common measures project
DESCRIPTION
COMMON MEASURES PROJECT. Workshop on Selecting Indicators Tuesday, March 13, 2007. WELCOME & UPDATES. What Have We Accomplished To Date? Where Do We Go From Here? Goal of Today’s Meeting. IDEAL WORLD VS. REAL WORLD. Common Sector Definitions Common Indicators Common Collection Methods - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
COMMON MEASURES PROJECT
Workshop on Selecting Indicators
Tuesday, March 13, 2007
WELCOME & UPDATES
What Have We Accomplished To Date?
Where Do We Go From Here?
Goal of Today’s Meeting
IDEAL WORLD VS. REAL WORLD
Common Sector Definitions Common Indicators Common Collection Methods Common Analysis and Reporting
FEDERAL DEFINITION FOR SQGs
Between 100 kg/mo and 1000 kg/mo and accumulation of no more than 6000 kg
Seven states participating in SQGs (this includes Vermont who will be observing the sector). Of these seven states, four use Federal Definition for SQGs:
CO, MA, NY and VT
SQG DEFINITION DIFFERENCES CT:
Lower accumulation limit (1000 kg/mo). Will be noted in presentation results and should not be a problem
NH: FQG generates 100 kg/mo or more (SQG 0-100 kg/mo) May be able to weed out FQGs generating > 1000 kg/mo No accumulation limits but must ship within 90 days. Will be
noted in presentation results and should not be a problem RI:
SQG generates between 0 – 1000 kg/mo Unable to weed out those generating between 0-100 kg/mo No accumulation limits but must be shipped within 90 days.
Will be noted in presentation results and should not be a problem
AUTO BODY DEFINITION
Any operation involving collision repair, vehicle painting, paint stripping or sanding, body work, antique restoration or student training in any of these areas
Seven states participating in auto body sector (this includes CO who would like to look at SQGs at auto body shops). Of these states, all agreed conceptually with definition above
Other Refinements, e.g., do we need to create some kind of threshold?
SESSION 1: PICKING SQG INDICATORS
KEY FACTORS INFLUENCING DATA QUALITY
Precision Sensitivity Representativeness Completeness Bias Validation
SQG INDICATOR EXERCISE
Review and select indicator categories Compare indicators within selected
categories Select/develop final draft indicators using
worksheet
SESSION 2: PICKING AUTOBODY INDICATORS
AUTO BODY INDICATOR EXERCISE Review and select indicator categories Compare indicators within selected
categories Select/develop final draft indicators using
worksheet
WRAP UP & NEXT STEPS
Final draft indicator list from today will be sent via email to all states with homework instructions
Homework Share final draft indicators with agency staff and confirm
final list Confirm data source
Conference Call Report Back Thursday, April 12th at 11:00 a.m.?
Follow-up Training