datajournalism - dollars for docs: un caso studio

40
data journalism Dollars for docs A case study Elisabetta Tola formicablu srl

Upload: elisabetta-tola

Post on 29-Nov-2014

328 views

Category:

News & Politics


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Scuola di giornalismo, Università di Milano, febbraio 2011. Analisi di un caso studio di DataJ, la serie di articoli Dollars for docs pubblicati dalla rivista online ProPublica.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

data journalismDollars for docs

A case study

Elisabetta Tola

formicablu srl

Page 2: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Conventional news reporting aims to create an objective image of the world as it is.

Page 3: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Investigative reporting use objectively true material

(that is, facts that any reasonable observer would agree are true)

toward the subjective goal of reforming the world.

Page 4: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

That is not a license to lie in a good cause.

Page 5: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

it is a responsibility,

to learn the truth

so that the world can change.

Page 6: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio
Page 7: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

L’inchiesta Dollars for docshttp://projects.propublica.org/docdollars/

Page 8: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

$295 million

to just less than

20.000 providers

Page 9: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

http://www.propublica.org/podcast/item/reporters-discuss-how-to-use-dollars-for-docs-data/

Reporters Discuss How to Use Dollars for Docs Data

Page 10: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio
Page 11: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Scraping for Journalism: A Guide for Collecting Datahttp://www.propublica.org/nerds/item/doc-dollars-guides-collecting-the-data

Page 12: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

use of some

“power tool for working with messy data”

Page 13: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

what they actually are:

“remedy for eye fatigue, migraines, depression, and other symptoms of prolonged

data-cleaning.”

Page 14: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Results

drug companies

will begin

performing more stringent background checks

not to hire sanctioned doctors

Page 15: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

universities and teaching hospitals

are re-examining

compliance

with their conflict-of-interest policies

Page 16: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

several drug companies have submitted

revised reports

to the States

Page 17: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

three new companies

will release

their payment data

Page 18: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

complied the initial challenge:

building a database-backed site so that readers could freely

search it

to start a conversation about what might go into the federal database scheduled for 2013

Page 19: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Una reazione

http://www.policymed.com/2010/10/propublica-docs-for-dollars-or-journalist-for-dollars.html

Page 20: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

un altro esempio

http://projects.propublica.org/forensics/

Page 21: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

data journalismDollars for docs

A case study

Elisabetta Tolaformicablu srl

Page 22: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Conventional news reporting aims to create an objective image of the world as it is.

Page 23: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Investigative reporting use objectively true material

(that is, facts that any reasonable observer would agree are true)

toward the subjective goal of reforming the world.

Page 24: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

That is not a license to lie in a good cause.

Page 25: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

it is a responsibility,

to learn the truth

so that the world can change.

Page 26: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio
Page 27: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

L’inchiesta Dollars for docshttp://projects.propublica.org/docdollars/

Page 28: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

$295 million

to just less than

20.000 providers

Page 29: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

http://www.propublica.org/podcast/item/reporters-discuss-how-to-use-dollars-for-docs-data/

Reporters Discuss How to Use Dollars for Docs Data

Page 30: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio
Page 31: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Scraping for Journalism: A Guide for Collecting Datahttp://www.propublica.org/nerds/item/doc-dollars-guides-collecting-the-data

Page 32: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

use of some

“power tool for working with messy data”

Page 33: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

what they actually are:

“remedy for eye fatigue, migraines, depression, and other symptoms of prolonged

data-cleaning.”

Page 34: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Results

drug companies

will begin

performing more stringent background checks

not to hire sanctioned doctors

Page 35: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

universities and teaching hospitals

are re-examining

compliance

with their conflict-of-interest policies

Page 36: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

several drug companies have submitted

revised reports

to the States

Page 37: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

three new companies

will release

their payment data

Page 38: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

complied the initial challenge:

building a database-backed site so that readers could freely

search it

to start a conversation about what might go into the federal database scheduled for 2013

Page 39: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

Una reazione

http://www.policymed.com/2010/10/propublica-docs-for-dollars-or-journalist-for-dollars.html

Page 40: Datajournalism - Dollars for docs: un caso studio

un altro esempio

http://projects.propublica.org/forensics/