corporate information · 2014. 3. 13. · itc, pearson education (singapore) pte limited, shree...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Corporateinformation
Directors Mr. G.P. Goenka
Chairman and Wholetime Director
Mr. Shiromani Sharma
Dr. B.L. Bihani
Mr. P.N. Ghatalia
Mr. Shrivardhan Goenka
Registered office 27, Biplabi Trailokya
Maharaj Sarani,
(formerly Brabourne Road)
Kolkata – 700 001
Mill Saharanpur – 247 001
(Uttar Pradesh)
Directors Mr. N.J. Jhaveri
Mr. Supriya Gupta
Mr. M.P. Pinto
Nominee of IDBI
Mr. Madhukar Mishra
Managing Director
AuditorsLodha and Company
Chartered Accountants, Kolkata
Bankers Bank of Baroda
Punjab National Bank
Registrar and sharetransfer agentsKarvy Computershare Private
Limited
Karvy House, 46, Avenue 4,
Street no.1, Banjara Hills,
Hyderabad-500034
2
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
The year 2005-6 was toughfor Star Paper Mills. Toughfor employees. Tough forstockholders.But there is optimism toshare.We took a number ofinitiatives towards corporaterenewal that will strengthenour performance over thecoming years.
3
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Corporaterenewalthrough…
Strengthening ourindustry presence
Page 10
Streamlining our fiberprocurement
Page 14
Capitalising on ourmarketplace visibility
Page 16
Renewing our assets
Page 12
4
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Against all odds
5
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
There is no question that 2005-6
was an eventful year at Star Paper.
While we remained committed to
enhancing operational efficiencies
and improving our financial
performance, we clearly had our
share of challenges during the
financial year under review.
A runaway increase in raw material
prices on account of the rising
demand for wood, strengthening
crude prices, which in turn spiked
fuel oil prices and the shut of PM 2 –
our largest paper machine – for
retrofit, were the main contributors
to a downturn in our fortunes.
Star Paper succeeded in increasing
average product realisation by 7.5
per cent and was able to increase
gross turnover despite the handicaps
mentioned above.
However, these efforts were not
enough to offset the impact of
adverse factors and the net result
was a decline in the bottomline.
But for the stringent cost control
efforts, the situation could have
been a lot worse.
Although in the current year, I do
not foresee any respite from both
raw material and fuel oil prices, I will
take this opportunity to tell you why,
despite these challenges, I remain
optimistic about our future.
Our Rs. 85 cr modernisation and
expansion programme, to be
completed in 2006-7, will result in
improved performance down the
years. This programme envisages
investments that will not only
strengthen our efficiencies in
managing costs but also reinforce
our environmental commitment.
At Star Paper, we are optimistic that
the demand for the Company’s
products is expected to increase in
line with the country’s economic
growth, resulting in ample
opportunities for growth.
I seek your continued support in
facing the odds and scripting a
success story over the coming years.
Sincerely,
G.P. Goenka
Chairman and
Wholetime Director
Chairman’s statement
6
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Star Paper Mills is amongthe 15 largest virgin fiberpaper mills in India.
7
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
PositioningStar Paper Mills Limited is an
integrated pulp and paper mill
located in Saharanpur, Uttar
Pradesh.
The Company possesses an
installed manufacturing capacity
of 75,000 tonnes per annum of
paper and paperboard.
It is a part of the Duncan Goenka
Group of companies.
PortfolioStar Paper possesses a rich
product portfolio comprising
industrial and cultural paper.
The Company manufactures a
diverse range of industrial paper –
absorbent kraft, poster ARSR and
ribbed kraft, among others.
It produces a variety of cultural
paper – various grades of
maplitho paper, MG cover paper
and business communication
paper (azurelaid and copier
variety).
PatronsStar Paper enjoys a pan-Indian
distribution network comprising
50 dealers.
The Company enjoys steady
business from reputable
customers comprising Century
Laminating, Eveready, Greenply,
Thomson Press, Hindustan Lever,
ITC, Pearson Education
(Singapore) Pte Limited, Shree
Krishna Paper and Thomson Press,
among others.
Pride-enhancingcertifications
Star Paper is recognised for its
product consistency, reflected in
its ISO 9001:2000 certification.
The Company’s environment
management is reflected in its
ISO-14001 certification.
It received the Greentech Award
in Environmental Excellence in
November 2005 and Greentech
Award for safety in paper
industries in April 2005.
Its energy conservation initiatives
were recognized through a
Certificate of Merit given by the
Indian Paper Manufacturers
Association.
Performance, 2005-6 Star Paper’s gross turnover
increased 3.02 per cent to
Rs. 218.36 cr.
The Company reported a 4.54 per
cent decline in its production to
67,875 MT.
Interest outflow declined 11.90
per cent to Rs. 5.55 cr.
Post-tax profit declined 53.99 per
cent to Rs. 9.28 cr.
PresenceStar Paper is listed on the Bombay
and National stock exchanges.
The Company’s market
capitalisation was Rs. 86.43 cr as
on 31 March 2006.
8
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
“Our modernisation andexpansion plans areinitiatives towardscorporate renewal”
10-minutes with the Managing Director
Mr Madhukar Mishra, Managing Director, Star Paper Mills Limited, fields questions on the performance
of the Company in 2005-6 and shares his optimism for the future.
A number of investors andanalysts tracking Star PaperMills want to know the reasonsfor the decline in performancein 2005-6. There were a number of factors that
contributed to a decline in the
Company’s performance in 2005-6.
Foremost there was a steep
increase in wood prices due to a
sustained demand coming out of
the other regions and sectors.
Similarly there was a steep
increase in the global price of
crude oil, which led to a
corresponding increase in the cost
of fuel oil. Since Star is among
the few companies in the Indian
paper industry with a significant
dependence on fuel oil as
feedstock for power generation,
the Company was significantly
affected by this phenomenon.
Finally, the installation and hook-
up of the new equipment as a
part of the Company’s
modernisation programme
resulted in the plant being shut
for a certain period, resulting in
lower production.
9
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
However, it is a credit to the
Company’s commitment that it
faced these challenges through
numerous initiatives.
What initiatives? We altered our product mix. As the
key input prices jumped manifold,
resulting in an increase of 40 per
cent in raw material cost in 2005-6,
we re-engineered our portfolio with
speed; we graduated towards the
manufacture of value-added varieties
of industrial paper and cultural
paper, which enhanced our
realisations.
And as our power and fuel costs
rose 23 per cent during the year
under review, we commissioned a
multi-fuel boiler to provide flexibility.
What was the status of theCompany’s Rs. 85 crmodernisation and expansionprogramme that was supposedto go on stream during 2005-6? We expect the programme to be
completed in 2006-7, which will
reflect in our performance in the
coming years.
The rebuild of PM 2, our largest, was
completed in July 2005. It would be
relevant to note that this rebuild was
ordered in 1994, the principal
vendor had ceased to be in business
after supplying part of the items but
we completed the rebuild and
enhanced our installed capacity
independently without support from
the principal vendor. Going ahead,
this rebuild will not only increase our
production but also enrich it; since it
will provide us with the ability to
produce writing and printing grades
that enjoy attractive value-addition.
The oxygen de-lignification system
that will be commissioned in August
2006 will help modernise the
Company’s bleaching process. This
two-stage process is being supplied
by Metso, Finland, the world leader
in pulp and paper technology.
Following its commissioning, we will
be able to improve pulp quality and
strengthen our compliance with the
emerging environmental standards.
For our power generation unit, the
original vendor on which the order
for the turbine had been placed was
unable to manufacture on schedule
or as per the ordered specifications.
As a result, the Company was
compelled to identify another vendor
and after the delay, the turbine is
likely to be commissioned by the end
of 2006-7. We have already installed
a new multi-fuel boiler and
upgraded the recovery boiler to
match the new turbine.
What initiatives has theCompany taken to ensure low-cost raw material availability?Apart from accelerating the
distribution of normal seedlings as a
part of our social forestry
programme, we are investing to
increase our clonal capacities, which
will result in a higher wood
availability from the same plantation
area. It will comfort shareholders to
know that clones released by the
Company received a favourable
response from the farmer
community, which will result in the
accelerated use of the seedlings and
enhance wood availability.
In addition, the Company established
a number of direct purchase points.
This will translate into two
advantages: it will reduce the
intermediaries in the supply chain
and it will enable the Company to
strengthen its presence at the grass-
roots level.
Stockholders will be keen toknow the larger trendstranspiring in the Indian paperindustry and how Star is placedto capitalise on them.The demand for paper is
continuously increasing, more so in a
rapidly expanding economy with
rising literacy levels. Star, with its
ability in the manufacture multiple
products, is ideally placed to exploit
this growth.
Going forward, how does theCompany expect to enhanceshareholder wealth? Despite a challenging 2005-6, we
have maintained the dividend at
Rs.1.75 per equity share. In addition
we expect to complete the
modernisation programme without
any equity dilution. As the benefits
of modernisation kick-in, share
owners can look forward to a better
financial performance by the
Company.
10
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Strengtheningour industry presence
Corporate renewal – 1
11
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Overview Even as India is home to the second
largest population in the world, its
per capita paper consumption is one
of the lowest in the world at around
6 kgs. India’s growing economy and
initiatives in the area of education
and literacy are expected to drive the
demand for paper significantly.
Business Standard estimates that an
increase in consumption of paper by
one kg per capita will lead to an
increase in demand of one million
tonnes.
Star Paper’s presence Star enjoys a strong presence in the
industrial and cultural paper
segments (2:1 product mix),
segments that experience buoyant
demand. The Company has
capitalised on every upturn in the
demand in these segments through
the provision of a wide range (28 –
230 GSM in industrial and 58 – 130
GSM in the writing and printing
varieties) and adequate availability.
Industrial: The Company’s strong
presence in industrial paper is
desirable for the following reasons:
In an expanding economy, the
demand for industrial paper rides
growing consumerism, increasing
disposable incomes, modern retail
formats and robust exports.
The Company’s location in North
India is advantageous as it is the
sole manufacturer of industrial
grade virgin paper in this region.
Its locational advantage results in
quick delivery, prompt service,
dependability and repeat orders.
Nearly 60 per cent of the
Company’s output is sold within a
radius of 300 kms of its factory.
Result: Star is among the three
leading paper mills in India to
manufacture industrial paper.
Cultural: Star strengthened its
presence in the cultural paper
segment following the rebuild and
commissioning of its PM 2, resulting
in an increased output of writing
and printing paper. This volume-
value strategy will enhance
profitability as the demand for
cultural paper is expected to remain
robust on account of the following
factors:
Increasing allocation by the
Central Government towards
education and literacy. For
instance, the Union Government
has enhanced the allocation for
education by 31.5 per cent to Rs.
24,115 cr in 2006-7.
India is cost competitive in
publishing and there is a trend
towards outsourcing from India.
This will further enhance demand.
Result: Star is among the 16 leading
virgin paper mills in India
manufacturing cultural paper.
12
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Renewingour assets
Corporate renewal – 2
13
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
OverviewStar was engaged in a major Rs. 85
cr asset rejuvenation programme in
2005-6. Once complete – all the
phases of the programme are
expected to be implemented by the
end of 2006-7 – the Company will
produce better quality of pulp on
the one hand and gain the capability
to manufacture high value-added
paper varieties on the other. In
addition, an increase in co-
generation capacity will reduce
energy cost.
Highlights, 2005-6The rebuild of PM 2 – possessing
the highest capacity among all
machines at Star – was completed
in July 2005. This will result in not
only higher production but the
ability to produce cultural grades.
The shutting of PM 2 for rebuild
caused a reduction in the output
by 4.5 per cent to 67,875 MT
over the previous year.
The commissioning of a multi-fuel
boiler and retrofit of turbine in
October 2005 helped reduce the
cost of turbine generated power.
The pulping process
improvements enabled the
Company to reduce the
consumption cost of chemicals
and dyes by 8.5 per cent to Rs.
21.21 cr in 2005-6.
Results, 2005-6Decline in capital cost per tonof production (Rs)
Decline incoal consumption (MT)
Outlook, 2006-7The Company installed the DCS
system to automate its washing
line and digesters in March
2006.This initiative will benefit
the Company in a number of
ways: generate pulp of consistent
quality leading to enhanced paper
brightness, productivity
improvement and lower chemical
consumption.
The commissioning of the oxygen
de-lignification line (ODL) by
August 2006 will enable the
Company to reduce chlorine
consumption, enhancing quality,
and strengthening Environmental
compliance with future standards.
The commissioning of a second 5
MW steam turbine in December
2006 will enable the Company to
utilise the process steam
efficiently and reduce energy cost.
The installation of modern stock
screening system in the pulp mill
by March 2007 will improve
quality and reduce power
consumption.
14
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Streamliningour fiber procurement
Corporate renewal – 3
15
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Overview At Star, fiber costs jumped 40.11 per
cent to Rs. 46.73 cr in 2005-6, one
of the sharpest increases in recent
years. This increase in raw material
costs was the result of a number of
external developments:
Since paper mills located in other
parts of the country initiated
wood procurement from the
north, driving up costs.
A sharp jump in fuel prices led to
the increasing use of wood as
fuel.
Acute power shortages resulted in
State Governments offering
attractive purchase rates for the
supply of electricity by
independent power producers to
the grid, resulting in the increased
installation of steam turbines and
consequent reduced availability of
agri-residues.
With a view to mitigate the impact
of this scenario, Star has undertaken
a number of initiatives.
Highlights, 2005-6 The Company established new
purchase depots across Uttar
Pradesh to broadbase its raw
material procurement.
Bamboo was added to the farm
forestry programme.
As a part of the farm forestry
programme, the Company
increased distribution to 273 lacs
seedlings.
The Company stocked raw
material inventory to cover at
least 4.5 months of production,
as a result of which not a single
day of production was lost.
Results, 2005-6 Enhancing farm forestry (lac
seedlings)
Raw material costs as aproportion of turnover (gross)
Outlook, 2006-7The Company expects raw
material costs to stay firm in
2006-7.
The Company intends to enhance
the distribution of seedlings to
311 lac (eucalyptus, bamboo and
other varieties).
It also intends to establish a
nursery to nurture poplar plants.
16
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Capitalisingon our marketplace visibility
Corporate renewal – 4
17
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Overview At Star, our market-centric initiatives
involved a strong element of service
to reach the right quantity at the
right time to the customer. An
outward-looking approach and
application-driven product
customisation enabled the Company
to report the highest net sales
realisations.
Highlights, 2005-6The Company reduced its finished
goods inventory by 603 MT
during 2005-6 partially offsetting
its production loss.
Average realisations increased
7.47 per cent to Rs. 27,583 per
MT on account of price increases
and product mix improvement.
Web-enabled customer service
enabled the Company to shrink
customer response time.
The Company enjoys a robust
distribution infrastructure of 50
pan-Indian dealers and three
depots with over half the dealers
located in the fast-growing
markets of Punjab, Delhi, Uttar
Pradesh and Haryana. This
locational advantage enabled the
Company to market nearly 60 per
cent of its total output within a
radius of 300 kms from its
manufacturing facility in West
Uttar Pradesh.
Strong debtor management
practices enabled the Company to
maintain its debtor days at an
unchanged 11 days of turnover
equivalent.
Results, 2005-6 Stronger net sales realisations (Rs. per tonne)
Declining debtor days
Outlook, 2006-7Following the rebuilding of PM 2,
the Company intends to enhance
volumes of high value-added
cultural grades.
It intends to fortify customer
delivery standards through its
technical services team.
It expects net sales realisations to
improve further.
18
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
The global paper industryThe health of the global paper
industry is influenced by economic
growth, global trade, industrial
activity, corporate prosperity,
advertising, population growth,
literacy and demand-supply
dynamics.
While demand growth for writing
and printing paper remained modest
in the mature markets of Western
Europe and North America, the
markets of Asia, primarily driven by
China and India, reported a demand
surge. Demand for the packaging
grades also grew faster in the
developing economies compared to
the mature markets of North
America. As a result, the total global
demand for paper and paper
products is estimated to have grown
1 per cent to around 344 million
tonnes in 2005. The global paper
industry is expected to grow at a
compounded annual growth rate
(CAGR) of two per cent with a
consumption volume of 402 million
tonnes by 2010.
According to Jaakko Poyry, the
global trade of paper and board
amounts to 112 million tonnes,
accounting for 31 per cent of global
consumption. The principal exporting
regions comprised Central Europe,
Nordic countries and North America,
largely on account of the availability
of abundant wood fiber in these
regions and corresponding
production of paper and allied
products. Interestingly, demand for
paper is slowing in these mature
markets leading to increased export.
Europe, North America and Asia
represent the key paper markets of
the world. A brief description on the
performance of these markets in
2005 is highlighted below.
Europe: Production of writing and
printing paper in Europe is estimated
to have aggregated to 39.20 million
tonnes in 2005, while demand is
expected to have aggregated to
around 35 million tonnes. Europe
emerged as a net exporter of writing
and printing paper to the extent of
3.80 million tonnes in 2005,
signifying faster growth in
production over slower growth in
demand. Furthermore, the
production and demand for carton
boards in Western Europe was also
estimated to have de-grown by two
per cent apiece to six million tonnes
and 4.50 million tonnes respectively
in 2005.
North America: Production of
writing and printing paper totalled
28.20 million tonnes in North
America in 2005, unchanged from
2004. Total demand reached around
30.20 million tonnes, representing a
two per cent drop compared to
2004. This is a strong reflection on
Managementdiscussion andanalysis
19
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
the fact that while production
remained the same in 2005, demand
dipped during the year under review.
Asia: The capacity for writing and
printing paper grew in Asia to the
extent of five per cent, primarily
driven by China and India. Total
demand in the region aggregated to
around 38 million tonnes, driven by
a four per cent rise over 2004.
Growth in demand was the fastest in
China, which surged by
approximately six per cent. Asia
emerged as the only continent
among the large paper producing
nations to have reported a growth in
both production and demand.
Global consumer packagingmarket by material
Source: Pira International
Global consumer packagingmarket by end-use
The Indian paper industry Estimated at Rs. 15,000 cr, the
Indian paper industry comprises the
writing, printing, industrial and
newsprint segments. Though India is
the fifteenth largest paper market in
the world (1.40 per cent of the
world’s paper and board
consumption and 4.70 per cent of
the Asian consumption), the
interesting point to note is that
demand for paper and allied
products in India is growing faster at
around six per cent compared to a
demand growth of about three per
cent the world over. The Indian
paper industry provides employment
to around 13 cr people and
contributes about Rs. 2,500 cr to the
exchequer.
A number of interesting trends are
driving the Indian paper industry,
briefly described below.
Slow capacity growth: The Indian
Wrap it up…
According to a recentstudy undertaken by PiraInternational, paper andboard emerged as the
globally-preferredpackaging material over
other varieties, indicatingrobust and sustainabledemand for paper andpaper-based products.
The Indian paperindustry providesemployment to around13 cr people andcontributes about Rs.2,500 cr to theexchequer
Source: Pira International
20
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
installed paper manufacturing
capacity is expected to grow at a
compounded annual growth rate of
a mere 3.70 per cent to 8.75 million
tonnes per annum in 2008-09. This
growth in paper production is largely
expected to be a mix of de-
bottlenecking undertaken by
companies and brownfield
expansions. However, long gestation
period will result in slow pace of
capacity addition.
Demand rising: According to Jaako
Poyry, the demand for paper in India
is projected to grow at a
compounded annual growth rate of
6.10 per cent to an estimated 7.40
million tonnes in 2008-9. In terms of
various segments of paper, the
demand for:
Industrial paper (which enjoys the
largest chunk of the total paper
demand at around 60 per cent) is
estimated to grow at a
compounded annual growth rate
of 6.70 per cent.
Writing and printing paper
(accounting for 40 per cent of the
total paper demand) is expected
to grow at a compounded annual
growth rate of 5.50 per cent.
According to Jaakko Poyry, this
demand-supply mismatch is expected
to result in a supply shortage of
around 0.7 million tonnes in 2010.
Cost push and increase in
realizations: Paper prices in India
increased in tranches in 2005. This
was primarily driven by increasing
input cost. The cost of coal rose in
2005 (thereby inflating power and
fuel costs) and so did key chemicals.
Price increases were reflected in
other paper varieties as well
(newsprint, industrial paper and
coated paper among others).
Demand drivers The Budget 2005-6 increased the
total outlay under Sarva Siksha
Abhiyan from Rs. 1004 cr in
2005-6 to Rs. 7,156 cr in 2006-7
while Rs. 8,750 cr will be
transferred to Prarambhik Siksha
Kosh from the education cess. The
increased outlay for education will
drive demand and volumes for
writing paper. Besides, a cut in
excise duty on printing, writing
and packaging papers from 16
per cent to 12 per cent will
enhance affordability.
Growth in the domestic paper
industry mirrors the growth of the
Indian economy. While India’s
GDP grew 8.4 per cent in 2005-6,
domestic demand for paper and
paper products grew to nearly
6.30 million tonnes during the
same period. As per the Central
21
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
According to JaakoPoyry, the demand forpaper in India isprojected to grow at acompounded annualgrowth rate of 6.10 percent to an estimated7.40 million tonnes in2008-9
Government estimates, the Indian
GDP is likely to grow by 8.10 per
cent in 2006-7, even as it aims to
achieve and economic growth of
10 per cent over the future. This
scenario is expected to accelerate
the production and consumption
of paper and paperboard.
The presence of a large number
of modern retail formats,
convenience stores and exclusive
outlets is prompting FMCG
players and consumer durables
and non-durables manufacturers
to provide innovative packaging
solutions. The growing popularity
of ready-to-eat products and
perishable foods is expected to
grow the demand of packaging
paper.
Variety-wise forecast of demand in India (‘000 tonnes)
Product portfolio analysis
*Change in ratio in 2005-6 is on account of shut of PM 2 for part of the year
Source: CRIS INFAC
Variety 2005-6 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9
Writing and printing paper 2292 2419 2555 2701
Uncoated paper 1975 2075 2182 2296
Coated paper 317 344 373 405
Industrial paper 3600 3841 4100 4379
Kraft 1968 2110 2263 2427
MG poster 305 310 315 320
Paper segment Percentage share Percentage share Percentage share
in 2003-4 in 2004-5 in 2005-6*
Industrial paper 66 66 55
Cultural paper 34 34 45
22
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Product portfolio analysisStar manufactures cultural and
industrial paper, the portfolio
highlighted in the table below:
Cultural paper: Cultural paper
comprises writing and printing
paper and business communication
paper. This variety is used for a
number of diverse applications in
diaries, calendars, books, maps,
computer stationery, book/
notebook covers, wedding and
invitation cards, photo-copying
paper, ledger paper and account
book paper among others.
Industrial paper: Industrial paper
constitutes absorbent kraft, padding
paper, base paper, kraft paper,
poster paper, poster ARSR and
ribbed kraft paper. The various
applications of industrial paper
comprises laminates, clay/ colour
coating, corrugated box paper, foil
lamination, wrapper/ pouches, files,
identity card , soap wrapper, fire
crackers, water-proofing, tobacco
packing and metallization among
others.
Risks and concerns Risk is inseparable from business.
Nonetheless, the Company has
undertaken a number of initiatives
to mitigate risk impact through
continuous risk identification and
management. The Indian paper
industry might face a slowdown,
resulting in sluggish demand and
slow offtake. This could impact the
profitability of companies operating
within the industry. Moreover, non-
availability of key raw material
resources may inflate procurement
costs, impact production and affect
profitability. Star enjoys robust asset
flexibility and a diversified product
mix, which enables it to
manufacture a range of products to
speedily cater to emerging
demands. This flexibility also enables
the Company to switch its raw
material mix in favour of those
which are available cost-effectively.
Internal control systemsStar has an adequate system of
internal control procedures
commensurate with its size of
operations, which enables
information dissemination and
facilitates speedy decision-making. A
compliance with functions,
processes and policies is periodically
appraised through internal audit.
Internal control systems are devised
to ensure the reliability,
transparency and accuracy of all
23
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
financial records and statements.
Findings of the internal audit are
also forwarded to the Audit
Committee of the Board.
Human resourcesStar is strengthening its human
resource management practices,
which aim at the all-round
individual development. For
achieving this purpose, the
Company organises a number of
training sessions conducted by
trainers. It consistently seeks to
recruit, train and employ qualified,
capable and experienced
professionals with needed
competencies.
OutlookDespite being the second-most
populous country in the world
(population of over one billion),
India’s per capita paper
consumption is among the lowest in
the world at 6 kgs (as indicated in
the table). This represents
tremendous latent potential for the
growth in paper demand and
consumption in India.
Country/region Paper
consumption
(kg per capita)
USA 334
Japan 302
South East Asia 40
China 30
World average 53
India 6
Moreover within Asia, India is
expected to report the sharpest
demand growth on account of
increasing literacy levels, rising
corporate profitability, growing
population and increasing spending.
Estimates made by ICRA and IPMA
highlight the fact that by 2012 India
could be consuming more than 10
million tonnes of paper and paper
board.
Despite being thesecond-most populouscountry in the world,India’s per capita paperconsumption is amongthe lowest in the worldat 6 kgs
24
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Directors’ reportThe Directors present their report and audited accounts of the
Company for the financial year ended 31st March, 2006
Financial results(Rs. in crores)
Particulars Year ended 31st March, 2006 Year ended 31st March, 2005
Profit before interest and depreciation 30.01 44.90
Interest and finance charges (5.55) (6.30)
Depreciation (8.94) (7.36)
Profit before exceptional and non-recurring items 15.52 31.24
– Irrecoverable balances and pre-operative expenses written off – –
– Amount written off in respect of interest accrued (0.92) (0.98)
Profit before tax 14.60 30.26
Provision for Income Tax
– Current (2.06) (4.94)
– Deferred (3.26) (5.14)
Profit after taxation 9.28 20.18
Transfer to Debenture Redemption Reserve (1.50) (1.50)
Balance brought forward 27.65 13.61
Available for appropriation 35.43 32.29
Transfer to General Reserve (1.00) (1.55)
Proposed dividend (2.73) (2.73)
Tax on proposed dividend (0.38) (0.36)
Tax on dividend for earlier year (0.03) –
Balance carried to the Balance Sheet 31.29 27.65
25
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
DividendThe Directors recommend payment
of a dividend of Rs. 1.75 per equity
share of a face value of Rs 10 each
for the year under review subject to
the necessary approvals.
The year in retrospectDuring the year your Company
completed modernization of Paper
Machine # 2, installation of Multi-
fuel Boiler and retrofit of Turbine.
While there was lower production
during the year due to plant shuts
required for completing these jobs,
your company will reap the benefits
in the form of increased production
and lower costs in the coming years.
As mentioned in the last Annual
Report, there were sharp increases in
prices of wood and fuel oil. Your
company made strenuous efforts to
control costs in all other areas and
was partially able to mitigate the
impact. These measures coupled
with improvement in realization
enabled the company to post a
profit of Rs. 928 lacs.
Prospects for 2006-07Upward trend in costs of raw
material and fuel continues. Your
company will strive to meet the
challenges by focusing on improved
efficiencies.
Implementation of other parts of
modernization project initiated last
year is progressing well and will be
completed during the current year.
Environment, pollutioncontrol and safetyYour company is accredited with ISO
14001: 2004 and ISO 9001:2000.
Its efforts in this field were once
again recognized in the form of a
Gold Award for Environmental
Excellence and also for Safety in
paper Industries from the Greentech
Foundation .
Social farm forestryIn order to increase the yield and
improve economics for the farmers,
your company started Clonal
technology programme in the year
1996. Two high yielding clones of
Eucalyptus have been developed and
based on encouraging field
performance, are being
commercialized. Your company has
created necessary infrastructure for
clonal multiplication and plans to
expand this in a phased manner.
This will help in enhancing rural
incomes and facilitate sustained
availability of raw material to the
Company.
In the face of rising wood prices,
your company has further enhanced
the tree plantation programme
under social forestry scheme.
Human resource andwelfare Industrial relations remained cordial.
Your Company continues to
emphasise enhancement in
employee skills. The Directors wish to
place on record their deep
appreciation for dedication of
employees.
Fixed depositsNo fixed deposits remained unpaid
as on 31st March, 2006.
DirectorsDr. S.P. Vohra has resigned from the
Directorship of the Company and
ceased to be a director of the
Company with effect from
November 29, 2005. The Board
26
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
expresses its appreciation for the
services rendered by Dr. Vohra
during his tenure.
Mr. S. Sharma and Dr. B.L. Bihani
retire by rotation at the forthcoming
Annual General Meeting and being
eligible, offer themselves for re-
appointment.
Mr. Supriya Gupta was appointed
Additional Director of the Company
on February 27, 2006 and will hold
office till the forthcoming Annual
General Meeting. The company has
received notice from a member, as
required under section 257 of the
Companies Act, 1956, expressing his
intention to propose the
appointment of Mr. Supriya Gupta
as Director of the Company.
Particulars of conservationof energy, technologyabsorption and foreignexchange earnings andoutgoParticulars regarding energy
conservation, technology absorption
and foreign exchange earnings/outgo
pursuant to Section 217 (1)(e) of the
Companies Act, 1956, read with the
Companies (Disclosure of Particulars
in the Report of Board of Directors)
Rules, 1988, are furnished as
Annexure-I to this Report.
Particulars of employeesDetails of remuneration paid to
employees, as required by Section
217(2A) of the Companies Act, 1956
are furnished as Annexure-II to this
Report.
Directors’ responsibilitystatementAs required under the provisions of
Section 217(2AA) Directors
Responsibility Statement on the
preparation and presentation of
these accounts appears as Annexure-
III to this Report.
Corporate governanceA separate report on corporate
governance, together with a
certificate from the statutory auditors
confirming compliance with
corporate governance requirements
has been annexed as Annexure-IV of
this annual report.
AuditorsM/s Lodha & Co. Chartered
Accountants, retire at the ensuing
Annual General Meeting. They have
expressed their willingness to
continue in office, if re-appointed
and have furnished the requisite
certificate of their eligibility pursuant
to Section 224(1B) of the Companies
Act, 1956.
Auditors’ reportThe observations of the Auditors in
their report read with relevant notes
are self-explanatory and do not call
for any further comments.
Listing on stockexchangesThe Company’s equity shares are
currently listed with The Stock
Exchange, Mumbai (BSE) and
National Stock Exchange of India Ltd.
(NSE). The Company has paid the
requisite listing fees to the stock
exchanges for the financial year
2005-6.
AcknowledgementsThe Directors wish to place on record
their gratitude to the Company's
customers, dealers, suppliers, various
departments of the Government,
financial institutions and banks for
their continued support to the
Company.
For and on behalf of the Board
Place : Kolkata G. P. Goenka
Date : 29th May, 2006 Chairman
27
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Annexure-I Information pursuant to section 217
(1)(e) of the Companies Act-1956
,read with the Companies (
Disclosure of particulars in the
Report of Board of Directors )
Rules,1988.
A. Particulars with respectto conservation of energy.a) The Company has taken the
following measures for conservation
of energy:
Installation of 40 TPH steam
generation capacity and 42
kg/cm2 pressure Multi Fuel Boiler
and stopping 2 nos 21 TPH
existing 20 kg/cm2 pressure
boilers.
Retrofitting of existing 20 kg/cm2
pressure 5 MW BHEL turbine to
operate at 42 Kg/cm2 pressure
and increase co-generation of
power.
Installation of fan less cooling
tower in D.G.Sets.
Installation of energy efficient
Transformer.
Installation of steam and
condensate system for PM-2.
Installation of energy efficient
refiner for Paper Machines.
Installation of DCS in Pulp Mill.
b) Additional investments and
proposals, if any, being implemented
for reduction in consumption of
energy :
Installation of 5 MW turbine
further increase co-generation.
To Install Hot Stock Screening
system in Pulp Mill.
Installation of energy efficient FD
fan in Recovery Boiler
Installation of energy efficient
motors and VFDs.
c) Impact of measures (a) and (b)
above for reduction of energy
consumption and consequent impact
on the cost of production of goods.
Reduction in power generation
cost.
Reduction in power and steam
consumption.
Increased captive power
generation.
d) Total energy consumption and
energy consumption per unit of
production ( as per ‘Form-A’ of the
annexure to the rules)-annexed
B. Technology absorptionInformation as per Form ‘B’ of the
annexure to the rules – annexed.
C. Foreign exchangeearnings and outgoMembers are requested to refer to
note no. 20 (d), (e) and (f) of
schedule 16 forming part of balance
sheet and profit and loss account for
the year ended March 31, 2006.
28
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Form - AParticulars Current year ended Previous year ended
31st March, 2006 31st March, 2005
A. Power & fuel consumption
1. Electricity
a) Purchased
Units (Kwh in lakhs) 201.76 66.73
Total Amount (Rs. in lakhs) 860.02 350.02
Tariff Rate/Unit (Rs.) 4.26 5.24
b) Own Generation Through
i) Steam Turbine
Units (Gross) (Kwh in lakhs) 308.43 266.57
Units (Net) (Kwh in lakhs) 299.52 257.43
Units per MT of Coal (Kwh) 2188 1780
Cost/Unit (Rs.) 2.41 2.57
ii) Power Generating Sets
Units (Gross) (Kwh in lakhs) 413.98 521.05
Units (Net) (Kwh in lakhs) 392.57 496.81
Units per MT of Fuel Oil (Kwh) 4524 4524
Cost/Unit (Rs.) 4.61 3.44
2. Coal : Grade-A, B & C
Quantity (MT) 28852 28990
Total Cost (Rs. in lakhs) 1009.33 936.72
Average Cost (Rs./MT) 3498 3231
3. Agro Residue
Quantity (MT) 33428 37084
Total Cost (Rs. in lakhs) 329.64 341.88
Average Cost (Rs./MT) 986 922
4. Fuel Oil
Quantity (MT) 12934 14987
Total Cost (Rs. in lakhs) 2124.95 1825.99
Average Cost (Rs./MT) 16429 12184
B. Consumption per unit of production
Product - Paper (MT) 67875 71105
Electricity (Kwh) 1362 1202
Fuel Oils (MT) 0.211 0.211
Coal (MT) 0.43 0.41
Agro Residue (MT) 0.49 0.52
29
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Form - B
A. Research and development(R&D)The In-house R&D unit of the
Company is recognized by Govt. of
India, Ministry of Science and
Technology, Department of Science
and Industrial Research (DSIR). The
details of the In-house R&D activities
are given below:-
1.Specific areas in which in-house
R&D projects were carried out by
the Company.
(i) Studies on separate cooking of
Eucalyptus & Poplar wood.
(ii) Studied for Development of SS
Maplitho Ultra White.
(iii) Studies on manufacturing of
Special Kraft Paper.
(iv) Studies on
reduction/optimization of
Sizing Chemical consumption.
(v) Studies on NCG
2.Benefits derived as a result of
above R&D projects
(i) Commercial production of SS
Maplitho Ultra White.
(ii) Consumption of sizing
chemical optimized.
(iii) Studies on NCG completed.
3. Future Plan of Action
(i) Establishing AKD sizing on
PM-1.
(ii) Studies on development of
suitable surfactant based
cooking aid and its use for
further reduction of cooking
chemicals.
4. Expenditure on R&D
a)Capital Nil
b)Revenue Rs.21.26 lakhs
c) Total Rs21.26 lakhs
d)R&D expenditure 0.10%
as a percentage
of total turnover
B. Technology absorption,adaptation & innovation1. Efforts made, in brief, towards
Technology Absorption, Adaptation
and Innovation :
a) Up gradation Chemical Recovery
Boiler by increasing its operating
pressure from 20 Kg/Cm2 (g) to 42
kg/cm(g) to increase cogeneration
power from Steam Turbine also
increasing its firing capacity from
300 to 350 Black liquor solids .
b)Up gradation of Evaporator Plant
by increasing its product
concentration from 52% to 65%
and removal of cascade
Evaporators from Recovery Boiler
and installing economiser there for
increasing steam generation from
Recovery Boiler.
c) Installation of Bi-nip press in PM-2.
d) Retrofitting of steam and
condensate system for PM-2 by
installing rotary siphoning,
cascading and thermo
compression system.
For and on behalf of the Board
Place : Kolkata G. P. Goenka
Date : 29th May, 2006 Chairman
30
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Ann
exur
e-II
Part
icul
ars
of e
mpl
oyee
s as
req
uire
d un
der
Sect
ion
217
(2A
) of
the
Com
pani
es A
ct, 1
956
and
the
rule
s m
ade
ther
eund
erfo
rmin
g pa
rt o
f th
e D
irec
tor’
s Re
port
for
the
yea
r en
ded
31st
Mar
ch, 2
006.
A. E
mpl
oyee
s em
ploy
ed f
or w
hole
of
the
year
and
in r
ecei
pt o
f re
mun
erat
ion
aggr
egat
ing
not
less
tha
n Rs
.200
000/
- pe
r m
onth
Nam
eA
ge
Qua
lific
atio
nD
esig
nati
on/
Dat
e of
Expe
rien
ceRe
mun
erat
ion
Part
icul
ars
of la
st e
mpl
oym
ent
held
(Yea
rs)
Nat
ure
of D
utie
sco
mm
ence
men
t(Y
ears
)re
ceiv
ed
Empl
oyer
Last
pos
t an
d pe
riod
of E
mpl
oym
ent
(Rs.
in la
cs)
for
whi
ch p
ost
held
– in
yea
rs
Sh. G
.P. G
oenk
a65
B.Sc
.Ch
airm
an c
um15
.01.
2004
4572
.37
Dun
cans
Tea
Who
le-t
ime
Dire
ctor
,
Who
le-t
ime
Dire
ctor
Lim
ited
1 ye
ar a
nd 6
mon
ths
Sh. M
. Mis
hra
49B.
Sc.,
Man
agin
g D
irect
or01
.07.
2001
2943
.39
Dai
l Con
sulta
nts
Sr.V
ice
Pres
iden
t
DM
S (M
gt.)
Ltd.
(Cor
pora
te P
lann
ing)
–7 y
ears
1.Re
mun
erat
ion
rece
ived
incl
udes
Sal
ary,
Com
pany
’s c
ontr
ibut
ion
to P
rovi
dent
and
Pen
sion
fun
ds, S
uper
annu
atio
n fu
nd, H
ouse
Ren
t A
llow
ance
, Med
ical
exp
ense
s an
d m
onet
ary
valu
e of
per
quis
ites
calc
ulat
ed in
acc
orda
nce
with
the
pro
visi
ons
of In
com
e Ta
x A
ct, 1
961
and
rule
s m
ade
ther
e un
der.
2.N
atur
e an
d te
rms
of e
mpl
oym
ent
are
as p
er C
ontr
act.
31
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Annexure-III Directors’ Responsibility Statement
As required under the provisions of Section 217(2AA) of the Companies Act, 1956 the Board wishes to confirm that:
1. in preparation of accounts applicable accounting standards have been followed.
2. such accounting policies as were reasonable and prudent were selected in preparing the accounts and these were
applied consistently. Further judgments and estimates that were reasonable and prudent were also made in the course of
preparing the accounts so as to give a true and fair view of the Company’s state of the affairs as at the end of the financial
year and its profit for the year ended 31st March, 2006.
3. proper and sufficient care was taken for the maintenance of proper accounting records in accordance with the
provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 for safeguarding the assets of the Company and for preventing and detecting
frauds and other irregularities;
4. the accounts have been prepared on going concern basis.
For and on behalf of the Board
Place : Kolkata G. P. Goenka
Date : 29th May, 2006 Chairman
32
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Annexure-IV
Report on Corporate Governance(Pursuant to Clause 49 of the Listing Agreement)
The following is the composition of the Board of Directors as on 31st March, 2006
* Excludes Directorships in Indian Private Limited Companies, Foreign Companies, Companies under Section 25 of the Companies Act,
1956, memberships of Managing Committees of various Chambers/Bodies and Alternate Directorships.
** Represents Memberships / Chairmanships of Audit Committee, Shareholders / Investors Grievance Committee, Remuneration
Committee of Indian Companies.
*** Dr. S.P. Vohra ceased to be director of the Company w.e.f. 29th November, 2005.
**** Mr. Supriya Gupta joined as an additional director w.e.f. 27th February, 2006.
The Directors present the Company’s
Report on Corporate Governance for
the year ended 31st March, 2006.
I. Company’s philosophyon Corporate GovernanceThe Company places strong
emphasis on transparency,
empowerment, accountability and
integrity so as to continuously
enhance the stakeholders’ value.
II. Board of DirectorsIn terms of the Company’s Corporate
Governance Policy, all statutory and
other significant and material
information are placed before the
Board to enable it to discharge its
responsibilities of supervision, control
and direction setting for the
organisation.
(a) CompositionThe composition of the Board of
Directors consists of Executive and
Non-Executive Directors.
The total number of directors of the
Company is Ten during the year
under review, including the Whole-
Time Director and Managing
Director.
Director Category of Director Total No. of Total No. of Memberships/
Directorships (*) Chairmanships of
Committees (**)
Executive Director
Mr. G.P. Goenka Chairman cum 11 0
Whole-Time Director
Mr. Madhukar Mishra Managing Director 2 1
Non – Executive Directors
Dr. B.L. Bihani Independent Director 1 2
Mr. P.N. Ghatalia Independent Director 8 11
Dr. S.P. Vohra *** Independent Director 4 2
Mr. Shiromani Sharma Independent Director 4 5
Mr. S.V. Goenka Promoter Director 9 2
Mr. N.J. Jhaveri Independent Director 10 9
Mr. Supriya Gupta **** Independent Director 11 10
Mr. M.P. Pinto Independent Director 3 3
– Nominee of IDBI
33
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
(b) Meetings and AttendanceDuring the year ended 31st March, 2006, four meetings of Board of Directors were held on 30th May, 2005, 29th
August, 2005, 30th November, 2005 and 27th February, 2006.
Attendance of Directors at Board Meetings and at Last Annual General Meeting
Director (Name) No. of Board Meetings Attendance at last
attended Annual General Meeting
Yes or No
Mr. G.P. Goenka 4 Yes
Dr. S.P. Vohra 0 No
Mr. Shiromani Sharma 4 Yes
Dr. B.L. Bihani 4 Yes
Mr. P.N. Ghatalia 4 Yes
Mr. M.P. Pinto 3 Yes
Mr. S.V. Goenka 4 Yes
Mr. N.J. Jhaveri 2 No
Mr. Supriya Gupta – N.A.
Mr. M. Mishra 4 Yes
(III) Code of ConductA Code of Conduct for all its Board
Members and Senior Management
personnel for avoidance of conflict of
interest has been laid down and is
available on the Company's website.
Necessary declarations affirming
compliance has been received with it
during the period since it became
effective. There were no material
personal interest/ personal benefits
received by the Board Members/
Senior Management personnel,
which could lead to potential conflict
of interest with the Company as a
result of their position.
(IV) Committees of theBoard The Board of Directors has
constituted two Committees – the
Audit Committee and the
Shareholders/ Investors Grievance
Committee.
(i) Audit Committee The Company set up the Audit
Committee in accordance with the
requirements of section 292A of the
Companies Act, 1956 and the terms
of reference are in conformity with
clause 49 of the listing agreement
entered into with the stock
exchanges. Statutory Auditors,
Internal Auditors and Cost Auditors
are invitees to the Committee
meetings. The Company Secretary
acts as the Secretary to the
Committee. However, the Company
Secretary has resigned with effect
from 10th December, 2005 and till
the time a new Company Secretary is
appointed, Chief Financial Officer of
the Company is acting as Secretary
to the Committee.
Composition
The composition of the Audit
Committee as on 31st March, 2006
is on the following page:
34
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
# Salary also includes allowances, Performance Pay and Commission on net profits.
## Perquisites and other benefits include contribution to Provident and other funds but exclude company’s contribution to
Gratuity Fund.
The non-executive directors are not holding any shares in the company except 500 Equity shares held by
Mr. S.V. Goenka .
Apart from the above, none of the Non-Executive Directors had any pecuniary relationship or transactions with the
Company.
In Rupees
Director Salary # Perquisites and Sitting Fees Total
other benefits##
Mr. G.P. Goenka 6760000 476676 – 7236676
Dr. S.P. Vohra – – – –
Mr. Shiromani Sharma – – 50000 50000
Dr. B.L. Bihani – – 55000 55000
Mr. P.N. Ghatalia – – 20000 20000
Mr. M.P. Pinto – – 20000 20000
Mr. S.V. Goenka – – 25000 25000
Mr. N.J. Jhaveri – – 10000 10000
Mr. M. Mishra 2695000 1643754 – 4338754
Total 9455000 2120430 180000 11755430
(ii) Shareholders/InvestorsGrievance Committee The Committee oversees redressal of
shareholder and investor grievances,
like transfer of shares, non-receipt of
Annual Report, dividends and
approves of sub-division,
transmission, issue of duplicate
shares etc.
Composition
In 2005-6, the composition of the
Committee was as under :
Name of Category
the Director
Mr. Shiromani Non- Executive
Sharma, Chairman
Dr. B.L. Bihani Non-Executive
Mr. Madhukar Executive
Mishra
(V) Remuneration ofDirectors Remuneration of Managing Director
and Whole-Time Director were
determined by the Board of
Directors. Remuneration of Non-
Executive Directors was restricted
to only sitting fees for attending
meetings of the Board, Audit
Committee and Shareholders/Investor
Grievance Committee meetings.
The details of remuneration of the
directors for the financial year ended
31st March, 2006 were:
The Audit Committee meetings were held on 30th May, 2005, 29th July, 2005, 28th October, 2005 and 30th January,
2006.
Sl. No. Name of the Director Designation No. of Meetings attended
1. Mr. Shiromani Sharma Chairman 4
2. Dr. B.L. Bihani Member 4
3. Mr. M. P. Pinto Member 1
4. Mr. Shrivardhan Goenka Member 1
35
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Service contracts, severancefees and notice periodThe appointment of the Executive
Directors is governed by resolutions
passed by the Board of Directors and
the shareholders of the Company,
which covers the terms and
conditions of such appointment.
There is no separate provision for
payment of severance fee under the
resolutions governing the
appointment of Executive Director.
Statutory provisions however will
apply in case of severance of service.
The appointment is terminable by six
months’ notice from either side.
(VI) DisclosuresThere were no materially significant
related party transactions which may
have potential conflict with the
interest of the company at large.
Confirmations has been placed
before the Audit Committee and the
Board that all related party
transactions during the year under
reference were in the ordinary course
of business and on arm's length
basis. There was no non-compliance
during the last three years by the
company on any matter relating to
the Capital Markets. There were no
penalties, strictures passed on the
Company by stock exchanges/SEBI or
any Statutory Authority. There were
no pecuniary relationships or
transactions with Non-Executive
Directors. The Company does not
have any material non-listed
Subsidiary Companies as defined in
Clause 49 of the Listing Agreement
with Stock Exchanges.
(VII) Means ofcommunicationThe quarterly results of the Company
were announced within a month of
the end of each quarter and the
audited results were announced
within three months of the close of
the financial year; such results were
published normally in the ‘The
Financial Express’, ‘Business
Standard’, ‘The Economic Times’,
and ‘Aajkal’. The Management
Discussion and Analysis Report forms
part of the Annual Report. The
financial results of the Company is
provided to the web site
www.starpapers.com.
Compliance certificate of theAuditorsThe Company has obtained
certificate from the statutory auditors
certifying compliance of conditions
of corporate governance as
stipulated in Clause 49 of the listing
agreement and the same is annexed.
The certificate will also be sent to the
stock exchanges along with the
Annual Return that will be filed by
the Company.
(VIII) Shareholder Information68th AGM Details
Date Venue Book Closure Time Dividend Payment
dates dates
6th September, 2006 ‘KalaKunj’ 24.08.2006 to 06.09.2006 10.30 A.M. After 06.09.2006
(Kalamandir basement),
48, Shakespeare Sarani,
Kolkatta 700 017
36
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Registrar & Share TransferAgentsThe Company’s Registrar and Share
Transfer Agent is Karvy
Computershare Pvt. Ltd.
Address for correspondence Karvy House,
46, Avenue 4, Street No. 1,
Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500 034
Telephone : 0091-040-23312454 /
23320751 / 23320752 / 23320251
Fax : 0091-040-23311968/23323049
e-mail : [email protected]
The Shareholders holding shares in
the electronic form should address
their correspondence, except those
relating to dividend, to their
respective Depository Participants.
Compliance OfficerMr A. Ghosh, Chief Financial Officer
is the Compliance Officer under
Clause 47 of the listing agreement.
Transfer System The Registrars and Share Transfer
Agents process every fortnight
requests for approving share
transfers. The processing activities
with respect to requests received for
share transfer are completed within
7-10 days from the date of receipt of
request.
There were no shares pending
transfer as on 31st March, 2006.
Dematerialisation of Shares andLiquidityThe shares of the Company can be
traded in dematerialised form with
both NSDL (National Securities
Depository Ltd.) and CDSL (Central
Depository Services (India) Ltd.)
As on 31st March, 2006, a total of
1,43,74,307 shares of the company,
which form 92.09% of the share
capital, stand dematerialised. The
processing activities with respect to
the requests received for
dematerialisation are completed
within 3-5 days from the date of
receipt of request.
Under the depository system, the
International Securities Identification
Number (ISIN) allotted to the
company is INE 733A01018.
Shareholders ComplaintsThere was no complaints pending at
the begining of the year. 9 (nine)
complaints were received during the
year 2005-06 and settled. No
complaint is pending at close of the
year.
Distribution of shareholding as on March 31, 2006
No. of shareholders No. of ordinary shares
Slab Total % of shareholders Total % of share capital
1-500 10960 90.09 1446727 9.27
501-1000 626 5.15 522854 3.35
1001-2000 299 2.46 465555 2.98
2001-3000 86 0.71 221946 1.42
3001-4000 41 0.34 145759 0.94
4001-5000 33 0.27 154133 0.99
5001-10000 49 0.40 365530 2.34
10001 and above 71 0.58 12285846 78.71
Total 12165 100.00 15608350 100.00
37
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Monthly high and low quotations of shares traded on the listed stock exchanges
Category of shareholders as on 31st March, 2006
Category No. of Shares %
Foreign Holding 35000 0.23
Overseas Body Corporate 500 0.00
Non resident Indians 62901 0.40
Financial Institutions 1990177 12.76
Banks and Mutual Funds 5191 0.03
Promoter Group 8381993 53.70
Clearing Member (NSDL & CDSL) 84808 0.54
Public 5047780 32.34
Total 15608350 100.00
Month NSE BSE
High Low High Low
2005
April 63.70 57.15 63.85 51.10
May 74.90 61.00 75.00 61.00
June 72.95 64.75 71.90 64.50
July 69.90 62.00 69.75 63.05
August 87.40 61.50 87.00 61.35
September 123.70 85.00 118.70 85.20
October 102.80 72.20 102.90 69.00
November 86.90 61.15 90.00 69.95
December 88.80 72.00 87.50 73.15
2006
January 91.90 73.25 91.90 73.40
February 76.80 64.05 74.85 64.20
March 70.00 54.25 70.00 56.50
38
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Listing on stock exchangesThe Company’s Equity Shares are
currently listed with the Stock
Exchange, Mumbai (BSE) and the
National Stock Exchange of India Ltd.
(NSE) under Stock Codes ‘516022’
and ‘STARPAPER’ respectively. The
Company has paid the requisite
listing fees to the stock exchanges
for the financial year 2006-2007.
Registered office27, Biplabi Trailokya Maharaj Sarani,
(Formerly Brabourne Road),
Kolkata 700 001
Plant locationSeth Baldeodas Bajoria Road,
Saharanpur 247 001, Uttar Pradesh
Branches ati) IInd Floor, Express Building,
9-10 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg,
New Delhi 110 008
ii) 23, Mauji Colony, Malviya Nagar
Jaipur 302 017
Financial Calendar 2006-2007 The next financial year of the
Company is 1st April, 2006 to 31st
March, 2007
Apr’05 May’05 Jun’05 Jul’05 Aug’05 Sep’05 Oct’05 Nov’05 Dec’05 Jan’06 Feb’06 Mar’06
Star
Pap
er S
crip
(Rs.
)
Star Paper Scrip
BSE Sensex
BSE Sensex
0
3000
6000
9000
12000
15000
18000
21000
24000
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
The Schedule of approving the Financial Results of the Company is given below:
Postal BallotNo special resolution requiring a postal ballot was placed before the last Annual General Meeting. Similarly, no special
resolution requiring a postal ballot is being proposed at the forthcoming Annual General Meeting.
Particulars of Past three AGM’s
S. No. Financial Results Month for approving the Results ( Tentative)
1. First quarter results July
2. Second quarter and half yearly results October
3. Third quarter results January
4. Annual results June
Year Venue Date Time
2004-2005 ‘Kala Kunj’, 48, Shakespeare Sarani, 29.08.2005 10.30 A.M.
Kolkata 700 017
2003-2004 ‘Kala Mandir’(Main Auditorium), 31.08.2004 10.00 A.M.
48, Shakespeare Sarani, Kolkata 700 017
2002-2003 ‘Kala Kunj’, 48, Shakespeare Sarani, 08.09.2003 10.30 A.M.
Kolkata 700 017
Comparison of Star Paper scrip with Mumbai Stock Exchange (BSE) Sensex
2005-6
39
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Auditors’ Certificate on Corporate Governance
To the Members of,
Star Paper Mills Limited
We have examined the compliance of conditions of Corporate Governance by Star Paper Mills Limited, for the year ended
on 31st March, 2006, as stipulated in Clause 49 of the Listing Agreement of the said Company with Stock Exchanges in
India.
The compliance of conditions of Corporate Governance is the responsibility of the management. Our examination was
limited to procedures and implementations thereof, adopted by the Company for ensuring the compliance of the
conditions of Corporate Governance. It is neither an audit nor an expression of opinion on the financial statements of the
Company.
In our opinion and to the best of our information and according to the explanation given to us, we certify that the
Company has complied with the conditions of Corporate Governance as stipulated in the above mentioned Listing
Agreement.
We further state that no investor grievance is pending for a period exceeding one month against the Company as per
records maintained by the shareholder/ Investor Grievance Committee.
We further state that such compliances is neither an assurance as to the future viability of the Company nor the efficiency
or effectiveness with which the management has conducted the affairs of the Company.
For Lodha & Co
Chartered Accountants
HK Verma
Place: Kolkata Partner
Date: 29th day of May, 2006 Membership No. 55104
40
Star
Pap
er M
ills
Lim
ited
Ann
ual R
epor
t 20
05-6
Financial section
41
We have audited the attached Balance Sheet of Star Paper MillsLimited as at 31st March 2006 and also the Profit and Lossaccount and the cash flow statement for the year ended onthat date annexed thereto. These financial statements are theresponsibility of the Company's management. Ourresponsibility is to express an opinion on these financialstatements based on our audit.
We conducted our audit in accordance with the auditingstandards generally accepted in India. Those Standards requirethat we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonableassurance about whether the financial statements are free ofmaterial misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a testbasis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in thefinancial statements. An audit also includes assessing theaccounting principles used and significant estimates made bymanagement, as well as evaluating the overall financialstatement presentation. We believe that our audit provides areasonable basis for our opinion.
1. As required by the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order,2003 ('the order') issued by the Central Government ofIndia in terms of sub-section (4A) of section 227 of theCompanies Act, 1956 and in terms of the information andexplanations given to us and also on the basis of suchchecks as we considered appropriate, we state that:
I. Fixed Assetsa. The Company has maintained proper records showing
full particulars including quantitative details andsituation of fixed assets.
b. All the assets have not been physically verified by themanagement during the year but there is regularprogramme of verification, which, in our opinion, isreasonable having regard to the size of the Companyand the nature of its assets. There were no materialdiscrepancies with regard to book records in respectof the assets verified during the year.
c. During the year, the Company has not disposed off asubstantial part of its fixed assets.
II. Inventorya. The inventory has been physically verified by the
management at regular intervals during the year. Inour opinion and according to the information andexplanations given to us, the frequency of verificationis reasonable.
b. In our opinion, the procedure for the physicalverification of the inventory followed by the
management is reasonable and adequate in relationto the size of the Company and the nature of itsbusiness.
c. The Company is maintaining proper records ofinventory. As explained to us, discrepancies noticedon physical verification of inventory were not material.
III. Loans, secured or unsecured, granted or taken by theCompany to/from companies, firms or other partiescovered in the register maintained under Section 301 ofthe Companies Act, 1956:
a. The Company has granted unsecured loans to threecompanies. The maximum amount and year-endbalance of such loans were Rs 1564.26 lacs andRs.1343.85 lacs respectively.
b. In respect of loan referred to in Note 7(b) of Schedule16, the principal and interest thereon are repayableafter repayments to Financial Institutions. Other thanthis, in respect of loans given by the company, therate of interest and other terms and conditionsthereof are not prima facie prejudicial to the interestof the Company.
c. There is no overdue amount of loans taken by orgranted to the Company except in case of loansgranted by the company as stated in note 7(b) ofschedule 16 and Rs. 22 lakhs from one of the bodycorporates.
d. Steps for recovery except in cases of loans of Rs.1200lacs and interest there on, where reference has beenmade to BIFR and recovery will be dependent uponrevival scheme to be formulated /sanctioned by BIFR,has been taken.
e. The Company has taken unsecured loan from oneCompany. The maximum amount during the year ofsuch loan was Rs.51.65 lacs and the amountremaining unpaid at the year- end was Rs.1.65 lacs.
f. The loan taken by the Company is free of interest andis not due for repayment at the year-end.
g. There is no overdue amount of the principal repayableat the year end.
IV. In our opinion there are adequate internal controlprocedures commensurate with the size of the Companyand the nature of its business with regard to purchases ofinventory, fixed assets and with regard to the sale of goodsand services. During the course of our audit, no major
To The Members of Star Paper Mills Limited
Auditors’ Report
42
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
weakness has been noticed in the internal controls.
V. Transaction covered under Section 301 of the CompaniesAct, 1956a. According to the information and explanations given
to us there are no transactions during the year, whichare required to be entered into the registermaintained under Section 301 of the Companies Act,1956.
b. Accordingly, the provisions of clause v (b) of the Orderare not applicable to the Company.
VI. In our opinion and according to the information andexplanations given to us, the Company has complied withthe provisions of Section 58A and 58AA or any otherrelevant provision of the Companies Act, 1956 and theCompanies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 1975 withregard to deposits accepted from the public.
VII. In our opinion and according to the information andexplanations given to us, the Company has an internalaudit system commensurate with the size of the Companyand nature of its business.
VIII.We have broadly reviewed the books of accountmaintained by the Company pursuant to the Rules madeby the Central Government for the maintenance of costrecords under Section 209 (1) (d) of the Companies Act,1956 in respect of the Company's product to which thesaid rules are applicable and are of the opinion that primafacie the prescribed records have been made andmaintained. We have not, however, made a detailedexamination of the said records.
IX. Statutory Duesa. According to the records of the Company, the
Company is generally regular in depositing withappropriate authorities undisputed statutory duesincluding Provident Fund, Investor Education andProtection Fund, Employees' State Insurance, Income-tax, Sales-tax, Wealth-tax, Service Tax, Custom Duty,Excise Duty, Cess and other statutory dues applicableto it. According to the information and explanationsgiven to us, no undisputed amounts payable inrespect of aforesaid dues were outstanding, as at 31stMarch 2006 for a period of more than six monthsfrom the date they became payable.
X. The Company does not have any accumulated losses. TheCompany has not incurred any cash losses during thefinancial year covered by our audit and the immediatelypreceding financial year.
XI. Based on our audit procedures and on the informationand explanations given by the management, we are ofthe opinion that during the year the Company has notdefaulted in repayment of dues to financial institutions,bank or debenture holders.
XII. Based on our examination of documents and records andaccording to information and explanations given to us,we are of the opinion that the Company has not grantedloans and advances on the basis of security by way ofpledge of shares, debentures and other securities.
XIII. In our opinion, the Company is not a chit fund or a nidhimutual benefit fund / society. Accordingly, theprovisions of clause 3 (xiii) a to d of the Order are notapplicable to the Company.
b. According to the records of the Company and according to the information and explanation given to us by themanagement, the details of disputed statutory dues are as below:
Name of the Statute Nature of Forum where dispute Period to which Amount
the Dues is pending the amounts relate (Rs. in Lacs)
(Financial Year)
The Central Excise Duty Supreme Court 2002-03, 2003-04 4.68
Excise Act, 1944 High Court, Kolkata 1982 5.68
CESTAT 1989-99 3.21
The Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax High Court at Allahabad 1980-81, 1986-1989 75.83
Trade Tax Act, 1948 Trade Tax Tribunal 2000-01 1.68
The Central Sales Tax High Court at Allahabad 1995-1996 18.80
Sales Tax Act, 1956 Trade Tax Tribunal 1996-97 8.59
The Delhi sales Tax Act. Sales Tax Assistant Commissioner 2002-03 2.09
43
XIV. In our opinion, the Company is not dealing in or tradingin shares, securities, debentures and other investments.Accordingly, the provisions of clause 3 (xiv) of the Orderare not applicable to the Company.
XV. The Company has not given guarantees for loans takenby others from bank or financial institutions.
XVI. The Company has utilized the term loan for the purposefor which they were raised.
XVII. On an overall examination of the balance sheet of theCompany, we are of the opinion that no funds raised onshort- term basis have been used for long-terminvestment.
XVIII.The Company has not made any preferential allotment ofshares to parties and companies covered in the registermaintained under Section 301 of the Companies Act,1956.
XIX. The Company has created security in respect ofdebentures issued.
XX. The Company has not raised money by public issuesduring the year.
XXI. Based upon the audit procedures performed andinformation and explanations given by themanagement, we report that no fraud on or by theCompany has been noticed or reported during thecourse of our audit.
2. Attention is invited to notes (i) 7(b) of schedule 16,regarding certain overdue loans including interestthereon, in respect of which revenue recognitionshortfall and their impact, being currently notascertained have not been recognised in theseaccounts and as such cannot be commented uponby us; (ii) Non provision of dimunition in value ofinvestments as given in Note 9 of Schedule 16, theimpact whereof though likely to be material, inabsence of an independent valuation as such ispresently not ascertainable.
3. Further to above, we report that:
(i) We have obtained all the information andexplanations, which to the best of ourknowledge and belief were necessary for thepurposes of our audit;
(ii) In our opinion, proper books of account asrequired by law have been kept by the
Company so far as appears from ourexamination of those books;
(iii) The balance sheet, profit and loss account andcash flow statement dealt with by this reportare in agreement with the books of account;
(iv) In our opinion, the balance sheet, profit andloss account and cash flow statement dealtwith by this report comply with the accountingstandards referred to in sub-section (3C) ofsection 211 of the Companies Act, 1956;
(v) On the basis of information available with theCompany and written representations receivedfrom the directors, and taken on record by theBoard of Directors, we report that none of thedirectors is disqualified as on 31st March 2006from being appointed as directors in terms ofsection 274(1) (g) of the Companies Act 1956;
(vi) In our opinion and to the best of ourinformation and according to the explanationsgiven to us, the said accounts subject toparagraph 2 above the impact of which couldnot be ascertained and read together withnotes thereon give the information required bythe Companies Act, 1956, in the manner sorequired and give a true and fair view inconformity with the accounting principlesgenerally accepted in India:
a) in the case of the balance sheet, of thestate of affairs of the Company as at 31stMarch 2006;
b) in the case of the profit and loss account,of the profit for the year ended on thatdate; and
c) in the case of the cash flow statement, ofthe cash flows for the year ended on thatdate.
For Lodha & Co.,Chartered Accountants
H. K. VermaPlace: Kolkata Partner
Date: 29th day of May 2006 Membership Number: 55104
44
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Balance SheetAs at March 31, 2006
(Rs. in Lakhs)Schedule 31.3.2006 31.3.2005
I. SOURCES OF FUNDS
Shareholders' Funds
Share Capital 1 1560.83 1560.83
Reserves and Surplus 2 9111.91 8497.73
10672.74 10058.56
Loan Funds
Secured Loans 3 6441.30 4397.27
Unsecured Loans 4 9.81 70.18
6451.11 4467.45
Deferred tax Liabilities(Net) 2267.89 1941.80
19391.74 16467.81
II. APPLICATION OF FUNDS
Fixed Assets 5
Gross Block 20566.10 17229.58
Less: Depreciation 7639.95 6747.37
Net Block 12926.15 10482.21
Capital Expenditure in Progress 1342.35 1369.15
14268.50 11851.36
Investments 6 2107.21 1935.21
Current Assets, Loans and Advances
Inventories 7 3578.63 3199.00
Sundry Debtors 8 663.99 638.01
Cash and Bank Balances 9 133.91 114.08
Loans and Advances 10 2866.48 3115.27
7243.01 7066.36
Less: Current Liabilities and Provisions 11 4226.98 4385.12
Net Current Assets 3016.03 2681.24
19391.74 16467.81
Accounting Policies and Notes to the Accounts 16
The Schedules referred to above form part of the Balance Sheet
For Lodha & Co. On behalf of the BoardChartered accountants
H. K. Verma G P Goenka M P PintoPartner Chairman and Shiromani SharmaMembership No. 55104 Whole-Time Director P N Ghatalia
Shrivardhan GoenkaPlace: Kolkata Madhukar Misra Supriya GuptaDated: 29th May, 2006 Managing Director Directors
45
Profit and Loss AccountFor the year ended March 31, 2006
(Rs. in Lakhs)Schedule 31.3.2006 31.3.2005
INCOMESales (Gross) 21836.11 21195.78Less: Excise Duty 3044.69 3037.49Sales (Net) 18791.42 18158.29 Other Income 12 397.59 437.20
19189.01 18595.49 EXPENDITUREDecrease/(Increase) in Stocks 13 127.71 (141.46)Raw Materials Consumed 4672.72 3334.83 Manufacturing, Administrative and Selling Expenses 14 11387.16 10911.78 Interest and Finance Charges(Net) 15 555.43 630.31
16743.02 14735.46Profit before Depreciation 2445.99 3860.03Depreciation 893.95 736.36 Profit before Exceptional and Non-recurring Items 1552.04 3123.67– Amount written off in respect of loan and Interest accrued (91.68) (98.03)Profit before tax 1460.36 3025.64Provision for Income Tax– Fringe Benefit Tax 16.00– Current 190.00 493.74 – Deferred 326.09 514.26
532.09 1008.00Profit after Tax 928.27 2017.64Profit brought forward 2765.15 1361.36 Profit available for Appropriation 3693.42 3379.00AppropriationsProposed Dividend 273.15 273.15 Tax on Proposed Dividend 38.32 35.70 Tax on Dividend for earlier years 2.62 –Transfer to Debenture Redemption Reserve 150.00 150.00 Transfer to General Reserve 100.00 155.00 Balance Carried To The Balance Sheet 3,129.33 2,765.15
3693.42 3379.00 Basic & Diluted earning per Share (Rs.) 5.95 12.93 (Equity Shares of Face Value of Rs. 10 each)Number of shares used in computing earning per Share
Basic & Diluted 15608350 15608350Accounting Policies and Notes to the Accounts 16
This is the Profit & Loss Account referred to in our Report of even date
For Lodha & Co. On behalf of the BoardChartered accountants
H. K. Verma G P Goenka M P PintoPartner Chairman and Shiromani SharmaMembership No. 55104 Whole-Time Director P N Ghatalia
Shrivardhan GoenkaPlace: Kolkata Madhukar Misra Supriya GuptaDated: 29th May, 2006 Managing Director Directors
46
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Cash Flow StatementFor the year ended March 31, 2006
(Rs. in Lakhs)31.3.2006 31.3.2005
A. CASH FLOW FROM OPERATING ACTIVITIESNet Profit/(Loss) before Tax 1,460.36 3,025.64
Adjustments for:
Depreciation 893.95 736.36
Loss/(Profit) on sale of Fixed Assets (9.65) (52.28)
Dividend Income (4.41) (10.16)
Interest and Finance Charges (Net) 555.43 630.31
Loss/(Profit) on sale of current investments – (0.27)
Cash Flow Before Extra-Ordinary Items 2,895.68 4,329.60 Irrecoverable advance/interest written off 91.68 98.03
Operating Profit before Working Capital Changes 2,987.36 4,427.63Adjustments for:
Trade and Other Receivables 113.44 (50.59)
Inventories (379.62) (333.93)
Trade and Other Payables (75.02) 786.45
Cash generated from Operations 2,646.16 4,829.56
Income Tax Paid (232.30) (574.26)
Net Cash from Operating Activities 2,413.86 4,255.30B. CASH FLOW FROM INVESTING ACTIVITIES
Purchase of Fixed Assets (3,482.17) (2,736.34)
Purchase of Investment (172.00) –
Sale of Fixed Assets 9.71 69.18
Profit on sale of Investments 0.00 0.27
Dividend 4.41 10.16
Interest Income 92.85 156.44
Net Cash from Investing Activities (3,547.20) (2,500.29)C. CASH FLOW FROM FINANCING ACTIVITIES
Long Term Borrowings 884.02 (1,064.48)
Short Term Borrowings 1,185.06 (234.71)
Dividend Paid (307.57) (260.50)
Interest paid (608.34) (775.47)
Net Cash from Financing Activities 1,153.17 (2,335.16)Net Increase/(Decrease) in Cash and Cash Equivalents 19.83 (580.15)Cash and Cash Equivalents at the begining of the year 114.08 694.23 Cash and Cash Equivalents at the end of the year 133.91 114.08
For Lodha & Co. On behalf of the BoardChartered accountants
H. K. Verma G P Goenka M P PintoPartner Chairman and Shiromani SharmaMembership No. 55104 Whole-Time Director P N Ghatalia
Shrivardhan GoenkaPlace: Kolkata Madhukar Misra Supriya GuptaDated: 29th May, 2006 Managing Director Directors
47
Schedules to the AccountsAs at March 31, 2006 (Rs. in Lakhs)
31.3.2006 31.3.2005
1 SHARE CAPITAL
Authorized 10,000 5% Cumulative Tax Free Redeemable Preference Shares of Rs.100 each 10.00 10.003,98,00,000 Equity Shares of Rs.10 each 3980.00 3980.001,00,000 `A' Equity Shares of Rs.10 each 10.00 10.00
4000.00 4000.00Issued
1,55,11,250 Equity Shares of Rs.10 each 1551.12 1551.121,00,000 `A' Equity Shares of Rs.10 each 10.00 10.00
1561.12 1561.12Subscribed & Paid-up
1,55,08,350 Equity Shares of Rs.10 each fully paid-up (including 8,96,875 EquityShares allotted as fully paid-up Bonus Shares by capitalization of Reserves) 1550.83 1550.831,00,000 `A' Equity Shares of Rs.10 each fully paid-up 10.00 10.00
1560.83 1560.83
2 RESERVES AND SURPLUS
Capital ReserveRevaluation Reserve (as per last account) – 5747.38Less: Adjustment in respect of fixed assets sold/discarded (Net) – –
– 5747.38Less: Transfer to Profit and Loss Account – 0.00
– 5747.38Less: Revaluation Reserve reversed – 5747.38
– 0.00Other Reserve (As per last account) 3.20 3.20
3.20 3.20Capital Redemption ReserveAs per last account 50.00 50.00Debenture Redemption ReserveAs per last account 300.00 150.00Add:-Transfer from Profit and Loss Account 150.00 150.00
450.00 300.00Share Premium AccountAs per last account 4459.50 4459.50General ReserveAs per last account 919.88 764.88 Add:-Transfer from Profit and Loss Account 100.00 155.00
1019.88 919.88 Profit and Loss Account 3129.33 2765.15
9111.91 8497.73
48
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
(Rs. in Lakhs)31.3.2006 31.3.2005
3 SECURED LOANS
Rupee Term Loan from Financial Institutions (including funded interest term loan) 2547.87 3312.36Punjab National Bank(PNB) 1771.02 –Bank of Baroda(BOB) – 122.52
Debentures (privately placed) 600.00 600.00Working Capital Demand Loan and Cash Credit from Banks (including FCNR(B) facility) 1522.41 362.39
6441.30 4397.27
Notes:
1 (i) Rupee Term Loans from Financial Institutions are secured by way of first mortgage and charge on the immoveable
properties (except property at Kalol Distt: Mehsana in Gujarat, specfic assets acquired / to be acquired under term loan
from PNB and certain other properties at Saharanpur) and hypothecation of all the moveables, present and future, in
favour of the lenders (Financial Institutions) save and except book-debts, subject to prior charges created and/or to be
created in favour of the bankers on the stocks of raw materials, semi-finished and finished goods, consumable stores
including in transit and book debts for securing the working capital requirements, ranking pari-passu with the
charges created/to be created in favour of the Financial Institutions. The term loan from IDBI to the extent of Rs701.65
lakhs(Previous year Rs.1002.15)and from ICICI to the extent of Rs 650.00lakhs(Previous year Rs.750.00 lakhs) are further
secured by the personal guarantee of a Director and a corporate guarantee, respectively. These will be further secured by
way of second charge on assets acquired/ to be acquired under the term loan from PNB
ii) Rupee Term Loan from Punjab National Bank is secured by Exclusive First Charge by way of hypothication of specific plant
and machinery and moveable fixed assets acquired / to be acquired under the modernisation project being implemented
by the company, extension of charges on current assets,ranking pari-passu interse with charges created / to be created
in favour of consortium of bankers (BOB and PNB) providing working capital facilities to the Company. The loan is to be
further secured by way of second charge on other fixed assets of the Company subject to and subservient to the subsisting
first charge in favour of existing charge holders.
iii) Debentures represents 600,000 14% Non Convertible Secured Redeemable Debentures (NCD's) of Rs.100/- each. These
are secured by way of English mortgage of plot at Kalol, Distt: Mehsana in Gujarat, extension of first mortgage and
charge on the immoveable properties (except specific assets acquired / to be acquired under term loan from PNB) for
rupee term loan and hypothecation of all the moveables, present and future, in favour of the Debentures Trustees
save and except assets purchased under the bills re-discounting scheme and book-debts, subject to prior charges
created and/or to be created in favour of the bankers on the stocks of raw materials, semi-finished and finished goods,
consumable stores including in transit and book debts for securing the working capital requirements, ranking
pari-passu with the charges created/to be created in favour of the Financial Institutions and the personal guarantee of
a Director. These will be further secured by way of second charge on assets acquired/ to be acquired under the term loan
from PNB. These (NCD's) are redeemable at par in four equal installments commencing from March, 2007.
2 Working Capital Demand Loan, Cash Credit, FCNR(B) and other Working Capital facilities from Banks are secured by way of
hypothecation of stocks of finished goods, raw materials, chemicals, stores, other materials including those in transit,
book-debts both present and future and second charge on the fixed assets of the company, ranking pari-passu in favour of
the banks.
3 In respect of Rupee Term Loans of Rs.2547.87 lakhs (Previous year Rs.3212.36 lakhs) from the Financial Institutions, under
certain circumstances of default by the company, the Financial Institutions have an option to convert either the whole of the
outstanding amount of the loans or a part thereof not exceeding 20% of the loans, whichever is lower, into fully paid
up Equity Shares of the company at par.
Schedules to the AccountsAs at March 31, 2006
49
Schedules to the AccountsAs at March 31, 2006 (Rs. in Lakhs)
31.3.2006 31.3.2005
4 UNSECURED LOANS
Fixed Deposits 8.16 18.53Short Term Loans from Bodies Corporate 1.65 51.65
9.81 70.18
31.3.2006 31.3.2005
6 INVESTMENTS (Long Term other than Trade)No. of
Shares/ UnitsQuotedFully Paid Equity Shares of Rs.10 each:
Gujarat Carbon & Industries Ltd. 50000 5.00 5.00Duncans Industries Ltd. 3815000 1182.65 1182.65NRC Ltd. 313922 10.36 10.36Andhra Cements Ltd. 8000000 720.00 720.00Bank of Baroda 20000 9.20 9.20
1927.21 1927.21UnquotedGujarat Carbon & Industries Ltd. 1720000 172.00 – (10% Cumulative Redeemable Preference shares of Rs 10 Each)E.Hill & Co. Ltd. 80000 8.00 8.00
2107.21 1935.21Aggregate amount of:
Quoted Investments 1927.21 1927.21(Market value - Rs.3908.67 lakhs Previous year - Rs.2755.57 lakhs)Unquoted Investments 180.00 8.00
2107.21 1935.21
5 FIXED ASSETS
GROSS BLOCK DEPRECIATION NET BLOCKParticulars As on Reval- Additions Adjust- As on Upto Reval- For the Adjust- Upto As on As on
1.4.2005 -uation during the ments 31.3.2006 31.3.2005 -uation year ments 31.3.2006 31.3.2006 31.3.2005Reserve Period during Reserve during
reversed the Period reversed the year
Land 20.99 – – – 20.99 – – – – – 20.99 20.99
Buildings 660.43 – 161.82 – 822.25 375.62 – 29.51 – 405.13 417.12 284.81
Machinery 16,239.22 – 3,158.02 1.44 19,395.80 6,184.94 – 834.17 1.37 7,017.74 12,378.06 10,054.28
Railway Siding 6.83 – – – 6.83 6.66 – 0.02 – 6.68 0.15 0.17
Furniture and 177.44 – 12.40 – 189.84 137.17 – 8.44 – 145.61 44.23 40.27 Fittings
Vehicles 124.67 – 5.72 – 130.39 42.98 – 21.81 – 64.79 65.60 81.69
Total 17,229.58 – 3,337.96 1.44 20,566.10 6,747.37 – 893.95 1.37 7,639.95 12,926.15 10,482.21 Previous Year 22,761.77 7,432.87 2,095.39 194.71 17,229.58 7,874.10 1,685.49 736.36 177.60 6,747.37 10,482.21
Note:
1) Gross block and Net block of Buildings include flat acquired under joint ownership with others at New Delhi amounting Rs.55.30 Lakhs and Rs49.91 Lakhs. (Previous Year Rs. 55.30
Lakhs and Rs 52.54 Lakhs) respectively
2) Gross block and net block of machinery includes amounting Rs.21.27 Lakhs and Rs.18.65 Lakhs taken on lease respectively
50
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Schedules to the AccountsAs at March 31, 2006 (Rs. in Lakhs)
31.3.2006 31.3.2005
6 INVESTMENTS (Long Term other than Trade) (Contd.)
Notes1. Out of 3815000 equity shares 3769900 equity shares of Duncan
Industries Ltd.have been pledged on behalf of an associate company enabling them to avail certain relief from a financial Institution.
2. Subsequent to the date of Balance sheet,equity shares of Andhra Cements Limited have been pledged on behalf of an associate company enabling them to avail financial assistance from a financial institution
3. Details of current Investments purchased and sold during the year are as under.
No. of Units No. of UnitsFranklin Templeton Investment (Face Value Rs 10 Each) – 1507047HDFC Mutual Fund Income Fund (Face Value Rs.10 Each) – 997042Standard Chartered Mutual Fund (Face Value Rs 10 Each) – 990615LIC Mutual Fund (Face Value Rs 10 Each) – 6050515ILFS Mutual fund Dividend Plan – 1007480SBI Futual Fund (Face Value Rs 10 Each) – 1521996
7 INVENTORIES (As certified by the Management)
Spare Parts, Components, other Consumable Stores etc.(Includes Rs.1.34 lakhs Previous year Rs 1.34 lakhs of discarded assets) 597.53 513.75Raw Materials 2451.63 2023.95Chemicals and Dyes 119.21 123.01Loose Tools 0.53 0.85Finished Paper 190.66 300.93Stock in Process 219.07 234.56Wrapper – 1.95
3578.63 3199.00
8 SUNDRY DEBTORS (Considered good unless otherwise stated)
Debts due for a period exceeding six monthsSecured 23.35 33.49Unsecured 19.10 14.95
42.45 48.44Other Debts
Secured 345.20 281.02Unsecured 276.34 308.55
621.54 589.57663.99 638.01
51
Schedules to the AccountsAs at March 31, 2006
31.3.2006 31.3.2005
9 CASH AND BANK BALANCESCash and stamps on hand 12.44 10.18Cheques/Drafts on hand and/or in transit 2.48 28.67Balances with Scheduled Banks– In Current Accounts 72.67 30.85– In Unpaid Dividend Accounts 16.84 12.94– In Deposit/Margin Money Accounts (Receipts of Rs.Nil lakhs, 27.31 29.36
previous year Rs.0.17 lakhs, lying with Government Authorities)In Fixed Deposit/Saving Accounts (Employees Security Deposits) 2.17 2.08
133.91 114.08
(Rs. in Lakhs)
10 LOANS AND ADVANCES (Unsecured considered good unless otherwise stated)
Loans 1310.46 1575.00Advances recoverable in cash or in kind or for value to be received 406.62 430.30Advance payment of Income-Tax including Tax deducted at source 2663.42 2431.12Less: Provision for Taxation 2177.43 1987.43
485.99 443.69Balances with Customs and Excise 435.82 432.99Deposits with Government Authorities and Others 227.59 233.29
2866.48 3115.27
11 CURRENT LIABILITIES AND PROVISIONS
Current LiabilitiesAcceptances 31.39 –Sundry Creditors
Dues to small scale industrial undertakings 80.10 37.18Dues to others (including project creditors Rs.162.31 Lakhs 2615.69 2966.45Previous year Rs.283.48 Lakhs)VAT payable 24.30 –
Unclaimed liabilities in respect ofRedeemed Preference Shares 1.76 1.76Unclaimed Dividend * 16.82 12.94Deposits from whole sellers 605.34 519.92Interest accrued but not due on Loans 79.35 79.84
3454.75 3618.09ProvisionsProposed Dividend 273.15 273.15 Tax on Proposed Dividend 38.32 35.70 Provision for leave encashment and pension 460.76 458.18
772.23 767.03 4226.98 4385.12
Note:
*This is not due for payment to 'Investor Education and Protection Fund'.
The names of SSI undertakings to the extent such creditors have been identified from the information available with the company and
outstanding more than 30 days as per agreed terms are: Cardinal Chemicals Pvt. Limited, D. B. Engineering Pvt. Ltd., Indo Dynamics Pvt. Ltd.,
Khyati Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., M F Resins Manufacturing Company, Nainital Woven Sacks Pvt. Ltd., K D Traders, Orient Packing Ltd., Pal Minerals
Industries Pvt. Ltd., Rishab Metals & Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., Sonar Airotech Pvt. Ltd.,
52
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Schedules to the AccountsAs at March 31, 2006
31.3.2006 31.3.2005
12 OTHER INCOMESale of Scrap, etc. 179.24 183.72
Income on Investments-Other than trade:
– Dividend on long term Investments 4.41 2.62
– Dividend on current Investments – 7.54
– Profit on Sale of current Investments – 0.27
4.41
Profit on Sale/Discard of Fixed Assets(Net) 9.65 52.28
Liabilities and balances no longer required 115.17 58.18
Provision for doubtful debts written back – 0.50
Miscellaneous 89.12 132.09
397.59 437.20
(Rs. in Lakhs)
13 DECREASE/ (INCREASE) IN STOCKS
Opening Stock
Stock in Process 234.56 120.19
Finished Paper 300.93 275.79
Wrapper 1.95 –
537.44 395.98
Closing Stock
Stock in Process 219.07 234.56
Finished Paper 190.66 300.93
Wrapper – 1.95
409.73 537.44
127.71 (141.46)
53
Schedules to the AccountsFor the year ended March 31, 2006
31.3.2006 31.3.2005
14 MANUFACTURING, SELLING AND ADMINISTGRATIVE EXPENSESSalaries, Wages, Bonus, Gratuity etc. 1876.89 1761.78
Contribution to:
Provident and Other Funds 208.07 233.60
Employees State Insurance 56.83 47.11
Workmen and Staff Welfare Expenses 130.67 117.23
Chemicals and Dyes consumed 2120.96 2317.19
Stores and Components consumed 886.93 940.08
Power and Fuel 4639.36 3765.04
Repairs to:
Buildings 141.53 236.83
Machinery 360.76 525.68
Others 5.74 7.86
Rent 53.32 49.18
Rates and Taxes 73.10 77.97
Excise Duty on Stocks (Net) (28.77) 6.16
Insurance 60.70 71.11
Freight, Transportation etc. 184.60 167.01
Charity and Donations 3.16 8.24
Directors' Fees 1.80 1.90
Research and Development Expenses 21.26 24.47
Irrecoverable Balance/debts written off 10.08 235.09
Provision for doubtful debts – (235.09)
Miscellaneous Expenses 580.17 553.34
11387.16 10911.78
(Rs. in Lakhs)
15 INTEREST AND FINANCE CHARGES
On Debentures and Fixed Loans 458.20 621.29On Other Accounts 132.85 70.39
591.05 691.68Less: Interest Income(Gross) (Tax deducted at source Rs.10.23 lakhs, previous year Rs 28.08 lakhs) 48.85 125.02
542.20 566.66Finance Charges 13.23 63.65
555.43 630.31
54
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Schedules to the Accounts
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS
1. Accounting Policiesi) General
a) These accounts have been prepared on historical cost assets and on the accounting principles of going concern.
b) Accounting policies are consistent and are in consonance with generally accepted accounting principles.
ii) Use of EstimatesThe preparation of financial Statements require management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the
reported amount of assets and liabilities and disclosures relating to contingent liabilities and assets as at the Balance
Sheet date and the reported amounts of income and expenses during the year. Difference between the actual results
and the estimates are recognised in the year in which the results become known/ materialise.
iii) Fixed AssetsFixed assets are stated at cost of acquisition/construction. Cost includes interest and pre-operative expenses as allocated
to the fixed assets.
iv) InvestmentsLong-term investments are stated at cost less diminution in the values thereof, other than temporary.
v) Inventoriesa) Inventories are valued at cost or estimated net realisable value whichever is lower. The value of inventories other
than raw materials is determined on weighted average basis. The value of raw materials is determined by first in
first out method. Cost of raw materials includes expenses incurred for procuring the same. Cost in respect of
finished goods, stock in process and wrapper represents manufacturing cost and does not include interest, selling
and distribution and certain administrative overheads.
b) Customs duty on materials in bond and excise duty on finished goods lying in the factory as at the year-end is
considered as cost for valuation of stocks.
vi) Impairment Fixed Assets are reviewed at each balance sheet date for impairment. In case events and circumstances indicate any
impairment, recoverable amount of fixed assets is determined. An impairment loss is recognised, whenever the carrying
amounts of assets exceeds recoverable amount. The recoverable amount is the greater of assets net selling price or its
value in use. In assessing the value in use, the estimated future cash flows from the use of assets are discounted to their
present value at appropriate rate. An impairment loss is reversed if there has been change in the recoverable amount
and such loss either no longer exists or has decreased. Impairment loss/reversal thereof is adjusted to the carrying value
of the respective assets.
vii) Foreign Exchange TransactionsTransactions in foreign currencies are accounted for at the exchange rate prevailing on the date of the transaction.
Foreign currency monetary assets and liabilities at the year end are translated using closing exchange rates. The loss or
gain thereon and also on the exchange differences on settlement of foreign currency transactions during the year are
recognised as income or expenses and are adjusted to the profit and loss account under respective heads of accounts,
except in cases (a) where such liabilities and/or transactions relate to fixed assets/ projects and these were entered into
before 1-4-2004; (b) fixed assets acquired from a country outside India, in which case, these are adjusted to the cost of
respective fixed assets.
viii) Revenue Recognitiona) Revenue is being recognised on accrual basis.
b) All expenses, claims, interest on overdue debts/demands and other incomes to the extent ascertainable and
considered payable or receivable as the case may be, have been accounted for.
55
Schedules to the Accounts
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
ix) SalesSales are recognised on passing of the property in the goods as per the terms of the sales, irrespective of actual delivery.
Sales include excise duty and incidental charges but rebates, discounts and Sales Tax/Value Addred Tax(VAT) are
excluded therefrom.
x) Retirement Benefitsa) Liability for gratuity is provided on the basis of actuarial valuation and the amount thereof is funded to the extent
required in terms of scheme with the Life Insurance Corporation of India.
b) Liability for Leave Encashment is provided on the basis of actuarial valuation.
c) Contribution towards Provident Fund are accounted for according to the rules of the Funds.
d) Provision for pension to employees under non-funded Pension Scheme has been made on actuarial valuation.
xi) Borrowing CostsBorrowing costs that are attributable to the acquisition/construction of fixed assets are capitalised as part of the assets.
Other borrowing costs are recognised as expenses in the year in which they are incurred.
xii) DepreciationDepreciation has been provided for as per Schedule XIV of the Companies Act, 1956, on written down value method
and in respect of plant and machinery acquired on or after 1.4.76, on straight-line method. Certain plants have been
considered as continuous process plants on technical evaluation.
xiii) Income TaxProvision for Tax is made for both current and deferred taxes. Current Tax is provided on the taxable income using the
applicable tax rates and tax laws. Deferred tax assets and liabilities arising on account of timing differences, which are
capable of reversal in subsequent periods are recognized using tax rates and tax laws, which have been enacted or
substantively enacted. Deferred Tax Asset is recognized and carried forward only to the extent there is virtual certainty
that asset will be realised in future.
xiv) Provision, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent AssetsProvisions involving substantial degree of estimation in measurement are recognised when there is a present obligation
as a result of past events and it is probable that there will be an outflow of resources. Contingent Assets are neither
recognized nor disclosed in the financial statements.
2. Estimated amount of contracts remaining to be executed on capital account (net of advances) Rs. 1313.21 lakhs (Previous
year Rs.1038.92 lakhs).
3. Contingent Liabilities
(Rs. in Lakhs)Sl. No. Particulars 31.3.2006 31.3.2005
A In respect of various demands raised, Which in the opinion of the management are not tenable and are under appeal at various stages:
i. Sales Tax 3.08 2.09ii Excise Duty 4.68 1.76iii Electricity Duty 2.70 2.70iv Employees State Insurance Corporation (On Good work bonus) 4.90 4.90
B Workmen Claims 50.11 37.72C Interest on Mandi Fee, if any, is disputed by the Company and is sub
judice(amount un-ascertainable).D Gurantees given by bank on behalf of the company 105.81 110.81
56
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Schedules to the Accounts
4. Capital Expenditure in Progress of Rs.1342.35 lakhs includes machinery in stock, construction/erection materials, advances forconstruction/erection works and machinery etc. and the following pre-operative expenses.
5. The Company has been legally advised that notwithstanding the capitalisation of interest and replacement cost of worn outspare parts of certain plant and machinery in earlier years, these are to be considered as allowable for determination of Taxliability in view of various court decisions.
6. Pursuant to the order of the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) and the Scheme of Rehabilitationsanctioned by it in June 1994, Duncans Industries Ltd. (DIL) had acquired the control of Andhra Cements Ltd. (ACL). In termsof the agreement with DIL to participate in the said Scheme, the Company as an associate of DIL had subscribed for 80 lakhsequity shares of ACL at par.
7. a. Pursuant to a settlement arrived at with Bakelite Hylam Ltd., an erstwhile associate company Rs.91.63 lakhs out of theloan and interest accrued thereon, being no longer receivable has been written off and shown under exceptional andnon recurring items in these accounts
b. In terms of the restructuring scheme sanctioned by the Financial Institutions to an associate company, the loan ofRs.1200 lakhs given to that company and the interest thereon at the rates specified in the said scheme are not repayableby the said company during the currency of the Institutional loans to that company. A reference has been made to BIFRfor revival of the said company. Pending finalisation of the scheme by BIFR, the said amount has been considered goodand recoverable. Accordingly, no interest is being provided in these Accounts.
8. During the year, assumption with regard to future increase in salary considered for acturial valuation of Gratuity at the yearend has been revised taking into account the latest increase in salaries & wages. Consequent upon, this change in estimates,gratuity provision to the extent of Rs.25.44 lakhs being no longer required has been written back and charge for the year onaccount of this is lower to the extent of Rs.95.11 lakhs.
9. Revenue recognition in respect of diminution of Rs.495.95 lakhs in the value of investments in Duncans Industries Limitedhas not been made in these accounts since these are long term strategic investments.
10. In terms of modifications to the restructuring of loans and NCD's, in earlier years the Financial Institutions have requested foran option to convert outstanding Funded Interest Term Loan during its currency (outstanding balance as on 31 March, 2006Rs.218.69 lakhs, Previous year Rs.277.01 lakhs) at par into equity. The company had sought modification and/or waiver tothe said condition together with certain other terms and conditions.
11. The break-up of Deferred Tax Assets and Liabilities is follows:
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
(Rs. in Lakhs)31.3.2006 31.3.2005
Interest, other financial charges 113.47 39.78Add : Expenditure upto previous year pending Allocation 11.26 –
124.73 39.78Less : Allocation to Fixed Assets 96.18 28.52
28.55 11.26
(Rs. in Lakhs)
Deferred Tax AssetsExpenses Allowable on Payment Basis and Others 471.68 37.41 509.09Sub Total 471.68 37.41 509.09Deferred Tax LiabilitiesDepreciation and Other Items 2413.48 363.50 2776.98Deferred Tax Liabilities (Net) 1941.80 326.09 2267.89
Opening as on Charge/(Credit) Closing as on1st April, 2005 during the year 31st March, 2006
57
Schedules to the Accounts
12. Rs.12.20 lakhs(Previous year Rs. 17.09 lakhs, net gain) being net loss due to exchange rate variation with regard to foreigncurrency transactions have been adjusted against the respective heads of accounts and Rs. 0.93 lakhs (Previous year Rs1.14lakhs, net loss) being net loss have been added to the cost of fixed assets.
13. Future obligations toward lease rentals under finance lease agreements are as follows:
14. Related Party disclosures as identified by the management in accordance with the Accounting Standard 18 issued by theInstitute of Chartered Accountants of India:
(a) Key Management Personnel and their relativeMr. G. P. Goenka (Chairman and Whole Time Director)Mr. S . V . Goenka (Director and son of Whole Time Director)Mr. M. Mishra (Managing Director) Mrs. M. Mishra (Wife of Managing Director)
(b) Associates/Group Companiesi) With whom the Company had transactions
Duncans Industries Limited, Duncans Tea Limited, Consolidated Fibres and Chemicals Limited, Gujarat Carbon andIndustries Limited, NRC Limited, Andhra Cements Limited, Silent Valley Investment Company Limited, KavitaMarketing Private Limited, ISG Traders Limited, Shubh Shanti Services Limited, Sewand Investments Private Limited.Stone India Limited, Unimers India Limited
ii) OthersAlbert Trading Company Private Limited, Bargate Communications Private Limited, Boydell Media Private Limited,Continuous Forms (Calcutta) Limited, Dail Consultants Limited, Duncans Agro Chemicals Limited, Duncans BiotechLimited, Duncans Tea House Pvt. Limited, Halcyon properties Limited, Infratech software services Private Limited,Julex Commercial Company Limited, Leyden Leasing and Financial Services Limited, Maharastra PolybutenesLimited, Marleybone Travels and Resorts Private Limited, Napier Softech Private Limited, National Standard IndiaLimited, Octave Technologies Private Limited, Odyssey Travels Limited, Orchard Holdings Private Limited, Oxidesand Specialities Limited, Portland Holding Private Limited, Pallmall Adu Systems and Medicare Services PrivateLimited, Pentonville Software Limited, Santipara Tea Company Limited, Skylight Trading Company Limited, SprintTrading Company Limited.
The parties listed in (ii) above, though are not required to be disclosed as per the requirement of AS-18, have been includedhereinabove in view of the requirement of Clause 32 of the Listing Agreement.
The aggregate amount of transactions with the related parties as mentioned in (a) above is as below:
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
(Rs. in Lakhs)
Not Later than one year 6.12 6.73 5.44 5.99Later than one year but not later than five years 5.51 11.62 3.44 8.71
Period Lease payment Present Value2005-06 2004-05 2005-06 2004-05
(Rs. in Lakhs)Particulars 2005-06 2004-05Managerial Remuneration– Mr. G. P. Goenka 72.37 71.59– Mr. M.Mishra 43.39 41.28Expenditure– RentMrs. M. Mishra 12.00 12.00Outstanding – Security Deposit GivenMrs. M. Mishra 6.00 6.00
58
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Schedules to the Accounts
The aggregate amount of transactions with the related parties as mentioned in (b - i) above is as below:
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
(Rs. in Lakhs)Particulars 2005-06 2004-05IncomeSalesISG Traders Limited 73.46 75.12Interest
ISG Traders Limited 11.77 8.19Shubh Shanti Services Limited 11.90 11.90Silent Valley Investment Company Limited 4.05 4.05Services RenderedDuncans Industries Limited 0.62 0.76Andhra Cements Limited 0.82 0.60Stone India Limited 1.08 –Consolidated Fibres and Chemicals Limited 0.49 –Duncans Tea Limited – 0.89Others 0.09 0.55Expenditure Services ReceivedShubh Shanti Services Limited 0.10 –Odyssey Travels Ltd. 15.29 –Duncans Industries Ltd. 0.13 –RentKavita Marketing Private Limited 1.80 1.80Interest ISG Traders Limited 2.20 1.88Finance And InvestmentLoans RepaidDuncans Industries Limited 50.00 123.85Advance GivenISG Traders Limited 100.00 –Advance RealisedGujarat Carbon and Industries Limited 172.00 –ISG Traders Limited 100.00 –Bakelite Hylam Limited 7.15 –Security Deposit TakenISG Traders Limited – 10.00Investment Gujarat Carbon and Industries Limited 172.00 –Outstanding Loan takenDuncans Industries Limited 1.15 51.15Loan GivenConsolidated Fibres and Chemicals Limited 1200.00 1,200.00Bakelite Hylam Limited – 65.00Gujarat Carbon and Industries Limited – 172.00Silent Valley Investment Company Limited 22.50 22.50ISG Traders Limited 45.50 45.50Shubh Shanti Services Limited 42.46 70.00
59
Schedules to the Accounts
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
(Rs. in Lakhs)Particulars 2005-06 2004-05Interest ReceivableBakelite Hylam Limited – 33.83Gujarat Carbon and Industries Limited 63.00 100.00Silent Valley Investment Company Limited 2.35 2.35ISG Traders Limited 4.76 3.07Shubh Shanti Services Limited 38.39 10.35Security Deposit receivedISG Traders Limited 20.00 20.00Security Deposit GivenKavita Marketing Private Limited * 35.00 35.00Sewand Investments Private Limited. 5.00 5.00Debtor/Debit BalanceDuncans Industries Limited 0.94 0.42Duncans Tea Limited 3.57 4.04ISG Traders Limited 2.20 10.91Others 0.70 0.83Creditor/ Credit BalancesUnimer India Limited 0.02 –Odyssey Travels Ltd. 0.90 –Investment In SharesDuncans Industries Limited 1,182.65 1,182.65Gujarat Carbon and Industries Limited 177.00 5.00NRC Limited 10.36 10.36Andhra Cements Limited 720.00 720.00OthersFixed Assets PurchasedShubh Shanti Services Limited – 27.54Amount Written OffGujarat Carbon and Industries Limited 98.03Bakelite Hylam Limited 91.68 –
* a company in which one of the director is a director.
The Company has provided security to a Financial Institution for certain relief availed by an associate company (Refer Note No. 1 & 2 in Schedule 6).
15. Disclosure required vide Clause 32 of the listing Agreement.
a) Amount of loans/advances in the nature of loans outstanding from Associates/Group Companies during 2005-06 :
(Rs. in Lakhs)
Consolidated Fibres and Chemicals Limited 1200.00 1200.00Bakelite Hylam Limited - 98.83Gujarat Carbon and Industries Limited 63.00 272.00Silent Valley Investment Company Limited 24.85 24.85Shubh Shanti Services Limited 80.85 92.26ISG Traders Limited 50.26 50.26
Name of the Company At the maximum
year end during the year
60
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Schedules to the Accounts
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
(Rs. in Lakhs)
(Rs. in Lakhs)
b) Investment by loanee companies in the shares of the company:
Name of the Company At the year end Maximum during the year No. of Shares Rs. lakhs No. of Shares Rs. Lakhs
Silent Valley Investment Company Limited 771000 475.32 771000 475.32ISG Traders Ltd. 1195135 736.80 5622019 3465.97
16. i) Remuneration paid or payable to Whole Time Director and Managing Director:
17. The company operates mainly in one business segment viz Paper and all other activities are incidental thereto.
18. Salary/wages Rs.92.73 lakhs, Provident Fund and Employee State Insurance Rs.2.91 lakhs,office expenses Rs.11.58Lakhs,Stores & components and repairs Rs.320.40 Lakhs,Rent Rs.6.58 Lakhs and insurance Rs.5.41 lakhs have been classifiedfunctionally under other heads of accounts.
19. Miscellaneous Expenses include
31.03.2006 31.03.2005 Whole Time Managing Whole Time Managing
Director Director Director DirectorSalary and Performance Pay 24.00 21.40 24.00 20.35Other Allowances 12.60 5.55 9.00 3.63Contribution to Provident and other Funds* 2.88 1.37 6.48 2.79Commission payable 31.00 – 31.00 –Other Benefits (Actual) 1.89 15.07 1.11 14.51
72.37 43.39 71.59 41.28
*Excluding Company's contribution to Gratuity Fund.
ii) Computation of Net Profit in accordance with Section 349 and 198 of the Companies Act, 1956
Profit Before Taxation 1460.36Add: Remuneration, Perquisite and other benefits payable to Managing Director
and Whole Time Director 115.76Director Fees 1.80Provision for wealth Tax 3.00Profit as per Section 349 of the Companies Act, 1956 1580.92
Less: Profit on sale of Fixed assets (9.65)Income from Investments (4.41)Profit as per Section 198 of the Companies Act, 1956 1566.86
(Rs. in Lakhs)31.3.2006 31.3.2005
Auditors Remunerationi) Statutory Auditors
a) Audit Fee 3.75 3.75b) In other capacities
– Fees for Tax Audit 0.75 0.75– Fees for Certificates and Review 1.46 2.14
ii) Cost Audit Fees 0.30 0.22
61
Schedules to the Accounts
20. Additional information pursuant to the provisions of paragraphs 3, 4 (c) and 4 (d) of Part-II of Schedule-VI of the CompaniesAct, 1956:-
a) Particulars in respect of Capacity, Production, Turnover and Stocks
Notes:i) Pulp Plant is an integrated part of the paper plant and therefore, the capacity and actual production of pulp are
not separately ascertained.
ii) Production and Stocks excludes Wrapper produced for the packing of finished goods.
iii) Production includes wastage of 69 MT (Previous year 79 MT) on conversion of reels into sheets on job work basisoutside the plant and 134 MT (Previous year 32 MT) re-pulped during the year.
iv) Turnover excludes 146 MT (Previous year 117 MT) of self consumed paper.
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
b) Raw Materials Consumed
31.03.2006 31.03.2005 Quantity Value Quantity Value
Tonnes Rs. lakhs Tonnes Rs. lakhsi) Wood, bamboo and wood waste 227857 4564.87 250660 3320.95ii) Waste paper and wood pulp 582 107.84 104 13.88
4672.72 3334.83
c) Value of Raw Materials and Spare Parts and Components consumed
d) C.I.F. Value of Imports
31.03.2006 31.03.2005 Rs. lakhs % Rs. lakhs %
i) Raw Materials– Indigenous 4628.5 99 3321.53 99– Imported 44.22 1 13.30 1
4672.72 100 3334.83 100ii) Spare Parts and Components
– Indigenous 188.28 78 180.36 90– Imported 53.80 22 23.00 10
242.08 100 203.36 100
(Rs. in Lakhs)31.3.2006 31.3.2005
– Raw Materials 20.82 7.38– Components and Spare Parts 382.31 190.80
31.03.2006 31.03.2005Licenced Capacity Not Applicable Not ApplicableInstalled Capacity (TPA)(As certified by the management) Paper and PaperBoard of different varieties 75000 71350
Tonnes Rs.lakhs Tonnes Rs.lakhsProduction 67875 71106Turnover 68129 21836.11 70755 21195.78Opening Stock 1269 300.93 1146 275.79Closing Stock 666 190.66 1269 300.93
62
STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED
Schedules to the Accounts
16 SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND NOTES TO THE ACCOUNTS (Contd.)
e) Expenditure incurred in Foreign Currency(Rs. in Lakhs)
31.3.2006 31.3.2005– Travelling 13.99 13.44– Professional Fee and Technical Services 5.00 5.78– Others 0.98 –
f) Earning in Foreign exchange
21. Figures have been given in Rupees lakhs and have been rounded off to the nearest
thousand.
22. Previous year figures have been regrouped/rearranged wherever necessary.
Signatures to schedule 1 to 16 forming part of Balance Sheet and Profit & Loss Account.
(Rs. in Lakhs)31.3.2006 31.3.2005
F O B Value of Exports 75.86 53.84
As per our report of even date.For Lodha & Co. On behalf of the BoardChartered accountants
H. K. Verma G P Goenka M P PintoPartner Chairman and Shiromani SharmaMembership No. 55104 Whole-Time Director P N Ghatalia
Shrivardhan GoenkaPlace: Kolkata Madhukar Misra Supriya GuptaDated: 29th May, 2006 Managing Director Directors
63
Balance Sheet Abstract and Company’s General busines profile(Information Persuant to Part IV of Schedule VI of the Companies Act, 1956)
Public Issue
Bonus Issue
3 1 0 3
Registration No.
Balance Sheet Date
I. Registration Details
II. Capital Raised during the year (Amount in Rs. thousands)
Total Liabilities
III. Position of Mobilisation and Deployment of Funds (Amount in Rs. thousands)
2 0 0 6
Date Month Year
Private Placement
Paid-up Capital
Sources of Funds
Total Assets
Reserves & Surplus
IV. Performance of the Company (Amount in Rs. thousands)
Product Description ITC Code No.
V. Generic Names of Two Principal Products / Services of Company (as per monetary terms)
Net Fixed Assets Investments
Turnover & Other Income
Profit Before Tax
Total Expenditure
Profit After Tax
Application of Funds
2 3 6 1 8 7 2
2 1 - 8 7 2 6
1 5 6 0 8 3
1 9 1 8 9 0 1
1 4 6 0 3 6
1 7 7 2 8 6 5
9 2 8 2 7
Earning per share (in Rs.)
-Basic & Diluted)Dividend Rate (%)
1. Paper
5 . 9 5
4 8 0 2 4 0 0
N A
1 7 . 5
2. N. A.
1 4 2 6 8 5 0 2 1 0 7 2 1
Net Current Assets Misc. Expenditure3 0 1 6 0 3 N I L
Accumulated Losses N I L
N I L
Rights Issue N I L
State Code 2 1
N I L
N I L
2 3 6 1 8 7 2
9 1 1 1 9 1
Secured Loans Unsecured Loans6 4 4 1 3 0
Net Deferred Tax Liabilities 2 2 6 7 8 9
9 8 1
On behalf of the Board
G P Goenka M P PintoChairman and Shiromani SharmaWhole-Time Director P N Ghatalia
Shrivardhan GoenkaPlace: Kolkata Madhukar Misra Supriya GuptaDated: 29th May, 2006 Managing Director Directors
64