civil procedure in cross-cultural dialogue: eurasia context

ÌÎÑÊÂÀ 2012

INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF PROCEDURAL LAW

CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

SUPREME COURT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

SUPREME ARBITRAZH COURT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

ASSOCIATION OF LAWYERS OF RUSSIA

MOSCOW STATE LOMONOSOV UNIVERSITY

CIVIL PROCEDURE IN CROSS-CULTURAL DIALOGUE:

EURASIA CONTEXT

IAPL World Conference on Civil Procedure18–21 September, 2012,

Moscow, Russia

CONFERENCE BOOK

Edited by Dmitry Maleshin

УДК 347.9ББК 67.410 C 58

С 58 Civil Procedure in Cross-cultural Dialogue: Eurasia Context: IAPL World Con-ference on Civil Procedure, September 18–21, 2012, Moscow, Russia: Conference Book / Ed. by Dmitry Maleshin; International Association of Procedural Law. – Moscow: Statut, 2012. – 608 p. – На английском языке.

ISBN 978-5-8354-0874-0 (hardcov.)

The idea is to discuss the evolution of civil procedure in different societies, not only in the well-known civil or common law systems, but also in different countries of Eurasia, Asia, etc. Civil procedure in Europe and North America is a subject of enormous scientific and practi-cal importance. We know a lot about these systems. But we do not know enough about civil procedure in the rest of the world. How does it work and what are the main principles? Cul-ture is one of the main factors that makes civil procedure of these countries different. There-fore it is necessary to discuss the main links between different systems of civil procedure.

The discussion was held on the basis of national report from 24 countries, at the all there were participated from more than 40 countries.

УДК 347.9ББК 67.410

ISBN 978-5-8354-0874-0

Printed in the Russian Federation

© Authors, 2012© Translators, English translation, 2012

© Statut Publishing House, editing, proofreading, layout, 2012

ORGANISING TEAMOF THE CONFERENCE

Dmitry Maleshin, coordinator (Moscow State Lomonosov University);

Nataliya Bocharova, website, general support (Moscow State Lomonosov University);

Tatiana Moiseeva, executive secretary (Moscow State Lomonosov University);

Lubov Skulskaya, visa assistance (Moscow State Lomonosov University);

Daria Simakova, registration (Monomax Congresses)

572

LIST OF PRESIDIUM, COUNCIL AND MEMBERS OF THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF PROCEDURAL LAW

(as of July 2011)

PRESIDIUM

Professor Loïc CadietEcole de droit de la Sorbonne – Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne President

Professor Oscar G. ChaseNew York University School of LawVice President (North America)

Professor Masahisa DEGUCHIRitsumeikan University Faculty of Law, Japan Vice president (Asia)

Professor Eduardo OTEIZAArgentinaVice president (South America)

Professor Michele TARUFFOIstituto di diritto privato e processuale, Pavia, ItalyVice President (Europe)

Professor Neil H. AndrewsClare College, Cambridge, United KingdomSecretary General

Professor Burkhard HESSRuprecht-Karls-Universität HeidelbergSecretary General

Professor Manuel ORTELLS RAMOSUniversitat de València, Facultad de derecho, SpainExecutive Secretary General

ProfessorJanet WALKER Osgoode Hall Law School of York University, Toronto, Ontario, CanadaSecretary General

List of Presidium, Council and members of the International Association of Procedural Law

573

COUNCIL

Professor Teresa ARMENTA DEUFacultad de Derecho, Universitat de Girona, GIRONA, Spain

Professor Teresa ARRUDA ALVIM WAMBIERPontificia Universidade Católica de São Paulo, Brazil

Professor David Newton BAMFORDFlinders University School of Law, Australia

Professor Paolo BIAVATIItaly

Professor Remo CAPONIIstituto di Diritto Privato e Processuale, Facoltà di Giurisprudenza, Italy

Professor José Roberto DOS SANTOS BEDAQUETribunal de Justiça de S. Paulo, Brazil

Professor Laura ERVOUniversity of Örebro School of Law, Sweden

Professor Frédérique FERRANDUniversité Jean Moulin, Lyon, France

Professor Fernando GASCON INCHAUSTISpain

Professor Moon-hyuck HOSeoul National University School of Law, South Korea Professor Dr. Miklós KENGYELUniversity of Pécs Faculty of Law, Hungary

Professor Angela Ester LEDESMAArgentina

Professor Dmitry MALESHINMoscow State Lomonosov University Law Faculty, Russia

Professor Richard L. MARCUSHastings College of the Law, San Francisco, USA

Professor Vytautas NEKROŠIUSVilnius Univesity, Lithuania

Appendices

574

Professor Dr. Dr.h.c. Walter H. RECHBERGERInstitut für Verfahrensrecht – Universität Wien, Austria

Professor C.H. (Remco) VAN RHEEUniversiteit Maastricht, Faculteit der Rechtsgeleerdheid, Netherlands

Prof. Dr. Michael STÜRNER,Europa-Universität Viadrina Frankfurt (Oder)Lehrstuhl für Bürgerliches Recht, Internationales Privatrecht und Rechtsvergleichung, Germany

Professor Rolf STÜRNERAlbert-Ludwigs-Universität, Institut fur deutsches und ausländisches Zivilprozessrecht, Freiburg, Germany

Professor Piet TAELMANUniversity of Gent Faculty of Law, Belgium

Professor Alan UZELACUniversity of Zagreb Faculty of Law CROATIA

Professor Garry D. WATSONOsgoode Hall Law School,York University, Toronto, Canada

HONORARY MEMBERS

Honorary Presidents

Professor Marcel STORMEUniversity of Gent, Belgium

Professor Peter GOTTWALDUniversität Regensburg – Fakultät für Rechtswissenschaft, Regensburg, Germany

Professor Federico CARPIUniversity of Bologna, Italy

Honorary Members of the Presidium

Professor José Carlos BARBOSA MOREIRARio de Janeiro, BrazilHonorary Vice President

Professor Ada PELLEGRINI GRINOVERSão Paulo, BrazilHonorary Vice President


575

Professor Yasuhei TANIGUCHISenshu University Law School, Tokyo, JapanHonorary Vice President

Professor Keith UFFFaculty of law University of Birmingham, United KingdomHonorary Secretary General

Honorary Members of the Council

Professor Aguda T. AKINOLALagos, Nigeria

Professor Italo ANDOLINADipartimento di diritto processuale civile – Università di Catania, Italy

Professor Wouter de VosUniversity of Cape Town School of Law, South Africa

Professor Victor FAIREN GUILLENMadrid, Spain

Professor Héctor FIX-ZAMUDIOUniversidad National Autónoma de México, Instituto de Investigaciones juridícas, Mexico

Professor Bryant G. GARTHSouthwestern Law School, Los Angeles, USA

Prof. em. Dr. Dr.h.c. Dr.h.c. Peter GILLESInstitut für Rechtsvergleichung Johann Wolfgang Goethe Universität Frankfurt/M, Germany

Professor Walther J. HABSCHEIDGermany

Professor Konstantinos D. KERAMEUSHellenic Institute of International and Foreign Law, Athens, Greece

LL. D Sakari LAUKKANENUniversity of Turku, University of Joensuu and Technical University of Lappeenranta, Finland

Professor Dr. Per Henrik LINDBLOMUniversity of Uppsala, Sweden

Appendices

Professor Janos NEMETHBudapest, Hungary

Professor Jacques NORMANDFaculté de Droit et de Science Politique de Reims, Reims, France

Professor Roger PERROTUniversité de Paris II, France

Professor Zhivko STALEVSofia, Bulgaria

577

MEMBERS

ALBANIA

Professor Ledina MANDIA

ARGENTINA

Professor Roland AraziFundación de estudios superiores e investigación, Buenos Aires

Professor Roberto Omar BERIZONCE

Professor Pedro Juan BERTOLINO

Professor Fernando DE LA RUA

Professor Mabel Alicia DE LOS SANTOS

Professor Osvaldo Alfredo GOZAÍNI

Professor Juan Carlos HITTERS

Professor Mario Ernesto KAMINKER

Professor Angela Ester LEDESMA

Professor Héctor Eduardo LEGUISAMÓNUniversity of the Argentine Social Museum. University Institute of the Argentine Federal Police. University of Buenos Aires. University of Morón.

Professor Rita MILL DE PEREYRAFacultad de derecho, U.N.N.E.

Professor Eduardo David OTEIZA

Professor Jorge Walter PEYRANO

Professor Jorge Armando ROJAS University of Buenos Aires

Appendices

578

Professor Alberto Osvaldo VARELA WOLFMr Francisco VERBIC

AUSTRALIA

Professor David Newton BAMFORDFlinders University, School of Law

Professor Neil James WILLIAMSUniversity of Melbourne, Faculty of Law

Professor Ted WRIGHTUniversity of New Castle School of Law

Professor Dr. William Van CaenegemBond University School of Law

AUSTRIA

Professor Dr. Wolfgang JELINEKKarl-Franzens Universitat Graz, Institut für Zivilgerichtliches Verfahren

Professor Dr. Georg E. KODEK, LL.M.Wirtschaftsuniversitaet Wien, Institut für Zivil- und Unternehmensrecht

Professor Dr. Franz MATSCHERÖsterreichisches Institut für Menschenrechte, Internationales Forschungszentrum Edmundsburg

Professor Dr. Paul OBERHAMMERUniversität Wien. Rechtswissenchaftliche FakultätInstitut für Zivilverfahrensrecht

Professor Dr. Dr.h.c. Walter H. RECHBERGERInstitut für Verfahrensrecht – Universität Wien

Prof. Dr. Marianne ROTH, Universität Salzburg

Professor Dr. Günter H. ROTHUniversität Innsbruck

Professor Mag. Dr. Daphne-Ariane SIMOTTAInstitut für Zivilgerichtliches Verfahren an der Karl-Franzens-Universität Graz


579

BELGIUM

Prof. dr. Benoît ALLEMEERSCHInstitute for Civil Procedure Law, Faculty of Law, Tiensestraat 41

Prof. dr. Karen BROECKXFaculty of Law, Instituut voor Procesrecht

Prof. dr. Georges DE LEVALFaculté de droit-Sart-Tilman

Prof. dr. Alphonse KOHL

Professor Ernest KRINGS

Prof. dr. Paul LEMMENS

Professor Paul MEIJKNECHT

Prof. dr. Marie-Thérèse MEULDERS-KLEIN

Prof. Dr. Dr.h.c. Marcel STORMEUniversity of Gent

Prof. dr. Matthias STORMEKatholieke Universiteit Leuven

Prof. dr. Piet TAELMANFaculty of Law, Instituut voor Procesrecht

Prof. dr. Jacques VAN COMPERNOLLEU.C.L. Faculté de Droit – College Thomas More

Prof. dr. Paul VAN ORSHOVENKatholieke Universiteit Leuven

BENIN

Professor Joseph DJOGBENOUAgrégé des facultés de droit

BOTSWANA

Professor Geoffrey Matthews KAKULIUniversity of Botswana, Department of Law

Appendices

580

BRAZIL

Professor Teresa ARRUDA ALVIM WAMBIERUniversity of São Paulo

Professor José Carlos BARBOSA MOREIRACOPACABANA-RIO DE JANEIRO

Professor Sidnei Agostinho BENETI

Professor Sérgio BERMUDES

Professor Marcos Afonso BORGES

Professor Petrônio CALMON ALVES CARDOSO FILHOInstituto Brasileiro de Direito Processual

Professor José Joaquim CALMON DE PASSOS

Professor Alexandre Antonio Franco FREITAS CÂMARA

Professor Hélio Márcio CAMPO

Professor Carlos Alberto CARMONA

Professor Athos Gusmão CARNEIRO

Professor José Rogério CRUZ e TUCCI

Professor Sálvio DE FIGUEIREDO TEIXEIRASuperior Tribunal de Justiça, Brasilia

Professor Carlos Alberto Alvaro de Oliveira

Professor Fredie Souza DIDIER JrUniversidade Federal da Bahia, Faculdade de Direit, Salvador

Professor Candido Rangel DINAMARCO

Professor Antonio DO PASSO CABRALUniversity of Rio de Janeiro

Professor José Roberto DOS SANTOS BEDAQUETribunal de Justiça de S. Paulo

Professor Paulo Henrique dos Santos LUCON


581

Professor Adroaldo FURTADO FABRÍCIOFaculdade de Direito da UFRGS

Prof. Dr. Aluisio Goncalves DE CASTRO MENDES

Professor Galeno LACERDA

Professor Antonio Carlos MARCATO

Professor Luiz Guilherme MARINONI

Professor Daniel MITIDIERO Faculdade de Direito da Universidade

Professor Egas Dirceu MONIZ DE ARAGÃORua Abraham Lincoln, 262, 80310-530 Curitiba (Parana’)Tel.: +55-41-2423166

Professor Dr. Nelson NERY JÚNIORPontifícia Universidade Católica de São Paulo, Faculdade de Direito

Professor Ada PELLEGRINI GRINOVER

Professor Ricardo PERLINGEIRO MENDES DA SILVA

Professor Nelson Luiz PINTO

Professor Guilherme RIZZO AMARAL

Dr. Carlos Alberto de SALLESUniversidade de São Paulo – Faculdade de Direito

Professor Cassio SCARPINELLA BUENO

Professor Humberto THEODORO JÚNIOR

Professor Kazuo WATANABE

Professor Flávio Luiz YARSHELL

Prof. Hermes ZANETI Jr

BULGARIA

Professor dr. Valentina POPOVAJuristische Facultät der Sofioter Universität, Sofia

Appendices

582

Professor Dr. Zhivko STALEVSofia

CANADA

Professor H. Patrick GLENN

Professor Daniel JUTRAS

Professor Catherine PICHE Faculty of Law Université de Montréal

Professor Janet WALKEROsgoode Hall Law School of York University, Toronto

Professor Garry D. WATSONOsgoode Hall Law School,York University, Toronto

Professor Frederick H. ZEMANSOsgoode Hall Law School,York University, Toronto

CHILE

Professor Arturo Felipe ONFRAY VIVANCOFacultad de Derecho. Universidad Diego PortalesE mail: [email protected]

Professor Hugo PEREIRA ANABALON

Professor Raul TAVOLARI OLIVEROS

CHINA

Professor Guang-zhong CHENChina University of Political Science and Law, Beijing

Professor Wei.-dong CHENLaw School, Renmin University, Beijing

Doctor Huang FENGMinistry of Justice People’s Republic of China

Professor Yu-lin FUSchool of Law, Peking University, Beijing

Professor Wei JIANRen Min University of China


583

Professor Rong-jun LIUInstitute of Law, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS), Beijing

Professor Wei-jian TANGLaw School, Renmin University, Beijing

Professor Min-yuan WANGInstitute of Law, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS), Beijing

Professor Jinxi WANGInstitute of Evidence Law and Forensic ScienceChina University of Political Science and Law

Professor Ya-xin WANGLaw School of Tsinghua University

Professor Qiu-hong XIONGChinese Academy of Sociel Sciences (CASS), Beijing

Professor Song-nian YINGLaw Department of State Administration College, Beijing

Professor Baosheng ZHANGChina University of Political Science and Law (CUPL)

Professor Jian-wei ZHANGLaw School, Tsinghua University, Beijing

Professor Wei-ping ZHANGLaw School, Tsinghua University, Beijing

Professor Hai-feng ZHAOSchool of Law – Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin

COLOMBIA

Professor Ramiro BEJARANO GUZMÁN Departamento de Derecho Procesal. Universidad Externado de Colombia.

Professor Hernán Fabio LOPEZ BLANCODepartamento de Derecho Procesal. Universidad Externado de Colombia.

Professor Jairo PARRA QUIJANO

Professor Diana María RAMÍREZ CARVAJALUniversidad de Medellìn. Jefatura del Doctorado en Derecho ProcesalContemporàneo

Appendices

584

COSTA RICA

Professor Dr. Sergio ARTAVIA BARRANTES

Dr. Olman Arguedas SALAZAR

CROATIA

Professor Dr. Mihajlo DIKAZagreb University Law Faculty

Professor Dr. Alan UZELACZagreb University Law Faculty

CZECH REPUBLIC

Professor Judr. Alena WINTEROVAPravnicka fakulta University Karlovy

DENMARK

Professor Dr. Ole LANDO

Professor Eva SMITHUniversity of Copenhagen, Institute of Legal Science

EGYPT

Professor Azmy Abdul Fattah ATEIAUniversité El Mansoura-Faculté de droit

Professor El Meligi OSAMAFaculté de Droit de l’Université du Caire, Cairo

Professor Fathi Ismail WALYUniversité du Caire

FINLAND

Professor Laura ERVOUniversity of Örebro School of Law

Professor Irma LAGERUniversity of Helsinki

LL. D Sakari LAUKKANENUniversity of Turku, University of Joensuu


585

and Technical University of LappeenrantaJustice of the Court of Appeal

Justice Gustaf MÖLLER

FRANCE

Professeur Soraya AMRANI MEKKI Université Paris 10 – Nanterre

Professor Jean Louis BERGEL Université d’Aix-Marseille III

Professor Georges BOLARD

Professor Loïc CADIETEcole de droit de la Sorbonne – Université Paris I

Professor Cécile CHAINAISUniversité de Picardie Jules Verne, Faculté de droit et de sciencepolitique

Professor Thomas CLAYUniversité de Versailles, Faculté de Droit

Professor Frédérique FERRANDUniversité Jean Moulin, Lyon

Professor Francoise GRIVART DE KERSTRAT Faculté de Droit, Université d’Aix-en-Provence

Dr. Dominique HASCHERl’Université Paris I

Professor Emmanuel JEULAND

Professor Pierre JULIENUniversité de Nice, Faculté de Droit

Professor Eric LOQUIN

Professor Marie-Laure NIBOYETUniversité Paris Ouest Nanterre La Défense

Dr Marie NIOCHEUniversité Paris Ouest Nanterre La Défense

Appendices

586

Professor Jacques NORMANDFaculté de Droit et de Science Politique de Reims

Professor Roger PERROTUniversité de Paris II

Professor Jean-Pierre ROYER

Professor Yves STRICKLERUniversity Nice Sophia AntipolisFaculty of Law

GERMANY

Professor Dr. Jens ADOLPHSENLehrstuhl für Bürgerliches Recht, nationales und internationales Zivilverfahrensrecht und Sportrecht, Licher

Professor Dr. Jürgen BASEDOW

Professor Dr. Dagmar COESTER-WALTJEN

Notar Professor Dr. Reinhold GEIMER

Professor em. Dr. Dr.h.c. Dr.h.c. Peter GILLESInstitut für Rechtsvergleichung, Johann Wolfgang Goethe Universität

Professor Peter GOTTWALDUniversität Regensburg – Fakultät für Rechtswissenschaft

Professor Dr. Wolfgang GRUNSKYUniversitat Bielefeld

Professor Dr. Dres.h.c. Walther J. HABSCHEID

Professor Dr. Wolfgang HAUUniversität Passau, Juristische Fakultät

Professor Dr. Dr.h.c. Wolfram HENCKEL

Professor Dr. Burkhard HEßRuprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg

Professor Dr. Peter HUBERUniversität Mainz

Professor Dr.Abbo JUNKER


587

Professor Dr. Harald KOCHJuristische Fakultät, Humboldt Universität zu Berlin

Professor Dr. Stefan LEIBLEUniversität Bayreuth, Rechts- und Wirtschaftswissenschaftliche Fakultät

Professor Dr. Dr.h.c. Dieter LEIPOLDAlbert-Ludwigs Universitat

Professor Dr. Wolfgang LÜKELehrstuhl für Bürgerliches Recht Zivilverfahrensrecht und Rechtsvergleichung Technische Universität

Professor Dr. Peter MANKOWSKISeminar für ausländisches und internationales Privat

Professor Dr. Heinz-Peter MANSELUniversität zu Köln, Institut für Internationales und Ausländisches Privatrecht

Professor Dr. Dieter MARTINYEuropa-Universität Viadrina

Professor Dr. Christoph G. PAULUSHumboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Juristische Fakultät

Professor Dr. Thomas PFEIFFERInstitut für ausländisches und internationales Privat- und Wirtschaftsrecht der Universität Heidelberg

Professor Dr. Hanns PRÜTTINGInstitut für Verfahrensrecht der Universität zu Köln

Prof. Dr. Thomas RAUSCHERJuristenfakultät – Universität Leipzig

Professor Dr. Herbert ROTHUniversität Regensburg, Juristische Fakultät

Prof. Dr. Ingo SAENGERWestfaelische Wilhelms-Universitaet MuensterInstitut für Internationales Wirtschaftsrecht

Professor Dr. Peter SCHLOSSER

Rechtsanwalt und Notar Professor Dr. Dr. h.c. Rolf A. SCHÜTZE

Appendices

588

Professor Dr. Kurt SIEHR

Professor Dr. Ulrich SPELLENBERGLehrstuhl für Zivilrecht, Internationales Privatrecht und Rechtsvergleichung der Universität Bayreuth

Professor Dr. Astrid StadlerJuristische Fakultät, Lehrstuhl für Bürgerliches Recht und Zivilprozessrecht

Professor Helmut STEINBERGERMax-Planck-Institut für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht

Prof. Dr. Michael STÜRNEREuropa-Universität Viadrina Frankfurt (Oder)Lehrstuhl für Bürgerliches Recht

Professor Dr. Rolf STÜRNERAlbert-Ludwigs-Universität, Institut fur deutsches und ausländisches Zivilprozessrecht

Professor Dr. Gerhard WAGNERUniversität Bonn - Rechts-und Staatswissenschaftliche Fakultät

GREECE

Professor Paris S. ARVANITAKISAristotle University of ThessalonikiFaculty of Law, Economics and Political SciencesLaw Department

Professor Dr. Dr.h.c. Kostas BEYS

Dr. Ioannis DELIKOSTOPOULOSLecturer in Law at the University of Athens

Professor Dr. Georgios DIAMANTOPOULOSAristotle University of Thessaloniki

Dr. iur. Konstantinos GIANNOPOULOSResearch Institute for Procedural Studies

Professor Dr. Athanassios KAISSIS

Professor Dr. Nikolaos KATIFORISNational and Capodistrian University of Athens, Faculty of Law,


589

Professor Dr. Dres.h.c. Konstantinos D. KERAMEUSHellenic Institute of International and Foreign Law, Athens

Professor Dr. Nikolaos K. KLAMARISNational and Capodistrien University of Athens – Institute of Procedural Studies

Professor Kalliope Th. MAKRIDOUAristotle University of Thessaloniki,Faculty of Law

Professor Dr. Dr.h.c. George MITSOPOULOSUniversité d‘Athenes

Professor Dr. Georgios ORFANIDISInstitut für prozessuale Studien, Akadimisas

Professor Dr. Constantine POLYZOGOPOULOSUniversity of Athens

Professor Dr. Pelayia YESSIOU-FALTSIAristotle University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Law

Professor Dr. Dimitrios TSIKRIKASUniversity of Athens

GUATEMALA

Professor Mario AGUIRRE GODOY

HUNGARY

Dr. Viktória HARSÁGI Pázmány Péter Catholic UniversityFaculty of Law, Department of Civil Procedure Law,Budapest

Professor Dr. Miklós KENGYELUniversity of Pécs, Faculty of Law

Professor Dr. János NÉMETH

INDIA

Professor K.B. AGRAWALIndian Institute of Comparative Law

Appendices

590

Mr. Justice Arun MADANIndian Association of procedural law, c/o Indian Law Institute, JAIPUR

Professor Yadlapalli VISHNUPRIYA

INDONESIA

Professor Paulus LOTULUNG

Professor S. H. SETIAWAR

IRAN

Dr. Hassan MOHSENIUniversity of Tehran, Faculty of Law & Political Sciences

Dr. Majid POUROSTAD

ISRAEL

Professor Eliahu HARNONThe Hebrew University of Jerusalem-Faculty of Law

Professor Michael KARAYANNIFaculty of Law, The Hebrew university of Jerusalem

Professor Shimon SHETREETHebrew University of Jerusalem Faculty of Law

Professor Celia WASSERSTEIN FASSBERGHebrew University of Jerusalem Faculty of Law

ITALY

Professor Italo ANDOLINADipartimento di diritto processuale civile, Università di Catania

Professor Chiara BESSO MARCHEISUniversity of Turin

Professor Paolo BIAVATI

Professor Girolamo BONGIORNO

Professor Domenico BORGHESI


591

Professor Antonio BRIGUGLIO

Professor Remo CAPONIIstituto di Diritto Privato e Processuale, Facoltà di Giurisprudenza

Professor Federico CARPIIstituto di applicazione forense «E. Redenti»

Professor Sergio CHIARLONI

Professor Vittorio COLESANTI

Professor Luigi Paolo COMOGLIOUniversità degli studi di Pavia

Professor Claudio CONSOLO

Professor Giorgio COSTANTINOUniversità «Roma Tre» Facoltà di Giurisprudenza

Professor Marco DE CRISTOFAROUniversità di Padova

Professor Giuseppe DI FEDERICO

Professor Angelo DONDIUniversità di Genova

Professor Giuseppe FINOCCHIAROUniversità degli Studi di Brescia

Professor Mariacarla GIORGETTI

Professor Andrea GIUSSANI

Professor Sergio LA CHINA

Professor Francesco Paolo LUISO

Professor Michele Angelo LUPOI

Professor Elena MARINUCCIUniversità degli Studi Milano-Bicocca

Luca PASSANANTE

Appendices

592

Ricercatore nell’Università di Brescia

Professor Nicola PICARDI

Professor Andrea PROTO PISANI

Professor Carmine PUNZI

Professor Achille SALETTI

Professor Elisabetta SILVESTRIUniversity of Pavia

Professor Michele TARUFFOIstituto di diritto privato e processuale

Professor Nicolò TROCKERUniversità degli studi di Firenze

Professor Giulio UBERTISUniversità di Milano-Bicocca

Professor Vincenzo VARANOUniversity of Florence

Professor Giovanni VERDEUniversità LUISS

Professor Vincenzo VIGORITIUniversità degli Studi di Firenze

Professor Francesca ZANNOTTIFacoltà di Scienze Politiche dell’Università di Bologna

Professor Elena ZUCCONI GALLI FONSECA

JAPAN

Professor Dr. Masahisa DEGUCHIRitsumeikan University

Professor Yukiko HASEBEGakushuin University

Professor Dr. Yasunori HONMANagoya University


593

Professor Dr. Tatsuo IKEDAOsaka University

Professor Dr. Akira ISHIKAWA

Professor Makoto ITOWaseda University

Professor Weidong JIKobe University

Professor Dr. Masanori KAWANO

Rechtsanwalt Professor Dr. Toichiro KIGAWA

Professor Ichiro KITAMURA

Professor Takeshi KOJIMAYokohama University

Professor Noboru KOYAMA

Professor Dr. Hiroyuki MATSUMOTO(office) Ryukoku University Kyoto

Professor Koichi MIKIKeio University

Professor Dr. Dr.h.c. Hideo NAKAMURA

Professor Shunichiro NAKANOUniversity of Kobe

Professor Munehide NISHIZAWAAoyama-Gakuin University

Professor Masahiko OMURAChuo University

Professor Dr. Koji SHINDO

Professor Masahiro SUZUKI

Professor Hiroshi TAKAHASHIChuo University

Appendices

594

Professor Morio TAKESHITA

Professor Yasuhei TANIGUCHISenshu University

Professor Manabu WAGATSUMATokyo Metropolitan University

KOREA

Prof. Dr. choong-soo HANHanyang Law School

Professor Young-joo HAMChung-Ang University

Professor Moon-hyuck HOSeoul National University

Professor Kyeng-wook KIM

Professor Sang-soo KIM

Professor Yong-Jin KIM Taejon School of Law Chungnam National University

Professor Gyoo-ho LEEChung-Ang University

Professor Sang-hyun SONGSeoul National University College of Law

LESOTHO

Hon. Mr. Justice T.E. MONAPATHIPalace of Justice

LITHUANIA

Professor Valentinas MIKELÉNASVilnius Universitetas

Professor Vytautas NEKROŠIUSVilnius University


595

MAROCCO

Professor Abdellah BOUDAHRAIN

MEXICO

Dr. Gonzalo M. ARMIENTA CALDERÒN

Professor Eduardo FERRER MAC-GREGOR POISOT

Professor Dr. Héctor FIX-ZAMUDIO

Dr. Fernando FLORES-GARCIA

Professor Macarita ELIZONDO GASPARIN

Dr. Jorge I. GODINEZ GUTIERREZ

Professor Josè OVALLE FAVELA

Professor Sergio Garcia RAMIREZ

NEW ZEALAND

The Honourable Christopher Francis FINLAYSONAttorney-General, Parliament Buildings

Graham D. S. TAYLOR

NIGERIA

Professor Aguda T. AKINOLA

NORWAY

Professor Inge Lorange BACKERUniversitet I Oslo

Dr Anna NYLUNDUniversity of Tromso

PANAMA

Professor Jorge FABREGA P.

Professor Abel Augusto ZAMORANO

Appendices

596

PERU

Professor Juan Federico MONROY GÁLVEZ

Professor Juan José MONROY PALACIOS

Professor Carlos PARODI REMÓN

Professor Anibal QUIROGA LEON

Professor Adrián SIMONS PINO

POLAND

Professor Maria BORUCKA-ARCTOVA

Professor Dr. Witold BRONIEWICZUniversity of Lòdz, Faculty of Law and Administration

Professor Dr. Tadeusz ERECINSKI

President of the Supreme Court

Professor Dr. Kazimierz LUBINSKI

Professor Dr. Mieczyslaw SAWCZUKMaria Curie-Sklodowska University, Faculty of Law, Department of Civil Procedural Law and International Commerce Law

Dr. Anna SWIDERSKA-CICINELLIUfficio della Promozione del Commercio e degli Investimenti dell’Ambasciata della Republica di Polonia

PORTUGAL

Professor Joao Antonio ALVARO DIAS

Professora Paula COSTA E SILVAFaculdade de Direito da Universidade de LisboaAlameda da Universidade (Faculdade de Direito)

Professor Carlos Manuel FERREIRA DA SILVA

Professor José Manuel LEBRE DE FREITAS

Professor Álvaro REIS FIGUEIRAProfessor Dr. Miguel TEIXEIRA DE SOUSA


597

REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA

Professor Cojuhari Alexandru NICHIFOR

REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA

Professor Pamela Jane SCHWIKKARDUniversity of Cape Town

Professor Dr. Andries Charl CILLIERS

Professor Wouter DE VOSUniversity of Cape Town

Professor Roshana Alice KELBRICKUniversity of South Africa

Professor S. SANDILE NGCOBO

REPUBLICA DE CABO VERDE

Professor Jorge Carlos DE ALMEIDA FONSECA

Dr. Antonio Manuel MASCARENHAS GOMES MONTEIROPresident of the Republica de Cabo Verde

ROMANIA

Professor Sebastian SPINEI«Lucian Blaga» University

RUSSIA

Professor Nataliya S. BOCHAROVAMoscow State Lomonosov University

Professor Maria FILATOVARussian Academy of ForeignTrade

Professor Rimma KALLISTRATOVARussian Academy of Law

Professor Dmitry MALESHINMoscow State Lomonosov University

Professor Irina V. RESCHETNIKOVAUral State Law Academy

Appendices

598

Professor Alexander VERSCHININSaint-Petersburg State University

Professor Elena VINOGRADOVAInstitute of State and Law ot the Russian Academy of Sciences

Professor Vladimir V. YARKOVUral State Law Academy

SENEGAL

Dr. Seydou BACourt Supreme

SERBIA

Professor Vesna RAKIC VODINELIC

SINGAPORE

Professor Hock Lai HONational University of Singapore

SLOVAKIA

Katarína GEŠKOVÁComenius University in Bratislava

SLOVENIA

Professor Aleš GALIČUniversity of Ljubljana

SPAIN

Professor José ALMAGRO NOSETETribunal Supremo

Professor Sara ARAGONESES MARTINEZ

Professor Dr. Teresa ARMENTA DEU

Professor Lorena BACHMAIER WINTER

Professor Dra. Dra. h.c. Silvia BARONA VILAR University of Valencia


599

Professor José BONET NAVARRO Universitat de València, Facultad de derecho

Professor Lorenzo-Mateo BUJOSA VADELLUniversidad de Salamanca

Professor Dr. Andrés DE LA OLIVA SANTOS

Professor José DE LOS SANTOS MARTIN OSTOS

Professor Ignacio DÍEZ-PICAZO GIMÉNEZ

Professor Manuel Serra DOMINGUEZ

Professor Dr. Carlos ESPLUGUES MOTAUniversity of Valencia

Professor Dr. Victor FAIREN GUILLEN

Professor Regina GARCIMARTÍN MONTERO Universidad de Zaragoza

Professor Fernando GASCON INCHAUSTIUniversidad Complutense de Madrid

Professor Vincente GIMENO SENDRAUniversidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia

Professor Juan-Luis GÓMEZ COLOMERUniversidad Jaime I, Departamento de Derecho Público

Professor Jesus GONZALEZ PEREZ

Professor Faustino GUTIERREZ ALVIZ Y CONRADI

Professor Rafael HINOJOSA SEGOVIA

Professor Francisco LÓPEZ SIMÓ Universidad de las Islas Baleares

Professor Juan MONTERO AROCA

Professor Manuel ORTELLS RAMOSUniversitat de València

Professor Ernesto PEDRAZ PENALVA

Appendices

600

Professor Joan PICÓ I JUNOYUniversidad Rovira i Virgili

Professor Dr. Francisco RAMOS MENDEZ

Professor Carmen SENÉS MOTILLA Universidad de Almería

Professor Isabel TAPIA FERNÁNDEZ Universidad de las Islas Baleares

Professor José Luis VAZQUEZ SOTELO

SWEDEN

Professor Torbjörn ANDERSSONUppsala University

Professor Gunnar BERGHOLTZUniversity of Lund

Professor Dr. Christian DIESENUniversity of Stockholm

Professor Henrik EDELSTAMUniversity of Stockholm

Professor Lars HEUMANUniversity of Stockholm

Professor Ulla JACOBSSON

Professor Dr. Per Henrik LINDBLOM

Professor Bengt LINDELLUppsala University

Professor Roberth NORDHUppsala University

Professor Dr. Patricia SHAUGNESSYUniversity of Stockholm

Professor Dr. Per Ole TRÄSKMANUniversity of Lund


601

Professor Dr. Peter WESTBERGUniversity of Lund

SWITZERLAND

Professor Steven BERTI

Professor François BOHNET

Prof. Tanja DOMEJUniversity of Zurich

Professor Ulrich HAASUniversity of Zurich

Prof. Ingrid JENT-SØRENSEN

Professor Dr. Alexander MARKUSUniversité de Berne

Professor Dr. Isaak MEIERUniversity of Zurich

Dr. iur. Fridolin WALTHERRechtsanwalt, LL.M. (Yale)

Professor Dr. Gerhard WALTER

TAIWAN

Professor Dr. Shen KUAN-LINGNational Taiwan University

THE NETHERLANDS

Professor Dr. Daan ASSER

Professor Dr. Erhard BLANKENBURG

Paulien M.M. van der GRINTENMinistry of Justice

Professor Ewoud HONDIUSUtrecht University

Professor Dr. Robert JAGTENBERGERASMS Universiteit Rotterdam

Appendices

602

Professor dr. Anthonie W. JONGBLOEDUtrecht University

Prof. Dr. Xandra E. KRAMERErasmus University Rotterdam

Prof. Dr. Bart KRANSUniversity of Groningen

Professor Adnan Buyung NASUTION

Professor Dr. B.C. PUNT

Professor Anni J. de ROOERASMS Universiteit Rotterdam

Professor Dr. G. Robert RUTGERS

Professor Henk J. SNIJDERSUniversiteit Leiden

Professor Taco A. W. STERKUniversity of Leiden

Dr. Bartosz SUJECKI

Professor Dr. Toon VAN MIERLOErasmus Universiteit Rotterdam

Professor C.H. (Remco) VAN RHEEUniversiteit Maastricht

Dr. R.Ch. VERSCHUUR

Professor Dr. J.B.M. VRANKEN

Professor Wil G. Ph. E. WEDEKIND

TURKEY

Professor Baki KURU

Professor Dr. Ergun OZSUNAYIstanbul University

Av. Murat R. OZSUNAY, M.C.J. (U.T. Austin)Bar Assoc. of Istanbul & Frankfurt/M


603

Professor Hakan PEKCANITEZGalatsaray Üniversitesi

UKRAINE

Professor Zorian BAZYLEVYCH

Professor Svitlana KRAVCHENKO

UNITED KINGDOM

Professor Neil H. ANDREWSClare College Cambridge University

Mr. George APPLEBEYThe University of Birmingham

Professor J.W.K. BLAKIEUniversity of Strathclyde

Mr. Carla CRIFÒUniversity of Leicester

Ms Déirdre DWYERUniversity of Oxford

Professor M.S. DOCKRAYCity University

Professor Cyril GLASSERUniversity College

Professor Christopher J.S. HODGESOxford University

The Hon. Lord Leonard HOFFMANHouse of Lords

Professor Wendy KENNETTCardiff University

Professor Julian LONBAYUniversity of Birmingham

Professor C.G.J. MORSEKing’s College London

Appendices

604

Professor Rachael MULHERONSchool of Law, Queen Mary, University of London

Dr. K. P. NOUSSIAUniversity of Birmingham

Professor John PEYSNERUniversity of Lincoln

Professor I. R. SCOTTUniversity of Birmingham

Dr. John SORABJIJudicial Institute, Faculty of Law, University College, London

Professor W. L. TWININGUniversity College

Professor Keith UFFUniversity of Birmingham

Professor Adrian ZUCKERMANUniversity College

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Professor Samuel BAUMGARTNERUniversity of Akron School of Law

Professor Stephen BURBANKUniversity of Pennsylvania Law School

Professor Paul D. CARRINGTONDuke University School of Law

Professor Robert C. CASADThe University of Kansas

Professor Oscar G. CHASENew York University School of Law

Professor Kevin M. CLERMONTCornell Law School

Professor Mirjan DAMASKAYale Law School


605

Professor Theodore EISENBERGCornell University

Professor Owen M. FISSYale Law School

Professor Maryellen FULLERTONBrooklyn Law School

Professor Marc GALANTERUniversity of Wisconsin-Madison

Professor Bryant G. GARTH Southwestern Law School

Professor Antonio GIDIUniversity of Houston Law Center

Professor Simona GROSSILoyola Law School

Professor Dr. Peter HAYEmory University School of Law

Professor Geoffrey C. HAZARDHastings College of the LawUniversity of California

Professor Deborah R. HENSLERStanford Law School

Professor Helen HERSHKOFFNew York University, School of Law

Professor Peter HERZOGCollege of Law Syracuse University

Dr. Justice Earl JOHNSON Jr.

Professor Mary KAY KANEHastings College of the Law

Professor John H. LANGBEINYale Law School

Professor John LEUBSDORFRutgers Law School

Appendices

606

Professor Dennis LYNCHUniversity of Miami School of Law

Professor Thomas Orin MAINUniversity of the Pacific McGeorge School of Law

Professor Richard L. MARCUSHastings College of the Law

Professor Toni Marie MASSAROUniversity of Arizona College of Law

Professor James MAXEINERUniversity of Baltimore School of Law

Professor John Henry MERRYMANStanford Law School

Professor Linda S. MULLENIXUniversity of Texas School of Law

Professor Peter Loos MURRAYHarvard Law School

Professor Judith RESNIKYale Law School

Professor Thomas D. ROWE, Jr. Duke University School of Law

Professor Martin SHAPIROUniversity of California, School of Law (Boalt Hall)

Professor Edward SHERMANTulane Law School

Professor Linda SILBERMANNew York University School of Law

Professor Linda S. SIMARD Suffolk University Law School

Professor Lawrence B. SOLUMGeorgetown Law school

Professor Stephen SUBRINNortheastern University School of Law


Professor Ellen E. SWARDUniversity of Kansas School of Law

Professor Louise Ellen TEITZRoger Williams University School of Law

Professor Carl TOBIASUniversity of Richmond School of Law

Professor Joseph H. H. WEILERNew York University School of Law

Professor Margaret Y.K. WOONortheastern University School of Law

Professor A.N. YIANNOPOULOSTulane University Law

URUGUAY

Professor Jaime L. GREIFDr. Walter D. GUERRA PEREZ

Professor Margarita de HEGEDUS

Professor Martha JARDI ABELLA

Professor Angel LANDONI SOSA

Dr. Santiago PEREIRA CAMPOS

Dr. Luis María SIMÓN OLIVERA

Professor Edgar J. VARELA-MÉNDEZ

VENEZUELA

Professor Arminio José BORJAS HERNANDEZ

Professor Pedro J. MANTELLINI GONZÁLEZ

Professor Mariolga QUINTERO TIRADO

Professor Arístides RENGEL ROMBERG

Dr. Rodrigo Antonio RIVERA MORALESUniversidad Católica del Táchira

Научное издание

Гражданский процесс в межкультурном диалоге: евразийский контекст: Всемирная конференция

Международной ассоциации процессуального права, 18–21 сентября 2012 г., Москва, Россия

Сборник докладов

На английском языке

Civil Procedure in Cross-cultural Dialogue: Eurasia Context: IAPL World Conference on Civil Procedure, September 18–21, 2012, Moscow, Russia

Conference Book

Художественное оформление: В.В. СамойловаКомпьютерная верстка: О.Л. Божьева

Подписано в печать 21.08.2012. Формат 70х100 1/16. Бумага офсетная.Гарнитура Newton. Печать офсетная. Печ. л. 38. Усл. печ. л. 49,4. Тираж 1000 экз.

Заказ №

Издательство «Статут»:119454, г. Москва, ул. Лобачевского, д. 92, корп. 2;

тел./факс: +7(495) 649-18-06E-mail: [email protected]

www.estatut.ru

ISBN 978-5-8354-0874-0

civil procedure in cross-cultural dialogue: eurasia context

Documents

evolution of civil procedure

civil procedure1821

countries different

different countries

common law systems

different societies

conferencedmitry maleshin

russian federation authors