corporate healthcare ideas: thinking outside the box with employer sponsored clinics wahu john...

32
Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Upload: nigel-russell

Post on 18-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Corporate Healthcare Ideas:Thinking Outside the Box withEmployer Sponsored Clinics

WAHU

John NeubergerVice President Operations

September 19, 2008

Page 2: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

The Problem

Healthcare Cost and Quality

CRISIS

Page 3: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

PCPSpecialist

A Lack of Coordination & Integration

A Crisis in Healthcare

Page 4: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Our Healthcare System

• Costs $7,000/person, twice as much as other industrialized countries spend to cover every citizen

• 30% of dollars and up to half of doctors and nurses time spent on paperwork

• Only 1/3 of time is evidence-based medicine practiced

• Healthcare costs to businesses up 140% in the last 10 years, 5x wage growth

• But primary care real incomes are down

Page 5: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Overstressed PCP

No System Integration

No Universal EMR

No Financial Incentives

Lack of Care Coordination

A Crisis in Healthcare

Page 6: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

One Employer’s Solution to the Healthcare Crisis

Page 7: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Who is Quad/Graphics?

• Founded in 1971 • The world’s largest privately held printer of magazines and catalogs• 10 printing plants in 6 states• International partnerships with printers in Poland, Argentina and Brazil• More than 10,000 employees• $2.0 billion in annual sales

Page 8: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

A Sample of Quad/Graphics Clients

Advertising Age

Cargo

Entertainment Weekly

Elegant Bride

Golf Digest

Health

JC Penney

Life

National Geographic

Newsweek

People

Self

Time Inc.

U.S. News & World Report

Victoria’s Secret

Williams-Sonoma

Page 9: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Why Is Quad/Graphics In The Health Care Business?

• Control costs by providing a full range of healthcare services

• Focus on wellness and preventive medicine

• Enhance quality through best practice guidelines and Evidence-Based Medicine

• Offer benefits that attract, retain staff

• Maintain flexibility in benefit design

• Improve patient access with onsite facilities

Page 10: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Who Is QuadMed?

Page 11: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Quad Med – A Medical Subsidiary of Quad Graphics

• Opened first clinic in 1990

• Currently manages 8 clinics

– 5 Quad Graphics

– 2 Briggs & Stratton (2002 & 2004)

– 1 Miller Brewing Company (2005)

• In 2007 Quad Med Provided

– 120,500 Clinic Visits

– 122,100 Prescriptions

– 21,800 Dental Visits

– 17,600 Rehab Visits

– 230,000 Adjudicated Claims

Page 12: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Briggs & Stratton Health Center

Page 13: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Miller Health & Fitness Center

Page 14: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Comprehensive integrated on-site services: Requires balance

Risk Management

MedicalManagement Health Transformation/

Population Management

OSHAReporting

Acute careInjuries and

Illness

Workers Compensation

DisabilityManagement

Absence

Management

Case Management

Primary Care

ReferralManagement

Health Advocacy

Wellness/Prevention

Chronic Disease

Management

On-site pharmacy

Page 15: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

QuadMed Strategy

• Provide onsite primary care & selected specialty care

• Focus on prevention and wellness

• Restructure the delivery of primary care– Focus on patient centered care– Salaried providers, not “production” based reimbursement– Incentives based on quality – customer satisfaction, adherence to guidelines,

preventive services, collegiality, committee participation– Provide ample “face time” with patients– Provide resources supporting quality care

• Provide specialty care & hospital care through direct contracting “Narrow Networks”

• Remove waste and improve quality - LEAN

• Integrate workers’ compensation into primary care services

Page 16: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

The Power of Integration & Coordination

Health Plan Design

Workers

Compensation

Occupational

Health

On-Site

Primary

Care Clinic

Pharmacy

Prepackaged

meds

Prevention &

Wellness

Fitness Centers

Physical &

Occupational

Therapy

EAP & AODA

Counseling

TPA

Case Management

Disease Management

Electronic

Medical

Record

Direct Contracting

High Performance

Networks

Data Warehouse

Page 17: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

The Savings of Employer Managed Healthcare

Page 18: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

QuadMed Track Record

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

$ Thousands

Midwest Quad/Graphics

Average healthcare cost per employee

Page 19: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Actuarial Study

Quad/Graphics’ healthcare costs are consistently below the benchmark,

when adjusted for demographics and benefit design:

• 18% below in 1998• 19% below in 2000• 17% below in 2002 • 26% below in 2004• 32% below in 2006

Page 20: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Potential Savings for an On-Site Clinic and Pharmacy

Onsite care can provide the following

additional savings

Lab – 94% Savings

Rehab – 54% Savings

Pharmacy- 8% Savings

Direct Contracting – 11% Savings

Page 21: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Average Healthcare Cost Trend

2000-2007 per employee per year

4.9%

Page 22: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Briggs & Stratton Per Employee Cost Comparison

$-

$1,000

$2,000

$3,000

$4,000

$5,000

$6,000

$7,000

$8,000

$9,000

FY04 (7/03-6/04) $7,400 $7,096 $3,818

FY05 (7/04-6/05) $8,537 $7,823 $4,222

FY06 (7/05-6-06) $8,508 $6,936 $6,259

FY07 (7/06-7/07) $7,417 $5,726 $7,398

Milwaukee (Salaried) Poplar Bluff Murray

Page 23: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Steinhafels Experience at Quad

21

$343

127

$369

154

$318

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

Avgerage participation perMonth

Average Claim Cost perPartipant per Month

The Alliance Network(Madison)

PHCS Network

Quad Med Network

PHCS VS Quad shows 16% savings per month per participant

Based on 2007 Data

Page 24: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

The Health Plan

Page 25: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Preferred

Quad/Clinics400 Specialists

9 Hospitals

$6 Co-Pay

$30 Co-Pay

$25-200 Co-Pay

100% 84%

Network 98 Hospitals

6,650 Doctors

$300/500$2,300 max

80% 9%

Nonnetwork $400/800 70% 7%

Power Of Benefit Design

Weekly Premium of $11 per single, $22 per couple, $32 per Family

Providers Deductible/

Copay

Coverage Dollars Spent

Page 26: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Quality of Care Measures

Page 27: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Quality of Care – Reporting Tools

• Satisfaction Surveys– Patient – Staff– Provider

• Data Warehouse (Ingenix)– Key Indicator Report – Comparative Activity Report– Evidence-Based Medicine Report– Ad Hoc Reports

• EMR/PM (GE Centricity)– Focused EBM Reports – Individually Actionable

Page 28: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Key Indicator Report – National Experience

Metrics Current Norm Difference Status I npatient

Admissions per 1,000 45.2 45 0.30%

Average Length of Stay 3 3.8 -21.00%

Type of Admission:

Medical Admissions per 1,000 15.5 16.7 -7.30%

Medical Average Length of Stay 3.3 3.9 -15.10%

Surgical Admissions per 1,000 10 8.2 22.10%

Surgical Average Length of Stay 2.8 3.5 20.60%

Maternity Admissions per 1,000 16.6 16 3.50%

Maternity Average Length of Stay 2.4 3.1 -21.80%

Outpatient

Outpatient Surgeries per 100 Members 6.6 9 -26.90%

Physician Office Visits per 100 Members 236 305.3 -22.70%

X-Ray Services per 100 Members 57.4 76.7 -25.20%

Lab Services per 100 Members 276 353 -21.80%

Prescription Drug

Prescriptions per Member 5.1 6.2 -17.90%

Average Paid per Prescription $38 $54 -29.60%

Page 29: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Evidence-Based Medicine Compliance

Condition WI Compliance Rate National Compliance Rate Benchmark

Depression 84.4% 84.3% 88.7%

Diabetes Mellitus 74.1% 55.6% 56.0%

Epilepsy 82.4% 53.9% 69.4%

Hyperlipidemia 93.6% 71.3% 74.9%

Hypertension 89.2% 73.0% 75.8%

Obesity 75.5% 46.1% 46.1%

Ingenix Database

Page 30: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

Quality of Care Analysis - EMR

Immunizations

Up-to-date on all immunizations at age 2• QuadMed - 98%• NCQA - 68%

Up-to-date at age 13• QuadMed - 88%• NCQA - 50%

Page 31: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008

In Summary

• QuadMed has developed a program that has been successful in controlling cost and improving quality of care for QuadGraphics.

• The program focuses on:– Patient Centered Care– Empowered Primary Care– Wellness and Prevention– Practice of Evidence-Based Medicine– True Integration of Healthcare Across Disciplines

• The program can be successfully implemented at a myriad of industries and organizations with similar results.

Page 32: Corporate Healthcare Ideas: Thinking Outside the Box with Employer Sponsored Clinics WAHU John Neuberger Vice President Operations September 19, 2008