cosmic ray interactions in extreme molecular media · yoast-hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 models...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media
Tova Yoast-HullTova Yoast-HullUniversity of Wisconsin-Madison
Department of Physics2 June 2015
Collaborators: Erin Boettcher, J. S. Gallagher III, Ellen Zweibel (University of Wisconsin), Susanne Aalto (Chalmers University, Sweden), John Everett (Northwestern University)
Funded by: Center for Magnetic Self-Organization & Wisconsin IceCube Particle Astrophysics Center
![Page 2: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Cosmic Ray Populations in Galaxies● Significant fraction of energy
from supernovae goes into CRs and is redistributed via:– Interactions with the ISM
(heating)
– Launching of galactic winds (cooling)
● CRs detected at Earth were scrambled by the galactic B-field; other messengers:– Radio (CR electrons &
magnetic field)
– Gamma-rays, neutrinos (CR protons & ISM density)
Supernova Remnant W28Aharonian+ 2008, A&A, 481
~3
5 pc
![Page 3: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Cosmic Rays at Earth● In the Milky Way, we find
equipartition of:– Cosmic rays
– Magnetic fields
– Radiation fields
– Interstellar gas
● What is the distribution of energy in other galaxies?
● What role do cosmic rays play in formation & evolution of galaxies?
Beatty & Westerhoff 2009, ARNPS, 59
![Page 4: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
From Cosmic Ray Sources to Earth
![Page 5: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
From Cosmic Ray Sources to Earth
Cosmic Rays
![Page 6: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
From Cosmic Ray Sources to Earth
Cosmic Rays
Gamma-Rays
![Page 7: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
From Cosmic Ray Sources to Earth
Cosmic Rays
Gamma-Rays
Neutrinos
![Page 8: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
YEGZ Starburst Model
SNR
Cosmic rays are accelerated by supernova remnants.
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, ApJ, 768
![Page 9: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
YEGZ Starburst Model
SNR
Cosmic rays are accelerated by supernova remnants.
∫Emin
Emax
Q(E)EdE=ηνSN E51
V
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, ApJ, 768
![Page 10: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
YEGZ Starburst Model
SNR
MolecularGas
They diffuse through the medium to interact with molecular clouds.
e-p
Cosmic rays are accelerated by supernova remnants.
∫Emin
Emax
Q(E)EdE=ηνSN E51
V
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, ApJ, 768
![Page 11: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
YEGZ Starburst Model – Hadrons
SNR
MolecularGas
p
CR protons collide with Hydrogen and Helium to create charged and neutral pions.
p
p
Magnetic mirroring effects?
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, ApJ, 768
![Page 12: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
YEGZ Starburst Model – Hadrons
SNR
MolecularGas
p
As the pions decay, secondary electrons, positrons, gamma-rays, & neutrinos are created.
e-e+
ν
CR protons collide with Hydrogen and Helium to create charged and neutral pions.
p
p
Magnetic mirroring effects?
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, ApJ, 768
![Page 13: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
YEGZ Starburst Model – Hadrons
SNR
MolecularGas
p
As the pions decay, secondary electrons, positrons, gamma-rays, & neutrinos are created.
e-e+
ν
CR protons collide with Hydrogen and Helium to create charged and neutral pions.
p
p
Magnetic mirroring effects?
N (E)≈Q(E)τ (E)
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, ApJ, 768
![Page 14: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Starburst Model – Bremsstrahlung
SNR
MolecularGas
CR electrons are accelerated by Hydrogen and Helium nuclei and radiate gamma-rays.
e-
e- e-
e-
p npn
e-
Magnetic mirroring effects?
![Page 15: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Starburst Model – Inverse Compton
SNR
CR electrons interact with the interstellar radiation field and produce gamma-rays.e-
e- e-
e-
e-
Radiation Field
![Page 16: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Starburst Model – Synchrotron
SNR
CR electrons interact with the magnetic fields and produce non-thermal synchrotron.e-
e- e-
e-
e-
B
Magnetic Field
![Page 17: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Prototype Galaxy: M82 Starburst Core● Our original model
was developed for and tested on M82.
● Nearest and best studied starburst galaxy
● Observed in radio & gamma-rays
● Contains large-scale galactic wind
Weiss+ 2001, A&A, 365
~450 pc
![Page 18: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Model Overview
![Page 19: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1
![Page 20: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
![Page 21: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
![Page 22: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
2
![Page 23: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
2 CR Protons
![Page 24: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
2Spectral Index
+ Wind Speed
CR Protons
![Page 25: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
2Spectral Index
+ Wind Speed
3
CR Protons
![Page 26: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
2Spectral Index
+ Wind Speed
3
CR Protons
CR Electrons
![Page 27: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Model OverviewSupernova Rate
+ Gas Mass
1CR Source Functions
2Spectral Index
+ Wind Speed
3Magnetic Field Strength
+ Thermal Radio Contribution
CR Protons
CR Electrons
![Page 28: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Observational Information● Radio
– Supernova rate
● Millimeter– Molecular gas content
● Infrared– Radiation field
– Dust temperatures
● Optical– ISM pressures, wind
● X-Rays– Hot gas content, wind
Muxlow+ 1995, L-Band MERLIN Image
M82 Core – Radio Continuum
![Page 29: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
M82 Radio & Gamma-Ray Spectral Fits
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015
Gamma-ray emission is mainly from neutral pion decay, but also includes bremsstrahlung and inverse Compton.
Radio spectrum contains both synchrotron and free-free emission with free-free absorption at low-frequencies.
![Page 30: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
M82 Chi-Squared Tests
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015
Radio Spectrum Gamma-Ray Spectrum
We use chi-squared tests to optimize magnetic field strength (B), wind speed (vadv), ionized gas density (nion).
![Page 31: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Chi-Squared Tests: Joint Solutions
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015
16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.312 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2
Differences in the cosmic ray populations show up in our results of modeling the radio and gamma-ray spectra. In particular, the radio data are highly sensitive to supernova rate and average gas density.
![Page 32: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Chi-Squared Tests: Joint Solutions
Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015
Differences in the cosmic ray populations show up in our results of modeling the radio and gamma-ray spectra. In particular, the radio data are highly sensitive to supernova rate and average gas density.
M82 is a ~50% proton calorimeter! B ~ 300 μG
![Page 33: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Merging Galaxy Arp 220● Closest ultraluminous
infrared galaxy– Contains two starburst
nuclei
– Western nucleus is optically thick to the thermal infrared
● Window into the high redshift universe
Sakamoto+ 2008, ApJ, 684
![Page 34: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Energy Density Comparison
Milky Way M82 Arp 220 East Arp 220 CND
Supernova Power
2 x 1048
erg yr-17 x 1048
erg yr-17 x 1049
erg yr-11.3 x 1050
erg yr-1
Radiation Field Energy Density 1 eV cm-3 1000 eV cm-3 40,000 eV cm-3 440,000 eV cm-3
Magnetic Field Energy Density
1 eV cm-3
(5 μG)2200 eV cm-3
(300 μG)620,000 eV cm-3
(5 mG)1.2x106 eV cm-3
(7 mG)
Average Gas Density 1 cm-3 260 cm-3 7,700 cm-3 42,000 cm-3
Cosmic Ray Energy Density 1 eV cm-3 450 - 650
eV cm-31100 - 3700
eV cm-32500 - 5140
eV cm-3
![Page 35: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Arp 220 Radio Chi-Squared Tests
Yoast-Hull+ 2015, submitted
Eastern Nucleus Western Nucleus
In the calorimeter limit, wind speed does not affect the total cosmic ray electron population. Thus, the gamma-ray spectrum can be reliably predicted with only an observed radio spectrum and star formation rate.
η = 5%, p = 2.3
![Page 36: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Arp 220 Radio Chi-Squared Tests
Yoast-Hull+ 2015, submitted
Eastern Nucleus Western Nucleus
In the calorimeter limit, wind speed does not affect the total cosmic ray electron population. Thus, the gamma-ray spectrum can be reliably predicted with only an observed radio spectrum and star formation rate.
η = 10%, p = 2.3
![Page 37: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Detectable Gamma-Ray FluxArp 220 is likely detectable at GeV energies by Fermi, but not above ~10 TeV due to gamma-gamma absorption.
Due to the extremely short lifetimes, the Arp 220 nuclei are > 90% proton calorimeters.
Yoast-Hull+ 2015, submitted
![Page 38: Cosmic Ray Interactions In Extreme Molecular Media · Yoast-Hull+ 2013, 2015 12 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.2 16 of 11,000 Models for p = 2.3 Differences in the cosmic ray populations](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022050111/5f48ac47a8190c55df1fcca6/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Summary● Joint modeling of gamma-ray and radio spectra is
necessary for constraining the properties of CR populations in galaxies.
● Strong magnetic fields & low CR energy densities in starbursts.
● M82: winds are vital to correctly modeling the CR populations.– ~50% CR energy back into ISM, ~50% into the wind
● Arp 220: winds are irrelevant as all regions are so dense, no CRs escape & self-absorption is key– ~100% CR energy back into ISM