compilation 3-3_privileged communications v. 1.pdf
TRANSCRIPT
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 1/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"
!"#$#%&'&( *+,,-.#*/0#+.1
,/"#0/% (#12-/%#3#*/0#+. "-%&
45 !&+!%& $5 */"%+1 6"%7
#$%$ &'$ ()**+,-. /01"21"+*3 . 456%7&89 :$
!89:9:;<8=>?@ ;<'=>< '? @A< ;AB>B==BC< DE>FCGE9 =>FBC@B??)F==<>><
"8?A;<B8<9>?@ HFIE@' J$ KFL>'E9 G<?<CGFC@)F==<>>FC@
1-,,/"C@
8L$ ;FM>' 5B@NFL '=<LF@<G 'C HFIE@' KFL>'EO PB?< ?'L F==<CGBQB@BE FCG '@A<L
@L<F@R<C@$ SBE PB?< Q'C@BCI'IE>N L<Q<BT<G @L<F@R<C@ @A<L<F?@<L F@ ABE Q>BCBQ BC
UEQ'>@F$ HFIE@' PFE @A<C Q'C?BC<G FCG L<Q<BT<G F ><@@<L ?L'R 8L$ 5B@NFL ?'L @A<
=FNR<C@ '? ABE =L'?<EEB'CF> E<LTBQ<E$ VA<C HFIE@' PFE L<><FE<G ?L'R @A<
A'E=B@F>9 A< E'IWA@ @' Q'C?L'C@ @A< 8L$ MI@ @' C' FTFB>$ UT<C@IF>>N9 A< PFE FM><
@' G' E'9 PABQA ><G @' @A< G<F@A '? @A< G'Q@'L$ ;L'E<QI@B'C EIMRB@E @AF@ HFIE@'
F@@FQX<G @A< 8L$ PB@A F XCB?< FCG E@FMM<G ABR 0 @BR<E MI@ HFIE@' FLWI<E @AF@ B@
PFE ?'L E<>?)G<?<CE<$ S< @A<C EILL<CG<L<G @' @A< Q'CE@FMI>FLN F@ YI>FQFC$ 6A<(K Q'CTBQ@<G ABR '? RILG<L9 PB@A =L<R<GB@F@B'C =L'T<G @AL'IWA F ><@@<L @A<
='>BQ< 'M@FBC<G BC ABE A'IE< PAB>< @A<N P<L< E<FLQABCW ?'L ABR$ K'ICE<> '?
G<?<CGFC@ FLWI<E @AF@ EIQA ><@@<L ?L'R @A< PB?< ?<FLBCW @AF@ HFIE@' P'I>G
L<EI>@ @' =ANEBQF> TB'><CQ< BE BCFGRBEEBM><9 FE B@ Q'CE@B@I@<E =LBTB><W<G
Q'RRICBQF@B'C$ 6A< 5K FWL<<G$ D@ A<>G @AF@ F =LBTB><W<G Q'RRICBQF@B'C ?L'R
'C< E='IE< @' @A< '@A<L Q'R<E BC@' @A< AFCGE '? F @ABLG =FL@N9 PB@A'I@
Q'>>IEB'C 'L T'>IC@FLN GBEQ>'EIL< 'C @A< =FL@ '? <B@A<L '? @A< E='IE<E9 @A<
=LBTB><W< BE @A<L<MN <Z@BCWIBEA<G FCG @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'C9 B? '@A<LPBE<
Q'R=<@<C@9 M<Q'R<E FGRBEEBM>< BC <TBG<CQ<$ HIL@A<L9 F ><@@<L PLB@@<C MN F PB?<
@' A<L AIEMFCG BE BCQ'R=<@<C@ FE <TBG<CQ< BC F QLBRBCF> QFE< FWFBCE@ @A< >F@@<L
PA<L< @A<L< BE C' BCGBQF@B'C '? FEE<C@ 'C ABE =FL@ @' @A< E@F@<R<C@E Q'C@FBC<G
BC @A< ><@@<L$ 6A< ><@@<L RFN9 A'P<T<L9 M< FGRBEEBM>< @' BR=<FQA @A< @<E@BR'CN
"# @A< PB?< B? EA< W'<E I='C @A< PB@C<EE)E@FCG BC @A< @LBF> '? @A< QFE<$ 6A<
><@@<L BE @A<L<?'L< C'@ABCW MI@ =IL< A<FLEFN FCG B@E FGRBEEB'C BC <TBG<CQ<
TB'>F@<E @A< Q'CE@B@I@B'CF> LBWA@ '? @A< G<?<CGFC@ BC F QLBRBCF> QFE< @' M<
Q'C?L'C@<G PB@A @A< PB@C<EE<E ?'L @A< =L'E<QI@B'C FCG AFT< @A< '=='L@ICB@N @'
QL'EE)<ZFRBC< @A<R$
3/*01
• 4C [FLQA 09 "+*,9 8L$ ;FM>' #$ 5B@NFL9 BC [FLN KAB><E S'E=B@F>9
=<L?'LR<G F EILWBQF> '=<LF@B'C I='C @A< HFIE@' KFL>'EO PB?< ?'LF==<CGBQB@BE FCG Q<L@FBC '@A<L FB>R<C@E$
• 5A< E@FN<G BC @A< A'E=B@F> IC@B> @A< "-@A '? @A< EFR< R'C@A9 MI@ F?@<L
A<L L<><FE<9 EA< PFE L<\IBL<G @' W' E<T<LF> @BR<E @' @A< Q>BCBQ '? 8L$
5B@NFL F@ &'$ ,/ UEQ'>@F9 ?'L @A< =IL='E< '? GL<EEBCW @A< P'ICGE ?L'R
@A< '=<LF@B'C$
• 4C 'C< TBEB@9 HFIE@' PFE E<C@ 'I@ MN 8L$ 5B@NFL @' MIN E'R< R<GBQBC<$
o VAB>< A< PFE 'I@9 8L$ 5B@NFL 'I@LFW<G @A< PB?<$ 6A< PB?< @'>G
ABR F>> FM'I@ @ABE F?@<L @A< TBEB@$
o
HFIE@' P<C@ @A<L< FWFBC ?'L F >ICW @L'IM>< Q'CEI>@F@B'C9 PFE=L<EQLBM<G @L<F@R<C@ FCG RFG< F@ ><FE@ 'C< R'L< TBEB@ F?@<L
@A< EFR<$
• 4C [FN "*9 "+*,9 HFIE@' <C@<L<G @A< ;AB>$ #<C<LF> S'E=B@F> F?@<L
EI??<LBCW ?L'R E'R< E@'RFQA @L'IM><$
• S< L<Q<BT<G F ><@@<L PAB>< A< PFE Q'C?BC<G FEXBCW ?'L @A< BRR<GBF@<
E<@@><R<C@ '? @A< FQQ'IC@ ?'L @A< =L'?<EEB'CF> E<LTBQ<E L<CG<L<G @' ABE
PB?<$
• 7?@<L M<BCW L<><FE<G ?L'R @A< A'E=B@F>9 A< P<C@ @' TBEB@ @A< 8L$ E<T<LF>
@BR<E MI@ @' C' FTFB>$
•
8ILBCW F TBEB@9 CILE< KFMFC<LF FEX<G HFIE@' B? A< AFG Q'R< @' E<@@>< ABEFQQ'IC@ @' PABQA @A< >F@@<L L<E='CG<G @AF@ A< GBG C'@ 'P< @A< G'Q@'L
FCN@ABCW$
• 4C [FN *]9 A< FWFBC P<C@ @' @A< '??BQ< FCG ?'ICG ABR F>'C<$
• 7QQ'LGBCW @' @A< =L'E<QI@B'COE <TBG<CQ<9 HFIE@' F@@FQX<G @A< 8L$ PB@A
F ?FC)XCB?< FCG E@FMM<G ABR @PBQ< PB@A'I@ FCN =L<>BRBCFLN \IFLL<>$
• 8L$ 5B@N' @LB<G @' <EQF=< MI@ HFIE@' =ILEI<G ABR FCG BC?>BQ@<G FC'@A<L
P'ICG ^@'@F> '? 0 P'ICGE_$ 6A< G'Q@'L GB<G PB@ABC RBCI@<E$
• HFIE@' <EQF=<G MI@ EILL<CG<L<G ABRE<>? @' @A< K'CE@FMI>FLN F@
[F>'>'E9 YI>FQFC @A< ?'>>'PBCW GFN$
•
HFIE@' FGRB@@<G @AF@ A< XB>><G @A< G'Q@'L GI< @' E<>?)G<?<CE<$o S< <Z=>FBC<G @AF@ A< P<C@ @A<L< @' =L'@<E@ FWFBCE@ @A< ?<<
QAFLW<G FCG FEX ?'L FC <Z@<CEB'C '? @BR< @' =FN$
o 6A< G'Q@'L F>><W<G>N BCEI>@<G ABR BC F Q'C@<R=@I'IE RFCC<L
MN @<>>BCW ABR @AF@ A< Q'I>G E<CG ABE PB?< @' @F>X @A< RF@@<L
'T<L FE @A< >F@@<L PFE @A< 'C< @L<F@<G$
o HFIE@' @''X '??<CE< PB@A EIQA BCE'><C@ @L<F@R<C@ E' A<
QAF>><CW<G @A< G'Q@'L$
o 6A< G'Q@'L @''X F ='QX<@)XCB?< ?L'R @A< Q<C@<L GLFP<L FCG
F@@FQX<G ABR$
o VA<C A< EIQQ<<G<G BC @FXBCW @A< XCB?< ?L'R @A< G'Q@'L9 F?@<L
IEBCW ABE ?<CQBCW EXB>>E ^><WB@ `@' FA_9 A< E@FMM<G @A< G'Q@'L BC
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 2/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*
@A< LBWA@ EBG< '? @A< ML<FE@ FCG BC @A< <=BWFE@LBQ L<WB'C FCG
>F@<L 'C ABE MFQX$
• 6A< @<E@BR'CN '? HFIE@' FCG @A< <TBG<CQ< '? @A< =L'E<QI@B'C FL<
Q'C?>BQ@BCW$
• 7EEIRBCW HFIE@'OE BE @LI<9 B@ ?FB><G @' <E@FM>BEA E<>?)G<?<CE<$
• ('P<L Q'IL@ ! ?'ICG ABR WIB>@N '? RILG<L$ ;L<R<GB@F@B'C PFE EA'PC
@AL'IWA F ><@@<L ^UZABMB@ (_9 PABQA BE F ><@@<L PLB@@<C @' HFIE@' MN ABE
PB?< FCG E<Ba<G MN @A< ='>BQ<$o D@ PFE GF@<G @P' GFNE M<?'L< @A< RILG<L FCG EA'PE @AF@ @A<
PLB@<L ?<FL<G @AF@ HFIE@' Q'C@<R=>F@<G L<E'L@BCW @' =ANEBQBF>
TB'><CQ< BC G<F>BCW PB@A @A< G<Q<FE<G$
• K'ICE<> ?'L @A< G<?<CGFC@ FLWI<E @AF@ @A< ><@@<L PFE F =LBTB><W<G
Q'RRICBQF@B'C FCG @A<L<?'L< C'@ FGRBEEBM>< BC <TBG<CQ<$
o 6A< CIR<LBQF> P<BWA@ '? FI@A'LB@N BE9 A'P<T<L9 @' @A< <??<Q@
@AF@ PA<L< F =LBTB><W<G Q'RRICBQF@B'C ?L'R 'C< E='IE< @'
FC'@A<L Q'R<E BC@' @A< AFCGE '? F @ABLG =FL@N9 PA<@A<L ><WF>>N
'L C'@9 PB@A'I@ Q'>>IEB'C FCG T'>IC@FLN GBEQ>'EIL< 'C @A< =FL@
'? <B@A<L '? @A< E='IE<E9 @A< =LBTB><W< BE @A<L<MN <Z@BCWIBEA<GFCG @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'C9 B? '@A<LPBE< Q'R=<@<C@9 M<Q'R<E
FGRBEEBM><$
#11-&@ V1& @A< ><@@<L RFG< MN @A< PB?< BE FGRBEEBM>< FE <TBG<CQ< FWFBCE@ @A<
AIEMFCGb &4$
D&%(@
• [<LB@'LB'IE$
• 6A< E<C@<CQ< F==<F><G ?L'R BE @A<L<?'L< R'GB?B<G MN L<GIQBCW @A<
=<CF>@N @' ?'IL@<<C N<FLE9 <BWA@ R'C@AE FCG 'C< GFN '? $%&'()*"+
,%-."$/' 9 PB@A @A< Q'LL<E='CGBCW FQQ<EE'LN =<CF>@B<E FCG PB@A @A<
Q'E@E FWFBCE@ @A< F==<>>FC@$ 5' 'LG<L<G$
"/0#+
• ;L'?<EE'L VBWR'L< E@F@<E @A< LI>< FE ?'>>'PEc
o H'L G'QIR<C@E '? Q'RRICBQF@B'C E;F:<G :<9; 9H8 A;??8??:;<
;I J 9H:=B A8=?;<9 F B:?9:<E9:;< ?H;KLB ;M9J:<9 FCF>'W'IE @'
@AF@ F>L<FGN BCGBQF@<G ?'L F Q>B<C@OE Q'RRICBQF@B'CE$
" #I 9H8N O8=8 ;M9J:<8B I=;F 9H8 JBB=8??88 MN
P;LK<9J=N B8L:P8=NQ 9H8N ?H;KLB ?9:LL M8 A=:P:L8G8B ^?'L
'@A<LPBE< @A< =LBTB><W< Q'I>G MN Q'>>IEB'C M<=LFQ@BQF>>N CI>>B?B<G ?'L PLB@@<C Q'RRICBQF@B'CE_d
" #I 9H8N O8=8 ;M9J:<8B ?K==8A9:9:;K?LN ;= ;9H8=O:?8
O:9H;K9 9H8 JBB=8??88R? E;<?8<9Q 9H8 A=:P:L8G8 ?H;KLB
E8J?85
"$ 6A< L8998= :< SK8?9:;< OJ? ;M9J:<8B 9H=;KGH J ?8J=EH I;= OH:EH <;
OJ==J<9 JAA8J=? 9; HJP8 M88< :??K8B5
• KB@BCW 0"12 /+2 0"12 3)4 5+*,%2 6,/,%) /+2 6*'3%$,7"$+% 8(-9%$ :"4
/+2 6*'3%$,7"$+% 3)4 5+*,%2 6,/,%)9 Q'ICE<> ?'L G<?<CGFC@ FLWI<E @AF@@AF@ B;EKF8<9? ;M9J:<8B MN :LL8GJL ?8J=EH8? ;I 9H8 B8I8<BJ<9R?
8II8E9? J=8 <;9 JBF:??:ML8 :< 8P:B8<E8 :< J E=:F:<JL EJ?85
• ;L'?<EE'L VBWR'L<c
o 6A< G'Q@LBC< @AF@ @A< FGRBEEBMB>B@N '? <TBG<CQ< BE C'@ F??<Q@<G
MN @A< B>><WF>B@N '? @A< R<FCE @AL'IWA PABQA @A< =FL@N AFE
M<<C <CFM><G @' 'M@FBC @A< <TBG<CQ< PFE C<T<L G'IM@<G IC@B>
@A< F==<FLFCQ< '? @A< B>>)E@FLL<G RFe'LB@N '=BCB'C '? Y'NG TE$
f5$
" Y'NG L<RFBC<G IC\I<E@B'C<G ?'L */ N<FLE MI@
L<Q<BT<G ?L<\I<C@ GBE?FT'L BC E@F@< Q'IL@E$" ;2/-) 3)4 <%= >"$? ^"+/,_ TBL@IF>>N L<=IGBF@<G BC @A<
H<G<LF> 5K9 FCG @A< 'L@A'G'Z =L<Q<G<C@E L<Q'LG<G BC
@A< 5@F@< Q'IL@E P<L< <Z=L<EE>N F==L'T<G$
" 7?@<L FC'@A<L */ N<FLE9 @A< H<G<LF> 5K9 BC @%%?) 3)4 569
L<T<L@<G @' @A< 'LBWBCF> G'Q@LBC< '? @A< Y'NG KFE<9 MI@
PB@A F Q'CGB@B'C @AF@ @A< :LL8GJL:9N ;I 9H8 ?8J=EH J<B
?8:TK=8 ?H;KLB I:=?9 HJP8 M88< B:=8E9LN L:9:GJ98B J<B
8?9JML:?H8B MN J F;9:;<9 RFG< M<?'L< @LBF>9 ?'L @A<
L<@ILC '? @A< @ABCWE E<Ba<Gd E' @AF@9 JI98= ?KEH J
F;9:;<Q J<B 9H8< ;<LNQ 9H8 :LL8GJL:9N O;KLB M8 <;9:E8B
:< 9H8 FJ:< 9=:JL J<B 9H8 8P:B8<E8 9HK? ;M9J:<8BO;KLB M8 8UELKB8B5
o DC @A< 6*'3%$,7"$+% 8(-9%$ :"4 &/)%A @A< f5 5K FGA<L<G @' B@E
G<QBEB'C BC @A< V<<XE KFE<$
o 6A< G'Q@LBC< >FBG G'PC BC @A<E< QFE<E AFE M<<C ?'>>'P<G MN
E'R< '? @A< 5@F@< Q'IL@E MI@ AFE M<<C E<T<L<>N QLB@BQBa<G FCG
G'<E C'@ F==<FL @' AFT< M<<C W<C<LF>>N FQQ<=@<G$
• YI@ FEEIRBCW @AF@ B@ =L<TFB>E BC @ABE eILBEGBQ@B'C B@ BE9 C<T<L@A<><EE9
ICG<L @A< G<QBEB'CE BC @A< V<<XE FCG 5B>T<L@A'LC< QFE<E9 BCF==>BQFM><
@' @A< =L<E<C@ QFE<$
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 3/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0
• D8=8 9H8 :LL8GJL:9N ;I 9H8 ?8J=EH J<B ?8:TK=8 OJ? <;9 VB:=8E9LN L:9:GJ98B
J<B 8?9JML:?H8B MN J F;9:;<Q FJB8 M8I;=8 9=:JLQ I;= 9H8 =89K=< ;I 9H8
9H:<G? ?8:T8B5W
X5 0H8 L8998= &UH:M:9 % FK?9 M8 8UELKB8B I;= =8J?;<? <;9 B:?EK??8B :< 9H8
M=:8I?5
• 0H8 L8998= OJ? O=:998< MN 9H8 O:I8 J<B :I ?H8 HJB 98?9:I:8B J9 9H8 9=:JL
9H8 L8998= F:GH9 HJP8 M88< JBF:??:ML8 9; :FA8JEH H8= 98?9:F;<NQ MK9?H8 OJ? <;9 AK9 ;< 9H8 O:9<8??Y?9J<B J<B 9H8 L8998= OJ? <;9 ;II8=8B
I;= 9HJ9 AK=A;?85
• #I 9H8 B8I8<BJ<9 8:9H8= MN J<?O8= ;= ;9H8=O:?8 HJB :<B:EJ98B H:?
J??8<9 9; 9H8 ?9J98F8<9? E;<9J:<8B :< 9H8 L8998= :9 F:GH9 JL?; HJP8
M88< JBF:??:ML85
• 6A< ?FQ@ @AF@ A< AFG @A< ><@@<L BC ABE ='EE<EEB'C BE C' BCGBQF@B'C '?
FQ\IB<EQ<CQ< 'L FEE<C@ 'C ABE =FL@$
• 0H8 L8998= :? 9H8=8I;=8 <;9H:<G MK9 AK=8 H8J=?JN J<B :9? JBF:??:;< :<
8P:B8<E8 P:;LJ98? 9H8 E;<?9:9K9:;<JL =:GH9 ;I 9H8 B8I8<BJ<9 9; M8
E;<I=;<98B O:9H 9H8 O:9<8??8? I;= 9H8 A=;?8EK9:;< J<B HJP8 9H8;AA;=9K<:9N 9; E=;??Y8UJF:<8 9H8F5
• DC @ABE L<E=<Q@ @A<L< QFC M< C' GB??<L<CQ< M<@P<<C FC 'LGBCFLN
Q'RRICBQF@B'C FCG 'C< 'LBWBCF>>N =LBTB><W<G$
0$ 6A< \I<E@B'C BE LFGBQF>>N GB??<L<C@ ?L'R @AF@ '? @A< FGRBEEBMB>B@N '?
@<E@BR'CN '? F @ABLG =FL@N FE @' F Q'CT<LEF@B'C M<@P<<C F AIEMFCG FCG
PB?< 'T<LA<FLG MN @A< PB@C<EE$
• 6<E@BR'CN '? @AF@ QAFLFQ@<L BE FGRBEEBM>< 'C @A< WL'ICG @AF@ B@ L<>F@<E
@' F Q'CT<LEF@B'C BC PABQA M'@A E='IE<E @''X =FL@ FCG 'C @A< ?IL@A<L
WL'ICG @AF@ PA<L< @A< G<?<CGFC@ AFE @A< '=='L@ICB@N @' FCEP<L F
E@F@<R<C@ RFG< @' ABR MN ABE E='IE< FCG ?FB>E @' G' E'9 ABE EB><CQ<
BR=>B<E FEE<C@$
• 6AF@ EJ<<;9 JAALN OH8=8 9H8 ?9J98F8<9 :? E;<9J:<8B :< J<
K<J<?O8=8B L8998=$
• 6A< 7@@'LC<N)#<C<LF> BC EI=='L@ '? @A< Q'C@LFLN TB<P \I'@<E VBWR'L<9
FE ?'>>'PEc
o K'RRICBQF@B'C @' F AIEMFCG 'L PB?< BE F>PFNE L<Q<BTFM>< @'
EA'P =L'MFM>< XC'P><GW< MN @A< '@A<L ^<ZQ<=@ PA<L< @A<N FL<
>BTBCW F=FL@ 'L FL< C'@ BC W''G @<LRE_9 M<QFIE< @A<L< BE F>PFNE
E'R< =L'MFMB>B@N @AF@ 'C< PB>> @<>> @A< '@A<L9PABQA BE F>> @AF@
QFC M< ?FBL>N FEX<G ?'L FGRBEEBMB>B@N$
o 6ABE RFN ='EEBM>N M< W''G >FP9 @A'IWA VBWR'L< QB@<E C'
FI@A'LB@N BC EI=='L@ '? ABE FEE<L@B'C9 MI@ FE ?FL FE P< QFC E<< B@
AFE >B@@>< 'L C'@ABCW @' G' PB@A @A< =L<E<C@ QFE<$
• /? O8 HJP8 JL=8JBN :<9:FJ98BQ :I &UH:M:9 % :? 8UELKB8BQ 9H8=8 :? :< ;K=
;A:<:;< <;9 ?KII:E:8<9 8P:B8<E8 :< 9H8 =8E;=B 9; ?H;O 9HJ9 9H8 E=:F8
OJ? A=8F8B:9J98B$
• 6A< =L'E<QI@B'C RFBC@FBCE @AF@ @A< QLBR< PFE Q'RRB@@<G PB@A F><T'EBF$
o
6ABE Q'C@<C@B'C BE MFE<G =LBCQB=F>>N 'C @A< ?FQ@ @AF@ 'C< '? @A<P'ICGE L<Q<BT<G MN @A< G<Q<FE<G EA'P<G F G'PCPFLG
GBL<Q@B'C BCGBQF@BCW @AF@ @A< G<Q<FE<G PFE EB@@BCW G'PC PA<C
@A< P'ICG PFE BC?>BQ@<G$
o V< G' C'@ @ABCX @ABE ?FQ@ BE EI??BQB<C@ =L''?$ 6A< GBL<Q@B'C '?
@A< P'ICG P'I>G G<=<CG >FLW<>N I='C @A< RFCC<L BC PABQA
@A< XCB?< PFE A<>G$
• H'L @A< L<FE'CE E@F@<G P< ?BCG @A< B8I8<BJ<9 GK:L9N ;I ?:FAL8
H;F:E:B8Q O:9H;K9 JGG=JPJ9:<G ;= 8U98<KJ9:<G E:=EKF?9J<E8?5
JD((7[4%9 :$9 GBEE<C@BCWc• 6A< eIGW< PA' @LB<G @ABE QFE<9 BCE<L@E BC ABE G<QBEB'C @A< @<E@BR'CN '?
@A< PB@C<EE (IQB' :FTB>>'CFL9 PA' @<E@B?B<G ^FR'CW '@A<LE_ @AF@ A< P<C@
@' 8L$ 5B@NFLOE '??BQ< E' @A<N Q'I>G W' A'R< @'W<@A<L9 MI@ @A< >F@@<L PFE
E@B>> MIEN$
• S< A<FLG C' <ZQAFCW< '? AFLG P'LGE '? FCN XBCG FCG >F@<L 'C
PB@C<EE<G @A< G<Q<FE<G LIEABCW M>''GB<G$ S< F>E' PB@C<EE<G @A<
FQQIE<G E@FMMBCW @A< G'Q@'L$
• DC G<QBGBCW @A< \I<E@B'C FE @' PA<@A<L @A< FQ@ Q'RRB@@<G BE RILG<L9
PB@A @A< \IF>B?NBCW QBLQIRE@FCQ< '? @L<FQA<LN9 FE Q>FBR<G MN @A<
7@@'LC<N)#<C<LF>9 @A< @LBF> eIGW< EFNE @AF@ @A< =LBCQB=F> WL'ICG '? @A<
=L'E<QI@B'C ?'L A'>GBCW @AF@ @A< Q'RRBEEB'C '? @A< QLBR< PFE
F@@<CG<G MN @A< \IF>B?NBCW QBLQIRE@FCQ< '? @L<FQA<LN BE F R<L<
BC?<L<CQ< ?L'R @A< @<E@BR'CN '? (IQB' :FTB>>'CFL9 FCG @AF@ @A< CF@IL< '?
@A< P'ICGE ?'ICG 'C @A< <=BWFE@LBQ L<WB'C '? @A< G<Q<FE<G FCG ABE
MFQX G' C'@ R<FC FCN@ABCW9 M<QFIE< @A<N Q'I>G AFT< M<<C BC?>BQ@<G
PAB>< @A< G<Q<FE<G PFE E@FCGBCW9 E<F@<G 'L BCQ>BC<G$
• 7 QFL<?I> Q'CEBG<LF@B'C '? @A< @<E@BR'CN '? (IQB' :FTB>>'CFL PB>> EA'P
@AF@@A< G<Q<FE<G PFE PB@A ABE FLRE >'P<L<G FCG FM'I@ @' ?F>> @' @A<
?>''L PA<C @A< FQQIE<G E@FMM<G ABR 'C @A< LBWA@ EBG< '? @A< QA<E@ PB@A
@A< P<F='C A< PFE QFLLNBCW9 @A<L<MN BC?>BQ@BCW F P'ICG 'C @A< LBWA@
CB==><9 FCG @AF@9 FQQ'LGBCW @' @A< G'Q@'L PA' <ZFRBC<G @A< P'ICGE9FCN'C< '? @A<R Q'I>G AFT< QFIE<G @A< G<F@A '? @A< G<Q<FE<G$
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 4/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
,
• 6A<E< M<BCW @A< ?FQ@E =L'T<C9 D FR '? '=BCB'C @AF@ F==>BQF@B'C RIE@ M<
RFG< A<L< '? @A< G'Q@LBC< >FBG G'PC MN @ABE Q'IL@ BC @A< QFE< '? fCB@<G
5@F@<E TE$ YF>IN'@ PA<L<BC B@ PFE A<>G @AF@ gUT<C @A'IWA F G<FG>N
F@@FQX RFN M< M<WIC ICG<L Q'CGB@B'CE C'@ <ZABMB@BCW @A< ?<F@IL< '?
F><T'EBF9 N<@ B? @A< FEEFI>@ BE Q'C@BCI<G FCG @A< QLBR< Q'CEIRRF@<G
PB@A F><T'EBF9 EIQA QBLQIRE@FCQ< RFN M< @FX<C BC@' Q'CEBG<LF@B'C FE F
\IF>B?NBCW ?FQ@'L BC @A< '??<CE< '? RILG<L$h
•
D@ ='EB@BT<>N F==<FLE ?L'R @A< @<E@BR'CN '? (IQB' :FTB>>'CFL @AF@ @A<G<Q<FE<G PFE F>L<FGN P'ICG<G FCG FM'I@ @' ?F>> @' @A< ?>''L9 A<
E@LIQX ABR PB@A FC'@A<L R'L@F> M>'P PB@A @A< P<F='C A< PFE QFLLNBCW9
PABQA EA'PE @AF@ @A< FQQIE<G Q'CEIRRF@<G @A< QLBR< PB@A @L<FQA<LN$
H'L @A< ?'L<W'BCW9 D FR '? '=BCB'C @AF@ @A< eIGWR<C@ F==<F><G ?L'R RIE@ M<
F??BLR<G9 Q'CEBG<LBCW @A< FQ@ Q'RRB@@<G FE RILG<L9 PB@A @A< \IF>B?NBCW
QBLQIRE@FCQ< '? @L<FQA<LN9 FCG BC @ABE E<CE< D GBEE<C@ ?L'R @A< RFe'LB@N '=BCB'C
/00+".&CY*%#&.0 !"#$#%&'&
45 -C *D#*+ $15 -.#+. %#3& 6*!7
'5"5 .;5 %YZX[4 \ ]J<KJ=N ^Q 4Z4_1-,,/"C@ fN KABQ' E<<XE @' L<Q'T<L @A< TF>I< '? @P' BCEILFCQ< ='>BQB<E I='C
F E@'QX '? GLN W''GE G<E@L'N<G MN ?BL<$ VB@A fN KABQ'iE Q'CE<C@9 @A< F@@'LC<N
EILL<CG<L<G @A< ='>BQB<E '? BCEILFCQ< @' @A< FGRBCBE@LF@'L '? @A< <E@F@<9 PA'
Q'R=L'RBE<G PB@A @A< BCEILFCQ< Q'R=FCN ?'L 'C<)AF>? @A<BL ?FQ< TF>I<9 'L
;]9///$ 5IME<\I<C@>N9 PFBT<L ^Q'CE<C@_ PFE PB@AGLFPC$ DEEI< BE PA<@A<L @A<
Q'R=L'RBE< '? @A< BCEILFCQ< ='>BQB<E PFE TF>BG FCG PA<@A<L @A< FQ@ MN @A<
Q'ICE<> Q'I>G M< Q'CEBG<L<G FE =LBTB><W<G BC?'LRF@B'C$ &4j 6A< Q'R=L'RBE<
^FQ@ MN Q'ICE<> PB@A @ABLG =<LE'C_ PFE PB@A XC'P><GW< FCG F==L'TF> '? fN
KABQ'$
3/*01
• 6A< ?F@A<L '? fN KABQ' GB<G BC "-+29 F@ PABQA @BR< A< PFE Q'CGIQ@BCW F
MIEBC<EE ICG<L ABE 'PC CFR<9 fN (FNQ'$
• fN KABQ' FCG ABE ML'@A<L @''X 'T<L @A< MIEBC<EE FCG Q'C@BCI<G B@
ICG<L @A< EFR< CFR<9 kfN (FNQ'$k
• DC @ABE QFE<9 fN KABQ' E<<XE @' L<Q'T<L @A< ?FQ< TF>I< '? @P' BCEILFCQ<
='>BQB<E I='C F E@'QX '? GLN W''GE G<E@L'N<G MN ?BL<$
• 5'R<@BR< M<?'L< @A< GF@< '? @A< ?BL<9 fN KABQ' =ILQAFE<G ABE ML'@A<LOE
BC@<L<E@ BC @A< MIEBC<EE FCG Q'C@BCI<G @' QFLLN 'C @A< MIEBC<EE ICG<L
@A< ?F@A<LOE CFR<$
• 7@ @A< @BR< '? @A< ?BL< kfN (FNQ'k PFE A<FTB>N BCG<M@<G FCG
EIME<\I<C@ @A<L<@' @A< QL<GB@'LE =<@B@B'C<G ?'L @A< F=='BC@R<C@ '? FC
FGRBCBE@LF@'L '? @A< <E@F@< '? @A< fN KABQ'iE ?F@A<L$
• 8ILBCW @A< Q'ILE< '? @A<E< =L'Q<<GBCWE9 fN KABQ'iE F@@'LC<N
EILL<CG<L<G @A< ='>BQB<E '? BCEILFCQ< @' @A< FGRBCBE@LF@'L '? @A<
<E@F@<9 PA' Q'R=L'RBE<G PB@A @A< BCEILFCQ< Q'R=FCN ?'L 'C<)AF>?
@A<BL ?FQ< TF>I<9 'L ;]9///$ 6ABE R'C<N PFE =FBG BC@' Q'IL@ FCG BE C'P
M<BCW A<>G MN @A< EA<LB??$• fN KABQ' C'P MLBCWE @ABE FQ@B'C9 RFBC@FBCBCW @AF@ @A< ='>BQB<E FCG
W''GE BCEIL<G M<>'CW @' ABR FCG C'@ @' @A< <E@F@< '? ABE G<Q<FE<G
?F@A<L FCG F>><W<E @AF@ A< BE C'@ M'ICG MN @A< Q'R=L'RBE< <??<Q@<G MN
@A< FGRBCBE@LF@'L '? ABE ?F@A<LOE <E@F@<$
• fCB'C (B?< 7EEILFCQ< E'IWA@ @' EA'P @AF@ @A< =>FBC@B?? AFG FWL<<G @'
Q'R=L'RBE< E<@@><R<C@ '? @A< ='>BQB<E9 FCG ?'L @AF@ =IL='E<
BC@L'GIQ<G <TBG<CQ< EA'PBCW @AF@ fN KABQ'iE F@@'LC<N AFG
EILL<CG<L<G @A< ='>BQB<E @' @A< FGRBCBE@LF@'L PB@A @A< ICG<LE@FCGBCW
@AF@ EIQA F Q'R=L'RBE< PFE @' M< <??<Q@<G$
•
VAB>< 'C @A< PB@C<EE E@FCG9 -N *H:E; OJ? J?`8B :I H8 HJB J<N;Ma8E9:;< 9; H:? J99;=<8Nb? 98?9:IN:<G E;<E8=<:<G 9H8 ?K==8<B8= ;I 9H8
A;L:E:8?Q 9; OH:EH H8 =8AL:8B :< 9H8 <8GJ9:P8$ 6A< F@@'LC<N PFE @A<C
QF>><G ?'L @AF@ =IL='E<$
• 6A< Q'ICE<> ?'L fN KABQ' ?'LRF>>N PB@AGL<P @A< PFBT<L =L<TB'IE>N
WBT<C MN @A< =>FBC@B?? FCG ;Ma8E98B 9; 9H8 98?9:F;<N ;I 9H8 J99;=<8N
;< 9H8 G=;K<B 9HJ9 :9 OJ? A=:P:L8G8B$ K'ICE<>9 'C @ABE F==<F>9 MFE<
@A<BL FLWIR<C@ '? @A< =L'='EB@B'C @AF@ F PFBT<L '? @A< Q>B<C@iE =LBTB><W<
RFN M< PB@AGLFPC F@ FCN @BR< M<?'L< FQ@<G I='C$
#11-&@ VSU6SU% 6SU 6U56D[4&l Yl K4f&5U( D5 K4&5D8U%U8 7 ;%DJD(U#U8
K4[[f&DK76D4& ) &4
"-%#.'
• 4IL =LFQ@BQ< 7Q@ =L'TBG<Ec k7 >FPN<L RIE@ E@LBQ@>N RFBC@FBC BCTB'>F@<
@A< Q'C?BG<CQ< FCG =L<E<LT< @A< E<QL<@E '? ABE Q>B<C@$ S< EAF>> C'@ M<
=<LRB@@<G BC FCN Q'IL@9 PB@A'I@ @A< Q'CE<C@ '? ABE Q>B<C@9 WBT<C BC '=<C
Q'IL@9 @' @<E@B?N @' FCN ?FQ@E BR=FL@<G @' ABR MN ABE Q>B<C@ BC
=L'?<EEB'CF> Q'CEI>@F@B'C9 'L ?'L @A< =IL='E< '? 'M@FBCBCW FGTBQ< I='C
><WF> RF@@<LE$k ^5<Q$ 0"9 7Q@ &'$ "+/$_
• D@ PB>> M< C'@<G @AF@ @A< <TBG<CQ< BC \I<E@B'C Q'CQ<LC<G @A< G<F>BCWE
'? @A< =>FBC@B??iE F@@'LC<N PB@A F @ABLG =<LE'C$ 4? @A< T<LN <EE<CQ< '?
@A< T<B> '? E<QL<QN PABQA EILL'ICGE Q'RRICBQF@B'CE RFG< M<@P<<C
F@@'LC<N FCG Q>B<C@9 BE @AF@ EIQA Q'RRICBQF@B'CE FL< C'@ BC@<CG<G ?'L@A< BC?'LRF@B'C '? @ABLG =<LE'CE 'L @' M< FQ@<G I='C MN @A<R9 =I@ '?
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 5/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
3
@A< =IL='E< '? FGTBEBCW @A< Q>B<C@ FE @' ABE LBWA@E$ D@ BE <TBG<C@ @AF@ F
Q'RRICBQF@B'C RFG< MN F Q>B<C@ @' ABE F@@'LC<N ?'L @A< <Z=L<EE
=IL='E< '? B@E M<BCW Q'RRICBQF@<G @' F @ABLG =<LE'C BE <EE<C@BF>>N
BCQ'CEBE@<C@ PB@A @A< Q'C?BG<C@BF> L<>F@B'C$
• cH8< 9H8 J99;=<8N HJ? IJ:9HIKLLN EJ==:8B ;K9 H:? :<?9=KE9:;<? M8
B8L:P8=:<G 9H8 E;FFK<:EJ9:;< 9; 9H8 9H:=B A8=?;< I;= OH;F :9 OJ?
:<98<B8B J<B 9H8 LJ998= JE9? KA;< :9Q :9 EJ<<;9Q MN J<N =8J?;<:<G
OHJ98P8=Q M8 ELJ??:I:8B :< J L8GJL ?8<?8 J? J A=:P:L8G8B E;FFK<:EJ9:;<M89O88< 9H8 J99;=<8N J<B H:? EL:8<95
• D@ BE =>FBC @AF@ EIQA F Q'RRICBQF@B'C9 F?@<L L<FQABCW @A< =FL@N ?'L
PA'R B@ PFE BC@<CG<G F@ ><FE@9 BE F Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C @A< Q>B<C@
FCG F @ABLG =<LE'C9 FCG @AF@ @A< F@@'LC<N EBR=>N 'QQI=B<E @A< L'>< '?
BC@<LR<GBFLN 'L FW<C@$
• D@ BE RFCB?<E@ @AF@ @A< 'Me<Q@B'C @' @A< @<E@BR'CN '? @A< =>FBC@B??iE
F@@'LC<N FE @' ABE FI@A'LB@N @' Q'R=L'RBE< PFE =L'=<L>N 'T<LLI><G$
0H8 98?9:F;<N OJ? 9; 9H8 8II8E9 9HJ9 OH8< 9H8 J99;=<8N B8L:P8=8B 9H8
A;L:E:8? 9; 9H8 JBF:<:?9=J9;=Q H8 K<B8=?9;;B 9HJ9 9H8=8 OJ? J
E;FA=;F:?8 9; M8 8II8E98BQ J<B 9HJ9 OH8< H8 :<I;=F8B 9H8 ALJ:<9:II;I 9H8 ?K==8<B8= ;I 9H8 A;L:E:8? I;= 9HJ9 AK=A;?8 9H8 ALJ:<9:II FJB8 <;
;Ma8E9:;< OHJ98P8=$ 6A< <TBG<CQ< BE EI??BQB<C@ @' EA'P @AF@ @A<
=>FBC@B?? FQ\IB<EQ<G BC @A< Q'R=L'RBE< E<@@><R<C@ '? @A< ='>BQB<E$
SFTBCW FWL<<G @' @A< Q'R=L'RBE<9 A< QFCC'@ C'P GBEFT'P B@ FCG
RFBC@FBC FC FQ@B'C ?'L @A< L<Q'T<LN '? @A<BL ?FQ< TF>I<$
X5 "&'/%/ $15 1/.(#'/.d/C/. 6""7
#% "/3+0- . /+1*/1"++] . m7;f&7&9 :$
!89:9:;<8=>?@ 6U484%4 %U#7(79 U8#7%84 7%79 7JU(D&4 K%fn9 :45U
K4&KU;KD4&9 %4#U(D4 JD&(f7&9 JDK64% (7n76D&9 7&8 U8f7%84 U5KfU67
"8?A;<B8<9>?@ 57&8D#7&Y7l7&9 %U;fY(DK 4H 6SU ;SD(D;;D&U5 o 7K6D&#
6S%4f#S ;K##9 7&8 %7f( %4K4
#% "/-""0
S7lf8D&D J$ 57&8D#7&Y7l7& 7&8 %;
1-,,/"C@ 6ABE BE F Q'C@L'T<LEBF> QFE< BCT'>TBCW ABWA =L'?B>< =<LE'CF>B@B<E$ 7@
@A< A<BWA@ '? @A< BCT<E@BWF@B'C PB@A L<WFLG @' B>>)W'@@<C P<F>@A9 <E@<<R<G
>FPN<LE ?L'R 7KK%7 P<L< RFG< G<?<CGFC@E BC F QFE< ?'L F>><W<G>N M<BCWFQQ'R=>BQ<E BC @A< FQ\IBEB@B'C '? B>>)W'@@<C P<F>@A$ DC @A<BL G<?<CE<9 @A<N
F>><W<G @AF@ EFBG FQ@E P<L< G'C< BC ?IL@A<LFCQ< '? ><WB@BRF@< >FPN<LBCW$ &'P
@A< RFBC BEEI< BCT'>T<E @A< ?BGIQBFLN L<>F@B'CEAB= M<@P<<C >FPN<L FCG Q>B<C@c
'C< '? @A< G<?<CGFC@E9 %FI> %'Q'9 PFE <ZQ>IG<G MN @A< ;K## M<QFIE< A< BE
EFBG @' AFT< FWL<<G @' ?ILCBEA @A<R BC?'LRF@B'C PB@A L<WFLG @' @A< BG<C@B@N '?
ABE Q>B<C@E$ 6A< 7KK%7 >FPN<LE PA' FL< G<?<CGFC@E A<L<BC9 A'P<T<L9 L<?IE<G
@' GBTI>W< EFBG BC?'LRF@B'C$ 6A< 5FCGBWFCMFNFC =L'RI>WF@<G F G<QBEB'C BC
?FT'L '? ;K##$ 6A< 5K9 A'P<T<L9 @''X @A< EBG< '? @A< 7KK%7 >FPN<LE$ HBLE@9 B@
='BC@<G 'I@ @AF@ B@ BE \IB@< F==FL<C@ @AF@ ;K##OE =>'N PFE @' BR=><FG @A<7KK%7 >FPN<LE FCG @A<C QI@ F G<F> PB@A @A<R @' =L'TBG< @A< CFR<E '? @A<BL
Q>B<C@E$ YI@ Q'CEBG<LBCW @A< ?FQ@E '? @A< QFE< F@ MFL9 @ABE BE TB'>F@BT< '? @A<
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ 6A'IWA FE F W<C<LF> LI><9 BG<C@B?BQF@B'C '? @A< Q>B<C@ BE
+", =LBTB><W<G BC?'LRF@B'C9 FE A<>G BC F E@LBCW '? f5 eILBE=LIG<CQ<9 B@ RFN M<
=LBTB><W<G PA<L< B@ QFC M< EA'PC @AF@ F E@L'CW =L'MFMB>B@N <ZBE@E @AF@
GBEQ>'EIL< '? EIQA BC?'LRF@B'C P'I>G BR=>BQF@< @A< Q>B<C@ BC @A< T<LN QLBRBCF>
FQ@BTB@N ?'L PABQA ><WF> FGTBQ< PFE E'IWA@$
6.;98@ 0H:? :? J L;;;<G EJ?8 MK9 9H8 G:?9 :? 8J?N 9; K<B8=?9J<B5 0H8 ?KFFJ=N
?JN? :9 JLL <J5 #9R? FJ:<LN L;<G M8EJK?8 ;I 9H8 ?9=:<G ;I EJ?8? E:98B :< 9H8
B8E:?:;<5 /%1+Q ?;==N I;= ?;F8 L;<G SK;98? e F;?9LN `J?: J<G GJ<BJ <K<G
O;=B:<G <G 1* J<B O8 `<;O 1:= L:`8? H8J=:<G 9H8 8UJE9 O;=B?57
3/*01
!"#$%$ '(%$% )*+'# )#$ ,$-. '*-/$-%)*/$ *0 $,$-. 1)()$2% 3+45'5(6 %.%)$7 BBB C
,7% )/+&,*,1 "# #*2(&*/$1 2(,1 *+ ,7% &'*%+,C'/=1%$ $%'/,*"+)7*.4 "#$ 054+'5(-.
4+). *0 ( '*+/%$6 (/4 (4,*'()$ 5% (6%* 8#() 7(9$% )#$ 6(8 :-*0$%%5*/ (
+/5;+$ :*%5)5*/ *0 )-+%) (/4 '*/054$/'$ BBB 8$ #(,$ /* -$'*+-%$ <+) )*
+:#*64 (/4 %)-$/=)#$/ )#$ 7(/)6$ *0 :-*)$')5*/ (''*-4$4 )* )#$
'*/054$/)5(65). )#() :-*'$$4% 0-*7 )#$ :$-0*-7(/'$ *0 )#$ 6(8.$-2% 4+). )*
#5% '65$/) 4D
• 6ABE QFE< BE FC '??EA''@ '? @A< 5FCGBWFCMFNFC QFE< ?B><G MN @A< ;K##
FWFBCE@ UGIFLG' K'eIFCWQ' :L9 ?'L @A< L<Q'T<LN '? F>><W<G B>>)W'@@<C
P<F>@A9 PABQA BCQ>IG<E EAFL<E '? E@'QXE BC Q'L='LF@B'CE$ 6ABE BE ;K##
KFE< &'$ 00$ ^6ABE QFE< PFE ?B><G :I>N "+-2_
• 7R'CW @A< G<?<CGFC@E CFR<G BC @A< QFE< FL< A<L<BC =<@B@B'C<LE9 PA'
F>> P<L< @A<C =FL@C<LE '? @A< >FP ?BLR 7CWFLF9 7M<>>'9 K'CQ<=QB'C9
%<WF>F FCG KLIa (FP 4??BQ<E ^A<L<BCF?@<L L<?<LL<G @' FE @A< 7KK%7 (FP
HBLR_$
• 7KK%7 (FP HBLR =<L?'LR<G ><WF> E<LTBQ<E ?'L B@E Q>B<C@E9
PABQA BCQ>IG<G9 FR'CW '@A<LEc
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 6/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
]
) @A< 'LWFCBaF@B'C FCG FQ\IBEB@B'C '? MIEBC<EE FEE'QBF@B'CE FCG1'L
'LWFCBaF@B'CE
) B@E R<RM<LE FQ@<G FE BCQ'L='LF@'LE9 'L EBR=>N9 FE E@'QXA'>G<LE
) G<>BT<L<G @' B@E Q>B<C@ G'QIR<C@E PABQA EIME@FC@BF@< @A< Q>B<C@iE
<\IB@N A'>GBCWE
) FQ\IBL< BC?'LRF@B'C L<>F@BT< @' @A< FEE<@E '? Q>B<C@E FE P<>> FE @A<BL
=<LE'CF> FCG MIEBC<EE QBLQIRE@FCQ<E
•
;<@B@B'C<LE FCG =LBTF@< L<E='CG<C@ %FI> %'Q' FGRB@ @AF@ @A<N FEEBE@<GBC @A< 'LWFCBaF@B'C FCG FQ\IBEB@B'C '? @A< Q'R=FCB<E BCQ>IG<G BC KBTB>
KFE< &'$ 009 FCG BC X<<=BCW PB@A @A< '??BQ< =LFQ@BQ<9 7KK%7 >FPN<LE
FQ@<G FE C'RBC<<E)E@'QXA'>G<LE '? @A< EFBG Q'L='LF@B'CE BCT'>T<G BC
E<\I<E@LF@B'C =L'Q<<GBCWE
• &'P E'R<@BR< BC 7IW$ "++"9 ;K## ?B><G F R'@B'C <ZQ>IGBCW %FI> %'Q'
?L'R KBTB> KFE< &'$ 00 FE =FL@N)G<?<CGFC@9 MFEBCW B@E <ZQ>IEB'C 'C @A<
>F@@<LOE ICG<L@FXBCW @AF@ A< PB>> L<T<F> @A< BG<C@B@N '? @A< =LBCQB=F>1E
?'L PA'R A< FQ@<G FE C'RBC<<1E@'QXA'>G<L BC @A< Q'R=FCB<E$
• 6A<E< FL< ;K##OE F>><WF@B'CE FWFBCE@ @A< F?'L<R<C@B'C<G 7KK%7
>FPN<LEc"$ 6A< 7KK%7 >FPN<LE =>'@@<G9 G<TBE<G9 EQA<R<G$ Q'CE=BL<G FCG
Q'C?<G<LF@<G PB@A <FQA '@A<L BC E<@@BCW I=9 @AL'IWA @A< IE< '? @A<
Q'Q'CI@ ><TN ?ICGE9 @A< ?BCFCQBF> FCG Q'L='LF@< ?LFR<P'LX FCG
E@LIQ@IL<E @AF@ ><G @' @A< <E@FM>BEAR<C@ '? fK;Y9 f&DK4[9
K4K4(DHU9 K4K4[7%m9 KDK9 FCG R'L< @AFC @P<C@N '@A<L Q'Q'CI@
><TN ?ICG<G Q'L='LF@B'CE9 BCQ>IGBCW @A< FQ\IBEB@B'C '? 5FC [BWI<>
K'L='LF@B'C EAFL<E FCG B@E BCE@B@I@B'CF>BaF@B'C @AL'IWA =L<EBG<C@BF>
GBL<Q@BT<E '? @A< Q'Q'CI@ R'C'='>N$
*$ 6AL'IWA BCEBGB'IE R<FCE FCG RFQABCF@B'CE9 7KK%79 M<BCW @A<
PA'>>N)'PC<G BCT<E@R<C@ FLR9 7KK%7 DCT<E@R<C@E K'L='LF@B'C9
M<QFR< @A< A'>G<L '? F==L'ZBRF@<>N ?B?@<<C RB>>B'C EAFL<E
L<=L<E<C@BCW L'IWA>N 0$0p '? @A< @'@F> 'I@E@FCGBCW QF=B@F> E@'QX '?
fK;Y9 @A<L<MN LFCXBCW 7KK%7 @A< ,,@A MBWW<E@ E@'QXA'>G<L '?
fK;Y
• H'L @A<BL =FL@9 @A< 7KK%7 >FPN<LE F>><W<G @AF@c
"$ 6A<BL =FL@BQB=F@B'C BC @A< EFBG FQ@E FL< =FL@ '? ><WB@BRF@< >FPN<LBCW
*$ DC @A< Q'ILE< '? L<CG<LBCW =L'?<EEB'CF> FCG ><WF> E<LTBQ<E @' Q>B<C@E9
G<?<CGFC@E)7KK%7 >FPN<LE M<QFR< A'>G<LE '? EAFL<E '? E@'QX BC
@A< Q'L='LF@B'CE >BE@<G ICG<L @A<BL L<E=<Q@BT< CFR<E FE
BCQ'L='LF@BCW 'L FQ\IBLBCW E@'QXA'>G<LE 'C>N FCG9 FE EIQA9 @A<N G'
C'@ Q>FBR FCN =L'=LB<@FLN BC@<L<E@ BC @A< EFBG EAFL<E '? E@'QX$• 7E ?'L G<?<CGFC@ 7T<>BC' KLIac
) A< PFE 'C< '? @A< BCQ'L='LF@'LE BC "+2] '? [<LRFBG [FLX<@BCW
K'L='LF@B'C9 PABQA PFE 'LWFCBa<G ?'L ><WB@BRF@< MIEBC<EE =IL='E<E
C'@ L<>F@<G @' @A< F>><WF@B'CE '? @A< <Z=FCG<G 7R<CG<G K'R=>FBC@
) A< AFE >'CW FW' @LFCE?<LL<G FCN RF@<LBF> BC@<L<E@ @A<L<BC FCG
@A<L<?'L< G<CB<E @AF@ @A< `EAFL<EO F==<FLBCW BC ABE CFR< FL< ABE
FEE<@E
• 7E ?'L =<@B@B'C<L ;FLFeF SFNIGBCBc
)
A< AFG E<=FLF@<G ?L'R 7KK%7 >FP ?BLR) ?B><G F E<=FLF@< FCEP<L G<CNBCW @A< F>><WF@B'CE BC @A< Q'R=>FBC@
BR=>BQF@BCW ABR BC @A< F>><W<G B>>)W'@@<C P<F>@A$
• ;K## E<@ @A< ??$ Q'CGB@B'CE ?'L @A< <ZQ>IEB'C '? =<@B@B'C<LEc
"$ @A< GBEQ>'EIL< '? @A< BG<C@B@N '? B@E Q>B<C@E
*$ EIMRBEEB'C '? G'QIR<C@E EIME@FC@BF@BCW @A< >FPN<L)Q>B<C@
L<>F@B'CEAB=
0$ EIMRBEEB'C '? @A< G<<GE '? FEEBWCR<C@E =<@B@B'C<LE <Z<QI@<G BC
?FT'L '? B@E Q>B<C@E Q'T<LBCW @A<BL L<E=<Q@BT< EAFL<A'>GBCWE
• 7E ?'L %FI> %'Q'OE Q'R=>BFCQ< PB@A @A<E<9 @A< ??$ =L''? P<L< FGGIQ<G
MN ;K##c"$ (<@@<L '? %'Q'OE Q'ICE<> @' ;K## L<B@<LF@BCW F =L<TB'IE L<\I<E@ ?'L
L<BCT<E@BWF@B'C
*$ 7??BGFTB@ '? %'Q' FE F@@FQAR<C@ @' F?'L<EFBG ><@@<L
0$ (<@@<L '? @A< %'Q'9 YICFW9 FCG mF=ICFC (FP 4??BQ<E @' ;K## BC
M<AF>? '? =LBTF@< L<E='CG<C@ %'Q' 'LBWBCF>>N L<\I<E@BCW @A<
L<BCT<E@BWF@B'C FCG1'L L<)<ZFRBCF@B'C '? @A< <TBG<CQ< '? @A< ;K##
FWFBCE@ %'Q' BC B@E K'R=>FBC@ BC ;K## KFE< &'$ 00
• .+0&fff =8?A;<B8<9 ";E; B:B <;9 =8IK98 A89:9:;<8=?b E;<98<9:;< 9HJ9
H8 B:B <;9 JE9KJLLN =8P8JL 9H8 :B8<9:9N ;I 9H8 EL:8<9 :<P;LP8B :< !*''
*J?8 .;5 [[Q <;= HJB H8 K<B8=9J`8< 9; =8P8JL 9H8 :B8<9:9N ;I 9H8
EL:8<9 I;= OH;F H8 JE98B J? <;F:<88Y?9;E`H;LB8=
#11-&
45 V& 5FCGBWFCMFNFC WLFT<>N FMIE<G B@E GBEQL<@B'C BC EIMe<Q@BCW
=<@B@B'C<L 7KK%7 >FPN<LE @' @A< E@LBQ@ F==>BQF@B'C '? @A< >FP '? FW<CQN
o C&1
X5
V& 5FCGBWFCMFNFC WLFT<>N FMIE<G B@E GBEQL<@B'C BC C'@ A'>GBCW @AF@
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< =L'ABMB@E =<@B@B'C<L 7KK%7 >FPN<LE ?L'R
L<T<F>BCW @A< BG<C@B@N '? @A<BL Q>B<C@E FCG @A< '@A<L BC?' L<\I<E@<G MN
;K## o C&1
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 7/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
2
[5 V& 5FCGBWFCMFNFC WLFT<>N FMIE<G B@E GBEQL<@B'C BC C'@ Q'CEBG<LBCW
=<@B@B'C<L 7KK%7 >FPN<LE FCG [L$ %'Q' FE EBRB>FL>N EB@IF@<G FCG
@A<L<?'L< G<E<LTBCW '? <\IF> @L<F@R<C@ o C&1
D&%(@
• [U%D64%D4f5
•
cD&"&3+"&Q #. $#&c +3 0D& 3+"&'+#.'9 @A< %<E'>I@B'CE '?L<E='CG<C@ 5FCGBWFCMFNFC ^HBLE@ 8BTBEB'C_ =L'RI>WF@<G 'C [FLQA "-9
"++* FCG [FN *"9 "++* FL< A<L<MN 7&&f((U8 FCG 5U6
75D8U$ %<E='CG<C@ 5FCGBWFCMFNFC BE ?IL@A<L 'LG<L<G @' <ZQ>IG<
=<@B@B'C<LE 6<'G'L' 8$ %<WF>F9 UGWFLG' :$ 7CWFLF9 7T<>BC' J$ KLIa9 :'E<
K$ K'CQ<=QB'C9 q%'W<>B' 7$ JBC>IFC9 JBQ@'L ;$ (FaF@BC9 UGIFLG' f$
UEQI<@F FCG ;FLFeF #$ SFNIGICB FE =FL@B<E)G<?<CGFC@E BC 5Y KBTB> KFE<
&'$ //00 <C@B@><G kE%.(9'*& "# ,7% F7*'*..*+%) 34 G2(/$2" :"H(/+I&"A J$4A
%, /' $k
"/0#+
3#"10 #11-&
• D@ BE \IB@< F==FL<C@ @AF@ =<@B@B'C<L 7KK%7 >FPN<LE P<L< BR=><FG<G C'@
L<F>>N M<QFIE< @A< ;K## PFE F?@<L @A<R9 MI@ LF@A<L9 M<QFIE< B@ PFE
F?@<L @A< gMBWW<L ?BEA$h
• 6A< 5K <T<C ICG<LEQ'L<G F ='L@B'C '? @A< 5FCGBWFCMFNFC L<E'>I@B'Cc
g6A< 7KK%7 >FPN<LE QFCC'@ <ZQIE< @A<RE<>T<E ?L'R @A< Q'CE<\I<CQ<E
'? @A<BL FQ@E IC@B> @A<N AFT< M<WIC @' <E@FM>BEA @A< MFEBE ?'L L<Q'WCBaBCW
@A< =LBTB><W<d @A< <ZBE@<CQ< FCG BG<C@B@N '? @A< Q>B<C@$ 6ABE BE PAF@
F==<FLE @' M< @A< QFIE< ?'L PABQA @A<N AFT< M<<C BR=><FG<G MN @A<
;K## FE G<?<CGFC@E A<L<BC$ g
•
>-57(,$-( ?(-7% ,@ >ABBC F Q>'E<>N L<>F@<G QFE< PA<L<BC @A< ;K##
PFC@<G @' <E@FM>BEA @AL'IWA 7KK%7 @AF@c
) @A<BL gE' QF>><G Q>B<C@ BE [L$ UGIFLG' K'eIFCWQ'h
) @AF@ gB@ PFE [L$ UGIFLG' K'eIFCWQ' PA' ?ILCBEA<G F>> @A< R'CB<E
@' @A'E< EIMEQLB=@B'C =FNR<C@E BC Q'L='LF@B'CE
) @AF@ @A< 7KK%7 >FPN<LE <Z<QI@<G G<<GE '? @LIE@ FCG G<<GE '?
FEEBWCR<C@9 E'R< BC @A< CFR< '? =FL@BQI>FL =<LE'CE9 E'R< BC M>FCX
) @AF@ R'E@ '? @A<E< Q'L='LF@B'CE FL< L<F>>N eIE@ =F=<L Q'L='LF@B'CE
# @A<N AFT< C' =<LRB@E ?L'R @A< RICBQB=F> FI@A'LB@B<E BC [FXF@B$
# F>> @A<BL FGGL<EE<E C'P FL< QFL< '? JB>>FL<F> (FP 4??BQ<
•
6A< 5K ='BC@<G 'I@ @AF@ =<@B@B'C<LE FL< M<BCW =L'E<QI@<G E'><>N 'C @A<MFEBE '? FQ@BTB@B<E FCG E<LTBQ<E =<L?'LR<G BC @A< Q'ILE< '? @A<BL GI@B<E
FE >FPN<LEd @AF@ @A<BL BCQ>IEB'C BC @A< Q'R=>FBC@ BE R<L<>N M<BCW IE<G FE
F ><T<LFW< @' Q'R=<> @A<R @' CFR< @A<BL Q>B<C@E
• #. *+.*%-1#+.@ "8?A;<B8<9 !*'' HJ? <; PJL:B EJK?8 ;I JE9:;< J?
JGJ:<?9 A89:9:;<8=? J<B ?H;KLB 8UELKB8 9H8F I=;F 9H8 0H:=B
/F8<B8B *;FALJ:<9
1&*+.( #11-&
•
6A< CF@IL< '? >FPN<L)Q>B<C@ L<>F@B'CEAB= BE =L<RBE<G 'C @A< %'RFC (FPQ'CQ<=@E '?
) 6*'()5* '*/4+')5* *:$-(-+7 6E;<9=JE9 ;I L8J?8 ;I ?8=P:E8?7c PA<L<
'C< =<LE'C ><@E ABE E<LTBQ<E FCG FC'@A<L ABL<E @A<R PB@A'I@
L<?<L<CQ< @' @A< 'Me<Q@ '? PABQA @A< E<LTBQ<E FL< @' M< =<L?'LR<G
) 7(/4()* 6E;<9=JE9 ;I JG8<EN7@ PA<L<BC F ?LB<CG 'C PA'R L<>BFCQ<
Q'I>G M< =>FQ<G RFX<E F Q'C@LFQ@ BC ABE CFR<9 MI@ WBT<E I= F>> @AF@
A< WFBC<G MN @A< Q'C@LFQ@ @' @A< =<LE'C PA' L<\I<E@<G ABR
• Yf6 6SU (7VlU%)K(DU&6 %U(76D4&5SD; D5 [4%U 6S7& :f56
;%D&KD;7()7#U&6 7&8 (U554%)(U55UU
• 7C F@@'LC<N BEr
) R'L< @AFC F R<L< FW<C@ 'L E<LTFC@9 M<QFIE< A< ='EE<EE<E E=<QBF>
='P<LE '? @LIE@ FCG Q'C?BG<CQ< L<='E<G 'C ABR MN ABE Q>B<C@
) FE BCG<=<CG<C@ FE @A< eIGW< '? @A< Q'IL@
) 'QQI=B<E PAF@ RFN M< Q'CEBG<L<G FE F k\IFEB)eIGBQBF> '??BQ<k EBCQ<
A< BE BC ?FQ@ FC '??BQ<L '? @A< K'IL@ FCG <Z<LQBE<E ABE eIGWR<C@ BC
@A< QA'BQ< '? Q'ILE<E '? FQ@B'C @' M< @FX<C ?FT'LFM>< @' ABE Q>B<C@
• 6AIE9 9H8=8 J=8 =KL8?Q 89H:EJL E;<BKE9 J<B BK9:8? 9HJ9 M=8J9H8 L:I8 :<9;
:9Q JF;<G 9H;?8Q 9H8 I:BKE:J=N BK9N 9; H:? EL:8<9 OH:EH :? ;I J P8=N
B8L:EJ98Q 8UJE9:<G J<B E;<I:B8<9:JL EHJ=JE98=Q =8SK:=:<G J P8=N H:GH
B8G=88 ;I I:B8L:9N J<B G;;B IJ:9HQ 9HJ9 :? =8SK:=8B MN =8J?;< ;I
<8E8??:9N J<B AKML:E :<98=8?9 MJ?8B ;< 9H8 HNA;9H8?:? 9HJ9 JM?9:<8<E8I=;F ?88`:<G L8GJL JBP:E8 :< J G;;B EJK?8 :? J< 8P:L OH:EH :? IJ9JL 9;
9H8 JBF:<:?9=J9:;< ;I aK?9:E85
• D@ BE F>E' @A< E@LBQ@ E<CE< '? ?BG<>B@N '? F >FPN<L @' ABE Q>B<C@ @AF@
GBE@BCWIBEA<E ABR ?L'R FCN '@A<L =L'?<EEB'CF> BC E'QB<@N$
• D/*) 57:*-)(/)E 1)*'9)*/ ,@ ?*-4C f5 5K A<>Gc
g6A<L< FL< ?<P '? @A< MIEBC<EE L<>F@B'CE '? >B?< BCT'>TBCW F ABWA<L @LIE@
FCG Q'C?BG<CQ< @AFC @AF@ '? F@@'LC<N FCG Q>B<C@9 'L W<C<LF>>N E=<FXBCW9
'C< R'L< A'C'LFM>N FCG ?FB@A?I>>N GBEQAFLW<Gd ?<P R'L< FCZB'IE>N
WIFLG<G MN @A< >FP9 'L W'T<LC<G MN @A< E@<LC<L =LBCQB=><E '? R'LF>B@N
FCG eIE@BQ<d FCG B@ BE @A< GI@N '? @A< Q'IL@ @' FGRBCBE@<L @A<R BC FQ'LL<E='CGBCW E=BLB@9 FCG @' M< PF@QA?I> FCG BCGIE@LB'IE9 @' E<< @AF@
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 8/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
-
Q'C?BG<CQ< @AIE L<='E<G EAF>> C'@ M< IE<G @' @A< G<@LBR<C@ 'L
=L<eIGBQ< '? @A< LBWA@E '? @A< =FL@N M<E@'PBCW B@$h
• !"+$#1#+.1 "&@ /00+".&CY*%#&.0 "-%&
) 18E5 [g[ ;I 9H8 4Zh4 *;B8 ;I *:P:L !=;E8BK=8@ E=<QB?BQF>>N g?'LMBGE
Q'ICE<>9 PB@A'I@ FI@A'LB@N '? ABE Q>B<C@ @' L<T<F> FCN
Q'RRICBQF@B'C RFG< MN @A< Q>B<C@ @' ABR 'L ABE FGTBQ< WBT<C
@A<L<'C BC @A< Q'ILE< '? =L'?<EEB'CF> <R=>'NR<C@$
)
18E5 Xi "KL8 4[h ;I 9H8 EK==8<9 "KL8? ;I *;K=9@ 7C F@@'LC<N QFCC'@9PB@A'I@ @A< Q'CE<C@ '? ABE Q>B<C@9 M< <ZFRBC<G FE @' FCN
Q'RRICBQF@B'C RFG< MN @A< Q>B<C@ @' ABR9 'L ABE FGTBQ< WBT<C
@A<L<'C BC @A< Q'ILE< '?9 'L PB@A F TB<P @'9 =L'?<EEB'CF>
<R=>'NR<C@9 QFC FC F@@'LC<NOE E<QL<@FLN9 E@<C'WLF=A<L9 'L Q><LX
M< <ZFRBC<G9 PB@A'I@ @A< Q'CE<C@ '? @A< Q>B<C@ FCG ABE <R=>'N<L9
Q'CQ<LCBCW FCN ?FQ@ @A< XC'P><GW< '? PABQA AFE M<<C FQ\IBL<G BC
EIQA QF=FQB@N$
) 18E5 Xh "KL8 4[g ;I 9H8 EK==8<9 "+*@ B@ BE @A< GI@N '? @A< F@@'LC<N
ZZZ @' RFBC@FBC BCTB'>F@< @A< Q'C?BG<CQ<9 FCG F@ <T<LN =<LB> @'
ABRE<>?9 @' =L<E<LT< @A< E<QL<@E '? ABE Q>B<C@9 FCG @' FQQ<=@ C'
Q'R=<CEF@B'C BC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@A ABE Q>B<C@OE MIEBC<EE <ZQ<=@ ?L'R
ABR 'L PB@A ABE XC'P><GW< FCG F==L'TF>$
) *J<;< 4jQ *;B8 ;I !=;I8??:;<JL "8?A;<?:M:L:9N@ 7 >FPN<L 'P<E
?BG<>B@N @' @A< QFIE< '? ABE Q>B<C@ FCG A< EAF>> M< RBCG?I> '? @A<
@LIE@ FCG Q'C?BG<CQ< L<='E<G BC ABR$
) *J<;< 4_Q *J<;< ;I !=;I8??:;<JL &9H:E?@ >FPN<L 'P<E k<C@BL<
G<T'@B'C @' @A< BC@<L<E@ '? @A< Q>B<C@9 PFLR a<F> BC @A<
RFBC@<CFCQ< FCG G<?<CE< '? ABE LBWA@E FCG @A< <Z<L@B'C '? ABE
I@R'E@ ><FLCBCW FCG FMB>B@N9k @' @A< <CG @AF@ C'@ABCW M< @FX<C 'L
M< PB@AA<>G ?L'R ABR9 EFT< MN @A< LI><E '? >FP9 ><WF>>N F==>B<G$ &'
?<FL '? eIGBQBF> GBE?FT'L 'L =IM>BQ ='=I>FLB@N EA'I>G L<E@LFBC ABR?L'R @A< ?I>> GBEQAFLW< '? ABE GI@N$ DC @A< eIGBQBF> ?'LIR @A< Q>B<C@ BE
<C@B@><G @' @A< M<C<?B@ '? FCN FCG <T<LN L<R<GN FCG G<?<CE< @AF@ BE
FI@A'LBa<G MN @A< >FP '? @A< >FCG9 FCG A< RFN <Z=<Q@ ABE >FPN<L @'
FEE<L@ <T<LN EIQA L<R<GN 'L G<?<CE<$ YI@ ZZZ @A< '??BQ< '?
F@@'LC<N G'<E C'@ =<LRB@9 RIQA ><EE G'<E B@ G<RFCG '? ABR ?'L FCN
Q>B<C@9 TB'>F@B'C '? >FP 'L FCN RFCC<L '? ?LFIG 'L QABQFC<LN$ S<
RIE@ 'M<N ABE 'PC Q'CEQB<CQ< FCG C'@ @AF@ '? ABE Q>B<C@$
• *;<?9:9K9:;<JL J?A8E9 ;I 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8@
) @A< =LBTB><W< WBT<E ?><EA @' 'C< '? @A< R'E@ EFQL'EFCQ@ LBWA@E
FTFB>FM>< @' @A< FQQIE<G9 @A< =:GH9 9; E;K<?8L
) D? F Q>B<C@ P<L< RFG< @' QA''E< M<@P<<C ><WF> L<=L<E<C@F@B'C
PB@A'I@ <??<Q@BT< Q'RRICBQF@B'C FCG GBEQ>'EIL< FCG ><WF>
L<=L<E<C@F@B'C PB@A F>> ABE E<QL<@E L<T<F><G @A<C A< RBWA@ M< Q
) 'R=<>><G9 BC E'R< BCE@FCQ<E9 @' <B@A<L '=@ @' E@FN FPFN ?L'R @A<
eIGBQBF> ENE@<R 'L @' >'E< @A< LBWA@ @' Q'ICE<>$
) FC'@A<L EFQL'EFCQ@ BCGBTBGIF> LBWA@c @A< =:GH9 9; M8 A=8?KF8B
:<<;E8<9
•
!;L:EN E;<E8=<? :<P;LP8B@ ) F Q>B<C@OE BG<C@B@N EA'I>G C'@ M< EAL'IG<G BC RNE@<LN
) 6Sf59 6SU #U&U%7( %f(U D5 ^M'@A A<L< FCG BC @A< f5_c F >FPN<L
FJN <;9 BCT'X< @A< =LBTB><W< FCG L<?IE< @' GBTI>W< @A< CFR< 'L
BG<C@B@N '? ABE Q>B<C@9 ?'L @A< ??$ L<FE'CEc
# Q'IL@ AFE F LBWA@ @' XC'P @AF@ @A< Q>B<C@ PA'E< =LBTB><W<G
BC?'LRF@B'C BE E'IWA@ @' M< =L'@<Q@<G BE ?><EA FCG M>''G
# =LBTB><W< M<WBCE @' <ZBE@ 'C>N F?@<L @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@
L<>F@B'CEAB= AFE M<<C <E@FM>BEA<Gd B@ G'<E C'@ F@@FQA IC@B>
@A<L< BE F Q>B<C@
# =LBTB><W< W<C<LF>>N =<L@FBCE @' @A< )(9H%&, -/,,%$ '? @A<
L<>F@B'CEAB=
# BK8 A=;E8?? E;<?:B8=J9:;<? L<\IBL< @AF@ @A< '=='EBCW =FL@N
EA'I>G9 FE F W<C<LF> LI><9 XC'P ABE FGT<LEFLN
) Yf6 6SU%U 7%U #,!+"0/.0 &k*&!0#+.1c ^<FQA '? @A<E< PB>> M<
GBEQIEE<G BC G<@FB> >F@<L_
"$ *L:8<9 :B8<9:9N :? A=:P:L8G8B OH8=8 J ?9=;<G A=;MJM:L:9N 8U:?9?
9HJ9 =8P8JL:<G 9H8 EL:8<9R? <JF8 O;KLB :FAL:EJ98 9HJ9 EL:8<9 :<
9H8 P8=N JE9:P:9N I;= OH:EH H8 ?;KGH9 9H8 LJON8=R? JBP:E8
^[456 D[;4%67&6 ;7%6 4H 6SD5 K75U_
*$ VA<L< GBEQ>'EIL< P'I>G '=<C @A< Q>B<C@ @' QBTB> >BFMB>B@N9 ABE
BG<C@B@N BE =LBTB><W<G$0$ VA<L< @A< W'T<LCR<C@OE >FPN<LE AFT< C' QFE< FWFBCE@ FC
F@@'LC<NOE Q>B<C@ IC><EE9 MN L<T<F>BCW @A< Q>B<C@OE CFR<9 @A<
EFBG CFR< P'I>G ?ILCBEA @A< 'C>N >BCX @AF@ P'I>G ?'LR @A<
QAFBC '? @<E@BR'CN C<Q<EEFLN @' Q'CTBQ@ FC BCGBTBGIF> '? F
QLBR<9 @A< Q>B<C@OE CFR< BE =LBTB><W<G$
# 5f[[7%DnD&# 6SU5U 0 D& 7 &f65SU((c :<I;=FJ9:;< =8LJ9:<G
9; 9H8 :B8<9:9N ;I J EL:8<9 FJN IJLL O:9H:< 9H8 JFM:9 ;I 9H8
A=:P:L8G8 OH8< 9H8 EL:8<9R? <JF8 :9?8LI HJ? J< :<B8A8<B8<9
?:G<:I:EJ<E8Q ?KEH 9HJ9 B:?EL;?K=8 O;KLB 9H8< =8P8JL EL:8<9
E;<I:B8<E8?(&0/#%&( (#1*-11#+. +. &k*&!0#+. l4@
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 9/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
+
• FGH>(-)$ F/I*-C
) @A< ICBG<C@B?B<G Q>B<C@9 FC <><Q@B'C '??BQBF>9 BC?'LR<G ABE F@@'LC<N BC
Q'C?BG<CQ< @AF@ A< AFG M<<C '??<L<G F MLBM< @' TB'>F@< <><Q@B'C
>FPE 'L @AF@ A< AFG FQQ<=@<G F MLBM< @' @AF@ <CG
) F@@'LC<N FT<LL<G @AF@ EA< Q'I>G C'@ L<R<RM<L PA<@A<L A<L Q>B<C@
AFG M<<C9 BC ?FQ@9 MLBM<G
) >FPN<L PFE QB@<G ?'L Q'C@<R=@ ?'L A<L L<?IEF> @' L<T<F> ABE Q>B<C@OE
BG<C@B@N) E@F@< EI=L<R< Q'IL@ A<>G @AF@ K<B8= 9H8 E:=EKF?9J<E8? ;I 9H8
EJ?89 FCG ICG<L @A< <ZQ<=@B'CE G<EQLBM<G FM'T<9 8P8< 9H8 <JF8
;I 9H8 EL:8<9 OJ? A=:P:L8G8B
• J@1@ ,@ K*4=$ (/4 L8$5=C
) QFE< BCT'>T<G ?<G<LF> WLFCG eILN =L'Q<<GBCWE BC\IBLBCW BC@' @A<
FQ@BTB@B<E '? @A< g5FCGBC' #FCW9h F WFCW BCT'>T<G BC @A< B>><WF>
BR='L@F@B'C '? GLIWE BC @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E
) L<E='CG<C@E9 >FP =FL@C<LE9 L<=L<E<C@<G X<N PB@C<EE<E FCG
EIE=<Q@E BCQ>IGBCW @A< ><FG<L '? @A< WFCW9 :'< 5FCGBC'
) DC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@A F @FZ BCT<E@BWF@B'C9 D%5 BEEI<G EIRR'CE @'
S'GW< FCG nP<BW9 L<\IBLBCW @A<R @' =L'GIQ< G'QIR<C@E FCG
BC?'LRF@B'C L<WFLGBCW =FNR<C@ L<Q<BT<G MN 5FCGBC' 'C M<AF>? '?
FCN '@A<L =<LE'C9 FCG TBQ< T<LEF$ 6A< >FPN<LE L<?IE<G @' GBTI>W<
@A< CFR<E$
) K'IL@ I=A<>G @A< C'C)GBEQ>'EIL<d F E@L'CW =L'MFMB>B@N <ZBE@E @AF@
GBEQ>'EIL< '? EIQA BC?'LRF@B'C P'I>G BR=>BQF@< @AF@ Q>B<C@ BC @A<
T<LN QLBRBCF> FQ@BTB@N ?'L PABQA ><WF> FGTBQ< PFE E'IWA@$
• M(5-4 ,@ N*$-/$-C <CICQBF@<G @A< =LBCQB=>< @AF@ gDC 'LG<L @' =L'R'@<
?L<<G'R '? Q'CEI>@F@B'C '? ><WF> FGTBE'LE MN Q>B<C@E9 @A< F==L<A<CEB'C
'? Q'R=<>><G GBEQ>'EIL< ?L'R @A< ><WF> FGTBE'LE RIE@ M< L<R'T<Gd
A<CQ<9 @A< >FP RIE@ =L'ABMB@ EIQA GBEQ>'EIL< <ZQ<=@ 'C @A< Q>B<C@OEQ'CE<C@h
(&0/#%&( (#1*-11#+. +. &k*&!0#+. lX
• O$+=(%% ,@ "$-75/(6 A(< A*-:*-()5*/C
) &<IWFEE A @A< =>FBC@B??9 EI??<L<G BCeILN PA<C @A< @FZBQFM EA< PFE
LBGBCW9 'PC<G MN L<E='CG<C@ Q'L='LF@B'C9 Q'>>BG<G PB@A F E<Q'CG
@FZBQFM9 PA'E< 'PC<L PFE ICXC'PC$
) ;>FBC@B?? ML'IWA@ FQ@B'C M'@A FWFBCE@ G<?<CGFC@ Q'L='LF@B'C FCG
@A< 'PC<L '? @A< E<Q'CG QFM9 BG<C@B?B<G BC @A< BC?'LRF@B'C 'C>N FE
:'AC 8'<$
)
PA<C @A< F@@'LC<N '? G<?<CGFC@ Q'L='LF@B'C F==<FL<G 'C=L<>BRBCFLN <ZFRBCF@B'C9 @A< ?FQ@ PFE E'R<A'P L<T<F><G @AF@ @A<
>FPN<L QFR< @' XC'P @A< CFR< '? @A< 'PC<L '? @A< E<Q'CG QFM
=7%+ / -/+A / &'*%+, "# ,7% *+)($/+&% &"-./+1A .$*"$ ," ,7%
*+),*,(,*"+ "# '%I/' /&,*"+A &/-% ," 7*- /+2 $%."$,%2 ,7/, 7% =/)
*+3"'3%2 *+ / &/$ /&&*2%+, $
) F==FL<C@ ICG<L @A< QBLQIRE@FCQ<E @AF@ @A< RFC PFE @A< 'PC<L '?
@A< E<Q'CG QFM
) K'IL@ A<>G @AF@ JLL E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? FJB8 MN J EL:8<9 9; H:?
E;K<?8LQ I;= 9H8 AK=A;?8 ;I A=;I8??:;<JL JBP:E8 ;= J??:?9J<E8Q J=8A=:P:L8G8BQ OH89H8= 9H8N =8LJ98 9; J ?K:9 A8<B:<G ;= E;<98FALJ98BQ
;= 9; J<N ;9H8= FJ998= A=;A8= I;= ?KEH JBP:E8 'L FBG
) OH8<8P8= 9H8 E;FFK<:EJ9:;< FJB8Q =8LJ98? 9; J FJ998= ?;
E;<<8E98B O:9H 9H8 8FAL;NF8<9 J? J99;=<8N ;= E;K<?8L J? 9;
JII;=B A=8?KFA9:;< 9HJ9 :9 OJ? 9H8 G=;K<B ;I 9H8 JBB=8?? MN 9H8
EL:8<9Q 9H8< :9 :? A=:P:L8G8B I=;F B:?EL;?K=8
• P())$- *0 1#(87+) P5/5/= A*7:(/.C
) >FPN<L BCT'>T<G PFE L<\IBL<G MN F >'P<L Q'IL@ @' GBEQ>'E< PA<@A<L
A< L<=L<E<C@<G Q<L@FBC Q>B<C@E BC F Q<L@FBC @LFCEFQ@B'C
) =IL='E< '? @A< Q'IL@OE L<\I<E@ PFE @' G<@<LRBC< PA<@A<L @A<
ICCFR<G =<LE'CE FE BC@<L<E@<G =FL@B<E P<L< Q'CC<Q@<G PB@A @A<
=ILQAFE< '? =L'=<L@B<E BCT'>T<G BC @A< FQ@B'C
) 5K I=A<>G @A< >FPN<LOE L<?IEF> @' GBTI>W< EFBG CFR<E
# gD? B@ QFC Q'R=<> @A< PB@C<EE @' E@F@< ZZZ @AF@ A< L<=L<E<C@<G
Q<L@FBC =<LE'CE BC @A< =ILQAFE< 'L EF>< '? @A<E< RBC<E9 B@ AFE
RFG< =L'WL<EE BC <E@FM>BEABCW MN EIQA <TBG<CQ< @A<BL T<LEB'C '?
@A< >B@BWF@B'C$h
# g.; EJ?8 HJ? 8P8= G;<8 9; 9H8 L8<G9H ;I E;FA8LL:<G J<
J99;=<8N9 F@ @A< BCE@FCQ< '? F A'E@B>< >B@BWFC@9 9; B:?EL;?8 <;9
;<LN H:? =89J:<8=Q MK9 9H8 <J9K=8 ;I 9H8 9=J<?JE9:;<? @' PABQA
B@ L<>F@<G9 OH8< ?KEH :<I;=FJ9:;< E;KLB M8 FJB8 9H8 MJ?:? ;IJ ?K:9 JGJ:<?9 H:? EL:8<9$h
(&0/#%&( (#1*-11#+. +. &k*&!0#+. l[
• M(5-4 ,@ N*$-/$-C
) >FPN<L PFE Q'CEI>@<G MN @A< FQQ'IC@FC@E FCG @A< >FPN<L '? Q<L@FBC
ICGBEQ>'E<G @FZ=FN<LE L<WFLGBCW E@<=E @' M< @FX<C @' =>FQ< @A<
ICGBEQ>'E<G @FZ=FN<LE BC F ?FT'LFM>< ='EB@B'C BC QFE< QLBRBCF>
QAFLW<E P<L< ML'IWA@ FWFBCE@ @A<R
) F==<FL<G @AF@ @A< @FZ=FN<LEO L<@ILCE '? =L<TB'IE N<FLE P<L<
=L'MFM>N BCQ'LL<Q@ FCG @A< @FZ<E ICG<LE@F@<G
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 10/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"/
) Q>B<C@E @A<RE<>T<E P<L< ICEIL< FM'I@ PA<@A<L 'L C'@ @A<N
TB'>F@<G @FZ >FPE FCG E'IWA@ FGTBQ< ?L'R YFBLG 'C @A< AN='@A<@BQF>
='EEBMB>B@N @AF@ @A<N AFG
) &' BCT<E@BWF@B'C PFE @A<C M<BCW ICG<L@FX<C MN @A< D%5
) F@@'LC<N '? @A< @FZ=FN<LE G<>BT<L<G @' YFBLG @A< EIR '? s"*92/]$-39
PABQA AFG M<<C =L<TB'IE>N FEE<EE<G FE @A< @FZ GI<9 FCG FC'@A<L
FR'IC@ '? R'C<N L<=L<E<C@BCW ABE ?<< ?'L @A< FGTBQ< WBT<C
)
YFBLG @A<C E<C@ F QA<QX @' @A< D%5 BC [FLN>FCG9 PB@A F C'@<<Z=>FBCBCW @A< =FNR<C@ MI@ PB@A'I@ CFRBCW ABE Q>B<C@E
) D%5 G<RFCG<G @AF@ YFBLG BG<C@B?N @A< >FPN<LE9 FQQ'IC@FC@E9 FCG
'@A<L Q>B<C@E BCT'>T<G
) YFBLG L<?IE<G 'C @A< WL'ICG @AF@ A< GBG C'@ XC'P @A<BL CFR<E9
FCG G<Q>BC<G @' CFR< @A< F@@'LC<N FCG FQQ'IC@FC@E M<QFIE< @ABE
Q'CE@B@I@<G =LBTB><W<G Q'RRICBQF@B'C
) K'IL@ A<>Gc
g 0H8 P;LK<9J=N <J9K=8 ;I 9H8 AJNF8<9 :<B:EJ98? J M8L:8I MN 9H8
9JUAJN8=? 9HJ9 F;=8 9JU8? ;= :<98=8?9 ;= A8<JL9:8? J=8 BK8 9HJ<
9H8 ?KF A=8P:;K?LN AJ:B9 B? FCN$ D@ :<B:EJ98? J I88L:<G ;I GK:L9 ?'L
C'C=FNR<C@ '? @FZ<E9 9H;KGH OH89H8= :9 :? E=:F:<JL GK:L9 :?
K<B:?EL;?8B $ YI@ B@ RFN P<>> M< @A< >BCX @AF@ Q'I>G ?'LR @A< QAFBC
'? @<E@BR'CN C<Q<EEFLN @' Q'CTBQ@ FC BCGBTBGIF> '? F ?<G<LF>
QLBR<$h
+0D&" &k*&!0#+.1m 1C.0D&1#1
• +9H8= ?:9KJ9:;<? 9HJ9 E;KLB SKJL:IN J? 8UE8A9:;<?@
45 FCN Q>B<C@ Q'RRICBQF@B'C @' F >FPN<L >B<E PB@ABC @A< =LBTB><W< B? B@ BE
L<><TFC@ @' @A< EIMe<Q@ RF@@<L '? @A< ><WF> =L'M><R 'C PABQA @A<
Q>B<C@ E<<XE ><WF> FEEBE@FCQ<
Q@ PA<L< @A< +/,($% '? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ L<>F@B'CEAB= AFE M<<C
=L<TB'IE>N GBEQ>'E<G /+2 *, *) ,7% *2%+,*,1 =7*&7 *) *+,%+2%2 ," 9%&"+#*2%+,*/' 9 @A< BG<C@B@N '? @A< Q>B<C@ AFE M<<C A<>G @' M<
=LBTB><W<G9 EBCQ< EIQA L<T<>F@B'C P'I>G '@A<LPBE< L<EI>@ BC
GBEQ>'EIL< '? @A< <C@BL< @LFCEFQ@B'C
• 0H8 E:=EKF?9J<E8? :<P;LP:<G 9H8 8<GJG8F8<9 ;I LJON8=? :< 9H8 EJ?8 J9
M8<EHQ 9H8=8I;=8Q EL8J=LN =8P8JL 9HJ9 9H8 :<?9J<9 EJ?8 IJLL? K<B8= J9
L8J?9 9O; 8UE8A9:;<? 9; 9H8 G8<8=JL =KL85
• 6A< >BCX M<@P<<C @A< F>><W<G QLBRBCF> '??<CE< FCG @A< ><WF> FGTBQ< 'L
><WF> E<LTBQ< E'IWA@ PFE GI>N <E@FM>BEA<G BC @A< QFE< F@ MFL9 MN C' ><EE
@AFC @A< ;K## B@E<>?$
•
^HL'R @A< ?FQ@E '? @A< QFE< FE CFLLF@<G FM'T<_ P< QFC L<FGB>N G<GIQ<@AF@ @A< Q>B<C@E BCG<<G Q'CEI>@<G @A< =<@B@B'C<LE9 BC @A<BL QF=FQB@N FE
>FPN<LE9 L<WFLGBCW @A< ?BCFCQBF> FCG Q'L='LF@< E@LIQ@IL<9 ?LFR<P'LX
FCG E<@)I= '? @A< Q'L='LF@B'CE BC \I<E@B'C$
) DC @ILC9 =<@B@B'C<LE WFT< @A<BL =L'?<EEB'CF> FGTBQ<$
) 6A<L< BE C' \I<E@B'C @AF@ @A< =L<=FLF@B'C '? @A< F?'L<E@F@<G
G'QIR<C@E PFE =FL@ FCG =FLQ<> '? =<@B@B'C<LEO ><WF> E<LTBQ<
) !89:9:;<8=?Q 9H8=8I;=8Q HJP8 J L8G:9:FJ98 I8J= 9HJ9 :B8<9:IN:<G
9H8:= EL:8<9? O;KLB :FAL:EJ98 9H8F :< 9H8 P8=N JE9:P:9N I;= OH:EH
L8GJL JBP:E8 HJB M88< ?;KGH9Q :585Q 9H8 JLL8G8B JEEKFKLJ9:;< ;I :LLYG;998< O8JL9H :< 9H8 JI;=8F8<9:;<8B E;=A;=J9:;<?5 ^[456
D[;4%67&6 6SD&# 64 %U[U[YU%_
• "8P8LJ9:;< ;I 9H8 EL:8<9b? <JF8 O;KLB ;MP:;K?LN A=;P:B8 9H8
<8E8??J=N L:<` I;= 9H8 A=;?8EK9:;< 9; MK:LB :9? EJ?8 9 =7%$% +"+%
",7%$=*)% %B*),)$
• &46U 6S76 7 8D5K6D&K6D4& S75 64 YU [78Uc
F$_ PA<L< F Q>B<C@ @FX<E 'C @A< E<LTBQ<E '? FC F@@'LC<N ?'L B>>BQB@
=IL='E<E
!G'<E C'@ ?F>> PB@ABC @A< =LBTB><W< M<QFIE< @A< EFR< QFCC'@ M<
BCT'X<G ?'L B>><WF> =IL='E<E
! LF@B'c B@ BE C'@ PB@ABC @A< =L'?<EEB'CF> QAFLFQ@<L '? F >FPN<L @'
WBT< FGTBQ< 'C @A< Q'RRBEEB'C '? F QLBR<
<@R PA<L< F Q>B<C@ @ABCXE A< RBWA@ AFT< =L<TB'IE>N Q'RRB@@<G
E'R<@ABCW B>><WF> FCG Q'CEI>@E ABE F@@'LC<N FM'I@ B@
!H:? <JF8 EJ<<;9 M8 K?8B ;= B:?EL;?8B :I 9H8 B:?EL;?K=8 L8JB? 9;
8P:B8<E8 /*) .$) :< 9H8 HJ<B? ;I 9H8 A=;?8EK9:;<
• 6A< dJ:=B 8UE8A9:;< ^FE GBEQIEE<G FM'T<_ BE F==>BQFM>< BC @A< =L<E<C@
QFE<$
! @ABE AFE M<<C EIE@FBC<G BC S/ -$ B-(/4 T+-. >-*'$$45/=% FCG
"566*)%*/ ,@ M*+=#/$-
! @A<E< QFE<E ICFCBR'IE>N E<<X @' FT'BG @A< <Z=>'B@F@B'C '? @A<W<C<LF> LI>< BC PAF@ RFN FR'IC@ @' F 3#1D#.' &k!&(#0#+. MN 9H8
A=;?8EK9:;<
• 6A<L< FL<9 F?@<L F>>9 JL98=<J9:P8 ?;K=E8? '? BC?'LRF@B'C FTFB>FM>< @' @A<
=L'E<QI@'L OH:EH B; <;9 B8A8<B ;< K9:L:T:<G J B8I8<BJ<9b? E;K<?8L FE
F &"+3%+*%+, FCG $%/2*'1 /3/*'/9'% E'ILQ< '? BC?'LRF@B'C
• 4@A<LPBE<9 B@ P'I>G M< @FC@FR'IC@ @' EFCQ@B'CBCW ?BEABCW <Z=<GB@B'CE
MN >FaN =L'E<QI@'LE FCG >B@BWFC@E$
• 6A< E=KU ;I A89:9:;<8=?b ;Ma8E9:;<? I>@BRF@<>N ABCW<E 'C @A<BL
<Z=<Q@F@B'C @AF@ B? @A< =L'E<QI@B'C AFE F QFE< FWFBCE@ @A<BL Q>B<C@E9 @A<
>F@@<LiE QFE< EA'I>G M< MIB>@ I='C <TBG<CQ< =FBCE@FXBCW>N WF@A<L<G MN@A<R #$"- ,7%*$ "=+ )"($&%) FCG C'@ ?L'R Q'R=<>><G @<E@BR'CN
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 11/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
""
• K+", *-."$,/+,L 59%$$*-%* #*2%* L<>F@B'CEAB= M<@P<<C F >FPN<L FCG ABE
Q>B<C@ @A<L<?'L< BR='E<E F E@LBQ@ >BFMB>B@N ?'L C<W>BW<CQ< 'C @A< ?'LR<L$
• K+", *-."$,/+,L P56<(/9U "8$$4U K(46$. (/4 P'A6*. ,@ M**/C
) >FP?BLR A<>=<G B@E Q>B<C@OE ?'LR<L FW<C@ BC Q>'EBCW F G<F> ?'L @A<
FW<C@iE M<C<?B@ 'C>N F?@<L B@E Q>B<C@ A<EB@F@<G BC =L'Q<<GBCW PB@A
@A< @LFCEFQ@B'C
) K'IL@ LI><G BC ?FT'L '? @A< Q>B<C@9 E@F@BCW @AF@ ML<FQA<E '? F
?BGIQBFLN L<>F@B'CEAB= BC FCN Q'C@<Z@ Q'R=LBE< F E=<QBF> ML<<G '?QFE<E @AF@ '?@<C >''E<C C'LRF>>N E@LBCW<C@ L<\IBL<R<C@E '?
QFIEF@B'C FCG GFRFW<E
• K+", *-."$,/+,L 1$(-'.U V$//$.U 1'(-*6(U M(-/#(-)U (/4 1#5:6$. >@W@ ,@
1'#$66$C
) F Q'C@BCW<C@ ?<< >FPN<L PFE ?BL<G EA'L@>N M<?'L< @A< <CG '?
Q'R=><@B'C '? ABE P'LX9 FCG E'IWA@ =FNR<C@ M(/+,(- -%$(*, '?
P'LX G'C<
) >FPN<L PFE ?BL<G ?'L QFIE< F?@<L A< E'IWA@ @' =L<EEIL< ABE Q>B<C@
BC@' EBWCBCW F C<P ?<< FWL<<R<C@
) f5 K'IL@ ?'ICG @AF@ @A< >FPN<L BCT'>T<G PFE ?BL<G ?'L QFIE<9 @AIE
G<E<LT<G C' F@@'LC<NiE ?<<E F@ F>>
• K+", *-."$,/+,L P$5/#(-4 ,@ 1(67*/C BC @A< P'LGE '? @A< BC?FR'IE
:IE@BQ< KFLG'a'
V&'@ A'C<E@N F>'C<9 MI@ @A< .(+&,*'*" '? FC A'C'L @A< R'E@ E<CEB@BT<9 BE
@A<C @A< E@FCGFLG '? M<AFTB'L$k
• K+", *-."$,/+,L -9F;?9 T8JL WBT<C MN K'IL@E @' @A< =L'@<Q@B'C '? @A<
>FPN<L)Q>B<C@ Q'C?BG<C@BF>B@N =LBTB><W< UUU 8U98<B? 8P8< JI98= 9H8
98=F:<J9:;< ;I 9H8 =8LJ9:;<?H:A5
• K+", *-."$,/+,L #< 9H8 O;=B? ;I 9H8 G=8J9 +L:P8= c8<B8LL D;LF8?Q 9H8
LJO@
V&P8=N EJLL:<G :? G=8J9 OH8< G=8J9LN AK=?K8B $ YI@ ZZZ BC PAF@ '@A<LG'<E 'C< =>ICW< E' G<<= BC @A< E@L<FR '? >B?< ) E' EAFL< B@E =FEEB'CE B@E
MF@@><E9 B@E G<E=FBL9 B@E @LBIR=AE9 M'@A FE PB@C<EE FCG FQ@'Lb Z Z Z YI@
@AF@ BE C'@ F>>$ cHJ9 J ?KMa8E9 :? 9H:? :< OH:EH O8 J=8 K<:98B Y 9H:?
JM?9=JE9:;< EJLL8B 9H8 %JOQ OH8=8:< J? :< J FJG:E F:==;=Q O8 ?88
=8IL8E98BQ <;9 ;<LN :< ;K= L:P8?Q MK9 9H8 L:P8? ;I JLL F8< 9HJ9 HJP8
M88<5 VA<C D @ABCX 'C @ABE RFe<E@BQ @A<R< RN <N<E GFaa><$ #I O8 J=8
9; ?A8J` ;I 9H8 LJO J? ;K= F:?9=8??Q O8 OH; J=8 H8=8 `<;O 9HJ9 ?H8 :?
J F:?9=8?? ;<LN 9; M8 O;< O:9H ?K?9J:<8B J<B L;<8LN AJ??:;< ) 'C>N @'
M< P'C MN E@LFBCBCW F>> @A< ?FQI>@B<E MN PABQA RFC BE >BX<C<G @' #'G$h
/!!%C#.' 0D& 3+"&'+#.' 0+ 0D& 3/*01 +3 0D& */1& /0 d/"
• %UK7;c KBTB> KFE< &'$ 00 F>><W<G @AF@ @A< G<?<CGFC@E @A<L<BC9 BCQ>IGBCW
A<L<BC =<@B@B'C<LE FCG UGIFLG' K'eIFCWQ'9 :L$c
) Q'CE=BL<G PB@A <FQA '@A<L BC E<@@BCW I= @AL'IWA @A< IE< '? Q'Q'CI@
><TN ?ICGE @A< ?BCFCQBF> FCG Q'L='LF@< ?LFR<P'LX FCG E@LIQ@IL<E
@AF@ ><G @' @A< <E@FM>BEAR<C@ '? fK;Y9 f&DK4[ FCG '@A<LE
) @AF@ @AL'IWA BCEBGB'IE R<FCE FCG RFQABCF@B'CE9 7KK%79 IEBCW B@E
PA'>>N)'PC<G BCT<E@R<C@ FLR9 7KK%7 DCT<E@R<C@E K'L='LF@B'C9
M<QFR< @A< A'>G<L '? F==L'ZBRF@<>N ?B?@<<C RB>>B'C EAFL<EL<=L<E<C@BCW L'IWA>N 0$0p '? @A< @'@F> QF=B@F> E@'QX '? fK;Y
• ;K## PFC@<G @' <E@FM>BEA @AL'IWA @A< 7KK%7 >FPN<LE @AF@ [L$
K'eIFCWQ' BE @A<BL Q>B<C@ FCG B@ PFE K'eIFCWQ' PA' ?ILCBEA<G F>> @A<
R'CB<E @' @A< EIMEQLB=@B'C =FNR<C@d A<CQ<9 =<@B@B'C<LE FQ@<G FE
GIRRB<E9 C'RBC<<E FCG1'L FW<C@E MN F>>'PBCW @A<RE<>T<E9 FR'CW
'@A<LE9 @' M< IE<G FE BCE@LIR<C@ BC FQQIRI>F@BCW B>>)W'@@<C P<F>@A
• YN Q'R=<>>BCW =<@B@B'C<LE9 @A< ;K## P'I>G <ZFQ@ ?L'R =<@B@B'C<LE F
>BCX g@AF@ P'I>G BC<TB@FM>N ?'LR @A< QAFBC '? @<E@BR'CN C<Q<EEFLN @'
Q'CTBQ@ @A< ^Q>B<C@_ '? F QLBR<$h
0D#"( #11-&
• %<E='CG<C@E ?FB><G @' EA'P ) J<B JM?;LK98LN <;9H:<G 8U:?9? :< 9H8
=8E;=B? ;I 9H8 EJ?8 J9 MJ= ) @AF@ =LBTF@< L<E='CG<C@ FQ@IF>>N L<T<F><G
@A< BG<C@B@N '? ABE Q>B<C@^E_ @' @A< ;K##$
• 6*+&% ,7% (+2%$,/?*+I 7/..%+) ," 9% ,7% '%*,-",*# "# ,7% %+,*$%
/$$/+I%-%+, 9%,=%%+ N$4 E"&" /+2 ,7% F:OOA /+ (+2%$,/?*+I =7*&7 *)
)" -/,%$*/' /) ," 7/3% H(),*#*%2 F:OOP) ).%&*/' ,$%/,-%+, %B%-.,*+I ,7%
.$*3/,% $%)."+2%+, #$"- .$")%&(,*"+A $%)."+2%+, 6/+2*I/+9/1/+
)7"('2 7/3% $%M(*$%2 .$""# "# ,7% (+2%$,/?*+I -"$% )(9),/+,*/' ,7/+ /
Q9/$% /))%$,*"+Q ,7/, .$*3/,% $%)."+2%+, 2*2 *+2%%2 &"-.'1 =*,7 ,7%
(+2%$,/?*+I$• 6A< ??$ P<L< @A< 'C>N =L''? =L<E<C@<Gc
"$ @P' L<\I<E@E ?'L L<)BCT<E@BWF@B'C
X5 'C< G'QIR<C@ PABQA GBEQ>'E<G Q<L@FBC Q>B<C@E PABQA =<@B@B'C<LE
^7KK%7 >FPN<LE_ P<L< @A<RE<>T<E PB>>BCW @' L<T<F>
! Q>B<C@E @' PA'R M'@A =<@B@B'C<LE FCG %'Q' L<CG<L<G ><WF>
E<LTBQ<E PAB>< F>> '? @A<R P<L< =FL@C<LE F@ 7KK%7d C'@ @A< Q>B<C@E
PABQA @A< ;K## PFC@<G GBEQ>'E<G ?'L @A< F>><W<G \I<E@B'C<G
@LFCEFQ@B'CE
1-,,#.' #0 /%% -!
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 12/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"*
• 6A< Q'CGB@B'C =L<Q<G<C@ L<\IBL<G MN ;K## ?'L @A< <ZQ>IEB'C '?
=<@B@B'C<LE 7KK%7 >FPN<LEc
) TB'>F@<E @A< >FPN<L)Q>B<C@ Q'C?BG<C@BF>B@N =LBTB><W<
) Q'CE@B@I@<E F @LFCEWL<EEB'C MN L<E='CG<C@E 5FCGBWFCMFNFC FCG
;K## '? @A< <\IF> =L'@<Q@B'C Q>FIE<
) ;K##OE G<RFCG C'@ 'C>N @'IQA<E I='C @A< \I<E@B'C '? @A< BG<C@B@N
'? @A<BL Q>B<C@E MI@ F>E' 'C G'QIR<C@E L<>F@<G @' @A< EIE=<Q@<G
@LFCEFQ@B'CE9 C'@ 'C>N BC TB'>F@B'C '? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<MI@ F>E' '? @A< Q'CE@B@I@B'CF> LBWA@ FWFBCE@ E<>?)BCQLBRBCF@B'C$
• VABQA<T<L PFN N'I >''X F@ B@c HD5SD&# Ut;U8D6D4&
• 7C FLWIR<C@ BE FGTFCQ<G @AF@ @A< BCT'QF@B'C '? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@
=LBTB><W< BE =L<RF@IL< FCG @AF@ @A<N EA'I>G PFB@ IC@B> @A<N FL< QF>><G @'
@<E@B?N FCG <ZFRBC< FE PB@C<EE<E FE @' RF@@<LE ><FLC<G BC Q'C?BG<CQ<$
) YI@ =<@B@B'C<LE FL< C'@ R<L< PB@C<EE<E$ 6A<N FL< Q')=LBCQB=F>E BC
@A< QFE< ?'L L<Q'T<LN '? F>><W<G B>>)W'@@<C P<F>@A$
) K'CE@B@I@B'CF> LBWA@ FWFBCE@ E<>?)BCQLBRBCF@B'C FCG '? @A<BL
?ICGFR<C@F> ><WF> LBWA@ @' RFBC@FBC BCTB'>F@< @A< =LBTB><W< '?
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ Q'C?BG<C@BF>B@N$
)
6A< QFE< AFCWE FE F L<F> FCG =F>=FM>< @AL<F@9 J A=;P8=M:JL 1O;=B
;I (JF;EL8? ;P8= A89:9:;<8=?b H8JB?5
• cH:L8 O8 J=8 JOJ=8 ;I =8?A;<B8<9 !*''R? L8GJL FJ<BJ98 9; =8E;P8=
:LLYG;998< O8JL9HQ O8 O:LL <;9 ?J<E9:;< JE9? OH:EH P:;LJ98 9H8 8SKJL
A=;98E9:;< GKJ=J<988 J<B 9H8 =:GH9 JGJ:<?9 ?8LIY:<E=:F:<J9:;< J<B
?KMP8=9 9H8 LJON8=YEL:8<9 E;<I:B8<9:JL:9N A=:P:L8G85
1&!/"/0& +!#.#+.
$:9KG
• 6A< ><WF> =L'?<EEB'C9 G<E=B@< F>> @A< ICL<E@LFBC<G QF>IRCN AIL><G FWFBCE@
B@9 BE E@B>> @A< C'M><E@ '? =L'?<EEB'CE$• 6A< =L'@<Q@B'C '? E;<I:B8<9:JL:9N ;I 9H8 LJON8=YEL:8<9 =8LJ9:;<?H:A BE 'C<9
FCG B@ AFE EBCQ< M<<C FC FQQ<=@<G ?BLRFR<C@ BC @A< =L'?<EEB'C$ D@ JLL;O?
9H8 LJON8= J<B 9H8 EL:8<9 9; :<?9:9K9:;<JL:T8 J K<:SK8 =8LJ9:;<?H:A MJ?8B
;< IKLL 9=K?9 J<B E;<I:B8<E8 8??8<9:JL :< J aK?9:E8 ?N?98F @AF@ P'LXE 'C
@A< MFEBE '? EIME@FC@BT< FCG =L'Q<GILF> GI< =L'Q<EE$
• 6A< LI>< BE C'@ PB@A'I@ B@E =B@?F>>E MI@ @A<E< =L'M><RE FL<9 BC @A< I>@BRF@<
FCF>NEBE9 C' R'L< @AFC R<L< @<E@E '? TBW'L @AF@ AFT< RFG< FCG PB>> RFX<
@AF@ LI>< <CGIL<$
• D E<< BC @A< QFE< M<?'L< IE F EB@IF@B'C '? @A< %<=IM>BQ F@@<R=@BCW @'
<E@FM>BEA F QFE< C'@ 'C PAF@ B@ =<LQ<BT<E @' M< @A< E@L<CW@A '? B@E 'PC
<TBG<CQ< MI@ 'C PAF@ B@ Q'I>G <>BQB@ ?L'R F Q'ICE<> FWFBCE@ ABE Q>B<C@$ # I:<B
:9 K<=8J?;<JML85
(#11&.0#.' +!#.#+.1
(/$#(&Q ]"5
• D E@L'CW>N ?<<> @AF@ @ABE K'IL@ RIE@ Q'C?BC< B@E<>? @' @A< X<N BEEI<c PA<@A<L
'L C'@ @A< 5FCGBWFCMFNFC FQ@<G PB@A WLFT< FMIE< '? GBEQL<@B'C BC C'@<ZQ>IGBCW @A< G<?<CGFC@E9 @A< =<@B@B'C<LE A<L<BC9 ?L'R @A< 6ABLG 7R<CG<G
K'R=>FBC@$
- 6AF@ BEEI<9 IC?'L@ICF@<>N9 AFE M<<C EBR=>N MILB<G ICG<L @A< FTF>FCQA<
'? FI@A'LB@B<E I=A'>GBCW @A< EFCQ@B@N '? >FPN<L)Q>B<C@ L<>F@B'CEAB=
PABQA F==<FLE @' R< @' M< =L<RF@IL<>N BCT'X<G$
- 6A< =L<L'WF@BT< @' G<@<LRBC< PA' EAF>> M< RFG< G<?<CGFC@E BC F QBTB>
QFE< BE BCB@BF>>N T<E@<G BC @A< =>FBC@B??9 'L @A< ;K## BC @ABE QFE<$ 6A<
Q'C@L'> '? @A< K'IL@ Q'R<E BC 'C>N PA<C @A< BEEI< '? kBC@<L<E@k ^<$W$
P1C FC BCGBE=<CEFM>< =FL@N AFE C'@ M<<C e'BC<G9 P1C @A<L<OE F
RBEe'BCG<L_ BE LFBE<G$
-6A< =<@B@B'C<LE E<<X @' M< FQQ'LG<G @A< EFR< M<C<?B@ WLFC@<G @' 'L @'
M< EBRB>FL>N @L<F@<G FE %'Q'$ %<FE'C FCG >'WBQ GBQ@F@< @AF@ @A<N QFCC'@9
IC><EE @A<N @'' P'I>G RFX< @A<RE<>T<E >BX< %'Q'$ 6A<N GBG C'@ G' E'
M<QFIE< @A<N M<>B<T<G @AF@ Q'R=>BFCQ< @A<L<'? P'I>G ML<FQA @A<
EFCQ@B@N '? @A<BL ?BGIQBFLN GI@N BC F >FPN<L)Q>B<C@ L<>F@B'CEAB=$
- 7E F RF@@<L '? ?FQ@9 @A< ;K## =L<E<C@<G <TBG<CQ< @' EIME@FC@BF@<
%'Q'iE Q'R=>BFCQ<$ ^@A<E< P<L< @A< EFR< 'C<E QB@<G BC @A< RFe'LB@N
'=BCB'C9 =>E QA<QX CF >FCW_
• 6A< LI>< '? Q'C?BG<C@BF>B@N ICG<L @A< >FPN<L)Q>B<C@ L<>F@B'CEAB= RFN 'C>N
M< BCT'X<G F@ @A< F==L'=LBF@< @BR<9 B$<$c PA<C F >FPN<L BE ICG<L
Q'R=I>EB'C @' FCEP<L FE PB@C<EE9 FE PA<Cc- AFTBCW @FX<C @A< PB@C<EE E@FCG9 A< BE \I<E@B'C<G FE @' EIQA
Q'C?BG<C@BF> Q'RRICBQF@B'C 'L FGTBQ<
- A< BE M<BCW '@A<LPBE< eIGBQBF>>N Q'<LQ<G @' =L'GIQ<9 @AL'IWA
EIM='<CF< GIQ<E @<QIR 'L '@A<LPBE<9 ><@@<LE 'L '@A<L G'QIR<C@E
Q'C@FBCBCW @A< EFR< =LBTB><W<G RF@@<L$
• SN='@A<@BQF>>N FGRB@@BCW @A< F>><WF@B'CE BC @A< Q'R=>FBC@ BC KBTB> KFE< &'$
//009 D ?BCG RNE<>? ICFM>< @' FWL<< PB@A @A< RFe'LB@N '=BCB'C9 PABQA E<<XE
@' <Z=FCG @A< EQ'=< '? @A< ;AB>B==BC< LI>< 'C @A< >FPN<L)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< MN
Q'=B'IE QB@F@B'CE '? 7R<LBQFC eILBE=LIG<CQ<$
•
HL'R @A< =><@A'LF '? QFE<E QB@<G9 @P' ?FQ@E E@FCG 'I@ BC M'>G L<>B<?$
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 13/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"0
"$ @A< BEEI< '? =LBTB><W< Q'C@<E@<G @A<L<BC FL'E< BC WLFCG eILN
=L'Q<<GBCWE 'C GB??<L<C@ 5@F@<E9 PABQA FL< =LBRFLB>N =L'Q<<GBCWE
M<?'L< @A< ?B>BCW '? @A< QFE< BC Q'IL@9 FCG P< FL< C'@ <T<C @'>G PAF@
<TBG<C@BFLN LI><E F==>N BC @A< EFBG A<FLBCWE$
! DC @A< =L<E<C@ QFE<9 @A< =LBTB><W< BE BCT'X<G BC @A< Q'IL@ PA<L< B@
PFE F>L<FGN ?B><G$
*$ DC @A< QFE<E QB@<G MN @A< RFe'LB@N9 @A< >FPN<LE Q'CQ<LC<G P<L<
R<L<>N FGT'QF@BCW @A< QFIE< '? @A<BL Q>B<C@E MI@ P<L< C'@ BCGBQ@<G?'L @A< QAFLW<E FWFBCE@ @A<BL EFBG Q>B<C@E$
! S<L<9 @A< Q'ICE<> @A<RE<>T<E FL< Q')G<?<CGFC@E GI>N QAFLW<G BC
Q'IL@ FE Q')Q'CE=BLF@'LE BC @A< '??<CE<E QAFLW<G$ 6A< QFE<E QB@<G MN
@A< RFe'LB@N <TBG<C@>N G' C'@ F==>N @' @A<R$
• 6A< >FPN<L)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BE C'@ F EAB<>G ?'L @A< Q'RRBEEB'C '? F QLBR< 'L
FWFBCE@ @A< =L'E<QI@B'C '? @A< >FPN<L @A<L<?'L$
- "KL8 45hXQ *J<;< 4Q *;B8 ;I !=;I8??:;<JL "8?A;<?:M:L:9N@ >FPN<LE FL<
RFCGF@<G C'@ @' Q'ICE<> 'L FM<@ FQ@BTB@B<E FBR<G F@ G<?BFCQ< '? @A<
>FP 'L F@ ><EE<CBCW Q'C?BG<CQ< BC @A< ><WF> ENE@<R
- "KL8 4Z5h4Q *J<;< 4Z@ @' <R=>'N 'C>N ?FBL FCG A'C<E@ R<FCE @' F@@FBC
@A< >FP?I> 'Me<Q@BT<E '? ABE Q>B<C@
- *J<;< 4_Q *J<;< ;I !=;I8??:;<JL &9H:E?@ F >FPN<L RIE@ E@<FG?FE@>N
M<FL BC RBCG @AF@ ABE WL<F@ @LIE@ BE @' M< =<L?'LR<G PB@ABC FCG C'@
PB@A'I@ @A< M'ICGE '? @A< >FP
- *J<;< [X@ ABE ICG<L@FXBCW <ZFQ@ Q'R=>BFCQ< PB@A @A< E@LBQ@<E@
=LBCQB=><E '? R'LF> >FP
• D& 5f[c 0H8?8 EJ<;<? ?9=:A J LJON8= ;I 9H8 LJON8=YEL:8<9Q A=:P:L8G8
OH8<8P8= H8 E;<?A:=8? O:9H 9H8 EL:8<9 :< 9H8 E;FF:??:;< ;I J E=:F8 ;= J
I=JKB5
• "J9:;<JL8 ;I =KL8 8UE8A9:<G E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? O:9H =8?A8E9 9;
E;<98FALJ98B E=:F:<JL ;= I=JKBKL8<9 JE9@- 6A< L<FE'C =<LAF=E R'E@ ?L<\I<C@>N FGTFCQ<G BE @AF@ BC EIQA QFE<E
@A<L< BE C' =L'?<EEB'CF> <R=>'NR<C@9 =L'=<L>N E=<FXBCW$
- R# 7*) &$*-*+/' "9H%&, *) /3"=%2A ,7% &'*%+, 2"%) +", &"+)(', 7*) /23*)%$
.$"#%))*"+/''1 9 M<QFIE< B@ QFCC'@ M< @A< E'>BQB@'LiE MIEBC<EE @' ?IL@A<L
FCN QLBRBCF> 'Me<Q@$
- R# ,7% &'*%+, 2"%) +", /3"= 7*) "9H%&,A 7% $%.")%) +" &"+#*2%+&%9 ?'L @A<
E@F@< '? ?FQ@E PABQA BE @A< ?'ICGF@B'C '? @A< EI=='E<G Q'C?BG<CQ< G'<E
C'@ <ZBE@$ 0H8 ?;L:E:9;=b? JBP:E8 :? ;M9J:<8B MN J I=JKB5
- D@ BE C' =FL@ '? @A< =L'?<EEB'C '? FC F@@'LC<N 'L Q'ICE<>'L F@ >FP @' M<
FGTBEBCW =<LE'CE FE @' A'P @A<N RFN Q'RRB@ QLBR<E 'L ?LFIGE9 'L A'P@A<N RFN <EQF=< @A< Q'CE<\I<CQ<E '? Q'C@<R=>F@<G QLBR<E FCG ?LFIGE
- 6A<N @A<C AJ=9J`8 ;I 9H8 <J9K=8 ;I J E;<?A:=JENQ ;= J998FA98B
E;<?A:=JEN 9 FCG B@ BE <;9 ;<LN LJOIKL 9; B:PKLG8 EIQA Q'RRICBQF@B'CE9
MI@ ICG<L Q<L@FBC QBLQIRE@FCQ<E :9 F:GH9 M8E;F8 9H8 BK9N ;I 9H8
J99;=<8N 9; B; ?;$
- D@ P'I>G M< R'CE@L'IE @' A'>G @AF@ BC EIQA F QFE< @A< >B=E '? @A<
F@@'LC<N P'I>G M< E<F><G9 PA<C @A< ?FQ@E RBWA@ M<Q'R< BR='L@FC@ @'
@A< <CGE '? eIE@BQ< BC @A< =L'E<QI@B'C '? QLBR<$ ;IM>BQ ='>BQN P'I>G
?'LMBG B@$• /? 9; B:?EL;?:<G 9H8 :B8<9:9N ;I 9H8 EL:8<9@
- VA<L< FC ICGBEQ>'E<G Q>B<C@ BE F =FL@N @' FC FQ@B'C9 @A< '=='EBCW =FL@N
AFE F LBWA@ @' XC'P PB@A PA'R A< BE Q'C@<CGBCW 'L PA' @A< L<F> =FL@N
BC BC@<L<E@ BE9 B? C'@ @A< C'RBCF> FGT<LEFLN$ ^7R :IL_
- 7 >B@BWFC@ QFCC'@ M< 'M>BW<G @' E@LIWW>< BC @A< GFLX FWFBCE@ ICXC'PC
?'LQ<E$
- 6A< =LBTB><W< QFCC'@ M< IE<G @' <TFG< F Q>B<C@iE L<E='CEBMB>B@N ?'L @A<
IE< '? ><WF> =L'Q<EE
!-.+Q ]5
• 6A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BE @A< '>G<E@ '? @A< =LBTB><W<E ?'L Q'C?BG<C@BF>
Q'RRICBQF@B'CE XC'PC @' @A< Q'RR'C >FP$
• DC @A< QFE< F@ MFL9 @A<L< BE F 6%D(U[[7 ^AFAF RFN WFCB@' =F>F_
"$ 4C< ;P8==:B:<G A;L:EN E;<?:B8=J9:;< :? 9H8 <88B I;= E;K=9? 9;
B:?E;P8= 9H8 9=K9H I;= 9=K9H JL;<8 :? 9H8 9=K8 9;KEH?9;<8 ;I aK?9:E8
*$ U\IF>>N Q'R=<>>BCW BE @A< C<<G @' =L'@<Q@ @A< FGT<LEFLN ENE@<R '?
eIE@BQ< PA<L< @LI@A BE M<E@ <Z@LFQ@<G MN WBTBCW F Q>B<C@ ML'FG =LBTB><W<
@' Q'C?BG< ?FQ@E @' ABE Q'ICE<>
0$ 5BRB>FL>N G<E<LTBCW '? E<GI>'IE Q'CQ<LC BE @A< C<<G @' X<<= BCTB'>F@<
@A< Q'CE@B@I@B'CF> LBWA@ FWFBCE@ E<>?)BCQLBRBCF@B'C FCG @A< LBWA@ @'
<??<Q@BT< Q'ICE<> BC QLBRBCF> >B@BWF@B'CE$• 6A<E< E;FA89:<G ?;E:89JL :<98=8?9? G<RFCG @AF@ F==>BQF@B'C '? @A<
=LBTB><W< C'@ <ZQ<<G @AF@ PABQA BE C<Q<EEFLN @' <??<Q@ @A< ='>BQN
Q'CEBG<LF@B'CE ICG<L>NBCW @A< =LBTB><W<9 * $%$9 @A< A=:P:L8G8 FK?9 M8 KAH8LB
;<LN :< 9H;?8 E:=EKF?9J<E8? I;= OH:EH :9 OJ? E=8J98B
• 6A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< QFC C<T<L M< IE<G FE F EAB<>G @' Q'RRB@ F
QLBR< 'L F ?LFIG$
• K'RRICBQF@B'CE @' FC F@@'LC<N AFTBCW ?'L @A<BL 'Me<Q@ @A< Q'RRBEEB'C '?
F QLBR< kZ Z Z =FL@FX< @A< CF@IL< '? F Q'CE=BLFQN9 FCG B@ BE C'@ 'C>N >FP?I>
@' GBTI>W< EIQA Q'RRICBQF@B'CE9 MI@ ICG<L Q<L@FBC QBLQIRE@FCQ<E B@ RBWA@
M<Q'R< @A< GI@N '? @A< F@@'LC<N @' G' E'$ ^7R<LBQFC (FP %<='L@E7CC'@F@<Gd lU59 =FL<A' EB>F CB 8FTBG< CF CFW)QB@< CB@' $ _
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 14/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
",
• 7E F W<C<LF> LI><9 @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< G'<E C'@ BCQ>IG< @A< LBWA@
'? C'C)GBEQ>'EIL< '? Q>B<C@ BG<C@B@N$ 0H8 G8<8=JL =KL8 J<B :9? 8UE8A9:;<?
J=8 JEEK=J98LN ?KFFJ=:T8B :< #< =8 '=J<B ]K=N #<P8?9:GJ9:;<5 ^7CW AFMF
WINE9 GB X' CF <>FM'LF@< EBCQ< @ABE QFE< BE BC @A< EN>>FMIE GBC CFRFC_
• # a;:< 9H8 FJa;=:9N :< H;LB:<G 9HJ9 @A< 5FCGBWFCMFNFC Q'RRB@@<G WLFT<
FMIE< '? GBEQL<@B'C MN ?FB>BCW @' L<Q'WCBa< @A< <ZQ<=@B'CE GBEQIEE<G FM'T<$
• # AJ=9 OJN? O:9H 9H8 FJa;=:9N OH8< :9 =KL8B 9HJ9 =<@B@B'C<LE C<<G C'@
=L'T< @A<N ?F>> PB@ABC @A< <ZQ<=@B'CE @' @A< W<C<LF> LI><$- 6A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BE C'@ F RFWBQ RFC@LF PA'E< BCT'QF@B'C
PB>> *.)" #/&," FCG *.)" H($% GLF=< A< PA' BCT'X<E B@ PB@A B@E =L'@<Q@B'C$
- 6A< =<LE'C Q>FBRBCW @A< =LBTB><W< 'L B@E <ZQ<=@B'C AFE @A< 'M>BWF@B'C @'
=L<E<C@ @A< ICG<L>NBCW ?FQ@E G<R'CE@LF@BCW @A< <ZBE@<CQ< '? @A<
=LBTB><W<
- DC @A< QFE< F@ MFL9 B@ QFCC'@ M< WFBCEFBG @AF@ A89:9:;<8=? HJP8 <;9
JBBKE8B 8P:B8<E8 9HJ9 9H8N IJLL O:9H:< J<N ;I 9H8 JM;P8 F8<9:;<8B
8UE8A9:;<? I;= J? JI;=8?9J98BQ 9H8 1J<B:GJ<MJNJ< B:B <;9 =8E;G<:T8
9H8 8UE8A9:;<?Q H8<E8Q 9H8 ;=B8= E;FA8LL:<G 9H8F 9; =8P8JL 9H8
:B8<9:9N ;I 9H8:= EL:8<95
- #9 ?88F? 9; F8 8P:B8<9 9HJ9 n9H8 P8=N JE9:P:9N I;= OH:EH H8 ?;KGH9 9H8
LJON8=b? JBP:E8n :? ( ;+$%)5*/ *0 0(') 8#5'# 7+%) 05-%) <$ $%)(<65%#$4
<$0*-$ )#$-$ '(/ <$ (/. -+65/= )#() )#$ $G'$:)5*/ '(/ <$ 5/,*9$4@
- 7E @' @A< <ZQ<=@B'C nOH8=8 9H8 G;P8=<F8<9b? LJON8=? HJP8 <; EJ?8
JGJ:<?9 J< J99;=<8Nb? EL:8<9 K<L8??Q MN =8P8JL:<G 9H8 EL:8<9b? <JF8Q 9H8
?J:B <JF8 O;KLB IK=<:?H 9H8 ;<LN L:<` 9HJ9 O;KLB I;=F 9H8 EHJ:< ;I
98?9:F;<N <8E8??J=N 9; E;<P:E9 J< :<B:P:BKJL ;I J E=:F8W@
^"_ A'P QFC P< G<@<LRBC< @AF@ ;K## AFE kC' QFE<k FWFBCE@
=<@B@B'C<LE PB@A'I@ =L<E<C@F@B'C '? <TBG<CQ<b
^*_ A'P QFC P< G<@<LRBC< @AF@ @A< CFR< '? @A< Q>B<C@ BE @A< 'C>N >BCX
PB@A'I@ =L<E<C@F@B'C '? <TBG<CQ< FE @' @A< '@A<L >BCXEb- #< 9H8 E:98B EJ?8 ;I M(5-4 A @A< ?FQ@IF> MFEBE ?'L @A< LI>BCW PFE =L'=<L>N
<E@FM>BEA<G MN @A< =FL@B<E$ #< 9H8 EJ?8 J9 MJ=9 @A<L< BE C' <TBG<CQ<
FM'I@ @A< EIMe<Q@ RF@@<L '? @A< Q'CEI>@F@B'C RFG< MN =<@B@B'C<LEi
Q>B<C@$
[5 d/"0+. $15 %&C0& /1!D/%0 o ,#.&"/% +#% *+ 6"17
&'$ *"*02.[FLQA **9 "+*,.5@L<<@9 :$
;>FBC@B??)F==<>><<c :FR<E YFL@'C
8<?<CGFC@)F==<>>FC@c (<N@< 7E=AF>@ u [BC<LF> 4B> K'$9 (68$ ^gK'R=FCNh_
q'"+IA &"+#()*+I &/)%S &".1 "# ,7% &"+,$/&, (.'"/2%2 ," 2$".9"BS .'%/)% )%%
)(--/$1 #"$ ,7% -/*+ ."*+,)S 7*I7'*I7,%2 *-."$,/+, %B7*9*,)A 9(, ,7%1 2"+T,
7/3% /+1 9%/$*+I "+ ,7% -/*+ 2"&,$*+% )*+&% ,7% '/,,%$ $%'/,%) ," / .*%&% "#
%3*2%+&% ,7/, #*$), /..%/$) *+ ,7% $/,*"4
1-,,/"C
YFL@'C FCG (<N@< <C@<L<G BC@' F Q'C@LFQ@9 FI@A'LBaBCW @A< ?'LR<L @' E<>> @A<
MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< =L'GIQ@E '? (<N@<$ YFL@'C <C@<L<G BC@' EIM)FW<CQNQ'C@LFQ@E PB@A <C@B@B<E BC @A< f59 7IE@LF>BF FCG :F=FC9 PB@A'I@ BC?'LRBCW (<N@<
'? EIQA EIM)FW<CQN FWL<<R<C@E$ &<W'@BF@B'CE <CEI<G$ 6A< Q'R=FCNOE FEEBE@FC@
RFCFW<L >F@<L BC?'LR<G YFL@'C @AF@ C' 'LG<LE QFC M< <C@<L@FBC<G IC><EE QFEA
AFE M<<C FQ@IF>>N G<='EB@<G$ YFL@'C \I<E@B'C<G @A< LBWA@ '? @A< Q'R=FCN @'
BCEBE@ I='C F QFEA G<='EB@ BC K<MI M<?'L< ?B>>BCW @A< 'LG<LE$ YFL@'C ?B><G F QFE<
?'L GFRFW<E BC @A< KHD)[FCB>F ?'L ML<FQA '? Q'C@LFQ@$ KHD LI><G ?'L YFL@'C$
D55fUc V& @A< G'QIR<C@E <TBG<CQBCW @A< 'LG<LE RFG< MN YFL@'COE F>><W<G
EIM)FW<C@E FL< EI??BQB<C@ @' EI=='L@ @A< eIGWR<C@ L<CG<L<G MN @A< @LBF> Q'IL@$
o &4$ :IGW<R<C@ L<T<LE<G$ 5fY567&6DJU [766U%c 7L@BQ>< *]2 '? @A< K'G< '?
K'RR<LQ< G<Q>FL<E @AF@ C' FW<C@ EAF>> =ILQAFE< ?'L ABRE<>? 'L ?'L FC'@A<L
@AF@ PABQA A< AFE M<<C 'LG<L<G @' E<>>$ 6A< >FP AFE =>FQ<G B@E MFC I='C F
ML'X<LiE =ILQAFEBCW ?L'R ABE =LBCQB=F> IC><EE @A< >F@@<L PB@A ?I>> XC'P><GW< '?
F>> @A< ?FQ@E FCG QBLQIRE@FCQ<E FQ\IB<EQ<E BC EIQA Q'ILE<d FCG <T<C @A<C @A<
ML'X<LiE FQ@B'C RIE@ M< QAFLFQ@<LBa<G MN @A< I@R'E@ W''G ?FB@A$ 7 EF>< RFG<
MN F ML'X<L @' ABRE<>? PB@A'I@ @A< Q'CE<C@ '? @A< =LBCQB=F> BE BC<??<Q@IF>
PA<@A<L @A< ML'X<L AFE M<<C WIB>@N '? ?LFIGI><C@ Q'CGIQ@ 'L C'@$ ;%4KU8f%7(
[766U%c UZABMB@ ", F==<FLE ?'L @A< "E@
@BR< BC @A< LF@B'd '??<L<G MN @A<
Q'R=FCNOE Q'ICE<>$ D@ BE F QFLM'C Q'=N '? F ><@@<L MN YFL@'C FGGL<EE<G @' ABE
F@@'LC<N DCW<LE'>> E@F@BCW9 *+,%$ /'*/9 YFL@'COE ='@<C@BF> =L'?B@E ?L'R ABE f5
Q'C@LFQ@$ YFL@'COE Q'ICE<> 'Me<Q@<G @' B@E F>>'PFCQ< 'C @A< WL'ICG '? F@@N)
Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ KHD EIE@FBC<G @A< 'Me<Q@B'C$ 5K EFBG @ABE PFE <LL'L$ &P8<?KAA;?:<G 9HJ9 9H8 L8998= OJ? O:9H:< 9H8 A=:P:L8G8 9HJ9 A=;98E9?
E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? M89O88< J99;=<8N J<B EL:8<9Q 9H:? A=:P:L8G8 OJ? L;?9 OH8<
9H8 L8998= EJF8 9; 9H8 HJ<B? ;I 9H8 JBP8=?8 AJ=9N5 /<B :9 FJ`8? <; B:II8=8<E8
H;O 9H8 JBP8=?J=N JESK:=8B A;??8??:;<5 0H8 LJO A=;98E9? 9H8 EL:8<9 I=;F 9H8
8II8E9 ;I B:?EL;?K=8? FJB8 MN H:F 9; H:? J99;=<8N :< 9H8 E;<I:B8<E8 ;I 9H8
L8GJL =8LJ9:;<Q MK9 OH8< ?KEH J B;EKF8<9Q E;<9J:<:<G JBF:??:;<? ;I 9H8 EL:8<9Q
E;F8? 9; 9H8 HJ<B ;I J 9H:=B AJ=9NQ J<B =8JEH8? 9H8 JBP8=?J=NQ :9 :?
JBF:??:ML8 :< 8P:B8<E8$ v[F>Q'R9 :$ GBEE<C@Ew
3/*01
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 15/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"3
• *J?8c 7Q@B'C BCE@B@I@<G BC @A< KHD)[FCB>F MN YFL@'C @' L<Q'T<L ?L'R
(<N@< GFRFW<E ?'L ML<FQA '? Q'C@LFQ@ ^f58 0"-93]0$0/_9 FCG @' E<QIL<
eIGBQBF> =L'C'ICQ<R<C@ FE @' =>FBC@B??OE <C@B@><R<C@ @' FC <Z@<CEB'C '?
@A< @<LRE '? @A< EF><E FW<CQB<E E=<QB?B<G BC @A< Q'C@LFQ@ ^ &UH:M:9 /_
o 6LBF> Q@$ ! FME'>T<G @A< Q'R=FCN ?L'R , '? @A< ] QFIE<E '?
FQ@B'C ^K47E_ BC @A< Q'R=>FBC@ FCG WFT< eIGWR<C@ ?'L YFL@'C
@' L<Q'T<L ?L'R @A< '@A<L * QFIE<E '? FQ@B'C$ 8<?<CGFC@
K'L='LF@B'C F==<F><G ?L'R @ABE 'LG<L$• YFL@'C BE F f5 QB@Ba<C9 [FCB>F L<EBG<C@9 PAB>< (<N@< 7E=AF>@ u [BC<LF>
4B> K'$9 (68$ BE F Q'L='LF@B'C 'LWFCBa<G ICG<L @A< >FPE '? @A< ;AB>B==BC<
DE>FCGE PB@A B@E =LBCQB=F> '??BQ< BC K<MI KB@N$ K'R=FCN F==<FLE @' M<
@A< 'PC<L '? F TF>IFM>< G<='EB@ '? MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< FCG '@A<L
FE=AF>@ =L'GIQ@E9 >'QF@<G 'C @A< DE>FCG '? (<N@< FCG XC'PC FE @A<
8(&*" RBC<$
• ,1*"1"+*/ o VB>>BFR /<B8=?;<9 FE =L<EBG<C@ FCG W<C<LF> RFCFW<L '?
@A< Q'R=FCN9 FGGL<EE<G F ><@@<L ^UZABMB@ Y_ @' YFL@'C9 FI@A'LBaBCW @A<
>F@@<L @' E<>> @A< =L'GIQ@E '? @A< 8(&*" RBC< BC @A< K'RR'CP<F>@A '?
7IE@LF>BF FCG &<P n<F>FCG I='C F EQF>< '? =LBQ<E BCGBQF@<G BC EFBG
><@@<L$
• &UH:M:9 / o RFBC Q'C@LFQ@ I='C PABQA @A< EIB@ BE MFE<Gd K'R=FCNOE
><@@<L @' YFL@'C9 RFXBCW ABR @A< )"'% /+2 %B&'()*3% )/'%) /I%+&1 #"$ ,7%
#"$-%$T) 9*,(-*+"() '*-%),"+% *+ ,7% ,%$$*,"$*%) "# ;(),$/'*/A <%= U4A
V/)-/+*/A 6/*I"+A R+2*/A 6(-/,$/A J/3/A :7*+/A WXA 6*/- /+2 ,7% 6,$/*,)
6%,,'%-%+,)A /')" *+ ,7% 5+*,%2 6,/,%) "# ;-%$*&/4
o 5'9 @A< Q'C@LFQ@ FI@A'LBa<G YFL@'C @' E<>> @A< Q'R=FCNOE
MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C<E$
• 7?@<L Q'C@LFQ@ ^UZABMB@ 7_ M<QFR< <??<Q@BT<9 YFL@'C L<\I<E@<G @A<
Q'R=FCN @' WBT< ABR F EBRB>FL E<>>BCW FW<CQN ?'L :F=FC$ 6A< Q'R=FCN9
@AL'IWA B@E =L<EBG<C@9 7CG<LE'C9 L<=>B<Gco gr P< FL< PB>>BCW @' WBT< N'I9 @A< EFR< Q'RRBEEB'C 'C F>> EF><E
RFG< MN N'I BC :F=FC9 'C @A< EFR< MFEBE FE N'IL 7IE@LF>BFC
EF><E9 MI@ P< G' C'@ ?<<> >BX< WBTBCW N'I F L<WI>FL FW<CQN ?'L
:F=FC IC@B> N'I QFC RFX< E'R< >FLW< EBa<G EF><E @A<L<9
M<QFIE< E'R< '@A<L =<'=>< AFT< WBT<C IE FEEILFCQ<E @AF@ @A<N
QFC AFCG>< 'IL :F=FC<E< EF><E9 @A<L<?'L< P< AFT< G<QBG<G @'
><FT< @ABE FW<CQN '=<C ?'L F @BR<$k
• [<FCPAB><9 YFL@'C P<C@ @' 5FC HLFCQBEQ'd A< <C@<L<G BC@' FC
FWL<<R<C@ PB@A %KBP:G?8< o ,E*K=BN9 PA<L<MN @A< >F@@<L PFE
Q'CE@B@I@<G F ?KMJG8<9 FCG WBT<C @A< E'>< E<>>BCW LBWA@E ?'L @A<MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< =L'GIQ@E '? @A< Q'R=FCN 'C @<LRE E@F@<G BC @A<
><@@<L ^UZABMB@ m_$ 6A< @<LLB@'LN FEEBWC<G @' (IGTBWE<C u [QKILGN
BCQ>IG<G 5FC HLFCQBEQ' FCG KF>B?'LCBF$
o YFL@'C F>E' P<C@ @' 7IE@LF>BF9 FCG RFG< FC FWL<<R<C@ PB@A
3=J<` d5 1F:9H '? 5NGC<N9 PA<L<MN @A< >F@@<L PFE @' FQ@ FE @A<
YFL@'COE EF><E FW<C@ ?'L MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< RBC<G F@ @A<
Q'R=FCNOE \IFLLN BC (<N@<$ ^UZABMB@ x_
• *131"+*" o (IGTBWE<C u [QKILGN PL'@< @' YFL@'C FGTBEBCW ABR @AF@ A<
RBWA@ <C@<L FC 'LG<L ?'L ]m @'CE '? MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< ^&UH:M:9 '_$YFL@'C BRR<GBF@<>N BCG'LE<G ABE FQQ<=@FCQ<
• 01*1"+*" o YFL@'C L<@ILC<G @' [FCB>Fd 7CG<LE'C PL'@< @' ABR @' @A<
<??<Q@ @AF@ @A< Q'R=FCN PFE M<ABCG PB@A Q'CE@LIQ@B'C FCG PFE C'@
FM>< @' AFCG>< MBW Q'C@LFQ@E ^UZABMB@ HH_
• 01"*1"+*" o 7CG<LE'C FCG YFL@'C R<@ BC [FCB>F S'@<>d YFL@'C
BC?'LR<G 7CG<LE'C '? @A< 5FCHLFC 'LG<Ld 7CG<LE'C @'>G YFL@'C @' A'>G
I= BC @A< RF@@<L '? @FXBCW 'LG<LE 'PBCW >FQX '? QF=B@F>$
• 0 GFNE >F@<L9 YFL@'C C'@B?B<G @A< Q'R=FCN @' M< =L<=FL<G @' EAB= 3m
@'CE '? MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< @' :'AC KAF=RFC K'$9 5FCHLFC$
•
0131"+*" ) HLFCX Y$ 5RB@A9 '? 5NGC<N9 QFM><G YFL@'C ?'L FC 'LG<L ?'L 3m@'CE '? MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C<
o 01"3 o YFL@'C FGTBE<G @A< Q'R=FCN @' M< =L<=FL<G @' EAB=
FC'@A<L 3m @'CE '? MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< BC FGGB@B'C @' @A<
BC@<CG<G Q'CEBWCR<C@ ?'L 5FCHLFC$
o S<CLN U$ VAB@< PFE BCGBQF@<G FE @A< CFR< '? @A< =<LE'C
@AL'IWA PA'R @ABE Q'C@LFQ@ AFG M<<C RFG<9 FCG B@ PFE E@F@<G
@AF@ @A< Q'CEBWC<< P'I>G M< CFR<G >F@<L9 C' G<E@BCF@B'C ?'L
@A< EAB=R<C@ M<BCW WBT<C$
o YFL@'C <Z=>FBCE @AF@ @A< CFR< VAB@<9 FE IE<G BC @ABE ><@@<L9
PFE MFE<G 'C FC BC?<L<CQ<9 PABQA A< AFG <LL'C<'IE>N GLFPC
?L'R @A< QFM>< E<C@ MN HLFCX Y$ 5RB@A9 FCG ABE BC@<C@B'C PFE @'AFT< @A< E<Q'CG EAB=R<C@ Q'CEBWC<G @' 7IE@LF>BF BC L<E='CE<
@' 5RB@AiE 'LG<L$
o DC @A< 01"3 ><@@<L9 C' R<C@B'C PFE RFG< '? @A< CFR<E '? @A<
=<LE'C9 'L ?BLR9 ?'L PA'R @A< EAB=R<C@E P<L< L<F>>N BC@<CG<G$
o 6A< 'MTB'IE <Z=>FCF@B'C BC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@A @ABE BE @AF@ YFL@'C
GBG C'@ @A<C QFL< @' L<T<F> @A< ?FQ@ @AF@ @A< @P' 'LG<LE AFG
'LBWBCF@<G ?L'R ABE 'PC EIMFW<C@E BC 5FC HLFCQBEQ' FCG
5NGC<N$
• 01*31"+*" ) 6' YFL@'COE 01"3 ><@@<L9 @A< FEEBE@FC@ RFCFW<L '? @A<
Q'R=FCN L<=>B<G9 FQXC'P><GWBCW @A< L<Q<B=@ '? FC 'LG<L ?'L 3m @'CE '?MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< @' M< Q'CEBWC<G @' :'AC KAF=RFC K'$9 '? 5FC
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 16/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"]
HLFCQBEQ'9 FCG 3m '? @A< EFR< @' M< Q'CEBWC<G @' S<CLN U$ VAB@<d FCG
B@ PFE E@F@<G @AF@ kC' 'LG<LE QFC M< <C@<L@FBC<G IC><EE QFEA AFE M<<C
FQ@IF>>N G<='EB@<G PB@A <B@A<L @A< DC@<LCF@B'CF> YFCXBCW K'L='LF@B'C 'L
@A< KAFL@<L<G YFCX '? DCGBF9 7IE@LF>BF FCG KABCF9 K<MI$k ^UZABMB@ n_
• 01*+1"+*" o YFL@'C L<=>B<G9 \I<E@B'CBCW @A< LBWA@ '? @A< Q'R=FCN @'
BCEBE@ I='C F QFEA G<='EB@ BC K<MI =LB'L @' @A< ?B>>BCW '? @A< 'LG<LE$
o YFL@'Cc kD AFT< FLLFCW<G ?'L G<='EB@E @' M< RFG< 'C @A<E<
FGGB@B'CF> EAB=R<C@E B? N'I PB>> EBWCB?N N'IL FMB>B@N @' ?I>?B>>@A<E< 'LG<LE 'C @A< GF@<E R<C@B'C<G$k &' CFR< PFE
R<C@B'C<G FE @A< =ILQAFE<L9 'L =ILQAFE<LE9 '? @A<E< BC@<CG<G
7IE@LF>BFC Q'CEBWCR<C@E$
• 7?@<L PLB@BCW @A< 01*+ ><@@<L9 YFL@'C P<C@ @' KABCF FCG :F=FC$
o DC 6'XB'9 :F=FC9 A< QFR< BC Q'C@FQ@ PB@A S$ SBPF@FLB9 PA'
F==<FLE @' AFT< M<<C F EIB@FM>< =<LE'C ?'L AFCG>BCW
MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< ?'L Q'CE@LIQ@B'C P'LX BC :F=FC$ DC @A<
><@@<L ^UZABMB@ t_9 SBPF@FLB E=<FXE '? ABRE<>? FE B? A< AFG M<<C
F=='BC@<G <ZQ>IEBT< EF><E FW<C@ ?'L YFL@'C BC :F=FC9 MI@ C'
G'QIR<C@ <Z=L<EE>N F=='BC@BCW ABR EIQA BE BC <TBG<CQ<$
• VAB>< YFL@'C PFE BC 6'XB'9 A< =L'QIL<G @A< ><@@<L ^&UH:M:9 c_9
FGGL<EE<G @' ABRE<>?9 @' M< EBWC<G MN SBPF@FLB$
o 6ABE ><@@<L Q'C@FBCE FC 'LG<L ?'L "m @'CE '? MB@IRBC'IE
>BR<E@'C< ?L'R @A< \IFLLB<E '? @A< Q'R=FCN$
o SBPF@FLB E@F@<E9 k'C L<Q<B=@ '? @A< QFM>< ?L'R N'I9 C'@B?NBCW
R< '? GF@< N'I PB>> M< L<FGN @' EAB=9 FCG F>E' @'CCFW< LF@<9 D
PB>> FWL<< @' @LFCE?<L @AL'IWA @A< YFCX '? 6FBPFC9 '? 6'XB'9 @'
@A< 7EBF YFCXBCW K'L='LF@B'C9 '? [FCB>F9 ;$ D$9 @A< <C@BL<
=FNR<C@ '? s"]9/// W'>G9 @' M< EIMe<Q@ @' 'IL 'LG<L 'C
G<>BT<LN '? G'QIR<C@E Q'T<LBCW MB>> '? >FGBCW '? EAB=R<C@E9 @A<
QIE@'RE L<='L@ '? P<BWA@9 FCG =L<=FBG <Z='L@ @FZ L<Q<B=@$ D PB>>FLLFCW< BC FGTFCQ< F Q'C?BLR<G 'L BLL<T'QFM>< ><@@<L '? QL<GB@
?'L @A< FM'T< FR'IC@E E' @AF@ =FNR<C@ QFC M< 'LG<L<G MN
QFM><9 BC L<=>N @' N'IL QFM>< FGTBEBCW EAB==BCW GF@<$k
• 31"]1"+*" ) DC F ><@@<L ^UZABMB@ t_9 SBPF@FLB BC?'LRE YFL@'C @AF@ A< AFG
EA'PC @A< Q'C@LFQ@9 EBWC<G MN ABRE<>?9 @' @A< EIMRFCFW<L '? @A<
6FBPFC YFCX PA' EFBG @AF@ A< P'I>G M< FM>< @' BEEI<9 I='C L<\I<E@ '?
SBPF@FLB9 F QL<GB@ C'@< ?'L @A< Q'C@LFQ@<G FR'IC@9 MI@ A< FGG<G @AF@
@A< EIMRFCFW<L PFE C'@ =<LE'CF>>N FM>< @' =>FQ< ABE F==L'TF> 'C @A<
Q'C@LFQ@ FE @AF@ PFE F RF@@<L M<N'CG ABE FI@A'LB@N$
•
3131"+*" o ><@@<L Q'C@FBCBCW SBPF@FLBiE 'LG<L ?'L "m @'CE '? MB@IRBC'IE>BR<E@'C<c E@F@<G @AF@ B? @A< RF@<LBF> EA'I>G =L'T< EF@BE?FQ@'LN9 A<
P'I>G Q'C@LFQ@ PB@A YFL@'C ?'L F RBCBRIR \IFC@B@N '? "/m FGGB@B'CF>
@'CE$
o 6A< Q'C@<C@E '? @A< 3131"+*" ><@@<L E<<RE @' AFT< M<<C
Q'CT<N<G9 @A'IWA BR=<L?<Q@>N9 MN YFL@'C @' ABE F@@'LC<N9 [L$
HLFCX Y$ DCW<LE'>>9 '? [FCB>F ^9J`8 <;98 ;I #<G8=?;LL_d
o 31"21"+*" ) DCW<LE'>> FGGL<EE<G F C'@< @' @A< Q'R=FCN BC
K<MI9 C'@B?NBCW @A< >F@@<L YFL@'C AFG FQQ<=@<G FC 'LG<L ?L'R
SBPF@FLB9 '? 6'XB'9 F==L'T<G MN @A< YFCX '? 6FBPFC9 ?'L FRBCBRIR 'LG<L '? "/m @'CE '? @A< E@'C< FCCIF>>N ?'L F =<LB'G
'? 3 N<FLE9 @A< ?BLE@ EAB=R<C@ '? "m @'CE @' M< RFG< FE <FL>N
F?@<L :I>N " FE ='EEBM><$
o 6ABE Q'RRICBQF@B'C GBG C'@ @LI>N L<?><Q@ @A< Q'C@<C@E '?
SBPF@FLBiE ><@@<L9 PABQA QF>><G ICQ'CGB@B'CF>>N ?'L 'C>N "m @'CE9
@A< @FXBCW '? @A< L<RFBCG<L M<BCW Q'C@BCW<C@ I='C ?I@IL<
<T<C@IF>B@B<E$
• 0H8 ;<LN O=:998< E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? M89O88< dJ=9;< J<B 9H8 E;FAJ<N
:< OH:EH 9H8 I;=F8= GJP8 <;9:E8 ;I HJP:<G J<N ;=B8=? ?'L @A< EF>< '?
MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< J=8 9H8 I;K= L8998=? &UH:M:9 CQ //Q ddQ J<B ## $
6A<E< FL< 'LG<LE @' M< Q'CEBWC<G @' ];H< *HJAFJ<9 *;$ '? 5FC
HLFCQBEQ'9 D8<=N &5 cH:989 D:OJ9J=: ;I 0;`:; FCG 35 d5 1F:9H
• YFL@'C ?B><G F EIB@d A< FR<CG<G ABE Q'R=>FBC@ BC PABQA A< E@B=I>F@<G
@A< 'LG<LE @AF@ A< Q>FBRE @' AFT< L<Q<BT<G FCG I='C PABQA ABE ><@@<LE
'? C'@B?BQF@B'C @' @A< Q'R=FCN P<L< MFE<G$
o 7R<CG<G FCEP<Lc @A< CFR< '? (IGTBWE<C u [QKILGN F==<FLE
?'L @A< ?BLE@ @BR<d FCG @A< CFR< '? HLFCX Y$ 5RB@A9 '? 5NGC<N9 BE
IE<G ?'L @A< ?BLE@ @BR< FE @A< E'ILQ< '? @A< BC@<CG<G
Q'CEBWCR<C@E '? @A< ><@@<LE ^&UH:M:9? 'Q %Q ,Q J<B c_9
Q'C@FBCBCW @A< 'LG<LE ?L'R (IGTBW<C u [QKILGN9 HLFCX Y$
5RB@A FCG S$ SBPF@FLB$• 6A< FPFLG MN @A< @LBF> eIGW< BC ?FT'L '? YFL@'C FL< F>> MFE<G I='C @A<
'LG<LE WBT<C MN (IGTBWE<C u [QKILGN ^&UH:M:9 '_9 MN HLFCX Y$ 5RB@A
^&UH:M:9 % J<B ,_9 FCG MN SBPF@FLB BC &UH:M:9 c$
#11-&@ V& @A< 'LG<LE BC &UH:M:9 'Q %Q ,Q J<B c9 BC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@A @A<
EIME<\I<C@ C'@B?BQF@B'C @A<L<'? WBT<C MN YFL@'C @' @A< Q'R=FCN9 FL< EI??BQB<C@
@' EI=='L@ @A< eIGWR<C@ L<CG<L<G MN @A< @LBF> Q'IL@$ o &4$
D&%(@ 4IL Q'CQ>IEB'C I='C @A< <C@BL< L<Q'LG BE @AF@ @A< eIGWR<C@ F==<F><G
?L'R RIE@ M< L<T<LE<Gd FCG @A< G<?<CGFC@ PB>> M< FME'>T<G ?L'R @A<Q'R=>FBC@$
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 17/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"2
"/0#+
1-d10/.0#$& ,/00&"1
• 6A< @LFCEFQ@B'C BCGBQF@<G BC @A< 'LG<LE ?L'R (IGTBWE<C9 u [QKILGN
FCG ?L'R HLFCX Y$ 5RB@A RIE@ M< <ZQ>IG<G ?L'R Q'CEBG<LF@B'C FE
<RFCF@BCW ?L'R =<LE'CE PA' AFG M<<C Q'CE@B@I@<G R<L< FW<C@E '?
YFL@'C$ 6A< 5FC HLFCQBEQ' 'LG<L FCG @A< 7IE@LF>BFC 'LG<LE FL< @A<
EFR< BC ><WF> <??<Q@ FE B? @A<N P<L< 'LG<LE EBWC<G MN YFL@'C FCG GLFPCI='C ABRE<>?d FCG B@ QFCC'@ M< =L<@<CG<G @AF@ @A'E< 'LG<LE L<=L<E<C@
EF><E @' M'CF ?BG< =ILQAFE<LE ?'ICG MN ABR$
• 6A< ;=:G:<JL E;<9=JE9 p&UH:M:9 /q MN PABQA YFL@'C PFE F=='BC@<G EF><E
FW<C@ ?'L F >BRB@<G =<LB'G '? @BR< BC 7IE@LF>BF FCG @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E
E;<98FALJ98B 9HJ9 H8 ?H;KLB I:<B =8L:JML8 J<B ?;LP8<9 MKN8=? OH;
?H;KLB M8 A=8AJ=8B 9; ;ML:GJ98 9H8F?8LP8? 9; 9J`8 9H8 SKJ<9:9N ;I
M:9KF:<;K? L:F8?9;<8 E;<9=JE98B I;= KA;< 98=F? E;<?:?98<9 O:9H 9H8
E;<9=JE9$
o 0H8?8 E;<B:9:;<? O8=8 <;9 F89 MN 9H8 9J`:<G ;I 9H8?8 ;=B8=?
I=;F dJ=9;<R? ;O< ?KMJG8<9?Q OH:EH OJ? J? :I H8 H:F?8LI HJB
M;KGH9 9H8 E;FF;B:9N OH:EH H8 OJ? JK9H;=:T8B 9; ?8LL 9;
;9H8=?$
o /=9:EL8 X^j ;I 9H8 *;B8 ;I *;FF8=E8 B8ELJ=8? 9HJ9 <; JG8<9
?HJLL AK=EHJ?8 I;= H:F?8LI ;= I;= J<;9H8= 9HJ9 OH:EH H8 HJ?
M88< ;=B8=8B 9; ?8LL$ 6A< >FP AFE =>FQ<G B@E MFC I='C F
ML'X<LiE =ILQAFEBCW ?L'R ABE =LBCQB=F> IC><EE @A< >F@@<L PB@A
?I>> XC'P><GW< '? F>> @A< ?FQ@E FCG QBLQIRE@FCQ<E FQ\IB<EQ<E BC
EIQA Q'ILE<d FCG <T<C @A<C @A< ML'X<LiE FQ@B'C RIE@ M<
QAFLFQ@<LBa<G MN @A< I@R'E@ W''G ?FB@A$ 7 EF>< RFG< MN F
ML'X<L @' ABRE<>? PB@A'I@ @A< Q'CE<C@ '? @A< =LBCQB=F> BE
BC<??<Q@IF> PA<@A<L @A< ML'X<L AFE M<<C WIB>@N '? ?LFIGI><C@Q'CGIQ@ 'L C'@$
• f='C BCE=<Q@B'C '? YFL@'COE ><@@<LE ^UZABMB@ l FCG 77_9 @A<L< PB>> M<
?'ICG FR=>< FEEILFCQ< @AF@ G<='EB@E ?'L @A< FR'IC@ '? <FQA EAB=R<C@
P'I>G M< RFG< PB@A F MFCX BC [FCB>F =L'TBG<G @A< Q'R=FCN P'I>G
BCGBQF@<G B@E FMB>B@N @' ?B>> @A< 'LG<LEd MI@ @A<E< FEEILFCQ< L<E@<G I='C
C' '@A<L MFEBE @AFC @A< ?BCFCQBF> L<E='CEBMB>B@N '? YFL@'C ABRE<>?9 FCG
@ABE QBLQIRE@FCQ< G'IM@><EE GBG C'@ <EQF=< @A< GBEQ<LCR<C@ '? @A<
Q'R=FCNOE '??BQ<LE$
• VB@A L<E=<Q@ @' @A< 'LG<L ?L'R S$ SBPF@FLB9 P< 'ME<LT< @AF@ PAB>< A<
BC@BRF@<E @AF@ A< AFG M<<C =L'RBE<G @A< <ZQ>IEBT< FW<CQN ICG<LYFL@'C ?'L :F=FC9 C<T<L@A<><EE B@ G'<E C'@ F??BLRF@BT<>N F==<FL @AF@ A<
AFG M<<C BC ?FQ@ F=='BC@<G @' M< EIQA F@ @A< @BR< A< EBWC<G @' 'LG<L
^&UH:M:9 c_ F@ YFL@'COE L<\I<E@$
o D@ RFN M< FEEIR<G9 @A<L<?'L<9 @AF@ A< PFE F@ @AF@ @BR< F
E@LFCW<L @' @A< Q'C@LFQ@ '? FW<CQN$ D@ Q><FL>N F==<FLE9 A'P<T<L9
@AF@ A< GBG C'@ <Z=<Q@ @' =ILQAFE< @A< @A'IEFCG @'CE '?
MB@IRBC'IE >BR<E@'C< L<?<LL<G @' BC ABE 'LG<L PB@A'I@ MFCXBCW
FEEBE@FCQ<d FCG F>@A'IWA @A< EIMRFCFW<L '? @A< YFCX '?
6FBPFC AFG EFBG E'R<@ABCW <CQ'ILFWBCW BC L<E=<Q@ @' @A<RF@@<L9 C<T<L@A<><EE @AF@ '??BQBF> AFG L<?LFBC<G ?L'R WBTBCW ABE
F==L'TF> @' @A< 'LG<L ^UZABMB@ V_$ D@ BE @A<L<?'L< C'@ EA'PC
F??BLRF@BT<>N @AF@ @ABE 'LG<L =L'Q<<GE ?L'R F L<E='CEBM><
E'ILQ<$
!"+*&(-"/% ,/00&"1
• 6A< Q'R=FCN9 BC B@E F==<>>FC@OE MLB<?9 FEEBWC<G <LL'LE AFTBCW @' G' PB@A
@A< @LBF> Q'IL@OE FGRB@@BCW Q<L@FBC <TBG<CQ< '??<L<G MN YFL@'C9 FCG
L<e<Q@BCW =B<Q<E '? <TBG<CQ< @AF@ @A< Q'R=FCN B@E<>? '??<L<G$
• vD[;4%67&6w &UH:M:9 4i ^?BLE@ @BR< @AF@ B@ F==<FLE BC @ABE QFE<_9 PABQA
PFE '??<L<G BC <TBG<CQ< MN @A< Q'R=FCN9 E;<?:?9? ;I J EJ=M;< E;AN ;I
J L8998= BJ98B ]K<8 4[Q 4ZX4Q O=:998< MN dJ=9;< 9; H:? J99;=<8NQ 3=J<`
d5 #<G8=?;LLQ &?S5Q ;I ,J<:LJ9 FCG BC PABQA YFL@'C E@F@<E9 FR'CW '@A<L
@ABCWE9 @AF@ ABE =L'?B@ ?L'R @A< 5FC HLFCQBEQ' Q'C@LFQ@ P'I>G AFT< M<<C
F@ @A< LF@< '? -3 Q<C@E ^W'>G_ =<L @'C$
o 6A< FI@A<C@BQB@N '? @ABE QB@N G'QIR<C@ BE FGRB@@<G9 FCG PA<C
@A< Q'R=FCNOE F@@'LC<N '??<L<G B@ BC <TBG<CQ<9 YFL@'COE
Q'ICE<> FCC'ICQ<G @AF@ A< AFG C' 'Me<Q@B'C @' @A<
BC@L'GIQ@B'C '? @ABE QFLM'C Q'=N BC <TBG<CQ< B? @A< Q'R=FCNOE
F@@'LC<N P'I>G <Z=>FBC PA<L< @ABE Q'=N PFE E<QIL<G$
o
K'R=FCNOE F@@'LC<Nc A< L<Q<BT<G @A< ><@@<L ?L'R @A< ?'LR<LF@@'LC<NE '? @A< Q'R=FCN PB@A'I@ <Z=>FCF@B'C '? @A< RFCC<L
BC PABQA @A< G'QIR<C@ AFG Q'R< BC@' @A<BL ='EE<EEB'C$
o YFL@'COE Q'ICE<>c kV< A<L<MN WBT< C'@BQ< F@ @ABE @BR< @AF@
IC><EE EIQA FC <Z=>FCF@B'C BE RFG<9 <Z=>FBCBCW ?I>>N A'P @ABE
QFLM'C Q'=N QFR< BC@' @A< ='EE<EEB'C '? @A< G<?<CGFC@
Q'R=FCN9 'L FCN 'C< L<=L<E<C@BCW B@9 P< =L'='E< @' 'Me<Q@ @'
B@E FGRBEEB'C 'C @A< WL'ICG @AF@ B@ BE F Q'C?BG<C@BF>
Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C Q>B<C@ FCG >FPN<L$k
o &' ?IL@A<L BC?'LRF@B'C PFE @A<C WBT<C MN @A< Q'R=FCNOE
F@@'LC<N FE @' @A< RFCC<L BC PABQA @A< ><@@<L AFG Q'R< @' ABEAFCGE FCG @A< 9=:JL aKBG8 @A<L<I='C 8UELKB8B 9H8 B;EKF8<9Q
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 18/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"-
;< 9H8 G=;K<B 9HJ9 :9 OJ? J A=:P:L8G8B E;FFK<:EJ9:;<
M89O88< EL:8<9 J<B J99;=<8N$
• p(+*"0"#.& /%&"0q 0H:? =KL:<G OJ? 8==;<8;K?$
o &P8< ?KAA;?:<G 9HJ9 9H8 L8998= OJ? O:9H:< 9H8 A=:P:L8G8 9HJ9
A=;98E9? E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? M89O88< J99;=<8N J<B EL:8<9Q 9H:?
A=:P:L8G8 OJ? L;?9 OH8< 9H8 L8998= EJF8 9; 9H8 HJ<B? ;I 9H8
JBP8=?8 AJ=9N$
o
7CG B@ FJ`8? <; B:II8=8<E8 H;O 9H8 JBP8=?J=N JESK:=8BA;??8??:;<$
o 0H8 LJO A=;98E9? 9H8 EL:8<9 I=;F 9H8 8II8E9 ;I B:?EL;?K=8?
FJB8 MN H:F 9; H:? J99;=<8N :< 9H8 E;<I:B8<E8 ;I 9H8 L8GJL
=8LJ9:;<Q MK9 OH8< ?KEH J B;EKF8<9Q E;<9J:<:<G JBF:??:;<?
;I 9H8 EL:8<9Q E;F8? 9; 9H8 HJ<B ;I J 9H:=B AJ=9NQ J<B =8JEH8?
9H8 JBP8=?J=NQ :9 :? JBF:??:ML8 :< 8P:B8<E8$
o 4IL W''G RFC9 [L$ VBWR'L< EFNEc 0H8 LJO A=;P:B8?
?KMa8E9:P8 I=88B;F I;= 9H8 EL:8<9 MN J??K=:<G H:F ;I
8U8FA9:;< I=;F :9? A=;E8??8? ;I B:?EL;?K=8 JGJ:<?9 H:F?8LI ;=
9H8 J99;=<8N ;= 9H8:= JG8<9? ;I E;FFK<:EJ9:;<5 0H:? FKEHQ
MK9 <;9 J OH:9 F;=8Q :? <8E8??J=N I;= 9H8 FJ:<98<J<E8 ;I 9H8
A=:P:L8G85 1:<E8 9H8 F8J<? ;I A=8?8=P:<G ?8E=8EN ;I
E;FFK<:EJ9:;< J=8 8<9:=8LN :< 9H8 EL:8<9b? HJ<B?Q J<B ?:<E8
9H8 A=:P:L8G8 :? J B8=;GJ9:;< I=;F 9H8 G8<8=JL 98?9:F;<:JL
BK9N J<B ?H;KLB M8 ?9=:E9LN E;<?9=K8BQ :9 O;KLB M8 :FA=;A8=
9; 8U98<B :9? A=;H:M:9:;< 9; 9H:=B A8=?;<? OH; ;M9J:<
`<;OL8BG8 ;I 9H8 E;FFK<:EJ9:;<?5 +<8 OH; ;P8=H8J=? 9H8
E;FFK<:EJ9:;<Q OH89H8= O:9H ;= O:9H;K9 9H8 EL:8<9b?
`<;OL8BG8Q :? <;9 O:9H:< 9H8 A=;98E9:;< ;I 9H8 A=:P:L8G85 0H8
?JF8 =KL8 ;KGH9 9; JAALN 9; ;<8 OH; ?K==8A9:9:;K?LN =8JB? ;=
;M9J:<? A;??8??:;< ;I J B;EKF8<9 :< ;=:G:<JL ;= E;AN5 • 7>@A'IWA @A< =L<Q<G<C@E FL< E'R<PAF@ Q'C?IEBCW9 @A< M8998= B;E9=:<8
:? 9; 9H8 8II8E9 9HJ9 OH8< AJA8=? J=8 ;II8=8B :< 8P:B8<E8Q J E;K=9 O:LL
9J`8 <; <;9:E8 ;I H;O 9H8N O8=8 ;M9J:<8BQ OH89H8= L8GJLLN ;=
:LL8GJLLNQ A=;A8=LN ;= :FA=;A8=LNm <;= O:LL :9 I;=F J E;LLJ98=JL :??K8 9;
9=N 9HJ9 SK8?9:;<5
18AJ=J98 +A:<:;<?
,/%*+%,Q T@U GBEE<C@BCWc
6A< RFe'LB@N G<QBEB'C BCQBG<C@F>>N @FX<E I= ?'L Q'CEBG<LF@B'C FEEBWCR<C@E '?
<LL'L " FCG * AFTBCW @' G' PB@A <B@A<L @A< FGRBEEB'C 'L @A< L<e<Q@B'C MN @A<@LBF> Q'IL@ '? Q<L@FBC <ZABMB@E$ SFTBCW BC RBCG @AF@ @A< K'IL@ L<T<LE<E @A<
Q'IL@ / M(" 'C @A< ?FQ@E9 PAF@ BE EFBG L<>F@BT< @' @A<E< @P' FEEBWCR<C@E BE
FME'>I@<>N ICC<Q<EEFLN ?'L F eIGWR<C@9 FCG <T<C FE "9*,%$ 2*&,/9 Q'C@FBCE
IC?'L@ICF@< <Z=L<EEB'CE$ UZABMB@ ",9 ?'L <ZFR=><9 BE F ><@@<L FGGL<EE<G MN @A<
=>FBC@B?? @' ABE >FPN<L FCG =L'MFM>N R<L<>N EA'PC @' @A< Q'ICE<> '? @A<
G<?<CGFC@ GILBCW C<W'@BF@B'CE @' E<<X F Q'R=L'RBE<$ VA<@A<L @AF@ <ZABMB@ M<
Q'CEBG<L<G BR=L'=<L>N L<e<Q@<G 'L C'@ P'I>G C'@ QAFCW< @A< L<EI>@ 'C< B'@F$
6A< LI>< C'P FCC'ICQ<G MN @A< K'IL@ @AF@ B@ RFX<E C' GB??<L<CQ< A'P @A<
FGT<LEFLN FQ\IBL<G ='EE<EEB'C '? @A< G'QIR<C@9 FCG @AF@ F Q'IL@ PB>> @FX< C'C'@BQ< '? A'P B@ PFE 'M@FBC<G9 BE G<E@LIQ@BT< '? @A< F@@'LC<NiE =LBTB><W< FCG
Q'CE@B@I@<E FCG 'ME@FQ>< @' F@@<R=@E F@ ?LB<CG>N Q'R=L'RBE<$ DC @A< QFE< '? 51
:7*&" 3)4 5+*"+ 8*#% ;))($/+&% 6"&*%,1 YZ[Z\]9 B@ PFE A<>G @AF@ Q'RRICBQF@B'CE
RFG< MN F Q>B<C@ @' 7*) /,,"$+%1 #"$ ,7% .($.")% "# 9%*+I &"--(+*&/,%2 ,"
",7%$) FL< C'@ =LBTB><W<G B? @A<N AFT< M<<C E' Q'RRICBQF@<G$ dK9 H8=8Q 9H8=8
:? <; :<9:FJ9:;< 9HJ9 &UH:M:9 4i OJ? ?8<9 MN 9H8 EL:8<9 9; 9H8 LJON8= I;= 9H8
AK=A;?8 ;I M8:<G E;FFK<:EJ98B 9; ;9H8=?$ 6A< 5I=L<R< K'IL@ '? #<'LWBF BC
@A< QFE< '? 6"(,7%$+ E/*'=/1 :"4 3)4 @7*,%9 A<>G @AF@ E@F@<R<C@E BC F ><@@<L @' F
=FL@NiE F@@'LC<N AFCG<G MN @A< >F@@<L @' @A< '=='C<C@iE F@@'LC<N9 FL<
Q'C?BG<C@BF> Q'RRICBQF@B'CE FCG RIE@ M< <ZQ>IG<G$
YLB<?>N9 @A< G<QBEB'C '? @A< RFe'LB@N F==<FLE @' R< @' M< G<?<Q@BT< BC
@A< ?'>>'PBCW =FL@BQI>FLEc ^"_ D@ E<@E FEBG< PB@A'I@ W''G L<FE'C @A< ?FBL ?BCGBCWE
'? ?FQ@ FE RFG< MN @A< @LBF> Q'IL@ FCG EIME@B@I@<E @A<L<?'L '@A<L ?BCGBCWE C'@
PFLLFC@<G MN @A< =L''?d ^*_ B@ ?FB>E @' E@L<EE =>FBC@B??iE RFBC FLWIR<C@9 FCG ^0_ B@
>FN G'PCE ICQF>><G ?'L LI><E PABQA ICG<LRBC< @A< BCTB'>FMB>B@N '? F Q>B<C@iE
Q'RRICBQF@B'CE @' ABE F@@'LC<N$
7QQ'LGBCW>N9 D GBEE<C@ FCG T'@< ?'L FC F??BLRFCQ< '? @A< v@LBF> Q'IL@OEw
eIGWR<C@$
i5 +"#&.0 #.1-"/.*& $15 "&$#%%/ 6(-7
+"#&.0 #.1-"/.*& *+,!/.CQ =<@B@B'C<L9TE$
&5 !5 "&$#%%/Q ]KBG8 ;I 3:=?9 #<?9J<E8 ;I ,J<:LJQ J<B 0&/% ,+0+" *+5Q
#.*5Q L<E='CG<C@E$
'5"5 .;5 [ihZg 18A98FM8= 4jQ 4Z[h U& Y7&K 10"&&0Q T
O*99) /+2 N&^"+"(I7 #"$ .%,*,*"+%$4
O(%3/$/A _$/+&*)&" /+2 E%&," #"$ $%)."+2%+,)4
1KFFJ=N@
DC F QFE< ?B><G MN 6<F> @' L<Q'T<L ?BL< BCEILFCQ< ='>BQN ?L'R 4LB<C@9 6<F>
;L<EBG<C@9 [L YFQALFQA ^U[Y_9 PFE <ZFRBC<G M< 4LB<C@ (FPN<LE$ S< PFE FEX<G
FM'I@ @A< QBLQIRE@FCQ<E L<WFLGBCW @A< ?B>BCW '? @A< QFE<$ U[Y EFBG @AF@ 6<F>(FPN<LE E<C@ F ><@@<L FGTBEBCW @A<R @' ?B>< @A< QFE<$ 4LB<C@ FEX<G @AF@ EFBG
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 19/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
"+
><@@<L M< L<=L'GIQ<G ^Y<E@ UTBG<CQ< %I><_$ U[Y =L'GIQ<G EFBG ><@@<L FCG
'??<L<G FE <TBG<CQ< 'C>N @A< =FL@ '? @A< ><@@<L PABQA 6<F> (FPN<LE
L<Q'RR<CG<G @A< ?B>BCW '? @A< QFE<$ VA<C 4LB<C@ PFC@<G @' E<< @A< L<E@ '? @A<
><@@<L9 6<F> >FPN<LE 'Me<Q@<G MFE<G 'C BLL<><TFCQ< FCG @AF@ '@A<L =FL@E '? @A<
><@@<L P<L< Q>B<C@)>FPN<L =LBTB><W<G Q'RRICBQF@B'CE$ :IGW< EIE@FBC<G @A<
'Me<Q@B'C$ (F@<L 4LB<C@ L<B@<LF@<G B@E L<\I<E@ 0)3 R'L< @BR<E BCQ>IGBCW FC [%
FCG F EIM='<CF MI@ eIGW< G<CB<G F>> FCG <T<C \IFEA<G @A< EIM='<CF$ 5'
4LB<C@ ?B><G @ABE RFCGFRIE FCG Q<L@B'LFLB PB@A @A< 5K$5K EFBG @AF@ EBCQ< =FL@ '? @A< ><@@<L PFE BC@L'GIQ<G BC M<AF>? '? @A<
=>FBC@B??9 @A< PA'>< '? @A< ><@@<L Q'I>G =L'=<L>N M< <ZFRBC<G MN @A< '@A<L
=FL@N9 BC FQQ'LGFCQ< PB@A @A< LI><E '? Q'IL@$ HIL@A<L9 5K FGG<G @AF@ RF@@<LE FE
@' @A< Q'C@LFQ@ M<@P<<C >FPN<LE FCG Q>B<C@ FL< C'@ Q'CEBG<L<G =LBTB><W<G
Q'RRICBQF@B'C$ 7EEIRBCW B@ PFE BCG<<G =LBTB><W<G9 @A< =LBTB><W< PFE PFBT<G
MN @A< BC@L'GIQ@B'C BC <TBG<CQ< '? =FL@ '? @A< ><@@<L$ 7E @' P1C @A< =L'=<L
L<R<GN PFE IE<G9 Q<L@B'LFLB PFE =L'=<L EBCQ< @A<L< BE C' '@A<L L<R<GB<E
FTFB>FM>< E<<BCW @AF@ @A< eIGW<9 MN ABE FQ@E9 AFE F>L<FGN G<QBG<G C'@ @' FGRB@
@A< PA'>< ><@@<L FE <TBG<CQ<$ [FCGFRIE >B<E F>E' @' Q'R=<> @A< eIGW< @'
FGRB@ @A< ><@@<L$
H7K65 ^?'L MFEBQ ?FQ@E9 E<< EIRRFLN_
# 'LBWBCF> =<@B@B'C ?'L PLB@E '? Q<L@B'LFLB FCG -/+2/-()
o ?B><G BC @ABE Q'IL@ MN @A< 4LB<C@ DCEILFCQ< K'R=FCN
o FWFBCE@ @A< L<E='CG<C@ eIGW< '? @A< K'IL@ '? HBLE@ DCE@FCQ< '?
[FCB>F FCG @A< 6<F> ['@'L K'$9 DCQ$
# @ABE BE MFE<G 'C F QFE<9 FE '? @BR< '? @A< G<QBEB'C9 PFE E@B>> =<CGBCW BC
KHD [FCB>F <C@B@><Gc 6<F> ['@'L K'$9 DCQ$ 3)4 4LB<C@ DCEILFCQ< K'R=FCN
QBTB> QFE< &'$ 03-*3
6<F> ['@'L K'$9 DCQ$ 3)4 4LB<C@ DCEILFCQ< K'R=FCN QBTB> QFE< &'$ 03-*3
#
6<F> ['@'L K'$9 DCQ$ E<<XE @' L<Q'T<L I='C @P' ?BL< BCEILFCQ< ='>BQB<EBEEI<G MN @A< 4LB<C@ DCEILFCQ< K'R=FCN FWWL<WF@BCW ;]/9///9 I='C F
E@'QX '? R<LQAFCGBE< F>><W<G @' M< '? @A< TF>I< '? ;,",93"0$3]9 PABQA9
PB@A @A< <ZQ<=@B'C '? EF>TFW< TF>I<G F@ FM'I@ ;3/9///9 PFE G<E@L'N<G
MN F ?BL< 'C 'L FM'I@ :FCIFLN ]9 "+*+$
# F"'*&*%) ),/,%2 ,7/, /'' 9%+%#*, (+2%$ ,7% ."'*&1 ="('2 9% #"$#%*,%2 *#A *+
&/)% "# '"))A ,7% &'/*- )7"('2 9% $%H%&,%2 91 ,7% *+)($%$ /+2 /&,*"+ "$
)(*, )7"('2 +", 9% &"--%+&%2 =*,7*+ ,7$%% -"+,7) /#,%$ )(&7 $%H%&,*"+
# ^%#%+)% "# "$*%+,/' =/) ,7/, V%/' &/+T, )(% ,7%- /+1-"$% )*+&% ,7%
&/)% =/) #*'%2 -"$% ,7/+ ,7$%% -"+,7) #$"- ,7% $%H%&,*"+ 91 `$*%+,/'
"# V%/'T) &'/*-4o &"-./+1 $%H%&,%2 ,7% &'/*- /+2 +",*#*%2 V%/' "+ ;.$*' Z\A Z[a[
o )(*, =/) +", *+),*,(,%2 "+ ,7% ."'*&1 (+,*' ;(I(), bA Z[a[
# F'/*+,*##CVG;8 /2-*,,%2 ,7/, ,7% &'/*- =/) $%H%&,%2 "+ /.$*' Z\A 9(,
V%/' )/*2 ,7/, G4 G4 G')%$A /) $%.$%)%+,/,*3% "# ,7% `$*%+,A %B.$%))'1
$%M(%),%2 ,7% .'/*+,*## ," 2%#%$ H(2*&*/' /&,*"+ (+,*' /#,%$ ,7% #"''"=*+I
J('1 bZA ),/,*+I ,7/, ,7%$% =%$% I$%/, ."))*9*'*,*%) ,7/, /+ %B,$/H(2*&*/'
&"-.$"-*)% -*I7, 9% /$$/+I%2 *+ ,7% -/,,%$
# .'/*+,*## 7/2 2%#%$$%2 /&,*"+A $%'1*+I (."+ ,7*) $%M(%),4
6A< BEEI< '? @ABE QFE< E@FL@<G PA<C$$$# PB@C<EE U$ [$ YFQALFQA9 =L<EBG<C@ '? @A< 6<F> ['@'L K'$9 DCQ$ PFE M<BCW
<ZFRBC<G MN 4LB<C@ 7@@'LC<NE$
o YFQA@LFQA ^U[Y ?'L EA'L@_ PFE M<BCW FEX FM'I@ QBLQIRE@FCQ<E
EILL'ICGBCW @A< BCE@B@I@B'C '? @A< FQ@B'C
o U[Y EFBG @AF@ 'C @A< "0@A '? :I>N9 A< L<Q<BT<G F ><@@<L ?L'R
@A<BL F@@'LC<NE9 #I<TFLF9 HLFCQBEQ' u %<Q@'9 ILWBCW ABR @' ?B><
@A<E< QFE<E$
o 4LB<C@ 7@@'LC<NE FEX<G @AF@ PB@C<EE M< L<\IBL<G @' =L'GIQ<
@A< ><@@<L L<?<LL<G @' ?L'R [L$ #I<TFLF9 'L <>E< ABE FCEP<L M<
E@LBQX<C 'I@
"
VAF@ 'LB<C@ PFE FQ@IF>>N G<RFCGBCW ?'L @A<
=L'GIQ@B'C '? k@A< M<E@ <TBG<CQ<9k
" %<R<RM<L9 PB@C<EE QFCC'@ M< =<LRB@@<G @' WBT< 'LF>
@<E@BR'CN FE @' @A< Q'C@<C@E '? F =F=<L PLB@BCW PABQA
QFC M< =L'GIQ<G BC Q'IL@
o C' 'Me<Q@B'C @' EA'P @AF@ AJ=9 ;I 9H8 L8998= BC PABQA #I<TFLF
ILW<G ABR @' =L'Q<<G PB@A @A< QFE<E
o Yf6jjj U@' CF$$$
# f='C M<BCW FEX<G FM'I@ @A< '@A<L =FL@ '? @A< ><@@<L9 @A< PB@C<EE EFBG
@AF@ @A< ;9H8= AJ=9 E;<9J:<8B A=:PJ98 FJ998=9 kM<@P<<C @A< F@@'LC<N
FCG 'ILE<>T<E9k ^E' FNFP CBNF B=F)MFEF_o `$*%+, /,,"$+%1 ,7%+ /)?%2 ,7% 2/,% "# ,7% '%,,%$ =7*&7 =*,+%))
)/*2 Zb H('1
o `$*%+, /,,"$+%1 )(II%),%2 ,7/, 7% ="('2 '*?% ," 7/3% ,7% '%,,%$
-/$?%2 =*,7"(, 7*) $%/2*+I *,A /+2 *, =/) /&&"$2*+I'1 -/$?%2
/) GB7*9*, c[
o 4LB<C@ F@@'LC<N @A<C PB@AGL<P ABE 'Me<Q@B'CE @' @A< E@F@<R<C@
'? U[Y MI@ FEX<G @A< Q'IL@ @AF@ A< ^@A< F@@'LC<N '? 'LB<C@_ @'
L<FG @A< ><@@<L ?'L ABE BC?'LRF@B'C$
o VA<C FEX<G MN @A< Q'IL@9 6<F> 7@@'LC<N L<B@<LF@<G PAF@ U[Y
EFBG BC ABE @<E@BR'CN @AF@ +=:8<9 J99;=<8N? EJ< =8JB 9H8
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 20/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*/
=8L8PJ<9 AJ=9? ;<LN MK9 <;9 9H8 ;9H8= AJ=9? PABQA Q'C@FBC<G
F@@N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<G Q'RRICBQF@B'C
o 6A< '@A<L =FL@ L<?<LL<G @' MN 6<F> 7@@'LC<NE O8=8 JM;K9
E;<9=JE9 ;I I88?Q ;= =89J:<:<G ;I 9H8 ?8=P:E8? '? =>FBC@B??iE
F@@'LC<NE BC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@A EFBG QFE<E9 E' @A<N BCEBE@ B@ BE
BLL<><TFC@ ?'L @A< QFE< FCG @AF@ B@ BE =LBTB><W<G
o 4LB<C@ 7@@'LC<NE Q'IC@<L<G @AF@ BCFERIQA FE F>> @A< ><@@<L
L<?<LE @' @A< QFE< @A<C BC Q'IL@9 @A< <C@BL< G'QIR<C@ EA'I>G M<<ZABMB@<G9 BC Q'C?'LRB@N PB@A @A< LI>< @AF@ PA<C =FL@ '? F
G'QIR<C@ BE '??<L<G BC <TBG<CQ<9 @A< <C@BL< G'QIR<C@ RIE@ M<
=L<E<C@<G
o :IGW< E@B>> GBG C'@ FQQ<G< @' L<\I<E@ '? 4LB<C@ 7@@'LC<NE9 MI@
@A< L<><TFC@ =FL@E9 FE R<C@B'C<G MN U[Y9 PFE L<FG F>'IG BC
Q'IL@ E' @AF@ B@ RFN ?'LR =FL@ '? @A< L<Q'LGE ^=><FE< E<< ?I>>
@<Z@ CF>FCW_
o ;I/*+A `$*%+, /,,"$+%1) $%M(%),%2 ,7/, ,7% %+,*$% '%,,%$ 9%
.$"2(&%2 =7*&7 ,7% H(2I% 2%+*%2
o ;#,%$ #($,7%$ 2*)&())*"+A (."+ ,7% )(II%),*"+ "# ,7% /,,"$+%1
#"$ ,7% 2%#%+2/+, /+2 91 /I$%%-%+, "# ,7% &"(+)%' #"$ 9",7
./$,*%)A ,7% )%&"+2 ./I% "# ,7% '%,,%$ =/) -/$?%2 c[C; 91 ,7%
&'%$? &"($,4
# @7%+ ,7% ,*-% #"$ "$*%+, /,,"$+%1) ," &$")) GN0 /$$*3%2A ,7%1
$%*,%$/,%2 ,7/, GN0 )7"('2 #"$-/''1 "##%$ ,7% '%,,%$ *+ %3*2%+&%A /I/*+
V%/' 8/=1%$) "9H%&,%2 /+2 J(2I% )(),/*+%2
# `$*%+, #*'%2 /+ NE =*,7 ,7% H(2I% 9(, =/) $%H%&,%2
# `$*%+, ,7%+ /)?%2 #"$ / )(9."%+/ 2(&%) ,%&(- ," 9% *))(%2 91 ,7%
:'%$? "# &"($, ," $%M(*$% V%/' ," .$"2(&% &%$,/*+ ./.%$ *+&'(2*+I ,7%
'%,,%$4
o
J(2I% M(/)7%2 ,7% )(9."%+/4
D55fUc V1& F =FL@N QFC M< =L'ABMB@<G ?L'R <ZFRBCBCW @A< PA'>< G'QIR<C@
=L<E<C@<G FE <TBG<CQ<$ 4@A<LPBE< E@F@<G9 PFE @A< :IGW< Q'LL<Q@ @' F>>'P @A<
<ZFRBCF@B'C '? eIE@ =FL@ '? @A< ><@@<L PABQA 6U7( G<<R<G L<><TFC@ ?'L @A<
@<E@BR'CN '? B@E PB@C<EEb
SU(8c &'j 4CQ< N'I =L<E<C@1BC@L'GIQ< =FL@ '? @A< ><@@<L1G'QIR<C@9 @A< PA'><
'? @A< ><@@<L1G'QIR<C@ Q'I>G =L'=<L>N M< <ZFRBC<G MN @A< '@A<L =FL@N$
%76D4c
# 6A< ><@@<L PFE C<Q<EEFLN EI=='L@ '? @A< 'LF> E@F@<R<C@ RFG< MN @A<
PB@C<EE$ ;FL@ '? B@ PFE =L<E<C@<G9 BC ?FQ@ RFG< =FL@ '? @A< L<Q'LG9 E'
@AF@ ABE @<E@BR'CN P'I>G C'@ M< E@LBX<C '??
# <ZQ<L=@ BC \I<E@B'C RIE@ @A<L<?'L< M< Q'CEBG<L<G FE =L''? EIMRB@@<G
MN @A< =>FBC@B??
# @A<L< QFC M< C' \I<E@B'C @AF@9 AJ=9 ;I 9H8 L8998= HJP:<G M88<
:<9=;BKE8B :< M8HJLI ;I 9H8 ALJ:<9:IIQ 9H8 OH;L8 ;I 9H8 L8998= E;KLB
A=;A8=LN M8 8UJF:<8B MN 9H8 ;9H8= AJ=9N
"&@ !=:P:L8G8 *;FFK<:EJ9:;<
# GB??BQI>@ @' E<< A'P F Q'C@LFQ@ ?'L ?<<E Q'I>G M< Q'CEBG<L<G =LBTB><W<G$
#
Q'C@LFQ@E M<@P<<C F@@'LC<NE FCG Q>B<C@E FL< BCA<L<C@>N =<LE'CF> FCG=LBTF@< RF@@<LE9 MI@ @A<N FL< F Q'CE@FC@ EIMe<Q@ '? >B@BWF@B'C9 FCG
E;<9=JE9? =8LJ9:<G 9; I88? J=8 8??8<9:JLLN <;9 ;I A=:P:L8G8B <J9K=85
# ;LBTB><W< =LBRFLB>N L<?<LE @' Q'RRICBQF@B'CE ?L'R Q>B<C@ @' F@@'LC<N9
FC BG<F PABQA '? Q'ILE< BCQ>IG<E Q'RRICBQF@B'CE ?L'R F@@'LC<N @'
Q>B<C@ L<>F@BT< @' =LBTB><W<G RF@@<LE$
#I :9 OJ? !=:P:L8G8Q :9 OJ? OJ:P8B
# 9H8 A=:P:L8G8 OJ? OJ:P8B MN 9H8 :<9=;BKE9:;< :< 8P:B8<E8 ;I AJ=9 ;I
9H8 L8998=5
# 6A< =L'TBEB'C BC E<Q@B'C *-0 '? @A< K'G< '? KBTB> ;L'Q<GIL< RFXBCW @A<
PA'>< '? F G<Q>FLF@B'C9 Q'CT<LEF@B'C9 'L PLB@BCW FGRBEEBM>< PA<C =FL@
AFE M<<C WBT<C BC <TBG<CQ< MN 'C< =FL@N9 RFX<E C' <ZQ<=@B'C FE @'
=LBTB><W<G RF@@<Ld FCG @A< eILBE=LIG<CQ< 'C @A< EIMe<Q@ G'<E C'@
L<Q'WCBa< FCN <ZQ<=@B'C$
# m<>>N 3)4 KIRR<CE QB@BCW V<E@<LC fCB'C 6<> Q' T YF>@BR'L<
o DEEI< '? @A< QFE< BE PA<@A<L F L<BEEI<G =F@<C@ I='C PABQA @A<
EIB@ PFE ?'ICG<G PFE 'M@FBC<G ?'L @A< ><WB@BRF@< =IL='E<E
o K'R=>FBCFC@ @' ?'L@B?N ABE @A<'LN RFG< F??BGFTB@E <Z@LFQ@<G
?L'R Q'RRICBQF@B'CE M<@P<<C =F@<C@ <Z=<L@E9 5'>W<C
(FPN<LE FCG Q'R=FCN '??BQ<LE$ ^E' R<FCBCW '@A<L =FL@E '? @A<
Q'RRICBQF@B'C P<L< C'@ GBEQ>'E<G_
o
5' G<?<CGFC@ E'IWA@ @' BC@L'GIQ< BC <TBG<CQ< @A< 'LBWBCF>Q'RRICBQF@B'CE ^HI>> C'@ eIE@ <Z@LFQ@E_ 'C @A< WL'ICG @AF@ @A<
=FL@E '? @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'C PABQA P<L< C'@ GBEQ>'E<G AFG FC
BR='L@FC@ M<FLBCW I='C @A< ABE@'LN '? @A< F==>BQF@B'C ?'L F
L<BEEI<
o K'R=>FBCFC@ EFBG @AF@ @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'C PFE =LBTB><W<G
Q'RRICBQF@B'C
o K'IL@ EFBG @AF@ J??KF:<G :9 OJ? :<B88B A=:P:L8G8BQ :9 OJ?
E;FA898<9 I;= 9H8 E;FALJ:<J<9 9; OJ:P8 :9? A=:P:L8G8$
o / AJ=9N EJ<<;9 OJ:P8 ?KEH J A=:P:L8G8 AJ=9:JLLN $ D8 EJ<<;9
=8F;P8 9H8 ?8JL ;I ?8E=8EN I=;F ?; FKEH ;I 9H8 A=:P:L8G8B
E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? J? FJ`8? I;= H:? JBPJ<9JG8Q J<B :<?:?9 9HJ9 :9
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 21/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*"
?HJLL <;9 M8 =8F;P8B J? 9; ?; FKEH J? FJ`8? 9; 9H8
JBPJ<9JG8 ;I H:? JBP8=?J=NQ ;= FJN <8K9=JL:T8 9H8 8II8E9 ;I
?KEH J? HJ? M88< :<9=;BKE8B
o B@ QFCC'@ M< RF@<LBF> F@ PAF@ E@FW< '? @A< =L'Q<<GBCWE BC F EIB@
F =FL@N PFBT<E ABE LBWA@ @' RFBC@FBC @A< E<QL<QN '? =LBTB><W<G
Q'RRICBQF@B'C
# YFQX @' @A< QFE<$$$ E' P< ^@A< Q'IL@_ FL< ><G @' @A< Q'CQ>IEB'C @AF@ @A<
F@@'LC<N ?'L @A< G<?<CGFC@ BC @A< Q'IL@ M<>'P PFE <C@B@><G @' <ZFRBC<@A< PA'>< '? @A< ><@@<L ^UZABMB@ ,+ FCG ,+)7_9 PB@A F TB<P @' @A<
BC@L'GIQ@B'C BC <TBG<CQ< '? EIQA =FL@E @A<L<'? FE RFN M< L<><TFC@ @'
@A< QFE< 'C @LBF>
"&@ /BF:??:M:L:9N ;I OH;L8 L8998= !=8FJ9K=8
# R, *) )(II%),%2 *+ ,7% /$I(-%+, #"$ ,7% $%)."+2%+,) ,7/, ,7% /,,"$+%1
#"$ ,7% 2%#%+2/+, )7"('2 7/3% =/*,%2 (+,*' *, 9%&/-% 7*) ,($+ ,"
.$%)%+, %3*2%+&% *+ &7*%#A =7%+A /) *) )(..")%2A ,7% M(%),*"+ &"('2
7/3% 9%%+ .$".%$'1 $/*)%2
# :"($, )/*2 ,7/, *# ,7% /,,"$+%1 #"$ ,7% 2%#%+2/+, 7/2 / $*I7, ," %B/-*+%
,7% '%,,%$A *, )7"('2 7/3% 9%%+ .$"2(&%2 =7%+ 7% /)?%2 #"$ *, "+ ,7%
&$"))C%B/-*+/,*"+ "# ,7% =*,+%))
# 0%)*2%)A #$"- ,7% #/&,)A ,7%$% =/) +", ,7% )'*I7,%), )(II%),*"+ #$"- ,7%
&"($, ,7/, ,7% ./$,) "# ,7% '%,,%$ =7*&7 =%$% 7%'2 *+/2-*))*9'% ="('2
9% /2-*,,%2 /, /+1 ,*-% Y,/.") ,7% H(2I% M(/)7%2 ,7% )(9."%+/ ./]
# ;'' *+ /'' *, )7"=) ,7/, &"($, -%/+, ," $('% ,7/, ,7% '%,,%$ &"('2 +", 9%
*+).%&,%2 /, /'' 91 ,7% /,,"$+%1 #"$ ,7% 2%#%+2/+,4
"&@ c=:9 ;I ,J<BJFK? J? 9H8 A=;A8= =8F8BN>F;B8
# V7% )*,(/,*"+ .$%)%+,%2 *)A 7"=%3%$A "+% =7%$% ,7% 7%$%*+ .%,*,*"+%$
7/) +" ",7%$ $%-%21
# 8%,,%$ 7/) 9%%+ $('%2 *+/2-*))*9'%
#
$%)."+2%+, H(2I% 7/2 +", .%$-*,,%2 ,7% 2"&(-%+, ," 9%&"-% / ./$, "#,7% $%&"$2 *+ )(&7 / =/1 ,7/, ,7% .%,*,*"+%$ &"('2 ,/?% /23/+,/I% "#
,7% %$$"$ (."+ /..%/' ," ,7*) &"($,
# *2'% ," 2*)&()) =7%,7%$ ",7%$ $%-%21 ="('2 9% ).%%21 "$ /2%M(/,%
=7%+ ,7%$% *) +" $%-%21 /, /''
# ,7*) &/)% 7/) 9%%+ .%+2*+I 9%#"$% ,7% $%)."+2%+, H(2I% #"$ /
&"+)*2%$/9'% .%$*"2 "# ,*-%A /+2 (+2"(9,%2'1 ,7% .$"9/,"$1 .%$*"2 =*''
9% +%&%))/$*'1 %B,%+2%2 -(&7 '"+I%$
# 5+2%$ ,7%)% &*$&(-),/+&%)A ,7% /&,*"+ "# ,7*) &"($, *+ %+,%$,/*+*+I ,7%
.$%)%+, /..'*&/,*"+ =*'' %*,7%$ 9% &"+2(&,*3% ," ,7% ).%%21
2%,%$-*+/,*"+ "# &/)%A "$ /, '%/), =*'' +", /..$%&*/9'1 %B,%+2 ,7%
.$"&%%2*+I)
# =$*, "#-/+2/-() /..$".$*/,%A )*+&% ,7% $*I7, #$"- ,7% %B%$&*)% "#
=7*&7 ,7% .%,*,*"+%$ *) %B&'(2%2 *) "+% ," =7*&7 *, *) %+,*,'%2 (+2%$ ,7%
'/= /+2 ,7% 2(,1 ," 9% .%$#"$-%2 *) "+% .%$,/*+*+I ," ,7% $%)."+2%+,
H(2I% *+ 7*) "##*&*/' &/./&*,14
_$"- =7/, 7/) 9%%+ )/*2 *, #"''"=) ,7/, ,7% =$*, "# -/+2/-() .$/1%2 #"$ =*''
9% I$/+,%2A /+2 ,7% $%)."+2%+, H(2I% *) 2*$%&,%2 ," .%$-*, ,7% /,,"$+%1 #"$ ,7%
2%#%+2/+, Y.%,*,*"+%$ 7%$%] ," *+).%&, ,7% '%,,%$ YGB7*9*, c[ /+2 c[C;] =*,7 /
3*%= ," ,7% *+,$"2(&,*"+ *+ %3*2%+&% "# )(&7 ./$,) ,7%$%"# /) -/1 9% $%'%3/+, ,",7% *))(%) -/2% 91 ,7% .'%/2*+I) *+ &*3*' &/)% <"4 b\da\ /+2 ",7%$ &/)%) =7*&7
7/3% 9%%+ &"+)"'*2/,%2 =*,7 *, #"$ ,$*/'4 6" "$2%$%2A =*,7 &"),) /I/*+), ,7%
$%)."+2%+, V%/' N","$ :"4A R+&4
;3/+&%e/A :4J4A f*''/-"$A `),$/+2A J"7+) /+2 E"-(/'2%gA JJ4A &"+&($4
18AJ=J98 +A:<:;<?
$#%%/Y"&/%Q T@U Q'CQILLBCWc
D Q'CQIL E'><>N 'C @A< WL'ICG @AF@ @A< ='L@B'C '? @A< ><@@<L F>><W<G @' M<
=LBTB><W<G BE C'@ E'$
_5
!&+!%& $15 1/.(#'/.d/C/. 6D$7
#% ""3,0+)," . /21"]1"++2 . %U#7(7849 :$
!89:9:;<8=@ !&+!%& +3 0D& !D#%#!!#.&1
"8?A;<B8<9?@ [7&5fU64 J$ S4&%7879 KUHU%D&4 5$ ;7%U8U59 :%$ FCG
#U&U%454 5$ 57&57U6
1-,,/"C 5FCEF<@ PFE G<EBWCF@<G FE F E@F@< PB@C<EE BC F QFE< '? ?F>EB?BQF@B'C
QAFLW<E FE FWFBCE@ 5FCEF<@9 S'CLFGF FCG ;FL<G<E$ 5FCEF<@ M<BCW @A< Q'ICE<> '?
;FL<G<E9 'M@FBC<G BC?'LRF@B'C ?L'R =LBTB><W< Q'RRICBQF@B'C$ S'P<T<L
#<>FQB'9 F @FZ=FN<L9 ?B><G F QFE< ?'L ?F>EB?BQF@B'C '? G'QIR<C@E F>><WBCW ;FL<G<E9
S'CLFGF FCG 5FCEF<@$ 5FCEF<@ PFE RFG< @A< E@F@< PB@C<EE$ 6A< R'@B'C @'GBEQAFLW< 5FCEF<@ FE E@F@< PB@C<EE PFE GBERBEE<G MN @A< 5FCGBWFCMFNFC FCG
@AIE PFE LFBE<G @' @A< 5I=L<R< Q'IL@$ 5K %f(U8c 0D& !&"#+( 0+ d&
*+.1#(&"&( #1 0D& (/0& cD&. 0D& !"#$#%&'&( *+,,-.#*/0#+. c/1
,/(& dC 0D& *%#&.0 0+ 0D& /00+".&C #. "&%/0#+. 0+ �D&" / *"#,&
*+,,#00&( #. 0D& !/10 +" c#0D "&1!&*0 0+ / *"#,& #.0&.(&( 0+ d&
*+,,#00&( #. 0D& 3-0-"&5 #. +0D&" c+"(1Q #3 0D& *%#&.0 1&&r1 D#1
%/cC&"R1 /($#*& c#0D "&1!&*0 0+ / *"#,& 0D/0 0D& 3+",&" D/1
0D&"&0+3+"& *+,,#00&(Q D& #1 '#$&. 0D& !"+0&*0#+. +3 / $#"0-/%
*+.3&11#+./% 1&/% cD#*D 0D& /00+".&CY*%#&.0 !"#$#%&'& (&*%/"&1
*/..+0 d& d"+r&. dC 0D& /00+".&C c#0D+-0 0D& *%#&.0R1 *+.1&.050D& 1/,& !"#$#%&'&( *+.3#(&.0#/%#0CQ D+c&$&"Q (+&1 .+0 /00/*D
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 22/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
**
c#0D "&'/"( 0+ / *"#,& cD#*D / *%#&.0 #.0&.(1 0+ *+,,#0
0D&"&/30&" +" #. 0D& 3-0-"& /.( 3+" !-"!+1&1 +3 cD#*D D& 1&&r1
0D& %/cC&"R1 /($#*&5
3/*01
• &F@IL< '? @A< QFE<c 6AL'IWA @A< E=<QBF> QBTB> FQ@B'C ?'L Q<L@B'LFLB F@ MFL9
=<@B@B'C<L E<<XE @A< FCCI>R<C@ '? @A< L<E'>I@B'C '? L<E='CG<C@
5FCGBWFCMFNFC9 =L'RI>WF@<G 'C 8<Q<RM<L **9 "++09 PABQA G<CB<G
=<@B@B'C<LOE R'@B'C ?'L @A< GBEQAFLW< '? L<E='CG<C@ #<C<L'E' 5$5FCEF<@ @' M< I@B>Ba<G FE F E@F@< PB@C<EE9 FCG B@E L<E'>I@B'C '? [FLQA 29
"++, G<CNBCW @A< R'@B'C ?'L L<Q'CEBG<LF@B'C '? B@E =L<Q<GBCW
GBE='EB@B'C$
• D;<=JBJ OJ? 9H8 *L8=` ;I *;K=9 J<B /E9:<G 198<;G=JAH8= ;I 9H8 3:=?9
,K<:E:AJL *:=EK:9 0=:JL *;K=9Q 1J< 3=J<E:?E;YdK<JOJ<Y";?J=:; :<
/GK?J< B8L 1K=5 "8?A;<B8<9 !J=8B8? OJ? ?KEE8??:P8LN 9H8 !=;P:<E:JL
/99;=<8N ;I /GK?J< B8L 1K=Q 9H8< ';P8=<;= ;I 9H8 ?JF8 A=;P:<E8Q J<B
:? J9 A=8?8<9 J *;<G=8??FJ<5 "8?A;<B8<9 1J<?J89 OJ? J A=JE9:E:<G
J99;=<8N OH; ?8=P8B J? E;K<?8L I;= !J=8B8? :< ?8P8=JL :<?9J<E8?
A8=9:<8<9 9; 9H8 E=:F:<JL EHJ=G8? :<P;LP8B :< 9H8 A=8?8<9 =8E;K=?85
•
6A< EFR< L<Q'LGE F>E' L<=L<E<C@ @AF@ E'R<@BR< BC "+2]9 L<E='CG<C@
;FL<G<E F==>B<G ?'L F ?L<< =F@<C@ 'T<L ('@ &'$ 0/+2)79 ;>E)]2 '? @A<
%'EFLB' ;IM>BQ (FCG 5IMGBTBEB'C 5ILT<N$ SBE F==>BQF@B'C PFE F==L'T<G
FCG9 =ILEIFC@ @' F ?L<< =F@<C@ WLFC@<G @' ABR9 FC 'LBWBCF> Q<L@B?BQF@< '?
@B@>< PFE BEEI<G BC ABE ?FT'L ?'L @AF@ >'@ PABQA BE EB@IF@<G BC @A<
='M>FQB'C '? 5FC HLFCQBEQ'9 7WIEFC G<> 5IL$
• DC "+-3 @A< 8BL<Q@'L '? (FCGE ?B><G FC FQ@B'C ?'L @A< QFCQ<>>F@B'C '?
;FL<G<EO ;F@<C@ FCG Q<L@B?BQF@< '? @B@>< EBCQ< @A< >FCG AFG M<<C
G<EBWCF@<G FCG L<E<LT<G FE F EQA''> EB@< BC @A< F?'L<R<C@B'C<G
EIMGBTBEB'C EILT<N$
•
('P<L Q'IL@ ! 6LBF> K'IL@ L<CG<L<G eIGWR<C@ CI>>B?NBCW EFBG =F@<C@FCG @B@>< F?@<L ?BCGBCW @AF@ L<E='CG<C@ ;FL<G<E AFG 'M@FBC<G @A< EFR<
@AL'IWA ?LFIGI><C@ RBEL<=L<E<C@F@B'CE BC ABE F==>BQF@B'C$ ;<L@BC<C@>N9
L<E='CG<C@ 5FCEF<@ E<LT<G FE Q'ICE<> '? ;FL<G<E BC @AF@ QBTB> QFE<$
• K'CE<\I<C@ @' @A< ?'L<W'BCW eIGWR<C@ '? @A< @LBF> Q'IL@9 I='C @A<
EIME<\I<C@ Q'R=>FBC@ '? @A< 5FCWWICBFCW YFNFC FCG @A< =L<>BRBCFLN
BCT<E@BWF@B'C Q'CGIQ@<G @A<L<'C9 FC BC?'LRF@B'C ?'L =<LeILN PFE ?B><G
FWFBCE@ L<E='CG<C@ ;FL<G<E BC @A< [ICBQB=F> KBLQIB@ 6LBF> K'IL@$
• 4C &'T<RM<L *29 "+-39 @A< ;L'TBCQBF> HBEQF> PFE9 A'P<T<L9 GBL<Q@<G MN
@A< 8<=I@N [BCBE@<L '? :IE@BQ< @' R'T< ?'L @A< GBERBEEF> '? @A< QFE< 'C
@A< WL'ICG BC@<L F>BF '? =L<EQLB=@B'C9 A<CQ< @A< =L'Q<<GBCWE P<L<@<LRBCF@<G$
• DC @ABE QLBRBCF> QFE<9 L<E='CG<C@ ;FL<G<E PFE >BX<PBE< L<=L<E<C@<G MN
L<E='CG<C@ 5FCEF<@ FE Q'ICE<>$
• &'C<@A<><EE9 %<E='CG<C@ ;FL<G<E PFE @A<L<F?@<L AF><G M<?'L< @A<
6FC'GMFNFC ?'L =L<>BRBCFLN BCT<E@BWF@B'C 'C @A< QAFLW< @AF@9 MN IEBCW
ABE ?'LR<L ='EB@B'C FE ;L'TBCQBF> 7@@'LC<N @' BC?>I<CQ< FCG BCGIQ< @A<
YIL<FI '? (FCGE '??BQBF>E @' ?FT'LFM>N FQ@ 'C ABE F==>BQF@B'C ?'L ?L<<
=F@<C@9 A< AFG TB'>F@<G 5<Q@B'C 0^F_ '? %<=IM>BQ 7Q@ &'$ 0/"+9 FE
FR<CG<G$ H'L @A< @ABLG @BR<9 L<E='CG<C@ 5FCEF<@ PFE ;FL<G<EOQ'ICE<> '? L<Q'LG @A<L<BC$
• 4C 7IWIE@ *+9 "+--9 @A< 6FC'GMFNFC9 BEEI<G F L<E'>I@B'C
L<Q'RR<CGBCW @A< QLBRBCF> =L'E<QI@B'C '? L<E='CG<C@ ;FL<G<E$ 7@@N$
5FCEF<@9 FE Q'ICE<> ?'L ABE F?'L<CFR<G Q')L<E='CG<C@9 R'T<G ?'L
L<Q'CEBG<LF@B'C$
• 7 QLBRBCF> QFE< PFE EIME<\I<C@>N ?B><G PB@A @A< 5FCGBWFCMFNFC$
QAFLWBCW L<E='CG<C@ ;FL<G<E PB@A F TB'>F@B'C '? 5<Q@B'C 0^F_ '?
%<=IM>BQ 7Q@ &'$ 0/"+9 FE FR<CG<G$ S'P<T<L9 F R'@B'C @' \IFEA ?B><G
MN @A< G<?<CE< PFE >F@<L WLFC@<G BC L<E='CG<C@ Q'IL@OE L<E'>I@B'C '?
7IWIE@ "9 "++" FCG @A< QFE< PFE GBERBEE<G 'C @A< WL'ICG '?
=L<EQLB=@B'C$
• 4C :FCIFLN *09 "++/9 'C< 6<'?B>' #<>FQB'9 F @FZ=FN<L PA' AFG BCB@BF@<G
@A< =<LeILN FCG WLF?@ QAFLW<E FWFBCE@ L<E='CG<C@ ;FL<G<E9 E<C@ F ><@@<L
@' @A< 4RMIGERFC E<<XBCW @A< BCT<E@BWF@B'C '? @A< @AL<< L<E='CG<C@E
A<L<BC ?'L ?F>EB?BQF@B'C '? =IM>BQ G'QIR<C@E$
• '8LJE:; ELJ:F8B 9HJ9 =8?A;<B8<9 D;<=JBJQ :< E;<?A:=JEN O:9H H:?
H8=8:< E;Y=8?A;<B8<9?Q ?:FKLJ98B J<B E8=9:I:8B J? 9=K8 E;A:8? E8=9J:<
B;EKF8<9? AK=A;=9:<G 9; M8 J <;9:E8 ;I J==J:G<F8<9Q BJ98B ]KLN 4Q
4Zg_Q J<B 9=J<?E=:A9? ;I ?98<;G=JAH:E <;98? ?KAA;?8BLN 9J`8< BK=:<G
9H8 J==J:G<F8<9 ;I !J=8B8? ;< 9H8 A8=aK=N EHJ=G85 0H8?8 IJL?:I:8B
B;EKF8<9? O8=8 J<<8U8B 9; =8?A;<B8<9 !J=8B8?R F;9:;< I;==8E;<?:B8=J9:;< ;I 9H8 0J<;BMJNJ< =8?;LK9:;< I;= 9H8 I:L:<G ;I J G=JI9
EHJ=G8 JGJ:<?9 H:FQ :< ;=B8= 9; ?KAA;=9 H:? E;<98<9:;< 9HJ9 9H8 ?JF8
O;KLB E;<?9:9K98 B;KML8 a8;AJ=BN5
• DC EI=='L@ '? ABE Q>FBR9 #<>FQB' F@@FQA<G @' ABE ><@@<L F Q<L@B?BQF@B'C
@AF@ <; <;9:E8 ;I J==J:G<F8<9 OJ? 8P8= =8E8:P8B MN 9H8 +II:E8 ;I 9H8
!=;P:<E:JL 3:?EJL ;I /GK?J< B8L 1K= :< E;<<8E9:;< O:9H 9HJ9 A8=aK=N
EJ?8m J<B J E8=9:I:EJ9:;< ;I !=8?:B:<G ]KBG8 *:=:JE; /=:s; 9HJ9 ?J:B
A8=aK=N EJ?8 :< H:? E;K=9 B:B <;9 =8JEH 9H8 J==J:G<F8<9 ?9JG8 ?:<E8
JE9:;< 9H8=8;< OJ? ?K?A8<B8B A8<B:<G 9H8 =8P:8O '? @A< QFE< MN @A<
8<=FL@R<C@ '? :IE@BQ<$
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 23/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*0
• 4RMIGERFC F==L'T<G @A< ?B>BCW '? ?F>EB?BQF@B'C QAFLW<E FWFBCE@ F>> @A<
A<L<BC =LBTF@< L<E='CG<C@E$ ! 0H8 MJ?:E A;?9KLJ98 OJ? 9HJ9Q 8UE8A9
I;= 9H8 8N8O:9<8?? 98?9:F;<N ;I =8?A;<B8<9 1J<?J89Q 9H8=8 OJ? <;
;9H8= B:=8E9 8P:B8<E8 9; A=;P8 9H8 E;<IJMKLJ98B IJL?:I:EJ9:;< ;I
B;EKF8<9? MN =8?A;<B8<9? D;<=JBJ J<B !J=8B8?5
• 5FCGBWFCMFNFC ! LI><G @AF@c h_$"- ,7% %3*2%+&% /22(&%2A ,7%
"..")*,*"+ =/) /9'% ," %),/9'*)7 ,7/, &'*%+, /+2 '/=1%$ $%'/,*"+)7*.
%B*),%2 9%,=%%+ ;,,14 6/+)/%, /+2 :%#%$*+" F/$%2%)A J$4A 9%#"$%A 2($*+I/+2 /#,%$ ,7% .%$*"2 /''%I%2 *+ ,7% *+#"$-/,*"+4 R+ 3*%= "# )(&7
$%'/,*"+)7*.A ,7% #/&,) )($$"(+2*+I ,7% &/)%A /+2 ",7%$ &"+#*2%+,*/'
-/,,%$ -(), 7/3% 9%%+ 2*)&'")%2 91 /&&()%2 F/$%2%)A /) &'*%+,A ,"
/&&()%2 6/+)/%,A /) 7*) '/=1%$ *+ 7*) .$"#%))*"+/' &/./&*,14 V7%$%#"$%A
,7% ,%),*-"+1 "# ;,,14 6/+)/%, "+ ,7% #/&,) )($$"(+2*+I ,7% "##%+)%
&7/$I%2 *+ ,7% *+#"$-/,*"+ *) .$*3*'%I%24D
#11-&
i5 "$_ V& @A< =L'e<Q@<G @<E@BR'CN '? L<E='CG<C@ 5FCEF<@9 FE =L'='E<G
E@F@< PB@C<EE9 BE MFLL<G MN @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< ! .+ e 188
"J9:; 6d;LB J<B K<B8=L:<8B7
_5
*$_ V& FE F Q'CE<\I<CQ< @A<L<'?9 A< BE <>BWBM>< ?'L GBEQAFLW< @' @<E@B?N
FE F ./$,*&%.) &$*-*+*) ! lU5$ 188 "J9:; 6d;LB J<B K<B8=L:<8B7
D&%(@
• fCR<LB@'LB'IE
• VSU%UH4%U9 @A< PLB@ '? Q<L@B'LFLB =LFN<G ?'L BE A<L<MN WLFC@<G
5U66D&# 75D8U @A< BR=IWC<G L<E'>I@B'CE FCG 4%8U%D&# @AF@ @A<
=L<E<C@ L<>B<?E E'IWA@ BC @A<E< QFE<E MN =<@B@B'C<L M< F>>'P<G FCG
WBT<C GI< Q'ILE< MN L<E='CG<C@ 5FCGBWFCMFNFC$
"/0#+
• 3#"10 #11-&@ D@ RFN Q'LL<Q@>N M< FEEIR<G @AF@ @A<L< PFE F Q'C?BG<C@BF>
Q'RRICBQF@B'C RFG< MN ;FL<G<E @' 5FCEF<@ BC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@AKLBRBCF> KFE<E &'E$ "22+")+0 ?'L ?F>EB?BQF@B'C M<?'L< L<E='CG<C@ Q'IL@9
FCG @ABE RFN L<FE'CFM>N M< <Z=<Q@<G EBCQ< ;FL<G<E PFE @A< FQQIE<G
FCG 5FCEF<@ ABE Q'ICE<> @A<L<BC$ DCG<<G9 @A< ?FQ@ @AF@ 5FCEF<@ PFE
QF>><G @' PB@C<EE @A< =L<=FLF@B'C '? @A< ?F>EB?B<G G'QIR<C@E MN
;FL<G<E FCG S'CLFGF PFE FE <>'\I<C@ F Q'RRICBQF@B'C9 B? C'@ R'L<9
@AFC T<LMF> E@F@<R<C@E M<BCW RFG< @' ABR MN ;FL<G<E FE @' @A< ?FQ@
FCG =IL='E< '? EIQA ?F>EB?BQF@B'C$ S) 5% %5=/505'(/) )#() )#$ $,54$/)5(-.
-+6$ */ )#5% :*5/) #(% (68(.% -$0$--$4 )* !(/. '*77+/5'()5*/UX
85)#*+) 45%)5/')5*/ *- ;+(6505'()5*/@
•
D@ BE ='E@I>F@<G @AF@ G<E=B@< EIQA Q'R=>BQB@N '? 5FCEF<@ F@ @A< BCE@FCQ<'? ;FL<G<E BC @A< QLBRBCF> FQ@ ?'L PABQA @A< >F@@<L E@FCGE QAFLW<G9 F
GBE@BCQ@B'C RIE@ M< RFG< M<@P<<C Q'C?BG<C@BF> Q'RRICBQF@B'CE
L<>F@BCW @' =FE@ QLBR<E F>L<FGN Q'RRB@@<G9 FCG ?I@IL< QLBR<E BC@<CG<G
@' M< Q'RRB@@<G9 MN @A< Q>B<C@$ K'L'>>FLB>N9 B@ BE FGRB@@<G @AF@ @A<
FCC'ICQ<G BC@<C@B'C '? F Q>B<C@ @' Q'RRB@ F QLBR< BE C'@ BCQ>IG<G
PB@ABC @A< Q'C?BG<CQ<E PABQA ABE F@@'LC<N BE M'ICG @' L<E=<Q@$
%<E='CG<C@ Q'IL@ F==<FLE9 A'P<T<L9 @' M<>B<T< @AF@ BC @A< BCE@FC@ QFE<
B@ BE G<F>BCW PB@A F =FE@ QLBR<9 FCG @AF@ L<E='CG<C@ 5FCEF<@ BE E<@ @'
@<E@B?N 'C F>><W<G QLBRBCF> FQ@E '? L<E='CG<C@E ;FL<G<E FCG S'CLFGF@AF@ AFT< F>L<FGN M<<C Q'RRB@@<G FCG Q'CEIRRF@<G$
• I;= 9H8 JAAL:EJ9:;< ;I 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8Q H;O8P8=Q 9H8
A8=:;B 9; M8 E;<?:B8=8B :? 9H8 BJ98 OH8< 9H8 A=:P:L8G8B
E;FFK<:EJ9:;< OJ? FJB8 MN 9H8 EL:8<9 9; 9H8 J99;=<8N :< =8LJ9:;< 9;
8:9H8= J E=:F8 E;FF:998B :< 9H8 AJ?9 ;= O:9H =8?A8E9 9; J E=:F8
:<98<B8B 9; M8 E;FF:998B :< 9H8 IK9K=85 #< ;9H8= O;=B?Q :I 9H8 EL:8<9
?88`? H:? LJON8=R? JBP:E8 O:9H =8?A8E9 9; J E=:F8 9HJ9 9H8 I;=F8= HJ?
9H8=89;I;=8 E;FF:998BQ H8 :? G:P8< 9H8 A=;98E9:;< ;I J P:=9KJL
E;<I8??:;<JL ?8JL OH:EH 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8 B8ELJ=8? EJ<<;9
M8 M=;`8< MN 9H8 J99;=<8N O:9H;K9 9H8 EL:8<9R? E;<?8<95 6A< EFR<
=LBTB><W<G Q'C?BG<C@BF>B@N9 A'P<T<L9 G'<E C'@ F@@FQA PB@A L<WFLG @' F
QLBR< PABQA F Q>B<C@ BC@<CGE @' Q'RRB@ @A<L<F?@<L 'L BC @A< ?I@IL< FCG
?'L =IL='E<E '? PABQA A< E<<XE @A< >FPN<LOE FGTBQ<$
• 19J98F8<9? J<B E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? =8GJ=B:<G 9H8 E;FF:??:;< ;I J
E=:F8 JL=8JBN E;FF:998BQ FJB8 MN J AJ=9N OH; E;FF:998B :9Q 9; J<
J99;=<8NQ E;<?KL98B J? ?KEHQ J=8 A=:P:L8G8B E;FFK<:EJ9:;<?5
*;<9=J=:LNQ 9H8 K<M=;`8< ?9=8JF ;I aKB:E:JL B:E9J :? 9; 9H8 8II8E9 9HJ9
E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? M89O88< J99;=<8N J<B EL:8<9 HJP:<G 9; B; O:9H 9H8
EL:8<9R? E;<98FALJ98B E=:F:<JL JE9?Q ;= :< J:B ;= IK=9H8=J<E8 9H8=8;IQ
J=8 <;9 E;P8=8B MN 9H8 EL;J` ;I A=:P:L8G8? ;=B:<J=:LN 8U:?9:<G :<
=8I8=8<E8 9; E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? M89O88< J99;=<8N J<B EL:8<9• @A< @<E@BR'CN E'IWA@ @' M< <>BQB@<G ?L'R 5FCEF<@ FE E@F@< PB@C<EE FL<
@A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE RFG< @' ABR MN =ANEBQF> FQ@E FCG1'L
FQQ'R=FCNBCW P'LGE '? ;FL<G<E F@ @A< @BR< A< FCG S'CLFGF9 <B@A<L
PB@A @A< FQ@BT< 'L =FEEBT< =FL@BQB=F@B'C '? 5FCEF<@9 P<L< FM'I@ @'
?F>EB?N9 'L BC @A< =L'Q<EE '? ?F>EB?NBCW9 @A< G'QIR<C@E PABQA P<L< >F@<L
?B><G BC @A< 6FC'GMFNFC MN 5FCEF<@ FCG QI>RBCF@<G BC @A< QLBRBCF>
QAFLW<E C'P =<CGBCW BC L<E='CG<C@ 5FCGBWFCMFNFC$ K><FL>N9 9H8=8I;=8Q
9H8 E;<I:B8<9:JL E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? 9HK? FJB8 MN !J=8B8? 9; 1J<?J89
O8=8 I;= AK=A;?8? ;I J<B :< =8I8=8<E8 9; 9H8 E=:F8 ;I IJL?:I:EJ9:;<
OH:EH HJB <;9 N89 M88< E;FF:998B :< 9H8 AJ?9 MN !J=8B8? MK9 OH:EHH8Q :< E;<I8B8=JEN O:9H H:? A=8?8<9 E;Y=8?A;<B8<9?Q LJ98= E;FF:998B5
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 24/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*,
DJP:<G M88< FJB8 I;= AK=A;?8? ;I J IK9K=8 ;II8<?8Q 9H;?8
E;FFK<:EJ9:;<? J=8 ;K9?:B8 9H8 AJL8 ;I 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G85
• 5FCEF<@ PFE ABRE<>? F Q'CE=BLF@'L BC @A< Q'RRBEEB'C '? @AF@ QLBR< '?
?F>EB?BQF@B'C PABQA A<9 ;FL<G<E FCG S'CLFGF Q'CQ'Q@<G FCG ?'BE@<G
I='C @A< FI@A'LB@B<E$ D@ BE P<>> E<@@><G @AF@ BC 'LG<L @AF@ F
Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C F >FPN<L FCG ABE Q>B<C@ RFN M< =LBTB><W<G9 B@
RIE@ M< ?'L F >FP?I> =IL='E< 'L BC ?IL@A<LFCQ< '? F >FP?I> <CG$ 6A<
<ZBE@<CQ< '? FC IC>FP?I> =IL='E< =L<T<C@E @A< =LBTB><W< ?L'R F@@FQABCW$• 1&*+.( #11-&c ;FL<C@A<@BQF>>N9 L<E='CG<C@ Q'IL@9 AFTBCW FLLBT<G F@ F
Q'C@LFLN Q'CQ>IEB'C 'C @A< =L<Q<GBCW BEEI<9 GBG C'@ =FEE I='C @ABE
E<Q'CG FE=<Q@ FCG @A< L<>B<? E'IWA@ MN @A< =L'E<QI@B'C PABQA FL< C'P
EIMRB@@<G ?'L 'IL L<E'>I@B'C BC @A< =<@B@B'C F@ MFLc
457 6A< ?FQ@ @AF@ L<E='CG<C@ 5FCGBWFCMFNFC GBG C'@ ?I>>N =FEE I='C @A<
\I<LN FE @' PA<@A<L 'L C'@ L<E='CG<C@ 5FCEF<@ PFE \IF>B?B<G @' M< F E@F@<
PB@C<EE C<<G C'@ =L<T<C@ @ABE K'IL@ ?L'R L<E'>TBCW @AF@ BEEI< FE =LFN<G ?'L
MN =<@B@B'C<L$ VA<L< @A< G<@<LRBCF@BT< ?FQ@E FCG <TBG<CQ< AFT< M<<C
EIMRB@@<G @' @ABE K'IL@ EIQA @AF@ B@ BE BC F ='EB@B'C @' ?BCF>>N L<E'>T< @A<
GBE=I@<9 B@ PB>> M< BC @A< =ILEIFCQ< '? @A< <CGE '? eIE@BQ< FCG @A< <Z=<GB@B'IE
FGRBCBE@LF@B'C @A<L<'? @' L<E'>T< @A< QFE< 'C @A< R<LB@E9 BCE@<FG '?
L<RFCGBCW B@ @' @A< @LBF> Q'IL@$
X57 7 L<E<LTF@B'C BE LFBE<G 'T<L @A< ?FQ@ @AF@ @A< @AL<< =LBTF@< L<E='CG<C@E
A<L< E@FCG QAFLW<G BC @AL<< E<=FLF@< BC?'LRF@B'CE$ D@ PB>> M< L<QF>><G @AF@ BC
B@E L<E'>I@B'C '? H<MLIFLN *,9 "++*9 @A< 4RMIGERFC L<Q'RR<CG<G @A< ?B>BCW
'? QLBRBCF> QAFLW<E ?'L ?F>EB?BQF@B'C '? =IM>BQ G'QIR<C@E FWFBCE@ F>> @A<
L<E='CG<C@E A<L<BC$ 6AF@ L<E'>I@B'C PFE F??BLR<G MI@9 L<='L@<G>N BC 'LG<L @'
'MTBF@< ?IL@A<L Q'C@L'T<LEN9 'C< BC?'LRF@B'C PFE ?B><G FWFBCE@ <FQA '? @A<
@AL<< L<E='CG<C@E A<L<9 L<EI>@BCW BC @AL<< BC?'LRF@B'CE ?'L @A< EFR< FQ@E '?
?F>EB?BQF@B'C$
•
W/2 *, 9%%+ *+,%+2%2 ,7/, /'' ,7% /&&()%2 )7"('2 /'=/1) 9% *+2*&,%2 *+"+% /+2 ,7% )/-% *+#"$-/,*"+A ,7% E('%) &"('2 7/3% )/*2 )" =*,7
#/&*'*,1A 9(, *, 2*2 +", )" $%M(*$% *+ &"+)*2%$/,*"+ "# ,7% &*$&(-),/+&%)
"9,/*+*+I *+ ,7% .$%)%+, &/)% /+2 ,7% .$"9'%-) ,7/, -/1 /$*)% #$"-
/-%+2*+I ,7% *+#"$-/,*"+4 ;#,%$ /''A ,7% .($.")% "# ,7% E('% &/+ 9%
/&7*%3%2 91 &"+)"'*2/,*"+ "# ,7% &/)%) /) /+ /',%$+/,*3% -"2%4
• 5FCEF<@ PFE F Q'CE=BLF@'L BC @A< QLBR< '? ?F>EB?BQF@B'C9 FCG @A< LI>< BE
@AF@ EBCQ< BC F Q'CE=BLFQN @A< FQ@ '? 'C< BE @A< FQ@ '? F>>9 @A< EFR<
=<CF>@N EAF>> M< BR='E<G 'C F>> R<RM<LE '? @A< Q'CE=BLFQN$ &'P9 'C<
'? @A< L<\IBL<R<C@E ?'L F E@F@< PB@C<EE BE @AF@ A< gG'<E C'@ F==<FL @'
M< @A< R'E@ WIB>@N$h
• 6AIE9 V< FWL<< PB@A @A< 'ME<LTF@B'CE '? @A< 5'>BQB@'L #<C<LF> @AF@ 9H8
=KL8 ;< 9H8 B:?EHJ=G8 ;I J< JEEK?8B 9; M8 K9:L:T8B J? ?9J98 O:9<8??
EL8J=LN L;;`? J9 H:? JE9KJL J<B :<B:P:BKJL AJ=9:E:AJ9:;< :< 9H8
E;FF:??:;< ;I 9H8 E=:F8Q OH:EH FJN ;= FJN <;9 HJP8 M88<
A8=A89=J98B :< E;<?A:=JEN O:9H 9H8 ;9H8= JEEK?8B5 1:<E8 d8=FKB8T
OJ? <;9 :<B:P:BKJLLN =8?A;<?:ML8 I;= 9H8 `:LL:<G E;FF:998B ;< 9H8
;EEJ?:;< ;I 9H8 =;MM8=N 8UE8A9 MN =8J?;< ;I E;<?A:=JENQ :9 EJ<<;9 M8
?J:B 9H8< 9HJ9 d8=FKB8T JAA8J=? 9; M8 9H8 F;?9 GK:L9N5 D8<E8Q H:?B:?EHJ=G8 9; M8 J O:9<8?? I;= 9H8 G;P8=<F8<9 :? EL8J=LN OJ==J<98B5W
• 6A< LI>< '? <\IF>B@N BC @A< =<CF>@N @' M< BR='E<G I='C Q'CE=BLF@'LE
?'ICG WIB>@N '? F QLBRBCF> '??<CE< BE MFE<G 'C @A< Q'CQILL<CQ< '?
QLBRBCF> BC@<C@ BC @A<BL RBCGE FCG @LFCE>F@<G BC@' Q'CQ<L@<G =ANEBQF>
FQ@B'C F>@A'IWA '? TFLNBCW FQ@E 'L G<WL<<E '? G<=LFTB@N$ 5BCQ< @A<
%<TBE<G ;<CF> K'G< BE MFE<G 'C @A< Q>FEEBQF> EQA''> '? @A'IWA@9 B@ BE @A<
BG<C@B@N '? @A< R<CE L<F PABQA BE Q'CEBG<L<G @A< =L<G'RBCFC@
Q'CEBG<LF@B'C FCG9 @A<L<?'L<9 PFLLFC@E @A< BR='EB@B'C '? @A< EFR<
=<CF>@N 'C @A< Q'CE<\I<C@BF> @A<'LN @AF@ @A< FQ@ '? 'C< BE @A<L<MN @A<
FQ@ '? F>>$
•
"8?A;<B8<9 1J<?J89 :? 9H8 ;<LN E;;A8=J9:P8 8N8O:9<8?? 9; 9H8 JE9KJL
E;FF:??:;< ;I 9H8 IJL?:I:EJ9:;< EHJ=G8B :< 9H8 E=:F:<JL EJ?8? A8<B:<G
M8I;=8 =8?A;<B8<9 E;K=9Q J<B 9H8 A=;?8EK9:;< :? IJE8B O:9H 9H8
I;=F:BJML8 9J?` ;I 8?9JML:?H:<G 9H8 GK:L9 ;I 9H8 9O; ;9H8= E;Y
=8?A;<B8<9? OH; ?98JBIJ?9LN B8<N 9H8 EHJ=G8 J<B ?9;K9LN A=;98?9
9H8:= :<<;E8<E85 0H8=8 :? 9HK? <; ;9H8= B:=8E9 8P:B8<E8 JPJ:LJML8 I;=
9H8 A=;?8EK9:;< ;I 9H8 EJ?8Q H8<E8 9H8=8 :? JM?;LK98 <8E8??:9N I;= 9H8
98?9:F;<N ;I 1J<?J89 OH;?8 B:?EHJ=G8 :? ?;KGH9 A=8E:?8LN I;= 9HJ9
AK=A;?85 1J:B =8?A;<B8<9 HJ? :<B:EJ98B H:? E;<I;=F:9N 9H8=89; J<B
HJ?Q I;= 9H8 AK=A;?8? =8SK:=8B MN 9H8 "KL8?Q B89J:L8B 9H8 ?KM?9J<E8 ;I
H:? A=;a8E98B 98?9:F;<N :< H:? /II:BJP:9 ;I &UALJ<J9:;<? J<B"8E9:I:EJ9:;<?5
• V7% :"($, *) $%/)"+/9'1 &"+3*+&%2A /+2 )" 7"'2)A ,7/, ,7% ",7%$
$%M(*)*,%) #"$ ,7% 2*)&7/$I% "# $%)."+2%+, 6/+)/%, /) / ),/,% =*,+%))
/$% .$%)%+, /+2 %#*+64 #(,$ <$$/ 0(,*-(<6. (::-$'5()$4 <. )#$
1(/45=(/<(.(/@
• E%)."+2%+, 1(/%($) 5% )#$ */6. '**:$-()5,$ $.$85)/$%% )* )#$ (')+(6
'*775%%5*/ *0 )#$ 0(6%505'()5*/ '#(-=$4 5/ )#$ '-575/(6 '(%$% :$/45/=
<$0*-$ -$%:*/4$/) '*+-)U (/4 )#$ :-*%$'+)5*/ 5% 0('$4 85)# )#$
0*-754(<6$ )(%9 *0 $%)(<65%#5/= )#$ =+56) *0 )#$ )8* *)#$- '*H-$%:*/4$/)% 8#* %)$(40(%)6. 4$/. )#$ '#(-=$ (/4 %)*+)6. :-*)$%)
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 25/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*3
)#$5- 5//*'$/'$@ "#$-$ 5% )#+% /* *)#$- 45-$') $,54$/'$ (,(56(<6$ 0*-
)#$ :-*%$'+)5*/ *0 )#$ '(%$U #$/'$ )#$-$ 5% (<%*6+)$ /$'$%%5). 0*- )#$
)$%)57*/. *0 1(/%($) 8#*%$ 45%'#(-=$ 5% %*+=#) :-$'5%$6. 0*- )#()
:+-:*%$@ 6/*2 $%)."+2%+, 7/) *+2*&/,%2 7*) &"+#"$-*,1 ,7%$%," /+2 7/)A
#"$ ,7% .($.")%) $%M(*$%2 91 ,7% E('%)A 2%,/*'%2 ,7% )(9),/+&% "# 7*)
.$"H%&,%2 ,%),*-"+1 *+ 7*) ;##*2/3*, "# GB.'/+/,*"+) /+2 E%&,*#*&/,*"+)4
^5
D#*r,/. $15 0/C%+" 6$'75IRRFLN '? W*&?-/+ 34 V/1'"$ 9 0*+ f$5$ ,+39 ]2 5$ K@$ 0-39 +" ($ UG$ ,3" ^"+,2_$
3/*01
7 @IWM'F@ EFCX XB>>BCW ?BT< QL<P R<RM<LE$ SBQXRFC ^;_ ML'IWA@ @ABE
PL'CW?I> G<F@A >FPEIB@ FE L<=L<E<C@F@BT< '? 'C< '? @A< G<Q<FE<G FWFBCE@ 6FN>'L
<@ F>$ ^8E_$ 6A< ?'IL EILTBT'LE @<E@B?B<G F@ F =IM>BQ A<FLBCW M<?'L< @A< fCB@<G
5@F@<E 5@<FRM'F@ DCE=<Q@'LE FCG @A<BL @<E@BR'CN PFE L<Q'LG<G FCG RFG<
FTFB>FM>< @' F>> '? @A< =FL@B<E$ 6A< G<?<CGFC@E Q'CGIQ@<G @A<BL 'PC BC@<LTB<PE
'? @A< EILTBT'LE FCG '@A<LE AFTBCW BC?'LRF@B'C L<WFLGBCW @A< FQQBG<C@$
6A< G<?<CGFC@E FCEP<L<G F>> BC@<LL'WF@'LB<E <ZQ<=@ ?'L F EIRRFLN '?
E@F@<R<C@E 'M@FBC<G BC @A< Q'ILE< '? @A<BL 'PC BC@<LTB<PE$ 6A< G<?<CGFC@E
Q'C@<CG<G @AF@ @A< L<\I<E@<G EIRRFLN =<L@FBC<G @' g=LBTB><W<G RF@@<L
'M@FBC<G BC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L >B@BWF@B'Ch FCG PFE @A<L<?'L< =LBTB><W<G$
SBQXRFC 'Me<Q@<G FCG @A< GBE@LBQ@ Q'IL@ A<>G @AF@ @A< L<\I<E@<G
BC?'LRF@B'C PFE C'@ =LBTB><W<G FCG 'LG<L<G @A< G<?<CGFC@E @' =L'GIQ< B@$
K'ICE<> ?'L @A< G<?<CGFC@E L<?IE<G @' Q'R=>N FCG P<L< A<>G BC Q'C@<R=@$ 6A<
K'IL@ '? 7==<F>E L<T<LE<G FCG @A< 5I=L<R< K'IL@ WLFC@<G Q<L@B'LFLB$
#??K8?
"$ 8' @A< H<G<LF> %I><E '? KBTB> ;L'Q<GIL< =<L@FBCBCW @' GBEQ'T<LN L<\IBL< FC
F@@'LC<N @' =L'GIQ< 'LF> FCG PLB@@<C E@F@<R<C@E 'L '@A<L BC?'LRF@B'C'M@FBC<G BC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L ='EEBM>< >B@BWF@B'C F?@<L F Q>FBR AFE FLBE<Cb
*$ DE BC?'LRF@B'C =L<=FL<G 'L 'M@FBC<G MN Q'ICE<> BC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L >B@BWF@B'C
F?@<L F Q>FBR AFE FLBE<C =L'@<Q@<G MN @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<b
D;LB:<G J<B "KL8 6,K=AHN7
"$ &'$ DC @A<E< QBLQIRE@FCQ<E9 %I><E *]9 00 FCG 0, '? @A< H<G<LF> %I><E '? KBTB>
;L'Q<GIL< G' C'@ L<\IBL< FC F@@'LC<N @' =L'GIQ< 'LF> FCG PLB@@<C
E@F@<R<C@E 'L '@A<L BC?'LRF@B'C 'M@FBC<G BC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L ='EEBM><
>B@BWF@B'C F?@<L F Q>FBR AFE FLBE<C$
*$
&'$ DC?'LRF@B'C =L<=FL<G 'L 'M@FBC<G MN Q'ICE<> BC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L>B@BWF@B'C F?@<L F Q>FBR AFE FLBE<C BE C'@ =L'@<Q@<G MN @A< F@@'LC<N)
Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< FCG BE C'@ =L'@<Q@<G ?L'R GBEQ'T<LN 'C @AF@ MFEBE$
8BEQ'T<LN '? PLB@@<C RF@<LBF>E 'M@FBC<G 'L =L<=FL<G MN '=='EBCW
Q'ICE<> BC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L ='EEBM>< >B@BWF@B'C RFN C'@ M< AFG IC><EE @A< =FL@N
E<<XBCW GBEQ'T<LN QFC <E@FM>BEA @AF@ L<><TFC@ FCG C'C)=LBTB><W<G ?FQ@E L<RFBC
ABGG<C BC FC F@@'LC<NOE ?B><9 FCG PA<L< =L'GIQ@B'C '? @A'E< ?FQ@E BE <EE<C@BF> @'
@A< =L<=FLF@B'C '? @A< =FL@NOE QFE<$
%I>< 0/^M_ WBT<E @A< @LBF> eIGW< @A< L<\IBEB@< GBEQL<@B'C @' RFX< F eIGWR<C@ FE @' PA<@A<L GBEQ'T<LN EA'I>G M< F>>'P<G FE @' PLB@@<C E@F@<R<C@E
E<QIL<G ?L'R PB@C<EE<E$ DC @ABE QFE< A'P<T<L @A<L< PFE C' WL'ICG ?'L @A<
<Z<LQBE< '? @AF@ GBEQL<@B'C BC ?FT'L '? @A< =>FBC@B??$
6 A< 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ <LL<G BC A'>GBCW @A< G<?<CGFC@E BC Q'C@<R=@ ?'L
?FB>IL< @' =L'GIQ< @AF@ PABQA PFE BC @A< ='EE<EEB'C '? @A<BL Q'ICE<>9 FCG BC
A'>GBCW @A<BL Q'ICE<> BC Q'C@<R=@ ?'L ?FB>IL< @' =L'GIQ< @AF@ PABQA A< Q'I>G
C'@ M< Q'R=<>><G @' =L'GIQ< ICG<L <B@A<L %I>< 00 'L %I>< 0,$
!KML:E !;L:EN
6A< W<C<LF> ='>BQN FWFBCE@ BCTFGBCW @A< =LBTFQN '? FC F@@'LC<NOE Q'ILE<
'? =L<=FLF@B'C BE E' <EE<C@BF> @' FC 'LG<L>N P'LXBCW '? 'IL ENE@<R '? ><WF>=L'Q<GIL< @AF@ F MILG<C L<E@E 'C @A< 'C< PA' P'I>G BCTFG< @AF@ =LBTFQN @'
<E@FM>BEA FG<\IF@< L<FE'CE @' eIE@B?N =L'GIQ@B'C @AL'IWA F EIM='<CF 'L Q'IL@
'LG<L$ 6A<L< RIE@ M< E'R< EA'PBCW '? C<Q<EEB@N 'L eIE@B?BQF@B'C MN @A< =FL@N
E<<XBCW B@E GBEQ'T<LN$ D? L<><TFC@ FCG C'C=LBTB><W<G ?FQ@E L<RFBC ABGG<C BC FC
F@@'LC<NOE ?B>< FCG @A< =L'GIQ@B'C '? @A'E< ?FQ@E BE <EE<C@BF> @' @A< =L<=FLF@B'C
'? F QFE<9 GBEQ'T<LN RFN M< RFG<$
fCG<L @A< QBLQIRE@FCQ<E '? @ABE QFE<9 C' EA'PBCW '? C<Q<EEB@N Q'I>G M<
RFG< PABQA P'I>G eIE@B?N L<\IBLBCW @A< =L'GIQ@B'C '? 'LF> E@F@<R<C@E RFG< MN
PB@C<EE<E @' Q'ICE<> ?'L @A< G<?<CGFC@E9 PA<@A<L =L<E<C@>N BC @A< ?'LR '? ABE
R<C@F> BR=L<EEB'CE 'L BC @A< ?'LR '? R<R'LFCGF$ SBQXRFC AFG FC FG<\IF@<'=='L@ICB@N @' E<<X GBEQ'T<LN '? @A< EFR< ?FQ@E =FL@BQI>FL>N MN @A< GBL<Q@
BC@<LTB<PE '? @A< PB@C<EE<E FCG RFG< C' F@@<R=@ @' EA'P PAN =L'GIQ@B'C PFE
C<Q<EEFLN$
(:?A;?:9:;<
:IGWR<C@ F??BLR<G$
*;<EK==8<E8 6]JE`?;<7
6A< \I<E@B'C BE EBR=>N PA<@A<L EIQA F G<RFCG BE FI@A'LBa<G MN @A< LI><E
L<>F@BCW @' TFLB'IE FE=<Q@E '? gGBEQ'T<LN$h 8BEQ'T<LN EA'I>G =L'TBG< F =FL@N
FQQ<EE @' FCN@ABCW @AF@ BE <TBG<CQ< BC ABE QFE<$ 8BEQ'T<LN EA'I>G C'@ A'P<T<L
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 26/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*]
CI>>B?N @A< =LBTB><W< '? Q'C?BG<C@BF> Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C F@@'LC<N FCG
Q>B<C@$ YI@ @A'E< =LBCQB=><E WBT< IE C' L<F> FEEBE@FCQ< A<L< M<QFIE< PAF@ BE
E'IWA@ BE C<B@A<L <TBG<CQ< C'L F =LBTB><W<G Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C F@@'LC<N
FCG Q>B<C@$
6' Q'CEBG<L ?BLE@ @A< R'E@ <Z@L<R< FE=<Q@ '? @A< L<\IBL<R<C@ BC >B@BWF@B'C A<L<9
P< ?BCG B@ QF>>E I='C Q'ICE<> @' gE<@ ?'L@A BC G<@FB> @A< <ZFQ@ =L'TBEB'C '? FCN
EIQA 'LF> E@F@<R<C@E 'L L<='L@E$h 6AIE9 @A< G<RFCG BE C'@ ?'L @A< =L'GIQ@B'C
'? F @LFCEQLB=@ BC <ZBE@<CQ<9 MI@ QF>>E ?'L @A< QL<F@B'C '? F PLB@@<C E@F@<R<C@ C'@
BC M<BCW$ 6A< E@F@<R<C@ MN Q'ICE<> '? PAF@ F PB@C<EE @'>G ABR BE C'@ <TBG<CQ<$
5<< >5:$- W5-'-(0) ,@ Y$./* ?'L F >FP EQA''> QBTB> =L'Q<GIL< QFE< MLB<? A'>GBCW
@AF@ FQQ<EE @' <TBG<CQ< FCG @A< FTFB>FMB>B@N '? PB@C<EE<E FL< ?FQ@'LE @' M<
Q'CEBG<L<G BC WLFC@BCW F R'@B'C @' GBERBEE 'C ?'LIR C'C Q'CT<CB<CE WL'ICGE$
6A< QFE< BCT'>T<G F PL'CW?I> G<F@A >FPEIB@$
j5 -!]+D. *+5 $15 -51 6,d7
!89:9:;<8=@ f=e'AC K'R=FCN
"8?A;<B8<9@ fCB@<G 5@F@<E
:FCIFLN "09 "+-"
,,+ f$5$ 0-0
[L$ :IE@BQ< %<AC\IBE@
1-,,/"C@
VA<C #<C<LF> K'ICE<> 6A'RFE ?'L f=e'ACOE =AFLRFQ<I@BQF>
RFCI?FQ@ILBCW Q'L='LF@B'C PFE BC?'LR<G @AF@ 'C< '? B@E ?'L<BWC EIMEBGBFLB<E
AFG RFG< \I<E@B'CFM>< =FNR<C@E @' ?'L<BWC W'T<LCR<C@ '??BQBF>E BC 'LG<L @'
E<QIL< W'T<LCR<C@ MIEBC<EE9 FC BC@<LCF> BCT<E@BWF@B'C '? EIQA =FNR<C@E PFE
BCB@BF@<G$ f=e'ACiE F@@'LC<NE E<C@ F \I<E@B'CCFBL< @' F>> ?'L<BWC RFCFW<LE
E<<XBCW G<@FB><G BC?'LRF@B'C Q'CQ<LCBCW EIQA =FNR<C@E9 FCG @A< L<E='CE<EP<L< L<@ILC<G @' #<C<LF> K'ICE<> 6A'RFE$ 5IME<\I<C@>N9 MFE<G 'C F L<='L@
T'>IC@FLB>N EIMRB@@<G MN f=e'AC GBEQ>'EBCW @A< \I<E@B'CFM>< =FNR<C@E9 @A<
DC@<LCF> %<T<CI< 5<LTBQ< ^D%5_ M<WFC FC BCT<E@BWF@B'C @' G<@<LRBC< @A< @FZ
Q'CE<\I<CQ<E '? EIQA =FNR<C@E FCG BEEI<G EIRR'CE<E G<RFCGBCW
=L'GIQ@B'C '? @A< \I<E@B'CCFBL<E9 R<R'LFCGF FCG C'@<E '? @A< BC@<LTB<PE$
f=e'AC L<?IE<G @' =L'GIQ< @A< G'QIR<C@E 'C @A< WL'ICGE @AF@ @A<N P<L<
=L'@<Q@<G ?L'R GBEQ>'EIL< MN @A< gF@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<h FCG Q'CE@B@I@<G
@A< gP'LX)=L'GIQ@h '? F@@'LC<NE =L<=FL<G BC FC@BQB=F@B'C '? >B@BWF@B'C$ f5 @A<C
?B><G F =<@B@B'C BC H<G<LF> 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ E<<XBCW <C?'LQ<R<C@ '? @A< EIRR'CE$
8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ LI><G @AF@ @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< AFG M<<C PFBT<G MNf=e'AC FCG @AF@ @A< #'T<LCR<C@ AFG RFG< F EI??BQB<C@ EA'PBCW '? C<Q<EEB@N
@' 'T<LQ'R< @A< =L'@<Q@B'C '? @A< P'LX)=L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC<$ 6A< K7 L<e<Q@<G @A<
?BCGBCW '? F PFBT<L FCG A<>G @AF@ ICG<L @A< kQ'C@L'> WL'I= @<E@k @A< =LBTB><W<
GBG C'@ F==>N @' @A< <Z@<C@ @AF@ '? Q'RRICBQF@B'CE RFG< MN '??BQ<LE FCG
FW<C@E C'@ L<E='CEBM>< ?'L GBL<Q@BCW f=e'ACiE FQ@B'CE BC L<E='CE< @' ><WF>
FGTBQ< M<QFIE< @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE P<L< C'@ @A< iQ>B<C@iE$i K7 F>E' A<>G @AF@
@A< P'LX)=L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC< GBG C'@ F==>N @' D%5 EIRR'CE<E$ 5K A<>G @AF@c
^"_ 6A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE MN f=e'ACiE <R=>'N<<E @' Q'ICE<> FL< E;P8=8B MN
9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8 BCE'?FL FE @A< L<E='CE<E @' @A<
\I<E@B'CCFBL<E FCG FCN C'@<E L<?><Q@BCW L<E='CE<E @' BC@<LTB<P
\I<E@B'CE FL< Q'CQ<LC<G$ 6A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE Q'CQ<LC<G RF@@<LE
PB@ABC @A< EQ'=< '? @A< <R=>'N<<Ei Q'L='LF@< GI@B<E9 FCG @A<
<R=>'N<<E @A<RE<>T<E P<L< EI??BQB<C@>N FPFL< @AF@ @A<N P<L< M<BCW
\I<E@B'C<G BC 'LG<L @AF@ @A< Q'L='LF@B'C Q'I>G 'M@FBC ><WF> FGTBQ<$
^*_ 6A< O;=`YA=;BKE9 B;E9=:<8 JAAL:8? @' D%5 EIRR'CE<E$ 7E H<G<LF> %I><
'? KBTB> ;L'Q<GIL< *]9 PABQA FQQ'LGE E=<QBF> =L'@<Q@B'C ?L'R GBEQ>'EIL<
@' P'LX =L'GIQ@ L<T<F>BCW FC F@@'LC<NiE R<C@F> =L'Q<EE<E9 RFX< Q><FL9
EIQA P'LX =L'GIQ@ QFCC'@ M< GBEQ>'E<G EBR=>N 'C F EA'PBCW '?
EIME@FC@BF> C<<G 'L BCFMB>B@N @' 'M@FBC @A< <\IBTF><C@ PB@A'I@ ICGI<
AFLGEAB=$
3/*01@
• 6ABE BE F =<@B@B'C ?'L Q<L@B'LFLB @' FGGL<EE @A< EQ'=< '? @A< F@@'LC<N)
Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BC @A< Q'L='LF@< Q'C@<Z@ FCG @A< F==>BQFMB>B@N '? @A<
P'LX)=L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC< BC =L'Q<<GBCWE @' <C?'LQ< @FZ EIRR'CE<E$
• f=e'AC RFCI?FQ@IL<E FCG E<>>E =AFLRFQ<I@BQF>E BC @A< f5 FCG FML'FG$
• DC :FCIFLN "+2]9 BCG<=<CG<C@ FQQ'IC@FC@E Q'CGIQ@BCW FC FIGB@ '? 'C<
'? f=e'ACOE ?'L<BWC EIMEBGBFLB<E GBEQ'T<L<G @AF@ @A< EIMEBGBFLN RFG<
=FNR<C@E @' 'L ?'L @A< M<C<?B@ '? ?'L<BWC W'T<LCR<C@ '??BQBF>E BC 'LG<L
@' E<QIL< W'T<LCR<C@ MIEBC<EE$o 6A< FQQ'IC@FC@E BC?'LR<G [L$ #<LFLG 6A'RFE9 f=e'ACiE JBQ<)
;L<EBG<C@9 5<QL<@FLN9 FCG #<C<LF> K'ICE<> ?'L */ N<FLE$
o D@ PFE G<QBG<G @AF@ @A< Q'R=FCN P'I>G Q'CGIQ@ FC BC@<LCF>
BCT<E@BWF@B'C '? PAF@ P<L< @<LR<G k\I<E@B'CFM>< =FNR<C@E$k
• 6A< F@@'LC<NE =L<=FL<G F ><@@<L Q'C@FBCBCW F \I<E@B'CCFBL< PABQA PFE
E<C@ @' kF>> ?'L<BWC W<C<LF> FCG FL<F RFCFW<LE$k
o 6A< \I<E@B'CCFBL< E'IWA@ G<@FB><G BC?'LRF@B'C Q'CQ<LCBCW
EIQA =FNR<C@E$
o D@ C'@<G L<Q<C@ GBEQ>'EIL<E @AF@ E<T<LF> 7R<LBQFC Q'R=FCB<E
RFG< k='EEBM>N B>><WF>k =FNR<C@E @' ?'L<BWC W'T<LCR<C@
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 27/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*2
'??BQBF>E FCG <R=AFEBa<G @AF@ @A< RFCFW<R<C@ C<<G<G ?I>>
BC?'LRF@B'C Q'CQ<LCBCW FCN EIQA =FNR<C@E RFG< MN f=e'AC$
o D@ BG<C@B?B<G 6A'RFE FE k@A< Q'R=FCNiE #<C<LF> K'ICE<>k FCG
L<?<LL<G BC B@E '=<CBCW
o 7CN ?I@IL< FWL<<R<C@E PB@A ?'L<BWC GBE@LBMI@'LE 'L FW<C@E
P<L< @' M< F==L'T<G kMN F Q'R=FCN F@@'LC<Nk FCG FCN
\I<E@B'CE Q'CQ<LCBCW @A< ='>BQN P<L< @' M< L<?<LL<G k@' @A<
Q'R=FCNiE #<C<LF> K'ICE<>$k
o [FCFW<LE P<L< BCE@LIQ@<G @' @L<F@ @A< BCT<E@BWF@B'C FE kABWA>N
Q'C?BG<C@BF>k FCG C'@ @' GBEQIEE B@ PB@A FCN'C< '@A<L @AFC
f=e'AC <R=>'N<<E PA' RBWA@ M< A<>=?I> BC =L'TBGBCW @A<
L<\I<E@<G BC?'LRF@B'C$
o %<E='CE<E P<L< @' M< E<C@ GBL<Q@>N @' 6A'RFE$ 6A'RFE FCG
'I@EBG< Q'ICE<> F>E' BC@<LTB<P<G @A< L<QB=B<C@E '? @A<
\I<E@B'CCFBL< FCG E'R< 00 '@A<L f=e'AC '??BQ<LE 'L
<R=>'N<<E FE =FL@ '? @A< BCT<E@BWF@B'C$
o 6A'RFE G<EQLBM<G ABE C'@<E '? @A< BC@<LTB<PE FE Q'C@FBCBCW
kPAF@ D Q'CEBG<L @' M< @A< BR='L@FC@ \I<E@B'CE9 @A< EIME@FCQ<
'? @A< L<E='CE<E @' @A<R9 RN M<>B<?E FE @' @A< BR='L@FCQ< '?@A<E<9 RN M<>B<?E FE @' A'P @A<N L<>F@<G @' @A< BC\IBLN9 RN
@A'IWA@E FE @' A'P @A<N L<>F@<G @' '@A<L \I<E@B'CE$ DC E'R<
BCE@FCQ<E @A<N RBWA@ <T<C EIWW<E@ '@A<L \I<E@B'CE @AF@ D
P'I>G AFT< @' FEX 'L @ABCWE @AF@ D C<<G<G @' ?BCG <>E<PA<L<$k
• 4C [FLQA *]9 "+2]9 @A< Q'R=FCN T'>IC@FLB>N EIMRB@@<G F =L<>BRBCFLN
L<='L@ @' @A< 5<QILB@B<E FCG UZQAFCW< K'RRBEEB'C 'C H'LR -)m
GBEQ>'EBCW Q<L@FBC \I<E@B'CFM>< =FNR<C@E$
o K'=N '? @A< L<='L@ PFE EBRI>@FC<'IE>N EIMRB@@<G @' @A<
DC@<LCF> %<T<CI< 5<LTBQ<9 PABQA BRR<GBF@<>N M<WFC FC
BCT<E@BWF@B'C @' G<@<LRBC< @A< @FZ Q'CE<\I<CQ<E '? @A<=FNR<C@E$
• 6A< 5<LTBQ< BEEI<G EIRR'CE G<RFCGBCW =L'GIQ@B'C '?c
"$ 7>> ?B><E L<>F@BT< @' @A< BCT<E@BWF@B'C Q'CGIQ@<G ICG<L @A<
EI=<LTBEB'C '? #<LFLG 6A'RFE
*$ %<Q'LGE EA'I>G BCQ>IG< MI@ C'@ M< >BRB@<G @' @A< PLB@@<C
\I<E@B'CCFBL<E9 R<R'LFCGF 'L C'@<E '? @A< BC@<LTB<PE
Q'CGIQ@<G BC @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E FCG FML'FG PB@A '??BQ<LE FCG
<R=>'N<<E '? @A< f=e'AC K'R=FCN FCG B@E EIMEBGBFLB<E$
• 6A< Q'R=FCN G<Q>BC<G @' =L'GIQ< @A< G'QIR<C@E ICG<L y* FM'T< 'C
@A< WL'ICGE @AF@ @A<N P<L< =L'@<Q@<G ?L'R GBEQ>'EIL< MN @A< F@@'LC<N)
Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< FCG Q'CE@B@I@<G @A< P'LX =L'GIQ@ '? F@@'LC<NE
=L<=FL<G BC FC@BQB=F@B'C '? >B@BWF@B'C$
• 6A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E ?B><G F =<@B@B'C E<<XBCW <C?'LQ<R<C@ '? @A<
EIRR'CE BC @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ ?'L @A< V<E@<LC 8BE@LBQ@ '?
[BQABWFC$
• ^*),$*&, :"($, #"$ ,7% @%),%$+ ^*),$*&, "# N*&7*I/+ ! FG'=@<G F
RFWBE@LF@<OE ?BCGBCW FCG LI><G @AF@ @A< EIRR'CE EA'I>G M< <C?'LQ<G$
f=e'AC F==<F><G$• :; #"$ ,7% 6*B,7 :*$&(*, ! L<e<Q@<G @A< RFWBE@LF@<iE ?BCGBCW '? F PFBT<L
'? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<9 MI@ FWL<<G @AF@ @A< =LBTB><W< GBG C'@
F==>N @' @A< <Z@<C@ @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE P<L< RFG< MN '??BQ<LE FCG
FW<C@E C'@ L<E='CEBM>< ?'L GBL<Q@BCW f=e'ACiE FQ@B'CE BC L<E='CE< @'
><WF> FGTBQ< ?'L @A< EBR=>< L<FE'C @AF@ @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE P<L< C'@
@A< iQ>B<C@iE$i
o 7QQ<=@BCW f=e'ACiE Q>FBR ?'L F ML'FG<L F==>BQF@B'C '? @A<
=LBTB><W< P'I>G <CQ'ILFW< I==<L)<QA<>'C RFCFW<R<C@ @'
BWC'L< IC=><FEFC@ ?FQ@E FCG QL<F@< @'' ML'FG F ka'C< '?
EB><CQ<$k
o
&'@BCW @AF@ f=e'ACiE Q'ICE<> AFG BC@<LTB<P<G '??BQBF>E EIQA FE
@A< KAFBLRFC FCG ;L<EBG<C@9 @A< K'IL@ '? 7==<F>E L<RFCG<G
@' @A< 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ E' @AF@ F G<@<LRBCF@B'C '? PA' PFE PB@ABC
@A< kQ'C@L'> WL'I=k ^E<< LF@B'_ Q'I>G M< RFG<$
o 6A< P'LX)=L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC< ^E<< LF@B'_ BE C'@ F==>BQFM>< @'
FGRBCBE@LF@BT< EIRR'CE<E BEEI<G$
• S<CQ< @A< =L<E<C@ =<@B@B'C ?'L Q<L@B'LFLB$
#11-&1@
1. 5Q'=< '? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BC @A< Q'L='LF@< Q'C@<Z@
2.
7==>BQFMB>B@N '? @A< P'LX =L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC< BC =L'Q<<GBCWE @' <C?'LQ<@FZ EIRR'CE<E
D&%(@ f=e'AC PBCE$ &' GBE='EB@BT<$ 5<< %F@B'$
"/0#+@
45 %JO J<B aK=:?A=KB8<E8 ;< J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8
• _%2%$/' E('% "# G3*2%+&% \iZ ))) @A< =LBTB><W< '? F PB@C<EE EAF>> M<
W'T<LC<G MN @A< =LBCQB=><E '? @A< Q'RR'C >FP FE @A<N RFN M<
BC@<L=L<@<G MN @A< Q'IL@E '? @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E BC >BWA@ '? L<FE'C FCG<Z=<LB<CQ<$
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 28/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*-
• @*I-"$% ))) 6A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BE @A< '>G<E@ '? @A< =LBTB><W<E
?'L Q'C?BG<C@BF> Q'RRICBQF@B'CE XC'PC @' @A< Q'RR'C >FP$
• D@E =IL='E< BE @' <CQ'ILFW< ?I>> FCG ?LFCX Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C
F@@'LC<NE FCG @A<BL Q>B<C@E FCG @A<L<MN =L'R'@< ML'FG<L =IM>BQ
BC@<L<E@E BC @A< 'ME<LTFCQ< '? >FP FCG FGRBCBE@LF@B'C '? eIE@BQ<$ 6A<
=LBTB><W< L<Q'WCBa<E @AF@ E'ICG ><WF> FGTBQ< 'L FGT'QFQN E<LT<E =IM>BQ
<CGE FCG @AF@ EIQA FGTBQ< 'L FGT'QFQN G<=<CGE I='C @A< >FPN<L M<BCW
?I>>N BC?'LR<G MN @A< Q>B<C@$• V$/--%' 34 5+*,%2 6,/,%) ))) 6A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< L<E@E 'C @A<
C<<G ?'L @A< FGT'QF@< FCG Q'ICE<>'L @' XC'P F>> @AF@ L<>F@<E @' @A<
Q>B<C@iE L<FE'CE ?'L E<<XBCW L<=L<E<C@F@B'C B? @A< =L'?<EEB'CF> RBEEB'C
BE @' M< QFLLB<G 'I@$
• _*)7%$ 34 5+*,%2 6,/,%) ))) @A< =IL='E< '? @A< =LBTB><W< @' BE @'
<CQ'ILFW< Q>B<C@E @' RFX< ?I>> GBEQ>'EIL<E @' @A<BL F@@'LC<NE$
• K'R=>BQF@B'CE BC @A< F==>BQF@B'C '? @A< =LBTB><W< FLBE< PA<C @A< Q>B<C@
BE F Q'L='LF@B'C9 PABQA BC @A<'LN BE FC FL@B?BQBF> QL<F@IL< '? @A< >FP9 FCG
C'@ FC BCGBTBGIF>d MI@ @ABE K'IL@ AFE FEEIR<G @AF@ @A< =LBTB><W< F==>B<E
PA<C @A< Q>B<C@ BE F Q'L='LF@B'C9 FCG @A< #'T<LCR<C@ G'<E C'@ Q'C@<E@
@A< W<C<LF> =L'='EB@B'C$
X5 0H8 */ 8==8B :< <J==;OLN JAALN:<G 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G85
• K7 Q'CEBG<L<G @A< F==>BQF@B'C '? @A< =LBTB><W< BC @A< Q'L='LF@< Q'C@<Z@
@' =L<E<C@ F kGB??<L<C@ =L'M><R9k EBCQ< @A< Q>B<C@ PFE FC BCFCBRF@<
<C@B@N FCG 'C>N @A< E<CB'L RFCFW<R<C@9 WIBGBCW FCG BC@<WLF@BCW @A<
E<T<LF> '=<LF@B'CE QFC M< EFBG @' ='EE<EE FC BG<C@B@N FCF>'W'IE @' @A<
Q'L='LF@B'C FE F PA'><$
o K7 F==>B<G @A< :"+,$"' I$"(. ,%), PABQA FEXEc DE B@ @A<
Q'L='LF@B'C PABQA BE E<<XBCW @A< >FPN<LiE FGTBQ< PA<C @A<
FEE<L@<G =LBTB><W<G Q'RRICBQF@B'C BE RFG<bo D? @A< <R=>'N<< RFXBCW @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'C9 '? PAF@<T<L LFCX
A< RFN M<9 BE BC F ='EB@B'C @' Q'C@L'> 'L <T<C @' @FX< F
EIME@FC@BF> =FL@ BC F G<QBEB'C FM'I@ FCN FQ@B'C PABQA @A<
Q'L='LF@B'C RFN @FX< I='C @A< FGTBQ< '? @A< F@@'LC<N9 $$$ @A<C9
BC <??<Q@9 7% *) Y"$ .%$)"+*#*%)] ,7% &"$."$/,*"+ PA<C A< RFX<E
ABE GBEQ>'EIL< @' @A< >FPN<L FCG @A< =LBTB><W< P'I>G F==>N$k
• 5K GBEFWL<<E EFNBCW @AF@ EIQA F TB<P 'T<L>''XE @A< ?FQ@ @AF@ @A<
=LBTB><W< <ZBE@E @' =L'@<Q@ C'@ 'C>N @A< WBTBCW '? =L'?<EEB'CF> FGTBQ< @'
@A'E< PA' QFC FQ@ 'C B@ MI@ F>E' @A< WBTBCW '? BC?'LRF@B'C @' @A< >FPN<L
@' <CFM>< ABR @' WBT< E'ICG FCG BC?'LR<G FGTBQ<$
o DCGBTBGIF> Q>B<C@ ))) @A< =L'TBG<L '? BC?'LRF@B'C FCG @A< =<LE'C
PA' FQ@E 'C @A< >FPN<LiE FGTBQ< FL< 'C< FCG @A< EFR<$
o K'L='LF@< Q'C@<Z@ ))) B@ PB>> ?L<\I<C@>N M< <R=>'N<<E M<N'CG
@A< Q'C@L'> WL'I= FE G<?BC<G MN @A< K7 PA' PB>> ='EE<EE @A<
BC?'LRF@B'C C<<G<G MN @A< Q'L='LF@B'CiE >FPN<LE$ [BGG><)
><T<>))FCG BCG<<G >'P<L)><T<>))<R=>'N<<E QFC9 MN FQ@B'CE
PB@ABC @A< EQ'=< '? @A<BL <R=>'NR<C@9 <RML'B> @A< Q'L='LF@B'C
BC E<LB'IE ><WF> GB??BQI>@B<E9 FCG B@ BE 'C>N CF@ILF> @AF@ @A<E<
<R=>'N<<E P'I>G AFT< @A< L<><TFC@ BC?'LRF@B'C C<<G<G MN
Q'L='LF@< Q'ICE<>$
o 6A< F@@'LC<N G<F>BCW PB@A F Q'R=><Z ><WF> =L'M><R BE @AIE
?FQ<G PB@A F iS'ME'CiE QA'BQ<$i D? A< BC@<LTB<PE <R=>'N<<E C'@
AFTBCW i@A< T<LN ABWA<E@ FI@A'LB@Ni @A<BL Q'RRICBQF@B'CE @'
ABR PB>> C'@ M< =LBTB><W<G$ D?9 'C @A< '@A<L AFCG9 A<
BC@<LTB<PE "+'1 @A'E< <R=>'N<<E PB@A @A< iT<LN ABWA<E@
FI@A'LB@N9i A< RFN ?BCG B@ <Z@L<R<>N GB??BQI>@9 B? C'@ BR='EEBM><9
@' G<@<LRBC< PAF@ AF==<C<G$k
o 6A< CFLL'P EQ'=< WBT<C @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< MN @A<
Q'IL@ M<>'P C'@ 'C>N RFX<E B@ GB??BQI>@ ?'L Q'L='LF@< F@@'LC<NE@' ?'LRI>F@< E'ICG FGTBQ< PA<C @A<BL Q>B<C@ BE ?FQ<G PB@A F
E=<QB?BQ ><WF> =L'M><R MI@ F>E' @AL<F@<CE @' >BRB@ @A< TF>IFM><
<??'L@ '? Q'L='LF@< Q'ICE<> @' <CEIL< @A<BL Q>B<C@iE Q'R=>BFCQ<
PB@A @A< >FP$
o S<L<9 BC?'LRF@B'C C'@ FTFB>FM>< ?L'R I==<L)<QA<>'C
RFCFW<R<C@ PFE C<<G<G @' EI==>N F MFEBE ?'L ><WF> FGTBQ<
Q'CQ<LCBCW Q'R=>BFCQ< PB@A E<QILB@B<E FCG @FZ >FPE9 ?'L<BWC
>FPE9 QILL<CQN L<WI>F@B'CE9 GI@B<E @' EAFL<A'>G<LE9 FCG
='@<C@BF> >B@BWF@B'C BC <FQA '? @A<E< FL<FE$ 6A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE
Q'CQ<LC<G RF@@<LE PB@ABC @A< EQ'=< '? @A< <R=>'N<<EiQ'L='LF@< GI@B<E9 FCG @A< <R=>'N<<E @A<RE<>T<E P<L<
EI??BQB<C@>N FPFL< @AF@ @A<N P<L< M<BCW \I<E@B'C<G BC 'LG<L
@AF@ @A< Q'L='LF@B'C Q'I>G 'M@FBC ><WF> FGTBQ<$
• 6A< K7 G<Q>BC<G @' <Z@<CG @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< M<N'CG @A<
>BRB@E '? @A< Q'C@L'> WL'I= @<E@ ?'L ?<FL @AF@ G'BCW E' P'I>G <C@FB>
E<T<L< MILG<CE 'C GBEQ'T<LN FCG QL<F@< F ML'FG ka'C< '? EB><CQ<k 'T<L
Q'L='LF@< F??FBLE$
o 6A< =L'@<Q@B'C '? @A< =LBTB><W< <Z@<CGE 'C>N
@' &"--(+*&/,*"+) FCG C'@ @' ?FQ@E$ 7 ?FQ@ BE 'C< @ABCW FCG F
Q'RRICBQF@B'C Q'CQ<LCBCW @AF@ ?FQ@ BE FC <C@BL<>N GB??<L<C@
@ABCW$ 6A< Q>B<C@ QFCC'@ M< Q'R=<>><G @' FCEP<L @A< \I<E@B'C9
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 29/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
*+
iVAF@ GBG N'I EFN 'L PLB@< @' @A< F@@'LC<Nbi MI@ RFN C'@
L<?IE< @' GBEQ>'E< FCN L<><TFC@ ?FQ@ PB@ABC ABE XC'P><GW<
R<L<>N M<QFIE< A< BCQ'L='LF@<G F E@F@<R<C@ '? EIQA ?FQ@ BC@'
ABE Q'RRICBQF@B'C @' ABE F@@'LC<N$
o 6A< Q'IL@E AFT< C'@<G @AF@ F =FL@N QFCC'@ Q'CQ<F> F ?FQ@
R<L<>N MN L<T<F>BCW B@ @' ABE >FPN<L$
o S<L< @A< #'T<LCR<C@ PFE ?L<< @' \I<E@B'C @A< <R=>'N<<E
PA' Q'RRICBQF@<G PB@A 6A'RFE FCG 'I@EBG< Q'ICE<>$ f=e'AC
AFE =L'TBG<G @A< D%5 PB@A F >BE@ '? EIQA <R=>'N<<E9 FCG @A< D%5
AFE F>L<FGN BC@<LTB<P<G E'R< *3 '? @A<R$ VAB>< B@ P'I>G
=L'MFM>N M< R'L< Q'CT<CB<C@ ?'L @A< #'T<LCR<C@ @' E<QIL<
@A< L<EI>@E '? f=e'ACiE BC@<LCF> BCT<E@BWF@B'C MN EBR=>N
EIM='<CFBCW @A< \I<E@B'CCFBL<E FCG C'@<E @FX<C MN f=e'ACiE
F@@'LC<NE9 EIQA Q'CEBG<LF@B'CE '? Q'CT<CB<CQ< G' C'@
'T<LQ'R< @A< ='>BQB<E E<LT<G MN @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$
o J(),*&% J/&?)"+ ))) 8BEQ'T<LN PFE AFLG>N BC@<CG<G @' <CFM>< F
><FLC<G =L'?<EEB'C @' =<L?'LR B@E ?ICQ@B'CE $$$ 'C PB@E
M'LL'P<G ?L'R @A< FGT<LEFLN$
•
6A< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE MN f=e'AC <R=>'N<<E @' Q'ICE<> FL< Q'T<L<G MN@A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< E' ?FL FE @A< L<E='CE<E @' @A<
\I<E@B'CCFBL< FCG FCN C'@<E L<?><Q@BCW L<E='CE<E @' BC@<LTB<P
\I<E@B'CE FL< Q'CQ<LC<G$
• 5<T<C '? @A< -] <R=>'N<<E BC@<LTB<P<G MN Q'ICE<> AFG @<LRBCF@<G
@A<BL <R=>'NR<C@ PB@A f=e'AC F@ @A< @BR< '? @A< BC@<LTB<P$ f=e'AC
FLWI<E @AF@ @A< =LBTB><W< EA'I>G C'C<@A<><EE F==>N @' Q'RRICBQF@B'CE
MN @A<E< ?'LR<L <R=>'N<<E Q'CQ<LCBCW FQ@BTB@B<E GILBCW @A<BL =<LB'G '?
<R=>'NR<C@$ &<B@A<L @A< 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ C'L @A< K'IL@ '? 7==<F>E AFG
'QQFEB'C @' FGGL<EE @ABE BEEI<9 FCG P< G<Q>BC< @' G<QBG< B@ PB@A'I@ @A<
M<C<?B@ '? @L<F@R<C@ M<>'P$
[5 /AAL:EJM:L:9N ;I 9H8 O;=`YA=;BKE9 B;E9=:<8
• 6A'RFE AFE @<E@B?B<G @AF@ ABE C'@<E FCG R<R'LFCGF '? BC@<LTB<PE W'
M<N'CG L<Q'LGBCW L<E='CE<E @' ABE \I<E@B'CE$
• 6' @A< <Z@<C@ @AF@ @A< RF@<LBF> EIMe<Q@ @' @A< EIRR'CE BE C'@
=L'@<Q@<G MN @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< FE GBEQ>'EBCW
Q'RRICBQF@B'CE M<@P<<C FC <R=>'N<< FCG Q'ICE<>9 P< RIE@ L<FQA
@A< LI>BCW MN @A< K7 @AF@ @A< P'LX)=L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC< G'<E C'@ F==>N @'
@A< EIRR'CE<E
•
6A< #'T<LCR<C@OE FLWIR<C@Ec
"$ VAB>< Q'CQ<GBCW @A< F==>BQFMB>B@N '? @A< P'LX)=L'GIQ@
G'Q@LBC<9 @A< #'T<LCR<C@ AFE RFG< F EI??BQB<C@ EA'PBCW '?
C<Q<EEB@N @' 'T<LQ'R< B@E =L'@<Q@B'CE$
*$ W*&?-/+ CCC V< G' C'@ R<FC @' EFN @AF@ F>> PLB@@<C RF@<LBF>E
'M@FBC<G 'L =L<=FL<G MN FC FGT<LEFLNiE Q'ICE<> PB@A FC <N<
@'PFLG >B@BWF@B'C FL< C<Q<EEFLB>N ?L<< ?L'R GBEQ'T<LN BC F>>
QFE<E$ VA<L< L<><TFC@ FCG C'C=LBTB><W<G ?FQ@E L<RFBC ABGG<C
BC FC F@@'LC<NiE ?B>< FCG PA<L< =L'GIQ@B'C '? @A'E< ?FQ@E BE
<EE<C@BF> @' @A< =L<=FLF@B'C '? 'C<iE QFE<9 GBEQ'T<LN RFN
=L'=<L>N M< AFG $$$ vFwCG =L'GIQ@B'C RBWA@ M< eIE@B?B<G PA<L<
@A< PB@C<EE<E FL< C' >'CW<L FTFB>FM>< 'L RFN M< L<FQA<G 'C>N
PB@A GB??BQI>@N$
0$ 6A< #'T<LCR<C@ E@L<EE<E @AF@ BC@<LTB<P<<E FL< EQF@@<L<G
FQL'EE @A< W>'M< FCG @AF@ f=e'AC AFE ?'LMBGG<C B@E <R=>'N<<E
@' FCEP<L \I<E@B'CE B@ Q'CEBG<LE BLL<><TFC@$
• W*&?-/+A A'P<T<L9 GBG C'@ F==>N @' k'LF> E@F@<R<C@E RFG< MN
PB@C<EE<E PA<@A<L =L<E<C@>N BC @A< ?'LR '? @A< F@@'LC<NiE R<C@F>
BR=L<EEB'CE 'L R<R'LFCGF$
•
H'LQBCW FC F@@'LC<N @' GBEQ>'E< C'@<E FCG R<R'LFCGF '? PB@C<EE<Ei
'LF> E@F@<R<C@E BE =FL@BQI>FL>N GBE?FT'L<G M<QFIE< B@ @<CGE @' L<T<F> @A<
F@@'LC<NiE R<C@F> =L'Q<EE<E$
• %I>< *] FQQ'LGE E=<QBF> =L'@<Q@B'C @' P'LX =L'GIQ@ L<T<F>BCW @A<
F@@'LC<NiE R<C@F> =L'Q<EE<E$
o 6A< %I>< =<LRB@E GBEQ>'EIL< '? G'QIR<C@E FCG @FCWBM>< @ABCWE
Q'CE@B@I@BCW F@@'LC<N P'LX =L'GIQ@ I='C F EA'PBCW '?
EIME@FC@BF> C<<G FCG BCFMB>B@N @' 'M@FBC @A< <\IBTF><C@ PB@A'I@
ICGI< AFLGEAB=$
o %I>< *] W'<E 'C9 A'P<T<L9 @' E@F@< @AF@ BC 'LG<LBCW GBEQ'T<LN
'? EIQA RF@<LBF>E PA<C @A< L<\IBL<G EA'PBCW AFE M<<C RFG<9@A< Q'IL@ EAF>> =L'@<Q@ FWFBCE@ GBEQ>'EIL< '? @A< R<C@F>
BR=L<EEB'CE9 Q'CQ>IEB'CE9 '=BCB'CE 'L ><WF> @A<'LB<E '? FC
F@@'LC<N 'L '@A<L L<=L<E<C@F@BT< '? F =FL@N Q'CQ<LCBCW @A<
>B@BWF@B'C$
• YFE<G 'C @A< ?'L<W'BCW9 E'R< Q'IL@E AFT< Q'CQ>IG<G @AF@ +" EA'PBCW
'? C<Q<EEB@N QFC 'T<LQ'R< =L'@<Q@B'C '? P'LX =L'GIQ@ PABQA BE MFE<G
'C 'LF> E@F@<R<C@E ?L'R PB@C<EE<E$ 6A'E< Q'IL@E G<Q>BCBCW @' FG'=@ FC
FME'>I@< LI>< AFT< C'C<@A<><EE L<Q'WCBa<G @AF@ EIQA RF@<LBF> BE
<C@B@><G @' E=<QBF> =L'@<Q@B'C$
•
6A< 5K G'<E C'@ G<QBG< @A< BEEI< ^'L QL<F@< F C<P E@FCGFLG_ F@ @ABE@BR<$
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 30/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0/
o D@ BE Q><FL @AF@ @A< RFWBE@LF@< PFE PL'CW BC F==>NBCW @A<
kEIME@FC@BF> C<<Gk FCG kPB@A'I@ ICGI< AFLGEAB=k E@FCGFLG$
o 6A< C'@<E FCG R<R'LFCGF E'IWA@ MN @A< #'T<LCR<C@ A<L<
FL< P'LX =L'GIQ@ MFE<G 'C 'LF> E@F@<R<C@E$ D? @A<N L<T<F>
Q'RRICBQF@B'CE9 @A<N FL<9 BC @ABE QFE<9 =L'@<Q@<G MN @A<
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$
o VAB>< P< FL< C'@ =L<=FL<G F@ @ABE eICQ@IL< @' EFN @AF@ EIQA
RF@<LBF> BE F>PFNE =L'@<Q@<G MN @A< P'LX)=L'GIQ@ LI><9 P<
@ABCX F ?FL E@L'CW<L EA'PBCW '? C<Q<EEB@N FCG ICFTFB>FMB>B@N MN
'@A<L R<FCE @AFC PFE RFG< MN @A< #'T<LCR<C@ 'L F==>B<G MN
@A< RFWBE@LF@< BC @ABE QFE< P'I>G M< C<Q<EEFLN @' Q'R=<>
GBEQ>'EIL<$
g5 #. "& '"/.( ]-"C #.$&10#'/0#+. 6],7
2*0 H$*G ,,2 . /21"*1"+-0 . f5 K'IL@ '? 7==<F>E9 5BZ@A KBLQIB@
!89:9:;<8=>?@ ;,,"$+%1 E*&7/$2 ^($/+, ZV+-(/)R ^;<@B@B'C<L)7==<>>FC@_
"8?A;<B8<9>?@
1-,,/"C
7@@'LC<N %BQAFLG 8ILFC@ ^8ILFC@_ F==<F>E F ?BCGBCW '? Q'C@<R=@ ?'L
?FB>IL< @' GBEQ>'E< @' @A< WLFCG eILN I='C 'LG<L '? Q'IL@ @A< BG<C@B@N '? ABE
Q>B<C@$
7C HYD FW<C@ P<C@ @' 8ILFC@OE '??BQ< @' BC\IBL< FM'I@ E@'><C QA<QXE
@AF@ P<L< RFG< =FNFM>< @' DY[$ 5'R< QA<QXE P<L< @LFQ<G FCG G<='EB@<G @'
MFCX FQQ'IC@E '? C'C)<ZBE@<C@ 'LWFCBaF@B'CE$ 6A< FW<C@ ML'IWA@ PB@A ABR F
=A'@'E@F@BQ Q'=N '? F QA<QX9 GLFPC ?L'R 'C< '? @A<E< ?BQ@B@B'IE MFCX FQQ'IC@E9
RFG< =FNFM>< @' 8ILFC@OE >FP ?BLR$ 8ILFC@ EFBG @AF@ @A< QA<QX PFE =FBG @' ABR?'L E<LTBQ<E L<CG<L<G ?'L F Q>B<C@ BC @P' QFE<E9 'C< g?BCBEA<Gh FCG 'C< g'=<Ch$
8ILFC@ L<?IE<G @' BG<C@B?N ABE Q>B<C@9 FEE<L@BCW @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ S<
PFE EIM='<CF<G BC @A< 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@9 PA<L<BC A< L<=<F@<G>N L<?IE<G @'
BG<C@B?N ABE Q>B<C@9 G<E=B@< FC 4LG<L ?L'R @A< Q'IL@$ 7R'CW '@A<LE9 8ILFC@
FLWI<G @AF@ @A< QFE< ?F>>E ICG<L @A< g><WF> FGTBQ<h <ZQ<=@B'C9 PA<L<BC @A<
CFR< '? @A< Q>B<C@ PB>> M< Q'CEBG<L<G =LBTB><W<G PA<L< @A< QBLQIRE@FCQ<E '?
@A< QFE< FL< EIQA @AF@ @A< CFR< '? @A< Q>B<C@ BE RF@<LBF> 'C>N ?'L @A< =IL='E< '?
EA'PBCW FC FQXC'P><GW<R<C@ '? WIB>@ 'C =FL@ '? EIQA Q>B<C@ '? @A< T<LN
'??<CE<E 'C FQQ'IC@ '? PABQA @A< F@@'LC<N PFE <R=>'N<G$ S< PFE @A<C A<>G BC
Q'C@<R=@$ S< ?B><G FC F==<F> PB@A @A< f5 K'IL@ '? 7==<F>E PA<L<BC B@ PFE A<>G
@AF@ @A< BG<C@B@N '? @A< Q>B<C@ PFE C'@ =L'@<Q@<G ICG<L @A< g><WF> FGTBQ<h
<ZQ<=@B'C FCG @AF@ 8ILFC@ EA'I>G AFT< R'T<G ?'L FC *+ &/-%$/ %B ./$,%
7%/$*+I BCE@<FG '? L<E@BCW 'C ABE M>FCX<@ FEE<L@B'C @AF@ ABE Q>B<C@ BCB@BF>>N E'IWA@
><WF> FGTBQ< L<>F@BCW @' RF@@<LE BCT'>TBCW @A< @A<?@ BC \I<E@B'C$
3/*01
• 4C [FLQA "9 "+-09 5=<QBF> 7W<C@ UGPFLGE '? @A< HYD TBEB@<G 8ILFC@OE
'??BQ< FCG <Z=>FBC<G @AF@ @A< HYD PFE BCT<E@BWF@BCW @A< @A<?@ '?
CIR<L'IE QA<QXE RFG< =FNFM>< @' DC@<LCF@B'CF> YIEBC<EE [FQABC<E
^DY[_$ 7 CIRM<L '? E@'><C QA<QXE AFG M<<C @LFQ<G FCG G<='EB@<G @'
TFLB'IE MFCX FQQ'IC@E ICG<L CFR<E '? C'C)<ZBE@<C@ 'LWFCBaF@B'CE9 F@
><FE@ 'C< '? PABQA BCQ>IG<G @A< BCB@BF>E gDY[h$ 6A< HYD FW<C@ =L'GIQ<G
F =A'@'E@F@BQ Q'=N '? F QA<QX GLFPC I='C 'C< '? @A<E< ?BQ@B@B'IE
FQQ'IC@Ez@ABE QA<QX ?'L s"39/// PFE RFG< =FNFM>< @' 8ILFC@OE >FP
?BLR$
• 8ILFC@ Q'CQ<G<G @AF@ @ABE QA<QX PFE L<Q<BT<G FCG <CG'LE<G MN ABE
?BLR ?'L E<LTBQ<E L<CG<L<G @' F Q>B<C@ BC @P' QFE<E9 'C< '? PABQA PFE
g?BCBEA<Gh FCG @A< '@A<L '? PABQA PFE g'=<Ch$ (K=J<9 =8IK?8B 9;
B:?EL;?8 9H8 :B8<9:9N ;I H:? EL:8<9 @' PA'E< QL<GB@ @A< =L'Q<<GE AFG
M<<C F==>B<G9 FEE<L@BCW @A< J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8$
• (K=J<9 OJ? ?KMA;8<J8B 9; JAA8J= M8I;=8 9H8 G=J<B aK=N @A<
?'>>'PBCW GFN9 [FLQA *9 "+-09 PA<L< A< JGJ:< =8IK?8B 9; :B8<9:IN ABE
Q>B<C@9 FEE<L@BCW F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ 6A< W'T<LCR<C@ BRR<GBF@<>N
R'T<G @A< f5 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ ?'L FC 4LG<L L<\IBLBCW 8ILFC@ @' =L'TBG<
@A< L<\I<E@<G BC?'LRF@B'C$ 7@ F A<FLBCW @AF@ EFR< F?@<LC''C9 8ILFC@
BC?'LR<G @A< Q'IL@ @AF@ @A< GBEQ>'EIL< '? ABE Q>B<C@OE BG<C@B@N P'I>G
BCQLBRBCF@< @AF@ Q>B<C@ BC QLBRBCF> FQ@BTB@N9 E' FE @' eIE@B?N BCT'XBCW
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ 8ILFC@ F>E' E@F@<G @AF@ gR 2" +", ?+"= /+1 "#
,7% #/&,) /9"(, ,7*) ,7%#, "$ /+1,7*+I %')%D FCG EIWW<E@<G @AF@ @A<
BC?'LRF@B'C M< FQ\IBL<G @AL'IWA '@A<L R<@A'GE$ 6A< Q'IL@ GBG C'@ MINABE <ZQIE< FCG EFBG @AF@ @A< =LBTB><W< GBG C'@ F@@FQA FCG 'LG<L<G ABR
@' BG<C@B?N ABE Q>B<C@$ 8ILFC@ L<?IE<G @' Q'R=>N ^EI=<L XI>B@ >FCW_ PB@A
@A< 4LG<L FCG PFE A<>G :< E;<98FA9$
• 8ILFC@ =L'='E<G @AF@ @A< W'T<LCR<C@ EA'I>G IE< '@A<L R<FCE @'
@LFQ< @A< R'C<N FCG E@F@<G gR )7"('2 /22 ,7/, *# ,7% #/&,) /) ,7% /I%+,)
7/3% 2*)&())%2 ,7%- =*,7 -% /$% &"$$%&, /+2 ,7%$% *) )(9),/+,*/'
+(-9%$ "# &7%&?) #'"=*+I /$"(+2 ,7% &*,1A /'' ,7")% &7%&?) &"-% 9/&?
," ,7% 2$/=%% 9/+? =*,7 9/+? %+2"$)%-%+,) "+ ,7% 9/&?4 R, )7"('2 9%A
*, )%%-) ," -%A %M(/''1 ."))*9'%A =*,7"(, 3*"'/,*+I ,7% /,,"$+%1C&'*%+,
.$*3*'%I%A #"$ ,7% /I%+,) ," #*+2 "(, =7" .$%)%+,%2A =7" &/)7%2 /+2 ,",$/&% ,7% -"+%1 ,7$"(I7 +"$-/' &"--%$&*/' &7/++%')A ," )/1 +",7*+I
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 31/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0"
"# ,7% #/&, ,7/, =7" ".%+) 7% -/*' /, R0N +"= "93*"()'1 9%&"-%) "#
)*I+*#*&/+, *-."$,/+&%4D
• 6A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E BEEI<G F E<Q'CG EIM='<CF @' 8ILFC@ 'C [FLQA +9
"+-09 'LG<LBCW ABR @' F==<FL M<?'L< @A< WLFCG eILN 'C [FLQA "]9 FCG
=L'GIQ< @A< ?'>>'PBCW G'QIR<C@Ec
o 7 >BE@ '? F>> Q>B<C@E '? ABE >FP ?BLR FE '? H<M -9 "+-0 BCQ>IGBCW F>>
Q>B<C@E PB@A FQ@BT< QFE<E FCG Q>B<C@E PA' 'P< ?<<E 'L AFT<
=L'TBG<G F L<@FBC<L @' @A< ?BLR
o 7>> Q>B<C@ ><GW<L QFLGE FCG '@A<L M''XE9 L<Q'LGE FCG G'QIR<C@E
L<?><Q@BCW 'L L<Q'LGBCW =FNR<C@E @' @A< >FP ?BLR ?'L @A< =<LB'G
'? H<M " "+-0z[FLQA " "+-0
• 8ILFC@ R'T<G @' \IFEA @ABE EIM='<CF GIQ<E @<QIR9 FWFBC QB@BCW
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ 7@ @A< A<FLBCW9 8ILFC@ FWFBC FLWI<G @AF@ @A<
=L'GIQ@B'C '? @A< L<\I<E@<G G'QIR<C@E Q'I>G BR=>BQF@< ABE Q>B<C@ BC
QLBRBCF> FQ@BTB@N$ S< FGGB@B'CF>>N 'ME<LT<G @AF@ @A< HYD FGRB@@<G M<?'L<
8ILFC@ FCG @A< GBE@LBQ@ Q'IL@ eIGW< BC)QAFRM<LE @AF@ FC FLL<E@ P'I>G
M< <??<Q@<G MN @A< HYD BRR<GBF@<>N ?'>>'PBCW @A< GBEQ>'EIL<$ SBE Q>B<C@
P'I>G @A<C M< @A< LJ?9 L:<` ;I 8P:B8<E8 C<Q<EEFLN ?'L FC BCGBQ@R<C@$
o
S< F>E' BC?'LR<G @A< Q'IL@ @AF@ @A< HYD9 PAB>< @A< Q'IL@ PFE BCL<Q<EE9 @'>G ABR @' ML<FQA @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< @'
BG<C@B?N ABE Q>B<C@ PB@A'I@ BC?'LRBCW @A< EFBG Q>B<C@$ VA<C A<
L<e<Q@<G @AF@ EIWW<E@B'C9 A< PFE @'>G @AF@ A< gQ'I>G M< =LBC@<G
FC GA<>G BCQ'RRICBQFG' ?'L EBZ 'L E<T<C A'ILEh FCG
BCE@LIQ@<G ABE '??BQ< @AF@ gB? @A<N AFGCO@ A<FLGh ?L'R ABR MN
0c0/ @' Q'R< 'T<L @' @A< Q'IL@ PB@A F PLB@ '? AFM<FE Q'L=IE$
• 8ILFC@ ?FB><G @' R'T< @A< Q'IL@ ?'L FC %B ./$,% *+ &/-%$/ EIMRBEEB'C
'? <TBG<CQ< 'L @<E@BR'CN @' <E@FM>BEA @AF@ ABE Q>B<C@ AFG BCG<<G E'IWA@
><WF> FGTBQ< L<>F@BCW @' =FE@ QLBRBCF> FQ@BTB@N BCT'>TBCW @A<?@ '? DY[
QA<QXE$ &'L GBG @A< GBE@LBQ@ Q'IL@9 )(/ )."+,%9 EIWW<E@ FC <Z =F@< BCQFR<LF EIMRBEEB'C '? <TBG<CQ< @' =L'M< 8ILFC@OE M>FCX<@ E@F@<R<C@E$
• 5BCQ< @A< BEEI<E e'BC<G BC @A< ?BLE@ FCG E<Q'CG EIM='<CFE E<LT<G I='C
8ILFC@ P<L< @A< EFR<9 @A< 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ G<QBG<G @' PB@AA'>G @A<
G<QBEB'C '? 8ILFC@OE R'@B'C @' \IFEA @A< E<Q'CG EIM='<CF GIQ<E
@<QIR =<CGBCW @A< F==<>>F@< L<E'>I@B'C '? @A< Q'IL@OE Q'C@<R=@ 4LG<L
'? [FLQA *9 "+-0$
#11-&
V& 8ILFC@ EI??BQB<C@>N <E@FM>BEA<G @AF@ @A< GBEQ>'EIL< '? @A< BG<C@B@N '? ABE
Q>B<C@ P'I>G M< F TB'>F@B'C '? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ o.+5
D&%(@
• fCR<LB@'LB'IE$
• 8f%7&6 AFE ?FB><G @' <E@FM>BEA @A< <ZBE@<CQ< '? FCN <ZQ<=@B'C @' @A<
W<C<LF> LI>< @AF@ GBEQ>'EIL< '? @A< BG<C@B@N '? F Q>B<C@ BE C'@ PB@ABC @A<
=L'@<Q@BT< FRMB@ '? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ 6A<L<?'L<9 @A<
Q'C@<R=@ 4LG<L '? @A< GBE@LBQ@ Q'IL@ BEEI<G FWFBCE@ 8ILFC@ BE A<L<MN
7HHD%[U8$
"/0#+
• 6A< MILG<C '? <E@FM>BEABCW @A< <ZBE@<CQ< '? @A< =LBTB><W< L<E@E PB@A @A<
=<LE'C FEE<L@BCW B@$
• 6A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBT <ZBE@E @' =L'@<Q@ Q'C?BG<C@BF> Q'RRICBQF@B'CE
M<@P<<C F >FPN<L FCG ABE Q>B<C@ BC RF@@<LE @AF@ L<>F@< @' @A< ><WF>
BC@<L<E@E '? E'QB<@N FCG @A< Q>B<C@$ DC 'LG<L @' =L'R'@< @A< ?L<<G'R '?
Q'CEI>@F@B'C '? ><WF> FGTBE'LE MN Q>B<C@E9 @A< F==L<A<CEB'C '?
Q'R=<>><G GBEQ>'EIL< ?L'R ><WF> FGTBE'LE RIE@ M< L<R'T<Gd A<CQ< @A<
>FP RIE@ =L'ABMB@ EIQA GBEQ>'EIL< <ZQ<=@ 'C @A< Q>B<C@OE Q'CE<C@$
• 5BCQ< @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBT RFN E<LT< FE F R<QAFCBER @' ?LIE@LF@<
@A< BCT<E@BWF@BT< 'L ?FQ@)?BCGBCW =L'Q<EE9 B@ QL<F@<E FC BCA<L<C@ @<CEB'C
PB@A E'QB<@NOE C<<G ?'L ?I>> FCG Q'R=><@< GBEQ>'EIL< '? F>> L<><TFC@
<TBG<CQ< GILBCW BR=><R<C@F@B'C '? @A< eIGBQBF> =L'Q<EE$ DC =FL@BQI>FL9
BCT'QF@B'C '? @A< =LBTB><W< M<?'L< @A< WLFCG eILN RFN e<'=FLGBa< FC
<??<Q@BT< FCG Q'R=L<A<CEBT< BCT<E@BWF@B'C BC@' F>><W<G TB'>F@B'CE '?
@A< >FP FCG @A<L<MN @APFL@ @AF@ M'GNOE GIF> ?ICQ@B'CE '? G<@<LRBCBCW
'? @A<L< BE =L'MFM>< QFIE< @' M<>B<T< @AF@ F QLBR< AFE M<<C Q'RRB@@<G
FCG '? =L'@<Q@BCW QB@Ba<CE FWFBCE@ IC?'ICG<G QLBRBCF> =L'E<QI@B'CE$
0H8?8 E;<IL:E9:<G :<98=8?9? B8FJ<B 9HJ9 JAAL:EJ9:;< ;I 9H8 A=:P:L8G8
<;9 8UE88B 9HJ9 OH:EH :? <8E8??J=N 9; 8II8E9 9H8 A;L:EN E;<?:B8=J9:;<?
K<B8=LN:<G 9H8 A=:P:L8G85• '8<8=JL =KL8c 9H8 :B8<9:9N ;I J EL:8<9 :?Q O:9H L:F:98B 8UE8A9:;<?Q <;9
O:9H:< 9H8 A=;98E9:P8 JFM:9 ;I 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G85
o 6ABE W<C<LF> LI>< F==>B<E <\IF>>N @' ?<< FLLFCW<R<C@E$ 6A<
L<Q<B=@ '? ?<<E ?L'R F Q>B<C@ BE C'@ IEIF>>N PB@ABC @A< =LBTB><W<
M<QFIE< @A< =FNR<C@ '? F ?<< BE C'@ C'LRF>>N F RF@@<L '?
Q'C?BG<CQ< 'L F Q'RRICBQF@B'C$ 6A< RBCBE@<LBF> 'L Q><LBQF>
E<LTBQ<E '? FC F@@'LC<N BC @LFCE?<LLBCW ?ICGE @' 'L ?L'R F Q>B<C@
BE C'@ F RF@@<L '? Q'C?BG<CQ< @AF@ BE =L'@<Q@<G MN @A< =LBTB><W<$
• UZQ<=@B'CEc ^@A<E< FL< WL'ICG<G 'C @A< QFE< '? 0/*$2 3 X"%$+%$S :IE@ BC
QFE< EBL FEXEc BC @ABE QFE< @A< D%5 L<Q<BT<G F ><@@<L ?L'R FC F@@'LC<NEFNBCW @AF@ FC <CQ>'E<G QA<QX @' @A< FR'IC@ '? s"*92/] PFE M<BCW
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 32/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0*
@<CG<L<G ?'L FGGB@B'CF> FR'IC@E GI< ?L'R ICGBEQ>'E<G @FZ=FN<LE$
VA<C @A< D%5 EIRR'C<G @A< F@@'LC<N9 A< L<?IE<G @' BG<C@B?N @A<
G<>BC\I<C@ @FZ=FN<LE FEE<L@BCW @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBT_
o 647 0H8 L8GJL JBP:E8 8UE8A9:;<c 6A< CFR< '? @A< Q>B<C@ PB>> M<
Q'CEBG<L<G =LBTB><W<G PA<L< @A< QBLQIRE@FCQ<E '? @A< QFE< FL<
EIQA @AF@ @A< CFR< '? @A< Q>B<C@ BE RF@<LBF> 'C>N ?'L @A<
=IL='E< '? EA'PBCW FC FQXC'P><GW<R<C@ '? WIB>@ 'C =FL@ '?
EIQA Q>B<C@ '? @A< T<LN '??<CE<E 'C FQQ'IC@ '? PABQA @A<
F@@'LC<N PFE <R=>'N<G$
" YV7% *2%+,*,1 "# ,7% 0/*$2 ,/B./1%$ =/) /2H(2I%2
=*,7*+ ,7*) %B&%.,*"+ ," ,7% I%+%$/' $('%4]
" S'P<T<L9 @A< L8GJL JBP:E8 8UE8A9:;< FJN M8 B8I8J98B
@AL'IWA F .$*-/ #/&*% EA'PBCW @AF@ @A< ><WF>
L<=L<E<C@F@B'C PFE E<QIL<G BC ?IL@A<LFCQ< '? =L<E<C@
'L BC@<CG<G Q'C@BCIBCW B>><WF>B@N9 E PA<L< @A< ><WF>
L<=L<E<C@F@B'C B@E<>? BE =FL@ '? F >FLW<L Q'CE=BLFQN$
o 6X7 (:?EL;?K=8 ;I 9H8 :B8<9:9N O;KLB M8 9J<9JF;K<9 9;
B:?EL;?:<G J< ;9H8=O:?8 A=;98E98B E;<I:B8<9:JL :<I;=FJ9:;<5 D?
@A< BG<C@B?BQF@B'C '? @A< Q>B<C@ Q'CT<NE BC?'LRF@B'C PABQA'LGBCFLB>N P'I>G M< Q'CQ<G<G @' M< =FL@ '? @A< IEIF> =LBTB><W<G
Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C F@@'LC<N FCG Q>B<C@9 @A<C @A<
=LBTB><W< EA'I>G <Z@<CG @' EIQA BG<C@B?BQF@B'C BC @A< FME<CQ< '?
'@A<L ?FQ@'LE$
o 6[7 cH8=8 ?; FKEH ;I 9H8 JE9KJL E;FFK<:EJ9:;< HJ? JL=8JBN
M88< B:?EL;?8B 9HJ9 9H8 :B8<9:I:EJ9:;< ;I 9H8 EL:8<9 JF;K<9?
9; B:?EL;?K=8 ;I J E;<I:B8<9:JL E;FFK<:EJ9:;<5
" D@ BE @A< >BCX M<@P<<C @A< Q>B<C@ FCG @A<
Q'RRICBQF@B'C9 LF@A<L @AFC @A< >BCX M<@P<<C @A<
Q>B<C@ FCG @A< ='EEBMB>B@N '? ='@<C@BF> QLBRBCF>=L'E<QI@B'C9 PABQA E<LT<E @' MLBCW @A< Q>B<C@OE BG<C@B@N
PB@ABC @A< =L'@<Q@BT< FRMB@ '? @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@
=LBTB><W<$
o 6i7 %J?9YL:<` 8UE8A9:;<c ^C'@< A'P<T<L @AF@ @ABE PFE L<e<Q@<G
MN @A< K'IL@_ PA<C @A< GBEQ>'EIL< '? @A< Q>B<C@OE BG<C@B@N MN ABE
F@@'LC<N P'I>G AFT< EI==>B<G @A< >FE@ >BCX BC FC <ZBE@BCW QAFBC
'? BCQLBRBCF@BCW <TBG<CQ< >BX<>N @' ><FG @' @A< Q>B<C@OE
BCGBQ@R<C@$
" 6A< K'IL@ Q'CQ>IG<E @AF@ @ABE <ZQ<=@B'C R<C@B'C<G BC
@A< YFBLG QFE<9 B@ BE EBR=>N C'@ WL'ICG<G I='C @A<
=L<E<LTF@B'C '? Q'C?BG<C@BF> Q'RRICBQF@B'CE FCG
A<CQ< C'@ eIE@B?BFM>< @' EI=='L@ @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@
=LBT$ 6A< K'IL@ @AIE L<e<Q@E @A< >FE@ >BCX <ZQ<=@B'C FE
=L'C'ICQ<G BC @A< QFE< '? F/3'*&? FCG QB@<G BC 0/*$2 $
• /"'-,&.01 +3 (-"/.0 /.( 0D& "&1!+.1& +3 0D& *+-"0@
o 8ILFC@c 8BEQ>'EIL< RBWA@ ='EEBM>N BR=>BQF@< @A< Q>B<C@ BC
QLBRBCF> FQ@BTB@N
" K'IL@c 7E @ABE eIE@B?BQF@B'C AFE C' L''@E BC Q'CQ<=@E '?
Q'C?BG<C@BF>B@N 'L Q'RRICBQF@B'C9 B@ QFCC'@ M<
FGTFCQ<G @' EI=='L@ FC FMGBQF@B'C '? @A< W<C<LF> LI><
@AF@ @A< BG<C@B@N '? F Q>B<C@ BE C'@ =LBTB><W<G$
o 8ILFC@c HYD BC?'LR<G ABR @AF@ FC FLL<E@ P'I>G M< <??<Q@<G
I='C GBEQ>'EIL< '? @A< BG<C@B@N '? @A< Q>B<C@$
" K'IL@c 6ABE BE EBR=>N FC FEE<L@B'C @AF@ GBEQ>'EIL< P'I>G
=L'TBG< @A< >FE@ >BCX '? <TBG<CQ< @' EI=='L@ FC
BCGBQ@R<C@zF =L<Q<G<C@ PABQA PFE F>L<FGN L<e<Q@<G
MN @A< K'IL@ FE GBEQIEE<G FM'T<$
o 8ILFC@c HF>>E ICG<L ><WF> FGTBQ< <ZQ<=@B'C$
"
K'IL@c B@ BE BCQIRM<C@ I='C 8ILFC@ @' @AF@ F E@L'CW='EEBMB>B@N <ZBE@<G @AF@ GBEQ>'EIL< P'I>G BR=>BQF@< @A<
Q>B<C@ BC @A< T<LN RF@@<L ?'L PABQA 8ILFC@OE ><WF>
FGTBQ< AFG M<<C E'IWA@ BC @A< ?BLE@ =>FQ<$
" / O8LL =8E;G<:T8B F8J<? I;= J< J99;=<8N 9;
B8F;<?9=J98 9H8 8U:?98<E8 ;I J< 8UE8A9:;< 9; 9H8
G8<8=JL =KL8Q OH:L8 J9 9H8 ?JF8 9:F8 A=8?8=P:<G 9H8
E;<I:B8<9:JL:9N ;I 9H8 :B8<9:9N ;I H:? EL:8<9Q :? 9; F;P8
9H8 E;K=9 I;= J< 5/ '(7$-( $G :(-)$ #$(-5/=5
" 5BCQ< @A< MILG<C '? <E@FM>BEABCW @A< <ZBE@<CQ< '? @A<
=LBTB><W< L<E@E PB@A @A< =FL@N FEE<L@BCW @A< =LBTB><W<9 B@PFE BCQIRM<C@ I='C 8ILFC@ @' R'T< ?'L FC *+ &/-%$/
%B ./$,% A<FLBCW$ 8ILFC@ ?FB><G @' G' E'$ %F@A<L9 A<
L<E@<G 'C ABE M>FCX<@ FEE<L@B'C @AF@ ABE Q>B<C@ AFG
BCB@BF>>N E'IWA@ ><WF> FGTBQ< L<>F@BCW @' RF@@<LE
BCT'>TBCW @A< @A<?@ '? DY[ QA<QXE$ 5IQA ICEI=='L@<G
FEE<L@B'CE '? =LBTB><W< FL< E@L'CW>N GBE?FT'L<G$
" HIL@A<L9 B@ EA'I>G M< 'ME<LT<G @AF@ 'C @A< ?BLE@ A<FLBCW
'C [FLQA *9 8ILFC@ EFBG @AF@ A< AFG C' XC'P><GW< '?
@A< <ZBE@<CQ< '? E@'><C DY[ QA<QXE$ 6ABE E@F@<R<C@
GBRBCBEA<G @A< QL<GBMB>B@N '? ABE EIME<\I<C@ E@F@<R<C@
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 33/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
00
'C [FLQA **9 @AF@ ABE Q>B<C@ AFG BCG<<G <CWFW<G ABE
E<LTBQ<E ?'L =FE@ FQ@BTB@N L<>F@BCW @' E@'><C DY[ QA<QXE$
Z5
-515 $15 ,*!/"0%#. 6rd7
\[\ _4a2 ZbaZ. ^%&*2%2 N/$&7 ajA Z[k[. 64&U
;>FBC@B??)7==<>><<c O"$2"+ 04 </)7A J"/+ 04 6/##"$2A :/+2/&% J4 _/9$*A ;)),4 54 64
;,,1)4A :7*&/I"A R''4
8<?<CGFC@)7==<>>FC@c G2=/$2 J4 :/'*7/+A J$4A @*''*/- J4 W/$,%A :7*&/I"A R''4AW%$9%$, J4 N*''%$A J$4A @/)7*+I,"+A ^4 :4A J")%.7 ;4 8/-%+2%''/A W/$3%1 N4 6*'%,)A
J"7+ J4 J*I/+,*A :7*&/I"A R'' 4A #"$ 2%#%+2/+,)C/..%''/+,)4
1-,,/"C@
DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C PFE @'>G @AF@ B? @A<N PFC@<G @' E<QIL< @A< Q'C@LFQ@9 @A<N
P'I>G AFT< @' RFX< F g='>B@BQF> Q'C@LBMI@B'Ch PABQA FR'IC@<G @' s,3/9///$
Y<C@'C9 F TBQ<)=L<EBG<C@ '? @A< DCWLFR K'L=9 FQ@BCW PB@A @A< XC'P><GW< FCG
Q'R=>BQB@N '? HL<G<LBQX DCWLFR FCG @AL'IWA BC@<LR<GBFLB<E YI>> FCG V<M<L9
MLBM<G [Q;FL@>BC FCG :FCBQXB @' QFIE< @A< ?LKBG8YHJKL:<G E;<9=JE9 @' M<
FPFLG<G @' DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C$ 5'R<@BR< M<?'L< @A< ?F>> '? "+2, F ?<G<LF>WLFCG eILN Q'RR<CQ<G FC BCT<E@BWF@B'C '? @A< <T<C@E EILL'ICGBCW @A< E>IGW<)
AFI>BCW Q'C@LFQ@$ DC [FN9 "+239 @A< W'T<LCR<C@ WLFC@<G BRRICB@N @' Y<C@'C
FE F PB@C<EE '? @A< =L'E<QI@B'C$ Y<C@'C X<=@ GBFLB<E9 'L F=='BC@R<C@ QF><CGFLE9
BC PABQA A< RFG< C'@<E Q'CQ<LCBCW R<<@BCWE FCG @<><=A'C< Q'CT<LEF@B'CE9
CFRBCW @A< =<LE'CE BCT'>T<G FCG '?@<C L<Q'LGBCW @A< EIME@FCQ< '? @A<
Q'CT<LEF@B'CE$ 6A< Y<C@'C GBFLB<E ?BWIL<G =L'RBC<C@>N BC @A< W'T<LCR<C@iE
QFE<9 ?'L @A<N Q'LL'M'LF@<G RIQA '? ABE @<E@BR'CN$ [Q;FL@>BC FCG DCWLFR @A<C
E'IWA@ @' GBEQL<GB@ @A<E< GBFLB<E$ 7C :<P8?9:GJ9;= JE9:<G I;= 3=8B8=:E` #<G=JFb?
E;K<?8L @PBQ< BC@<LTB<P<G [Q;FL@>BC PB@A @A< Q'CE<C@ '? @A< >F@@<LiE
Q'ICE<> ?'L @A< =IL='E< '? G<@<LRBCBCW PA<@A<L @A<L< PFE F MFEBE ?'LQAF>><CWBCW @A< @LI@A '? E'R< '? @A< GBFLN <C@LB<E$ DC @A< E<Q'CG '? @A<E<
BC@<LTB<PE ,E!J=9L:< FJB8 E8=9J:< ?9J98F8<9?Q OH:EH #<G=JF J=GK8? 98<B 9;
?KAA;=9 H:? B8I8<?85 [Q;FL@>BCiE Q'ICE<> 'Me<Q@<G 'C @A< WL'ICG9 *+,%$ /'*/A '?
@A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ UTBG<CQ< BEEI< C'P BE P1C E@F@<R<C@E RFG< @'
@A< DCT<E@BWF@'L '? @A< Q'ICE<> '? FC'@A<L G<?<CGFC@ QFCC'@ M< FGRB@@<G FE
<TBG<CQ< 'C @A< WL'ICG '? F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ ,E!J=9L:< OJ? 8<9:9L8B 9;
9H8 A=;98E9:;< ;I 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8Q M8EJK?8 H:? ?9J98F8<9? O8=8
FJB8 :< E;<I:B8<E8 9; J< J99;=<8N I;= J E;YB8I8<BJ<9 I;= J E;FF;< AK=A;?8
=8LJ98B 9; M;9H B8I8<?8?5 6A<N P<L< RFG< BC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@A @A< =L'e<Q@ '?
F@@<R=@BCW @' GBEQL<GB@ Y<C@'C9 F =L'e<Q@ BC PABQA DCWLFR FCG [Q;FL@>BC FCG
@A<BL F@@'LC<NE P<L< e'BC@>N <CWFW<G ?'L @A< M<C<?B@ '? M'@A G<?<CGFC@E$
DCWLFR FQXC'P><GW<E @AF@ Q'RRICBQF@B'CE MN F Q>B<C@ @' ABE 'PC >FPN<L
L<RFBC =LBTB><W<G PA<C @A< >FPN<L EIME<\I<C@>N EAFL<E @A<R PB@A Q')
G<?<CGFC@E ?'L =IL='E<E '? F Q'RR'C G<?<CE<$ 6A< Q'RR'C)G<?<CE< LI><9
PABQA BE C'@ FE CFLL'P FE DCWLFR Q'C@<CGE9 AFE M<<C L<Q'WCBa<G BC QFE<E
E=FCCBCW R'L< @AFC F Q<C@ILN$ #<G=JF JL?; ?88F? 9; J=GK8 9HJ9 9H8
E;FFK<:EJ9:;< OJ? <;9 A=:P:L8G8B M8EJK?8 :9 OJ? FJB8 9; J< :<P8?9:GJ9;=
=J9H8= 9HJ< J< J99;=<8N5 6A< BCT<E@BWF@'L OJ? J< JG8<9 I;= #<G=JFb? J99;=<8NQ
H;O8P8=Q ?; :9 :? J? :I 9H8 E;FFK<:EJ9:;< OJ? 9; 9H8 J99;=<8N H:F?8LI5 0H8
J99;=<8N OH; 9HK? K<B8=9J`8? 9; ?8=P8 H:? EL:8<9b? E;YB8I8<BJ<9 I;= J L:F:98B
AK=A;?8 M8E;F8? 9H8 E;YB8I8<BJ<9b? J99;=<8N I;= 9HJ9 AK=A;?85
3/*01c ^%<F>>N ('CW KFE<_
^*$,1 0*22*+I /+2 0$*9*+I
• 6A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ '=<LF@<E F E<PFW< @L<F@R<C@ =>FC@ BC 5@BQXC<N9
D>>BC'BE$ fC@B> "+2" @A< E>IGW< =L'GIQ<G FE F MN)=L'GIQ@ PFE GBE='E<G
'? MN =IR=BCW B@ BC@' C<FLMN >FW''CE$ UFL>N @AF@ N<FL9 M<QFIE< @A<
>FW''CE P<L< LF=BG>N M<BCW ?B>><G FCG <??'L@E @' Q><FC @A<R AFG ?FB><G9
@A< 8BE@LBQ@ FCC'ICQ<G =>FCE @' AFT< @A< E>IGW< @LFCE='L@<G @' HI>@'CK'IC@N9 D>>BC'BE9 FCG E'>BQB@<G MBGE 'C @A< =L'e<Q@9 PABQA P<L< GI< 'C
[FLQA "+9 "+2"$
• JB<P<G BC @A< >BWA@ R'E@ ?FT'LFM>< @' @A< =L'E<QI@B'C9 9H8 8P:B8<E8
?H;O8B 9HJ9 d8<9;<Q JE9:<G O:9H 9H8 `<;OL8BG8 J<B E;FAL:E:9N ;I
3=8B8=:E` #<G=JF J<B 9H=;KGH :<98=F8B:J=:8? dKLL J<B c8M8=Q M=:M8B
,E!J=9L:< J<B ]J<:E`: 9; EJK?8 9H8 ?LKBG8YHJKL:<G E;<9=JE9 9; M8
JOJ=B8B 9; #<G=JF *;=A;=J9:;< FCG 'C< '? B@E EIMEBGBFLB<E9 FCG >F@<L
MLBM<G @A< EFR< '??BQBF>E @' E<QIL< ?FT'LFM>< @L<F@R<C@ ICG<L @A<
Q'C@LFQ@ FCG R'GB?BQF@B'CE '? @A< Q'C@LFQ@$ 6A< G<@FB>E P<L< FE ?'>>'PEc
•
VA<C @A< 8BE@LBQ@ E'>BQB@<G MBGE 'C @A< E>IGW<)AFI>BCW =L'e<Q@9G<?<CGFC@ YI>> FEEBE@<G HLFCX 4M<L><9 FC <R=>'N<< '? DCWLFR
K'C@LFQ@'LE9 DCQ$9 F PA'>>N 'PC<G EIMEBGBFLN '? DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C9 BC
BCT<E@BWF@BCW @A< C<P =L'='EF>$ 8ILBCW @A< P<<X M<?'L< @A< MBGE P<L<
@' M< EIMRB@@<G9 dKLL P:?:98B ";M8=9 D;O?;<9 F TBQ< =L<EBG<C@ '?
DCWLFR K'C@LFQ@'LE9 DCQ$9 BC &<P 4L><FCE9 ('IBEBFCF9 FCG 9;LB D;O?;<
9HJ9 :I #<G=JF *;=A;=J9:;< 8UA8E98B 9; ?8EK=8 9H8 E;<9=JE9Q :9 O;KLB
HJP8 9; FJ`8 J nA;L:9:EJL E;<9=:MK9:;<5n S'PE'C L<E='CG<G @AF@ A<
PFE C'@ BC @AF@ E'L@ '? MIEBC<EE9 MI@ @A<C @''X YI>> @' R<<@ VB>>BFR :$
Y<C@'C9 TBQ< =L<EBG<C@ '? DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C FCG =L<EBG<C@ '? DCWLFR
K'C@LFQ@'LE9 DCQ$
| |
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 34/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0,
• DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C9 YIL>BCW@'C &'L@A<LC9 DCQ$9 FCG @A< 7@QABE'C9
6'=<XF FCG 5FC@F H< %FB>PFN K'R=FCN P<L< @A< ><FGBCW Q'C@<CG<LE
FR'CW @A'E< EIMRB@@BCW MBGE 'C [FLQA "+9 "+2"$ 6' C<W'@BF@< PB@A
@A<E< @AL<< MBGG<LE9 @A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ <E@FM>BEA<G F Q'RRB@@<<9
PABQA R<@ PB@A L<=L<E<C@F@BT<E '? @A< MBGG<LE ?'L @A< ?BLE@ @BR< 'C
[FLQA *09 "+2"$
• 6AF@ <T<CBCW YI>>9 4M<L><9 FCG Y<C@'C R<@ BC Y<C@'CiE A'@<> L''R9
PA<L< @A<N P<L< >F@<L e'BC<G MN G<?<CGFC@ V<M<L$ 7?@<L YI>> AFG
BC@L'GIQ<G V<M<L @' Y<C@'C9 YI>> FCG 4M<L>< ><?@ @A< L''R$ c8M8=
9H8< 9;LB d8<9;< 9HJ9 :I #<G=JF *;=A;=J9:;< OJ<98B 9H8 ?LKBG8Y
HJKL:<G E;<9=JE9Q :9 O;KLB HJP8 9; FJ`8 J tX_hQhhh nA;L:9:EJL
E;<9=:MK9:;<5n Y<C@'C L<=>B<G @AF@ A< P'I>G AFT< @' W<@ F==L'TF> ?L'R
ABE EI=<LB'LE$ 7?@<L FWL<<BCW @' R<<@ Y<C@'C @A< C<Z@ GFN9 V<M<L ><?@$
• Y<C@'C @A<C @<><=A'C<G G<?<CGFC@ HL<G<LBQX DCWLFR @' BC?'LR ABR '?
V<M<LiE k='>B@BQF> Q'C@LBMI@B'Ck =L'='EF>$ #<G=JF JG=88BQ A=;P:B8B
9HJ9 9H8 E;<9=:MK9:;< E;KLB M8 JBB8B 9; 9H8 E;?9 ;I 9H8 E;<9=JE95
• 4C [FLQA *,9 "+2"9 Y<C@'C FWFBC R<@ PB@A YI>>9 PA' <Z=L<EE<G ABE
M<>B<? @AF@ B? @A< DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C FQQ<=@<G V<M<LiE =L'='EF>9 B@
P'I>G W<@ @A< Q'C@LFQ@$ dKLL JL?; 9;LB d8<9;< 9HJ9 :I 9H8 E;=A;=J9:;<
B:B G89 9H8 E;<9=JE9Q H8 OJ<98B t4hhQhhh :< JBB:9:;< 9; J<N9H:<G :9
AJ:B c8M8=$ 7@ FC'@A<L R<<@BCW >F@<L BC @A< GFN9 V<M<L FEX<G Y<C@'C
@' '=<C FC FQQ'IC@ F@ F KABQFW' MFCX @' G<R'CE@LF@< DCWLFR
K'L='LF@B'CiE kW''G ?FB@A$k 6AF@ EFR< GFN9 Y<C@'C '=<C<G FC FQQ'IC@
F@ @A< HBLE@ &F@B'CF> YFCX '? KABQFW'$
• 6A< ?'>>'PBCW P<<X9 c8M8= EJLL8B d8<9;< J<B 9;LB H:F 9HJ9
dK=L:<G9;< .;=9H8=<Q #<E5 HJB ;II8=8B 9; FJ`8 J tXZ_Qhhh A;L:9:EJL
E;<9=:MK9:;<5 /EE;=B:<G 9; c8M8=Q :9 OJ? 9H8=8I;=8 <8E8??J=N I;=
#<G=JF *;=A;=J9:;< 9; =J:?8 :9? E;<9=:MK9:;< 9; ti_hQhhhQ :<ELKB:<G J
t4_hQhhh EJ?H AJNF8<9 M8I;=8 9H8 E;<9=JE9 OJ? JOJ=B8B $ 7WFBCY<C@'C Q'CEI>@<G HL<G<LBQX DCWLFR9 PA' FWFBC FWL<<G 'C Q'CGB@B'C
@AF@ @A< Q'C@LBMI@B'C Q'I>G M< FGG<G @' @A< Q'C@LFQ@ =LBQ<$ Y<C@'C
Q'RRICBQF@<G DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'CiE F==L'TF> @' V<M<L9 MI@ EFBG @AF@
@A< Q'L='LF@B'C Q'I>G C'@ LFBE< s"3/9/// BC QFEA 'C EIQA EA'L@ C'@BQ<$
V<M<L L<=>B<G @AF@ E'R< '? @A< s"3/9/// AFG @' M< =FBG MN 7=LB> 09
"+2"$
• 4C 7=LB> 09 "+2"9 V<M<L FCG [Q;FL@>BC P<C@ @' Y<C@'CiE KABQFW' A'@<>
L''R9 PA<L< V<M<L BC@L'GIQ<G [Q;FL@>BC @' Y<C@'C FE @A< RFC PA'
AFCG><G F>> ='>B@BQF> Q'C@LBMI@B'CE ?'L @A< 8<R'QLF@BQ ;FL@N BC D>>BC'BE$
[Q;FL@>BC FEEIL<G Y<C@'C @AF@ DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C P'I>G L<Q<BT< F@><FE@ s*"93//9/// BC @'@F> L<T<CI< ?L'R @A< E>IGW<)AFI>BCW Q'C@LFQ@$
Y<C@'C WFT< [Q;FL@>BC s239/// BC QFEA9 BCQ>IGBCW E<T<LF> 'C< @A'IEFCG
G'>>FL MB>>E$ 4C 7=LB> ]9 "+2"9 V<M<L G<='EB@<G CBC< 'C< @A'IEFCG
G'>>FL MB>>E BC @A< FQQ'IC@ '? 'C< '? ABE G<?ICQ@ Q'L='LF@B'CE9 D>>BC'BE
5'I@A<LC [F@<LBF>E$
• 4C 7=LB> ]9 "+2"9 V<M<L @<><=A'C<G Y<C@'C9 FEXBCW ?'L s*39/// BC QFEA
BRR<GBF@<>N @' E<QIL< @A< Q''=<LF@B'C '? @AL<< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ E@F??
R<RM<LE$ VA<C Y<C@'C =L'@<E@<G @AF@ A< Q'I>G C'@ G<>BT<L s*39///
QFEA 'C EIQA EA'L@ C'@BQ<9 V<M<L EIWW<E@<G @AF@ DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C
BEEI< F QA<QX BC @AF@ FR'IC@ @' YI>> 6'PBCW K'R=FCN9 PABQA Y<C@'C
QFIE<G @' M< G'C< @A< C<Z@ GFN$ 4C 7=LB> -9 "+2"9 UGPBC YI>> G<='EB@<G
@A< DCWLFR QA<QX BC @A< FQQ'IC@ '? YI>> 6'PBCW K'R=FCN FCG9 F@ @A<
EFR< @BR<9 PB@AGL<P s*39/// BC QFEA ?L'R @A< FQQ'IC@$
• 6A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ L<\I<E@<G @A< @AL<< MBGG<LE 'C @A< E>IGW<)AFI>BCW
Q'C@LFQ@ @' EIMRB@ C<P MBGE MN 7=LB> "39 "+2"$ 5FC@F H< G<Q>BC<G$
YIL>BCW@'C &'L@A<LC EIMRB@@<G F L<TBE<G MBG '? s"-90//9///$ 4M<L><
EIMRB@@<G DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'CiE L<TBE<G MBG '? s"]9++/9///9 F?@<L
PABQA A< L<@ILC<G @' ABE A'@<> L''R9 PA<L< A< L<Q<BT<G F @<><=A'C<
QF>> ?L'R <B@A<L Y<C@'C 'L V<M<L$ 6A< QF>><L BCE@LIQ@<G ABR @' W' @'
@A< MFL F@ @A< K'C@BC<C@F> ;>FaF S'@<> @' R<<@ G<?<CGFC@ :FCBQXB9PABQA 4M<L>< GBG$ 7@ @A< R<<@BCW BC @A< MFL ]J<:E`: 9;LB +M8=L8 9; =J:?8
#<G=JFb? =8P:?8B M:B 9; t4jQZZhQhhh$ 4M<L>< @A<C L<@ILC<G @' ABE A'@<>
L''R FCG @<><=A'C<G Y<C@'C ?'L FGTBE<$ Y<C@'C BCE@LIQ@<G 4M<L>< @'
F@@<CG @A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ C<W'@BF@BCW Q'RRB@@<< R<<@BCW EQA<GI><G
?'L @AF@ F?@<LC''C$ VAB>< F@@<CGBCW @A< R<<@BCW9 4M<L>< L<Q<BT<G
@<><=A'C< BCE@LIQ@B'CE ?L'R Y<C@'C @' LFBE< @A< DCWLFR MBG MN
s"9///9/// @' s"29++/9///$ 4M<L>< GBG E'$
;#,%$ 0*22*+I F"'*,*&)
•
4C 7=LB> **9 "+2"9 @A< 1J<:9J=N (:?9=:E9 d;J=B ;I 0=K?988? P;98B 9;JOJ=B 9H8 E;<9=JE9 9; #<G=JF *;=A;=J9:;< $ Y<@P<<C @AF@ GF@< FCG
[FN "*9 "+2"9 F Q'C@LFQ@ PFE GLF?@<G MN R<RM<LE '? @A< 5FCB@FLN
8BE@LBQ@ E@F?? FCG DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C L<=L<E<C@F@BT<E9 BCQ>IGBCW :'AC
8'CC<>>N9 =L<EBG<C@ '? DCWLFR YFLW< K'R=FCN9 @A< DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C
EIMEBGBFLN @AF@ P'I>G @LFCE='L@ @A< E>IGW< ICG<L @A< Q'C@LFQ@$ 6A<
E@F?? BCEBE@<G 'C F >B\IBGF@<G GFRFW<E Q>FIE< FI@A'LBaBCW @A< 8BE@LBQ@ @'
=L<EQLBM< @A< FR'IC@ '? E>IGW< @' M< @LFCE='L@<G BC FCN *,)A'IL
=<LB'G FCG =L'TBGBCW @AF@ DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C P'I>G M< FEE<EE<G F
=<CF>@N ?'L <FQA @'C '? E>IGW< C'@ @LFCE='L@<G9 FE =L<EQLBM<G9 BC FCN
*,)A'IL =<LB'G$ 8'CC<>>N9 F?@<L BCB@BF>>N L<?IEBCW @' FWL<< @' @A<
=L'TBEB'C9 GBEQIEE<G B@ PB@A Y<C@'C9 PA' @'>G ABR @' FWL<< @' B@$ 4C>N
EVIDENCE 3 II | 3A 2015 | ATTY L ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 35/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
03
F?@<L @F>XBCW PB@A HL<G<LBQX DCWLFR9 A'P<T<L9 GBG 8'CC<>>N FQQ<G< @'
BCQ>IEB'C '? @A< >B\IBGF@<G GFRFW<E Q>FIE<$
• 6A< Q'C@LFQ@ =L'TBG<G @AF@ DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C P'I>G Q'CE@LIQ@
FGGB@B'CE @' @A< @L<F@R<C@ ?FQB>B@B<E F@ 5@BQXC<N FCG FC IC>'FGBCW G'QX
FCG =IR= E@F@B'C BC HI>@'C K'IC@N9 ?'L PABQA P'LX @A< 5FCB@FLN
8BE@LBQ@ PFE @' =FN s2009///$ DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C PFE F>E' @' Q'CE@LIQ@
F =B=<>BC< 'T<L =L'=<L@N C'@ 'PC<G MN @A< 8BE@LBQ@9 ?'L PABQA
Q'CE@LIQ@B'C @A< 8BE@LBQ@ FWL<<G @' =FN s]-9/// =<L R'C@A ?'L 0]
R'C@AE9 F @'@F> '? s*9,,-9///$ 6A< Q'C@LFQ@ F>E' =L'TBG<G @AF@ DCWLFR
K'L='LF@B'C P'I>G L<Q<BT< s"$-/* =<L @'C '? E>IGW< AFI><G ?L'R
5@BQXC<N @' HI>@'C K'IC@N$ 6A< =FL@B<E <E@BRF@<G @AF@ 'T<L @A< >B?< '?
@A< Q'C@LFQ@ -9///9/// @'CE '? E>IGW< P'I>G M< @LFCE='L@<G$
• 4C [FN "+9 "+2"9 V<M<L FCG Y<C@'C R<@ BC &<P 4L><FCE @' GBEQIEE
PFNE '? BCQL<FEBCW DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'CiE @'@F> L<T<CI< ICG<L @A<
Q'C@LFQ@ @' @A< s*"93//9/// @AF@ [Q;FL@>BC AFG FEEIL<G Y<C@'C P'I>G
M< ?'L@AQ'RBCW$ V<M<L @'>G Y<C@'C @AF@ :FCBQXB FCG A< @A'IWA@ @AF@
@A< Q'L='LF@B'C Q'I>G L<Q<BT< FC FGGB@B'CF> s*9"//9/// MN MB>>BCW @A<
5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ F E<Q'CG @BR< ?'L @A< Q'CE@LIQ@B'C '? @A< =B=<>BC< FCG
@A< Q'CE@LIQ@B'C BC HI>@'C K'IC@N$• 4C :IC< *]9 "+2"9 V<M<L @'>G Y<C@'C @AF@ :FCBQXB C<<G<G s*"9*3/ @'
=FN '?? @AL<< 8BE@LBQ@ E@F?? R<RM<LE$ DCWLFR BEEI<G F QA<QX ?'L @AF@
FR'IC@ @' 5'I@AP<E@ UZ=L<EEPFN9 FC'@A<L '? V<M<LiE G<?ICQ@
Q'L='LF@B'CE$
• 4C :I>N *29 "+2"9 V<M<L BEEI<G F s*/9/// QA<QX @' YI>> 6'PBCW
K'R=FCN$ UGPBC YI>> G<='EB@<G @A< QA<QX FCG9 F@ @A< EFR< @BR<9
PB@AGL<P s*/9///$ 6A< C<Z@ GFN9 @A< D>>BC'BE K'RR<LQ< K'RRBEEB'C
WLFC@<G DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'CiE L<\I<E@ ?'L F Q<L@B?BQF@< '? Q'CT<CB<CQ<
FCG C<Q<EEB@N$
•
4C 7IWIE@ ",9 "+2"9 UGPBC dKLL <8G;9:J98B 9O; E;<9=JE9? O:9H #<G=JF*;=A;=J9:;<5 DC 'C< '? @A<R DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C JG=88B 9; =8<9 MJ=G8?
I=;F dKLL 0;O:<G *;FAJ<N @' @LFCE='L@ E>IGW< ?L'R @A< (<R'C@
YLBGW< 'T<L @A< D>>BC'BE %BT<L @' HI>@'C K'IC@N$ 8'CC<>>N EBWC<G @ABE
Q'C@LFQ@ MI@ L<?IE<G @' EBWC @A< '@A<L Q'C@LFQ@9 ICG<L PABQA DCWLFR
K'L='LF@B'C P'I>G FWL<< @' AJN dKLL t54j A8= 9;< I;= 9=J<?A;=9:<G
?LKBG8 I=;F 19:E`<8N 9; 9H8 %8F;<9 d=:BG8$ 6<C Q<C@E =<L @'C P<L<
BC@<CG<G FE =FNR<C@ ?'L FQ@IF> @'PBCW E<LTBQ<Ed @A< '@A<L E<T<C Q<C@E
=<L @'C P<L< BC@<CG<G FE =FNR<C@ ?'L Q'CEI>@BCW E<LTBQ<E FCG
<CWBC<<LBCW FCG ?<FEBMB>B@N E@IGB<E @AF@ YI>> AFG F>><W<G>N =<L?'LR<G
?'L DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C$ 6A< E<Q'CG Q'C@LFQ@ F>E' =L'TBG<G ?'LAJNF8<9 9; dKLL ;I J tj^Qhhh nI:<B8=b? I885n (;<<8LLN ;Ma8E98B 9; 9H8
nI:<B8=b? I88Qn \I<E@B'C<G PA<@A<L FCN Q'CEI>@BCW E<LTBQ<E 'L E@IGB<E
@AF@ YI>> =L'TBG<G @' DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C P<L< P'L@A s3]/9///9 FCG
\I<E@B'C<G YI>>iE Q'R=<@<CQ< FE F MFLW< '=<LF@'L$ 4I@ '? YI>>iE
=L<E<CQ<9 d8<9;< 9;LB (;<<8LLN 9HJ9 :I dKLL B:B <;9 AJ=9:E:AJ98 :< 9H8
?LKBG8YHJKL:<G E;<9=JE9Q 9H8=8 O;KLB M8 <; E;<9=JE95 8'CC<>>N E@B>>
L<?IE<G @' EBWC @A< E<Q'CG DCWLFR)YI>> Q'C@LFQ@9 MI@ =<LRB@@<G Y<C@'C
@' EBWC B@ 'C M<AF>? '? DCWLFR YFLW< K'L='LF@B'C FE P<>> FE DCWLFR
K'L='LF@B'C$
• 4C 7IWIE@ "39 "+2"9 Y<C@'C9 V<M<L9 FCG [Q;FL@>BC R<@ BC KABQFW' @'
GBEQIEE ?IL@A<L =FNR<C@E$ Y<C@'C FWL<<G @' =L'TBG< s",]9/// BC @P'
BCE@F>>R<C@E$ 4C 7IWIE@ "-9 "+2"9 4EQFL SFLGBE'C9 Q'R=@L'>><L '?
DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C9 G<>BT<L<G s0/9/// BC QFEA @' V<M<L F@ 4iSFL<
7BL='L@ BC KABQFW'$ 4C 7IWIE@ *-9 "+2"9 FC'@A<L DCWLFR <Z<QI@BT<9 #$
#><C [FL@BC9 WFT< V<M<L s""]9///9 PABQAQ'CEBE@<G '? s,]9/// BC QFEA
FCG s2/9/// BC QA<QXE =FNFM>< @' V<M<LiE G<?ICQ@ Q'L='LF@B'CE$
• DCWLFR YFLW< K'L='LF@B'C M<WFC @LFCE='L@BCW E>IGW< ?:U BJN? LJ98=
9HJ< 9H8 BJ98 :9 OJ? =8SK:=8B 9; B; ?; ICG<L @A< E>IGW<)AFI>BCW
Q'C@LFQ@d PA<L<I='C @A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ FEE<EE<G >B\IBGF@<G GFRFW<E
'? s0/9/// ICG<L @A< >B\IBGF@<G GFRFW<E Q>FIE<$ DC <FL>N 4Q@'M<L9"+2"9 Y<C@'C9 V<M<L9 FCG :FCBQXB A<>G F R<<@BCW BC KABQFW' @' GBEQIEE
@ABE RF@@<L9 ?'>>'PBCW PABQA @A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ PB@AGL<P @A<
FEE<EER<C@$ 7?@<L @A< R<<@BCW9 c8M8= 9;LB d8<9;< 9HJ9 ]J<:E`:
OJ<98B t4hhQhhh MN 9H8 8<B ;I 4Zj45 cH8< :<I;=F8B MN d8<9;< ;I
9H:? =8SK8?9Q H;O8P8=Q 3=8B8=:E` #<G=JF =8IK?8BQ ?JN:<G 9HJ9 <; F;=8
AJNF8<9? O;KLB M8 FJB8 K<9:L 9H8 1J<:9J=N (:?9=:E9 M8GJ< FJ`:<G
AJNF8<9? ;< 9H8 A:A8L:<89 FE V<M<L AFG =L'RBE<G B@ P'I>G$
• 4C 8<Q<RM<L "39 "+2"9 V<M<L @<><=A'C<G Y<C@'C @' @<>> ABR @AF@ @A<
5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ P'I>G BEEI< F QA<QX @' DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C ?'L
s"9///9///9 FE =FL@BF> =FNR<C@ 'C @A< =B=<>BC<$ VA<C Y<C@'C FLLBT<GF@ :FCBQXBiE '??BQ< @A< ?'>>'PBCW GFN9 A'P<T<L9 :FCBQXB GBEQ>FBR<G FCN
XC'P><GW< '? @A< s"9///9/// QA<QX$ d8<9;< 9H=8J98<8B 9; na8=` 9H8
=KGn I=;F K<B8= 8P8=N;<8 :< *H:EJG;5
• f='C ><FLCBCW '? Y<C@'CiE @AL<F@9 V<M<L BC?'LR<G 4M<L>< '? B@ FCG
FEX<G 4M<L>< @' G' PAF@<T<L A< Q'I>G FM'I@ Y<C@'C$ 4M<L><
@<><=A'C<G G<?<CGFC@ HL<G<LBQX DCWLFR @' @<>> ABR '? Y<C@'CiE @AL<F@$
DCWLFR <Z=L<EE<G C' EIL=LBE<9 EBR=>N @AFCX<G 4M<L>< ?'L @A<
BC?'LRF@B'C FCG AICW I=9 FCG >F@<L BC @A< GFN R<@ PB@A Y<C@'C @'
GBEQIEE @A< RF@@<L$ 7@ @A< R<<@BCW @A<N FWL<<G @AF@ Y<C@'C P'I>G
Q'C@BCI< @' L<=L<E<C@ DCWLFRiE BC@<L<E@ BC G<F>BCW PB@A @A< KABQFW'
'??BQBF>E$
EVIDENCE 3 II | 3A 2015 | ATTY L ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 36/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0]
• 4C 8<Q<RM<L *"9 "+2"9 V<M<L9 :FCBQXB9 FCG Y<C@'C R<@ BC Y<C@'CiE
A'@<> L''R BC KABQFW'$ Y<C@'C F='>'WBa<G ?'L ABE @AL<F@$ S< @A<C WFT<
V<M<L @P' QA<QXE =FNFM>< @' V<M<LiE G<?ICQ@ Q'L='LF@B'CE BC @A<
FR'IC@ '? s3/9/2/$ 6ABE =FNR<C@ M=;KGH9 #<G=JFb? 9;9JL E;<9=:MK9:;<
9; t[4jQ[XhQ L8JP:<G J MJLJ<E8 ;I t4[XQ^gh ;< 9H8 ti_hQhhh
E;FF:9F8<95
• DC H<MLIFLN9 "+2*9 c8M8= 9;LB d8<9;< 9HJ9 M8EJK?8 ;I 9H8 B:II:EKL9:8?
:< G899:<G 9H8 1J<:9J=N (:?9=:E9 9; AJN 9H8 JBB:9:;<JL tXQ4hhQhhh I;=
9H8 A:A8L:<8Q #<G=JF *;=A;=J9:;< O;KLB HJP8 9; :<E=8J?8 :9?
E;<9=:MK9:;< 9; t^XhQhhh5 4C H<MLIFLN "29 "+2*9 V<M<L FEX<G Y<C@'C
?'L s"//9/// BC QFEA BRR<GBF@<>N$ VA<C Y<C@'C @'>G G<?<CGFC@
DCWLFR '? @A< L<\I<E@9 DCWLFR L<E='CG<G @AF@ A< P'I>G BCT<E@BWF@<
PFNE '? LFBEBCW @A< R'C<N$ 4C H<MLIFLN *-9 "+2*9 Y<C@'C G<>BT<L<G
s"//9/// @' [LE$ JF><C@BC< :FCBQXB$
• 7@ @LBF>9 G<?<CGFC@ 3=8B8=:E` #<G=JF E;<98<B8B 9HJ9 H8 B:B <;9 L8J=<
K<9:L 9H:? 38M=KJ=NQ 4ZjX F889:<G O:9H d8<9;< 9HJ9 H:? E;FAJ<N HJB
?8EK=8B J FKL9:YF:LL:;< B;LLJ= E;<9=JE9 MN AJN:<G F;=8 9HJ< t[hhQhhh
9; *H:EJG; ;II:E:JL?5 DCWLFR @<E@B?B<G @AF@ A< =L'@<E@<G FWFBCE@ =FNBCW
@A< MLBM<E9 MI@ L<>IQ@FC@>N FWL<<G PA<C Y<C@'C BC?'LR<G ABR @AF@ B?A< L<?IE<G @' =FN9 @A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ P'I>G C'@ =FN @A< FGGB@B'CF>
s*9"//9/// ?'L @A< =B=<>BC< FCG P'I>G IE< @A< >B\IBGF@<G GFRFW<E
Q>FIE< @' =<CF>Ba< DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C$
• 4C [FLQA "/9 "+2*9 V<M<L @'>G Y<C@'C @AF@ B? DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C
Q'I>G G<>BT<L s"//9/// M<?'L< @A< <CG '? @A< R'C@A9 @A< 5FCB@FLN
8BE@LBQ@ Y'FLG '? 6LIE@<<E P'I>G F==L'T< @A< =ILQAFE< '? @A< =B=<>BC<$
4C<)?'IL@A '? @ABE FR'IC@ PFE G<>BT<L<G9 MI@ @A< MF>FCQ< PFE C'@9 FCG
@A< @LIE@<<E ?FB><G @' F==L'T< @A< =ILQAFE<$ 7@ F :I>N ]9 "+2* R<<@BCW
M<@P<<C Y<C@'C9 :FCBQXB9 FCG V<M<L9 A'P<T<L9 :FCBQXB =L'RBE<G @AF@
@A< @LIE@<<E P'I>G @FX< E'R< FQ@B'C 'C @A< =B=<>BC< BC @A< R'C@A '?:I>N$ 7E =L'RBE<G9 @A< M'FLG '? @LIE@<<E FI@A'LBa<G @A< E@F?? @'
C<W'@BF@< PB@A DCWLFR ?'L @A< =ILQAFE< '? @A< =B=<>BC< 'C :I>N */9 "+2*$
• 4C 7IWIE@ *09 "+2*Q d8<9;< GJP8 ,E!J=9L:< tghQhhh :< EJ?H5
,E!J=9L:< 9;LB d8<9;< 9HJ9 9H8 9=K?988? O;KLB JAA=;P8 9H8
AK=EHJ?8;I 9H8 A:A8L:<8 :< 18A98FM8=Q MK9 #<G=JF O;KLB HJP8 9; AJN
9H8 MJLJ<E8 ;I :9? E;<9=:MK9:;<Q JM;K9 tZ_QhhhQ :< 18A98FM8= JL?;5
• Y<@P<<C 7IWIE@ FCG &'T<RM<L9 "+2*9 DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C FCG @A<
KABQFW' '??BQBF>E C<W'@BF@<G F C<P FWL<<R<C@$ DCWLFR P'I>G =FN
s23/9/// 'T<L F @AL<< N<FL =<LB'G9 FCG @A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ P'I>G
=ILQAFE< @A< =B=<>BC<9 R'GB?N @A< >B\IBGF@<G GFRFW<E Q>FIE<9 FCG
<Z@<CG @A< E>IGW<)AFI>BCW Q'C@LFQ@ ?'L @AL<< N<FLE F@ F ABWA<L =LBQ< =<L
@'C$
• 4C 8<Q<RM<L *-9 "+2*9 L<=L<E<C@F@BT<E '? @A< DCWLFR Q'R=FCB<E FCG
@A< 8BE@LBQ@ EBWC<G FC FWL<<R<C@ Q'T<LBCW @A< =B=<>BC< =ILQAFE< @AF@
PFE @' M< <??<Q@BT< 'C>N B? @A< =FL@B<E F>E' EBWC<G @P' '@A<L
FWL<<R<C@Ec F L<@L'FQ@BT< R'GB?BQF@B'C '? @A< >B\IBGF@<G GFRFW<E
Q>FIE< FCG F @AL<< N<FL <Z@<CEB'C '? @A< E>IGW<)AFI>BCW Q'C@LFQ@$ 4C
:FCIFLN *]9 "+209 @A< FGGB@B'CF> FWL<<R<C@E P<L< EBWC<G$
• 7?@<L @A< EBWCBCW9 Y<C@'C L<@ILC<G @' ABE A'@<> L''R FCG @<><=A'C<G
:FCBQXB @' @<>> ABR @AF@ ABE R'C<N PFE L<FGN$ :FCBQXB E<C@ ABE E<QL<@FLN
@' =BQX I= F =FQXFW< Q'C@FBCBCW s3/9/// BC QFEA$ Y<C@'C @A<C
@<><=A'C<G V<M<L @' @<>> ABR @' Q'R< FCG =BQX I= @A< MF>FCQ< '? @A<
R'C<N GI<$ VA<C V<M<L FLLBT<G9 d8<9;< GJP8 H:F tZ_Qhhh :< EJ?H
J<B <:<8 L8998=? ;I E=8B:9 B=JO< ;< J 1O:?? MJ<` :< 9H8 JF;K<9 ;I
tjhQhhh 8JEH5
• 4C< '? @A< ><@@<LE '? QL<GB@ RF@IL<G BC :IC<9 "+209 FCG <FQA '? @A<
'@A<LE RF@IL<G E<\I<C@BF>>N F@ EBZ)R'C@A BC@<LTF>E$ V<M<L FGRB@@<G
C<W'@BF@BCW @A< ?BLE@ ?'IL ><@@<LE F@ @A< 5PBEE MFCX BC :I>N9 "+209
8<Q<RM<L9 "+209 :IC<9 "+2,9 FCG 8<Q<RM<L9 "+2,$ 4C <FQA 'QQFEB'C9A< =ILQAFE<G ABE =>FC< @BQX<@ @' UIL'=< PB@A QFEA9 FLLFCW<G ?'L ABE @LB=
@' 5PB@a<L>FCG 'C>N F?@<L A< FLLBT<G BC UIL'=<9 FCG E@'==<G BC 6'L'C@'9
KFCFGF9 'C @A< PFN MFQX @' @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E$ 4C ABE >FE@ @P' @LB=E9
V<M<L @<><=A'C<G :FCBQXB ?L'R UIL'=<$
R+3%),*I/,*"+
• 5'R<@BR< M<?'L< @A< IJLL ;I 4Zji J I8B8=JL G=J<B aK=N E;FF8<E8B J<
:<P8?9:GJ9:;< ;I 9H8 8P8<9? ?K==;K<B:<G 9H8 ?LKBG8YHJKL:<G E;<9=JE95
DC [FN9 "+239 @A< W'T<LCR<C@ WLFC@<G BRRICB@N @' Y<C@'C$
•
DC &'T<RM<L9 "+23Q c8M8= ?8<9 H:? M=;9H8=Q D8<=N c8M8=Q 9; &K=;A89; <8G;9:J98 9H8 I:I9H J<B ?:U9H L8998=? ;I E=8B:99 PABQA RF@IL<G BC
:IC<9 "+239 FCG 8<Q<RM<L9 "+23$ H'>>'PBCW ABE ML'@A<LiE BCE@LIQ@B'CE9
S<CLN V<M<L GBG C'@ =L'Q<<G GBL<Q@>N @' @A< GLFP<< 5PBEE MFCX MI@
P<C@ @' F MFCX BC JFGIa9 (B<QA@<CE@<BC9 @' AFT< @AF@ MFCX =L<E<C@ @A<
><@@<LE @' @A< 5PBEE MFCX$
• 4C &'T<RM<L *]9 "+239 @P' P<<XE F?@<L ABE L<@ILC ?L'R (B<QA@<CE@<BC9
S<CLN V<M<L F==<FL<G M<?'L< @A< WLFCG eILN FCG @<E@B?B<G @AF@ A< AFG
'C>N TBEB@<G HLFCX?IL@ FCG [ICBQA$ 4C 8<Q<RM<L 09 "+239 @A<
W'T<LCR<C@ QF>><G S<CLN V<M<L @' F==<FL F E<Q'CG @BR< M<?'L< @A<
WLFCG eILN9 @ABE @BR< FEXBCW V<M<L @' MLBCW ABE @LFT<> L<Q'LGE$ (K=:<GH:? ?8E;<B JAA8J=J<E8Q D8<=N c8M8= 98?9:I:8B 9HJ9 H8 HJB M88<
EVIDENCE 3 II | 3A 2015 | ATTY L ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 37/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
02
F:?9J`8< OH8< H8 ?J:B 9HJ9 H8 HJB ;<LN P:?:98B 3=J<`IK=9 J<B ,K<:EH
J<B 9HJ9 H8 HJB JL?; P:?:98B $JBKT5
• 4C 8<Q<RM<L +9 "+239 3=J<`L:< c8M8=b? J99;=<8N 98L8AH;<8B ;<8 ;I
9H8 G;P8=<F8<9b? J99;=<8N? :< 9H:? EJ?8 J<B :<I;=F8B H:F ;I OHJ9
9H8 G;P8=<F8<9 J99;=<8N JL=8JBN HJB =8J?;< 9; ?K?A8E9Q <JF8LNQ 9HJ9
3=J<`L:< c8M8= HJB A;??8??:;< ;I 9H8 =8FJ:<:<G L8998=? ;I E=8B:95
#??K8c V1& [Q;FL@>BC BE <C@B@><G @' @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BC 'Me<Q@BCW @'
@A< BCQ>IEB'C '? @A< E@F@<R<C@E A< WFT< @' DCWLFROE BCT<E@BWF@'Lb ^C&1_
"J9:;c ^V'C@ GBEQIEE F>> '? @A< BEEI<E FE B@ BE L<F>>N >'CW FCG BLL<><TFC@_
"KF PA>WY"[SO 1"W"FPFO"1 WOV "KF W""\YOF]HA[SFO" >YS^S[FBF
WP\OB A\HVF?FOVWO"1 WOV "KFSY A\JO1F[ ZF^SVFOAFR
• 6AL'IWA'I@ @A< =<LB'G Q'T<L<G MN @A< BCGBQ@R<C@9 d8<9;< ̀ 8A9 B:J=:8?Q
;= JAA;:<9F8<9 EJL8<BJ=?9 BC PABQA A< RFG< C'@<E Q'CQ<LCBCW
R<<@BCWE FCG @<><=A'C< Q'CT<LEF@B'CE9 CFRBCW @A< =<LE'CE BCT'>T<G
FCG '?@<C L<Q'LGBCW @A< EIME@FCQ< '? @A< Q'CT<LEF@B'CE$ 6A< Y<C@'C
GBFLB<E ?BWIL<G =L'RBC<C@>N BC @A< W'T<LCR<C@iE QFE<9 ?'L @A<N
Q'LL'M'LF@<G RIQA '? ABE @<E@BR'CN$• 8<E@L'NBCW Y<C@'CiE QL<GBMB>B@N PFE BR='L@FC@ @' DCWLFR9 FE B@ PFE @'
@A< '@A<L G<?<CGFC@E9 <T<C @A'IWA DCWLFRiE G<?<CE< PFE MFE<G9 BC
=FL@9 'C @A< FLWIR<C@ @AF@ A< AFG RFG< @A< =FNR<C@E BC L<E='CE< @'
@A< @AL<F@E Y<C@'C AFG L<='L@<G @' ABR9 M<QFIE< DCWLFRiE FQQ'IC@ '?
<T<C@E BC BEEI< GB??<L<G RF@<LBF>>N ?L'R Y<C@'CiE9 FCG M<QFIE< @A<
W'T<LCR<C@iE QFE< ABCW<G >FLW<>N 'C Y<C@'CiE @<E@BR'CN5 1:<E8
d8<9;<b? B:J=:8? E;==;M;=J98B ?; FKEH ;I H:? 98?9:F;<NQ :9 OJ?
:FA8=J9:P8 I=;F 9H8 ?9J<BA;:<9 ;I JLL B8I8<BJ<9? 9HJ9 J< 8II;=9 M8
FJB8 9; B:?E=8B:9 9H8F5
•
5IQA FC <??'L@ PFE RFG<9 FCG HL<G<LBQX DCWLFR FCG [Q;FL@>BCQ''=<LF@<G BC @AF@ <??'L@$ DC F MLB<? EI=='L@BCW F =L<@LBF> k['@B'C ?'L
7GGB@B'CF> 6BR< @' K'CGIQ@ 8'QIR<C@ 7CF>NEBE9k DCWLFRiE Q'ICE<>
E@F@<G9 PB@A L<?<L<CQ< @' Q'C@<R=>F@<G @<E@E 'C @A< Y<C@'C GBFLB<E9
o v6wA< G<?<CGFC@ HL<G<LBQ Y$ DCWLFR BE C'@ @A< 'C>N G<?<CGFC@
PA' RFN M< F??<Q@<G MN @A< L<EI>@E '? @A<E< @<E@E$ Y<EBG<E @A<
W<C<LF> <??<Q@ '? @A< G'IM@E @AF@ RFN M< LFBE<G FE @' Y<C@'CiE
T<LFQB@N FCG @A< QL<GBMB>B@N '? @A< GBFLN <C@LB<E9 @A< QFE<
FWFBCE@ F@ ><FE@ 'C< '@A<L G<?<CGFC@ z %'M<L@ H$ [Q;FL@>BC z
RFN M< EIME@FC@BF>>N F??<Q@<G MN @A< L<EI>@E '? @A< @<E@E$ HL'R
@A< L<EI>@E '? @A< @<E@E Q'CGIQ@<G E' ?FL9 B@ F==<FLE @AF@ F@
><FE@ @P' '? @A< EIE=BQB'IE GBFLN <C@LB<E L<>F@< @' F>><W<G
=FNR<C@E '? R'C<N @' [L$ [Q;FL@>BC$
• /< :<P8?9:GJ9;= JE9:<G I;= 3=8B8=:E` #<G=JFb? E;K<?8L 9O:E8
:<98=P:8O8B ,E!J=9L:< O:9H 9H8 E;<?8<9 ;I 9H8 LJ998=b? E;K<?8L I;= 9H8
AK=A;?8 ;I B898=F:<:<G OH89H8= 9H8=8 OJ? J MJ?:? I;= EHJLL8<G:<G 9H8
9=K9H ;I ?;F8 ;I 9H8 B:J=N 8<9=:8?5 DC @A< E<Q'CG '? @A<E< BC@<LTB<PE
,E!J=9L:< FJB8 E8=9J:< ?9J98F8<9?Q OH:EH #<G=JF J=GK8? 98<B 9;
?KAA;=9 H:? B8I8<?8$ 7@ @LBF>9 PA<C DCWLFR '??<L<G <TBG<CQ< '? @A<E<
E@F@<R<C@E9 ,E!J=9L:<b? E;K<?8L ;Ma8E98B ;< 9H8 G=;K<BQ 5/)$- (65(U ;I
9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9 A=:P:L8G8Q FCG @A< Q'IL@9 F?@<L FC *+ &/-%$/ A<FLBCW9
EIE@FBC<G @A< 'Me<Q@B'C 'C @ABE FCG FC'@A<L WL'ICG$
• 6A< <ZQ>IEB'C '? @A< [Q;FL@>BC E@F@<R<C@E P'I>G C'@ M< L<T<LEBM><
<LL'L <T<C B? A< AFG C'@ M<<C <C@B@><G @' Q>FBR @A< =LBTB><W<$ V< FL<
EF@BE?B<G ?L'R 'IL <ZFRBCF@B'C '? @A< @LFCEQLB=@ '? @A< *+
&/-%$/ A<FLBCW9 PABQA PFE E<F><G FCG RFG< F =FL@ '? @A< L<Q'LG 'C
F==<F>9 @AF@ @A< E@F@<R<C@E R<L<>N Q'LL'M'LF@<G ?FQ@E PABQA P<L<
FGRB@@<G BC <TBG<CQ< FCG PABQA @A< eILN 'MTB'IE>N ?'ICG @' M<
@LI<$ V< G' C'@ GBEQ>'E< @A< Q'C@<C@E '? @A< E@F@<R<C@E M<QFIE< @A<N
L<RFBC =L'@<Q@<G MN @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<9 'C PABQA P<F>@<LCF@BT<>N MFE< 'IL LI>BCW 'C @ABE ='BC@$
• ,E!J=9L:< OJ? 8<9:9L8B 9; 9H8 A=;98E9:;< ;I 9H8 J99;=<8NYEL:8<9
A=:P:L8G8Q M8EJK?8 H:? ?9J98F8<9? O8=8 FJB8 :< E;<I:B8<E8 9; J<
J99;=<8N I;= J E;YB8I8<BJ<9 I;= J E;FF;< AK=A;?8 =8LJ98B 9; M;9H
B8I8<?8?5 6A<N P<L< RFG< BC Q'CC<Q@B'C PB@A @A< =L'e<Q@ '?
F@@<R=@BCW @' GBEQL<GB@ Y<C@'C9 F =L'e<Q@ BC PABQA DCWLFR FCG
[Q;FL@>BC FCG @A<BL F@@'LC<NE P<L< e'BC@>N <CWFW<G ?'L @A< M<C<?B@ '?
M'@A G<?<CGFC@E$ DCWLFR FQXC'P><GW<E @AF@ Q'RRICBQF@B'CE MN F
Q>B<C@ @' ABE 'PC >FPN<L L<RFBC =LBTB><W<G PA<C @A< >FPN<L
EIME<\I<C@>N EAFL<E @A<R PB@A Q')G<?<CGFC@E ?'L =IL='E<E '? FQ'RR'C G<?<CE<$ 6A< Q'RR'C)G<?<CE< LI><9 PABQA BE C'@ FE CFLL'P
FE DCWLFR Q'C@<CGE9 AFE M<<C L<Q'WCBa<G BC QFE<E E=FCCBCW R'L< @AFC
F Q<C@ILN$
• fCBCABMB@<G Q'RRICBQF@B'C FR'CW e'BC@ =FL@B<E FCG @A<BL Q'ICE<>
FM'I@ RF@@<LE '? Q'RR'C Q'CQ<LC BE '?@<C BR='L@FC@ @' @A<
=L'@<Q@B'C '? @A<BL BC@<L<E@E$ DC QLBRBCF> QFE<E B@ QFC M< C<Q<EEFLN @' F
?FBL '=='L@ICB@N @' G<?<CG$ 6A<L<?'L<9 PFBT<L BE C'@ @' M< BC?<LL<G ?L'R
@A< GBEQ>'EIL< BC Q'C?BG<CQ< @' F Q')=FL@NiE F@@'LC<N ?'L F Q'RR'C
=IL='E<$
•
DC @A< QFE< F@ MFL9 @A< eIGW< ?'ICG9 FE F =L<>BRBCFLN \I<E@B'C '? ?FQ@9?L'R @A< <TBG<CQ< FGGIQ<G F@ @A< A<FLBCW A<>G =ILEIFC@ @' %I>< ,/,^F_9
EVIDENCE 3 II | 3A 2015 | ATTY L ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 38/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0-
H<G$%$UTBG$9 @AF@ ,E!J=9L:< HJB FJB8 9H8 ?9J98F8<9? 9; 9H8
:<P8?9:GJ9;= :< E;<I:B8<E85 6AF@ ?BCGBCW BE C'@ Q><FL>N <LL'C<'IE$
• DCWLFR FLWI<E @AF@ @A< Q')G<?<CGFC@Ei G<?<CE<E RIE@ M< BC F>> L<E=<Q@E
Q'R=F@BM>< B? @A< e'BC@)G<?<CE< =LBTB><W< BE @' M< F==>BQFM><$ 6A< QFE<E
G' C'@ <E@FM>BEA EIQA F >BRB@F@B'C FCG @A<L< BE C' L<FE'C @' BR='E< B@$
%I>< 3/0^M_^0_ '? @A< =L'='E<G H<G<LF> %I><E '? UTBG<CQ<9 FE F==L'T<G
MN @A< 5I=L<R< K'IL@9 E@F@<G @AF@ @A< =LBTB><W< F==>B<E @'
Q'RRICBQF@B'CE MN F Q>B<C@ k@' F >FPN<L L<=L<E<C@BCW FC'@A<L BC F
RF@@<L '? Q'RR'C BC@<L<E@$k 6A< 7GTBE'LN K'RRB@@<<iE &'@< @'
=L'='E<G %I>< 3/0^M_ RFX<E B@ Q><FL @AF@ @A< e'BC@)BC@<L<E@ =LBTB><W< BE
C'@ >BRB@<G @' EB@IF@B'CE BC PABQA @A< ='EB@B'CE '? @A< =FL@B<E FL<
Q'R=F@BM>< BC F>> L<E=<Q@Ec
o 0H8 9H:=B 9NA8 ;I E;FFK<:EJ9:;< ;EEK=? :< 9H8 na;:<9
B8I8<?8n ;= nA;;L8B :<I;=FJ9:;<n ?:9KJ9:;<Q OH8=8 B:II8=8<9
LJON8=? =8A=8?8<9 EL:8<9? OH; HJP8 %*7$ :<98=8?9? :<
E;FF;<5 5 5 5 0H8 =KL8 B;8? <;9 JAALN 9; ?:9KJ9:;<? OH8=8
9H8=8 :? /* E;FF;< :<98=8?9 9; M8 A=;F;98B MN J a;:<9
E;<?KL9J9:;<Q J<B 9H8 AJ=9:8? F889 ;< J AK=8LN JBP8=?J=N
MJ?:?5• 7>@A'IWA @A< K'CWL<EE9 BC B@E L<TBEB'C '? @A< H<G<LF> %I><E '? UTBG<CQ<9
G<><@<G @A< G<@FB><G =LBTB><W< LI><E FCG ><?@ @A< EIMe<Q@ '? =LBTB><W< BC
?<G<LF> \I<E@B'C QFE<E @' kM< W'T<LC<G MN @A< =LBCQB=><E '? Q'RR'C
>FP FE @A<N RFN M< BC@<L=L<@<G MN @A< Q'IL@E '? @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E9k %$
3/" H<G$%$UTBG$9 @A< L<Q'RR<CGF@B'CE '? @A< 7GTBE'LN K'RRB@@<<9
F==L'T<G MN @A< 5I=L<R< K'IL@9 FL< F IE<?I> WIBG< @' @A< ?<G<LF>
Q'IL@E BC @A<BL G<T<>'=R<C@ '? F Q'RR'C >FP '? <TBG<CQ<$ DC @ABE
BCE@FCQ< P< ?'>>'P @A< L<Q'RR<CGF@B'C$ 0H8 A=:P:L8G8 A=;98E9?
A;;L:<G ;I :<I;=FJ9:;< I;= J<N B8I8<?8 AK=A;?8 E;FF;< 9; 9H8
AJ=9:E:AJ9:<G B8I8<BJ<9?5 K''=<LF@B'C M<@P<<C G<?<CGFC@E BC EIQAQBLQIRE@FCQ<E BE '?@<C C'@ 'C>N BC @A<BL 'PC M<E@ BC@<L<E@E MI@ E<LT<E
@' <Z=<GB@< @A< @LBF> 'L9 FE BC @A< QFE< F@ MFL9 @A< @LBF> =L<=FLF@B'C$
• #<G=JF JL?; ?88F? 9; J=GK8 9HJ9 9H8 E;FFK<:EJ9:;< OJ? <;9
A=:P:L8G8B M8EJK?8 :9 OJ? FJB8 9; J< :<P8?9:GJ9;= =J9H8= 9HJ< J<
J99;=<8N5 6A< BCT<E@BWF@'L OJ? J< JG8<9 I;= #<G=JFb? J99;=<8NQ
H;O8P8=Q ?; :9 :? J? :I 9H8 E;FFK<:EJ9:;< OJ? 9; 9H8 J99;=<8N H:F?8LI5
kD@ AFE C<T<L M<<C \I<E@B'C<G @AF@ @A< =LBTB><W< =L'@<Q@E
Q'RRICBQF@B'CE @' @A< F@@'LC<NiE $ $ $ FW<C@E $ $ ?'L L<CG<LBCW ABE
E<LTBQ<E$k &'L PFE B@9 FE DCWLFR Q'C@<CGE9 ?F@F> @' @A< =LBTB><W< @AF@
[Q;FL@>BC RFG< @A< E@F@<R<C@9 BC <??<Q@9 @' DCWLFRiE F@@'LC<N LF@A<L
@AFC ABE 'PC$ VA<C @A< DCWLFR FCG [Q;FL@>BC QFR=E G<QBG<G @' e'BC BC
FC F@@<R=@ @' GBEQL<GB@ Y<C@'C9 @A< F@@'LC<N ?'L <FQA L<=L<E<C@<G
M'@A ?'L =IL='E<E '? @AF@ e'BC@ <??'L@$ 6A< L<>F@B'CEAB= PFE C' GB??<L<C@
@AFC B@ P'I>G AFT< M<<C B? GILBCW @A< @LBF> @A< DCWLFR FCG [Q;FL@>BC
F@@'LC<NE AFG G<QBG<G @AF@ DCWLFRiE F@@'LC<N P'I>G QL'EE)<ZFRBC<
Y<C@'C 'C M<AF>? '? M'@A9 FCG GILBCW QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'C [Q;FL@>BC
=FEE<G DCWLFRiE F@@'LC<N F C'@< Q'C@FBCBCW BC?'LRF@B'C ?'L IE< BC @A<
QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'C$ 0H8 J99;=<8N OH; 9HK? K<B8=9J`8? 9; ?8=P8 H:?
EL:8<9b? E;YB8I8<BJ<9 I;= J L:F:98B AK=A;?8 M8E;F8? 9H8 E;Y
B8I8<BJ<9b? J99;=<8N I;= 9HJ9 AK=A;?85 7 Q>FBR '? =LBTB><W< PFE I=A<>G
BC QBLQIRE@FCQ<E EIQA FE @A<E< PA<L< Q'RRICBQF@B'CE P<L< RFG<
GBL<Q@>N @' @A< F@@'LC<N ?'L FC'@A<L =FL@N BC R+ ,7% N/,,%$ "# O$/+2
J($1 6(9."%+/ ^(&%) V%&(-A 5+*,%2 6,/,%) 34 _$*%2-/+9 L<>B<G 'C MN
DCWLFR9 BE C'@ @' @A< Q'C@LFLN$ DC _$*%2-/+ @A< Q'IL@ A<>G B@E G<QBEB'C
BC W(+12%% 34 5+*,%2 6,/,%)A )(.$/A BCF==>BQFM><9 M<QFIE< C' e'BC@
G<?<CE< 'L Q'RR'C BC@<L<E@ PFE F>><W<G$ 6A< Q'IL@ P<C@ 'C @' E@F@<9
BC @A< ?''@C'@< L<>B<G I='C9 @AF@ <T<C B? W(+12%% PFE F==>BQFM><9 @A<L<
PFE C' =LBTB><W< EBCQ< k@A< ?FQ@E '? @A< Q'CT<LEF@B'C C<WF@<
Q'C?BG<C@BF>B@N$k
•
DCFERIQA FE [Q;FL@>BC PFE <C@B@><G @' FEE<L@ @A< =LBTB><W< PA<@A<LDCWLFR PFE @LB<G e'BC@>N 'L E<=FLF@<>N9 C' =L<eIGBQ< P'I>G AFT<
L<EI>@<G ?L'R @A< e'BC@ @LBF> MN L<FE'C '? @A< <ZQ>IEB'C '? @A< [Q;FL@>BC
E@F@<R<C@E <T<C B? @A'E< E@F@<R<C@E AFG C'@ M<<C R<L<>N QIRI>F@BT<$
5UJU%7&KU vC'@ BR='L@FC@w
• Y<?'L< GBEQIEEBCW @A< E=<QB?BQ F@@FQXE 'C @A< GBE@LBQ@ Q'IL@iE G<CBF> '?
E<T<LFCQ<9 E'R< W<C<LF> =LBCQB=><E EA'I>G M< C'@<G$ 6A< \I<E@B'C '?
PA<@A<L QAFLW<E @AF@ AFT< M<<C =L'=<L>N e'BC<G 'IWA@ @' M< E<T<L<G
?'L @LBF> BE ?'L @A< GBEQL<@B'C '? @A< @LBF> eIGW<9 PA'E< G<QBEB'C PB>> M<
L<T<LE<G 'C>N I='C F EA'PBCW '? Q><FL FMIE<• 6A< G<?<CGFC@ AFE @A< MILG<C '? EA'PBCW =L<eIGBQ<9 PABQA BE F GB??BQI>@
'C<$ DG$ 7 G<CBF> '? E<T<LFCQ< PB>> LFL<>N M< L<T<LE<G 'C L<TB<P9 FCG
@A<C 'C>N ?'L @A< R'E@ kQ'W<C@ L<FE'CE9k 6A<L< BE9 R'L<'T<L9 F E@L'CW
='>BQN BC ?FT'L '? e'BC@ @LBF> kPA<L< @A< QAFLW< FWFBCE@ F>> @A<
G<?<CGFC@E RFN M< =L'T<G MN @A< EFR< <TBG<CQ< FCG L<EI>@E ?L'R @A<
EFR< E<LB<E '? FQ@E$k
;<V;O`<R6VR: ^G_G<6G vC'@ BR='L@FC@w
• 6A< DCWLFRE Q'C@<CG<G @AF@ @A< =FNR<C@E P<L< RFG< 'C>N M<QFIE<
@A< 5FCB@FLN 8BE@LBQ@ @AL<F@<C<G @' @FX< FQ@B'C @AF@ P'I>G AFT<
L<EI>@<G BC ?BCFCQBF> GBEFE@<L @' DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C9 FCG @A<L<?'L<
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY L ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 39/44
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
0+
C<B@A<L '? @A<R AFG @A< kBC@<C@ ^@' BC?>I<CQ< @A< =<L?'LRFCQ< '? FC
'??BQBF> FQ@_ L<\IBL<G MN @A< D>>BC'BE MLBM<LN E@F@I@<$k
• DCWLFRE Q>FBR @AF@ @A<BL G<?<CE< BE FC@FW'CBE@BQ @' @A< '@A<L
G<?<CGFC@E PABQA BE PAN @A< FQ@B'C FWFBCE@ EA'I>G M< E<T<L<G
• K'IL@ EFBG @AF@ <T<C B? @A< G<?<CE<E P<L< @' F G<WL<< FC@FW'CBE@BQ9
A'P<T<L9 B@ G'<E C'@ ?'>>'P @AF@ @A<L< EA'I>G AFT< M<<C @P' 'L R'L<
@LBF>E$ 4C< AFE C' LBWA@ @' FCN @FQ@BQF> FGTFC@FW< @AF@ P'I>G L<EI>@ B?
<TBG<CQ< @AF@ BE FGRBEEBM>< FWFBCE@ ABR BC <B@A<L F e'BC@ 'L E<=FLF@<
@LBF> RBWA@ M< ICFTFB>FM>< BC F E<=FLF@< @LBF>$
• D@ BE @A<L<?'L< @A< E<@@><G LI>< @AF@ F G<?<CGFC@ BE C'@ <C@B@><G @' F
E<T<LFCQ< R<L<>N M<QFIE< B@ P'I>G WBT< ABR F M<@@<L QAFCQ< '?
FQ\IB@@F>$ 6AIE FC@FW'CBE@BQ G<?<CE<E G' C'@ L<\IBL< @A< WLFC@BCW '?
E<T<LFCQ<9 9 <T<C PA<C 'C< G<?<CGFC@ @FX<E @A< E@FCG FCG M>FR<E ABE
Q')G<?<CGFC@ ?'L @A< QLBR<$ UT<C PA<C @A< G<?<CGFC@ PA' @<E@B?B<G A<
PFE @A< TBQ@BR '? <Z@'L@B'C AFG G<F>@ GBL<Q@>N PB@A @A< G<?<CGFC@
F>><W<G @' AFT< <Z@'L@<G @A< MLBM<9 P< EIE@FBC<G @A< G<CBF> '?
E<T<LFCQ<$
6FR88`fGE G__G:V `_ GfR^G<:G `__GEG^ ;O;R<6V _EG^GER:X R<OE;N vC'@BR='L@FC@w
• :FCBQXB FEE<L@E @AF@ A< PFE =L<eIGBQ<G MN <TBG<CQ< '??<L<G FWFBCE@
HL<G<LBQX DCWLFR EA'PBCW @AF@ DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C AFG MLBM<G F
YLFaB>BFC Q'L='LF@< '??BQBF> M<@P<<C "+]+ FCG "+2"9 M<QFIE< @A<
Q'CGIQ@ '? @A< YLFaB>BFC PFE EBRB>FL @' @AF@ PB@A PABQA :FCBQXB PFE
QAFLW<G$ 0H8 9=:JL E;K=9 :<?9=KE98B 9H8 aK=N 9; E;<?:B8= 9H8 8P:B8<E8
;I 9H8 8J=L:8= M=:M8 ;<LN J? 9; 3=8B8=:E` #<G=JFb? ?9J98 ;I F:<B 9 MI@
:FCBQXB FEE<L@E @AF@ @ABE BCE@LIQ@B'C PFE BC<??<Q@BT<$ V< E<< C'
EIME@FC@BF> LBEX @AF@ @A< eILN P'I>G M<>B<T< @AF@ M<QFIE< F YLFaB>BFC
Q'L='LF@< '??BQ<L @''X F MLBM< ?L'R DCWLFR K'L='LF@B'C9 :FCBQXB GBGF>E'9 FCG @A<L<?'L< P< Q'CQ>IG< @AF@ :FCBQXB PFE C'@ =L<eIGBQ<G MN @A<
FGRBEEB'C '? @ABE <TBG<CQ<$
4h5 -515 $15 '+"(+.Y.#rr/" 6#&7
3"- H$*G +2*. 5<=@<RM<L 39 "+23. 7D&5V4%6S
;>FBC@B??)7==<>><<c f&D6U8 5676U5 '? 7R<LBQF
8<?<CGFC@)7==<>>FC@c 7CF (IBEF #4%84&)&Dmm7%
1-,,/"C@
7CF #'LG'C)&BXXFL PFE Q'CTBQ@<G ?'L Q'CE=BLFQN @' ='EE<EE PB@A BC@<C@ @'GBE@LBMI@< Q'QFBC<$ 4C F==<F> EA< Q'C@<CGE @AF@ A<L Q'CTBQ@B'C EA'I>G M<
L<T<LE<G M<QFIE< @A< Q'IL@ =<LRB@@<G YL<CGF [FLQAFCG @' WBT< @<E@BR'CN
L<WFLGBCW =LBTB><W<G Q'CT<LEF@B'C M<@P<<C @A< F==<>>FC@OE F@@'LC<N FCG ABE
Q>B<C@E FCG @AF@ @A< Q'IL@ G<CB<G A<L R'@B'C @' \IFEA @A< eILN =FC<>$ 7E @' @A<
BEEI< '? P1C @A< E@F@<R<C@E BC @A< F@@'LC<NOE '??BQ< P<L< =L'@<Q@<G MN
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<9 @A< Q'IL@ A<>G @AF@ F Q'RRICBQF@B'C GBTI>W<G @'
kE@LFCW<LEk 'L 'I@EBG<LE QFC EQFLQ<>N M< Q'CEBG<L<G F Q'C?BG<C@BF>
Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C F@@'LC<N FCG Q>B<C@$ 7E @' @A< BEEI< 'C BR='EBCW
QB@Ba<CEAB= FE F \IF>B?BQF@B'C ?'L eILN E<LTBQ<9 @A< Q'IL@ A<>G @AF@ @A<L< PFE F
Q'R=<>>BCW E@F@< BC@<L<E@ BC Q'C?BCBCW @A< E<><Q@B'C '? eIL'LE @' @A'E< PA' FL<
QB@Ba<CE FCG =L<T<C@BCW L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE ?L'R E<LTBCW FE eIL'LE BE LF@B'CF>>N
L<>F@<G @' K'CWL<EEi ><WB@BRF@< ='P<L @' G<?BC< @A< <Z@<C@ '? L<EBG<C@ F>B<CEi
LBWA@E =LB'L @' 'M@FBCBCW QB@Ba<CEAB=$
3/*01c
• 7==<>>FC@9 7CF #'LG'C)&BXXFL9 PFE Q'CTBQ@<G F?@<L F @LBF> MN eILN 'C F>>
@AL<< Q'IC@E '? FC BCGBQ@R<C@ QAFLWBCW A<L PB@A
o Q'CE=BLFQN @' ='EE<EE PB@A BC@<C@ @' GBE@LBMI@< F==L'ZBRF@<>N ?'IL
XB>'WLFRE '? Q'QFBC<9FCG
o
EIME@FC@BT< QAFLW<E '? ='EE<EEB'C PB@A BC@<C@ @' GBE@LBMI@< FCGGBE@LBMI@B'C '? @A< Q'QFBC<$
• 4C F==<F>9 F==<>>FC@ Q'C@<CGE A<L Q'CTBQ@B'C EA'I>G M< L<T<LE<G M<QFIE<
"$ @A< GBE@LBQ@ Q'IL@ =<LRB@@<G F #'T<LCR<C@ PB@C<EE9 d=8<BJ ,J=EHJ<BQ
@' WBT< @<E@BR'CN L<WFLGBCW F>><W<G>N =LBTB><W<G Q'CT<LEF@B'CE
M<@P<<C F==<>>FC@iE F@@'LC<N FCG ABE Q>B<C@E9 FCG
*$ M<QFIE< @A< Q'IL@ G<CB<G A<L F;9:;< 9; SKJ?H 9H8 aK=N AJ<8L 'C
FQQ'IC@ '? @A< <ZQ>IEB'C '? L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE ?L'R WLFCG FCG =<@B@ eILB<E$
d=8<BJ ,J=EHJ<B 6&$#(&.*& !/"07
• QAFLW<G FE F Q'G<?<CGFC@ PB@A @A< QLBR<E ?'L PABQA F==<>>FC@ PFE
Q'CTBQ@<G$• [FLQAFCG EIME<\I<C@>N =><G WIB>@N 'C K'IC@ D '? @A< BCGBQ@R<C@ FCG
@<E@B?B<G F@ @LBF> ?'L @A< #'T<LCR<C@$
• ;LB'L @' <C@<LBCW A<L =><F9 [FLQAFCG AFG @P' R<<@BCWE BC @A< '??BQ< '?
F==<>>FC@iE F@@'LC<N9 [L$ UE@LIREF$
• 4C <FQA '? @A<E< 'QQFEB'CE9 E<T<LF> '? @A< Q'G<?<CGFC@E P<L< =L<E<C@$
[FLQAFCG9 A'P<T<L9 OJ? <;9 J EL:8<9 ;I &?9=KF?JQ FCG B@ BE ICQ><FL
PA<@A<L F>> @A< '@A<L =<LE'CE BC @A<E< R<<@BCWE P<L< UE@LIREFiE
Q>B<C@E$
• 4? @A< @P' Q'CT<LEF@B'CE L<>F@<G MN [FLQAFCG9 @A< E<Q'CG PFE @A<
EIMe<Q@ '? @A'L'IWA QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'C MN UE@LIREF$ 6A< E<Q'CGQ'CT<LEF@B'C BCT'>T<G UE@LIREFiE F>><W<G L<Q'RR<CGF@B'C @AF@
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 40/44
EVIDENCE 3 II | 3A 2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
,/
[FLQAFCG ><FT< @A< Q'IC@LN FCG W' @' J<C<aI<>F$
• 4C L<GBL<Q@9 @A< #'T<LCR<C@ BC\IBL<G9 'T<L G<?<CE< 'Me<Q@B'C9 BC@'
@A< EIME@FCQ< '? @A< Q'CT<LEF@B'C GILBCW @A< ?BLE@ R<<@BCW$ [FLQAFCG
@<E@B?B<G @AF@ F@ @ABE R<<@BCW @A< =FL@BQB=FC@E9 F@ [L$ UE@LIREFiE
EIWW<E@B'C9 FWL<<G @' WBT< =<LeIL<G Q'T<L)I= @<E@BR'CN F@ @LBF> @' @A<
<??<Q@ @AF@ C'C< '? @A<R AFG ='EE<EE<G @A< Q'QFBC<9 MI@ BCE@<FG
R<L<>N AF==<C<G @' M< F@ F =FL@N PA<L< @A< Q'QFBC< PFE GBEQ'T<L<G$
#??K8c V1& @A< E@F@<R<C@E BC F@@'LC<N UE@LIREFiE '??BQ< P<L< =L'@<Q@<G MN @A<
F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W<$ ^.+_
"J9:;c
• 6A<L< P<L< F@ ><FE@ ?BT< =<LE'CE =L<E<C@ F@ UE@LIREFiE '??BQ< 'C @ABE
'QQFEB'Cd F@ ><FE@ 'C< '? @A< =<LE'CE9 YL<CGF [FLQAFCG9 FCG =<LAF=E
'@A<LE9 P<L< C'@ Q>B<C@E '? [L$ UE@LIREF$ 7 Q'RRICBQF@B'C GBTI>W<G @'
kE@LFCW<LEk 'L 'I@EBG<LE QFC EQFLQ<>N M< Q'CEBG<L<G F Q'C?BG<C@BF>
Q'RRICBQF@B'C M<@P<<C F@@'LC<N FCG Q>B<C@$
• 6A<L<?'L<9 @ABE Q'RRICBQF@B'C BE C'@ =L'@<Q@<G MN @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@
=LBTB><W<$ YI@ <T<C B? B@ F==<FL<G @AF@ @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'C BC \I<E@B'C P<L<
'@A<LPBE< =LBTB><W<G ^B$ <$9 @AF@ @A< Q'RRICBQF@B'C PFE Q'CEBG<L<G
Q'C?BG<C@BF> G<E=B@< @A< =L<E<CQ< '? F E@LFCW<L_9 @A< @<E@BR'CN PFEC'C<@A<><EE FGRBEEBM><$
• 6A< Q'CT<LEF@B'CE BC \I<E@B'C G<F>@ PB@A =>FCE @' Q'RRB@ =<LeILN E' FE @'
ABG< @A< QLBRBCF> FQ@BTB@N '? F==<>>FC@ FCG '@A<LE$ D@ BE M<N'CG GBE=I@< @AF@
@A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< G'<E C'@ <Z@<CG @' Q'RRICBQF@B'CE L<WFLGBCW
FC BC@<CG<G QLBR<$
• 6A< ='>BQN ICG<L>NBCW @A< F@@'LC<N)Q>B<C@ =LBTB><W< BE @' =L'R'@< @A<
FGRBCBE@LF@B'C '? eIE@BQ<$ D@ P'I>G M< F =<LT<LEB'C '? @A< =LBTB><W< @'
<Z@<CG B@ E' FE @' =L'@<Q@ Q'RRICBQF@B'CE G<EBWC<G @' ?LIE@LF@< eIE@BQ< MN
Q'RRB@@BCW '@A<L QLBR<E @' Q'CQ<F> =FE@ RBEG<<GE$
,;9:;< 9; 2KJ?H 9H8 ]K=N !J<8L 6<;9 =8LJ98B 9; 8P:B8<E87
• 7==<>>FC@ FLWI<E @AF@ @A< @LBF> Q'IL@ <LL'C<'IE>N L<?IE<G @' \IFEA @A< =<@B@
eILN T<CBL< 'C @A< WL'ICG @AF@ @A< <ZQ>IEB'C @A<L<?L'R '? L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE
G<=LBT<G A<L '? A<L LBWA@ @' @LBF> M<?'L< F eILN L<=L<E<C@BCW F ?FBL QL'EE)
E<Q@B'C '? @A< Q'RRICB@N$
• 6A< LBWA@ FCG GI@N @' FQ@ FE WLFCG 'L =<@B@ eIL'LE BE =L<E<C@>N L<E<LT<G @'
QB@Ba<CE$ k7CN &*,*g%+ '? @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<E $ $ BE Q'R=<@<C@ @' E<LT< FE F
WLFCG 'L =<@B@ eIL'L$k
• 6ABE RFCGF@< <ZQ>IG<E L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE ?L'R eILN E<LTBQ<E$ 7>> G<?<CGFC@E F@
@A< @LBF> P<L< '? KIMFC 'LBWBC 9 G<?<CGFC@ F>><W<G @AF@ BC [BFRB9 PA<L<@LBF> @''X =>FQ< 0/p FL< L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE R'E@>N '? KIMFC G<EQ<C@9 <ZQ>IEB'C
'? L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE G<=LBT<G A<L '? F ?FBL @LBF>$
• 7>@A'IWA @A< 5BZ@A 7R<CGR<C@ <CQ'R=FEE<E F ?ICGFR<C@F> LBWA@ @' @LBF>
MN F eILN PABQA BE F @LI>N L<=L<E<C@F@BT< QL'EE)E<Q@B'C '? @A< Q'RRICB@N9 B@
AFE C<T<L M<<C @A'IWA@ @AF@ ?<G<LF> eILB<E RIE@ M< GLFPC ?L'R F QL'EE)
E<Q@B'C '? @A< ,",/' ='=I>F@B'C PB@A'I@ @A< BR='EB@B'C '? FCN \IF>B?BQF@B'CE$
#11-&c V1& #'T<LCR<C@ QFC Q'CE@B@I@B'CF>>N BR='E< QB@Ba<CEAB= FE F
\IF>B?BQF@B'C ?'L eILN E<LTBQ<
"/0#+c
• :ILBE=LIG<CQ< AFE A<>G @AF@ F>B<CE FL< =L'@<Q@<G MN @A< U\IF> ;L'@<Q@B'C
K>FIE< '? @A< H'IL@<<C@A 7R<CGR<C@9 FCG @AF@ Q>FEEB?BQF@B'CE MFE<G 'C
F>B<CFW< FL< BCA<L<C@>N EIE=<Q@ FCG EIMe<Q@ @' Q>'E< eIGBQBF> EQLI@BCN$
• 6A< EFR< FCF>NEBE BE F==>BQFM>< @' @A< 8I< ;L'Q<EE K>FIE< '? @A< HB?@A
7R<CGR<C@9 PABQA L<>F@<E @' Q>FEEB?BQF@B'CE MN @A< H<G<LF> #'T<LCR<C@$ D?
F Q>FEEB?BQF@B'C BE BCTF>BG ICG<L @A< U\IF> ;L'@<Q@B'C K>FIE< '? @A<
H'IL@<<C@A 7R<CGR<C@9 B@ BE F>E' BCTF>BG ICG<L @A< 8I< ;L'Q<EE K>FIE< '?
@A< HB?@A 7R<CGR<C@$
• 5BCQ< F>B<CFW< BE F EIE=<Q@ Q>FEEB?BQF@B'C9 @A< H<G<LF> #'T<LCR<C@ RIE@
@A<L<?'L< G<R'CE@LF@< @AF@ B@ AFE F Q'R=<>>BCW E@F@< BC@<L<E@ BC Q'C?BCBCW@A< E<><Q@B'C '? eIL'LE @' @A'E< PA' FL< QB@Ba<CE$
• DC F%$?*+)A @A< Q'IL@ A<>G @AF@ @A<L< PFE F Q'R=<>>BCW BC@<L<E@ kBC <CEILBCW
@AF@ =<LE'CE PA' E<LT< FE eIL'LE FL< =<LE'CF>>N Q'RRB@@<G @' @A< =L'=<L
F==>BQF@B'C FCG <C?'LQ<R<C@ '? @A< >FPE '? @A< fCB@<G 5@F@<Ek PABQA
@A<L<?'L< eIE@B?B<E @A< <ZQ>IEB'C '? F>B<CE
o CF@BT<)M'LC QB@Ba<CE P'I>G M< Q'CT<LEFC@ PB@A @A< E'QBF> FCG
='>B@BQF> BCE@B@I@B'CE '? 'IL E'QB<@N9 @A< QIE@'RE '? @A< >'QF>B@N9 @A<
CIFCQ<E '? >'QF> @LFGB@B'C FCG >FCWIFW<
o (BX<PBE< CF@ILF>Ba<G QB@Ba<CE9 AFT< G<R'CE@LF@<G F MFEBQ
ICG<LE@FCGBCW '? 'IL ?'LR '? W'T<LCR<C@9 ABE@'LN FCG @LFGB@B'CE$o 6A<L< BE C' Q'LL<E='CGBCW MFEBE ?'L FEEIRBCW @AF@ L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE9
PA' 'P< F>><WBFCQ< C'@ @' FCN E@F@< 'L @' @A< ?<G<LF> W'T<LCR<C@9
MI@ FL< EIMe<Q@E '? F ?'L<BWC ='P<L9 AFT< E' FEEBRB>F@<G 'IL
E'QB<@F> FCG ='>B@BQF> R'L<E @AF@ FC <\IF> L<>BFCQ< Q'I>G M< =>FQ<G
'C @A<BL =<L?'LRBCW FE P<>> FE QB@Ba<CE @A< GI@B<E '? eIL'LE BC 'IL
eIGBQBF> ENE@<R$
• :ILN G<>BM<LF@B'CE FL< =<LAF=E @A< R'E@ E<QL<@ ?'LR '? G<QBEB'C)RFXBCW BC
@A< CF@B'Cd F EBCW>< eIL'L PA' ?FB><G @' ICG<LE@FCG @A< BR='L@ '? @A<
<TBG<CQ< M<BCW =L<E<C@<G 'L PA' >FQX<G FCN Q'CQ<LC ?'L @A< ?FBLC<EE '?
@A< 'I@Q'R< Q'I>G E<T<L<>N 'ME@LIQ@ 'L GBE@'L@ @A< Q'ILE< '? eIE@BQ<$
• %<EBG<C@ F>B<CE MN G<?BCB@B'C AFT< C'@ N<@ M<<C FGRB@@<G @' QB@Ba<CEAB=$
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 41/44
EVIDENCE 3 II | 3A 2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
,"
fC@B> @A<N M<Q'R< QB@Ba<CE9 @A<N L<RFBC BC R'E@ QFE<E ><WF>>N M'ICG @' @A<
Q'IC@LN '? @A<BL 'LBWBC$
• 7C'@A<L L<FE'C PAN F>B<CE RFN M< <ZQ>IG<G ?L'R ?<G<LF> eILB<E BE @AF@
fCG<L 7L@BQ>< D9 E<Q@B'C -9 Q>FIE< , '? @A< K'CE@B@I@B'C9 K'CWL<EE BE WLFC@<G
@A< ='P<L k@' <E@FM>BEA FC ICB?'LR %I>< '? &F@ILF>BaF@B'C$k
• VAB>< L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE FL< <C@B@><G @' @A< ?I>> =L'@<Q@B'C '? @ABE Q'IC@LNiE
>FPE9 IC@B> @A<N 'M@FBC FCG RFBC@FBC QB@Ba<CEAB= MN CF@ILF>BaF@B'C @A<N FL<
EIMe<Q@ @' @A< =><CFLN FI@A'LB@N '? K'CWL<EEi BRRBWLF@B'C FCG
CF@ILF>BaF@B'C ='P<LE$
• 7>@A'IWA K'CWL<EE RFN C'@ EBCW>< 'I@ F>B<CE ?'L GBEQLBRBCF@'LN @L<F@R<C@
BC RF@@<LE C'@ L<>F@<G @' @A< ?IL@A<LFCQ< '? B@E CF@ILF>BaF@B'C
L<E='CEBMB>B@B<E9 ^@AL<<)eIGW< Q'IL@_9 K'CWL<EE AFE @A< ='P<L @' G<?BC<
L<FE'CFM>< =L<L<\IBEB@<E @' FC F>B<CiE <Z<LQBE< '? @A< LBWA@E FCG GI@B<E '?
QB@Ba<CEAB=$
• V< M<>B<T< @AF@ =L<T<C@BCW L<EBG<C@ F>B<CE ?L'R E<LTBCW FE eIL'LE BE
LF@B'CF>>N L<>F@<G @' K'CWL<EEi ><WB@BRF@< ='P<L @' G<?BC< @A< <Z@<C@ '?
L<EBG<C@ F>B<CEi LBWA@E =LB'L @' 'M@FBCBCW QB@Ba<CEAB=$
• 5BCQ< K'CWL<EE RFN TF>BG>N <ZQ>IG< F>B<CE ?L'R eILN E<LTBQ<9 F==<>>FC@ PFE
G<=LBT<G '? C' 5BZ@A 7R<CGR<C@ LBWA@ MN @A< ?FB>IL< @' AFT< L<EBG<C@F>B<CE BCQ>IG<G BC @A< WLFCG 'L =<@B@ eILN T<CBL<E$
445 -515 $15 .+d%&1 6,"7
,** f5 **3. /]1*01"+23 . [%$ :f56DKU ;4VU((
!89:9:;<8=>?@ -.#0&( 10/0&1
"8?A;<B8<9>?@ "+d&"0 .+d%&1
1-,,/"C
&'M><E PFE @LB<G FCG Q'CTBQ@<G '? FLR<G L'MM<LN '? F MFCX$ 6A< 'C>N <TBG<CQ<'? @A< =L'E<QI@B'C >BCXBCW ABR @' @A< QLBR< PFE @A< @<E@BR'CN '? * PB@C<EE<E$
SBE M<E@ G<?<CE< BE @A< GBEQL<GB@BCW @A<E< * PB@C<EE<E$ K'ICE<>9 M<?'L< @LBF>9
<CWFW<G FC BCT<E@BWF@'L @' BC@<LTB<P @A< * PB@C<EE<E9 PABQA BC@<LTB<PE P<L<
<RM'GB<G BC F L<='L@$ 6A< G<?<CE< Q'ICE<> IE<G @ABE L<='L@ FE MFEBE ?'L QL'EE)
<ZFRBCF@B'CzFE BC @A< Q'ICE<> P'I>G =L'='ICG \I<E@B'CE9 PABQA L<T<F><G @A<
Q'C@<C@E '? @A< BC@<LTB<P9 PABQA P'I>G @<CG @' M< GB??<L<C@ ?L'R @A< FCEP<LE
'? @A< PB@C<EE<E BC Q'IL@$ 6A< >'P<L Q'IL@ EFBG @AF@ B? G<?<CE< Q'ICE<> PBEA<G
@' =I@ @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L 'C @A< E@FCG9 @A<N RIE@ ?ILCBEA @A< =L'E<QI@B'C @A<
=FL@E '? @A< L<='L@ @AF@ @<CG @' GBEQL<GB@ @A< PB@C<EE<E$ BC L<?IEBCW9 @A< G<?<CE<
BCT'X<G ^F_ HB?@A FR<CGR<C@zPABQA BE PL'CW M<QFIE< @A< =LBTB><W< 'C>NQ'T<LE E<>?)BCQLBRBCF@B'C '? @A< FQQIE<G9 C'@ L<='L@E '? BC@<LTB<PE RFG< 'C
M<AF>? '? @A< FQQIE<Gd ^M_ H<G$ %I>< KLBR$ ;L'Q$ "]zPABQA BE PL'CW M<QFIE< B@
'C>N F==>B<G @' =L<)@LBF> GBEQ'T<LNd ^Q_ P'LX =L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC<zPABQA BE PL'CW
M<QFIE< @A< LI>< BE C'@ FME'>I@<$ %<E='CG<C@ QFC C' R'L< FGTFCQ< @A< P'LX
=L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC< @' EIE@FBC F ICB>F@<LF> @<E@BR'CBF> IE< '? P'LX =L'GIQ@
RF@<LBF>E @AFC A< Q'I>G <><Q@ @' @<E@B?N BC ABE 'PC M<AF>? FCG @A<L<F?@<L FEE<L@
ABE HB?@A 7R<CGR<C@ =LBTB><W< @' L<EBE@ QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'C 'C RF@@<LE
L<FE'CFM>N L<>F@<G @' @A'E< ML'IWA@ 'I@ BC GBL<Q@ <ZFRBCF@B'Cd ^G_ ?BEABCW
<Z=<GB@B'CzPABQA BE PL'CW9 M<QFIE< @A< Q'IL@ BE 'C>N Q'R=<>>BCW <ZFRBCF@B'C
'? @A'E< =FL@E '? @A< @<E@BR'CN '? @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L PABQA P'I>G @<CG @'
GBEQL<GB@ @A< PB@C<EE<EO @<E@BR'CN
3/*01
• %<E='CG<C@ PFE @LB<G FCG Q'CTBQ@<G 'C QAFLW<E FLBEBCW ?L'R FC FLR<G
L'MM<LN '? F ?<G<LF>>N BCEIL<G MFCX$
• 6A< 'C>N <TBG<CQ< >BCXBCW ABR @' @A< QLBR< PFE BG<C@B?BQF@B'C
@<E@BR'CN '? @P' PB@C<EE<E9 F MFCX @<>><L FCG F EF><ERFC PA' PFE BC
@A< MFCX GILBCW @A< L'MM<LN
•
%<E='CG<C@ '??<L<G FC F>BMB MI@ ABE E@L'CW<E@ G<?<CE< PFE GBEQL<GB@BCW@A< @<E@BR'CN '? @A'E< * <N<PB@C<EE<E
• DC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L @A<BL G<?<CE<9 FC BCT<E@BWF@'L ?'L @A< G<?<CE<
BC@<LTB<P<G M'@A PB@C<EE<E FCG =L<E<LT<G @A< <EE<CQ< '? @A'E<
Q'CT<LEF@B'CE BC F PLB@@<C L<='L@$ VA<C @A< PB@C<EE<E @<E@B?B<G ?'L @A<
=L'E<QI@B'C9 L<E='CG<C@iE Q'ICE<> L<>B<G 'C @A< L<='L@ BC Q'CGIQ@BCW
@A<BL QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'C$
• KL'EE '? MFCX @<>><Lc
o 7EX<G PA<@A<L A< L<QF>><G AFTBCW @'>G @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L @AF@ A<
AFG E<<C 'C>N @A< MFQX '? @A< RFC A< BG<C@B?B<G FE L<E='CG<C@$
S< GBG C'@ L<R<RM<L$ S< PFE F>>'P<G9 G<E=B@< G<?<CE<Q'ICE<>OE 'Me<Q@B'C9 @' L<?L<EA ABE R<R'LN MN >''XBCW F@ @AF@
='L@B'C '? @A< BCT<E@BWF@'LOE L<='L@$ ;L'E<QI@'L PFE F>E'
F>>'P<G @' >''X MLB<?>N
o 6A<L<F?@<L @<E@B?B<G @AF@ F>@A'IWA @A< L<='L@ BCGBQF@<G @AF@ A<
@'>G @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L A< AFG
• KL'EE '? EF><ERFCc
o 7QXC'P><GW<G @AF@ A< @'' AFG E='X<C @' @A< G<?<CE<
BCT<E@BWF@'L$ %<E='CG<C@iE Q'ICE<> @PBQ< BC\IBL<G PA<@A<L A<
@'>G @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L @AF@ kF>> M>FQXE >''X<G F>BX<k @' ABR9 FCG
BC <FQA BCE@FCQ< @A< PB@C<EE G<CB<G AFTBCW RFG< EIQA F
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 42/44
| |
,*
E@F@<R<C@$ 6A< =L'E<QI@B'C FWFBC E'IWA@ BCE=<Q@B'C '? @A<
L<><TFC@ ='L@B'C9 @' PABQA G<?<CE< Q'ICE<> 'Me<Q@<G
o 0H8 E;K=9 B8EL:<8B 9; ;=B8= B:?EL;?K=8 J9 9HJ9 9:F8Q MK9 =KL8B
9HJ9 :9 O;KLB M8 =8SK:=8B :I 9H8 :<P8?9:GJ9;= 98?9:I:8B J? 9; 9H8
O:9<8??8?b JLL8G8B ?9J98F8<9? I=;F 9H8 O:9<8?? ?9J<B5
• K'IL@ ?I@A<L FGTBE<G @AF@ B@ P'I>G <ZFRBC< @A< BCT<E@BWF@'LiE L<='L@ *+
&/-%$/A FCG P'I>G <ZQBE< F>> L<?<L<CQ< @' RF@@<LE C'@ L<><TFC@ @' @A<
=L<QBE< E@F@<R<C@E F@ BEEI<$
• 7?@<L =L'E<QI@B'C Q'R=><@<G B@E QFE<9 L<E='CG<C@ QF>><G @A<
BCT<E@BWF@'L FE F G<?<CE< PB@C<EE$ 6A< Q'IL@ L<B@<LF@<G @AF@ F Q'=N '?
@A< L<='L@9 BCE=<Q@<G FCG <GB@<G *+ &/-%$/A P'I>G AFT< @' M<
EIMRB@@<G @' #'T<LCR<C@ Q'ICE<>
• VA<C L<E='CG<C@iE Q'ICE<> E@F@<G @AF@ A< GBG C'@ BC@<CG @' =L'GIQ<
@A< L<='L@9 @A< Q'IL@ LI><G @AF@ @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L P'I>G C'@ M< F>>'P<G
@' @<E@B?N FM'I@ @A'E< BC@<LTB<PE
• K7 ?'L &BC@A KBLQIB@ ! L<T<LE<G$ HB?@A 7R<CGR<C@ =L'ABMB@<G @A<
GBEQ>'EIL< Q'CGB@B'C BR='E<G$ HIL@A<L9 H<G$%I>< KLBR$;L'Q$ "]9 PAB><
?LFR<G <ZQ>IEBT<>N BC @<LRE '? =L<@LBF> GBEQ'T<LN9 =L<Q>IG<G
=L'E<QI@'LBF> GBEQ'T<LN F@ @LBF> FE P<>>$
#11-&
V& BC @A<E< QBLQIRE@FCQ<E9 @A< ?<G<LF> Q'IL@ RFN Q'R=<> @A< G<?<CE< @'
L<T<F> @A< L<><TFC@ ='L@B'CE '? @A< BCT<E@BWF@'LOE L<='L@ ?'L @A< =L'E<QI@B'COE
IE< BC QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'CzlU5
D&%(@
6A< eIGWR<C@ '? @A< K'IL@ '? 7==<F>E ?'L @A< &BC@A KBLQIB@ BE @A<L<?'L<
E%3%$)%24
"/0#+
0H8 JBP8=?J=N ?N?98F
• 6A< GIF> FBR '? @A< QLBRBCF> eIE@BQ< ENE@<Rzk@AF@ WIB>@ EAF>> C'@
<EQF=< 'L BCC'Q<CQ< EI??<L9k
• VAB>< @A< FGT<LEFLN ENE@<R G<=<CGE =LBRFLB>N 'C @A< =FL@B<E ?'L @A<
=L<E<C@F@B'C FCG <Z=>'LF@B'C '? L<><TFC@ ?FQ@E9 @A< eIGBQBFLN BE C'@
>BRB@<G @' @A< L'>< '? F L<?<L<< 'L EI=<LTBE'L$ D@E Q'R=I>E'LN =L'Q<EE<E
E@FCG FTFB>FM>< @' L<\IBL< @A< =L<E<C@F@B'C '? <TBG<CQ< BC Q'IL@ 'L
M<?'L< F WLFCG eILN$
•
6A< <CGE '? QLBRBCF> eIE@BQ< P'I>G M< G<?<F@<G B? eIGWR<C@E P<L< @' M<?'ICG<G 'C F =FL@BF> 'L E=<QI>F@BT< =L<E<C@F@B'C '? @A< ?FQ@E$
• 6' <CEIL< @AF@ eIE@BQ< BE G'C<9 B@ BE BR=<LF@BT< @' @A< ?ICQ@B'C '? Q'IL@E
@AF@ Q'R=I>E'LN =L'Q<EE M< FTFB>FM>< ?'L @A< =L'GIQ@B'C '? <TBG<CQ<
C<<G<G <B@A<L MN @A< =L'E<QI@B'C 'L MN @A< G<?<CE<$
• 38B8=JL aKB:E:J=N HJ? :<H8=8<9 A;O8= 9; =8SK:=8 9H8 A=;?8EK9:;< 9;
A=;BKE8 9H8 A=8P:;K?LN =8E;=B8B ?9J98F8<9? ;I :9? O:9<8??8? ?; 9HJ9
9H8 B8I8<?8 FJN G89 9H8 IKLL M8<8I:9 ;I E=;??Y8UJF:<J9:;< J<B 9H8
9=K9H I:<B:<G A=;E8?? FJN M8 8<HJ<E8B5
• /9 :??K8 H8=8 :? OH89H8=Q :< J A=;A8= EJ?8Q 9H8 A=;?8EK9:;< EJ< EJLL
KA;< 9HJ9 ?JF8 A;O8= I;= A=;BKE9:;< ;I O:9<8?? ?9J98F8<9? 9HJ9
IJE:L:9J98 nIKLL B:?EL;?K=8 ;I JLL 9H8 p=8L8PJ<9q IJE9?5n
o 6A< G<?<CE< =L'='E<G @' QF>> B@E BCT<E@BWF@'L @' BR=<FQA @A<
BG<C@B?BQF@B'C @<E@BR'CN '? @A< =L'E<QI@B'CiE <N<PB@C<EE<E$ D@
PFE <TBG<C@ ?L'R QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'C @AF@ @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L
P'I>G @<E@B?N @AF@ <FQA PB@C<EEi L<Q'>><Q@B'C '? @A< F==<FLFCQ<
'? @A< BCGBTBGIF> BG<C@B?B<G FE L<E='CG<C@ PFE Q'CEBG<LFM>N
><EE Q><FL F@ FC <FL>B<L @BR< @AFC B@ PFE F@ @LBF>$
o D@ F>E' F==<FL<G @AF@ @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L FCG 'C< PB@C<EE GB??<L<G
<T<C FE @' PAF@ @A< PB@C<EE @'>G ABR GILBCW @A< BC@<LTB<P$ 6A<
BCT<E@BWF@'LiE Q'C@<R='LFC<'IE L<='L@ RBWA@ =L'TBG< QLB@BQF>BCEBWA@ BC@' @A< BEEI<E '? QL<GBMB>B@N
o D@ Q'I>G FEEBE@ @A< eILN BC G<@<LRBCBCW @A< <Z@<C@ @' PABQA @A<
BCT<E@BWF@'LiE @<E@BR'CN FQ@IF>>N GBEQL<GB@<G @A< =L'E<QI@B'CiE
PB@C<EE<E$ D?9 ?'L <ZFR=><9 @A< L<='L@ ?FB><G @' R<C@B'C @A<
=IL='L@<G E@F@<R<C@ '? 'C< PB@C<EE @AF@ kF>> M>FQXE >''X<G
F>BX<9k @A< eILN RBWA@ GBEL<WFLG @A< BCT<E@BWF@'LiE T<LEB'C
F>@'W<@A<L$ 4C @A< '@A<L AFCG9 B? @ABE E@F@<R<C@ F==<FL<G BC
@A< Q'C@<R='LFC<'IE>N L<Q'LG<G L<='L@9 B@ P'I>G @<CG
E@L'CW>N @' Q'LL'M'LF@< @A< BCT<E@BWF@'LiE T<LEB'C '? @A<
BC@<LTB<P9 FCG @' GBRBCBEA EIME@FC@BF>>N @A< L<>BFMB>B@N '? @AF@PB@C<EEi BG<C@B?BQF@B'C$
• 6" ,7% &"($,T) )/1*+I ,7/, *,T) "93*"()'1 *-."$,/+, ," )%$3% ,7% %+2) "#
H(),*&% ,7/, ,7% .$")%&(,*"+ *) /9'% ," %B/-*+% ,7% $%."$, )" ,7/, =%
I%, 9",7 %+2) "# ,7% ),"$14 V7% M(%),*"+ +"= *) =7%,7%$ ,7%$% *) )"-%
.$*3*'%I% /3/*'/9'% ," ,7% 2%#%+)% ," $%#()% 2*)&'")($%
3:I9H /F8<BF8<9 <;9 JPJ:LJML8
• 6A< HB?@A 7R<CGR<C@ =LBTB><W< FWFBCE@ Q'R=I>E'LN E<>?)BCQLBRBCF@B'C
BE FC kBC@BRF@< FCG =<LE'CF> 'C<9k PABQA =L'@<Q@E kF =LBTF@< BCC<L
EFCQ@IR '? BCGBTBGIF> ?<<>BCW FCG @A'IWA@ FCG =L'EQLBM<E E@F@<
BC@LIEB'C @' <Z@LFQ@ E<>?)Q'CG<RCF@B'C$k
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 43/44
| |
,0
• D@ BE F =<LE'CF> =LBTB><W<c B@ FGA<L<E MFEBQF>>N @' @A< =<LE'C9 C'@ @'
BC?'LRF@B'C @AF@ RFN BCQLBRBCF@< ABR$
• D8=8Q =8?A;<B8<9 B:B <;9 A=8AJ=8 9H8 =8A;=9Q J<B 9H8=8 :? <;
?KGG8?9:;< 9HJ9 9H8 A;=9:;<? ?KMa8E9 9; 9H8 B:?EL;?K=8 ;=B8= =8IL8E98B
J<N :<I;=FJ9:;< 9HJ9 H8 E;<P8N8B 9; 9H8 :<P8?9:GJ9;=5 0H8 IJE9 9HJ9
9H8?8 ?9J98F8<9? ;I 9H:=B AJ=9:8? O8=8 8L:E:98B MN J B8I8<?8
:<P8?9:GJ9;= ;< =8?A;<B8<9b? M8HJLI B;8? <;9 E;<P8=9 9H8F :<9;
=8?A;<B8<9b? A8=?;<JL E;FFK<:EJ9:;<?5
• HB?@A FR<CGR<C@ =LBTB><W< G'<E C'@ <Z@<CG @' @A< @<E@BR'CN 'L
E@F@<R<C@E '? @ABLG =FL@B<E QF>><G FE PB@C<EE<E FE @LBF>
38B5 "KL8 *=:F5 !=;E5 4^ <;9 JPJ:LJML8 6# B;KM9 H8RLL G89 :<9; 9H:? =8JLLN EJK?8
O8 HJP8 <; :B8J OHJ9 :9 :?7
• d;9H 9H8 LJ<GKJG8 J<B H:?9;=N ;I "KL8 4^ :<B:EJ98 9HJ9 :9 JBB=8??8?
;<LN A=89=:JL B:?E;P8=N$ %I>< "]^?_ L<\IBL<E @AF@ F R'@B'C ?'L GBEQ'T<LN
M< ?B><G kPB@ABC "/ GFNE F?@<L FLLFBWCR<C@ 'L $ $ $ EIQA L<FE'CFM>< >F@<L
@BR< FE @A< Q'IL@ RFN =<LRB@9k FCG ?IL@A<L Q'RRFCGE @AF@ B@ BCQ>IG<
F>> L<>B<? E'IWA@ MN @A< R'TFC@$
•
D@ BE G<EBWC<G @' <CQ'ILFW< =L'R=@C<EE BC ?B>BCW FCG @' <CFM>< @A<GBE@LBQ@ Q'IL@ @' FT'BG ICC<Q<EEFLN G<>FN 'L RI>@B=>BQF@B'C '? R'@B'CE
• 6A< #'T<LCR<C@iE LBWA@ '? GBEQ'T<LN FLBE<E 'C>N F?@<L @A< G<?<CGFC@
AFE EIQQ<EE?I>>N E'IWA@ GBEQ'T<LN ICG<L EIME<Q@B'CE ^F_^*_ 'L ^M_9 FCG BE
Q'C?BC<G @' RF@@<LE kPABQA @A< G<?<CGFC@ BC@<CGE @' =L'GIQ< F@ @A<
@LBF>$k H<G$%I>< KLBR$;L'Q$ "]^Q_$ 6ABE AFLG>N EIWW<E@E FCN BC@<C@B'C @AF@
@A< %I>< P'I>G >BRB@ @A< Q'IL@iE ='P<L @' 'LG<L =L'GIQ@B'C 'CQ< @LBF>
AFE M<WIC$
Vc;=` A=;BKE9 B;E9=:<8W <;9 JPJ:LJML8
•
S<L<OE PAF@ @A< G'Q@LBC<OE FM'I@co DC =<L?'LRBCW ABE TFLB'IE GI@B<E9 A'P<T<L9 B@ BE <EE<C@BF> @AF@ F
>FPN<L P'LX PB@A F Q<L@FBC G<WL<< '? =LBTFQN9 ?L<< ?L'R
ICC<Q<EEFLN BC@LIEB'C MN '=='EBCW =FL@B<E FCG @A<BL Q'ICE<>$
;L'=<L =L<=FLF@B'C '? F Q>B<C@iE QFE< G<RFCGE @AF@ A<
FEE<RM>< BC?'LRF@B'C9 EB?@ PAF@ A< Q'CEBG<LE @' M< @A<
L<><TFC@ ?L'R @A< BLL<><TFC@ ?FQ@E9 =L<=FL< ABE ><WF> @A<'LB<E9
FCG =>FC ABE E@LF@<WN PB@A'I@ ICGI< FCG C<<G><EE BC@<L?<L<CQ<$
o 6ABE P'LX BE L<?><Q@<G9 '? Q'ILE<9 BC BC@<LTB<PE9 E@F@<R<C@E9
R<R'LFCGF9 Q'LL<E='CG<CQ<9 MLB<?E9 R<C@F> BR=L<EEB'CE9
=<LE'CF> M<>B<?E9 FCG Q'IC@><EE '@A<L @FCWBM>< FCG BC@FCWBM><
PFNE
o V<L< EIQA RF@<LBF>E '=<C @' '=='EBCW Q'ICE<> 'C R<L<
G<RFCG9 RIQA '? PAF@ BE C'P =I@ G'PC BC PLB@BCW P'I>G
L<RFBC ICPLB@@<C$ 7C F@@'LC<NiE @A'IWA@E9 A<L<@'?'L< BCTB'>F@<9
P'I>G C'@ M< ABE 'PC$ DC<??BQB<CQN9 IC?FBLC<EE FCG EAFL=
=LFQ@BQ<E P'I>G BC<TB@FM>N G<T<>'= BC @A< WBTBCW '? ><WF> FGTBQ<
FCG BC @A< =L<=FLF@B'C '? QFE<E ?'L @LBF>$ 6A< <??<Q@ 'C @A< ><WF>
=L'?<EEB'C P'I>G M< G<R'LF>BaBCW$
o 6A< Q'IL@ @A<L<?'L< L<Q'WCBa<G F \IF>B?B<G =LBTB><W< ?'L Q<L@FBC
RF@<LBF>E =L<=FL<G MN FC F@@'LC<N gFQ@BCW ?'L ABE Q>B<C@ BC
FC@BQB=F@B'C '? >B@BWF@B'Ch
• 7@ B@E Q'L<9 @A< P'LX =L'GIQ@ G'Q@LBC< EA<>@<LE @A< R<C@F> =L'Q<EE<E '?
@A< F@@'LC<N9 =L'TBGBCW F =LBTB><W<G FL<F PB@ABC PABQA A< QFC FCF>Na<
FCG =L<=FL< ABE Q>B<C@iE QFE<
• YI@ @A< G'Q@LBC< BE FC BC@<CE<>N =LFQ@BQF> 'C<9 WL'ICG<G BC @A< L<F>B@B<E
'? >B@BWF@B'C BC 'IL FGT<LEFLN ENE@<R$ 4C< '? @A'E< L<F>B@B<E BE @AF@
F@@'LC<NE '?@<C RIE@ L<>N 'C @A< FEEBE@FCQ< '? BCT<E@BWF@'LE FCG '@A<L
FW<C@E BC @A< Q'R=B>F@B'C '? RF@<LBF>E BC =L<=FLF@B'C ?'L @LBF>$ D@ BE
@A<L<?'L< C<Q<EEFLN @AF@ @A< G'Q@LBC< =L'@<Q@ RF@<LBF> =L<=FL<G MN
FW<C@E ?'L @A< F@@'LC<N FE P<>> FE @A'E< =L<=FL<G MN @A< F@@'LC<NABRE<>?$
• 0H8 A=:P:L8G8 B8=:P8B I=;F 9H8 O;=` A=;BKE9 B;E9=:<8 :? <;9 JM?;LK985
%:`8 ;9H8= SKJL:I:8B A=:P:L8G8?Q :9 FJN M8 OJ:P8B5 D8=8Q =8?A;<B8<9
?;KGH9 9; JBBKE8 9H8 98?9:F;<N ;I 9H8 :<P8?9:GJ9;= J<B E;<9=J?9 H:?
=8E;LL8E9:;< ;I 9H8 E;<98?98B ?9J98F8<9? O:9H 9HJ9 ;I 9H8
A=;?8EK9:;<b? O:9<8??8?5 "8?A;<B8<9Q MN 8L8E9:<G 9; A=8?8<9 9H8
:<P8?9:GJ9;= J? J O:9<8??Q OJ:P8B 9H8 A=:P:L8G8 O:9H =8?A8E9 9;
FJ998=? E;P8=8B :< H:? 98?9:F;<N5
• "8?A;<B8<9 EJ< <; F;=8 JBPJ<E8 9H8 O;=` A=;BKE9 B;E9=:<8 9;
?K?9J:< J K<:LJ98=JL 98?9:F;<:JL K?8 ;I O;=` A=;BKE9 FJ98=:JL? 9HJ<H8 E;KLB 8L8E9 9; 98?9:IN :< H:? ;O< M8HJLI J<B 9H8=8JI98= J??8=9 H:?
3:I9H /F8<BF8<9 A=:P:L8G8 9; =8?:?9 E=;??Y8UJF:<J9:;< ;< FJ998=?
=8J?;<JMLN =8LJ98B 9; 9H;?8 M=;KGH9 ;K9 :< B:=8E9 8UJF:<J9:;<
0H8 *;K=9 B:B <;9 JK9H;=:T8 J G8<8=JL VI:?H:<G 8UA8B:9:;<W
• #9? E;<?:B8=8B =KL:<G OJ? SK:98 L:F:98B :< ?E;A8Q ;A8<:<G 9;
A=;?8EK9:;< ?E=K9:<N ;<LN 9H8 A;=9:;< ;I 9H8 =8A;=9 9HJ9 =8LJ98B 9; 9H8
98?9:F;<N 9H8 :<P8?9:GJ9;= O;KLB ;II8= 9; B:?E=8B:9 9H8 O:9<8??8?b
:B8<9:I:EJ9:;< 98?9:F;<N
• %<E='CG<C@iE FLWIR<C@ @AF@ @ABE LI>BCW G<=LBT<G ABR '? @A< 5BZ@A
7R<CGR<C@ LBWA@E @' Q'R=I>E'LN =L'Q<EE FCG QL'EE)<ZFRBCF@B'C
EVIDENCE 3-II | 3A-2015 | ATTY. L. ARROYO
8/10/2019 Compilation 3-3_Privileged Communications v. 1.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/compilation-3-3privileged-communications-v-1pdf 44/44
RBEQ'CQ<BT<E @A< BEEI<$ 6A< 8BE@LBQ@ K'IL@ GBG C'@ MFL @A< BCT<E@BWF@'LiE
@<E@BR'CN$ D@ R<L<>N =L<T<C@<G L<E='CG<C@ ?L'R =L<E<C@BCW @' @A< eILN
F =FL@BF> TB<P '? @A< QL<GBMB>B@N BEEI< MN FGGIQBCW @A< BCT<E@BWF@'LiE
@<E@BR'CN FCG @A<L<F?@<L L<?IEBCW @' GBEQ>'E< @A< Q'C@<R='LFC<'IE
L<='L@ @AF@ RBWA@ '??<L ?IL@A<L QLB@BQF> BCEBWA@E$
• 6A< 5BZ@A 7R<CGR<C@ G'<E C'@ Q'C?<L @A< LBWA@ @' =L<E<C@ @<E@BR'CN
?L<< ?L'R @A< ><WB@BRF@< G<RFCGE '? @A< FGT<LEFLBF> ENE@<Rd
*;<ELK?:;<@ @A< ?I>> @<E@BR'CN '? @A< BCT<E@BWF@'L9 LF@A<L @AFC F @LICQF@<G
='L@B'C ?FT'LFM>< @' L<E='CG<C@9 P< @ABCX B@ P'I>G M< FL@B?BQBF> BCG<<G @'
G<=LBT< @A< Q'IL@ '? @A< ='P<L @' <??<Q@IF@< @AF@ eIGWR<C@$ &'L G' P< ?BCG
Q'CE@B@I@B'CF> EBWCB?BQFCQ< BC @A< ?FQ@ @AF@ @A< Q'IL@ BC @ABE BCE@FCQ< PFE FM>< @'
<ZQ>IG< @A< @<E@BR'CN BC FGTFCQ<9 LF@A<L @AFC L<Q<BT< B@ BC <TBG<CQ< FCG
@A<L<F?@<L QAFLW< @A< eILN @' GBEL<WFLG B@ PA<C L<E='CG<C@iE Q'ICE<> L<?IE<G9
FE A< EFBG A< P'I>G9 @' =L'GIQ< @A< L<='L@$