chiral separations using nano-liquid chromatography · microfluidic separation techniques,...

9
Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169 Instituto Internacional de Cromatografia http://dx.doi.org/10.4322/sc.2016.029 ISSN 1984-4433 CROMATOGRAFIA LÍQUIDA Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3) 161 Abstract Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied in different fields of analytical chemistry. They can offer some advantages over conventional analytical tools such as high-performance liquid chromatography, e.g., higher mass sensitivity due to reduced chromatographic dilution, use of minute volumes of mobile phases, lower costs for both waste and organic solvent consumption and last but not list perfect coupling with mass spectrometry. Capillary/nano-liquid chromatography (CLC/nano-LC) have been recently proposed and applied to the analysis of a large number of compounds including proteins, peptides, drugs, herbicides, pesticides, enantiomers etc. In this paper principles, instrumentation and selection of experimental conditions are illustrated also presenting some selected applications to document the usefulness of these LC techniques. Advantages, limitations and future trends of CLC/nano-LC are also presented. Keywords: microfluidic techniques; nano-liquid chromatography; capillary- liquid chromatography; enantiomers separation; chiral stationary phases. Chiara Fanali 1 Giovanni D’Orazio 2,3 Salvatore Fanali 2 * 1 Centro Integrato di Ricerca, Campus Bio-Medico University, Rome, Italy 2 Istituto di Metodologie Chimiche, Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR), Monterotondo Rome, Italy 3 Departamento de Quimica, Universidad de La Laguna (ULL), La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain *e-mail: [email protected] Received: 17-06-2016 Accepted: 22-07-2016 Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jan-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169Instituto Internacional de Cromatografiahttp://dx.doi.org/10.4322/sc.2016.029ISSN 1984-4433

CROMATOGRAFIA LÍQUIDA

Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3) 161

AbstractMicrofluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied in different fields of analytical chemistry. They can offer some advantages over conventional analytical tools such as high-performance liquid chromatography, e.g., higher mass sensitivity due to reduced chromatographic dilution, use of minute volumes of mobile phases, lower costs for both waste and organic solvent consumption and last but not list perfect coupling with mass spectrometry. Capillary/nano-liquid chromatography (CLC/nano-LC) have been recently proposed and applied to the analysis of a large number of compounds including proteins, peptides, drugs, herbicides, pesticides, enantiomers etc. In this paper principles, instrumentation and selection of experimental conditions are illustrated also presenting some selected applications to document the usefulness of these LC techniques. Advantages, limitations and future trends of CLC/nano-LC are also presented.Keywords: microfluidic techniques; nano-liquid chromatography; capillary-liquid chromatography; enantiomers separation; chiral stationary phases.

Chiara Fanali1 Giovanni D’Orazio2,3 Salvatore Fanali2*

1Centro Integrato di Ricerca, Campus Bio-Medico University, Rome, Italy2Istituto di Metodologie Chimiche, Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR), Monterotondo Rome, Italy3Departamento de Quimica, Universidad de La Laguna (ULL), La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain*e-mail: [email protected]

Received: 17-06-2016Accepted: 22-07-2016

Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography

Page 2: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography

162 Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169

1. IntroductionThe separation of chiral compounds is an

interesting topic in various areas including biochemistry, bio-medicine, clinical chemistry, pharmaceutical industry etc. Enantiomers are compounds possessing one or more asymmetric centres exhibiting quite similar properties (same molecular weight but substituent groups with different orientation on the space). Two enantiomers are mirror image and rotate the plane of the polarized light in the opposite direction. In nature, for example, only L-aminoacids are present. very often, in a certain compound one enantiomer exhibits quite different properties from its isomer, e.g., (+)- limonene and (-)-limonene have a different aroma, orange and lemon, respectively.

A large number of drugs possess asymmetric center/centres and most of them are commercialized as a single enantiomer[1]. This is a need because ingested drugs can react with chiral compounds present in the organisms such as body fluids, cells etc. Often the antipode of a certain enantiomer in a drug can be pharmacologically less active or sometime even dangerous. Therefore there is a necessity to optimize analytical and/or preparative methods capable to analyze enantiomers in an easy, cheap, rapid and eco-friendly way.

Ananlytical methods so far used for enantiomers separation and analysis include gas chromatography (GC), high performace-liquid chromatography (HPLC), super critical fluid chromatography (SFC) and miniaturized techniques such as capillary electrophoresis (CE) and capillary-/nano-liquid chromatography (CLC/nano-LC)[2-4].

Capillary techniques have been recently proposed as alternative and/or complementary tools mainly applied for analytical purposes and because their features can offer some advantages over the conventional ones. Among them it is worth mention their environmental compatibility, the reduced volumes of both mobile phases and sample with consequently reduction of waste,

shorter analysis time and perfect coupling with mass spectrometry (MS) due to lower flow rates employed.

Both capillary/nano-LC and CE have been successful applied to enantiomers separation in different fields such as bio-medicine, forensic, pharmaceutical, agro-chemical analysis etc.[2,4].

This publication presents a brief discussion about the principles of enantiomers separation, the main features of CLC/nano-LC and the potentiality of these LC miniaturized techniques in analyzing chiral compounds. Finally some selected applications of CLC/nano-LC to chiral analysis will also be presented.

2. An overview on enantiomers separationBecause their very similar physical-chemical

properties, the separation of two enantiomers is a difficult task in separation science, however the goal can be achieved employing a chiral environment (chiral selector, CS) on forming diastereoisomers exhibiting different properties.

Two different separation methods have been used since along time, namely indirect and direct ones. In the first case the CS reacts with the two enantiomers on forming stable products (strong bonding are formed) that are separated in conventional achiral media (stationary phases, background electrolytes). This method presents some advantages, e.g., increase the molecular weight offering higher sensitivity in mass spectrometry (MS), presence of more interaction sites with stationary phases. However it is worth mentioning that high optical purity of the CS is required[5].

The other process that is largely utilized, is the direct separation method making use of a CS added to the background electrolyte (in CE) or to the mobile phase in LC. Although this approach is widely used in CE, other practical solution have been proposed in LC and capillary electrochromatography (CEC). Among them the CS is bonded to the capillary wall or to silica or to different polymeric material. Here enantiomers interact

Page 3: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S

Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169 163

during the run on forming labile diastereoisomeric

complexes with different physical-chemical properties

and thus separated from each other.

Although several model concerning chiral

recognition have been proposed, the most simple model

widely accepted is the so called “three-point” model

where three contact points are proposed and one of them

have to be stereoselective[6].

Figure 1 shows the three point interaction model.

The compound at the left side of panel a and b is the CS.

As can be observed the two enantiomers both interact

with the CS, however the (+)-isomer exhibits three bonds,

while the arbitrary (-)-isomer only two. The (+)-isomer

is forming more stable complexes than its antipode.

The list of CSs that have been studied and applied

till now is quite large and includes proteins, chiral

amino acids (or their derivatives), peptides, antibiotics,

cyclodextrins, polysaccharides (amylose and cellulose

derivatives), chiral surfactants, chiral crown-ethers,

synthetic chiral compounds etc. These CS have been used taking in mind their properties and considering the type of possible interactions for a successful chiral recognition utilizing different separation techniques including GC, HPLC, CE and CLC/nano-LC[2,5,7].

3. Capillary/nano-liquid chromatography main features and instrumentation

Although HPLC remains the most selected LC methodology for both preparative and analytical separations in a wide range of application areas, recently microcolumns of different I.D. either packed with stationary phases (SPs) or containing polymeric material (e.g., monolithic) have been developed and studied. Classification of miniaturized techniques is done considering the different I.D. of the columns employed, e.g., with 10-100 and 100-350 mm I.D., classify nano-LC and CLC, respectively[8]. Another parameter to be considered is the mobile phase flow rate. In fact when using packed capillary column columns, flow rates in the range 10-800 nL/min and 1-10 mL/min are used in nano-

Figure 1. Three points interaction model for enantiomers resolution.

Page 4: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography

164 Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169

LC and CLC, respectively. Concerning the efficiency, reducing column I.D. causes a reduction of plate-heights, however as demonstrated also theoretically, in conventional HPLC I.D. lower than 2.1 mm is not offering advantages[9]. Recently in our lab we showed that the efficiency is increased passing from 150 to 25 mm I.D. packed capillaries[10]. Although these results are interesting, the efficiency observed in packed capillaries is not satisfactory when compared with the ones achieved with conventional columns “well-packed”.

The use of packed capillaries can offer several advantages over conventional columns, e.g., higher mass sensitivity. This has been demonstrated in practice and also theoretically considering the chromatographic dilution that is decreasing by decreasing the capillary radius (r 2)[8]. When dealing with practical nano-LC analysis, it must be considered that this technique, due to the reduced injected volumes (10-60 nL) exhibits low sensitivity and therefore other approaches have to be used to overcome this drawbacks. To solve the problem, detectors with higher sensitivity, e.g., MS can be proposed. In addition higher sample volumes could be injected, e.g., 500-1500 mL[11] carefully considering sample-solvent, mobile and stationary phases. This approach is based on a focusing effect where analytes are dissolved in a solvent with lower elution capability than the mobile phase causing their focusing on the column without affecting the efficiency.

Reducing I.D. column can offer several advantages over conventional systems, however other practical aspects have to be considered, e.g., extra column band broadening. Therefore attention must be paid in avoiding loss in efficiency that causes a decrease of resolution; this is obtained, e.g., carefully selecting i) the appropriate injection system (sample volume), ii) detector, iii) tubes connections etc.

Based on our experience the optimum detector cell (UV detector) is obtained utilizing the same packed capillary where the path length is the capillary diameter with a volume of a few nanoliters. When working

with an MS, the column is directly connected through a capillary tip to the orifice; in this way mobile phase and analytes are tranferred to the MS increasing the sensitivity. To reduce band broadening, the capillary column can be directly connected to the injection valve. The injected sample volume must be as low as possible (usualy 10-60 nL) and tube connections I.D. are in the range 50-100 mm.

In nano-LC, mobile phase flow rates applied are in the range 10-800 nL/min and these can be generated utilizing dedicated pump systems commercially available. Syringe or reciprocating pumps are usually used to produce low flow rates.

A very simple approach that could be considered is the use of conventional pumping systems where a mechanical split is used in order to reduce the flow rate. The split is a stainless steel T connected with the pump, with the injection valve and with waste: selecting appropriate tubes (length and I.D.) the nano-flow can be easily attained. The production of a constant and stable flow can be achieved. This system is perfectly working in isocratic elution, however in our laboratory it has been demonstrated that step gradient can also be performed[12].

Figure 2 shows a scheme of a nano-LC laboratory assembled instrumentation.

4. Enantiomers separation by using nano-flow techniques.

The separation of enantiomers by using nano-flow techniques such as CLC/nano-LC is of great interest for several groups interested in developing new chiral stationary phases and with experience in preparing their own column. This can be easily argued considering that only a few mg of material are needed to packing capillaries; this is very useful especially when new chiral stationary phases, usually expensive, are tested. Additionally, this technical approach results advantageous when the chiral selector (expensive) is added to the mobile phase; only a few mLx day of mobile phase are used.

Page 5: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S

Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169 165

A few examples concerning the applicability of the last mentioned approach are available in literature. Takeuchi firstly reported the study of enantiomers separation adding g-cyclodextrin (g-CD) to the mobile phase (acetonitrile-water, 2:8 v/v) using CLC where the capillary (350 mm I.D.) was packed with develosil ODS-5 particles. The separated enantiomers were R and S-1,1’-binaphtyl-2-2’-dihyl hydrogen phosphate[13]. Our group was also interested in this topic studying the enantiomers separation of different compounds of pharmaceutical interest such as non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs or fluoroquinolone antibiotics[14-16] utilizing nano-LC with packed capillaries of 100 mm I.D. and different CDs (trimethylated-, sulphated-, dimethylated- or hydroxy-propyl-g-CD) added to the mobile phase. Without going into details, it is noteworth mentioning that the proposed method in addition to achieving good enantiomers resolution, allowed the calculation of association constants between CDs and analytes[14].

Although the described enantiomers separation method has some advantages over the ones performed with conventional HPLC, it presents some restrictions especially due to the limited applicability of known chiral selectors, e.g., reduced analytes sensitivity caused by the absorption of the CS. Therefore better results can be achieved utilizing CLC/nano-LC with chiral stationary phases (CSP). The CS can be adsorbed on the packed particles[4,17,18] or bonded to the stationary phase[11,19-22]. Finally the CS can be bonded on the capillary wall[23]. In this last approach bovine serum albumin (BSA) was chemically bonded to the capillary wall: some amino acid derivatives and hydoxy-benzodiazepines enantiomers were resolved using both open tubular electrochromatography and liquid chromatography. Although such system allowed achieving good chiral resolutions, along the time was not developed too much; this is most probably due to the use of capillaries with very low I.D. (<50 mm) and to a lower loadability.

Figure 2. Scheme of a nano-LC laboratory assembled instrumentation.

Page 6: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography

166 Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169

In order to show the usefulness of CLC/nano-LC for chiral separations applying CSPs with the chiral selector either adsorbed or bonded to the silica particles some practical aspects related to the selection of optimum experimental parameters and applications to real samples are reported.

Analysis of amino acid enantiomers is an important topic not only in biochemistry but also in food chemistry because several food products, being of natural origin, contain only L-amino acid. Most of these compounds do not possess absorbing groups in their chemical structure and therefore are very difficult to be analyzed. Being interested in microfluidic techniques employing UV detectors and mass spectrometry, it was decided to analyze amino acid enantiomers using nano-LC/MS[20]. Enantioseparations were achieved in a capillary column packed with silica-based particles containing chemically bonded vancomycin. Analytes were derivatized with fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC); the derivatives had a higher molecular weight improving the MS response and additional interaction sites with the CS. The analytical method was optimized, validated and applied to the analysis of different orange juices. Analytical results obtained analyzing both fresh and commercial orange juices did not report the presence of D-amino acids documenting that the juice was not adulterated and/or was correctly stored. Later on nano-LC was applied to the analysis of hesperetin (HT) enantiomers in human urine after ingestion of orange juice. HT is a nutraceutical compound useful to treat several illness and is not naturally present in the orange juice that, on the other hand, contain esperedin that is transformed in HT in the body and excreted in the urine fluid. In this work several urine samples of a person that drank 1 L of orange juice were obtained at different times, treated with glucuronydase, extracted with organic solvent and analyzed. HT enantiomers were separated employing a capillary column packed with silica particles modified with phenyl-carbamate-propyl-b-cyclodextrin. Triethylammonium acetate buffer (1%, v/v, pH 4.5) and water/methanol (30:70, v/v) was the mobile phase used to elute in isocratic mode the studied enantiomers. The

metabolism was stereoselective finding S-HT about five times higher than its antipode[21]. Figure 3 reports the nano-LC separation of the two enantiomers of HT present in an extract of human urine sample obtained after drinking orange juice.

Another interesting class of chiral selectors, widely studied and applied in HPLC, is represented by modified polysaccharides (cellulose or amylose). Conventional columns where the CS is either coated onto the silica surface or bonded to the particles are commercially available[24-29].

The work done till now with these CSs utilizing microfluidic techniques is scarce and therefore some examples will be proposed here to document the potentiality of such capillary columns.

Chankvetadze’s group widely studied different types of modified cellulose or amylose CS adsorbed onto silica particles utilizing CLC/nano-LC and comparing the results with the ones achieved in capillary electrochromatography (CEC)[30-34]. The capillary columns packed with porous material containing the polysaccharides

Figure 3. nano-LC chromatogram of hesperetin enantiomers separation present in an extract of human urine sample obtained after drinking orange juice. Capillary 100 mm I.D.x22 cm packed with phenyl-carbamate-2-propyl-b-CD silica; mobile phase, 1% (v/v) TEAA pH 4.5 in methanol/water 70/30 (v/v), flow rate 400 nL/min (modified from ref. [21].).

Page 7: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S

Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169 167

allowed to obtain good enantiomeric separation of various classes of compounds including carboxylic acids, basic drugs, nutraceutical compounds etc.

Recently two different types of silica (fully porous and core-shell) were modified adsorbing with cellulose tris(4-chloro-3-methylphenylcarbanate). The CSP was applied to the separation of some selected enantiomers using both nano-LC and CEC. Surprisingly core-shell material offered higher efficiency in CEC than in nano-LC generating sufficient electroosmotic flow even if the silica material is limited compared to the porous one. Enantioresolutions for ethozoline, praziquantel and thalidomide as high as 8.51, 9.85 and 4.52 were obtained by using CEC with core-shell particles packed in a capillary column of 75 mm I.D.[35].

In another study we evaluated the enantioresolu-tion of compounds of pharmaceutical and food chemistry interest employing nano-LC and CEC with capillaries packed with core-shell particles coated with amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate). The CS was coated at concentrations in the range 1-5 % and the pore size of the support was 100 and 300 A. Both techniques allowed to obtain the enantioresolution for all studied compounds with slight better performance in CEC. As expected lower electroosmotic flow (EOF) was observed by increasing the concentration of the CS; on the contrary enantioresolution increased. The highest efficiency in both nano-LC and CEC was obtained using 1 % of amylose. From the obtained results it is noteworth mentioning that core-shell particles can offer advantages over fully porous silica due to the possibility to run nano-LC at higher mobile phase flow rates without compromising the efficiency of the separation. This is shown in Figure 4 where the enantioseparation of 4’-methoxyflavanone is obtained at different flow rates. As can be observed in the figure, at 1.5 mL/min baseline resolution of the studied flavanone derivative was obtained in a short analysis time (less than 1.5 min). The experiments were carried out with a laboratory assembled instrumentation without necessity of high pressure[34].

Fast chiral separations are a challenging issue in separation science and recently several groups paid

attention to this topic. The use of core-shell material is one way to reach the goal, however recently new technology such as ultra high performace liquid chromatography (UHPLC) was developed. Dedicated instrumentation is available not only for conventional column but also for nano-LC. The basic principle behind this technique is the reduction of particles diameter. Reducing d causes a reduction of plate height (increase of efficiency) and a modification of the second part of van Deemter plot (more flat). This means that increasing the flow rate efficiency will not change too much, however shorter analysis time are obtained. Sub-2 mm particles are used in conventional columns of 2.1 mm with generation of very high pressure and need of special pump capable to operate at P> 800 atm. In our laboratory these particles have been packed into capillaries for 10-15 cm length operating without problems with a laboratory assembled

Figure 4. nano-LC enantioseparation of 4’-methoxyflavanone obtained at different mobile phase linear velocities. Capillary column: 100 µm I.D.x23 cm packed with core-shell silica particles (2.6 µm, 100 Å pore size) coated with amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) at 2% (w/w) concentration. Mobile phase, 500 mM ammonium acetate buffer pH 4.5/H2O/MeOH/ACN (1:24:20:55, by vol.). (unplublished results).

Page 8: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography

168 Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169

Figure 5. Separation of some selected herbicides and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs enantiomers using a capillary column packed with silica hydride modified with vancomycin stationary phase. Capillary column: 75 µm I.D.x 11 cm packed 1.8 µm vancomycin-diol hydride-based silica particles. Mobile phase: 500 mM ammonium acetate buffer pH 4.5/H2O/MeOH 5/10/85 (v/v/v), flow rate ~ 230 nL/min (herbicides) and 500 mM ammonium acetate buffer pH 4.5/H2O/ACN 1:9:90 (v/v/v), flow rate ~ 360 nL/min (NSAIDs). (modified from ref. [36]).

basic compounds, while very high enantioresolution factors were observed for acidic compounds such as anti-inflammatory drugs, herbicides and derivatized aminoacids. Based on the results achieved by NMR it was concluded that the different behavior can be ascribed to the secondary interactions between enantiomers and silica substituents, e.g., the hydride CSP does not contain free silanol groups[36].

As an example of good performace of the novel CSP towards the separation of acidic compounds, Figure 5 shows the separation of some selected herbicides and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. As can be observed the acidic compounds were baseline resolved with high Rs in a relatively short time.

5. Conclusions and future trendsCLC/nano-LC are powerful tools that can be used

for the separation and analysis of enantiomers present in different matrices such as biological, food bio-medicine etc. Two different enantiomeric separation methods can be applied, however, the direct one can offer better results. The CS can be either added to the mobile phase or bonded to the stationary phase or to the capillary wall. The microfluidic techniques offers some advantages over conventional ones, e.g., lower consumption of mobile phase and/or stationary phase, reduced cost for waste, higher mass sensitivity, perfect coupling with mass spectrometry etc. Fast chiral separations can be obtained employing particles of lower diameter (increasing the efficiency and the flow rate-decreasing retention time). Advantages can be also obtained utilizing core-shell particles where more homogeneous material is obtained with analytes-CS interactions take place only on the outside of particles.

In conclusion new material and new chiral selectors need to be studied and developed for chiral separations employing capillaries as well as chip technology.

AcknowledgementsThanks are due to Dr Silvia Rocchi for the data

related to the use of chiral stationary phases in nano-LC performed during her PhD thesis.

instrumentation of nano-LC. The system was applied also for chiral separations derivatizing with vancomycin 1.8 mm hydride diol-silica particles[22,34].

The novel CSP, fully porous, was packed 11 cm in silica capillary columns (75 mm I.D.) and used for enantiomers separation employing a laboratory assembled nano-LC instrument. The results obtained were compared with the ones achieved using a ordinary 5 mm silica particles modified with vancomycin (same conditions). The novel sub-2 mm CSP exhibited lower enantioselectivity than the column packed with conventional particles analyzing

Page 9: Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography · Microfluidic separation techniques, including electromigration and liquid chromatography have been studied, developed and applied

Chiral Separations Using Nano-Liquid Chromatography Fanali C, D’Orazio G, Fanali S

Scientia Chromatographica 2016; 8(3):161-169 169

References[1] S. C. Stinson, Chem. Eng News, September 19, 38-72 (1994).

[2] B. Chankvetadze, Capillary electrophoresis in chiral analysis, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, UK, 1997, pp. 1-555.

[3] D. W. Armstrong, Y. B. Tang, S. S. Chen, Y. W. Zhou, C. Bagwill, J. R. Chen, Anal. Chem 66, 1690-1695 (1994).

[4] S. Fanali, G. D’Orazio, K. Lomsadze, B. Chankvetadze,, J. Chromatogr. B 875, 296–303, 2008.

[5] G. Gubitz, M.G. Schmid, Chiral separation principles. An introduction in Chiral separations Methods and Protocols, G.Gubitz and M.G. Schmid, Humana Press Totowa, New Jersey, 2004, pp. 1-28.

[6] C. E. Dalgliesh, J. Chem. Soc. 137; 3940-3942 (1952).

[7] A. Rocco, Z. Aturki, S. Fanali, Trends Anal. Chem. 52; 206–225 (2013).

[8] J. P. C. Vissers, H. A. Claessens, C. A. Cramers, J. Chromatogr. A 779; 1-28 (1997).

[9] G. Guiochon, F. Gritti, J. Chromatogr. A, 1218; 1915-1938 (2011)

[10] S. Fanali, S. Rocchi, B. Chankvetadze, Electrophoresis 34; 1737-1742 (2013).

[11] G. D’Orazio, S.Fanali, J. Sep. Sci. 31; 2567-2571 (2008).

[12] S. Fanali, Z. Aturki, G. D’Orazio, A. Rocco, A. Ferranti, L. Mercolini, M. A. Raggi, J. Sep. Sci. 33; 2663-2670 (2010).

[13] T. Takeuchi, J. High Resolut. Chromatogr. 14; 560-561(1991).

[14] A. Rocco, S. Fanali, J. Sep. Sci., 32; 1696 – 1703 (2009).

[15] N. Rosales-Conrado, M.E. Leon-Gonzalez, A. Rocco, S.Fanali, Curr. Anal. Chem. 6; 209-216 (2010).

[16] A. Rocco, A. Maruška, S. Fanali, Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 402; 2935–2943 (2012).

[17] J. Vindevogel, J. van Dijck, M. Verzele, J. Chromatogr. 447; 297-303 (1988).

[18] B. Chankvetadze, C. Yamamoto, Y. Okamoto, Chemistry Letters 32; 850-851 (2003).

[19] B. Preinerstorfer, C. Hoffmann, D. Lubda, M. Lämmerhofer, W. Lindner, Electrophoresis 29; 1626-1637 (2008).

[20] G. D’Orazio, A. Cifuentes, S. Fanali, Food Chem. 108; 1114-1121 (2008).

[21] K. Si-Ahmed, F. Tazerouti, A. Y. Badjah-Hadj-Ahmed, Z. Aturki, G. D’Orazio, A. Rocco, S. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 51; 225–229 (2010).

[22] S. Rocchi, C. Fanali, S. Fanali, Chirality 27; 767-772 (2015).

[23] H. Hofstetter, O. Hofstetter, V. Schurig, J. Microcol. Sep. 10; 287-291 (1998).

[24] G. Hesse, R. Hagel, Chromatographia, 6; 277-280 (1973).

[25] E. Francotte, R. M. Wolf, Chirality 3; 43-55 (1991).

[26] B. Chankvetadze, E. Yashima, Y. Okamoto, J. Chromatogr, A 694; 101-109 (1995).

[27] P. Franco, A. Senso, L. Oliveros, C. Minguillon, J. Chromatogr. A 906; 155-170 (2001).

[28] M. Gegenava, L. Chankvetadze, T. Farkas, B. Chankvetadze, J. Sep. Sci. 37; 1083–1088 (2014).

[29] K. Gogaladze, L. Chankvetadze, M. Tsintsadze, T. Farkas, B. Chankvetadze, Chirality 27; 228-234 (2015).

[30] B. Chankvetadze, I. Kartozia, Y. Okamoto, G. Blaschke, J. Sep. Sci. 24; 635-642 (2001).

[31] B Chankvetadze, I. Kartozia, C. Yamamoto, Y. Okamoto, G. Blaschke, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 30; 1897–1906 (2003).

[32] B. Chankvetadze, C. Yamamoto, N. Tanaka, K. Nakanishi, Y. Okamoto, J. Sep. Sci. 27; 905–911 (2004).

[33] S. Fanali, G. D’Orazio, K. Lomsadze, S. Samakashvili, B. Chankvetadze, J. Chromatogr. A 1217; 1166-1174 (2010).

[34] S. Rocchi, S. Fanali, T. Farkas, B. Chankvetadze, J. Chromatogr. A 1363; 363-371 (2014).

[35] S. Fanali, G. D’Orazio, T. Farkas, B. Chankvetadze, J. Chromatogr. A 1269; 136–142 (2012).

[36] S. Rocchi, A. Rocco, J. J. Pesek, M. T. Matyska, D. Capitani, S. Fanali, J. Chromatogr. A 1381; 149–159 (2015).