11A

City Council Meeting Correspondence12/ 4/ 2018

ADOPT AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA ANA ESTABLISHING NEW

BOUNDARY LINES OF THE WARDS OF THE CITY OF SANTA ANA AND REPEALING ORDINANCE NO, NS -2826

Date of Name Representative of In Favor In Opposition CommentCorrespondence of RA*. of RA.*

1 12/ 4/ 2018 George M. Collins Santa Ana Resident Yes

2 12/412018 Chris Schmidt Santa Ana Resident Yes

3 1214/ 2018 Ken Nguyen Santa Ana Resident Yes

TOTAL: 3

RA - Recommended Action

Wednesday, December OS, 2018 Page 1 of 1

Orozco, Norma

From: Huizar, Maria

Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2018 1: 35 PMTo: eComment

Subject: ECOMMENT: Item 11A Agenda December 4 2018

Categories: Correspondence

From: George M. Collins [

Sent: Tuesday, December 4, 2018 1: 28 PMTo: Huizar, Maria < MHuizar@santa- ana. org> Subject: Item 11A Agenda December 4 2018

Mayor,

Councilmember' s.

I live in ward 6. 1 have standing.

I believe it is in the best interest of Santa Ana to make sure any redistricting is done by ward. I do not want my votediluted because the original redistricting was done by city and not by ward.

The only FAIR way to make sure every candidate that is willing to serve has an equal chance of winning anelection. Unless redistricting is done AFTER any ward boundaries are changed the redistricting will not properly representthe voters in the ward. There will not be a FAIR representation for the ward.

George M. Collins

Before I send this to

ecommentCa santa-ana.org.

Does the city use any special names for redistricting, ward boundaries, is there a commission that still exists and how do Ifind the members that are on the commission or committee?

Thanks

Orozco, Norma

From: Chris S <

Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2018 2: 52 PMTo: eComment; City CouncilCc: Huizar, Maria; Carvalho, Sonia R.

Subject: 11A. ADOPT AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA ANA

ESTABLISHING NEW BOUNDARY LINES OF THE WARDS OF THE CITY OF SANTA ANA

AND REPEALING ORDINANCE NO. NS -2826

Attachments: SEC 101- 2jpg

Mayor and City Council Members, If you read Sec 101. 2 of the City Charter which covers Ward Boundary changes, it clearly states there are ONLY 3 reasons

why it would be reasonably necessary to redraw Ward Boundaries:

Shown necessary by most recent Federal Decennial Census Data

more current census data certified by the City Council as sufficiently reliable and detailed to serve as a basis

forward boundary alteration

or by annexation or consolidation of territory

Our city redraw ward boundaries in 2012 using the 2010 Census data, and we have not annexed or consolidated any

new territory into our city.

So when did the city council certify more current census data, other than the 2010 Census data, to be reliable and

detailed to serve as a basis for ward boundary alteration?

The Demand Letter dated March 6`h- 2018 from the Asian Americans Advancing Justice regarding the CVRA violation does

not mention anything about requiring the Ward Boundaries to be redrawn or altered. The Demand Letter only asks that

our city transition from At -large to District -based elections.

So if we are still using the 2010 Federal Census Data and we have not met any of the 3 criteria mentioned in Sec 101. 2 of

the City Charter, then there is absolutely nothing reasonably necessary to redraw Ward Boundaries since we already didthat in 2012.

Kind regards,

Chris Schmidt

Sec. 101. 2. - Wards, boundary changes.

Ward boundaries shall not be altered except as reasonably necessary to promote greater equality of population among

the wards when such necessity is shown by the most recent federal decennial census, or by more current census data

certified by the City Council as sufficiently reliable and detailed to serve as a basis for ward boundary alteration, or by

annexation or consolidation of territory. Such boundary alteration shall be made only by ordinance adopted by

affirmative vote of at least two-thirds ( 2/ 3 ) of the full membership of the City Council in accordance with section 101. 4.

Any such ordinance adopted within one hundred twenty (120) days immediately preceding any election of council

members shall not become effective until the day following such election.

EN

rata Ana, CA Search CL

California f PART I - THE CHART... / ARTICLE[. - INCOR... Sec. 101. 2. - Wards,... -; C

AUG 8, 2018 (CURRENT)–*

ITA ANA MUNICIPAL CODE

PLEMENT HIS=TORY TABLE

T I - THE CHARTER

kRTICLE I. - INCORPORATION AND

UCCESSION

Sec. 100. - Name of city.

Sec. 101. - Boundaries.

Sec. 101. 1. - Wards of the city.

Sec. 101. 3. - Reserved.

Sec. 101. 4. - Same— Notice and

It -1111-

Prop. of 4-9- 57, approved on 4- 1657; Prop. of 2-4-63, approved on 4-2- 63

027; Ord. No. NS -1316, 8-24-76, approved at election 11- 2-76; Ord. No. NS -

approved at election 6- 3-80; Ord. No. NS -1864, 8- 19-86, approved at electii

sec. 101. 2. R Wards, boundary changes.'

Ward boundaries shall not be altered except as reasonably necessary

greater equality of population among the wards when such necessity is sh

most recent federal decennial census, for by more current census data ceri

City Council as sufficiently reliable and detailed to serve as a basis for war(

alteration, or by annexation or con soliclation' of territory. Such boundary a

be made only by ordinance adopted by affirmative vote of at least two -thin

the full membership of the City Council in accordance with section 101. 4.

ordinance adopted within one hundred twenty (120) days immediately prE

election of council members shall not become effective until the day follovelection.

Prop. of 4-9- 57, approved on 4- 16- 57; Prop. of 2-4-63, approved on 4-2-63

027; Ord. No. NS -1316, 8-24-76, approved at election 11- 2- 76)

Orono, Norma

From: Huizar, Maria

Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2018 6: 34 PMTo: eComment

Subject: FW: Nguoi- Viet Daily News article published 12/ 01/ 2018

Categories: Correspondence

Please enter into the record.

Original Message -----

From: Ken Nguyen [ mailto: kennguyen104@gmail. com]

Sent: Tuesday, December 4, 2018 5: 39 PMTo: Huizar, Maria < MHuizar@santa- ana. org>; Mitre -Ramirez, Norma < NMitre- Ramirez@santa- ana. org>

Subject: Re: Nguoi-Viet Daily News article published 12/ 01/ 2018

Hi Maria,

The article in support of item 11A. Please help to add this information into eComment@santa- ana. org as well.

Thankyou,

Ken Nguyen

Sent from my Whone

On Dec 4, 2018, at 5: 15 PM, Ken Nguyen < kennguyenl04@gmail. com> wrote:

Vietnamese residents have a better chance of being elected to Santa

lei

so ngaoi &n di tap the` ducngang qua khunghia trang lang Diu, hay con goi la thonNghia Trang, thi tran Yen My thi phithien cac bat hucrag dat tren nhieu ngoiM6 bi iiap vd lien bio voi chime quyen diaphucing.

Xem tie"p tang BB

Kh®i tai san' kech su' tua

gia diinh ®ng Tran Bac Hatai BinhDinh

r

Khu Resort Hoang Gia Quy WdtOng Han WcTU, phL(ftg G1

Quy Nhon, tinh Binh Dinh. (Hinh:

BINH DINH, Viet Nam (NirTran Bac Ha, cliu clm Lich Hoi DoiTri Ngm Hang Dau Tu VA Phit"INam (BIDV Bank), ngdoi vifa bfCanh Sat Dieu Tra Bo Cong An7giam, cokho"itai saa "ke'chsit" taiBu

Hom 30 Thing Mnai Mot, 2CTien Phong cho biet̀ mot trongkho"i tai sdn ldn tai Binh Dinh alio

Xem tie"p

01

Phong)

OngQuan

On Viet

i Quan

t tam

bio

w.a rvvvu aivicia, u uc u1uOc 1V1arIlOn:, Ke tL nam

2014 td nay, cb the dalay cap cdc dV kien ca nhancua khoang 500 trieu khdch hhng.

Tin nay cilia ra lam cha"n do, ng thuong tru8ng, khie'n tri gid co' phieeu tong ty rot gan 5%, xuo"ngcon $115 mot co phie"u trtidc gist thi trtibng ch 3ngkhoin New York mo ciia, theo ban tin cila hang . thongtdn Reuters,

Cong ty Marriott not do"i voi 327 trieu khachhang cila ho, cac tin tdc bila"

y di c5 the` gore ci cacchi tie"t ve so thSng hanh, so Nn tboal va dia chiemail. Wivdimotsokha; c6thebt'laymafcactin: t& thetmdur Luaho , y

Cong tynoY ang ho bee"t ve coot taan tong nayXem tiep tang A2 Hirsh minh hoa: AP)

N90i 96 el co Cd bbi C80

CLI din Little Sagon song tai Santa Ana ! @n tdichiem̀ 113%. (tfinh: Ngtfdi Viet)

SANTA ANA, CaliforniaNV) - Hoe Dong Thanh Pho 1

Santa Ana viia bie"u quyet viec = chop ban do cbia dia hat chinhth1Yc de' cu ddn bau chop nghivien then khu vlic.

44ng CiaoNguoi Vet

Theo ban do khu vvc chinh

th((c nay viia thong qua hom 20 Thing mu&iMot, khuA, thuoc pbia Dong SamaAna,1a notcd dart go"c Viet tap trung dong duc nha"t trongsdu khu vuc.

Ba"u theo khu vtfc la co hoi ra"t to"t de` ngtioi

Xem tiep̀ tang A10

Tu® i tho Mgmingyiaveafiva su dung thu®c qui lies

V)- IUVI

tho d My gidm trong mun 2017 trongI(lc ngay Gang co nhieu ngti6i tiet(i vas(t dung thuoc qua lieu,"da°y so' tooltrung birth cna din My xuo"ng tbap

u

A10• NGUO7VIfi1 - a t-f{altyaa uwmuac ase, ThtVUy,01 thing l2- 2018( 25th6ug 10 nam Mau TUat) Saturday, December t 2018..

II DIA PHLIONG l

Nguoti go"c Viet co cat hoi cao do cu nghi vien tai Santa Ana TrUung Tieu Hoc Codk dugt trio tang74 tr„„ gAf azarcuoin9um net Bang Men Uu Hang Quoc Gia

Tfdp tranga7g6c Viet c6 the tranh cd 1980 den gib, va van mong PUP Ship hoc sinh loan khigiptr6ngaivekythu4tchic nghj vi@n vdi hyv9ng ® main to mot dai diOn cut tWbnS phot buy tinh thin trong I6p bar. Su them giadaccd cao. minh 6 thanh ph6. Dung ciu ilea, shot quen hoc tap d6ng g6p cua pity huynh

Biu thea toanthinhph6 -- ra cbuyon nay pbai say chuy@n cin, limb Men tri cung rat manh me; phinho td tradc d6n nay air ra tit leu r6d. Nan nhd, Idc curd nhdng ky ning khac huynh c6 nh!6u cd hot d£ kh6 cho ngd6i g6c Viet A ; trd6c, ngd6i Viet minh Ship hoc sinh dat thanh hoc hot va tham gia cic lopSanwAnac6gim80%lag6c - m61 qua My' din rut nhau qua trongviec hoc. Tra6ng hd6ng din, phit buy tinhHispanic, mol sac din khnc' vd day. Vd sau, khi c6 khu Cook rang c6 Nhom H6 thin lash dao. Mukhongth619tvio. Phutdc Loc Tho, ho m6i to Try Hoc Sinh vi nhang Theo Bo Giao Duc Tieu

Phan d6ng cd din g6c - v6 Westminster va Garden chudngtrL h daYkem khat Bang California, ChuangViet tai Santa Ana tit chin _ Grove.” giAp hoc sinh dat mpc ti@u Trinh Tuyen Dddng Cacphin trd6c tin nay. Nhdng t6 Ong ring hit hili thu6c va tuy6n during su thing TWbng Uu Hang Thuocc6 nhdng ngubi khong b r6i dpi tat: " Thieq khbng Uncuacicem. Dao Luft Giao Duc Cipthinh ph6 nay cung t6 ra u6ng cling t6t ch6 dpi Tai Im6ng Cook, cic em Tieu Hoc va Trung Hocvuim3ngkhengk6m. 38 nam. Cam on nhang hoc sinh chd dong trong ( ESEA) ghi nhen thanh tich

Ong Phnt Bbl, nghi vien " ngutb! am Ihdm tranb' da"u vier gm gia van hda vam6l hoctep xuitsac cua nhangthanh ph6 Garden Grove, cho quyen lyl ngubi g6c tnOng h9c tip cat minh. tWeag nhin quyhen bang. reovuh" Diyli tin vat. H6i Viet. Thi Wt Ming phni Mot so hoc sinh gia vai Chddng trinh nay tuy2nThing Ba t6i c6 via dung ty nhi@n ma c6 daoc allay trd sa gia his bink nham dddng nhdng tMdng tr@nmots6ngd6lg6cVietcbng

rMSaAUAM

h6m nay ddu. Xin cam an khuy6n khich cic ban kbnc town qu6c nhi bit vd! thighAV phidn hap Hot Ding Lr••.+.arw tat ca nhbng at c6 cling mb cung hda thuon v6i nhau. qua hoc t4pxu6tsacc6ah9cThnnh Ph6 Santa Ana rid dubng cho ngd6i g6c Viet Nhdnghgcsinh We thaw sinh cung abut giam brit suunghQ nghj quyetnay." ga a a via Hot D6ng Thinh Ph6. gia Nh6m Ky- Thuit rid h6 chmhlechv6thanhqunglaa

C6 mot nghi vi6n g6c 01=2201=22®

Daylathanhph6c6angd6i try va hd6ng din cic ban cic nh6mhoc sinh.( L'.N.) Viet tai Santa Ana la mot Ban do C-3 iliac ch9n lam chfnh thdc ngay 4 Thing Mu61 Hal, g6c M6TayComi c6ngd2dviec tit hay A dtdu nay not 201a.( Hinh: santaana.org) g6c Viet lot van, Phil nhi la.

I6nddycs4din chit thycsy kyc6ng." can midc My. Quart tryng kh6mg c6 earth gid! tharth Kk chobi6tdiyMmotdMu C1111906ngatfic6thAda tit tWdc den gib van birth cindaocbiove"( Protectedhon. cut din g6c Viet c6 dai ph6." tit ding rating cho cd din rytre, dody. thut6ng. Bbl voy, t6i nghi ai Class). Trong A nay, 24, 374dionn6dlantiunw, nguyen Ngoii ra, viec c6 nghl g6cViettalSantaAna. Ong Cang Nguyen, cd lam nghi vi@n thl Gang voy la ca tri g6c Viet, can dourv9ngc6ah9," 6ngtl6p. vi6n g6c Viet tai Santa Ana " Van bi6t nghj vi6n din Santa Ana, n6iv6itha! thoi." got la CVAP ( Citizen

Gini thick ly do bng co cung la mot didu c6 Iot thanh ph6 Phil to viec do da dib "Ban nht@u nam H6i Thing Ba nam Voting Age Populationm4ttaiphtenh9pH0iD6ng cho Garden Grove. Ong chungchomoiNdintrong nay, bo may hank chinh b nay, Nghj Vida Vicente ( Dan S6Tuoi BduCd). Thinh Ph6 Santa Ana d6 gini thich: "Garden Grove khu vac cua minh, nb9ng diydinhutv3yr6!vikh6ng Sarmiento la ngu6l c6 Ong Phan Ida cd din Viet6ngh0nghjquy6tnay, 6n9 Pam cha' WMo Wick Golf n6u li ngd6i g6c Viet thl ai phan nim. Bay gib, n6u din My manh rid nghj bio Nam cd ago trongkhu vaccho hay, la chi rich Cong Comse' rang gin 100 mai it nbiiu cung c6 chat cam nghj vi@n g6c Viet vie, c6 ngbi vien theo khu vac nay A• phia Do % SamaAna. D6ngNgut6iViet Qu6c Gia tai 3017 W. Fifth St., Santa thong cho nhdng van rid thud cii' status quo' bj 110 no nghltrinh. Ski Nang Phan giaa ty' 1p

Nam California, bng cin Ana. Dat cua Garden ngubi g6c Viet quan tam; iron. Lac do ngadi to se Ong nhi: " Tat rat vul cit tri g6c Hispanic vdi cuban ve quyin I91 can nhidu Grove, nhunglainamtrong giro sun6i. quay lei ma d6 thtia nodi rating khi thiy cd din got tri Sic Viet vi da tring chohot vi@n b nhieuadi tr@n ilia hat Santa Ana. Cd mot La TWdng Ban Tri Sy sump" Hispanic va g6c Viet cung thiy to rang, tit tNdc denCalifornia. nghj Ada g6c Viet, t6i by Glno Hot Phot Glao Hba Tro6c kh! di, bng not: szrcanhben nhaud6lamdd nay, Hol D6ng Thnnh Ph6.

Ho 6 Santa Ana, vault sd doa d6n mot giii Hao Mien Nam California, " Day la con dao had Idol. luetnaythanhluit" Santa Ana thi6u su g6p mitFountain Valley, vi nhi6u phip cA hai bila cimgc6loi, bng lam viec tai Hot Quin Phai cin than chi kh6ng Theoth6ngkdm6inhit, caadaidioncuacacsacdanthanh ph6 khnc. O ddu thi nghla la ca din hai thank Phot Gino Hba' Hno thuoc phi! chili." thanh ph6 Santa Ana c6 khnc, mchito4nnlpuAg6ct6iceagd9utnwhchoh9," ph6seddychd6nglyi." Santa Ana. Ba Cao Phdon& cd din 324,583 cd din, trong do, Hispanicmath6l. bng Wong quydt moi. " Xm Glio So Nguydn Thanh Ong Tommy Thai Santa Ana, n6i v6i thii do 36,845 la ngabi g6c Viet, nh6, viec ban ve quyen Id Gia t, chd rich Ho! Ding Nguyen, cu din Santa Ana, binh thin: "T6i thay cuoc chi6m 11. 3% tr@n t6ng s6 @n lac ticgia' ngabi g6c Viet, v6i t6i, LlenT6nVietNamTatHoa W6itool:" T6i6diytun5m sung cua tui tad Santa Ana W dart, dooc col Ii' nh6m ngo.giao@nguoi-vietccm.