challenges in aligning workplace learning with business...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals:
A perspective from HRD professionals in New Zealand
Tom ShortUniversity of South Australia
Roger HarrisUniversity of South Australia
Modern organisations have become more complex, less mechanistic and increasingly sensitive to rapid changes in the external environment than in previous eras. Today, executives lead employees through a maze of complexity and changing contexts. However, another group of dedicated professionals, the human resource managers and practitioners, also play a big part in shaping business success. For human resource managers, learning how to cope with a diverse range of people-centred challenges has generated a succession of workplace development initiatives aimed at aligning education and training with business strategy (Anderson 2009). In the knowledge economy, the value of workplace
![Page 2: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 359
education and training has become a mantra for business survival. Simultaneously, in response to a requirement for change, the human resource management (HRM) profession has engaged in frequent and often inward-looking processes to re-define its own contribution, not only to the effectiveness of an enterprise but also to the individual employee and wider community. Within this evolution, in some organisations, the traditional sub-areas of HRM, such as human resource development (HRD), have gradually become detached from mainstream HRM and assumed a role quite different in both purpose and approach to from the more hegemonic notion of resources management. This paper draws insights from a group of senior HRD professionals in New Zealand to review the significance of workplace learning in a strategic context and identify the challenges the profession faces in meeting the demands of complex workplaces. The paper focuses on how HRD professionals go about aligning learning activities with business objectives—often with mixed results.
Introduction and background
Inrecentyears,humanresourcemanagement(HRM)practiceshavegrownsystematicallytobecomefirmlyembeddedwithinabusinessmindset(Boxall&Purcell2003,Elsey1997),yetbycontrast,humanresourcedevelopment(HRD)activitieshaveevolvedtoperchawkwardlybetweenthemore-establisheddisciplinesofbusiness,educationandsocialpolicy(Short2009).Intheacademicworld,HRDspecialistsare‘strugglingfortheirownspaceandfreedom,distinguishingthemselvesfromHRMorvocationaleducation’(Sambrook2004:617).HRDprofessionalshave‘longsearchedforcredibility’(Iles,Preece&Chuai2010:125)andmuchhasbeenwrittenaboutthechallengesHRDfaces,primarilykeepingthefieldrelevant,adoptingmorestrategicapproaches,embracingtechnologicalchangesandmeasuringitscontribution
![Page 3: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
360 Tom Short and Roger Harris
toorganisationalperformance(McGuire&Cseh2006).ItsgradualevolutionhasbothgeneratedopportunitiesandcreatedlimitationsforHRDresearch.Inbecomingwedgedbetweenmainstreamacademicdisciplines,HRDcanbeperceivedasfertilegroundandanattractiveplaceforappliedstudy;ontheotherhand,thispositioningcanalsobeinterpretedasbeinginthedisciplinarywilderness,resultinginalackofinterestfrompuristsonallsidesandadilutingoftheimportanceofHRDasastrategicareaofinterest.
Partofthisresponsecomesfromtherecurrenttensionsofideologybetweenthedisciplines.TheunfortunateresultisthatHRDofferingsbecomeoverlookedbytopexecutivesorsubsumedasalessimportantactivityofHRM,andthissituationbecomesmostevidentwhenanorganisationre-alignsitsstrategyinordertocopewithever-changingmarketcompetitionanddemand.SomeorganisationshaveamplifiedthisestrangementbyplacingHRMinacentralised,corporateservicewhiledevolvingHRDtolinemanagement.Therearetwokeyimplicationshere.First,itrelegatestheidentityofHRDtowardstheoperationallevelofabusiness;andsecond,itassumesthatlinemanagersareequippedwiththeknowledge,skills,motivationandtimetoorganiseworkplacetraining.Moreover,Sambrook(2004)foundthat,whenlinemanagerswerekeentoacceptautonomyonHRDdecisions,atensiondevelopedaboutthepurposeofHRD—thatistosay,whowouldbenefitmost,theindividualortheorganisation?Asaconsequence,manyHRDpractitionershavebecomeresignedtotheirrelegatedstatuswithincorporateaffairs,butthislackofrecognitionhasimpactedadverselyontheirprofessionalidentityasworkplaceeducatorsandmayevenhaveinhibitedtheircareerdevelopment.
Historically,workplacedevelopmentprojectshavebeenamongthefirstcasualtiesofrationalisation,especiallysofterskillprograms,whereevaluationsofbenefitsarehardertosourcethanstraightforward,practical,skill-basedtraining.Yet,evenbeforethe
![Page 4: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 361
widespreaduptakeofHRDinthemid-1980s,workplacelearningandtrainingwasseenasasub-activityofpersonneldepartments(Buckley&Caple1990).Asaresult,anorganisation’scommitmenttotraininganddevelopmentwasverymuchdependentonthepersonnelmanager’senthusiasm.Inspiteofever-increasingtrainingbudgets,present-dayresearchshowsanongoingandtenuousexistenceforworkplacedevelopment,inthatonlyasmallpercentageoftheUK’sFTSEtop100organisationshaveahumanresourcesrepresentativeatboardroomlevel(Manocha2006).Suchever-presentdilemmascreatemanychallengesforHRDprofessionalswhobelievetheircontributiontoworkplaceperformanceisspecial,notonlyintermsofenrichmentofpeoplebutalsotothelonger-termdevelopmentoftheorganisationandwidercommunity.
Therearetwofactorstoconsiderhere. First,despitetherepeatedassertionsofHRMadvocatesthattrainingshouldbefullyintegratedintobusinessstrategy(Guest1987,Purcell1989,Story1989,Hendry1995,Tyson1997,Mueller1996,Elsey1997,Boxall&Purcell2003,Field2004),thecontributionofHRMasagenuinestrategicactivitycontinuestodominatestudies,thoughsometextsindicatethatHRDisawell-establishedconceptwithinthewiderfieldofHRM(Sambrook2009,Wang,Hutchins&Garavan2009).Second,despiteglobalincreasesintrainingbudgets,thereremainsongoingdoubtatboardroomlevelaboutthepositiveconnectionbetweenworkplacelearningactivities(oftenincludedinthenotionofHRD)andlonger-termbusinesssuccess.Somecommentatorsbelievethattopexecutivesfailtoacknowledge,orvalue,HRDasastrategicimperativeandthissituationpresentsaninterestingparadox,becausetrainingbudgetsareeverincreasing.TheestimatedforecastfortheUKin2008was£24billionandlaterrevisedto£36billion(CIPD2008).
CommitmentfromthetopisanessentialfactorinthesuccessofHRD(Pareek&Rao2008).AccordingtoSambrook(2004:619),‘how
![Page 5: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
362 Tom Short and Roger Harris
seniormanagersthinkaboutHRDcaninfluencehowitispractised’andpartofthereasonwhyexecutivesreducetrainingbudgetssoeasilyispoorevaluationpractices.HRDprofessionalsrecognisetheimportanceofgainingfeedbackfromlearningevents,butresearchfindingscallintoquestionthethoroughnessofevaluationprocesses,claimingtheyrarelyhappentothesatisfactionofseniormanagers.Thisproblemfuelspre-existingscepticismamongseniormanagerswhoneedevidenceofthepayback(Horwitz1999,Sloman2004).Consequently,traininganddevelopmentprojectsthatareunabletodemonstrateclearalignmentwiththefirm’sobjectivesarepostponedorcancelledaltogether(Tarrant2009).TheuneasyrelationshipbetweenHRDandstrategy,therefore,meansthattraditionalapproachestoevaluationmayhavefailedtoconvincemanagers—creatinganeedtodiscoverbetterwaysofexpressingthebenefitsoftraining,ifthestrategicvalueofHRDistostrengthen.Moreover,inrecentyears,theterm‘alignment’hasgrowninuse—especiallyinthepro-HRMliterature—asadescriptivetermtosymbolisearangeofmanagement-drivenprocessesbasedonplanninganddirectingtrainingprojectstowardsstrategicgoals(Anderson2009).Thereisnoshortageofadviceonhowtoachievealignment,butsometimestheofferingsseemoverplayedandsimplistic,andtooverlooktheincreasingcomplexityoforganisationallife(Short2008b).HRDprofessionalsknowthatachievingalignmentisnotstraightforward.Forexample,inaculturallyrichsetting,alignment-basedscorecardsthatsetanobjectivisttonemayfailtorecognisethequalitativecircumstancesinwhichorganisationsdeploytheirlearningstrategies.Arguably,thenotionofalignment(inthecontextofHRD)takesamanagerialperspective(Field2004,Short2008a)andoverlooksthatorganisationsfrequentlygaincompetitiveadvantagebypursuingseveralstrategiesatthesametime(Thompson1995),thusmakingalignmentdifficulttoquantifyanddefineasauniversalentity.Consequently,confusionprevailsandalignmentdegeneratesintoamanagementdream,orperception,ratherthananachievablereality.
![Page 6: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 363
TheupshotisthatorganisationsusingalignmentasareasonformakingstrategicdecisionsonHRDfinditchallengingtoarticulateaccuratelywhatalignmentmeansandhowitimpactsonbusinesssuccess.
Withallthisferment,thetraditionalsub-areasofHRM,suchasHRD,havegraduallybecomedetachedinsomeorganisationsfrommainstreamHRMandassumedarolequitedifferentinbothpurposeandapproachfrom themorehegemonicnotionofresourcesmanagement.Sambrook(2010:121)suggeststhereare‘varioustitlesassociatedwithHRD’andsuchsignificantissuesareinneedofilluminationthroughresearchonactualpractice.Thispaper,therefore,drawsinsightsfromagroupofseniorHRDpractitionersinNewZealandtoreviewthesignificanceofworkplacelearninganddevelopmentandtoidentifythechallengestheHRDprofessionfacesinmeetingthedemandsofcomplexworkplaces.ThepaperexaminestheperceptionsoftheHRDpractitionersoftheirroleandprofessionalcontribution,howtheyestablishanidentityandhowtheyinfluencewhatmanagersandemployeesconsiderasimportantfororganisationstosucceed.Indoingso,itrevealsanumberofoccupationaltensionsforHRDpractitioners.
Research method
Aninterpretiveapproachhasbeenusedinthisresearch,sincethestudywasprimarilyconcernedwithperceptionsandexperiences.Aninterpretiveapproachisbasedontheviewthatpeoplesociallyandsymbolicallyconstructtheirownorganisationalrealities(Berger&Luckman1967).Itconstruesknowledgeasbeinggainedthroughsocialconstructionssuchaslanguage,sharedmeaningsanddocuments.Thustheindividualiscastas‘acentralactorinadramaofpersonalmeaningmaking’(Fenwick2001:9).Inthisway,individualsareunderstoodtoconstructtheirownknowledgethroughinteractionwithenvironments(constructivism).
![Page 7: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
364 Tom Short and Roger Harris
ThedataonwhichthispaperisbasedwerederivedfromaspeciallyconvenedfocusgroupoffivehumanresourcepractitionersinNewZealandduring2007.Thegroupwasdrawnfromaselectionoforganisationstoprovidecommentaryonarangeof HRDissuesandpractices.Noneoftheparticipantskneweachotherbeforethemeeting,butoneoftheresearchersknewtheindividualsthroughpreviousconnections.Thegroup,comprisingtwoearly-careermaleHRDmanagersandthreeseniorfemalepractitioners,hadallexperiencedHRDinaninternationalsetting.Theyweredrawnfromfiveindustrysectors,includingmanufacturing(MF),automotiveretail(AR),localgovernment(LG),commercialbanking(CB)andtertiaryeducation(TE).Theseindustrysectorswerepurposivelyselectedwiththeintentofobtainingasdiverseaspreadofviewsaspossible.
Thefocusgroupwasledbyanindependentandprofessionalfacilitator.Usingafacilitatorwithsubject-matterknowledgeaddedmuchcredibilitytothediscussion,enabledparticipantstorelatequicklytotherangeofissuesandalloweddiscussionto‘freewheel’withintherangeofquestions(seeappendix).Thediscussionwasaudio-tapedtoassistwithlateranalysisandeachmemberverifiedthewrittentranscription.Usingdesktopanalysis,thetextdatawereclusteredforthepurposeofwriting-upthefindings.Thefindingsthatfollowarestructuredaroundtenthemes.Thesethemesemergedfromtheinterviewtranscripts,interpretedfromnotestakenduringthefocusgroupandinformedbyanextensivereviewoftheliterature.Thisstrategywaschosentobestcapturetheessenceofhowgroupmembersnotonlycontributedtotheirorganisation’ssuccessbutalsoreconciledtheirownprofessionalagendaofeducatingemployeeswithinthewidercontextoflifelonglearning.(Thecodesusedafterquotationsindicatethequestionnumberandtheindustrysector).
![Page 8: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 365
Findings and discussion
Strategic HRD considerations in a global workplace
ThehighturnoverofemployeesinNewZealand’smobilelabourmarket,particularlyinlargecitiessuchasAuckland,raisedconcernaboutthechallengesoffinding,retaininganddevelopingcapablepeople.Thegroupdiscussedhoworganisationsmightfallbackonahistoricreluctancetoinvestintrainingiftheythoughtstaffmembersweregoingtobepoachedatalaterstage.Therewassomebeliefthisattitudeprevaileddespiteresearchtothecontraryshowingthattraininganddevelopmentactuallyhelpedinretainingemployees(SmithandHayton1999).Oneparticipantsaid:
Ithinkthereisquitealotofreluctanceouttheretodeveloppeoplesometimeswhenyouthinkthey’regoingtobepoachedifIdevelopthemtoomuch.Youknowtheoldsortofmodelwherewe’vejustinvestedalotinJim,andnowJim’sgoingsolet’snotinvestanymoreandnotmakethatmistakeagain.Thatkindofattitudestillprevailsinalotofareasandyouhavetotryandconvincethemthatinactualfacttheresearchisincreasinglyshowingthatdevelopmentisvaluedbyemployeesandthey’remorelikelytostayiftheyaredevelopedandstimulatedinthatwayandtryingtoconvincepeopleofthat.(Q3,LG)
Theneedforeconomicsurvival,growthandincreasedlevelsofcompetitivenessweresignificantconcerns,especiallythedeclineofwholeindustryinfrastructures,asincreasingnumbersofNewZealandorganisationsmovedoffshore.Inanatmosphereofsurvival,peoplerarelyconsideredthatifonecompanyfailedithadaknock-oneffectonmanyotherpartsofthesupplychain.ThegroupbelievedNewZealand,asanationofsmallbusinesses,wasparticularlyvulnerable,andthechallengewasforlargerorganisationstoseebeyondthemselves,considerhowtheycouldsupportthesmallfirms,andcreateaformofstrategicinterdependence.Guaranteesofpartnershipwouldthengivesmallfirmstheconfidencetoinvestincapitalanddeveloppeople.Buildingonthisidea,oneparticipantfromthe
![Page 9: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
366 Tom Short and Roger Harris
bankingsectorrecognisedtheneedtobecreativeanddifferentfromthecompetition.Inhisview,‘Itwouldbesoeasytogetsuckedintotherestofthepackandnobodywouldbeabletotellthedifference’(Q3,CB).Hebelievedcustomersvaluedapointofdifference—soimportantwhenattractingnewtalent.NewZealandhasarelativelysmallpooloftalent,limitingtheavailabilityofhighcalibrepeople.Inthetradeunionsector,importantchallengesincludedencouragingpeopletoseelearningaspartofthebiggerpictureandbecomingmulti-skilled.NewZealandersarealsonotoriouslylowrisk-takersandworkingpeoplerarelytakeonalearningchallengeforfearoffailureorbeingperceivedasafailure.Theemergenceoftheknowledgeeconomyhadbeenahugewake-upcallformanyworkingNewZealandersaseconomicsuccessincreasinglydependedlessonagricultureandmoreonadvancedtechnology.Themanagerconcluded:‘Inmostcases,theproblemwasnotthetechnologyitselfbutthemannerinwhichpeoplecommunicatedthedifficultiesorhelpedothersovercometheirdifficulties.’(Q3,CB).
Influences on workplace development decisions
Asorganisationsstruggletosurviveintheglobaleconomy,prioritiesareever-changingandHRDpractitionersplayanimportantroleinshapingthemanagementdecisionsontraininganddevelopment.Participantsreportedawiderangeoforganisationalissues,largelycentredonselectingthecorrectpeoplestrategy,overcomingresourceconstraintsanddrivingtheneedforperformanceimprovement.Mostly,decisionsrelatedtotrainingwerebasedonaprimaryassessmentoftheexternalenvironmentandmarket.Thisappraisalwasundertakentodeterminecustomerexpectationsonperformance,andthenexaminehowemployeescouldbestmeetthoseexpectations.Oneparticipatingmanagerfromthebankingsectorexplained:‘Welookatthebig-ticketissuesthatarepresentlyonthehorizonandintothefuture.Thenwelookinsidetheorganisationtoseewhatourcapabilitiesareinrelationtothosethings.Itisaclassicgap
![Page 10: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 367
closingactivity,startingwiththebigpictureandthenworkingdown’.Thompson(1995:229)referstothis‘relational’processasdealingwiththestrategic‘architecture’.Themanagercontinuedhisaccountoftheprocessasfollows:
Costissecondarytobusinessneedovertheshortertermandwhatstafftrainingwasneededtomoveforward.Inthelongerterm,itwasaboutconsideringwhatformulasworkedinthemarketplace-investigatingwhatactivitiesweregoingwellandwhatappearedlikegoodinitiativestodeployoverthemediumtolongterm.Culturalfitwasalsoanimportantpartofthisassessment,asexperiencehadshownthattraininginitiativesfailedwhentheydidnotfitwiththeorganisationalculture.(Q2,CB)
Thetertiarysectorparticipantemphasisedfinancialfactorsinrecountingthat‘inmyorganisation,allwehearaboutisbudgetsbutatthesametimeyouaresupposedtokeepyourselfuptospeedwithprofessionaldevelopmentandgetonwiththenextthing...itisreallyanissueofrhetoricversusreality’(Q2,TE).Interestingly,participants’commentsreflectedbothstrategicandoperationallevelsofdecision-makingontraining.Typically,seniorexecutivessetthreetofiveprioritiesperyearasstrategicitemstosupporttheoverallbusinessplan,butatthenextlevel,trainingwasdeterminedmorebytheengagementofoperationalline-managersandavailabilityofbudgets.
Therewaswidespreadagreementthatdecisionsontraininganddevelopmentoftenresultedfromamanagerialdesireforperformanceimprovement,atrendsupportedbyresearch(Tarrant2009).However,onefeaturethatemergedfrequentlywasthelevelofunderstandingrequiredtobringaboutperformanceimprovement.Experiencehadshownthatsomeleadersdoggedlystucktoatriedandtestedstyleofcurriculummanagementapproachandwerenotactuallyfocussedonmakingdecisionsaroundwhatmadeadifferencetoperformance,yetthiswasrequiredatastrategiclevel.
![Page 11: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
368 Tom Short and Roger Harris
SuchexperiencesupportsthefindingofRiggandTrehan(2008)whoreportedhowdifficultitistoemploycriticalreflectionwithintheworkplacebecauseofthecomplexpowerrelationsbetweenmultiplestakeholdersinacommercialcontext.Learningwasacknowledgedasakeypartofanorganisation’sdevelopmentstrategyandwasnotsomethingthatfeaturedonitsown,orhappenedtopeople.Participantsreportedthatsometimesevenhumanresourceprofessionalsdidnothavethedepthofunderstandingrequired—especiallyamongthoseappointedintohumanresourcesrolesfromotherprofessionalareas.Oneparticipantclaimed:‘AsaHRDmanager,youoftenhavetoworkforpeoplewhodon’thaveyourdepthofknowledgeandthatcanbedangerous’(Q2,LG).
Ways in which HRD practitioners add value in their organisations
ParticipantsplacedgreatimportanceonthesupportingroleofHRDinhelpingpeopletomaintainfocusandensuringalignmentwithbusinessgoals.Furthermore,itwasthoughttheabsenceofaHRDpractitionermightleadtomanagersbecomingdistractedby‘fire-fighting’activitiesand/ordealingwiththecomplexitiesofroutinework.Afterall,HRDpractitionersweretherespecificallytohelpmanagersmaketherightdecisionsintermsofdevelopmentandtoidentifyopportunitiestoleverimprovementsinperformance:
Ifyou’reaHRDpractitioner,thendevelopmentispartofyourgameandIthinkyou’rekeepingyoureyeontheballandfocusingonit—you’resupportingmanagementinthatrole.Ifyouhaven’tgotHRDpractitioners,whathappensisthateveryoneknowsit’sreallyimportantbuttheyaresobusyfightingfirestheynevergetroundtoit.SoIthinkthemainroleistokeepthingsfocusedonwhat’simportantandtomakesureHRDpractitionershelpmanagersmaketherightdecisionsintermsofdevelopmentalopportunities.(Q5,LG)
Thegroupmembersalsoacknowledgedthevitalroleofthehumanresourceprofessionalasaninternaladvisor/consultanttolinemanagement.However,theyacknowledgedthelogisticaldifficulty
![Page 12: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 369
ofaloneHRDpractitionerorganisingeveryaspectoflearninganddevelopmentinalargeorganisation.Theybelievedthatcoachinglinemanagerstocarryoutactivities,suchastaskanalysisandtrainingneedsanalysis,helpedtoraiseawarenessoftheneedtoidentifyperformancegaps,andensuredaconsistentleveloflearninganddevelopmentthroughouttheorganisation.However,astrongpartnershipwithlinemanagerswascentraltomakingthissuccessful.Aboveall,thegroupconsideredHRDpractitionersaspeoplewhohadacatalysingeffectonlinemanagers.Accordingtoonerespondent,‘theyinfluencedfirstandtransactedsecond’(Q5,AR).ThefollowingstatementtypifiedtheimportanceoftheHRDeffortbeingtotallyalignedwithbusinessgoals:‘Youhavetobesoinextricablylinkedthatyouaresuchapartofthebusinesstheydon’tseeyou’(Q5,AR).Thegroupconcludedthatthislevelofintegration(thatis,workingbehindthescenes)hadtobevaluedatalllevelsintheorganisation.
Alignment of workforce development with business strategy
Discussionfocusedonthepopularconceptofdevelopinghumancapital(Boxall&Purcell2002)asthebasisforahumanresource,service-ledmodel,buttheyconsideredthisideaassomewhattransactionalandfundamentallydifferentfromthephilosophyoflearninganddevelopment.Someofthegrouphadworkedinhumanresourcedepartmentswheretrainingwasviewedassomeoneelse’sproblemandwhereworkwasinappropriatelycontractedoutinthenameofefficiency.Onerespondentproclaimed:‘Ithinkthatlearninganddevelopmentstrategieshavetobetalkingaboutpeople—notresources,bitsofcardboardorasortofdisembodiedsomething.Ialwayssay,youmanageresourcesbutyouleadpeople’(Q6,TE).
Atanorganisationallevel,therewasagreementthatlearninganddevelopmentactivitiesshouldfocusonthewholebusinessaswellasthecomponentparts.Thissuggestionreflectsthesystematicorholisticapproachandsupportstheideaofworkinginclosepartnershipwiththoseresponsiblefordevelopinganddeploying
![Page 13: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
370 Tom Short and Roger Harris
thebusinessstrategy.Participantsconsideredhowhumanresourcefunctionsinlargerorganisationshadbecometooremote.Somebelievedlearninganddevelopmentmanagerswereperceivedassubservienttothehumanresourcesfunctionandexamplesweregivenofhowhumanresourcesdepartmentshadinitiatedtrainingwithoutfirstconsultingthelearninganddevelopmentpractitioners,creatingmuchconfusionandmisalignment:
Quiteoften,they’re[HRstaff]offrunningcoursesforAfrica[everywhere],butwhatdoesithavetodowithanythingelse?Youcanactuallyfindtheyarerunningprogramswiththebestofintentionthatactuallydonotalignatall.Ithinktheonlywayyoucanspecificallyalignistocarryonwithapartnershipatahighlevelandalwaysgobacktowhatthebusinessstrategyisforthefuture.Iftheydonotcontribute,thendonotdothem…itisthatstraightforward.(Q6,LG)
Thenotionoflearninganddevelopmentactivitybeingphilosophicallydifferentfromthatofpersonnel-relatedworkisaninterestingoneandcloselyassociatedwiththecreationofhumanresourcemanagementaswehavecometoknowit.Uptothelate1970s,trainingandpersonneldepartmentswereoftenseenastotallydifferentdisciplines,buttheadventofHRMinthe1980ssoughttomeldthesetwoactivitiestogetherforthebettermentofbothprofessions.Overtheyears,thisunitaryvalueofpersonnelortraininghasbeendebatedinglobalstudies(Cunningham&Hyman1999),butinthisfocusgroup,itseemedtheHRDpractitionerswerefeelingcompromisedandinhibitedfrommakingafullcontributiontothewiderstrategyonhumanresourcemanagement.Simplyput,someoftheHRDprofessionalsinthefocusgroupfeltlessvaluedthantheirHRMcounterparts.However,oneparticipantfromthemanufacturingsectorthoughthavingroleseparationwasadvantageousattheoperationallevelandgaveanexampleofhowinternalhumanresourceconsultantsandlearninganddevelopmentprofessionalshadworkedinpartnershiponaperformancemanagementissue—human
![Page 14: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 371
resourcestaffdealingwiththedisciplinaryaspectsandlearninganddevelopmentstafffacilitatingalearning-centredsolution.Inthisexample,theorganisationalstructureinfluencedroleboundaries—withhumanresourcesreportingtoacentralservicefunctionandHRDtolinemanagement.
What employees value
TheHRDpractitioners,intheirworkwithinorganisations,frequentlybecameinvolvedintheimplementationoforganisationaldevelopmentactivitiesthataimedtopromoteandsustainavalue-drivenculture.Fromthisexperience,participantscommentedonwhattheythoughtemployeesvaluedintheirrespectiveorganisation.Thepurposeofthisquestionwastoidentifyhowgroupmembersunderstoodandreconciledemployeevalueswiththeirownandthoseoftheorganisation.Asummationoftheparticipants’viewsindicatedthatcareerprogressionandfairlevelsofremunerationfeaturedstronglyinemployeeengagementsurveysasvaluedemploymentpractices.Additionally,formalandinformalcommunicationswereconsideredasimportantprocessesforprovidingfeedbacktoemployees.Participantshighlightedthatinformalfeedbackhelpedtoembedcommunicationsintotheorganisationatanaturallevel.Incomparisonwiththepast,newentrantshadamuchhigherexpectationfromtheiremployer,especiallyonworkplacecommunicationsystems,workplacedemocracyandstructuredfeedbackmechanisms.Thiscontrastedsharplywithlongerservingmanagers,whomaynothaveexperiencedthesameapproachtocommunicationsearlierintheircareers.Youngpeopleenteringtheworkforcetoday,oftenreferredtoasGenerationY,seemedtocravecommunicationsandfeedback,especiallyonindividualperformanceandprogression(MacLeod2008).Thegroupbelievedthislevelofpersonalvalidationwasimportant,asemployeeswerequicktocriticiseleaderswhodidnotadapt—seeingpoorcommunicationsasasignofmanagementincompetence.
![Page 15: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
372 Tom Short and Roger Harris
Increasingly,peopleatanylevelintheorganisationstructurewerethoughttovalueaworkinglifethatdevelopedinparallelwiththeirpersonalidentity.Forexample,theyasked,‘DoesthisorganisationhelpmefeelgoodandclarifywhereIamgoing?’(Q1,TEandRB).Alltoofrequently,managerswerereportedtobenotgoodatcommunicatingthevision,valuesandoverallobjectivesoftheirorganisation.Employeesalsovaluedbeingabletotrusttheirorganisationwastreatingthemfairly.Oneparticipantcommentedthat‘managerscangetawaywithalmostanythingaslongastheyareperceivedasbeingfair.Ifitis[consideredtobe]fairandconsistent,thenemployeesareusuallywillingtodowhatisaskedofthem,withinreason’(Q1,CB).Thisviewsuggeststhatperceptionsoffairnessareanimportantfactorinthelevelofemployeelenienceonpotentiallycontentiousissuesandreinforcesthenotionofpsychologicalcontracting.Issuesmightincludeunexpectedchange,workre-organisationortheimpositionofnewrules.Inotherwords,whenmanagersdemonstrateabeliefintheirpeopleandareperceivedasbeingfair,employeesrespondwithunobstructedconsentonmostinitiatives,aspeoplearehappytogobeyondthelimits.However,thislenienceisfragileandarevealingexamplewascitedbytheparticipantfromthemanufacturingsectorwhosaidthat,whenmanagementtookaunilateraldecisiontoimposethewearingofsafetyhatsinthefactory(afterreportsofafatalaccidentinanotherorganisation),workersdidnotseetheneedforthisrulingandtookexceptiontothewayinwhichtherulewasbeingenforced.Theparticipantrecalledoneemployeesaying:
Ablanketrulewasmadethatweshouldwearhardhats.Therewasabsolutelynodiscussionandforusitwasabittoughbecausewewerenotusedtowearingahelmet.Weareallintosafety,butitwasablanketrule…eveninareaswherenothingcouldfallonyourhead.They[management]saiditwasforourownsafety,butwebelieveditwasjusttocoverthemandnotworryaboutus.Noonecares,Ineverusedtosweatbefore…butnowmyheadisdrippinganditiscausingirritatingrashes.(Q1,MF)
![Page 16: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 373
Overall,thefocusgroupmembersagreedthathard-earnedgoodwillcouldbeerodedveryquicklybythreefactors:managerinconsistency,internalpolitickingandthepresenceofavacuumincommunications.Intheorganisationsoftheseparticipants,engagementsurveysandintranetfeedbacktestedthelevelofemployeecommitmentbyaskingindividualsarangeofquestions,includingtheextenttowhichtheywouldgotheextramile.
Evaluation of learning
ThefocusgroupparticipantsreportedaheavyrelianceontheuseoftheKirkpatrickmodelofevaluationintheirorganisationsandalloftheparticipantswereabletoarticulatethewell-knownfourlevelsofevaluation:reaction,learning,behaviourandresults(Kirkpatrick1996,Parry1997).Therewasrecognitionthatcomputer-basedtechnologyhadmadeitmucheasiertocollectevaluationdata,butthemainchallengewasfindingthetimetoanalyseandinterpretthem.
Thesizeofthetraininginvestmentwasanimportantconsiderationbutpresentedaparadoxicalsituation.Forexample,evaluationsoftrainingprojectsthatdirectlyaffectedbusinessperformancewereconsideredamuchhigherprioritythansmallertrainingactivities,yetthesetrainingprojectswerereportedasbeingthemostdifficulttoevaluate.Furthermore,organisationaldevelopmentprogramsoftenraninparallelwithseveralotherprojects,makingithardertoisolateandevaluatethebenefitsofanyonetraininginterventioninaneffectiveandtimelyway.Poorinitiationoftrainingprojectspresentedanotherreasonwhyevaluationwasdifficult.Thegroupsuggestedthatunderstandingthebusinessdriversfirstandthenbuildingperformancemeasurementintotrainingneedanalysesmightofferamorereliableplatformforassessingtrainingoutcomesandthecorrespondingvaluetotheenterprise.
Ithinkitdependsonthesizeoftheinitiativeandwhatyouaretryingtoprovebyit.Youcanspendanawfullotofenergyonevaluatingaprogram.Idefinitelythinkonthe‘bigticket’
![Page 17: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
374 Tom Short and Roger Harris
itemsitisworthplanningfortheevaluationanddoingsomemeasurementbeforeyoustarttheinitiative,soyoucanshowtheaddedvalueafterwards.Wesometimesthinkwearemakinganimpactbut,whenyoulookattheresults,wearenot.(Q7,LG)
Onerespondentexplainedthat‘gaininggenericimprovements,throughcollaborativeworkingwithmanagers,oftenmeantthat“non-curriculum”trainingwasundertakenspontaneously’,makingitmoredifficulttoderiveafixedmodelofevaluation(Q7,AR).Sometimes,HRDinterventionsfocusedontheaffectivedomainoflearning(suchassecuringengagement),soasuccessfultrainingoutcomemightbebeneficialtoadiverserangeofperformanceindicators.Forexample,oneparticipantacknowledgedthedifficultyinposingthisquery:‘Howdoyoumeasurethatcoachingsomebodytogivefeedbackisgoingtoimprovetheirabilitytogivefeedbackuntilwegetthenext[employee]engagementresult,whichmaybearesultofsomethingelse?’(Q7,AR).SuchcommentstypifytheinherentcomplexityofaligningHRD,especiallywhentryingtobalancetheneedsandlearningoutcomesofspecifictrainingprojectswiththelongertermgoalsoftheorganisation.
Anotherdimensionofevaluationrelatedtotheformalversusinformallearningenvironmentandtheorganisation’sculturetowardspeopledevelopment.Thegroupconsideredtheseissuestobeimportantbecausetheyhadadirectbearingonhowleadershipvaluedemployeesandhowindividuallearningneedswereaccommodatedintheprocessofongoingperformancecoaching.Thegroupagreedthatlearningcontinuedirrespectiveoftheorganisation’sintent,butthiscouldhaveapositiveordetrimentaleffectonalignment.Thisperspectivesuggeststhat,inmostcircumstances,itishelpfultocaptureandrecognisetherelevantinformallearning,oftenemanatingfromtacitexperienceacquiredatworkoroutsideofemployment.
![Page 18: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 375
Barriers to learning
Therewasauniversalacceptanceinthefocusgroupthatleanorganisationalstructuresandbusinesspressuresfrequentlymadeitdifficulttoreleaseemployeesforformaltrainingcourses.Lackofadvocacybyandsupportfromlinemanagersmadeitaneasyoptionforpeopletowithdraw.Fromthediscussion,thereappearedtobeampleevidenceofstrongrhetoricbyseniormanagersaboutpeopledevelopmentandperformancereviews,butoperationalrequirementsfrequentlygotintheway.Evenmoredisturbingwasthesuggestionthatseniormanagerswereamongtheworstoffendersandthisreflectedpoorrolemodelling.However,thecurrenttrendtowardsflatterorganisationalstructuresmadeiteasiertoobservewhethertopmanagementwassupportinglearning-relatedprojects:
Ireckonlackofadvocacyiswhereitcounts.Ifyou’retryingtodosomethingwhereeveryoneisagreeing—sotherhetoric’sthere,youknow,yeswedoagreethatyoushouldhaveaperformanceimprovementprocessinplace,yesweshouldhaveperformancereviews…[however]whenyou’redrivingsomekindofinitiativethatthosepeoplethatareatveryseniorlevelifthey’renotrightinbehindit,ifthey’renotfilteringthroughtherightinformationtotheirdirectreports,thenyou’reindeep[trouble].(Q8,AR)
Thefocusgroupthoughtthatthosepeoplewhoputupbarrierstolearningwereoftenthesameindividualswhofailedtounderstandthetruevalueoflearning.Typically,theysoughtquickfixsolutionsandcouldnotseethateffectivelearningtakestime.Forsome,theirtraditionalperceptionoflearningemanatedfromschoolanduniversity.Theyunderstoodtheroleoftrainingbutdidnotfullyappreciatethechangeoflanguagetowardsamoredistinctnotionofadultlearning.Inthisregard,HRDmanagersfrequentlystruggledtochangethemindsetoftheircolleaguesandthisresistancestemmedfromtheorganisationculture.
![Page 19: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
376 Tom Short and Roger Harris
Finally,thegroupdiscussedanemerginglearningbarriermorespecificallyrelevanttothoseolderworkerswhostruggledtoseeanybenefitfromtraining.Therewasgeneralacknowledgementthatthisgroupofpeoplehadexperiencedintensiveorganisationdevelopmentoverthelasttwodecades,oftenwithlittleornodirecttraining.Somehadexperiencedlossofemploymentormadelateralcareertransitionsandcarriedaresultantlowesteem.Conversely,thegroupdiscussedhowotherlong-servingemployeesmightbevictimsofmisalignmentwhentheirorganisationschangedstrategicdirection.Ironically,changesinthedemographicmixofsocietymeanttheoverallageofemployeeswouldincreasesignificantlyintheyearsahead.
Employer recognition of tacit knowledge and experience
Onerecurringthemewithinthefocusgroupdiscussionwastheimportanceofapartnershipapproachtolearninganddevelopmentandthecomponentpartsofthisprocessincludedablendofdirecttraining,individualcoachingandongoingprofessionaldialoguewithteamleadersandhumanresourcepractitioners.Thefocusgroupbelievedthatidentifyingandutilisingtacitknowledgeorextra-murallearningwasanimportantrequirement,becauseunderstandingthevalueoftacitknowledgeandusingperformance-basedcoachingmodelstomaximisethisinformationwouldencouragestaffretention.Peoplewouldmorereadilyappreciatethealignmentbetweentheirownobjectivesandthoseoftheirorganisation.Furthermore,thefocusgroupmembersrecognisedthatformalmentoringprogramsandinformalmentoringactivitieshadbeensuccessfullyusedintheirorganisationsasawayofdisseminatingtacitknowledgetolessexperiencedstaff:
Ithinkthatperformancemodelsworkwellintermsofthecoachingmodelandyou’vegotyourindividualwiththeirownskillneedsandtheirownobjectivesandtheirownmissionandpurposeandyou’vegottheorganisation’s;ifyou’vegotthatalignmentthroughgoodcoaching,thentheymaynotleave.If
![Page 20: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 377
they’regoingtoleaveinfiveor10yearstime,thenyou’vehadthebenefitoftheirservicesforthattimeandtheymaywellcomebackorhavefosteredotherrelationshipswiththeorganisation.(Q9,MF)
Thecontradictionbetweenrhetoricandrealityoftencreatedincongruencebetweentheplanningofformalandthatofinformallearning.Insomesituations,suchasbusinessre-structuringprograms,employeescontinuedtolearnirrespectiveofwhattheorganisationwantedthemtolearn,butsuchlearningdidnotalwaysalignwiththebusinessstrategy.Itwasthoughtthecompetitivemarketsofthe1990shadforcedorganisationsselfishlytodirecttheirlearningactivitiestowardsbusinessgoals,butindoingso,hadneglectedthebroaderneedsofsociety.Itwasrecognisedenterprisesexistedwithinawidercommunityandorganisationsthatvaluedlearningquicklybuiltanexternalreputationforvaluingtheirpeople.Overall,theHRDfocusgroupmembersconsideredtheirorganisationswereweakatrecognisingandutilisingtacitknowledge.Thosethatdidattempttoharnessthefullextentoftacitknowledgedevelopedablackholeofunmanageabledatathatwasneverminedandused.Equally,organisationswerereluctanttoinvestinextra-murallearningthatdidnotofferanydirectbenefittothebusiness.Thoseorganisationsthatpaidforextra-muralstudyrarelyutilisedthefullextentofthelearning.
HRD challenges facing New Zealand in the 21st century
Thegrouprecognisedthechangingdemographicmixintheglobalworkforceandreflectedhowthisaffectedissuessuchasfewerpeopleretiringearlyandlessyoungpeoplebecomingavailableforemployment.Astheaverageageoftheworkforceincreased,apolarityinvalueswaslikelytoemergebetweenthedifferentagegroupsintheworkplace:
Iwanttopickuponthisone…aboutthechangeofdemographics.Ithinkthatprobablythegreatestproblem
![Page 21: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
378 Tom Short and Roger Harris
wehaveinNewZealandisrecognisingtheageingworkforceandrealisingthatthosepeopleovertheageof50constitutealmostthemajorityofpeopleintheworkforce,andthat’sarealchallenge.Seeingtheneedsofanolderworker,andwhatdrivesthem,isverydifferentfromwhatyouaregettingina25yearold,andyetwehaven’tevencometogripswiththis.(Q10,TE)
EarlierinthispapertheHRMchallengesassociatedwithdistinctivedemographicgroups,suchasGenerationXemployeeswereraised.Membersofthefocusgroupreflectedontheirownpersonalexperiencesandsawthisasasignificantchallengeforhumanresourcepractitioners.Examplesincludedemergingvalues,suchasapproachestotime-keeping,debt,expectationsofworkingconditions,andattitudestoacademicsubjectssuchasmaths,sciencesandtechnology.Thedeclineintechnicalcompetence,atanelementarylevel,washarmfultotheNewZealandeconomy—asasmallislandnationthathadhistoricallyreliedonexport,manufacturingandagriculture.AnotherconcernwasthesizeofNewZealand’seconomy,itsgeographicisolationandthelackofabilitytosourcenewtechnology.Membersofthegroupcommentedthatuniversitieswereusingoutdatedequipmenttotrainstudents—puttingNewZealandlearnersatadisadvantagecomparedwiththosestudyinginoffshoretertiaryinstitutions.Emergingservice-basedindustries,suchastravelandtourism,seemedtobegrowing,butweregeneratinglowerpaidemploymentopportunities,andtherewasconcernoverhowmanyservice-sectorjobstheeconomycouldsustain.Thebankingsectorinparticularwascontinuallyseekingnewwaysofdoingbusiness,soinnovationwasthekeychallengeforthatindustryinthe21stcentury—despitethehugeprogressmadeinrecentyears.
Inrelationtogloballearning,theissueofconsistencycameupasamajorconcern—especiallyinthedeploymentofglobalHRDsolutionsinitiatedbyanoffshoreheadoffice.Thisfrequentlyledtoinitiativesbeingre-inventedtofitwiththeindigenouswayofdoingbusinessorviceversa.Themainchallengewasdevelopingglobalvaluesand
![Page 22: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 379
consistentpoliciesthatallowedtheincorporationoflocalculturesortraditionsintothesepolicies.Thegrouprecognisedhowincreasinglocalcomplianceissues(suchassafetyandlegislativereporting)oftenmadeanorganisationriskaverseandconsequentiallylesswillingtobecreative.InmanyNewZealandorganisationalsituations,thepressuretoperformdidnotcomefromoverseasmastersbutlocalgovernmentagenciesthathadaresponsibilitytoprotectthenationalinfrastructureandenvironment.
Factors affecting organisational success
TheparticipantsreflectedonHRDoutcomesthatwouldmostcontributetomakingtheirorganisationssuccessful.Akeyfactorthegroupstressedwastheimportanceofvaluingpeople,inparticularrecognisingwhatindividualscouldcontributeatalllevels.Theysuggestedemployeesshouldbeabletoarticulateanddefendthebusinessstrategyandknowwheretheycontributedtoit.Thestrategyneededtobeabalancebetweentheneedsoftheorganisationandthoseoftheindividualemployees.Theimportanceofbeingabletorelatepersonallytoavisionensuredthatpeopleremainedfocusedwhenthingsbecamedifficult.Asoneparticipantexpressedit,‘whenthingsstarttogettough,thevisiongivesyouamaptofollowandkeepsyouontrack’(Q12,MF).However,inadditiontounderstandingthevision,itwasimportanttohavetheabilitytobeflexiblewhenthesituationchanged:
Fromanemployeeperspective,theyarekeenonamorestablevisionandstrategybecauseitfeelsasthoughtheyknowwheretheyare—butitismakingsureyouarenotstuckwithasinglevisionandsinglestrategy.(Q12,CB)
Systemintegrationwasalsosignificant.Thisinvolvedconnectingtheneedsofindividualswiththeneedsoftheirorganisationsandembeddingtherelationshipwithsystemsandprocesses.Thegroupagreedthat‘visionwasnothingwithouttherealityofplanningandoperatingsystems’(Short2008a:237).Furthermore,theparticipants
![Page 23: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
380 Tom Short and Roger Harris
claimedpeoplewhoweregoodatdevelopingstrategyoftenneglectedtheimplementationissues.Inthisregard,aworthwhileHRDoutcomewouldbetoalignandsynthesisethedevelopmentofallleaders,bothstrategicandoperational.Thegroupre-emphasisedthatbeingaleaderandvisionarywasnotexclusivetoseniormanagersaspeopleatalllevelshadacapacityforstrategicthinking.Theyoftenhadasignificantcontributiontomake,reinforcingtheneedforfeedback.Finally,thediscussionrevertedtoapotentialpolaritybetweenlearninganddevelopmentactivitiesandhumanresources.Onreflection,thegroupthoughtsuchpolaritywasdetrimentaltothewholeareaofperformanceimprovement,duetothestrongneedforagenuinepartnershipbetweenallstakeholdersinthebusiness.
Conclusions
ThispaperhasreviewedhowHRDprofessionalsinarangeoforganisationalsettingsdealwiththechallengesofimplementingworkplacelearningprojects,andinparticular,attempttoalignlearningactivitieswithbusinessobjectives.Throughsynthesisofthesepractitioners’views,ithasbeenpossibletogaininsightintothemajorthrustoforganisationaldevelopmentissuesintheworkplaceandtheroleofHRDprofessionals.Analysisoftheseprofessionals’perspectivesoftheirhumanresourcepracticesandexperiencessupportsanumberofconclusionsregardingthesignificanceofworkplacelearninganddevelopment.
First,seniormanagerswerefoundtodevelopstrategicplansandcascadeinformationthroughtheirorganisationsbymeansofbriefingsystemsandothercommunicationmechanisms.Inmanycases,HRDprofessionalswereresponsiblefortheimplementationofthesecommunicationsystemsandhelpedtoadvocatethedownstreambenefitstoemployeesaspartofanoverallchangemanagementstrategy.
![Page 24: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 381
Second,theresearchsupportedfindingsfromaDelphisurveyofleadingHRDacademicsbyMcGuireandCseh(2006)whofoundthatworkplacelearning,employeedevelopmentandtraininganddevelopmentwerethemosthighlyrankedconstituentcomponentsofHRD,butinthisstudy,theneedforaperformance-basedculturewaspermeatingthroughmanagementdecisionsonworkplacelearninganddevelopmentandwasinextricablylinkedwiththeorganisationalperformancemanagementsystems.Takingacriticalperspective,Sambrook(2004:613)arguesthatthischaracteristicwillslowlychangeasthestudyofHRDmatures,when‘organisationswillneedtoconsiderotherdiscoursesincludingthePRroleofHRDinpromotingcorporatesocialresponsibilityanditsmorehumanisticrole’.Evidenceofthistrendcouldbeseenattheindividuallevel,wherepeopleweremotivatedtodeploytheircompetenciesinanethicalandfairway.Thatmeantworkingforvalue-driventeamsandorganisationsthatalignedtheirbehaviourswithsociallyappropriategoals.Onceagain,HRDprofessionalswereplacedcentre-stageintheimplementationofthesealignmentstrategies.
Third,thespecialleadershiproleofhumanresourcepractitionersandtheemergingcomplexitiesofthistaskwereevidentintheresponses.Throughouttheresearch,theatmospherereflectedamixofoccupationalpassionandpersonalcommitmenttothedevelopmentofpeople,yetthispassionwastemperedbyamoodoffrustrationwithintherole.Majorsourcesofanxietyforthemwereinconsistencyinseniormanagementcommitmentandcontinuingresourceconstraints.Clearly,bridgingthegapbetweenstrategicidealsandoperationalrealitywasamajorchallengefortheseHRDprofessionalsinmeetingthedemandsoftheirmodern,complexworkplaces.
Fourth,thefailuretoevaluatelearningeventsandshowpositivebusinessresultswasclearlylinkedtoanundervaluingoftraininganddevelopmentinvestmentamongseniormanagers.Historically,
![Page 25: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
382 Tom Short and Roger Harris
thisissueismostevidentinthewayHRDprojectsarecut-backwhenbusinessperformanceispoor.
Finally,mostoftheorganisationsembracedbytheseHRDprofessionalswerefailingtoexploittheopportunitiesthatcouldbeavailablethroughanimprovedandsystematicrecognitionoftheemployees’tacitknowledgeandskillswithjobrequirements.Intheirstudyofcrisismanagement,KhatriandNg(2000)highlightedthevalueoftacitlearningandhoworganisationscandrawonknowledgethathasaccumulatedfromyearsofexperience.
References
Anderson,V.(2009).‘Desperatelyseekingalignment:reflectionsofseniorlinemanagersandHRDexecutives’,Human Resource Development International,41(3):263–277.
Berger,P.L.&Luckman,T.(1967).The social construction of reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge,Harmondsworth,UK:Penguin.
Boxall,P.&Purcell,J.(2003).Strategy and human resource management,Basingstoke:PalgraveMacmillan.
Buckley,R.&Caple,J.(1990).The theory and practice of training,London:KoganPage.
CharteredInstituteofPersonnelandDevelopment(2008).‘Trainingspendup’,People Management,14:13.
Cunningham,I.&Hyman,J.(1999).‘Devolvinghumanresourceresponsibilitiestotheline:beginningorendforpersonnel?’,Personnel Review,28(1/2):9–27.
Elsey,B.(1997).Australian graduate human resource studies—the people factor in workplace change management,Adelaide:UniversityofSouthAustralia.
Fenwick,T.(2001).Experiential learning,Informationseriesno.385,ERICClearinghouseonAdult,CareerandVocationalEducation,Columbus,Ohio:OhioStateUniversity.
Field,L.(2004).‘Rethinking“organisational”learning’,inFoley,G.(ed.),Dimensions of adult learning: Adult education and training in a global era,CrowsNest,NSW:Allen&Unwin:201–218.
![Page 26: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 383
Guest,D.(1987).‘Humanresourcemanagementandperformance:Areviewandresearchagenda’,International Journal of Human Resource Management,8(3):263–276.
Hendry,C.(1995).Human resource management—A strategic approach to employment,Oxford:Butterworth-Heinemann.
Horwitz,F.(1999).‘Theemergenceofstrategictraininganddevelopment:Thecurrentstateofplay’,Journal of European Industrial Training,23(4/5):180–190.
Iles,P.,Preece,D.&Chuai,X.(2010).‘TalentmanagementasamanagementfashioninHRD:Towardsaresearchagenda’,Human Resource Development International,13(2):125–145.
Khatri,N.&Ng,H.A.(2000).‘Theroleofintuitioninstrategicdecisionmaking’,Human Relations,53:57–86.
Kirkpatrick,D.L.(1996).Evaluating training programs—the four levels,SanFrancisco:Berett-Koehler.
MacLeod,A.(2008).Generation Y: Unlocking the talent of young managers.London:CharteredManagementInstitute:1–11.
Manocha,R.(2006).‘HRisstillnotstrategicenough’,People Management,12:13.
McGuire,D.&Cseh,M.(2006).‘ThedevelopmentofthefieldofHRD:ADelphistudy’,Journal of European Industrial Training,30(8):653–667.
Mueller,F.(1996).‘Humanresourcesasstrategicassets:Anevolutionaryresource-basedtheory’,Journal of Management Studies, 33(6):757–785.
Pareek,U.&RaoT.V.(2008).‘Fromasaplingtoarainforest:ThesagaofthedevelopmentofHRDinIndia’,Human Resource Development International,11(5):555–564.
Purcell,J.(1989).‘Theimpactofcorporatestrategyonhumanresourcemanagement’inStorey,J.(ed.),New perspectives on human resource management,London:Routledge:67–91.
Rigg,C.&Trehan,K.(2008).‘Criticalreflectionintheworkplace:Isitjusttoodifficult?’,Journal of European Industrial Training,32(5):374–384.
Sambrook,S.(2004).‘A“critical”timeforHRD?’,Journal of European Industrial Training,28(8/9):611–624.
Sambrook,S.(2009).‘CriticalHRD:Aconceptanalysis’,Personnel Review,38(1):61–73.
Sambrook,S.(2010).‘ThebestofHRD:Fad,factorfactions’,Human Resource Development International,13(2):121–123.
![Page 27: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
384 Tom Short and Roger Harris
Short,T.W.(2008a).‘Strategicalignmentandlearninginhumanresourcedevelopment:Ahermeneuticexploration’,unpublishedPhDthesis,UniversityofSouthAustralia,Adelaide.
Short,T.W.(2008b).‘Aligninghumanresourcedevelopmentwithbusinessstrategy’,Proceedings of the11th Australian VET Research Association Conference,Adelaide,3–4April,http://www.avetra.org.au/annual_conference/papers.shtml
Short,T.W.(2009).‘TheplaceandshapeofHRDinaglobalisedandturbulentworkplace’,Proceedings of the10th International Conference on Human Resource Development Research and Practice across Europe,NewcastleuponTyne,10–12June.
Sloman,M.(2004).‘Evaluationandevolution’,People Management,9:50.
Storey,J.(1989).New perspectives on human resource management,London:Routledge.
Tarrant,D.(2009).‘Trainsofthought’,HR Monthly,May:28.
Thompson,J.L.(1995).Strategy in action,London:Chapman&Hall.
Tyson,S.(1995).Strategic prospects for HRM,London:CharteredInstituteofPersonnelandDevelopment.
Wang,J.,Hutchins,H.M.&Garavan,N.2009).‘Exploringtheroleofhumanresourcedevelopmentinorganizationalcrisismanagement’,Human Resource Development Review,8(22):22–53.
Appendix: Focus group questions
General
1. Whatdoyouthinkemployeesinorganisationsvalue?2. Whatfactorsmoststronglyinfluencethedecisionsontrainingand
development?
Strategy
3. Whatwouldyousayisstrategicallyimportantfororganisationsatthepresenttime?
4. Howdoesyourorganisationcommunicatestrategytoitsemployees?
![Page 28: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business goals 385
Human resource development
5. WhatrolesdoHRDpractitionersfulfilinorganisations-howdotheyaddvalue?
6. Inwhatwaysdolearninganddevelopmentactivitiesspecificallyalignwithbusinessstrategy?
Learning
7. Howdoyouevaluatelearninginyourorganisationandusetheinformation?
8. Whatwouldyousayarethecurrentbarrierstolearninginorganisations?
9. Howcanorganisationsrecognisethebroader‘extra-mural’learningandcapturethe‘tacit’knowledgepeoplehave?
Closing questions
10.Whatdoyouthinkarethechallengesfacingorganisationswhenoperatingina21stCenturyNewZealand?
11.Towhatextentisthephenomenonof‘globalisation’affectingorganisations?
12.Ifyoucouldrecommendjustonethingtoanorganisationtohelpmakeitmoresuccessful,whatwoulditbe(inthecontextofthisstudy)?
About the authors
Dr Tom Short has been a research fellow with the Centre for Research in Education, Equity and Work (CREEW) since 2008. Prior to that his career has included work in the education and manufacturing sectors as an engineer, business manager, management consultant and human resources manager. His research interests are strategic human resource management and adult learning in relation to workplace development.
![Page 29: Challenges in aligning workplace learning with business ...files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ952239.pdf · Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 50, Number 2, July 2010 Challenges](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052515/5a7330307f8b9aac538e5a1a/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
386 Tom Short and Roger Harris
Dr Roger Harris is a Professor in the School of Education and Director of the Centre for Research in Education, Equity and Work, University of South Australia. He has had extensive experience in VET teacher education and VET research, with a focus on national training reform. Recently, he was Director of the national research consortium, Supporting VET providers in building capability for the future. Current professional activities include the South Australian Training and Skills Commission; Program Leader in the CRC for Rail Innovation; the Academic Board of a private provider; and Visiting Research Fellow in the Institute for Adult Learning, Singapore, for three months.
Contact details
Centre for Research in Education, Equity and Work, University of South Australia, Mawson Lakes Boulevard, Mawson Lakes, SA 5095Tel: (08) 8302 5421Email: [email protected]
Tel: (08) 8302 6246Email: [email protected]