chief justice roberts dissent on gay marriage ruling

8/21/2019 Chief Justice Roberts dissent on gay marriage ruling

1/29

"""""""""""""""""

"""""""""""""""""

#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#+4

5678590: $/ ;/: (Z>TX'=&) Z@@&'< %= )@\%(]

^@]%\_ (=< \@=)%W X(ZZ%(>': YT)& ]%[' @^^@)%&'C)'a

\@T^]')/ 9W(& ^@)%&%@= W() T=


2/29

" #$%&'%(%)) !" *#+'%,

$%&-,. /0 10. 2344567368

9:47 43; ?75=4 :62 @5834@:7?=4 36 5@5>56 ,7:754 :62

7A5 +347=3B7 ?C /?@DEF3: A:>5 =5>3452 7A53= @:G4 7? :@@?G

E:==3:85 F57G556 7G? 95?9@5 ?C 7A5 4:E5 45;0

$D7 7A34 /?D=7 34 6?7 : @5834@:7D=50 HA57A5= 4:E5I45;

E:==3:85 34 : 8??2 325: 4A?D@2 F5 ?C 6? B?6B5=6 7? D40

J625= 7A5 /?64737D73?6. KD2854 A:>5 9?G5= 7? 4:< GA:7

7A5 @:G 34. 6?7 GA:7 37 4A?D@2 F50 -A5 95?9@5 GA? =:73C352

7A5 /?64737D73?6 :D7A?=3L52 B?D=74 7? 5;5=B345 M6537A5=

C?=B5 6?= G3@@ FD7 E5=5@< KD28E5670N -A5 (525=:@347 O?0

PQ. 90 RST U/0 &?44375= 520 VWSVX UY0 *:E3@7?6X UB:937:@3L:I

73?6 :@75=52X0

Y@7A?D8A 7A5 9?@3B< :=8DE5674 C?= 5;7562368 E:==3:857? 4:E5I45; B?D9@54 E:< F5 B?E95@@368. 7A5 @58:@ :=8DI

E5674 C?= =5ZD3=368 4DBA :6 5;75643?6 :=5 6?70 -A5 CD6I

2:E567:@ =38A7 7? E:==< 2?54 6?7 36B@D25 : =38A7 7? E:[5

: ,7:75 BA:685 374 25C36373?6 ?C E:==3:850 Y62 : ,7:75\4

25B343?6 7? E:367:36 7A5 E5:6368 ?C E:==3:85 7A:7 A:4

95=434752 36 5>5=< BD@7D=5 7A=?D8A?D7 ADE:6 A347?=< B:6

A:=2@< F5 B:@@52 3==:73?6:@0 ]6 4A?=7. ?D= /?64737D73?6 2?54

6?7 56:B7 :6< ?65 7A5?=< ?C E:==3:850 -A5 95?9@5 ?C :

,7:75 :=5 C=55 7? 5;9:62 E:==3:85 7? 36B@D25 4:E5I45;

B?D9@54. ?= 7? =57:36 7A5 A347?=3B 25C36373?60

-?2:5=. 7A5 /?D=7 7:[54 7A5 5;7=:?=236:=< 4759?C ?=25=368 5>5=< ,7:75 7? @3B5645 :62 =5B?863L5 4:E5I45;

E:==3:850 ^:6< 95?9@5 G3@@ =5K?3B5 :7 7A34 25B343?6. :62 ]

F58=D285 6?65 7A53= B5@5F=:73?60 $D7 C?= 7A?45 GA? F5@35>5

36 : 8?>5=6E567 ?C @:G4. 6?7 ?C E56. 7A5 E:K?=375 :BA35>52 B?64325=:F@5 4DBB544 95=4D:2368

7A53= C5@@?G B373L564_7A=?D8A 7A5 25E?B=:73B 9=?B544_7?

:2?97 7A53= >35G0 -A:7 5624 7?2:5 @:G5

B@?452 7A5 25F:75 :62 56:B752 7A53= ?G6 >343?6 ?C E:==3:85

:4 : E:775= ?C B?64737D73?6:@ @:G0 ,75:@368 7A34 344D5 C=?E

7A5 95?9@5 G3@@ C?= E:6< B:47 : B@?D2 ?>5= 4:E5I45; E:=I

=3:85. E:[368 : 2=:E:73B 4?B3:@ BA:685 7A:7 EDBA E?=523CC3BD@7 7? :BB5970


3/29

"#$%& '() *+, -. /. 0000 1234*5

67896:/; #. %$>?

:@& A'BCD$%EF( =&G$($C> $( '> 'G% CH I$JJ; >C% J&?'J BK=?L

A&>%. :@& D$?@% $% '>>CK>G&( @'( >C M'($( $> %@& #C>(%$L

%K%$C> CD %@$( #CKD%F( ND&G&=&>%. :@& A'BCD$%E &OND&((JE

=$(GJ'$A( BK=$G$'J PG'K%$C>Q '>= CA$%( &R&> ' ND&%&>(& CH

@KA$J$%E; CN&>JE D&JE$>? C> $%( =&($D& %C D&A'S& (CG$&%E

'GGCD=$>? %C $%( CI> P>&I $>($?@%Q $>%C %@& P>'%KD& CH

$>BK(%$G&.Q !"#$; '% 44; 2"% T( ' D&(KJ%; %@& #CKD% $>R'J$L

='%&( %@& A'DD$'?& J'I( CH ACD& %@'> @'JH %@& /%'%&( '>=

CD=&D( %@& %D'>(HCDA'%$C> CH ' (CG$'J $>(%$%K%$C> %@'% @'(

HCDA&= %@& M'($( CH @KA'> (CG$&%E HCD A$JJ&>>$'; HCD %@&

U'J'@'D$ 8K(@A&> '>= %@& V'> #@$>&(&; %@& #'D%@'?$>L

$'>( '>= %@& TW%&G(. S I& 'D&XY% G'> M& %&AN%$>? HCD BK=?&( %C GC>HK(& CKD CI> ND&H&DL

&>G&( I$%@ %@& D&ZK$D&A&>%( CH %@& J'I. 8K% '( %@$( #CKD%

@'( M&&> D&A$>=&= %@DCK?@CK% CKD @$(%CDE; %@& #C>(%$%KL

%$C> P$( A'=& HCD N&CNJ& CH HK>='A&>%'JJE =$HH&D$>? R$&I(.Q

'()*"$+ R. ,$- .(+/; 4[\ -. /. ]*; +, 14[3*5 1VCJA&(; %$>?5. TGGCD=$>?JE; PGCKD%( 'D& >C% GC>G&D>&= I$%@

%@& I$(=CA CD NCJ$GE CH J&?$(J'%$C>.Q 01%; '% ,[ 1V'DJ'>; %$>?5. :@& A'BCD$%E %C='E >&?J&G%( %@'% D&(%D'$>&=

GC>G&N%$C> CH %@& BK=$G$'J DCJ&. Y% (&$W&( HCD $%(&JH ' ZK&(L

%$C> %@& #C>(%$%K%$C> J&'R&( %C %@& N&CNJ&; '% ' %$A& I@&>

%@& N&CNJ& 'D& &>?'?&= $> ' R$MD'>% =&M'%& C> %@'% ZK&(L%$C>. T>= $% '>(I&D( %@'% ZK&(%$C> M'(&= >C% C> >&K%D'J

ND$>G$NJ&( CH GC>(%$%K%$C>'J J'I; MK% C> $%( CI> PK>=&DL

(%'>=$>? CH I@'% HD&&=CA $( '>= AK(% M&GCA&.Q !"#$; '%

4[. Y @'R& >C G@C$G& MK% %C =$((&>%.

->=&D(%'>= I&JJ I@'% %@$( =$((&>% $( 'MCK%) Y% $( >C%

'MCK% I@&%@&D; $> AE BK=?A&>%; %@& $>(%$%K%$C> CH A'DL

D$'?& (@CKJ= M& G@'>?&= %C $>GJK=& ('A&L(&O GCKNJ&(. Y% $(

$>(%&'= 'MCK% I@&%@&D; $> CKD =&ACGD'%$G D&NKMJ$G; %@'%

=&G$($C> (@CKJ= D&(% I$%@ %@& N&CNJ& 'G%$>? %@DCK?@ %@&$D

&J&G%&= D&ND&(&>%'%$R&(; CD I$%@ H$R& J'IE&D( I@C @'NN&>

%C @CJ= GCAA$(($C>( 'K%@CD$W$>? %@&A %C D&(CJR& J&?'J

=$(NK%&( 'GGCD=$>? %C J'I. :@& #C>(%$%K%$C> J&'R&( >C=CKM% 'MCK% %@& '>(I&D.


4/29

" #$%&'%(%)) "# *#+'%,

$%&-,. /0 10. 2344567368

9

:57373;6553< $%&'& ?=45 7>53< =5

B7 7; A=


5/29

"#$%& '() "*+ ,- .- //// 0123"4

567859.: #- ;-:

'=(- ?% '@A(& $= %B& ='%C@& AD %B$=>( %A E&&% ' F$%'G =&& %B'% HB$G H@&'%C@&(: %B& D$@(% IA=< AD C=$A= $( %B'% I&%[&&=

BC(I'=< '=< [$D&S %B& =&\%: %B'% I&%[&&= K'@&=%( '=<

HB$G $=

HAEEA=-]4-

9B& K@&E$(&( (CKKA@%$=> %B$( HA=H&K% AD E'@@$'>& '@& (ADC=B (&\C'G @&G'%$A=( I&%[&&= ' E'= '=< ' [AE'=-

UB&= (&\C'G @&G'%$A=( @&(CG% $= %B& HA=H&K%$A= AD ' HB$G&=&@'GGJ I&%%&@ $D %B& EA%B&@

'=< D'%B&@ (%'J %A>&%B&@ @'%B&@ %B'= >A$=> %B&$@ (&K'@'%&

['J(- 9B&@&DA@&: DA@ %B& >AA< AD HB$G

IA=&( E&= '=< [AE&= %A

HA=& @'%B&@ %B'=

[$%BAC%- N( A=& K@AE$=&=% (HBAG'@ KC% $%: WP'@@$'>& $( '

(AH$'GGJ '@@'=>&< (AGC%$A= DA@ %B& K@AIG&E AD >&%%$=> K&AKG&

%A (%'J %A>&%B&@ '=< H'@& DA@ HB$G& B'( K@&F'$G&<

$= %B& ,=$%&< .%'%&( %B@AC>BAC% AC@ B$(%A@J- 9B& E'cA@$%J

'HH&K%( %B'% '% W%B& %$E& AD %B& d'%$A=Z( DAC= eE'@Y@$'>&f ['( C=


6/29

" #$%&'%(%)) !" *#+'%,

$%&-,. /0 10. 2344567368

9 :96 962 9 ;


7/29

"#$%& '() *"+ ,- .- //// 0123*4

567859.: #- ;-:

?'$=%&='=@& '=< &A'>& 03L1L4- H= $=CEA&=%$'E

3M%DN@&=%AFJ %F&'%$(& & '( O' @$P$E (%'%A(:

&Q$(%$=> $= B=& ?'= '=< B=& RB?'= E&>'EEJ A=$%&< CBF E$C&

CBF %DB(& @$P$E '=< (B@$'E SAFSB(&( RD$@D 'F& T'(&< $= %D&

& '=< I$PBF@& 1* 03L*14- 9D& C$F(% &D% %B SFB@F&'%&-G

=(>02?7/ P- '+-%(/0: Y\Y ,- .- \"Y: \L+ 03M"L4-

H( %D& ?'XBF$%J =B%&(: (B?& '(S&@%( BC ?'FF$'>& D'P&

@D'=>&< BP&F %$?&- HFF'=>&< ?'FF$'>&( D'P& E'F>&EJ

>$P&= R'J %B S'$F$=>( T'(&< B= FB?'=%$@ EBP&- .%'%&( D'P&

F&SE'@&< @BP&F%AF&: %D& &: RD$@D O'FB(& '( '= $=@$


8/29

" #$%&'%(%)) "# *#+'%,

$%&-,. /0 10. 2344567368

$%"&'( . 9"" :0 ,0. ;7 0

-?5 @;ABC37D BE45CF54 7?;7 7?545 25F5GBH@5674 IJ5C5

6B7 @5C5 4KH5CL3M3;G M?;6854N 36 @;CC3;85. EK7 C;7?5C

IJBCO52 255H 7C;64LBC@;73B64 36 374 47CKM7KC50N )'*+. ;7

0 -?5D 232 6B7. ?BJ5F5C. JBCO ;6D 7C;64LBC@;73B6 36

7?5 MBC5 47CKM7KC5 BL @;CC3;85 ;4 7?5 K63B6 E57J556 ; @;6

;62 ; JB@;60 PL DBK ?;2 ;4O52 ; H5C4B6 B6 7?5 47C557 ?BJ

@;CC3;85 J;4 25L3652. 6B B65 JBKG2 5F5C ?;F5 4;32. IQ;CR

C3;85 34 7?5 K63B6 BL ; @;6 ;62 ; JB@;6. J?5C5 7?5 JB@;6

34 4KEA5M7 7B MBF5C7KC50N -?5 @;ABC37D @;D E5 C38?7 7?;7

7?5 I?347BCD BL @;CC3;85 34 B65 BL EB7? MB6736K37D ;62

M?;685.N EK7 7?5 MBC5 @5;6368 BL @;CC3;85 ?;4 562KC520 )'*+. ;7


9/29

"#$%& '() *+, -. /. 0000 1234*5

67896:/; #. %$>?

(@$A%&= B'C$=DE. F> 233"; %@& D&?$(D'%GB&( HA I&BJH>%; K&L

M'JC(@$B&; '>= %@& N$(%B$O% HA #HDGJP$' P&O'J& %@& A$B(%

$> %@& K'%$H> %H &>'O% D'L( %@'% B&Q$(&= %@& =&A$>$%$H> HA

J'BB$'?& %H $>ODG=& ('J&R(&S OHGCD&(; L@$D& 'D(H CBHQ$=$>?

'OOHJJH='%$H>( AHB B&D$?$HG( P&D$&Q&B(. F> 2344; %@& K&L

THBU V&?$(D'%GB& &>'O%&= ' ($J$D'B D'L. F> 2342; QH%&B( $>

W'$>& =$= %@& ('J&; B&Q&B($>? %@& B&(GD% HA ' B&A&B&>=GJ

XG(% %@B&& E&'B( &'BD$&B $> L@$O@ %@&E @'= GC@&D= %@&

%B'=$%$H>'D =&A$>$%$H> HA J'BB$'?&.

F> 'DD; QH%&B( '>= D&?$(D'%HB( $> &D&Q&> /%'%&( '>= %@&

N$(%B$O% HA #HDGJP$' @'Q& O@'>?&= %@&$B =&A$>$%$H>( HA

J'BB$'?& %H $>ODG=& ('J&R(&S OHGCD&(. :@& @$?@&(% OHGB%(HA A$Q& /%'%&( @'Q& =&OB&&= %@'% ('J& B&(GD% G>=&B %@&$B

HL> #H>(%$%G%$H>(. :@& B&J'$>=&B HA %@& /%'%&( B&%'$> %@&

%B'=$%$H>'D =&A$>$%$H> HA J'BB$'?&.

Y&%$%$H>&B( PBHG?@% D'L(G$%( OH>%&>=$>? %@'% %@& NG&

YBHO&(( '>= 9ZG'D YBH%&O%$H> #D'G(&( HA %@& [HGB%&&>%@

\J&>=J&>% OHJC&D %@&$B /%'%&( %H D$O&>(& '>= B&OH?>$]&

J'BB$'?&( P&%L&&> ('J&R(&S OHGCD&(. F> ' O'B&AGDDE B&'R

(H>&= =&O$($H>; %@& #HGB% HA \CC&'D( 'OU>HLD&=?&= %@&

=&JHOB'%$O ^JHJ&>%GJ_ $> A'QHB HA ^&SC'>=`$>?a %@&

=&A$>$%$H> HA J'BB$'?& %H $>ODG=& ?'E OHGCD&(;_ PG% OH>R

ODG=&= %@'% C&%$%$H>&B( @'= >H% J'=& ^%@& O'(& AHB OH>(%$R%G%$H>'D$]$>? %@& =&A$>$%$H> HA J'BB$'?& '>= AHB B&JHQ$>?

%@& $((G& ABHJ %@& CD'O& $% @'( P&&> ($>O& %@& AHG>=$>?) $>

%@& @'>=( HA (%'%& QH%&B(._ ++2 [. b=; '% b",; c3b. :@'%

=&O$($H> $>%&BCB&%&= %@& #H>(%$%G%$H> OHBB&O%DE; '>= F

LHGD= 'AA$BJ.

FF

Y&%$%$H>&B( A$B(% OH>%&>= %@'% %@& J'BB$'?& D'L( HA %@&$B

/%'%&( Q$HD'%& %@& NG& YBHO&(( #D'G(&. :@& /HD$O$%HB d&>R

&B'D HA %@& ->$%&= /%'%&(; 'CC&'B$>? $> (GCCHB% HA C&%$%$H>R

&B(; &SCB&((DE =$(HL>&= %@'% CH($%$H> P&AHB& %@$( #HGB%.

/&& :B. HA 7B'D \B?. H> eG&(%$H> 4; '% bfgb". :@& J'XHB$%E>&Q&B%@&D&(( B&(HDQ&( %@&(& O'(&( AHB C&%$%$H>&B( P'(&=


10/29

"# $%&'(&)&** "# +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

:;6;? =7 8@6 ,A6 B>=C655 0;:A561

.@6 48? EA>E=>85 8= 436784F? F=A> GE>47C4E;65 :73

8>:3484=75H 47 8@45 0=A>8I5 3A6 E>=C655 E>6C636785 8@:8

5AEE=>8 : FA73:49@8 F=> 5:?1 $%&'/ :8 "L1 M7 >6:;48?/ @=N6O6>/ 8@6 48?I5 :EJ

E>=:C@ @:5 7= P:545 47 E>47C4E;6 => 8>:3484=7/ 6KC6E8 F=> 8@6

A7E>47C4E;63 8>:3484=7 =F DA34C4:; E=;4C?J

:C86>4R63 345C>634863 36C454=75 5AC@ :5 ()*+%', O1 -'.

/),0/ "ST U1 -1 VW1 -8>4EE63 =F 485 5@47? >@68=>4C:; 9;=55/

8@6 48?I5 :>9A=C655 0;:A56

94O65 5:?

P6C:A56 48 N4;; P6 9==3 F=> 8@6< :73 F=> 5=C468?1 MF M N6>6 :;6945;:8=>/ M N=A;3 C6>8:47;? C=75436> 8@:8 O46N :5 :

=F 5=C4:; E=;4C?1 %A8 :5 : DA396/ M F473 8@6 48?I5 E=54J

84=7 4736F6754P;6 :5 : =F C=75848A84=7:; ;:N1

X

B68484=76>5I GFA73:49@8H C;:4< F:;;5 478= 8@6

? =F C=75848A84=7:; :3DA34C:84=71

B68484=76>5 3= 7=8 C=78673 8@:8 8@64> -8:865I >4:96 ;:N5

O4=;:86 :7 '%12',3&'4 C=75848A84=7:; >49@8/ 5AC@ :5 8@6

F>663=< =F 5E66C@ E>=86C863 P? 8@6 )4>58 X :;;/ 7= G0=58:73J

479H => GY=P4;48? :73 ,49748?H 0;:A56 47 8@6 0=75848A84=71

-66 3%&'/ :8 Z/ "V1 .@6? :>9A6 47586:3 8@:8 8@6 ;:N5 O4=J

;:86 : >49@8 52675'4 P? 8@6 )=A>86678@ X68?H 4O63 N48@=A8

G3A6 E>=C655 =F ;:N1H

.@45 0=A>8 @:5 4786>E>6863 8@6 ,A6 B>=C655 0;:A56 8=

47C;A36 : G5AP58:784O6H C==86C85 C6>8:47

;4P6>8? 4786>6585 :9:4758 58:86 36E>4O:84=7 G7= N@:8

E>=C655 45 E>=O43631H 8'%) O1 97),':/ W#\ U1 -1 LSL/ Z#L

]"SSZ^1 .@6 8@6=>? 45 8@:8 5=8465 :>6 G5= >==863 47

8@6 8>:3484=75 :73 C=75C467C6 =F =A> E6=E;6 :5 8= P6 >:7Q63

:5 FA73:6F=>6 C:77=8 P6 36E>4O63 N48@J=A8 C=


11/29

""#$%& '() *+, -. /. 0000 123"*4

567859/: #. ;.:

-. /. ?+: "3* 1"?@A4.

BCCDE$=> F=&C&G%&< H&K%( I'=N '( OHF=K% %K'% (KDFC< $=K&I& $= '= $$(C'%$D= I&L

(%I$G%$=> %K& $=(%$%F%$D= DH (C'S&IU S$DC'%&< %K& $MTC$&<

I$>K%( DH (C'S&KDCDS&I= %K& $=%&ILTI&%'%$D= DH C'E( a'I&b 'R'=


12/29

"# $%&'(&)&** "# +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

:;474:75 :< 4734=43>?@5 ?A6 ?@@:B63 8: C:78A:@D 8E6 0:7584F

8>84:7G5 H6?7479/ IB6 E?=6 7: @:796A ? 0:75848>84:7J B6

?A6 >736A 8E6 9:=6A7H678 :< 4734=43>?@ H67/ BE: 84:7 45/

?CC:A3479 8: 8E64A :B7 =46B5 :< BE?8 48 :>9E8 8: H6?71D

$%#/ ?8 L#"1

&'(% )*+,,G5 E:@3479 B?5 :=6AA>@63 :7 8E6 K?88@66 QA:C655 0@?>56

A6?;;6?A631 R7 ? 56A465 :< 6?A@N #S8EFC678>AN C?565/ H:58

;A:H47678@N -+*./(' =1 0(1 2+'3/ 8E45 0:>A8 47=?@43?863

58?86 58?8>865 8E?8 ;A6567863 IH633@65:H6 4786A?@/D ?73 I>73>6 4786A@3 K6 =46B63 ?5 ? A6?5:7?K@6 A65;:756 8:

@6945@?84=6 C:7C6A7 ?K:>8 8E6 E6?@8E :< K?W6AN 6H;@:N665/

?7 455>6 :7 BE4CE 8E6A6 B?5 ?8 @6?58 IA::H 78AN 3:65 7:8 6786A8?471D $%#4 ?8 \[

]:;474:7 :< +:@H65/ 21^1 O5 2>584C6 +:@H65 H6H:A?K@N ;>8

48/ I.E6 ):>A86678E OH673H678 3:65 7:8 67?C8 `A1 +6AF

K6A8 -;67C6AG5 -:C4?@ -8?84C5/D ? @6?3479 B:AW :7 8E6 ;E4F

@:5:;EN :< -:C4?@ ,?AB4745H1 $56%# .E6 0:75848>84:7 I45

7:8 47867363 8: 6HK:3N ? ;?A84C>@?A 6C:7:H4C 8E6:AN 1 1 1 1

R8 45 H?36


13/29

"#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ 1111 234"+5

67896:0; $/ DE%B& F%&@ &@' $C>)&%&G&%C>/H !"#; (& ,+I,-/

J> &@' ='B(=') (D&'K $%&'()*; &@' $CGK& )&KGBL =CF>

>'(KEM 344 E(F) () N%CE(&%C>) CD %>=%N%=G(E E%O'K&M; CD&'>

CN'K )&KC>? =%))'>&) BC>&'>=%>? &@(& PQ&R@' BK%&'K%C> CD

BC>)&%&G&%C>(E%&M %) >C& F@'&@'K F' O'E%'N' &@' E(F &C O'

DCK &@' SGOE%B ?CC=/H +",-(. N/ /'-0"*)(1. 3%.4-560 %7

8# /#; 3-" ./ 0/ +3+; +,4 2"T3#5 2CS%>%C> CD UCEA'); ? VG=?') &C 'E'N(&' &@'%K CF> SCE%BM VG=?A'>&)

&C &@' )&(&G) CD BC>)&%&G&%C>(EEM SKC&'B&'= PE%O'K&M;H &@'

$%&'()* E%>' CD B()') E'D& P>C (E&'K>(&%N' &C K'?(K=%>? &@'

BCGK& () ( / / / E'?%)E(&%N' B@(AO'K/H W/ U(>=; :@' 8%EE CD

6%?@&) X3 2"T+Y5/9N'>&G(EEM; &@' $CGK& K'BC?>%Z'= %&) 'KKCK (>= NCF'=

>C& &C K'S'(& %&/ P:@' =CB&K%>' &@(& / / / =G' SKCB')) (G&@CK[

%Z') BCGK&) &C @CE= E(F) G>BC>)&%&G&%C>(E F@'> &@'M O'E%'N'

&@' E'?%)E(&GK' @() (B&'= G>F%)'EM;H F' E(&'K '\SE(%>'=;

P@() EC>? )%>B' O''> =%)B(K='=/ ]' @(N' K'&GK>'= &C &@'

CK%?%>(E BC>)&%&G&%C>(E SKCSC)%&%C> &@(& BCGK&) =C >C&

)GO)&%&G&' &@'%K )CB%(E (>= 'BC>CA%B O'E%'D) DCK &@' VG=?[

A'>& CD E'?%)E(&%N' OC=%'); F@C (K' 'E'B&'= &C S()) E(F)/H

9)*:;.%( N/ ? $%&'()* =C') >C& K'_G%K' =%)(NCF%>? &@'

=CB&K%>' CD %ASE%'= DG>=(A'>&(E K%?@&); (>= &@%) $CGK& @()

>C& =C>' )C/ 8G& &C (NC%= K'S'(&%>? $%&'()*`) 'KKCK CD

BC>N'K&%>? S'K)C>(E SK'D'K'>B') %>&C BC>)&%&G&%C>(E A(>[

=(&'); CGK AC='K> )GO)&(>&%N' =G' SKCB')) B()') @(N'

)&K'))'= &@' >''= DCK PVG=%B%(E )'ED[K')&K(%>&/H /%00-(. N/

36*,)* 3)-:'5.; +4# ./ 0/ ""+; "3+ 2"TT35/ 7GK SK'B'='>&)@(N' K'_G%K'= &@(& %ASE%'= DG>=(A'>&(E K%?@&) O' PCOV'B[


14/29

"# $%&'(&)&** "# +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

84:6;??863 47 8@45 AB84?7C5 @458?>< B73 8>B34D

84?7/E B73 F4G=;4H48 47 8@6 H?7H6=8 ?I ?>36>63 ;4J6>8 ;4J6>8< 7?> LK584H6 M?K;3 6N458 4I 8@6< M6>6

5BH>4I4H631E $%&'()*+,- / OP" Q1 -1/ B8 RPSTRP" U4786>7B;

VK?8B84?7 GB>W5 ?G48863X1

Y;8@?K9@ 8@6 0?K>8 B>84HK;B863 8@6 4G=?>8B7H6 ?I @45D

8?>< B73 8>B3484?7 8? 8@6 IK73BG678B; >49@85 47VK4>< G?58

=>6H456;< 47 $%&'()*+,- / GB7< ?8@6> HB565 J?8@ J6I?>6 B73

BI86> @B:6 B3?=863 8@6 5BG6 B==>?BH@1 -66/ +#-#. /0)1,0'1

2113,4+56) 7880'+ 83, 9:0,; ?=6> >6;4B7H6 ?7 @458?>< B73 8>B3484?7 ?I H?K>56 >6D

VK4>65 ;??W479 J6< 4G=?565

;4G485 ?7 8@6 LK34H4B>< 8@B8 B>6 G?>6 G6B7479IK; 8@B7 B7<

JB563 ?7 dB7e BJ58>BH8 I?>GK;B/E A33,+/ #\" Q1 -1/ B8 OS#/

71 "P U=;K>B;48< ?=474?7X1 &N=B73479 B >49@8 5K3367;< B73

3>BGB84HB;;< 45 ;4W6;< 8? >6VK4>6 86B>479 48 K= I>?G 485>??851 &:67 B 547H6>6 =>?I6554?7 ?I F345H4=;476E 47 436784I


15/29

"#$%&' ()* #+, -. /. 0000 123"#4

567859/: $. ;.: D&): "#$%: (& "3E"": %= J@A'=&4.

7

9D' A(JFC%&M (IN=FLB'') =F=' F? &D%) CF@=C(&':R FC K'< &D'%C A%=


16/29

"# $%&'(&)&** "# +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

3: 7:8 ;::?@56/ 8;A8 A7B:76 C;: CA785 8: 968 DA@E

@463 ;A5 A >:75848?84:7A< @49;8 8: 3: 5:1 .;6B 47586A3

@6F?4@6 A -8A86 8: G?584=B HA@@46@5 8: DA@@4A96 A5 8;A8

475848?84:7 ;A5 AA565 58A73 =:@ 8;6 4DE

K:@8A78 H?8 ?84:75

:7 A>>655 8: DA@@4A96 *8 51*9&5&%'*,,7 92:&'29 T4:6551 .;656 K@6>636785 5AB 7:8;479 A8 A;A796 485 36=47484:7 := DA@@4A96/ C;4>; 45

8;6 @49;8 K68484:76@5 A>8?A


17/29

"#$%&' ()* +#, -. /. 0000 123"+4

567859/: $. ;.: C&. JA=' 'K%)&): (=< &C(& %)

'=AD>C &A IAB'@?A)' &C'%B @?(%L.

2

9C' L(MAB%&G )D>>')&) &C(& N&C'B' (B' A&C'B: LAB' %=O

)&BD@&%F' EB'@'C& &A L(BBG. "#$%:

(& "2. Q?&CAD>C =A& '=&%B'?G @?'(B: &C%) B'I'B'=@' )''L) &A

@ABB')EA=< &A ( ?%=' AI @()') (= %LE?%'< ID= CALA)'KD(? )A ND=V(BO

B(=&'< >AF'B=L'=& %=&BD)%A=)P &C(& N&AD@^C_ DEA= &C'

LA)& EB%F(&' CDL(= @A=C& &C(& E'&%&%A='B) ())'B&

C'B'. -=?%[' @B%L%=(? ?(V) H(==%=> @A=&B(@'E&%F') (=<

)AAFO

'B=L'=& %=&BD)%A=. 9C'G @B'(&' =A @B%L' (=< %LEA)' =A

ED=%)CL'=&. /(L'O)'K @ADE?') B'L(%= IB'' &A ?%F' &A>'&C'B:

&A '=>(>' %= %=&%L(&' @A=


18/29

"# $%&'(&)&** "# +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

7655: ;< 8=6 >?@5 A=?>>67963 47 8=656 A?565B7C C761 $%&'/

?8 D#1 E8 8=6 5?F6 84F6/ 8=6 >?@5 47 7C @?< 4786GH6G6 @48=

8=6 IG49=8 8C ;6 >68 ?>C761:

.=6 F?JCG48< ?>5C G6>465 C7 2K584A6 +?G>?7L5 47H>K6784?>

3455678479 CM474C7 47 ()' N1 *++,-%/ OPQ R1 -1 STQ U"TP"V1

E5 8=6 F?JCG48< G6ACK785/ 8=?8 CM474C7 58?865 8=?8 IW3XK6

MGCA655 =?5 7C8 ;667 G63KA63 8C ?7< HCGFK>?1: ./#0 ?8 YSD1

%K8 H?G HGCF AC7H6GG479 8=6 ;GC?3 4786GMG684N6 345AG684C7

8=?8 8=6 F?JCG48< 345A6G75/ 2K584A6 +?G>?7L5 CM474C7 F?Z65

A>6?G 8=?8 ACKG85 4FM> G49=85 ?G6 7C8

IHG66 8C GC?F @=6G6 K79K4363 5M6AK>?84C7 F49=8 8?Z6

8=6F1: .12/# .=6< FK58 47586?3 =?N6 IG69?G3 8C @=?8=458CG< 86?A=65: ?73 6[6GA456 7C8 C7>< IJK39F678: ;K8

IG658G?4781: .12/# $H M?G84AK>?G G6>6N?7A6/ 2K584A6 +?G>?7

6[M>?4763 8=?8 I>?@5 G69?G3479 F?GG4?96 @=4A= MGCN436

;C8= @=67 8=6 56[K?> MC@6G5 F?< ;6 K563 ?73 8=6 >69?>

?73 5CA468?> AC786[8 47 @=4A= A=4>3G67 ?G6 ;CG7 ?73

;GCK9=8 KM 1 1 1 HCGF ? M?886G7 5C 366M>< MG65563 478C 8=6

5K;58?7A6 CH CKG 5CA4?> >4H6 8=?8 ?7< 0C75848K84C7?> 3CA\

8G476 47 8=45 ?G6? FK58 ;K4>3 KMC7 8=?8 ;?5451: ./#/ ?8 YSP1

]7 5KF/ 8=6 MG4N?A< A?565 MGCN436 7C 5KMMCG8 HCG 8=6

F?JCG48?84C75=4M5/ ?>C79 @48= ACGG65MC73479 9CN6G7F678

;676H4851 $KG A?565 =?N6 AC75458678>< G6HK563 8C ?>>C@

>4849?785 8C AC7N6G8 8=6 5=46>3 MGCN4363 ;< AC75848K84C7?>

>4;6G8465 478C ? 5@CG3 8C 36F?73 MC5484N6 67848>6F6785

HGCF 8=6 -8?861 -66 3'45-%'6 N1 72%%'1-8) 9):%&6 3';

)< 4)=2-+ 4'>"?#/ S#T R1 -1 "#T/ "TP U"T#TV_ 4-% $%&)%2)

.%/';'%/'%& 4=5))+ 32? N1 @)/>28:'A/ S"" R1 -1 "/ OY`OQ

U"TQOV_ ;)?&/ ?8 T`"O U.+$aE-/ 21/ 3455678479V1 .=K5/

?>8=CK9= 8=6 G49=8 8C MG4N?A< G6AC974b63 ;< CKG MG6A636785

A6G8?47>< M>?6 47 MGC86A8479 8=6 4784F?86 AC73KA8 CH

5?F6\56[ ACKM>65/ 48 MGCN4365 7C ?HH4GF?84N6 G49=8 8C G636\

H476 F?GG4?96 ?73 7C ;?545 HCG 58G4Z479 3C@7 8=6 >?@5 ?8455K6 =6G61


19/29

"#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ 1111 234"+5

67896:0; $/ ='B%K'

LBFM DB'E'='>&; &C' M(NFB%&O ?F') FJ& FL %&) H(O &F N'&&%)F>

&C' PE(B'LJIQ (DDBF(EC &F %MDI%'= LJ>=(M'>&(I B%?C&)

&(R'> SO &C%) $FJB& %> "#$%&'()*+ / ,-.); (& "T 2UJF&%>?

+3" ./ 0/; (& ,3"5/ V& %) B'K'(I%>? &C(& &C' M(NFB%&OW) DF)%X

&%F> B'UJ%B') %& &F 'LL'E&%K'IO FK'BBJI' "#$%&'()*+ ; &C'

I'(=%>? MF='B> E()' )'&&%>? &C' SFJ>=) FL )JS)&(>&%K' =J'

DBFE'))/ Y& I'()& &C%) D(B& FL &C' M(NFB%&O FD%>%F> C() &C'

K%B&J' FL E(>=FB/ ZFSF=O EFJI= B%?C&IO (EEJ)' &C' M(NFB%&O

FL &(R%>? ( E(B'LJI (DDBF(EC/

.I&%M(&'IO; F>IO F>' DB'E'='>& FLL'B) (>O )JDDFB& LFB

&C' M(NFB%&OW) M'&CF=FIF?O* /0%1-)* K/ 2)3 40*&; "#T

./ 0/ [+/ :C' M(NFB%&O FD'>) %&) FD%>%F> SO (>>FJ>E%>?

D'&%&%F>'B)W B%?C& &F P='L%>' (>= '\DB')) &C'%B %='>&%&O/Q

,-.); (& "]3/ :C' M(NFB%&O I(&'B '\DI(%>) &C(& P&C' B%?C& &F

D'B)F>(I ECF%E' B'?(B=%>? M(BB%(?' %) %>C'B'>& %> &C'

EF>E'D& FL %>=%K%=J(I (J&F>FMO/Q ,-.); (& "3/ :C%) LB''X

HC''I%>? >F&%F> FL %>=%K%=J(I (J&F>FMO 'ECF') >F&C%>? )F

MJEC () P&C' ?'>'B(I B%?C& FL (> %>=%K%=J(I &F S' 5*)) 6- 16'

7)*'0- (>= %> C%) DFH'B &F EF>&B(E& %> B'I(&%F> &F C%) FH>

I(SFB/Q /0%1-)*; "#T ./ 0/; (& +T 2'MDC()%) (=='=5/

:F S' L(%B; &C' M(NFB%&O =F') >F& )J??')& &C(& %&) %>=%XK%=J(I (J&F>FMO B%?C& %) '>&%B'IO J>EF>)&B(%>'=/ :C'

EF>)&B(%>&) %& )'&) (B' DB'E%)'IO &CF)' &C(& (EEFB= H%&C %&)

FH> PB'()F>'= NJ=?M'>&;Q %>LFBM'= SO %&) P>'H %>)%?C&Q

%>&F &C' P>(&JB' FL %>NJ)&%E';Q HC%EC H() %>K%)%SI' &F (II

HCF E(M' S'LFB' SJ& C() S'EFM' EI'(B P() H' I'(B> ^&C'_

M'(>%>?Q FL I%S'B&O/ ,-.); (& "4; ""8 :C' &BJ&C %) &C(&

&F=(OW) ='E%)%F> B')&) F> >F&C%>? MFB' &C(> &C' M(NFB%&OW)

FH> EF>K%E&%F> &C(& )(M'X)'\ EFJDI') )CFJI= S' (IIFH'= &F

M(BBO S'E(J)' &C'O H(>& &F; (>= &C(& P%& HFJI= =%)D(B(?'

&C'%B ECF%E') (>= =%M%>%)C &C'%B D'B)F>CFF= &F ='>O &C'M

&C%) B%?C&/Q ,-.); (& "#/ `C(&'K'B LFBE' &C(& S'I%'L M(O

C(K' () ( M(&&'B FL MFB(I DC%IF)FDCO; %& C() >F MFB' S()%)

%> &C' $F>)&%&J&%F> &C(> =%= &C' >(R'= DFI%EO DB'L'B'>E')


20/29

"# $%&'(&)&** !" +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

:3;


21/29

"#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ 1111 2"3#+4

5678590: $/ ;/: H( DG I=DC%=>

&@'%B G(H%A%') (B' )DH'@DC A'))'B:J "#$%: (& #+: C@K

CDEA &@' DMMDBQ

&E=%&K &D H(BBK F)'BP') &D +33:333

MDAK(HDBDE) G(H%A%') %= &@' .=%&'< 0&(&')4X Y%: Z(BB%'<

Y')R%(= F9@BDEMA'J 8UM'?&%=> [%B)& $@%A': -_ 8HDBK Y/ ;/

#W,, 2"3#+4/

O ') %= (AA B')M'?&)/ 9@'B' H(K

C'AA R' B'A'P(=& EH'=&: M'&%&%D='B) ())'B&'< &@(& ( 0&(&' F/ D= bE')&%D= ": M/ -/

7E& &@(& %) 'U(?&AK &@' MD%=&* &@' 0&(&') (& %))E' @'B' '

&D %=?AE


22/29

"" #$%&'%(%)) !" *#+'%,

$%&-,. /0 10. 2344567368

-956 :62 6; 795 ?9:=@ A=36B3AC5D

4;E624 @;=5 36 A93C;4;A9F 79:6 C: 795

>ECC547 3623G32E:C 45C>H=5:C3I:73;6 ;G5= 795 B;647=:3674 79:7

4;B357F 9:4 5JA=54452 36 C:< @:F ;= @:F 6;7 K5 :77=:B73G5

@;=:C A93C;4;A9F0 $E7 : 1E473B5L4 B;@@3443;6 2;54 6;7

B;6>5= :6F 4A5B3:C @;=:C. A93C;4;A93B:C. ;= 4;B3:C 3643897

4E>>3B3567 7; ME473>F 3@A;4368 79;45 A5=B5A73;64 ;6 >5CC;<

B373I564 E625= 795 A=575645 ;> ?2E5 A=;B5440D -95=5 34

362552 : A=;B544 2E5 795 A5;AC5 ;6 344E54 ;> 7934 4;=7N795

25@;B=:73B A=;B5440 &54A5B7368 79:7 E625=47:62368 =5H

OE3=54 795 /;E=7 7; K5 8E3252 KF C: 4;B3:C 79;E8970 P4 1E285 *56=F (=3562CF ;6B5AE7 37. 5B9;368 1E473B5 *;C@54L4 2344567 36 #$%&'(). 795

(;E=755679 P@562@567 2;54 6;7 56:B7 1;96 ,7E:=7 Q3CCL4

#6 )3K5=7F :6F @;=5 79:6 37 56:B74 *5=K5=7 ,A56B5=L4

,;B3:C ,7:73B40 ,55 &:62;CA9. $5>;=5 *$( !" ,-.(R 1E285

(=3562CFL4 +=:>7 PK;=73;6 #A363;6. "S *:=G0 10 )0 T UEK0

U;CLF VWXY. VWXZ[VWX\. VWY] ^"WWZ_0 P62 37 B5=7:36CF 2;54

6;7 56:B7 :6F ;65 B;6B5A7 ;> @:==3:850

-95 @:M;=37FL4 E625=47:62368 ;> 2E5 A=;B544 C:F4 ;E7 :

7:67:C3I368 G343;6 ;> 795 >E7E=5 >;= Q5@K5=4 ;> 7934 /;E=7R

`> :6 E6G:=F368 4;B3:C 364737E73;6 562E=368 ;G5= :CC ;>

=5B;=252 9347;=F B:66;7 3693K37 ME23B3:C A;C3BF@:a368.;= 795 =EC5 ;>

C: 364347368 79:7 3@AC352 >E62:@567:C

=38974 9:G5 =;;74 36 795 9347;=F :62 7=:2373;6 ;> ;E= A5;AC5

34 7; 564E=5 79:7


23/29

"#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ 1111 2"34+5

67896:0; $/ E& 'A'> @()&/F G/ H(IJK>'B;

6'LI%'M NEB ( OI> P" 24P+45/

CCC

C> (==%&%E> &E &Q'%B =I' @BER')) (B?IM'>&; @'&%&%E>'B)

RE>&'>= &Q(& &Q' 9LI(J SBE&'R&%E> $J(I)' B'LI%B') &Q'%B

0&(&') &E J%R'>)' (>= B'RE?>%T' )(M'U)'V M(BB%(?')/ :Q'

M(WEB%&X =E') >E& )'B%EI)JX '>?(?' Y%&Q &Q%) RJ(%M/ C&)

=%)RI))%E> %); LI%&' NB(>KJX; =%NN%RIJ& &E NEJJEY/ :Q' R'>&B(J

@E%>& )''M) &E Z' &Q(& &Q'B' %) ( [)X>'B?X Z'&Y''>F &Q'

9LI(J SBE&'R&%E> $J(I)' (>= &Q' \I' SBER')) $J(I)'; (>=

&Q(& )EM' @B'R'='>&) B'JX%>? E> E>' $J(I)' Q(A' (J)EB'J%'= E> &Q' E&Q'B/ "#$%; (& "3/ ]Z)'>& NBEM &Q%) @EB&%E>

EN &Q' E@%>%E>; QEY'A'B; %) (>X&Q%>? B')'MZJ%>? EIB I)I(J

NB(M'YEBK NEB ='R%=%>? 'LI(J @BE&'R&%E> R()')/ C& %) R()'U

ZEEK =ER&B%>' &Q(& &Q' [ME='B> 0I@B'M' $EIB&D) &B'(&U

M'>& EN 'LI(J @BE&'R&%E> RJ(%M) Q() I)'= ( M'(>)U'>=)

M'&QE=EJE?X %> YQ%RQ WI=?') ()K YQ'&Q'B &Q' RJ())%N%R(U

&%E> &Q' ?EA'B>M'>& %) I)%>? %) )INN%R%'>&JX B'J(&'= &E &Q'

?E(J) %& %) @IB)I%>?/F ^/ 0&E>'; _/ 0'%=M(>; $/ 0I>)&'%>;

`/ :I)Q>'&; a S/ b(BJ(>; $E>)&%&I&%E>(J _(Y c+# 2,&Q '=/

"34#5/ :Q' M(WEB%&XD) (@@BE(RQ &E=(X %) =%NN'B'>&*

[6%?Q&) %M@J%R%& %> J%Z'B&X (>= B%?Q&) )'RIB'= ZX 'LI(J@BE&'R&%E> M(X B')& E> =%NN'B'>& @B'R'@&) (>= (B' >E&

(JY(X) REU'V&'>)%A'; X'& %> )EM' %>)&(>R') '(RQ M(X

Z' %>)&BIR&%A' () &E &Q' M'(>%>? (>= B'(RQ EN &Q'

E&Q'B/ C> (>X @(B&%RIJ(B R()' E>' $J(I)' M(X Z'

&QEI?Q& &E R(@&IB' &Q' '))'>R' EN &Q' B%?Q& %> ( MEB'

(RRIB(&' (>= REM@B'Q'>)%A' Y(X; 'A'> () &Q' &YE

$J(I)') M(X RE>A'B?' %> &Q' %='>&%N%R(&%E> (>= ='N%>%U

&%E> EN &Q' B%?Q&/F "#$%; (& 4P/

:Q' M(WEB%&X ?E') E> &E ())'B& %> RE>RJI)EBX N()Q%E> &Q(&

&Q' 9LI(J SBE&'R&%E> $J(I)' @BEA%=') (> (J&'B>(&%A' Z()%)

NEB %&) QEJ=%>?/ "#$%

; (& ""/ d'& &Q' M(WEB%&X N(%J) &E @BEUA%=' 'A'> ( )%>?J' )'>&'>R' 'V@J(%>%>? QEY &Q' 9LI(J


24/29

"# $%&'(&)&** "# +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

:;465 4736A673678 B649C8 D %?

0.//# H1 @(.'*/ KP_ M1 -1 L_K/ LOP Q"RR"S Q` &aa&,b / 21/

=


25/29

"#$%&' ()* #+, -. /. 0000 1"23#4

567859/: $. ;.: I='B I='MN

&D(A L@GG'=N

&(DO.J !"#$: (& +PQ.

R@BC'D' %) &C' G(S@D%&OT) 'U&D(K(>(=& L@=L'?&%@= @F

SM):J (=<

IG@D' &C(= 322J %&'()* ED%'F) %= &C')' L()') (A@='. !"#$:

(& Q: 32: "Y. ZC(& B@MA< E' &C' ?@%=& @F (AA@B%=> &C'

@ @=[ \& %) C%>C &%G' F@D &C' $@MD&

&@ @F G(DD%(>': E()'< @= F%K' A(BO'D)T

IE'&&'D %=F@DG'< M= SM') &@

@K'DD% () &C'O


26/29

"# $%&'(&)&** !" +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

5:; 8?6@/ 8?6 A636BC; DE34F4CB> @C> GB655 C =EHH6B

C73 8CI6 485 8EB7 C8 AC5?4:7479 C 5:;E84:71J '6?7KE458/

.?6 L:84:7 :A C *4


27/29

"#$%&' ()* +#, -. /. 0000 1"23+4

567859/: $. ;.: =%F%H(=H'. $GB)%=> ?

FBC (


28/29

"# $%&'(&)&** "# +$,(&-

'$%&'.-/ 01 21/ 3455678479

:6;494:?@84@61 .A6 B?C


29/29

"#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ 1111 2"34+5

67896:0; $/ = %>AI%G& HO=P%?>%&(CQ

R@K>=)L KM@> &E'%C ?(Q (>= I')N%(> >'%?EN@C)/ "#$%; (&

4,; 4#; ""; "+/ :E')' (MM(C'>& ())(KI&) @> &E' GE(C(G&'C @A

A(%CB%>='= M'@MI' R%II E(F' (> 'AA'G&; %> )@G%'&Q (>= %>

G@KC&/ 0'' &'($; (& -S, 2T UV:7; &%C'IQ ?C(&K%&@K)/ V& %) @>' &E%>? A@C &E' B(X@CY

%&Q &@ G@>GIK=' &E(& &E' $@>)&%&K&%@> MC@&'G&) ( C%?E& &@

)(B'Y)'Z B(CC%(?'[ %& %) )@B'&E%>? 'I)' &@ M@C&C(Q 'F'CQY

@>' RE@ =@') >@& )E(C' &E' B(X@C%&Q\) HN'&&'C %>A@CB'=

K>='C)&(>=%>?L () N%?@&'=/ "#$%; (& 4#/

V> &E' A(G' @A (II &E%); ( BKGE =%AA'C'>& F%'R @A &E'$@KC&\) C@I' %) M@))%NI'/ :E(& F%'R %) B@C' B@=')& (>=

C')&C(%>'=/ V& %) B@C' )J'M&%G(I &E(& &E' I'?(I (N%I%&%') @A

XK=?') (I)@ C'AI'G& %>)%?E& %>&@ B@C(I (>= ME%I@)@ME%G(I

%))K')/ V& %) B@C' )'>)%&%F' &@ &E' A(G& &E(& XK=?') (C'

K>'I'G&'= (>= K>(GG@K>&(NI'; (>= &E(& &E' I'?%&%B(GQ @A

&E'%C M@R'C ='M'>=) @> G@>A%>%>? %& &@ &E' 'Z'CG%)' @A I'?(I

XK=?B'>&/ V& %) B@C' (&&K>'= &@ &E' I'))@>) @A E%)&@CQ; (>=

RE(& %& E() B'(>& A@C &E' G@K>&CQ (>= $@KC& RE'> =)/ T>= %& %) I'))

MC'&'>&%@K) &E(> &@ )KMM@)' &E(& RE%I' M'@MI' (C@K>= &E'

R@CI= E(F' F%'R'= (> %>)&%&K&%@> %> ( M(C&%GKI(C R(Q A@C&E@K)(>=) @A Q'(C); &E' MC')'>& ?'>'C(&%@> (>= &E' MC'Y

)'>& $@KC& (C' &E' @>') GE@)'> &@ NKC)& &E' N@>=) @A &E(&

E%)&@CQ (>= &C(=%&%@>/

] ] ]

VA Q@K (C' (B@>? &E' B(>Q TB'C%G(>)D@A RE(&'F'C

)'ZK(I @C%'>&(&%@>DRE@ A(F@C 'ZM(>=%>? )(B'Y)'Z B(CY

C%(?'; NQ (II B'(>) G'I'NC(&' &@=(Q\) ='G%)%@>/ $'I'NC(&'

&E' (GE%'F'B'>& @A ( =')%C'= ?@(I/ $'I'NC(&' &E' @MM@CY

&K>%&Q A@C ( >'R 'ZMC'))%@> @A G@BB%&B'>& &@ ( M(C&>'C/

$'I'NC(&' &E' (F(%I(N%I%&Q @A >'R N'>'A%&)/ 8K& =@ >@&

G'I'NC(&' &E' $@>)&%&K&%@>/ V& E(= >@&E%>? &@ =@ R%&E %&/V C')M'G&AKIIQ =%))'>&/

chief justice roberts dissent on gay marriage ruling

Documents