BOOK 543 PAGE Pr)0 ~coma~BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

REVXFIgy SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER REGARDING DOCKET NUMBERVGOB 01-0417~

ELECTIONS: UNIT D-22(bcuein "Subject Drillmg Unit" )

REPORT OF BOARD

FINDINGS AND ORDER

This Supplemsaml Order is nnsred bygs Board cua c)ronu in the farm tborized by the Bond at issringcbekl an pcbrsay 15, 1994 snd June 16, 1992; sad this Supphmeoml Order is being nxenhd Su tbc pmpace ofnyphmcnthg tbc Order previously in the csptoned matter an July 27, 2001 which was recorded at Dead BookS20, Pa&s S69 h &s 0&ks ofSs Clsh «fthe Circuit Court ofBucbaaan Couscy, Virginia, an Augmt 0, 2001,(bsum "Board OnhfT aad oomple&ag gs recanl nyadig ehetims.

Tls Bond Onbs diectcd Consol Enngy hc. (bnem "Designated ~to mail copies of the Board Ordertn all Rccqxurdcas whose ~ifsay, were pooled by Ss said Boenl Order,

Tls~Opccetm &hd is aSdavit ofshebeen disabsmg tbat b bad ma&ed a true sad correct copy oftbe Bond's Order to a& Respandcns whose ~ifsay, were poohd by said Band Order,

Tbe Board Order requhed cncb Reqxrmhnt wbaee bnswm, ifeny, were pooled by Ss tenne ofsaid BoardOnhr ta make ca chance udgrh tbhty(30) dsps egards Ins ofmailing ar recanbng, as applicable, ofsaid Onhr,tbe almavit afehcthm Shd bnein end~hereto as Exhibit A sauce: (i) wbccbcr eacb Rcspotxhm bacmade m lb&ed to make a tbnrdy chctho; (b) tbe nanna ofsap ehathn(s) made; ead (ib) wbsgxx, by remrm ofs Sdlue m shet or to timely shet ane ar nxue Respamhss me deemed, under Ssnmac ofSsBoenl'c Onbs, tohave based all their rigbm, tide, isnaess, ectmm snd chime h &ablest Dril&eg Unit to SsAppgcseh

Tlat Ss aadsvlt ofchcthm ~bcnso wbb Ss Exbibbs submit@ tbcceud% ideate tbe Rmparxhnt(s)msheg a thsb cdectha, ifeny, idea&&ca Ss Rnqrorxhnt(s), ifsay, wbo se deemed to have lamed; idea&&ca dsconghthg isnsmm sad cbmns which mquire teener, idccni&es tbe internxs snd chime, ifany, requidng eccmwunder Vbginh Cods megan 45.1-3612133.;snd idaa&&m Ss Respamham, ifsry, wbo may be dhmiseed bynssan ofbavtng leased ar cntsed ieso a vobumuy ~wbb SsAppbcaat.

Tls a%dash ofehctims iadicsns that Ss cscmw ofhnds h requbed wbb regmd to Unit D-22;

By,this Order, tbc Board ordss tbe Desiysssd Opennor to tender, consksent with snd in~widt tbe Isdings sst Satb at Ccugrupb 2. above ead tbe snnumd a%davit ofelectians wbb Exbibns Ssreto, saySade ndgcet ts cecmw end istruch tbe Escmw Ayetglrst Union Neticaal Bak, Corporus Trust PA1 328,123Bmed Street, Pb&edslpbia, PA 19109-1199,Tcdepbone: (215) 985-3405 ar ($00) 664-93S9, Atnr. DonBallbrghrdf, ar say ucccesar named by tbe Basnl to cetubgsh imccest bearing escmw eccouai(s), IRS Tsx~a~ Number 54-1629506, h e ~wbb the i rgumathm set Sxthh the e&idsvit ofebenacs wbblhbhgs SrcnSe, to recebe Smds end account lathe Board there&us. Tbs respandents listed in Exhbit B-2 to tbeA&bhvb ofEhcdans se~

BOOK 542 PACE 2~1Megtneefonhv aad Filins ofAtgdsvia Tbe Designaled Operator under tbe~Order or shall Se sn

tdgdsvit with tbe Seaenay ofthe Boenl within ten (10)days ager the date ofnesipt of this Order stating that strue aad ccrrect ocpy ofgds Ordra was maged to such Respondent whose hrtcrests or ctshns are subject to escmwor who is bmeby tsmissed aad whose sddrem is huown edgda sevvn seven (7)days gum the drar ofreceipt «fthis Order.

EIBctlve Dsse: Mis Order shall be e%ctive on tbe dear cfgs esectnhuL

DoNE AND ExgcUTED this 2L day of ~et(Heeen ~,2002, by a majority oftbe virginiaGss sad OR BoarcL tr

STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF WISE

Achnowh0dgsd oa ddt~day ot'~~, 2002, ecrscnsgy before me a nosey publicis sad fcr thc Ccrmraarwruhh ofVhghde, sppcmed Banay R.W, bsiag duly sworn did depom and say gun

he is Cbshnam ofthe Virginia Gas end Oit Board, that he~ and was~to do so.

Notary

My crarunissioa asphaltum. Br/ ~re .d /

OONHHNOPHHPOHMHOTHN@dlPN&A .200HHPHNN fib hO

B.4C~Dhector ofthe Division ofGss 4 OII Board snd

Prieipd Ihrccultm to the Bomd

STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF WASHINGTON

Achtmwirdgcd «0~day of /gdt J,2002, prscmdly betbre me a notarypublic m and kr tbe Cormnmrwtubh ofVhginii, ippcsrad B.IL Wgscn, bsiag duly swann did depose aad saythat he is Dbuctor ofthe Division ofGas th Og Bomd aad riacipal Executim to the Board, that be caccutcd

CBmer /~ Dame J.Davis, Notary

Order Recorded >: . Code ofginia Eectjott 4

Cor!I 542 PACE 2~2

Exhibit A

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

Applicegca «fBucbsnaa producthm ~Srr Forced poogag ofattracts in CBM Unit D-22VGOB OIMI7MSS ia the Gmdea DisHct cfBucbem» County, Virgmis

AFFIDAVff OF Consol Energy Inc. (herein "Dmigneted ~REGARDING EIECTIONS, ESCROWAND SUP~AL ORDER

Iasgs K.hrrhrgtcn, bciag Snn duly sworn on oath, deposes snd says:

Tbst your eSaat b empbrJed by Ccasol Eaargy Inc„ss e Gas Eugh»tr sad is duly utheccmd to mshe Susstgdevit an behalf ofConsol Energy Inc., the designated operator,

1bst 0» Order cerned an July 27, 2001,byg» Virginia Ges snd Og Board (heremsgsr "BosrrP)~ths csptiaaal CBM Unit requhed tbs Appgcsm to mail a true sad correct copy ofsaid Onbr to sech peso»pookd by S» Onbr,

7bat wigdn sevmr (7)days ofreceipt ofan esecutsd copy ofthe Order regrred to at~2. above, youreghmt caused e true end conect copy of said Ordsr to bs msged vis tbs Unhed Sneer Pound Service to each

spcndsat nsmsd in 0» unpinned Appliceticn, whose ahhess was known, sad to ell persons, ifeay, wbo wracadded m Rsspcadtrus at 0» hearing behl in 0» cspthmed neuter, S»t proof ofsuch maibag bas pviously bacatasdsred to 0» Diviioa ofGas sad Og, tbe Ogh» os» Gss sml Og b»pecan, at~Vhginis;

Ibm g» Ohhr of0» Bomd in tbs cepncaed mettrr required ell persons pooled thereby to trndtr their wrnten

ehrctians to S» Unit Operator whhin thirty(30) days ofS» da» S» Onhs'ss recorded in 0» county 'dcntigsd

above; S»t said Order was recorded on August 8, 2001;

2bst 0»'='=: cptrstcr Consol Eumgy lac. hm established procedmm to review ell mail received end ellwrhtm docmnttmmcshud cgur thea hymsg to esotrtam wbsg»r pmtiss whose huerests have bess poobrd have

made ewrgtm ehsu»n, br e they gubica, mnquhed by the cspthmed Order, S»t said Omcedunn wme Sdhraedto idcnSFJS» ebcgcns, ifany, made whh regard to 0» Subject Urdh that tbs tbllowing persons delivered, by mail

or og»rwise, wrinen lecticns tbs Unh Open»or, whhm tbs Sdrty day sections psrhsh

None

7bst Requuubtm idanggsd ht EshgrhB-3 btreto»e, bavhtg Bged to mshe any cdecgcn, deemed to have b»sedtheir ccalbsd meg»ns rights, hutres» sad chmns to Applicsnt, all as provided in ths Board's Order ofJuly 27,2001;

1bst 0» rqthts, hnrswm sad claims ofthe Sdbwiag purser» me subject to escrow uadrr tbs Board's Orderpootmg S» capt»asd Unit, Board Regubrtue» snd 0» Code ofViqpnnc

None

Nane

Yldtcn P~ Coal Company» et 8L hchldeg Yuhcn y~ Coal Campsrry» BuduuxmCaal ~sad gapers-Fr Coal Caapaay

Ibat tbe yersore xhntiged in Exhibit EE anached hereto have ensued into royalty split~that agowde Ayygceughseeted Operator to y«0»them dheady wigeut de need to escrow gmds which wauld oderwisebe in caught

None

Ihn ager Ibe pooling hearing beld h de sption«d neuter, de Operator, through bs caatiawd dse~~a~~ det tbe ouaum ofIhrct 02 wwe h grat de yersons listed on de annextd revis«d Bdubit B-3 and ibatde p«scorn Hsaxl aa tbs annexed Exhibit 8-2 should be d'smissed as Respomhets by reason af tbe get that theydo nat have an~interest in Tract ¹2.

Ibstyursuammdepruviians ofVAC2S-160 70%.10.aad C.aad VAC 2S-16000de~mvv~order sam gath ge iatrsests aad claims that require escrow ofkmds ymsusat to Vhginh Code sectiaas 43.1-361213Kaad 4S.1-36122~.aad 4.

Dandat Taaewell, Virginia,dusglCyof ~mr¹I'«I,2002.

Taken, subset«Ied and sw«n to bogue me by Leslie K At«incan as Gas Engineer ofConsol Energy Inc., anbehalf ofde acrpanne Designauxl opcnuor, this 2 Ic+ day of Fcbe«««m, 2002.

»

Notary 6

PPGPEPTY LTIES SHOWN WERE 'I, . M PROM V/PSPeovoEO RY EmmoL lnc. Mm wERE RGT $%v5RETv

II 30I.~Ad.ia:BOOKI

E 90A.529.40

I80 ACRE DNIT'I

E 9M,495.99

()

I I

'i )II I

I IIl I

I

I

/

/

1 I(

II

=C jiII W CBll<22

I

fQ I r')I 'r

I.r

j

I)I)

r ))

I'

l

IIIIIIIIII

3\

I .r.~"I

I

I

I I/'/

II

I

I

+I

I

. I

I

)

I

I

II

N 3$LSOLSAE 909,A25.00

.)l.i,

II

EXHIBIT 4OAKWOOD F IELD UN I 7 D-22

FORCE POOLING

VGOB-01-D417-D886

-'" nCONSIS Enerav inc. We I I Nome and Nudber IINIT 022

' O',' I attel ecRI'' ~ *4ElevoticnCaylty 8uchNIan District Garden Sca dl I" M lpp'ate ~5 I /

or a final IIHIt

KX. r7l"e" 9/OI L I cmlsed Prafesd lono I Enpl neer dr L I censed Land Surveyor

~lÃEPGGL03I OPI45RI1 OIGTGRAM

SOOK 542NNI 2~5CONSOL Energy Inc.

UNIT D22Tract ~race~

C. L RNter Lumber Company Tr. 13-FeeCoal Lesseesisland Creek Coal Company - Below Drahage Coal LeasedJeweg Smok¹ess Coal Corp. - Above Dminage Coal LeasedBuchanan Production Company - CBM Leased (Seems B¹owTrier Seam)18.52acres 23.1500%

Plum Creek Timberland, L.P. (prevhusly North American Timber Corp.) Tr. 6 - FeeCoal LesseesIsland Creak Coal Company (B¹orrDrainage Coal)Jeweg Smokeless Coal Corp. (Above Drahage Co¹)Cabot ON & Gas Corp. - Ol & Gas Leased (?)0.01 acres 0.0125%

Stocum Land Corp. - Coal, Oil & GasCoal Lesseeskrtand Creek Coal Company - Bekw Dmhage Coal LeasedJeweg Smokekws Coal Corp. - Above Drahage Coal LeasedBuchanan Productkm Company - CBM LeasedPtrsn Creek Tknberland, LP. (prevhusly trorth American Tknber Corp.) - Surface47.97acres 59.9825%

J.W. W. Baldwin Heirs, et al. - Coal, Oil & GasCoal r~)stand Creek Coal Company- B¹owDmhage Coal LeasedJeweg Smok¹ess Coal Corp. -Abave Deinage Coal LeasedBucharum Producron Company - CBM Leased13.50acres 16.8750%

Suhhrh aa BO(!K 542 PACE QOUdt 042

DcchetOVOM814417 Wluald.: . Sshe~

flsdshm Oe

Acme In Unll

(1) Yuhcn ~~ Ccd Ccmpeny et U.. Tr. 38

(ro Yuhcn ~ Ccd CampenyP.O. Sar 1$fTasmml. VA 2e861

(6) Suchanm Ccd CompanyP.O. Sec 187Taeewek VA Ie861

(c) Su/are Ccel CanpenyP.O. Sar 187TasewcI, VA 2S661

~. tm. 8 reah phh

0.01 msm

0.0060 mmwi/2 cf0.01sass

0.0011 aam1/I d 0.01 ames

0.0008 msm1/II cf0.01 maes

0.0126%

0.0088% Natch~

0.0014% Ncl en cwner

(1) YUan ~Ccd Campany d U, Tr. 38

(s) Ydrcn.- -Ccel Ccmpany

P.O. 8mr 187Tmawel, VA IC661

(0) Suchsnan Ccd CcmpanyP.O. Sat 187Tensest VA Ie861

(c) Oct)am Ccd CcmpanyP.O. Scs 187TaeswN. VA 2e861

0.01 maes

0.0060 easei/2 sfO.O1 acres

0.0011 ames1/I d 0.01aam

0.0008 mcm1/18 sf 0.01 acme

0.0126%

0.0066% NU en asner

0.0014% Ncl en cwna

Pcoe 1 sf 1

Sxkgdt S4Unb DS2

Doabst 8 )fOOS 81441M888Lhl R~~ Bn!N 5 22 PICE287

L.P.Amerknm Tknbsr Carp.)

NW, SuRe 2850

Tract SL SXQasa

(1) J.W. W. Mdwh Hebe, Oartsees,ts Aesttpe, inst

(20) Kenm Mdwh3230 West fttdgeHaustan, TX 77025

(22) ISabsh MdwhRt.1 tkts 1450~IK 048)8

(26) Omsd Carr Mdwh916N. Psnrdsuh Odvad2Dnylons Beach, FL 32018

13.50 msm

0.0781 ares5f884 d 13.60msm

0.0195msmtiS(H af 13.50mass

0.0196maes15)91 af 13.50saran

16.8750%

0.02442%

0.03442%

(1) Plum Crush lmbmlsnd, LP.Plum Ossek (pier. Narlh Amerhan Timber Corp.)Nsbssf aacuulnes Cewir sisad100~m~ Sheet NW, 8ube 2660Attsntst OA 30303

(1) J.W. W. Mdwm Hsbs, Duchess,Suaceesam ar Assigns, et al.

13.50 msm

0.0781 acres$184 af 13.50msm

16.6750%

(22) Ibcheta MdwhRL1 Stfr 1460~,ME 04878

(25) David Carr Mdwh916 IL Psnrdsuh Drbm 82Oaytwm Beach. FL 32018

0.0195ecrm1i891 af 13.50anus

0.0196mass1iStH af 13.50msm

0.02442%

VIRGINIA: Inl the Clerk's Office of tta) C)i)reit Court of Buchanan County. The foregoing instrument

Deed Book No. L ~~~d Page No. csJII~ TRST)f: 4 IReturned this date to: /V'lllwax i W/I A~ TBSTWd4fdr0..i&LWNoDdoutyC)erk

g