commonwealth of pennsylvania legislative journal · 5/10/2000  · representatives and pastor of...

16
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL WEDNESDAY, MAY 10, 2000 SESSION OF 2000 184TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 31 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES The House convened at 11 a-rn., e.d.t. THE SPEAKER PRO TEMPORE PATRICIA H. VANCE PRESIDING PRAYER REV. JULIANN PUGH, Chaplain of the House of Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer: Let us pray: Awesome God, we thank You this morning for the amazing gift of sleep: such a quiet, overlooked good and gentle grace it is. We rise from sleep born again, re-created to this never-before-nor-ever-again day, new and fresh and Yours. Speak to us, Lord, this day Your disturbing, unwanted, off-balance, necessary Word to each timid, safe, and sorry soul. Afflict the complacent. Discomfort those who are unwilling to get their hands soiled or their faith ruffled or their lives lived: those who would rather withdraw passing than fail, who by never failing never succeed. Make them cold or hot, not tepid. We thank You for the passion that allows us to have strong views, but in our excitement to share our views with others, we often forget our civility. Help us to respect one another’s views, though they be different from ours, and not attack them for their beliefs. Passionate God, how wonderful it is that in the midst of all the gray and banal and sad stuff of life, we have met a person really caring about truth, that we have seen something so beautiful it took our boredom away - quiet courage in a timid person, a man who could laugh at himself, a genuinely humble person who did not realize they were humble, and real indignation that was better than self-righteousness. 0 God, take the sleepers from our eyes, the wax from our ears, and the cataracts from our souls so that we may have clarity to our perception and joy to our hearts this and every thy. Allow the people that represent so many to be filled with passion beyond the limitations of this room and themselves so that they may have a sincere desire to care for the people whom they are called to serve. Thank You, God, for the dependability and the democracy of nature. We are glad that the wind blows across the fences and the boundaries, whether carrying fresh air or pollution; that the sun belongs to no nation: and that from a satellite, the national boundaries are invisible: that the pink. green. red, and blue nations of the map are all earth-colored. Thank You for coloring outside of our lines. And so. our God, we thank You today for the most constant of gifts, Your steadfast love for us throughout the generations. In interesting times, when life unravels and there seems to be nothing to hold on to, we turn to You. Your gift of hope is the thread strong enough to hold life together. With it. our dreams will never perish. May Your name be praised. Hear this our common prayer. Amen. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by members and JOURNAL APPROVAL POSTPONED visitors. The SPEAKER pro tempore. Without objection. the approval of the Journal of Tuesday, May 9. 2000, will be postponed until printed. The Chair hears no objection. HOUSE BILLS INTRODUCED AND REFERRED No. 2535 By Representatives CI VERA, BARRAR. RAYMOND, GORDNER, MARKOSEK, ALLEN and MAJOR An Act amending the act of June 19, 1931 P.L.589, No.202, referred to as the Barbers’ License Law, further providing for applications for licensure and for student barbers. Referred to Committee on PROFESSIONAL LICENSURE. May 10. 2000. No. 2536 By Representatives BELFANTI, DeWEESE. FAIRCHILD, LUCYK, PHILLIPS, TRICH, LEDERER. McGILL, WATERS. VAN HORNE, LAUGHLIN. MANDERINO. CURRY, GRUCELA. WALKO, WOJNAROSKI. PETRARCA, SOLOBAY. HARHAI. COY, CLYMER. ARGALL, BEBKO-JONES. PESCI. McCALL, DeLUCA, HORSEY. RAMOS. GEORGE, STABACK, HESS. M. COHEN, SHANER. JOSEPHS, RAYMOND. YOUIsIGBLOOD. PETRONE, SATHER, SURRA, WOGAN, VEON, LESCOVITZ, READSHAW. TIGUE, BELARDI, YUDICHAK. HASAY and ROBERTS An Act amending thc act of June 21, 1939 P.L.566. No.284, known as The Pennsylvania Occupational Disease Act, providing further benefits: and making an appropriation. Referred to Committee on LABOR RELATIONS. May 10, 2000.

Upload: others

Post on 30-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA

LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL

WEDNESDAY, MAY 10, 2000

SESSION OF 2000 184TH OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 31

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVESThe Houseconvenedat 11 a-rn., e.d.t.

THE SPEAKER PRO TEMPOREPATRICIA H. VANCE PRESIDING

PRAYER

REV. JULIANN PUGH, Chaplain of the House ofRepresentativesand pastorof CampHill PresbyterianChurch,CampHill. Pennsylvania,offeredthe following prayer:

Let us pray:AwesomeGod, we thank You this morningfor the amazing

gift of sleep: sucha quiet, overlookedgood and gentle grace itis. We rise from sleep born again, re-created to thisnever-before-nor-ever-againday, newand freshand Yours.

Speak to us, Lord, this day Your disturbing, unwanted,off-balance,necessaryWord to each timid, safe,and sorry soul.Afflict the complacent.Discomfort those who are unwilling toget their handssoiled or their faith ruffled or their lives lived:those who would rather withdraw passing than fail, who bynever failing neversucceed.Make themcold or hot, not tepid.

We thank You for the passionthat allows us to havestrongviews, but in our excitementto shareour views with others, weoften forget our civility. Help us to respectone another’sviews,thoughthey be different from ours,and not attackthem for theirbeliefs.

PassionateGod, how wonderful it is that in the midst of allthe gray and banal and sad stuff of life, we havemet a personreally caring about truth, that we have seen something sobeautiful it took our boredom away - quiet couragein a timidperson,a man who could laugh at himself, a genuinelyhumbleperson who did not realize they were humble, and realindignationthat wasbetterthanself-righteousness.

0 God, take the sleepersfrom our eyes, the wax from ourears, and the cataractsfrom our souls so that we may haveclarity to our perceptionand joy to our heartsthis and everythy. Allow the peoplethat representso many to be filled withpassionbeyond the limitations of this room and themselvessothat they mayhavea sinceredesireto care for the peoplewhomthey are calledto serve.

Thank You, God, for the dependabilityand the democracyofnature. We are glad that the wind blows acrossthe fences andthe boundaries,whethercarrying freshair or pollution; that thesunbelongs to no nation: and that from a satellite, the nationalboundariesare invisible: that the pink. green. red, and bluenationsof the map are all earth-colored.ThankYou for coloringoutsideof our lines.

And so. our God, we thank You today for the most constantof gifts, Your steadfastlove for us throughoutthe generations.In interesting times, when life unravelsand thereseemsto benothing to hold on to, we turn to You. Your gift of hope is thethreadstrong enoughto hold life together.With it. our dreamswill neverperish.May Your namebepraised.

Hearthis our commonprayer.Amen.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by members and

JOURNAL APPROVAL POSTPONED

visitors.

The SPEAKERpro tempore.Without objection. the approvalof the Journalof Tuesday,May 9. 2000, will be postponeduntilprinted.The Chair hearsno objection.

HOUSE BILLSINTRODUCED AND REFERRED

No. 2535 By Representatives CIVERA, BARRAR.RAYMOND, GORDNER,MARKOSEK, ALLEN andMAJOR

An Act amending the act of June 19, 1931 P.L.589, No.202,referred to as the Barbers’ License Law, further providing forapplicationsfor licensureand for studentbarbers.

Referredto Committee on PROFESSIONALLICENSURE.May 10. 2000.

No. 2536 By RepresentativesBELFANTI, DeWEESE.FAIRCHILD, LUCYK, PHILLIPS, TRICH, LEDERER.McGILL, WATERS. VAN HORNE, LAUGHLIN.MANDERINO. CURRY, GRUCELA. WALKO,WOJNAROSKI. PETRARCA, SOLOBAY. HARHAI. COY,CLYMER. ARGALL, BEBKO-JONES. PESCI. McCALL,DeLUCA, HORSEY. RAMOS. GEORGE,STABACK, HESS.M. COHEN, SHANER. JOSEPHS, RAYMOND.YOUIsIGBLOOD. PETRONE, SATHER, SURRA, WOGAN,VEON, LESCOVITZ, READSHAW. TIGUE, BELARDI,YUDICHAK. HASAY and ROBERTS

An Act amending thc act of June 21, 1939 P.L.566. No.284,known as The PennsylvaniaOccupational Disease Act, providingfurtherbenefits:and making an appropriation.

Referred to Committee on LABOR RELATIONS. May 10,2000.

Page 2: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

1034 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE MAY 10

No. 2537 By Representatives LaGROTTA, WILT, SB 1305, PN 1681FARGO, M. COHEN, LAUGHLIN, CORRIGAN, MANN,ROBINSON, WALKO, MANDERINO, BEBKO-JONES, Referredto Committeeon CONSUMER AFFAIRS, May 10,DEMPSEY, HESS, J. TAYLOR, THOMAS. WATERS. 2000.CORNELL, SEYFERT, GANNON. HARHAI, STABACK,RUBLEY, SEMMEL, ROONEY, YOIJNGBLOOD. FICHTER, SB 1418,PN 1849RAMOS, MELIO, EACHUS andGRUCELA

Referredto Committee on TRANSPORTATION, May 10,An Act providing for interscholastic athletic accountability; 2000.

establishingthe PennsylvaniaAthletic Oversight Council; providingfor powers and duties of the State Board of Education; establishingeligibility appealboards;and makinga repeal.

SENATE RESOLUTION FOR CONCURRENCEReferredto Committeeon EDUCATION,May 10, 2000.

The clerk of the Senate, being introduced, presentedtheNo. 2538 By RepresentativesGLADECK, BARRAR, following resolutionfor concurrence:

BELARDI, BENNINGHOFF, BUNT, CASORIO, CLARK,CLYMER, M. COHEN,CURRY, DAILEY, GEIST,GEORGE, SR 127, PN 1935HENNESSEY, HORSEY, KENNEY. LAUGHLIN,

R. MILLER, MYERS, ORIE, RAMOS, READSHAW, Referredto Committeeon RULES, May 10, 2000.ROBERTS, SEYFERT, SHANER, STABACK,E. Z. TAYLOR, THOMAS, TRICH, VEON, WATERS,WILLIAMS, WRIGHT, YOUNGBLOOD and YUDICHAK SENATE MESSAGE

An Act amendingthe act of May 17, 1921 P.L.682, No.284, AMENDED HOUSE BILL RETURNEDknown as The Insurance Company Law of 1921, providing forreimbursementfor brandnameprescriptiondrugs. FOR CONCURRENCEAND

REFERREDTO COMMITrEE ON RULES

Referredto Committeeon INSURANCE, May 10, 2000.The clerkof the Senate,being introduced,returnedRB 1099,

PN 3504, with informationthat the Senatehaspassedthe sameHOUSE RESOLUTION with amendmentin which the concurrenceof the House of

INTRODUCED AND REFERRED Representativesis requested.

No. 495 By RepresentativePERZEL

A Resolutioncreatinga selectsubcommitteeof the Committeeon GUESTS INTRODUCEDEducation to examineand study matters relating to the PennsylvaniaSystemof School AssessmentTest; and providing for its composition The SPEAKER pro tempore. The Chair is pleased toandpowersandduties, welcomeSuzannahMellinget She is servingas a guestpagefor

RepresentativeRon Miller. Suzannahis a seventhgrade studentReferredto Committeeon RULES,May 10, 2000. at EasternYork Middle School.Would Suzannahpleaserise.

The Chair is also pleasedto welcome to the House floorSENATE BILLS FOR CONCURRENCE Jessica Griffith of Halistead. Jessicais a guest page under

RepresentativeJ. Scot Chadwick. Jessica is a junior atThe clerk of the Senate, being introduced, presentedthe MontroseHigh School.Would Jessicapleaserise.

following bills for concurrence: -

SB 1101,PN 1916BILLS REMOVED FROM TABLE

Referred to Committee on URBAN AFFAIRS, May 10, The SPEAKER pro tempore. The Chair recognizes the2000- majority leader.

Mr. PERZEL. Madam Speaker,I move that the followingSB 1178,PN 1467 bills be removed from the table:

Referred to Committee on STATE GOVERNMENT, HB 1728:May 10, 2000. HB 1960; and

HP 2139.SB 1224,PN 1855

On the question,Referred to Committeeon JUDICIARY, May 10, 2000.

Will the Houseagreeto the motion?Motion was agreed to.

Page 3: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

2000 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE 1035

BILLS ON SECOND CONSIDERATION Barrar Forcier McGill SnyderBastian Frankel Mcllhattan SolobayBattisto Freeman Mcllhinney Staback

The following bills, having beencalled up, were considered Bebko-Jones Gannon McNaughton Stairsfor the secondtime and agreedto, and ordered transcribedfor Belardi Geisl Metio Steelman

third consideration: Belfanti George Meicalte SteilBenninghoff Gladeck Michlovic StemBirnielin Godshall Micozzie Stetler

HB 1728, PN 3414; HB 1960, PN 2673; and RB 2139, Bishop Gordner Miller, R. Stevenson

PN 2792. Blaum Grucela Miller, S. StrittmattcrBoyes Gruitza Mundy SiurlaBrowne Habay Myers SurraBunt Haluska Nailor Tangretti

BILLS RECOMI4ITTED Buxton Hanna Nickol Taylor, F. Z.Caltagirone Harhart Oliver Taylor.J,

The SPEAKER pro tempore. The Chair recognizesthe Cappabianca Hasay Perzel ThomasCam Hennessey Pesci Tigucmajority leader. Casorio Herman Petrarca Travaglio

Mr. PERZEL. Madam Speaker.I move that the following Cawley Hershey Peirnne Trellobills be recommittedto the Committeeon Appropriations: Chadwick Hess Phillips Trich

Civera Horsey Pippy TrueClark Hutchinson Pistella Tulli

HP 1728; Clymer Jadlowiec Platis VanceHB 1960; and Cohen.L. I. James Preston Van Home

HP 2139. Cohen.M. .losephs Ramos VeonColafella Kaiser Raymond Vitali

- Comell Keller Readshaw WalkoOn the question, Corrigan Kenney Reinard Washington

Will the Houseagreeto themotion? Cosia Kirkland Rieger WatersCoy Krebs Roberts Williams

Motion was agreedtO. Curry LaGrotta Robinson WiltDailey Laughlin Roebuck WoganDaley Lawless Rohrer Wojnaroski

BILL REPORTED FROM COMMITTEE, Daily Lederer Rooney Wright

CONSIDEREDFIRST TIME, AND TABLED DeLuca Leh Ross YewcicDempsey Lescovitz Rubley YoungbioodDermody Levdansky Rutting Yudichak

08 1837,PN 2254 By Rep.SCHULER DeWeese Lucyk Sainaio ZimmermanDiGirolamo Lynch Samuelson Zug

An Act establishingthe KeystoneQuality Certificate program for Donatucci Maher Santoni

certain child day-care providers; and providing for the powers and Druce Maitland SatherEachus Major Saylor Ryan,dutiesof theDepartmentof Public Welfare. Egoif Manderino Schroder Speaker

AGING AND YOUTH.

ADDITIONS-ULEAVES OF ABSENCE

The SPEAKERpro tempore.Are thererequestsfor leavesof NOT VOTING-0absence?

The Chair recognizesthemajority whip, who movesthat thelady, Miss ORIE. from Allegheny County and the gentleman, EXCUSED-SMr. O’BRIEN, be placedon the leave list.

The Chair recognizesthe minority leader, who moves that Buikovitz Harhai O’Brien One

the gentleman,Mr. HARHAI. from WestmorelandCounty and Gig]iotti

Mr. BUTKOVITZ from Philadelphiabe placedon the leavelist.Without objection. the leavesof absenceare granted.

LETTER SUBMITTED FOR THE RECORD

MASTER ROLL CALLVOTE CORRECTIONS

The SPEAKER pro tempore. The clerk is about to take themasterroll call. Memberswill proceedto vote. Mr. FLICK submittedthe following letter for the Legislative

Journal:

The following roll call was recorded:Houseof Representatives

Commonwealthof PennsylvaniaPRESENT-l97Harrisburg

Adolph Evans Mann SchulerAllen Fairchild Markosek Scrimenri May 10, 2000Argali Fargo Marsico SemmelArmstrong Feese Masland Seyfert The HonorableMatthew J. RyanBaker Fichter Mayemik ShanerBard Fleagle McCall Smith. B. Speakerof the House

Barley Flick McGeehan Smith. S. H. Room 139. Main Capitol Building

Page 4: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

1036 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE MAY 10

Dear Mr. Speaker, Caltaginone llarhart Oliver Taylor. J.Cappabianca Hasay Pcrzel ThomasCam Hennessey Pesci TigueSinceI wason official leave for yesterday’slegislative session,I wish Casorlo Herman Petrarca Travaglio

to submit the following reniarksfor the record. Dueto surgerymy son Cawley Hershey Peirone Trellois going to have, I felt it necessaryto be at his surgical consultation. Chadwick Hess Phillips TnichAfterward. I did come to Harrisburg but arrived shortly after Civena Horsey Pippy True

adjournment. Clark Hutchinson Pisiella TulliClymer Jadlowiec Plans VanceCohen,L. I. James Ramos Van Home

Had I been in the House Chamber, I would havecast my vote in the Cohen.M. Josephs Raymond Veonaffirmativeon the following legislation: Colafella Kaiser Readshaw Vitali

Comell Keller Reinard WalkoHR 819Motion to Postpone Corrigan Kenney Rieger Washington

Costa Kirkland Robens WaiersHB 1523 Final Passage Coy Krebs Robinson WilliamsHR 1537Final Passage Curry LaGrotta Roebuck WiltHB 1686Motion to Reconsider Dailey Laughlin Rohrer WoganHB 1686-AmendmentAl992 Motion to Reconsider Daley Lawless Rooney WojnaroskiHP 2083 Final Passage Daily Lederer Ross Wright

HB 2083-AmendmentA2062 GeorgeAmendment DeLuca Leh Rubley YeweicDempsey Lescovitz Rufling Youngblood

HB 2083-AmendmentA2 178 GordnerAmendment Dermody Levdansky Sainato YudichakHP 2463Final Passage DeWeese Lucyk Samuelson ZimmermanSB 1109 Final Passage DiGinolamo Lynch Santoni ZugSB 1109-AmendmentA2l69 O’Brien Amendment Donatucci Maher Sather

SB 1109-AmendmentA2221 O’Brien Amendment Druce Maitland SaylorEachus Major Sehroder Ryan,

SB 1134 Final Passage Egolf Manderino Speaker

Best regards.

Sincerely, NAYS-U

RobertJ. Flick

RJF/mmgw NOT VOTING-I

PrestonCALENDAR

RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO RULE 35 EXCUSED-5

Mr. HABAY called up HR 487, PN 3505,entitled: Buikovitz Harhai OBrien OneGigliotti

A Resolution honoring Shaler Township. Allegheny County, onthe occasion of its centennial anniversary as a township of thefirst classin 2000.

- The majority having voted in the affirmative, the questionwas determined in the affirmative and the resolution was

On the question,adopted.Will the House adopt the resolution?

The following roll call was recorded: GUESTS INTRODUCED

YEAS-196 The SPEAKER pro tempore. The Chair is pleased towelcome to the hail of the House two guest pages who are

Adolph Evans Mann Schuier here with Representative Steelman: Jenna Hennessey andAllen Fairchild Markosek ScrimentiArgall Fargo Marsico Semmel Laura Kealey. They are also accompaniedby their principal,Armstrong Feese Masiand Seyfert Dr. WalterG. Kealey.Will all threepeoplepleaserise.Baker Fichier Mayernik ShanerBard Fleagle McCall Smith. B.Barley Flick McGeehan Smith, S. H. RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO RULE 35Barrar Fonder McGill SnyderBastian Frankel Mclihattan Solobay Mr. BENNINGHOFF called up HR 488, PN 3506,entitled:Batiisto Freeman Mellhinney StabackBebko-Jones Gannon MeNaughton StairsBelardi Geisi Melio Steelman A Resolutiondesignatingthe Village of Boalsburg,Pennsylvania,Beifanti George Metcalfe Steil astheofficial birthplaceof Memorial Day in the fall of 1864.Benninghoff Gladeck Michiovic SternBirmelin Godshaii Micozzie StetierBishop Gordner Miller. R. Stevenson On the question,B]aum Gruceta Miller. S. Stritimatter Will the House adopt the resolution?Boyes Gruiiza Mundy SturlaBrowne Habay Myers SurraBunt Haluska Nailor Tangretii The following roll call wasrecorded:Buxton Hanna Nickol Taylor. F. Z.

Page 5: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

2000 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE 1037

YEAS-I 96 The SPEAKER pro tempore.We are informed that they arebeing passedout right now. They are also on your computeras

Adolph Evans Mann Schuler well.Allen Fairchild Mankosek ScrimentiArgali Fargo Mansico Semmel Mr. GODSHALL. Thankyou.Armstrong Feese Masland SeyfertBaker Fichier Mayemik ShanerBand Fleagle McCall Smith. B. THE SPEAKER MATTHEW I RYANBarley Flick McGeehan Smith, S. H. PRESIDINGBarar Forcier McGill SnyderBastian Frankel Mcllhattan SolobayBattisto Freeman Mcllhinney Staback BILL ON THIRD CONSIDERATIONBebko-Jones Gannon McNaughton StairsBelardi Geist Meiio SteelmanBelfanti George Metcalfe Steil The House proceededto third considerationof HB 2209,Benninghoff Gladeck Michlovic Stern PN 3233,entitled:Binmelin Godshall Micozzie StetlerBishop Gondoen Miller. R. StevensonBlaum Grucela Miller, S. Strinmatter An Act amendingtheact of December4, 1996 P.L.893,No.141,Boyes Gruitza Mundy Stunla known as the Volunteer Health Services Act, allowing doctors withBrowne Habay Myers Sunra volunteerlicensesto prescribemedicationto family members.Bunt Haluska Nailor TangretiiBuxton Hanna Nickol Taylor. F. Z. On the question,Caltagirone Harhant Oliver Taylor, J.Cappabianca Hasay Perzel Thomas Will the Houseagreeto thebill on third consideration?Cam Hennessey Pesci TigueCasonio Herman Petrarca Travaglio Mr. GEORGE offered the following amendmentNo.Cawley Hershey Petrone TrelloChadwick Hess Phillips Tnich A2102:Civera Horsey Pippy TrueClark Hutchinson Pisielia Tutu Amend Sec. I Sec. 10.1, page 1, line 15, by striking outCtymer Jadlowiec Plans Vance

"membersof his" and insertingCohen,L. I. James Preston Van HomeCohen,M. Josephs Ramos Veon any memberof hisColafella Kaiser Raymond Vitali Amend Sec. I Sec. 10.1, page 2. lines I through 6, by strikingCornell Keller Readshaw Walko out "his own care or whether the family members"in line I, all ofCorrigan Kenney Remand Washingion lines 2 through6 and insertingCosta Kirkland Rieger Waters that member’sown care or whetherthat memberCoy Krebs Roberts WilliamsCurry LaGrotta Robinson Wilt is beingtreatedat anapprovedclinic.Dailey Laughlin Rohrer Wogan Amend Sec. I Sec. 10.1, page 2, by inserting betweenlines 14Daley Lawless Rooney Wojoaroski and 15Daily Lederen Ross Wright d Definition-As used in this section, the termDeLuca Leh Rubley Yewctc

"family member" means a volunteer license holders’s spouse,child,Dempsey Lescovita Ruffing YoungbloodDermody Levdansky Sainato Yudichak daughter-in-law, son.in-law. mother, father, sibling, mother-in-law,DeWeese Lucyk Samuelson Zimmerman father-in-law, sister-in-law, brother-in-law, grandparent, grandchild,DiGirolamo Lynch Santoni Zug niece,nephewor cousin.Donatucci Maher SatherDruce Maitiand Saylor

On the question,Eachus Major Schnoder Ryan,Egolf Mandenino Speaker Will the Houseagreeto theamendment?

NAYS-U The SPEAKER. On the question of the adoption of theamendment,Mr. George.

NOT VOTING-I Mr. GEORGE.Mr. Speaker,on 2102. there is languagein itsaying that whom you could attend to is a matter of family

Roebuck members.This amendmentsimply addsniece and nephewto thelist of family members for which a volunteer licensee may

EXCUSED-5 prescribemedication.So often I find myself, Mr. Speaker. trying to helpButkoviiz Harhai OBnien One

Gigliotti individuals who fall through the cracks in regard to our Statelaws. A niece or a nephew who is in need of a medicalprescription should be considereda family member for the

The majority having voted in the affirmative, the question purposeof this act.

was determined in the affirmative and the resolution was This amendmentdoes not hurt the bill, Mr. Speaker.It only

adopted. makes it more complete by adding these important familymembersto the list. I urgean affirmative vote.

The SPEAKER pro tempore. For what purpose does the The SPEAKER.The Chair thanksthe gentleman.

gentleman.Mr. Godshall,rise?Mr. GODSHALL. Madam Speaker.is there any reason we On the questionrecurring,

do not have calendars? Will the Houseagreeto the amendment?

The following roll call was recorded:

Page 6: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

1038 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE MAY 10

YEAS--193 GUESTS INTRODUCEDAdolph Fairchild Mann Scrtmenli The SPEAKER.The Chair is pleasedto welcome to the hallAllen Fargo Mankosek SemnielArgall Feese Marsico Seyfert of the House today, asthe guestsof RepresentativesMcCall andBaker Fiehten Masland Shaner Harhart,studentsand teachersfrom St. JohnNeumanSchool inBand Fleagle Mayemik Smtlh. B. Palmerton,Pennsylvania.Would the guestspleaserise.Barrar Flick McCall Smith. S. H.Bastian Foncien McGeehan SnyderBattisto Frankel McGill SolobayBebko-Jones Fneeman Mcllhaitan Staback CONSIDERATION OF HB 2209 CONTINUEDBelardi Gannon Mcllhinney StairsBelfanti Geisi McNaughton Sieelman BILL PASSEDOVER TEMPORARILYBenninghoff George Melio SteilBirmelin Gladeck Meicalfe StemBishop Godshali Michlovic Stetler The SPEAKER. The Chair awaits the arrival of theBlaum Gondner Mtiler, R. Stevenson gentleman, Mr. Cohen. Until such time, HB 2209, WithBoyes Grucela Miller, S. Strttimaiter amendments,will be withdrawntemporarily.Bnowne Gruitza Mundy SturlaBunt Habay Myers SurraBuxton Haluska Nailor TangreltiCaltagirone Hanna Nickol Taylor, E. Z. GUESTSINTRODUCEDCappabianca Harhart Oliver Tayior,J.Cam Hasay Perzel Thomas The SPEAKER. The Chair is pleasedto welcome to theCasonio Hennessey Pesci Tigue hail of the House today as guest pages David Hyson andCawley Herman Peirarca TravaglioChadwick Hershey Petrone Trelto Adrienne Zootell. David and Adrienne are guests ofCivera Hess Phillips Trich RepresentativeSaylor. Would the guestspleaserise, here in theClark Horsey Pippy True well of the House.Clymen Hutchinson Pistella TulliCohen,L. I. Jadlowiec Plaits Vance The Chair is pleasedto welcome to the hail of the HouseCohen,M. James Preslon Van Home today, as the guestof RepresentativeCoy, Antonio Diaz. He isColafella Josephs Ramos Veon seatedto the left of the Speaker.Would the gentlemanpleaseCornell Kaiser Raymond viiahCorrigan Keller Readshaw Walko rise.Costa Kenney Reinard Washtngton The Chair is also pleasedto welcometo the hail of the HouseCoy Kirkland Rieger Waters today Professor of Nursing Lenore Resick. She is fromCurry Knebs Roberts WilliamsDailey LaGrotia Robinson Will DuquesneUniversity, the guest of the lady from MontgomeryDaley Laughlin Rohrer Wogan County, Mrs. Dailey. She is also a nursing school classmateofDaIly . Lawless Rooney WoJnaroski Mrs. Dailey’s. Welcometo Harrisburg.DeLuca Lederer Ross WrightDempsey Leh Rubley YewcicDermody Lescovitz Ruffing Youngblood BILLS ON THIRD CONSIDERATIONDeWeese Levdansky Sainato YudichakDiGinolamo Lucyk Samuelson ZimmermanDonatucci Lynch Santoni Zug The House proceededto third consideration of SB 262,Druce Maher Sather PN 1913, entitled:Eachus Maitland SaylonEgolf Major Schroder Ryan.Evans Manderino Schuler Speaker An Act amending Title 18 Crimes and Offenses of the

Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, further providing for explicitsexualmaterials.

NAYS-i

Micozzie On thequestion,Will the Houseagreeto the bill on third consideration?

NOT VOTING-Mr. GANNON offered the following amendment No.

Armslrong Barley Roebuck A2024:

EXCUSED-5 Amend Sec. I, page 3, line 9, by striking out "and b" andinserting

Butkovitz Hanhai O’Brien One , b and h IGigliotti Amend Sec. I Sec. 5903, page 7, by inserting betweenlines 18

and 19h Criminal prosecution.-

The majority having voted in the affirmative, the question I Any personwho violates subsectionaJfl or fl iswas determinedin the affirmative and the amendmentwas guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree. Violation ofagreedto. subsectiona is a felony of the third degreeif the offenderhas

previously been convictedof a violation of subsectiona or ifthe material was sold, distributed, preparedor publishedfor theOn the question,

Will the House agree to the bill on third considerationas pumoseof resale.* **

amended?

Page 7: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

2000 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL--HOUSE 1039

On the question, EXCUSED-SWill the Houseagreeto theamendment?

Butkovitz Harhai O’Brien One

The SPEAKER. On the question of the adoption of theGigliotit

Gannon amendment,the Chair recognizesthe gentlemanfromDelawareCounty.

Mr. GANNON. Thankyou. Mr. Speaker. The majority having voted in the affirmative, the question

Mr. Speaker, this is merely a technical amendmentwhich was determinedin the affinnative and the amendmentwas

addsjust a subsectionenumeration,and I would ask for a "yes" agreedto.

vote. Thankyou.On the question,

On the questionrecurring, Will the House agree to the bill on third considerationas

Will the Houseagreeto the amendment?amended?

Bill as amendedwas agreedto.

The following roll call wasrecorded:The SPEAKER. This bill has been considered on three

YEAS-197 different daysandagreedto and is now on final passage.Thequestionis, shall thebill passfinally?

Adolph Evans Mann Schuler Agreeableto the provisionsof the Constitution,the yeasandAlien Fairchild Markosek Scrimenti nayswill now be taken.Argall Fargo Marsico ScmmelArmstrong Feese Masland Seyt’enBaker Fichter Mayernik Shaner The following roll call was recorded:Bard Fleagle McCall Smith. B.Barley Flick McGeehan Smith. S. H.Banar Forcier McGill Snyder YEAS-l97Bastian Frankel Mcllhattan SolobayBaitisto Freeman Mcllhinney Staback Ado]ph Evans Mann SchulerBebko-Jones Gannon McNaughton Stairs Allen Fairchild Markosek Scrimenii

Belandi Geisi Melio Steelman Argall Fargo Marsico SeninielBelfanti George Meicalfe Steil Armstrong Feese Masland Seyfert

Benninghoff Gladeck Michlovic Slern Baker Fichier Mayemik Shaner

Birmelin Godshall Micozzie Steiler Bard Fleagle McCall Smith, B.

Bishop Gordner Miller, R, Stevenson Barley Flick McGeehan Smith. S. H.

Blaum Grucela Miller. S. Sinittmatter Barrar Forcien McGill Snyder

Boyes Gruitza Mundy Sturia Bastian Frankei Mcllhattan Solobay

Browne Habay Myers Surna Baitisto Freeman Mclihinney StabackBunt Haluska Nailor Tangretti Bebko-Jones Gannon McNaughton StairsBuxion Hanna Niekol Taylor. E. z, Belardi Geist Melio SteelmanCaliagirone Harhart Oliver Taylor. J. Belfanit George Metcalfe SteilCappabianca Hasay Perzel Thomas Benninghoff Gladeck Michlovic SternCam Hennessey Pesci Tigue Birmelin Godshall Micozzie StetlerCasonio Herman Petnarca Travaglio Bishop Gordnen Miller, R. StevensonCawley Hershey Petnone Trello Blaum Grucela Miiler, S. StnittmatterChadwick Hess Phillips Tnich Boyes Gruitza Mundy StunlaCivera Horsey Pippy True Browne Habay Myers SurraClark Hutchinson Pistella Tuili Bunt Haluska Nailor Tangretti

Clymer Jadlowiec Plaits Vance Buxton Hanna Niekol Taylor, E. Z.Cohen.L. I James Preston Van Home Caltagirone Harhart Oliver Taylor. J.Cohen.M, Josephs Ramos Veon Cappabianca Hasay Perzel Thomas

Colafella Kaiser Raymond Vitali Cam Hennessey Pesci Tigue

Comell Keller Readshaw walko Casorio Herman Petrarca Travaglio

Corrigan Kenney Reinard Washington Cawley Hershey Petrone Trello

Costa Kirkland Rieger Waters Chadwick Hess Phillips Tnteh

Coy Krebs Roberts williams Civera Horsey Pippy TrueCurry LaGrotta Robinson Wilt Clark Huichinson Pistella Tulli

Datley Laughlin Roebuck Wogan Clymer .ladlowiec Plaits Vance

Daley Lawless Rohrer Wojnaroski Cohen,L. I. James Preston Van Home

DaIly Lederer Rooney Wright Cohen,M. Josephs Ramos Veon

DeLuca Leh Ross Yewcic Colafella Kaiser Raymond Vttali

Dempsey Lescovitz Rubley Youngblood Cornell Keller Readshaw Walko

Dermody Levdansky Ruft’ing Yudichak Corrigan Kenney Remand WashingionDeWeese Lucyk Sainato Zimmerman Costa Kirkland Rieger Waters

DiGirolamo Lynch Samuelson Zug Coy Krehs Robens WilliamsDonatucci Maher Santoni Curry LaGrotla Robinson WiltDruce Maitland Sather Dailey Laughlin Roebuck Wogan

Eachus Major Saylor Ryan. Daley Lawless Rohrcr WojnaroskiEgolf Manderino Schroder Speaker Daily Lederer Rooney Wnighi

DeLuca Leh Ross YewcicDempsey Lescovit, Rubley YoungbloodDermody Levdansky Ruffing Yudichak

NAYS-O DeWeese Lucyk Sainato ZimmermanDiGirotamo Lynch Samuelson ZugDonatucci Mahcr SanioniDruec Maitland Sather

NOT VOTING-O

Page 8: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

1040 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE MAY 10

Eachus Major Saylor Ryan. The following roll call was recorded:Egolf Manderino Sehroder Speaker

YEAS-196NAYS-O

Adolph Evans Mann Schuler

NOT VOTING-U Allen Fairchild Markosek ScrimentiArgali Fargo Marsieo SemmelArmstrong Feese Masland Sey4ert

EXCUSED-5 Baker Fichter Mayernik ShanerBard Fleagle McCall Smith. B.

Butkoviiz Harhai O’Brien One Barley Flick McGeehan Smith. S. H.Barrar Foreier McGill Snyder

Gigliotti Bastian Frankel Mcllhattan SolobayBaitisto Freeman Mcilhinney StabaekBebko-Jones Gannon McNaughton StairsBelardi Geist Melio SteelmanThe majority required by the Constitution having voted ii Beltnti George Metcalfe Steil

the affirmative, the questionwas determinedin the affirmative Benninghoff Gladeek Michiovic Stemand the bill passedfinally. Btrmelmn GodshaIl Miller. R. Steiler

Ordered,That the clerk retum the sameto the Senatewith Bishop Gordner Miller. S. SievensonBlaum Gruceta Mundy Smrittmatter

the information that the House has passed the same with Boyes Gruitza Myers Sturlaamendmentin which the concurrenceof the Senateis requested. Browne Habay Nailor Surra

Bunt Haluska Nickol TangrettiBuxton Hanna Oliver Taylor. E. Z.Caltagirone Harhart Perzel Taylor. J.Cappabianca Hasay Pesct ThomasCam Hennessey Petrarca TigueThe House proceededto third considerationof HB 2313, Casorio Herman Petrone Travaglio

PN 3294, entitled: Cawley Hershey Phillips TrelloChadwick Hess Pippy Trieh

An Act providing for certain immunizations in long-term care Civera Homey Pistella True

facilities. Clark Hutchinson Plaits TulliClymer Jadlowiec Preston VanceCohen.L. I. James Ramos Van Home

On the question, Cohen.M. Josephs Raymond VeonWill the Houseagreeto the bill on third consideration? Colafetla Kaiser Readshaw Vitali

Cornell Keller Remand WalkoCorrigan Kenney Rieger Washingion

Mr. GEORGE offered the following amendment No. Costa Kirkland Roberts WatersA2103: Coy Krebs Robinson Williams

Curry LaGrotia Roebuck WiltDailey Laughlin Rohrer Wogan

Amend Sec.4, page2. line 20, by striking out "and location" and Daley Lawless Rooney Wojnaroskiinserting DaIly Lederer Ross Wright

and the location in which and the person by DeLuca Leh Rubley Yewcie

whom Dempsey Lescovitz Rufflng YoungbloodDermody Levdansky Sainato Yudichak

Amend Sec. 5, page 3, line 10, by striking out "and" and DeWeese Lucyk Samuelson Zimmermaninsertinga comma DiGirolamo Lynch Santoni Zug

Amend Sec. 5, page3, line 10, by insertingafter "location" Donamucei Maher Satherand by whom Druce Maitland Saylor

Amend Sec.7, page 4, line 16, by insertingafter "act," Eachus Major Schroden Ryan,Egoif Manderino Speaker

and eachthree-yearperiod thereafter,

NAYS-IOn the question,Will the Houseagreeto the amendment? Micozzie

The SPEAKER. On the question of the adoption of the NOT VOTING-Uamendment,the Chair recognizesthe gentleman,Mr. George.

Mr. GEORGE. Mr. Speaker,this amendmentonly strives to EXCUSED-5keep records as complete as possible for employees andresidentswho needto beimmunized underthis act by including Buikovitz Harhai O’Brien Onethe name of the physician or nurse who administeredthe Giglioiti

vaccine.This amendmentalso requiresthe Departmentof Health to

issue a report every 3 years to the General Assembly on the The majority having voted in the affirmative, the questionnumberof outbreaks, hospitalizations,and complications that was determined in the affirmative and the amendmentwashaveoccurreddue to influenza and from pneumococcaldisease. agreedto.Eachyear about20,000Americansdie becauseof influcnza.

I think we shouldadopt this amendment. On the question,Will the House agree to the bill on third considerationas

On the questionrecurring, amended?Will the Houseagreeto the amendment?

Page 9: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

2000

Mr. DeLUCA offeredthe following amendmentNo. A2111:

Amend Title, page I. tine 2, by removing the period after"facilities" anti inserting

requiring nursing homes to submit information annually to theDepartment of Health; requiring the Departmentof Health to placecertain information on the Internet;and providing for certainduties ofthe Departmentof Health andthe Departmentof Aging.

Amend Bill, pagel,by inserting betweenlines4 and 5CHAPTER I

PRELIMINARY PROVISIONSAmend Sec. l,page 1, lineS, by striking out"I" and inserting

Amend Sec. I, page1, line 7, by inserting after "Immunization"and Nursing Home Consumer InternetInformation Access

Amend Sec. 2, pageI, line 8, by striking out "2" and inserting

Amend Sec. 2, pageI, by insertingbetweenlines II and 12"Consumer Information Internet Guide." The Nursing Home

ConsumerInformation InternetGuide requiredto be published undertheprovisionsof chapter5.

Amend Sec. 2, page1, by insertingbetweenlines 12 and 13"Elderly persons." Those persons residing within this

Commonwealthwho are 60 yearsof age or older.Amend Bill, page2, by insertingbetweenlines Sand6"Nursing home." A facility that provides either skilled or

intermediatenursing careor both levels of such careto two or moreelderly persons, who are unrelated to the licensee, for a periodexceeding24 hours. Intermediatecare facilities exclusively for thementally retarded,commonlycalled CF/MR. shall not be considerednursing homesfor the purposeof chapters.

CHAPTER 3IMMUNIZATIONS IN

LONG-TERM CARE FACILITIESAmend Sec. 3, page2, line 6, by striking out "3" and inserting

Amend Sec. 3. page2, line 7, by striking out "6" and inserting

Amend Sec. 4, page2. line II, by striking out "4" and inserting

Amend See.5, page3. line 2, by striking out "5" and inserting

Amend Sec. 6, page3, line 25, by striking out"6" andinserting

Amend Sec. 7, page4. lineS, by striking out "7" and inserting305

Amend Sec. 7, page4. line 8, by striking out "act" and inserting

Amend Sec. 7, page4, line 16, by striking out "act" andinsertingchapter

Amend Bill, page4. by insertingbetweenlines 21 and 22CHAPTERS

NURSING HOME CONSUMERINTERNET INFORMATION ACCESS

Section501. NursingHomeConsumerInformationReport.In addition to the information required by the Department of

Health on a form providedby the Departmentof Healthpursuantto theprovisions of the act of July I 9, 1979 FL. 130, No.48. known as theHealth Care Facilities Act, and regulations promulgated pursuantthereto, each nursing homeshall provide to the Departmentof Healthno laterthan 90 daysafter thecloseof eachcalendaryear thefollowinginformation on the above-referencedform:

I Nursing hours worked per patient per day andnursing hours requiredby the Departmentof Health per patientperday. Actual hoursworkedper patientper day are for the mostrecentlyconcludedfiscal or calendaryear.

1041

2 Average length of service of professionalnursingstaffapdthe avcragelength of serviceof nurseaide personnelatthe nursing homecompletingthe form.

3 Average length of licensure and/or certification ofprofessionalnursing staff and the average length of licensureand/orcertification of nurseaidepersonnel.

4 Nursing hours per patient per day of temporaryagencyprofessionalnursing staff and nurseaidepersonnel.

5 Whether a residentcouncil exists and meets on aregular basis.

Section 502. Nursinghome consumerinformation.a Guide.-

I The Departmentof Aging shall produce,in a timelymanner,a nursing home information site on the Internet. It shallinclude:

i The itemslisted in section501.ii Information obtained from the annual

Long-Term Care Facilities Questionnairessubmitted tothe Departmentof Health.

iii Informationobtainedfrom the Health CareFinancingAdministrationOwnershipDisclosureForm.

iv A comparative list of nursing homesdevelopedin the mannerprovidedin subsectionb.

v The Nursing Home Consumer InquiryTelephone Hotline telephone number required undersubsectionc.2 If errors are found in the Consumer Information

InternetGuide,all facilities shall be sent a correctionsheetwithin30 days of the Departmentof Aging’s receipt of notification ofthe error. For the purposesof this section, an error shall bedefined as information incorrectly transcribedfrom the formsprovidedto the Departmentof Health to the consumerguide.

3 The Department of Aging will send final proofs tothe nursing home of its dataprofile that will be publishedin theconsumerguide prior to publication.The nursing home will havefive days to notify the Departmentof Aging of any errors to becorrected.If the Departmentof Aging receivesno notification oferrors, the data profile will be consideredaccurate and will bepublished.b Comparativelist-The comparative list of nursing homes

shall be developedand included in the ConsumerInformation InternetGuide by the Department of Aging. It shall include the followinginformation:

I Name of facility.2 Facility addressand telephonenumber.3 Bed capacity.4 Owner of facility and managing company, if

applicable.5 Type of sponsorship,including, but not limited to.

governmental,nonprofit and for-profit or religious affiliation, ifapplicable.

6 Paymentsourcesaccepted,including, but not limitedto, Medicare. Medicaid, Veterans’ Administration, long-termcareinsuranceandprivatepay.

7 Current license, deficiencyand certification statusasdeterminedby the Departmentof Health; whether, within thepreviousfive years, the facility has beensubject to a provisionallicense, a ban on admissions,penalties imposed in connectionwith the licensureor certification process,a licenserevocationorappointmentof a temporary managerto operate the facility orMedicare or Medicaid decertification and the correspondingdates.

8 Nursing hoursper patient per day and nursing hoursrequiredby the Departmentof Healthper patientper day. Actualhours worked per patient per day are for the most recentlyconcludedfiscal or calendaryear.

LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE

101

102

301

304

302

303

304

chapter

Page 10: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

1042

9 Average length of service at the nursing home ofprofessionalnursing staff and the averagelength of service ofnurseaidestaff.

10 Average length of licensureand/orcertification ofprofessionalnursing staff and the averagelength of licensureand/orcertificationof nurseaidepersonnel.

II Nursing hours per patient per day of temporaryagencyprofessionalnursing staffand nurseaidepersonnel.

12 A listing of existenceand availability of specifictherapyservices, including, but not limited to, physical therapy,occupationaltherapy,speechtherapyandrespiratorytherapy.

13 Whether a residentcouncil exists and meetson aregularbasis.

Name and telephonenumberof a local ombudsman.Costsperday, month andyear.Visiting hours.

If there are telephones available for privateconversations.

181920

the nursing home.21 If there are isolation rooms for patients with

contagiousillnesses.22 If there is an Alzheimer/Parkinsondiseaseprogram.23 Whether there are qualified physical therapists

on site.24 Whether there is a written descriptionof patients

rightsand responsibilities.25 Whether there are written policies on "do not

resuscitateorders,"physicalrestraintsandchemicalsedation.26 What medical services are available onsite,

including dentists,podiatrists,pharmacists,ophthalmologists.27 The current residentprofile, including avengeage,

raceand sex.28 Informationon how to contactthe local areaagency

on aging, including the services available to persons over60 years of agethroughthe local areaagencyon aging.

29 Information on communityresourcesthat can assistin the selection of a long-term care facility, such as tradeassociationsor consumeradvocacygroups.c Nursing Home Consumer Inquiry TelephoneHotline.-The

Departmentof Aging shall establish a Statewidetelephonenumber toserveas the Nursing HomeConsumerInquiry TelephoneHotline. Thisnumber shall be a toll-free number. The purpose of this telephonenumberis to respondto calls regardingthe currentlicensure,deficiencyand certification statusof nursing homes. All data provided by thehotline shall be updatedeachweek using information provided by theDepartmentof Health in a timely fashion.This telephonenumbershallbe prominently displayedin the annualConsumerInformationInternetGuide.

d Disclosure-TheState Long-Term Care Ombudsmanin theDepartmentof Aging shall mail at least the addressof the ConsumerInformation InternetGuide to the local long-term care ombudsmanofeach area agency on aging, to each nursing home and to thePennsylvaniaCouncil on Aging annually.

e Availability-Each nursing home shall post next to itsDepartmentof Health licensean exactcopy of its listing as found in theConsumerInformationInternetGuide. A nursing homeshall provide toeach prospective resident and family member of such prospectiveresidentwho visits the facility, or any member of the public uponrequest, during normal businessor visiting hours. Sunday throughSaturday. an exact copy of its listing as set forth in theConsumerInformation InternetGuide.

f Inspections-TheDepartment of Health shall verify theavailability of the listing during annual licensing surveys. TheDepartmentof Health shall monitor compliancewith the requirements

MAY10

of this act for regular filing of the Long-Term Care FacilitiesQuestionnairewith the Departmentof Health.

g Update-TheDepartmentof Healthshall issue modificationsto the Long-Term Care Facilities Questionnaireresulting from changesin the reimbursementsystem for nursing homes. Such modificationsshall providethe sameinformation in an updatedformat.

h Regulations-TheDepartmentof Aging shall promulgateregulationssetting forth proposedadditions, changes,or both, if thedepartmentdoesany of the following:

I Expandsthe scopeof the consumerguide beyondthosetopicsexpresslysetforth in subsectiona.

2 Expandsthe scopeof the comparative list beyondthosetopicsexpresslyset forth in subsectionb.

3 Expandsthe scopeof any topic expresslyset forth insubsectiona or b.

Section 503. Complaints.Complaintsof noncompliancewith this act shall be filed with the

Departmentof Aging. A complainantshall include a local ombudsman,a nursing home employee, a nursing home resident, a prospectivenursing home resident, or any personrepresentingthe interestsof anursinghomeresidentor prospectivenursing homeresident.Section504. Additional consumerinformation.

Each nursing home shall provide to each prospectiveresidentorrepresentativethereof at the time of initial inquiry, a companionconsumerguide which describeshow to selecta nursing home. Thisinformation can be eithera publication of the Departmentof Aging, acamera-readycopy of a publication provided by the DepartmentofAging or a comparablepublication that will inform the consumeronhow to choosea nursinghome.Section505. Penalties.

The Departmentof Aging shall have the authority to assessa$1,000 civil penalty for each violation of this chapter. Any personaggrievedby an adjudicationby the Departmentof Aging shall havethe right to appeal under42 Pa.C.S. relating to judiciary and judicialprocedure.

CHAPTER 7MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS

Section 701. Repeals.All acts and parts of acts are repealed insofar as they are

inconsistentwith this act.Amend Sec. 8, page4, line 22. by striking out "8" and inserting

On the question.Will the Houseagreeto the amendment?

The SPEAKER. On the question of the adoption of theamendment,the Chair recognizesMr. DeLuca.

Mr. DeLUCA. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.Mr. Speaker, amendmentA2111 is an amendmentthat

requires the department to establish certain nursing homeconsumerinformation on the Internet.

Mr. Speaker,growing older is a fact of life for every one ofus. Here in Pennsylvania.by the year 2020. it is estimatedthatalmost 25 percent of our population will be over 60. Thisnumber is staggering, and it also means that most of ourfamilies will be faced with making a very important decisionabout putting one of their loved ones into a nursing home,andthey needall the informationthat they canget.

Now, every oneof us has senior citizens in our district, andevery one of us should want to help thesefamilies know thatwhen they make thesedecisions,they are well informed aboutthe information pertaining to this difficult decision. CurrentlyPennsylvaniahasprovided very little information to help themmake an informed decision aboutone of the mostdifficult yet

LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE

14IS1617

If there is a registereddietitian.If thereis a written emergencyevacuationplan.Thenearesthospital and the distancein miles from

702

Page 11: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

2000

important decisionsthey may face: choosing the right nursinghome for those whom they love.

You know, we work hard to ensure that proper care andtreatmentis provided inside our nursing homes,and as we aredoing with this bill, however, we are doing very little to helpthosewho are in the processof placing a family memberin oneof these homes. Those citizens have so many questions, somanyconcerns, and that is what this amendmentis designedtodo, is to help easethose fearsand anxietiesfor our constituentswho mustmakethat life-changingdecision.

Many of those decisions must be made immediately, andwith very little time for writing letters, requestingbooklets,visiting many different facilities, and comparingmany varietiesof reports that can be overwhelming to a stressedfamilymember.

My amendment is simple. It says, in the informationhighway that we are on today, that we need to place thisinformation in a useful, easy-to-readformat on the Internet. Theamendment calls for useful, practical information- informationfamilies want andneed- accurateand up-to-dateinformation tobe placedat their fingertips.

Technologyis moving at the speedof light, and the Internetis becoming a natural, commonplacelocation to turn forinformation. My amendment would ensure that ourCommonwealthmakes the best use of today’s technologyandenhancesthe printed information alreadyavailable.

Now, Mr. Speaker,we all have our State Websiteaddressonour license plates. All we are asking today is, let us use thistechnologyto help our families gain the knowledgethey needtoincreasetheir comfort and decreasesome of the stress thataccompaniesthis decision.

Let me also say that this amendmentwas also a bill that wasreportedin the last sessionout of committee. It was reportedJune 15 of 1999 overwhelminglyout of committee.The timehas come for this type of legislation, and I ask you for yourconsideration and your vote on this type of legislation.Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

The SPEAKER.The Chair thanksthe gentleman.The Chair recognizes the lady, Mrs. Vance, on the

amendment,theDeLuca amendment.Mrs. VANCE. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.I rise to oppose the DeLuca amendmentnot becauseit is a

bad idea, and a year ago this informationwas notavailable.TheDepartmentof Health recentlypostedon their Websitea surveyof all the nursing homes in Pennsylvania.You can see thedeficienciesand the plusesof eachnursing home,and you cansee what each nursing home has done to correct it. Also, Iwould be happy to provide anybodywith a MedicareWebsitethat comparesnursinghomesside by side in eachcountyso thatyou can comparethem and know which is the best home foryour loved one.

At one time in my career,I was a chargenurse in a nursinghome, so I truly care a great deal about the care that thesepatients get. The information is now available. AsRepresentativeDeLuca, the prior speaker, said, it was notavailable a year ago. It is now available.But the best way todeterminethe bestsite for your loved one is a personalvisit.

But again I ask for a "no" vote, only becauseit wouldreplicatewhat is alreadythere.Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.

The SPEAKER. The Chair thanksthe lady.The Chair recognizesthe gentleman,Mr. Rooney.

1043

Mr. ROONEY. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.Mr. Speaker,I would like to ask the gentleman,Mr. DeLuca,

to stand for a brief interrogation.The SPEAKER.The gentlemanindicateshe will stand for

interrogation.You maybegin.Mr. ROONEY. Thankyou.Mr. Speaker,you and I haveworked on this issue for a long

time, and I would like to just follow up on what the previousspeakersuggestedabout the information that is containedinyour amendmentthat would be offered to the people ofPennsylvaniaandthe argumentthat it is not necessary,that theinformation alreadyexists. Could you addressthat, becauseit ismy understandingthat that is not thecase.

Mr. DeLUCA. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.Mr. Speaker,althoughthe departmenthasmade stridesto put

some of this information onto the information highway, whichis voluntary- let me saythis, it is not in statute; it is voluntaryright now - a lot of this information, after researchingit andhaving my staff peoplepull up some of the nursing homes inAllegheny County and talking to the Departmentof Aging inAllegheny County, we find out that a lot o this information isnot available.

Let me just allude to what we are askingto be put on thisinformationalhighway which peopledo not haveaccessto.

We are asking for the name and telephonenumber of thelocal ombudsmanpersonthere. We are asking for the cost perday, month, andyear.We are askingfor visiting hours. If thereare any telephonenumbersavailable for private conversations.Is there a registered dietitian on board? Is there a writtenemergencyevacuationplan? What is the nearesthospital? Ifthereare isolation areasand roomsfor patientswith contagiousdiseases. Is there an Alzheimer’s or a Parkinson diseaseprogram? Whether there are qualified physical therapists onboard. Whether there is a written description of the patient’srights andresponsibilities.Whetherthere is a written policy on"do not resuscitate"orders, physical restraints, and chemicalsedation.What medical servicesare available onsite, includingdentists,podiatrists,pharmacists,ophthalmologists.

This is some of the information we are asking. Althoughsomeof that information is on a voluntary basis - it is not instatute- this is what we are asking for, to put in statute.

Now, I have contacted my Department of Aging inAllegheny County, and I hadmy staffpersonwho is very wellfamiliar with the Internet process, it took her a half hour to gothrough the different sites, and we got very little informationpertainingto one of our nursinghomes,which is a big nursinghome, Beverly Nursing Home in Allegheny County, which isthroughoutthe Commonwealth.We talked to thepeopleof theDepartmentof Aging. They could not accessit themselves.They put us on to the ombudsman,who said there is certaininformation they couldnot give us.

But this is commonsenselegislation, commonsenseissues,requirementsthat somebodywho is placing their loved one inthis facility should know, to make an intelligent decision. Weare in a busy world today. This is one of the toughestdecisionsa personhas to make, and they should have this information.We are wiring up our schools, our libraries. Everybody isgetting the Internet. The Governoris specifying that we do thaton our licenseplates. Any one of you. turn on our Website on

LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE

Page 12: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

1044

our license plate and see what you can get as far as thisinformation pertainingto your district.

That is what we are asking for, Mr. Speaker.Mr. ROONEY. Mr. Speaker, I have concluded my

interrogation.May I speakon the amendment?The SPEAKER.The gentlemanis in order.Mr. ROONIEY. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.The SPEAKER.Will the gentlemanyield for a moment.There continues to be a loud, I cannot even call it an

undercurrentanymore of conversationon the floor, and it isdistractingto the peoplewho areengagedin debate.

Mr. Rooney.Mr. ROONEY. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.Mr. Speaker, I commendthe gentleman,the makerof the

amendment, the Democratic chairman of the InsuranceCommittee. What this amendmentwould do would be toprovide people with much-neededinformation. He referencedthe fact that oftentimes choosing a nursing home for one’sparentor loved one is the most difficult decision a family canface. I know that firsthand. And let me say that, you know,oftentimes family membersdo not all live in the samecommunityas their parent.They may havemoved after havinggone to school- Whateverthe case may be. they are not there.And for a child of a parentwho is about to be placed into anursing home, they care as deeply abouthow their parentwillbe treated as the people, their siblings, who live in thatcommunity, who have accessto go to the facility, to be able tounderstandall the programsthat are in placeand how well theirparentwill be treated.But if you live in California and yourmotheris being put in a nursinghome in Bethlehem,that canbevery difficult to accomplish.What the chairman,Mr. DeLuca,has offered through this amendmentis some very simple andbasicinformation that I think is not in any way, shape,or formunreasonableto ask be postedon a Websiteso that people canhave accessto this very basic information. I do not think it isexcessive.I do not think it is intrusive. I think it is somethingthat needsto occur.

As he indicated, the chairmanhad this bill reportedout ofcommitteeand voted on, as I recall, in the last sessionof theGeneralAssembly. The time to act on this important issue istoday. We have the vehicle to do that through amendmentA2I 11, and I would just ask my colleaguesto stand in supportof providing Pennsylvaniaconsumerswith information that theyneedto make informed, reasoned.intelligent decisionsabout thecare that their loved oneswill be receiving in their remainingdays.

So I ask my colleaguesfor an affirmative vote.The SPEAKER.The gentleman,Mr. Blaum.Mr. BLAIJM. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.Mr. Speaker,I rise in support of the DeLuca amendment,

and I havegot to tell you, it is a little difficult to sit here andlisten to the commentsof thoseon the otherside opposingthisamendmentwhen for years this departmentopposedthe effortsof RepresentativeVeon to amend legislation to get the verysameinformation out to thepeopleof Pennsylvania.

This information that is currently available is inadequate,andit is thereat the whim of the department.It can go away at anytime, and I daresay, Mr. Speaker, there is nothing on thatWeb pagethat the nursing home industrydoes not want on thatWebpage.

MAY 10

The peopleof Pennsylvaniaand the families of Pennsylvaniadeservethis information.They deserveit to be partof statute inPennsylvania,that this information is requiredto be put beforethe public via the Internet and other means that may beavailable to us so that Pennsylvaniafamilies are knowledgeableabout what information is contained in various reportssubmittedon various nursing homes.

We need only go back a few months, and we see theshortcomingsof more than one department,as documentedbythe Auditor Generalin the inspectionsof nursing homesacrossPennsylvania. This is basic information for Pennsylvaniafamilies. It should be in statute, and I ask the membersfor anaffirmative vote.

The SPEAKER.Thegentleman,Mr. Grucela.Mr. GRUCELA. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.Mr. Speaker, I, too, rise in support of Representative

DeLuca’s amendment.I believe it makes a good bill better.And like my good friend and colleague, Mr. Rooney,RepresentativeRooney. I have firsthand experience,and thatexperience,for 2 1/2 years my motherwas in a nursing home.Luckily, having had county backgroundand county experience,most of the information I was able to understandor know howto access.But I can tell you that many, many times thereweremembers from other families who approached me forinformation, and that should not have to happen. I think thisinformation is necessary.I think anyone who visits a nursinghome or would have any memberof their family in a nursinghomewould certainlyappreciatethis.

So I ask my colleaguesto pleasesupport this amendment.I think it is a good amendment, and if you ever have theopportunity to visit these places firsthand, I think you canunderstandthe intent.

So I ask for your support for RepresentativeDeLuca’samendment. It makes a good bill better. Thank you,Mr. Speaker.

The SPEAKER.The Chair thanks the gentleman.The Chair recognizesthe lady, Mrs. Vance, for the second

time on theamendment.Mrs. VANCE. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.I askedthat we opposeit becausethe information was there

and is repetitive, but I will say that I will not allow old peopletobecome a political issue, so it is there already; I pulled mynursing homesup without any problem, but we will put it inagain. So we will all vote "yes." Thank you.

The SPEAKER.On the questionof the adoption- Do notlose this now, Mr. DeLuca.

Mr. DeLUCA. I thank the Representative fromCumberlandCounty for her remarks,but let me say this to you:I did not skirt the committee process. This bill cameoverwhelmingly out of committee on June 15, 1999. Theinformation is not available. I disagreewith my colleague.Wehavebeenon the Internet. We could not ascertainit, and I hopethat eachone of you would try to ascertainit as an individual tosee what information that you could find out about a nursinghome in your district.

So I appreciate and I thank her for supporting theamendment.I just hope that it will stay in in thc Senate.Thankyou very much.

On the questionrecurring,Will the Houseagreeto the amendment?

LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE

Page 13: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

2000 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE 1045

The following roll call wasrecorded: The SPEAKER. This bill has been consideredon threedifferentdays and agreedto and is now on final passage.

YEAS-197 The questionis, shall the bill passfinally?Agreeableto the provisionsof the Constitution, the yeasand

Adolph Evans Mann SchulerAllen Fairchild Markosek Scrimenti nayswill now be taken.Argall Fargo Marsico ScmmelArmstrong Feese Masland Seyfert The following roll call was recorded:Baker Fichter Mayernik ShanerBard Fleagle McCall Smith. B.Barley Flick McGeehan Smith, S. H. YEAS-197Barrar Forcier McGill SnyderBastian Frankel Mcllhattan Solobay Adolph Evans Mann SchulerBattisto Freeman Mcllhinney Staback Allen Fairchild Markosek ScrimentiBebko-Jones Gannon McNaughtnn Stairs Argall Fargo Marsico SemmelBelardi Geist Melio Steelman Armstrong Feese Masland SeyfertBelfanti George Metcalfe Steil Baker Fichter Mayernik ShanerBenninghoff Gladeck Michiovic Stern Bard Fleagle McCall Smith, B.Birmelin Godshall Micozzie Stetler Barley Flick McGeehan Smith, S. H.Bishop Gordner Miller, R, Stevenson Barrar Forcier McGill SnyderBlaum Grucela Miller. S. Strittmatter Bastian Frankel Mc!lhattan SolobayBoyes Gruitza Mundy Sturla . Battisto Freeman Mcllhinney StabackBrowne Habay Myers Surra Bebko-Jones Gannon MeNaughton StairsBunt Haluska Nailor Tangretti Belardi Geist Melio SteelmanBuxton Hanna Nickol Taylor, E. Z. Belfanti George Metcalfe SteilCaltagirone Harhart Oliver Taylor, J. Benninghoff Gladeck Michlovic StemCappabianca Hasay Perzel Thomas Birmelin Godshall Micoz.zie StetlerCam Hennessey Pesci Tigue Bishop Gordner Miller. R. StevensonCasorio Herman Petrarca Travaglto Blaum Grucela Miller. S. SlrittmatterCawley Hershey Petrone Trello Bnyes Gruitza Mundy SturlaChadwick Hess Phillips Trich Browne Habay Myers SurraCivera 1-lorsey Pippy True Bunt Haluska Nailor TangrettiClark Hutchinson Pistella Tulli Buxton Hanna Nickol Taylor, E. Z.Clymer Jadlowiec Platts Vance Caltagirone Harhart Oliver Taylor, 3.Cohen, L. I. James Preston van Home Cappabianca Hasay Perzcl ThomasCohen, M. Josephs Ramos veon Cam Hennessey Pesci TigueColafella Kaiser Raymond Vilali Casorio Herman Petrarca TravaglioCornell Keller Readshaw Walko Cawley Hershey Petrone TrelloCorrigan Kenney Reinard Washington Chadwick Hess Phillips TrichCosta Kirkland Rieger Waters Civera Horsey Pippy TrueCoy Krebs Roberts Williams Clark Hutchinson Pistella TulliCurry LaGrona Robinson Will Clymer Jadlowiec PlaIts VanceDailey Laughlin Roebuck wogan Cohen. L. I. James Preston Van HomeDaley Lawless Rohrer wojnaroski Cohen, M. Josephs Ramos VeonDaily Lederer Rooney wright Colafella Kaiser Raymond VitaltDeLuca Leh Ross Yewcic Cornell Keller Readshaw WalkoDempsey Lescovitz Rubley Youngblood Corrigan Kenney Reinard WashingtonDermody Levdansky Ruffing Vudichak Costa Kirkland Rieger WatersDeWeese Lucyk Sainato Zimmerman Coy Krebs Roberts WilliamsDiGirolamo Lynch Samuelson Zug Curry LaGrotta Robinson WiltDonatucci Maher Santoni Dailey Laughlin Roebuck WoganDruce Maitland Sather Daley Lawless Rohrer WojnaroskiEachus Major Saylor Ryan, Daily Lederer Rooney WrightEgolf Manderino Schroder speaker DeLuca Leh Ross Yewcic

Dempsey Lescovitz Rubley YoungbloodDermody Levdansky Ruffing Yudichak

NAYS.-M DeWeese Lucyk Sainato ZimmermanDiGirolamo Lynch Samuelson Zug

NOT VOTING-U Donatucci Maher SantoniDnice Mailland SatherEachus Major Saylor Ryan.

EXCUSED-5 Egolf Manderino Schroder Speaker

Butkovitz Harhai O’Brien One NAYS-UGigliotti

NOT VOTING-U

The majority having voted in the affirmative, the questionEXCUSED5

was determined in the affirmative and the amendmentwasagreedto. Butkovilz Harhai O’Brien One

Gigliotti

On the questionrecurring,Will the House agree to the bill on third considerationas

amended? The majority required by the Constitution having voted inBill as amendedwas agreedto. the affirmative, the questionwas determinedin the affinnative

and the bill passedfinally.

Page 14: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

1046 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE MAY 10

Ordered, That the clerk presentthe same to the Senatefor EXCUSED-Sconcurrence.

Bulkovitz Hamhai O’Brien OneGigliotti

SUPPLEMENTAL CALENDAR A

RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO RULE 35 The majority having voted in the affirmative, the questionwas determined in the affirmative and the resolution was

Mr. MASLAND called up HR 493, PN 3483, entitled: adopted.

A Resolution designating May 14 through 20, 2000, as"PennsylvaniaMADD Awareness Week." CALENDAR CONTINUED

On the question, CONSIDERATION OF HR 2209 CONTINUEDWill the Houseadopt the resolution?

On the questionrecurring,The following roll call was recorded: Will the House agree to the bill on third considerationas

amended?YEAS-l 97

The SPEAKER.The gentleman,Mr. Cohen, withdraws hisAdolph Evans Mann Schuler amendment.The amendmentof Mr. George has alreadybeenAllen Fairchild Markosek ScrimentiArgall Fargo Marsico Semmel accepted.Armstrong Feese Masland SeyfemtBaker Fichier Mayentik Shaner On the questionrecurring,Bard Fleagle McCall Smith, B.Barley Flick McGeehan Smith, S. H. Will the House agree to the bill on third considerationasBarrar Fomcier McGill Snyder amended?Bastian Frankel McI lhattan Solobay Bill asamendedwas agreedto.Battisto Freeman Mcllhinney StabackBebko-Jones Gannon McNaughton Stairs ‘ -

Belardi Geist Melio Steelman The SPEAKER. This bill has been consideredon threeBelfanti George Metcalfe Steil different daysandagreedto and is now on final passage.Benninghoff Gtadeck Michlovic StemBirmelin Godshall Micozzie Stetler The questionis, shallthe bill passfinally?Bishop Gordner Miller, R. StevensonBlaum Grucela Miller. S. Slrittmatter Mr. Gordner,for whatpurposedo you rise?Boyes Gruitza Mundy SturlaBrowne Habay Myers Surra Mr. GORDNER.Final passage.Bunt Haluska Nailor Tangreni The SPEAKER.The gentlemanis in order.Buxton Hanna Nickol Taylor, E. Z. Mr. GORDNER.Thank you, Mr. Speaker.Caltagirone Hanhart Oliver Taylor, 3.Cappabianca Hasay Pemzel Thomas I am going to vote "no" againstthis bill, and I may be one ofCam Hennessey Pesci Tigue the few that do. I happenedto take the time to pull up theCasonto Herman Petrarca Travaglio VolunteerHealth ServicesAct, and in section 2 of the act, itCawley Hershey Petrone Trello

talks about thepurpose.and it says."It is the purposeof this actChadwick Hess Phillips InchCivera Honsey Pippy True to increasethe availability of primary health care servicesbyClark Hutchinson Pislella Tulli establishing a procedurethrough which physiciansand otherClymer Jadlowiec Platts Vancc

health care practitionerswho are retired from active practiceCohen, L. I. James Preston Van HomeCohen,M. Josephs Ramos Veon may provide professionalservices as a volunteer in approvedColafella Kaiser Raymond Vitali clinics serving financially qualified persons and in approvedCornell Keller Readshaw WalkoCorrigan Kenney Remand Washington clinics located in medically underserved areas or healthCosta Kirkland Rieger Waters professionalsshortageareas."Coy Krehs Roberts Williams The purposeof this act. again,was to do threethings: one,toCurr’ LaGrotta Robinson Will

allow folks to be in approved clinics serving financiallyDailey Laughlin Roebuck woganDaley Lawless Rohrer Wojnaroski qualified persons or to be in approved clinics located inDaily Lederem Rooney Wright medically underservedareas or health professionalsshortageDeLuca Leh Ross Yewcic areas.This bill allows thosevolunteerfolks to take care of theirDempsey Lescovitz Rubley YoungbloodDermody Levdansky Rufuing Yudichak cousins and their sisters-in-law and their brothers-in-law andDeWeese Lucyk Sainato Zimmerman their nephewsandniecesand everyoneelse, and it goesbeyondDiGirolamo Lynch Samuelson Zug what the intent of this Volunteer Health Services Act wasDonalucci Maher SantoniDruce Maitland Sather supposedto do, and as a result of that, I am going to be votingEachus Major Saylor Ryan, "no." Thankyou.Egoif Manderino Schroder Speaker The SPEAKER.Ms. Steelman.

Ms. STEELMAN. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.NAY S-U I am joining the gentlemanwho just spoke in opposingthe

bill, which is a little bit embarrassingbecause I originallyNOT VOTING-O signedon to it. but the more I look at this legislation, the more

Page 15: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

AdolphAllenArgallArmstrongBakerBardBarleyBamrarBastianBattistoBebko-JonesBe lardBeifantiBenninghoffBirmei inBishopBlaumBoyesBrowneBuntBuxtonCaltagironeCappabiancaCamCasonioCawIcyChadwickCivera

EvansFairchildFargoFeeseFichterFleagleFlickForcierFrankelFreemanGannonGeistGeorgeGiadeckGodshallGrucelaGnuilzaHabayHaluskaHannaF-IarhartHasayHennesscyHermanHcrshcyHessHorscyHutchinson

YEAS-I 92

MannMarkosekMarsicoMaslandMayemikMcCallMcGeehanMcGillMcllhattanMcllhinneyMcNaughtonMetcalfeMichlovicMicozzieMiller, R.Miller. S.MundyMyersNailorNickoiOliverPerzelPesciPctrarcaPetronePhillipsPippyPistclla

LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE

SchroderSc hu icrScrimentiSemmelSeyfertShanerSmith, B.Smith, S. H.SnyderSolobayStabackStairsSte iiStemStet IcrStevensonStrittmatterSturlaSurraTangrettiTaylor. E. LTaylor. J.ThomasTravagltoTrelloTrichTrueTulli

ClarkClymemCohen,L. I.ColafellaComeIIComriganCostaCoyCuriyDaileyDaleyDailyDeLucaDempseyDermodyDeWeeseDiGinolamoDonatucciDruceEachusEgolf

Cohen.M.Gordner

JadlowiecJamesJosephsKaiserKellerKenneyKirklandKrebsLa Gro ItaLaughlinLawlessLedererLehLescovitzLevdan skyLucykLynchMaherMaitlandMajorManderino

PlattsPrestonRamosRaymondReadshawReinardRiegerRobensRobinsonRoebuckRohrerRooneyRossRubleyRutTingSainatoSamuelsonSantoniSalherSay br

VanceVan HomeVeonVitaliWalkoWashingtonWatersWilliamsWillWoganWojnaroskiWrightYewcicYoungbloodYudichakZimmermanZug

Ryan.Speaker

2000 1047

I am concernedthat there is a potential for abuseherewhen wehave physiciansprescribingdrugs for membersof their ownfamilies that we shouldnot overlook. As the previousspeakerpointed out, this language,generousand thoughtful though itmay seem to be, actually violates the original intention of thevolunteerlicenses.Regretfully, we have to recognizethe factthat medicalprofessionalsthemselveshave higher ratesof drugaddictionand abusethan the generalpopulation. Looking at thepotential here for abusewithin the family, I do not think I cansupportthis bill.

The SPEAKER.Mrs. Vance.Mrs. VANCE. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.I believeperhapsa clarificationmay be in order.Severalyearsagowe passedthe volunteerhealthlicensebill

for retired health-care practitioners. Retired physicians havealways beenable to prescribefor their family. That has neverchanged.That has alwaysbeenthe practice. So someof themstarted to work in volunteer clinics with a volunteer license,giving of their time. The Departmentof State said, well, thelegislation that we had passedearlier did not specifically givethem the right to continue to do that. So we needto do this inorder for them to keep volunteering in clinics. We hadphysicians who were already volunteering in clinics whodecided,well, if I cannotcontinueto prescribefor my family, asI had for generations and generations,I am not going tovolunteermy time.

The bottom line, by voting "no" on this, is that you areimpactingpeople that are gettingmuch-neededservicein clinicsbecausetheseretired health-careprofessionalsare volunteeringtheir time, and I urge you to vote "yes" in order to facilitatetheseclinics. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.

On the questionrecurring,Shall thebill pass finally?The SPEAKER. Agreeable to the provisions of the

Constitution,the yeasandnayswill now be taken.

The following roll call was recorded:

NAY S-5

Meiio Steelman Tigue

NOT VOTING-f

EXCUSED-5

Harhai O’Brien OneButkovitzGigliotli

The majority required by the Constitution having voted inthe affirmative, the questionwas determinedin the affirmativeand the bill passedfinally.

Ordered,That the clerk presentthe same to the Senateforconcurrence.

The SPEAKER.Therewill be no furthervotes today.

AGRICULTURE AND RURAL AFFAIRSCOMMITTEE MEETING

The SPEAKER.There will be a meetingon the adjournmentmotion of the Agriculture Committee in the rear of the hall ofthe House.

Are thereany otherannouncements?

REPUBLICAN CAUCUS

The SPEAKER.Mr. Fargo.Mr. FARGO. Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.There will be a meetingin the caucusroom, a caucusof the

Republicanmembers.I think you will want to be there. It is anextremely important meeting, so please head for the caucusroom upon recess.Thankyou.

The SPEAKER. Republican members, please goimmediatelyto the caucusroom.

Page 16: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL · 5/10/2000  · Representatives and pastor of Camp Hill Presbyterian Church, Camp Hill. Pennsylvania, offered the following prayer:

The SPEAKER.Mr. Cohen.Mr. COHEN.Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.Mr. Speaker,therewill also be a Democraticcaucuson the

first of thebills that we know are going to comeup nextweek.The SPEAKER. Democratic memberswill report to their

caucusroom. Mr. Cohen.now?

EDUCATION COMMITTEE MEETING

The SPEAKER.Mr. Stairs.Mr. STAIRS.Thankyou, Mr. Speaker.At 1 o’clock. after caucusesand a short lunch break,I would

like to reconvene the Education Committee meeting that werecessedearlier in the moming. So that is at 1 o’clock,room 205, theRyan Office Building.

The SPEAKER.The Chair thanksthegentleman.

BILLS REMOVED FROM TABLE

The SPEAKER.The Chair recognizesthe majority leader.Mr. PERZEL. Mr. Speaker,I move that the following bills

be takenfrom the table:

HR 1333;HR 1334;HR 1853;andHR 2261.

On the question,Will the Houseagreeto the motion?Motion was agreedto.

BILLS TABLED

The SPEAKER.The Chair recognizesthe majority leader.Mr. PERZEL. Mr. Speaker,I move that the following bills

beplacedbackupon the table:BILLS AND RESOLUTIONS PASSED OVER

HB 1333HR 1334’ The SPEAKER.Without objection, all remainingbills and

HB 1853; and resolutionson today’scalendarwill be passedover. The Chair

HB 2261. hearsno objection.

On the question, ADJOURNMENTWill the Houseagreeto the motion?Motion was agreedto. The SPEAKER. Are thereany further announcements?Any

correctionsto the record?Any further businessfrom either ofthe leadershipdesks?

Hearing none, the Chair recognizes the gentleman fromWashingtonCounty,Mr. Solobay.

Mr. SOLOBAY. Mr. Speaker,I move that this House donow adjourn until Monday, May 15. 2000, at 1 p.m.. e.d.t..unlesssoonerrecalledby the Speaker.

On the question,Will theHouseagreeto the motion?Motion was agreedto, and at 12:08 p.m.. e.d.t., the House

1048 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-HOUSE

DEMOCRATIC CAUCUS

MAY 10

SRB 581, PN 3529Amended By Rep. ARGALL

An Act amendingthe act of May 24, 1945 P.L.991, No.385,known as the Urban RedevelopmentLaw, including boroughs in thedefinition of "city" for purposesof creation of a redevelopmentauthority.

URBAN AFFAIRS.

RB 2163,PN 2823 By.Rep.ARGALL

An Act amendingthe act of June 23, 1931 P.L.932, No.317,known as The Third ClassCity Code, further providing for vacanciesin council,office of mayor,controllerandtreasurer.

URBAN AFFAIRS.

HR 2436, PN 3280 By Rep. ARGALL

An Act amendingthe act of August 23, 1967 P.L.251, No.102,known as the Economic Development Financing Law, furtherproviding for membershipand compensationof the authority; andmakingeditorial changes.

URBAN AFFAIRS.

RB 2440, PN 3530 Amended By Rep.ARGALL

An Act amendingthe act of March 7, 1901 P.L.20, No.14,referredto as the SecondClassCity Law, prohibiting certain residencyrequirementsin constructioncontracts.

URBAN AFFAIRS.

HB 2441, PN 3531 Amended By Rep. ARGALL

An Act amending the act of July 28. 1953 P.L.723, No.230.known as the SecondClassCounty Code, prohibiting certain residencyrequirementsin constructioncontracts.

URBAN AFFAIRS.

BILLS REPORTED FROM COMMITTEES,CONSIDERED FIRST TIME, AND TABLED

lIE 549, PN 573 By Rep. STAIRS

An Act amending the act of March 10, 1949 P.L.30, No.14.knowii as the Public School Code of 1949, further providing forpurchaseof supplies.

EDUCATION.

adjourned.