cesi-ms -a sensitive and versatile approach for metabolomics & … · 2020-05-18 ·...

1
Polar Pesticides & Herbicide Analysis Concerns about the safety of glyphosate-based herbicides mandate their analysis in foods, especially fruits and nuts. Current IC-MS methods have significant limitations, including ion suppression, retention time instability and difficulty to distinguish alternative herbicides (such as fosetyl aluminum) and degradation products. Additionally, both false positive IDs and inaccurate quantitation of the degradation products (phosphate and phosphonate) are possible with current IC-MS methods. As CESI is a charged based separation technique it is ideally suited for separations and quantitation of small polar molecules. The CESI technology drastically simplifies the integration of a charged based separation technique with MS. In this example, ions as simple as phosphate and phosphonate have been separated and detected amongst other related pesticides, herbicides that are of common use and their degradation products (Figure 4). 9 Glycosaminoglycan Analysis Heparin is a naturally occurring glycosaminoglycan (GAG). This anticoagulant is employed as a therapeutic for deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolism, arterial thromboembolism, heart attacks, and unstable angina. Heparin proves extremely difficult to analyze due to the high negative charge and sequence heterogeneity. The complexity of heparin therapeutics necessitate digestion to smaller oligosaccharides to facilitate the characterization process. CESI-MS can provide an excellent alternative to HILIC and RP-LC without the need for ion pairing agents. The highly efficient separation can resolve isomers (Figure 5A). Next, the CESI assay is highly sensitive and robust (Figure 5B). Finally, the ability to achieve negative ionization ESI facilitates clean spectra (Figure 5C). RESULTS Metabolite Analysis The study of metabolites is critical in many fields as it can provide key insight towards understanding drug toxicities, drug interactions and the mechanisms of actions of therapeutics and biomarkers of disease states. Unfortunately, many metabolites are small and highly polar and thus not suited to RPLC-MS. To address this challenge chemical derivatization, ion pairing agents and HILIC are routinely employed, but each approach has unique disadvantages. CESI-MS is a powerful analytical tool uniquely suited towards the analysis of small, polar, highly charged analytes. Anionic metabolites The disregulation of metabolites across the central carbon metabolism (CCM) (consisting of glycolysis, gluconeogenesis, pentose phosphate pathway, and tricarboxylic acid (TCA cycle) is often indicative of a diseased state, particularly cancer. These challenging metabolites include isobaric sugar phosphates, nucleotides, phosphocarboxylic and free carboxylic acids. CESI-MS has proven powerful for the targeted analysis of CCM metabolites, particularly the small organic acids of the TCA cycle and the isobaric phosphorylated sugars of the pentose and glycolysis pathways (Figure 2). 7,8 Cationic metabolites Chimeric antigen-receptor (CAR) T-cells are a promising targeted cancer therapy. In CAR T-cell therapy, indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) modulates the T-cell response and can be monitored to assess the effectiveness of the tumor therapy. As IDO catabolizes tryptophan, the metabolites of the tryptophan pathway could serve as biomarkers for IDO activity in CAR T-cell therapy. , which makes is necessary to develop a highly sensitive method to analyze these challenging metabolites. The ultra-low flow rate of CESI-MS increases ionization efficiency and hence facilitates highly sensitive analyses. Here, CESI-MS was evaluated for the analyses of potential biomarkers for IDO (Figure 3 & Table 1). CESI-MS - A Sensitive and Versatile Approach for Metabolomics & Polar Molecules Esme Candish 1 , Stephen Lock 2 and Bryan Fonslow 3 SCIEX Separations, 1 Framingham, MA, 2 Warrington, UK and 3 Brea, CA. INTRODUCTION The analysis of small polar molecules present an analytical challenge, particularly metabolites, nucleotides/nucleosides, polar pesticide and glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). Further, these classes of analytes present many structural isomers which often can’t be differentiated by MS or MS/MS alone, making a separation crucial. Unfortunately, the liquid chromatography (LC) separations of small, highly charged molecules often proves difficult; some hydrophilic analytes are poorly retained by reversed phase (RP)-LC necessitating ion-paring agents, while column-to-column reproducibility can sometimes be more challenging with hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC). Furthermore, the interface between ion chromatography (IC) and MS has inherently limited compatibility. In contrast, capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) is well suited for the analysis of these challenging charged and polar molecules. CESI-MS integrates CE and electrospray ionization (ESI) into a single device, effortlessly combining the benefits of a high-resolution separation with the increased MS sensitivities that result from the ultra-low flow rates. 1 Many of these benefits have already been seen for the post-translational modification analysis on biological 2 and therapeutic 3 proteins, hydrophobic peptide quantitation, 3 and top-down proteomic analysis. 5,6 In this work, we demonstrate the versatility of CESI-MS for the analysis of these challenging polar metabolites, polar pesticides/herbicides and GAGs. MATERIALS AND METHODS Sample Preparation: Metabolite and polar pesticide/herbicide standards were acquired from Sigma-Aldrich. Heparin disaccharides were acquired from Galen Laboratory Supplies. Samples were diluted in either 10% background electrolyte (BGE) or a 100 mM ammonium acetate pH 4 which acted as the leading electrolyte (LE). CESI Conditions: All experiments were carried out on a SCIEX CESI 8000 Plus. A bare fused-silica OptiMS cartridge was used for all analyses. Acetic acid (3-10%) or ammonium bicarbonate (pH 9 – 10) was used as the BGE. In negative ion mode 10% isopropanol was added to the BGE. Approximately, 1 - 50 nL of sample was injected hydrodynamically. MS Conditions: A SCIEX TripleTOF ® (5600 or 6600 ) or a QTRAP ® 6500+ system equipped with a NanoSpray ® III source and CESI adapter was used for all analysis. Data acquisition was controlled by Analyst ® software. Positive or negative ESI was performed. For TOF MS, 75 - 1000 m/z was scanned and confirmed with MS/MS. An MRM strategy was employed for QTRAP ® systems. Data Analysis: PeakView ® and MultiQuant TM software’s were utilized for data analysis. CONCLUSIONS CESI-MS has been demonstrated to be a versatile separation and ionization technique that provides unique separation selectivity’s that is highly beneficial for the analysis of challenging small, charged, polar molecules. The highly efficient charged based separation technique was able to resolve isomeric phosphorylated sugars and disaccharides. CESI seamlessly interfaced with MS to provide a highly sensitive and robust analysis of anionic and cation metabolites, polar pesticides/herbicides and GAGs. REFERENCES 1. Moini, M., Anal. Chem. 2007, 79, 4241-4246. 2. Faserl, K. et al., J Chromatogr A., 2017, 17, 30180-2. 3. Bush, D.B. et al., Anal. Chem., 2016, 88, 1138−1146. 4. Lock, S., SCIEX Poster RUO-MKT-10-3951-A. 5. Han X. et al., J Proteome Res., 2014, 13, 6078-86. TRADEMARKS/LICENSING AB Sciex is doing business as SCIEX. © 2018 AB Sciex. For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures. The trademarks mentioned herein are the property of AB Sciex Pte. Ltd. or their respective owners. AB SCIEX™ is being used under license. Document number: RUO-MKT-10-7414-B For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures. Figure 1. A. CESI 8000 Plus, B. CESI-MS interface, the etched porous capillary tip allows electrospray generation without dilution of the sample by a make-up liquid. C. TripleTOF ® 6600 and QTRAP ® 6500 A B C Figure 4A. The rapid separation of glyphosate and fosetyl aluminum; their degradation products, phosphate, phosphonate, and aminomethylphosphonic acid (AMPA); and pesticide glufosinate. A CESI-MS/MS IC-MS/MS Figure 5A. Total ion electropherogram of heparin disaccharide standards Figure 5B. Calibration curves for each disaccharide from 75 μM – 0.36 μM Figure 5C. MS spectra of heparin disaccharide standards in negative ESI mode A B C Figure 4B. Comparison of migration/retention times for phosphonic and phosphoric acid across a ~170 replicate analyses. Figure 4C. Identical spikes of phosphonic acid into 0.1% formic acid (solvent) and almond, walnut, and pistachio extracts analyzed by CESI-MS/MS and IC-MS/MS on the TripleTOF® 5600. Black lines represent the linear curve fit for blank solvent calibration curves. Matrix suppression was observed by LC-MS, but not CESI-MS, indicated by curved and linear calibration trends, respectively. Markers outlined in red were samples diluted 5x with 0.1% formic acid. B C 6. Han X. et al., Anal Chem. 2014, 86, 11006-12. 7. Gulersonmez, M.C. et al., Electrophoresis, 2015, 00, 1–8. 8. Lock, S. et al.. SCIEX Technical Note RUO-MKT-02-2643-A. 9. Fonslow, B.R., et al., SCIEX Technical Note RUO-MKT-07-4555-A. Metabolite LOD (nM) Nicotinamide 0.56 Serotonin 0.19 3-hydroxy-kynurenine 0.80 L-kynurenine 0.39 Tryptophan 0.11 3-hydroxy anthranilic acid 1.45 Kynurenic acid 0.05 Xanthurenic acid 0.04 Quinolinic acid 0.07 Table 1. LODs for metabolites of the tryptophan pathway Figure 2. CESI-MS analysis of anionic metabolites in CCM. Limits of detection (LOD)s are listed after each labeled metabolite. Figure 3. CESI separation of metabolites in the tryptophan pathway IC-MS/MS CESI-MS/MS

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CESI-MS -A Sensitive and Versatile Approach for Metabolomics & … · 2020-05-18 · PolarPesticides&HerbicideAnalysis Concernsaboutthesafetyofglyphosate-basedherbicidesmandatetheiranalysisinfoods,especiallyfruitsandnuts.Current

Polar Pesticides & Herbicide AnalysisConcerns about the safety of glyphosate-based herbicides mandate their analysis in foods, especially fruits and nuts. CurrentIC-MS methods have significant limitations, including ion suppression, retention time instability and difficulty to distinguishalternative herbicides (such as fosetyl aluminum) and degradation products. Additionally, both false positive IDs andinaccurate quantitation of the degradation products (phosphate and phosphonate) are possible with current IC-MS methods.

As CESI is a charged based separation technique it is ideally suited for separations and quantitation of small polarmolecules. The CESI technology drastically simplifies the integration of a charged based separation technique with MS. Inthis example, ions as simple as phosphate and phosphonate have been separated and detected amongst other relatedpesticides, herbicides that are of common use and their degradation products (Figure 4).9

Glycosaminoglycan AnalysisHeparin is a naturally occurring glycosaminoglycan (GAG). This anticoagulant is employed as a therapeutic for deep veinthrombosis, pulmonary embolism, arterial thromboembolism, heart attacks, and unstable angina.

Heparin proves extremely difficult to analyze due to the high negative charge and sequence heterogeneity. The complexity ofheparin therapeutics necessitate digestion to smaller oligosaccharides to facilitate the characterization process.

CESI-MS can provide an excellent alternative to HILIC and RP-LC without the need for ion pairing agents. The highlyefficient separation can resolve isomers (Figure 5A). Next, the CESI assay is highly sensitive and robust (Figure 5B). Finally,the ability to achieve negative ionization ESI facilitates clean spectra (Figure 5C).

RESULTSMetabolite Analysis The study of metabolites is critical in many fields as it can provide key insight towards understanding drug toxicities,drug interactions and the mechanisms of actions of therapeutics and biomarkers of disease states. Unfortunately, manymetabolites are small and highly polar and thus not suited to RPLC-MS. To address this challenge chemicalderivatization, ion pairing agents and HILIC are routinely employed, but each approach has unique disadvantages.CESI-MS is a powerful analytical tool uniquely suited towards the analysis of small, polar, highly charged analytes.

Anionic metabolitesThe disregulation of metabolites across the central carbon metabolism (CCM) (consisting of glycolysis,gluconeogenesis, pentose phosphate pathway, and tricarboxylic acid (TCA cycle) is often indicative of a diseased state,particularly cancer. These challenging metabolites include isobaric sugar phosphates, nucleotides, phosphocarboxylicand free carboxylic acids.

CESI-MS has proven powerful for the targeted analysis of CCM metabolites, particularly the small organic acids of theTCA cycle and the isobaric phosphorylated sugars of the pentose and glycolysis pathways (Figure 2).7,8

Cationic metabolitesChimeric antigen-receptor (CAR) T-cells are a promising targeted cancer therapy. In CAR T-cell therapy, indoleamine2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) modulates the T-cell response and can be monitored to assess the effectiveness of the tumortherapy. As IDO catabolizes tryptophan, the metabolites of the tryptophan pathway could serve as biomarkers for IDOactivity in CAR T-cell therapy. , which makes is necessary to develop a highly sensitive method to analyze thesechallenging metabolites.

The ultra-low flow rate of CESI-MS increases ionization efficiency and hence facilitates highly sensitive analyses. Here,CESI-MS was evaluated for the analyses of potential biomarkers for IDO (Figure 3 & Table 1).

CESI-MS - A Sensitive and Versatile Approach for Metabolomics & Polar Molecules

Esme Candish1, Stephen Lock2 and Bryan Fonslow3

SCIEX Separations, 1Framingham, MA, 2Warrington, UK and 3Brea, CA.INTRODUCTIONThe analysis of small polar molecules present an analytical challenge, particularly metabolites, nucleotides/nucleosides,polar pesticide and glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). Further, these classes of analytes present many structural isomerswhich often can’t be differentiated by MS or MS/MS alone, making a separation crucial. Unfortunately, the liquidchromatography (LC) separations of small, highly charged molecules often proves difficult; some hydrophilic analytesare poorly retained by reversed phase (RP)-LC necessitating ion-paring agents, while column-to-column reproducibilitycan sometimes be more challenging with hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC). Furthermore, theinterface between ion chromatography (IC) and MS has inherently limited compatibility.

In contrast, capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) is well suited for the analysis of these challenging charged and polarmolecules. CESI-MS integrates CE and electrospray ionization (ESI) into a single device, effortlessly combining thebenefits of a high-resolution separation with the increased MS sensitivities that result from the ultra-low flow rates.1Many of these benefits have already been seen for the post-translational modification analysis on biological2 andtherapeutic3 proteins, hydrophobic peptide quantitation,3 and top-down proteomic analysis.5,6 In this work, wedemonstrate the versatility of CESI-MS for the analysis of these challenging polar metabolites, polarpesticides/herbicides and GAGs.

MATERIALS AND METHODSSample Preparation: Metabolite and polar pesticide/herbicide standards were acquired from Sigma-Aldrich. Heparindisaccharides were acquired from Galen Laboratory Supplies. Samples were diluted in either 10% backgroundelectrolyte (BGE) or a 100 mM ammonium acetate pH 4 which acted as the leading electrolyte (LE).

CESI Conditions: All experiments were carried out on a SCIEX CESI 8000 Plus. A bare fused-silica OptiMS cartridgewas used for all analyses. Acetic acid (3-10%) or ammonium bicarbonate (pH 9 – 10) was used as the BGE. In negativeion mode 10% isopropanol was added to the BGE. Approximately, 1 - 50 nL of sample was injected hydrodynamically.

MS Conditions: A SCIEX TripleTOF® (5600 or 6600 ) or a QTRAP® 6500+ system equipped with a NanoSpray® IIIsource and CESI adapter was used for all analysis. Data acquisition was controlled by Analyst® software. Positive ornegative ESI was performed. For TOF MS, 75 - 1000 m/z was scanned and confirmed with MS/MS. An MRM strategywas employed for QTRAP ® systems.

Data Analysis: PeakView® and MultiQuantTM software’s were utilized for data analysis.

CONCLUSIONSCESI-MS has been demonstrated to be a versatile separation and ionization technique that provides unique separationselectivity’s that is highly beneficial for the analysis of challenging small, charged, polar molecules. The highly efficientcharged based separation technique was able to resolve isomeric phosphorylated sugars and disaccharides. CESIseamlessly interfaced with MS to provide a highly sensitive and robust analysis of anionic and cation metabolites, polarpesticides/herbicides and GAGs.

REFERENCES1. Moini, M., Anal. Chem. 2007, 79, 4241-4246.2. Faserl, K. et al., J Chromatogr A., 2017, 17, 30180-2.3. Bush, D.B. et al., Anal. Chem., 2016, 88, 1138−1146.4. Lock, S., SCIEX Poster RUO-MKT-10-3951-A.5. Han X. et al., J Proteome Res., 2014, 13, 6078-86.

TRADEMARKS/LICENSINGAB Sciex is doing business as SCIEX.© 2018 AB Sciex. For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures. The trademarks mentioned herein are the property of AB Sciex Pte. Ltd. or their respective owners. AB SCIEX™ is being used under license. Document number: RUO-MKT-10-7414-B

For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures.

Figure 1. A. CESI 8000 Plus, B. CESI-MS interface, the etched porous capillary tip allows electrospray generation without dilution of the sample by a make-up liquid. C. TripleTOF® 6600 and QTRAP ® 6500

A B C

Figure 4A. The rapid separation of glyphosate and fosetyl aluminum; their degradation products, phosphate, phosphonate, and aminomethylphosphonic acid (AMPA); and pesticide glufosinate.

A CESI-MS/MS IC-MS/MSCESI-MS/MS LC-MS/MS

Figure 5A. Total ion electropherogram of heparin disaccharide standards

Figure 5B. Calibration curves for each disaccharide from 75 μM – 0.36 μM

Figure 5C. MS spectra of heparin disaccharide standards in negative ESI mode

A B

C

Figure 4B. Comparison of migration/retention times forphosphonic and phosphoric acid across a ~170replicate analyses.

Figure 4C. Identical spikes of phosphonic acidinto 0.1% formic acid (solvent) and almond,walnut, and pistachio extracts analyzed byCESI-MS/MS and IC-MS/MS on theTripleTOF® 5600. Black lines represent thelinear curve fit for blank solvent calibrationcurves. Matrix suppression was observed byLC-MS, but not CESI-MS, indicated by curvedand linear calibration trends, respectively.Markers outlined in red were samples diluted5x with 0.1% formic acid.

B

C

6. Han X. et al., Anal Chem. 2014, 86, 11006-12.7. Gulersonmez, M.C. et al., Electrophoresis, 2015, 00, 1–8.8. Lock, S. et al.. SCIEX Technical Note RUO-MKT-02-2643-A.9. Fonslow, B.R., et al., SCIEX Technical Note RUO-MKT-07-4555-A.

Metabolite LOD (nM)Nicotinamide 0.56Serotonin 0.193-hydroxy-kynurenine 0.80L-kynurenine 0.39Tryptophan 0.113-hydroxy anthranilic acid 1.45Kynurenic acid 0.05Xanthurenic acid 0.04Quinolinic acid 0.07

Table 1. LODs for metabolites of the tryptophan pathway

Figure 2. CESI-MS analysis of anionic metabolites in CCM. Limits of detection (LOD)s are listed after each labeled metabolite.

Figure 3. CESI separation of metabolites in the tryptophan pathway

IC-MS/MSCESI-MS/MS