the candidates on the 2015 ballot is
required by July 1, 2015. Any additional nominations for the
ballot must be submitted prior to August 1, 2015. The distribution
of the election ballot is required by August 15, 2015. For more
information on the balloting and election procedure, a copy of
the NCSLI Bylaws is available on the NCSLI website.
Also, during these meetings, the board held a special session
on training and certification. The discussions focused on
potential avenues to promote continuous improvement and
value in the training provided by NCSLI. Key points from the
session were captured and are now being incorporated into a
business proposal. Further review of this topic and discussion of
the business proposal are expected at the October, 2015 meeting.
The Vice President of Standards and Practices, Jeff Gust,
presented an update on the activities of the ISO/CASCO Working
Group 44 on the revision of ISO/IEC 17025. The first meeting
of the working group was held in early February with the next
meeting scheduled in June. It was reported that a draft of the
document is expected later this year.
The next board meeting will take place at our annual conference
in Grapevine, Texas in July. The October meeting will be in Lake
Tahoe, Nevada. The board meetings are open to everyone and we
would welcome your attendance and participation.
fromtheboardroom
The Boardroom
NCSLI Board of Directors.
Dana Leaman | NCSLI Secretary
4 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
newmembers
McHale & Associates4700 Coster Road Knoxville, TN 37912 Contact: Dave Price, 865-588-2654, [email protected]
National Calibration, Incorporated3737 E. Broadway Road Phoenix, AZ 85040 Contact: Robert “Buck” Halloran, 602-437-0114, [email protected]
National Calibration Inc. (NCI) is an A2LA accredited full service laboratory serving a variety of clients throughout the United States. NCI began as a department within one of its sister companies in 1955 and became a separate entity in 1985. NCI has been meeting and satisfying the needs of a diverse set of clients ranging from aviation to construction, from government to industry. NCI’s professional technicians’ service and repair a wide variety of instrumentation and measuring devices in strict compliance of industry standards and requirements.
Providing in lab and on-site service, NCI is a true one stop shop for all of your calibration needs. Our state of the art, on-line tracking system, “Cal Hub” allows clients instant access to their reports and inventory for scheduling, organizing or printing a missing report. With locations in 4 states across the west, NCI has the personnel and capabilities to customize your calibration program to meet or exceed expectations. Call us toll free at 1-800-NCI-4500 for more information or a quote and see how NCI can serve you and help make your calibration program a winner.
Primo Instrument, Inc.4407 Charleroi Montreal, Quebec, H1H 1TC, Canada Contact: Christian Lefroit, 514-329-3242, [email protected]
Sandia National LaboratoriesP.O. Box 5800 MS 0665 Albuquerque, NM 87185 Contact: Meaghan Carpenter, 505-845-0883, [email protected]
Setra Systems159 Swanson Rd Boxborough, MA 01719 Contact: Tom Lish, 978-263-1400, [email protected]
Accurate Solutions Atlanta6303 Woodlore Drive N.W. Acworth, GA 30101 Contacts: Robert Hamilton, 770-428-9400 [email protected] Galen Evans, 770-355-0407 [email protected]
Allometrics, Incorporated2500 Bayport Blvd Seabrook, TX 77586-2405 Contact: Jayson Dirks, 281-474-3329, [email protected]
Allometrics specializes in laboratory product sales and instrument services. Incorporated since 1978, our growth and success as a distributor and service provider has enabled us to operate from 2 branches - Seabrook, TX and Baton Rouge, LA. These geographical locations enable us to best serve the Gulf Coast markets where we excel; Chemical, Petrochemical, Refining, Universities, Environ-mental, Bio-medical, Medical, Metallurgical, Aerospace, Food Pro-cessing, Pharmaceutical.
Today, our sales consist primarily of general laboratory products and instrumentation. As a well-known accredited service provider, we manage a broad base of experience in the disciplines of testing, cer-tification and repair where we have the highest levels of technical competency; Laboratory Balances, Weight Measurement, HEPA Fil-tered Systems, Chemical Fume Hoods, Temperature Measurement, Gas Chromatography, Microscopy, Coulometry, Conductivity, pH.
Enercon Services Canada, Inc.325 Rue Joliette 912, Longueuil, Quebec, J4H 2G6, Canada Contact: Jean-Philippe Bedard, [email protected]
IndySoft Corporation212 Adley Way Greenville, SC 29607 Contact: Charles Thompson, (864) 627-8858 [email protected]
At IndySoft we believe the purchase of a calibration or tooling asset management system is one of the most important decisions you can make in relation to your quality program needs. We un-derstand that these are your operations and the right software package is going to be the one that can compliment and aug-ment your process, not unflinchingly dictate how you have to run your business. At IndySoft we take the time to understand your business needs and challenges, then pull from our extensive experience to offer just the right mix of products and services to meet your long-term goals. We look forward to hearing from you, learning about your business, and showing you all the great things you can accomplish by working with us.
Welcome
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 5
newmembers
SIMCO Electronics65 E. Wadsworth Park Drive, Ste. 101 Draper, UT 84020 Contact: Curtis Keller, 801-576-0790, [email protected]
Space Exploration Technologies1 Rocket Road Hawthorne, CA 90250 Contact: Rodney Weissenburger, [email protected]
SpaceX is a US-based advanced technology company founded by residing CEO and CTO, Elon Musk. Founded in 2002, SpaceX builds rockets and spacecraft from the ground up, including cut-ting edge electronics, software, vehicle structures, and engine systems. The Falcon Launch Vehicle and Dragon Spacecraft pro-grams are some of the most ambitious engineering systems in the world, designed to support our ultimate goals of aviation-like spaceflight capability and making humanity a multi-planet spe-cies. Our team is made up of more than 3,000 SpaceXers located across our Hawthorne, California headquarters; and other facili-ties in Florida, Texas, and Washington, DC.
Transportation Technology Center, IncorporatedP.O. Box 11130 Pueblo, CO 81001 Contact: Steve Renfrow, 719-585-1846 [email protected]
Transportation Technology Center, Inc. (TTCI), a wholly owned subsidiary of the Association of American Railroads. TTCI is a world-class transportation research and testing organization, providing emerging technology solutions for the railway indus-try throughout North America and the world. Headquartered in Pueblo, Colorado TTCI manages extensive track facilities, state-of-the-art laboratory facilities, and a highly talented engineering and support staff.
GEO Calibration2190 Smithtown AvenueRonkonkoma, NY 11779
Tel: (631) 471 - 6157Fax: (631) 471 - 6158Email: [email protected]
www.GeoCalibration.com Distributors Welcome
±0.2%RH @ 10% to 50%RH±0.3%RH @ 90% to 96%RH
Humidity
5 - 55°C5 - 95%RH
Controlled Range
Temperature Humidity@23°C
5 Minutes
±0.1°C±0.6%RH
Stability
Temperature Humidity
•User Friendly•Probe Feedback•Fast and Easy Probe Connections•Remote Control and Monitoring.••Automatic Report Generation•Probe Information Database•Pre-written scripts
Features•Model 500•Model 1000•Model 1500•Model 2000•Model 2000SP DFB-11•Model 2000SP DFB - 44••Model 2015 TS•Model Glove Box
GEO Models
• Software Trials • More Chamber Models • Loaner Units • • Video Demonstrations • Further Speciications •
• Leasing Programs are Available •
Please visit www.GeoCalibration.com for:
Humidity Generators
Data-Logging Software
GEOCalibration
GAYLORD TEXAN RESORT AND CONVENTION CENTER | GRAPEVINE, TEXAS | JULY 19 – 23, 2015 TUTORIAL PROGRAM: JULY 19 – 20 | EXHIBITION HALL: JULY 20 – 23 | TECHNICAL PROGRAM: JULY 21 – 23
NCSLI 2015 Workshop & SymposiumMeasurement Science and the Quality of Life
MEASUREMENT SCIENCE
AND THE
OF
LIFE
GAYLORD TEXAN RESORT AND CONVENTION CENTERGRAPEVINE, TEXAS | JULY 19 – 23, 2015
TUTORIAL PROGRAM: JULY 19 – 20 | EXHIBITION HALL: JULY 20 – 23 | TECHNICAL PROGRAM: JULY 21 – 23 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Workshop & Symposium2015
MEASUREMENT SCIENCE AND THE QUALITY OF LIFE
Have you considered what impact Measurement Science has had on the quality of your life? If you take time to consider it,
you can appreciate what a large impact it has.
Conference SponsorsTHANK YOU TO OUR
Gold Sponsors
Media Sponsor
Silver Sponsors
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 8
Keynote SpeakersTUESDAY, JULY 21 | 8:30 AM - 10:30 AM | GRAPEVINE AB
THURSDAY, JULY 23 | 8:30 AM - 10:30 AM | GRAPEVINE AB
Dr. Chris Greer, NISTCommunities ranging from small towns to megacities are looking to the power of emerging Internet of technologies to better manage their resources and improve everything from health and safety to transportation and energy. They can meet their smart city needs with cyber-physical systems — interconnected hybrids of engineered and IT systems — if key engineering, security, and measurement challenges can be addressed. This presentation will focus on the example of smart grid as a foundation for smart city solutions, including measurement science principles for smart
city systems design and analysis, standards and guidelines for interoperability, and test beds for science-based design.
Dr. Chris Greer is NIST Senior Executive for Cyber Physical Systems and National Coordinator for Smart Grid Interoperability. In these positions, he is responsible for strategic planning, program implementation and coordination with partners across the public and private sectors. Prior to joining NIST, Dr. Greer served as Assistant Director for Information Technology R&D in the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy and Cybersecurity Liaison to the National Security Staff.
Steve Russell, Duke EnergyThe electric utility industry has largely remained unchanged for over a century. However, electric utilities have recently experienced a renaissance in the area commonly referred to as “Smart Grid.” Advances in technology have affected utilities in two ways. For the customer, technology is driving the need for highly reliable electric service as well as flexibility associated with electric sources, pricing, and services. For the utility, technology is enabling the performance to the electric grid to be driven to unprecedented levels of efficiency and reliability. Key catalysts and enablers for this
dynamic change are advances in measurement science and measurement technology. This presentation will discuss the past and present impacts of measurement science on the revitalization of the electric grid, and it will discuss emerging needs and challenges that measurement science is poised to address in the future.
Steve Russell is the DMS/DA Project Director for Duke Energy Carolinas and the Alstom DMS product within Grid Modernization. During his 29 year career with Duke Energy, Steve has worked in a wide variety of leadership roles including engineering, field operations and construction, finance, forecasting, scheduling, outage management and dispatching operations, metering, and corporate compliance and ethics. Steve also served as assistant to two of Duke Power’s presidents where he managed the office of the president and worked on a wide variety of special projects both internal and external to Duke Energy.
Amy Young, Filmmaker“Relying on the kindness of strangers”A metrologist’s work is unknown to most people. And the impact of metrology is hidden behind systems that work invisibly—as intended. So how can the general public understand the effect of measurement on the quality of life? This presentation shows some filmmaking strategies to engage the general public in mass measurement and in the work of metrologists, engineers, and
physicists. Video clips and other examples are taken from prime-time television and from the forthcoming documentary film, The State of the Unit. Intended for a general audience, the film presents the redefinition of the kilogram through location filming and interviews with people who weigh molecules, gunpowder, corn harvests, and kilograms.
Screenwriter Amy Young is a filmmaker with strong experience in communicating science to a general audience. For six seasons, she was a technical script consultant on the CBS show NUMB3RS, which won a Public Service Award from the National Science Board. For her current documentary project, The State of the Unit: The Kilogram, Amy has filmed and interviewed people weighing everything from atoms to semi-trucks, gunpowder and fields of corn.
Amy graduated from CalArts with an MFA in Film Directing. She currently works for two universities as a videographer and as program staff for a computational physics research group.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 9
Exhibit HallMONDAY, JULY 20 - THURSDAY, JULY 23 | LONGHORN EXHIBIT HALL EF
Metrology MixersMeet and mingle with fellow
conference attendees at these fun networking events.
TUESDAY, JULY 21 | 4:00 PM - 5:30 PMDrinks and Appetizers
Salmon sponsored by Fluke Calibration
WEDNESDAY, JULY 22 | 4:00 PM - 5:30 PMIce Cream Social
MONDAY, JULY 20, 20156:00 PM – 8:00 PM Exhibitor Welcome Reception
TUESDAY, JULY 21, 20157:30 AM - 8:30 AM Continental Buffet Breakfast7:30 AM - 5:30 PM Exhibit Viewing 11:30 AM - 1:00 PM Lunch Buffet in Exhibit Hall11:30 AM - 12:30 PM Poster Presentations4:00 PM - 5:30 PM Metrology Mixer Join us for drinks, appetizers and networking! Salmon sponsored by Fluke Calibration
WEDNESDAY, JULY 22, 20157:30 AM - 8:30 AM Continental Breakfast7:30 AM - 5:30 PM Exhibit Viewing 11:30 AM - 1:00 PM Lunch Buffet in Exhibit Hall11:30 AM - 12:30 PM Poster Presentations4:00 PM - 5:30 PM Metrology Mixer Join us for networking and the Ice Cream Social!
THURSDAY, JULY 23, 201510:00 AM - 1:00 PM Open to the Public Exhibit Hall closes at 1:00 PM
10 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
regionalnews
ExhibitorsA.com Electronic Measurement Technology 623
A.K.O. Inc. Torque Specialties Div. 504
ABTech 208
AccuMac Corporation 210
ACR Technical Services Inc. 607
AcuCal, Inc. 626
Additel Corporation SPONSOR 315
Alpha Electronics Corporation 613
American Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA) 414
American Technical Services 105
Ametek Test & Calibration Instruments 213
ANAB 212
Andeen-Hagerling, Inc. 214
AOIP 523
ASQ-MQD 122
AssetSmart 314
Automotive Industry Action Group 120
Bruel & Kjaer North America Inc. 617
Cal Lab Solutions, Inc. 104
Colorado Engineering Experiment Station Inc. (CEESI) 422
Consumers Energy Lab Services SPONSOR 622
Essco Calibration Laboratory 521
Exelon Powerlabs 507
Flexim Americas 604
Fluke Calibration SPONSOR 307
Fowler Precision Tools 322
GE Measurement & Control Solutions 327
GEO Calibration 602
Guildline Instruments 321
IEEE 116
Interface, Inc. 313
International Accreditation Service (IAS) 603
International Test and Evaluation Association 426
Isotech North America 102
JM Test Systems, Inc. 118
Kaymont Consolidated 610
Keysight Technologies SPONSOR 405
King Nutronics Corporation 620
Liberty Labs, Inc. 323
Lockheed Martin Misson Systems and Training 206
Lockheed Martin IS&GS 409
Mahr Federal, Inc. 320
regionalnews
Masy BioServices 513
Measurement Science Conference 124
Measurements International 306
Mensor SPONSOR 202
Mettler Toledo 609
Michell Instruments Inc. 527
Mitutoyo America Corporation 228
Morehouse Instrument Company, Inc. 103
National Institute of Standards and Technology 117
National Research Council Canada 223
National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP) 217
NCSL International 301
NCSLI — Dimensional PT Program 127
Northrop Grumman Corporation 302
Norway Labs 515
Ohm-Labs, Inc. 412
On Time Support, Inc. 716
Pond Engineering Laboratories 516
Pratt & Whitney Measurement Systems 508
Precision Environments, Inc. SPONSOR 417
Presys Instruments Inc. 428
Quality Magazine SPONSOR 601
Radian Research 427
Ralston Instruments 606
RH Systems, LLC 517
Rice Lake Weighing 221
Sartorius Mechatronics Corporation 416
Setra Systems, Inc. 616
Sika USA Inc. 720
Tegam, Inc. 310
Tektronix, Inc. 401
The Bionetics Corporation 211
The Boeing Company SPONSOR 621
The Modal Shop 209
Thunder Scientific Corporation 501
Tovey Engineering, Inc. 526
Transcat, Inc. 207
Transmille Calibration 100
Trescal Inc. SPONSOR 411
TRS - Rentelco 611
Vaisala, Inc. 600
Vibration Research Corporation 506
Western Environmental Corp. 511
WorkPlace Training, Inc. 205
Yokogawa Corporation Of America 312
12 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
The National Metrology Laboratory (NML) of The Gambia Standards
Bureau (TGSB) has recognized the event of World Metrology Day
yearly by organizing a host of sensitization programs for different sec-
tors of the economy. This year NML intends to continue in the same
vein by collaborating closely with the Weights and Measures Bureau
(WMB), the institution responsible for Legal Metrology in The Gam-
bia in commemoration of World Metrology Day. Below is the list of
activities planned for recognizing the signing the Metre Convention:
• TV and radio talk shows for the general public
• Sensitization workshop for stakeholders on World Metrology day
• Sensitizing local “Sandikaa” vendors of main markets within
the Greater Banjul
• Site visits and free calibration promotion for public institution
• Metrology sensitization for tertiary institutions
World Metrology DayCelebrations
World Metrology Day, The Gambia
worldmetrologyday
Africa
World Metrology Day National Research Council of Canada (NRC)To celebrate World Metrology Day and Interna-
tional Year of Light 2015, the National Research
Council of Canada (NRC)’s national metrology
institute, NRC Measurement Science and Stan-
dards, launched an awareness raising campaign
with the theme “Lights, camera, measure!”
diffusing articles, internet banners and posters
displayed in all NRC facilities across Canada.
The campaign promoted how measurement sci-
ence uses light for quality standards and how
accurate and reliable measurement underpins
industrial success across all sectors of the econ-
omy. NRC also hosted a seminar with invited
speaker, Dr. Isabelle Berbezier, Research Direc-
tor, of CNRS, Institute Matériaux Microélec-
tronique Nanosciences of Provence, Marseilles,
France, who gave a presentation on Roadmap
for SiGe Studies.
Canada
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 13
worldmetrologyday
The first Metrology Student Colloquium “Interacting with metrol-
ogy” was held at Universidad Politécnica de Santa Rosa Jáuregui
(UPSRJ) from May 20 to May 22 within the commemorative dates
of the World Metrology Day. The event was organized by the In-
dustrial Metrology Engineering Department with the participation
of students from all generations. [email protected]
For celebrating 2015 World Metrology Day,
the Center for Measurement Standards, ITRI
(CMS/ITRI) co-organized a conference focus-
ing on the same topic of the theme of this
year - Measurements and Light on May 18.
A total of 200 metrology-related participants
were attracted to attend the event.
CMS/ITRI was very pleased to invite Dr.
Martin Milton, Director of BIPM to Taiwan
to publicize the event with us together. Dr.
Milton gave a speech during the Conference
entitled “The Importance of Metrology for
Standards, Industry and Trade.” He outlined
the key elements of metrology, the recent
progress towards a new SI, and new challeng-
es for metrology in chemistry and biology.
World Metrology Day Celebration Universidad Politécnica de Santa Rosa Jáuregui in Mexico
World Metrology Day Nouakchott, Mauritania
World Metrology Day in Taiwan
The Universidad Politecnica de Ramos Arizpe from Saltillo Coahuila was pres-ent in the Colloquium as a Guest. University represented by 27 students, pro-fessors and administrative staff and the Rector Raúl Martínez Sergio Farias.
Dr. Martin Milton, Director of BIPM (right 7) was invited to Taiwan to publicize the event.
Mexico
Mauritania
Taiwan
14 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
worldmetrologyday
Lockheed Martin, Ocala OperationsLockheed Martin Missiles and Fire Control Ocala Operations
celebrated World Metrology Day by sharing what Metrology is
and why it is important to our line of business. Topics also covered
were calibration labels and inspection plates used in the Ocala
facility along with key command media for Control of Company-
Owned Standard Tools and Use of Ovens and Chambers in the
Manufacturing Process. The celebration also included Cake for
all to enjoy.
Consumers Energy Laboratory ServicesConsumers Energy’s Laboratory Services takes time to recognize World
Metrology Day with employees each year. The purpose of celebrating
is to help inform employees of what metrology is and what it means
to us in our everyday lives. The theme for 2015 is ‘Measurements
and Light’ which was chosen to collaborate with the UNESCO
International Year of Light and Light-based technologies 2015. The
alignment of these topics aims to focus on the key role light plays in
our daily lives and the importance light holds for our future.
Essco Calibration Laboratory
McClelland Elementary School
USAFlorida Michigan
Massachusetts
New HamshireRoy Carnival – Metrology Asc. Manager, Richard Fromert - QA Engineering Sr Mgr, Mike Whitman - Metrologist Sr, Ryan Boorman - Technician Calibration
McClelland Elementary School, Magnets and Magnetism.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 15
worldmetrologyday
We’re handing out FREE hot dogs in our
lab today to the site. How cool is that!
Dave Perkins
Metrology Engineer
HP - Corvallis, Oregon
Fluke Calibration celebrates World Metrology Day with games, cake, and a “Lunch and Learn” presentationFluke Calibration celebrated World Metrology Day with a variety of fun and educational
activities in multiple locations:
• In the temperature calibration center of excellence in American Fork Utah, the team
played a rousing game of Metrology Word Search.
• In the pressure and flow calibration center of excellence in Phoenix, Arizona, the
theme was cake and lots of it.
• There was cake in the Everett headquarters as well, plus a display of antique calibration
instruments. The highlight of the day was a “Lunch and Learn” presentation by Fluke
Chief Corporate Metrologist Jeff Gust on “The Pending 2018 Redefinition of the SI.”
• Fluke Calibration associates in Norwich, United Kingdom enjoyed a variety of cakes
and watched Jeff Gust’s video. They also played a variety of measurement games.
• Fluke Calibration associates also participated in the NCSLI Northwestern Region Mea-
surement Training Summit and World Metrology Day Celebration in Beaverton, Oregon.
To celebrate in American Fork, we had ice
cream sundaes and watched Jeff Gust’s
presentation on the upcoming changes to
the SI. I also went to a local 5th grade class
and shared a presentation on metrology
and temperature – froze a racquetball in
liquid nitrogen, all kinds of fun!
Mike Coleman
Fluke Calibration
Oregon Washington
Utah
16 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
learning+development
STEMGirlsBACKGROUNDNew Hampshire Governor Maggie Has-
san, in a statement dated January 13,
2015, observed that “modernizing how
we educate our students in the STEM
fields of science, technology, engi-
neering and math is critical to helping
them develop the skills needed for good
jobs in the innovation economy…”1
Executive Order 2014-012 established the
Governor’s Task Force on K-12 Science,
Technology, Engineering and Math (STEM)
Education3, returning their final report to
the Governor this past January. A por-
tion of the report documents a significant
gap between the numbers of girls as com-
pared to boys in STEM related education.
“Nationally, only 25 percent of engineers
and scientists are women” and census data
for New Hampshire finds “that only about
one in four (27 percent) of the computer
and mathematical occupations and… one
in seven (14 percent) architecture and en-
gineering occupations are held by women”
according to the report.
Steeped in
TECHNOLOGY DAY
By William Hinton, New Hampshire statewide Metrology Ambassador
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 17
THE CHALLENGEHow do we improve these statistics? How do we make an impact?
We do what we have been doing for many years now within NCSL
International through our education outreach efforts. The 2015
GTD (Girls Technology Day) event allowed us an opportunity to
participate in STEM related activities with an enhanced focus on
the girls and a much larger target audience.
The first GTD event was a one day event held March 14, 2013 at
NHTI (New Hampshire Technical Institute) in Concord, NH. Lisa
Danley, Director, Career Development Bureau, stated that this
event fostered the development of partnerships between the ed-
ucation community and industry within the state, with 120 girls
participating in 10 workshops that first year. Non-traditional ac-
tivities for this first GTD were based on programs in Vermont and
other states and the planning committee retooled this information
to create a STEM based event with a focus on information technol-
ogy and manufacturing. NHTI again hosted the 2014 GTD event
with 205 girls participating.
THE PROCESSGirls Technology Day 2015 was a collaboration between the New Hampshire Department of Education, the New Hampshire Community College System and industry and trade partners.The phenomenal success of this program, demonstrated by the
annual growth with a doubling of the attendees, resulted in 485
ninth and tenth grade girls participating in the workshops and
other events. Logistics required dividing the group in half with
the venue expanding to two days with NHTI and Manchester
Community College each hosting one day of the event. Twen-
ty-six high schools took advantage of 38 workshops from 57 pre-
senters representing academia and industry along with countless
volunteers assisting administration, workshops and a noon-time
vendor/college fair.
Meghan Haidul (right), NextEra Energy – Seabrook Station’s Fire
Protection Engineer and Cindy Brown, Senior Vice President for
the Dyn Corporation, were keynote speakers for this year’s event
as well as role models for the girls in attendance.
Meghan also visited the metrology workshop and spoke to the
girls about STEM careers and her engineering role at Seabrook Sta-
tion. She was impressed with how excited the girls were to be in-
volved and getting to interact with the materials and equipment,
saying “It was good to see girls’ realizing it was okay to be ‘nerdy’.
The girl peers seemed to make it okay. “
NCSL International metrology ambassadors have been in-
volved with local area students through education outreach for
many years. Courtney Ritchings, Education Consultant for the
Career Development Bureau was aware of NCSL International re-
lated education outreach on the state and local level and asked
William Hinton and his group of volunteers to support the 2015
GTD event. The material this group typically presents at an event
is agnostic to gender and would work well for the target audi-
ence. However, the event organizers desired to have the girls
more deeply immersed in hands-on experimentation, discovery
and learning.
William Hinton, owner of Hinton Technical Services; Gary Con-
falone and Eric Rosenberg of ECM Global Solutions in Topsfield,
MA and Tim Osmer, New Hampshire State Metrologist, facilitated
The bleachers were filled with 9th and 10th grade girls for the opening ceremony of the 2015 GTD event.
18 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
learning+development
three Metrology/STEM experiments within the workshop. Tradi-
tional presentations were retooled with additional material and
equipment to provide experiments and experiences in the applica-
tion and use of metrology related to STEM.
WORKSHOP EXPERIMENTSThree sub-workshop experiments were conducted in the area
of metrology of length and temperature measurements. Gary
and Eric provided a Faro Edge Arm and presented “Metrology
– Length – Laser Measurement. “ The operating theory, design
and STEM applications for the Faro laser measurement arm along
with an explanation of data acquisition were discussed and
demonstrated. Once the girls understood the operating theory
and the delicate operating requirements for this machine, they
were allowed to operate the unit, collecting scans of many differ-
ent objects including a facial scan of one of the students and a
biomedical skeleton. The scan data was captured as a point cloud
in the attached laptop where the rendering could be further ma-
nipulated. The technology behind the Faro Edge Arm made this
equipment the darling of our workshop. Tim Osmer commented
that “ECM’s FARO arm is always a show
piece and a unique opportunity for
anyone that gets to use it”.
Tim Osmer mentored
“Metrology – Temperature
– Infrared Thermometry”
using an infrared ther-
mometer from the NCSL
International Vernier kit
to measure insulation
performance on engi-
neered wall panels, con-
structed by the students.
The girls designed and as-
sembled their wall structures
from an assortment of materials
and installed them on the test fixture
which contained a 60 watt lamp (heat source). After the initial wall
temperatures were recorded, the heat source was energized and the
wall exteriors were monitored with the infrared thermometer. Test
data was collected every three minutes and uploaded to an Excel file
that charted the wall performance. The data was evaluated and the
best and worst performing wall panels were subjected to a forensic
analysis to determine why the walls performed with such disparity.
The Metrology Laboratory at NextEra Energy’s Seabrook Station,
and an NCSL International member, provided an additional infra-
red thermometer and a FLIR thermal imaging camera that allowed
the girls to search the event location for heated components (lamp
ballasts, heat ducts, etc.). Since it was well below freezing during the
day, they were also monitoring for poor, degraded or missing insu-
lation in exterior walls and windows. The girls soon discovered that
the FLIR camera could be used to measure the temperature of their
teammates with some interesting results. A spontaneous investiga-
tion was started by several students who noted an interesting arti-
fact in the images of those who wore glasses. Some lens coatings for
glare and scratch control have some infrared reflectance or absor-
bance properties making the lens standout against the background.
Metrology Workshop – Eric Rosenberg (ECM), Gary Confalone (ECM), Keynote Speaker Meghan Haidul (NextEra Energy), William Hinton (Hinton Technical Services) and Tim Osmer (NH State Metrologist).
“Industry involvement is
necessary to expose kids to
different career paths they
probably don’t know exist. This
is especially true for girls who
are rarely exposed to these STEM
careers, or who may be steered
away because of cultural and
social norms.”
- Gary Confalone, ECM
Girls in this experiment learn how to use the Faro arm to scan an artifact, assisted here by Eric Rosenberg.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 19
learning+development
William Hinton mentored “Metrology
– Temperature – Ice Point” using a tem-
perature probe and the Quest data collec-
tion unit from the Vernier kit. Vernon
Alt, Learning and Development committee
chairman, supported this
event by purchasing
and donating two
Vernier tempera-
ture probes for
incorporation
into the NCSLI
Kit. The abili-
ty to prepare
two concurrent
ice baths allowed
a control bath to
compare data against a second bath altered
with salt to measure the change in ice melt
point and resulting temperature depression.
Distilled ice and water were combined in
two insulated containers. Once the baths
were at equilibrium and relatively stable at
0 °C, one bath was dosed with NaCl (table
salt) and the effect on the temperature was
monitored, analyzed and discussed. The
girls noted that additional salt would lower
the temperature even further. Time con-
straints only allowed for two doses during
the experiment. For the sake of simplicity,
-20 °C was accepted as the lowest achiev-
able point. (The lowest obtainable tem-
perature is -21.1 °C at the point where the
solution becomes a eutectic mixture.)
“The experienceparticipating in GTD provided me with new information on STEM, careers to explore, and taught me that you can accomplish anything as a woman- there’s no limit to what you can do based on your gender.” - Anonymous Student
“I hope that you could
expand the program to
all high school girls, so
that we as sophomores
can come back and
learn more as juniors
and seniors.”
- Kearsarge Student
Girls receive coaching in the use of a FLIR infrared imaging camera from Tim Osmer.
Interaction with the metrology equipment found alternate uses for infrared technology.
Students prepare identical ice-point baths in preparation for dosing one with table salt.
20 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
“I really like howhands on and fun all of the things were, yet still educational. Nothing was boring and I think we learned a lot from this
experience.” - Kearsarge Student
learning+development
The science and engineering behind this phenomenon result-
ed in dialog with New Hampshire state Governor Maggie Hassan
during her afternoon visit to our workshop on the first day. There
was discussion regarding salting roads and walkways for safety,
the limits of effectiveness and how predictions of weather con-
ditions can be used to calculate the amount of salt the state may
need to dispense.
The Governor asked the girls if this type of event was of value
and the response was overwhelmingly positive. “The opportunity
to get our hands on the equipment and perform the experiments
was better than simply having a reading assignment from our
teacher then testing our memory” responded one student.
The Governor then challenged them saying “…you have a re-
sponsibility to talk with your teachers and parents and let them
know that this is a style of education that works for you.”
Feedback from the girls, observations of the other workshops
and the massive amount of work and preparations that went into
this two day event demonstrate the importance of engaging and
embracing this very important segment of our population. NCSL
International, in concert with academia and industry across the
country, will continue to successfully address STEM in general and
Metrology specifically to the girls in our communities.
William Hinton
NextEra Energy Retiree and Owner of Hinton Technical Services, LLC
in Rochester, NH.
An NCSLI member since 1996, Hinton is a past NCSLI Board
Member currently engaged in writing NCSLI documents and is a
New Hampshire statewide Metrology Ambassador.
Future STEM professionals collecting thermal data for their insulation performance experim
ent.
“STEM is vital for the future of food
security, water security, economic security and independence. STEM countries will lead, all others will be reliant.”
- Tim Osmer, NH State
Metrologist
Governor Maggie Hassan speaking with the girls in the Metrology workshop.
REFERENCES1. Governor Hassan’s Statement on
the STEM Task Force Report,
Communications Office, January
13, 2015
http://governor.nh.gov/media/
news/2015/pr-2015-01-13-stem.htm
2. Executive Order 2014-01, “Estab-
lishing the Governor’s Task Force on
Science, Technology, Engineering
and Math Education”
http://governor.nh.gov/media/or-
ders/documents/eo-2014-01.pdf
3. “Governor’s Task Force on K-12
STEM Education”
http://governor.nh.gov/commis-
sions-task-forces/stem/
documents/stem-01-2015-final-re-
port.pdf
July 2012 : Metrologist 13www.ncsli.org
Inspiring the Next GenerationWe seek to inspire the next generation of mea-surement scientists by introducing them to the diverse opportunities of careers in metrology.
Promoting Measurement ScienceMeasurements are the foundation of our global economy. Everything we purchase, create, de-sign, and build depends on metrology. Our goal is to promote the value of metrology’s impact in our everyday lives.
Educating to Meet Workforce ChallengesWe are committed to cultivating life-long edu-cation and professional development through scholarships, training opportunities, publica-tions, networking, collaboration and support of professional certification.
Investing in Measurement Science We strive to identify, secure, and invest the financial resources necessary to reach our strategic learning and development goals: inspire, promote and educate the next genera-tion of metrologists.
22 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
Lindsey Bass is a junior double majoring in Mechanical Engineering and Music Performance at Virginia Tech.She is originally from Pasadena, Maryland. As an active
undergrad, Lindsey is a member of Virginia Tech’s
University Honors Program, and in the summer
of 2014, she joined the Design, Research,
and Education for Additive Manufacturing
Systems (DREAMS) lab where she mainly
works with PolyJet material jetting, an
Additive Manufacturing (AM) process
involving liquid photopolymer selectively
jetted and simultaneously cured by UV
light in a layer-by-layer fabrication process.
Because AM applications are rapidly
expanding, there exists a need to quantify
the mechanical properties of the materials
to ensure reliable performances in different environments.
Lindsey’s current research explores two common materials
printed on the Objet350 Connex printer: a polypropylene-
like material (VeroWhitePlus) and an elastomer-like material
(TangoBlackPlus.) She printed standard tensile testing “dogbone”
specimens in six various mixtures of these two materials
and in three build orientations. Performing tensile
testing allowed her to characterize key anisotropic
properties such as ultimate strength, modulus
of elasticity, and elongation at break for
each material. She has also investigated
how aging of parts in different lighting
conditions affects material properties as
well as how part spacing on the build tray
affects part strength with attention to UV
light over-cure.
Lindsey previously completed a summer
undergraduate research fellowship involving
Additive Manufacturing (AM) at the National
Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
involving process-intermittent measurement of the binder
jetting process to help establish a future method of feedback
control on a 3D printer.
Her interest of combining creativity with technology and hands-
on engineering increases her drive to continue pursuing AM. Also
a member of the Virginia Tech Chamber Singers, Lindsey’s other
extra-curricular involvements include participating in a world
premiere opera, studying abroad for a semester in Switzerland via
the Presidential Global Scholars Program, and holding multiple
leadership roles in the Newman Catholic Community with the
musicians and mission trips.
learning+development
LindseyBass
173857--removing VeroWhite specimens from the Objet350 Connex printer.
Joe D. SimmonsMETROLOGY SCHOLARSHIPWINNER
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 23
QUALIFIED STUDENTS ARE ENCOURAGED TO APPLY
$3000 SCHOLARSHIP
Founded in the memory of Joe Simmons to support the study of measurement science
and metrology related quality topics.
For application forms or more information contact your advisor, student aid office, or the Scholarship itself at:
[email protected] www.ncsli.org (search Simmons)
Submit to: Simmons Scholarship
2995 Wilderness Place, Suite 107Boulder, CO 80301
Completed applications are due March 1
Joe D. Simmons NIST (NBS) (1963-1994)
1992 NCSLI, William A. Wildhack award winner. 1995 MSC, Andrew J. Woodington award winner.
Co-founder and Chair of ASQ Measurement Quality Division.
PROMOTINGACADEMIC
EXCELLENCE IN METROLOGY
www.ncsli.org
24 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
internationalnews
By The National Research Council Canada
Leading in Emerging Areas of NanotechnologyAs Canada’s leading Research and
Technology Organization, the National
Research Council of Canada (NRC)
offers innovative technology and high-
performance laboratories that address
some of the world’s foremost innovation
challenges. One such challenge is nanoscale
measurement. Through its expertise in
Measurement Science and Standards,
NRC enables the characterization
and standardization of manufactured
nanomaterials, including cellulose
nanocrystals (CNCs), which are emerging
as a highly valuable material for industry.
Cellulose nanocrystals – the eco alternative to oil-based productsCellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) are tiny, rod-
shaped particles composed of crystalline
cellulose. They are primarily derived from
wood but can also be extracted from other
plant materials, from bacteria to algae. CNCs
are the most abundant natural biopolymer
(complex, chain-like molecules made up
of repeating chemical blocks) found in
nature. In addition to being renewable and
sustainable, they provide an eco-friendly
alternative to oil-based products.
CNCs have high mechanical strength,
high surface area and thermal stability.
Their ability to take various forms, such
as gels and films, has triggered a wave
of recent activities aimed at turning
nanocellulose into commercial products
in diverse areas, including composite
materials, biomedical applications, paints,
coatings and packaging.
Certified Reference MaterialsGiven their unique properties, CNCs are
poised to penetrate numerous markets. The
National Research Council is supporting
Canada’s leadership position in the
production of CNCs by releasing two unique
Certified Reference Materials to further
develop and support CNC material for
the Canadian economy. These highly
homogeneous reference materials are used
to benchmark performance evaluations
and to ensure that testing protocols return
accurate information – regardless of where
or when the testing is performed.
Development of standardsNRC also supports the commercialization
of cellulosic nanomaterials by its
involvement in the development of
documentary standards. On behalf of
the Standards Council of Canada, NRC
is leading the development of a technical
report on CNCs with the International
Standards Organization (ISO). The report
will provide a framework for future
development of international standards
for CNCs and for nanocellulose-enhanced
products, facilitating their entry into
global markets.
Developing technical specifications and
standards for new products assists industry
to improve operations and become more
efficient. Standards help break down
barriers to international trade and open up
global markets. Furthermore, conformity
to standards reassures consumers that new
products are safe and do not pose a risk to
either humans or the environment.
For example, the Canadian Forestry
Service (CFS), looking to promote this next
wave of technology development in the
forestry/pulp and paper sector, is providing
external support to NRC for its standards
work, recognizing that international
standards are essential in ensuring the
adoption of Canadian products in the
global marketplace.
With its work in nanotechology, the
National Research Council of Canada is
helping to ensure a safe transition toward
the development of new products and
materials, such as cellulose nanotcrystals,
and is achieving quality levels that are
recognized world-wide.
Atomic force microscopy image of cellulose nanocrystals extracted from wood pulp. (Credit: The National Research Council of Canada)
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 25
26 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
25thAnniversaryof EurolabAt the invitation of Lorens Sibbeson, the Secretary of Eurolab
Denmark, I was pleased to represent NCSL International at the
Eurolab 25th Anniversary celebration and related meetings. The
meetings were held at the Radisson Blu H.C. Andersen Hotel in
Odense, Denmark on April 8–10, 2015. For those who may not
know, one of the claims to fame for Odense is being the birthplace
and home town of Hans Christian Andersen.
The events began on April 8, with the meeting of the Eurolab
Technical Committee for Quality Assurance (TCQA). The
meeting was chaired by the TCQA Vice-Chair, Irache Visiers Sanz
(EUROLAB España).
Various topics were discussed during the TCQA meeting, such as:
• Improving relationships with metrology/calibration laboratories;
• TCQA documents: Cook Books, Technical Documents, and Position
Papers later approved by the Board of Administrators (BoA);
• Standardization: Revision of ISO/IEC 17025. EUROLAB has been
actively involved in the revision process from an early stage,
having representatives in the working groups. The EUROLAB
representatives will continue to follow up the activities of the
working groups and the committees they attend.
The anniversary celebration continued the following day
with the EUROLAB 25th Anniversary Seminar. The Seminar
was titled: “Traceable testings in the International Context. The
Role of EUROLAB in the past 25 years – and in the next!” and
included delegates from 19 countries to discuss the role of me-
trology in Europe and identify some of the EUROLAB highlights
and involvement in the sector. This seminar was an excellent
platform for sharing the experiences and expectations of speak-
ers as well as participants from the laboratory sector. It was also
By Roger Burton, NCSLI President
Jiri Sobola and Roger Burton sign a new MOU between NCSL International and Eurolab.
internationalnews
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 27
internationalnews
an occasion to exchange memories with
the EUROLAB past-Presidents, present the
EUROLAB evolution during the past 25
years, and look towards future develop-
ments and opportunities.
The seminar included eight formal
presentations.
Dr. Horst Czichos, EUROLAB represen-
tative to NCSL International, gave an in-
teresting talk about the involvement of
EUROLAB in relation to the role of metrol-
ogy and testing to characterize materials
and products.
Warren Merkel, Chief of NVLAP, pre-
sented a talk on “Metrology in the Ac-
creditation Perspective.” NVLAP (National
Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Pro-
gram) provides third party accreditation
to testing and calibration n laboratories in
response to legislative actions or requests
from government agencies or private sec-
tor organizations. What are the synergies
with NIST and their activities?
My presentation was “NCSL Interna-
tional: Serving the World of Measure-
ment, More than 50 Years of Experience
in the Field.” I provided a brief look back
at how our organization was formed, pro-
vided a short history of NCSLI, reviewed
our current strategic plan, and presented
the value of NCSLI and what the benefits
are for being a member. Many of the at-
tendees were interested in NCSL Interna-
tional activities and expressed an interest
in becoming a member and attending the
Workshop & Symposium in July.
These and all other presentations from the
seminar are available on the EUROLAB 25th
Anniversary website: http://eurolab25.dk/
Roger Burton presents plaque to Jiri Sobola (former Eurolab President) on behalf of NCSL International to recognize EUROLAB’S 25 years.
Roger Burton, NCSL International President.
28 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
CPC4000Industrial Pressure Controller
Extended pressure rangesAutomated control
Best price/performance
For more information visit www.mensor.com or call us at 1-800-984-4200
The successful seminar was followed that evening by the Gala
Dinner to celebrate the EUROLAB 25th anniversary. During the
dinner, I was honored to present a plaque to Jiri Sobola (former
Eurolab President) on behalf of NCSL International to recognize
EUROLAB’S 25 years of success.
The EUROLAB General Assembly meeting was conducted on
the third and final day of the event. During the General assembly
meeting, Jiri Sobola and I signed a new MOU between NCSL
International and Eurolab.
During the General Assembly, the EUROLAB members elected a
new EUROLAB Board of Administrators:
• Álvaro Silva Ribeiro, RELACRE, EUROLAB President
• Jeff Llewellyn, BMTA, Vice-President
• Ruud Zantman, Fenelab, Vice-President and Treasurer
New Members of the BoA:
• Paolo Moscatti, Alpi Associazione
• Alexander Šafařík-Pštrosz, EUROLAB-CZ
• Kurt Ziegler, EUROLAB-Deutschland
Reelected members to the BoA:
• Ewa Bulska, POLLAB
• Jeff Llewellyn, BMTA
• José-Luis Sanchez, EUROLAB-España
• Ömer Güzel, TURKLAB, Representative of associated members
TCQA Chair:
Irache Visiers was elected as the new chair of the TCQA, following
Manfred Golze.
The EUROLAB General Assembly 2015 closed with thank-you
remarks from new President Álvaro Silva Ribeiro to the former
President Jiří Sobola for his valuable contributions and hard work
for EUROLAB.
If you have any questions, please contact the EUROLAB General
Secretariat: [email protected].
internationalnews
Conference on Precision Electromagnetic Measurements
This biennial conference is the premier international forum for the exchange of information on precision electromagnetic measurements.
JULY 10-15, 2016OTTAWA, CANADA
www.cpem2016.com Hosted by the National Research Council Canada
2170_CPEM_ad_8.375X10.875_e_v1_HR.pdf 1 2015-01-22 8:43 AM
30 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
internationalnews
Letter fromEuropeBy Prof. Horst CzichosBHT Berlin, University of Applied Sciences, Contributing Editor
The role of metrology and testingto characterize materials and productsEUROLAB, the European Federation of Measurement, Testing and Analytical Laboratories commemorated its 25th Anniversary in April
with an Anniversary Seminar, organized by EUROLAB-Denmark, and entitled “Traceable Testings in the International Context.” As Past
President of EUROLAB I was invited to give a talk on the role of metrology and testing to characterize materials and products. This Letter
summarizes the contents of this talk with key figures and explanations.
1. Background: Origin of Conformity Assessment• To facilitate the free movement of goods, persons, services, and capital – while protecting essential
public needs, e.g. safety, health, environment – the New Approach was established 1985 in the European Union (EU) as flexible regulatory framework for market and trade.
• Essential requirements are defined in EU-Directives. CE marking declares that the product is safe and in conformity with the relevant EU Directives.
• Harmonised EN Standards define the technical details Ô European Standards are valid in the whole EU, conflicting National Standards have to be withdrawn: “one standard, one test, accepted everywhere”.
• In connection with the formation of the European Union, EUROLAB was set up in Brussels April 1990. Since 1998 it is a Legal Entity under Belgian Law, composed of National Associations of Measurement, Testing and Analytical Laboratories with over 2,000 members and about 100,000 technical experts and laboratory practitioners. EUROLAB represents the laboratory community regarding political and technical issues, its members perform confomity assessment services.
2. Conformity Assessment as requirement for market and trade – and metrology and testing as scientific and technological base to characterize materials and products
The EU: 28 states,
24 languages, 500 million citizen
2
2. Conformity Assessment as requirement for market and trade
3. Metrology and Testing as scientific and technological base to
characterize technical objects
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 31
internationalnews
3. Metrology and Testing as base to characterize technical objects
4. Methodology of MeasurementMeasurement begins with the definition of the measurand, the quantity intended to be measured.
2
2. Conformity Assessment as requirement for market and trade
3. Metrology and Testing as scientific and technological base to
characterize technical objects
3
4. Methodology of Measurement
5. Methodology of Testing
32 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
internationalnews
5. Methodology of TestingTesting begins with the definition of the characteristics of an object to be determined by applying a test load to the object with refrence
to a test procedure.
6. The combination of Metrology and TestingThe combined methodologies of measurement and testing are necessary to characterize technical objects.
3
4. Methodology of Measurement
5. Methodology of Testing
4
6. The combination of Metrology and Testing
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 33
internationalnews
Combination of Metrology and TestingExample: Determination of Elasticity and Strength of a Technical Object
7. Traceability in Metrology and Testing: the Confidence Ring
AcknowledgmentAt the 25th Anniversary of EUROLAB I am very grateful to all collegues
with whom I discussed over the years the topics presented in this talk.
Some figures of the presentation were adopted from the Handbook
of Metrology and Testing, which was worked out in an international
cooperation wth contributions from Europe, Japan and the USA.
4
6. The combination of Metrology and Testing
5
7. Traceability requirements to characterize materials and products:
the Confidence Ring
***************
!"#
Springer
Handbookoƒ
Metrology and Testing
Czichos Saito Smith Editors
HKS 91
specialfeature
Toward aMeasurementInformationInfrastructure Smart Certificates
By Mark KusterPantex Metrology, Contributing Editor
Hello again and welcome to your MII column. This time we cook up a basic data model for smart certificates. As we will see, the stock we previously laid up in our MII instrument specifications and accreditation scope document models will come in handy. Let’s get started.
34 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 1
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 35
specialfeature
Pie in the SkyFirst, reconsider the main information that certificates supply:
• The customer, service, and UUT1 identification• The vendor and its accreditation status• Dates, personnel, procedures and deviations, amendments, miscellaneous info• Sampling detail, environmental conditions, other qualifiers• Measurement method and results, uncertainties, specifications, confor-
mance statements, traceability evidence
From an MII perspective, we would like to capture that information,
not only in an aesthetically pleasing human-readable document, but
also in a standardized machine-recognizable format, one version
either packaging or generating the other. Such a semantically
meaningful certificate would allow MII-aware software to
• Receive notification and retrieve the document directly from the vendor’s web service;
• Validate the vendor, accreditation status, ID numbers, dates, traceability, and the other pertinent administrative detail;
• Match reported measurements to the requested measurements and the vendor’s accreditation scope;
• Check that uncertainties suffice and fall within the accredited scope or tested specifications equal the expected specifications;
• Determine whether the conformance-tested instruments fell in tolerance before adjustments or test newly and previously reported values for metrological equivalence
• Initiate non-conformance actions if appropriate;• Transfer the reported results to the appropriate automation systems, data
files, lab management system, and uncertainty budgets;• Pass along the whole measurement chain’s traceability data to smokelessly2
account for correlations.
GastronomyWe obviously have a large plate before us so we will take it one bite
at a time. This installment will digest the more administrative tidbits
and freeze the juiciest technical leftovers for later.
Borrowing from past columns’ recipes for instrument specifications
and accreditation scopes, we jot down this high-level data model that
handles either a single instrument or a system of NI instruments:
Certificate
• System Identifier• Customer Identifier• Measuring Entity• Service• Accreditation (optional)• Qualification• Environmental Conditions• Measuring Instrument 1 Results
– Instrument 1 Identifier
– (technical data organized by functions and ranges)
• Measuring Instrument 2 Results ⋮
• Measuring Instrument NI Results• Locale-Language• Human-Readable Document• Visual Aids Script
We borrow past material not only for ease, but for compatibility—
information from the various MII documents should flow
seamlessly between them. So, reusing the appropriate specification
model elements, the UUT identifiers may appear like:
System or Instrument Identifier
• Unique ID (UUID3, hash, URL4, DOI5, etc.)• Nomenclature• Manufacturer• Model
Similarly, the Measuring Entity comes from the capability scope
model, structured simply as
Measuring Entity
• Organization Identifier• Organization Name
with the Service Identifier that matches the vendor’s appropriate
General Function (test, calibration, inspection, etc.) from its
capability scope document. The optional Accreditation element
holds the unique IDs that enable its validation:
Accreditation
• AB Identifier• Scope Identifier• AB Logo-Signature
For example, an ILAC6 or other registration web service might
accept the AB7 Identifier and direct the inquiry to the correct
AB web service, which would take the Scope Identifier and AB
Logo-Signature, validate the AB Logo approval, and serve up the
accreditation document for examination. A secure implementation
would detect unscrupulous vendors’ false accreditation claims that
A2LA’s8 Peter Unger has reported.
The customer information, new to this MII document, might
include:
Customer
• Unique Identifier• Name• Address
The qualifications element comprises all the administrative
data pulled from the vendor’s prepopulated laboratory
management system that qualify the service and fulfill certificate
content requirements such as those in ISO17025, including
cryptographically protected electronic signatures:
1 Unit under test2 See the April 2013 column.3 Universally unique identifier4 Universal resource locator5 Digital object identifier6 International Laboratory Accreditation Cooperation7 Accreditation body8 American Association for Laboratory Accreditation
specialfeature
Qualification
• Certification Date• Expiration Date (optional)• Procedure Identification• Procedure Deviations• Sampling Detail• Miscellaneous Text• Amendments• Personnel Identification• Approval Signature
Next, the Environmental Conditions element also draws from
the specifications document model
Conditions
• Quantity Value Interval 1• Quantity Value Interval 2 ⋮
• Quantity Value Interval NC
and lists the NC relevant environmental parameters’ values or
ranges within which the vendor performed the measurements.
Since the data structure matches that for the specification
document’s Operation Conditions and Reference Conditions, MII-
software may validate the certification conditions or use them
together with the instrument’s Quantity Function and Condition
Equations to correct measurement results for future Operating
Conditions as required.
As with our other MII documents, let’s stir in a Locale-Language
element to customize the certificate for a world region’s language
and character set, the Human-Readable Document template, and
the Visual Aids Script technology to populate any desired graphics.
That wraps up the basic ingredients for smart certificates. Perhaps
a bit bland so far, but in upcoming installments, we will continue
this discussion, add some VIM9 spice, and slice into the technical
detail. After that, a few tastings and revisions should refine our
model to cover most or all certificate flavors in use.
Conference DelectablesFollowing past practice, we would like to highlight some MII-
related topics from the upcoming NCSLI Workshop & Symposium
in Grapevine, Texas. A glance at the tutorial abstracts elsewhere
in this issue or at http://events.ncsli.org/ should entice you to
sample them further. The items with the more evident MII tastes
and aromas include:
• T2: LabVIEW™ Automation• T3, T5, T7, T11-T14, T19-T23, T25-T27: These metrology courses cover a
nice variety of measurement and analysis techniques optimized for specific measurement areas and equipment. If you attend one or more, think about how MII instrument models might capture the metrological knowledge presented.10
• T8: Geometric Dimensioning and Tolerancing (instrument specs)• T10: Lab Management Software. Don’t forget to ask Walter when he plans
to add MII features to his checklist!
The core technical program, both posters and live sessions,
offers traditional and more exotic dishes related to instruments,
uncertainty, automation, reports, accreditation, and other MII-
related fare too numerous to mention individually. Take a look at
the menu and enjoy your selections. Many thanks to those of you
who fired up your own grill to create these entrees.
An MII will require many chefs and burn lots of calories on
discussion, feedback and implementation so please send your
thoughts and ideas via email or the MII community discussion
forum at www.ncsli.org. See you in Grapevine.
9 International Vocabulary of Metrology10 See the October 2013 through April 2014 columns.
36 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
February 1-2, 2016OMNI JACKSONVILLE HOTEL
245 WATER STREET | JACKSONVILLE, FLORIDA 32202 | 904-355-6664
The NCSLI Technical Exchange provides a forum for exchanging ideas, measurement techniques, best practices and innovations with others interested in metrology industry trends. This measurement training will build or enhance specific hands-on skills in the calibration of measurement and test equipment, and teach best practices along with
introducing new and innovative calibration hardware, software and calibration services.
This two-day event will offer metrology training covering several fields. Each training session is taught by subject matter experts from throughout the industry.
For registration questions and answers, please call theNCSLI business office. 303-440-3339 or visit ncsli.org
ncsli.org
NCSL International2995 Wilderness Place | Suite 107Boulder CO 80301303-440-3339
38 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
technicalpaper
1. IntroductionThe trends of increasing device complexity
and technology convergence are driving
test systems to be more flexible. Test
systems must accommodate device changes
over time, even though cost pressures
are demanding longer system lifetimes.
One way to accomplish these objectives
is through a software-defined, modular
architecture. Virtual Instrumentation
provides options for the hardware platform
and software implementations, required to
meet these challenges.
Fundamentally there are two types
of instrumentation today, virtual and
traditional. Figure 1 illustrates the
architectures of these types.
AbstractHigh accuracy Virtual Instrumentation applications in the industry have grown exponentially in the last ten years, particularly after the
adoption of the PXI Modular Instrumentation standard.
Measurement system developers pick and choose off the shelf measurement I/O and controller capability to create custom measurement
systems that do not require custom hardware. Most of the integration work is done by R&D engineers and software developers who are not
concerned with long term maintenance or accuracy evaluation. In addition calibration requirements of the measurement systems are, in
most cases, not fully addressed. Complicating matters further, the Modular Instruments are often integrated within more complex systems
or they are seen as computer extensions that do not require adjustment or calibration. This preconception cannot be further from the
truth, and can ultimately lead to customer liability due to inaccurate measurements. Today, Modular Instrument based T&M performance
is comparable or superior to conventional instruments, and like them, they require comparable levels of calibration and traceability.
Not all computer based instruments are born equal. Modular Instrumentation independent hardware and software nature poses
further challenges to manufacturers and developers. The T&M expert needs to evaluate characteristics that are taken for granted on
bulkier bench top equipment. Only the best Modular Instrument manufacturers offer solutions to these questions. On the other hand,
the T&M industry will greatly benefit from the unique characteristics of these instruments, reduce their own development processes and
improve time to market.
The purpose of this paper is to raise the awareness of the industry community, and in particular measurement system integrators,
quality assurance officers and calibration laboratory managers of the necessity to apply the same level of scrutiny and traceability to
modular T&M instruments as they do for the conventional equipment used by their organizations.
By Jorge Martins and Paul Packebush National Instruments
Virtual Instrumentation New Challenges
Figure 1 - Traditional and Virtual Instrumentation.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 39
The diagrams show the similarities in these two
approaches. Both have measurement hardware, a chassis,
a power supply, a bus, a processor, an OS, and a user
interface. Because the approaches use the same basic
components, the most obvious difference from a purely
hardware standpoint is how the components are packaged.
A traditional instrument puts all of the components in the
same box for every discrete instrument. An example of a
stand-alone instrument is a manual instrument controlled
with GPIB, USB, or LAN/Ethernet. These instruments are
designed as discrete entities with defined functionality.
By contrast, Virtual Instrument provides the raw data from the
hardware directly to users, allowing them to define their own
measurements and user interface. With this software-defined
approach, users make custom measurements, and modify the
system if requirements change; for example, to add instruments,
channels, or measurement modes.
This combination of flexible, user-defined software and scalable
hardware components is the core of Modular Instrumentation.
2. Modular Hardware for System ScalabilityModular Instrumentation can take several forms. In a well designed
Modular Instrumentation system, many of the components - such
as the chassis and power supply - are shared across instrument
modules not duplicated for every instrument function.
In cases such as PXI (PCI eXtensions for Instrumentation)
- a rugged platform for test, measurement and control - the
measurement hardware is housed in an industrial chassis. In a
PXI system, the host computer can be embedded in the chassis (as
shown in Figure 3) or it can be a separate laptop, desktop, or server
that controls the measurement hardware through a cabled interface.
This sharing of the chassis and controller greatly reduces cost
but also enables the user to control the measurement-and-analysis
software. While there are many configuration choices for Modular
Instrumentation, the differentiator between this approach and
traditional instrumentation is that the software is open, so that the
user can define his/her own measurements as test needs change or
as measurements are unavailable on traditional instruments.
While the term “modular” is sometimes misapplied based on
the hardware packaging alone, Modular Instrumentation is about
more than just packaging. Users expect other benefits from a
Modular Instrumentation system:
• Reduced capital equipment costs and system size: Deploy a
complete test system for a lower cost with the same footprint as
a single traditional instrument.
• Rapid test development: Design and deploy test systems faster.
• Faster test execution with increased flexibility: Achieve higher
performance with PC data buses, multicore processors, and
field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs).
• Increased system scalability and success: Add or update
functionality as your needs evolve and benefit from world-class
services and support.
3. Modular Instrument ArchitectureWhile interchangeability of a Modular Instrument system is a
huge benefit, there is more to creating a test and measurement
platform than plugging hardware into a chassis or backplane. The
total platform contains both hardware and software components
at many different levels. Figure 4 represents the total investment
for a Modular Instrument platform.
The layer, Measurement and Control Services, is one of the most
crucial elements of a Modular Instrumentation system, though of-
ten overlooked. This layer represents the driver I/O software and
hardware configuration tools. This driver software is critical, be-
cause it provides the connectivity between the test development
software and the hardware for measurement and control.
Instrument drivers provide a set of high-level, human-readable
functions for interfacing with instruments. Each instrument driv-
er is specifically tailored to a particular model of instrument to
provide an interface to its unique capabilities. Of particular im-
Figure 2 - Examples of Modular Instrument hardware.
Figure 3 - Example of ModularInstruments Chassis PXI.
technicalpaper
40 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
technicalpaper
portance in an instrument driver is its inte-
gration with the Application Development
Environment (ADE) so that the instrument
commands are a seamless part of the ap-
plication development. System developers
need instrument driver interfaces opti-
mized for their development environment
of choice, for example, LabVIEW, C, C++,
or Microsoft .NET.
Also represented in Measurement and Con-
trol Services are configuration tools. These
configuration tools include resources for con-
figuring and testing I/O, as well as storing scal-
ing, calibration, and channel-aliasing infor-
mation. These tools are important for quickly
building, troubleshooting, and maintaining
an instrumentation system.
The software in the ADE layer provides
the tools to develop the code or procedure
for the application.
Every layer of this software architecture
should be considered for a Modular
Instrumentation system.
4. Adoption of Modular InstrumentationThe adoption of Modular Instrumentation
as a test platform continues to grow.
Considering only PXI systems there are
over 1,500 individual products support by
over 60 vendors [1].
Understanding the growth and adoption
rates of Modular Instruments, in all their
variations, helps us to see that metrology
laboratories will have an increased need to
service this type of instrumentation.
5. Case Study on Measurement AccuracyMany developers look at PXI instruments
as low accuracy versions of state-of-the-
art benchtop T&M instruments. Some
refer to them as “mindless beasts, which
uncertainties cannot be determined even
if we try to”, a statement that is not the
case. Modern PXI T&M instruments have
performance, capabilities, functions and
characteristics comparable and in most
cases superior to the best traditional
benchtop counterparts. That is not to say
that challenges in performing accurate
repeatable measurement do not exist for
PXI instrumentation, but instead these
challenges are common to all high accuracy
measurements. As an example, the following
sections compare the characteristics and
capabilities of two high performance PXI
based instruments to comparable world
class traditional instruments.
The most common and widely used
measurement instruments are the digital
multimeter and the oscilloscope. For the
purpose of this comparison a 7½ -digit
DMM and a 300 MHz oscilloscope are
chosen. The intent of this comparison is
not to evaluate all PXI and conventional
DMM characteristics and functions, but
rather to highlight their similarities and
basic specifications.
5.1. 7½ -digit DMMThis simple comparison of a 7½ -digit
DMM’s basic features shows that the
level of performance achieved by today’s
PXI Modular Instruments is at the level
of the best benchtop DMM’s. In addition
PXI Modular Instruments add the design
flexibility required to carry out extensive
measurement analysis in real time by
taking advantage of ever improving off the
shelf computer technology.
Device I/O and Connectivity
(Modular Instrument, Sources, Switches, Motion,
Vision, Data Acquisition, Digital, etc.)
Computing System and Form Factor
(cPCI, PXI, Embedded Processor,
Triggering, Synchronization)
Measurement and Control Services
(Drivers, Test Panels, Configuration SW)
Application Development Environment
(LabVIEW, C++, .NET, Others)
Operating System
(Windows, Linux, VxWorks, Embedded, etc.)
Environments
Instrument or I/O Libraries
Test
Programs
Figure 4 - Modular Instrument test and measurement system.
DC V 90 day accuracy Temperature Coefficient
PXI Benchtop Ratio PXI Benchtop Comparison
[18-28]°C [18-28]°C PXI vs. Benchtop [0-55]°C [0-50]°C PXI vs. Benchtop
100 mV ± 2.5 µV ± 3.7 µV 1.5x better ± 0.13 µV/°C ± 0.63 µV/°C 4.8x better
10 V ± 95 µV ± 260 µV 2.7x better ± 3.1 µV/°C ± 40 µV/°C 13x better
1000 V ± 18.5 mV ± 43 mV 2.3x better ± 0.31 µV/°C ± 6.1 mV/°C 20x better
Reading rate/s
7½-digit 7 6 1 more reading/s
6½-digit 100 57 43 more reading/s
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 41
technicalpaper
Resistance 90 day accuracy Temperature Coefficient
PXI Benchtop Ratio PXI Benchtop Comparison
[18-28]°C [18-28]°C PXI vs. Benchtop [0-55]°C [0-50]°C PXI vs. Benchtop
100Ω/4w ± 3.5 mΩ ± 5 mΩ 1.4x better ± 92 µΩ/°C ± 700 µΩ/°C 7.6x better
1 GΩ/2w ± 60 kΩ ± 20 kΩ 3x worst ± 2.5 MΩ/°C ± 4.0 MΩ/°C 1.6x better
Digitizer 2 year accuracy Flatness error
PXI Benchtop Ratio PXI Benchtop Comparison
[18-28]°C [18-28]°C PXI vs. Bench top 340 kHz BW na PXI vs. Bench top
Voltage 1.8 MS/s na na ± 0.014 dB na na
Current 1.8 MS/s na na ± 0.01 dB na na
AC V 2 year accuracy Temperature Coefficient
PXI Benchtop Ratio PXI Benchtop Comparison
[18-28]°C [18-28]°C PXI vs. Benchtop [0-55]°C [0-50]°C PXI vs. Benchtop
10 V @ 1 Hz ± 12.5 mV ± 15 mV 1.2x better ± 100 µV/°C ± 800 µV/°C 8x better
10 V @ 100 kHz ± 40 mV ± 33 mV 1.2x worst ± 600 µV/°C ± 800 µV/°C 1.3x better
DC I 90 day accuracy Temperature Coefficient
PXI Benchtop Ratio PXI Benchtop Comparison
[18-28]°C [18-28]°C PXI vs. Benchtop [0-55]°C [0-50]°C PXI vs. Benchtop
1 µA ± 360 pA na na ± 26 pA/°C na na
100 µA ± 9.1 nA ± 35 nA 3.9x better ± 1.1 nA/°C ± 7.2 nA/°C 6x better
2 A ± 870 µA ± 1280 µA 1.4x better ± 24 µA/°C ± 126 µA /°C 5x better
Technology advances continue to provide new features that make
the oscilloscope more useful to engineers. One of the most significant
transformations of the oscilloscope is its transition into the digital
domain, enabling powerful features such as digital signal processing
and waveform analysis.
Today’s digital oscilloscopes include a high speed, low resolution
(typically 8 bits) analog-to-digital converter (ADC), defined controls,
displays, and a built-in processor to run software algorithms for
common measurements.
Modular Instrument based digitizers, on the other hand, leverage
the latest processing power and high resolution display available
from a PC, while providing all the other features that comprise an
oscilloscope. As a result, they are used not only for oscilloscope
measurements, but also as spectrum analyzers, frequency counters,
ultrasonic receivers, and other customer measurements.
Standalone oscilloscopes are vendor-defined while Modular
Instrument digitizers are user-defined and flexible in the applications
they can solve. A benchtop oscilloscope provides many of the standard
functions that are common to the needs of engineers. As you can
imagine, these standard functions will not solve every application,
especially for automated test applications. If custom measurements
are required, a modular digitizer provides more options.
AC V 90 day accuracy
Comparison
PXI Benchtop PXI vs. Benchtop
Bandwidth 300 MHz 300 MHz =
Sampling rate 1 GS/s/2ch. or 2GS/s/1ch. 2.5 GS/s 2.5x worst
Vertical resolution 8 bit 9 bit 1 bit less
Accuracy 1V ± 2.3 % ± 2 % 1.2x worst
Time base accuracy ± 25 µHz/Hz ± 20 µHz/Hz 1.3x worst
Maximum record length 100,000 10,000 10x better
5.2. 300 MHz Oscilloscope
42 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
technicalpaper
6. Basic Calibration Requirements - Maintain traceabilityThe Modular Instruments transition from basic measurement low
accuracy to high performance measurement instruments happened
gradually over the course of several years. Some organizations and
users still have the misconception that they don’t need traceability
to the SI units and periodic calibration for them. At the same time
they evaluate the measurement results provided by their non-
calibrated instruments and make decisions about the quality of
their products. This oversight is potentially damaging for the long
term reputation of the user and extremely costly in the short term,
in case of a product recall or a stop shipping notice.
Several factors contributed to this dangerous misconception:
• A relatively long transition period from low accuracy to high
accuracy measurement instruments
• Perception of Modular Instruments as a digital computer boards
• The remote location of the PXI chassis and modules in the plant
• Lack of front panel controls
• Measurements are available in a computer monitor
• Presentation of the measurement results, after mathematical
treatment in a graphic form or a PASS/FAIL indication.
• Misleading messages from less informed sales representatives
that their boards never need verification. Their measurements
are solid as a rock, trust us!
PXI Modular Instruments measurement performance and
accuracy is comparable to the equivalent benchtop instruments
and need to be treated as such.
The process used to verify these instruments must:
• Check directly or indirectly all critical functions and
measurement capabilities
• Use a methodology that achieves the required uncertainties
under specific conditions
• Have an adequate uncertainty analysis
• Have an unbroken traceability chain to the SI units
• Be performed under controlled and repeatable conditions
7. Understanding Chassis MaintenancePXI systems are used in a wide range of applications including
benchtop, rack-mount and embedded setups. In each case we must
consider the system’s ambient temperature, cooling clearances
and power quality.
7.1. Chassis Airflow and CoolingThe ambient temperature of a PXI system is defined as the
temperature at the chassis fan inlet (air intake). This air intake
is usually located either at the rear or bottom of the chassis. If
the PXI chassis is setup as a benchtop instrument, a simple room
temperature measurement is a good estimate of its temperature. If
it is rack mounted the same measurement may not be the actual
ambient temperature of the PXI system due to heat dissipation
from surrounding equipment.
Adequate ambient temperature evaluation is a concern for rack-
mount deployments. If the PXI system is deployed in a rack there
are several guidelines that should be considered:
• Where possible place high power units above the PXI system(s).
• Use rack fan trays, at the top, at the bottom or both, depending
on power dissipation requirements.
• Design you rack layout to avoid abrupt temperature variations
• Strictly follow chassis cooling clearances requirements
Adequate cooling clearances are fundamental to keep the ambient
temperature of your PXI system stable and within the specifications
for all of the system components. The chassis must be installed in
such a way that the cooling clearances meet the specifications stated
in the manufacturer’s manual. A common clearance specification
Figure 6 – Example of PXI instruments and chassis.
Figure 7 - The ambient temperature of a PXI system is defined as the tem-perature at the air intake, which can be on the rear or bottom of the chassis.
Figure 8 - An example of two PXI 18-slot chassis rack-mounted with the required 1.75 in. (1U) of cooling clearance above each chassis.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 43
technicalpaper
for a PXI chassis with a rear air intake and top/side exhaust is a
minimum of 3 in. of clearance from the air intake on the rear of the
chassis and 1.75 in. (1 U) of clearance above and on the sides of the
chassis. The figure below shows an example of two 18-slot chassis
with the required 1U of clearance above each chassis.
7.2. Power QualityLike any other measurement instrument, the quality of the power
provided to the PXI system it is very important, it should have
low noise and distortion. It must be properly grounded, to a high
quality ground, either through the power cord or the chassis
grounding screw.
7.3. Calibration laboratory deploymentEven in a well controlled calibration laboratory environment,
either a benchtop or a rack mounted configuration can benefit
from the application of few simple techniques to improve the
cooling performance and temperature stability of the chassis.
• Filler panels – Empty slots must have filler panels installed to
attain the chassis temperature specification.
• Slot blockers – Install slot blockers on all unused chassis slots
to reduce air flow bypass and improve airflow through the
installed devices
• Fan speed selector – If the chassis has a fan speed selector with
AUTO option select a constant speed adequate for the chassis
power load, instead of the AUTO option.
8. Calibration Environmental ConcernsThere is some discussion about how PXI instruments should be calibrat-
ed. Some believe that they should be externally calibrated in situ with its
chassis and the other companion instruments. Others feel that it is ac-
ceptable to send the individual instruments to the calibration laboratory.
The more advanced PXI instruments use a self calibration function
to compensate for the majority of temperature effects. Temperature
impact that is not compensated for by self calibration is included in the
full operating temperature range accuracy. Based on these premises,
PXI instruments can be adjusted and/or calibrated independently of
the chassis and companion instruments in the normal calibration
laboratory environmental conditions. The calibration laboratory
should follow the recommendations of paragraph Understanding
Figure 9 - Slot blockers can improve the cooling performance of PXI chassis by reducing air flow bypass.
44 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
technicalpaper
chassis maintenance concerning all aspects of air flow, cooling,
laboratory deployment and power quality.
Once the instrument is reinstalled in its usual measurement
deployment it should reach a stable operating temperature for the
period recommended by the manufacturer before a self calibration
is performed. Moving an instrument from one slot to another in
a PXI chassis is equivalent to moving a conventional instrument
from one room to another. The self calibration, in most cases, is
valid within a defined temperature range from self calibration; for
example Tcal ± 1 °C or Tcal ± 3 °C .The PXI chassis temperature
can be monitored regularly to decide if another self calibration is
required to compensate for temperature variations.
Specific measurement applications and chassis loads (e.g.
chassis with high accuracy measurement instruments along with
switching high power boards) may require closer monitoring Most
Modular Instruments have an onboard temperature sensor that is
used to monitor instrument temperature.
9. Software driver impact on Adjustment and CalibrationThe hardware is the body of a Modular Instrument while the
SW driver is the brain, the smallest error in the driver can have
a significant impact in the behavior and performance of the all
instrument. When performing an adjustment the SW driver:
• Interfaces with the standard to obtain the its assigned value
• Interfaces with the Unit Under Test (UUT), to obtain the readings
• Performs mathematical computations using more or less
sophisticated algorithms
• Stores the adjustment constants in the UUT
After an adjustment it is fundamental to run a comprehensive
calibration/verification procedure to confirm that the adjustment
constants were properly calculated and saved in the instrument
hardware.
10. Software driver updatesUnlike conventional instruments which firmware is seldom
updated, Modular Instruments software drivers may be regularly
updated to improve the performance, add functions and features,
or keep the instrument up to date with different communication
standards and computer software. In principle it is a good practice
to use the latest instrument driver, however any update should be
considered carefully.
Most manufacturers publish, along with the driver release,
a detailed description of the changes and their impact on
the instrument. If any of these modifications are related to
the measurement functions of the instrument, it may be
advantageous to consider performing an external calibration
with the new driver before the instrument is put into service.
Many times these updates don’t have any impact in the
measurement process and the driver update can be done with
confidence and without an external calibration.
When a Modular Instrument is sent for external calibration the
user must verify if the driver used by the calibration laboratory
matches the user’s driver. If not an impact evaluation should
be performed.
®
Thunder Scientificprovides instrumentcalibration for virtually all humidity or dew-point hygrometers with as found and as leftdata with uncertainties.
Service you can rely on, and as always FREE tech support.
Thunder is the leading manufacturer of two-pressure humidity calibrationsystems, with an uncertainty of 0.3% RH traceable to NIST.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 45
technicalpaper
Case 1 - The calibration laboratory driver version is newer than the user’s
• Determine how many driver revisions were released between
your driver revision and the calibration laboratory driver.
• Carefully read each revision release document to find if any
impacts the instrument measurement functions.
• If none has impact on the measurement functions you can
accept the calibration and should consider updating your system
to the newest driver.
• If one or more has impact on the measurement functions there
are two options:
° Update your system to the calibration laboratory current driver
and accept the calibration.
° Request the calibration laboratory to perform the calibration
with a driver that matches the user’s revision number. We do
not recommend this approach because it is almost impossible
for the calibration laboratory to keep copies of all previous
drivers’ versions for all instruments.
Case 2 - The calibration laboratory driver version is older than the user’s
• Find how many drivers revisions were released between your
driver and calibration laboratory driver.
• Carefully read each revision release document to find if any
impacts the instrument measurement functions.
• If none has impact on the measurement functions you can
accept the calibration.
• If any has impact on the measurement functions reject the
calibration and request a new adjustment and verification done
with the most current driver.
When performing Modular Instrument external calibration it is
fundamental to keep track of the software driver revision number
for future reference.
The calibration laboratories and users are encouraged to use
the latest driver revision to maintain compatibility and the
instruments’ performance at their best.
11. Adjustment constants protectionMost PXI manufacturers recognized that the measurement
instruments need to be protected from unintended or unauthorized
adjustment, to fulfill this requirement an adjustment password
protection and time stamp should be available.
12. Modular Instruments interchangeabilityThe interchangeability of modules is one key to the success of
Modular Instruments. Vendors design Modular Instruments to
operate within specification regardless of Computing System,
Chassis and slot within the chassis, as long as the operating
requirements are met. For the customer this makes it more
convenient to return only the Modular Instrument for service.
For the laboratory this means an investment in the appropriate
computing systems and hardware.
References
1. PXI alliance www.pxisa.org
Who do you call when your testequipment requires service?
Trescal, who else?Trescal is a worldwide leader for the calibration and repair of test, measurement,
and diagnostic equipment with an extensive range of solutions for the management of equipment and measurement processes.
Simply stated, “We do it all.”Call 810.225.4601 today and visit trescal.com for the answers
to all your test equipment repair needs and more.
calibration solutions to improve your performance
United States: Atlanta 678.965.4660 l Baltimore 410.337.0687 l Charlotte 704.987.4300 l Chicago 847.718.0172 Cleveland 440.442.8080 l Dallas/Ft. Worth 214.591.8300 l Detroit 810.225.4601 l Houston 281.242.2957
Newark 973.299.2950 l Santa Clara 408.727.3286
Worldwide: Austria l Belgium l Czech Republic l Denmark l France l Germany l Holland l Italy Romania l Singapore l Spain l Sweden l Switzerland l Tunisia l United Kingdom
trescal.com
4243 Metrologist 2015_4139 Metrologist 2015 6/16/15 10:23 AM Page 1
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 46
regionalnews
2016 NCSLI WORKSHOP & SYMPOSIUM
JULY 24–28, 2016ST. PAUL CONVENTION CENTER ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA
NCSL INTERNATIONAL | ncsli.org2995 Wilderness Place, Suite 107 | Boulder, CO 80301 | (303) 440-3339 | [email protected]
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 47
regionalnews2016 CALL FOR PAPERSThe NCSL International 2016 Workshop & Symposium theme is Measurement Accuracy and the Impact on Society. Measurements in science are important because they are used to express results and make conclusions for just about everything; therefore accuracy is crucial. Even the slightest error in measurement can render impractical data.
Accurate measurements not only impact us through technological innovations, but also through other aspects of our lives. For example, accurate measurements are needed as they ensure that the weight and volume of goods sold in the market are correct, thus maintaining a fair playing field between competitive buyers and sellers.
Please consider sharing your metrological experiences regarding Measurement Accuracy and the Impact on Society.
NCSL INTERNATIONAL | ncsli.org2995 Wilderness Place, Suite 107 | Boulder, CO 80301 | (303) 440-3339 | [email protected]
CALL FOR PAPERSwww.ncsli.org
EXHIBIT [email protected]
SPONSORSHIP [email protected]
ADVERTISING [email protected]
GENERAL REQUIREMENTSAbstracts are required for all proposed papers, panels and workshops.
ABSTRACT REQUIREMENTS AND DEADLINEAbstracts must be 350 words or less and be submitted electronically using the NCSLI Abstract Management System on the NCSLI website no later than November 1, 2015. Submitters may edit and track their abstract using the NCSLI Abstract Management System. Speakers will return to this page to upload their manuscripts once accepted.
ABSTRACT ACCEPTANCE DATESpeakers will be notified on or before November 30, 2015 if their abstract has been accepted. Once abstracts are selected for the NCSLI Technical Program, authors will be provided manuscript instructions.
MANUSCRIPT REQUIREMENTS AND DEADLINEAll manuscripts must be uploaded by February 17, 2016. All papers received by the manuscript deadline will be included in the NCSLI Conference Proceedings CD.
SPEAKER DISCOUNTS • All speakers who upload their abstract by the November 1, 2015 deadline (and are accepted) will receive a $150 discount o� of registration. • All speakers who upload their manuscript by the February 17, 2016 deadline will receive a $350 discount o� of registration. • All deadlines must be met to receive the speaker registration discount of $500.
BEST PAPER AWARDSA Best Paper Award will be presented in each track. The overall Best Conference Paper will then be awarded to the paper which receives the overall highest point total. To be considered for the Best Paper Award, all deadlines must be met.
48 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
Automatic Vacuum Calibration System Model: AVCS3SDThe AVCS-3SD is the only system on the market with Fully Automatic pressure and process flow control,
as well as data acquisition, from 1.3x10-3 to 1.3x10+5 Pa (1x10-5 to 1000 Torr). Fast, patent pending pressure
control algorithm ensures unsurpassed accuracy. Integrated controls, calibration and data analysis software
will provide you with a cost effective approach to calibration of vacuum gauges that is NIST traceable, fast and
repeatable. You can develop, store and recall multiple process recipes for each gauge or a group of gauges, and
AVCS-3DS will consistently follow the selected calibration protocol today, tomorrow or 10 years later.
A built in calibration process log file in addition to data and process security provide you with complete
supervisory oversight of each process step. Standard RS232 inputs for UUT data collection (optional 0-10VDC
inputs with built in +/-15VDC linear power source) allows AVCS to automatically process a wide variety of
vacuum gauges including most of the Capacitance Diaphragm gauges. AVCS-3SD is fully compliant with
ISO-3567 and has 3 process modes and a service mode.
Leon Tsymberov | 617.364.0400 x16 | www.vacuumsystemsinc.con
Essential Weights™ - Customized Test Weights by Rice Lake Weighing SystemsEssential Weights are customized sets of three or four stainless steel test weights in a small, durable carrying
case. Laboratory professionals no longer need to carry around large cases with unnecessary test weights.
The weights are specifically tailored to your precision weighing equipment, maintaining best practices in
routine laboratory calibration.
Pharmaceutical and laboratory professionals can benefit from being able to customize configurations
ideal for specific calibration, shift test, and sensitivity tests. Equipped with ASTM Class 1, polished stainless
steel Type II design weights, Essential Weights maintain the quality standards Rice Lake Weighing Systems
upholds.
www.ricelake.com/essentialweights
Automated Microwave Calibration SystemTEGAM has condensed their experience with microwave calibration into one convenient accurate
automated system that operates from 100 KHz to 50 GHz and supports sensors from most major
manufacturers. One turnkey package includes the VNA, signal generator, microwave power
standards, software and accessories for immediate productivity.
[email protected] | 1-800-666-1010
Consumers Energy offers Phasor Measurement Unit (PMU) Type Certification ServicePMU hardware is based on proven technology and is used to gather and act on information in an automated fashion to improve the
efficiency, reliability, economics, and sustainability in the production and distribution of electricity. Phasor Measurement Units (PMU’s)
are at a minimum, synchronized 3 phase data acquisition systems that are able to sample electrical grid current, voltage, phase, and
frequency. Communication is accomplished in packets which contain command, configuration, data, and header frames. Data rates can
be as fast as 50 (50Hz) and 60 (60Hz) frames per second. The data acquired by PMU’s is orders of magnitude in speed and resolution better
than legacy Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition Systems (SCADA).
Interoperability across manufacturer and product lines is a fundamental requirement to ensure data integrity.
The new certification service provides complete type acceptance testing of PMU’s to IEEE C37.118 Standard for
Synchrophasor Measurements for Power Systems and the associated IEEE Synchrophasor Measurement Test
Suite Specification which stipulates acceptance criteria, test methods, and measurement uncertainty.
Consumers Energy- Laboratory Services in Jackson, Michigan became an IEEE Authorized Testing
facility for the IEEE Sychrophasor Certification Program in May 2015.
www.laboratoryservices.com
New ProductsandServices
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 49
newproductsandservices
New Series of Precision Fluid BathsGuildline Instruments is pleased to announce the release of a new 5600 Series of Precision Fluid Baths. The
Company has been making the most stable and reliable fluid and oil baths since its incorporation over 58
years ago. In recent years many customers have approached Guildline requesting that we develop a new
line of high performance fluid and oil baths for metrology and oceanography applications with better
performance and a modern user interface.
As a result, Guildline has developed unique features and functionality that make the 5600 Series the
best Fluid Baths now and for the future. This Series of Fluid Baths is designed for both electrical metrology
and oceanographic applications and can be used with oil, water, salt water, and other liquids. These high
precision fluid/oil baths provide uniform, constant fluid temperature over a range from -5°C to 55°C with a
unique laminar flow, and with stability as low as ±0.001°C. Three convenient sizes are available: 50 Liters,
75 Liters, or 100 Liters; all containing a proprietary EMI Shielded Fiberglass tank that is corrosion resistant.
[email protected] | 800-310-8104 x104
New Benchtop Pressure Controller Provides a Standalone Solution to 3,000 psi (200 bar)Yorba Linda, Calif., Jul 1, 2015–Additel Corporation introduces their new ADT780 series benchtop pressure
controllers with precision accuracy to 0.005% of reading + 0.005% FS. The ADT780 configurations have the
unique capability of generating pressure to 3,000 psi (200 bar) without the aid of a gas supply. By utilizing
an electric pump this unit produces pressures to 1,000 psi (70 bar) and with an electric pump and gas
booster to 3,000 psi (200 bar).
Each unit comes with one Intelligent Pressure Module configured to the many range offerings provided.
Standard accuracy sensors are certified with a 1 year accuracy of 0.02% FS. The precision quartz-based
sensors improve the 1 year accuracy specification to 0.005% of reading + 0.005% FS. Each unit contains
process calibrator functionality with HART® and Profibus PA communication capabilities.
The Additel 780 series offers two base ranges: to 1,000 psi (70 bar) and to 3,000 psi (200 bar). The base
range establishes the maximum controlling range of the controller. Each configuration includes a control
sensor in which is preselect to the range best suited for the application need. External and internal sensors
can be used which allows for expanded range and accuracy capability in the future.
Mensor Releases CPC4000 Industrial Pressure ControllerSan Marcos, Texas – July 23, 2015, Mensor announces the release of the CPC4000 Industrial Pressure Controller.
The CPC4000 Industrial Pressure Controller represents the most recent advancement in an affordable, entry-level pressure controller for
the calibration and instrumentation industry.
Key features include:
• Custom pressure ranges from 1 to 3045 psi
• Up to two transducers with auto-ranging
• Barometric reference for emulation
• 0.02% accuracy
• Fast and stable control
• Optional contamination filter
This product features a modern intuitive user interface and a price that will fit your budget. The CPC4000 stands out for its ease of
use, versatility and affordability. In addition, custom transducer ranges make it configurable to your specific requirements. Remote
communication to a computer is achieved via IEEE-488, RS232, USB, Ethernet or optional WiFi.
The Mensor CPC4000 Industrial Pressure Controller gives the user ultimate control and versatility at an affordable price. It provides an
automated way to maintain pressure for calibrating and testing pressure gauges, transducers, transmitters or other pressure sensing instruments.
www.mensor.com
Send your Product or Service announcements to: [email protected]
The HPC40 Series is the world’s first combined pressure
and mA loop calibrator to be fully temperature compensated
from -20 to 50° C. You can count on the same accuracy whether measuring pressure,
current, voltage, or temperature.
The HPC40 Series is the world’s first combined pressure
and mA loop calibrator to be fully temperature compensated
from -20 to 50° C. You can count on the same accuracy whether measuring pressure,
current, voltage, or temperature.
0.035% of Reading Accuracy
Gauge, Absolute, and Differential Pressure to 15,000 psi / 1000 bar / 100 MPa
Advanced Simplicity “Non-Menu” Interface
Measure & Source mA with External Loop Power or Internal 24 VDC Power Supply
High Accuracy Thermometer with “True Ohm” Technology
Store & Recall Previously Used Screens
Flexible Power Options Including Rechargeable
0.035% of Reading Accuracy
Gauge, Absolute, and Differential Pressure to 15,000 psi / 1000 bar / 100 MPa
Advanced Simplicity “Non-Menu” Interface
Measure & Source mA with External Loop Power or Internal 24 VDC Power Supply
High Accuracy Thermometer with “True Ohm” Technology
Store & Recall Previously Used Screens
Flexible Power Options Including Rechargeable
CrystalXP2i
CrystalnVision Lab
JOFRAASC-400
crys
tale
ngin
eeri
ng.n
et
JOFRARTC Series
M & GPKII
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 51
Brian KingGulf Coastregionalnews
JM Test Systems located in Baton Rouge,
Louisiana, graciously hosted the NCSLI
Gulf Coast Section Meeting on April 28th,
2015 at their new electrical safety testing
laboratory. After a brief meet-and-greet, the
meeting was kicked off at 9:00 by the Section
Coordinator Brian King of A2Research. He,
and the President of JM Test Systems Mr.
Scott Morrison, welcomed the 26 attendees
and briefly went over the day’s agenda before
introducing Dr. Hy Tran.
Dr. Tran, Sandia National Laboratories
and the NCSLI Central Division VP, gave
the NCSLI Board of Director’s update
and encouraged everyone to attend the
upcoming NCSLI Conference to be held in
Grapevine, Texas.
Mike Scott, of The Modal Shop was
next on the agenda. Mike gave a 45
minute presentation on the “Calibration
and Verification of Vibration Protection
Systems.” His presentation touched on the
advantages and challenges that exist in the
calibration process.
After a short break, the attendees enjoyed a
tour of JM Test Systems new Electrical Safety
Laboratory and the Metrology facilities.
Many compliments of the size and scope
of the facilities were shared by many of the
participants.
Next, we broke for a wonderful lunch
which was graciously provided by JM Test
Systems. The Jambalaya was highly talked
about and enjoyed by all!
Next up was Jason Dewar of Fluke
Calibration who gave an informative
presentation on the “HART Communication
Protocol.” He provided a brief history
of the origins of the protocol as well as
outlining the advantages associated with
the technology.
Our final presentation was given by
Richard Roddis of Fluke Calibration, whose
topic was of special interest to those in
attendance. His presentation was entitled
“Fluke’s Artifact Calibration and Its Use in
Calibration of 8.5 Digit DMM’s.” Richard
was able to give the attendees the necessary
tools in which to analyze their own use
scenarios and perhaps take advantage of 24
hour specifications or 90 day specifications
of laboratory standards that they may
already have.
The day was concluded with a group
photo and a thanking of all in attendance
for their participation, the speakers for
their contributions, and JM Test Systems
for hosting this very successful meeting.
Gulf Coast Meeting.
regionalnews
Beverly Garcia
University of Alabama Huntsville (UAH) Shelby Center for Science
and Technology, once again, proved itself to be an excellent venue
for the Huntsville Section spring meeting on April 30, 2015.
After morning announcements by coordinator Beverly Garcia,
Mark Lapinskes, NCSLI Division VP delivered a Board of Directors
update and information on the upcoming conference.
Meeting presentations featured:
Topic: High Resistance Measurement SystemsMike Frisz, Measure-
ments International
Topic: Good Weighing Practices
Ian Ciesniewski, Mettler Toledo
Topic: Fluke’s Artifact Calibration and its use in Calibration
of 8.5 Digit DMMs
Richard Roddis, Fluke Calibration
Topic: Calibration & Verification of Vibration
Protection Systems
Mike Scott, The Modal Shop
Topic: Understanding the HART Protocol –
Communication vs. Calibration
Jason Dewar, Fluke/Martel
Following the meeting we held an open forum
where attendees were given the opportunity to
discuss NCSLI membership participation and
how it relates to their workplace.
Breakfast and lunch were provided by
Pinnacle Test Solutions, Southern Market-
ing Associates, Keysight Technologies,
Tegam, and JM Test Systems, Inc
After door prizes the meeting was adjourned.
The Huntsville Fall Section meeting is tentatively scheduled for
November 19, 2015.
Mike Frisz.
Ian Ciesniewski. Richard Roddis.
Mike Scott. Jason Dewar.
Huntsville
52 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 53
The Los Angeles/Orange County Section 1422 meeting was held
on May 12, 2015 at Transcat in Fullerton, California. A total of 44
participants were in attendance. This event covered a range of topics
relating to improving uncertainty, quality, and measurements. Tours
of the Transcat laboratories were conducted throughout the meeting.
After a brief welcome by Jon Sanders, the Los Angeles/Orange
County Section Coordinator, Jack Somppi, the NCSLI Western
US Division VP, provided an introduction to NCSL International
and board update. Jack’s presentation covered an update on board
meetings, NCSLI membership benefits, and divisional highlights.
Of particular interest were the upcoming events, namely the 2015
NCSLI Workshop & Symposium in July.
After the host introduction by Tim Mason, Howard Zion, Director
of Service Application Engineering, Transcat, started the technical
portion of the meeting covering In Tolerance Non-Conformance
Investigation. Many presentations focus on out of tolerance (OOT)
non-conformance investigation and the steps required to ensure
the results are not biased. Howard explores the conditions where
and instrument could be believed to be in tolerance but actually
have a negative impact on the process it is used in. Guard banding
and decision rules were discussed within this presentation.
Following Howard, Jack Somppi, Business Development
Manager, Measurements International, presented “Taking the
Ohm from the SI to the Workbench to Benefit Industry.” Jack’s
presentation reviewed the standards, instrumentation, and
measurement techniques that support resistance through ranges of
more than 20 orders of magnitude with the best possible traceable
measurement uncertainties. He also presented an overview of
Jon Sanders
LA Orange County
LA Orange County Meeting.
regionalnews
54 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
regionalnews
metrology equipment ranging from the intrinsic standard for
resistance, through primary to secondary and working standards.
During lunch Bob Stern, chair of the NCSLI 174 Standards
Writing Group and currently employed by Keysight Technologies,
presented on “Leveraging Automation to Assure the Quality of
Calibration Results and Why It Matters.” He provided several
examples of how Keysight has recently been able to apply near
real-time statistical analysis for quality process control in their
calibration labs which has resulted in significant improvements
when combined with periodic proficiency testing. He discussed
how the process works and provided data from examples of their
quality monitoring.
In the afternoon Marty Conway, Regional Sales Manager,
Fluke Calibration discussed “How to Know Your Temperature
Probe is in Tolerance and How to Keep It in Tolerance.” Marty
discussed temperature probe drift, probe types, and causes for drift.
He showed the ins and outs of As Found data and determining
tolerance status of temperature probes. Clear instructions for
calculating tolerance status will be given plus some helpful tips on
how to keep temperature probes in tolerance.
Chester Franklin, Franklin Training Group presented on the topic
of “Establishing a RAMP,” which stands for Risk Assessment and
Mitigation Plan for calibration laboratories. Chester showed a tool for
risk analysis called Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA). FMEA
was one of the first systematic techniques developed by reliability
engineers for analyzing risks in order to ensure the reliability of
processes and operations. Usually thought of as a manufacturing or
engineering design too it is applicable to calibration laboratories as
well. The first step in using this tool is an understanding of what is
meant by Failure Mode. After that it is relatively easy to identify failure
modes, in other words incidents that could cause failures. The FMEA
tool provides ways to evaluate and rate the effects of failures, and the
criticality of those effects, and then how to prioritize preventive and/
or corrective actions to mitigate those effects.
To wrap up the meeting door prizes were provided complements
of NCSLI, Additel Corporation and Keysight Technologies.
Exhibitors included Additel Corporation, AssetSmart, Fluke
Calibration, International Accredition Service (IAS), King Nutronics
Corporation, Measurements International, Rotronic Instrument
Corporation and Wilmington Instruments.
The Los Angeles/Orange County Section would like to thank all
the exhibitors for supporting this event. The presenters for their
time and knowledge, and Transcat for their facility - they did a
fantastic job!
We are very excited for our next section meeting which is
scheduled for November 11, 2015 in Los Angeles, California at
Baxter..
Tim Mason, Transcat.
Bob Stern, Keysight Technologies.
Are improper calibrations placing your business at risk?
Trust the Difference . . . The Transcat DifferenceCheck us out at Transcat.com/thedifference
Not all calibrations are created equal. Is your provider giving you adequate TURs?Qualified Technicians? Appropriate standards?Valid Test Points?
REJECTED
Visit us at Booth 207 at the NCSL Conference
800-828-1470 • Transcat.com
regionalnews
The New England region held its spring meeting on
May 13, 2015 in scenic Pepperell, Massachusetts.
Our host was Masy BioServices, a provider to the
pharmaceutical, medical device, biotechnology,
and regulated industries markets. Breakfast was
provided by ProTEQ Solutions.
Our first speaker was Elizabeth Carbonel-
la. Elizabeth is a Senior Accreditation Officer
for the American Association for Labora-
tory Accreditation (A2LA). She regularly
conducts training, on behalf of A2LA, for
CABs, assessors and users of accredit-
ed organizations on a variety of top-
ics related to the ISO/IEC 17025 and
ISO/IEC 17020 standards.
Elizabeth provided a mini-tutorial
on “Root Cause Analysis.” She
introduced terms associated with
root cause analysis, and provided
clarity on when a root cause
analysis is required. We were
provided tips and tools for
performing root cause analysis.
Pitfalls and common mistakes
in performing a root cause
analysis were also illustrated.
Real-world examples were sited, and methodology was discussed
in providing objective evidence to resolve issues. The importance and
processes of monitoring corrective actions were advanced as well.
Elizabeth provided an introduction and illustration of tools that
should be used in a root cause analysis. These included techniques
in interviewing, the concept of fish bone diagrams, and the “5
whys” to identify a root cause.
A non-metrology example of how to use the “5 whys” was
illustrated as follows; A person borrows a bicycle from a friend
to use for training for a bike run. The back tire goes flat (and it
happens multiple times).
Tim Cooke
New England
Elizabeth Carbonella.
New England Meeting.
56 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 57
regionalnews
The first “why” is why did it go flat? The short answer is there
was a hole in the tube. The person borrowing the bike replaces the
tube. But to find out the reason(s) it keeps happening, there is a
second “Why.” That is, “Why is there a hole in the tube?”
This leads to group discussion. Was there a nail or foreign object
found in the tire? Was there enough air in the tire? What were the
road and environmental conditions?
Elizabeth taught us that by asking the right questions, and not
being satisfied with just the obvious answer to the first “why,” you
can find the root cause!
George Rodriguez, PhD, Senior Scientific Manager for Artel,
then provided a presentation on “Value Stream Mapping.” Artel is
introducing a new volume measuring instrument that is based on
air space compression and the ideal gas law. It is an interesting
technology, and Artel is in the process of value stream mapping to
identify how metrology activities add value to the customer for this
product. This includes the efficient application of standards, defining
the calibration and testing processes, and adding value of importance
to the customers for this new product. The process, and what Artel
has learned in applying value stream mapping, with particular
emphasis on the metrology component, was reviewed. We were
able to have some group discussions on bringing this value to the
customer... and were afforded the opportunity of putting ourselves
in the customer shoes, to know what is really important to them.
Eliminating showstoppers, or roadblocks, to the process of providing
desired results to the customer was an important part of the dialogue.
After a hearty lunch (graciously provided by our hosts at Masy
Bioservices), George Rodriguez continued at the podium with a new
topic “The Business Case for Developing and Observing Voluntary
Standards.” George related that an ISO document for specifying
and testing volumetric performance of automated liquid handling
systems had recently been developed. It was an interesting case study
of 18 different parties (inclusive of manufacturers, end users and third
party services) getting together to find common ground and come up
with a “prototype standard” that would benefit all stakeholders. The
concept of International Workshop Agreements (IWA) was discussed.
Those who participated had to weigh the cost of participation against
the benefits. This session discussed key technical outcomes and what
remained to be done. The advantages, as well as potential drawbacks,
of participating in such a process were included in group deliberation.
Cesar D. (Jun) Bautista, Jr. PhD, Senior Director of Laboratory
Operations at Masy BioServices rounded out a full day of learning
with his presentations. Discussed were recent updates, proposed
changes, and future initiatives in metrology regulations.
Jun acquainted us to the probable revisions to ISO 9001:2015.
These include the additional management responsibilities contained
therein. Management must ensure the risks that affect customer
satisfaction are identified. There is additional focus on fault
prevention... as opposed to correcting things after they go wrong.
The reason for the upcoming roll-out of the revised
ISO/IEC 17025 was also presented. The old standard references
many documents that are now obsolete. The proposed and updated
requirements contained in the new standard were also discussed.
Jun also provided highlights of the new RP-6 rewrite. Included
in the 5 year review will be revised table of contents, reference to
Good Automated Manufacturing Practice (GAMP), and relevance
to ISO/IEC 17025 and ISO 13485.
Jun delivered insight on the amendments to USP 41 /USP 1251.
Proper test weight values are the source of some confusion, so this
was clarified. Jun also shed some light on the topic of rounding
errors and resolution definitions for calibration of balances.
Lastly, the Guide for the Determination of Uncertainty in
Measurements (GUM) was deliberated. With dialog on the
concept of the unification of type A and B uncertainties and less
emphasis on degrees of freedom, there was interest in this topic
by all who attended.
A tour of the Masy BioServices facility was then made available
to the attendees.
We thank our host, and all the presenters, for what was a
very interesting and informative day to the over 30 industry
professionals in attendance. I hope to see you all again at the 2015
Workshop & Symposium, July 19-23 in Grapevine, Texas as well as
at our next regional meeting in October.
George Rodriguez. Jun Bautista, Jr.
Your comprehensive partner for cGMP production services.
www.masy.comMeasurable Quality for Life Sciences
‣ Validation Services
‣ Calibration Services
‣ Monitoring Systems
‣ Equipment Rentals
‣ cGMP Biostorage
‣ Datalogging Systems
CHOOSE MASY FOR:
10 Lomar Park | Pepperell, MA 01463
To control life science product quality, you have to control the process — which includes accurate and precise measurement of all the variables that affect the successful development and manufacturing of life-improving technologies. Masy BioServices' integrated suite of calibration capabilities, validation services, biorepository facility, and equipment inventory can help ensure measurement accuracy in your key research and production facilities.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 59
On April 21, 2015, a New York City Section Meeting was held,
and although there hasn’t been a meeting in this area for many
years, the scheduled topics for the presentations appeared to
resonate and drew attendees from around the region. Jennifer
Camarda, Premium Weighing Sales Specialist at Sartorius, worked
with Marcus McNeely, NCSLI Northeastern US Division VP, to
coordinate the meeting as well as host the meeting at Sartorius’
facility in Bohemia, New York. Jennifer also accepted the
nomination to become the NYC Section Coordinator.
The meeting featured the following three presentations and
then ended with a tour of the Sartorius facility.
First up was Edward Mulhern and Leon Chao, Mechanical Engi-
neers at NIST presenting “Towards the Definition and Dissemination
of a New International Mass Standard: Precision Metrology and the
Real World.” They discussed how NIST will realize and disseminate
a Planck constant based kilogram via the Watt Balance, the current
mass calibration system and its traceability to the official mass stan-
dard, the International Prototype Kilogram (IPK) and also appreciate
how the new SI affects science, industry and daily life. They even
displayed the Lego version of the Watt Balance (see group picture).
Scott Mimbs, retired NASA Metrology Program Manager presented
“Metrology and the Consequences of Bad Measurement Decisions.”
He discussed how measurement-based decisions flow through the
product lifecycle, how measurement decision risk can translate
to product risk and also identify the three essentials elements of
“good” measurement data.
Jennifer Camarda, Premium Weighing Sales Specialist at
Sartorius presented “USP Chapter 41: It’s Easier than You Think.”
She discussed the recent changes to the USP Chapter 41, including
revised terminology and calculations as it now defines repeatability
and accuracy, which now specifies the operating range of a balance
as well as offered recommendations on how to perform the test.
Examples were also shown to demonstrate different outcomes of
the operating range.
Sartorius supplies high-quality lab instruments such as
balances, mass comparators, pipettes and lab water purification
systems, as well as offers the widest range of consumables,
including filters, pipette tips and products for microbiological
quality control. “We look forward to our next New York City
section meeting.”
Jennifer Camarda
New York Cityregionalnews
New York City Meeting.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 60
regionalnews
Come Tour the Trescal Dallas Calibration Laboratory and help us celebrate the
opening of our new facility!
As part of this year’s NCSL International Workshop & Symposium, conference theme “Measurement Science and the Quality of Life,” Trescal is sponsoring a tour of our new facility in Irving, Texas, just 15 minutes from the Gaylord Texan Resort and Convention Center.
When: ................................... Thursday July 23, 2015
Two Tour Times: ................ 11:00 a.m. and 12:00 p.m. Facility tour will be approximately 50 minutes with reception and open discussion following
Where: ................................. Trescal, 6601 Beltline Rd, Suite 140, Irving, Texas 75063
Cost: ...................................... $10.00 (Fee will be donated to the NCSLI Education fund).
Transportation: For your convenience, buses are available to pick up and return from the Gaylord Convention Center Circle lower-level underneath the exhibit hall. (You are welcome to drive to the Trescal facility to participate in either or both the tour and reception).
Activities Include:- Trescal Global Overview- Tour of Trescal’s Facility- See the Mitutoyo Measurement show room- New RF suite- TAM Online asset management overview
Register Today!www.ncsli.org
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 61
James Littlefield
Northern Ohioregionalnews
The Northern Ohio/Western Pennsylvania section held its spring
meeting on April 14th, 2015. The meeting was hosted by the
Keithley Instruments, Cleveland, Ohio. A special thanks to the
Keithley’s team and our contact Ralph Travise.
We started the meeting at 9:00 am with introductions of all
participates.
The first presentation, “Gage Error Studies” was presented by
Paul Mathews of Mathews Malnar and Bailey, Inc. Paul presented
a case study of hand held bore gages used to hold tight tolerances
on the large diameter bore of gears for Caterpillar. The studies
objective was to determine the best gage. Several old and new
gages were evaluated. The analysis of the data was surprising -
people’s prior opinions of the different measurement instruments
didn’t have any bearing on how the instruments performed. In the
end, the oldest gage should the least variation.
Ben Yurick, Design Engineer for Keithley Instruments, presented
concerns and issues with electronic equipment measurement
uncertainty specifications. Comparison and contrast of different AC
measuring techniques including traditional AC RMS converter IC’s
and digit sampling techniques utilized in today’s digital multimeters.
We uncovered accuracy differences, crest factor uncertainty, design
limitations, and calibration/verification challenges.
The morning sessions ended with a tour of Keithley’s Metrology
department. Ralph Travise, Quality Manage for Keithley, included
a description of Metrology Department’s role in supporting
Keithley instruments. Keithley team members describe the systems
at each test station.
At noon, participates were dismissed for lunch. Keithly provided
in-house dining facilities.
Dilip Shah, of E=mc3, provided training and hands on
demonstration of Proficiency Testing. Training include the need
for proficiency testing, current industry requirements, and an
explanation of some the options. Dilip divided attendees into
groups and dispensed artifacts. Groups then participated in a
proficiency testing study. Afterwards, Dilip analyzed the data and
presented results. A Q&A session followed.
The meeting wrapped up with Lloyd Baker, NCSLI Regional
Coordinator. Lloyd covered NCSLI Updates, held an open
discussion, including reviewing NCSLI‘s mission and recruited
volunteers.
Planning is underway for our next meeting in October 2015.
Dilip Shah.
regionalnews
The Southern Ohio/Kentucky Section held a meeting on 16 April
2015. The Ohio Department of Agriculture (ODA), Division of
Weights and Measures hosted the meeting at their Reynoldsburg
complex. The Bionetics Corporation, Newark Metrology
Operations, sponsored meeting refreshments and lunch for
attendees. Mr. Matthew Denslow, Bionetics Training Manager and
Section Coordinator greeted attendees. Mr. Daniel Walker from
the ODA Weights and Measures Division’s calibration laboratory
assisted with attendee registration and later provided a tour of
the laboratory. The day’s agenda began with Ms. Fran Elson-
Houston, Chief of the Weights and Measures division explaining
the many responsibilities of the ODA and the numerous divisions
of the campus. Next, Fran introduced the ODA Director, Mr.
David Daniels. Mr. Daniels welcomed attendees emphasizing
the importance that measurement plays to Ohio commerce. He
thanked Fran for all the great support she and her team provide.
I greatly appreciate Mr. Daniels taking the time from his busy
schedule to speak to our group. His doing so truly demonstrates his
understanding of the importance measurement plays to society.
Mr. Lloyd Baker, 1130 NCSLI Mid-Western Regional Coordina-
tor, presented the NCSLI Board of Directors’ meeting activities,
highlighted with the welcoming of our new NCSLI President Rog-
er Burton. Lloyd encouraged everyone to attend the upcoming
conference and tutorial program. Additionally, Lloyd discussed
the many current committee projects and asked anyone interested
to volunteer to help.
Mr. Warren Merkel Chief, National Voluntary Laboratory Ac-
creditation Program, spoke to the group next giving a presentation
titled, “From Paris, France to Paris, Ohio: The Role of International
Mutual Recognition Arrangements in Traceability.” Mr. Merkel’s
explanation of the International Bureau of Weights and Measures
(BIPM) and numerous subcommittees provided a clear insight to
their purpose. Mr. Merkel went on to describe the development
and interaction of the global regional metrology organizations.
Next, we discussed the purpose and role of the International Lab-
oratory Accreditation Cooperation (ILAC). Membership in ILAC
provides for the recognition of accrediting bodies and promotes
confidence in the services provided by an accredited member.
SouthernOhio/Kentucky
Matthew Denslow
Southern Ohio/Kentucky Meeting.
62 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 63
regionalnews
Concluding the presentation Mr. Merkel touched on how the Na-
tional Conference for Weights and Measures has influenced legal
metrology within the United States.
Mr. Dilip Shah, President E=MC3 Solutions Inc., again volunteered
his time for our NCSLI members with a presentation titled, “The
Impact of Legal Metrology on Everyday Life.” Dilip provided
examples of how conversion factors can influence the result and
of how not being aware of measurement uncertainty can critically
impact the consumer. In respect to measurement it is noted that
emphasis must be placed on the documentation of traceability.
Consumer confidence can be achieved through the purchase of
products and services from accredited vendors. Dilip pointed out
the various common components of a properly documented test
or calibration certificate. It is the responsibility of the purchaser to
ensure they have received all the information requested.
Following lunch, meeting attendees were given a tour of the
numerous campus facilities. We began with the calibration
laboratory. The laboratory is accredited to ISO 17025:2005 through
NVLAP and is certified by NIST to provide metrological traceability
for the State of Ohio. The laboratory’s scope of calibration and
measurement capabilities includes surveying rods and tapes,
mass determination and volume transfer. Weights and Measures
Division personnel are proud to operate one of four National Type
Evaluation Program (NTEP) laboratories. This laboratory evaluates
new scale designs and technology such as the automatic weighing
systems, point of sale scales and multiple dimensions measuring
devices. Next, the group visited the Animal Health Division where
we introduced to the necropsy laboratory, the animal disease
diagnostic laboratory and the infectious disease area. The group
then traveled to the Consumer Protection Laboratory. While
there we were introduced to the microbiology, pesticides, general
chemistry and analytical toxicology sections. These laboratories
support dairy and meat inspection and other food safety programs,
plant industry and the animal industry. Unfortunately we were
not able to visit the remaining divisions due to time constraints
but thanks for the tour.
Mr. Warren Merkel Chief, National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program.
Imagine maintaining and protecting smart grid reliability through testing and calibration.
THAT’S US.
IMAGINE A CONFORMITY ASSESSMENT program to provide testing of phasor measurement units’ (PMU’s) compliance with respect to IEEE C37.118.1™ Standard for SynchroPhasor Measurements for Power systems.
IMAGINE THE POSSIBILITIES.
The ability to test and calibrate PMU’s that provide real-time measurement data for electric power grids, allows operators to make quick, accurate decisions based on sound, detailed data with respect to the condition of the grid.
AN INDUSTRY CHANGING IMPACT.
Consumers Energy Laboratory Services and IEEE Standards Association (IEEE-SA) are working together to provide PMU conformance testing.
THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING.
To learn more, call Consumers Energy Laboratory Services at (800) 736-4147, or visit www.LaboratoryServices.com.
64 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
Michael DuncanTennesseeregionalnews
The Tennessee Section of the NCSLI celebrated World Metrology
Day with a spring meeting at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory on
May 20. With over 64 registered attendees and several more drop-
in participants from the Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s research
and operations staff. Attendees also included several members of
the International Society for Automation (ISA) who were especially
interested in the field calibration topics and in developing closer
ties with the metrology laboratories. The meeting included several
excellent technical presentations on topics including, “High
Resistance Calibrations” Mike Frisz, Measurements International;
“Understanding OMIL Weight Classes” Ann Crowley, Rice Lake;
“Good Weighing Practices” Ian Ciesniewski, Mettler Toledo;
“Field Calibrations” Cliff Ambrose, Trescal; and “The Role of
International Mutual Recognition Arrangements in Traceability”
Barbara Belzer, NIST.
In addition to the technical presentations, the meeting
included an exhibit room where metrology equipment and service
companies and representatives were offered a first-come, first-serve
opportunity to exhibit their equipment and services. A total of 9
exhibitors participated in the exhibit hall opportunity with several
expressing interest in future opportunities. The exhibit room, the
continental breakfast (Compliments of Mettler-Toledo) and lunch
(Compliments of Beamex and Additel) provided an excellent
venue for networking and collaborating.
The meeting culminated with a tour of the Oak Ridge National
Laboratory’s Metrology Lab, where interest was high in some
unique measurement areas such as air velocity (wind tunnels),
laser Frequency/wavelength and the Echelon I mass lab as well as
the other primary-level measurement capabilities.
A post-meeting online survey is currently being conducted
and the feedback obtained in the survey will be used to identify
potential topics of interest for future meetings, identify venues
which may be beneficial to members and generally used to
improve future meetings.
[email protected] Tennessee Meeting.
NVLAP Lab Code 105001-0
www.ricelake.com/calibration
Our expert metrology staff provides the service, selection and speed you need for each test weight and calibration service. From cast iron, stainless steel and electronic to NIST, ASTM and OIML, Rice Lake’s extensive selection of quality test weights meets the needs of a wide range of applications. Our mass calibration services also lead the industry in metrology solutions—with a turnaround in four days or less.
Trust our experts here at Rice Lake and call 1-800-472-6703 and visit us at NCSLi, booth 221.
Calibration turnaround in four days or less!
AD_Metrology_Service_atyour_Fingertips.indd 1 5/21/2015 4:40:14 PM
66 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
regionalnews
Chris KuczynskiTwin Citiesregionalnews
The Twin Cities NCSLI Section 1311 held their first meeting of the
year on May 7. We met at the St. Louis Park Community Center
where we’ve had several meetings. The event was sponsored by
Fox Valley Metrology, a longtime supporter and sponsor of the
NCSLI section! This full day event had four presenters, two of
which were from out of town. We had 66 attendees which is a bit
low for our section.
The first presenter was Dr. Michael Marcus from Lumetrics.
Dr. Marcus has over 37 years’ experience in the development of
metrology and measurement systems for manufacturing process
monitoring and control applications. He received his PhD in
Applied an Engineering Physics from Cornell University. He has
97 patents issued and is the inventor of the technology used in
the Optigauge®. Dr. Marcus presented “Non-contact light-based
thickness measurement, related applications and challenges.”
He explained the basics of the technology, it’s advantages and
limitations, and demonstrated some typical applications including
measurements of medical and ophthalmic devices. Lumetrics is
the manufacturer of the Optigauge® which was on display at the
meeting. Some of us were interested in the technology used in
the Optigauge®, but the majority was much more interested in
its application. It really is a remarkable measurement device in its
capability and accuracy (measurement uncertainty).
Barry Eisan from Vaisala presented next. Barry graduated from
Wentworth Institute of Technology with a Bachelor of Science in
Applied Physics. He’s been with Vaisala for 24 years and recently
changed positions from instrument sales to concentrate on sales
for Continuous Monitoring Systems. His presentation topic was
“Independent Environmental Monitoring System vs. Building
Automation System (BAS) for Validated Data Storage.” Barry
showed us the advantages and disadvantages of a BAS. Many if
not most manufacturers have some type of a BAS to manage the
environmental controls – at least temperature. Some are more
sophisticated than others. But a CMS, continuous monitoring
system, can provide the information at the accuracy you need
for validated data storage, particularly in life science businesses
Twin Cities Meeting.
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 67
regionalnews
(medical device, pharmaceutical manufacturers, etc.). In
particular, calibration labs need both a very accurate monitoring
system and precise control. The systems offered by Vaisala provide
the accuracy needed to monitor critical environments. In case
you hadn’t heard, Vaisala bought Veriteq and has integrated their
products into their systems.
Up next was Josh Zahorik from Burns Engineering. Josh is a
Design Engineer and the Calibration Lab Technical Manager.
He has had previous experience as a Design and Applications
Engineer for ProSpect Analytical NIR Technology, performed
process control for the Gluek Brewing Company, and graduated
from the University of Minnesota with a Bachelor’s Degree
in Material Science and Engineering, minoring in Chemistry.
Josh’s presentation, “Aligning Lab Results with Temperature
Measurements in Small Diameter Lines” covered the terminology,
available technologies, and the key factors in their selection and
installation so that the error between the laboratory and process
results can be minimized. Josh showed us that measurements
taken in the laboratory may not align with process measurements
for a given sensor due to a variety of factors. There were quite
a few diagrams to show what factors impact temperature
measurements in processes. The diameter of the line as well as
the placement of the sensor in the flow can make a significant
difference in the results.
The last presentation of the day was by Gary Meyer with J-G
Technologies. His background includes over 59 years of experience
in electronics, calibration, measurements, quality, radio broad-
casting/engineering, aircraft radio maintenance, airline simulator
maintenance, electrical test design, electronic sales, and technical
education in computers and metrology at Ridgewater College. He
also holds classes for his own consulting firm, J&G Technology,
provides technical support for WorkPlace Training customers, and
instructs courses for the QC Group in Minnetonka, MN. Gary’s
presentation, “Statistics and Math for Technicians,” provided in-
formation on the math requirements for ASQ exams such as Cer-
tified Calibration Technician (CCT), Certified Quality Technician
(CQT), and Certified Quality Engineer (CQT). He reviewed the
requirements for each and then began an in-depth explanation of
specific requirements for the CCT. Much of this would also apply
to other certifications. However, he covered specifics for the CCT
such as measurement uncertainty. Included were several videos of
how to use a TI-30X IIS calculator for some of the math.
It was a great NCSLI Section meeting with presentations and
product demonstrations. We are thankful for having such a large
and active section here in the Twin Cities. We are planning our
next meeting for September or October this year.
This was my last meeting as the Twin Cities Section Coordinator.
It’s been a great opportunity and I’m happy to have served the
local community. Corey Garbers with Martin Calibration will be
taking over the coordinator position.
Over 3000 courses delivered last year!
Find out if your training is effective. Try our PreTest/sample lesson at wptraining.comWayzata MN, Boca Raton FL, USA 1-612-308-2202 www.wptraining.com [email protected]
OJT/Inhouse Training vs. MyTrain CalibrationTraining
Is your calibration training effective?OJT/Inhouse Training vs. MyTrain CalibrationTraining
Is your calibration training effective?
Instructional design features include: Easy to navigate Main and Sub Menus, Instructional Objectives clearly stated, Glossary (VIM), Printed Course Notes, OJT
Mentor; SME Instructor help tool, graphics, formulas, Pre and Post Tests.
MyTrain Admin complianceaudit function includes:course delivery, individualized scoring, usage tracking, record keeping, Certificate of Completion printing and storage.
❚ 30 COURSES FOR THE CALIBRATION
TECHNICIAN OR METROLOGY ENGINEER:
• Electrical • PhysD • Measurement Uncertainty • 17025 Compliance
❚ NEW COURSES: • RF Measurement Calibration and Connector Care • GDT for the Calibration Technician
68 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
regionalnews
For our NCSLI Utah Section meeting, we met at the Utah State Space
Dynamics Laboratory which is a research and development arm of
Utah State University in Logan, Utah. It is a very applicable and
interesting place to meet because SDL has contributed significantly
to research efforts in space-born observations of earth’s atmosphere
as well as exploring galaxies with highly advanced IR detectors used
on satellites used to find asteroids, take high resolution images of
galaxies, among other scientific activities.
We started the day with Jack Somppi delivering a message of
greetings from the NCSLI Board of Directors including updates on
NCSLI activities and events. After that, we were excited to have
representatives from the Utah Department of Agriculture – Weights
and Measures Laboratory, Brett Gurney, Bill Rigby, and Shelley
Walker, present on their legal metrology program. It was interesting
to hear the huge impact they have in all our lives, most of which we
don’t even realize. It was really interesting to hear how the Weights
and Measures Lab recently made news in Utah. A few years ago they
had received several questions and concerns about scales being used
in the trade of precious metals. They began a program in 2013 to
visit all the precious metal traders in the state of Utah to check their
scales and work with them on making proper measurements. In the
first year they found that more than 62% of the scales were out of
tolerance. As they worked with the shops, providing education and
training, they were able to see that only 17% of scales were out of
tolerance in 2014. This was a great example of how metrology really
does make a difference in the world.
After lunch we were able to rotate through multiple demonstra-
tions provided by our meeting sponsors; Additel Corporation, Fluke
Calibration, and The Modal Shop. We learned how to make auto-
mated low-pressure measurements and automated accelerometer
calibrations. We also saw a demo on the importance of understand-
ing emissivity settings in IR thermometry.
Our afternoon technical presentation was provided by Mike
Dillon, a Product Group Manager, from The Modal Shop. He
spoke on calibration of dynamic sensors (accelerometers). It was
very interesting to see how different accelerometer technologies
work and the different ways of calibrating them. We were also
able to learn how accelerometers can be used for dynamic pressure
measurements as well.
We appreciate everyone who helped with this meeting,
especially Marla Richman at SDL who did a great job with getting
the facility set up for us and a nice catered lunch. She even picked
up a variety of Utah State Aggie ice cream for our afternoon snack!
Mike ColemanUtah
Utah Meeting.
regionalnews
www.ncsli.org July 2015 | Metrologist 69
Mons Lee
Washington/Oregonregionalnews
On World Metrology Day; present and fu-
ture scientists, engineers, and technicians
joined the celebration by attending the
NCSLI Northwestern Region “Measure-
ment Training Summit” held at Tektronix’s
scenic Beaverton, Oregon, Campus. The
overall goal of the meeting was to provide a
high quality measurement science summit
at minimal cost to attendees through mea-
surement practice tutorials, white paper
presentations, hands on demonstrations,
and lab tours.
As the new Washington/Oregon sec-
tion coordinator, this was my first time
planning and coordinating an NCSLI
meeting. I learned that planning and co-
ordinating a section meeting can be chal-
lenging, but having a good team to aide
in the meeting planning process can help
mitigate these challenges.
Our team consisted of measurement and
quality professionals working together from
the electronics and aerospace industries,
with Jennifer Fleenor of Tektronix taking
the lead on a variety tasks that significantly
supported our planning. Each team member
was able to bring a unique skill set to the table,
and contributed to the meeting by helping
obtain the venue and meeting sponsorship,
getting the word out to measurement
professionals and students, planning the
logistics of setting up the meeting space,
recruiting exhibitors to demonstrate their
latest and greatest measurement equipment,
and most importantly enlisting training and
knowledge transfer opportunities in the form
of tutorial and white paper presentations.
Without this team in place, the meeting
wouldn’t have been the success it was.
The meeting began with Randy Van
Wie of Tektronix welcoming attendees,
discussing safety, and giving a brief
overview of the scheduled Tektronix Service
lab tour. Following Randy was Jack Somppi
of Measurements International, and NCSLI
Division VP. Jack shared a brief summary of
the recent NCSLI Board of Directors meeting
including; revisions to ISO/IEC 17025, the
benefits of having an NCSLI membership
and the upcoming NCSLI Workshop &
Symposium in Grapevine, Texas.
I provided the final introductory remarks
by introducing World Metrology Day and
reinforcing why we have these meetings; to
learn, to try something new, and to network
with our fellow measurement and quality
professionals. Attendees then broke out to
pursue training, presentations, and get their
hands on measurement equipment.
Amongst the many interesting white
paper presentations and tutorials that
ranged from measurement systems analysis
to using water as the ultimate liquid density
standard, one presentation tied in directly
with the World Metrology Day theme,
“Measurements and Light.”
Brian Kenison of The Boeing Company
gave a tutorial on “Photometric Measure-
ments of a Light Meter.” Using a portable
measurement apparatus fabricated at home
that serves as a rugged replica of the lab ap-
paratus he uses at his Boeing metrology lab
in Seattle, Washington. Brian introduced at-
tendees to one of the more unique measure-
ment parameters in metrology, Photometry.
Northwestern Meeting.
70 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
regionalnews
He began by describing how Photometry is the science of light mea-
surement in terms of its perceived brightness to the human eye as a
subset of Radiometry, and defining and discussing common terms
to this measurement parameter; the candela, lumens, lux, illumi-
nance, photopic response, luminous flux, and the inverse square
law of light intensity. After introducing attendees to Photometry,
Brian used his portable lab apparatus to demonstrate how one goes
about calibrating a light meter using a calibrated lamp, screens, and
distances to provide measurement traceability for light intensity
measurements and why these measurements are important to the
manufacturing of aerospace products. Brian highlighted the role
light plays in our daily lives and their importance to our future.
To finish the meeting, we held a group discussion to thank our
presenters and demonstrators, discuss what people had learned
during the meeting, and get feedback on how to make future
meetings better. We also reached out to attendees to pursue acting
as hosts to future NCSLI meetings and encouraged them to spread
the word on the benefits of being an NCSLI member and attending
section and regional meetings. The goal of providing high quality,
high value measurement training to new and future measurement
and quality professionals was achieved thanks to our meeting
sponsors Tektronix and The Boeing Company, our planning team,
the presenters, exhibitors and NCSLI. Thanks again to everyone for
making the meeting a success! We are looking forward to more
meetings like this in the future.
Jay Skovbjerg of Anton Paar, discusses water as the ultimate density standard.
Jordan Hiller of JMP, presenting on Measurement Systems Analysis.
Randy Van Wie of Tektronix, pre-senting on Oscilloscope Bandwidth Measurements.
Jennifer Fleenor of Tektronix, discusses Internal Proficiency Testing.
The 6270A Pressure Calibrator lets you mix up to five measurement modules so you can calibrate a wide variety of pressure gauges and sensors with a single instrument, from vacuum to 20 MPa (3000 psi). Two levels of accuracy let you match each module to the appropriate workload and requirements.
Maintenance and repair are fast and easy too, making downtime a worry of the past.
©2015 Fluke Calibration. 6003963a-en
Electrical Temperature Pressure SoftwareFlowRF
Fluke Calibration. Precision, performance, confidence.™
MIX, MATCH, CALIBRATE. Learn more about the 6270A
www.flukecal.com/6270A
Reliable measurements have a fundamental impact on the quality of life of people on all levels of society.
What are the things required to improve the quality of our lives? Philosophically we think of more permanent things such as relationships. The physical aspects of quality of life, such as the air
we breathe, the water we drink, the food we eat, good health, the energy and resources we need to create wealth and prosperity, are also very important. Reliable measurements are
an integral requirement for the preservation, monitoring and enhancement of all these physical aspects required for the improvement of quality of life.
Measurements have an impact on our survival. The quality assurance performed on the production of the food we eat is based on measurement results.
Also the monitoring of ambient air quality and water quality depends on measurement results. Primary health care is based on measurements,
such as blood pressure, EKG, MR scans, etc.
Manufacturing and trade will not be possible without measurements, such as the dimensions of a spark plug , the octane number and volume dispensed by a petrol pump, the purity and accurate mass of an ounce of gold being traded on the stock exchanges of the world. Research and innovation also depends on an international system of units that are comparable between countries all over the world.
C A L L F O R P A P E R S
NATIO
NALLA
BO
RATORY ASSOCIATIO
N
-SO
UTH
AFRICA
N A T I O N A L
A S S O C I A T I O NS O U T H A F R I C A
L A B O R A T O R Y
CONFERENCE & WORKSHOP
Test&2015Measurement
Quality of Life
12th - 14th October 2015Lord Charles Hotel, Somerset West,Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa
Tel: +27(0)12 349 1500www.nla.org.za
What is the measure of it?
INTERNATIONAL
72 Metrologist | July 2015 Vol. 8 No. 3
Thank You Advertisers!
Reference Recorder
Accuraterugged&Portable
Accuracy up to 0.025%.
Collects and stores up to 1 million data points.
Replaces a deadweight tester and chart recorder.
Temperature, current, voltage, and switch.
Also available in a Lab Reference configuration.Additelwww.additel.com Page 43
Ametekwww.ametek.com Page 50
Collége Français De Metrologiewww.metrologie2015.com Page 25
Consumers Energy Laboratory Serviceswww.laboratoryservices.com Page 63
CPEMwww.cpem2016.com Page 29
Fluke Calibrationwww.fluke.com Page 70
Geo Calibrationwww.geocalibration.com Page 5
Lockheed Martin Mission Systems and Trainingwww.lockheedmartin.com/calibration Page 15
Masywww.masy.com Page 58
Mensor Corporationwww.mensor.com Page 28
National Laboratory Association - South Africawww.nla.org.za Page 71
NCSLI Technical Exchangewww.ncsli.org Page 37
NCSLI 2016 Workshop & Symposiumwww.ncsli.org Back Cover
Rice Lakewww.ricelake.com/calibration Page 65
Thunder Scientific Corporationwww.thunderscientific.com Page 44
Transcatwww.transcat.com Page 55
Trescal Lab Tourwww.trescal.com Page 60
Trescalwww.trescal.com Page 45
WorkPlace Trainingwww.wptraining.com Page 67
NCSL INTERNATIONAL | ncsli.org2995 Wilderness Place, Suite 107 | Boulder, CO 80301 | (303) 440-3339 | [email protected]
JULY 24–28, 2016ST. PAUL CONVENTION CENTER ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA
2016 NCSLI WORKSHOP & SYMPOSIUM