chapter 5 conflict management 1
TRANSCRIPT
CONFLICT MANAGEMENT
Definition. Traditional vis-à-vis Modern view of conflict
– Types of conflict – Intrapersonal, Interpersonal, Organizational. Constructive
and Destructive conflict. Conflict management.
DEFINITION
Conflict may be defined as the disagreement between two or more individuals or groups over an issue of mutual interest.
Conflicts may arise between two parties when: one party (an individual or a group) feels that the actions of the other party will either affect its interests adversely or obstruct the achievement of its goals; the goals of both the parties differ significantly or are interpreted differently; or the basic values and philosophies of the two parties are different. Conflicts can range from small disagreements to violent acts.
SOURCES OF CONFLICT
Organizational change: Generally, employees of an organization hold different views on the changes in organization with respect to technology, structure, hierarchy, etc., and this might lead to conflicts between them.
Personality clashes: When individuals do not recognize differences in personalities such as emotional stability, behavior, etc., it might lead to a conflict.
Differences in values sets: When people with contradicting values and beliefs interact with each other, conflicts are likely to occur.
Threats to status: When individuals feel that the acts of other individuals may affect their reputation and status in society, it might lead to a conflict.
Perceptual differences: When individuals believe that what they perceive is true irrespective of reality, then they fail to understand the ideas of another person. This again might lead to a conflict.
TRADITIONAL VIS-A-VIS MODERN VIEW OF CONFLICT
Conflict is avoidable.
Conflict is caused by management error in designing organizations or by trouble makers.
Conflict is inevitable.
Conflict arises from many causes, including organizational structure, unavoidable differences in goals, differences in perceptions and values of specialized personnel and so on.
TRADITIONAL VIEW MODERN VIEW
Conflict disrupts the organization and prevents optimal performance.
The task of the management is to eliminate conflict.
Optimal organizational performance requires the removal of conflict.
Conflict contributes and detracts from organizational performance in varying degrees.
The task of the management is to manage the level of conflict and its resolution for optimal organizational performance.
Optimal organizational performance requires a moderate level of conflict.
THE CONFLICT PROCESS
Antecedent conditions
( preceding or prior)
•Communication•Structure•Personal variables
Felt conflict
Perceived
conflict Conflict handling
intentions
•competing•Collaborating•Compromising•Avoiding•accommodating
Overt conflict
•Party’s behavior
•Other’s reaction Decrease
d group performa
nce
Increased group
performance
Stage 1
Potential opposition or incompatibility
Stage IICognition and personalization
Stage III
Intentions
Stage IV
Behavior
Stage IV
outcomes
DIMENSIONS OF CONFLICT- HANDLING INTENTIONS
Ass
ert
iveness
Unass
ert
ive
Ass
ert
ive
Competing
Avoiding Accommodating
Collaborating
Compromising
cooperativeness
Uncooperative Cooperative
(Att
em
pti
ng t
o s
ati
sfy o
wn c
on
cern
)
(Attempting to satisfy others concern)
INTRAPERSONAL CONFLICT
Individuals might experience stress and frustration in the process of achieving their goals. This leads to ‘intrapersonal conflict.’ Intrapersonal conflict may arise under the following circumstances:
when the employee’s roles and responsibilities are not defined clearly
when the employee receives conflicting orders from more than one boss
when the employee faces conflicting expectations from superiors and subordinates (usually middle level managers face this situation).
INTRAPERSONAL CONFLICT ARISES FROM
Frustration:- it occurs when a motivated drive is blocked before a person reaches a desired goal.
The frustrated individual adapts any of four defence mechanisms:-
Aggression Withdrawal Fixation Compromise
Goal conflict
Goal conflict occurs when the attainment of one goal excludes the possibility of attaining another.
Four major type of goal conflict may be distinguished:-
1.Approach-Approach conflict:- this conflict occurs when the individual is caught between two or more positive but mutually exclusive goals.
2.Approach-Avoidance conflict:-this conflict occurs when an individual is simultaneously attracted and repelled by a single goal object.
3.Avoidance-Avoidance conflict:- this occurs when an individual is forced to choose between two mutually exclusive goals , each of which possesses unattractive qualities.
4.Multiple approach-avoidance conflict:- a conflict, in which two alternatives- both involving positive and negative features is referred to as multiple approach-avoidance conflict.
Role conflict The final reason for intra-personal conflict is
the need of an individual to play several roles simultaneously but finding time and resources inadequate to do so .
Cognitive dissonance It occurs when individuals recognise
inconsistencies in their own thoughts and/or behaviours. Such inconsistencies are stressful and uncomfortable, leading to intrapersonal conflict.
INTERPERSONAL CONFLICT
In general, differences in the perceptions and attitudes of individuals lead to interpersonal conflicts.
The communication gap is another major aspect that leads to interpersonal conflicts.
It involves two or more individuals. Reasons for interpersonal conflicts:-
a. Personality differencesb. Perceptionsc. Clashes of values and interestsd. Power and status differencese. Scarce resources
IMPORTANT FACTORS
Difference in perception. Informational differences. Differences in personality. Differences in value system. Differences in status. Differences in resources or strengths. Divergent roles.
INTRA GROUP CONFLICTS
Intra group conflict refers to disputes among some or all of group’s members which often affect the group’s performance.
INTERGROUP CONFLICT
Intergroup conflicts often arise when one group considers that it is being treated unfairly (in comparison to one or more groups) with respect to working conditions, rewards, and status.
When one group feels that it has not been recognized for its efforts in achieving a common goal and that another group has been given its due, it might lead to intergroup conflicts between the groups involved.
REASONS FOR INTER GROUP CONFLICT
Task interdependence Task ambiguity. Goal incompatibility. Competition for limited resources. Competitive reward resources. Line and staff. Intrapersonal and interpersonal conflict.
CONSTRUCTIVE AND DESTRUCTIVE CONFLICT
Some conflicts support the goals of the group and improve its performance; these are functional or constructive conflicts.
Constructive Aspects of Conflict better ideas are produced people are forced to look at new approaches long standing problems surface and can be
dealt with people are forced to clarify their views
tension stimulates interest and creativity people have a chance to test their capability opens up issues of importance, resulting in
their clarification increases the involvement of individuals in
issue of importance to them serves as a release to pent-up emotion,
anxiety, and stress helps build cohesiveness among people by
sharing the conflict, celebrating in its settlement, and learning more about each other
DESTRUCTIVE CONFLICTS When conflict hinders group performance it is
dysfunctional or a destructive form of conflict.
Destructive Aspects of Conflict defeat or demean people creates distance between people climate of distrust and suspicion develops people or departments defend their narrow
interests
resistance (active or passive) develops where teamwork is needed
causes turnover diverts energy from more important activities
and issues destroys the morale of people or reinforces
poor self-concepts polarizes groups so they increase internal
cohesiveness and reduces inter-group co-operation
deepens differences in values produces irresponsibility and regrettable behavior such as name-calling and fighting
CONFLICT MANAGEMENT
OPEN COMMUNICATION.
EXPLAINING LOGIC.
SEARCH FOR FACTS/DATA.
CONSIDERING CRITICISM.
CLICHÉ FORMING.
LEGAL STEPS.
Use resolution under these conditions
Conflict has become disruptive.
Too much time and effort are spent on conflict rather than on productive efforts
Conflict focuses on internal goals of the group rather than on organizational goals
Use stimulation under these conditions
Work group are stagnant
Consensus among groups is too easily reached.
Change within the organization is needed to remain competitive.
Conflict management
CONFLICT RESOLUTION
Problem solving. Organization redesign. Super ordinate goals. Expansion of resources. Avoidance. Smoothen. Resolving line and staff conflict.
THE NEGOTIATION PROCESS
Preparation and planning
Definition of ground rules
Clarification and justification
Bargaining and problem solving
Closure and implementation