coaa industry benchmarking what gets measured, gets improved! “when you’re average, you’re...
TRANSCRIPT
COAA Industry Benchmarking
What gets measured, gets improved!
“When you’re average, you’re just as close to the bottom as you are to the top.”
Agenda
Committee members
Background
CII (resource & support)
Input and Output
Milestones & Phases
Next steps
Workshops and Booth
COAA Industry BenchmarkingCommittee Members
Don Mousseau Suncor Energy Inc.Steve Revay Revay and AssociatesLea Chambers Golder Associates Ltd.Bob Montgomery Colt EngineeringLarry Sondrol Suncor Energy Inc.Dave Williams Bantrel Mahendra Bhatia Jacobs CanadaMel Otteson Imperial Oil Ltd.Patricia Armitage Alberta Economic
Development
COAA Industry Benchmarking
Committee Members (con’t) Dave Widdifield Shell Canada Ed Sobstyl Petro Canada Rick Campbell Cobra Bob Gandhi CNRL Blaine Skelton Opti Canada Greg Sillak B A Energy Michele Power Imperial Oil Peter Janson CNRL
COAA Industry Benchmarking
Member companies that are executing large capital projects are encouraged to participate.Both Construction Owners and Contractors can
participateConfidentiality is assured Owners and Contractors can agree to share
information on the same project however
COAA Industry Benchmarking
Projects will be Benchmarked twice in the life cycle:At Project Sanction or AFEAt Mechanical Completion
The Questionnaire has been adapted to Alberta Projects to reflect our standards and typical metrics.
®
Questionnaire OverviewQuestionnaire Overview
COAACOAA
Calgary, AlbertaCalgary, Alberta
November 29-30, 2005November 29-30, 2005
®
GeneralGeneral PerformancePerformanceEngineeringEngineering
ProductivityProductivityConstruction Construction ProductivityProductivity PracticesPractices CloseoutCloseout
COAA QuestionnaireCOAA Questionnaire
®
GeneralGeneral PerformancePerformanceEngineeringEngineering
ProductivityProductivityConstruction Construction ProductivityProductivity PracticesPractices CloseoutCloseout
General General Project Project InformationInformation
PIP PIP Implementation Implementation for HI Projectsfor HI Projects
Project Project ScopeScope
Project Project ParticipationParticipation
% Union % Union WorkforceWorkforce
COAA QuestionnaireCOAA Questionnaire
®
GeneralGeneral PerformancePerformanceEngineeringEngineering
ProductivityProductivityConstruction Construction ProductivityProductivity PracticesPractices CloseoutCloseout
CostCost
ScheduleSchedule
ChangesChanges
ReworkRework
COAA QuestionnaireCOAA Questionnaire
®
GeneralGeneral PerformancePerformanceEngineeringEngineering
ProductivityProductivityConstruction Construction ProductivityProductivity PracticesPractices CloseoutCloseout
ConcreteConcrete
Structural Structural SteelSteel
ElectricalElectrical
PipingPiping
InstrumentationInstrumentation
EquipmentEquipment
COAA QuestionnaireCOAA Questionnaire
®
GeneralGeneral PerformancePerformanceEngineeringEngineering
ProductivityProductivityConstruction Construction ProductivityProductivity PracticesPractices CloseoutCloseout
ConcreteConcrete
Structural Structural SteelSteel
ElectricalElectrical
PipingPiping
InstrumentationInstrumentation
EquipmentEquipment
InsulationInsulation
OffsiteOffsite
COAA QuestionnaireCOAA Questionnaire
®
GeneralGeneral PerformancePerformanceEngineeringEngineering
ProductivityProductivityConstruction Construction ProductivityProductivity PracticesPractices CloseoutCloseout
Pre-Project Pre-Project PlanningPlanning• Building PDRIBuilding PDRI
Full or Abbrev.Full or Abbrev.• Industrial PDRIIndustrial PDRI
Full or Abbrev.Full or Abbrev.
Project Risk Project Risk AssessmentAssessment
Team BuildingTeam Building
Alignment for PAlignment for P33
Design for Design for MaintainabilityMaintainability
ConstructabilityConstructability
Materials Materials ManagementManagement
COAA QuestionnaireCOAA Questionnaire
®
GeneralGeneral PerformancePerformanceEngineeringEngineering
ProductivityProductivityConstruction Construction ProductivityProductivity PracticesPractices CloseoutCloseout
Achieving Achieving Facility Facility CapacityCapacity
Work-Hrs Work-Hrs & & AccidentsAccidents
Project Project ImpactsImpacts
Workforce Workforce ConditionsConditions
Practices Practices Wrap-upWrap-up
COAA QuestionnaireCOAA Questionnaire
Key Results
Key Results
Key Results
The Value of Benchmarking
Improves project & company performance when used as an ongoing measure
Establishes improvement goals based on external/competitive benchmarks
Enables your company to understand & achieve “best in class” performance
Key Milestones
COAA and the Construction Industry Institute reached agreement to develop a “Made in Alberta” Benchmarking Program
Government of Alberta agreed to fund 50% of the $300,000 project cost
Training held for 28 Benchmarking Associates in Calgary last November
COAA Industry Benchmarking
Phase 1 – Definition of Metrics and Development of the COAA Questionnaire Complete
Phase 2 – Programming of the web based COAA Questionnaire by the Construction Industry Institute of Austin Texas- Complete
Phase 3 – Training the Benchmarking Associates November/05 - Complete
Phase 4 – The Alberta Report - Scheduled for completion in April - 2008
COAA Industry Benchmarking
Member companies and their Contractors that are executing large capital projects are encouraged to participate.
The success of the Project will depend on the degree of participation.
Currently have 10 Member companies committed and thirty projects.
How to Participate?
Contact The Benchmarking Committee
Steve Revay (Chair) [email protected]
Don Mousseau (Chair) [email protected]
Benchmarking Workshops
12:45 – 2:00 Room TBA
2:30 - 4:00 Room TBA
Dr. Steve Thomas of CII will be presenting on the benefits of Benchmarking.
Visit our Booth to Learn More!