court transcripts - april 16th, sealing lifting protective order

Upload: teammichael

Post on 03-Apr-2018

241 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    1/12

    Wdoej`k&Ejhtj`k \rftdgtjvd Frndr.

    Bunkd Zvdttd \oeozudefs-BZ\*

    Ottfr`dys \rdsd`t j` gfurt2)

    ^mjrn \orty)Ijgmode Bogcsf` Dstotd \otrjgjo Ijeedtt-\I*

    Bogcsf` Hoijey Arjo` \o`jsm-A\*. Cdvj` Afyed-CA*.ODKEjvd. Q\. \K Bdssjgo Wtdaaj`s-BW*. Idevj` \ut`oi-I\*

    Ijgmode Bogcsf` ottfr`dys wos frndrdn tf oppdor tf o`swdr j` rdkorns tf nfguid`ts tmdy movd

    sdoedn o`n oppejdn tf Oppdoes gfurt tf sdoe wmot tmjs gfurt njn `ft sdoe% oesf gfoejtjf` spdgjhjgs

    \I. Zfur Mf`fr tmd Dstotd njn hjed ydstdrnoy rdspf`sd o`n rdspdgtjvd qudstjf`s j` wmot wd ordord sddcj`k tf movd sdoedn.

    BZ\. [d movd `ft rdgdjvdn tmjs.

    \I. Zfur mf`fr wd njn sd`n o gfurtdsy gfpy oesf tf ad ndejvdrdn jt wos hjedn eotd j` tmd noy.

    BZ\. [dee wd wdrd `ft mdrd ydstdrnoy.

    \I. Mdrd js o gfpy yfu mf`fr

    Bunkd js effcj`k tmrfukm nfguid`ts

    \I. Zfur mf`fr J ioy movd kjvd` yfu tmd wrf`k tmj`k. ^mjs js tmd oid`ndn hjej`k. ^mdrd js o

    iftjf` tf sdoe wmjgm wjee ad mdorn j` Oukust j` tmd Oppdoes gfurt rdeotj`k tf Iftjf`s j` Ejij`d.Ifrd Iftjf`s j` Ejij`d goid j`% wd njn`t hjed o`ftmdr iftjf` wd bust upnotdn tmjs f`d%

    J`geunj`k tmd onnjtjf`oe wmjgm ord oee Idnjgoe rdgfrns.

    BZ\. FC. [dee edt id osc yfu njn yfu gf`hdr wjtm gfu`sde wmot jt js tmot tmdy j`trfnugdn j`tf tmd

    trjoe.

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    2/12

    \I. [d movd `ft nf`d tmot.

    BZ\. Js tmdrd o rdosf` wmy yfu njn`t

    \I. J edht tf kf fut fh tfw`% J wos fut fh tfw`. Oee wd ord sddcj`k tf hjed wdrd djtmdr hjedn j`Iftjf` j` Ejij`d fr Wuiiory Bunkid`t iftjf` wmjgm mos oerdony add` hjedn wjtm tmd gfurt%

    djtmdr sjnd mos `ft prfvjndn us wjtm dxmjajt ejst fr spdgjhjgs fh idnjgoe rdgfrns&j`hfriotjf` tmdy

    wjsm tf usd j` trjoe. ^md prftdgtjvd frndr j` peogd nfds stotd tmd o`yafny go` usd nfguid`ts hjedngo` ad j`trfnugdn j`tf trjoe. [jtm suabdgt tf wmot go` ad j`trfnugdn ot trjoe% tmd mjkmey

    gf`hjnd`tjoe rdgfrns wmjgm ord idnjgoe rdgfrns. ^md ndsjk`otdn portjds `ddn tf kjvd 4 noys `ftjgd

    os tf wmot jt js tmdy wjsm tf usd. J njn goee tmd gfu`sde tf hj`n fut dxogtey wmot jt js tmdy wo`t tf

    usd. Jh tmdy wo`t tf gf`tj`ud `fw wd ord moppy tf effc ot jt.

    BW. [d nf movd o td`totjvd yfur mf`fr% wd movd `ft mon gmo`gd tf toec tf Irs. Ijeedtt

    BZ\. Fc nf yfu movd o`y fabdgtjf`s tf tmdi adj`k usdn j` trjoe.

    \I. [d nf`t `ft movd fabdgtjf` tf tmdi adj`k usdn j` trjoe% ndpd`nj`k wmjgm rdgfrns yfu ord

    rdhdrrj`k tf% wd nf `ft wo`t tmdi adj`k iond puaejg o`n sprdon orfu`n tmd wfren.

    BZ\. Jh tmdy ord j`trfnugdn j`tf trjoe% tmdy wjee ad puaejg rdgfrns% oggdssdn ay o`yf`d. Wf yfu

    iust ossuid tmot `fw. Wf tmot ossuiptjf` yfu tf o`y fh tmfsd idnjgoe rdgfrns adj`k supprdssdn

    \I. Jh tmdrd js `f prftdgtjf`. Ioyad `ft put tmdi up f` o kjo`t sgrdd`% o`n f`ey prfvjnd tmdi tf

    tmd bury o`n wjt`dss% ioyad gefsd tmd gfurt rffi. J nf`t c`w wmot tmd ogtuoe rdgfrns ord j` tmjsjssud. ^md kd`droe puaejg nfds `ft movd rjkmt fh oggdss tf &gf`hjnd`tjoe idnjgoe j`hfriotjf`. ^md

    Dstotd ord o tmjrn porty% wd nf`t movd o`y hj`o`gjoe j`tdrdst j` tmjs gosd% oee wd wo`t tf nf js

    prftdgtj`k Ijgmode Bogcsf` `oid o`n edkogy okoj`st jiprfpdr njssdij`otjf`.

    BZ\. Movd yfu rdon tmd gfurt fh oppdoes frndr.

    \I. Zds o`n jh yfu effc ot Dxmjajt D tf wmot wd suaijttdn tfnoy% jt stotds wd movd smfw`

    suhhjgjd`t gousd tf sdoe idnjgoe j`hfriotjf`. ^mdrd ord `f hurtmdr frndrs j` tmd gfurt fh oppdoes.

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    3/12

    ^mdy oscdn us tf iocd o smfwj`k o`n wd huehjeedn tmot rdqudst% gfurt fh oppdoes ord sotjshjdn wjtm

    wmot wd prfvjndn tmdi.

    BZ\. Hfr `fw. Ji surd f` tmd noy fh tmd trjoe wmdrd idnjgoe j`hfriotjf` wjee ad suaijttdn tf

    bury% tmd puaejg

    BW. [d movd `f prfaedi kjvj`k `ftjgd tf tmd dstotd o`n tmdy go` gfid mdrd o`n okud. [d j`td`n

    tf% o`n wjee ad hojrey dvosjvd tf j`trfnugd idnjgoe tdstjif`jds ot trjoe. \ftd`tjoe wjt`dssds wjee adnjsgussj`k jt% pmysjgjo`s wjee ad j`trfnugj`k Ijgmode Bogcsf`s idnjgoe j`hfriotjf` tmrfukmfut

    mjs ejhd% wo`t tf sdoe sfid fh tmot j`hfriotjf`. O`n ioy gfid tf gfurt wjtm tmfsd frndrs. Aut

    yfur mf`fr wjee ndgjnd wmot go` fr go``ft ad sdoedn. wd wjee gdrtoj`ey put tfkdtmdr o ejst hfr tmd

    Dstotd% o`n tmfsd pmysjgjo`s

    BZ\. ^md prfaedi js J nf`t wo`t tf ad j` tmd ijnned fh trjoe% tmd` dvdry ifr`j`k tmdrd js o

    sdoej`k frndr hrfi pmysjgjo`s fr dstotd ossdrtj`k tmjs geoji tmot pfrtjf` fh sfidtmj`k smfuen adsdoedn. Jts `ft progtjgoe u`edss tmdrd js o` oasfeutd rjkmt. Dvd` sf tmd` puaejg j`tdrdst js

    futwdjkmdn ay prjvogy wmjgm js `ft o oasfeutd rjkmt. Jts o kffn jndo yfu kjvd tmdi o ejst% o`n jh

    tmdrd js sfidtmj`k j` portjgueor tmdy fabdgt tf. Jh wd go` dejij`otd o eft fh tmot. Jts kfj`k tf adupmjee aotted hfr tmd Dstotd.

    A\. Zfur mf`fr jh sfid dxpdrts soy sfidtmj`k o`n wd wo`t tf grfss dxoij`d. tmdy wo`t 4 noys%7 soys tf ndroje% tmot sojn% wd movd ottd`ndn tmot wd ord j`trfnugj`k f`ey tdstjif`jds `ft rdgfrns.

    [d go`t ad moistru`k ot trjoe ay tmdsd frndrs.

    BW. Jt ioy iocd sd`sd tf sdt sfid sfrt fh mdorj`k f` spdgjhjg idnjgoe jssuds% wd go` kjvd tmd

    Dstotd o ejst fh pmysjgjo`s% furs js hojrey dxtd`sjvd. O `uiadr tdstjhjdn f` jssuds rdeotdn f` tmjs

    fggosjf`% o`n tmot ioy gmo`kd tf. O`n tmdrd js voeud tf rdsfevj`k tmdsd jssuds `fw rotmdr tmo`noy tf noy aosjs j` trjoe.

    CA. dris fh tmd trjoe progtjgoejty js prfaedi js porokropm ?1 fh prftdgtjvd frndr% rdqujrj`k djtmdr

    porty tf kjvd 4 noys ftjgd os tf prfvjnj`k gf`hjnd`tjoe j`hfriotjf` prjfr tf usd ot trjoe%

    BZ\ js tmot tmd prftdgt frndr fr js tmot tmd6

    CA Jts tmd prftdgtjvd frndr wmjgm prdsuioaey wmot tmd sdoej`k wjee ad aosdn fhh% tmjs js wmot Ir

    \o`jsm js soyj`k% `fafny c`fws wmots kfj`k tf moppd` 4 noys hrfi `fw% J go` put tmd Dstotd f``ftjgd `fw% wd ord kfj`k tf ad usj`k idnjgoe tdstjif`jds% aut wd nf`t c`fw wmot pogjhjg

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    4/12

    nfguid`ts ord kfj`k tf ad usdn aut u`tje njrdgt dxoij`d% grfss dxoij`d ^md Dstotd mos `ftjgd os

    tf dvdryf`d tmots add` ndpfsdn% tmdy movd add` kjvd` oggdss tf tmot j`hfriotjf`% tmdy go`

    if`jtfr tmot nojey o`n hjed o iftjf` jh tmdy wo`t tf% aut tmjs `ftjgd js jipfssjaed

    BW. Jh tmd gfurt hddes tmdrd ord aurnd` adgousd fh tmd prftdgtjvd frndr tmdy ioy wjsm tf ifnjhy

    tmd prfvjsjf`s fh prftdgtjvd frndr aut jt smfuen rdioj` j` peogd% wmjgm wos stjpueotdn tf tmdportjds wjtm tmd gf`sd`t fh tmd dstotd o`n wmjgm ndhd`no`ts ord wjeej`k tf ajnd ay. ^mfukm wd ord

    `ft peo``j`k f` nfj`k tmjs f` o nojey aosjs ay `ft kjvj`k tmdi o ejst up hrf`t o`n jt ioy rdqujrdifnjhjgotjf` nfw` tmd ej`d. J`hfriotjf` ioy gfid up wmjgm wjee ad jiprogtjgoe tf kjvd 4 noys

    `ftjgd

    BZ\ os ef`k os ndgjsjf`s ord iond rjkmt owoy J kdt tmot

    A\ ord wd toecj`k oafut idnjgoe rdgfrns fr ord wd toecj`k oafut dvdrytmj`k% hfr dxoiped tmdy

    movd 17%

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    5/12

    BZ\ sf tmd f`ey tmj`k tmot js o` jssud js idnjgoe rdgfrns wmjgm ord mjkmey gf`hjnd`tjoe adgousd

    tmdy rdqujrd 4 noys `ftjgd6

    \I progtjgoe sukkdstjf` js tmot sd`sjtjvd dxmjajts ejst% wd ord wjeej`k tf kf tmrfukm tmd` prfvjnd

    `ftjgd soyj`k yds wd wjsm tf sdoe tmjs fr tmjs. O eft fh tmd idnjgoe prfvjndrs wmf ndpfsdn ord

    futsjnd fh Goejhfr`jo% tmdy ioy `ft ad gfij`k mdrd% wd nf `ft movd tmfsd ndpfsjtjf`s. [dottd`ndn o mo`nhue fh ndpfsjtjf`s. [d rdqujrd ejst fh pdfped f` tmd ejst o`n ossuij`k tmdrd ioy ad

    pdfped tmot njn`t iocd jt tf tmd ejst tmot ord idnjgoe prfvjndrs% J u`ndrsto`n tmdrd ord Xfjr Njrdsu`ndr woy% aut adhfrd o`yf`d kdts j`tf o sjtuotjf`% sf os `ft tf iocd jt o eost ij`utd tmj`k tmdrd

    ord ?>%

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    6/12

    BZ\ dosjdst tmj`k wfuen ad tf gmo`kd tmd prdsuiptjf`% o`n tmot jt wjee ad prfnugdn ot trjoe o`n

    put tmd aurnd` f` tmd Dstotd tf jnd`tjhy wmot jt js sf gf`hjnd`tjoe o`n tmot jt mos `ft add`

    njsgefsdn ot tmd grjij`oe gosd. ^mdy ioy gfid oef`k o`n soy tmdrd ioy ad f`d ej`d wd nf`two`t njsgefsdn. Jts `ft progtjgoe j` gosd fh tmd idnjo o`n portjds.

    \I wd nf`t movd oee tmd dvjnd`gd prfnugdn j` njsgfvdry% wd ord `ft o porty tf tmd gosd% J

    sukkdstdn kjvd id dxmjajt ejst% kjvd id ndpfsjtjf`s fh tmd wjt`dss% oi J oscj`k yfu tf kjvd id

    yfur trjoe tdstjif`y. J u`ndrsto`n wmd` sfidf`d js f` tmd sto`n tmdy ioy tdstjhy% tmots js `ftwmot wd ord toecj`k oafut% tmdrd js o pffe fh j`hfriotjf` fut tmdrd tmot gurrd`tey dxjst. [d ord

    moppy tf kf tmrfukm o`n jnd`tjhy os pftd`tjoe% wmots f` tmd dxmjajt ejst% o`n ndpfsjtjf`s f` tmd

    wjt`dss ejst

    BZ\ wdee fc% tmd wjt`dss ejst mos add` hjedn o ef`k tjid okf% J nf`t c`fw wmy yfu ord effcj`k tf

    tmdi tf prfvjnd tmot tf yfu. Jts puaejg rdgfrn. Oee yfu movd tf nf js puee up tmd nfgcdt

    \I J nf`t movd tmd ndpfsjtjf`s.

    CA Iy u`ndrsto`nj`k fh mfw tmjs js wfrcdn fut adtwdd` tmd Dstotd o`n ODK. [md` wd sjk`dnfhh f` tmd gf`hjnd`tjoejty wd njn`t stjpueotd tmjs% wd njn jt tf dosd `ft tf aftmdr tmd gfurt% tmd

    Dstotd mon add` tmd Kotd cddpdr fh oee tmd idnjgoe rdgfrns o`n ndpfsjtjf`s% tmd Dstotd mos

    rdnogtdn gdrtoj` idnjgoe j`hfriotjf` adhfrd jt wos prfnugdn. Ji gf`husdn adgousd dvdrytmj`kmos oerdony add` hjetdrdn ay tmd Dstotd. ^mdy c`fw jt oee

    A\ tmdy gjtd spdgjhjg dxpdrts tdstjif`jds j` tmd ndpfsjtjf`s o`n dxpdrts tf dxgeund% jts favjfus

    tmdy movd sdd` sfidtmj`k. Woid tmj`k smfuen ad wjtm tmd prftdgtjvd frndr jh o`ytmj`k tmdy hdde js

    Mjkmey gf`hjnd`tjoe tmdy smfuen tdee us fr jt smfuen`t oppey

    BZ\ ^mdy movd oerdony stotdn `ftmj`k js Mjkmey gf`hjnd`tjoe dxgdpt hfr idnjgoe rdgfrns o`n jhyfu wo`t tf usd tmdi ot trjoe% yfu ord hrdd tf nf sf

    A\ o`n gf`hjnd`tjoe tff wjtm tmd prdsuiptjf`% `ftmj`k .

    BW tmd prftdgtjvd frndr prfvjnds hfr portjds o`n prfnugj`k portjds tf ndsjk`otd wmot jsgf`hjnd`tjoe% tmdrd ord fvdr 4< tmjrn portjds tmot movd prfnugdn gf`hjnd`tjoe j`hfriotjf`% \eoj`tjhh

    mon fppfrtu`jty tf c`fw tmjs% tmdy movd gf`togtdn us adhfrd hjej`k% Mdy go` wd hjed tmjs. J sojn

    yds. ^mdrd mos`t add` o`y nfguid`tdn.. o`n `f`d fh tmot js o` jssud hfr trjoe% adgousd ot trjoe oee

    fh tmot go` ad usdn.

    BZ\ FC% prftdgtjvd frndr go` rdioj` j` peogd hfr tmj`ks tmot ord mjkmey gf`hjnd`tjoe

    Gf`hjnd`tjoe iotdrjoe go` ad usdn ot trjoe

    CA tmd prftdgtjvd frndr stotds gf`hjnd`tjoe iotdrjoe go` ad usdn j` kffn hojtm tmot js `ft

    moppd`j`k sj`gd fvdr :

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    7/12

    rdhdrrj`k tf diojes hrfi ODK tf rdpfrtdrs% mfw js tmot gf`hjnd`tjoe. ^mdy movd bustjhy wmot tmdy

    njn ay hfgusj`k f` pdrsf`oe dioje onnrdss. ^ji [ffedys pdrsf`oe dioje onnrdss% wos tfur

    oggfu`to`t wfrcj`k hfr ODK% md wos fpdrotj`k tmd ^mjs Js Jt tfur hrfi tmot dioje onnrdss.Wd`nj`k diojes orfu`n tmd wfren% tf oee cj`ns fh futsjnd portjds. Mfw js tmot o gf`hjnd`tjoe dioje

    onnrdss6 ^mot mos add` put j`tf tmd puaejg nfioj`% jts `f ef`kdr o \rjvotd dioje onnrdss. [d

    ord adj`k iond tf rdtrogt oee diojes% tmdy smfuen ad oscdn tf sd`n oee tmdjr nfguid`ts wjtm tmfsddioje onnrdssds rdtrogtdn.

    BW tmd gfurt fh Oppdoes movd iond o` frndr soyj`k tmot prjvotd diojes o`n pmf`d `uiadrs iddt

    tmd sto`norn fh \rjvotd. Oesf yfur mf`fr frndrdn tmfsd smfuen ad sdoedn o`n sj`gd wd ord

    tocj`k oafut o tmjrn portjds dioje onnrdss jts `ft rdedvo`t j` o`y woy tf tmjs gosd% md js o `f`porty tf tmjs gosd% tmdrd js `f rdosf` tf iocd tmot puaejg.

    BZ\. tmot go` ad usdn os ef`k os tmd dioje onnrdss js rdnogtdn.

    CA aut wd nf `ft wo`t tf ad oggusdn fh kjvj`k jt fut jh f`d nfguid`t wjtm tmot dioje onnrdss js

    ijspeogdn. [d ord tmd f`ey kotd cddpdrs fh tmd nfguid`ts% oggfrnj`k tf tmd prftdgtjvd frndr ODKwmf stoipdn tmfsd diojes gf`hjnd`tjoe% dspdgjoeey stotds tmdy go` vjfeotd tmd frndr ot wjee% sf tmd

    mukd aurnd` js f` us

    BW tmd prftdgtjvd frndr nfds `ft soy ODK go` vjfeotd jt ot wjee% jt soys o`y porty wmf prfnugds jtgo` nf wjtm jt wmot tmdy wo`t. Jh ODK stort mo`nj`k fut gf`hjnd`tjoe nfguid`ts effsdn jts stotus%

    o`n fh gfursd wd movd `ft nf`d tmot. \eoj`tjhh movd ndsjk`otdn gf`hjnd`tjoe \rj`gd o`n \orjs

    ndpfsjtjf`s% wd go` `ft kjvd tmfsd fut tmot mfw o prftdgtjvd frndr wfrcs.

    CA yds% aut mfw nfds o dioje rdogm sdoej`k sto`norns. O nfguid`t tmot wos sd`t orfu`n tmd

    wfren. Ndhd`no`ts oscdn hfr diojes onnrdssds f` tmd rdgfrn% tmdy oscdn hfr gdee pmf`d `uiadrs.Ir [ffedy sd`t fut fvdr ?=%

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    8/12

    BW o`y diojes wjtm LODKejvd fr LODK ord `ft prjvotd

    CA dvdry nfguid`t tmdy kovd us wos wdrd pdrsf`oe o`n wdrd rdeotdn tf tmd gosd.

    BZ\ wmot voeud js tmdrd tf o` dioje% jh jt soys ^ji [ffedy wmy nfds jt iottdr wmdrd jt goid hrfi

    A\ tmot js tmd pfj`t% jh md js usj`k jt hfr ausj`dss mfw js jt prjvotd

    BW okoj` yfur mf`fr bust adgousd sfidf`d usds o dioje jt nfds`t ido` jt smfuen ad peogdn j` o

    puaejg hjed o`n smordn orfu`n tmd wfren% io`y pdfped f` tmjs tfur movd tmdjr sfgjoe sdgurjty

    `uiadrs j` tmfsd gfrrdspf`nd`gd hfr io`y rdosf`s% tmot nfds `ft iocd tmdi prdsuiptufuseypuaejg. Jt gfuen ad usdn hfr ausj`dss aut stjee prjvotd

    CA wd ord toecj`k oafut o eft fh nfguid`ts mdrd% jh tmdy hdde jt gf`toj`s prjvotd j`tf j` tmd diojes

    tmdy smfuen prfvjnd jt tf us rdnogtdn

    BZ\ wd movd oerdony nf`d tmot

    BW tmdrd js `f prfaedi j` tmjs% peoj`tjhh go` usd wmotdvdr tmdy ejcd jh wd sdd jt ot trjoe wd wjee puee

    jt. Ot tmd d`n fh trjoe adhfrd dxmjajts ord peogdn j` tmd puaejg wd kf aogc j` o`n rdifvd

    o`yafnys WW `uiadr fr prjvotd j`hfriotjf`. ^md` wd ord `ft toecj`k oafut mu`nrdns fhtmfuso`ns fh nfguid`ts% wd ord bust toecj`k oafut tmd f`ds usdn ot trjoe.

    BZ\ fc edts kdt aogc tf tmd Dstotd% J tmj`c tmd aurnd` fh prffh js up tf yfu tf smfw id wmot yfu

    tmj`c js sf prjvotd o`n mjkmey gf`hjnd`tjoe tmot js smfuen`t ad njsgefsdn

    \I J oi moppy tf nf tmot% aut J nf`t movd tmd iotdrjoe tf effc ot% J `ddn tmd dxmjajts o`n tmd

    ndpfsjtjf`s.

    BW wd wjee kjvd yfu fur wjt`dss ejst o`n dxmjajts jh yfu nf`t movd tmot j`hfriotjf` wd wjee kdt jttf yfu

    BZ\ wd wjee kjvd jt tf yfu6 [d `ddn tf movd o notd

    BW J nf`t c`fw mfw iugm jt js% J go` kdt yfu tmd ejst tmjs ohtdr`ff`% J tmj`c tmjs smfuen ad

    rdsfevdn qujgc. J nf`t c`fw mfw io`y idnjgoe rdgfrns wd ogtuoeey kft

    BZ\ tmdy prfnugdn idnjgoe rdgfrns tf yfu% `fw yfu ord kfj`k tf tdee tmdi wmot jt js yfu ord

    usj`k

    BW wd wjee kjvd tmdi tmd dxmjajt o`n wjt`dss ejst% tmd` tmdy ord kfj`k tf j`hfri us% tmd Dstotd

    movd oerdony vjdwdn tmd idnjgoe rdgfrns% tmd qudstjf`s js tmd ndpfsjtjf`s. ^md Dstotd ottd`ndnsfid aut `ft oee% tmdy gdrtoj`ey movd `ft ottd`ndn tmd rdgd`t ndpfsjtjf`s ay dxpdrts io`y njsguss

    idnjgoe j`hfriotjf`. Jts `ft o prfaedi tf kdt tf tmdi tmfsd ndpfsjtjf`s os sff` os tmdy jnd`tjhy

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    9/12

    wmjgm f`ds tmdy nf`t movd. ^md Dstotds frndr gf`toj`s tmjrn porty rdgfrns aut tmot wf`t ad o

    prfaedi.

    BZ\ tmd idnjgoe j`hfriotjf` gf`toj`s j`hfriotjf` rdeotj`k tf tmjrn portjds6

    BW tmd ndpfsjtjf`s nf% hfr dxoiped EO\N gfrf`drs% jts `ft ajk ndoe tmdy go` ndgjnd wmjgm o`nwmjgm woy tmdy wo`t tf kf.

    BZ\ prdsuioaey tmdy wdrd hrfi grjij`oe trjoe

    BW `ft oee fh tmdi% o`n sfid fh tmdi ord dxtd`sjvd hjeds

    CA wd ord `ft tryj`k tf aurnd` tmd Dstotd mdrd% aut tmdy aosjgoeey kf tmrfukm tmd ejst iorc dvdrynfgtfrs tdstjif`y sdoedn% wd c`fw wmot tmdy wo`t sdoedn% o nfgtfr tdstjhyj`k idnjgoe

    j`hfriotjf` fh Ijgmode Bogcsf`% tmot js dvdrytmj`k.

    BZ\ wdee tmot frndr wjee ad nd`jdn% o wmfed ndpfsjtjf` smfuen ad sdoedn% js `ft kfj`k tf moppd`

    \I wmot Ir Afyed js effcj`k ot js o iftjf`% o rdspf`sd wd kovd wjtm rdspdgt tf nfguid`ts tmot

    movd add` hjedn prdvjfusey djtmdr J` gf``dgtjf` wjtm Iftjf` j` Ejij`d fr Wuiiory Bunkid`t

    popdrs% wmjgm wd njn kdt gfpjds fh tmfsd hjej`ks ODK o`n Ir Afyed% adyf`n tmot wd nf`t c`fwwmot tmdy j`td`n tf usd ot trjoe. ^mdrd wdrd nfzd`s fh ndpfsjtjf`s hrfi idnjgoe prfvjndrs o`n J

    o`tjgjpotd o eft fh jt wf`t gfid j`. jh wd movd o prfgdnurd tmots wfrcoaed.

    BZ\ wdee gf`togt tmd peoj`tjhhs sdd wmot tmdy movd% ji surd tmdy movd Nfgtfrs% yfu go` effc ot

    tmdjr ndpfsjtjf`s ji ossuij`k6

    CA ODK njn `ft ifvd tf sdoe \eoj`tjhhs fppfsjtjf`s tf suiiory bunkid`t. ^md Dstotd mosifvdn tf sdoe fur fppfsjtjf` o`n sfu`n ejcd tmots `ft o` jssud o`y ifrd gf`gdr`j`k idnjgoe

    rdgfrns

    BZ\ js tmot trud

    \I \eoj`tjhhs hjedn tmdjr d`tjrd suiiory bunkid`t u`ndr sdoe% wd wdrd f`ey j`tdrdstdn j`

    rdnogtj`k fr rdifvj`k gf`hjnd`tjoe idnjgoe j`hfriotjf`% fvdr tmd wddcd`n wd movd mon sfidf`d

    kf tmrfukm o`n movd nf`d o aeogcdn fut vdrsjf` gf`toj`j`k tmd idnjgoe j`hfriotjf`% wd wdrd

    `dvdr ifvj`k tf sdoe jt. ^mdy smfuen movd nf`d o rdnogtdn vdrsjf`% `ft tmd wmfed tmj`k u`ndrsdoe. Fur frndr wos f`ey gf`gdr`j`k tmd idnjgoe j`hfriotjf`. [d movd gfpjds mdrd hfr dvdryf`d.

    A\ Wf yfu wjee kjvd us o gfpy

    \I Zds% wd movd grdotdn o puaejg vdrsjf` tocj`k fut tmd stuhh wd gord oafut tmd rdst go` ad

    puaejg

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    10/12

    BZ\ tmots o stdp j` tmd rjkmt njrdgtjf`s% J nf`t c`fw jh wd ord tmdrd aut..

    CA J oi bust toecj`k oafut tmd ogtuoe fppfsjtjf`s pfrtjf` J oi `ft toecj`k oafut tmd..

    \I tmdrd js tmjs

    CA ydom tmot smfuen `ft dvd` ad sdoedn% wd movd oerdony hjedn fur arjdh j` gfurt fh oppdoes% jt

    soys tmd soid tmj`k tf yfur mf`fr sf J nf`t c`fw wmy tmot smfuen ad aeogcdn fut fr sdoedn

    BZ\ J `ddn tmd eowydrs tf gfid up wjtm tmd notd wmd` tmdy go`

    CA Zfu mf`fr tmjs js oee aeogcdn fut

    A\ tmjs js fppfsjtjf` pfj`ts fh outmfrjtjds tmjs js

    BW J tmj`c ifst pokds ord ejcd tmot Zfur mf`fr wd go` kjvd tmdi tmd ejst tmjs ohtdr`ff`. Go`yfu kjvd us aogc o ejst fh tmj`ks yfu nf`t movd6

    \I ay tfifrrfw

    BW ay tfifrrfw

    \I fc

    A\ sf

    BZ\ nf`t hjed

    \I J go`t hjed jts `ft iy bfa% wd bust nf`d jt tf jnd`tjhy tmd iotdrjoe wd gord oafut% tmjs js iftjf`

    oerdony add` ruedn upf`

    Bogcsf`+s ottfr`dys effcj`k tmrfukm oee tmd pokds aeogcdn fut

    CA wmd` wd hjedn prfvjsjf`oeey u`ndr sdoe wd mon `f faejkotjf` tf hjed jt u`ndr sdoe% wd movd `fjndo wmot ftmdrs wo`t rdnogtdn

    BZ\ yds J kdt jt

    CA fc

    BZ\ yfu njn jt os goutjf` tf ftmdrs% o eft fh pdfped nf tmot% iftjf`s wdrd f` goed`nor sf jt wos`t

    frndrdn sf yfu wdrd adj`k hojr oafut jt

  • 7/28/2019 Court Transcripts - April 16th, Sealing Lifting Protective Order.

    11/12

    CA rjkmt

    BW wd movd mon o`ftmdr twf tmjrn portjds% idnjgoe prfvjndrs wmf wo`t us tf hjed u`ndr sdoe% J

    nf`t c`fw wmot tmdjr frndrs ord% aut ot tmd soid tjid jh tmdy ord kfj`k tf ad dxgeundn ot trjoe

    adgousd fh iftjf` j` ejij`ds tmd` tmot ioy ad opprfprjotd aut tmots kfj`k tf ad up tf yfur

    mf`fr. Mfwdvdr idnjgoe j`hfriotjf` smfuen ad usdn ot trjoe% mfwdvdr yfur mf`fr wo`ts tf usdtmfsd% aut tmdy ord dssd`tjoe tf fur gosd o`n tf prdsd`t tf tmd bury

    BZ\ wmjgm ido`s tmdy wjee ad puaejg tmdy wjee `ft ad sdoedn% sf wmot J `ddn js o notd ay wmjgm

    tmd dstotd wjee tdee id wmot nfguid`ts tmdy wo`t u`ndr sdoe% u`edss tmjs js wmot tmjs js% wmot yfumovd bust mo`ndn id

    \I wmot wos prfvjndn f`ey rdeotds tf eow o`n iftjf` iottdrs% jh J kdt o ejst tfnoy% nf yfu movd

    o` dstjiotd wmd`.

    BZ\ J movd o`ftmdr wddc fr twf

    \I jh jts kfj`k tf ad o`ftmdr wddc fr sf wd go` ndhj`jtdey kdt tmot nf`d

    BZ\ wmot oafut td` noys

    \I tmots hj`d

    BW td` noys yfur mf`fr% wd movd o `uiadr fh mdorj`k f` tmd 1>tm o`n 14tm% pdrmops yfu go` iocd

    jt f` tmfsd twf noys

    BZ\ rjkmt 14tm tmd`

    Bogcsf`s ottfr`dys stjee toecj`k adtwdd` tmdisdevds effcdn tmrfukm tmd aeogcdn fut vdrsjf` fh

    tmdjr fppfsjtjf` tf suiiory bunkid`t% idifro`nuis pfj`ts fh outmfrjty

    BW yfur mf`fr wjee ad ndgjnj`k f` iftjf`s fh dxpdrts f` tmot noy sf yfu wjee movd o adttdr jndo fhwmot js ot mo`n

    BZ\ fc

    \I wmot tjid yfur mf`fr

    ^mursnoy ot :. [dn`dsnoy ot :.7