consumer wealth & target markets highlighting opportunities in marketing tri-state fpa quarterly...
TRANSCRIPT
Consumer Wealth & Target Markets
Highlighting Opportunities in MarketingTri-State FPA
Quarterly ConferenceNovember 13, 2007
207.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Why are so many financial advisors so darn reactive regarding marketing? Is it cultural? Is it the beauty of existing client bases? Should it change?
Is wealth management a marketing or a sales game?
What are the benefits of target marketing? [revenues & costs]
Isn’t target marketing difficult? How do you create a specialty (or a series of specialties)?
A Discussion of Target Marketing
307.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Opportunity: Baby Boomers & their Likely Liquefaction
The Challenges…
– Increasing Competition
– Consumers’ Need for Broader Advice
The Huge Target Marketing Opportunity
Tiburon Conclusions & Suggestions
Outline
407.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Consumer Investable Assets are Concentrated in a Small Share of the Population
Consumer Household Investable Assets
$7.0
36.8
$5.8
$3.0
$7.0
3.5
76.0
Households Investable Assets
<$100,000
$100,000 - $1 Million
$1 - $5 Million
$5 Million+(0.7 Million)
117 Million $22.8 Trillion
Source: 8/17/07 Wachovia Presentation (Kelly); 6/07 Fisher Investments Brochure (Federal Reserve Flow of Funds Report); 3/31/07 Federal Reserve Flow of Funds Report; 2/5/04 TD Waterhouse Presentation (Bradley) (Merrill Lynch; CEG); 1/22/04 McKinsey Quarterly; 12/03 Financial Planning; 3/03 Powell Johnson Newsletter; 5/22/02 Wachovia Presentation (Spectrem; McKinsey & Company); Tiburon Research & Analysis
507.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
More than Three-Quarters of Baby Boomers Over the Age of 55 Have Less Than $100,000 in Investable Assets…
Source: 2/3/05 New York Times; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Baby Boomers Over Age 55 by Investable Assets
<$100,00079%
>$100,00021%
607.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
$132.4
$184.7$174.9 $174.3
-$34.8
-$96.4-$82.3
Consumer Household Personal Savings($ Billions)
…Baby Boomers are Not Saving the Traditional Way…
Note: Household consumer personal savings refers to the difference between disposable personal income and personal consumption expendituresSource: 3/31/07 Federal Reserve Flow of Funds Report; Tiburon Research & Analysis
2001 2002 2003 2004
2005 2006 2007
707.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
… And Only 2% of Baby Boomers Will Receive an Inheritance of More than $100,000
Inheritance >$100,000
2%
Inheritance <$100,000
98%
Source: 2/04 Journal of Financial Planning; 8/12/01 US Bancorp Piper Jaffray Web Site (Gallup); 12/00 SunAmerica Brochure; 7/96 Commonwealth Club Newsletter; 2/19/96 US News & World Report; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Baby Boomers by Size of Inheritance
807.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Savings Crisis is Even Worse Because the Risk of Dying Too Young is Increasingly Being Replaced by the Risk of Living Too Long
Source: 11/03 Institutional Investor; 3/11/03 First Quadrant Presentation (Arnott); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Life Expectancy by Birth Year
6369 70 72 74 75 77 78 79 80
1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030
907.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
80.174.8
Women Men
And While the Average is 77-78, Lucky Women Have a Higher Life Expectancy Than Men
US Life Expectancy by Sex
Source: 12/9/05 San Francisco Chronicle (US Center For Disease Control); Tiburon Research & Analysis
1007.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Issue is Even Greater Because More than Half of 65 Year Olds Will Reach Age 85 and Over One-Third Will Reach 90
Source: 12/11/06 Investment News; 8/12/01 US Bancorp Piper Jaffray Web Site; 8/12/01 Allstate Brochure; 12/00 SunAmerica Brochure; 7/22/96 Business Week; Tiburon Research & Analysis
100+6%
90-9418%
85-8920%
95-9911%
65-8445%
65 Year Old Person Life Expectancy
1107.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Good News… Consumer Households Have Almost $23 Trillion of Investable Assets, $35 Trillion of Financial Assets, and $70 Trillion of Total Assets, Up Hugely Again this Year
Source: 6/07 Fisher Investments Brochure; 3/31/07 Federal Reserve Flow of Funds Report; 1/22/04 McKinsey Quarterly; 5/22/02 Wachovia Presentation (Doe) (Spectrem; McKinsey & Company); 5/9/02 Wachovia Presentation (Blythe); 5/9/02 Spectrem Presentation (Doe); 8/14/01 Wall Street Journal; 7/01 Registered Rep (Cerulli); 6/19/00 Investment News; 12/97 Federal Reserve Bank Survey; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Consumer Households Net Worth($ Trillions)
$69.6
$22.8
$56.3
$13.3
$12.2
$27.0$7.5
InvestableAssets
RetirementPlan Assets
PersonalAssets
Other IlliquidAssets
TotalHousehold
Assets
TotalHouseholdLiabilities
TotalHouseholdNet Worth
1207.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Hence, the Solution to the Perceived Savings Crisis is Baby Boomers’ Liquefaction, Including Retirement Plan Rollovers, and Small Business Sales
Source: 6/07 Fisher Investments Brochure (Federal Reserve Flow of Funds Report); 3/31/07 Federal Reserve Flow of Funds Report; 1/22/04 McKinsey Quarterly; 5/22/02 Wachovia Presentation (Spectrem; McKinsey & Company); 5/9/02 Wachovia Bank Wealth Management Presentation (Blythe); 5/9/02 Spectrem Presentation (Doe); 8/14/01 Wall Street Journal; 7/01 Registered Rep (Cerulli); 6/19/00 Investment News; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Consumer Households Net Worth($ Trillions)
$56.3
$22.8
$12.2
$27.0
$7.5
InvestableAssets
RetirementPlan Assets
PersonalAssets
Other IlliquidAssets
TotalHousehold
Assets
1307.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Opportunity: Baby Boomers & their Likely Liquefaction
The Challenges…
– Increasing Competition
– Consumers’ Need for Broader Advice
The Huge Target Marketing Opportunity
Tiburon Conclusions & Suggestions
Outline
1407.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Life and P&C Insurace Agents
(87,609)23%
Bank Brokers & Trust Officers
(82,729)22%
Independent Reps (82,306)
22%
Wirehouse, Regional, & Boutique
Brokers (92,648)23%
Partners at Fee-Only Financial Advisor
Firms (30,024)8%
Discount Broker & Mutual Fund
Company Reps (6,951)
2%
Financial Advisors By Market
Close to 400,000 Financial Advisors are in the US Market; the Independent Rep Channel is Quickly Catching the Captive Broker Channel in Numbers
Source: 7/25/05 Forbes; 6/05 Research; 2/21/05 Money Management; 2/04 Registered Representative; 11/24/03 Cerulli Edge; 2/9/00 Prima Capital Meeting (Watson); 1/00 Prima FA, CPA, & FO Interviews; 12/10/99 Prima Capital Conversation (McColl); Tiburon Research & Analysis
1507.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Wirehouse, Regional, & Boutique Brokers
$6.2 Trillion31%
Retail Banks & Bank Trust Departments
$5.4 Trillion27%
Discount Brokers & Mutual Fund
Companies Direct $3.1 Trillion
16%
Life and P&C Insurance
Companies $3.0 Trillion
15%
Fee-Only Financial Advisors $1.1 Trillion
6%
Independent Reps $1.0 Trillion
5%
Consumer Households Investable Assets by Market
The Brokerage Firms and Banks Still Have Most of the Assets…
Source: 3/02 Open Finance (Tower Group); 8/13/01 On Wall Street Web Site; 7/13/01 Cerulli Presentation (SIA); 11/6/00 Investment News (Cerulli Associates); 12/97 Securities Industry Yearbook; 12/97 S&P’s Securities Dealers of North America; 7/22/97 American Banker; 6/97 Financial Planning; 6/97 Dow Jones Investment Advisor; 5/12/97 Pensions & Investments; 4/12/97 American Banker; Tiburon Research & Analysis
1607.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
But the Independent Financial Advisor Channels Have Been Outgrowing the Other Channels
Client Assets Annual Growth Rate by Market(1995 - 2006)
Source: 7/19/04 Federal Reserve Bulletin; 12/97 Securities Industry Yearbook; 7/22/97 American Banker; 5/12/97 Pensions & Investments; 3/97 Federal Reserve Bulletin; 12/96 ACLI Life Insurance Factbook; 11/95 Best’s Review; Tiburon Research & Analysis
18%
14%
11%9%
3%2%
Fee-OnlyFinancial Advisors
Independent Reps Discount Brokers& Mutual Funds
Direct
Wirehouses,Regional, &
Boutique Brokers
Retail Banks &Bank Trust
Officers
Life and P&CInsurance
Companies
1707.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Opportunity: Baby Boomers & their Likely Liquefaction
The Challenges…
– Increasing Competition
– Consumers’ Need for Broader Advice
The Huge Target Marketing Opportunity
Tiburon Conclusions & Suggestions
Outline
1807.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#1: Mutual Fund are the Dominant Investment Product…
Source: 3/05 ICI Web Site; 7/19/04 Barron’s; 4/04 Research (MMI); 12/15/03 Investment News (Cerulli); 7/03 Ticker; 5/27/02 Merrill Lynch Presentation (Cerulli) (Doe); 10/01 Investment Consulting News; 7/13/01 Cerulli Presentation (Strategic Insight) (Cerulli); 7/11/01 RunMoney Conversation (Jorgensen); 7/2/01 RunMoney Quarterly Report; 7/01 Financial Advisor; 6/25/01 Investment News; 4/01 AIM Brochure (Cerulli); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Leading Investment ProductsAssets Under Management
($ Billions)
$460 $720
$1,743 $1,800 $1,900
$3,000
$10,800
ExchangeTradedFunds
SeparatelyManagedAccounts
VentureCapital &PrivateEquity
Annuities HedgeFunds
LifeInsurance
(Cash Value)
MutualFunds
1907.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Commissionable Mutual Funds
39%
Commissionable Variable & Fixed
Annuities22%
No-Load Mutual Funds & Other
Products in Fee-Accounts
16%
Individual Securities11%
Fixed & Variable Life Insurance
7%
Other5%
The Fast Growing Independent Rep Market Has Long Relied Heavily on Mutual Funds…
Source: 5/03 Independent Rep Best Practices Survey; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Investment Products UtilizationAcross All Independent Reps
2007.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
As Has the Even Fastest Growing Fee-Only Financial Advisors (RIAs) Market…
Investment Products UtilizationAcross All Fee-Only Financial Advisors
No-Load Mutual Funds in Fee-
Accounts61%
Individual Securities in Fee-
Accounts19%
Other Investment Products in Fee-
Accounts5%
Commissionable Investment Products
15%
Source: 5/03 Fee-Only Financial Advisor Best Practices Survey; Tiburon Research & Analysis
2107.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#2: Packaged Fee-Accounts Assets Have Grown Substantially Over the Past Eight Years to Over $1.5 Trillion
Source: 8/23/05 Fund Fire; 8/12/05 Mutual Fund Daily; 5/25/04 Money Management Executive (FRC); 4/04 Research (MMI); 2/10/04 MMI Press Release; 12/15/03 Investment News (Cerulli); 12/15/03 FRA Conference Brochure; 3/27/03 Wealth Management Letter; 3/10/03 American Banker; 9/30/02 IIR Conference Brochure (Cerulli); 9/23/02 Investment News; 8/7/02 Wealth Management Letter; 6/02 Ticker; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Packaged Fee-Account Assets($ Billions)
$82 $115 $117 $120$180
$235$356
$452
$662$769 $800
$927
$1,081
$1,208
$1,500
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
2207.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Movement Though is to Unified Managed Accounts and Broker Wrap Accounts
Source: 5/27/02 Merrill Lynch Presentation (Doe) (Cerulli); 12/13/00 HD Vest Meeting (Vest); 11/00 HD Vest Presentation (Pinion); 9/18/00 Northwestern Mutual Presentation (Mendelson); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Eight Core Types of Packaged Fee-Accounts
Eight Core Typesof Packaged
Fee-Accounts
BrokerWrap
Accounts
ETF WrapAccounts
Fee-BasedBrokerageAccounts
Multiple Style
Portfolios
UnifiedManagedAccounts
MutualFundWrap
Accounts
AnnuityWrap
Accounts
SeparatelyManaged Accounts
2307.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#3: More Broadly… The Investments Process is Being Polarized with Twin Growth Patterns in Both Market-Linked Products and Alternative Investments
Source: Tiburon Research & Analysis
Polarization of Investments Process
Polarization
Market-Linked Products
Alternative Investments
Indexed Separate Accounts
Exchange Traded Funds
Index MutualFunds
Hedge Funds
Other Alternative
InvestmentsReal Estate
Venture Capital & Private Equity
2407.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Exchange Traded Fund Assets Have Experienced Uninterrupted Growth Since 1993, Reaching $460 Billion in 2007
Source: 1/8/07 Investment News (SSGA); 1/23/06 Ignites Email (ICI); 1/18/06 Dow Jones Email (Ryan); 12/19/05 Rydex Investments Brochure (ICI); 11/30/05 ICI Web Site;11/9/05 Morgan Stanley Analyst Report; 10/24/05 Investment News; 10/05 Research; 9/12/05 New Millennium Advisors Presentation (Carty) (ICI); 8/29/05 Investment News (ICI); 8/05 Morgan Stanley Analyst Report (Bloomberg); 7/12/05 IIR Conference Brochure; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Exchange Traded Fund Assets($ Billions)
$1 $7$20
$36
$70$83
$102
$151
$226
$290
$407
$460
1993 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
2507.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Hedge Funds Assets Have Also Grown Significantly to Almost $2 Trillion
Hedge Fund Assets($ Billions)
Source: 3/21/07 American Banker Online (Hedge Fund Net) ; 3/19/07 Investment News; 3/6/06 Business Week (Hedge Fund Research); 12/5/05 Money Management Executive (Hedge Fund Research); 10/15/05 Financial Times; 6/8/05 Wall Street Journal; 1/5/05 Wall Street Journal (Hennessee); 9/2/04 Financial Times; 5/24/04 Forbes (Hedge Fund Research); 3/29/04 Barron’s (Tass); 3/04 Tremont Presentation (Schulman); Tiburon Research & Analysis
$55
$435$500
$600
$750
$980
$1,530
$1,900
$200
1990 1995 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
2607.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#4: But Health Care & Retirement Income are Becoming the Keys for the Vast Majority of Consumers
Source: 4/5/07 Raymond James Email (Stolz); 5/5/04 NFP Presentation (Montgomery); 2/10/04 SEI Email (Smith); 1/7/04 SEI Conversation (Smith); 9/23/03 SEI Presentation (Smith); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Baby Boomer Financial Phases of Life
Estate Planning & Charitable
Giving Distribution
Years
Early Accumulation & Protection Years
Peak Accumulation &
Protection Years
Estate Planning & Charitable
Giving Planning Years
• 30s-40s
• Marriage & children
• Early earnings years
• Term life insurance
• Disability income insurance
• 50s-60s
• Aging parents & wealth transfer (received)
• Retirement & liquefaction (e.g., IRA rollovers, business sales, stock options, & sales of homes)
• Retirement income challenge (e.g., index annuities)
• 80s-90s
• Death of spouse• Estate planning
& charitable giving (execution)
Approximate Ages
Key Life Events
Liquefaction, Health Care, &
Retirement Income
Challenge Years
• 50s
• Peak earnings & savings (e.g., variable annuities)
• Long-term care insurance
• Vacation homes• Divorces• Children's
college• Children’s
marriages & grandchildren
• 60s-70s
• Estate planning & charitable giving (planning)
2707.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Will Not Need Nursing Home
Care52%
Will Need Nursing Home
Care48%
Individuals Over Age 65 by Need for Nursing Home Care
Nearly Half of Individuals Over Age 65 Will Spend Time in a Nursing Home
Source: 10/11/99 Wall Street Journal (Gallup); Tiburon Research & Analysis
2807.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Nearly Half of Consumers Fear that they Will Outlive their Savings, Creating a Large Potential for Retirement Income Products
Fear They Will Outlive Their
Savings48%
Feel Their Savings Will Be
Sufficient52%
Consumers by Propensity to be Concerned About Retirement Savings
Source: 2/9/04 American Banker (American Bankers Insurance Association); Tiburon Research & Analysis
2907.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#5: For the More Affluent, Estate Planning & Charitable Giving are Two of the Key Wealth Management Services
Source: 4/5/07 Raymond James Email (Stolz); 5/5/04 NFP Presentation (Montgomery); 2/10/04 SEI Email (Smith); 1/7/04 SEI Conversation (Smith); 9/23/03 SEI Presentation (Smith); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Baby Boomer Financial Phases of Life
Estate Planning & Charitable
Giving Distribution
Years
Early Accumulation & Protection Years
Peak Accumulation &
Protection Years
Estate Planning & Charitable
Giving Planning Years
• 30s-40s
• Marriage & children
• Early earnings years
• Term life insurance
• Disability income insurance
• 50s-60s
• Aging parents & wealth transfer (received)
• Retirement & liquefaction (e.g., IRA rollovers, business sales, stock options, & sales of homes)
• Retirement income challenge (e.g., index annuities)
• 80s-90s
• Death of spouse• Estate planning
& charitable giving (execution)
Approximate Ages
Key Life Events
Liquefaction & Health Care &
Retirement Income
Challenge Years
• 50s
• Peak earnings & savings (e.g., variable annuities)
• Long-term care insurance
• Vacation homes• Divorces• Children's
college• Children’s
marriages & grandchildren
• 60s-70s
• Estate planning & charitable giving (planning)
3007.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
In the Affluent Market, Life Insurance May Play an Increasingly Important Role; Almost Half of Consumer Households Say that They Need More Life Insurance
Consumer Households By Perceived Need for Life Insurance Coverage
Source: 8/15/05 Investment News (Hayden Financial); Tiburon Research & Analysis
3107.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
And While It Seems to Be Basic Financial Planning, Over Half of All Consumers Have Not Created a Will…
Source: 1/2/05 New York Times (FindLaw.Com); 1/05 Research (Lawyer.Com); 12/20/04 Wall Street Journal (Martindale-Hubbell); 11/5/03 Wall Street Journal; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Consumers by Will Creation
Have Not Created a
Will58%
Have Created a
Will42%
3207.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
And Similarly, Three-Quarters of US Households Also Want to Learn More About Charitable Giving Strategies
Source: 11/01 Financial Advisor (Prince & Associates); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Charitable Contributorsby Interest in Charitable Giving Strategies
3307.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Opportunity: Baby Boomers & their Likely Liquefaction
The Challenges…
– Increasing Competition
– Consumers’ Need for Broader Advice
The Huge Target Marketing Opportunity
Tiburon Conclusions & Suggestions
Outline
3407.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
There is an Opportunity for Financial Advisors to Market! The Potential is Huge! Most Financial Advisors Invest Limited Time in Marketing…
Note: One source indicated that financial advisors of all sizes list marketing as the largest single problem facing their businessesSource: 1/03 Journal of Financial Planning; 12/7/02 Bank of America Conversation (Klein); 11/8/02 EnvestnetPMC Conversation (Yanari); 10/02 Financial
Advisor; 9/98 Fidelity Investments Financial Advisor Research; 9/98 Cerulli Associates Research; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Financial Advisors’ Weekly Investment of Hours in Marketing
Zero Hours/Week
48%
1-5 Hours/Week37%
>5 Hours/Week15%
3507.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
$30
$40
$50
2005 2006 2007
Fisher Investment Private Client Group Direct Mail & Web Advertising Expenditures
($ Millions)
Need Perspective?... Fisher Investments’ Private Client Group Spends $50 Million Per Year on Direct Mail and Web Advertising
Source: 7/26/07 Fisher Investments Meeting (Ornani); Tiburon Research & Analysis
3607.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Fisher Investments Private Client GroupAssets Under Management
By Propensity to Stay at Fisher Investments
#1: Client Retention is Key; For Instance, Fisher Investments’ Private Client Group Retains Nearly 100% of its Client Assets Each Year, Up in 2007
Source: 7/26/07 Fisher Investments Meeting (Ornani); 7/18/07 Fisher Investments Email (Ornani); 7/15/07 Bob Veres Newsletter; Tiburon Research & Analysis
95.0% 96.5%
3.5%5.0%
2006 2007
Retained
Lost
3707.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#2: As Clients Liquefy, Financial Advisors Need to Beat the Competition to Consolidate Client Accounts…
Source: 10/05 Research; 2/5/04 TD Waterhouse Presentation (Bradley) (Merrill Lynch; CEG); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Financial Advisor Relationships by Investable Assets
2.9
4.5
5.7
$1 Million - $5 Million $5 Million - $10 Million More Than $10 Million
3807.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
New Assets from Existing Clients
20%
New Clients80%
Fisher Investments Private Client GroupNew Assets by Source
For Instance, Fisher Investments’ Private Client Group Sources Almost One-Quarter of its New Assets from Existing Clients
Source: 7/26/07 Fisher Investments Meeting (Ornani); Tiburon Research & Analysis
3907.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#3: Client Referrals Present a Huge Opportunity! Almost All Financial Advisors Could Get More Proactive on Client Referrals…
Passive Client
Referrals43%
Proactive Client
Referrals15%
CPA, Attorney, &
Broker Referrals
22%
Seminars & Other
Proactive Marketing Methods
20%
Source: 1/9/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Filicky-Peneski); 1/8/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Busey); 1/8/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Michels); 1/8/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Garrett); 1/8/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Ater); 1/7/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (DeFrance); 1/7/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Cruse); 1/7/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Zeidler); 1/7/04 RW Baird Advisor Conversation (Carter); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Marketing Methods Generating New Client AssetsAcross All Full-Service Brokers
4007.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Passive Client Referrals
36%
Proactive Client Referrals
20%
Seminars8%
Other Proactive Marketing Methods
26%
Networking10%
… As Do Independent Reps…
Source: 5/03 Independent Rep Best Practices Survey; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Marketing Methods Generating New Client AssetsAcross All Independent Reps
4107.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
… And Fee-Only Financial Advisors (RIAs)
Marketing Methods Generating New Client AssetsAcross All Fee-Only Financial Advisors
Passive Client
Referrals43%
Proactive Client
Referrals11%
CPA, Attorney, &
Broker Referrals
14%
Seminars5%
Other Proactive Marketing Methods
27%
Source: 5/03 Fee-Only Financial Advisor Best Practices Survey; Tiburon Research & Analysis
4207.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
#4: There are Three Distinct Benefits of Segment Marketing, All of Which are Frequently Overlooked
Source: 3/03 Financial Planning; 2/03 On Wall Street; 2/03 Financial Planning; 1/03 On Wall Street; 10/02 Financial Advisor; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Segment Marketing Benefits
Decreased Competition & Better Close Rate
• Competition decreases as advisors establish themselves as experts in a particular niche
• Segment marketers win every time
Lower Cost to Serve Clients
• Isn’t serving the incremental client who looks alike easier?
Increased Flow of Referrals
• Target marketing will lead to improved prospecting results due to an increase in real and perceived value
• One’s reputation spreads much faster in niche markets than in broad markets
• Having a niche will positively affect public relations
• Able to better use time and money
4307.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
First Generation Money
80%
Inherited Money20%
Almost All High Net Worth Households are First Generation Wealthy, With Money Created Through Businesses or Corporate Stock
Sources of Wealth Amongst High Net Worth Households
Note: On this chart, high net worth households describe those with $1 million + net worthSource: 12/8/03 Money Management Executive; 9/23/03 SEI Presentation (Smith); Tiburon Research & Analysis
4407.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Private Business Owners, Corporate Executives, and Professional Occupations are the Key Sources of Wealth
Source: 8/14/01 American Banker; 8/01 Money; 3/9/00 US Trust Web Site; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Affluent Households by Occupational Segment
Professional Occupations
25%
Corporate Employment
28%
Other Segments8%
Private Businesses
39%
4507.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
12%26%
88%74%
US Population $1 Million Investable AssetHouseholds
Private Business
Owners
Other Sources of Employment
Source: 1/07 Money (CNN Money); Tiburon Research & Analysis
US Population & Affluent HouseholdsBy Employment Status
Private Business Owners are an Attractive Segment, Accounting for Over One Quarter of Affluent Households
4607.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Professional Occupations… There are Several Speaking Opportunities within a Health Care Niche
Source: 11/93 Physicians Medical Seminars; Tiburon Research & Analysis
Health Care Speaking Opportunities
Contact Continuing
Medical Education
Office
Speaking Opportunities
Professional Societies Hospitals
Other Professional Societies
American Medical Association
General Staff Meetings
Department Meetings
Contact local or state society
Contact hospital librarian
Contact local Society
4707.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Source: 1/22/04 Hanson McClain Conversation (Neeley); 1/21/04 Hanson McClain Email (Neeley); 1/8/04 Hanson McClain Web Site; 1/7/04 Hanson McClain Conversation (Neeley); Tiburon Research & Analysis
Sacramento-Based Hanson McClain Serves Telephone Company Retirees (Not a High Net Worth Market!)…
• About half of the firm’s 2,000 clients are Pacific Bell retirees– Believes they have captured about 70% market
share• Capitalized on announced telephone company
layoffs– Contacted human resources director– Hired high school kids to put fliers on
windshields– Mailed letters to employees– Faxed fliers to company departments– Placed advertisements in company newsletters– Sponsored lunches, brought coffee &
doughnuts, attended retirement parties, etc.
Comments
4807.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Source: 11/17/03 Cleary Gull Web Site; Tiburon Research & Analysis
…Milwaukee-Based Cleary Gull Has a Customized Program for Pilots…
• Introduction uses pilot terminology such as engineer, safety, stay on course, etc.
• Custom seminars for pilots of leading airlines• Services listed for pilots including AA Super Saver
401k Asset Allocation and UAL DAP Asset Allocation• Specialized questionnaires for pilots from American,
United, Delta, and others• Several ex-pilots on staff for pilot relationships
Comments
4907.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Source: 2/6/02 Ron Blue Email (Guffin); Tiburon Research & Analysis
…And Atlanta-Based Ron Blue & Company Approaches Christian Clients From a Unique Perspective
Ron Blue Client Approach
• God owns it all ~ we are Stewards• Quote biblical principals for each
aspect of the financial planning process
• Ask “how much is enough?”• Emphasize eternal perspective• Emphasize charitable giving • “Wealth” transference including
financial, social and spiritual capital
Christian Clients
• Goal setting• Net worth calculations• Income tax projections• Estate & will review• Cash flow projections– Spend less than you earn– Avoid the use of debt
• Investment overview• Education analysis• Charitable giving strategies• Retirement analysis• Insurance analysis
All Clients
5007.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Magazines (so many ways…)
Conferences (again, so many ways…)
Reaching Those Target Markets – Two Words
Reaching those Target Markets
5107.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
In Other Words, Once a Niche is Established, Marketing Flows Easily…
Hanson McClain Financial Advisor sWeekly Investment of Hours in Marketing
Zero Hours/Week
0%1-5 Hours/Week
20%
>5 Hours/Week80%
Source: 1/16/04 Securities America Advisor Conversation (Anderson); 1/16/04 Securities America Advisor Conversation (Anderson); 1/13/04 Securities America Advisor Conversation (Simmons); 1/12/04 Securities America Advisor Conversation (Nentwich); 1/13/04 Securities America Advisor Conversation (Crandell); Tiburon Research & Analysis
5207.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
The Opportunity: Baby Boomers & their Likely Liquefaction
The Challenges…
– Increasing Competition
– Consumers’ Need for Broader Advice
The Huge Target Marketing Opportunity
Tiburon Conclusions & Suggestions
Outline
5307.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Tiburon Summary Conclusions…
Source: Tiburon Research & Analysis
Tiburon Summary Conclusions
The Opportunity The Challenges
Increased Competition• 400,000 financial
advisors• Increasingly similar
offers
Broadening Needs• Mutual funds• Fee-accounts• Polarization• Health care• Retirement income• Estate planning• Charitable giving
Marketing
• Client retention is #1• Need to win the
consolidation war• Need to proactively
seek client referrals• The ultimate new
asset win… Target marketing- Increased number
of referrals- Increased close
rate- Decreased cost to
serve
Savings Crisis• No savings• No savings rate• Long live
expectancies
Liquefaction• Wow… • IRA rollovers are
already the #1 source of assets for all three core markets
5407.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Tapping Into Tiburon Research; Three Free Follow-Ups…
Source: Tiburon Research & Analysis
Free Tiburon Research
• Obtain Copy of Today’s Slides- Business Card with Email Address (preferred) or
send me an email – [email protected]
• Encourage Your Financial Advisors to Benchmark their Businesses & Receive Free Comprehensive Report- www.IndependentRepBestPractices.Com- www.FABestPractices.Com- www.BrokerBestPractices.Com- Thirteen total tools…
• Receive Free Weekly Research Releases- Business Card with Email Address or Sign Up
Online at www.TiburonAdvisors.Com
5507.11.13 – Tri-State (Philadelphia) FPA © Tiburon Strategic Advisors, LLC™
Source: Tiburon Research & Analysis
Tiburon Strategic Advisors
• Focus on corporate-level strategy- Serve senior executives only at financial
services companies- Key services: market seminars, market
research, & strategy consulting - Served almost 300 corporate clients and
completed almost 1,000 projects since 1998- Host semi-annual CEO Summits, offer free
weekly research releases, and offer free business benchmarking tools for all types of advisors
• Chip Roame background- McKinsey & Company; Charles Schwab &
Company; Tiburon since 1998- Email address: [email protected]
Comments