cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass...

6
工学院大学研究報告第 123 号 平成 29 年 10 月 —  — 59 ガラスナノピペット内に作製したセシウムイオン選択膜 西山北斗 *1 ,高見知秀 *2 Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass nanopipette Hokuto NISHIYAMA *1 and Tomohide TAKAMI *2 Abstract ガラス製ナノピペット中にセシウムイオン選択膜を作製した.1,3-alternate thiacalix[4]biscrown-6,6 をイオン選択 リガンドとして用い,その選択性を確認するためにセシウム,カリウム,ナトリウムの各イオンについてそれぞれ 0.01 mM から 100 mM まで濃度を変えていったときの信号強度からイオン選択性を計測した.イオン選択膜の主成分であ るポリ塩化ビニルが,ナノピペット中でゲル化する前段階において,予めナノピペット中に入れている水と混ざってし まうことを防止するために,選択膜ゲル化の前段階においてその選択膜の原料を溶かした溶媒と水との液界面にシクロ ヘキサンの液膜を張っておく手法を開発して,選択膜作製の確度を上げることができた. Keywords: Ion-selective Electrode, Nanopipette, Cesium Ion 1.Introduction Glass nanopipettes have been used as a bridge between macro world and nano world. 1) Pipettes have been used as a tool to transfer liquids with various volumes, 2) and many novel phenomena and applications are involved as going down the size of pipettes to micro or nano-meters. 3-8) Nanopipettes could be also used as probes in scanning electrochemical microscopy and scanning ion conductance microscopy for high resolution imaging. 9-11) Moreover, microinjection is a useful method of transfection to cells, 12) though the viability of cells after the microinjection is not high enough to obtain statistical and quantitative results. 13) An ion-selective electrode with polymer membrane is a universal and known tool for the recognition of ions in a liquid, and various types of ion-selective electrodes have been developed. 14,15) However, the typical size of a conventional ion-selective electrode is on the order of millimeters, and thus, such as an ion- selective electrode cannot be used with a nanopipette. Therefore, we developed a method to prepare an ion-selective membrane in a nanopipette; further we developed a nanopipette-based detection system for subtle signals. 16-20) The ion detection mechanism of an ion-selective electrode in a nanopipette is discussed in our recent paper. 21) Further, we applied our method to the determination of local concentrations of target ions in various kinds of living cells. We applied this method to determine the local concentration of potassium or sodium ions in HeLa cells, 22) rat vascular myocytes, and neuron cells from embryonic stem cells. 23) Although the detection of sodium, potassium, and calcium ions could be identified with ion-selective nanopipettes, 16-23) cesium ion-selective nanopiette, which would have an application of local detection of cesium ions in a living cell, has not been developed yet. Choi et al. reported the cesium ionselective glass tube electrode with the ionophore of 1,3alternate thiacalix[4] biscrown-6,6 in poly(vinyl chroride) membrane. 24) They reported the linear response with a near Nernstian slope of 57.6 mV per decade within the concentration range of 0.001 to 32 mM, and the limit of detection was determined as 0.38 µM. 24) In this paper, we have succeeded in producing cesium ionselective nanopiette. We have estimated *1 工学院大学工学部応用化学科 2017 年卒業 Department of Applied Chemistry, Kogakuin University *2 工学院大学教育推進機構ナノ化学研究室教授 Nanotechnology Chemistry Laboratory, Division of Liberal Arts, Kogakuin University

Upload: others

Post on 23-Sep-2019

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass ...ft13537/NishiyamaResRepKogakuinUniv123_59_2017.… · Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass nanopipette Hokuto

工学院大学研究報告第123号 平成29年10月

—  —59

ガラスナノピペット内に作製したセシウムイオン選択膜

西 山 北 斗*1,高 見 知 秀*2

Cesiumion-selectivemembranefabricatedinaglassnanopipette

HokutoNISHIYAMA*1andTomohideTAKAMI*2

Abstract

  ガラス製ナノピペット中にセシウムイオン選択膜を作製した.1,3-alternatethiacalix[4]biscrown-6,6 をイオン選択リガンドとして用い,その選択性を確認するためにセシウム,カリウム,ナトリウムの各イオンについてそれぞれ 0.01mM から 100mM まで濃度を変えていったときの信号強度からイオン選択性を計測した.イオン選択膜の主成分であるポリ塩化ビニルが,ナノピペット中でゲル化する前段階において,予めナノピペット中に入れている水と混ざってしまうことを防止するために,選択膜ゲル化の前段階においてその選択膜の原料を溶かした溶媒と水との液界面にシクロヘキサンの液膜を張っておく手法を開発して,選択膜作製の確度を上げることができた.Keywords:Ion-selectiveElectrode,Nanopipette,CesiumIon

1.Introduction

 Glass nanopipettes have been used as a bridgebetweenmacroworldandnanoworld.1)Pipetteshavebeenusedasa tool to transfer liquidswithvariousvolumes,2)andmanynovelphenomenaandapplicationsare involvedasgoingdown the size ofpipettes tomicroornano-meters.3-8)Nanopipettes couldbealsousedasprobesinscanningelectrochemicalmicroscopyand scanning ion conductancemicroscopy forhighresolution imaging.9-11)Moreover,microinjection is ausefulmethodof transfection to cells,12) though theviabilityof cells after themicroinjection isnothighenoughtoobtainstatisticalandquantitativeresults.13)

 An ion-selectiveelectrodewithpolymermembraneisauniversalandknowntool for therecognitionofions in a liquid, andvarious types of ion-selectiveelectrodes have been developed.14,15) However, thetypicalsizeofaconventional ion-selectiveelectrodeisontheorderofmillimeters,andthus,suchasan ion-selectiveelectrodecannotbeusedwithananopipette.Therefore,we developed amethod to prepare anion-selectivemembrane inananopipette; furtherwe

developedananopipette-baseddetection system forsubtlesignals.16-20)The iondetectionmechanismofanion-selectiveelectrodeinananopipetteisdiscussedinourrecentpaper.21)Further,weappliedourmethodtothedeterminationoflocalconcentrationsoftargetionsinvariouskindsoflivingcells.Weappliedthismethodtodetermine the localconcentrationofpotassiumorsodiumionsinHeLacells,22)ratvascularmyocytes,andneuroncellsfromembryonicstemcells.23)

 Although thedetectionof sodium,potassium,andcalcium ions could be identifiedwith ion-selectivenanopipettes,16-23)cesiumion-selectivenanopiette,whichwouldhaveanapplicationoflocaldetectionofcesiumions ina livingcell,hasnotbeendevelopedyet.Choiet al. reported the cesium ionselective glass tubeelectrodewiththeionophoreof1,3alternatethiacalix[4]biscrown-6,6inpoly(vinylchroride)membrane.24)Theyreported the linear responsewithanearNernstianslopeof57.6mVperdecadewithintheconcentrationrangeof0.001to32mM,andthelimitofdetectionwasdeterminedas0.38µM.24)

 In this paper,we have succeeded in producingcesium ionselectivenanopiette.Wehave estimated

*1工学院大学工学部応用化学科2017年卒業 DepartmentofAppliedChemistry,KogakuinUniversity*2工学院大学教育推進機構ナノ化学研究室教授 NanotechnologyChemistryLaboratory,DivisionofLiberalArts,KogakuinUniversity

Page 2: Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass ...ft13537/NishiyamaResRepKogakuinUniv123_59_2017.… · Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass nanopipette Hokuto

工学院大学研究報告

—  —60

the select ivity coeff ic ient and conf irmed thenegativevaluesof the selectivitycoefficientsat theconcentrationofthesamplesolutionofCsCl,KCl,andNaClfrom0.01mMto100mM.

2.Experimental methods

 The resource of ion-selectivemembranewas (i)32mg of poly(vinyl chloride) (Sigma-Aldrich, highmolecularweight,CAS9002-86-2)forthemainresourceofthemembrane,(ii)62mgof2-Nitrophenyloctylether(NPOE,Dojindo,purity>99.0%,CAS37682-29-4) fortheplasticizer, (iii) 5mgof 1,3alternate thiacalix[4]biscrown-6,6 forthe ion-selective ionophore,and (iv)1mgof tetrakis[3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenyl]borate,sodiumsalt(TFPB,Dojindo,purity>99.0%,CAS79060-88-1) for theanion repeller.Theyweredissolved in1mL tetrahydrofuran (THF,Sigma-Aldrich, purity>99.9%,with250ppmdibutylhydroxytoluene(BHT)forthestabilizer,CAS109-99-9).Herewecallthesolution

“solutionA”. Next,weprepared the sample solutions ofCsCl(Sigma-Aldrich, purity>99.5%,CAS7647-17-3),KCl(Yanagishima,specialgrade,purity>99.5%,CAS7447-40-7),andNaCl (Manac, specialgrade,purity>99.5%,CAS7447-14-5)attheconcentrationsof0.01,0.1,1,10,and100mMindistilledwaterproducedwithOrganoBB-5B/G-35PA(resistivity5MΩcm).Inthisway,wehaveprepared15kindsofsamplesolutions.

 Before thepreparationof ion-selectivenanopipette,we prepared conventional ion-selective electrodeswithboronsilicateglasstubes (7mmouterdiameter,0.8mmthickness,70mmlength).Thecutfaceoftheglass tubewaspolishedwithawaterproof abrasivepaper.Figure1 shows theprocess to fabricate theconventional ion-selectiveglass tubeelectrode.Thesolution A was poured in a glass petri dish and

dried for1daytopreparePVCmembranefilmwithionophore.The filmwas cut and attached to thebottomoftheglasstubewithanepoxy.Aftercuringtheepoxy,0.01MCsClaqwasfilledintheglasstube.Finally,a0.20mmdiametersilverwire(Niraco,purity>99.99%) coated with a Ag/AgCl ink (BAS) wasinsertedintotheglasstubetopreparetheion-selectiveelectrode.

 TheNanopipettewasfabricatedfromboronsilicatecapillary tubes (NarishigeGD-1 outerdiameter: 1.0mm, innerdiameter: 0.6mm)with apuller (SutterP-2000) at ShizuokaUniversity.Thedetails of thepreparationmethodwerewritten in the previousreports.25-28)Figure2showstheprocesstofabricatetheion-selectivenanopipette.First,purewaterwasfilledin thenanopipette to the shankendusingamicro-

Fig.1 (Color online) The process to prepare ion-selective electrode. The details of the process are described in the text.

Fig.2 (Color online) The process to prepare ion-selective nanopipette. The details of the process are described in the text.

Fig.3 (Color online) Photos of nanopiette tube during the curing process of PVC membrane inside the nanopipette. (A-1): After pouring the PVC solution (“solution A” in the text) on the distilled water covered with cyclohexane. (A-2): Five minutes later after taking the photo (A-1). (B-1): After pouring the PVC solution on the distilled water, without using cyclohexane. (B-2): Five minutes later after taking the photo (B-1).

Page 3: Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass ...ft13537/NishiyamaResRepKogakuinUniv123_59_2017.… · Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass nanopipette Hokuto

ガラスナノピペット内に作製したセシウムイオン選択膜

—  —61

syringe.Then,wepoured ca. 0.01µL cyclohexane(Sigma-Aldrich,purity>99.0%,CAS110-82-7) on thewater.Aftermaking the cyclohexane solvent layeron thewater, 10µLof“solutionA”waspoured inthenanopipette,anddriedfor1daytocurethePVCmembrane in the nanopipette.Using cyclohexanebeforepouring thesolutionA is the improvedpointin this study.Figure3 showshow thecyclohexanesolventworksbetweenPVCsolutionandwater.Theupperphotos (A-1)and (A-2) inFig.3 indicates thatthemixing ofwater and solutionAdidnot occurevenafter5minutesofpouring(A-2)sothatthePVCmembranecanbeformedfirmlyinthenanopipette.Ontheotherhand,thelowerphotos(B-1)and(B-2)showsthemixingofwaterandsolutionAbecauseTHFcandissolve inwater.Moreover, themixedPVCsolutioninwatergotwhite to start theprecipitationafter5

minutes(B-2).Inthisway,wecouldpreventthemixingof PVC solutionwithwater byusing cyclohexanebetweenthePVCsolutionandwater.It isnotedthatthecyclohexane solventwas finally transpiredwithTHFonthedryingprocess.Afterthedryingprocess,0.01MCsClaqwasfilledinthenanopipette,anda0.20mmdiametersilverwirecoatedwithaAg/AgCl inkwas inserted into theglass tube toprepare the ion-selectivenanopipette. Figure4showstheschematicsofthediagramoftheexperimental setup forconventionalglass tube ion-selectiveelectrode (a) and ion-selectivenanopipette(b).Thesignalwasamplifiedwithapatch/wholecellclampamplifier (NihonKohdenCEZ-2400)atconstantcurrentmode, and theoutputvoltagewas recodedwith adigitalmultimeter (Fluke 287) and thedatawere transferred to apersonal computer (PC).Thered lines indicate theshieldedpart in theapparatus.Weprepared the shield fromconventionalmediumdensity fiberboard, aluminum mesh, and 0.1 mmthicknessaluminumfoil, asshown inFig.5.Withoutthe shield, 100Hznoisewith 250mVpeak-to-peakfromthe flickeringof fluorescent lighthindered themeasurement.Thepreparedshieldcouldreduce thenoiselessthan5mV.

 

Hereshowsthesequenceof themeasurement.First,purewaterwaspoured in theglasspetridishandmeasuretherelativevoltagebetweentheion-selectiveelectorode/ nanopipette and reference/counterelectorode,Ag/AgClwire immersed in thedish asshowninFig.4.Therelativevoltagewasadjustedtozeroafterthemeasuringvoltagewassettled.Thenthedishwaschangedto0.01mMsolutionandmeasuredthe relativevoltage.After themeasurementof 0.01

Fig.4 (Color online) Schematic diagram of the experimental set up for conventional glass tube ion-selective electrode (a) and ion-selective nanopipette (b).

Fig.5 (Color online) Photo of the shield used for the prevention of the noise on the experiments shown in Fig. 4.

(a)

(b)

Page 4: Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass ...ft13537/NishiyamaResRepKogakuinUniv123_59_2017.… · Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass nanopipette Hokuto

工学院大学研究報告

—  —62

mMsolution,thedishwaschangedto0.1mMsolution.Inthisway, thesolutionwaschangedandmeasuredfrom0.01 to 100mM, and the same sequencewasconductedonCsCl,KCl,NaClsolutions.

3.Results and discussion

 First, the resultson theconventional cesium ion-selectiveglass tube electrode are shown.Figure 6shows themeasuredrelativevoltagesonCs,K,andNa ionsat theconcentrations from0.01mMto100mM.Table 1 shows themeasured relativevoltagevaluesonCs,K,andNa ionsattheconcentrationsof0.01,0.1,1,10and100mM,respectively.Theobtainedrelativevoltagevalues forcesiumionare largerthanthoseforpotassiumandsodiumions,whichprovestheselectivityofthepreparedelectrode.

 Selectivitycoefficient wasestimatedfromtheseparatesolutionmethodusingthefollowingequation,29)

   (1)

whereEM andEN are the responsevoltages [V] fortheM andN ions at the same concentration,ZMandZN are thevalences ofMandN,F isFaraday

constant [Cmol−1],R isgasconstant [JK−1mol−1],Tis the temperature [K], andCM is theconcentrationof thesolution [M].Sinceall the ionsdetectedbytheion-selectiveelectrode in this studyarecations, thenegativevalueoftheselectivitycoefficientindicatestheselectivity.Table1showstheestimatedselectivitycoefficientvalues.All theestimatedvaluesarenegative,sothattheion-selectivityofthepreparedglass tube electrode has been confirmed at theconcentrationrange from0.01 to100mM.Choiet al.reportedthatthecesiumionselectivityoverpotassium

=−3.7.24) Since they measured with fixedinterferencemethod,differentfromthemethodinthisstudy,directcomparisonofthevaluesisnotavailable.Inanycase, itwasconfirmed that theselectivityofthe ion-selectiveglasstubeelectrodeprepared inthisstudyisaswellastheoneinthepreviousreport.24)

 Next, the results on the cesium ion-selectivenanopipetteareshown.Figure7showsthemeasuredrelative voltages on Cs, K, and Na ions at theconcentrations from0.01mM to 100mM.Table 2shows themeasured relativevoltagevalues onCs,K, andNa ions at the concentrations of 0.01, 0.1, 1,10and100mM, respectively.Theobtained relative

C[mM] 0.01 0.1 1 10 100

VCs[V]VK[V]VNa[V]VNa[V]

-0.763-1.101-1.063-1.063-5.820-5.160

-0.775-1.162-1.210-1.210-6.660-7.480

0-0.04550-0.74030-0.84600-0.8460-13.5000-15.3000

0-1.20900-0.02930-0.24420-0.2442-21.3000-25.0000

02.28000.77200.51800.518-25.90-0-30.30-0

C[mM] 0.01 0.1 1 10 100

VCs[V]VK[V]VNa[V]VNa[V]

-0.0351-0.0185-0.0190-1.0630-0.9210-0.2770

00.062100.015200.0559-1.210--0.807--0.108-

0.12500.00190.0746-0.8460--2.1220--0.8720-

0.13210.05840.0891-0.2442--1.270-0-0.741-0

0.1580.1070.1180.518-0.867--0.687-

Table 1 Measured relative voltage values on Cs, K, and Na ions with conventional ion-selective glass tube electrode and the estimated selectivity coefficients at the concentrations from 0.01 to 100 mM.

Fig.6 (Color online) Measured relative voltages on Cs, K, and Na ions with conventional ion-selective glass tube electrode at the concentrations of 0.01, 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 mM.

Fig.7 (Color online) Measured relative voltages on Cs, K, and Na ions with ion-selective nanopipette at the concentrations of 0.01, 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 mM.

Table 2 Measured relative voltage values on Cs, K, and Na ions with the ion-selective nanopipette and the estimated selectivity coefficients at the concentrations from 0.01 to 100 mM.

Page 5: Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass ...ft13537/NishiyamaResRepKogakuinUniv123_59_2017.… · Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass nanopipette Hokuto

ガラスナノピペット内に作製したセシウムイオン選択膜

—  —63

voltagevalues for cesium ionare larger than thosefor potassium and sodium ions,which proves theselectivityof theprepared ion-selectivenanopipette.Also,theselectivecoefficientsareestimated,asshowninTable2.Thenegativevaluesindicatesthattheion-selectivityof theprepared ion-selectivenanopipettehasbeenconfirmedat theconcentrationrange from0.01to100mM. In principle, the ion-selective electrode has theselectivity that the increaseof theconcentrationoftargeted ion increases the signal significantlywhilethe increase of the concentration of non-targetedions increases the signal little.29)Table3 shows theestimatedslopesand thePearsonrelativecoefficientR2. Incaseof conventionalglass tubeelectrode, theslopevalueforCsis1.65timesforKand1.95timesforNa.Ontheotherhand, theslopevalue forCs is1.07times forKand1.36times forNa,whichmeansthattheselectivitywiththeion-selectivenanopipetteisnotaswellasthatwithconventionalglasstubeelectrode.

 Thereasonof the insufficientselectivity incaseofnanopipettemight attribute to theexistence of theionicleakingpartinthePVCmembrane,whichistheassignmentof thenext study.The leakingproblemduetothemixingof thePVCmembranewithwateron thecuringprocesshasbeenmostly fixed in thisstudy,asshowninFig.3.However,werecognizedtheprecipitationofPVCinwaterevenusingcyclohexaneduringthecuringprocess,confirmedwiththeopticalmicroscope,owingtothedifferenceinsolubilityofPVCbetweenTHFandcyclohexane.Also,wesometimesobservedtheslightdetachmentofthePVCmembranefromthenanopipetteinnerwall,whichcausestheionicleakage.Thecontrolof thecuringprocess, includingthehumidityandtemperature isalsotheassignmentofthefurtherstudy.

4.Conclusion and Remarks

 We have prepared the cesium ion-selectivenanopipette with the ionophore 1 ,3 -a l ternatethiacalix[4]biscrown-6,6.Comparedtherelativevoltageof theCsCl,KCl, andNaCl solutionsat thevariousconcentrationsfrom0.01to100mM,theionselectivitywasconfirmed.Fortheapplicationof thecesiumion-selectivenanopipette to thepracticaluse, thecuringprocess of thePVCmembrane in the nanopipetteshould be reconsidered in order to obtain higherselectivitycoefficient.

Acknowledgment

 WearegratefultoProf.FutoshiIwatawhoprovidedustheglassnanopipettesusedinthisstudy.Thisworkwas supportedby JSPSKAKENHIGrantNumber15K04678.

参考文献1)T.Takami,B.H.Park,andT.Kawai,NanoConvergence1,17

(2014).2)C.A.Morris,A.K.Friedman,andL.A.Baker,Analyst135,

2190(2010).3)Y.Zhao,S. Inayat,D.A.Dikin,J.H.Singer,R.S.Ruoff,and

J.B.Troy, Proc. IMechE,PartN: J.Nanoengineering andNanosystems222,1(2008).

4)M.Malboubi,Y.Gu,andK.Jiang,Microelectron.Eng.87,778(2010).

5)S.An,C.Stambaugh,G.Kim,M.Lee,Y.Kim,K.Lee,andW.Jhe,Nanoscale4,6493(2012).

6)A.P.SuryavanshiandM.F.Yu,Appl.Phys.Lett.88,083103(2006).

7)A.P.SuryavanshiandM.F.Yu,Nanotechnology18,105305(2007).

8)F.O.Laforge,J.Carpino,S.A.Rotenberg,andM.V.Mirkin,Proc.Nat.Acad.Sci.U.S.A.,104,11895(2007).

9)C.B.Prater,P.K.Hansma,M.Tortonese,andC.F.Quate,Rev.Sci.Instrum.62,2634(1991).

10)Y.Takahashi,A. I. Shevchuk,P.Novak,Y.Murakami,H.Shiku,Y.E.Korchev,andT.Matsue, J.Am.Chem.Soc.132,10118(2010).

11)P.Elsamadisi,Y.X.Wang,J.Velmurugan,andM.V.Mirkin,Anal.Chem.83,671(2011).

12)R.E.Hammer,V.G.Pursel,C.E.RexroadJr.,R.J.Wall,D.J.Bolt,K.M.Ebert,R.D.Palmiter,andR.L.Brinster,Nature315,680(1985).

13)H.Matsuoka,M.Saito,andH.Funabashi, in“Embryonic Stem Cells - Basic Biology to Bioengineering”(M.S.Kallos,Ed.),InTech;2011,p.149.

14)E.Bakker,P.Bühlmann,andE.Pretsch,Chem.Rev.97,3083(1997).

15)E.Bakker,P.Bühlmann,andE.Pretsch,Talanta63,3(2004).16)J.W.Son,T.Takami, J.K.Lee,B.H.Park,andT.Kawai,

Appl.Phys.Lett.99,033701(2011).

Electrode Ionspecies Slope R2

Conventionalglasstube

Cs+

K+

Na+

0.80700.48800.4130

0.9240.8860.844

NanopipetteCs+

K+

Na+

0.03150.02950.0231

0.9360.8600.975

Table 3 Slopes and the Pearson relative coefficient (R2) estimated from the data shown in Figs. 6 and 7.

Page 6: Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass ...ft13537/NishiyamaResRepKogakuinUniv123_59_2017.… · Cesium ion-selective membrane fabricated in a glass nanopipette Hokuto

工学院大学研究報告

—  —64

17)T.Takami,J.W.Son,J.K.Lee,B.H.Park,andT.Kawai,Jpn.J.Appl.Phys.50,08LB13(2011).

18)T.Takami,J.W.Son,J.K.Lee,B.H.Park,andT.Kawai, in“Physics, Chemistry and Applications of Nanostructures”,ed.byV.E.Borisenko,S.V.Gaponenko,V.S.Gurin,andC.H.Kam(WorldScientific,Singapore,2011),pp.535-538.

19)X.L.Deng,T.Takami,J.W.Son,T.Kawai,andB.H.Park,Appl.Phys.Express5,027001(2012).

20)E.J.Kang,T.Takami,X.L.Deng,J.W.Son,T.Kawai,andB.H.Park,J.Chem.Phys.B118,5130(2014).

21)X.L.Deng,T.Takami,J.W.Son,E.J.Kang,T.Kawai,andB.H.Park,J.Nanosci.Nanotech.13,5413(2013).

22)T.Takami,F.Iwata,K.Yamazaki,J.W.Son,J.K.Lee,B.H.Park,andT.Kawai,J.Appl.Phys.111,044702(2012).

23)T.Takami,J.W.Son,E.J.Kang,X.L.Deng,T.Kawai,S.W.Lee,andB.H.Park, in“Physics, Chemistry and Applications of Nanostructures”,ed.byV.E.Borisenko,S.V.Gaponenko,V.S.Gurin,andC.H.Kam (WorldScientific,Singapore,2013),pp.305-308.

24)Y.S.Choi,H.S.Kim,J.K.Lee,S.H.Lee,H.B.Lim,andJ.S.Kim,Talanta64,975(2004).

25)F.Iwata,S.Nagami,Y.SumiyaandA.Sasaki,Nanotechnology18,10531(2007).

26)S.ItoandF.Iwata,Jpn.J.Appl.Phys.50,08LB15(2011).27)T.Takami,F.Iwata,K.Yamazaki,J.W.Son,J.–K.Lee,B.H.

Park,andT.Kawai,J.Appl.Phys.,111,044702(2012).28)F.Iwata,K.Yamazaki,K.Ishizaki,andT.Ushiki,Jpn.J.Appl.

Phys.53,036701(2014).29)Japanese IndustrialStandard“General rules for ion selective

electrode method”,JISK0122:1997(1997).