company movement and assessment tool command brief v5
DESCRIPTION
Command Brief and Users Guide on the Company Movement and Assessment ToolTRANSCRIPT
Marine Corps Combat Development Command
Marine Corps Combat Development Command 3300 Russell Road Quantico, VA 22134-5130 3300 Russell Road Quantico, VA 22134-5130
Company Movement & Assessment Tool
(CMAT)
Command Brief
January 2012
Unclassified.
Unclassified.
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Contents
• Situation: Tactical C2
• Intent: Why CMAT?
• What is CMAT?
• Examples of CMAT analysis
• Support
• Counterargument
• Demonstration
• Backup Slides (CMAT Users Guide)
Operations Analysis Division 2
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Tactical C2
• (U) How will you train your COC to
do C2?
• (U) How will you task your patrols?
• (U) How will you collect information
in order to shape future ops?
• (U) How will you show your platoon
commanders that their efforts are
working/not working?
• (U) How will you illustrate the
changes in capabilities to your
partnered force?
• (U) How will you turn over your
battlespace?
Operations Analysis Division 3
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Intent – enable planning, reporting, assessment
• (U) Purpose: to provide Company Commanders a tool to
organize their patrolling effort against COIN objectives.
• (U) Method: an Excel Workbook on a COC workstation
where patrol information is stored for analysis.
• (U) End state: Commanders posses a standard,
supportable, sustainable, tool that organizes patrol-
generated information for decision-making.
Operations Analysis Division 4
“Subordinate commanders must make decisions on their own
initiative, based on their understanding of their senior’s intent,
rather than passing information up the chain of command and
waiting for the decision to be passed down.” MCDP 1, page 78
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Intent – enable planning, reporting, assessment
• (U) Purpose: to provide Company Commanders a
tool to organize their patrolling effort against COIN
objectives.
Operations Analysis Division 5
Why?
(U) Because otherwise they rely on initiative, what the last
unit did, or what they’re told to do – and this may fall short
of the answering the questions on the first slide.
(U) Because there are no C2 systems alternatives that
appropriately address this for the tactical environment
(U) Helping tactical commanders do objective assessments
is a responsibility of operations research analysts
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Intent – enable planning, reporting, assessment
• (U) Method: an Excel workbook on a COC workstation
where patrol information is stored for analysis
Operations Analysis Division 6
(U) Because it requires no software installation
(U) Compatible with web-enabled C2 systems
(U) Documents are small enough to travel through bandwidth
limited pipes
(U) Excel supports validated data input
(U) Easy to use charts and graphs for trend analysis
(U) Web systems (CPOF, Google Earth, C2PC) may not be practical
in the tactical environment
(U) Text, MS Word, PowerPoint are difficult to use for analysis
(U) Web systems (MarineLink, CPOF, Google Earth, C2PC) may not
be set up to database activity
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Intent – enable planning, reporting, assessment
• (U) End State: Commanders possess a standard,
supportable, sustainable tool that organizes
patrol-generated information for decision-making.
Operations Analysis Division 7
(U) Decision makers up and down the chain of command
have objective data that supports planning.
(U) Supports the relief in place
(U) Supports analysis and decision making throughout the
supporting establishment
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) What is CMAT?
• Company Movement and
Assessment Tool
– (U) Supports Company
Command and Control (C2)
– (U) Supports Company
Ops/Intel Cycle
– (U) Builds historic record of
activity for turnover
• (U) Microsoft Excel file
saved on workstation
• (U) Files can be uploaded
to CPOF, Google Earth, etc.
for further analysis
8
This is not an additive burden!
Tactical units will be searching for a
way to do this somehow regardless.
We owe them a tool. (“Do this instead
of that…and this is what you get!”)
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) CMAT in the Company COC
• (U) The Company COC uses CMAT to organize patrol
reports and information.
• (U) CMAT establishes an Excel Workbook digital log of
information typically written down in a green book or a
yellow canary.
• (U) Company COC opens CMAT and records patrol
information contained in Mission Cards and Debriefs.
• (U) Information radioed up from patrol bases (voice or
data) before and after missions.
• (U) Uses pre-formatted lists and dropdown menus to
standardize locations, call signs, tasks, ratings for
partnered forces, atmospherics, and user defined
CCIRs
9
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) CMAT List Management
• (U) The information in the lists can be managed through
the CMAT Settings section. Also, the points of contact
both CONUS and deployed can adjust these lists if big
changes are necessary.
– (U) For example, if you’re training at Fort A.P. Hill and your
CMAT version only has 29 Palms GRG checkpoints, entering in
hundreds of points manually would be difficult. Use the POCs.
10
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) What CMAT is NOT
• (U) CMAT is not a C2 system
• (U) CMAT is not an acquisition program or off-the-
shelf software
• (U) CMAT is not a contracted arrangement
• (U) CMAT is not web-enabled software
• (U) CMAT does not require software installation
• (U) Does not provide geospatial analysis (GIS)
– (U) Data is exported to GIS-enabled software
• (U) CMAT is not a substitute for good reporting and
COC procedures
• (U) CMAT does not add a reporting burden! Operations Analysis Division 11
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
AUP Patrol Partnering, Planning and Execution Ratings by PB
24 March to 1 June
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Ja Camp Ali Fatwan Gul UN
Overall Level of Partnering 24 March - 1 June
ANSF Only ISAF Only Joint
•82.8% of all patrols in the AO were partnered or AUP
only
•Fatwan Gul had the most AUP only patrols at 97
(29.9% of their total patrol activity)
•UN had the highest percentage of AUP only patrols
at 94 (40.9% of their total patrol activity)
•Fatwan Gul had the highest number of patrols rated
independent in planning at 51 (18.7%)
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
independent in planning at 24.3%
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
effective with assistance or effective with mentoring
in planning at 75.7%
•Fatwan Gul had the highest number of patrols rated
independent in execution at 51 (18.7%)
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
independent in execution at 24.3%
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
effective with assistance or effective with mentoring
in execution at 75.7%
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
24-Mar 31-Mar 7-Apr 14-Apr 21-Apr 28-Apr 5-May 12-May 19-May 26-May
Level of Partnering w/AUP by week 24 March - 1 June
ANSF Only ISAF Only Joint
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
24-Mar 31-Mar 7-Apr 14-Apr 21-Apr 28-Apr 5-May 12-May 19-May 26-May
AUP Patrol Planning Rating by Week 24 March - 1 June
Established Developing Effective w/Assistance Effective w/Advisors Independent
CMAT automatically
generates power point
presentation with graphs (by
location and over time) with a
word picture of summary
stats for the commander to
assess the unit’s progress
and provide insight (context)
to the trends identified by
CMAT
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
23 Mar 11 to 21 Apr 11
ANSF Only Patrols
22 Apr 11 to 23 May 11
ANSF Only Patrols
23 Mar 11 to 21 Apr 11
USMC Only Patrols
22 Apr 11 to 23 May 11
USMC Only Patrols
Example of CMAT output data displayed in IDAPT Density map Comparing 2 time periods on Range220 at 29 Palms
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) The Counterargument
• (U) “Great tool, but we don’t need another system
that doesn’t talk to the others.”
– (U) CMAT is not a system, but establishes a standard
way of collecting information. Electronic notebook.
– (U) Interfaces with Palantir and CPOF
• (U) “This is a reporting drag on companies.”
– (U) CMAT directly benefits the company by maintaining
patrol activity and debriefs in digital format.
– The tradeoff is the ability to quickly answer RFI’s
• (U) “This is too sophisticated.”
– (U) No web connection, FSR, software download, or
money.
Operations Analysis Division 14
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) Who we’ve talked to
• Operating Forces
• EWS
• MCTOG
• C2 ID
• CAOCL
• C2TECOE
• Combat Hunter
• Marine Corps Intel
Schools
• Marine Corps Systems
Command
• TTECG
• MCWL
• PP&O
• Military Operations
Research Society
• Center for Army Analysis
• JIEDDO
• MCTSSA
• Palantir
• CPOF Developers
• Microsoft Operations Analysis Division 15
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Testimonials
From RCT-1 AAR:
• (U//FOUO) “There needs to be a standardized system or system
of systems supporting command and control to ensure
commonality and understanding across the service. The
current systems are also far from being expeditionary. The
RCT staff participated in numerous exercises during PTP which
prepared them fundamentally to employ the systems but not for
the scope of the architecture with connections to over 100
locations."
• (U//FOUO) Units down to the platoon level operated
COCs, often with little to no training on how to
establish or run one. During training, Marines should
occupy a forward operating base (FOB) replicating
how they would live and function while they are in
country.”
Operations Analysis Division 16
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Testimonials
• 2/6’s AAR on EMV:
“Bottom line, use EMV as an opportunity to refine IM plan and validate, not a venue to
build an IM Plan from the ground up.”
• 1/8 Company Commander:
“Thank you for all of your help and effort. I know this will make us smarter on the
battlefield.”
• 1/8 CLIC/COC Marines:
“We see and understand the potential of this product. We envision the possibility of
making the CMAT program an SOP for all Marine Corps forward operating forces
(especially Infantry battalions). By marrying this analytical database with the
operations side of the house, we see endless possibilities…..
• Palantir FSR:
– “From the data you provided we ingested 4,677 patrols occurring between 01APR and
03DEC. 16,240 grid references were associated (mostly CPs, LPs, and SPs). I'm
excited to do some further analysis of this data based off of IED emplacement
times...knowing when the last friendlies traversed the site is the holy grail!”
Operations Analysis Division 17
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Testimonials
• From the CO C/1/9:
“You truly have been combat enablers to the
Marines of Chaos Company 1/9…the virtues of
(CMAT) compromise the core of (watch chief’s
turnover to the oncoming watch officers/chiefs.”
• From the Watch Chief of C/1/9:
“We used CMAT as our patrol tracker database.
This tool allowed us to input data for each patrol
to include the areas covered and any SIGACTS
that occurred in our battle space.”
Operations Analysis Division 18
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Marine Corps Tactical Systems Support Activity (MCTSSA) Engineering Evaluation (Dec 2011)
• “CMATs enforcement of standardized entry assures data is
stored cleanly and consistently, facilitating the employment of
the tools and techniques used in analysis of properly formatted
spreadsheet data. Further, CMAT incorporates some of the
most complex aspects of working with and manipulating MS
Excel workbooks and consolidates them into a UI that someone
with even the most basic computer skill level can operate
effectively. Widespread use of CMAT by units in theater would
enhance the collection, analysis, and turnover of critical patrol
information. As such, it is recommended that CMAT be made
available to units through some central means such that they
can easily obtain and implement CMAT into their standard
operating procedures for recording the conduct of patrols.”
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
What is Next?
• CMAT is hosted at http://www.mctssa.usmc.smil.mil/
• Plan to transition program to PG-11 at MarSysComm
and C2ID for incorporation into future systems
• Planning for data consolidation and information
management
• Research and analysis on existing data, for ongoing
work and future programs.
Operations Analysis Division 20
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED Operations Analysis Division 21
Primary Maj John Wray NIPR: [email protected] SIPR: [email protected]
VOSIP 308.357.7109
DSN 318.357.6980
Alternate Maj John Bancroft
NIPR: [email protected] SIPR: [email protected]
VOSIP 302.278.4115
Comm 703.432.8560 DSN 378.xxxx
Alternate Maj Dan Zappa
NIPR: [email protected] SIPR: [email protected]
VOSIP 302.278.4115
Comm 703.784.4115 DSN 278.xxxx
Alternate Mr. Doug Hoffman
NIPR: [email protected]
SIPR: [email protected]
VOSIP 302.378.8556
Comm 703.432.8181
For questions or comments on CMAT, use the following points of contact
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
BACKUPS
Operations Analysis Division 22
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Part 1: CMAT Settings.
Operations Analysis Division 23
• Geographic Reference Points
– Start locations: Patrol bases, FOBs, COPs
– Checkpoints: Compound & building names, LZs, etc.
• Customized metrics to meet the commander’s needs
• Call signs
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Gridded Reference Graphics and CMAT
Operations Analysis Division 24
• Gridded Reference
Graphics provide
sector identifiers as
well as compound
numbers with
associated 10 digit
MGRS
• This data will auto-
populate CMAT to
quickly and accurately
record which
checkpoints the patrol
visited
• Ex: Compound B in
sector K5 =
11S MS 12345 67890
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Adjust Start Location List
• 1. Select “Adjust Start Location”
• 2. Select “Add” or “Delete
Location”
• 3. Select Unit, Type Start
Location Name, Type in 10 digit
MGRS with grid zone Identifier
(ex. 11S MS)
• 4. Select Submit
Operations Analysis Division 25
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Adjust Checkpoint List
• 1. Select “Adjust Check point
List”
• 2. Select “Add” or “Delete Entry”
• 3. Select Unit (Battalion and
Company) , Type “Checkpoint
Name,” Type in 10 digit MGRS
with grid zone Identifier (ex. 11S
MS)
• 4. Select Submit
Operations Analysis Division 26
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Adjust Commander’s Information Requests
• 1. Select “Adjust Commander’s
Information Requests”
• 2. Select “Add” or “Delete Entry”
• 3. Enter the question you want
the patrols to answer
• 4. Select if the question will be
“Mandatory” or “Optional”
• 5. Select the Unit (Battalion and
Company) that the question will
be answered by
• 6. Select “Submit”
Operations Analysis Division 27
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Part 2: Data Entry and Changes
Operations Analysis Division 28
• Enter Patrol from Scratch
• Change Previously Submitted Patrol
• Enter Mission Card for Planned Patrol
• Enter patrol From Previously Filled in Mission Card
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Mission Cards and CMAT
• Company COC manages CMAT on desktop
• Prior to departing friendly lines, patrols complete Mission
Card
– Patrols cannot leave wire without providing mission card info to
Company COC
• Mission Card information is sent from Patrol Base to
Company COC
• Either by voice or data burst over the radio
• COC enters Mission Card data into CMAT (2 methods)
• Post mission, patrol sends additional debrief data to
COC.
• COC completes the appropriate data fields.
Operations Analysis Division 29
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Process of Data Input For CMAT: Mission Card vs Patrol from Scratch
• Two choices for patrol data input for CMAT:
– Mission Card for Planned Patrol
– Patrol from Scratch
• Mission Card method puts the patrol data in
“holding” until mission is complete
– Company COC reopens the mission card at
patrol’s completion and submits the mission
card after mission debrief data is sent
– Mission Card is then automatically discarded
and the patrol is added to the database
• Patrol from Scratch method allows user to enter
patrol data at beginning of patrol and then “Save
Incomplete Patrol Report” until mission debrief is
complete
– Mission will not be added to the database
until the mission is submitted as complete
Operations Analysis Division 30
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Enter Patrol from Scratch Initial Input
• Select “Enter Patrol From Scratch”
• 1. Select “Battalion, Company and
Call Sign”
• 2. Select type of patrol:
“Mounted/Dismounted/Combined”
• 3. Select “Patrol Activity” (Up to 3)
• 4. Select the “Number of
Personnel” from each category
• 5. Select if there were SigActs to
report (Yes or No).
• 6. Select “Time Out (Hour and
Minute)”
• 7. Select “Date Out”
• Select “Next,” “Save Incomplete
Report,” or “Cancel”
Operations Analysis Division 31
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Enter Patrol from Scratch (Ctn’d) SigAct Information
• If you select that you have a SigAct to
report (on the previous menu) then there
will be a SigAct Info Menu to fill out
• 1. Select Yes/No for “Was there a TIC?”
– A. If so “# of Direct Fire / # of IDF
Events
– B. Friendly Action in response to TIC
(did you withdraw, proceed without
responding or neutralize the threat)?
– C. Did you use Air Support?
• 2. # of IED Attacks
• 3. # of IED Finds
– A. IED Method of Detection (Up to 3)
• 4. # of Friendly KIA
• 5. # of Friendly WIA, and level of severity of
each injury
• 6. # of Enemy KIA
• 7. # of Enemy WIA
• 8. # of EPW
• 9. # of CIVCAS
Operations Analysis Division 32
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Enter Patrol from Scratch (Ctn’d) Conduct of the Patrol
• 1. Start Location and District
• 2. a. Points Patrolled (up to 12)
• 2b. Atmospherics observed at
those each checkpoint
• 3. Type in Op Name
• If Joint, select whether ANSF
element are on the ground,
with the patrol or in overwatch.
• Rating of ANSF for Planning
and Execution of the Patrol
• 4. Additional Comments
• 5. Return time (Hour and
Minute)
• 6. Select Return Date
• Select “Submit Completed
Report,” “Save Incomplete
Report,” or “Cancel”
Operations Analysis Division 33
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Enter Patrol from Scratch (Ctn’d) Patrol Summary
• Patrol Summary Verifies all
data you input and gives
quick stats on patrol:
Duration, distance covered
• This reporting format does
not remove the requirement
to report SigActs in CIDNE
or other required databases
• Patrol receives unique
identifier
• Select “Ok” or “Modify this
Patrol” to adjust the data
you input
• Can also “Show Details” if
the initial Patrol Summary
does not give you enough
info
Operations Analysis Division 34
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Mission Card for Planned Patrol Data Entry
• Similar format to “Enter
Patrol from Scratch”
– CMAT will save Mission
Card which can be open
after mission completion by
the “Enter patrol From
Previously Filled in Mission
Card” for editing and
submission
• After submitting the patrol
the Mission Card will no
longer be available for
editing
Operations Analysis Division 35
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Enter Patrol From Previously Filled in Mission Card
• Select “Enter patrol From
Previously Filled in Mission
Card’
• 1. Select “Start for the filter”
to find the Mission Card
• 2 . Select “End date for the
filter”
• Select “Next”
• 1. Select the record you wish
to modify from the dropdown
• Select “Modify Selected
Patrol”
• Edit Mission Card with Patrol
Debrief info Operations Analysis Division 36
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Change Previously Submitted Patrol
• If after submitting a patrol,
the COC realizes there is
an error with the data, the
COC can re-open the
patrol and update the data
• Select “Change Previously
Submitted Patrol”
• Select Date Range
• Select the record you wish
to modify from the
dropdown
• Edit patrol
Operations Analysis Division 37
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Part 3: Data Management and Analysis.
Operations Analysis Division 38
• Save CMAT: “Save As” for archive and management.
• Close CMAT (exit the document)
• Run Analysis
• Output Patrol Data to New Workbook
• Output Mission Card Data to New Workbook
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
• Run Analysis Button
• Charts and graphs
• Statistics on performance
– # of patrols during given time period
(broken down by unit, type, start point,
etc)
– # partnered versus unpartnered (%
breakdown of composition)
• Trend analysis
– Changes to the composition of patrols
(USMC, Partnered, HN)
– Changes to the capabilities of partnered
force particular to planning and execution
Operations Analysis Division 39
Part 3: Data Management and Analysis.
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Data to Assessment Products
• On demand, user pushes a button that
generates PowerPoint slide-show
– Displays charts and graphs
– Text boxes to record additional context
• Units can email CMAT Excel files to analysts as
needed for further study/analysis.
– Would be done according to SOP or when higher
units needed it.
– Company to battalion, battalion to RCT, etc.
Operations Analysis Division 40
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
AUP Patrol Partnering, Planning and Execution Ratings by PB
24 March to 1 June
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Ja Camp Ali Fatwan Gul UN
Overall Level of Partnering 24 March - 1 June
ANSF Only ISAF Only Joint
•82.8% of all patrols in the AO were partnered or AUP
only
•Fatwan Gul had the most AUP only patrols at 97
(29.9% of their total patrol activity)
•UN had the highest percentage of AUP only patrols
at 94 (40.9% of their total patrol activity)
•Fatwan Gul had the highest number of patrols rated
independent in planning at 51 (18.7%)
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
independent in planning at 24.3%
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
effective with assistance or effective with mentoring
in planning at 75.7%
•Fatwan Gul had the highest number of patrols rated
independent in execution at 51 (18.7%)
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
independent in execution at 24.3%
•UN had the highest percentage of patrols rated
effective with assistance or effective with mentoring
in execution at 75.7%
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
24-Mar 31-Mar 7-Apr 14-Apr 21-Apr 28-Apr 5-May 12-May 19-May 26-May
Level of Partnering w/AUP by week 24 March - 1 June
ANSF Only ISAF Only Joint
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
24-Mar 31-Mar 7-Apr 14-Apr 21-Apr 28-Apr 5-May 12-May 19-May 26-May
AUP Patrol Planning Rating by Week 24 March - 1 June
Established Developing Effective w/Assistance Effective w/Advisors Independent
CMAT automatically
generates power point
presentation with graphs (by
location and over time) with a
word picture of summary
stats for the commander to
assess the unit’s progress
and provide insight (context)
to the trends identified by
CMAT
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Saving, Closing, and Exporting CMAT Data
• Recommend Saving CMAT at least Daily
– Click “Save CMAT” and pick the
location for saving CMAT
• If you want to close CMAT, you will be
prompted for where to save CMAT to
• For external (Geo-Spatial in CPOF, Google
Earth, or IDAPT select “Out Completed
Patrol Data to New Workbook”
– Select how many weeks of CMAT data
you want to export
– Creates new workbook (flat Excel file)
for Analysis
– Automatically saves flat file to same
folder that CMAT is saved to
• Filename is the Date Time stamp
• Can also export the Mission Cards as a
flat Excel File
Operations Analysis Division 42
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
CMAT Excel Output
• Two Tabs in CMAT Excel
Output:
– Data
– IDAPT Feed
• Data Tab gives you a row
for each patrol for
summary stats analysis
(Pivot Tables)
• IDAPT Feed Tab gives you
a row for each patrol
check point reported in the
data tab
– Useful for importing to
CPOF, Google Earth or
IDAPT to display
Company’s Patrol
Footprint (Gaps/Seams)
Operations Analysis Division 43
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
23 Mar 11 to 21 Apr 11
ANSF Only Patrols
22 Apr 11 to 23 May 11
ANSF Only Patrols
23 Mar 11 to 21 Apr 11
USMC Only Patrols
22 Apr 11 to 23 May 11
USMC Only Patrols
Example of CMAT output data displayed in IDAPT Density map Comparing 2 time periods on Range220 at 29 Palms