cl$r$lg oritrni$t pg$lt...
TRANSCRIPT
o-gcrajl a=g-rlil
cl$r$lg oritrni$t pg$lt h ltoas+f f a.r.b - a-.?ttlg Jr"njJl 5+r,j.e ;.ta3
fuSr.., 14ra.ai3 i L.r-^;3r : l?'r
.l\lYiu;-.1 rY'\ Y -!-I J-J. .1ril *,ll
d#Stl e^ci+tf L a+eEill di !.alri'J t, . r.itl rlt+rr;&19SJI ar.Ll qrlL i,r f.i-r.e, et-;i
i.itg -r...,1"1c-.r.1
qp ':jl
aJS - .-.rr(l a*;
r. >;Jl ,'rl ,i; -r... ..rL-Y
4{+-'Jl qlS -,-'ir<Jl asL
pY.\Y/-oltff
a.ftatf ar.b - arajf tj'16jJtjS;r
.1r!tr.slt -ll tll e.1/ tl. I Y#iri 5$tr[r9 iril$i[t psln nrp
e.iliiJl eit*iliq qrfritl rlsi,f.esll s.ir.ll d
+r(ll Ar.b qlllle g. ai{. ehl
. t,
r:l.J.r-i OJ..r.i
t"J:Jl ailS - '',iJ<ll ar t+
elJl dt-- ,) -r- .r
A#':Jl a{K -'-'{r<ll a-b
s.illl,rt :-:l our;.tt!|, ,rljJl *Jl ,r0i. or .i5lJ i..L :Jrt* ;-LJl "j. Jg-Y.\\/Y.t.s-Lrll lul ji-lrJl c--.71 sr"+aLJt F{+1ir.'-JSJI C.:+ll jot"l5Jl, ,-;! lar.';:':Jl € {r, nr. .-t* v}L cr +Jtl, Ut! \ \ f t &{ i.",}g! ii:.S U' lc* iLyl i-LJl cJrLr.:iJ;ilt :o ,t rll orFl, i-.Ll fL.ilt, '.- Ut
iJl.rJl ,.1:e r=itilJl c$L crr.i-<11., F+ll j *$Jl, *.i.;tlJl - ,:Jl .r"--.9.r.,ri.7)flJl
sjJdll oi4l c*Jl 6r+.r--l .:- trXlLYl oLlr-rJl o.;-l)Jl ru rw1 q;lr. ji-rAr ijr*lti.-! 4
!i.rll, i-}t '-t1, i;tlJl r$j.ii-q .. --tr tA Lr.:- t .Jtr j a-LJt .- ... ri,e;)[Jl +., . ,rrJfll C.:+fl d nt+ .ltr! j l] l.rr: !:-r! ,y-rJl Jl+rr aii:f l ;l c^+.r
:',Jl :lril 6l i*lrll .:':r tJ, cJl;! s:Jl lJr rq.r= i-L, itrll {Jr.-i._ ll i:-lt ,;l. "*t
--'Jl ;$l ir..rrr+ oU.;11 .:jl;! or;,-r 4Jt*,! Jl:;r,, , Jl ,pi, jl ;r97-
;rrtljl "s rr,.a- 6.r, g. -)&Jl .iir" j i-lrJl i;-Jl, ::l(Jl .r;;, rt'L i-!.iJl ,: .,s
;1..a1'1.;-l .t+ .ri^r- q:Jl LtJl dit --y'| g. r.4 i-lJ.rJl 4i s:. C.:+f l j k .Lnr
.traL J, - rr:ruJt "L i.."ty' i;lr -L!;r
;e!t.r6rt
l1r!tr.ult -rl trr ri?J / tY. t tJ{i# tiglr$rg i'+il,uig p gldt a tp
l-ule pll J*"_ :.il;;.Il .Jt5.:,l,= -.:Jtati Ot -Jt tj.l j Jllofu:.* -ll ;LJl .ra .,i;J.-tJl rr:.Jl ot-;.all +li r;Jlot_.r,.:Jl ,*i_l.r.o ,cU- LL-, . -rii.:Jlr i*r-JJ gUq;-; Cf .o./f U:.i i--rb crJ'l* ll*j L)l ,-*r *l.r.lt 6I1t $: ,,2-rC i-rr+, i;l OU v *Jlot 1!i-.r3 tr*tJ;, .3i illil.r:. '{i+ .,i ;ri- :*et-:?lr +-t- olrr*,
.torr+,
Pr ,rrt;)l C--r[:Jl e& ,ri b-rrr+ t-tr-hi:;-rb ;JrU ., -.:jU
.3.LL- .,. dtl lb,rfl-, qet^:?lr +rt'ii-r .l'"t*- cf,lrL., * ,)S;b-
.JiL.aJt,,,,.UJl, .t'ifL,,,i'itlJl t+t Flr-- i,;;,,^ i2,.,-a *.Jlot*allcJSi;- ;i ,tt -Yl u -# C .:-Ul ;ts. ?,-,_.-.2 .t'L.:;y! ,"'.t=.Jl,
.&t+J 411'l )l,..r_J cl-rL- flJ.-e.,rJl l.r.r -L_;ol.r-ll 6. .rli- ,f,!ll!l li. 0i ..jl ,jl f1ll .1tS* ;,r,L;U -,.r.y'| *tJl 6l.Jt € t*-y, y'Ut ,t .';l.iL; g g-*,1f +_"f f, i#tLil,ol,r"-a;Jl, oL;rJl :r-\- dre,_ tilr. .jj,:Jl, v. --Jl r..l g! a.rJl -rrLall.,J .*_ cr,,_.ijt JLilllr.r .Jl u Al-;]l C;iyl cr.ijril,.jyyl JUaj;.# )UJ ir3.,.$*i- o.,j-g lj.re ,,i_rJl, d.ltL,/ttJl .ddl t-t*.;ir-lll ot*atl i_tJ 6J"(JI ota*;lr;*yl ft I t :.iL.ll ;; otoS1
.LJt--:+. j ijr+sJlr rr+rll r*9- .g.rJlJr . .lt.l!l ljr O.
'*jl J. |b ctJ+ .iL; j Jfu_ *" -Jt oF -r!t ,ii_ t-r.,eiLtl,-. r'-:.,Ic.."1 lrJl.pEr t*-t- t_.rr.f5i;- tJ.e.:rFllr L-Alt.Q3 c[=1ti-.r3 e;UL .;Lr...-r .rL,l .l.rj, 0342 ,..o1;_e.ri$r3 ua_le.
.r;h-r f-"l;r {tlrE. u'i tlrol '6lt{.:*,/le|;:Jlot,+;lr*!l
,J9!t.urlt altrf s.J/tl .Ilr{irJ nr-ltrftg 6+itrtri[t pgkll il+D
i.,ti. - \;$l olt+ .iJ;; ',i ,=SJl ,rr.z- .,fiJlr ./Xl t 4l e*-.-,|-r-Y i)*,*.;Jl ll" r+r.r,,b9, .-r.oul !.y'lot -:.+IlC r.ct-+Yl
: ;L'l 1, ;jltrl f L.+l +L-J I ol.r-!l r ol+ ;;lr,. \t-4L .9t:.
.+:, J! -;1+ r.l,tllr t .- i*"*tl igttJl ,"klt !t;-! J! osl ll{rir .t1.i .*Blr .*t-r"Yl ;t+l C.). o. t-J g,r:Jl .,.'o^rjl
-.:.-l+L+!lr tur.;Jl ,J.lr.Jl cr..F ,;l+ b-,. bK- 'r, .:JlrcLi;Il .r.r ly'lCr":Jlr d)trll &lrL; l!;L;Yl, ,*lt t+t - cr +-,- dt +u:tt,.?1, ;l o)sillll ,5.r-!J'<.r, ;::-:Jl, r dl ilfu-i ,r.. --tl.r
.(vAr\ t t \ ..r-l ) ;J.rtJl * Jl ot-'-r,ll.*l; dloL-.r.*;Jl,,.l .r-l;p3- * --rlsl :.;t, ll lia j JiJlost :
iitiiJl F:+ d.rtJ6 (**-9t sll/utC i.rt 'r!le r=-i=-!t ;tlliJtr)l t#Lr-! o41 c) t{tt L irx-yl i-;l Lll ,r-l;,4t i;t
.1,JL&Ll,.
,jb- ,/l i:+Jfl 'rr.Jl ot'-:4lt .r-ir*-tJl "ijl g.:all .-,..:e
i:..r :ll i,rt-:-l I ;tJ I cruti .iL; € lr'2- t,="-,':,1 *& €V tr.L,tlal LJ C ..J ,?A = ,JU. ,pt-.;llr jtijJlr ,,-pl t{*,U+
+L+!l ot*3l1, f}"!l ,IL:: iiy+Ilr ..i-.-Jl r; pt+Ytr pX<tt
i-<iJlot*3l1 Arl CVv *lllb iJt? 4 blU-.p.-*Jr..+feJlr
iit--..4jl ol*3.je i.4.r6!1, i-t+l ot*3Jl "f
JUl.er LJ .ptiljl:
9y'1 ot--:411 b. ,r;S.i-.,S'Jl C.:+Jl ,il + ..fi ! k3 69.rJlr lXeylr+Ii, Yt*,i;r;L- d;.t,l q. dl lI l+ .."Lt?Yl
.5rur.jf:
:'i.J .lsi clc.r.i,.1e1ql .,;9!t+tltt
;leltr.r'rt Jl tff '-r..J / tY.l I t-iJ* iuJ r$lg it+ir$i$l p gldl h I 1 ^
i|/l ,/ eiL- W,ic*ll3 ;.tAlt i,jfll f}')l .JiL, C cl.,[.r.3
,L.,iil Jhft C l.l;*,_: +t-Jl cit'l.Jl j j*ji---r ,LrJ'(.Jyl
&t ill "iL; €,r*..rJ't<:"_r iitJLi;;Yl is1.t € d*s dr- i;L_,
.rLrul e-t ci ri it;:vt ilr*ll ,rr ri ilt ,*- ,st,l-ry r=-t*Jl\
n|; # cr i,->,_re;lrLil.,; .,l?iJlr,;;t.LJlq .,,,J1 !JtS.;! F:r*il; C oLc.23 dJl rl; at, tl ,t4l .r*i Ctr- CJJI s)UJlr,-i .*Jtc.i: t . \ \i \ . /r o g--rti LYI u-I+J,f-r*Jl $-.ijl Ct;il i*[:rF'itu l;?.+_ --$Jl tj.-:a. 4 u.*-;l +jJl *l_Ju.Jl: .:LrtJl .l!" Ji+fiU|, iJ.;Jlol,, Jlo-r; c..- +trl [+l-j c -r r3-rJl,ff &):4l.*-" t^rtiri -V ,irJl g*1, i-ul ijk+ll rF i .-:all L-:.Ji,t:
Ctr:,-r ."iFtlJl: Jjl Ll"-,. .71* ,rL, :;, ' t1 .-l$l dJ*:J t+/*
;r..rll,.-.rtJl.j,1.1 -,!illi_i;, ot,, Jl'id tiJ. t->U_)12 i-rLi-!l.;. ( \ ) "rlri:-Jl;. ,;Vl.i_J .t+ C .{.t" J:- cr prr
€r41,: d g+r C..+Jt € *c,rJl ol.r-Yl ;l ta;-,' ,\l *-i-,
,i # ,l *U f * i..11:)11 i..t=-Jl &Ut-;Jlr ol.r-il ,F -altL ,fn Lt u ol*i J*3 L lJlr r.-rjl iUJIJ(i .€ieJ! $: L4,. Lr. ln;,.-1r.rr"Yl &i Fi- liar f_, rl .,.;S,# ri
* r-J Jtott,r' i_rL!I, .t-5-,.r1, d ,*-r J- J!.* *.-"1, JJ Jl ;jb ir. ,tq--.Jl u -J C .r:.':ll i,+J> c.,2 1b.)l l.u
rz$; &Jlr'J .iJ, l jl" t-iG i;L Lt iJ I Lijtl"J I o!..-;.t I -,i.r,.e oLJ I
! *J, , ,E: :\.f-a; ;1.r t{-it*t .t+!l tr* .r*- i-*,-re JV'-AUKJY'l \/\'/Yog+tEA,)l .r".Ufe+.,'.:"tl J.iJl gtXrl f r)l,Jl ,*,r*r-ffi
.Y.lt/r./Yotjjs
.,ye!r.rr3tr1't-r.r...,i glc.t.i.lr!t.r.l*tt
.;9!tt.rrrtt .olilf rs.,1 /lt'llr:3l* Qgr$rg 6$ttui$l Pgf dr ilP
.ft^t"Yl tglr.'+ i',^, ireUi Wt t'r r*t'';l ;Jrt! ..-..a..:JU
qp;ttt,l+{+lr, &,f |#fu Jtl-:ll lb -, i-':i"..:i':lle'rUl,
..::ul.r ^ptiillr +t-."!l b'r+, iiur-C C r*itltJ)t; cr
tlr + ,1..-# .,5{ ! lr$ L*J i:r csl ,}t F 9l ; '--lU,v,p.+i.i.u 6lLi- Ji], slrt' ..;; Jl t c&l
"''tt ot":a-lt gSr
.rL,-iF ,ii t:J" .-q-- Lu3 ..rUir L-JSiJlr j:'\Jle liti:Jl o$LiJl
V+l-r:.|JI tid i:-L'il r-Ul.jt-:*-tof olJ'glr ':lbi 'l'r "-^'o'ull
.t+J&.-!,:Jl i u:j !.5-- ,hJl U.r iplt C JrYl ;rbU 6B L;rJl 'j'r ,,Jtt*L,::*LYl ,-uirl +n f c4 .tt *l ifl.,l Ct c22^J> *lr e .-i'sjl
J6; ;retlf l .i+J iJJl i*lrJl .jif- ltt2 ,t;+ai2'e l<l.i;j + Lt<Jl
,q ,j,W ,-,*?- Jl i-rlrl rP ,)# LJ i{aUl iLe .,r i-'ri
47le.C &K, l;L>tter)t- g.r"-IJ o+- *lt:*i+fl"t'aa-lr*'JlsL.iJl, dtlJl '= dl c,tr;;d J! ,t'r';'Jl, l..;-Jtr '4<'tJl J'lrtiJrtJl,.t",tL i3Jl .'r.r ,t' €t.:::ll tit":+' d,t''llr,,-tiJlJu + L-3: *r.-atJl oi-,SJl C.:+ll .,i 'lJl l'u rL'i..jt.K:-t i+Jl.l*Jl li.r rrLL.+ll j i-Li uL JSJ .ri td,J.-t- .i--5Jl i-t+ v)t!
;V ,tJUl r" tJ.r"-tJl .i-.;Sll g.t"-U llrJl ;orJt et:'L- :t5-- ''e'rJl
.(J?.JlftJlr 6lllJr,:-,lJJlutful-T
,:+ r-! 1\+rr .Li !F, Yt;,\)U*tlrF fJl '-l.Jt tnl; ,-J
;rb o.ri -d ,e,;i:Jl.i'L,-, -'IJt *-: J.jJI F- rf it" C.ft Jl .,...a,;lL,/*ll .--'oJl Ji-lo- ti,e, r9;1 ;rti glltl ;rti sljro2.- ,*dl lb i;L-r . l"l$i i-b c^il* :=--r..r qJlr- C ,l LiJl * *Jt+
.;rltr.rtlt -rltffe..l/tI .lY.j# iir-1trf 19 it*it$i}t p gldr a I l.
..J tt-;S'* CpJ . otz>)\ tt Otf,at !'/- u C3, € "ny
g,.-ar:Jt
,rl;i .lri *, C.:aJl ,r* ,j c.,.a / t. q.Ic f!b" ! ;l;)l6r, ;.5L)tlle ,:rlUl tJ e-:+ll ,t l.'..a-djl
.-?i dii:jt gUL C.:+Jl € ,::,.;- ct.r.r r, -dl i-12r3 . d!q.atf,
L,Fdfl c,Ut-iJl u Gi r.c te.rljL il! i"t^+yl ;tll salr l.Js
l-,' " rj rti;! if.+l i*jtl .,Ic Urt - gr i_tJl ,:*" J.i or: .tJJle
)* qg-rl i-[l .?)tl e,_jr .it-i**l C J.:J rl ,r. *Jl t* .,i .-f+-4.1-5t4 i-t+t C.7}LJLi.&--SJl C.:+tl *r o.rt.itle,:. -dl liri.elr :-lL a-J53-r.qJlorr..*_ lrll e..+il LL;J.iLi*-l j:_-t;l-l
,rlc ;r.uJl !-514.y)ttJl sictti & d_r.d!-r C+Jl t_14 i*r.;.i-"!l crl .F rlt o*_ L93 .ttU., C;4ll LbrY :.;^:- i:p (S./t.LJl v -Jl ireUi:3.r-e rtn!;_rSJl *l+ v}!.gir.;U*-t6t<r-J'-Yl
ir. (F r.o .:rHl: ^."t-+!lr<.1=-.1 f+*J* C.:+JlC #L
.ilL;l I c!U., t^rt+L ;.r.t!J I a.w gi rz;;,rJ I i++il:*bJl :u,.*l-r
: q-LlrrL. :-.ri.,i .-lrr!l ilu,l7:*!4;tlJl ^Jtt*iL
., -*Jl irrt.b rt r-:1 (,r. .it*r*-l j Jrllrdl Js^:,_ - \
. v)[Jt -b +t cr *UUlr iirJl: ':"1.;ll,
)t' € Jiiitlr i *:lJ .t'li:Jl ot4lLl o.c .i5JlC dt,JlJdl Jj-!- -Y
.,i..,t-., q" -' i,jlc t ;;::'J'liijll;., d.lj iil:;lteJtF .7llJtotnt+t € eUl.,r,-Jt J:r_ - t
l&J.r...i gla..r-iUr}.'l+u ..1elt.rtatt
Jelfi r-rrtl -oltff e.1/lf .tltaiu nt_lf rDf g i'rit\i$l pglr$ a r l.
J+;_ )titr-*rr iilJloi.6 q|r!.iJl$ {irt<J)li$l * ,}-rJl vtliU,
e, !**ll u|, C*.rll ,=Lt1 Gs v;e.If-fl .tl::"_ Yr .gLlt. Cf:'Jl .,.--.rll* -Jl6U+
u.:Sl;*J .-11 v -J Jl d"-Ul tr* Cb- Y 'fU., dU
;it-*uJlr f){"yl *l .|..iJle i*rul, JAI * Cr+Jl C t'rrtt b-rr.-a-
-pt '' :lS;r.+;l bL-rtrr bt --r uJl;l; jirs.:.Jl ot5*ill, ;l:Jl,..+Hlr .fk?!l ;t=2.U L;)l C.a; .-.-.:Jl
ti;-rti C -rr*f l \tA f ;.r"tJiJl oi.o .re--1 or .f&d ,rl b-.,;* ,-,-:L
-* ,*t t " r iJ.;llr iijttJl oe 6jJ.rr;.-l;6 ,rz', t +,,.UU.t"i[iirr;i er ;!l .*--rJl oSJr .t:L t+ -*Sl ,(i l, ;1r,.-!l ej )(i Jr+;
e.ft, kL|;-! )c ,4t kJ!g,Lu J-lJ. i.LrlJr ru ipr^u O.-l s. .*lFlr *ill r..+t, t"roL:..
:t+xt Jt* t5 L ,'*i t'rtltt eijtjt Lr:+- ,l ;i-l]*ll iJtsi;!l.r-
Ulr l;t5 ty ':Jl 'F- 6, ir. llJ;Jl .F_ 6t o,liii.ttlJl '-S- rs;. -JtfuiJS ,tl asts..= uJle L-t'-ilt Ur;llr i,iiGJl.J'ir.lJl bp-;ro o:;- tfu ,,.rdtr t5 L.rc t:.<Jr tiit*;)|1 gL;)l .u; i:,.J v *tl
v b-J;e'-.;;ul.slJi.; l+ L"r tdlrlrrU tl e$ ,f :lrt- gl
,!4: *+Xl ..r* I [*rG U<L ;:iultil 'F or.:j ..irUl JljJl lir
* JS.t+ifit"; Lu!.-r L5)* €sl+!- l(!,' ztsv" .tjl.Frtrrir Ji.iJl .F or";! lnjrQ,rL g.:all ..,i.rljYl ;r.ri.iri .,rUJt, .ft!
..tJ)t 1r,.J'lL tsl, y'l|.F, r.t ,ii o-'(*..;Jl JLr .t-{;i C P L"(! :::liJlr 1,i;tUl .F; ir,.i lrS.r,
t+ o5*_ $ .rSJr El.r"! oti;; Ye of; ..g.rJl d+Ll fJrJl Ju,rtl.LJl
.1r'ltr.r..lt -rl trl tra_r / f Y. I I rail, 6,r_gr[tg 6.ri- t$igt pgklt Afp
drlfuIl g. i.r-le c.p vlr:Jl .-L:<j l-lJJLi..r,_.r*.:Jl +: ,.* ,'-fll:.r-cL 'rYl3 .fq.Jl fL.:lYl dUi gtir,i,,SJl C.:+ll k<*l-r,- dl ..srs]f
.C+llC;,lf tq.".rt-.J.e.r Jt3 t#.+tJ itllt.i*\
. ', ^ i-lr.rll .il.rel _ o
: dll &i3,rll .-r.-ll ,J.q"_
. "ijlC.:+Jl,rr * .or,:Jl ;r"U rt+L r9b o.e.i^i5Jl-
. k*i ;j-illJ"lr*ll, ;,.ltlJl oi.r;:L - crr.,i.j53l-.;r"tbl,i.r r-.; ..7:,tlJl&trql !-r.j -
.114+lr.r;.r.UJl ob :JL ; UJI ss, qi -;r,.Jl irt_Jri Jt l#^br,,rJl Lr..:-Jl ,_Jo ,= *Jl ,= . : .j.r ;rtt! -
.;rLll i;l,5ll o! ;-.11, +t-+ytt{Jrrb q"jJl.t4l./:. ' :ll..rg.rckaylr s-t:,,J1 pUl,glJl ;rb!-.;eL+YI l+lrJr., b.t-ery2 ,-W.Jr ;trlt ii*i<Jl,J*Jl rto"_!,,e-, .L
...rti:Jlr
i-lJJlreJr -1
Y \\-r \ ji,fiill"il-Icl13., orl i-;1 6br., 'uJl
.,rtJ; C vlltt Jrl ,* e.*-Jl,*=:.i_ _
.l*lJJlol...ujl.ii:;-; i-Ul,-)tt U + c.*-JlJrr,i_ -Wt iLitJlr t*lrJl -.,." Jlr iJ(Jlr r*:*lol.:i;.;t i*lrJlJrb _
.ilc*il olr..dl
:1" g.briglc.l-i .1e!tutatt ;e$.rr1t
;e!lr,slt -rl lfl sc..1 / fY' t l rairJ ir_rrrgg \ilrilr tordl arrD
lle lrLrte t,--.:Jllt!. cr d-jJl C.:aJt;L. Jr ir-t, irrlJ!LJ l.--Jl l{J +Eitl a$lll t-r te.:+Il d.r.-':Jl t.ir **,- L *l
lirgll ci=il;. .-.."dJl li.r ,l;!i-Ul ./11otrt+l
rJl.*)l c,Y3L Jl Lt'?;-lrJl ut<.iy +Jl-*!i& iil'::' J*l cru
:e-lul
lsLtulr f-Jl.r cittJl, ,#1.." tjl v ,*;(/rg.:.lll,/l-- J" - \
,j ,-.-'lt t:; ,i l-,13-r ;}e)le cr-Jl Jl+"rr i,dl .',r\ Jt -I!C.:rFtl
*.-;Jt Jtil;i #r dulr .JiJl ,, djl .tJ! ijrJl ,* *- J$ -r. tol"U i.rt ' \l
t etrlJ ;rL' tl &l,irl-, ,/UJl .*-djl .l;! -,)ttJl dibt+l t- - t
i-lrJl :.:-Jlr lJJl iJfllr ,;{l alr::t ./XLJI Jti ;V Jr - o
o{J l.ii: fgtit?! c'!.r Ut -! rJl: eei cr, Jt:, .pe .,rcL.atl 'lJYtrtil;:*llolri:Il
Z*lr.rllirpl- f.e-$.C.:+ll C tr-rr- Jl ;J.rt-LJl .r-l c,. ^:-."1
e"--Jl .r-:*-
611l Jr:r ;;L{l r+lr ,rJt ot-.r,":Jl .blta"l c,,. ttl, 6'.i r--', . -.:JU
d.-Jl t{a"a;,- .,rjl ?p:rl 6)t.}Jl g,. ta::.rl :*lJJl J-:*t LJ .d.llr,:(-c li.rr t+-tq!r,br!-i cre .-i.i<Jl, tn.r,--r* J*l - ;r"ttll .r" i.j.r .f-|.r" ,!o;)tt u ,l.ll ,-.,l',-"\ ;rii z,asl;-l L3) u*3'- 6l
.t{i{rlJ.:-ul: +tt-:?Ylr L-1.'y'l LLl.l g>::b2:t '^ ,i*;4t;r"tlJl
dk d | .5y't 6$t Cr &--6Jl i ;:?tljl iiLlrJl o, :*lrJl oir -u;3
.rUl e .sU+ d, b.rl-1re :,.q1 ./1L Lj, J>U U. ,*4'll L*y
.9i rJ ;rrlJl o':lt-+-ll .!:,-.,,i,1Jt+Il l$.i oJJl o-) 4clr.- )5'
;le!t.r"u.tt -ol tfl tl.'...r / tY. I I #3e ii$rr$rg i\fibilf pgldl q,tf .
t{.i./l ot+y'| U x:S Jre rpr v {Jl t_6 d d-Ul }-)t-k-^ic4 cit'i,-y'lob y rr" Jl;rt-ryl ;,fu Lj-,:jl .t-Ic,e 1L=yl.Lle+l,,(, :rill ,# {L,y Jl .irr- sg.rJl (Allport. 1954. p.t6) orrJl a-;.+:3*. :lji ,; ri J<5 : =J. -L" -ra +r-ri .r.t+r ;tt- f" ,* *'*r1* ot^[+l":+;!!1516phan, t!!t) ;t:,-" - rij_e .i"t+l.r.lJs ;.L;ri,,g1,i *,_, ,-Li .-J" -L+l o.r.r .i6 .lr- i;* i"L? J! .1*;_ rljlrr;.'i.i* ,r.Jl*;.F^J +-5J,rl;;* .ft-+t IL! Jl ,s; tgiri 17V
.'';3 lt.Lb *(-. ri +-, irrTe ;r*.r;L_ .r; Fanatisme., . dS
lLiYl ;tr!, .JsJl ;:l-rl JJ d.:i- ,.-L.d,Jl, .;)t;)l cr +Jlo .+r+
y, elt: i-ut L-.r,'".:Jl r'+b f px+f l Ur ,* .ljJt. (\ q I t ,.,<J'Jl)
. (Crawitz.1983:155) .. -.tjl f# f ,?:V_.5lJ1 g.l*Jl ,.e+L;-* t\ ,--.t4dJ"€Jl.,i,E,, eL * Jl .ft-r?Yl;j,Jl,-.rlJ -.--:"ii{--" Yl-r .i!l J! t'rj"- $r .g.t*rlJ bli 1.r,- I .:.2- ;.r;c ai l.r-. el
.(\ot:\lAVr.g3q)trl,4l rl t ;r- Jfu_ ;r..'Lll .f L-"! I prLJ I oto-ri rrr- u,-*dl 2
Jfu" .d,i-Jl',Jlrl :llr"ytrirSiU ocL^}lrl t'rlt i3uJ;t 'b s*.-.trsljl v .sl :1 rt-;\ b+,4,)-rl .r.,t+,_!
q]" FilJ L_tr ri.jt5 c-ir i;i;3, t.tL J$.r- : r;L,-" .:Jl.io-
'Fl*lJ rL:cl ;e> rit:.cl ,*,_r ,!J* ri t*t*.! .flJt lj.l l-& .ri3 ,,.ir -:L
.f t-r?l ier,.4. J! or*-:l1l .Lr ,rrt* €L i2ee *- ;)l irL-r .:-lClirt" J! ;*Il )liYl G-? oi )t:.,.-..a.:ll uau;l a(*,_.ra.:+,t;ir+L , L -r! ,j db 31, u-+ 3l , ,s,-s sl ,,j-p ,l ,et S-l ol,z;*,
. ulJi.Jr ,it"-,r t'ill .r::--- ;i,3j., ;,.-U-3 iLie
sL:- 31,lL ri ;rr".t,r^oi ,*l-" r;ir,r;r"Jt .rr-ry.*.6 n.* $t
;eltt.urlt -rltlf e.1/ll'lf J*rJ nr3lr$q ilit$i$ l|Idt llrD
.+lt(!b':" "qll prfi. -V
,i ,s.tt Vrr.z- g.' ,ll ilt#yl P+tAt ir' '*":Jl l.r{'o' r^,-
,-...:jt C i+ o1 .tFl tir i u ,i*: .+rt Jlr lit-;ll lrLtl ots'l
'--'l\,,nitrJl '*-;;Jlt ,d)l ''ldtt rJU{i 'L-LiJ i'ilA llt#l
i;$.cr 022,- ,ibb c/ *..a--tl Jli ^l5 elJ3 gr './tlJl *'rJlt ';-'rll
it$lq ,?:V ol,r'-a;trt<i\l,r'ittJtrt$tJtr'l.e'i 'r'-lf i ,* S,-
+P)l,tjyl ,),1 d 4rllL i+SIl i.illl oLrlJlJ!- *-'tl f#';,1'.l+r--r\ ,r:Jl i:ill .r,itJl g +u"!Lii ;j-lQ Q$Jl ;6 d"- 'irrill
,i; rj4.rL..+i ,Vt'62ra,L-2.L-r*'Ll e: "jr;l ,-*,., F 'iyrt- i!
..i!e3 ;L3Jl -V ,i;ttJiJloi.r &.":-1, 'i;;a'2 ry2a !;l*2Vr Olk+t
, ,;Jl oLrl j #. .,:Jl iirlll i-r*-'il &UtlJl oe Eil lrsll t'tr
ol rr..a:ri.r- letar d I qJJ!*l I oLr[Jlj L-J-)l Jl''i\l I "ir Lt "Jr
..tu)l g--rulir, it.-JlJi-Ul'ir i #"Jl
Jrr,-,3l io.-,)lt,:,...o.Jlcr v -*tl 31 ,*z cri'ry'l!U C'l''. Y .y]i el l;6 qlt! , gdr[:,- u ,*,<"' :JItJlr u"'a'c;r"a; J! Jtrl
.(f t1rr,\lA'.r:}iO,l)
i+'/ i.l5 O.liLrqPr Fanatisme +'*;.,Jl i'lsu i'a; .-'aiJlr
ol,=*ii Li-i-i-rt* i.5.rrr Temple @?) i'I5 ";; fle fanum
F ,J"Jl Bellone o:I* crn6 J! rsy t' UE i'i5 ./r 'c{<Jlr qJl.}Jl
,l.i*1 r..r 6-r,- tls o-r^. a ,l1,1l &'u. *-;l ,rt1 ^;' .,.*S ;rt-11 qtt+
..rdli,t-Ul li^ 'L.brY
.(y11,r-,ttA. ..,.r.r1 ritJ.)JJa;.ir{l) ( Y)
.lelttaqtt UrItrt+tt
JiJlr.sJl -r! tt'f u.1J / tY' I I rllr! auHtrg ii'P\$iSl P g}rll ilIP
trgtriti3r. Jfu ;J*.,tJl .ft.;?'Jl p:LJl'-ln'i ':..'* tJ --'ll)
,\* ri .JKt 6;1b.-..t+ -ilt lb .-'l*i ,/ ,r.4-":Jl ser -judging
.(r o:t 1A 1, a..rlyl) qi"i! t'orlil U 5-f 'yG. E. "r-7;- b-*"s "J# e,*" U # tf-''- tr(rll ti" t/.l
uir.i;r )r r^ , !t4--! fi LJ* ;61 'lr- '''*'';Jl 'ii Simson and J' M' Yinger
f* *,f:t"- Y .*.-dJl oli JUtr 'a .-r'tJl ir'Itt^" '4 pWt &b
.(y . .:\ 1 I t.tjlr) {.<Il li,r -- ,*u;'-l ab-ule "-"*i.;t*
J,A --^-rJl l-J Jr d! ll li^ i $; cb- rsJl (;lt JUlt
,.<Jl J;ul l.r,o;r.c iL'il iJ., r;r ti-;i fii-rl"i qrL '-'-*Jl-r..,-
;s i,-,,-:a12,!ri! .1q ,;;, *--:)q 6I; djl dilill A Jl;rtilt dr(:
: (r ' ':\ I 1 !r..olr ) JulFJl,Jt t{n'ntJ o*J 'r':Jl+t-,i;-;Yl u> l;.-,,:- lz ;,,iJti'! ,J..1U 'L--J.l. At/'- 'U- '*"':Jl - \
dj-rtr C r!5Jl .5-rJ 'ul-)t' &'t !!..,t4 t i l.l * - \l rU'oJl Jtil'il a'J
.l=.il: tJ
.$ v J!\-r-r*Y iL '-' ';JliiL- -Y
JillJ"r',l -o\tlf e.'1/trf 'tIrigiir-$r$f g iit+il$i$J P glrl\'il! t'
g;!l r'il , lj-., ;-i,JU ,i iout :t.',si"; ot'"t4t f!* ^cjlu 'r--r
fr, ",r*,
nJl &';rLo gJ- 'Ul
*"rv 'UL
€ **fr Jl":'i-
-.*a,s y-b ,tiJL --'-tjl *'u-I;rL- 'i;;t!Jl ,li ioufl ulb Jl
(L{at4 .--rJl cr' ;Jt- iB;l ,-- '::^'- i'i'it^L '1
aV Jr -L;L. (Y':\ t 11'J'et*l)
,+- q,g;JLi'Jl r-/l ei'JFl "J'dJt o' ^pY XL'/iJU
cf , dl ,i-S-- ) '6;1'rt'b'i ;tot'7 F ioL+t ei rlt obt+l
\'-r..Ji)ll ot-ot-+rl'n y'kJl *- 4l i"L+l \Lil t5 LP
,[;.;-l J!J.. g. ,r.r*iJl J! ;o'yr cr' r'l+ -,U!'/ f Ul i.3., J! J='dlJ+
(Taylor&Ryan'1988) u-iYl f 'J't"lt d'tJl
,1 u.;ailJl g',b" t! '-...odJl i"l-:-'il ;;,Lll 'r.:l,E
il':
;l-:*'ilJ.;!f J! Qt'v-$'1g.[JJ t':ti 1'r'''i e^"'r 'or.Joe tll'rt-3i;t'S
.(\o!:\tVA'g;e4)
C D. ROM aee;31 aa,r9l-l 'ei>'ll ,t'ilt)
..1e!t.rqrt .ljlt.r.l+tt u *ilt ;l'1i1v 'r airf.1 li orc':'i
.1r'Jtrr.lt -ll tlf e. I / arf . t I Jrijr-i 6a$.r$lg ir$t$i$ Pir.rl h rln
*,lJl '"" r:Jl - \ /V
,J-- dJl fJYl sJl J1,-- lr" g): ,,--'dl, :=.-*ll p)t-)l .,rL|;::As -1, ,J;U U 6 A:Jr-- .( \ o A: \ 1 c v,sL-rl) (:3lr .5,i ole2)" i*,o,-J. at- cr b .rJr.5.rJl =+JK .1r1r .ill * * uy .,,a o." :rIJb ;X^-Jl .-|;ii Lie
,k 4l J*_: .(\ o A:\ t l v..,l.2rl) (re3b e,l ole.z) "4+ L?_ * €3,Jr-- ,, ."tib ,jr.r!)l
^+-r C[; J'-ii.J * -l rit, d g,.": p9+&.llld.iJl /:iyjg ,i ,jjl * & +4i .-; gr" :$13 i\-Jl Fii &le
;gltr'r'tt -ll tfi r-r.+-2 / ll' I I r43rt irr-ltrfrg it$r$.i$l Pglf r 6IP
riJ#ll :*rLJl ;r.5,-.z.'dl iiE! Jt*-!l J}; cr .--t-- '-..a':Jl -f
.g;;i,-Loi--o.1 JLdll ri .:ltK=Vt J)u cr .rJr.rli'it ir:-e!.'--"- 1r '&LeL'l
U L':t- ', ^Jl't
tj:,6-;ctL J-djti) intt' &!ir ri &t+L CiJ'*'Jl 'r:r'-'0.;rl&Jlr .l-r:-c)lJ e# rl J.l;ilt
,>9 ,,-.-.';JlJ ,-.i;.Jl .a1 ii)LJl ,rlc ;9'r'r-!- ir,,-'rJt qt:-Ul tF+ Jt':'rJ
,F 4#r'oL;!f! +r';,b # r!:g;Jl'^'-'' 6G;'r-Jl'-iv;
ei,Wt ni #:',r!rldL ,l fv '1 €r'if'"i;to 'i,:kJl: )lA uzi) #s,,?vv f ,f-F & #t 'L-+l i/-'ut Js
,,lt*;} LrELI ..a,;lll1 oL-rJl, ,i);lt', rhr' -l J5r "rt-ltr 6: .':Jlr
lj.re . (t:\ 1v l,.u:..);if i tJlo-:&Llt' "r', !! .ro L .,;rtJi,ll ''r'r.1
. l-;,-i r.r .:-J tl,;Jl lP e,rilr-- ar*Jl
;riJlr ,.,JjtJl L.rV so.i'Jl ;l rt"a:;L J-iJt !* tittll lit C.1
* dl rLi:i- rir. u-i1t,Jr; -tr Jl,.;,.r11'r'Jl3 e.rl, vbrllr 'lJllr,giir .g+i-LI-, ,'+t-1 ir' -"Al 'till cr '5Jl d"'- i! 'J=r Jl 'k 't.-Ulcr ib' Jlet'4- ):!* r* qF rJlabUle'rlriJlr oL*3'll
,6;i--:+, Q$ dl.-...odJl 7L* g,,Url6f Jtii- ! ';l'p "*"dJl cllt
.rUi cr l*n Fl r*UJl .r4,,1 a-,(,- ol Jt':-l Lt-:?il 'Llc ':Jr"l 'ri3
.+:v:r*i;,.rriJliij; i oL:'-$l.,le .i*.;)ll lj'r 'ri;'; 'u-;1
j .:l*3fl;;, oicr.4ft,ry Jt'';Yt.LGl .ti"., -ul 'ret l 'rie
JJi:Jt J!ofrr-all .4, Jt--;!l qti- b\ gr-t "-iJl ir+r i.r'J&Jl
,rS ;-:;.i*t';J,'lt" ot'o-r-afl.p L'rc ,S s J!v *Jlir-r Cr
$ +rjl i-.-s (t' di;lJ ,&l'rul1 ,-rylr'Jl-r at*3ll € ol-* ol's!'i
..*.Jl U,.-; ;Jt;! J!,fr-i,-
,.19!r.rr1r ;eltrtTtt
.19'lt:"rrlt -ol tl'f e..1/ tt. t y r*irj iu3lrff g G+if.lrri$ pnr rrl e r lr
,, : : c9!l,jro|,tJl hr;.iitfl J<r dr,_Jly, qjllly..:f3r 6Li,--e
t*! ;rf- ;rl e V*,,..4,.:JL AtJl Aryl,j f* .. t:., .y_.r.ll3 .uJyl
CD J\ ;.-u;L ; =-,:JU (...) Jt*Jl l.r.r .l;l g";ll,y ;itr,ifl,eJlr .td
.,.pLi-r;lj 9r*l- Y!orti u ,-{:qt'l-JJl ciJ prr ,,,.j=i o.r-j .ri !r*$Jlc.,. o,l: oil:+ .-.i,1 to$ .,-l" .lJl ietL J*rL_^jiJ+, Jr-_ .grll 6 *i
. ( \ y l.: \ t A t.,6.*_J),',r:4.r,, et*.,i- c+- .-ll Jr-,i;llll dr-jJl i_E oF- ,b, *.dJU dJU bqJ&.;; o-S-, ,*_..-jlbn-Sy- dl &U-tJl ir. +.L i-te Y ri.r,L ;lrl .Ul .r J-+-i ,- dl tiq .Jlti*J!t'r<.- aiJ-rt*-r +J!,!+; .IJt*.-- cr!lt:,q4i4,. r-.;utt rsrl;-rl"-.r.:**Jl +al;\ L__rjr 4-r dJl cr,J.o:, &.l; ++i
4lJ l.-Li )AJ: .i; F- g_rJl ,i ., -*ll Ui 4f ,p;,_j ot ii,-e .lJti cr-i,_
,alJl ;:lrl ot5. C .r;:lrl C;*; crl.,le rlJl ;.r*i cr:ryl r*-r e_.L 6*.,Li,-l 'rl, JL-*l: ,rlJlr r+lr ..-.lJ ^'Lryl * t, iJ-jllrL4:;ur.r:..r #: rl-llr JF;ll, aJlr rJl .r*4,_ i! ,+t*.;!l l; i:Ar+, *. cUdJl ;Lll +?
">;t- gpt n-);*,=. *.ijl3,+yL;)lr.rUyl -a .41+lJ r;U J! *Itr.1t4Yl .tit-L Jr-,"-..".4-:JU,r*ij aiJl C aL;!l-rtr 6r;J:;-- ar"_.rJl ,Y3l r,+l+- L.rc .lJl +-- 6i .r;r-- ..* --\1..e ..1.i-j
i'.ri *, J!.Lryt rl;lt, iiut,.;rJt, a,,-.rJU
:r"-Lll .Ja J--L-r .* - dltl*L J:fu- €.f6;re fi-; oicrfurr iv .'Jl t-:i,_ r;r .4:.lllj r.r-:;Jl ,,L_Jl ir..i/l ,+-Jlrt<-i!t,rjt::Jl
L_Ulr :::Cl cr ,rs-*I ilr-4-.-'jts b--,_ ;i U .or-a' .,^;; L.r:o
!*Yr ,;i_Jl ,t5;Vt .;r.-i .r.i, .i_rt ^iiyl uriJl ,i ,i*t, Jl, ;rJl,
;trJl -".a,,uJl .,..=-L j ,lJ,_ti. b_r ,-;.;:r; Jl otoul 6. g.L,,Jl p*c
.( \ Y:\ t 11.iJUl \.Sl ter*)l),.,r.ijlr
2't r.r&igb.t.i ...;e!tl3rr Jrlt.J+lt
;9!t.urtt .oltlf o.-1 /lY'lYdiri i.t-1rr-Srg 6$r$i[r Ptlrlt ar t -
"-kJl ;rs Et * Jl ,F; 6rfJt bi;j,l € r!5 ot-l r,sss
l;-&- r*.J. ,,.iJl or5; ;;lii"." i(.li .V crs o.i.Ii,t-.i g,." :\i,d^J k ,-& ,f" i' srl sss iils ,i ls" ,o.i,-Jl € J;l)1" ." g,,.L;
. oL+,,
g-t^..:Jlr.-f bt*)leiLr- J,(.i; +,--rl ^ .ll aL-.t!lrLr.rl-!l ir,-!U
,r--Jl.-.-;Jl.i!i cll: dE (JI9r,i;]lliJiJ)ltull )rt .t '' '!lr
C rlrJll c-Jl ir. iJL" ,+.rJl ', - '.'J[i .c-r"+ 'rsiL-t ,r-l*)l lb r'Jt ..lrl ..iU;:-Yf l!,grir- k ..--, ;.SjJ;r& #11 d:.-hj l,4...Jlr .,.U I
rJL rrr,l+l-,.,- g{.rJI rre lil.> {.Alr k .-rL.r.o/}i|&hi:."rJ-ldlt t;*)\ Jar i.E )* J! gr; ,t't-+lr gr./l .tr:-Jl ,* *-",r+.rJl.-..-:ll .sr-!,- L l$r,rgl.t;':-r cr-ritr ijt+- !lr $'Jl cre r-Jl-,
;-r.r, ,..e;11 &tdJ q.-tJlr i9t-+!l ,'illrK! ill ;.u, ';: J!
.r--.rJl *" *Jl u-..a;,- L rrle Jtj, i!-t{.4J1 *-d C J*Jr,i.tt :?Yl.,LJl
Jl *-L ;r:JJ,-i C ,.:jU*tr;lr .'!rit<Jl e-a'; a3ps ,ol1ss &t5l o.
:jlr! J! &-r,Ll 4l € L)Al &lr!'ll 6.+ ,4 t -r'ij ,;l-r'r J"b .;J.( v 1A: \ I A o,Jl,$,ll ) .r-.rt-.e ,--.dl .=" -*Jl
L" +;c ill &r9fU *icr ,* Jtt @r,Jl F: €J+i t Jb?lo.rz,---,;Jl F, ;'J-S ;tll] ..ir-J5iJl J-*-s" d;t ; i.U Ylat*-!q d
,*s,zJl'....o.:Jl € €:-)l * C* l;-ll Jr-- l,i. .i, ,';1, glv" -.:Jl u
'trrtil *-l el"t*- O d', lul f{ilt .rV ,f ;rk L. i.rlrile ,r.:,--rJl
g;.r---1 ,-!il| t= l 'er *l 4 q-1, ,l-r,ri-.r,=. r.'ll" ,jt J*-:;i;rUl ,..; .r!..J-Ll1 &bi-:-'Jl d;;j tJ Jil.SJl rli:;j 4;-2-rf l"9-r-- tJ
2s u,,^r;.Jgr.Ji,- r^-.- 61, ,r.:tr ;i,; r,t --oi J'J lp- 92.)1"-x;'.,-
C.,tJt ojr ,-,.rj3 rLJl ;Li.ii; .r11: ,i!i U:J o){+-,;r, .r,.tjl !t ft Jq;
. ( \ Y r:\ t A 1.,;.*-J) 6rt-sl € $li: sS r jle o-,-lJl
.Jrlfir.ult -ol tt'f rlr._r / tt.l tJ*irJ 6uJ rgrg Luit\i g p grrtl ilp
dtlJlr r:Jl-y/v
"t -:Yl :i O-oJ|.L+tlJ,:.:J,-:;. ft* r,r"-o,- ,rL)l o.i.et-:,i.rt!Jl
s4 cr JL:n peL" Q;L Ut^ttt ,_ij;3 -(y . . A.u-+Jl),.iijl3l ,+.rJl.*l !-l,* J-*,- s-hill .trJu ( aU ri,ul,g .i&_ .iU) 9 ,.!r,c-pr*"11 .:F dHt: ,+iL}t L:,.rr oJU! C !-*-,_1. +o ,l-;:.-.iiler ,-fKJl cr..r;.ult JSJ'rGl, itFll i_.:.r,Jl iJiyl .elcli .r- C qliVf zf; :r-.2;.-.ulrJl 6r,_.rJl ,pl.r c -,..-llr pt*i;1l i, 4lL tj;L" r;GJt ;r..JrU ci,*_
.( r . . A,u-riJl),, d;1, C rrHl LlAt ,* -*? u*:iJL t{i--r Li.ttljl.* L: r:cl-qli':.^f:.LtttJl+ L L:o i.:';Jl,*?-_r.rr cJLi )*rV Cf .iir-_ Y,.,;:l,- J,i. L+;-2U.tt!Jl,J+i d,_* j:: .j
^U: 7.,-\ V-ea r" rJ t F!- t$<J ,L iL; - i+ -rj ,i:_r*.. itij"lf J! ).2; u*.(," L.$t r,'=*, .-rE t1;l". (o o:y . . A,u+.:Jl),
*r iU l.rJ- ;lrJl arr ;-er-il)l Jr-i+ ;J!l ,-k j LJ-, ..r.k; r*i41:.t-U:. g9 4ia;.fL)l ,_L; gt-LJ ;U._(*Jl .r.;b dr.c d.+.,; l3l
.riYl) dYl -b J.iJl t# ,.1{,_ .ri}s' C ,;.Jlr ;AJJ JrL; .1ta,;dJl; Cl ,Ug t+! .(o 1:\ t i i,.r_; ,,i) (i;lL 63.(; :, .^ .:.- .-tl J,.-;-, l-G I ollG;t ,;3.: ,f...i:--j .,{u # t{.+1, Ct4 g.ar F-:dl j
.iirts.lt &J3r J-!-r of ..p lui.Ji t t|Jo)r/4.,,t-i5Yl-e .r.JlI ;[ .ilr -S ;r* €,/t!Jl r. -..11 r.,.+i_-r
.r"_J+!lt el.i;Jl-1 u:;:Jlr -r;Jl Oy t{.1t-.--i -& F lrr_ olJo t .L J lr i,_rl -iy I .r"t-+y I o 113,t' l, .+UjJ I o lr*;;l I 4 e .2$:,-j JS;J lrt JSJ u5J i+,, d,! .r-.a;.Jlr .La:Jl'a:rlb o;rJlr , _*lyi l! i_UlJ*:-r o,_JllU- .,i t#" it-,lli_FJl ;.r:LJl
C-,_ .-o Cy"L *,t;!.( \ o: \ f A . ,.,.^iut :llr .rrol! ,j:i,_ y Lt* t{, .,.t il
11r-J.lryi('L-J.i ;r!l.r4u .lelt.r4tt
1;9!turlt rttff r.e'rlPl'llrufuE ir:lrltqarib{r tddlatrr
;-5s., *Jl .14 .iJl .Lrltjl -+ Jl ;rl^ill ir. + t .ttJl li..'i,
"cr,Js.ifl u)n: '7--t tJ' y -':Jl:el tilL! Jfu Cl'J.H|",L.ilrl Lt;;li; i,l f- ruJL .rutl ;F .,;ldl .rt-;ylS+lr;J
uJll rl u:t.alJ 1!6 F .91 'i-.ri.o ,>-'r-ltdul cr neJTo ri i= ,*
,* ab-::LJl ali i1:.rt& crr dJi,J' t*- d --l-ll: oJu Y!
Lr-ll FJlr^ rLJl ,J-Lti r, vr 'J$ Y'.51 .,.t-.tt ,ilt JIL J,l
J-',; g.Fll C-:tJl ,U! C rt<iiJl "i. t -JJo li!, -(\ o o:\ I Av.i+r)
.lb . r:-U diYrl^*. :-' o, rUJl frt4 i+fl =r*-;tlrr v dl : dil sle
6.rti:el /-li; .;l aL* allrr ,Cjl ,s*- .,i.&+ cllre ri-r- \ t. ^.:Jl lJr
tdl JL-!l*-l;lC J'-i"Jtr t+& gr<-. olrul"i. ol*., '&!ti, dli'il.r :*)Jl .rr.ll uf ii+fl ir;rlU ...^--dl i+f t i+rll crt .i-iS-- !cfr)tll (,i ..ienlb .rrlj J"till * ,.J, Lrr^ll ,l' rttll' gfe .i^ill
.(\ oV:\ t AV.i*r)'.,Jl
"b.-li Cr rtJl dr. .fL.:}':. ,* f*!3J:,-'r'-tl alaUl e *,..rekatl J,.iJ I rri d | .,r t..-. rJr-.r,-! I ol "---l I .:'r:,- ot1.-. rJt-.r"-! I
ul' '.i;U| .;iJl cr ,y'|" Le- o.r- lile .o--.dt, .,iu:Jl .-.odl Us
U ,-.J lig (6Ldja ,-.J.c) , }b J:r!l -;r';-)l J!"c;lt.(v \:\ r A v.duJf.il;al.>t -
*- --ll .lJ 1.r9,.1,<-:; s i-.r;':Jl 6.rJl vt* Jf a +U:tl ati-l:-lti
sE)l'Jt ,* ;l-$ +lrjloL,-tllcr irul', -dlJ!.g.t-:Jl ,-'t-a,
c,bX'Jl ili-X. f+- l\J, .L-lCl ol'iE:Jl FJ "5t"- v, r i..ai-il|
c,L,-tllo. t 1- ! /.rJl 1rl,st.ri.uee.+iUir &L:,-t+ a;i.rlilqg eJ:tJl
..ft-."!l o$Ltl *: cr Jp ..-*'.i iitiiJl
gr.irl lllA.f .rrr.r 14.,.L-i1,lsr.i
l1r!tr.rtlt -ll trf +r-_r / pl.l lryir* Ar-1f r$g ii+itltri|t p Sf dt a I f .
,AkJ d crr- [Jr ,;,lrJl € or,..,_ [J:+.rllr i.c.iUJI& J*Jlr.-..a.:lJ.i;i, r* # .r C-t*Jt LidJtri.i,&i;f -r; g:EJt,
. t#l:"r:rjl-l/V.JU.Yl ?.p +rb dl ;=filt 6;.^."cr s!-iJl f,1rL;l.1 v-"Jl u*.-"Jl Gbl Liet JS ,r-.tr-_,r.LjJl? dlj l:-* ,g|l -.^:ll in zz-,
V2,-ee "l;- oj5lt s{-ijl .= ".adJ '* gb|.U:;ll ci..a .,i cJ)l:j
t*f -rrc- .::. ;#,Jl frf cr 2r.o 7iJ- C &rrr ,-ijl o. otni;..l.a,:Jr-- ;!iJ.:ll :r^4,tJld-t d,tt* J5.rr._ Yi
v.-'; .-:*te=4.t |*',i^t {;;-qthi*lal?Jl&+ &3&+jb l:,t- -1'i ;.fg+l Y )i
., . ^dl J-a, € i_F i-J Jq.*- Ji,.r*l u L--i e-nl -p.;ll f,t*l-1: d.;,.li.rl.ill
Ul :t.i. iri Jo:t ,,c l Lt:lll liJ gll 6.a.i fJ c.r.rt r.r. c.XC
t-l.r-j9,it-alpa,r1 1r1a peJ+.r+E.s+ipl rilps
. t'it .-r+ JL3l- sJc,,:,lj)lJl 4 {c-d+-+ Ce gB.iCrli*l y
tjtA!b1i 1;,f,Jti,. lJ.-.J r.rr..5-J! tg:S0!9"-c-9io.(J
Lll ot*:411 C .#l v. .-Jl "J-t 611 6r.o J.a, nt*!l ob .5lr
.il"t+l
.,,,Jl ./rYl e\S c!':b-e : .iJl ;t.. .;.53*- *;Jl i_J,..tll ll:,Ylr
:r*L-all Jt + .J$,,:Jl u-*)l J-?i o,r*r1 z,_;e *t tb c.-* o* bllj u\l! Ui t r
.4;#.,,[Jl;r-ca :::.o,JJ t;-f- J++lc,c *;t?)l 'F- JAI l,i".,i,
;.p J*_ d.:i-.lrrlJ J'--a, /.-hs,f ,lrlJ l-ie) dll tsJl C;tS li!:torct*i9 .* r-r s6,r--.rjl
aaca.rri Otc.r.i;r!r.rt;u .lelt.r6rt
Jrlt.u"lt .lttll r-r4/tf '\Yr*ra 6u-$r$rg it$r$i$r P gklt e r I ^
,tiIJ d*l ,l ,rStt rfl ,!3 .'1" t-t+,Jl C,/UJl '-"Al 1*:..s ei;$ .':,--rJl , " +Jl .rL- ir. 64!- r"re ,i'or'rllri i;ttlt .J,ll)t"..;Jlt
!! .r-lJl C.:+Jl € Al ' i:' ',rLl d *+l-rll b-Sr ;-F Jt ,-l ,f.(\' Y:T'' f . iil3) oJ.-Lr.J ictl''^;.1-'rc.i'ilrl
gftJ ifi.ttl"Jt3.rp.rll '- 'j1;r. tsV- 12-.r1-)lg:kJl 'i-P Ss
i -z e lf ul ol32 Li',, Jl li" J,.i..Jt f*,-rttJl .ulr;Jl ,-rr Oi
+,t-) o7 +i e LP.g-rJl er Nl r-*t *tt- o+ ^lJl ** .,?t--Jl
L.rr rJ lJti CrF! 't Vos .i;t i'.i-.-Il Ul-' C:lll ir' itL?
u Jl.roir' .dlbii UJ"L- d;-b J' t'Jl al zlj,l- ,l rlJl .,L:5i oe'ub
e)l-J;l,lr, cP &-rll ,,l Lb-l It ul g ' ir .6LJl Gr 'J'*i, J+Jl
csrt 'll.^-! ;r;,.- z'.'> pJ* Jlg6r" vF o* s't-"'Jl l'ti o'-!l
Ol:q.Ug l!-^t,cr.t \.ri; JU-i ,lj' fl*;liofJU t{.-t- J! lr+ir
;.r-)*:.rt - o* s,t-.-Jl .;r$l l--+s' zrr;|.-zJlJtn.l.r+ ptY tjt-Jl dJl
.(tA:I . . \.ri+Jl) "l.(.J! ,r-tlUiJr "(;i
Fllrn, t +Jl ,/tlJl ,t'rll v dl i,k C *-.ll s--]Jl o.t
,!,-l) -;$ ,il .1*trs #t"i s,',lLo u ,kl:'-* V bbrle !'l-2:
62l/;l p*..r|-r; &-t € r,t-..-l cr bt t'-r ';1rr{;ll ./Fll 'U.' ir'
Ur. pt-!r ,s*" t;;) JU J-l: 6t ,;: s ;;!t gecL ,rt? lF-L
a l i - bs* J6*:l Ju tdl,t---L c;l v 6-rFt lLqs.Jll cr- r-i Jb' J* 'tjl il5Jl i-it tr--;
'Ji rrJ JUi - L*)l
lr.,L r, dJl l)t5 v plll ii l^.^-r'dJl f)ti f- e.-b .:lrtot-l
. ,r-L JleJ.-j ,;+ a*12,Uo o, ,J.-it ts,l--- Ji- .iJ :! zX7- +l* €: +lre t"r+ U ql-f. o.5't t':'r1
b-tp.g;.rJlq5J^:.ll :li- f uJ..l.,l;ltr ltu € dJl -,US J-,.,- JJ*
gr .tfl 5lki.f -rr -r a " t, ,ltui clc-l-i
.1r'ttr.slt -oltl'fe.-1/tl.llJ:i# iu3lr$g 64ifui$l pnr.rl a I ln
j i-._.r.Il drl.Ytlr dll,LrYl o- ;rj* Lt.o i$c Jr:rr illlp Jl
Jir .tcr_r" e -# ,o t{+:F ;rU!:; t<-; aF duU., ,rctJl ;t,\.,,oG C .13.r.1i ir,lrti,i rii. sLiJl v,.o,.:-U,.grlJl ,-L!l ,;t tl ,j.tt-+irt :.9t" r^zlu:rJl .|'J LlAt cp p+tJl K)lrrs.i:Jl ,-xL J!t-
t+L cr c* Jitt"{J Js Jrt-:;.rcEllo.r.r r-Li up3,6l;rl,;-i.:- Ud
,iLJl li^ ,j ;i.rl; g,l ,sts .u-.,-7l .,.b t !.-J1, iLdl, rgl dlL:J
."+t,!:t1irlLl
ol,LiYl dji J,fu"- Jli_Y-r ;t5 r--,Jl ;t--:all j ,#l .Li)lUiJrJU .(t . . L49,r,_.') OYI .r, qln4l ji :.;_rUJl ),*"Jl ,;c la-.;le
lUil" tt{;6, .r$.,*Ll.rJ" .+r - t'-*41 .r-"_ 6 - {.}-)ll +.llJtIl ', .:Lj tJr:llo -.;*lr.t{<<i,_ ;i,;-e, ei-|, #,J.ttJJl r:r*Jl)riijs
t e Jlr*Yl -*. ft;L;Vl, Jlp'rl -S ,*., .9;ll ,U'Jl a-SJ
€-;t-b # .-Li ,* f*;?y't JrJt +.i ri-l,Lt i!!t ijrJt rJ+;lr:-Jl.e l,:Jr .jlllr L-rr: vy'lr ;rr!13 611l J:r .=t JUt 4 tJ
. (Y . . t rs9.r,_:)l.rrp5
JS^l' .':. s$Jl Ctlt Lf.-- (r,.ll dul Or i.r,_.rc d.ttj, Jtr
;t*all ,.-r[ ,sis,tl*s,elll Jl*i dr &_-6Jl C .r1ct-+Yl ;.r-rJl iL;Jl
J,,(-Li l.!rl;1 6^+r ,,..rJl ilj ri", :ifuk ,-Jl; ^l,rllr ..irr!lrp,il:JJl C J+, # .,:;,-t .iS;;-:-.]!+l:: dltt rkl" tf-/.-t,.r-1, ,U!;.:Urlr.- ,, .kJ!,.r-- Cr.r t{5 jJr,:|1, ' 4E_ .-L+ n 36* r;i
e- rE, o. rl.r-;!1,.[;Yt? ,.l_,,t.c;r.*JlJ."*tJt, pV;:,-llllS ,:-\r.In!.ri cJ,,:t ,;1 * rj vt,*11 ..rjJ3.;r.;Jl-e iL.iJl .r-
L., .g;Yl ,J.ttjJl .t+i.^; i.--,.; ;f,G..rr l.r.r.;i3 JLi!.4, #, r91 65,
2't !, .t /.,i gl4.t-i;r!r.rr1l ..;e!t.rt4tt
;elttr,rrlt lltlf e.-1/tt.tltri# nr-tlr$f g 6'f if rtri$t p glrll a t t.
)3.-,:iJt <..tgrt Jl Jt4 C3.l,6o..r.;-Jl Jbr.J),,.',t1
:d}cr ii.';.Jlr.-.."dJl ,rt: j t'rtrj.l "iuz )e2 )r;,-,
.:.. dlJ,1;' ptraltuUi t- 1c.l.l,i-1 ga:Jt 4 lfr.,'. --t,
L"r-L 6.lt ;.";t-*Ll l+ 6*,- 3\5,.r,;-,i"V cr -* +-t yl.rS"
Jtj. J-iJl ljr.rt:" -p u Lo)[S-r,.tflJt t-5,.,-;l cr.A -* 4t c.t
Jr--r i*J"4lvy'l ;t* d..q, j;lg;.rll,r!il|.-.--dJl 4,L sc ;tt--v. 'dl .J, i;lt iJl.r J.2il1 lfn +" t llL ri uU Ju-i .--;1" ,-,flJtir .J-ll l.u y'-: 4" r.lJl ,"V -"Jl J.ro -rir .i!ql d crcil +t+lcr tlr 04 .A|t;- cf gb LrJL- . *;1, y'liJl ;1t t,:^1.9i Ut! ....-.;t
,JIJU.',JLJI ,* e;.4. Ji:JlJ:]-.--.Jl L.J:-.r L- :cJi":Jb 6i-Yl.t+.r,-rrtfor-r + Jl nl +
Jit{--L- ta*l, ,JL- .,;Jl :r! Jl :JEi i...--Jl c C,}l u ,! ,}L:u, ,Y)1.^,.,- .3i + -Jl 4: .a--pi p ,V u l-* +.1 :l-i ,st_
Jf53l .r-i & . .L.ill .*"':JU .( t )"y'.hJl ,* ui q-- Jl ":r Jl cr o$r&-r,Lt? s,-.rJl ilJl Jn- -rii .$3L,ilrs L ,s-.-"'Jl ft"^lJ ;y'| ', -'ll
"*r"-,rfY1l r.h;Jl u F +j,,;t1;.,rl!qlJ.4.Jl ,i.#l v dl .pse*:21:.s l..li!;rt" il::-ill cl;r;LLJI, ,s.ll ,F i-l-. oLcl-1 ;.rzet 4- t!.r::-- ;.r-rJl9 ir.t ' -lt? ,.Sl :-*: i.r-13 riJg 6.:-::',.iUU t16i
.( \ 1 A A,c^:"Ur!l d-LlrFJl cr.
Ur:t: C *V €41 6tJ +l,r;ll.; .i.Lijlr :t^,;ll .;ri; 61 ta&,
+-JloU. u t!-l,r+. ft f !-bt:!& ,r+t 4rtttl-i,t't-:+lt
* * ""l
L.,r+..iJt--:Jl & * ,?Al;.r-r. iLl-, al:;tlr ,Jl;-Y-1
(r.Ad--Y,j,+ -aKtl - !
;ls!tr"rrft -lr\ lll c1 / tY. I I .i3J* nr3f r$lg ii\$fr$$l roa r. rl a 116
;.:YrJl ;L;.../ cJU L i *tt oLlrJt aL Ot..Jt lj.l .,i Jlt !fu;r,ot.LJl ,ra u*4ii ,rJl oLlr.rJl F+ rYlt +Il * i-ul ,,+ iJ r:er.1y'| ;t-^4ll ;Jl; L1 ,iYlr +Il .1* ^:-t*lr +:rti!l ot-.u.-ll jlb./,.{i!;JI .Jt5..it .*"-:lIJt*.,'i oLf,rlJ If.,I:-t tdJ. JS.;;..ro Jr ---,..lCli.!.,: llr ioy'loLlrJlF+ ;|..;-lu o*Ot=-Jl
.+-ll: L--,.JI ot ;+tI;;r.rtU|ir5-loLlJ, -
" l^
.(Bogardus Bogardus, I 9 25 I sas s) tr. i*,1-1r
;JrtJ Jl oLlr.rJl ,*i, el gr Bogardus ,-*r..,Qr i-l-2.r .r,.;.1
,r#dJl r-t:: - ,j-t+ r-.:-2Lr;[i c ,-. .-,,.';jl+ diU)l'JlJ r ---Jl i.;;r+_ L dulc^.ii.3 i[$_/Yl o. \ v r o .-;\i i-# +,Je r.nd,fl
xeli: x rrac * gttltr xj:br)il srliill iitrl1.c
OL t1 C.J, eritlYY 1V eai,d
IY Y1 p1-;S-i0v 0t t1 ,r.!'b.sF.bj
u_-p r+ \ t o . lb d.rt+Jl lb 6...IJ rtcir*:.2153, 61,.;_)St ;r.,. -,.dJl..u.re; qs_/lliit,lt4t ,i .# flro_ fr ,Li.c
. (BRALY (Katz & Braly 1933 Jl-".r Kats .r;t5 i-l-pJ*te-l+ v)tl iitnQl BRALy Jl.,r; Kats;6 i-lrr;J1!stiJU;, 4!l e:l-Ll3 ole. tl u* Jli*lrJl;i.u.-,o;Jl ,i+,.;,q:<,-J.Yl :1JtJl i- *:Jl otc-{l ir. ieJ-1. Jj r--L; ,rijl: -,}LJt.rJl;Yl ,CtJl,.rra=Jl ,..aJ!tJl,*JtL.)l ,c4,-.r.Jr,-)1,;U!l ,;]jYlc#:-Jl(J-,:qr qv ,], i..4_ilJt 4ult.r p]t 6+1t aurll lG;*l
"' !r.h.,ri glc.r.i.lrltr,rl+tr ;e!t.rtatt
Jey$rtl -ol tff e;. -1 / ;l' l l rxi+ nr3tr[rg qil$i$ PglOl atl^
i#;lt..,.,.o.:Jl li.l ,i!i C!t*, . *: +l-S s t-P ,clL n k"b grf'-
.(f . :\ 1t V r.aj),r,llLil xivVl oi -*s,s'Al )r,lJlr./b-
,rliJl rih;Ju,&i .rL:?il ;$l r*[l il:vll .r; r?-F.J1 a':+tt .;;J.,:U rj; -rir .a:, +t*Jl ;+l dl[r g*It .',*t^'..rl r"=; J5:;-
itiJl c.riilo.r:rrt{ :t --, $l*:t"*Jb ,* JEj;?;i c'-fJl o'
F . torrr;t tg',+r W*. f 6.:+ll € i'-*..."t-+l ;'l-;S L-9
.rtrtJl .Jr iIJJl ,liie^" ,r*s1plLe e+l f lJ:-t.rla''- r'lr,;tl
lLiJl cJri ,-Yl o.ro, ,.1*ll2 ,l,-Jl € iliJl ;.r-rl .rle3 ,rcL';11
r*oL:"!l ;t+l ,/ il;taJl olr+:Jl ,'c: otJl & Vrs:tCt-i, t+v
..+Hlr +t=*Jl1
$r ift:?!l;$l*;lr* dL;. ; :r2r.J,l.r'>L.r p'ti,rlliJli'i.L.:;Ju
i.|i",rt" t*,-L ,AJ:r;];r,r-.t u.":lll', Jl ,s'l:i )t*bllli'^ e rtlrri :L;IJ .kj!U rij,jlr iI;Jl :tiJl i:.ri & :5; ll t{iuiir il:Jjl
.iL$lr crLl .LtYi', ,;i*i'Jl re.r--;etq.:,-
iluloLllJl-A
Lt-:all ,t-Ie !t?i cr. :-lrJl er;;;.:^' iI(;'rl.+Ll ', -*-Jl ,r1L
Vaughan, 1988. Sherif,\ u$l Ujl v iil':!J":.'jl i L,;iJl 't'le'# i,.fq:i:-.r!l i-l-r,.e otti)|.:Jl Dl; 'l* :'rJl tV gt;t ,n967
bsss1 -;rVrr- ,;1 ,-*,+JUJI +LJl .rrf f ,+ f;fot i.r"L; o3,-'!l r'r
drr'"Jl r,rc ;6 .-.-dJl iJ .i1.e,-1 \ t o t' ;l.o i-t\l c-lrr Allport &,ll
;r"rbl dl i.ni J! i*lrrll ,jr orLll ,1br2L +:*1.# t{rJ':-l djl
f .* C--rkjl li.r i':.r .(Ar :I " "'Jr) ':;+Jlr J-*Jt't 'i'di dllt
+t.-L .Ji*,I Tirut', 4t ;.r.t! :* 4 rti -'Jl &LlJrll ir',jb.roel-1.:";
guif r O$J.rr.., .r a'r', 'r'"'i gb'J'i
.,,1t "lt.r.rtlt -ol tff r-r+.2 / tl. I I Ji3Ji lrjrr[rg iir+ibi g p g\dt ilrD
t 'r r-i .]bql c'trtjl ,V. $lesl ir-;,-J.Jl 25"41a Z-lss
.(Pettigrew. 1958)
.q i iiti:Jl +"t^+Yl .J.lr'Jl Ll-r* \ t o A 1lc C rJ* fti,-lu,Jl r"_r/ J! i'-rf
' ,i.r c^i.r.r $r ."e;.Jl b ' r;* iibtJl .rtrt.4l
. t{r;- r,-.; iitetJl .:trt+l r.rr ;t +Jt^iiJl q"ti?Yl.ir+ .it-t+ .r)lb cr UU t'* y . ) d;! + ,*:*lrJl c--J+l $r
lEr ..iaJlr ,r-Jl .t 'u 'Jl otrt+1t t-t;' Lt+ fg;-lr t:;.jl
'J$ 15r :y'| t;.--dJl i.r,_.r-i. c^::i Jl ,all :.:.r f:-i+ d-Ul.*FrVt ,rf.-jl qr.-ll pJ'j'Llr i.eti-Yl :rtlll lrl:i,. * ; v . -*tjl
;.r,-.r-i, O.o +t-:?Yl dlr.o)u r.otll ;.r,.r; &btJl ;1 n;U:tt oratl S,
.y *'ijl
Heaven.) " l.+ijl 9-* t;c Jp-j crbl+Il : +i+ d;! i-|.;r(tgee
v-n t-f S r- ,r- i_j*il obQyl .it-i*-l Jl #* i*lr.: ;-i.u
cr. Zt\t,u+Jl dr. irL? :ijt-tll v)tl Cr .1rL. J)t; !/ t+jl;ii;;- ot-L oX .7)tL cr aL:" i)l.t .Jr :-lrJl .b c:r.al .rrJldiLt-ri ;1;-{.$ LJ-4J| :;rUll cr UU ( \ f . ) cr Jrll :.,Jlc;,f--:Liy
!,r,.:; *q cr,,J-4J1,-,)t!Jlcr Ut.L (v o) cr +tilli+Jl 6-&:.:^:lil. ,r-Jl v){LJl i,. UU (o 1) cr :iJUJl :.:rJl u-&:,ijJ4)l
.=".o,gJL Jr*!_ ,liltJl ,;:Jl .-)LLJl nl t{+.ttrJ (J; i-!.rJl c*-.3
u 14l.JLtt .^r i=l- ot-rt+l re-j J! i-lrJl or3l, , 6r,-:.ll,z;,41 41 L-r.-a:.oeL + strQl &,4.l; LJ r Jl,-)rttJl r,J,,$rJl
.ry'l
a" !.rsigb.r-i.,!e!t.rql ,.1e!t.rt7tt
;9lttr,rrlt .lltff s..1 /tf 'II.t0Ji tu3tr$lg ili- rruif t p gldt ilro
*t+.rll cr ^Jllr.JU L c.rlr Lf :*lrJldJ(^ir rrrd'll v1-';ltrUl ,,)A.LJ| Jri o".J.t<Jl ^., et;Yl ;-lrJl '- j ,Ja,Jl dil"- tJr .opJJt*-Yl r*t .;.*- d v>tLtt ,iip"r , *-i'Jl i-.*;'Jl otcr,.-all ,i.r .jL.orl
,-Ll d iJr;:ll +-Jl ;rsl;Jl ,i,r si g;lJl3 ,obtJl '-t| rL'I J^itJl
.t"-i ,*JLe .otct^f l .i.r g. rl .r;.,)t'LJl .13r obQY iy'l Jr<fl
;^li!lr cn;.Jlr q$-J.Ylt*!: -,. ri,Jl ,r>+ v 'V ll .:t*Jl:UUJI ettCl ir. rr+;-lr!l 4rt
. !9-r-7r -;9r.lc:3UYl
...lfl+. - 1tj;r rtdl
. br,_ b*lr _ JtJ :gi)l. i.FrL - niLi:;;!tL-)l
. or-!,ii -,tJ3l,;gyl
,lJ1lJ ,J,.-Jl .i^ Jr C.:all j;$L i."it itt' c.r i.,!.lril ..i. Ji
dul.-,. r*1 Jr i:.ry'|(Upadhya (Sinha & Upadhya. 1960 t+ rbL Sinha t+'" i-l-p
Upadhya b ,trL Sinha t<.i- i-l-;.r Jtall l-i,r .,i Li{Jl oLl-r.rJl ir.r
,r-{Jl1l!l .tsi"tr Jr, Sl t; fl'dl ./l;.lJ i-.*a&Jl otrQYt .1-ot.t+t 6l i-t .rtt .r. dirt cr.r.tr+ iS.;..i.ll r1.r'Ll J3'' CLJi H+-Jldf i c4 glJl LtAt Jt, *h"-!ci6 .:bi.-Jlr-j .r.u'1Jl vul
..rn +J- J!
,.lr"ltutlt -o'l tlf e- -1 / tl . t I J:6t-i dr3tsltlg iili- tui$l p gldt Cl+D
Sergent t992\"VlJlr-j irrqlJ$ obt4! )tsttr;,qr;- i-l;.:.(&WoodS
,is,_J.Yl c,,t-ul d vy'l F i-t+l Jt! otlt+l i-lrJl cJrlu
-),l,tJl ;itotr; +f,J! l.u-,11{J&Jl ';-}l g{.lt aij-lllr.r;;*l-,
;l t-r-Illl ;)',-)l' ;r.t* Jl dr. o.l^;1 ayt-- qi--r!l ot-tJl € +/l(\ \ r) cJ., iit ,Je i.-l)!l ,ir .;-r,-i . .ry'l cp glcll JiiL, t+*r
,<*,*):( r-{t/.[I r;U! lo,r) lrVt ;*ll v)lb cr. ti..i+ UU
olL r-;.c u.r;p # u#t,r;lloUQ)u SAS, APS.,*F ;r.6U;,'-o
"t i re.:_2
"/ L1.. )Lb l{+ Oy'li,F-:i+ J. ilL JS J-.-a.i-)3 +t-t?l
tAL- s-r- i-I5 t+.p.r"- l;li-;Ll olL -* u r-t=L tg;-,.:ll.iir1:-Jl ;Al -; oljl .r,-.r-:,
.rt=L!, .vltF .Jttil ntll'4|r,--r;:J ;lJl ..1.+ll l.r.;;-l $9
ir. ..t4){J -# c- -';il ,'-l t{., -SL- zrrr,i,-rt"- ire.-o i bV:-t-
L-r^-r* .il:i.-;t5 r-t.:\1 6;r.:,.o i.,, iitit+!1v1;ia-lyrJl'1r ett:;
6J*-a O^J,_ k ,-Fll .r (v) ,Al.J o1rJl ,# f; "p lLrvy'lvltJlot-*;.r,--r-:, ;::a.n; iito4l ,*t J-* .,:Jl l*lrJl i*>;
.'i .,*LYl JrUl J'<;- f}")l ;i .*tr*tt ">&tlt.ol--tJl .i" "/.ti-.,.Yl iit .lJl ,/ f,{rt4 €}l.rdJl ;*-ir -,,y'| ;-p.e t3.!;
. (YANG Iuhial992ffang. lggzq-r+ gU- i*l;
i-t+ C .rdJl Jr c"--,+l ujl YANG Julia U:+ g[- e-lr: a;L-. --J,l;r,n$.;i \ 11Y f[e .+*11 .r..:,FtJ F.ll rl*a:;l ;r.rt]r,rlp
cr:,sF C;Ul -kJl i:r .;-e ot-ul ef C q.ii:. t"t-+l i;trUrr..:- f 1 q.li Lf d-Ul JrL'-: i-Je ;rr--r ;9t!Jl o.La ,t ;' | ..1+i
t=l$ \r r.l*4lrti!r. \r:,t=l* lii;-i lr ;Jl .i.r;l-i c*
!!iJt rj!i-,,trg -: lil.r.t .,i glc.r.i.1elt,rt7tt ;eltr.rt7tt
.;9!tsrlr -altlf r+1 /tl'tlrr3rj d.rjtrlltg dri- tuill Pgtrdl e r'! ^
q5,-rr'11!/)f-LJl.r.e iJjtJl ;:L -'Jlol 'r"ajl : rtlllr'o':'' i-l2s
.(t r,rr ,r!fl ) ",4y'! 9;q5--rlt v:,r.tJl .rr i-rjtJl ',L Jl ol ,r"-o:Jl" Js- c,'],.2:'tll ctJ+i
i:LJl olr....aJl \r J! ]*lrJl c.i-r-r .".7y'1 ,r; ;t-a'::r' i-t+ Cr-i q$-/ilt/ltJlcr. eJU T 11 dJ *,* i-lr.r.ll 6-*1r;$tJl(dl+) ..rcl d;! I .---dJl nV r* t,r$*:Jl P il gG:Il 1.l-;&-1, v-*l I
.H.G.Gough
'L;1 ,a;1 ,* v-,J,t J! at.Lr- q$-/!l v)lLJl 6l Oult c':*.,
v)[Jl olr'n: *L-]r UJ; i:Ul -r:-r -tir.9rJl .;3-rlo-e 69.L;"
,9-,Jl e u4l b. Fl*to-t olrr.n: i,J-*,- r.*Jti..rf .AJlj 'rjJloL,Lll )J-,'. rr;e;ilJl 6i :-tr-^Jt Jt*\t o-w-)l.rlo ..-'*- U're
* cs,;.,:)lJt-iYl ai,.*- C ill olr...-llgrr g)'ttJl'rc i=-L!l. ..:t-.-Y t obt-4Yl r.r.-.
;il ,r.; 4siJ,il g)l-LJl v *.rUt*l ,"".r1l '!i,-a i*11(\ t A V.J"..eiD
.rlLJl u + &tal-+l';lr;+ i*lr.r, (\rrv)r",.c!l ,U..o.itigi-rt: .'v-'tils et)|, cl*.rrrll cr JS *: 6*U1e"' a$.,"!tc.--,+1..rrt! I .;r*U 4.i-.'l t .rlLJ I oK lr-r! ot rt+ I ti * J!:* lJ J I
i:-Ulc-..r;-l-e l.rti11 i-t+ v)tL cr. UU (vv) cr + ,*:*lrJl'lr,L!l ir. l.r- (l \) o--u; g;.rJl;tJl ,rl;j,-t t{;:+{J. } ,P}l 4lcJ:,,.r .(.-,.S - Fs r.o- -g):Jt ;L ;\\ '*-t' L'n'r-i :ejtCl
dtlb g* d d"Ji ,-r .15-l!l ab4l *ta,-! t{e.-ttt i i*lrJl.6r.ri a[i..
"l q*.r.rr! l r-' rtr t't4l
",t---L
2'r.J .&,i glc-r.i
;l3lttr.rrlr -oltlre..1/tl.llJii€ n r3rr$g \ilsiSl pgf dl il+o
iiLulr iit5,l ,t;E;20; .>^-r-l i*;f t .Jt<-ii* ,-*g,,'Jl L_L' i o!"
't;c € 4c c;ti U -{l ar;*l.r,tL "..:,
:t<-l O-1.*;,lti.'i:.ijl;'Jt ,r:- L.L- : L-lrJl, Lr-JhIl ;,1 .: .jtt o-s, -dl lu cr ijl.:::..J|
. Ojangi 1993:5) " .---o,uJtr0l iJtj!
ot*!|, .rrlJlgl l,rt!..r.k; ,.g.r.llv -*Jlo!r: c-Ul ,ir' !:'*;Jlt r,_.-^.:,Jl tV e-*- !t!l e..+ll r,,,Lt 1*15rt ;L- i-;t
. (Djangn1993:10) a ,.9 r.-)l: !l!l!lrt* aiirsr :*lrJl b- .rU dlJrIIlc'
& J'j,*iltJt C.+; * fi1,.:.tr,.r_.rdl lt. .t;ei .r:$ - \
€ll tl.,rtiiJl .r-iJl ar.r, &i- t{.11r.-Yl3 i5rtill .-"lrJL-, ,'.b4l
,/ t'.r:fl pr,rtr -{L: :*'-;ll o.rt; .r-:l:tl i+ 'L;ci pL:.rl al; -f.1",.Lti,,rle ;,-LJl
dL; L.rl*. ,-J" k".a* Jr-i i-rJl i*jn! -A--bl, i-1,,. err -f.v1Llt.* .,i6:Jtr ,3r.-.Al '#lt'= ':JlJl*,l
)F -ll olrt*i)l.iL; o,la'rt'J, 'r. ,JlerLllii,ir,yts C,+..-ltt-t. + dttrijl
\.ts obltr -llAJ-t oJl oL;13 dt-:"ll gotutl iJ.r :g..'Jl .q.c .rr- ;-!r
.( \ 1v . .i,..'Jl .!s) ;,".at'll i#.lltiJt'.+, j..'.a,r;Jrlr
* ;'tl ot4$l .ri € o.,e: LrLe., dl +-a; e-Ul +y*-a,.j,-;-,;l .:-Ul Jrt -_ i-lrrtl ,j.r.i; Cr..ftlll ..1d:,.eL:+YlJ
.i-hll :.I- k"Jt.4 dl q"t-t?flrrlpl g. b'q- or,.-1 ., *Jl ;rrt!. ;11-r..Jl1 d.:'Jb ."tlr)l: .+ll b,.;Jlt
Jglt.uttt -ll tll e. -1 / ft' t l r.\irt Qgrlfg 6ri- rrui$f Ptldl arf .
,W:,i.uL;. ,;t-vv c,)[?[L ,lJ'"!.J slji J! iiL,! d-Ul IUIq-q.k)tL, ly)yt4i-tll ;iLlg. i.t-.tc ;;l"zt;dJ ::^t*iJl;'\b U
+-.,",-a,.zi:4;otrQl :eae i*l-,,.rJl,b t{r,t}i ,:Jl dt -'Jlr'i cr
.€.Jrltiti:Jl .e '*ll C ''d
oFJt;II otcQl oQ ")ttlJl -r
,,;li- ;r.5:*t d L-3.t c.t 3;L- .i=Jl '/)l'LJl lF Ot-Jl li" C';rLL- ! F:Jl v)[Jl ,,a 6l g.:.r:Jl yaLJl r; rt,;-Ylr +lFl;rr"a..4iJIl .t4 .#t4--! yl^t 6S.h ! ,*l Y! :5-Jl 'r; l=.'-'; LrGl
Lte
(Diangi Ahmad (Djangn1993'r'-l urU- i*l-p
\ 11r ltt l*5 C JtJl FiJl i Lr*A Jr- l*lJJl o'i'n c'-,'i
* dlr|..ic^lrLu-r,i-.r:(Jl r.tt b4.".;:Jl/" 4t cr i*lr rt" &iit*3Jl ;l :-tr.rJ t o-i.r c^a $r .JU l,J':ll ot*; j ;'rey'l ( t''Al
r.+Hl oWlrJl V:* y:Jl .-'.oJl ir' iiL; J63i cr *'tr i3ll
':: --ll ;t-.t*'Jl .l,tt; l*trJl .:;1 ri, .+li$Jl rrjl':t*, :';-rujl
.r.-ii 4Ljl a+r $;,.Jl J!,'9:V- '''n'CLi 'i3Jl &l*jllr :-t+l CtrU:yt',*J1*- .,-r.ll ir. ULU 'ti'\i- .5'rJl fL3!l +i ,; --Al lb sl*,c^43 cr,-.,,til ;i, -,)lljl u-t+ i-t!l € ,F- 6'Jl ,r"LJl i:^:Jl Jl
tltJl JtrL; .itt! J! gry .r-r-1,r.r' {tf q;!+'l I.-ii$l'j'n ;i i-l.,'rll
.q'il q.i ).*- /l L,rlt i*3IU 1+ ;kr'Jl t''' ,i td"t+ f- cr'-'rJt
cys )4iJ jlgr*. s+ i,..r--r*Jl ib .l'belrt#l J!t+- ,.''*ttt
(Djangi 1993:1)tr.i L-tJl:*tl irb!J!i^t' ':Jl ; Ja':Jl 'i'r ≪ '',
i,-t' 1Jt(;l cr n dl Jrtll: oLl;jllg' b'r i-lJJlcrrir
'E IUK;I cr.i-i; ;i t{5{ djl'L-t Jl:*3'iJ itJ'Jl i-t=JlC
p.r,.oJl lrr j e-Ul Jr4,- .rFJl +u r 1,'e---;'uJ l''::a'Licl g;'rJ ;:3';3Il
f'ib9 Jsi glc-r-i.1rlt.rt.3rt lJe$.rl7tt
.rflrult -.1trr g'.J / Fl.l YJ:jrJ nrjr$lg n$rrtri$l p gtdt a I I ^
Olll e ^#tU +.r*l rr.re.:Jl, t" dl ,€|,|glJl &, i-bl.( r r,r r .f+lrr! lgrl-,Jl
LJI ;l i,::, r*.-dlr L-Jlcar ei)r,Jl l]t;3,t €lrli-1.,.r;J3!u6p C t-.-ir +ll LJU ,i.,.a,uJl &t^l+Yl )* c-ll crt tt C^r-Ltll: kL '.:-YioL:;Jt cr :--ULtrt<i!t, Lut dt :f ro Jt ;r*yt;*lrJl c^.ne .+;)Ms ,2o i.2e,a.;,;Yl cr" iJ- iE crlrr.n: ..*:ij-,J;lt
ol*3. t+-Yr ,-*/l *jl C i-4-:Jl,fb-.,Jl litiiJl,j.tr,Jlcr.L+$r .L-Jl ;t'-;+ll rlr ;-,adJl 7:)l ^,-.t;.J" J-,r Jl i_.l}.ijl :fJl$r.ol--j o;.-.lje., rjl i<+lr. i-.1 .Jr *JirJl Jt i-lrJl c".al;
.L_efl:.*t-+yl ;$! ;l,a.iL;-; ca_q .Ul!e
{.s) ;ltiJl ;.rrt7 ,-r)rt}J ii.-rrJl otltjll :rlll .ro.c .ron- ;rr.. i-l-p.(rrr.,dll
;r.rinloLQ v)$ cr ^Jt!r..Jt! r . . #! * rrtri-lrJl.i" ctll
:"p tdld^L-r y:Jletcl cr, \ r r . lt' q* Vs. .-gl v)tL o :,,, -Cl otreyl JU- *"t* o.r5l-
. i_,Jl litijjlJu!('i if.adjlot"tjx l.rs t.(-. J& iliitJl.tjt o!-+r) gU}lr ,_f i! grr, ir*ar:Jl crbtjYl :elll .qs .r.- ,.;r. i-!r
.(rrr.,djl!tu i:.adJl ot-nt-4Y|" !* d Lb+ (\ t 1v) .lJl *r" * lS,oLlt4)tJ ;;*tt :;!t :*lrJl sJrLl;r ',,sr.-Ll e.;+ll j &Uyl, ,J.rJli-Ul1cu-l .iir t&t;Ylr _r_f "Jl e c4;lk r$:p .r:, u,.hlJ':: cjl
(,le ;*l-rJl&--*L ;:: -dlouljltirr.i-su *Urlr &) dl93 ,iiueV;-$lr LUI i;Ell v)l'L cr .JU, Utl
^ . . d *! c.c
i':r $.r .oU).J rilr,Jilj L.n.r-ld{..ill ,Jtu i::.adjl otrq)tJ LU.
ltl.J.rrigle.r-i ,..lrltt.rtatr Jrlt.rhlt
Jr!ilr,rrtl rltlf r9.1/lY'IIJ*irg Ir.gru. tg tril$i$l prfdl nf+p
is; ;rrilart ,{J .fL+il Jr.-!l."b c-*Ut -r5;,- e,u:Jldl- ./,+e)|}.lrl C d,-Ul ,t t, d nr|ta'41 .J- f-J.t ,! .-.-;ll ;iaie-Ut OU.- -"t-tl lig..1 *-lJlJYl C tra;r ;r"t}Jl dr "F ,rJl
aat F t ,." '::, ujlrtlall .b Cb! €irrt."'t- g.y't o!!l ; ;r-lt
.*Lt?11 ;$lr r.:all,rlc,t/t{t q/t+l e.+Jl oi crtlells el'Lill 6KJre .-.,.1-3 i-,1.2.r
.(trvr.OKJr-t
dt+lJl g.r*t! j otct-all i)!.1r1, .il,t-.:1|" at*r .7L-! r--2r
.dl .i\ r+ ")!
1-1.2*l I o,u c.i-rer,'obL.*l ou iH ;::B lJl itrUlJlr
+i--"Yti*qtC -,1I -'}LlI.s-rJ.il*u-!l ,H € o.!-Jl:.ttt :?YI
\ I oVr\ t v' i:dJel-:, Ofrt- € Jte. €( \ t o Y) fb vy't ULrl ,r ,Yrtl .;; .it:-Ul .r.o, L-lJl 'b J*l c4
,rlJ*:Jl ,;*-)l6Cf aU-Ul 1.r;.;-t 'rir (tf v') fb ; o't"'r 'lrc15
# u;"r*l;J e),t!Jl .rr .'JrJl ..}*.l; t4;tjrr ".=;;
IL:, I ll-r.;lL..f!Jl e*l:,i".;ll ,or-rJl ,s.rJl J'^-ll ,iJiUl :.r'r 1*,.,J--t &t;L?
.ii.ry-Fll+L c-'.r- dl .*Ut llr +L*Jl ol-r-!l ;1;E-ut 'e-*l:e)flJl u; .rc,Lill ot-rJrlo;
&.rd lF- Jl'-rt vlLll u;*J .LtYl oL; i*l-r.rJl c;:: *rr
ilulv)lhtl*!1 .;13 Jril UJ! il"lul Jl ,ti.;!l -la;:-l c^o ;ll,rt-ll .ajllr i+ll J! ,Ltll 6; tj btJ :d .:,r- Lr: otJtr
. ayr+llr Cr,-db
;g'rlt-r"rtlt r\tfle..,1 /tf .\llxiJ. 6,13r$19 \i\ui$ p $rrf tlp
ilfu. ni d-'Ul irt-,- JIrdJl .rr"r vt#Jl i5 .rc t*Y r ,r,.y'l e.:+ll,* ip.ii<t Ul Lt+ ...X*)l Ly'l tit--:+- .,i .jrLrJl ) qAl
..t ;Yl i-:+ll i.l;!l cr. trJ:e Ji 1:+.:Jlr L-1^'JJ i.Jill;a.ca
sp @,J,l.ftJ; cr--$ C J;t i-Ll ,!l*, -tl; ;-re.:*Ul r.rcj
I zslle
'''{-t". cr_i)ll ri*t (J!-Jl, :'Jlilllrt r':1
. i*JJlr;J*'ilJi*.,/'1&Jq F* UrL -tUi1r:-V, ;. d-Ul C
i" iL:.tl €t q1.#.-,.".dJl lf v ,jh,. ;)lt.'i-l.:Jl e'--n'Al r.ftt_s g.{ 'tl p St_L-tt
qribr-Jl U t-tl crbt+l . frrtl +r q:*fl-, iiJi dJl -r..o i.""|-p
.(t r r o , f*il .r.t.2 ii$) y't'Jl.r. ,'-l e'r tznq,:1.:y'1 ir. i-Lfl v)tl ot.t4l ;,,c .i^531 J! i*lrJl o.i.r c-i-r..r
'r o t c*l* + *;-lrJl c"-*l rir ,ful o.d u:z-t ,4 *_A\J _r _t
t- ar,,_.rJ I +-.,.-l I j +.; I :rJ I ./ ItJ I ir. .f q I d.:J I iL,r *J l.L: U U
:i*lr.r.ll t+ g=; djleth,:Jl crr ;rrHl :-t? C.,lrili-K,
dr. !j 1 \ r,'.j 'gYl .l- g,. oUt!|, ^JLtl + L-t* 6st "rs le -
,!tul,-,.,-.ijl
.qAl q - rllF gt+"-!'t+l .rr-J +t-lA r as;l.r-rJl v){lJl ;:&i-../t-.,_yl ,i .= J- tl .,lr rLll* 1i-i)l ,,j*j.Jl y; 4h l,ii.Ql ,;Brl -
..y)t-)lr r.1y'1-,F:Jlr; .,*t.a,-)t? i+Jl ,l,il.Qlr;l -
."- t"jL #l-)t.^iJlr" i.JlrljY i*:.lt +lJ -,r;,jl;5la!-...tlUlr s+t-IiJl,=. itl 15
..!r!t"rt4tr ;e!t.rt3tl
;e!tlrlt rltrr €.J/tt'\lr{ig a;1tr$rg bi- \'rlrilr P*rt ilec
t{i-:ir Lrrrrq ;ii- ! .,:=1 ;lrtt pl i:t-e: ;;*?- :6il1 6l i*t.,Jl
j.iFJl ;i/t &lr$ us o$53-2"1';+l ''a1 ;l3tJl 32'2i2-2 +};!t
,h)l ,*r.|^i; g.r3 ,J+Jl .tFl ,/ i'i':Jl 6l'r'iie ;lrtJb ot';!lc;i g'^-
,h)l :t* J!t*ltJ ,..-o.-- v .{lJt?.ru C':+ltv-riil 'ilLJl i o'r--e
.,L1,.:,
.p ;.#Jlr,r.lfiJl !- r;tl Jr'r-l J!'" gJl'rr'o i-l'p.(rrrt,.r.rf 1
C.lFll C.i-rJt ).t#\.--':Jlrl^iil Lrr' o'i'r r:-l-r: C *lan'
.#':Jl iK.t Ol c.-Ul 6J-t ' YFJI i5 't:r' b'rlr "'
4 '4Ali.btil .*-t :-F cre,t':-S U!it* !.}-)lt L;tL!-t-ia' .,l d'}Jl.l
!L;u ;.rc.r.r-:r.,-
"i cr:."er\ll i'-:+Jli'laj\Jl u6* J# L :\*'Jl' "lrllz4t.p \rt-,,-,'fl'';,,! uS C.tr" L-Ll 'bl*'t
'p;-fl ,r*i/-Jt p-ti FaJe t-t-,l rrso crj'jl '& * FII -
''"J".cr-rJl
'jSJ t,ri--r.ll ;'-tl iretJa .rL
t':l -
.:-rJl r ;J-!l Jh- C ,.i':'Jt? r- 4 -b -Lui A'+ -
Vr.*i e.-Ul 6i- tpl €t gl.X '",uJl tV v ,b u+t'..i}:Jlr.=iJl szit- t g.kJl 4 S?-;.i
* -i rtfjJl g.kJl +ti Jr s+Ll i..)t-"r..Jl i''l.p
. (t r r \ ,g."i.11 ) .i.-L:,| i€U i'*Lei Zi."a
..1; dl o)rt(:-tl -J;;l ,su!J5'-t- ', ';Jl ;l itrJl oi'r q;
U .rrfl ;.r.n Lrt-a- L-21 teqa Jl UU; ilfu'll 'i'! .,ifl '/FJl.f;+^U LUIiJEll'r++tl
C .i-*Jl t €fill - -JlrL'::L i'-ULtct!-). o,..ilb' c-Ulr
..1r"ltr"rrrt -ol tff e.1 / FY. I I J:riri n t3l rf tg iiLri\$iSl p gldl n r I n
r.*- rt.:*Jl-; J-l* ra,_!: r-r-_ l ,.o-. C,-iJl ei,$i;-Jl --lil rga_-
Y i^I;l!l .J.lr.Jl ir. LJq ,--,_, 1;|+ qi L!_J C^;+ll f,-J C J,,-
!*.rBl:"lL .:rJl ,ft.b +Jy ./ e.ct+yl oXill ir-i .,.1" Jji;*il JSI -
. +tAJt yt*: lLJt : g,-.>Arrt-_! I 4 1t-i;.,yto)K,.;-lJ J,Ifl ,q-_b +lAJt iFtJl ..-"i g.o 6r;.t*U *lr-
.t rr+, )-j'ajs 'iilI ;rltl; ;r.-ol--,1irjtI.=ck"YIJUll fr\t d)t r t, .itl Jr. .fil .t1.c Jr*;:r, i...|.,p
. ( \ I 1^, 4lJlrir) i5 J-Jl;-L .,|-'Yl 4i,U-lr.!l o. t \ I ir. :j..o .,lc ;-l)Jl ..i.n c-_r-i
,l.r.i t . cr J-*-: d*Ul o.ri .,. dJ Li+:-lrdl ;.r-rlr;raEil,*4 ,* c.,i-i5 tJ y ':Jl iJ .r*r rt+L,J-|r".:1--1 i-lr.rJl c,.i.e
*_r -# !L;rl r-e--e ltJt c.1-1 .&U)lr #l)l il'r,4- ,|l* * -#.:.rJl-rlji,rc lt*i;ylJrLJl! +., ., . dl j w, gt
-bLri d oe5tlJl t, ';lll :.rtreL-ll U:Jl illl i-l.lr. (r . .'r ,iJ.rs) ut:,lj +{x.b
ot rL-U i:JJJI il+Jl s-*i oU .")tL lLri.1 t'il 1>tL-t q.,
1xa K*:. cJl; L .1;t+l .*..tJl y)ttJl +JU ,:1 ,r . . o t-l* €d- l{i. e_ dr ftr JS.; t{Li dfi r::^Lr +r.l,l.+r. f , *:":l$lcr ^JU: Ut.L r v o iiJUl i*"Jl .'lji ,y 'l ov,A oJel $J .,r,)LLJl -Jllil ;;-Jl d.rl,lJl ir.r.i iiL. C.-F:,Jl 6J,,;;- r<,1 +tl ol-t+ g*d..;*Il C rfr- ;:) .* b\ L-&,i<J F{5- r;L:- rt;:-l L-,- l}rl4l',;;- r<-l r- /.1.,\ ot'i tJ.6,t*tl ;t(l ,j +.:;6 ,.e.rJl r*;
;e!t.urtt rl tff o..l / tl'l l +r. iuSrr$t g d$r$'i$r Pgtdr e I l.
,gi a)l2J932 Jif-, J.t.. 'l--ss f luv g't"'r i-l;r.(\ r 1A r.l.r-,9 6,.,r) ;9UJl ;.t t" 91.b
;JrUJl r-t+ v)[t .5J ,*-',c'Jl 2lL. ,;t3r2 g.* i-l.;r alrLu
.rLL gl.r;.:-ti i-ql 4t Cr r:rc,.5.rJ v '.;Jl 4;r, g*t{,Je c^Ler
+ ,*l-l.,Jl a-*ls..+:til r.r-!l i...o;*iJl-rt+;l ,r L,;*\l .--d'Jl
.;,:* Y f-\ A os farL"l c.-2l1;JrAl i-q .,i ^JG, UU t r r c;t:
I o r ai ealt;r.r$Jl i-L yll.* * . .Jlr-a,r 1L[rl l*lrJl oi.r d;-.3
v- dl nl, &1 € ey argl- i*Jl C ,6ll v I t ^.,
ou1l cr.
,JIl.,-t+Il "f;lLbJ +-..all 4.iiftl V + ,'-3t , iV ir*..r.:,.' i-l-p
.(rrrA,gLi;)(-LrJl
J-rb- i! , v -':Jl ',.' : Jrk"- g:Jl Lt{Jl &LlrJl if (V i-1.2.r .t'';
oi.r ,r:-1,.r .tl.- C J-Ul ,.SJr- .,.it;Al;r,rtLt c4,-,"-ll .li.A'tl V * l3:..,.-[Jt *Al c.;+Il; t{"J ,rt l!vb,)l9';iJl: *- *Jl.ri
yt-l Jr e.+{'Jl oY3t -J1 uJz:t i;:rtl &-1ll oir y 6}Llr
i.fc ot1$! J! Jelt ,b\ vt ' C':+ll or ;r"-r'llr"lpl oi'r ot-iJ;3
C.:+tl .'i qi.ij.llr ir,J$Il ,inle. -13e;-l .:-ul JeL !'^;t1 o'rt Jr.*Jl ol ;-lrJl ,i^ i rCl cr, .:. ' ;ll o.i.r 5'; p1rtot4l $$*le *Al* :? :..."q- ., l;i ;rLil .b-qi- o. U-it,.ll tl'.U I ;.r,-Ll,t ta*bl d
: Q-1 ir.rYlLJt ett,i g.o i-l,.rJl..r.r o;-l $3.,4),-*3
,-.ij,Jlr -,bryl r+b .a1 .raall ji:+J I i...ri J' ^+Jl rlii 6e:;*ll'rsl -
f+Lill ofr * Jt -jjYl., .J.Jt+iJlJ Jt-,-il ,21^. x-;ur.-' 611.r'Jl3 ,.r-;JlJ
itLJl e-;G .g.rJl LtAl .i,iJl : .:'-ll ir, cltr .ry irr:":Jl ji -
ir:"-.rJl otot{l r-rG ,.g.rJl 1:rJl * ill.ry3 f*'il| ol*tl-,
Jrlld+U ;e!t.rt7tt
.-,1;-ll, oLL'(l:
.19'Jtr.rrlt -oltlie..;/tl'tlr{irj ir11lr$f g iri- \rui|lt P g\dl a rl'
q6- *lAJl ,reJl .ri *;-- 1.u.1 6e.r.Jle J.rtt ,; r:: 'i &bt-+l
irJ-,.,- i':"Jl rlJii .Jci .:i-rt -11 "t'i Ul;i li! L*' )lr ;rJ qJt('^:!
;i/l "Urb clt- -Jl i-l* 'ub .,t:rJl u*:lrdi .uor a:li+ c,lrl{ i+lj{,Jl ;Jt*lJ :-' i-rdl t-l5jl .f5*: ;*t} tl l{rt-oljQ A &l$nl Cjl,ip .4Ji 6.r .cf,-fJl ed,Fll ,1 ;',olJl
;l +lr4.rJl oL-.r.-:Jl g, l:.r +lt- r*-15Jl C-:+Jl Jl.r Lr i.-z'-S
.,Jlri{Jl .rerl J5-5 6p G'r-bt.r!U rt -- r-l;il'Jl Elt,. j g.kJti ;Jf'il l,'-;;Jrl fonUfl ,.i|,-.-ajli-,|;s
.( t t t o,sil,...ajl) Ul'qtl
eb .1 ".kJl
gp .1. ;:..)l 1*ij .il,Jl -l; c^-*, n-t-,W ef .:"-tJl .r-rl -rie .\ 1t o fb .-rFl rJe.r, L-il.ri':ll iLJlrl.5Jl.e g)t-)l o,:ll, -*ll ilJl c'ls-p J:ld.ll F c'-- Jj-;llplr"-Yl-1 ,iihJl9 ,sekJl.1 ,fL.;Jl a..rU- .VJ:-l fr .rpt-:a!l
.5FJl 3-1r .!11 L g.L;ll r., ni r-tCl i i-lJJl c^:'y -rie .r./lr'
i.r,ll i-lS d-L-l L;,i i-tJl UJI C o,L i..-- trr-r-Lt -'J,llll. i"lJl iiJjl c rJlr' .,rHl rt iih*,Jl t+b Jrll i"j/l
rrbr)l-r .i.J.rjl t""J6,* Jr J"et*l ** ''t3s i*'l2s
.(trrr.J.tt -.,D
€ a-r\s:Jl ,-t-bJ)lr .j-bl i=.r-rfu Jr J*Ll i-lr': c^i'u
.j)tJlt-t;; J,- +,tlrll cr * 'lri,)[o:-lJ! t t r 1 lt' 3;5Jl C+llv: u-slll;r. l.:j rY v c^;! * ,* l*lrJlob c--rri .t31.,-.2'dle
ip i-tr.^:t ,b, ...*-.fJl C.:+ll ilF, ;l;;"- ;r,,2 is.t;. qitii ot-r;-.
pr**. "rrtf--
a;.rJl drLJl l1r. lr;il t+l f +tj:' iir' '= -'dl il3o., .i-lrJl v.*l sJl etul J){.; cr ** [J er r,.,: v" cjl
Jrltr,r'lt rl tll s--; / tl'I f r:,3rd nrjf r$f g Ari\$i$ pglc$ e t I ^
.ti.;11 ;i .;Ul C \.,0 oJoi sr.te.i LJiJI .rgG JS; sjl iiL.tl
.LxYl ;irUt j [ 0,1 J, t^+ "j:U.r.-l-r!;l,ri;f:tl.r-.r-i.1,,s
('i-.rJl
,Li)[J ;! rUl d t. Jlir .r.n.6.r-i r+-rL;l ,j i*l t'+ ,rJ ,,.,-.rJl
.a.n'ti.r.-i rajU:;l i i.:e.r:., i..rl ,r--.rJl
.4--f oL[s -r/A
,.g:l.rill)*4rflI ftJ dlJl .rlrt4l' u-r-l-Jl r g;rl.riJl i*l-2r
.(trrr,o*,-JcJl3
.=eirttourat Jr .r-."-dlC)o, sgrl.riJl l-iilr, ,pi,>"-$Jl o7:
cr, i+U i..,U" i-"tt \ c 1r lt^e i-t !l L-t ' ;ll .iL; Jp ;-fJl 1'tJl
,lr.ii c,tnQl3 JrL j t -*ll +lr+l t*Yr t++t - .':Jl [-t ' ;ll i.^ri
,iL---e(Jl u )j r - . . dJ 4l-* * ,*:-lJJl oio c,--l .i;-.Jl
j iJ).;U)J lr.,r JpU. 111,v i;-Jl C.r-Jrtt i:,r c.rli d^:.
.rie ,iiJl ;l;1 ;r.lV Y,1 tJc olrta.: .,Ic ql^-Ut ! " a;6r ollro-rJl
Jl,:,- t- t{.:. rU; +t".Jl L-L'-;lL 6I*:; ;.rc ob*-r J!l*lJJlc.i}:+JUJI ett,;;Jl os i*lt-\Jl b-b,\,+- .U:r-,
DrU! lo A, dilgt[ '/.t orv -,t21:;j!lr-=.a.q.3; .-[.r -
,y I Y r,r Jytn lt t,v .ii$tr etqi :r;EJl ;"--;U ,tJ! ,,-i J" -
*q^}rtJl
./h)ti irJl rlii v ltt, et.i:eb;!t 6-;'$t 't]"!r-r J" -
.:':Jl.:lji g,. /.olrV qirtJlr.ro $ L+
.-Lu..7L7,-)! 'lr o,Y *gl:g:-lle .,Li:;Yl 6- JJI .lL-o!'-t'5 9 -.( o ).J5Jl', lv r,v
C*: Ji +n i*lJJ.ll .i-r t{r$ ,lt +}t-.FJl ;rr"-Jl 'LrLl .' itl siE!. &. *:rJ$r ;lltr ",-'ijl
cjLaL;la+h:i-l;: . lr+rrrll si .6:L1Jl *i 1 o1
('\.0-Av.r-) ltrrrtii.l'11 rsJl .lo::...r1 .r.,lrtl i$ift at:{.!-ll L-lt..rl
2'r.J &",igra.l.i;e!t.r.ql .1e!r.rt3tt
..1e'ltrutt -ol tlt e. I / tY. I l r:{irj tu-$ r$g ii+i\.tui$t P gldt e r'!'
.lLJl .f LlJJl,rttg*-i.t
.rlAt4l ;*1,2.r ,rlca !r'Jl i-r.rJL ,tlt --;Sl t-Ui ,* f ; i..:-Yl
n;\ & r^rtiJl,ir-aJl ;l;)t Jl, cr-.rkJl: +qlll r-, g..+rl rl,.ii
f-Jl.r g,.'tljl: '-dlvL; cr" JUI L::.l^r r-u li.6r.g1l, -,.';Jto"-u
.LV i-2-. ^: ryll ot -:4f l ;,;t i:!a,tl i?r,S-*Jl otoQYl ,* f .i r--Jl .:LlJJl l-it+-, t+t! ri;L- ,.9!lq *Jl i*l.,,r,rl,o t ' ,i;Llr.rJl '.t"u iS;2.t+;t -;4.
.,jl+fl ba .,i i-JL+Ilr+-YIoLlr.iJI.j)[;.rlt dlJ;r tai.tUr
t",-J ^l=u r- Jl ;r"U.rtr *--,+i Jl oLl-r.rJt ;i u' ,i lJ q.; s,
W ,-e*lt;r"ot-LJl .j.l :l.i san L.t'e cf f.?L; l.ia3 .,,ll tJLJI d.yt5-)l: J/t!t6L-+ ol,,-Yl,ia J,:^i..+X;ir *:r,-rr ?!:. olrLrY
j-iUjl -r*Jl JrL; oLlr.: J-*9 f- ":l ,rct.?':lle (Jit-aJl lul rU]|,.!r'Jl ol-;+Jl C f-Jl,
j|+,/ Le.t ..:;-r l-r+ ir:L; oLlr-rJI ;ti :..a.=l$I J9JJ ;*,:JUr
L.-ys;r^t.hJl oi,t 1-,or"o; Jf trUJ; "fl
t{"J cilJq:e)u elJlJ'ri t- t'; ry &-fJt .,i qltr{Jl ,lrgll ;!r.LnrG e e}t;l-r.11 lj.o € r-*ijr+itl&LlrJl.rQ;ti +k &l-J.v.lrut t-
.br.c ;jr L-e,Jl q.t- ' \t ,Jt kJ j t i'-tt L.,J o.r;1,
q-$Jl C .r"tJitt ,{J si---Jl Jrul aL Jll o* ,it!l li" d,Jl tLlr-rJl u:'+:jae J!.. ' ,i oe.c1t ' :ll .! CJo c..2 crl; '.^:,-
Jr \ 111 ft' bQ.*l djl l-11116 lrYl +2.rJt te).L-l t+U j;i;. #y'|'JUIC lJl*ulr +t ...--*:Jl
l&J.b.',1 gle.r.t.19!t.r.t7tt ,,!e!l.rl7tt
Jrllr,rt l rl tlf e..r / tl. I I J:lirj nr-1tr$tga\$- r$iSt pgfdf 6I+0
oli.,L;ll Clr, cr J;nlr J-r:Jl .,i iiJl tl a:t-:'oJl rlji rr 7A \ -..411b.1)l:
.12.; a-'-, aat;..illl;!.1e-r;*- ll t -..,5,i 62;r,r.lrt="J,iiQ ofi$l al a:t-lv Y -
.Uly {$ i|;'J^*,-.i}:ll a\ Ut-lo A -
.,*a'A\.j-bl Jl ."t-.r ,.'1J g)L-)t tl a:t-'t[ L -
.fX-N.t-.*JlL::Lll t &:6-',. dl:.j.}1l ol;rrt-/-;.t -
. ..1,--rll 'l-2e o;;;; ;glb o--.rJl .;pl l1 d:t- &. /.V 1 -
rlii Ji g'. dt-,i.L3 ctoQl-, uj3.-.a*lJ t ::l-, Uir,.4., e[:.:Jl ,i.rr
..,.-Lll .i-fJl C.:+Jl C j.inll
.r;,,Jl *tl i lrLi:jlr i+t, ,.-.4rJl ..r.-il-l i.i.b3 i-I.;r. (r . . r,.rpit, i'j)|rl
i-t+ v)lL u + .,.b \r11 ftr &--SJl .,i i*lrJl ob cl-i.iL:*-lJ!.i-, ,.g,_r(ll .;)ltll cr ^Jtl, UtL v t t c.iJ dJ &--$Jl
.i. j v)[Jl ,il"i S, .,J_.rJl ]]l € ort ':.ilr',--dl ,e.r-.e rLi/.t t,v oJ"is, ,,-d-,Jl *jt e rill;tl ecl;L * cllrt '-:ldrr i-lrJlIt r
"s.r"i, ,e/l *-)l C d-rJl * Jl rt#l i:1Jl .'l,ji ,-).LJl o.
flr/.A4,\ otei t vt,..ll4lojr i o.rt;;lr,rjtll'," Jl t*s g..:ltllirL- rL L:-L.r.lr r + -.: uXul.- djl.)t- .,liiJl *" .:Jlrl :-:1
r,,+Utt ifJl Cdttjl i. dl +L-,Jr!l iJ/l i;L-,r--.rJl r *Jl 6l
sr.;;lltiiJlC dut, v. Jl t;l,i::u:t iijlC s$J|.. dJl
l* Sl a+.,{ 4ll/ul C,*i;;- Jtft,i.il*r,, *ijt ;l->tLJl ol"i'*-fJl e':'all i
l19!tstlt -rl trr @.J / tl .l Y qiJt n$lrltg iiui- t.ttri$t pglrll a rlo
l9$.r;bY.;.r-a -t tq: +1145 ; ql*tl o. )r' 'lJ! Uir o+rt:Ll d' ll vl* id,lL-}-lJ Lii: t+L_*- r't.+Fl :-t+ C 1L*11 f& ,*r.,l.'il i-l5
6,^Gll ;rtJl t-ol.r,l JlContent Validitl .9r"*Il ,i,v j;e.;Il cir, s,t - i i vt.LLirYl ii.,;.e-t;i .r.i3 .olriill ,J;lJl .;L;Yl, .LL.;rYl ii "i.il tiir
=,2:1,ll i 4Lg i;..ar Jl.r ol-rt,Jl .iL; ;ru lL-rYl 6i ;l.r!t i.-l,Il
.fLll ,-,-t=;!l 6..;* .,i t5 iy.-a .,. \ ,.9j- ,) rp -ri lL;rYl ;i6r-- ba qJLo .=-r,,-J. Jr,; r+ :'; I I oj.r, . *. J I ot--:4-ll,,i-.,S'Jl 6.:+lt,
. ..1.*ll r,! ,rl;l-r.ll ot iYlGronbach UJi 6t*r-5 iJ.,u Gi3 dltr'll J.t. yL f r,
9tJ trr:.i J:SYI, J.:i!l ./ .i-rtJl oj.r .r.;j ,otJl .,u Alpha
:.:,l:'llJ.l- d-*_r.(T Y o:\ q 1Y,(J'-rul)ot!l
'Yel.o(---\)X--=Lill;,Y1(\-o)
,=^;,- q=::Jt or!-r .,'tYAf iJ<Jl t{irr"-.?;l.r)u oL:Jl j-L * S,
i+d t-c.i, ot,-Jl9t* f +1JU r1-" Cr.r:qJU ,.*L. Jt" oti j.L J!qJ'-; Jl,,-ti!l olrj. { u 1+#Il .i.r dltir,split-half U;*:Jl
*:-+. !J ob;l| e i $r ,L{+ llll J-L .rQ J*! i v,JJL:II lb -, ,ar-;3Jl ltiJll g. ^rEJlr
i_:rrJl l6ryl g. .'il,,i L.rl.r-!
j.t- * .:.:: u,F*lJ ;Ell, JrYl ,; 'Jl )r+ c* lltJl &L vL F
& J*_ Utr l'!L-rl J"f lb, ,eel2t 3V2*,-UJ Ut, . ,o o 1 !ti,-rYl
. qJb at,* L-u;;*llihll&U
.;e!t.rqrt ;e!t.r.t4tt
;9!t.rrrtt -ll tfl r+1 / tI' I l riliJ{ tu_1rr$rg 6ri- rui$ tddril+D
\ 1 11 tt' ,-,-,'dl Jf i-JsjJl LtLrJli lJ,}- iJUl i-lr.rJl ;L,;,';- oz):-r-L .r! CU kJ ;-r,-.q [-L;i 6.] ula l*bJl "b ,rii.:t^t4lr .{-b ,L' ;ll ri:b j iJrJl .1111 iilii'll ,;lt?t v ;ll.zrL.cr
,-r.r; [1.r, U;i:*t -rtt oi! cf ;.r,-.$l +ltl ir.3.-,a'dl l-t F.i]LJl;Llr.rJl .io Ji d Urtu *,r:Jl oly'lr,J.lr.Jl uz'r;l; zlt'o.t
,....oJl :*'^i r.r..i r.1,bi.4l: .7)ltJl ,* 6$l: s$ll ,LJil;L Ji
!J,;-,*" &LlrJ r? oi.r k-l-;r gi .rii;j .+y|;!l t#tl+.ilgri'r.zi ,.Sl ercl.,,-.. .,J.c vUl € €:.-.-':Jl U,L;; 1jry .,i d.'i;
.::.tjliJt-!|, i-,:tJl3 ;1)\ F b--re igtlr..tt- C...-dJli-lJJleF. -1
cr. 6e-:ll li" +1" J^'-j"- \ t*}t d.,.-tJl e#t tiie i-lr.rJl .9;::.' ;rl :,-tJ e.4:*_ e#fl ljl Oi OUI e dt .i€r*t i-Ic olrL;
u &r c;}-y'1l,rt U lii: r*. ^rl*.. ib Jl UU g:Jl i-.,lflolrl-;Yl n*,l ,*t .:*Jl olLr t;i, o!3t-;ll, o[;ll ,t-:;l
,t*:.u:J,l4:' ;U iJtK^i)l+L+l'ib;...rtu J-;JI sle;116lliJt --.yl
tJ)J;bl- I .
y*-dJl t-Ui Jr,- i+#ll;l,lreJl ir. )re,rl".t+ d.--Jl e;F lo.r-cl
ot,l,Jl i+,',e .,le r-lJJl ;l.rl cJ-:-:,| ,;l;)l o.b:.:;ll oitll,Jr {lri,.r)$Jl .;;13r ul;tl 1: 'LYl :J.:-Yl cr. ',b .,,t": i-t-!t.r r" --Jl V ,F; ,el-- rarl.Jt,,-t+ll J&:lr.&--fJl,J ...-dJl
,*.-i v)ttJl otrQl t ut t;a-12. i iJrJl 2ere o2s62 orl i-:l;".o
.(1).-.a.l:Jl li"F
6ja-r.),):1ta:-:L-,- r:qjjliajtll-rA,J"dJtir!J,!c:Jr alLltr]- li.;;l:!t ''':..'"( f )
..1r!ru.rtt -ll tif r.9-; / tl' I f .:tilj Ar-1f rSr9 64ibrilr P gldt tlp
ful C c.,q$Jl Lrlli i l-Ul -,)tl L*./t --)l g.t*Jt', o;,j2 "lL,\
.^-*Jl l*;.,t* f:,41L:UU rr\Yl alul Y'\\/Y'\' s-lrJl;*? + €:(/.!,\'- \ "'Yt \r t/\ \1t) IJUJI i,1tJl eJ'rlJl .;ie
tAt!-J+i..rJl iJl-.-llolrt-a:-Yl 6,.lt --.)l C.:+^U ; L Jlet:r. ( \ r,r, Jr-rll ) c,t':.r.Jl ..-- Jb, e @l .ta+ 3
eJlsyl C.:+f r gr -el.;til! furt-Jl crbsn lii9 li-nrr rl.lii ejrr (! ) Fl Jr'r+Jl
d.i: L:'Jl ,l.,ilg' LjJl i5 e)U i*; Lbrl ( \ ) r+, Jr'll i;'tp-slr,vt,1:*r sjri ,i.rli L+ ir.'Jl C * 4 ,*l et ltr,ov d;!i-Ul cg1l, o:Jf
;-r,,<f f &tr,'.i.Jl J!."!l l.r.r -:3,---1 ,;*r':'eJl +5 v:[tJ
d:iLi ;.r,-L"i I v -# *o u2!1.:-:- t.LJl sirSJl i tk' Yl t C)r,: l.J ,ilt-l(Jl,i. j t Ul: i-FJl es.,ll L::Ll l,,li; Fa1-J
i;b il
lb €,rcL.:-':ll3 €tJl d^,nlJ i-L u-5t Jb iilFJl L::'l' Jlcui. olffll .j.r,rr c1*-2'dl gr 'rJc
CrlilSJl fslJFlJt fiac f.ed{rlt
eftoilT qlllsi
-/*n .]ll !Yt tA,1 l.1t lo, cl I I,cAI
gt:-Jl loA tf ,t t1lf l1,ov c,tT'tr
-.q,.iJl tl t l,Y Yt.A l l,fo 1,rt1
tJ.Jl l1l tr,1 tt,Al t,l.'/
,..Lrl, ir.riajl lr,t trw f,YA'1,
gt aft I ttt I IYAYI I 1,1A'/
Z&J"b.'rigL.r-i.blt.rl+tt .1e$.rl7tt
;9!t.urlt -ol tfY r-rr1 / fl' l I J*lt tu_1rr$rg 6$trui$r prf dl il+r
i-bJli+e - \ f
o!l5 c*. W j rt +5 t t &--5ll ;-t+ d i..t+l d,tJfll ,*o ad
.r!l oiJt il9 d.lJi Jldb-, i^;^.L-Jl frLU oW 6-r rrt;ll frLu
Cl+*tl .7)rt!Jl L* ttr ,i-Flr iJJl oL-t -:;Yl o, UJ; jfu.r . \ \/r . t . .,-lrJl fulC^JUr UU I 1 \ I t &t$Jloi.C
.:)lLr-ro 6,. /.tt,t aJ4pr: \AArt !t;)liiq<Jlyllrrc$j,Wtr (&t!l 43 *
"r.) r*::b- frlcr rrt;!lrt" Jti,ti.Lalt i..Ul
v /.y o,L i,.-.,;u. UU \ . \ . o (i-iJ- pI') i+Jl otJ(,ll vlL r.re 6f,
.L--El, :, -LJl otJ$t Y)tL *o le,*r ^
ir. &W 'r ? JrYl :LJl ; f '&r!'i=Jl * i,&LJS u.-; &jt'-tt&. L,,ll ;ll..:'Jl,.^"-Jl';rL, iJf \ r J"rilr t i.; ditJ<Jl,b J,-r ,;*rj.fJlr ,pLJl-, ,i--/lt,.llrilr,r*ll:.'r
.i-t+l&Ll5.r.rc g.
ctp:.ti,,-.-,!\ll+t tn, i::-]-^rl.r:r...* * i VUJI:Lrtl jJ
€ulS {:^lJ ,J.-!l C.hll .7}L .l.r.c u./. o ,F ! i:-J .Jt Jr.^ll t#iliiulr .++tr.iI*- dl :-lrJI olr+l J+:Jlcr. +.rb .,.- C*i ta-i
i;t,'"..!l 6-l e*t!l JrL u./l ljr ,tl! "f, ,::JJl ijt-rL.d;tlr
;6e,---*ll i,L^r ii"ll otJ<Jl !iL; j./)tLJl U. U* ts fl ;1t,
* Jl ;t-ol.r t{-+- & r -t €ui o<.i t- ii:r L* crle &.-fl .i{Jl
.:.tlr i:llr";r ry ,*;l* q:- -tt o. .i! .t+lr+! i.gfl irlt a-yl
UU \ \ t t cJ + ,* trt:- "Yl 6:itr o, gl.rcul i,r:-Ul drti s,l*r4lt pLllr b-,j,lt.TlrYlj +.;Jl o!f5 C .,.q1 v)tL cr UUrla- c.-^' el i*Jl di!<Jl L* g,. / l,lA ir*Jl !-j c-;f.,
itla-ll C.:+tl o. e*Jl iy:4).(/.1,1A = t..xlVAVf /l \ t i)
.1r'ltur.tt -ol tif s. -1 / tl . l I r*iJ* iu_1rr[f 9 i]qi\.ruiSl pd . rl nf ro
Jr :y.:*Ji i{:-, ll c^j-.ti .-..odJl l.r.n ,t-i-9 )tJ> G'a;i J*i cr.,
dV u*bt *ir -,}tJl -E +t u,s;"-;5Jlrg.:+llC...--:Jl-rL;;|.9-r.. ( Y ) r*.r J.,**l d Jy'l lJ.i
Jl'':rl rt.r, (r) r.SJ.rf.t+Jlrl)lfalt :tei icag C;r dJ-JSJI e,.:iif I L t+4:JI Jr'':r| rt.r,
er.+fllrlt=i,
(
Noa)14 X+lt x&tv @:Jl{i* ,t "t-i
1,tir, +rgl e.+{t eit r-
g,[illeiflI
I t l,o !a g:,-r<Jl C.:+fl frrl+
'"i3t.lrl tad.ill
r
I I,t ;" utrrlUtg&\rty'ttgltdl !JJ-.:J|
t
dJ. dJ-rSJle..+fl9,qt,^lJl :" -trl
t
i er'all
o-se*b 6p.'l JrYt rrJl &*,- .,!-ljl -..-djt ai(f ) Jrr*l.p-
+- ,l.- dijl li.6 ,,1*jl ./)ttJl U ll rr' crl-- c.:: C-:+Jl .rr o1L&,;13
I v t,t ./Ul v ..o.tJl p I r r, o dJ L, :,, i;[.:Jl iiJl C dttJl .-...".:Jl
.;F!lr i-ul irJl (Ji lv ^,\ u!-Jl .*-djt ;! ijutt iiJl c
?. djl u\ ;yt-.")iLJl u /.Ao,o Jl Ut^"I i:-t- ,! Jrr*l .*,-r
oj.r rL;- l ;rrL; -rS5; ettrJl .iar..i-fJl C.:aJl ,j;a-i,iEll .Jt(.lfi
..* t<J-Lr C.;+Jl d'ftllt,53i il;:*rl olr+rl -*v Jr L--iJl ov-ll rLFl J*i cru
.,Jlr $,-z-t:*).ret^^+)ll ,ti,;!l qP.rl" (T.tesd jUJl rL3Yl
. ( Y ) r.,-r Jr*fl d rL3Yl dl;; i">tt
'LJ &,,ri gl4.r.iJelr"!+lt ,1r!t.rt7rt
;elturlt l!1ri e..1/tr'lllirJ iu3bfrg ii'$r$i$ pgf dl il+o
i-lJJlettl-\f./ntJl €1, Jr i.+{ill o!;L;Jl o. iet-1- d*Jl iJt(*i,!c"'^ ''';i i_t-tt .u u;i J.,J., .t-ul .,i .,!.allr.,i'itlJl +i*! i" .:Jlr.5qj d-r. i,.rct--':ll l'{jJL J!rr-t qp6l i*3.;-t'Ll6':l C.:+Il ;ilr cr. JIIJ
a^all € ,uA.,rJ :l.u.l Jn .,,t+l d ..---Jl )-rb uli .Jutr14; .r-*- ;i i-tr.ll i!*i irr LL'JI ;r- "f
d-Ul j1 Ji .o"-bUl
,,-r4 F 69lr Ur )oel:l7lJlJ$l ,yt eU J!ptJt cr i-r,,- \1.t5;
i-ql ./ i ur, J<5 g.t rll ; .sdJl ;4lb .,r,2- .,i *:*tJl ,.Ei,
r, .y),t!Jt.rJ r. ,cr^--.,1-r!l"g.rJ ;1tlJl,.b rt.i u-n Jli-tJl,ir-,,LL;,.oi}Jl 'ir rJl;! ,/ v),t}'tt iiLr.L .t4il ,-)LU qiBd';l| &LrtJl i
.gr+tl,j t1;ib Jt-tu[
C.:"lld ?..4r:Jl )-t -a> JrilJy'ltJrilrr,*tl- \/ \ rr;l I J tiJU e-JJl C.:+J
I,/ .-tU ^f
t-t? | +,# I f
Ui:J I JS"i-
tnJr.*",- Li.r,t{.rU-: b"Jbr lpl-rtca tdt*! C.:+tl €t*VcJl, L
.fl.:1l ,,,!r- rl;Ju .::!iJl-, il,,;llqy rl.rgtt .*"J,lt U,tll+ ''.*Jl
,rf:.iJlrbJlaF- aiq-,ltlcr.r.stt-+lly- *:Jl i- u r': ;:Ii.ijlr
;)tfJ\ e.r$Jl ,*t;:Jl e;? .;! .Jl .pb ;r. lr-r.a..,rcL:-Yl
$ .,liJl .s-:Jl .ri *i.- liar .ili'll iepl -,,l,'= *;St c.f L-r"-r+t
qb- *-JJIe.:,JU.*',;||:.r i-L)lI 4 rh\eVt L;6.i-6-
ot-::Jl ,Ar". ,rp L.tU t{iLJtJ: i,,L'! ic,-blt ili .."t-t+l + ,-J,
Ci+Jl € PV .' djl 6L ;l;ill .35{ b cJ.r ifL+!l1 iv-t-Jl
.t;lj;*v a;$a;f;- C lU,
a&, &."isle-t.i
;jltra'tt altrYs.J/tY.llrrirJ iirjtrltg 6t+if $i$f P Tlrlt i r'! n
nuby -{.5t6Jl 6r.iJt uJ.rl IANOVA; .L*.-rrl !Ht+l J*r^l (t ) sal Jr-r+tt-l*.J.jl irtalStl :drl.r+ill tnb, ( g.bf l L s:Jlrrx.h-) .;9'*t lstt r3'i ,rfc firrf t rt;ii
titrarl ltll x x
i*lrJl &l..;*Jl ( ,;dE, Ut --! eJb .;ji'* s ( L) p-, Jrtll .*-di l.&J l -*,f : iL-)Ll l +J t--y l Orl l ol d,U Lz-y l rJr .iL,itJ lr
C ti.-;Jl :3ae l5.ru:;'-l cr,-!l l.LJl ol..*Jl v)tL CU 'o it"t+lt-r LJIJI '' .ll ,-,)tt L-3- id :;rYll:,l..:*Jl d.rr)-; u. -5!Ciall'| .,v * L':t,iiLi.ll i'" tl .,),t! !*:Jly \ .,A I l-tll l.u glr r \ \,\ dri
.JrYl ;:*ll .i)ttj i*:JU
.*aslJ LiE:tldtt+iltl - dUJlJrr.Jl-Y/ \ f.iEr ,r!-fJl C.:+ll C r.6, -*V', dt ;i,1rltry'l 6iLu -,-rtil
..Jt(.i,i
€ c,1t!r*-e .rd,Jl lj,o g;i;"- U | *;Vt .-.i C-h- g,JJJIr-Jl:
iF.Jl u -# -:.1$i tr.;, r;--rk & Pt y ':JlU" d-n,rJlol-:;Jl
.ir3 .rit-i:Jl-e cr,_!lr JSiJlr l-Ul JQ, trr.r^.a.. r:iEi oun Jr st$
.:4 i')\.1 ;.,;t-i*'il i.!r' : t"jf v. Jl o113, Jr z,-'..fl.i.6 rti;t J'?l
€ +:.*"-:Jt i-b C f1")l Jt+-rr u-Jl Jt+.rr olri:llJt'L JJ,- :ii'ts
.Cr+Jl
li+lJEdl&lJtuJlJ
-dtAJl
-a1.ilsll F, ,r..teJ!.CrLdl
c,br-!JFll
L#,:rt -|Jr I
ir1l r:rl ttail JFfl rta t
I
l ,1lo
!,1!r I t ll,oVt drle3.+tl&J &talSJlJiin.
2r tl-ll
-T
f,wo ffrff ttM,o^o nleJ.+ll dilr
xx.,.lf f,tl.
I lo,M CrlcJ.+fl i61 drlgUll t4iit-.a-lJd.l
Y
f,Y.1 I llw tnt, t lt 'rleJ.+fl Jtib
;e!t.rslt ll tlf s.-1 / tl'I ll:i.9c iu-1f r$g nf if $ilf Pglrlt e r't ^
o&.rll &Uri:,. J,iltiJ -qJL6Jl ilJdl o"t+i, 1 T-Testl gJlitlJt+itl (r) FfJ &.+tl
r1a:Jl*1!!:il t.13'Jt,g*tt s3'! !e rlIlcJl drtrb!g g-LJls.cl'':i*l, (J*b-'lf f+tt)ft t2 I
lltallLiteJl
sig-
t2-tailedl
c,brLJstl
f-!ill-+li'l
(o) r4.r
&rJafl t4 uA
=5il
Jiart lnrl
itb I I lAt t,rrrll cvA x5i
r14i+l I
eu!
Ulr I lol r,t. q
,+Jrarillr..rdlil,il.r
tY.
,rJ'i*.Jl :liiotta!,* Ut -lrJl.r 63i ,:rr (f) p.r J:r*l ++-
,J.rJl 66pl g;.r.,- c.r2 ^Jti *{* ir. r*bJ1t + u -;t'.rJl fLal r.y.;
cf LtJJlr dut, 9.-!1, t'tutt .,, dl :-* & ,s-,s 1;tlt, ,aLl)a.r-ll -,)rttJ13 .iU)l g. frt'ill*.'lJir e.:+Il
1y..gl &l.&Jlr i-lfll) i:.r':ll ot'rQYl oli ol=+l[ OLo- t-+r
l=tL--y I A:.ll e.LKlJ,t^4Y I lrrLi cJ/- ! I I JJj rL:;- I d;J+l (&iu lr
.(t)r',-r Jr*llC:k;Yl li! e;tit dJr
fi6.rr."i Ufe.:.i.lelt.rqrt Jrlr.^rdt
;l5"ltr,rtft .tl1rle.3/tl .lY+i# nr3lr[f g i*if\i$ PTItlt n r'l^
,rl" i..Jl rl;i .:t!!,ir? Ut --l rJb .;jri .:.5ry3 (1) p-r J:rll ++-
CU ,o .irll ,L 6i ot!-rJl u;t ,J-hLlt tJl iz' dir rdl;l,U- A,t1 -;Ll e:tttt L-r". & trlt ./)lJt, L;)V J^bll./)tLJl
.e.r.Jl.7),{tll r,t .
-i 4:?,n-i' J,*r, .li-ijJl irJ..,.,- J..aJl ,-)[tJl 6i ,r*- l.r.ri
,rJl-)tLJl u. -;1.+,{ * 'Jl(i:-t+l olJl, i.I.(Jl) ;r.r.;Il otrQ':ll ol! ol,+lt OIo- t-*,c -L,, i.:t-a-)l O:-dl C.L:(IJ.t-4!1,.r:Lic,r/-l*Jl JJr ;l-;l qt21
.(v) r".r Jr*fl C ru;Yl lia ettrl+ttett br nll ItIJt (ANOVAI .t .*rtr ;,autl dl.l'3 (v) pf., cbqltr6r,,x$t titg ( ',:trilt ?gfuiitl C,laigJl) 6/Utr5rrlr rjQ st Z;{t rL'fi dll+b}t
e*alJdtl AlJtutt3 a1llelt &laSlt
AJTJI
ii5leflF -.1
'L- ,t -
crL!.J,ll
el+.r,
i,JsJltfret-..lJl
.jt;Jl rL-ll .*ll:j-i1 I
Y,oYt
YV , Yo1 oley;ll ,;3 ot+Kll rF.l+.lJl
I
r,tl. I tA{ elcy+ll rli.l:
. 01. Y e[ejrAll go slr: . .il Jrii.lialJJ
Y
I,\tY YYot,lYl eLeSr;fl Ji'l:
l13La>1 llt^r x x
-#:.i-JJI;!KJIr+-t U-ir tJt---!eJl.r,;3j r3,;e (V) pr Jrrll,4,,-r.p i-JJl iiqKJl -* t?t;!-Xf l ULa-)l O:ll ai cit;Lo-yl
vX! eS r, t r astz! L-2-* Jr:t itrtl ./ .-lr!l iJS .i)tt CU
^,r 1 dJUJI Urll d ^:.,.Jl
y)"L '-
!'UJl iJ.rJl C A,r \ ,' Lllr i*-{Jlq5 v)tt .L i* t-ill i+-/l c lroL rrul .r)l! ,t+ i-lJl i;Jl ,rr.e
,^Jl ,:r.rS-i,- i-.li:fJl3 ,-,lr!l -,1t Jl .r)t !.trtJl l.r-r J-r,; v,A o 1.,- Jl.till &qKJl d r<r).; u Sl r+:+.---*lJ t'X")|, ,r--'rll il'r:Jl
.l-_-JJll5 (Jil*!,
a&J,!,.,i gl4.:.iUrlt.rt+tt ..,;e9.rqrt
.19!lr,rrtt -rllff e..l/tl'lI.a]€ 613rr$\ iui- t tui$r pgkll ar!^
(o) r.r-r ;rt ll J1.r,Ll ,r*ll lrrJ trH, iLLi itp (ft J+icr.,
at
.l=..)t"j, i+_r: t+t.ii v- +Jl t:l-o- Jt-'t.42 I U & $l I p:Af t i! elal I -LaUiil I CtqJiJ I (0, f.al dr.^-J
Ai.+fltltt =ir
'/.t-tal- '/..1.12 /.,UV '=-. ''ll:r+ Jh.l-i
r,Y et++': - ':rl .iil,'$tfl d;+ I
Ill,Y
r,Y Ao,lt.-.-tJl r,:.ji f)lsll JL. r ui+
t':_fY
I lY, t Y,Y Ar, t+..-. -'rl .rilcxJl Jl+J u.L+
F:+fI
I lt Y'Y Ao,A &..+fl
sift LaEiJl{3L.At;rJl
-.Jtdl
11ttalr
sig.
r2-tailedl
Ot-..1l
alstl
L+All
usJlInl L-l
&-Jill i4 Ura
J,ii:ll
J'ii:ll
Ji:-ll
UbJra,A . ,tr t t^tA,l Vl Jr55
1;liillA,ttt t.rB!
lrrr I Irl t,l tr,{
JFqtl
Jrlrrl,A, t1r
1Y.
td-
,f.AA,A CiaJl C...--:Jl -#- e.SI e,fd;.tl ;i (o) Jr.r-ft c'-,-
i:Jull lijl c cr--rjt Jt*, .tL-, Lt:Jl iirrl j lr o,l f}')l Jt?r F..t-
.:tiiitlr cr-Jl Jt*-r ,.rt vltJl U lA o'A oL- Lb i2.2.a.,5 .lt rrt. 4 : ? ;3,t-*,_9 C.:+tl C \r.--:J I e.ry-,41)lc) 19
.erai iu:*tt otr.dt ;L- Jr \/al rVAl ri.;l Jql "r,,J-:Ilr Qz-t r*).rrk;Yl .Li'tl gP.rJc (T.Tesd jUJl rti;Yl
. (1) p'r Jr*ll C.rt ;Yl glV c.';tt&rJ{i:-. Jiltu aJtclr u JaJ t,rr, :t 1T-T€st ) gjlit I Jq,:ijl (1 ) ts., Jr.rrl I
rajtitllsllrj! irr 9)llctl c'brT tL g*tt o,"l'aitJl3 !!'b-Jlrrlall), o4:-tt
;lelt.ult -ol trr sJ / tl. I f .a:# iu3t rlrg ii+ilrtl'i[t p glf t Up
J$'gJ 1,-6L-'tl ltvdt s"Vt ( T-Test) ('iEllJt+;ifl (1) FiJdg"tAlllrjJ1 rrF, 9)t!.t I if t; b I L sAlt o.L.i;I b 0/:'r, b J+ I )3 !s+tl O!{i:.
gltlt3 g,i3tl.l| +..:f I Ilj! ll1.tl|gr ,<iltgnlt
-4JJall
iiltoJl
sig.
1r-tailqdl
&l-.1
i.rJarl
LaJl
urrfn) z-J
&4jll ufJii:rl
Ja:-ll ri:rl
-eJ lr 1,.ca
l,Alrc JJSi
d.i"Jlt,ootlogl
fJ 1r llctt,tMl ,+
rA,rtbr+lo,l. tftv.
,J" i+-ll ,l;i ;!tq!* Uti-l rJb 6ei )r+r (1),*.r J-r-r.ll c*-
.,J;+lr *Jlt e-xll 6;;- ,g-, t/l./)ltJl CLJ rF ci-r-,il| ..r.n gi-,tl-r:Ilqa-3:.rckaYl .L:;Ylr;;.
e),t!tJ t,Y Jet; o,t r,-h!l e)tlJl L-2- * tr*Jt yXLJti \lL J-bll
Jt"- j;i i*"i :jrJl ,Ur! cl o:r.r..a:- .*.a,Ll -,)l,tJl ;l ..,;-- U.rr . rrJl..r-le ;i d .f tlJl, .,liJl .. *:Jl .* ")l
;i ot:LJl .{'..-Orll ol Utr-)l ilt:LJl i^-- ,/l ,+r et:,- L=ie:"*{l ,,':.
.'r_ li.t3 &U)tJ [,0 ;!U. t,A ,<L* * J^.- rj.rJl CL=J Ul -yl
.--dJl iJl;l i-Lc .,i iu)ll f rrt;l!.,S1 q-"i !,.rJl ;-rJr,- rJ-rJl si t ' ,i.,#llr,/tlJl
(i-+l c:lr*Jlr iJ(Jl) ;r,r'-\l &Lrt-+Yl ;l! olr;lL .rb- L*-t
,>,b, Ut--)l O-t.ll c di<! .QYl ,.erLiiJp-tJl J+14 2l-;l gsl.(t ') r'r.r Jr*ll d -rl..;Yl li.r ettrJ
1&r.lryl gl4.t-l..1elr.r6rt Jrlt.L!+tl
Jrhr.rJl -rl [ff e.-1/ tl . t I rl]g 6$f rfrg'qi\$i$t Pgldt er !^
sl+ill-, ,ltlJl ,, dl 'l;[iJ.e-r.ll :cJul -;y'| -r/ \ f
t.,ljJlr ,/t!Jl v. Jl .l;! rJl.rJl t" J! sr.=Ul .ilLJl .J;a-,;S
* ' :rI..ir rL-ig.c.i53IJ*icr. til;Jlr i#tljlill;!iJ-e-rJI*.*,- J"li.L.;Jl irl-. iJrJl ,* *.n- J" tl-rJri :qJlr- l*lrJl i;t+.*l c^:...-a;
.rr-..r+ cJUJI ty'l ;r->:.lL#tll ',. Jl L.JL-, t{.Ie.-+,-,-p: L+,tbr
FIJU J-i ut.J4lt,/ttJl ',. ^dl 4Q € il1.rJl.,3.: Jr ,**Li.(r) J-rrll.t+ 1v)ttlriq) uL")l;rAl
9)ut jiill ,y ilflssafiU.tl ':+.:tl rljl llg.rllgr (r) d1r!"tall
L..+fllltl =(J
lrrlV :/.al- /.ug,lv .,.- .r4 rl+ J."LJ
Ilt\ ,Y
l\ ,0 ./.oo ,^...- -:tl1 i,Lill iu..lLr. aJJJl sle.r.TJ
sL,JlI
/.lt,L lr ,\ lYo,t,:.. ^:llj :J:tlLjl L.Jlv Ul.rJl gJe'.'tr
"ill"ilY
rYrl lr ,\ 10,A ry+ll
at-r* tdUl +,L j iJrJl )t' & ;t:f .,-..XtJl ti(r) Jrr,f t cr-,-
!;t!Jl vrLr o1;J.rJl .Je ,.*",- 4;i./)t!Jl g. /.Y orl6rJ.ci:i$Jt u. ;iLb i2.+5.iJ,; t t ill-t! r.! I .jl,r V-w lo o,A .rJl c,J$ i*:Jl oj.r i5l3
+r.[Jlr 4,;ll i..lL. ijrJl .sL di.-),LJl g,. l1 o,A oL- qjlj-Jl et e)..r-1, ;1;
.e-i r *tl olr+ll .;U Jr'u; -tl ov.y'l,,t =l J*i cru
,-,**1, (r>-t r+) .rrL;all .ti.;Yl tt*.rJo (f.fest) jUJl rt :;11
. (t ) r'r Jrr*l C rl=3Yl dV J.'-b)t
&t.r&..,igf.-r.i
je'Sturlt l\ tlt e.1 / tY. I f qlrd iirrjlr$lg it+i\$ri$t par rrl iil53
iJJJI J';-\! 'irj Fi ;F\ll i,l.Jl v)tt ,i .,j!- lra-, LlJl ij-Jl -,}LJ
.+Ul.r J,Yl ;13;Jl .r)l ,.r, s!-iJlr *.o;tlJl ---Al .t->
...-.a*:Jl y.j ..r)r{Jall rrt t+l :glJl .,;y'1 - t / \ fJ l-fu i JL;r,=-r.^J I ;,.,,)AtJ I .iG t+l Uti*- I g l, I ry' I t*)*-i/ q:;,&-./j,{!Jl 6r.,-,-FJ r.e,i ii')[' ijlr Yl c-i^.; 'i;r.dql4r.;-t_,IJ;rr ;\t o1.Y!1,,-.^Jl Jt*,i ,iL;r (Jujlr iUJl ," ;Jl
----,:Jl Jlr;t Jl.:; -,){!lj d,l+,i d,)t rdl U,b O-J'r- rS-e\ ;.rV:
F*; J-i v) .*-)\ ^Jr.rrJ ;rull -. -Jl Jts*:i J'r ,J!-iJlr dttJl
.( \ \) r.e.r Jr*ll 'E f r:-lt IGJ :irU. nJL+l ;r:-
!<-anltalt urerill ctjt +)lalt C]bl"3l ( t I ) FfJ&a*!lLJFTU
\'\11 =!,'/..*)U. 1.,$t-y lsiJtrg'! &L;
A1, tirjisl+r'
-:rtJtld;6li.+-lt
el! eaJU.Jl t*4:Jl !rl1, (i-lg'tt
t
irl.' rl &hJCl Jj Jlll oj.ii
irl"rtlr UrdJ
Ar.+fl
.iJ.;* ; .-..o-dJl Jli € ,)-*-/-./lLJl u /.hA,t ;i Jr*ll .*"-f.A,y sr-e etli Jil;;_r .Jr.rIJ ;"L:.llc,l.'ill J5, U,tllr ..;tlJl dL-.:*
)o l: f t--),l.tJ I Ji Jrr+ I u *-t.o+; I Lt a,;2.zi r'-ir,-.rJ I .,)ttJ I g,
ir l,r r,\ i/*- ,.JJJI .r-d)l v -Jla+.r+,5it!1., -Jl Jlst;.ts-e';t- g1,i:,slri.Jl .r-d.IJ '/.t :rrt J"U- ,FtUl .*odJl Jl-,j -ct"u,-)ttJl
.*)1, alr.r.u;rt 't|., -JlJt<.jiJs.J /.1.,A JlJt-:l,rJl ha
j ;LlrJJ ilii*ll .f,lfuJl -;y J^;lt .*; C-b- ,s;,.|l Jlll:
a&J J&i ('f6.:.i..1elr"rqrr Urlt.rt+tt
;r!t.urtt .ltrr s.J/lY.Itr*irj 6r_1f r$lg tr$f ui$t pglrl a r .p
7.t->/t Otrjlrr lrydt (ANOVA) .\.-lt, r*tfil dg'i ( t . ) rri.lclr.r+trtib (*.dl l r ljl lt3.tll gr ) &t E'l t rllrtt r3{ sle 1jr-rt .r tJ,f i &l-J ti})l
t{tar't lllr x x
.-ll..ot+Yl .iLi. ; UL--! lJl" ,i-tS )*s (r . ) r*r Jrrll .p-.;* lr J I ii l.&J I .F : : : -li.J I di Ll(.J l r.ii :;$;.-l I o l.=rl l-,
&qKJl -,y 19: iL-)ul ut---yl O:r'll Oi .-,ut-a-!l =|s,
y)tl r, frLll: .= Lll: i--ueJl ':.l*Jl olJ(jl .r,)tL ClJ r3; i-L!l
e ,* 6.t' or. r q Lllr i-l+Jl L-2- $ :r-_rJl, iorJl, ,-bYl
+.|l L* d,tl-/|.i.6 Jqli-r !1r 1.pl L-1- +l- o!5JlillL,i..:)tt oi,Jr dttJ oir Js.e .t,y :-_ *iJl l;1, t,o Lll ,+ r,v -l:ytJt r .1 int*.;)l oLls'Jl .r)tL .r. JiJ-q iJs.rJl 63,JtL-
.,-|',Jl o[J(Jt
. sLiJlr ,,;.;tlJlr" djl
i.rb J! 1.. -5i iJJt olfsJt vx! Ji Jlt ir* dJ-i ;.rr.':+,
.itUylp:LlleXt g. iirElLdlJir iJrJl ,t-) oo oplr uitttl.-.,:Jtq*- t-t+l iilJl -* ,9: iL-)Ul iJt--)l ,JJl! dLr- r+rLr::Jl.Jl ;i*Jl) t+Jl .il,'. ll -,)tt Jt-oJ r.*,- q!3r.cJl .i";[,-!r -11
[,1, Jr\ll L.Jl,-)tLJ t,y J"U- t,A tJJl&li*Jl L-3-tii +: Gt
I I
irtitlzdt4Il
F r..r.L,j'-
ot !,1,1
-l-.1fuaJl
tFOL1.;ll
!rtt+lat?i1 grllrli I .pt-;
,,AlAI r i+r
cl,AViols3.all
xsc,t+SJl I
:r I l-tlI,fot I lAlJl-l'lvtl,.fv
ol,r3-+lt
t,oA1r. ,ltt I tA/.
CrteJr.fll -r,. ;
I&lJn-Jl r
la-tJ*t i
j ditrntc.sll
a.i4.rr,.,i *rtc.r.i
'19-lt r.uf t -o'\ tfr u;1 / tY. 1Y q.rlrj irSt r$\g iii+it$i$J P gl.dl h r-l'
Z.=irls:ll luJ.ill ltvJt (ANOVA) .b.sirt !*tr:ll dlit'i ( \ r) 113'1 dr-t+lt
Laig (u.ar;trin3qi)ur dlbl"3r) 6;!Jrgnfr lJt:+ sle ?'i{rtl rLii ifgb)|
titc*1 lllr x x
drl.&Jl .tt-;&. .,i Ut*! ill-: .;3r.i "*s (lr) r*r Jrr*l c*,-
Jl-;Jl -* t?s iL-)tll iJt--'il .irroll .ri oUt:Jl -F: . i..qlL-r-& J..- (dr, L: rJl':Jl;i-Jl) lLJlol+Jl./)tt Cl.J rri 4.,t+l
;Jtjjl r*Jl -)tJ A,r, Jrllt ;j-Jl *,).LJ A,t J"U.4,1 LJ'JI d,l.i-Jl
.rJ qn ;1 =-^--Jl;Jl;jr*,' ;J+)ll drlt-Jl v)lt otnL*t 6l .r*- l.u,
^rHl: lrYlolr*Jl*)tti-lrJl;.r)ti - \ t
; ;jJ;Jl dLI+: ., ^Jl r,., drbL+l.r v),tlJl ,lri ;*lr.rJl ,>3q;*l
W);l ;lj-Yl .iL; cp o!t?l f$ oi .-rL--' l.r .d-fll C.:+Il
v>tlJJl "l)iJ l-lrJl,Jl :i:,.a1r;)LJlJt - j tii.ri./l JV-ll rk;1,. -".-'.tjl ,i
:i)ll (J; ;-lrJl dd ;t't-;r,- 6ti; bs.t
tJ,;_r!le dul, dutr,JJJI ,." .-Jl iy,/-15J1c-:+Jl ,lt*- -\. :.=Jl rlji vllJl ,:.lh o, o cJ*-
2 r' -' |,.rtl Sl ti-t l t 1 r r r-r I dllJllll t AIJ{iil
4J)Jl
i,:L --rlFa.+
'| ' Jt'
ohy'lsb-rr
4rraJlol,-./l394- ;2kJl cLil gr,l,l rj-i1 I
oLca.3ll so
ol+lglq+.l,Jl
I
Yl10.!rlJil,
elcar.nf l
\,lYo
Y rY,tlt olca*{l .a1
e$Jlti..lJril
YJrl:olej..1f l
la!.J .r&i glc.:.i.1e'tlt.r4ft Jrlt.LLdt
..19"lt.lrrlt lltfl e.1/ll'llJ:n9J 6q$r$g t'$- r!ri$ pgldl ar l.
;l; Jr L-.i-)l JV-ll rt .;l J.i ;r.5 .-.o';Jl e* e)ttJl drtat4l
,t' t-:+V t'LdjY I € P.rJo (f.resd i UJ I .rL^:;'i l,s r1 ll;;"J I .i I ri.l I
( \ r) r*., Jr*f l C.rlt3Yl dl;; &*>tt u*+lr (;,-t tx1
&!ri:.J*'E a;3te)ll antdl s,lt*it (T-Test) (iE lJiid;vl ( \ l) piJd1+!l
' gtt3l I grtt r3i; uc 9!J I n Lr b I L ir.lrll s.tJdi.)t 19 OGd tJ r&t I ) 9 sftl t
,i 4l rlii otQl 0!r ULi-l rJl:.;1i 'ns(l Y) fr J:-r*l at'-
t* o:-,Jl.i^ .3i otl-/l q-;-t $,2!tt;+Jl),.*t.+':ll ,t-:':ll -ri:.
.!,U. r,o J.-LJI-,ytJI L**trlt./)ttjt? iru- *!l.r'XlJICuFII -,ILJI otoQl ,ri f- l.iar .r.r.Jl e),lllJ r,r
.d$*r dl*,i .iliir .---.:Jl Jle;
(;.-ql drl,;*Jlr iJil) ;:.r*Il ot"k':ll oli olr+l[ JIn- t+r*i, Ut--)l a:-ll c.i5lJ .t4Yl Lr:Li;,r-trJl JJsi ,L;;l 621
.( \ r) F r Jr**l C.,,L:;Yl li.! ettr
gcriltgn.i11)lalt
UJrtl
143l4Jl
sig.
tr-tailed)
&bJl
fr-JtJ I
i.-.a!l
+sr(c,) '-:a
&-Jifl t&Att
,+i:rl
ri:tl
d;:--rl
Lllr;i
A, tflt 'tl5i
LF4rJlA,tlloCrlll
2.llr Itol, t,1tt-A,rt I I ,+ ,l.aJl
)/btJltA,o1A1 tv.
;9'lr.u.lt -oltile.t/tI .\YrrjrJ iiult rSf g ii'+ibrill p gldt tl;o
L-lrJl €-i "-;L) I ;tllot-r. JKI .*t-, i); ,-^dl ;J"6t! JYr -
-t-+;l-;-Y| rr-,;r,rtlJ|.i.n.,Lik"; Jrt - $: S);rr!l,/e .-lJt.b.:3,-3 &t* ,* iUl, q5i;.1t4-. Y i<^tl
;LrtJl ir- r-lJ lgr6le Lriol"lr,l!)L;-t ;-Ul ;.rl:!l-l,.rJl ei -\
,,)$Jl g;-rJ -.i U--r-ujl ;:^rll,l;s.l t;o,lr-;-t+l ,/ ,r:-.lt gtlJl ol!
.a-rr6Y I ;[J I ; lr,;dls- ; oL.,tJl ojr .l-e;- 13
.41, ,rr.r6'Jl ,f.Jl oU|.; t +s\ ';Js- ;t ;*lrJl olr;ll ;.Lql d spt:?1lr
;eltr.utt ..oltil e.1/ll.llJ+', 6u3rr gg oril$ilr pSlrll A\D
^Jt<.:i., ., " .Jl * Jrr.,}o)|, ,o,Jl JLr JL r" tJ ;..i-i:ll
'ot*- - Y
..r)lLJl g,. /.s o,A crL- tJ iil*Il
v. .;Jl iJl-i! ,/ +l1.rJl ,1.r, .jI"- ta t =.J Qt*,-l tAt-+l -,)l.tJl t'r,,- -f
&tJt v- Jl ill;! iJ3.rJl .-J" .r.*,- li a9- l1o,l .il*- e^.- l;..21n2
' - JYtl-, i$tljl JlS.l'i'iL;r
drl*j &/.r'4,1 irL- .-".--djl J;l +' '":l y)tLjl irtat4! Jl'!- L+J - t
. CJ+II o. dtj;+l3 ,, " .:ll Jlrl
r+;rl:-C q*lr-r'tt ol.;*ll,,t'k+lt .ti.;Yl *, ;U l-lrJl .+ $:;t "t+U :;r,-r+l I .r-b .F: +lt-- I tir.,i i*lrJ.l I o ;11 e2 .-.=';J I cr.
Lii t+Jl ol..:-Jl v)tL: ,3.r.Jl g;-r.l W SI '=.-,ll x; tz!|.7),[Jl.(lil.:.J lr Jr! l) !.rJ I ol,*J I v)lb o. .-.."dJl ill;! r; k t;
;*lJJl.rtn-a;-\ o
:r:JtJl .,L.-!l .t+ o(4';*lrJl ,ro i tdl ;-^,dl p- Ult n;Ut & .tl;l=Il .-L-..:- .il.l; ,S *l*!rrr** iJe.rJl pr; ;L ;*trrJt ,7t -
.C.:+tl *e ,+.--ll;tb u ill .ql C rf t :?)llr o:*ul
Lr; *.Jl;?lb u r-lj iLt-*. L_t1; Ols4l*l & i-lr.dl ft' -
. dUfr iJt-(.i i.iEr C.:"tJl
* JW,rr iJt .-iJl oLrlJJ l;2l- gb: ..,1"! ot +.1-l;*l 'ti -
. **lFl: *. dl
i*;t-tlJ;l ' - o--r & e*.+-.!lo:FJlr..iEr!l ;.rl11r*l.r.ill ,ft -
.Jt+ll liA C t:' ':Jlcr-JlJl+-r &LrLJ ttb t2ss C.;+ll,J L"il1r
U o*t.*-tsJl C.+Jl C ...-.:Jl iJt(;l J1,- ;;* oLlr.: )*! -
€ *|b;:+lll ol.-:+Jl .t tr;b oLlrr J-,+b . L+.LLI gt';+'ll
6;r.riJt J$'1.t-, -r lit J.tri gle-r-i a:4.r*i *t-.r.iJe"llJ.L:dl .19!t"rt4tt
. u.t-Ll lil
;jftr.slt -o\ tlt ur+1 / rrY' I I qijii ii.rjlr[fg i+ibtri$t Pgldt hr-l ^
F i-ql w)lt ,-trt<l .(\ t 1o) r,Jl + ,q*ll ,.dJl rg ,i-i-l;.;iJ*,it-...o.Ile qJbJ-Jl ./ylJl .* t-,b i-12: ,fUl +F '.h- \ . 1 r \ 1 1 o .Y1 r.r-s,t l-;Jl,-,L(IJ i-.-,il LUI ij*dl.,-ijl y''c
.\r\ii-;L'u-t; ;,;aa\ *-#l g.L*.'ll o*.i (\ t 1 \ ) L)t- J:.Jl ,,-"1+l
. \ . t-v v ,rl;i/ .1*.2L,Y 1 )rr .;J.rul L;Jl (ci,ltJl lQ-U
rJl .r-.c :a^1rr) .,-.-.d12.=ft-:+11 ,'-LJl de .(r ' ' ') g-5; .5r..f/'Jl .SiJl ;b :i'rrt-oJl (r*l:! Jtie
.,?rt-!lr Gy'll ,rl;lrll :...rrJl iitji.iJl L-:'r'uil (Y' 't) ,sls-r'tsJ-)
...,,U ;r,-r*l ,gtJl :.r*Jl ,lir,;5.J:Jl aJl'r.c ;J+- , (!9r.:-Jl)
,.* i,[ii- 73tr:i,-"1* i-.oL;-l ci>{i;. (\1tt) + &**l)vtlL
.ur ica*q-.:&-J,<Jl ,l L ir.oV +f Ql'-4-
y'il ,l: :.p: ,.1)*':ll ,rr OUll .err- .( \ 1 1v) "r^- '.rI*Jl*-llt,J*Jl.Jb'Jl:
;9!t.lrrtt -oltlf 9.;.,1 /tl .Ilrii# iu-lrrlrg i'*il$ri$l pgldl tlp
i*lJJl €l-.,
C r1:tu .r-..ullcgr-:Jl.lr ., dJl .( \ I A 1),g,-.rJl .r*,r'."1:!
Jti!'il :guJl :J#l fral i;,,S.ll i:*+l :;r-> ,o2.Jl gbll,i-r.."ul L-Jl iit"i.llJ ,rj;hjlr[1#Yl o'JL --l:.*.-Jlr .= . {Jl,
.V \ - \ I,c--rSJl,,.r-rtJl 9$l,./Ufl I
Jst ,J/t -,t-U; ,!;J-p:dll llrr. ( \ 1 I 1) .uL ...-a.;, !-j -*l.cr'Jl qi u:Jt J )tz
,;.r.r.r cL.-2! ,liJ-; iitiijjl ',-.+ll .(\ I t \) * e.-Jl .r- ,-r-i.r-rrL,\ . l-r t lr.rer;J"rtJl liJl
oUr , .,Lo;)le ..i}tJl t+r-fu (\ i 1\).!- r? ].c7L*!.A 1- \ 1,4 r^J/|,&-JSJI i-t4, -,l.rYl r=,15
,-,j* lI uJr').tt;.:4:<,-/1I U+&trt4l d\ I AV) 'l;.n,r,--\l.J4Yl i;i,;rrl;Jl,t'|*.. .:-, :g;,;i|
2Jttt,itL:?Yl;:LJI;t-Lt--. f-Ts (\ I vA)Jj -r*l,,.ge4
.ntrJ ir<-y'Jl ,l.r ,Y A.!, €f ,:#!,-,-_rl;:s2iJl (\ I t t) r... ,,r$-Jl
.\ 11t ,J)f ,.p-}^lJ
iit^t-fY l=t=L+ i*lrr .( \ I I r) ,*i ,r--t-.,.11 .-r*l rg;.:l-rlJl
il+- i-Lll i*t !l L-t ' ;ll ;.Ii'- Jf e-&l ful .gul. A Vr.r&Jl. \ o l;*Jl ,€/l J:a-ll
;r.ijlrl.r ,&t-6t-fYl sr$-1 ol,b;-..-Yl,te (\ 1t Y) ,.r,_l1,.ri.rUl
.;.r>. *;ll9 itl LU
., - *-ll '*F
.( \ I 1 A) Jr- .r.-*,. J-L..itr r':Lr- tl'* t;'*,;J,bUJl .1 o-1 \ .(Y f ),,JiJl fl" .t+- .:-t+l .f)tL cr i-.e' .g,rJ
g"t Jl z(7-t')4: :lt ;r->,F-tJl3 d'Lt-tJl (\ 1 A v) L! 'u1f;r*lJ 4-y'1 *t::il 4tr^+^iJ JrYl ,r^-$'Jl
/4Yl ii<- :;2tjill .\ 1^ \ fG -#' f t-Y \
:i..o-e rlr- cj*; ,..,itjul g"L-llJ !qrJe-.i,-'Jl .(\ 1A v) i*t.t,qL-*
*-J,l 4rr:Yl ;'r*+JJ Jr'Jl ,r^^Ijil ;tl -t4i :itrill g.t*:Jl
:i-.;(.:;r.o[il] ,\1A\ * -#i Y t-Y \ ; ri,:ll +t-:?Yl ;r*lj
jtl .:t-i :.j$:jl
.,i $d.Il l*t*:-)ll
.V 1-V f ,L-J.zJl
.v \-r \ ,L_ JlJ4Yl
.,-t(IJ .,-,Jl LUI i:.*ll
Je'Yl.^ilfl .1e!t.rt7tt
-o\ tt'\' .-r;1 / tI'l l r+Ja iiu3trl}tg ii+i\$l$l P$' rl AI:.o .19'Itr.rtlt -6,\tff s.J/tl'lYJElri riu-1f r$tg iir+i\Nilt pgkll h r -l ^JeYl.r.uJl
'ir-ql".5 !r- ,!:!r.***)l; Lr!-r-r,-Yl .n" asll (\ 1A ') -r*i ' .;
.F .^.t*, \ Y .r'uJl .LtJl
c* a* i.:i,"i-U "rUi ct- -C;.t\lAt) o'-rsl '53,*-r$
. JlJ.-f ,.1.i;, gr--rJl
.g 4.J \ rlr iJ ) t. \ .jJ 1,4*!. Jl itr*/l .( \ 1 A o ) .ittrl'."' JqsJl.;trLllr.;:lJ
;-.Jl ,fr,;_r.rJl j-;y'l .^^:tl-r,rill Jji.JI .(\tvt) 6t4, J.*.r-rLlrl!l ,r t t;-lrJlrlJ.
Jt.;i .r*; :u>L-)l,JJYI iJJl .(\11'1) i:JUl Ly'l b--Al.{}ltFlJ 'l'r*/1
^--Jl :.,.)l-'Jl .rill -,1/l g- ;la'i"a '(\ t 1V) ,t'iJl -r'^c' "=-;
.i A-Y t ,(r'\),4;/l ;,I+-.SUi, k/*;, aJ,:t1
.;u ,4j *i .;s-r- a-41 ;.-oit-!Jl ,.(Y ' ' A)
"- l, **i '.*+Jl
.;r-^-'r,J\ 1ll ;t*;dl .J; 'Li'il, t-J+Jl !t.fu'!.(r ' ' Y ) ./e .d'tr
. \ \ r-1 1,,*!-ii / .,i.r A Y r.r.Jl .,-rill J+-ll
; lrt-:.:lr ;-rL *--,Jl .(I " r) i*rl -L'-e r-\p'il '* ''tLt,--)'|.lJ-L-,r )-kJl ,r . rLJl t+-,5J1 .$l dt" ri"T- ,,r?r'il olrl
.\ Y o-Vl
.:^+)i jif ;t-i "---
:^jJ'u*rJi, -t .Jl .(\ 1^v) :lr* i'l3
y i-r \ i -,.iJl 4^rL-:-'tl ;r-JJ '*.1\ 4:t:'ii j,tr-+Jj JrYl
.\ cA-\ o o ,L- Jl .,'Llil ;-J<-:;r'oLiiJl r\ 1A \ 1G-"se:
iLrllgat, C g.utr r;ldlli-rlla--oUfl.(\ 11 o) r.G,.jlJ--Jl.\ [-1 "t ^:/ ,-1,.-i! ,\ Y >-r.c,^:ll
^L= ']-jl;ri':ll
UUI ;9FJl:,e:2;-, \.; ,.r.i--Ljlf4Jl (\ 11 t)q& J* 'q&'"[JilJ
:ii_.r- !e.: C *.i.:;.Jl ;,t.,-^Jl .(\ 11Y) .ErL ,iUl -Uc
.Y f A-Y'f .(f ) r\ .j.ii -'Llr:.',- ^dlup i,-l.':
.J-L*J| oV;lr.t't^+Vt g,.-Uft iJ^e .(\lv') 'r* ';.,*-Jl 'r'c
t,],.-tl ,1 5s ii;-35JlFJl dt, ,it',,lAl iiy'l tJt'i"F uP r" ^-)ltrr - AY ,it-l ,-u
p:< ll;u'lt: r-f tl.{.: -::. illi]i-6t4!ld\ 11v) + F 'rIJl -r*c
. -*t,r,25 |,,-.jjl d,.c :i14. ..rL'Yle
+--p .)t:;rltjill .^*L.?l :^* :: j*lr) :g-a;Jl .( \ 1 1v) ,';o 'r'IJl 'r"c
.e)ilt.Jlr iel:LU
,14-3-s-6.r"e lxJtS;ia"i,;...--Jtot"Qlt(\ 1 1 '\ 4 r-,alJI-r's
,djl *)l d.t'Ut :t ,JiJl/' up '-l.l;,]<J J-g ei u'b. r1 - \ Y,..,[JU LUli-,Jlij-dl,J-tJlJ"ll
J9LJI Li 0. Ji t+-X", ! .:Jl i* (\ltA) 'r* ';o 'aIJl 'r"s
- rt1,..,4 / "!,--rl
,r :-r'Jl ,A J*Il , i^ ::;[-lrt1S-Al isrt.YAA
Lt*r\ ;;.eiru dfr*l ,oLrlJJ j-Jrll ;l+ll .(Y ' '1) 'rl;- 'i-,1'tc
. t-l-* t o 'L,r':ll rt 1 I \ .:-r,Jl ,-t*311 d.Jl , ^t;t! L)tt.,;.-ll ;J"5UJ +_ Jt .lGJl U + L-j, 1\ t t A)ir* -r^-. , ;tr,1 . -v A e.)Ul t-lJ+tl t-t..-,(! o ),rjJl d'' .l+-,":.-!r('*'i-lr':
. .,tKiJ L-.Jl LUI Ldl,ir.ol-cJl
aiy'l -,11r :i-r.r5i-'Jl .1t"*)l & nytr.(\1AA) ';Dtl 'e=;
U .,tJl jlii.r.lr4 .raibJ ..bl rtjr.:.1
Je'Y|"il+rl Jslt-r.l+rt
.19"1t r.rtlt altfl e. 1/tI'llJ:ri4 iir_1rr$f 9 i4i\.ruilf p gf rll df +D
;-.,:')lr-lJl, LitjAdorno, T.w. t1950t. the Authoritarian personality, , new York, Harper.
Allport, G. (1954). The nature ol prejudice. Massachusetts: Addison-
Wesley.
Banton, M (1971) Sociologie des relations raciales, Paris , Payot.
Bogardus,E.S.(1925) Measuring Social Distance J.App. Social,
45,PP.22-36.
Crawitz ,Madelein (1983). Lexique des sciences sociales. Paris, P.U.F.
Djangi, Ahmad R(1993). Racism ln Higher Education, Paper presented
at the annual meeting ol the American psychological association ,
Toranto-Canada.
Heavean. p.(1986): Attitudes towards a south alrican liberation
movement , Journal ol corflict resolution, september.
Katz, d, & Braly, k(1933) Racial Stereotypes, New York J. Abn. Soc. Psy
Chol.,22, PP-12-32.
Pettigrew, T. (Ed.). The Sociology of race relation: Reflections and
relorm. New York The Free Press.
Rillaer. Jaques Van t19881 L'agressivit6 humaine, Bruxelles: Ed.Pierre
Mardaga.
Sergent, Marie T:& Woods. Paula A (1992): Unversity Student Attitudes
Towards Arabs: lnlervention lmplication. Journal ol Multi -Gultural
counseling & Development, July.
Sherif, M. (1967). Group Conflict and Cooperation. London: Routhledge
& Kegan Paul.
Sinha, A, & Upadhya, Ya,t1960l 'Stereotypes ol mal and female
students, London, J. Soc. Psychol., 62,PP-70-99.
Vaughan, G. (1988). The psychology ol intergroup discrimination.
Journal ol Psychology.'l7,PP. 1-14.
Yang, Julia t1992t Chilly campus climate. Qualitalive study on white
racial identity development attitudes , University ol Pennstlvania
(Researsh report) , Pennsylvania.
s -iJl .iLi r.ls .i a l.J.r&i gl..:.i;rlr"rt7rr
.lrlt.utlt -lltffes/;l .tlfri* 6r_lrrf rg a;ilui$t pgln Lbo
Summary of the study
The challenges of fanaticism and its cultural backgrounds in
the Kuwaitisociety
Views of asample of students at the University of Kuwait
Prof. AliAsad Watlah
Dr. Saad Reghian Al-SheraYee
AbstractThis study represents a scientific attempt to reveal aspects of tribal and
sectarian fanaticism and the extent of its prevalence at the Kuwaiti society
from the point of view of Kuwait University students.
The study was conducted during the academic year 2010- 2011 on asample of 1194 students at the University, taking into account a conect
representation of both sex, university faculties, scientific departments and
the different years of college.
The study aims at identifying students' views regarding to the extent of
presenoe of tribal and sectarian fanaticism in the society, as well disclosing
the cultural backgrounds of this phenomenon and the role of the state at
facing it, using a descriptive and analytical research method to study the
issue in question.
The results of this survey study show a large presence of fanaticism in
its various sectarian, tribal and religious manifestations. Furthermore, it
shows that intellectuals and clergy play a major role in reviving the flame of
fanaticism in the Kuwaiti society. While is also reveals that students consider
that the state must meet the challenges of fanaticism and eliminate it.
ln addition, the study shows that members of study sample tend to reject
fanaticism in all its forms, and also reflects their wishes to eradicate this
phenomenon from social life. As well as it shows a significant impact of
year of college and specialty variables in students' attitude of the presence
of this phenomenon and its proliferation in the Kuwaiti society.
Finally, the study comes out with several recommendations and
proposals regarding the construction of strategies and plans to address
this phenomenon and to eradicate it from Kuwaiti society'
2 !r.J .lsi gl4.r.i1.1r!l.rfatt