covid 19's economic impact on myanmar tourism and smes...covid 19's economic impact on...

36
COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: [email protected] 03 May 2020 1

Upload: others

Post on 12-Dec-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs

14 July 2020

03 May 2020

Richard Dagun (Takhun)Email: [email protected]

03 May 2020

1

Page 2: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

1.COVID 19 and Myanmar 2. Economic Impact of COVID 19 in Myanmar4. Possible Timeline of the Impact5. The Virus's Impact on SMEs and MSMEs6. Myanmar Government's Approach to COVD 197. Stimulus Package and It’s reach 8. COVID 19 Economic Relief Plan And Its Effectiveness9. Winners and Losers Aftermath of COVID 1910. Soaring Unemployment and who gets hit hardest11. COVID 19’s Impact on Tourism Economy12. Excepted Tourism Recovery Timeline13. Myanmar Tourism Before The Crisis14. Tourism Sector Competitiveness15. Myanmar’s Country Image: In The Eyes Of A Foreign Visitor and SWOT Analysis16.Crisis Respond by Ministry of Hotel and Tourism17. Forecasting the impact18. Looking Ahead : Tourism sector Near Term Solutions19. Looking Ahead : SMEs & Overall Economy20. Recommendations21. Upside & Downside22. References

CONTENT

2

Page 3: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

COVID 19 in Myanmar

Sources: World Health Organization (WHO) 2020.

Only 6 deaths Comparing to seriously hit countries, it’s insignificant Only 51451 people out of 54 million inhabitants were tested

3

Page 4: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Coronavirus brought catastrophic impact on Myanmar economy With health measures on top of sharply declining demand, businesses

face the challenges of daily operating cost, monthly salaries, and monthly bills

One out of three small and medium-sized businesses filed for closure and Nearly two-fifth of are reported unlikely to get the cash to survive for next four months

Massive laid off workers Most workers Return home to villages and added financial pressure

on rural economy inbound tourism and outbound tourism came to a standstill with zero

revenue and Uncertainty of tourist ever coming back Uncertainty of demand and employment problem, garment factories

closed down Migrant workers returning home from Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore,

and many more countries More than 90% of the businesses in Myanmar ineligible for any loans

by any Myanmar banking standard or even by the stimulus package projects valued in the billions of dollars are likely to be paused or

reconsidered with Virus Outbreaks in countries of key investors. The real estate sector in Yangon and Countrywide saw a severe

decline in transactions, Many properties listed for sale but no buyers Creates aggregate shocks, wounded businesses, households and

individual incomes.

Economic Impact of COVID 19 in Myanmar (SMEs and MSMEs shutting down!)

4

Page 5: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Economic Impact of COVID 19 in Myanmar (Continue) (SMEs and MSMEs shutting down!)

Myanmar has 65808 registered companies and probably more than 40000 unregistered businesses firms, of which 95% of them are SMEs and MSMEs , 4000 businesses were funded

SMEs have - only small reserves, limited working capital , rely solely upon demand for their products and services

such a prolonged period of reduced economic activity with no demand Despite all the government support , the real number of businesses

tormented by a cash-flow crisis is much wider. 29% of Businesses already closed down while 50% of all the

businesses are re-structuring and 20000 SMEs will be out of business Government is also not blessed with enough funds to help protect and

buffer SMEs from such economic shocks, Worst contraction in 25 years Growth is estimated to drop to 0.5 percent in FY2019/20, Weakening consumer demand the unemployment rate could rise up to (10% to 25%) 0.5 Million to 1.5

Million COVID 19 could easily outweigh and undermine the well-intended

stimulus plan workers are exiting the workforce and The fall of SMEs could have a

strong impact on national economies, as well as on growing poverty, food insecurities, inequalities

the economic shock of COVD 19 in Myanmar could become structural

5.8%6.4%

6.8%

0.5%

-1%

0%

1%

2%

3%

4%

5%

6%

FY2019 FY2020

INDUSTRY GDP

FY2017 FY2018

AGRI

SERVICES

Source: World Bank 2020 5

Page 6: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Economic Impact of COVID 19 in Myanmar

Covid 19

Economic Inactivities

2 out of 5 Businesses Closed down

1 Mllion workers laid off

Consumer Confidence in the market: Down

Aggregate Demand: Down

Productiity down

GDP, Export, Import, Investment down

Over two year: become Structural

Modified from source: Asia Foundation 2020, World Bank 2020

6

Page 7: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Possible Timeline of the Impact

Modified from Source: World Bank, OECD 20207

Page 8: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

The Virus's Impact on SMEs and MSMEs

29%Shut

Down

24%Normal

Operation

36% Limited Operation

12%Closed but still making

sales

72% Reduced half the

sales volume

92% Lacking

Demand & Lower

revenue

50% Almost

shutting down or restructuring

64%In need of Cash flow

Source: Asia Foundation, 2020

8

Page 9: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Myanmar Government's Approach to Covid 19 Crisis

COVID-19 Economic Relief Plan (CERP) unfolded seven goals, 10 strategies, 36 action plans and 76 sub-actions

to stimulate economic activities by stimulus packages for employees, businesses, and households and to ease banking regulations.

It sets up a fund of 100 + 100 billion kyats (USD 71.43 Million) , 0.01% of GDP, for local businesses,

helps each poor household with rice and beans and 40000 kyats (USD 28.6).

central banks of Myanmar reduced 3% interest rates in total and keeping the exchange rate more or less stable by buying out millions of USD reserves

A real commitment of the young democratic government

9

Page 10: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Stimulus Package and It’s effect

Have heard of Have applied it, but did not for a loan and apply, 26.9% waiting for the

result, 2.6%

Other, 6.1% Have not heard of it,

67.1% Tried to apply

for it but it was too difficult to

do so, 2.3%

Applied for a loan but it was rejected, 0.9%

Have received a loan from it,

0.1%

Source: Asia Foundation, 2020

10

Page 11: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

COVID 19 Economic Relief Plan And Its Effectiveness

Too modest for an impact No check and balance mechanism on awarding

permissions, and no proper guide lines for distribution of aids

No establishments of tax breaks, tax holiday, No import substitutions and forward looking export

oriented strategies, No stimulation or incentives for local production in

Myanmar SMEs most importantly did not stress enough on the

unemployment issue, i.e., how to absorb them in different industries.

No comprehension of the extent of such a large-scale real economy freeze

hard to launch harder to get through the layered bureaucratic systems hardest to reach the targeted bottom of the pyramid

and the most vulnerable ones because of the limited fund and the extent of the estimation of the impact 11

Page 12: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

• E-commerce, • Online payment

providers• Medical store, medical

equipment• Medicine• Telecom, communication

provider• Food deliveries, door to

door deliveries• Internet service provider• Rice and Bean Traders,

venders• Retail for Essentials

• Private schools• Food outlets and

restaurants• local transport• media• Agriculture• Construction• Metals and mining• Markets

Functioning IndustriesAfter Lockdown 02

Thriving Industries With Crisis 01

Hardest HitIndustries

04

Vulnerable Industries WithLess Demand

03

• Retail (Non-food)• Exports• Imports• Real estate• Software and IT• Service Companies• Local Flights• Oil and Gas• Luxury goods• Logistics• Clothing

• Entertainment, • Tour Agencies, • Lodging, Hotels• Tourist Transport, • Cruise Lines, • International Flights• Cinema• Automotive Manufacturer, • Car Dealers, • Car Brokers• Garment Manufacturer• Apparel Manufacturer

Source: World Bank, Asia Foundation, Myanmar Times 2020

Winners and Losers Aftermath of Covid 19

12

Page 13: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

4000 Businesses with proper documents

68000 registered+ 40000 unregistered

Micro entrepreneurs

Normal Employees

Casual and Temporary Workers

Home Returnees (migrant workers - almost 300,000)

Informal Economy Workers

Garment & Appreal sector (almost 400,000)

Workers in Tourism (almost 1 Million)

Unemployed workers

People Under Poverty Line and disabled persons

Modified from Source: The Irrawaddy, 2020

Soaring Unemployment and Who Gets Hit Hardest

13

Page 14: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Most employees (more than 90%) do not have saving accounts

Myanmar had one out of four people under poverty line before the crisis

a sharp decline in international remittances can be expected and that could directly reduce household income

With almost 300000 migrant workers returning home a sharp decline in international remittances can be expected and that could directly reduce household income, gradual

about 4000 local companies were lucky enough to receive the stimulus support out of almost 100000 formal and informal firms.

Those who get loans with 1 % interest may extend their benefits to their employees while many other firms have no other choice but to lay off workers.

Soaring Unemployment and Who Gets Hit Hardest

14

Page 15: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Local freelance tour guides, tourist transport drivers, horse/bull cart drivers from Innwa, Mingunand Bagan, Boat drivers of Inle lake and Taungthaman lake, souvenir vendors of touring villages, village trekking guides and service providers in Pindaya, Kalaw, Thibaw, Chin state, Loaikaw, Tachilake, Kyaingtong and so on.

Informal economy workers, casual and temporary workers, Young workers, whose employment prospects are

more sensitive to fluctuations in demand; Older workers, who even in normal times face

difficulties in finding decent work opportunities Home returnees (local migrant workers) Micro-entrepreneurs and the self-employed

Soaring Unemployment and Who Gets Hit Hardest

15

Page 16: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Tourism in Myanmar

Page 17: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Sea, Sand, Snow, Sunshine, Strong Culture

17

Page 18: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

TITLE GOES HERE 1

C O V I D 1 9 ’ s I m p a c t o n T o u r i s m E c o n o m y

Entire tourism industry came to a standstill. Even after the beginning of July, with international

flights under suspension, the cancellation of major festivals and events, the closure of tourism sites and attractions, postponements for tour plans and trips, asking for refunds and restrictions on public gatherings (indoor and outdoor),

jobs for low skilled workers, higher skilled jobs , many seasonal, part-time jobs

3188 licensed tour companies and 98% of them are SMES.

Myanmar has 1984 hotels which offer almost 80000 rooms.

Very profound impacts for the Myanmar's tourism sector, Overall revenue will be significantly reduced from 60% to 80%

Page 19: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Myanmar Tourism’s Contribution (2019)

4.6%CONTRIBUTION

OF TRAVEL & TOURISM TO

GDP

Total T&T GDP = USD3,671.1MN

+4.5% 2019 Travel & Tourism GDP growth vs +6.3% real economy GDP growth

1,073,500 JOBS

CONTRIBUTION OF TRAVEL & TOURISM TO

EMPLOYMENT

4.8% of total employment

10.3% of total

exportsINTERNATIONAL VISITOR IMPACT

in visitor spend (10.3% of total

exports) (USD1,669.7MN)

Source: World Travel & Tourism Council 2020

Tourism Sector

Created 1,073,500 Jobs, 4.8%

Of Total Employment

& Contributes

4.6% Of GDP (USD 3671

Million), And 10.3% Of Service

Exports

19

Page 20: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

COVID 19’s Impact on Tourism Economy (Continue)

4.With weak

international demand,

recovery to pre-crisis levels may take two years

or more

3.80% less of

international visitors in 2020 and 40% to 60%

less in 2021 and a loss of between USD 2

to 3 billion in export revenues from tourism

1.Interdependent with long value

chain

5.Half of Tourism SMEs will not survive after 2020, half a

million employees need

protection

2.A Quick

recovery is unlikely and

last industry to be on track

Page 21: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Excepted Tourism Recovery Timeline

Source: Tradingeconomics.com, Ministry of National Planning and Economic Development, Myanmar

Scenario 3: International tourist arrivals start to recover in November 2021, basedon limited recovery in international tourism before the end of the year (-90%). 21

Page 22: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Myanmar Tourism Before the Crisis

Source: Asean Dashboard 2018 22

Page 23: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Yearly Tourist Arrivals (2019)

4% 0%

10%

1%

0%0%

83%

2%

Who Comes to Myanmar as TouristNorth Americans Other Americans West Europe + Switzerland

East Europe + Russia Africa Middle East

Asia Oceania

2018 2019

North Americans 75122 77817

Other Americans 10786 10227

West Europe + Switzerland 183472 184015

East Europe + Russia 18386 18949

Africa 4345 4490

Middle East 5685 6006

Asia 1066345 1599185

Oceania 22455 30034

Total Tourist Arrivals 1386596 1930723

Types Of Visa 2017 2018 2019

Tourist 545934 565165 1078011

Business 242446 240833 281879

Others 2654753 2737180 3004211

Total 3443133 3543178 4364101

Source: Ministry of Hotel and Tourism 2020 23

Page 24: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

24

Tourism Sector Competitiveness

The tourism sector competitiveness is ranked 134 out of 141 countries

(WEF, 2015)

The real tourism economic drivers, western

tourist arrivals decline sharply by 2017 after the image of Myanmar was

defamed

Numbers of Chinese tourists, interested in

trading jade were surging

Source: World Economic Forum 2015

Page 25: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

25

25

Myanmar’s Country Image: In The Eyes Of A Foreign Visitor

• Not a rosy picture in a tourist's eyes. • Immense criticism on the topic of

humanitarian front such as Rohingya

• Prices are expensive, • Corrupted government, • un-ethical to visit

does not have a ‘brand’, not any people knows

Safety and health care standard very low

Other than cultural sites, not much products diversification

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Page 26: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Myanmar, however, has great potential to build a good image internationally because its greatness is immense, its land beautiful and diverse, its scenery stunning, its people most welcoming and its reality is 100 times better than the image, every tourist who has been to Myanmar agreed on that fact.

Myanmar’s Country Image: In The Eyes Of A Foreigner & SWOT Analysis

26

Page 27: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Crisis Respond by Ministry of Hotel and Tourism

i) survival, ii) reopening, iii) re-launching.

In the “survival” stage, taxes will be relaxed, license fees will be reduced, rental fees will be postponed and loans will be provided for the hotels and tourism businesses

In the “reopening” stage - with standard operating procedure (SOP) for the health and safety of travelers and staff.

. The “re-launching” stage is aimed at communication and promotion as well as providing incentives to investment.

However, there are immense amount of criticism on this ambitious plan

Some of the Complaints from Local Businesses were

problems with loan applications process, only 20% of the companies could apply because of the documents needed

Some were granted only as much as 10% of the applied loan amount.

Total (Stimulus Plan) loan amounts are very small relatively

Takes time up to three months from the application.

Taxes are not yet relaxed effectively. Incentives are not known to any tourism

investment or investors yet. Lacking check and balance mechanism and result

oriented management system.

27

Page 28: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Forecast

based on information available on 10th July 2020, overall tourism revenue is expected a combined drop of USD 2 billion in absolute terms for domestic and

international tourism in 2020, down 65% compared to 2019

International arrivals in 2020/21 are expected to fall by 60% to 80% compared to 2019.

A pessimist scenario with a contraction during the second and third quarters would mean a combined drop of USD 3.0 billion, or 90% in domestic and international tourism compared to 2019.

28

Page 29: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Looking Ahead : Tourism Sector (Near Term Solution)

• The demand for tourism is falling with potential tourists having financial troubles due to the crisis.

• The lower spending patterns are to be expected such as midscale and economy hotels.

• Therefore, eventual impacts will depend not only on the length of the pandemic, which will have ramifications for business survival, but also potential long-term changes in travel.

• Myanmar is not perceived as cheap and fun filled tourist destination and having no ‘brand’.

• It is expensive and politically corrupt and therefore, considered as unethical to visit.

• Potential to become one the rising star in Asia with up to 10 million tourists arrivals within 2 to 3 years' time

• For near term solution, government can think of china and Thailand and create ‘travel bubble’

• Think domestic tourism improvements for generating some revenue.

• To ignite the change of the national image and to attract more tourists requires much more effort than unrealized policies

• But to constructively put efforts in urgent recuperation plan to create employment and economic development

29

Page 30: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

30

Looking Ahead : SMEs & Overall Economy

The economic impact - gradual and non-linear process over two years,

long term Lower aggregate demand may pressurize Myanmar recent improvements and threatens

Myanmar’s recent progress in poverty reduction

Urban households are highly exposed to health and economic effect of Covid-19

Anticipated decline in remittance could directly reduce rural household income

A distinctive permanent impact on consumer behavior changes may be moving to online, with a greater

emphasis on hygiene and healthy living, and higher use of cashless and contactless payment methods

Page 31: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Looking Ahead : SMEs & Overall Economy

Majority of firms were not able to adopt innovation to combat Covid-19 & Low availability of fund

Tightly regulated loan products to borrow for SMEs

It is predicted that 20 to 25 percent of all SMEs will not be able to survive the next year

job markets containing a large number of informal workers ineligible for protection

Those terminated were having negative psychological effects, such as mental distress, losing self-

control, financial worries and frustration

Agriculture sector experienced the most cash flows shortages and reduction in access

to credit

Firms with female-participation were worse hit.

Majority (more than 90%) of firms did not apply (or not eligible) for any government support

Policy Priorities should bei. To Create jobs so as to absorb the entire unemployed work force affected by the COVID 19

(1 million jobs) is the single most urgent problem.ii. Serve the un-served “middle segment”iii. Make funds available for SME firms

31

Page 32: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

Upside & Downside

Upside Covid 19 controlled Reform Process Quicken 1st Ever Relief Plans (for the people) Businesses tend to become more

efficient, digitalized, risk mitigation plans

Downside Extended Timeframe of Crisis Large scale economy freeze Lower Consumer confidence Lower aggregate demand Soaring Unemployment Economic Contraction Collapse of many SMEs

At the very unlikely event, the virus might even rewrite the history of Myanmar’s governance , boost the economy, become competitive in tourism and other SME sectors

Page 33: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

1. Create jobs and Help thriving SMEs and businesses to absorb the unemployment (up to 1 million)2. SME's Problem(a) Shortage of capital: Central Bank of Myanmar can issues loans to private banks who in turn issue loans to industrial conglomerates, SMEs with least collateral requirements or without any as was the case in Japan after world war two, and authorize banks to fund viable project loans even without collateral(b)Incentives for local produce and government backing; also by encouraging local SMEs to create products that are imported, getbusiness expansion loans2. Export oriented and import substitution programs with incentives to local firms3.Not just by the stimulus fiscal instruments such as government projects, roads, infrastructure but also encouraging local production in large scale5. Real tax cuts for local businesses 6.Subsidy increases for farmers and poor households7.Not regarding innovation in the frame of only ecommerce, and e-payment8.Can we abruptly become a more business/investment friendly country?Forget 'business as usual' thinking. Forget the daily normal bureaucratic steps. We have to be proactive in strategically luring the moving manufacturers out of China recently such as Germany and Japan by offering whatever they need in cheapest possible way(a)open a new one stop investment department that will not just do the necessary licensing but also give away anything that investors will need such as land, electricity, water (b)Give Tax incentives(c)Promise them with protection of their wealth and rights(d)Strengthen backward linkages from FDI into the indigenous economy (e)Inform or pitch them professionally, government to government as well as government to businesses. (f)Setting-up a business-friendly financial system(g)Set up a vendor development programme to support the matchmaking process between foreign customers and local suppliers.

Mitigating COVID19's Economic Shock for SMEs and Employment

03 May 2020

33

Page 34: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

1.Initiative to create positive 'Myanmar's Tourism Image', promotions, campaigns, (such as ads in paid foreign medias)2.Make Myanmar Tourism competitive in pricing, (hotels, flights, transports, etc)3.Promote strategically & intensively with activities adapted to the various markets. (strategically targeting at the high value markets such as Europe)4. Diversify and Create different types of products 'unique travel bubble' (more fun filled programs, infrastructure) 5. Create the right framework conditions, and Integrated and coherent policy for the societal inclusiveness with all stakeholders participation6..Build a supportive environment by modernizing regulatory frameworks to promote fair competition and encourage innovation through travel-tech incubators, accelerators, mentoring opportunities and other non-tech initiatives (e.g. tourism networks) to encourage uptake, and promote a digital mindset.7. Facilitate strategic leadership appointments such as ‘Chief tourism entrepreneurs’ with specific mandate to evolve tourism business ecosystems and span boundaries between tourism, tech and other sectors. These trusted intermediaries should be leaders and strategic thinkers, not associated with any ties of the government nor the age nor any associations8..Targeted and nuanced approaches to regulation, funding, investment and incentives should be based on a better understanding of the different needs of digital native businesses and traditional tourism businesses9. Support accessibility and affordability of digital technologies, tools and solutions for tourism SMEs, including initial investment and ongoing costs.10. Encourage public-private partnerships and collaborations between traditional SMEs and digital native enterprises and education institutions to enhance knowledge sharing, innovation and diffusion. 11. Bring together actors with diverse and complementary expertise spanning tech, tourism and other sectors, to create a dynamic digital business environment in which both start-ups and existing tourism businesses can thrive.12.train tourism professionals in the country for research and development13.Make policies effective, result oriented management14.Establish Check and Balance mechanism15.Understand ecological foot prints of tourism16. Micro management task forces is urgently needed for destination managements; Establish Safety regulations for all tourist other than COVID 19, cleaning all the tourist destinations and the river banks, enforcement on money changers to take the stained, folded notes, seek proper help from police other than disturbing tourists, international language signs for easy accessibility, so on…….

Policy Focus and Recommendation; Tourism Sector

03 May 2020

34

Page 35: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

03 May 2020

35

Page 36: COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs...COVID 19's Economic Impact on Myanmar Tourism and SMEs 14 July 2020 03 May 2020 Richard Dagun (Takhun) Email: dagun007@gmail.com

03 May 2020

36

Alberti, F., 2020.Ant Financial Invests in Myanmar's Wave Money. The Asean Post. [Online] 21 May. Available at: <https://theaseanpost.com/article/ant-financial-invests-myanmars-wave-money> [Accessed 9 July 2020].ASEAN Visitor Arrivals Dashboard, 2018. Total visits to Asean selected countries and original countries. Available at : <https://data.aseanstats.org/dashboard/tourism> [Accessed 9 July 2020].Asia Foundation, 2020. Myanmar Business environment index (MBEI) Covid-19 impact on businesses: a survey. [pdf]: Available at: <https://asiafoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Myanmar-Business-Environment-Index-Covid-19-Impact-on-Businesses_EN.pdf> [Accessed 9 July 2020].CBM, 2020. Announcement of Interest rates. Central Bank of Myanmar. Myanmar. Available at: <https://www.cbm.gov.mm/> [Accessed 9 July 2020].Cordaid, 2020. Economic impacts of COVID-19 in fragile contexts and how SMEs can help. The Netherlands. Available at: <https://www.cordaid.org/en/news/economic-impacts-of-covid-19-in-fragile-contexts-and-how-smes-can-help/> [Accessed 9 July 2020].Diao, X., and Michael Wang, M., 2020. Significant economic impacts due to COVID-19 and falling remittances in Myanmar. International Food Policy Research Institute. Available at : <https://www.ifpri.org/blog/significant-economic-impacts-due-covid-19-and-falling-remittances-myanmar> [Accessed 9 July 2020].Frick, W., 2020. How to Survive a Recession and Thrive Afterward. May–June 2019 Issue. Harvard Business Review. Available at: <https://hbr.org/2019/05/how-to-survive-a-recession-and-thrive-afterward> [Accessed 9 July 2020].IATA, 2020. Traveller Survey Reveals COVID-19 Concerns. International Air Travel Association. Available at : <https://www.iata.org/en/pressroom/pr/2020-07-07-01/> [Accessed 9 July 2020].Lwin, N., 2020. Myanmar Prepares COVID-19 Relief Package Worth up to Several Billion Dollars. The Irrawaddy. [Online] 20 April. Available at : <https://www.irrawaddy.com/specials/myanmar-covid-19/myanmar-prepares-covid-19-relief-package-worth-several-billion-dollars.html>[Accessed 9 July 2020].Macola, G and Unger, L., 2018. Value Chain Analysis of Tourism Myanmar. CBI. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Available at: <https://www.cbi.eu/sites/default/files/2018_value_chain_analysis_tourism_myanmar.pdf > [Accessed 9 July 2020].MoHT, 2020. MYANMAR TOUISM DATA. Ministry of Hotel and Tourism (MoHT). Available at : <https://file:///E:/Burma%20Update%20Conference/Myanmar-Tourism-Statisitcs-2019-1.pdf> [Accessed 9 July 2020].

MOHT, 2020. COVID 19 Tourism Relief Plan. Ministry of Hotel and Tourism. Available at: <http://file:///E:/Burma%20Update%20Conference/COVID-19-Tourism-Relief-Plan.pdf> [Accessed 9 July 2020].MOI, 2020. The COVID-19 Economic Relief Plan. Ministry of Information (MOI). Myanmar. Available at:<https://www.moi.gov.mm/moi:eng/?q=about-moi> [Accessed 9 July 2020].OCHA, 2020. MYANMAR: COVID-19 Situation Report No. 06. [pdf]: United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Available at: http://file:///E:/Burma%20Update%20Conference/OCHA%20Myanmar%20-%20COVID-19%20Situation%20report%20No%206-1.pdf [Accessed 9 July 2020].OECD, 2020. Policy Responses to Coronavirus (COVID-19) COVID-19 crisis response in ASEAN Member States. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. [pdf]: Available at: http://www.oecd.org/coronavirus/policy-responses/covid-19-crisis-response-in-asean-member-states-02f828a2/ [Accessed 9 July 2020].Roberts, J.M, 2017. Import Substitution Made Countries Such as Argentina Poorer. Heritage Foundation. Available at: <https://www.heritage.org/trade/commentary/import-substitution-made-countries-such-argentina-poorer> [Accessed 9 July 2020].Tripadvisor.com, 2020. Myanmar Visit Forums. Available at: <https://www.tripadvisor.com/> [Accessed 9 July 2020].WEF, 2015. Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2015, World Economic Forum, Geneva. Available at: <http://www3.weforum.org/docs/TT15/WEF_Global_Travel&Tourism_Report_2015.pdf> [Accessed 9 July 2020].World Bank, 2019. Poverty Report- Myanmar Living Conditions Survey 2017. World Bank. Available at : <https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/myanmar/publication/poverty-report-myanmar-living-conditions-survey-2017> [Accessed 9 July 2020].World Bank, 2020. Myanmar Economic Monitor June 2020. Myanmar in the Time of Covid -19. [pdf]: World Bank . Available at: <http://file:///E:/Burma%20Update%20Conference/MEM%20June%202020_PPT.pdf> [Accessed 9 July 2020].World Health Organization, 2020. WHO Myanmar newsletter May - August 2020. [pdf] Myanmar: World Health Organization. Available at: <https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/searo/myanmar/newsletter-issue-62-vol17.pdf?sfvrsn=fdbcba20_0 > [Accessed 9 July 2020].WTTC, 2020. Myanmar2020 Annual Research: Key Highlights. [pdf]: World Travel and Tourism Council 2020. http://file:///C:/Users/DELL/AppData/Local/Temp/Myanmar2020_-1.pdf [Accessed 9 July 2020].

References