dairy industry doesn’t own the word milk - yale law school
TRANSCRIPT
Dairy industry doesn_t own the word _milk_ _ TheHill
'DLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQ WRZQWKHZRUG PLON _7KH+LOO
KWWSVWKHKLOOFRPEORJVFRQJUHVVEORJSROLWLFVGDLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQWRZQWKHZRUGPLON
Icktkpfv utfqg p,uqxpujg ,oknm, %<-867,13($562123,1,21&2175,%8725u30(67 7+(9,(:6(;35(66('%<&2175,%87256$5(7+(,52:1$1'1277+(9,(:2)7+(+,//
==< 6+$5(6 6+$5( 7:
-XVW,Q
+RXVH'HPRFUDWV ODXQFKLQTXLU\LQWR++6 VWLPXOXVSD\RXWV +286(u06$*2
0,7PDNHVKLVWRU\ HOHFWLQJLUVWEODFN ZRPDQVWXGHQWERG\ SUHVLGHQWLQ\HDUV 1(:6u06$*2
3HORVLFDOOV7UXPS V GHFLVLRQWRZLWKGUDZ86 IURP:+2 DQDFWRI H[WUDRUGLQDU\ VHQVHOHVVQHVV +286(u0$*2
3URWHVWHUXSWVRXWVLGH %URRNO\Q V%DUFOD\V &HQWHURYHUGHDWKRI *HRUJH)OR\G 1(:6u+0$*2
3URWHVWVYDQGDOLVP UHSRUWHGRXWVLGH&11 KHDGTXDUWHUVLQ$WODQWD 0(',$u+0$*2
.HQQHWK %UDLWKZDLWH}VZRUQLQDV 1DY\VHFUHWDU\ '()(16(u+0$*2
&KLFDJRPD\RUGURSV FRGHG IERPEEODVWLQJ 7UXPS VFRQWURYHUVLDO WZHHWRQ*HRUJH)OR\G SURWHVWV 1(:6u+0$*2
7UXPSYHWRHVPHDVXUH DLPHGDWEORFNLQJ
+VTUBTTFOBUPSTXFSFDFMFCSBUJOHUIFJSGSFFEPNUPESJOLNJMLSBUIFSUIBO KVTUXBUFSEVSJOHUIFJNQFBDINFOUUSJBM TPNFNFNCFSTPGUIFCPEZ DIPTFUPDPOUJOVFUIFJSRVFTUUPSFTUSJDU"NFSJDBOTGSPNCVZJOHBOZUIJOH MBCFMFEoNJMLpUIBUEPFTOnUDPNFGSPNBDPX*UnTBOBCTVSE BOE VODPOTUJUVUJPOBM BUUFNQUUPSFTUSJDUQSPEVDUTGSPNVTJOHBDPNNPOUFSN UIBUDPOTVNFSTVOEFSTUBOE
"UUIFSFRVFTUPGUIFEBJSZJOEVTUSZ 4FOT %8JT BOE 3*EBIP BTLJOH'%"$PNNJTTJPOFS
4UFQIFO)BIOUPCBOUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLpBOEoBMNPOENJMLp*OGBDU UIFTFOBUPSTXBOUBMMNJMLUFSNTCBOOFEVOMFTTUIFQSPEVDUCFJOH EFTDSJCFEJTDPXnTNJML5IFTFOBUPSTDMBJNUIBUUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLp BOEoBMNPOENJMLpBSFDPOGVTJOH
#BMEXJOBOE3JTDINBZCFFBTJMZDPOGVTFE CVU"NFSJDBODPOTVNFSTBSF OPU5IFZVOEFSTUBOEUIBUDPDPOVUNJMLEPFTOnUDPNFGSPNDPXT KVTUMJLF UIFZVOEFSTUBOEUIBUQFBOVUCVUUFSJTEJôFSFOUUIBOCVUUFS"OEUIBU DIJDLFOTEPOnUIBWFJOHFST"OEUIBUZPVEPOnUXFBSDPUUPODBOEZ
5IBOLGVMMZGPS"NFSJDBOTXIPFOKPZBMMUZQFTPGNJML UIFHPWFSONFOU EPFTOnUPXOPVSMBOHVBHF6OEFSUIF'JSTU"NFOENFOU XIBUNBUUFSTJT XIFUIFSSFBTPOBCMFDPOTVNFSTBSFDPOGVTFECZUIFTFUFSNT OPUXIBU QPMJUJDJBOTXJTIUIPTFXPSETNFBOU4JODFSFBTPOBCMFDPOTVNFSTBSFOPU DPOGVTFECZUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLpBOEoBMNPOENJML pUIF'JSTU "NFOENFOUQSPUFDUTUIFJSVTF
(FUUZ*NBHFT
'DLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQ WRZQWKHZRUG PLON _7KH+LOO
KWWSVWKHKLOOFRPEORJVFRQJUHVVEORJSROLWLFVGDLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQWRZQWKHZRUGPLON
9LHZ/DWHVW2SLQLRQV!!
9,(:$//
%PPS%BTIEFMJWFSZNBO IBTHVOESBXOPOIJN
#JSEXBUDIFSRVFTUJPOT XIFUIFSSFTQPOTFUP
E\
7FHFUBCMFNJMLUFSNTIBWFCFFOBSPVOETJODFPVSOBUJPOnTGPVOEJOH BOE FWFOGPSDFOUVSJFTCFGPSF"TGBSCBDLBTUIFUIDFOUVSZ SFDJQFTDBMMFE GPSUIFJOHSFEJFOUoBMNPOEFTNZMLp*O 'SBODJT#BDPOOPUFEUIBU oUIFSFCFQMBOUT UIBUIBWFB.JMLJOUIFNXIFOUIFZBSF$VUp"OEUIFUI DFOUVSZ&ODZDMPQBFEJB#SJUBOOJDBTUBUFEUIBUoUIFFNVMTJWFMJRVPSTPG WFHFUBCMFTNBZCFDBMMFEWFHFUBCMFNJMLTp*OGBDU DPOTVNFSTTP BQQSFDJBUFEUIFJEFBUIBUUIFUFSNoNJMLpEJEOPUOFDFTTBSJMZNFBODPXnT NJMLUIBUXIFO"NFSJDBOJOWFOUPS+PIO$BMMFOQBUFOUFEIJTOFXBOUBDJEJO IFOBNFEJU.JMLPG.BHOFTJB/POFPGUIJTBQQFBSTUPIBWFDPOGVTFE BOZPOF
5IJTMBDLPGDPOTVNFSDPOGVTJPOJTUIFSFBTPOXIZUIF'%"IBTSFQFBUFEMZ SFKFDUFE#JH%BJSZnTFôPSUTUPQVOJTIOPOEBJSZNJMLTFMMFSTGPSVTJOHUIFTF UFSNT8IFOZPVCBOUIFDPNNPOUFSNTUIBUDPOTVNFSTVOEFSTUBOE CFTU DPOTVNFSDPOGVTJPOEPFTOnUHPEPXO*UHPFTVQ
4POPXUIFHJBOUJOUFSOBUJPOBMEJBSZDPOHMPNFSBUFTIBWFGPVOEBHSPVQPG TFOBUPSTXIPBSFXJMMJOHUPGFJHODPOGVTJPOJOPSEFSUPEPUIFJSCJEEJOH0G DPVSTF OPPOFSFBMMZUIJOLT#BMEXJO 3JTDI BOEUIFJSPUIFSTVQQPSUFSTBSF DPOGVTFEBCPVUDPDPOVUNJML*OTUFBE XIBUJTIBQQFOJOHJTUIBUUIFZBSF HPJOHUPEPXIBUFWFSUIFHJBOUDPNQBOJFTUFMMUIFNUPEP OPNBUUFSIPX NBOZDPOTVNFSTUIFZIVSUPSDPOTUJUVUJPOBMQSPWJTJPOTUIFZTISFE
#JH%BJSZJTOnUMJNJUJOHJUTFMGUP$BQJUPM)JMMFJUIFS8JUIBOFWFSFOEJOH BSNZPGMPCCZJTUTBUJUTEJTQPTBM JUJTBMTPUSZJOHUPDPOWJODFTUBUF MFHJTMBUVSFTUPCBOUIJTUSVUIGVMTQFFDI+VTUMBTUXFFL UIF7JSHJOJB)PVTF KPJOFE/PSUI$BSPMJOBBOE.BSZMBOEJO #VUKVTUMJLFJO /PSUI$BSPMJOBBOE.BSZMBOE UIFMBXXJMMPOMZUBLFFôFDUJGTUBUFTEP UIFTBNFUIJOH TPFWFOJGUIF7JSHJOJB4FOBUFXFSFUPDPODVSBOE 7JSHJOJBnTHPWFSOPSXFSFUPTJHOUIFCJMMJOUPMBX OPUIJOHNFBOJOHGVM XPVMEIBQQFOGPSZFBST5IJTJTXIZ#JH%BJSZJTTPGPDVTFEPO#BMEXJO BOE3JTDI
5IFHPPEOFXTJTUIBUFTUBCMJTIFE'JSTU"NFOENFOUQSFDFEFOUBMSFBEZ TIPXTUIBUUIJTUZQFPGCBOJTMJLFMZUPCFSVMFEVODPOTUJUVUJPOBM#VUJOUIF QSPDFTTPGMPTJOHJODPVSU UIFHPWFSONFOUXJMMTQFOENJMMJPOTPGUBY EPMMBST BGUFSXIJDIUIFHPWFSONFOUXJMMMJLFMZCFPSEFSFEUPQBZFWFO NPSFUPUIFDIBMMFOHFSTnBUUPSOFZT)PQFGVMMZ #BMEXJOBOE3JTDIDBOJOE BCFUUFSVTFGPSUIFJSUJNFBOEUIFUBYQBZFSTnNPOFZ
+VTUJO1FBSTPOJTB4FOJPS"UUPSOFZBUUIFOPOQSPJU XIFSFIFXBTUIFJSTUBUUPSOFZJO64IJTUPSZUPXJOB'JSTU"NFOENFOU DIBMMFOHFBHBJOTUBGPPETUBOEBSEPGJEFOUJUZ)JTMBXKPVSOBMBSUJDMFPOUIJT UPQJDXBTSFDFOUMZQVCMJTIFEJOUIF(FPSHFUPXO+PVSOBMPG-BX1VCMJD 1PMJDZ
XFL 7$00<%$/':,1 -,05,6&+
7UXPS86 WHUPLQDWLQJ UHODWLRQVKLSZLWK:+2
6HFRQGVHQDWRUWHVWVSRVLWLYHIRUFRURQDYLUXVDQWLERGLHV
QBTTJOHTJNJMBSMBXT
*OTUJUVUFGPS+VTUJDF
6+$5( 7:((7
KWWSVWKHKLOOFRPEORJVFRQJUHVVEORJSROLWLFVGDLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQWRZQWKHZRUGPLON
Icktkpfv utfqg p,uqxpujg ,oknm, %<-867,13($562123,1,21&2175,%8725u30(67 7+(9,(:6(;35(66('%<&2175,%87256$5(7+(,52:1$1'1277+(9,(:2)7+(+,//
==< 6+$5(6 6+$5( 7:
-XVW,Q
+RXVH'HPRFUDWV ODXQFKLQTXLU\LQWR++6 VWLPXOXVSD\RXWV +286(u06$*2
0,7PDNHVKLVWRU\ HOHFWLQJLUVWEODFN ZRPDQVWXGHQWERG\ SUHVLGHQWLQ\HDUV 1(:6u06$*2
3HORVLFDOOV7UXPS V GHFLVLRQWRZLWKGUDZ86 IURP:+2 DQDFWRI H[WUDRUGLQDU\ VHQVHOHVVQHVV +286(u0$*2
3URWHVWHUXSWVRXWVLGH %URRNO\Q V%DUFOD\V &HQWHURYHUGHDWKRI *HRUJH)OR\G 1(:6u+0$*2
3URWHVWVYDQGDOLVP UHSRUWHGRXWVLGH&11 KHDGTXDUWHUVLQ$WODQWD 0(',$u+0$*2
.HQQHWK %UDLWKZDLWH}VZRUQLQDV 1DY\VHFUHWDU\ '()(16(u+0$*2
&KLFDJRPD\RUGURSV FRGHG IERPEEODVWLQJ 7UXPS VFRQWURYHUVLDO WZHHWRQ*HRUJH)OR\G SURWHVWV 1(:6u+0$*2
7UXPSYHWRHVPHDVXUH DLPHGDWEORFNLQJ
+VTUBTTFOBUPSTXFSFDFMFCSBUJOHUIFJSGSFFEPNUPESJOLNJMLSBUIFSUIBO KVTUXBUFSEVSJOHUIFJNQFBDINFOUUSJBM TPNFNFNCFSTPGUIFCPEZ DIPTFUPDPOUJOVFUIFJSRVFTUUPSFTUSJDU"NFSJDBOTGSPNCVZJOHBOZUIJOH MBCFMFEoNJMLpUIBUEPFTOnUDPNFGSPNBDPX*UnTBOBCTVSE BOE VODPOTUJUVUJPOBM BUUFNQUUPSFTUSJDUQSPEVDUTGSPNVTJOHBDPNNPOUFSN UIBUDPOTVNFSTVOEFSTUBOE
"UUIFSFRVFTUPGUIFEBJSZJOEVTUSZ 4FOT %8JT BOE 3*EBIP BTLJOH'%"$PNNJTTJPOFS
4UFQIFO)BIOUPCBOUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLpBOEoBMNPOENJMLp*OGBDU UIFTFOBUPSTXBOUBMMNJMLUFSNTCBOOFEVOMFTTUIFQSPEVDUCFJOH EFTDSJCFEJTDPXnTNJML5IFTFOBUPSTDMBJNUIBUUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLp BOEoBMNPOENJMLpBSFDPOGVTJOH
#BMEXJOBOE3JTDINBZCFFBTJMZDPOGVTFE CVU"NFSJDBODPOTVNFSTBSF OPU5IFZVOEFSTUBOEUIBUDPDPOVUNJMLEPFTOnUDPNFGSPNDPXT KVTUMJLF UIFZVOEFSTUBOEUIBUQFBOVUCVUUFSJTEJôFSFOUUIBOCVUUFS"OEUIBU DIJDLFOTEPOnUIBWFJOHFST"OEUIBUZPVEPOnUXFBSDPUUPODBOEZ
5IBOLGVMMZGPS"NFSJDBOTXIPFOKPZBMMUZQFTPGNJML UIFHPWFSONFOU EPFTOnUPXOPVSMBOHVBHF6OEFSUIF'JSTU"NFOENFOU XIBUNBUUFSTJT XIFUIFSSFBTPOBCMFDPOTVNFSTBSFDPOGVTFECZUIFTFUFSNT OPUXIBU QPMJUJDJBOTXJTIUIPTFXPSETNFBOU4JODFSFBTPOBCMFDPOTVNFSTBSFOPU DPOGVTFECZUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLpBOEoBMNPOENJML pUIF'JSTU "NFOENFOUQSPUFDUTUIFJSVTF
(FUUZ*NBHFT
'DLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQ WRZQWKHZRUG PLON _7KH+LOO
KWWSVWKHKLOOFRPEORJVFRQJUHVVEORJSROLWLFVGDLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQWRZQWKHZRUGPLON
9LHZ/DWHVW2SLQLRQV!!
9,(:$//
%PPS%BTIEFMJWFSZNBO IBTHVOESBXOPOIJN
#JSEXBUDIFSRVFTUJPOT XIFUIFSSFTQPOTFUP
E\
7FHFUBCMFNJMLUFSNTIBWFCFFOBSPVOETJODFPVSOBUJPOnTGPVOEJOH BOE FWFOGPSDFOUVSJFTCFGPSF"TGBSCBDLBTUIFUIDFOUVSZ SFDJQFTDBMMFE GPSUIFJOHSFEJFOUoBMNPOEFTNZMLp*O 'SBODJT#BDPOOPUFEUIBU oUIFSFCFQMBOUT UIBUIBWFB.JMLJOUIFNXIFOUIFZBSF$VUp"OEUIFUI DFOUVSZ&ODZDMPQBFEJB#SJUBOOJDBTUBUFEUIBUoUIFFNVMTJWFMJRVPSTPG WFHFUBCMFTNBZCFDBMMFEWFHFUBCMFNJMLTp*OGBDU DPOTVNFSTTP BQQSFDJBUFEUIFJEFBUIBUUIFUFSNoNJMLpEJEOPUOFDFTTBSJMZNFBODPXnT NJMLUIBUXIFO"NFSJDBOJOWFOUPS+PIO$BMMFOQBUFOUFEIJTOFXBOUBDJEJO IFOBNFEJU.JMLPG.BHOFTJB/POFPGUIJTBQQFBSTUPIBWFDPOGVTFE BOZPOF
5IJTMBDLPGDPOTVNFSDPOGVTJPOJTUIFSFBTPOXIZUIF'%"IBTSFQFBUFEMZ SFKFDUFE#JH%BJSZnTFôPSUTUPQVOJTIOPOEBJSZNJMLTFMMFSTGPSVTJOHUIFTF UFSNT8IFOZPVCBOUIFDPNNPOUFSNTUIBUDPOTVNFSTVOEFSTUBOE CFTU DPOTVNFSDPOGVTJPOEPFTOnUHPEPXO*UHPFTVQ
4POPXUIFHJBOUJOUFSOBUJPOBMEJBSZDPOHMPNFSBUFTIBWFGPVOEBHSPVQPG TFOBUPSTXIPBSFXJMMJOHUPGFJHODPOGVTJPOJOPSEFSUPEPUIFJSCJEEJOH0G DPVSTF OPPOFSFBMMZUIJOLT#BMEXJO 3JTDI BOEUIFJSPUIFSTVQQPSUFSTBSF DPOGVTFEBCPVUDPDPOVUNJML*OTUFBE XIBUJTIBQQFOJOHJTUIBUUIFZBSF HPJOHUPEPXIBUFWFSUIFHJBOUDPNQBOJFTUFMMUIFNUPEP OPNBUUFSIPX NBOZDPOTVNFSTUIFZIVSUPSDPOTUJUVUJPOBMQSPWJTJPOTUIFZTISFE
#JH%BJSZJTOnUMJNJUJOHJUTFMGUP$BQJUPM)JMMFJUIFS8JUIBOFWFSFOEJOH BSNZPGMPCCZJTUTBUJUTEJTQPTBM JUJTBMTPUSZJOHUPDPOWJODFTUBUF MFHJTMBUVSFTUPCBOUIJTUSVUIGVMTQFFDI+VTUMBTUXFFL UIF7JSHJOJB)PVTF KPJOFE/PSUI$BSPMJOBBOE.BSZMBOEJO #VUKVTUMJLFJO /PSUI$BSPMJOBBOE.BSZMBOE UIFMBXXJMMPOMZUBLFFôFDUJGTUBUFTEP UIFTBNFUIJOH TPFWFOJGUIF7JSHJOJB4FOBUFXFSFUPDPODVSBOE 7JSHJOJBnTHPWFSOPSXFSFUPTJHOUIFCJMMJOUPMBX OPUIJOHNFBOJOHGVM XPVMEIBQQFOGPSZFBST5IJTJTXIZ#JH%BJSZJTTPGPDVTFEPO#BMEXJO BOE3JTDI
5IFHPPEOFXTJTUIBUFTUBCMJTIFE'JSTU"NFOENFOUQSFDFEFOUBMSFBEZ TIPXTUIBUUIJTUZQFPGCBOJTMJLFMZUPCFSVMFEVODPOTUJUVUJPOBM#VUJOUIF QSPDFTTPGMPTJOHJODPVSU UIFHPWFSONFOUXJMMTQFOENJMMJPOTPGUBY EPMMBST BGUFSXIJDIUIFHPWFSONFOUXJMMMJLFMZCFPSEFSFEUPQBZFWFO NPSFUPUIFDIBMMFOHFSTnBUUPSOFZT)PQFGVMMZ #BMEXJOBOE3JTDIDBOJOE BCFUUFSVTFGPSUIFJSUJNFBOEUIFUBYQBZFSTnNPOFZ
+VTUJO1FBSTPOJTB4FOJPS"UUPSOFZBUUIFOPOQSPJU XIFSFIFXBTUIFJSTUBUUPSOFZJO64IJTUPSZUPXJOB'JSTU"NFOENFOU DIBMMFOHFBHBJOTUBGPPETUBOEBSEPGJEFOUJUZ)JTMBXKPVSOBMBSUJDMFPOUIJT UPQJDXBTSFDFOUMZQVCMJTIFEJOUIF(FPSHFUPXO+PVSOBMPG-BX1VCMJD 1PMJDZ
XFL 7$00<%$/':,1 -,05,6&+
7UXPS86 WHUPLQDWLQJ UHODWLRQVKLSZLWK:+2
6HFRQGVHQDWRUWHVWVSRVLWLYHIRUFRURQDYLUXVDQWLERGLHV
QBTTJOHTJNJMBSMBXT
*OTUJUVUFGPS+VTUJDF
6+$5( 7:((7