conference on the democratic oversight of intelligence ... · page 4 of 17 deutschland (g ermany)...
TRANSCRIPT
Directorate-General for the PresidencyDirectorate for Relations with National ParliamentsLegislative Dialogue Unit
European Parliament's Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs
Belgian House of Representatives - Committee responsible for monitoringthe Standing Committee P and the Standing Committee I
German Bundestag – Parliamentary Oversight Panel
Italian Parliament – Committee for the Security of the Republic
INTERPARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE MEETING
Conference on the Democratic Oversight of IntelligenceServices in the European Union
List of ParticipantsNational Parliaments
Thursday, 28 May, 09.00 - 12.30 and 14.30 - 18.00Friday, 29 May, 09.00 - 12.00
József Antall Building (JAN), Room 2Q2
European Parliament, Brussels
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/relnatparl/en/meetings.html
Closed on 20 May 2015
Page 1 of 17
BELGIQUE/BELGIE (Belgium)
CHAMBRE DES REPRESENTANTS/ KAMER VANVOLKSVERTEGENWOORDIGERS
Members:Mr Siegfried BRACKE
Chair, Parliamentary Committee for the Oversight ofIntelligence and Security ServicesN-VA - ECR
Mr Peter BUYSROGGE
Parliamentary Committee for the Oversight of Intelligenceand Security ServicesN-VA - ECR
Mr André FRÉDÉRIC
Parliamentary Committee for the Oversight of Intelligenceand Security ServicesPS - S&D
Mr Stefaan VAN HECKE
Parliamentary Committee for the Oversight of Intelligenceand Security ServicesEcolo-Groen - Greens/EFA
Officials:Mr Liêm DANG-DUYSecretary, Parliamentary committee for the Oversight ofIntelligence and Security Services
Page 2 of 17
Ms Nadia MARIONSecretary, Parliamentary committee for the Oversight ofIntelligence and Security Services
Mr Carlos DEMEYEREPrincipal Adviser, EU Department
Official of national political group:
Mr Nicolas BASN-VA - ECR
Belgian Standing Intelligence Agencies Review Committee (Committee I)
Mr Guy RAPAILLEChair of the Belgian Standing Committee I
Mr Gérald VAN DE WALLECounsellor of the Belgian Standing Committee I
Mr Pieter-Alexander DE BROCKCounsellor of the Belgian Standing Committee I
Mr Wouter DE RIDDERSecretary of the Belgian Standing Committee I
Page 3 of 17
БЪЛГАРИЯ (Bulgaria)
НАРОДНО СЪБРАНИЕ (National Assembly)Members:
Mr Dimitar LAZAROV
Chair, Committee for Oversight of the Security Services, theDeployment of Special Surveillance Techniques and theAccess of Data under the Electronic Communications ActPP GERB - EPP
Mr Atanas ATANASSOV
Chair, Internal Security and Public Order CommitteeReformist Bloc - EPP
Mr Ayhan ETEM
Committee for Oversight of the Security Services, theDeployment of Special Surveillance Techniques and theAccess of Data under the Electronic Communications ActMovement for Rights and Freedoms (MRF) - ALDE
Mr Miho MIHOV
Committee for Oversight of the Security Services, theDeployment of Special Surveillance Techniques and theAccess of Data under the Electronic Communications Act -Defense CommitteeCoalition ABV (Coalition for Bulgarian Revival) - Nonattached (NI)
Official:Mr Hristo KRAEVSKINational Parliament Representative
Page 4 of 17
DEUTSCHLAND (Germany)
BUNDESTAGMembers:
Mr Patrick SENSBURG
Chair, Committee of Inquiry on the NSACDU-CSU - EPP
Mr André HAHN
Chair, Parliamentary Oversight PanelDie Linke - GUE/NGL
Mr Hans-Christian STRÖBELE
Parliamentary Oversight PanelBündnis 90/Die Grünen - Greens/EFA
G 10-Commission
Mr Bertold HUBER
Vice-Chair, G 10-Commission
Officials:Ms Birgit SINGERAssistant Ministerial Councellor, Secretariat PD 5 -Parliamentary Oversight Panel
Page 5 of 17
Mr Fabian LANGDeputy National Parliament Representative
Officials of a national political group:
Mr Harald BERWANGERLiaison Office of the German Bundestag in BrusselsSPD Group - S&D
Mr Juergen KRETZOfficial, CDU/CSU Group - EPP
Ms Maria WICHMANNEU-Policy Adviser, Bündnis 90/Die Grünen - Greens/EFA
EESTI (Estonia)
RIIGIKOGUMembers:
Mr Ken-Marti VAHER
Chair, Security Authorities Surveillance Select CommitteePro Patria and Res Publica Union - EPP
Mr Andre SEPP
Constitutional CommitteeReform Party - ALDE
Official:Ms Kristi SÕBERNational Parliament Representative
Page 6 of 17
ESPAÑA (Spain)
CONGRESO DE LOS DIPUTADOSMembers:
Mr Pedro GÓMEZ DE LA SERNA
Constitutional CommitteeG.P. Popular (GP) - EPP
Mr José Ignacio SÁNCHEZ
Constitutional CommitteeG.P. Socialista (GS) - S&D
Officials:Mr JOSÉ LUIS PEÑARANDALawyer of the Constitutional Committee
Ms Carmen SÁNCHEZ-ABARCANational Parliament Representative
SENADOMembers:
Mr Dimas Francisco CUEVAS CUERDA
First Vice-Chair, Constitutional CommitteeG.P. Popular (GP) - EPP
Mr Pedro Antonio RUIZ SANTOS
Constitutional CommitteeG.P. Socialista (PSOE) - S&D
Page 7 of 17
Official:Mr José María CODES CALATRAVALegal adviser to the Constitutional Committee
FRANCE
ASSEMBLEE NATIONALEMember:
Mr Jean-Jacques URVOAS
Président, Commission des loisMembre de la délégation parlementaire au renseignement(président de la délégation durant l'année 2014)Socialiste, Républicain et citoyen - S&D
Officials:Mr Floran VADILLOCollaborateur parlementaire de Mr URVOAS, Commissiondes lois
Mr Vincent VIVESNational Parliament Representative
ITALIA (Italy)
SENATO DELLA REPUBBLICAMembers:
Mr Giacomo STUCCHI
Chair, Committee for the Oversight of Intelligence andSecurity ServiceLega Nord (LN-Aut) - Non-attached (NI)
Page 8 of 17
Mr Giuseppe ESPOSITO
Vice-Chair, Committee for the Oversight of Intelligence andSecurity ServiceArea Popolare (NCD-UDC) - EPP
Officials:Mr Alessandro PERRONECommittee for the Oversight of Intelligence and SecurityService
Ms Beatrice GIANANINational Parliament Representative
ΚΥΠΡΟΣ (Cyprus)
ΒΟΥΛΗ ΤΩΝ ΑΝΤΙΠΡΟΣΩΠΩΝ (House of Representatives)
Member:Mr Demetris SYLLOURIS
Deputy Chairman, Committee on Institutions, Merit and theCommissioner for Administration (Ombudsman)European Party - No group affiliation in the EP
Official:Ms Mary SAVVANational Parliament Representative
Page 9 of 17
LATVIJA (Latvia)
SAEIMAMember:
Ms Solvita ĀBOLTIŅA
Chair, National Security CommitteeUnity Parliamentary Group - EPP
Official:Ms Laura OSLEJAAdviser, National Security Committee
NEDERLAND (The Netherlands)
TWEEDE KAMER (House of Representatives)Member:
Mr Harry VAN BOMMEL
Committee on EU Affairs and DefenceSocialistische Partij (SP) - GUE/NGL
Officials:
Ms Lisa VERMEEREU Adviser, Committee on EU Affairs, Interior, Securityand Justice
Ms Suzanne NOLLENRepresentative of the Dutch Parliament
Page 10 of 17
The Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security (CTIVD)
Ms Liesbeth HORSTINK-VON MEYENFELDTThe Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security
Mr Aad MEIBOOMThe Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security
Ms Marieke KOETSJARJAN-DE BIEActing Secretary to the Review Committee on theIntelligence and Security
ÖSTERREICH (Austria)
NATIONALRATMember:
Mr Peter PILZ
Standing Subcommittee of the Interior Affairs CommitteeDie Grünen - Greens/EFA
Officials:Mr Wolfgang NIKLFELDAdviser to Mr Peter Pilz
Ms Katharina KLEMENTStanding Subcommittee of the Interior Affairs Committee
Mr Christian HUETTERERNational Parliament Representative
BUNDESRATMember:
Mr Franz PERHAB
Chair, Interior Affairs CommitteeAustrian People's Party (ÖVP) - EPP
Page 11 of 17
POLSKA (Poland)
SEJMMember:
Mr Andrzej GAŁAŻEWSKI
Vice-Chair, European Union Affairs CommitteeCivic Platform - EPP
Officials:Ms Joanna KOWALSKASecretary of the European Union Affairs Committee
Ms Anna TRĘBACZKIEWICZNational Parliament Representative
SENATMember:
Mr Aleksander POCIEJ
Human Rights, the Rule of Law and Petitions CommitteePlatforma Obywatelska - EPP
PORTUGAL
ASSEMBLEIA DA REPÚBLICAMember:
Mr Fernando NEGRÃO
Chair, Committee on Constitutional Affairs, Rights,Freedoms and GuaranteePSD - EPP
Page 12 of 17
Council for the Oversight of the Intelligence System
Mr José António BRANCOMember of the Council for the Oversight of the IntelligenceSystem
Official:Ms Maria João COSTANational Parliament Representative
ROMÂNIA (Romania)
CAMERA DEPUTATILOR (Chamber of Deputies)Members:
Mr Georgian POP
Chair, Joint Standing Committee of the Chamber ofDeputies and the Senate for the exercise of parliamentarycontrol over the activity of the Romanian Intelligent ServiceSRISocial Democratic Party (PSD) - S&D
Mr Mihăiţă CALIMENTE
Chair, Joint Standing Committee of the Chamber ofDeputies and the Senate for the exercise of parliamentarycontrol over the activity of the Foreign Intelligent ServiceSIENational Liberal Party (PNL) - EPP
Official:Mr Tudor DOBRINESCUNational Parliament Representative
Page 13 of 17
SENATMembers:
Mr Marian PAVEL
Juridical Committee on Nomination, Discipline, Immunitiesand ValidationsSocial Democratic Party (PSD) - S&D
Ms Vasilica-Steliana MIRON
Juridical Committee on Nomination, Discipline, Immunitiesand ValidationsNational Liberal Party - EPP
Officials:Mr Costel GRUIAJuridical Committee on Nomination, Discipline, Immunitiesand Validations
Ms Izabella MOLDOVANNational Parliament Representative
SLOVENIJA (Slovenia)
DRŽAVNI ZBOR (National Assembly)Members:
Mr Branko GRIMS
Chair, Commission for the Supervision of Intelligence andSecurity ServicesSlovenian Democratic Party (SDS) - EPP
Page 14 of 17
Mr Žan MAHNIČ
Commission for the Supervision of Intelligence and SecurityServicesSlovenian Democratic Party (SDS) - EPP
Official:Ms Romana NOVAKNational Parliament Representative
SLOVENSKO (Slovakia)
NÁRODNÁ RADA (National Council)Member:
Ms Janka ŠÍPOŠOVÁ
Special Committee for Oversight of Intelligence ServiceOĽaNO - ECR
SVERIGE (Sweden)
RIKSDAGENMembers:
Mr Anders SCHRÖDER
Committee on JusticeThe Green Party - Greens/EFA
Page 15 of 17
Mr Jakop DALUNDE
Committee on DefenceThe Green Party - Greens/EFA
NORWAY
STORTINGETMember:
Mr Michael TETZSCHNER
Vice-Chair, Standing Committee on Scrutiny andConstitutional AffairsConservative Party - EPP
Official:Per NESTANDENational Parliament Representative
Parliamentary Intelligence Oversight Committee
Mr Theo KORITZINSKYMember of the Norwegian Parliamentary IntelligenceOversight Committee
Mr Njord WEGGESenior Adviser, EOS Committee
Page 16 of 17
Officials(of Parliaments or Chambers not having a political delegation at the present meeting)
HRVATSKA (Croatia) HRVATSKI SABORMs Tanja BABIĆ, National Parliament Representative
ČESKÁ REPUBLIKA (Czech Republic) SENÁTMs Terezie PÍSAŘOVÁ, National Parliament Representative
SUOMI (Finland) EDUSKUNTAMr Henri JAAKKOLA, National Parliament Representative Assistant
MAGYARORSZÁG (Hungary) ORSZÁGGYŰLÉS (National Assembly)Ms Éva SZEKRÉNYES, National Parliament Representative
ITALIA (Italy) CAMERA DEI DEPUTATIMs Maria SCHININA, National Parliament Representative
LIETUVA (Lithuania) SEIMASMs Živilė PAVILONYTĖ, National Parliament Representative
MALTA KAMRA TAD-DEPUTATI (House of Representatives)Mr Kenneth CURMI, National Parliament Representative