ARTHROSCOPYTHE JOURNAL OF ARTHROSCOPIC AND RELATED SURGERY

Official Journal of the Arthroscopy Association of North AmericaInternational Society of Arthroscopy, Knee Surgery, and Orthopaedic Sports Medicine

International Society for Hip Arthroscopy

Onsempaiin tartmeDeunithefroproaccand

This jo

Volume 29 � Number 2 February 2013

CONTENTS

EDITORIAL 1

the Cover: Posteromediimembranosus tendon.

n sought consultation athe posterior body of thehroscopy, a capsular renniscus. The tendinous pospite these findings, theque and interesting. Thecapsule is shown in this

m surgery and is pain fregram and has since retuompanying video at wwMark Getelman, M.D.

urnal is listed in MEDLINE, Cu

91 G

al capsulA 23-yeour instimedial mt was nortion ofmedial mintimateimage. Te. She prned symw.arthros

rrent Conte

ood Things Come in a Green Package

James H. Lubowitz, Matthew T. Provencher,and Gary G. Poehling

LETTERS TO THEEDITOR

1

93 M easurement of Bone Mineral Density in AnteriorCruciate LigamentLInjured Patients by ComputedTomography Scan

Xingzuo Chen, Hua Feng, Hui Zhang,and Guanyang Song

1

93 A uthors’ Reply Liaobin Chen, Kai Tie, Hua Wang, and Xin Wang

ar avulsion inferior to the medial meniscus exposingar-old woman who had fallen onto her left knee and had severetute. Her workup included an MRI that showed some irregularityeniscus and she underwent surgery. At the time of her knee

ted at the inferior aspect of the posterior body of her medialthe semimembranosus was visualized through the capsular rent.eniscus was found to be stable. We found this pathology to berelationship of the semimembranosus tendon andhe patient is now approximately 2 months outarticipated in a routine postoperative rehabilitationptom free to her normal activities. Seecopyjournal.org. Courtesy of Randy Clark, M.D.,

nts/Clinical Medicine, SCISEARCH, Research Alert, BIOSIS, and Excerpta Medica.

ORIGINAL ARTICLES 1

95 C omparison of Tunnel Orientation BetweenTranstibial and Anteromedial Portal Techniques forAnatomic Double-Bundle Anterior Cruciate LigamentReconstruction Using 3-Dimensional ComputedTomography

Yoshitsugu Takeda, Toshiyuki Iwame,Tomoya Takasago, Kenji Kondo, Tomohiro Goto,Koji Fujii, and Akira Naruse

2

05 T ensile Forces on Repaired Medial MeniscalRoot Tears

Christian St€arke, Sebastian Kopf, Roland Lippisch,Christoph H. Lohmann, and Roland Becker

2

13 I mmediate Postoperative Anterior Knee Stability:Double- Versus Triple-Bundle Anterior CruciateLigament Reconstructions

Tatsuo Mae, Konsei Shino, Norinao Matsumoto,Kenji Yoneda, Hideki Yoshikawa, and Ken Nakata

2

20 T en-Year Survivorship After Knee Arthroscopy inPatients With Kellgren-Lawrence Grade 3 and Grade 4Osteoarthritis of the Knee

J. Richard Steadman, Karen K. Briggs,Lauren M. Matheny, and Henry B. Ellis

2

26 S econd-Look Arthroscopic Findings AfterOpen-Wedge High Tibia Osteotomy Focusing onthe Posterior Root Tears of the Medial Meniscus

Kyung-Wook Nha, Yong Seuk Lee, Dae-Hee Hwang,Jae Ho Kwon, Dong Ju Chae, Young Jee Park,and Jong In Kim

2

32 D oes Obesity Negatively Affect the FunctionalResults of Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy?A Retrospective Cohort Study

Mehmet Erdil, Kerem Bilsel, Mustafa Sungur,Goksel Dikmen, Nejat Tuncer, Gokhan Polat,Nuh Mehmet Elmadag, Ibrahim Tuncay,and Mehmet Asik

2

38 F emoral Tunnel Length in Primary Anterior CruciateLigament Reconstruction Using an AccessoryMedial Portal

Marc Tompkins, Matthew D. Milewski,Eric W. Carson, Stephen F. Brockmeier,Joshua C. Hamann, Joseph M. Hart,and Mark D. Miller

2

44 S urvival Analysis of Microfracture in theOsteoarthritic KneedMinimum 10-Year Follow-up

Dae Kyung Bae, Sang Jun Song, Kyoung Ho Yoon,Dong Beom Heo, and Tae Jin Kim

2

51 E ffect of Different Irrigation Fluids on HumanArticular Cartilage: An In Vitro Study

Abhinav Gulihar, David J. Bryson,and Grahame J.S. Taylor

2

57 F emoral Tunnel Drilling Angles for the PosterolateralCorner in Multiligamentary Knee Reconstructions:Computed Tomography Evaluation in a CadavericModel

Pablo Eduardo Gelber, Juan Ignacio Erquicia,Gustavo Sosa, Gonzalo Ferrer, Ferran Abat,Alfonso Rodriguez-Baeza, Cristobal Segura-Cros,and Juan Carlos Monllau

2

66 C linical Outcome in All-Arthroscopic VersusMini-Open Rotator Cuff Repair in Small toMedium-Sized Tears: A Randomized ControlledTrial in 100 Patients With 1-Year Follow-up

Peer van der Zwaal, Bregje J.W. Thomassen,Marc J. Nieuwenhuijse, Ruud Lindenburg,Jan-Willem A. Swen, and Ewoud R.A. van Arkel

2

74 S ensitivity of Preoperative Magnetic ResonanceImaging and Magnetic Resonance Arthrographyin Detection of Panlabral Tears of theGlenohumeral Joint

Eric T. Ricchetti, Michael C. Ciccotti,Michael G. Ciccotti, Gerald R. Williams Jr.,and Mark D. Lazarus

2

80 C linical and Ultrasonographic Outcomes ofArthroscopic Suture Bridge Repair for MassiveRotator Cuff Tear

Jin-Young Park, Sang-Hoon Lhee, Kyung-Soo Oh,Sung Gyu Moon, and Jung-Taek Hwang

2

90 S houlder Stiffness After Rotator Cuff Repair:Risk Factors and Influence on Outcome

Seok Won Chung, Cao Ba Huong, Sae Hoon Kim,and Joo Han Oh

3

01 C omparison of Mesenchymal Stem Cells(Osteoprogenitors) Harvested From ProximalHumerus and Distal Femur DuringArthroscopic Surgery

Knut Beitzel, Mary Beth R. McCarthy, Mark P. Cote,Thomas J.S. Durant, David M. Chowaniec,

Olga Solovyova, Ryan P. Russell, Robert A. Arciero,and Augustus D. Mazzocca

3

09 C lassic Versus Congruent Coracoid PositioningDuring the Latarjet Procedure: An In VitroBiomechanical Comparison

Harm W. Boons, Joshua W. Giles, Ilia Elkinson,James A. Johnson, and George S. Athwal

3

17 T endon Graft Fixation Sites at the CoracoidProcess for Reconstruction of the CoracoclavicularLigaments: A Kinematic Evaluation of ThreeDifferent Surgical Techniques

Kaywan Izadpanah, Martin Jaeger, Dirk Maier,Peter Ogon, Matthias Honal, Marco Vicari,J€urgen Hennig, Norbert P. S€udkamp,and Matthias Weigel

3

25 S imple Versus Horizontal Suture Anchor Repairof Bankart Lesions: Which Better RestoresLabral Anatomy?

Lindsey S. Hagstrom and John M. Marzo

3

30 R eturn to Play After Hip Arthroscopy WithMicrofracture in Elite Athletes

John E. McDonald, Mackenzie M. Herzog,and Marc J. Philippon

3

36 E ffect of Radiofrequency Use on Hip ArthroscopyIrrigation Fluid Temperature

Frank McCormick, Kyle Alpaugh,Benedict U. Nwachukwu, Siyan Xu,and Scott D. Martin

META-ANALYSES 3

43 A rthroscopic Single-Row Versus Double-RowRotator Cuff Repair: A Meta-analysis of theRandomized Clinical Trials

Shahin Sheibani-Rad, M. Russell Giveans,Steven Paul Arnoczky, and Asheesh Bedi

3

49 A ccuracy of Magnetic Resonance Imaging inGrading Knee Chondral Defects

Ming Zhang, ZhiGang Min, Netra Rana,and HongJuan Liu

3

57 O utcomes of Anterior Cruciate LigamentReconstruction Using Single-Bundle VersusDouble-Bundle Technique: Meta-analysisof 19 Randomized Controlled Trials

Mai Xu, Shuguang Gao, Chao Zeng, Rui Han,Jinpeng Sun, Hui Li, Yilin Xiong,and Guanghua Lei

SYSTEMATICREVIEWS

3

66 A n Evidenced-Based Examination of theEpidemiology and Outcomes of TraumaticRotator Cuff TearsNathan A. Mall, Andrew S. Lee, Jaskarndip Chahal,Seth L. Sherman, Anthony A. Romeo,Nikhil N. Verma, and Brian J. Cole

3

77 T ransosseous-Equivalent Rotator Cuff Repair:A Systematic Review on the BiomechanicalImportance of Tying the Medial Row

Nathan A. Mall, Andrew S. Lee, Jaskarndip Chahal,Geoffrey S. Van Thiel, Anthony A. Romeo,Nikhil N. Verma, and Brian J. Cole

3

2013 Arth

The Journal Boardpleased to announcagain be awarded to2013 prize will be ju

who will consider

He

Ma

Jason Miller

Executive Publisher

87 C

roscop

of True thatthe r

dged bthose

nry P. Ha

naging E

W

urrent Concepts in the Treatment ofAcromioclavicular Joint Dislocations

Knut Beitzel, Mark P. Cote, John Apostolakos,Olga Solovyova, Christopher H. Judson,Connor G. Ziegler, Cory M. Edgar, Andreas B. Imhoff,Robert A. Arciero, and Augustus D. Mazzocca

3

98 A nnouncements

y Journal Prize for Level I Evidence

stees, the AANA Board, and the Editors arethe Arthroscopy Journal Prize of $5,000 willeport of the best Level I Evidence study. They the Journal’s Editors and Associate EditorsLevel I papers published during the year.

PUBLICATION STAFF

ckett Deborah VanNoy

ditor Editorial Associate

inston-Salem, North Carolina

Elsevier Kristina W. O’Neil

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Journal Manager