citizen journalism and mainstream media in germany

39
A tale of two citizen journalisms Blogger Tour 2010 Visitor‘s Programme of the Federal Republic of Germany At the Invitation of the Federal Foreign Office Berlin, May 14, 2010 Matthias Spielkamp [email protected] Twitter: @spielkamp (mainly in German...)

Upload: spieli

Post on 18-Dec-2014

1.353 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

My presentation at the Bloggerreise (Blogger Tour) des Auswärtigen Amts (Foreign Office)

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

A tale of two citizen journalisms

Blogger Tour 2010Visitor‘s Programme of the Federal Republic of Germany At the Invitation of the Federal Foreign OfficeBerlin, May 14, 2010

Matthias [email protected]: @spielkamp (mainly in German...)

Page 2: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

www.immateriblog.de (since 2003)

Page 3: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

www.iRights.info (since 2005)

Page 4: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

www.recherche-info.de (since 2005)

Page 5: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Citizen journalism in Germany

1977: Radio Dreyeckland, Freiburg i.B.- "pirate radio" (Germany, France, Switzerland) - background: fight against nuclear power plants- legalized since 1988- funding:

- dues of approx. 1.500 members- 0.01 percent of public broadcasting fees of the state

of Baden-Württemberg

Page 6: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Free / Citizen / Non-commercial Radio

- 81 stations in Germany- radio and TV (so called "open channels")- instituted by law and publicly financed in three

states (Bremen, Lower Saxony, Northrhein Westphalia)

Page 7: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

taz - die tageszeitung

Page 8: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

taz - die tageszeitung

founded 1978/79 in West Berlin by journalists and non-journalists as a response to the political and journalistic situation during and after the so-called German Autumn ("Deutscher Herbst")

Page 9: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

taz - die tageszeitung

today an established left-wing nationwide daily with a circulation of >55.000 copies, 250 employees

Page 10: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

indymedia

Page 11: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

indymedia

"Indymedia is a collective of independent media organizations and hundreds of journalists offering grassroots, non-corporate coverage."

Page 12: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Wikinews

Page 13: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Weblogs

- few general interest / politcal weblogs- no German equivalent to Huffington Post- no German equivalent to Spot.us or ProPublica

Page 14: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Weblogs

Page 15: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Weblogs

Page 16: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Weblogs

Page 17: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Weblogs

Page 18: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Weblogs

Page 19: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Weblogs

Page 20: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Crowdsourcing

- no example of crowdsourcing project by German mainstream media I know of

Page 21: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Crowdsourcing | Data Driven Journalism

- Open Data Network

Page 22: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

abgeordnetenwatch.de

Page 23: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

mapnificent.de

Page 24: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

bundestagger

Page 25: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

wahlversprechen.info

Page 26: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

Crowdsourcing | Data Driven Journalism

none of these is financed or supported by mainstream media

Page 27: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

S.B. Johnson: Five things...

Page 29: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

S.B. Johnson: Five things...

1. Mainstream, top-down, professional journalism will continue to play a vital role in covering news events, and in shaping our interpretation of those events, as it should.

Page 30: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

S.B. Johnson: Five things...

2. Bloggers will grow increasingly adept at covering certain kinds of news events, but not all. They will play an increasingly important role in the interpretation of all kinds of news.

Page 31: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

S.B. Johnson: Five things...

3. The majority of bloggers won't be concerned with traditional news at all.

Page 32: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

S.B. Johnson: Five things...

4. Professional, edited journalism will have a much higher signal-to-noise ratio than blogging; examples of sloppy, offensive, factually incorrect, or tedious writing will be abundant in the blogosphere. But diamonds in that rough will be abundant as well.

Page 33: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

S.B. Johnson: Five things...

5. Blogs -- like all modes of contemporary media -- are not historically unique; they draw upon and resemble a number of past traditions and forms, depending on their focus.

Page 34: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

S.B. Johnson: Five things...

So here's my proposal:if you're writing an article or a blog post about this issue, and your argument revolves around one or more of these points -- and doesn't add anything else of substance -- STOP WRITING. Pick a new topic. Move on. There's nothing to see here.

Page 35: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

MSM

Page 36: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

MSM - FAZ, May 3, 2010

Page 37: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

MSM - FAZ, May 3, 2010

... the casual reader is sickend bythe smell of the gutter that arises from the blogs...

Page 38: Citizen Journalism and Mainstream Media in Germany

It ain't over yet...