community engagement for bike...

20
Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond Assistant Director Metro Nashville Department of Public Works Peter Bird Active Transportation Planner Metro Nashville Planning Department

Upload: others

Post on 03-Oct-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Community Engagement for Bike Projects

Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed

Jeff Hammond Assistant Director

Metro Nashville Department of Public Works

Peter Bird Active Transportation Planner

Metro Nashville Planning Department

Page 2: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

“Change happens when the pain of holding on becomes greater than the fear of letting go.”

- Spencer Johnson, Who Moved My Cheese?

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Change can be scary – this fear keeps us from doing it. For us, fear of project failure. Pain of holding on may or may not be great. For me, life without bike lanes doesn’t cause pain. So, I can get help, or…
Page 3: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

“The quicker you let go of old cheese, the sooner you find new cheese.”

- Spencer Johnson, Who Moved My Cheese?

Presenter
Presentation Notes
… I can think about it more like this. Can the street be better? Demand for change also seems to be cause of the day! Advocates/critics extremely vocal – expect to see some response from public sector.
Page 4: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Big Issues here in Nashville 1. New residents 2. More density 3. More congestion 4. More people walking and biking 5. More traffic deaths 6. Failed transit referendum 7. Affordability 8. Gentrification 9. Mixed land uses 10. Equity 11. Mobility opportunities 12. Business opportunities 13. Adopted WalknBike Master Plan

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Trying to address these with infrastructure (occasionally education, programming, etc.) – our only (inadequate) tool.
Page 5: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Big Issues here in Nashville 1. New residents 2. More density 3. More congestion 4. More people walking and biking 5. More traffic deaths 6. Failed transit referendum 7. Affordability 8. Gentrification 9. Mixed land uses 10. Equity 11. Mobility opportunities 12. Business opportunities 13. Adopted WalknBike Master Plan

CHANGE!

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Trying to address these with infrastructure (occasionally education, programming, etc.) – our only (inadequate) tool.
Page 6: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Introducing Change • Change is difficult, but necessary. • Allowing change to be framed in terms of loss, makes the

conversation much more difficult

2016 2018

51st Avenue North, Nashville, TN

Page 7: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Bike Projects are Change If you don’t control the narrative, someone else will.

• Talk to your audience,

not at them. If they care about traffic calming, show how your project helps calm traffic.

• Don’t make your project about just one thing—whether that’s bikes, transit, or anything else.

Page 8: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Cleveland Street

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Typical approach was restripe (w/ paving), get thru 2 weeks griping, move on. So, restriped, removed unwarranted stop sign, blew up. Met 3 times with invited group (generally opposed). Changed mind of 2/10. Held 2 more open house meetings (media, state reps, CM). Staff in middle of 2 charged opinions.
Page 9: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond
Page 10: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Master Plan Recommendation

Balanced Approach

Page 11: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

--But don’t just talk about bike lanes:

Show Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Design Options

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Issues: traffic growth, parking (didn’t want), gentrification (who asked for bike lanes?), CM against. Ideas: Talk about as improved street (not bike lanes), work for support of electeds beforehand. If can’t get, consider your commitment to work against will of elected.
Page 12: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond
Presenter
Presentation Notes
You have to talk to people, a lot, and from the beginning. You have to go to them where they are.
Page 13: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond
Page 14: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond
Page 15: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Lessons Learned from Cleveland Street

• Talk to people early and often • Talk to elected officials early on • Distrust is a hard thing to overcome • Conversations about change begin loaded • Frame your conversation

– It can’t just be about bikes, buses, or loss

• You need allies

Page 16: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

North Nashville

North Nashville

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Working with Simone
Page 17: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

North Nashville

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Working with Simone
Page 18: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Belmont Blvd

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Engagement during pilot
Page 19: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Harpeth Knoll

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Petition Process
Page 20: Community Engagement for Bike Projectstsite.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Presentation-1...Community Engagement for Bike Projects Profiling a Project that Didn’t Succeed Jeff Hammond

Peter Bird [email protected]

Jeff Hammond [email protected]

Ongoing Bikeway Projects in Nashville: mpw.nashville.gov/bikeways

!