chapter 08 risk and rates of return
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
1/48
8-18-1
CHAPTER8
RiskandRatesofReturnn Stand-aloneriskn Por3olioriskn Risk&return:CAPM/SML
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
2/48
8-2
Investmentreturns
Therateofreturnonaninvestmentcanbecalculatedasfollows:
(AmountreceivedAmountinvested)
Return=________________________
Amountinvested
Forexample,if$1,000isinvestedand$1,100isreturnedaOeroneyear,therateofreturnforthisinvestmentis:
($1,100-$1,000)/$1,000=10%.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
3/48
8-3
Whatisinvestmentrisk?
Twotypesofinvestmentrisk Stand-alonerisk Por3oliorisk
InvestmentriskisrelatedtotheprobabilityofearningalowornegaVveactualreturn.
ThegreaterthechanceoflowerthanexpectedornegaVvereturns,theriskiertheinvestment.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
4/48
8-4
ProbabilitydistribuVons
AlisVngofallpossibleoutcomes,andtheprobabilityofeachoccurrence.
Canbeshowngraphically.
Expected Rate of Return
Rate ofReturn (%)100150-70
Firm X
Firm Y
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
5/48
8-5
SelectedRealizedReturns,
19262004
AverageStandard
ReturnDeviaVon
Small-companystocks 17.5%.1%
Large-companystocks 12.4 20. L-Tcorporatebonds 6.2 8.6
L-Tgovernmentbonds 5.8 9.
U.S.Treasurybills .8 .1
Source:BasedonStocks,Bonds,Bills,andInfla1on:(Valua1onEdi1on)2005Yearbook(Chicago:IbbotsonAssociates,2005),p28.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
6/48
8-6
InvestmentalternaVves
Economy Prob. T-Bill HT Coll USR MP
Recession 0.1 5.5% -27.0% 27.0% 6.0% -17.0%
Below avg 0.2 5.5% -7.0% 13.0% -14.0% -3.0%
Average 0.4 5.5% 15.0% 0.0% 3.0% 10.0%
Above avg 0.2 5.5% 30.0% -11.0% 41.0% 25.0%
Boom 0.1 5.5% 45.0% -21.0% 26.0% 38.0%
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
7/48
8-7
WhyistheT-billreturnindependentofthe
economy?DoT-billspromiseacompletely
risk-freereturn?
n T-bills will return the promised 5.5%, regardlessof the economy.
n No, T-bills do not provide a completely risk-freereturn, as they are still exposed to inflation.
Although, very little unexpected inflation is likelyto occur over such a short period of time.
n T-bills are also risky in terms of reinvestment raterisk.
n T-bills are risk-free in the default sense of theword.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
8/48
8-8
HowdothereturnsofHTandColl.behavein
relaVontothemarket?
HTMoveswiththeeconomy,andhasaposiVvecorrelaVon.Thisistypical.
Coll.Iscountercyclicalwiththeeconomy,andhasanegaVvecorrelaVon.Thisisunusual.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
9/48
8-9
CalculaVngtheexpectedreturn
12.4%(0.1)(45%)(0.2)(30%)(0.4)(15%)
(0.2)(-7%)(0.1)(-27%)r
Prr
returnofrateexpectedr
HT
^
N
1iii
^
^
=+
++
+=
=
=
=
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
10/48
8-10
Summaryofexpectedreturns
Expectedreturn
HT 12.4%
Market 10.5%
USR 9.8%T-bill 5.5%
Coll. 1.0%
HThasthehighestexpectedreturn,andappearstobethebestinvestmentalternaVve,butisitreally?Havewefailedtoaccountforrisk?
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
11/48
8-11
CalculaVngstandarddeviaVon
deviationStandard=
2
Variance ==
i
2N
1ii P)r(r
=
=
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
12/48
8-12
StandarddeviaVonforeachinvestment
15.2%
18.8%20.0%
13.2%0.0%
(0.1)5.5)-(5.5
(0.2)5.5)-(5.5(0.4)5.5)-(5.5(0.2)5.5)-(5.5(0.1)5.5)-(5.5
P)r(r
M
USRHT
CollbillsT
2
22
22
billsT
N
1ii
2^
i
=
==
==
+
++
+
=
=
=
21
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
13/48
8-13
ComparingstandarddeviaVons
USR
Prob.T - bill
HT
0 5.5 9.8 12.4 Rate of Return (%)
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
14/48
8-14
CommentsonstandarddeviaVon
asameasureofrisk
StandarddeviaVon(i)measurestotal,orstand-alone,risk.
Thelargeriis,thelowertheprobabilitythatactualreturnswillbeclosertoexpectedreturns.
LargeriisassociatedwithawiderprobabilitydistribuVonofreturns.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
15/48
8-15
Comparingriskandreturn
Security Expectedreturn, r
Risk,
T-bills 5.5% 0.0%HT 12.4% 20.0%
Coll* 1.0% 13.2%
USR* 9.8% 18.8%
Market 10.5% 15.2%
* Seem out of place.
^
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
16/48
8-16
CoefficientofariaVon(C)
Astandardizedmeasureofdispersionaboutthe
expectedvalue,thatshowstheriskperunitof
return.
r
returnExpected
deviationStandardCV
==
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
17/48
8-17
Riskrankings,
bycoefficientofvariaVon
C
T-bill 0.0
HT 1.6
Coll. 1.2
USR 1.9 Market 1.4
n Collections has the highest degree of risk per unitof return.
n HT, despite having the highest standard deviationof returns, has a relatively average CV.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
18/48
8-18
IllustraVngtheCasameasureof
relaVverisk
A=B,butAisriskierbecauseofalargerprobabilityoflosses.In
otherwords,thesameamountofrisk(asmeasuredby)forsmallerreturns.
0
A B
Rate of Return (%)
Prob.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
19/48
8-19
Investoratudetowardsrisk
Riskaversionassumesinvestorsdislikeriskandrequirehigherratesofreturnto
encouragethemtoholdriskiersecuriVes.
Riskpremiumthedifferencebetweenthereturnonariskyassetandarisklessasset,
whichservesascompensaVonforinvestorsto
holdriskiersecuriVes.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
20/48
8-20
Por3olioconstrucVon:
Riskandreturn
Assumeatwo-stockpor3olioiscreatedwith$50,000investedinbothHTandCollecVons.
Apor3oliosexpectedreturnisaweightedaverageofthereturnsofthepor3olioscomponentassets.
StandarddeviaVonisalilemoretrickyandrequiresthatanewprobabilitydistribuVonforthepor3olioreturnsbedevised.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
21/48
8-21
CalculaVngpor3olioexpectedreturn
6.7%(1.0%)0.5(12.4%)0.5r
rwr
:averageweightedaisr
p
^
N
1i
i
^
ip
^
p
^
=+=
==
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
22/48
8-22
AnalternaVvemethodfordeterminingpor3olio
expectedreturn
Economy Prob. HT Coll Port.
Recession 0.1 -27.0% 27.0% 0.0%
Below avg 0.2 -7.0% 13.0% 3.0% Average 0.4 15.0% 0.0% 7.5%
Above avg 0.2 30.0% -11.0% 9.5%
Boom 0.1 45.0% -21.0% 12.0%
6.7%(12.0%)0.10(9.5%)0.20
(7.5%)0.40(3.0%)0.20(0.0%)0.10rp^
=++
++=
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
23/48
8-23
CalculaVngpor3oliostandard
deviaVonandC
0.516.7%
3.4%CV
3.4%
6.7)-(12.00.10
6.7)-(9.50.206.7)-(7.50.40
6.7)-(3.00.20
6.7)-(0.00.10
p
21
2
2
2
2
2
p
==
=
+
+
+
+
=
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
24/48
8-24
Commentsonpor3olioriskmeasures
p=.4%ismuchlowerthantheiofeitherstock(HT=20.0%;Coll.=1.2%).
p
=.4%islowerthantheweightedaverageof
HTandColl.s(16.6%).
Therefore,thepor3olioprovidestheaveragereturnofcomponentstocks,butlowerthanthe
averagerisk.
Why?NegaVvecorrelaVonbetweenstocks.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
25/48
8-25
Generalcommentsaboutrisk
5%foranaveragestock. MoststocksareposiVvely(thoughnot
perfectly)correlatedwiththemarket(i.e.,between0and1).
Combiningstocksinapor3oliogenerallylowersrisk.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
26/48
8-26
ReturnsdistribuVonfortwoperfectly
negaVvelycorrelatedstocks(=-1.0)
-10
15 15
25 2525
15
0
-10
Stock W
0
Stock M
-10
0
Portfolio WM
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
27/48
8-27
ReturnsdistribuVonfortwoperfectly
posiVvelycorrelatedstocks(=1.0)
Stock M
0
15
25
-10
Stock M
0
15
25
-10
Portfolio MM
0
15
25
-10
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
28/48
8-28
CreaVngapor3olio:Beginningwithonestockandaddingrandomly
selectedstockstopor3olio
pdecreasesasstocksadded,becausetheywouldnotbeperfectlycorrelatedwiththe
exisVngpor3olio.
Expectedreturnofthepor3oliowouldremainrelaVvelyconstant.
EventuallythediversificaVonbenefitsofaddingmorestocksdissipates(aOerabout10stocks),
andforlargestockpor3olios,ptendstoconvergeto20%.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
29/48
8-29
IllustraVngdiversificaVoneffectsofa
stockpor3olio
# Stocks in Portfolio10 20 30 40 2,000+
Diversifiable Risk
Market Risk
20
0
Stand-Alone Risk, p
p (%)35
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
30/48
8-30
Breakingdownsourcesofrisk
Stand-alonerisk=Marketrisk+Diversifiablerisk
MarketriskporVonofasecuritysstand-aloneriskthatcannotbeeliminatedthroughdiversificaVon.Measuredbybeta.
DiversifiableriskporVonofasecuritysstand-aloneriskthatcanbeeliminatedthroughproperdiversificaVon.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
31/48
8-31
Failuretodiversify
Ifaninvestorchoosestoholdaone-stockpor3olio(doesntdiversify),wouldtheinvestorbecompensatedfortheextrarisktheybear?
N!Stand-aloneriskisnotimportanttoawell-
diversifiedinvestor.
RaVonal,risk-averseinvestorsareconcernedwithp,whichisbaseduponmarketrisk.
Therecanbeonlyoneprice(themarketreturn)foragivensecurity.
NocompensaVonshouldbeearnedforholdingunnecessary,diversifiablerisk.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
32/48
8-32
CapitalAssetPricingModel(CAPM)
Modellinkingriskandrequiredreturns.CAPMsuggeststhatthereisaSecurityMarketLine(SML)thatstatesthatastocksrequiredreturnequalsthe
risk-freereturnplusariskpremiumthatreflectsthestocksriskaOerdiversificaVon.
ri=rRF+(rMrRF)bi
Primaryconclusion:TherelevantriskinessofastockisitscontribuVontotheriskinessofawell-diversifiedpor3olio.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
33/48
8-33
Beta
Measuresastocksmarketrisk,andshowsastocksvolaVlityrelaVvetothemarket.
Indicateshowriskyastockisifthestockisheldinawell-diversifiedpor3olio.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
34/48
8-34
Commentsonbeta
Ifbeta=1.0,thesecurityisjustasriskyastheaveragestock.
Ifbeta>1.0,thesecurityisriskierthanaverage(Aggressivestock)
Ifbeta
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
35/48
8-35
CanthebetaofasecuritybenegaVve?
Yes,ifthecorrelaVonbetweenStockiandthemarketisnegaVve(i.e.,i,m
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
36/48
8-36
CalculaVngbetas
Well-diversifiedinvestorsareprimarilyconcernedwithhowastockisexpectedtomoverelaVvetothemarketinthefuture.
Withoutacrystalballtopredictthefuture,analystsareforcedtorelyonhistoricaldata.AtypicalapproachtoesVmatebetaistorunaregressionofthesecurityspastreturnsagainstthepastreturnsofthemarket.
Theslopeoftheregressionlineisdefinedasthebetacoefficientforthesecurity.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
37/48
8-37
IllustraVngthecalculaVonofbeta
.
.
.
ri
_
rM
_-5 0 5 10 15 20
20
15
10
5
-5
-10
Regression line:
ri = -2.59 + 1.44 rM^ ^
Year r M ri
1 15% 18%2 -5 -10
3 12 16
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
38/48
8-38
Betacoefficientsfor
HT,Coll,andT-Bills
ri
_
kM
_
-20 0 20 40
40
20
-20
HT: b = 1.30
T-bills: b = 0
Coll: b = -0.87
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
39/48
8-39
Comparingexpectedreturnsand
betacoefficients
Security ExpectedReturn Beta
HT 12.4% 1.2
Market 10.5 1.00
USR 9.8 0.88T-Bills 5.5 0.00
Coll. 1.0 -0.87
RiskiersecuriVeshavehigherreturns,sotherankorderisK.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
40/48
8-40
TheSecurityMarketLine(SML):
CalculaVngrequiredratesofreturn
SML:ri=rRF+(rMrRF)bi
ri=rRF+(RPM)bi
Assumetheyieldcurveisflatandthatr RF=5.5%andRP
M=5.0%.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
41/48
8-41
Whatisthemarketriskpremium?
AddiVonalreturnovertherisk-freerateneededtocompensateinvestorsforassuming
anaverageamountofrisk.
Itssizedependsontheperceivedriskofthestockmarketandinvestorsdegreeofrisk
aversion.
ariesfromyeartoyear,butmostesVmatessuggestthatitrangesbetween4%and8%peryear.
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
42/48
8-42
CalculaVngrequiredratesofreturn
rHT =5.5%+(5.0%)(1.2) =5.5%+6.6% =12.10%
rM =5.5%+(5.0%)(1.00) =10.50%
rUSR =5.5%+(5.0%)(0.88) =9.90% rT-bill =5.5%+(5.0%)(0.00) =5.50% rColl =5.5%+(5.0%)(-0.87) =1.15%
-
8/2/2019 Chapter 08 Risk and Rates of Return
43/48
8-43
Expectedvs.Requiredreturns
r)r(Overvalued1.21.0Coll.
r)r(uedFairly val5.55.5bills-T
r)r(Overvalued9.99.8USR
r)r(uedFairly val10.510.5Market
r)r(dUndervalue12.1%12.4%HT
rr
^
^
^
^
^
^